Você está na página 1de 2

MANUSCRIPT REVIEW CHECKLIST FOR REVIEWER

Title :
Perbandingan Efektivitas Terapi Injeksi Bevacizumab
Intrastroma Kornea dan Subkonjunctiva pada
Neovaskularisasi Kornea
Sent Date :
Due Date for Review : Adequate Needs
revision
TITLE
Clearly describes the article √
Eficacy of Corneal and Subconjuntival Injection of
Bevacizumab Intrastroma Therapy in Corneal
Neovascularization
Abstract √

Reflects the content of the article


Contain purpose, methods, results, conclusion and
keywords
Consist of 261 words (>250 words)
INTRODUCTION
1. Rationale for study (need and significance) √
Contains : background, epidemiology,
patophysiology
2. Summarize relevant research to provide context, and √
explain others author’s findings
3. Describe the novelty of the study √
4. Objective of the study √
METHODS
1. The design is suitable for answering the question √
Experimental Study
2. The sampling is appropriate √
3. Data collection procedures √
Single Blind – Randomized Controlled Trial
4. Measurement have been described √
Neovascularization will compare between times of
observation (pre vs 1 week, pre vs 1 month, 1 week
vs 1 month)
5. Data analysis (description of statistical evaluation) √
Data analyzed using Mann-Whitney
6. Ethical clearance √
There is no information
RESULTS
1. Detail in narrative of the finding √
2. Descriptive quality of figures and tables (if relevant) √
Titles are placed above the tables. Measured
outcomes are described in tables.
3. Clearly laid out and in a logical sequence √
4. The analysis has been conducted appropiately √
DISCUSSION
1. Findings compared and contrasted with relevant √
literature
Mentioned several other studies with same
characteristics of the samples.
2. The results support or contradict previous theories √
There are some research which support this
research and some other studies with contradict
results.
3. Limitations of the study √
Tidak memperhitungkan faktor luasnya sikatrik
kornea masing-masing subjek penelitian pada kedua
kelompok yang mungkin dapat mempengaruhi hasil
penelitian (ada di bagian kesimpulan)
4. Clinical implications of the study √

5. Future directions of the study √


Injeksi bevacizumab baik secara intrastromal kornea
maupun subcinjunctiva dapat diberikan sebagai
terapi neovaskularisasi kornea
CONCLUSIONS
1. Drawin logically √
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
1. Describe unclearly √
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
1. Describe unclearly √
REFERENCES
1. Compliance with journal format (Vancouver style) √
2. The minimal number of references should be 20 and √
85% of them should be recent (published during the
last 10 year, with the majority during the last 5
years)
2008-2018 : 25
3. Abbreviate journal names according to standart √
RECOMMENDATION
1. Not appropriate for Unniversa Medicina
2. Accept as it is
3. Accept after minor revisions √
4. Accept after major revisions
5. Reject