Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
4: Market Failure
Definitions
1. Market failure occurs when resources aren’t allocated in an optimal manner, meaning
that the market isn’t allocatively efficient, and community surplus isn’t maximized.
2. Negative externalities are the ‘bad’ effects that are suffered by the third party, for which
the third party doesn’t get compensated, when a good or service is produced or
consumed.
3. Positive externalities are the beneficial effects that are enjoyed by a third party, but not
paid for by the third party, when a good or service is produced or consumed.
4. Demerit goods are goods or services considered to be harmful to people who consume
them and to society as a whole, that would be over-provided by the free market and so
over-consumed.
5. Merit goods are goods or services considered to be beneficial for people who use them
and society as a whole, that would be under-provided by the free market and so under-
consumed.
6. Tradable permits is a market-based solution to negative externalities of production. They
are permits to pollute, issued by government, which sets a maximum amount of pollution
allowable. Firms may trade these permits for money.
7. Public goods are goods or services which would be under-provided or not provided at all
by the free market. They are non-excludable and non-rivalrous, making it pointless for
private individuals to provide the good themselves.
8. Sustainability/Sustainable development is where consumption needs of the present
generation are met without reducing the ability to meet the needs of future generations.
4, Existence of externalities
● Production or consumption of a product have an effect on a third party.
● When marginal social cost (MSC) = marginal social benefit (MSB), the market reaches
full social efficiency and maximum surplus.
● If that’s not the case, then it leads to market failure and inefficient allocation of resources.
Negative externalities
1. Of production
● Occurs when the production of a product creates external costs that are harmful for third
parties. Examples include environmental problems.
● Happens when marginal social cost (MSC) > marginal private cost (MPC) + external
costs.
● MPC is below MSC because of the extra cost to society caused by things like pollution.
● The space between Q* and Q1 is a welfare loss to society because MSC > MSB.
● Solutions:
○ Government could tax the firm in order to increase the firm’s costs → Shifts
the MPC curve upwards.
○ Ban polluting firms or restrict their output in some way.
○ Governments could pass laws to meet the environment standards for firms
that pollute → Increasing the firm’s private costs.
○ Governments could issue tradable permits → Allows the government to
control pollution.
○ If a firm pollutes less than they allowed, they can sell permits and make money.
● Costs of implementing the solutions:
○ It is difficult to measure the pollution created and difficult to identify which firms
pollute and how much they pollute the environment.
○ Ban/restriction of output can lead to job losses and non-consumption of a valuable
product.
○ Cost of setting up and policing standards > Cost of the pollution.
○ If a firm pollutes more than they allowed, they can buy permits and it would raise
their costs.
○ Tradable permits and taxes doesn’t necessarily reduce pollution as firms and
individuals still continue to do the action, regardless of paying a higher price.
2. Of consumption
● ‘Bad’ effects suffered by third parties due to consumers consuming the product.
● Examples include cigarettes, cars, loud music and noise pollution.
● Happens where marginal social benefits (MSB) < marginal private benefits (MPB)
Positive externalities
1. Of production
● Occurs when production of a product leads to benefits for third parties.
● Examples include training employees.
● Happens where marginal private cost (MPC) > marginal social cost (MSC).
2. Of consumption
● Occurs when consumption of a product provides external benefits to third parties.
● Examples include health care and education.
● Happens where marginal social benefit (MSB) > marginal private benefit (MPB).
● There is a welfare gain because MSB > MPB.
● Solutions:
○ Subsidize services such as health care → Shifts MSC curve to the right →
Reaches the socially efficient level of consumption.
○ Advertize health care to encourage people to use them more → Shifts the MPB
curve to the right → Increase welfare.
○ Governments could pass laws for vaccinations and health checks if they provide it
for free.
● Costs of implementing the solutions:
○ Developing countries might face a problem with providing subsidies due to lack
of resources they have.
○ High costs of advertising and long time to take effect of the positive advertising.
○ People might resent laws for strict health care, which can be seen as an
infringement of civil liberties.
2. Clean technologies
● Renewable sources of energy use it as a solution to remove negative externalities from
the use and extraction of fossil fuels.
● Governments can subsidize the development of clean technologies or by offering tax
credits to firms that invest in clean technologies.
3. Government subsidies
● Lower a firm’s production costs → Increasing supply.
● Gives firms an incentive to use higher amounts of clean technologies.
● There is an opportunity cost involved as the money spent on the subsidies will not be able
to spend on achieving other objectives.