Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
(h`[ Ahjhy@Ah[ih[
(h`[f_aLmhhih[ ohr z;u[ ohr z;u[ ohr Ahjhy@Ah[
ukk[ Urhwfa%aw;' s}' Kxh}yk}@Ah[¢¢Zh_.¢¢
fatputw]tuhpkd[, k]tutAh]pdAhhsh,
ch;uhM} chts[ Ahzdghh;whMh ¢
w]tjtutzhprd[, Ah]tjtpw`rfahDsh
lrhAhk]'zt ghMh u:ohr's[ AhhMh ¢¢Zh_¢¢
faAhyhfat;' ohBt[' ohDAhpuyh Zhhsh
ihtmhfaAhy orhih; cps k]f]aAhht ¢
kjKh`uzd[ Qh]Zht d w]t; gh]mh ghhsh' ¢¢1¢¢
Zuohuoh`h'f]alh qh`[zhih; sh;nt ¢¢ch;uhM}¢¢1¢¢
Ahhs]py'gh ghzh Gh;bfa tpupfatmh[
dhpQhfaAhy orhih; qh`»rhih; Kxhhd¢
OhMf;a jhbfauhb[ w[r]Lhtkwhmh[
ºzr[ wzfa lhh;Qh; (h`[uSkyh'Id¢¢ch;uhM}¢¢2
Ahhpmhfatkdh k]t'ghukdh Ah_ghdrd[
¢¢
lhplhZhtuzdh thohk Ahzdhih[ ohdd[¢¢2¢¢
Ah]GhfaAhy whjsh k]Ghhpihrh fah;b[¢
shth lhpFs cghArh plhuQhohfah' ghh:t[
u;Zhy;Ahhdk jhtwy[ z_Lb[¢¢ch;uhM}¢¢3¢¢
chts[ ohpns Ah]gh]b orhihh z;z[WrAhhd¢
s;mh; s;oh; fah;'zy; cuHh; p!hQh]ud ¢¢ch;uhM}¢¢4¢¢
kh'Gr Ajmhs[ w`f_aps pdgh]"mh pdZhh"t[
ghhr!h[ pdohqh[ohh pdghAhhghAh kht[
w`ghb; wÓhus[ pdohZhAhh"ihht[
ghmhws[ih[ Vfahohdhz"d[ z;pGhry; %aw ¢
%aw whjsh ohhjy; cuHh; sz`}w¢¢ch;uhM}¢¢5¢¢
¢¢3¢¢ z]Kst sht[' uht[
Ahhrhwby w`mhAhs wptuht[
cAh_s Qhpts; kpts;
k]Ghfash" z]åGhjsh" uhsh" puHdhih[ ¢ d]tu[ w]tu[ cHhz]pts; uht[ Ahht[ z]Hh"b
w;`Ah f_awh ohrhih[ ¢
kuh=gh[ k]'zt Cb[ lh;'z]thih[ ¢ f'aB[ OhMf;a AhhM
¢¢ w`hxh"dh ¢¢ ck]th' Qhu j; %aw pihz`]w zhu[' pdZhh"t[¢¢4¢¢
ihs]thdd;' f]p(ihsfaAhh"irh ch;M[
Ah]FsheaMh'ih[ ¢Zh_¢ pypjYrh cks[y Ahhs; AhhOh; pdohQhhM[
ohr z;u ohr z;u ohr Ah'ghyAh}s[" zlh"dAhh!h; Hhhy[d yh;bh'ghmh, u'z[d ihtmh ¢ nh;MRh'd[ whpjd %aw s]Oh; ¢ w]kh;pd ihtmhhsM[ wzk]Ahd;' éhM[
AhdåfahAhdh w]ts[ ohr... ¢¢1¢¢ w`;Ah; chpy'gh[d chd'z; w}pohd ¢ Qhhu; ch;uhM[d Ajmh; dhAhh ¢¢1¢¢ Ah]Fs;(ut dhght é[tkhghtqhhM['¢¢ohr.¢¢5¢¢
tSdGhpihs eath s]oh ghh:t[f]aAhth ¢ ih'zdhih[ Cb[ SuAh;u Ahhsh ih pwsh SuAh;u ¢ SuAh;u qh'Zh](ih kGhh SuAh;u ¢
f']af]aAhf;alhth
pjt;ohpns Ah]f}ab lhh;Qhsh; qhth ¢ ÎamhOh]mhs[ d]w]t;
SuAh;u puÖh z`pumh' SuAh;u ¢ SuAh;u ku= AhAh z;u z;u ¢¢2¢¢ fahr;d
uhihh Ahdk;'pz`r:uh", qh]ÕrhSAhdh uh w`f_apsKuQhhuhs- ¢ fath;pAh
w`zp@hmhh
rÖAh kfay' wtKAh: dhthrmhhr;ps kAhw"rhpAh ¢¢3¢¢ ZhDr ZhDr jh; w`zp@hmhh kz-gh]Îathrhih[ ¢ Ohhy[ Suth k]tuth' puAhhd
ihtmh[ Hhhghptrh ohr.... ¢¢2¢¢ cir]s' f;alhu' thAhdhthrmh' f_aLmhzhAhh;zt' uhk]z;u' jpt ¢ (\[Zht' Csthrhih[ ¢¢ wzh;wz[ cwht OhhYrh w]mrhirh thlh[¢ ku"j[ s[xh;" Hhny[
y'qhh;zt w[sh'qht eapmhutu'Zhdh ¢ ktM kh;'n AhhZhu' ghh;pwfahuYyQh', ohhdfa[dhrf'a thAhih'z`' Qhoh; ¢¢4¢¢ chAjh chpz fa%apd fahlh[¢¢1¢¢ Ah_z'gh, bhM, Hhh;M QhFs Qhhuhxh;" ghhs[
uf`as]'n p!hdrdh ¢ jt; thAh jt; thAh, thAh thAh jt; jt; ¢ ¢ dhAhk'fa[s"d; qh`»hd'z; dhihs[ ¢¢2¢¢ fah;b[ qh`»jSrh jts[ faptsh
zhk thAhhihh uhb whj; kzdh ¢ k'fab[ whuhu; jt; f_aLmh jt; f_aLmh, f_aLmh f_aLmh jt; jt; ¢¢5¢¢ z'nus ¢ yh;bh'ghmh Hhhpysh Ahh;é yh;M; whrhs ¢¢3¢¢
pduh"mh[ t@hhu; k]tut u'zdh ¢¢3¢¢ gh]ÎaQhohdhihh AhpjAhh d faM; chghAhh?pdghAhhk[ ¢ cd]Qhu s; ohhmhs[
ohr z;u ohr z;u ohr Ah'ghyAh}s[" zlh"dAhh!h; oh; gh]Îawz[ih; tpjuhk[ ¢¢4¢¢ w`zp@hmhh fa%apd z;u Qhhu; uhpjyh ¢
AhdåfahAhdh w]ts[ ohr..... (h`[t'ghhSAhoh puÒy w]N; CQhh thpjyh ¢¢5¢¢
chts[ (h`[
kSrdhthrmhhih[ (\[ ghmhws[
cxhu"lh[Lh" ›
jptå ¡ dAhKs; ghmhwsr;› ¢ —SuAh;u w`Sr@h’' s~uAhpk ¢› Vs~huAhd]KuÎawAh-¢›
SuAh;u f;auy'’ fash"”pk ¢› ghfahth;— w}u"”%awAh-¢› cfahth;AhZrAh%awAh-¢›
CÕpty; ¢¢ohr.¢¢3¢¢ SuAh;u f;auy'’ Zhsh"”pk¢›› SuAh;u f;auy’' jsh"”pk¢› cd]Kuht(ihh’'Sr%awAh-¢› pqh'’z]Îa~ht%awAh-¢›
w`khz puk%apd wpsQh;b[yh fayhus[ gh;y[ SuAh;u ku= GhpYuz'’ q\»hpk ¢›› dhzå—k'’ZhhdAh-¢› k^-pjshk'pZh墛› k:Lhh ghmh;lhpu‰Öh¢› › ghmhfaXpLh—墛
@hh;Qh s]Ohh jh;shpih srhih[ dh:fah qh]nhy[ Su'’ kh@hhzhSAhhpk pdSr’'¢›¢›1¢›¢› pdih_z-ghhr!h[iI’'z墛 ghmhwps"z;”ush ¡ ™gh'’— ghmhwsr; dAh—å ¢›¢›7¢›¢›
ohr ohr pzdzrhMh kSrdhthrmh z;uh ¢ Xs'’ upiAh¢› kSr’' upiAh¢›¢›2›¢›¢› Vfaz’'shr puÓj; uf`as]mnhr Zh[Ahpj¢›› sDdh;z’pså—w`ihh;zrhs-¢›¢›8›¢›¢›
w'ihhtps ch;uhM} (h`[ws[ s]oh QhFs[Qhhuh c'ghZuohthohhk[ rhwt[ z]åGhpKxhs[ chy[
cu Su'’ Ahh'’¢› cu uFsht’' ¢›› cu(\h;sht'’ › VfazD’s’ ihs]j”=Ks’' whlhAh’'f]alhZhhptmhAh--¢›
¢¢ohr.¢¢Zh_.¢¢ Ah_suhsh" lhsw]!hh'ih[ kSut famh[" wkty[ cu zhsht'’ ¢› cu Zhhsht'’ ¢› cuhd}ihhdAhuplhLr’' ›¢› tz’' ih utz’' jKs:pqh”"Q\hmh’' Ah}LhfaZuohAh-¢›
pupZhr]Fs w]oh}d[ fapts[ w]thmh (h`umh ¢¢ohr¢¢4¢¢ cu w(ihh~hhs-¢› tFs’/-y’'qhh;zt’' lh}w”"famh”"f'’a tFsuhkkAh-¢›
wptAhMz`Urhkpjs w]LwAhhyh cw}"d w]dtpw w}oh]pd w`khz Qhémh faptsh sS@hmh[ cu w]tKshs- ¢› cuh;~hth~hhs-¢› cu zp@hmhh~hhs- ¢› tFsgh'’Zhhd]pyWsh’’gh’'tFsw]Lw:—å k]w}pohsAh-¢›
Zh_sr]Fs lhf"athpAh(h`[s ghh;Zh}Ahih}mh" wpsih[ dh:fah sty[ z;Gh; fayhus[ drd[ cu ihh;Zuh”"~hhs- ¢› QhFshd]f’'apwd’' z;u’' ohghSfahtmhAhir]sAh-¢›
c'ghZuohthohhk[ w]!h Qh;bs[ r;|apd cuh Zhth~hhs ¢› ku”"sh; Ahh’' whpjwhpjkAh’'shs- ¢›¢›3¢›¢› chpuQh}”"s'’ ih k_LbRhzh: w`f_as;—å w]ÎaLhhSwtAh-¢›
w`khz Qh@hmh faptsh w`kDd s} dhthrmh Su’' uh^-AhrSKu’' pihDAhr—墛 SuAhhd’'zAhrSKu’' q\»Ahr墛 Vu’' Zrhr’ps rh; pdSr’' krh;gh[ rh;pghdh’'ut—å ¢›¢›9›¢›¢›
¢¢ohr. ¢¢1¢¢ V;kh QhFsh k'fab[ whuk[ s} ihf`awhmh[
Su'’ kpiihzhd’'zhp‡Ôs[rh;Þpk¢› dAhh; U\hswsr; dAhh; ghmhwsr; dAhå w`Ahxhwsr; dAhKs; cKs]
lhshd'zpuw`; w}u[" u`s j; chihpty; ¢¢ohr.¢¢5¢¢ Su’' w`Sr@h’' q\»hpk¢› Su’' #hdAhrh;pu#hdAhrh;Þpk ¢›¢›4›¢›¢› y'’qhh;zthr Vfaz’'shr puHddhplhd;plhuk]shr
zhptz`R zun}pd c's[ Srhs; Ahh;@hwzh d;y; cdDrQhhu; w}oh]pd j; u`s oh; ohd chihts[ ku”= ohghpzz'’ Su~hh;ohhrs; ¢›› ku= ohghpzz’' Su~hpKsLBps¢›› (\[utzAh}s”"r; d/h; dAh—å ¢›¢›10›¢›¢›
Srhwhk]pd j; u`s rh fapyr]gh[ kfayh'(h`]s vpiIs w]tpuk[ Srhs; z;|apd k'ss[ k'w~h[ ku”= ohghpzz’' SupryrAh;Lrps ¢› ku”= ohghpzz'’ Suprw`Sr;ps ¢› ›
Ohhy; k'jhptk[ Qhu z}pts; ku"pj qh'Zhd; s]bs[ Su'’ Qh}pAhthwh; dyh;pdyh;dQh—墛› Su’' ihSuhptuhf-awzhpd › ¢›¢›5›¢›¢›
Su'’ gh]mh!hrhs[s墛 Su'’ z;j!hrhs[s墛 Su'’ cuKxhh!hrhs[s墛
Ah'!hw]Lwh'ohy[
Qhhuhxh;" w}pohsh ku" vpiIs yhZhy; thohh t'fah kAhhd Ahhd]pd whuk[ (h`[ws[ ¡ r#;d r#AhrohDs z;uhKshpd ZhAhh"pmh w`xhAhhDrhkd¢ s; j dhf'a AhpjAhhdå
¢¢ohr¢¢6¢¢ Su’' —fahy!hrhs[s—墛
¢¢ohr.¢¢2¢¢ Su'’ Ah}yhZhhtpKxhsh;Þpk pdSr’'¢› Su'’ lhpFs!hrhSAhfa—墛› kihDs r!h w}u;" khZrhå kpDs z;uhå¢ ¡ thohhpZhthohhr w`kÄ khpjd; ¢ dAhh;
khZh]u:lr; k'spskhB[ s]ohyh w`hpxh"ry; V;kh su u`sAhpjAhh cwht umh"} Ah[ f:akh Suh'’ rh;pghdh; ZrhrpDs pdSrAh-¢› ur' u:(h`umhhr f]aAh"j;¢ k Ah; fahAhhd- fahAhfahAhhr AhÄ' fahAh;(uth; u:(h`umhh; zzhs]¢¢
QhpFsw]tKkt chihts[ Srh whuk[ ohghz[lhh f]aqh;thr u:(h`umhhr Ahjhthohhr dAhå¢ ¡ KupKs ¢ khAh`hor', Qhh:or', Kuhthor'
vpiIs w]tsh Ahzh'Zh jh;|apd u`s d Su’' q\»hKSu’' puLmh]KSu’' Îaz`KSu’' v’z`KSu’' cpgdKSu’' u:thor', wthAh;LBR', thor', AhjhthorAhhpZhwSrAhr' kAh'swrh"r v"Krhs-
chihpty; QhFsh'ihh faduhM} faYwz`]Ah s} ku;"lhh uhr]KSu’' k}r”"KSu’'? khu"Qhh:Ahå khuh"r]Lrå ch'shzhwthZhh"s-¢¢ w_pxhUr: kAh]z`wr=Dshrh VfathpMps
Srh whwhd; k'fab[ wn}pd z]åGhj[ Qhh;pghy; Ahh;t;(utk]s uhk]z;u s]oh pudu[ Qhudhlhh ih'’z`AhhKSu’' q\»Qh}Qh”]"uå—Kuth;Ah-¢›¢› szWr;Lh (yh;fah;ÞpQhgh[sh; Ah%aså wptu;Lbhth; Ah%asKrhukd- gh_j;¢
¢¢ohr¢¢7¢¢ ghmhhpz’' w}u"”Ah]iihhr"”umhh"pz’' szd’'stAh-¢› cpup@hsKr fahAhw`;pu"(u;z;uhå kQhhkz vps¢¢ VfazDshr puz-Ahj; uf`as]mnhr
KAh_ps jh;|apd chihptsh' u`s Srh s]uh'pih cd]Kuht—å wtst—墛› cZh;”"Dz]ypks'¢› sht;mh’ ÎaÕ'’¢› Zh[Ahpj¢ sDdh;z's[å w`ihh;zrhs ¢ ¢¢(h`[ Ah'ghyAh}s[" Ahh;trh¢¢ (h`[ Ah'ghyAh}s[" Ahh;trh¢¢
chts[ ohr z;u ohr z;u ohr oh[ Ah'gh;lhh¢ chts[ ch;'uhM}
s]ohyh ku;"lhh¢¢Zh_.¢¢ AhjhKxhhd s]oh; ghh;Ahh'sfa w`h's[¢
(\[ Ah'gh;lhhih[ Qhhu;fa%ad[ faptsh; s]ohyh chts[ AhjhQhFs s]Oh;'
pdplhpzd[ gh]mh ghhs[¢ Ah[ sh; zhk s]Orh ihtmhh'ih[
Ahhs[¢¢ohr.¢¢1¢¢ Zhptyhk[ cusht z]Lbh Ahhthrh¢
khZh]k's ohd w_xu[ shthrh¢ QhFsh'ihh shtfa s}'
Ah'gh;lhthrh¢ kw" cér faptsh; s]ohuts[ Ihrh
¢¢ohr.¢¢2¢¢ z]åGh zptz`pzfa jh; puHd; pduht[¢
k'fabhwhk}d[ Ahohyhgh[ sht[¢ lhpFs Hh;|apd fat[ z]Lbh
k'jht[¢ oh:kh Zh;d} té[ f_aLmh; dtfaht[¢¢ohr ¢¢3¢¢ su
gh]mhumh"d faptsh' w]mrh r; ih;u¢ s]pOhrh ihtmh[ chj;
AhhOhh z_N Qhhu ¢ s]Oh; z;uhyr[ qhj]spih CSkhj¢
Ahh;t;(ut s]oh dpAhsh; ihtmh[' z; Bhu ¢¢ ohr z;u¢¢4¢¢
ch;Ohtihh puHdjt
r;xh[y Ah’'pzthyh fan;fah;b sbqh'’z[ chj;.
qh`»h, puLmh}, Ahj;lh, lhFs[ u k}r" z;uh'ihh thohh. thohh jh khu"Qhh:Ah shkhQhthd; qh’'z fatmrhs r;s;. CSkuhirh u;M[ qhkpumrhkhB[ œKuhAh[faht tmhoh[s z;khv=d[ w]Nhfaht Ah'’pzthirh c'’ghmhhs zh;d zghn[ z[wAhhMh chj;s.
(h`[ ghmhwps kAh}j rh lhqzhih[ AhjhpuLmh} sh; ohDAhyh Hh;syh jh;sh.Ah]Mh?Ah]Bh dz[irh fahBhut j; Ah’'pzt
UrhWs[ w`ih'n chj;. ghmhws[d; rh whih z;uh'dh z;uw'ihhrsd ck; u k~hhZhht[ cksh;. %az`k]FshAhZr; SuDAh]Ghhs¢ (h`[‘'irh Ah}s["“ut ohnohuhj[t u zhpghd; ihNpumrhs CSkuhztArhd rh z[wAhhM;s pzu; yhuy; ohhshs.
Ajmhshs. rhihh w`Ah]Gh KuhAh[ Ajmhoh; Qhghuhd lh'fathyh oh;LBthoh Ajby; r;shs. r;xh; dght w`zp@hmh;ih; Ahj~u chj;. SrhAh]M; uky; chj;. w]mh;?kh;yhw}t AhjhAhhghh"”ut yh;mh[ rhu;M[ j; z_lr eaht qhHhmrhkhtGh; cks;. ghmh;lhhih[
kht; pu(u Urhwy; chj;. ohh; Ahjhlh'Qh]j[ uhpmh"yh d;!hohhs ¢¢ ghhuhohuM}d Vfa eahbh e]absh;. s;xh}d whih pfa. Ah[.
pu(uUrhw[ chj.; sh; VfaAh;u ghmhws[ Ajmhoh;ih kSrpudhrfa. chj;. r#(h`]s[AhZr; puLmh}yh oh;LBSu puZh[ ohDAh Hh; whk}pd dhpQhz;lhh ¢ zlh"”dhyh chy;yh Qhhpufa Ah'’pzthV;uoh[ w}mh"” ghhuhyh w}mhh”"f_as[ Ah}s["“ cSr'’s chfaLh”"fa ck}d zh;Dj[
vst z;u j; rh whih z;uh'ih; pzy; chj;. k_Lb[ pdAhh"mh fatmrhirh w`zp@hmhh Hhhysh;. pkÕˆb;fa j; Qh[Ahh dz[irh pfad- c'’st gh;y; fa[ xh;b ghhuhs[y AhhZhuthu w;lhu; rh’'irh nh;MRhs Ahhmhf;a chj;s, st fawhM chpmh qh';’qh[s
k~hhZhht[ ghmh;lhih chj;. ku" z;u dAhKfaht AhhOhh s]yh (h`[ghmh;lhh¢¢ uhnRhkAhh;t.
j; ghmh;lhh'ih; fayh'lh chj;s. ku"ih cusht chj;s. Czh. (h`[f_aLmh, fahAhhs qh`»z;u oh;LBthoh chj;. AhjhlhFs[ Ohhy[ s]Orh uhAh hTrhut uky;y; chj;. r;xh; r;mrhk fahj[ w`Ahhmhhs pjth ohnuy;yh chj;.
z;u ghmh;lhhih[ w}ohh fatshs fahtmh w`Qh} thAh j; puLmh}ih;, (h`[ jd]Ahhd, Ahh;jfa uKs}s lhFs[ Ajmhoh; z;u[ c'gh[¢ cnihmh['‘ihh khAhdh fathuh yhghsh;. dght u w]mh; Ahjhnihh (h`[ utzpudhrfa th'’ohmhghhuihh Ahjhghmhws[
(h`[ ghmhthoh ku" z;uh'ih; Gh'nh;qhh, fahyQh:tu j; lh'fathih; u z;ush jh;r. z;ughmhhs oh;LBsh s]Oh; w]!h j; w'ihz;u;lh v"lhh ¢ r;xh}d pkˆÕb;fayh ohhsh r;s;. ghhmhwSr kh'’w`zhrhih; chÖ‰w`u"s”fa kAhohYrh cLbpudhrfahs Ahjhghmhws[ u;ghMh kAhohyh ohhsh;.
f]ayz:us chj;. orhw`Ahhmh; k'w}mh" cusht jh;r. rh kuh=ihh KuhAh[ v'z`hfan; chj;. dé!h u shTrhAhZr; dAhKfaht AhhOhh s]yh (h`[ ghmh;lhh why[ihh qhYyhM;(ut ohhmhhTrh gh]SkAhzXLh['‘d[ Kxhhwd f;ay;yh (h`[ghmh;lh z;u chpmh zhduh'irh r]ˆÕhs lh’'fath’'d[ p!hw]thk}thihh
Qhhtshs (h`[kSrdhthrmh w}ohh (h`[ ghmh;lh jh;r. ku" z;u (h`[ghmh;lhhih[ ih'z` (h`;LB Btsh;. @hp!hrhAhZr; (h`[ ghmh;lh jhih VfaAh;u pdkgh"t” Ar fah;famhhs[y thrghn pohYjRhs why[AhZr; Ajmhoh;ih Ahjhnihh utzpudhrf. 1690 AhZr; w`xhAh kAh}M CiI;z f;ayh. p!hw]thk}thirh Qhrhd; lh'f’ at pohxh;
HhthHhths}d fa;y[ ohhs;. Srhihw`Ahhmh; w}ohh fatshs. Ajmh}d chÖw}oh;ihh (h`[ thAhih'z` oh;LB chj;. cps w`xhAhw}or ckYrhd; sh;ih VfaAh;u qhYyhM;(uthih; Ah’'pzt chj;. Ah’'pzt w}uh"”pQhAh]Gh ck}d I!hws[ lhhj} Ahjhthohh’'d[ rh Kxhhdhyh kdz ywy; s[ gh]jh Ah'’pzthirh ohuMih ckYrhih[ uz'’sh
(h`[kSrpudhrfa w}ohh fatmrhihhj[ Ahhd ghmh;lhhyhih chj;. ghmh;lh lh[Hh` u;ghuhd Ajmh}d Ahd (h`;LB. oh;LBthoh chj;. puHdfash"j[ sh;ih u cih}fa pzlhh khZhd khZhYrhAh]M; k}rh;”"zrhkAhr[ pzy[. rh pudhrfahyh duk qhh;yYrhk w]!hw`hWs[ chj;. xhh;tYrh AhhZhuthu w;lhUrh'’d[ vxh; Ah'’pzthihh
w`Hhhs chj;. qh`»h'n w]thmhhAhZr; Kuså wtqh`» chj;. ku" z;uhih; AhjhqhyuhdAhZr; jd]Ahhd (h`;LB puHdjsh"j[ sh;ih. Ah}s[“"ut w`fahlhhpQhLh;fa jh;sh;. Ah’'pzthih[ Grhs[ ku”"z}t jh;s; clh[ Qhhpufah’'ih[ Zhhtmhh chj;. SrhAh]M; r;xh; ghhQhhth qhh'’Zhyh. Î'a’z fawhMhih[ ghmh;lhAh}s[“" whj}d
kSrhpudhrfahih[ w}ohh u u`sfaxhh f]ayz:us cky;Yrh (h`[ Btsh;. Ahjhw`shw[ Ajmh}d jUruhjd w`ih'’n ghz["“ jh;s cks;. Ah'’]qhv"”? w]mh; AhjhAhhghh”"ut
chy;y[ chj;. (h`[ kSrpudhrfa j[ ghmh;lhhirh cd;fa dhuh'w:fa[ Vfa (h`[ cpgd w'ihAhjhQh}shs Urh;Ah, ? kh;jd whb[y ckYrhd; r;xh; yhGhh; yh;fa r;s ckshs. r;xh;
Ghh;wh;y[doh[f Vfa eahbh yhghsh;. vxh}d z[n?zh;d
chwy; Ahd w`kDd jh;s;. th’'ohmhghhu j; w]mh;?dght
dhu oh;LBthoh jh;r. ghmh;lh ku" ohyz;ush, uÎamh, Zhpdfahs f]aqh;t, ghmh;lhAh}s[“"ih[ KujKs; w}ohh fatsh r;s;. AhjhAhhghh"”ut ck}d w]mh; u dght zh;Dj[fan}d ohhsh
Vfa Ahjhk~hh u lhFs[. xh;|atihh pih’'shAhmh[ Ah:yh’ut Ah'’pzt chj;. r;s;.
¢¢ z~hhih[ chts[ ¢¢
chts[ chts[
#hd;(uthih[ (h`[ zlhhushthih[
chts[ kw`;Ah ohr ohr puÒy wtqh`» QhFsk'fab[ dhdh Ku%aw[
Kxhhw]d[ KuZhAh"¢¢Zh_¢¢ c'qhXLh[fahtmh; ghQh"uhk kh;lh[k[ u;z d;y;
ihh;%ad[ qh`»h chmh]pdrh' z;k[ AhSKr%aw[ dhthrmh kWspj khght
Zh']n[k[ jKs yhghsh lh'Ghk]th s]Ohh ut z;k[ ¢¢chts[ ¢¢1¢¢
chts[ #hdthohh ¢ Ahjhf:auYrs;ohh ¢ k;pus[ khZh]k's ¢¢ tkhsMhlh[ ohhsh w_xu[ whB[ut Hh;k[ wth;wfahthkhB[ z;uh
AhZh] u;Zhyh AhhOhh ¢¢ chts[¢¢Zh_.¢¢ fahku Ohhyhk[ zhN; Zh%ad[ w_xu[ d;sh uthj%aw jh;k[
yh;wy; #hd ohgh[ ¢ j[s d;mhs[ fah;mh[¢ w`Yjhzfahtmh; dtjt[ Ks'Qh[ gh]tgh]tk[ ¢¢chts[¢¢2¢¢
cusht wh'n]t'gh¢ dhu B;puy; #hd[ ¢¢1¢¢ chts[¢¢ whihu; cusht[ qhM[irh Ôhthyh ohhk[ pQh@h; KxhM Ahhgh]d[
fadfahih; shb fat[ ¢ CQrh ghh;pwfah dht[ ¢ qhM[yh whshM[ d;k[ ku" kAhw"mh f;ay; Ajmh]pd w`kDd Srh
dhtz s]'qhtj[ ¢ khAh ghhrd fat[ ¢¢ ¢¢2¢¢ chts[ jh;k[ uhAhd%aw Zh%apd qhM[irh Ôht[ psLBk[ ¢¢chts[ ¢¢3¢¢
w`ghb gh]Ä qhh;y; ¢ pu(u qh`»ih[ f;ay;¢ thAhohdhz"d[ ¢ pdå—@h!h[ w_xu[ zhd pzZhy[ puw`hyh kjhuh cusht wtlh]thAh
ihtmh[ AhKsfa B;puy; ¢¢3¢¢ chts[ #hdthohh¢¢ p!hgh]mhhSAhfa !h:Ah}s[" z~h jh ohhmhh ¢ w`ghbyh ¢¢����������������
›������������������
chts[�����������
¢¢������
›��������
����������
4›¢¢�›���
p!hgh]mh[ cusht !h:yh;Frthmhh ¢ Ahhsyh thumh kuh" Cwz`u f;ayh s;js[k fah;b[ z;u qh'z[ jpty;
d;ps d;ps lhqz d r; cd]Ahhdh ¢ k[s;yh pws_uihdhkhB[ thAh; uduhk f;ayh pAhMu}pd uhdtk;dh
chts[ wtlh]thAhhih[ k]tut Ah]pdohd rh;gh[ kAhhpZh d r; Zrhdh ¢¢1¢¢
ohr z;u ohr z;u ohr (\[ gh]Îaz~hh ¢
thohhthAh w`ghbyh › ¢¢����������������
������������������
chts[�����������
z;ufa[?uk]z;u qh'z[ Ahh;ihd Srh' f;ay; d'zhHht[ ohhu}pd pdohk]Gh
›������������
¢¢������
5›������¢¢�›���
ohAhzgd[f]aMQh}Lhmh Ah]FsheaMzlh"dh¢ cpskoohd chts[ ch;uhM[sh' jty[ Qhupih'sh ¢¢Zh_.¢¢
AhdAhh;jdh tohd[fatuzdh¢ cghpmhs AhpjAhh s]Ohh dfaM; ghh;f]aMh pzZhy; ghh;tkihh;t[ faptsh duy@h ghh;whM pAhMpuy;
kqhhjR cQr'st[ s} Vfa z~h ¢ ghh;pwfah'ih; w`;Ah z;Gh}d[ (\[f_aLmh Qh]yy; › ¢¢����������������
������������������
chts[ ¢¢������ ›��������
6�����¢¢���›
k]tghmhh' ¢ uzsh;' f'aB[' uhmh[ ktk[%ajdrdh¢¢1¢¢ ohrthAh cQhhgrhk[ f:'aih[ faM;y j[ Ahhs ¢
(\[thAh ohr Qhhgh"uthAhh¢ d[th'ohd fa%a' s]ohyh wptw}mh"fahkh qhh:Õˆ fay'fa[ fay[r]gh[ cZhAh" jh cuHhh kh;n}d pzZhyh ZhAh"
wthj[ wtsy[ s;xh; f:'aihh j;s ¢ Ajmh}d[ d pzkk[ z;uh Ay;'iIAhz"d faptk[ Ajmh}d[ fay'fa[
¢¢Zh_.¢¢ kjRhpz`pghpt plhGht[ lht Hh;Cpd r;k[ ¢ kh;n]pd lht ohDAhtmhhihh w]tyhk; c's ¢¢2¢¢ ohr. ¢¢
wMu[k[ wp(ihAh ohyZh[k[¢ s]ohkAh tmhZh[t ohgh[' d wn; f;alhuh qhpjtu[ ohhDju[ ‰Öhu[
z_pLbk[ ¢ w`shw xhh;t s]Ohh d faM; faumhhk[ ¢¢ohr¢¢2¢¢ z~h r;|apdrh CQhh Bhfayh ¢ pdohk]Ghhd'zhih[ k;uh › ¢¢���������������
�����������������
chts[���������� ›�����������
¢¢�����
7›
�����¢¢›��
su fah;w qhj] whw[ qhhmh;'; k'jht[ ¢ zhduzjd fa%ad[ ukk[ kz-Qhhu; khLbh'gh; w`pmhwhs f;ayh ¢
pghptplhGht['¢ ép!hr Ahh%apd cud[ f;ay[ pdu":t[¢ khpSufa w`kDd jh;|ad[ chlh[uh"z pzZhyh ¢
thohk shAhk p!hgh]mhh' CÕht[ ¢¢ohr¢¢ z_N Qhhu;'su u'zd ohDAh/tmhhihh e;ath ih]fapuyh ¢¢3¢¢ ohr. ¢¢
fapts[ oh; ihtmh[ ¢ Srh's; QhuQhr dhj[' oh'uupt lhplhstmh[ ¢ z~h z~h V;k; yhghy; Zrhd ¢ jtwy; Ahd Ohhy; CDAhd ¢
lht Ahh%apd Cz-Qhpuy[ gh'ghh ohdstmh[ ¢ pih'shAhmh[ lhtmhhghs Ah[ s}' wmhhih[ Ohhy[ qhh;Mumh ¢
pdp(ihs su ihtmh[' ¢¢ohr thAh.¢¢4¢¢ Vfah ohdhz"d[ (\[ z~h ohhmh ¢¢4¢¢ ohr. ¢¢