Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Summary. Pretreatment bone marrow biopsies of 63 patients ATG. Stem cell damage, not identifiable morphologically,
with severe aplastic anaemia (SAA) who were not trans- and/or impairment of accessory cells might play a major role
planted and of whom 5 5 received ATG, were evaluated in eventual outcome of SAA patients. Thirty-five patients are
according to the amount and character of residual haemato- currently alive, median 3.8 years (up to 12.4) after ATG.
poiesis (‘genuine’ aplasia/intermediate/hypoplastic myelo- Follow-up bone marrow aspirates and biopsies of 32 patients
dysplasia (MD)), inflammatory infiltrate (Te Velde & Haak, were evaluable and none showed normal haematopoiesis.
1977, grade I/II/III), and number of mast cells (normal or One patient revealed persistent aplasia. Of the remaining 31,
slightly increased/increased). Of 6 1 evaluable biopsies, 4 7 haematopoiesis was decreased in 14 and increased in eight.
were ‘genuine’aplastic, 11 intermediate and three hypoplas- All had dyserythropoiesis, 2 8 dysplastic myelopoiesis and in
tic MD. Inflammatory infiltrates were graded as I11 in 36/60 16/29 with evaluable megakaryocytes, dysmegakaryopoie-
evaluable biopsies, as I1 in 2 1 and I in three. A moderate to sis was found. Sixteen patients had normo- to hypercellular
marked increase of mast cells was seen in 19/61. Of grade I11 bone marrows with two dysplastic cell lines (consistent with
patients, 86% had a < 9 0 d interval between diagnosis and myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS) according to the FAB-
administration of ATG, versus 50% of grade 1/11 patients group). The prognostic impact of the dysplastic abnormalities
(P<O.OI). No other correlations with pretreatment charac- found in these patients needs longer follow-up. Close observa-
teristics were found. No significant prognostic value for tion is indicated in view of the previously recognized, albeit
survival or response to ATG of any of these three criteria has uncommon, evolution of SAA to MDS/acute non-lymphocy-
been identified. More patients with grade 111 inflammation tic leukaemia.
tended to show adequate recovery at 4 and 6 months after
Acquired aplastic anaemia (AA) has been defined as a response to these factors (Bacigalupoet al, 1980; Zoumbos et
pancytopenia due to unexplained bone marrow failure al, 1985; Nissen et al. 1985a. b).
(Gordon-Smith, 19 79). In most patients aetiologic events are On the basis of both blood counts and bone marrow
unclear, but in a minority a relationship with recent viral cellularity. severe AA (SAA) has been defined and differen-
infections or exposure to drugs or chemicals can be found. tiated from moderate or non-severe AA (Camitta et al, 1976).
Bone marrow histology confirms the diagnosis by excluding Prior to the use of anti-thymocyte globulin (ATG). the
disorders which might lead to pancytopenia. survival of SAA was less than 20% without bone marrow
The pathogenetic process which leads to this failure of transplantation (BMT) (Camitta et al, 1975). Following the
haematopoietic cells to proliferate is still unclear. Various use of ATG, survival has improved (Young & Speck, 1984).
studies reveal ample evidence for a qualitative and/or but studies with long-term follow-up identify late deaths due
quantitative stem cell disorder, and for immunologic inhibi- to clonal evolution, suggesting that ATG does not cure the
tion of stem cell proliferation due to suppressive cellular disease (DePlanque et al, 1988a. b; Tichelli et al. 1988).
activity, humoral inhibition, or lack of growth factors or of A relationship between AA and clonal disease such as
paroxysmal nocturnal haemoglobinuria. myelodysplastic
Correspondence:Dr Mariet M. de Planque, Department of Immuno- syndromes (MDS) and leukaemia has long been recognized,
haematology and Blood Bank, Building 1, E 3-Q. University Hospital, but previously seen as a rare event (Dameshek, 1967: Milner
P.O. Box 9600. 2300 RC Leiden. The PIetherlands. &?Geary, 19 79; Appelbaum & Fefer, 198 1). MDS as defined by
439
440 Mariet M . de Planque et a2
the French-American-British (FAB) group are characterized Definition of response to ATG. Clinical responses were
by a normocellular or hypercellular bone marrow with at defined as partial response: improvement in all three cell
least dysplastic features in two haematopoietic cell lines lines, granulocyte count 3 0 . 5 x 1Oy/1, no transfusion re-
(Bennett et al, 1982). Attempts have been made to separate quirements: adequate recovery (‘complete response’, CR):
‘true AA’ from hypoplastic MDS on the basis of dysplastic normal haemoglobin, granulocyte count 1.0 x 10y/land
bone marrow characteristics, thus differentiating between platelet count 100 x 10y/l.
non-dysplastic AA which should not evolve and hypoplastic Bone marrow specimens. Bone marrow biopsy specimens
MDS which might eventually evolve into clonal disease were obtained from the posterior superior iliac spine or iliac
(Fohlmeister et al, 1985b). Whether this differentiation is crest using a bone drill or Y amshidi biopsy needle and after
indeed feasible and of eventual prognostic significance can be fixation without decalcification embedded in methylmeth-
questioned (De Planque et al. 1988a). acrylate (Te Velde & Haak. 1977). Sections (3 pm thick) were
Both ATG and BMT are now considered effective treatment stained with Periodic Acid Schiff, Gallamine-Giemsa,
for SAA, but short-term and long-term benefits differ from Gomori’s reticulin and Turnbull’s or Perl’s iron staining. For
patient to patient. Since therapy-related morbidity and early initial diagnosis at least 30 mm2 of trabecular bone and
mortality of BMT are higher, particularly in the older marrow surface per section was required. The cellularity was
patients, but also after multiple blood transfusions (Storb et al, determined semiquantitatively by analysis of intertrabecular
1980) a sound choice of treatment based on prognostic areas. Bone marrow aspirates obtained at the same time were
factors is of major importance. Several studies have identified stained with May Griinwald-Giemsa and Prussian blue.
prognostic factors for survival based on various patients’ The most recent pretreatment bone marrow biopsies of all
characteristics (Williamset al, 19 78: Faille et al, 1979: Jansen 63 patients were reviewed and categorized for evaluation of
et al, 1982; Hunter et al. 1985; Torok-Storb et al, 1985). In prognostic value according to:
1977 Te Velde & Haak reported the prognostic value for (i) residual haematopoiesis: (a) ‘genuine’ aplasia: severely
survival > 6 months of the intensity and distribution of hypocellular bone marrow with inflammatory infiltrate. ‘Hot
inflammatory infiltrates in methyl-methacrylate embedded spots’ of clustered erythropoiesis and limited remnants of
bone marrow biopsies of 15 AA patients treated with myelopoiesis could be present. No increase of reticulin fibres.
conventional therapy. Since then ATG has gradually become (b) Hypoplastic myelodysplasia (MD): bone marrow cellular-
the treatment of first choice in our institution and has ity <25% of normal with disturbed architecture of the
improved SAA survival. Therefore, we were able to assess the haematopoiesis. Dysplastic features of at least two cell lines.
prognostic value of this grading of inflammatory infiltrates in Increase of fine reticulin fibres frequently present. (c) Inter-
63 SAA patients, who were not transplanted and of whom mediate: biopsies which did not fulfil the criteria of the above
the majority were treated with ATG. In view of the above- mentioned categories.
mentioned evolution in patients initially diagnosed as (S)AA (ii) Amount and distribution of inflammatory infiltrate
we subsequently evaluated bone marrow histopathology in acording to Te Velde & Haak (19 77): (a)grade I: sparse diffuse
the SAA patients currently alive up to 12.4 years after ATG. inflammatory infiltrate: (b) grade II: moderate or extensive
inflammatory infiltrate in most but not all marrow fields; (c)
grade 111: moderate or strong inflammatory infiltrate in all
marrow fields.
MATERIALS A N D METHODS
(iii) Amount of mast cells, semiquantitatively scored as: (a)
low: normal or slight increase; (b) high: moderate to marked
Patients. Between 1974 and July 1987 the diagnosis of increase.
SAA (Camitta et al, 1976) has been confirmed in 82 patients, Of pretreatment biopsies of three patients, one was not
42 males and 40 females. In 83% the disease was idiopathic, available for review, one was not evaluable and one not
in 11%a relationship with hepatitis and in 6% with drugs or evaluable for grading of inflammatory infiltrate.
chemicals was suspected. Nineteen patients underwent BMT In the follow-up biopsies and aspirates, cellularity, overall
either as initial treatment (11patients) or after failure of ATG haematopoiesis, erythropoiesis, myelopoiesis and megakar-
(eight patients). These 19 patients were excluded from this yopoiesis were determined semiquantitatively. Dysplastic
analysis. features of the three cell lines were evaluated qualitatively as
Of the remaining 63 patients (median age 30.0, range was the presence or absence of an inflammatory infiltrate.
13.8-84.7 years) 55 were treated with ATG. The interval Tissue iron and the number of sideroblasts were scored as
between diagnosis and ATG was < 30 d in 22 patients, 30- decreased, normal or increased, and the presence or absence
60 in 13,60-90 in four and > 9 0 in 16. The majority of these of ringed sideroblasts was assessed. All bone marrow speci-
patients also received androgens prior to, or after ATG. mens were examined independently by at least two of the
Twenty of the 5 5 ATG-treated patients have died. Eight authors.
patients either died before treatment or received only hormo- Statistical considerations. Overall survival was calculated
nal therapy (androgens and/or prednisone). Six of these eight from the start of ATG therapy, or from diagnosis when no
patients have died and two are lost to follow-up. Of the 35 ATG was administered, using the Kaplan-Meier method of
patients currently alive following ATG therapy (median 3.8 non-parametric estimation for complete observations. The
years: range 0.3- 12.4) 3 2 gave permission to perform a bone Fisher’s exact test was used for comparison of two groups of
marrow biopsy and aspirate for follow-up evaluation. patients.
BM Histopathology and Severe Aplastic Anaemia 441
Fig 1.Methylmethacrylate-embeddedbone marrow biopsies, stained with periodic acid Schiff. (a) Biopsy of a patient with severe aplastic anaemia
showing only remnants of erythropoiesis with clustering of mature forms without atypia. (b) Area of dyserythropoiesis (abnormal nuclei and
dissociation of nucleus-cytoplasm ratio) in the follow-up biopsy of the same patient as in (a). (c) Abnormal myelopoiesis with many immature
forms and monocytoid cells. (d) Abnormal megakaryocytes in the follow-up biopsies of previously severe aplastic marrows with trilinear
dysplastic features.
Died Survived
C 6 months > 6 months Total
(n=13) (n = 48) (n=61)
Haematopoiesis
‘Genuine’aplasia 10 37 47
Intermediate/hypoplastic
myelodysplasia 3 11 14 P=0.626
Grade of inflammation.
Grade I and I1 5 21 26
Grade I11 8 26 34 P=0.470
No. of mast cells
Normal or slightly increased 7 35 42
Increased 6 13 19 P=0.163