DOCUMENT RESUME
ED 462 681 cs 014 625
TITLE Effective Literature Instruction Develops Thinking Skills.
INSTITUTION National Research Center on English Learning and
Achievement, Albany, NY.
SFONS AGENCY Office of Educational Research and Improvement (ED),
Washington, DC
PUB DATE 2001-00-00
NOTE 6p.; Adapted from "Improving Literary Understanding through
Classroom Conversation" (see CS 014 624)
conTRAcT R305A60005; R117G10015
AVAILABLE FROM National Research Center on English Learning and
Achievement, University at Albany, State University of New
York, 1400 Washington Avenue, Albany, NY 12222. Tel:
518-442-5026; Fax: 518-442-5933; e-mail:
celagesc.albany.edu; Web site: http://cela.albany.edu.
PUB TYPE Reports = Descriptive (141)
EDRS PRICE MP01/PCO1 Plus Postage.
DESCRIPTORS ‘critical Reading; "Discussion (Teaching Technique) ;
Elementary Secondary Education; Instructional Effectiveness;
‘Interpretive Skills; Literature Appreciation; *Teacher
Role; *Thinking Skille
IDENTIFIERS Purpose (Reading)
ABSTRACT
Whereas reading for information requires finding a sense of
the topic early in the reading and then searching for new information with
reference to that topic, literary reading is in a constant state of flux
Four stances describe how accomplished readers interact with a given text:
(2) people bring what they know fxom their reading and experiences to their
reading of the new text, seeking enough essential information to “step in” to
the text and form initial interpretations; (2) as people think, write about,
or discuss a literary work, they "move through" the text, exploring
possibilities and developing deeper understandings; (3) often emerging
uderstandings prompt reflection on the world beyond the text--sometimes
people "step out and rethink," using ideas they have gotten from the text to
inform their interpretations of their known world; and (4) at other times,
people distance thenselves from the reading experience, the text itself, and
the understandings they have developed--here they “step out and inspect” the
text for purposes of analysis, comparison, or other critical examination
Students are supported in developing literary interpretations when teachers
focus the discussion on students' ideas and questions; show them ways to
discuss and ways to think; ask questions that move students to different
stances; and foster student awareness and control of their "envisionments." A
possible sequence for guiding literature discussions is to: invite students
to read the text, responding in any way that helps them; tap readers' first
impressions after all have finished reading; continue to keep readers’
ideas/questions at the center of the discussion; and end the discussion by
taking stock of ideas. (NKA)
Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made
from the original document.CSO[4G6a5
ED 462 681
Effective Literature Instruction Develops
Thinking Skills
National Research Center on English
Learning & Achievement
BEST COPY AVAILABLECS 014 625
Effective
literature
instruction
ave Lops
thinlsisg,
guy)
SUCUULS
‘quage arts education te
us that:
[wren chitéren have daily,
thought provoking
experiences with all kinds
of literature, their under-
standing becomes more
varied and complex: and
Liwhen those experi
ences include substan-
tive discussions with
others, students learning
is further enhanced
(CELA). This brief highlights some of these re-
ee eee