Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Evidence from earthquake focal mechanisms, ill situ stress measurements, and surface
deformations indicate that the Australian continent is in a state of substantial horizontal com•
pression. Reliable focal mechanism determinations are now available from eight earthquakes
that have occurred in several parts of the continent since 1967. Each of these mechanisms
indicates that the faulting associated with the earthquakes was caused by compressive stress
acting close to horizontal. III situ measurements made in mines and tunnels, and close to the
surface in quarry floors or on rock outcrops, also indicate horizontal compressive stress in all
areas.
Near the epicentres of the 1968 Meckering and 1970 Calingiri earthquakes, shallow over•
coring measurements «10 m) were carried out to compare the ill situ observations with the
earthquake focal mechanisms and surface faulting. The measurements were made in competent
granite at seven locations along a 200 km north-south traverse. The results indicate a high
regional compressive stress acting about 77 °E of N. This agrees well with the 91 ° and
102 °E of N directions for the pressure axes obtained respectively from the earthquake focal
mechanisms. The highest stress (23 MPa) was measured at the site farthest north from the
Meckering epicentre. and the lowest stress was close to that epicentre where the maximum
principal stress was about 4 MPa.
During 1978 and 1979 several sites in NSW were tested at depths ranging from 3 to 9 m.
At each site the stress measured was compressive. In the eastern part of the State at
Buckley's Lake, Jindabyne, Milton, and Moruya the axes of maximum compression were
north-south, but in the west at Ardlethan, Mirrool. Berrigan, and Tocumwal the stresses are
close to east-west, agreeing with the earlier results at Broken Hill and Cobar. The highest
values of about 20 MPa were obtained in Silurian granite at Tocumwal.
The results give principal stress orientation in different directions for different regions of
the contin!'nt; it is therefore clear that simple models derived from plate tectonic concepts
cannot be applied directly to explain the high observed stresses or their directions.
•
--,
• "
",
"
(" ( __'I
,, -,
...-'\
-
:'
\
. •
,
.... -.....
-, ...,,_oJ
V
I
......
\
\ , 20·
\ r"...;
,, I,,
\
,, ,,
,I ''
.... / ~, .... ,
, ........
(]
,, \
"
\,
,I
:\
BRISBANE
,,
,,
I
30·
• __ e ---- ,
•
,,
' ...................
•• •
-..
o 500km
[TI
00
.-+-
STRESS MEASUREMENTS MAGNITUDE Archaean
Near surface
• • -140·
I
o MPa 20 • > 5.99 PLATFORM COVERS
[f!J
! , ,
Figure 1. Distribution of earthquakes greater than magnitude 4, 1873-1977; Earthquake focal mechanisms-lower focal
hemisphere displayed, black represents compression; in situ stress measurements made before 1976. <TV repre•
sents the vertical stress due to overburden.
Smith, 1979). Table 1 lists the focal parameters of the and hence correlate the earthquake fault planes with
earthquakes shown on Figure 1; also shown on this known faults. Possible exceptions are (1) in South Aus•
figure are epicentres of all known earthquakes with tralia, where diapiric intrusions in the Adelaide Geo•
magnitudes greater than 4 for the Australian region syncline may concentrate the stresses to more than
since 1873. twice the regional values, causing the zone of earth•
Although all Australian earthquakes for which focal quakes associated with the Geosyncline (see Campbell,
mechanisms are known result from compressive forces 1978); and (2) in Victoria. Recent work by Gibson &
acting close to horizontal, the directions of the pressure Cuthbertson (1979) suggests that Victoria is being com•
axes vary considerably and there is no predominant pressed northwestwards. Most earthquakes occurring
direction for the maximum pressure. It could be argued there are at depths less than 20 km; they appear to
that, because the relation between the axes of the define a series of northeast-southwest trending reverse
maximum and minimum principal stresses and the P faults that extend across the State. The focal mechanism
and T axes of the focal mechanisms may depend on of the 1977 Balliang earthquake supports this model.
the orientation of the planes of crustal weakness (such However, the large-scale faults suggested by the spatial
as pre-existing faults), there could be considerable distribution of the earthquakes are not evident at the
scatter in the directions of the pressure axes (see surface. They appear to be represented by a series of
McKenzie, 1969). However, evidence from North smaller, subparallel en echelon faults. So from surface
America (Sbar & Sykes, 1973), South America mapping alone it is difficult to identify the major
(Mendiguren & Richter, 1978) and the Meckering crustal faults.
region of Western Austraila (Denham & others, in From the evidence of earthquake focal mechanisms,
prep.) confirm that the P axes from focal mechanisms we are left with a picture in Australia of compressive
are usually aligned close to the direction of the maxi• forces acting close to horizontal but in several,
mum principal regional stress. apparently random directions. For example the 1978
Furthermore, since Australian earthquakes are not Halls Creek and the 1970 Canning Baisn earthquakes
associated with known major faults, it is impossible to give P axes almost at right angles to each other.
identify any zones of pre-existing weakness in the crust, Similarly the 1973 Picton and the 1977 Bowning earth-
STRESSES IN THE AUSTRALIAN CRUST 291
quakes which took place in the same region give stress obtained from the overcoring results with those
axes in different directions. There can be no doubt, from the earthquake focal mechanisms from the
however, that compressive forces are dominant in the Meckering and Calingiri earthquakes, and the surface
continental crust. faulting.
The Meckering earthquake is probably the best docu•
Evidence from in situ stress measurements mented of all Australian earthquakes. It took place on
Since 1957 over 1500 measurements of in situ stress 14 October 1968 and had a Richter magnitude of 6.9.
have been made at more than 50 localities in Australia The arcuate (concave to the east) north-south faulting
(see Worotnicki & Denham, 1976). Early results were produced a scarp 37 km ling with a maximum surface
obtained by flat jacks, but from 1963 most stress displacement of about 2 m (Everingham, 1968).
measurements have used borehole-overcoring methods;
these involve installing a gauge in a small pilot hole in
solid rock, and then monitoring the change in shape
of the hole when it is overcored by a larger (88 to
150 mm) diameter core barrel. The oyer coring relieves
the stresses in the rock surrounding the gauge-thus
enabling the change in shape of the pilot hole to be
measured, and the stresses in the rock to be computed.
Measurements have been carried out mostly in mines
and tunnels, at depths ranging from 1.5 m to 1.5 km.
The reliable results obtained before 1976 are sum•
marised in Figure 1. In 1976 CSIRO and BMR started
a systematic program of measuring regional stress
throughout the continent; several sites have been tested
using shallow « 10 m) holes drilled from the surface.
The site requirements for the shallow overcoring
tests are at present quite restrictive, calling for
unweathered competent rocks either cropping out or
lying close to the surface in regions of low relief. For
the measurements to be meaningful the rocks must be
well bonded to the crust and not mechanically
decoupled by joints, faults, or weathered material.
Furthermore, to obtain reliable observations in regions
of low stress, careful corrections must be made for
temperature and pore pressure effects. These correc•
tions can be as large as 3 MPa (Denham & others, in
prep.).
Most of the useful results from the recent overcoring
program have been obtained from the Meckering region
of Western Australia and the southern New South
Wales part of the Lachlan Fold Belt.
Meckering region
A detailed account of the Meckering measurements
is given in Denham & others (in prep.). The objective
was to measure the in situ stress near the epicentre of Figure 2. Meckering fault scarp, showing reverse-angle
a large earthquake, and to compare the directions of faulting.
292 D. DENHAM & OTHERS
--+-
STRESS MEASUREMENTS
~ actIvIty and uplift through the Tertiary to the
o
Near surfar:e
MP. 5
Quaternary.
~
The earthquake activity in the Lachlan Fold Belt is
50km
currently rather diffuse and occurs in a broad zone
H50/ B10- 17A
which parallels the coast. There are no major linea•
Figure 3. Stress measurements near Meckering; the earth· tions, but several localised clusters. Examples are the
quake distribution before 1978 and the fault Dalton-Gunning zone about 50 km north of Canberra,
scarps from the CaIingiri and Meckering earth· and near Lake Talbingo. The Talbingo earthquakes
quakes are also shown. were triggered by the filling of the Dam in 1971
(Timmel & Simpson, 1974) and provide evidence of
Figure 2 shows a section of the scarp indicating the tectonic stress in the crust. No focal mechanisms were
thrust nature of the faulting. Many smaller earth· determined for any of these earthquakes, but the
quakes have subsequently taken place in the region, the mechanisms from the 1973 Picton and the 1977 Bown•
largest being those at Calingiri on 10 March 1970 ing earthquakes both indicate a compressive regime
which had a Richter magnitude of 5.9 and Cadoux on in the Lachlan.
2 June 1979 which had a magnitude of about 6.2. The The sites for overcoring tests were restricted by the
Calingiri earthquake produced a fault scarp about criteria described earlier, but eight sites have so far been
3.5 km long with a maximum surface displacement of tested successfully (Table 2). The stresses observed fall
about 0.3 m (Everingham & Parkes, 1971). The into two main patterns. In the western region, at
Cadoux earthquake also produced a fault scarp; about Ardlethan, Mirrool, Berrigan, and Tocumwal the maxi•
12 km long and with a maximum surface displacement mum principal stresses tend to be approximately east•
of about 0.5 m (Gregson, pers. comm., 1979). west, agreeing with the earlier results from Cobar and
Broken Hill (see Fig. 1). In the east results from
Shallow overcoring measurements (3-10 m) were Buckley's Lake, Jindabyne, Milton and Moruya give a
made at seven sites in competent granite along a predominantly north-south direction for the maximum
200 km north-south traverse in the southwest corner principal stresses.
of the Archaean Yilgarn Block. The results are sum• The greatest stresses were observed at Tocumwal,
marised in Figure 3, which is adapted from Denham & where the results were similar to those obtained at
others (in prep.). At most sites three measurements
Berrigan on a different nearby batholith. Both these sets
were made at different depths and the magnitudes and
of measurements were in competent, high modulus
directions shown are the average result from each site.
rock sited in flat country. Additional confirmatory
Apart from the result at site 5 the observations indicate evidence of the Tocumwal results is provided by a
a marked east-west trending maximum principal stress. pop-up in the quarry floor (Fig. 5) which was caused
When the in situ stresses are averaged the resulting by compressive forces acting close to east-west.
regional maximum principal stress acts at about
N 77 °E, which is similar to the P axes from the
Meckering and Calingiri earthquakes, of N 91°Eand Discussion
N 102°E respectively. The highest principal stress, of There is now good evidence from several parts of
23 MPa, was measured at the site farthest north from the continent that compressive stresses are present
Meckering (....-'90 km) and the lowest stress (-4 MPa) throughout the upper crust. However, the simple models
was measured near the epicentre. The maximum stresses derived from standard plate-tectonic concepts that
STRESSES IN THE AUSTRALIAN CRUST 293
...
144' 146' 148' 150'
143' 152'
33'
... ..
.. .
.. . ...
:. :
.-.'. .. •.....
•.., • ~Picton
1.97l •
.. ..
. ........
MIRROOL • • • '-" •
J
. . ...
34'
-..
.-..
~
..
~
-:..
• ( . , CANBERRA
---',,1]1J'
1 \ • BERRIGAN
...
V/"~ ..,.;.
C',,- _••• 1\1' .... " ,;.~ ACT
.. .. .
-
'-.'
....
-.J'
..
........ WINDY CR'EEKI. •
a 36'
• I
TOCUMWAL
..
... .. :. ..
.....• .
......j JINDABYNE
•• '- .......
. '-
......
Balliang 1977
... ·.
~:. .. 38'
..
, ..
• Iw
--+-•
FOCAL MECHANISMS STRESS MEASUREMENTS
+
MAGNITUDE
< 5.00
In mlnes O'v
• 5.00-5.99
• > 5.99
o 200km
155/B10-3A
predict a consistent direction for stress throughout the two main possibilities. The first is that the earthquakes
whole continent do not apply, Within specific regions, occur along pre-existing zones of weakness in the crust.
such as the southwest Yilgarn Block and central New These zones would then determine the attitudes of the
South Wales, the evidence from earthquake focal fault planes and hence the true regional stress pattern
mechanisms, overcoring measurements, and ground would not be revealed-as suggested by McKenzie
deformations all give consistent results, However, the (1969); the second possibility is that the stress field in
boundaries of these specific regions are difficult to the crust is distorted by lateral inhomogeneities. These
define, and stress directions can change abruptly from would be expected at craton boundaries, and at the
region to region, For example, the 1973 Picton and edges of similar large crustal features.
1977 Bowning earthquakes which were close together, The results of the overcoring measurements are
gave pressure axes almost at right angles to each other, reasonably consistent. However, the data are scattered
although both mechanisms indicated that compressive thinly, and the problem remains of ascertaining whether
forces close to horizontal caused the earthquakes. or not the rock tested is properly coupled to the crust.
Similarly, the 1970 Canning Basin and the 1978 Halls It is therefore important that more overcoring
Creek earthquakes show thrust fault solutions, but with measurements are taken. This may involve testing at
pressure axes in different directions, greater depths than the current maximum of about
The reasons for the apparent inconsistencies in the 10m. Because of the deep weathering present through•
directions of the pressure axes obtained from the earth• out most of the continent, it is often difficult to find
quakes are not evident. However, there seem to be competent, coupled rock near the surface.
294 D. DENHAM & OTIfERS
bearing
degrees
depth principal stresses bearing E Mean Values E of N, of
Site m "1 MPa "2 of "1 GPa "1 "2 average "1
Milton
Cretaceous 4.9 18.0 6.0 15.5 69
monzonite 8.3 18.7 6.5 26.5 63 16.9 5.7 12
35.41 °S, 150.36*E 8.9 13.9 4.5 173.5 59
Moruya
Silurian 3.7 4.6 4.0 8 54 4.6 4.0 8
granodiorite
35.91 oS, 150.12°E
Berrigan 3.5 11.4 5.6 74 49 11 .8 7.6 77
Silurian 3.8 12.1 9.5 80 53
granite
35.68°S, 145.82°E
Tocumwal 6.7 17.0 12.2 79 47 17.6 11.4 76
Silurian 8.3 18.1 10.7 73 47
granite
35.76°S, 145.63°E
Ardlethan 9.2 0.6 -1.2 130 53
Silurian 6.2 3.5 2.1 100 44 4.2 1.5 102
granite 9.3 7.5 2.5 106 47
34.20 0 S, 146.80 0 E 10.0 5.4 2.6 70 50
Buckley's 4.2 3.0 2.4 32 73 3.0 2.4
Lake 6.2 1.7 1.5 132 72 2
Silurian 9.2 4.4 3.4 23 74
adamellite
36.46°S, 148.95 °E
Jindabyne 4.3 9.3 7.1 6 64 9.1 7.1
Silurian 6.2 9.1 7.5 165 62
tonalite 8.7 9.0 6.6 17 62
36.43 °S, 148.62°E
Mirrool 4.8 6.2 4.7 81 44 5.9 4.3
Silurian 6.4 8.3 6.7 81 44 81
granite 9.2 3.2 1.6 80 43
34.37 °S, 147.07°E
Acknowledgements
We thank G . Blows, A. Buckland and R. H. Thomp•
son of CSIRO for detailed site selection and testing;
L. Hodgins and N . Lodwick of BMR for carrying out
the drilling; R. Smith for providing pre-publication data
for the Balliang earthquake; and J. Mifsud for drafting
the figures.
References
AHORNER, L. & SCHNEIDER, G., 1974-Herd mechanisms
von Erdbeden in Oberrhein-Graben und in seinen
Radgebirgen, Approaches to Taphrogenesis, Interunio
Commission on Godynamics, Karlsruhe, West Germany,
Science Report 8, 104-17.
CAMPBELL, D . L., 1978-Investigation of the stress-con•
centration mechanism for intraplate earthquakes. Geo•
physical Research Letters, 6, 477-9.
CHAPPLE, W. M., & TULLIS, T. E., 1977-Evaluation of the
forces that drive plates. Journal of Geophysical Research,
82, 1967-84.
DENHAM, D., ALEXANDER, L. G., & WOROTNICKI, G. (in
prep.)-the stress field near the site of the 1968 Mec•
kering earthquake W.A.
DENHAM, D ., ALEXANDER, L. G., & WOROTNICKI, G., 1979
-Rock stress measurements in the Lachlan Fold Belt,
NSW. CSIRO Division of Applied Geomechanics, Techni•
cal Report, 84.
EVERINGHAM, I. B., 1968-Preliminary report on the 14
Figure 5. Tocumwal pop-up. The quarry floor has been October, 1968 earthquake at Meckering, Western Aus•
fractured by compressive forces which have tralia. Bureau of Mineral Resources, Australia, Record
caused the pop-up. 1968/ 142 (unpublished).
STRESSES IN THE AUSTRALIAN CRUST 295
EVERINGHAM, I. B., & PARKES, A., 1971-Intensity data RICHARDSON, R. M., 1978-Finite element modelling of
for earthquakes at Landor (17 June 1969) and Calingiri stress in the Nazca plate: driving forces and plate
(10 March 1970) and their relationship to previous boundary earthquakes. Tectonophysics, 50, 223-48 .
Western Australian Observations. Bureau Of Mineral RICHARDSON, R. M., SoLOMON, S. c., & SLEEP, N. H.,
Resources, Australia, Record 1971/80 (unpublished). 1976-Intraplate stress as an indicator of plate tectonic
EVERINGHAM, 1. B., & SMITH, R. S., 1979-Implications of driving forces. Journal Of Geophysical Research , 81,
fault-place solutions for Australian earthquakes on 4 July, 1847-56.
1977, 6 May, 1978 and 25 November, 1978. BMR SBAR, M. L. , & SYKES, L. R., 1973-Contemporary com•
Journal of Australian Geology and Geophysics, 4, 297- pressive stress and seismicity in eastern North America;
301. an example of intraplate tectonics. Geological Society of
FITCH, T. J., WORTHINGTON, M. H., & EVERINGHAM, I. B., America, Bulletin 84, 1861-82.
1973-Mechanisms of Australian earthquakes and con• SOLOMON, S. c., & SLEEP, N. H., 1974--S0me simple
temporary stress in the Indian Ocean Plate. Earth and physical models for absolute plate motion, Journal of
Planetary Science Letters, 18, 345-56. Geophysical Research, 79, 2557-67.
GIBSON, G., & CUTHBERTSON, R., 1979-Seismicity and the SoLOMON, S. C. , SLEEP, N. H. , & RICHARDSON, R. M., 1975
tectonic structure of Victoria. In DENHAM, D. (Compiler), -On the forces driving plate tectonics : inferences from
summaries of papers presented at CUMSEA symposium, absolute plate velocities and intraplate stress. Geophysical
Canberra February, 1979. Bureau of Mineral Resources, Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, 42, 769-801.
Australia, Record 1979/ 2 (unpublished). SYKES, L. R. , 1978-Intraplate seismicity, reactivation of
McKENZIE, D . P., 1969-The relation between fault plane pre-existing zones of weakness, alkaline magmatism and
solutions for earthquakes and the directions of principal other tectonism postdating continental fragmentation.
stresses. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, Reviews of Geophysics and Space Physics, 16, 621-88 .
59, 591-601. TIM MEL, K. E., & SIMPSON, D. W., 1972--Seismic events
MENDIGUREN, J . A., & RICHTER, F. M., 1978-0n the during the filling of Talbingo reservoir. ANCOLD
origin of compressional intraplate stresses in South Bulletin 36, 27-33.
America. Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, WOROTNICKI, G., & DENHAM, D. , 1976-The state of stress
16, 318-26. in the upper part of the earth's crust in Australia
MILLS, J . M., & FITCH, T. J., 1977-Thrust faulting and according to measurements in mines and tunnels and from
crust-upper mantle structure in East Australia. Geo• seismic observations. Proceedings of ISRM Symposium,
physical Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society, 48, Investigation of Stress in Rock, Advances in Stress
351-84. M easurement, Sydney, Australia, 71-82.