Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
1 Introduction
collaborate in the enterprise either while developing the design and later in the manage‐
ment of the building [2]. Future engineers should be trained in the large spectrum allowed
by BIM methodology.
One important competence of teaching is to promote the introduction of new knowl‐
edge that can enrich the student. In this sense the teacher must analyze the best method
of providing knowledge to the student. One of the methods is to drive the direction of
masters’ theses for the topic, BIM, in order to be able to explore the different applications
that the engineer can perform with the available BIM tools [3]. The BIM theme was
introduced in the Civil Engineering Department only 3 years ago and it is offered to
students of the first curricular year. As so, at this level only the handling of basic BIM
tool is taught. Senior students have a better understanding of what is the activity of the
engineer and some idea that the BIM methodology has been applied in all sectors all
over the world. So it is important that the finalists’ student earn that competence before
leaving school.
Several aspects were study within MSc researches in order to generate nD/BIM
models focuses on a wide perspective of the BIM used in the construction industry. The
main objective of the presented education strategy is to add competitive skills in the
training of future architects and civil engineers [4]. The text describes several research
works developed by MSc students, remarking the positive achievements and contributes
to the construction field. As the works developed by MSc students, are normally the
first contact with BIM, the study cases projects are of low complexity, and the range of
studied situations, are of course limited in order to achieve academic reports with the
depth and extension appropriate.
The implementation of BIM covers various sectors of the construction industry [5]. The
text presents several uses of the BIM model to support the analysis of inconsistency
between disciplines, the planning and construction management, the take-off of quan‐
tities of material and the structural design process. All were developed in an educational
context. Based on the presentation of studies applied to real situations there were iden‐
tified the main benefits and limitations in the generation of nD/BIM models. The nD
directions of the BIM use are based on a proper relationship and collaboration among
team members in order to optimize the process of development of the project [6]. The
required collaboration is based on features provided by a sustained methodology and an
effective interoperability of BIM tools.
The capabilities that have been demonstrated in recent reports, together with the
dissemination of technological advances achievements, should be known by the users.
The school, within its educational mission, has the role of encouraging the students,
future engineers and architects, to acquire new knowledge on BIM issue. So, the future
engineers and architects should obtain new knowledge concerning BIM concept and
multiuse. In the context of the education activity in a Civil Engineering and Architectural
school some topics of BIM application were developed by students within MSc research
works [7]. The present text describes several of these research works. The students have
416 A. Z. Sampaio
Fig. 1. nD/BIM didactic models – structural design, management and construction planning,
maintenance, conflict analyses and materials take-off.
The objective with the introduction of BIM methodology, at the last level of the
student’s school training, is to enable the future engineer with basic knowledge: in
handling BIM tools and in learning how to use them for running usual work, normally
developed based in traditional software. In this context, the study cases are real-projects
but the focus to be analyzed is selected in order give to each student a unique perspective
to follow (structures, planning construction or takeoff material).
BIM Applications in an Education Context 417
On the representation a vertical cut, the location of the intersection plane is shown
over a plan view (intersection plan line, name and guidance). The plant drawing that is
automatically obtained contains a reduced amount of information. The BIM tool allows
adding the missing information such as dimensions and designation of each room and
correspondent area [10]. In addition, vertical cuts can be applied over the 3D/BIM model.
It allows to shown in a perspective view the interior of the building and the graphical
representation of each material (Fig. 3).
The graphic documentation set that can be obtained from the model is one of the
advantages of BIM, when compared with the traditional process, emphasizing the ability
of automation, updating, adding details, and material composition of elements. To this
BIM Applications in an Education Context 419
In a second research work performed by Oliveira [8], after doing the safety check
for structural elements and the detailing of rebar in Robot, it was necessary to transfer
all the information back for the BIM model, but this process is still very limited (Fig. 5):
• Regarding the slab, Revit does not recognize the rebar information exported by
Robot. It is however possible, to create a dwg file in Robot, specifying the detail
drawings of reinforcement;
• The transposition process of information related to beam details between the calcu‐
lation and modeling software admits some degree of integration; however, the results
are still not satisfactory. It becomes necessary to set directly in Revit, the rebar on
each beam. There are still many limitations to full integration between Revit and
Robot;
• Contrary to what occurs for beams, the exportation of detailed rebar information for
columns between Robot and Revit is carried out without any difficulties. This takes
importance if a higher level of detail is desirable and for the account of material;
• For the foundation beams some problems occur when exporting detail information
about the reinforcement and it should be considered the correct splices of rebar in
the connection between columns and foundations to improve the quality of drawings.
The BIM methodology and tools associated with it present themselves as an excellent
asset to support the process of conflict analysis, as they make it possible to merge all
disciplines in an integrated virtual environment, the 3D/BIM model. The aim of the
study conducted by [9] was to evaluate the practical capabilities of the BIM concept in
the conflict analysis between building services, namely, the water supply and drainage
BIM Applications in an Education Context 421
systems design, and the architectural and structural design. As such, it was developed a
3D/BIM model containing the components: architecture, structures and building serv‐
ices. The model was analyzed oriented to the clash detection between elements from all
disciplines and for that the Clash Detective function in Revit was used. This work
contributes to demonstrate the advantages of BIM in the conciliation and coordination
between different specialties, as well as the benefits of its application in conflict analysis
in an engineering design.
The BIM tools admit to overlap three design disciplines and support the analyses of
conflicts verified between elements belonging to distinct disciplines. There are appli‐
cations such as Tekla BIMsight, Solibri Model Checker or Navisworks with additional
capabilities aimed at conflict analysis. The algorithm of conflict detection can evaluate
two modes of inconsistency:
• Conflict detection based on geometry consists in checking for intersections between
3D elements of different specialties;
• Analyze based on rules that allow to detect cases that do not check for compliance
with regulations or rules previously defined by the user (minimum distance between
elements or the space for people circulation may not be obstructed by systems
elements).
Tekla BIMsight can be used on the analysis between the specialties Mechanical,
Electrical, and Plumbing (MEP) and structures. First, the two components, both created
in a BIM modeler software, must be are exported to Tekla, in IFC compatible format.
The two models are then overlapped and the conflict detection is activated by selecting
the rule named MEP vs Structure. A list of points of conflicts is returned from the anal‐
ysis. The perspective of Fig. 6 allows the visualization of several collision points marked
with a symbol.
Then, it must be carried out a detailed analysis of each occurrence because duplicate
events can be considered and some conflicts are inevitability. The conflicting situations
adjustments cannot be carried out directly in Tekla BIMsight, which constitutes a limi‐
tation of most of the BIM viewers, and corrections must be performed in a BIM modeler
tool (Fig. 7).
422 A. Z. Sampaio
The 4D/model allows the visual simulation of the building construction. It allows
the detection of eventual conflict in work and supports the definition of logistics planning
in the shipyard and the coordination of the equipment and material supply. The appli‐
cation is easily manipulated using mobile devices at the construction site. The real
BIM Applications in an Education Context 423
construction and the planed process can be compared. In accordance with the specific
situation found the 4D/BIM model admits to update the timeline (delays and advances),
the inclusion of new elements and the redefinition of groups associated with each
task [18].
The analysis of energy sustainability performed over a BIM model is named a 6D/BIM
application. One of the factors to consider in selecting particular constructive system is
the ability to reduce energy consumption in a building, providing, at the same time, the
conditions of comfort required.
Regarding the environmental behavior simulation, Revit allows the user to transfer
the 3D/BIM model, using the IFC format, to other software such as Ecotec, Equest or
Energyplus [10]. Revit includes Green Building Studio functionality that allows the
energy simulation, on the BIM model. So, in an initial design the decision-making can
be substantiated in a comparative analysis of results relating to environmental perform‐
ance, reducing carbon dioxide emissions and economic energy consumption [19]. The
parameter concerning the thermal transmission coefficient is a characteristic of the
objects of the BIM model. This fiscal characteristic of the objects is used on the energetic
simulation performed by the software. Thus, the results may be obtained from the energy
simulation, and at different stages of the project (Fig. 9).
In a building during an inspection visit, the engineer can manipulate the BIM model
using a mobile device. The Navisworks allows incorporating both the BIM model and
the inspection application. Then when the user is faced with an anomaly, detected over
a component of the real building, can select the corresponding model element, and can:
• Consult the composition of the element (thickness and material of each layer), and
the relevant parameters for maintenance that have been associated to the respective
parametric object;
• Run the inspection program and fill out an inspection sheet, including photographs
taken in the real building;
• Archive the inspection sheet in pdf format and link the report to the correspondent
BIM model element.
Once completed the inspection visit to the building and linked each anomaly report
to the model (Fig. 11), the engineering, supported in the information allowed by the BIM
model, can draw up a sustainable rehabilitation work or a preventive maintenance plane.
426 A. Z. Sampaio
4 Conclusions
The report exposes several aspects of BIM methodology, from the generation of
3D/BIM models to the definition of 7D/BIM models. The use of BIM methodology for
the development of construction management emerged several situations that expose
the benefits of using BIM. So, the potential of BIM to support a transformation of the
processes of design and construction has been evident and reported in the multi-sectors
described.
Concerning the 3D/BIM model the automatic definition of drawings and sections,
the analyses of conflict between disciplines and the structural analyses support in the
methodology were described and the main benefits and limitations were worked out.
During the creation and usage of 4D/5D/6D/7D BIM models, some very positive points
where found, from which the following ones are highlighted: The ability to visualize
the schedule and the 4D simulation show that Navisworks can be a useful tool to support
the project planning, in a collaborative environment, as intended in the BIM method‐
ology; the BIM model allows obtaining tables covering several fields concerning surface
area of the elements, volume of materials, individual and global cost (5D/BIM model);
Revit includes the Green Building Studio plugin a functionality that allows the energy
simulation (6D/BIM model), in an initial design, allowing a comparative analysis of
results relating to environmental performance, reducing carbon dioxide emissions and
economic energy consumption; the developed 7D/BIM application demonstrates clearly
how BIM can support building inspections when integrated with a BIM viewer.
The text enabled the knowledge of the subject BIM within an education context but
oriented to the real activity. Research on the subject has exposed several objects of study
covering BIM, from its origin to its application in the Construction sector, seeking to
know the reasons for his development and how this methodology has been developed.
The multiuse methodology applied over the 3D/BIM model becomes very clear to the
new professionals as the students developed different nD/BIM models within their
research works. The main objective of this strategy was to add skills in the training of
future architects and civil engineers, in an innovative area of growing demand in the
BIM Applications in an Education Context 427
national and international construction. After the student perform successfully the study
set out to achieve, the young engineer has the ability, in a project, to carry out an adequate
analysis of the application of the methodology BIM and of what resources he can use
in its development. Of course, as each student studied only one perspective of the BIM
application, he will meet better the scope he studied. But the BIM concept and use are
cross at any direction of BIM and the student has the necessary knowledge to develop
BIM also in other areas of work.
References
1. Azhar, S., Hein, M., Sketo, B.: Building information modeling (BIM): benefits, risks and
challenges (2008). http://ascpro.ascweb.org/chair/paper/CPGT182002008.pdf. Accessed 09
Jan 2018
2. Eadie, R., Browne, M., Odeyinka, H., McKeown, C., McNiff, S.: BIM implementation
throughout the UK construction project life-cycle: an analysis. Autom. Constr. 36, 145–151
(2013). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2013.09.001. Accessed 09 Jan 2018
3. Sampaio, A.Z., Berdeja, E.P.: Collaborative BIM environment as a support to conflict analysis
in building design. In: 4th Experiment@ International Conference 2017 - exp.at’17, Faro,
Portugal (2017). Accessed 09 Jan 2018. ISBN 978-989-99894-0-5
4. Sampaio, A.Z., Simões, D.: Maintenance of buildings supported on BIM methodology. In:
XIV DBMC - Durability of Building Materials and Components (paper DBMC-p083.pdf,
abst.), p. 83. RILEM Publications S.A.R.L., Ghent (2017). e-ISBN 978-2-35158-159-9
5. Succar, B., Sher, W., Williams, A.: An integrated approach to BIM competency assessment,
acquisition and application. Autom. Constr. 35, 174–189 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1016/
j.autcon.2013.05.016. Accessed 09 Jan 2018
6. Chen, L.J., Luo, H.: A BIM-based construction quality management model and its
applications. Autom. Constr. 46, 64–73 (2014). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.
2014.05.009. Accessed 09 Jan 2018
7. Sampaio, A.Z., Simões, D.G., Berdeja, E.P.: BIM tools used in maintenance of buildings and
on conflict detection. In: Delgado, J.M.P.Q. (ed.) Sustainable Construction. BPR, vol. 8, pp.
163–183. Springer, Singapore (2016). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-0651-7_8. ISBN
978-981-10-0651-7, Print ISBN 978-981-10-0650-0
8. Oliveira, J.D.: Analysis of the implementation of BIM in structural project. M.Sc. thesis in
Civil Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2016). (in Portuguese)
9. Berdeja, E.P.: Conflict analysis in a BIM base project. M.Sc. thesis in Civil Engineering,
University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2014). (in Portuguese)
10. Araújo, L.: Development of a walls’ library to BIM methodology. M.Sc. thesis in Civil
Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2016). (in Portuguese)
11. Mota, C.: 4D Model in construction planning based on BIM technology. M.Sc. thesis in Civil
Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2015). (in Portuguese)
12. Silva, D.: Construction management supported on a BIM model. M.Sc. thesis in Civil
Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2015). (in Portuguese)
13. Silva, B.: BIM methodology as a support to the quantity take-off from projects. M.Sc. thesis
in Civil Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2016). (in Portuguese)
14. Simões, D.G.: Maintenance of buildings supported on BIM model. M.Sc. thesis in Civil
Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2013). (in Portuguese)
428 A. Z. Sampaio
15. Gu, N., London, K.: Understanding and facilitating BIM adoption in the AEC industry.
Autom. Constr. 19, 988–999 (2010). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2010.09.002.
Accessed 09 Jan 2018
16. Sampaio, A.Z.: BIM model - generation of architectural model. Didactic text of syllabus
Computer Aided Design, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2017). (in Portuguese)
17. Azevedo, V.: BIM model analysis in the structural design perspective. M.Sc. thesis in Civil
Engineering, University of Lisbon, Portugal (2014). (in Portuguese)
18. Sampaio, A.Z., Mota, C.: BIM model of structures used in construction planning. In: National
Meeting of Structural Concrete, Coimbra, Portugal, vol. 4, 10 p. (2016). (in Portuguese).
http://be2016.dec.uc.pt/. Accessed 09 Jan 2018
19. Coelho, E.: Establishment of parametric objects in BIM floors applied in buildings. M.Sc.
thesis in Civil Engineering, University of Lisbon, Lisbon (2017). (in Portuguese)