Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Circuit models of lines and transformers are developed and applied to practical
calculations.
Rdc = r L / A
where r is the resistivity in ohm-meters, L is the conductor length in meters, and A is the
conductor cross-sectional area in square meters. The resistivity varies with temperature
(approximately in direct proportion to the absolute temperature). Let T1 and T2 be two
conductor temperatures in degrees C:
where K = 228.1 for aluminum and K = 241.5 for hard-drawn copper. Due to the skin
effect, an AC current will not distribute itself uniformly across a conductor.
Consequently, the AC resistance of the conductor will be somewhat larger than the DC
resistance. The skin effect becomes more important as the conductor cross-sectional area
increases and as the frequency increases. At 60 Hz the skin effect becomes noticeable
with large conductor sizes used on transmission lines.
STEEL
ALUMINUM
-1.3.1-
C. W. Brice August 2002
Wire sizes are commonly given in American Wire Gauge (AWG) up to sizes of 4/0 (or
0000). Larger sizes are given in the cross-sectional area of the conductor in thousands of
circular mils, abbreviated kcmil. The unit of kcmil is the same as the unit of MCM, but
in the latter M stands for 1000 (as in the Roman numeral), which does not fit the metric
system. Since we use kV to mean 103 V and MW to mean 106 W, to be consistent, we
should use kcmil to mean 103 cmil. However, the usage of MCM is widespread, and one
should be aware of both, and that they are the same. One circular mil is the area of a
circle that has a diameter of one mil (= 0.001 inch).
Area [mm2] = Area [cmil] x (p / 4) [mil2 / cmil] x (0.001 [in/mil])2 x (25.4 [mm/in])2
The arrangements of strands for ACSR is listed in the tables as the number of strands of
aluminum and the number of strands of steel. For example, 795 kcmil ACSR has two
forms, one with stranding 26/7 and one with stranding 45/7. The first of these is assigned
a code name of Drake and the second a code name of Tern. ACSR code names are names
of various birds, other types of conductors are assigned other kinds of code names. We
will list ACSR conductors as 795 kcmil (45/7). AWG sizes will be listed as 4/0 AWG
(6/1), meaning four-aught (or four-naught) size with six strands of aluminum and one of
steel.
When an electric circuit composed of two or more conductors is closed, the currents in
the circuit loops produce a magnetic flux that links the conductors. Thus, the circuit must
have a self-inductance, to account for the induced voltage set up by the flux. In other
words, each conductor may be thought of as possessing a certain inductance per unit
length. The flux linkage inside a cylindrical conductor (assuming uniform current density
in the conductor) is
where D1 and D2 are the distances from the center of the conductor to the two points.
Figure 1.3.2 illustrates the geometry.
-1.3.2-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
D1
D2
Figure 1.3.2 Geometry for calculation of flux linkages between two points
Consider a two-wire line with one conductor having a radius of r1 and the other having a
radius of r2 and the separation between conductors being D, shown in Figure 1.3.3.
r1 r2
Figure 1.3.3 Geometry of two-wire line. Note that flux that links both wires will link a
net current of zero, so will not affect line inductance.
Likewise
-1.3.3-
C. W. Brice August 2002
and
L = L1 + L2
A three-phase line having equilateral spacing, see Figure 1.3.4, can modeled quite easily.
D D
C B
D
Figure 1.3.4 Cross section of three phase line with equilateral spacing.
Note that D and Ds can be in any units, as long as they are both in the same units. Note
that ln denotes logarithm to the base e (natural logarithm) and log denotes logarithm to
base 10 (common logarithm).
-1.3.4-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
Three-phase lines that are not equilaterally spaced may be transposed as shown in Figure
1.3.5.
D12
D31
The equivalent spacing Deq
may be used to calculate the
inductance:
-1.3.5-
C. W. Brice August 2002
Example: A three-phase distribution line, shown in Figure 1.3.6, has flat horizontal
spacing of 29", 59", and 88" between adjacent phases. The conductor is 336.4 kcmil
ACSR with Ds = 0.292". Calculate the
88"
inductive reactance in ohms/mile.
29" 59"
Although the line is not transposed, the
calculation assumes that it is, which is an
approximation that is generally adequate.
XL = Xa + Xd
The method of equivalent spacing is a special case of a fairly general approach called the
method of geometric mean distance. The idea is that to calculate an average reactance
value for composite conductor systems, such as bundled conductors, the geometric mean
of the various distances may be used. A simple example illustrates the idea without
unneeded mathematical complexity.
-1.3.6-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
for the same purpose. EHV (extra-high voltage) above 230 kV) lines are almost always
constructed with bundled conductors because of the extremely high fields produced near
the conductors. Sometimes high-voltage lines at 230 kV use bundled conductors.
1.5'
18' 18'
Figure 1.3.7 Transmission line with bundled conductors. Each phase has two
conductors.
First calculate the geometric mean radius of the bundle by taking the geometric mean of
the subconductor GMR Ds and the bundle separation d:
Parallel-circuit lines can be handled in a similar fashion. Figure 1.3.8 shows a cross-
section of a double-circuit line, where both circuits are connected in parallel.
-1.3.7-
C. W. Brice August 2002
18'
A C'
10'
21'
B B'
10'
C A'
The conductor is 300 kcmil ACSR (26/7), having Ds = 0.0229 ft. We desire to calculate
the inductive reactance of parallel combination.
Calculate the geometric mean distances for each phase-phase spacing, then use these to
calculate the equivalent spacing:
-1.3.8-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
Now calculate the geometric mean of the conductor GMR and the spacing from
conductor n to n' (which are in parallel), then use these to calculate the equivalent self-
GMD:
Each conductor of an electric circuit will have a certain amount of electric charge per unit
length q. Therefore, each conductor will produce an electric field:
E = q / (2 p eo r) V/m
The voltage drop from a point D1 meters from the conductor to a point D2 meters from
the conductor is the line integral of E with respect to r from D1 to D2:
The geometry and the path of integration are shown in Figure 1.3.9.
P1 PATH OF
INTEGRATION
D1
q
D2
P2
EQUIPOTENTIALS
-1.3.9-
C. W. Brice August 2002
Figure 1.3.9 Path of integration for calculation of voltage drop from point P1 to point P1
due to a line charge at the origin. P1 is D1 meters and P2 is D2 meters from the line.
The capacitance (per unit length) of a two-wire line is the charge per unit length q divided
by the voltage between the conductors. A cross section of a two-wire line is shown in
Figure 1.3.10 (a).
Ra Rb
a b
Cab
a n b
Can Cbn
c) CAPACITANCE TO NEUTRAL
If ra = rb = r:
Cab = p eo / ln (D / r) F/m
-1.3.10-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
the neutral point is midway between the two conductors). Figure 1.3.10 shows the
capacitances Cab and Cn where
XC = 29.6 ln (D / r) kW-miles
A three-phase line with equilateral spacing, neglecting the effects of ground, is considered
next. The voltage drop from conductor a to conductor b is
We are assuming balanced conditions and that the neutral is at the center of the phasor
diagram (see Figure 1.3.11).
Vca
Vcn
Van
Vbc
Vbn
Vab
Vab Vac
3 Van
Figure 1.3.11 Phasor diagram for balanced conditions, showing phase and line voltages.
-1.3.11-
C. W. Brice August 2002
qa = - ( qb + qc)
Then
Van = qa ln (D / r) / (2 p eo) V
Cn = 2 p eo / ln (D / r) F/m to neutral
Vs = Vr + (R + j X) I
The phasor diagram is shown in Figure 1.3.12 (b) for an inductive load (lagging power
factor) and in Figure 1.3.12 (c) for a capacitive load (leading power factor). The percent
voltage regulation is calculated at fixed Vs and fixed load power factor:
-1.3.12-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
Note that the voltage regulation is essentially a percent voltage magnitude drop. The
voltage regulation is positive for most power factors, but may be negative (i.e. a voltage
rise on the line) for low leading power factors.
Z=R+jX I
Vs Vr
Vs
Vr
(R + jX) I
I Vs
(R + jX) I
Vr
Ds = 0.0222 feet
-1.3.13-
C. W. Brice August 2002
I = 120.8 A /-25.8o
Many transmission lines are longer than 50 miles but shorter than 150 miles, where the
long-line equations are needed. These medium-length lines are adequately modeled by
lumped-parameter models that include both the series impedance and the shunt
admittance terms. Two well-known possible models are the nominal pi model and the
nominal tee model, shown in Figure 1.3.13 (a) and (b) respectively.
Is Z Ir
Ics Icr
Vs Y/2 Y/2 Vr
NOMINAL PI MODEL
Is Ir
Z/2 Z/2
Vs Vr
Y Ic
The nominal pi model has one less node than the nominal tee, so we generally prefer the
pi model, due to the prevalence of nodal analysis. If loop analysis were to be done, the
nominal tee model would be preferable. The word nominal is meant to indicate that these
-1.3.14-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
are not the "exact" models. In fact, they are not exact equivalents of each other. Rather,
they are each approximations, of about the same order, to the long-line equations.
Nevertheless, the vast majority of transmission lines, except for long EHV lines, may be
accurately modeled with the nominal pi model.
The circuit is the nominal pi circuit, similar to that of Figure 1.3.13 (a).
Ds = 0.0444 ft r = 0.0560 ft
R = 0.0832 ohm / mile
XL = 0.1213 ln (22.7 / 0.0444) = 0.757 ohm/mile
XC = 29.7 x 103 ln (22.7 / 0.0560) = 178.3 x 103 ohm/mile
BC = 1 / 178.3 x 103 = 5.61 x 10-6 mho/mile
Z = 4.81 + j 43.7 = 44.0 /83.7o ohms
Y = j 0.324 x 10-3 mhos
Vr = 220 kV / 31/2 = 220 / 1.732 = 127.0 kV L-N
Ir = (1/3) 100 MVA / [220 kV / 31/2]
Ir = 100 MVA / [1.732 x 220 kV] = 262 A
cos-1(0.90) = 25.8o
Vr = 127.0 /0o kV Ir = 262 /-25.8o A
Icr = 127.0 /0o kV x j 0.1621 m mhos = j 20.6 A
Iz = Ir + Icr = 254 /-21.6o A
Vs = Vr + Z Iz = 132.6 /4.27o kV
Ics = 132.6 /4.27o kV x j 0.1621 m mhos = 21.4 /94.3o A
Is = Iz + Ics = 245 /-17.1o A
Thus the sending-end voltage is 230 kV (L-L) and the sending-end current is 245 A. The
power factor at the sending end is cos (4.27o + 17.1o) = 0.931 lagging (i.e. current lags
the voltage). The sending end complex power is
Ps = 90.7 MW Pr = 90 MW
-1.3.15-
C. W. Brice August 2002
In cases where lines exceed about 150 miles, the long-line equations should be used for
accurate calculations. An alternative is to break long lines in several pieces, each no
longer than 100 miles, and use the medium-length line model for each.
The long line equations are derived in most textbooks, which develop the following
equations:
where z and y are the series impedance and the shunt admittance per unit length, and
where x is the distance from the receiving end (positive toward the sending end). The
solutions are
where
Surges due to lightning or switching operations may have very fast rise times, and so will
experience a nearly lossless line. The characteristic impedance of a line, neglecting
losses, is called the surge impedance:
z=jwL y=jwC
Surge impedance load is a resistive load equal to the surge impedance of the line. For
example, the 230 kV line considered earlier has a surge impedance of 338 ohms. Its
surge impedance loading is
Rules of thumb are sometimes used to relate line loadability to the surge impedance
loading:
A 300 mile line can be loaded to 1 x SIL (stability limits)
A 100 mile line can be loaded to 2 x SIL (voltage drop limits)
A 50 mile line can be loaded to 3 x SIL (thermal limits)
-1.3.16-
Fundamentals of Electric Power Systems
Figure 1.3.14 shows the loadability curve based on this rule of thumb. Note that these
rules and the curve based on them are approximate. Consequently, they are applicable to
preliminary designs only, and all designs should be checked fully by system planning
studies (to be discussed later) such as power-flow and transient stability studies.
LINE LOAD / SIL
[PER UNIT]
3.0
2.0
1.0
Figure 1.3.14 Line loadability limits in per unit of surge impedance loading.
Often transmission and distribution systems use reactive compensation. This may take
the form of shunt or series capacitors or reactors.
A short line serving a low power factor load (lagging) has excessive voltage drops and
line losses; compensate with shunt capacitors at load to improve the power factor, raise
the voltage and reduce line losses.
A long line that is limited by system stability considerations, has a loadability that is
limited by its series reactance; compensate with series capacitors at midpoint of line.
Note that series capacitors in the line form an RLC series circuit that has a resonant
frequency below 60 Hz. This may couple to torsional shaft oscillation modes of
turbogenerators, leading to subsynchronous resonance problems (that have caused
generator shaft failure in the southwestern US).
A distribution line serves a customer with a high-impact load that produces a severe
voltage dip or flicker for a short time. To reduce the effect of the flicker on other
customers, compensate for some of the inductive reactance of the line with a series
capacitor bank. The series capacitor will create overvoltage problems (at the bank) and
will increase the short-circuit current available (downstream of the bank). Several recent
-1.3.17-
C. W. Brice August 2002
applications of series capacitors on distribution systems have been made, although the
idea is not new. We will reconsider this application in Part 2.
A long line may have excessive voltage magnitude at light loads, due to the capacitive
charging currents flowing through the inductive reactances. Compensate with shunt
reactors that are switched out at heavy load.
Sometimes the short-circuit current is too large at some point in a system, and series
reactors (inductors) may be used to limit it. These are found between bus sections in
substations and on short lines.
Figure 1.3.15 shows one phase of a three-phase distribution line with a shunt capacitor for
power-factor correction at the top of the figure, and with a series capacitor to improve the
voltage regulation and flicker caused by an impact load. The series capacitor
compensates for part of the inductive reactance in the line impedance, but the shunt
capacitor compensates for part of the inductive reactance of the load (thus raising the
power factor and improving the voltage regulation of the line).
Zline
Zload
Zline
Zload
Figure 1.3.15 Shunt capacitor (top) and series capacitor (bottom) on distribution circuit.
For simplicity only one of the three phases is shown.
-1.3.18-