Leadership 9: Club Peer Review

Part 1:
Using the rubric below, use critical thinking skills to evaluate another group proposal. Please
remember that the purpose of the peer evaluation is to give insightful feedback and clear
suggestions as to how the group can make their proposal better, as well is an opportunity for
your group to get feedback to edit and review your own proposal.

Proposal being evaluated: ______________________________________________

Group evaluating: _____________________________________________________

Well Developed -4 Competent- 3 Emerging-2 Underdeveloped -1

Proposal Student provides a Student provides a Student provides a Student provides

Presentation fully developed thoughtful and partial or limited underdeveloped or
insightful proposal to adequate proposal proposal to the no proposal to the
Creates a product, the posed challenge to the posed posed challenge posed challenge
performance or challenge
service in response
to challenges

Comments:
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________

Well Developed -4 Competent- 3 Emerging-2 Underdeveloped -1

Club Design/ Student approaches Student approached Student approached Student approached
Participation club design with club design with club design with club design with
insightful and competent planning. emerging planning. partial or
Explores interests thorough planning. Club is adequately Club is limited in its underdeveloped
and skills in the Club is well developed and developed and planning. Club is
design of developed and executed partially executed. incomplete.
approaches to executed satisfactory
challenges comprehensively

Comments:
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
Part 2:
This section of the peer review will be used to give feedback on what you thought the group did
well in their proposal as well as an opportunity to give one specific suggestion on something you
wish the group would have done differently in their proposal.

Something done well:

____________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________

Something done well:

____________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________

Something to work on:

____________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________

Something to work on:

____________________________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________________________