Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Group #3
Members:
• Goldielyn Limsiy
• Mica Honasan
• Nikki Nava
• Katie Kim
• Michael Yap
• Sharlaine Sy
I. Introduction
• There is a misconception in the public where most people believe that bottled water is
safer and "healthier" than tap or filtered water. This misconception has caused many
• To raise awareness on the threats of bottled water to human health and the
environment
• To dispel the commonly held misconception that bottled water is better than water
filter
• Removes the misconception that bottled water is the best and healthiest alternative
bottled water
• Promotes environmental friendly methods in bottling our water
• Limited to the Philippine setting, with its focus mainly on Metro Manila, given that it is
highly populated and more developed compared to other regions in the country.
There are basically five kinds of bottled water: purified water, drinking water, flourinated
water, natural source water, and specialty water. The source water for the first three types-
purified water, drinking water, and flourinated water - is municipal, or city water, the same
In the illustration below, the bottling company will typically filter the water to remove dirt
The next step is to filter the water through multi-barrier sources which could include
source protections, source monitoring, reverse osmosis, ultraviolet light, distillation, micron
filtration and ozonation. Water bottlers may use one or more of those processes.
Demineralization is where positively charged ions like calcium, magnesium and sodium
are removed by the cation bed whereas negatively charged ions like sulfate and chloride are
Aeration as the name suggests introduces air into the water, in particular oxygen. The
oxygen metabolize micro organisms, reduce carbon dioxide as well as it removes methane
and hydrogen sulphide. It improves the smell of the water making it good to drink. Aeration
is a particularly good where water has a high iron and manganese content, removing the
After having its minerals removed water tastes "flat," so for the two kinds of water that
are sold for drinking - drinking water and flourinated water - some minerals are readded to
improve taste. For flourinated water only, flouride is also added to the water. As the final
step before bottling, all three types are isinfected by ozone or ultraviolet light.
Purified water may also be labeled distilled water, water for distillation uses, de-ionized
processes, each of these labels indicates that the water has had essentially all of its
minerals removed and none readded. So in the sense of there being nothing in it but water,
this is the purest water. However, the relevant point is not how "pure" it is, but whether or not
The majority believe that bottled water has some health benefits, but that they’re not
necessarily significant or superior to the benefits provided by tap water. Convenience and
taste were more influential factors when deciding to buy a bottle of water.
A small study has shown that people tend to believe that bottled water is somehow
healthier than water from the tap. However, the research also shows that people are unsure
1. Purified drinking water this type of water has been processed to remove chlorine and
named unless it is untreated public source of water. Basically, they are all types of water
2. Water fluoridation the controlled addition of fluoride to a public water supply to reduce
tooth decay. Fluoridated water has fluoride at a level that is effective for preventing
4. Drinking water – (also called potable water) is water of sufficiently high quality that it can
5. Natural source water - this is naturally carbonated from a spring or artesian well.
6. Demineralization - The loss, deprivation, or removal of minerals or mineral salts from the
body, especially through disease, as the loss of calcium from bones or teeth.
7. Aeration - (also called aerification) is the process by which air is circulated through,
electrical voltages.
12.Ion - an atom or molecule in which the total number of electrons is not equal to the total
IV. Discussions
A. “Healthy Water”
While every health and wellness expert will agree on the importance of "healthy water,"
most have different opinions on its definition and source. But the fact is that it's no longer an
opinion. There's now enough scientific data on the subject for a logical and reasonable
conclusion.
The healthiest water doesn't come from your tap, it doesn't come in a bottle, it doesn't
Many have switched to bottled water under the false assumption that its purity is assured
to be better than tap. The truth is that bottled water is only required to be "as good as" tap...
not better. Bottled water, due to several factors, is clearly not a healthier or purer alternative
to tap water. Also, bottled water is outrageously expensive when compared to the cost per
gallon of tap water. Despite all these, bottled water is currently the fastest-growing and most
over the quality and safety of tap water that sparked the growth of the bottled water industry
are still entirely present. Tap water is nowhere near free from dangerous contaminants. But
there is an innovative solution to the problems of low water quality that has come about in
the form of water filters. Water filters currently provide the best and healthiest solution to the
Water filters have a long history as a method of water purification, beginning as early as
2000 b.c. in ancient Egypt. Filtration has evolved from the simple Hippocratic sleeve of
ancient Greece, made from cloth, to the complicated solid block carbon and multimedia
water filters currently on the market. It is now the premier method of water purification,
The Process:
The filtration process involves some type of filter media, over which water flows. This
varies widely, but the most effective medias are made from carbon or a combination of
carbon with other elements. Modern filtration technology allows water filters to remove more
and more contaminants through the chemical process of adsorption. In the adsorption
process, contaminants are encouraged to break their bond with water molecules and
chemically adhere to the filter media. Generally, water goes through several stages of
filtration to ensure that each filter media will remove the ultimate number of contaminants.
Water normally passes through a water filter at a relatively low speed, in order to ensure
adequate contact time with the filter media. Once the water has passed through the required
Water filters are not limited in the type or size of contaminants they can remove. Thus,
water filters are able to remove far more contaminants than any other purification method.
Also, because they use the chemical adsorption process, water filters can selectively retain
As of now, filtration is the only purification method that is capable of removing chlorine,
chlorine byproducts, and VOCs from drinking water. Chlorine and VOCs are the most
dangerous and threatening contaminants of municipally treated drinking water. Besides the
removal of these dangerous chemicals, water filters also extract from drinking water the
chlorine-resistant protozoa giardia and cryptosporidium. These protozoa have plagued the
water treatment industry for several decades and have caused a number of epidemics of
Also, water filters, because they do not require the costly energy sources of reverse
osmosis and distillation, provide a source of relatively inexpensive, purified water. Aside
from that, water filters waste very little water, as compared to other methods.
Yet, although it has been scientifically proven that filtered water is better, many people
still believe that the healthiest water comes in a bottle due to the hype and expensive ad
campaigns. Companies like Coca-Cola and PepsiCo, with their Dasani and Aquafina bottled
water products, spend millions of dollars on ads that depict freshness and purity; when in
fact both of these brands, like many leading brands, use municipally treated tap water as
their source.
It is unrealistic to think that water can be bottled in PET (or PETE) bottles, produced at a
bottling factory, transported and stored at high temperatures for months at a time and be
purer than what a basic home water filtration system can provide. After all, plastic is made
from chemicals and the water that fills them can then sit for long periods of time at high
Figure 1:
Pollutants in Walmart and Giant Bottled Water Exceed Industry and California Standards
Figure 2.
testosterone and other hormones, can leach into bottled water over time. One study found
that water that had been stored for 10 weeks in plastic and in glass bottles contained
phthalates, suggesting that the chemicals could be coming from the plastic cap or liner.
Although there are regulatory standards limiting phthalates in tap water, there are no legal
limits for phthalates in bottled water -- the bottled water industry waged a successful
campaign opposing the FDA proposal to set a legal limit for these chemicals. Aside from
that, plastic bottles contain BPA. It’s now widely known that BPA mimics the female
hormone estrogen and may affect fertility and promote cancer. And just last year it came out
that BPA may also lead to heart disease, diabetes, and liver problems. As such, it is
- It takes 3 times as much water to produce the bottle as it does to fill it. This is the same
bottle that has an 80% chance of ending its long life in a landfill.
- Transporting dense, heavy containers of water throughout the world uses fossil fuels and is
responsible
-Only about 20% of plastic bottles will end up being recycled, a process which requires the
use of petroleum, more water and often the cost of transport overseas for the recycling
-Plastic takes over 300 years to degrade in nature. Think of it this way, each of the
thousands of bottles thrown away today will outlive us all at least 3 times over.
On the other hand, basic home water filtration is more convenient, produces higher
quality water and costs a fraction of what bottled water costs. "10 times the quality, 1/10th
Consistency - When you purchase a water filter, you know exactly how clean your water
is. This allows you to decide how serious you are about filtered water, then buy a system to
instructions when you replace your filters, you will drink clean water.
Freedom - Filtering your own water eliminates the unknown and frees you from reliance
A better end product - Filtering your own tap water provides double protection; not only
about a dollar apiece, a water habit is an expensive one. Installing a filtration system can
Peace of Mind - Beyond the money saved, drinking filtered water vs. bottled water is
better for the environment and better for the people you love.
At this point in time, there is simply no better choice-for purity and economy-than filtered
water.
GLOSSARY OF TERMS:
in a boiling liquid mixture. This is done through a process of heating a liquid until it
boils. Afterwards, they capture and cool the resultant hot vapors, and collect the
molecules and ions from solutions by applying pressure to the solution when it is on
one side of a selective membrane. The result is that the solute retained on the
pressurized side of the membrane and the pure solvent is allowed to pass to the
other side. To be "selective," this membrane should not allow large molecules or ions
through the pores (holes), but should allow smaller components of the solution (such
3. Selective Filtration involves separating a single flow into two streams, one more
concentrated than the other, by using pressure to selectively pass material through a
semi-permeable physical barrier called a membrane. The separate streams can then
has the ability to separate particulates from the dissolved species or separating
the filtration process can isolate dissolved species of specific sizes while allowing
4. Hippocratic sleeve a woolen bag of a square piece of flannel, having the opposite
5. Solid block carbon mechanically strains out dirt, sediment, rust, algae, bacteria,
designed to mechanically filter particles down to sub micron size. By micro- straining
the water, the consumer is assured that only the cleanest, clearest water is delivered
to the point-of-use.
to an exposed solid surface. Such attraction forces (adhesion or cohesion) align the
7. Trace Minerals minerals, required in much smaller levels by our bodies, but no
less important to good overall health. Trace minerals are usually found at
extraordinarily small levels in our bodies, in the parts per million range. In spite of the
relatively low concentrations of these minerals, scientists are discovering that they
play an increasingly vital role in our health, including the health of our bones and
joints.
8. Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) refers to organic chemical compounds which
have significant vapor pressures and which can affect the environment and human
one side of the cell body) that colonize and reproduce in the small intestines of
through the fecal-oral route, often through contaminated water; the main symptom is
polyester family and is used in synthetic fibers; beverage, food and other liquid
12.Phthalates- esters of phthalic acid and are mainly used as plasticizers (substances
13.FDA (Food and Drug Administration) an agency of the United States Department
of Health and Human Services, one of the United Stated federal executive
departments, responsible for protecting and promoting public health through the
14.BPA (Bisphenol A) an organic compound with two phenol functional groups used
to make polycarbonate plastic and epoxy resins, along with other applications.
Known to be estrogenic since the mid 1930s, concerns about the use of bisphenol A
in consumer products were regularly reported in the news media in 2008 after
several governments issued reports questioning its safety, A 2010 report from the
United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) raised further concerns regarding
The plastic bottles are made up of materials that are generally recyclable. IBWA has
been involved in supporting recycling initiatives to try and increase the number of water
bottles that are recycled, adding that two-thirds of bottled water is consumed at home, work
-Despite the number of bottles that end up in landfills, however, he says PET bottles
represent only a third of 1 percent (.0033) of all trash. Also, bottled water companies have
done their part to reduce the amount of PET resin in bottles by 40 percent over the last five
years.
A recent analysis performed by the Beverage Marketing Corporation (BMC) shows that
over the past eight years the average gram weight of the 16.9 ounce “single serve” bottled
water container has dropped by 32.6% which means, less plastic. This is called container
light-weighting.
IBWA also recently commissioned a Life Cycle Inventory (LCI) study to determine the
environmental footprint of the United States bottled water industry. They found that:
• Bottled water packaging discards accounted for only 0.64 percent of the 169 million
• Small pack bottled water generates 46 percent less CO2 eq. when compared to soft
Bottled water companies work hard to utilize and manage water resources in a
responsible manner by
• bottling and disposing of packaged water products in ways that best serve the
environment.
2. Argument in response to claims that plastic water bottles add to the contamination of the
bottled water
Pay attention to the type of plastic your water bottle is made of to ensure that the
chemicals in the plastic do not leach into the water. If you taste plastic, you are drinking it,
so get yourself another bottle. To be certain that you are choosing a bottle that does not
leach, check the recycling symbol on your bottle. If it is a #2 HDPE (high density
bottle is fine. Let the Plastic Identification Code guide you in your choices accordingly. As
such, you have a choice whether or not you will use plastic water bottles that is safe to drink
from or if you will use plastic water bottles that may leach chemicals into your water.
Price caps on bottled water proposed -in case of emergencies or calamities where
bottled water is needed (for example, Typhoon Ondoy, some traders reportedly made
money by raising the price of bottled water). As such, cheaper bottled water can actually be
found on the market nowadays. You just have to look for it.
GLOSSARY OF TERMS:
3. Life Cycle Inventory also known as life cycle analysis, ecobalance, and cradle-to-
grave analysis. This is the investigation and evaluation of the environmental impacts of a
4. Municipal solid waste (MSW) also called urban solid waste, is a waste type that
includes predominantly household waste (domestic waste) with sometimes the addition
of commercial wastes collected by a municipality within a given area. They are in either
solid or semisolid form and generally exclude industrial hazardous wastes. The term
residual waste relates to waste left from household sources containing materials that
and containers – the resin coding system offered a means of identifying the resin content
Pitcher Filters
This is an inexpensive, convenient and effective way to improve taste and color of your
water while reducing up to 99% of the chlorine in drinking water. Some water filter pitchers
can filter up to 2000 gallons of water on a single filter replacement cartridge and because
they have multiple stages of water filtration, can remove hundreds of contaminants from
water.
Water filter pitchers are good at filtering drinking water but are generally impractical for
filtering water that will be used in cooking since they can only filter about 10 cups of water
before they need to be refilled and the filtration takes several minutes to complete.
Pitcher Filters kept in your refrigerator are a convenient way of providing cool, clean
drinking water and they are small and convenient enough that they can also be taken along
on camping trips.
The most popular brands of pitcher filters are Brita pitchers and Pur Ultimate pitchers.
Pitcher filters range from 15 to 30 dollars depending on features and water capacity. (680-
1,360 pesos)
Faucet Mounted Filters
This cleans the water coming out of your faucets. Great tasting drinking water will be
only a faucet away after you install a filter. Many people choose bottled water for their
drinking water, but this expense can add up fast. Others choose not to go this route because
bottles are inconvenient. A faucet mount water filter can save you the money on bottled
water, making healthy water within easy reach of your family. Plus, it can be used not only
for drinking but for any other activity using water. The safety of your cooking water is often
overlooked, even for those drinking bottled water. A filter will ensure that any water you use
is clean and healthy. Many people overlook the dangers of using unclean water for anything
besides drinking. For example, you use water everyday for cooking, cleaning, or feeding to
the family pet. A faucet mount water filter can guard you against these dangers when you
A faucet mount water filter is easy to install on your kitchen or bathroom faucet,
providing plenty of drinking water. Many people are concerned about the filter getting in the
way of their kitchen activities, but actually a faucet mounted filter leaves you plenty of room
to use your sinks. Plus, they come in stylish white or stainless steel designs to easily blend
plenty of clean, clear, and healthy water for drinking, cooking, cleaning, or other household
activities. A faucet mounted water filter is capable of removing chlorine, sediment, heavy
metals, and hundreds of other contaminants. These contaminants often change the taste or
smell of your tap water. However, even if you live in an area with relatively good tap water,
When choosing a faucet mount water filter, it’s important to select one that removes the
contaminants present in your specific water supply. For best results, choose one with
Popular brands include Brita, Pur, and Omni. Prices range from 20 to 40 dollars. (907-
1,814 pesos)
An under-the-sink water filter leaves your counter top clean and your faucet head
unfettered. It's an elegant solution to water filtration, but a more complex one than faucet-
mounted or pitcher units. It requires slightly more time, but is worth the streamlined
approach to filtration.
The filtration unit mounts under your sink, out of sight. Water supply is gained by
attaching a simple assembly to your cold water supply pipe (copper or plastic). You will have
to drill a hole in your countertop or sink frame to attach the attractive chrome-finished long-
reach faucet. It is a relatively easy do-it-yourself project, or if you prefer, you can have it
Popular brands include Omni, Everpure, and Pur. Prices range from 200 to 300 dollars.
(9,069-13,604 pesos)
Countertop Distillers
Distilled water has many advantages over ordinary tap water. Distillation is the process
of converting water into steam by boiling. During boiling, the micro-organisms present in the
water are killed and the minerals present in the water are left behind. This will give you the
safest and purest form of water. Distilled water can help cleanse away the extra minerals in
your body and this can ensure you to stay healthy. Countertop Distiller has been
manufactured to provide the purest form of water for your house hold or for your office.
Countertop distillers are designed and manufactured using the latest technologies to provide
four litres of water. The interior of the distiller consists of 4 litre capacity stainless steel
placed underneath the container to provide long life. During operation, the heater heats the
container which in turn heats the water to boiling temperature. Once the water is converted
into steam, the steam is then passed through a stainless steel condenser, which is
constantly circulated with forced fresh and cool air by a 15 W fan. This will condense the
water to its liquid form. The hot gases containing minerals are let out through the waste
holes, and the water collected from the condenser tube is perfectly crystal clear and pure.
There are several advantages with countertop distillers. It provides a 100 % safe
drinking water. The baked enamel exterior of the distiller is easy to clean. Being 100%
stainless steel, the steam chamber has long life and is also quite easy to clean. The carbon
filter will retain the taste of the water, and the distiller is quite safe to operate, with an all new
automatic switch off feature. You will be able to buy a countertop distiller from all the leading
Waterwise 8800, and Kenmore 34480. These range from 150-300 dollars. (6,802-13,604
pesos)
Countertop distilling process:
Bottled Water Is Expensive, but How Does This Apply to Us?
-Government Aid
-Subsidies
Subsidies may distort markets, and can impose large economic costs. Financial
assistance in the form of a subsidy may come from one's government, but the
term subsidy may also refer to assistance granted by others, such as individuals
or non-governmental institutions, although these would be more commonly
described as charity.
-Government Loans
Loans are a type of debt. Like all debt instruments, a loan entails the
redistribution of financial assets over time, between the lender and the borrower.
the principal, from the lender, and is obligated to pay back or repay an equal
amount of money to the lender at a later time. Typically, the money is paid back
as interest on the debt, which provides an incentive for the lender to engage in
the loan. In a legal loan, each of these obligations and restrictions is enforced
by contract.
-Donation Drives
places of worship.
2. FoodBank
-LifeStraw
This is a complementary point-of-use water filters designed by the Swiss-based
Vestergaard Frandsen for tourists and people living in developing nations. There are
several models of the product: LifeStraw Personal filters a maxium of 700 litres of
water, enough for one person for one year. LifeStraw Family filters a maximum of
18,000 litres of water, providing safe drinking water for a family for more than two years.
viruses.
V. Conclusions
• Cost
• Safety
• Environmental Impact
VI. Recommendations
We recommend:
• Water Filtration plants so that tap water can be potable for the consumption of the
VII. References
Golub, Catherine. (2001). Liquid assets: Is bottled water really better than what’s on tap?
(2). Shermer, Michael. (2003). Bottled twaddle. Scientific American, 289 (1).
Binnie, Chris, Kimber, Martin, & Smethurst, George. (2002). Basic water treatment (3rd ed.).
Rona, Zolton P. and Martin, Jeanne Marie. (1995). Return to the Joy of Health. Vancouver:
Alive Books.
BOTTLED WATER: Pure Drink or Pure Hype? a March 1999 report by the Natural
http://www.bottledwaterblues.com/bottled_water_vs_filtered_water.php
http://coffeetea.about.com/cs/water/bb/bybwater.htm
http://www.metaefficient.com/water-filters/best-water-filters.html
http://www.allwaterfiltrationsystems.com/
http://www.newdream.org/water/calculator.php
http://www.xe.com/ucc/
http://www.wateronline.com/article.mvc/The-Water-Is-Life-Straw-A-Global-Clean-Water-
0001?VNETCOOKIE=NO
http://www.vestergaard-frandsen.com/lifestraw
www.bottledwaterblues.com/bottled_water_facts.php
http://coffeetea.about.com/cs/water/bb/bybwater.htm
http://www.metaefficient.com/water-filters/best-water-filters.html
http://www.allwaterfiltrationsystems.com/
http://www.newdream.org/water/calculator.php
http://www.xe.com/ucc/
http://www.wateronline.com/article.mvc/The-Water-Is-Life-Straw-A-Global-Clean-Water-
0001?VNETCOOKIE=NO
http://www.vestergaard-frandsen.com/lifestraw
www.foodandwaterwatch.org/water/bottled
www.bottledwatermatters.org
www.allaboutwater.org
http://www.freedrinkingwater.com/water-education3/31-water-bottled-water-purification-
process.htm
http://www.bottledwaterweb.com/articlesdetail.do?k=111