Você está na página 1de 13

ENGLISH த"# বাংলা മലയാളം िहंदी मराठी

Follow Us: Why only 23% of all rural


income comes from agriculture
Friday, August 24, 2018

Home India World Cities Opinion Sports Entertainment Lifestyle Technology Viral

Parenting Photos Videos Audio ePaper

Home Opinion Hold out an olive branch

Hold out an olive branch


Government today again holds upper hand vis a vis Naxals. It’s the best
time to make peace

Written by Prakash Singh | Updated: August 24, 2018 12:30:50 am


X
X

The trajectory of Maoist violence has been showing a downward trend (Express Photo/Praveen
Khanna/File)

The Home Minister of India recently claimed that the challenge of Naxalism in the
country is on its “last legs”. His assessment stems from the fact that the security
forces have been achieving signal successes against the Maoists. Fifteen Maoists
were killed in an encounter in the Konta area of Sukma district in Chhattisgarh on
August 6. According to the South Asia Terrorism Portal, at least 122 Maoists have
been killed across the country in the first six months of 2018. This is the highest
number of fatalities suffered by Maoists over the same period during the last eight
years. It is also a fact that the total area affected by Naxalism has shrunk to 90
districts of the country. The trajectory of Maoist violence has been showing a
downward trend. A number of central committee and politburo members have
been neutralised.

The government of India’s National Policy and Action Plan, with its emphasis on
security and development, is definitely making an impact. Apart from the
construction of roads, mobile towers, setting up of banks, post offices, Kendriya
Vidyalayas, etc, the most significant achievement has been in poverty reduction. A
recent study published in a Brookings blog says that by 2022, less than 3 per cent of
Indians will be poor and that extreme poverty could be eliminated altogether by
2030.

The above trends are, no doubt, positive. It would, however, be naïve to think that
we are about to see the end of Naxalism/Maoism in the country. If a historical
overview were taken of the movement during the last more than 50 years, there
were two occasions in the past when the government of India thought that the
Naxal movement had been disintegrated. The split in the party, the joint army-
police operations — ‘Operation Steeplechase’, as it was called — from July 1 to
August 15, 1971 followed by the arrest and subsequent death of Charu Majumdar
on July 28, 1972, gave, what then appeared to be a coup de grace to the movement.

The formation of the People’s War Group in Andhra Pradesh in 1980, however,
marked the revival of the movement and the beginning of its second phase. It soon
spread to the adjoining states of Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh and Orissa and
extended to Bihar, West Bengal, Karnataka and Tamil Nadu. Naxal violence touched
a peak in 1991. The movement was again hit hard by coordinated operations
undertaken by the security forces in the affected states. Internal dissensions leading
to the expulsion of Kondapalli Seetharamaiah weakened it further. The government
was lulled into believing that the movement had run its course.

The third phase of the movement began when the left-wing extremists decided, on
December 2, 2000, to set up a People’s Guerilla Army. In a comprehensive document
Strategy and Tactics of the Indian Revolution, it was said: “We cannot conceive a
people’s war without a people’s army”. The merger of the People’s War and the
Maoist Communist Centre in 2004 and the resultant formation of the CPI (Maoist)
consolidated the left-wing extremists and augmented their strength. The prime
minister (Manmohan Singh) said on September 15, 2009, while addressing the
police chiefs of the country, that “left-wing extremism is, perhaps, the greatest
threat our country faces.” The home minister (P Chidambaram), speaking at the
same gathering, stated that Maoist groups had pockets of influence in 20 states
across the country and 223 districts in these states were partially or substantially
affected.

The government today again holds the upper hand. However, the fact remains that
the basic problems which gave rise to the Naxal problem continue to haunt us. It
was rightly pointed out by the Expert Group of the Planning Commission back in
2008 that “the development paradigm pursued since Independence has aggravated
the prevailing discontent among marginalised sections of society” because “the
benefits of this paradigm have been disproportionately cornered by the dominant
section at the expense of the poor, who have borne most of the costs”.

It has been said that India has moved from British Raj to Billionaire Raj. India has
119 dollar billionaires, behind only the US and China. At the same time, according
to the World Inequality Report, 22 per cent of India’s national income is cornered
by the top one per cent. Inequalities have sharpened over the years. Such
disparities always have seeds of discontent, which have the potential to explode
into a rebellion. It is also a fact that on corruption, according to Transparency
International, we have slipped by two positions. Corruption is at the root of several
factors which cause popular dissatisfaction. Agrarian unrest continues to cause
serious concern. We saw in the month of March this year, the kisan long march
from Nashik to Mumbai. There are also reports that the Maoists have made a dent
in the Northeast and that they are active at the tri-junction of Kerala, Karnataka
and Tamil Nadu. All these are dangerous portents.

The government of India has two options before it. One, that it goes ahead and
crushes the Maoist movement. The possibility, in that case, is that the movement
would resurrect again, maybe in a new avtar, which could be even more lethal and
devastating than what we have seen so far. The other option is to offer the olive
branch to the Maoist leaders and carry out sincere measures to redress grievances,
particularly those relating to tribals.

Any offer of peace from a position of strength is always credible and has greater
chance of success. Perhaps the present situation offers an ideal opportunity to solve
the problem and save the future generations from the anger and frustrations of a
disgruntled and disaffected group of people. The government will, of course, have
to be careful that the Maoists do not use the peace period to gain time and regroup
their forces.
MUST WATCH

Xiaomi's
Rajkummar
How Kerala
Pocophone
Rao many Ooods:
launches
and Malayalees
A
Poco Shraddhalive quick
F1 Kapoorin guide
in Revealthe of
India: Eerie MiddleDOs
Here's Experience
East: and
a on News DON’Ts
Frst Stree in for
Thelook
writer, chairman of India Police Foundation, was member of Planning Commission’s
Sets Numbersthe
Expert Group to studypeople
‘Development Challenges in Extremist Affected Areas’
of
Kerala
For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App
after
returning
More From Prakashhome Singh

Towards a people’s police


The police force needs to be freed from the stranglehold of the executive and given
functional autonomy to enforce the rule of law. The Supreme…

A case of selective outrage


Kathua and Unnao incidents are barbaric, but calling these the darkest hour since
Independence is an overstatement...

Fear and faith


Under Yogi government, Uttar Pradesh police has instilled fear in criminals. But has it
won the people’s faith?..

SPONSORED CONTENT

People in Kolkata are 5 Tips That Will Help You Top Credit Card Deals
selected to test this new Take Awesome Pictures Unlocked For You!
German Hearing Aid TATA AIG BankBazaar.com
hear.com

Recommended by
What is your reaction? 1 vote Powered by Vuukle

0% 0% 100% 0% 0% 0%

happy unmoved amused excited angry sad

14 comments Recommend 0

Write a comment

3000

Name

or
Email

I agree with Vuukle's Privacy Policy

POST
Sort by: Latest Best Editor's Pick More

Bharat 15 points
B
6 minutes ago

NO this is not the time for peace. Eliminate the top naxal leaders who killed our
soldiers then talk... This will guarantee they will not rise again.

Like Reply

Reddy 575 points


R
an hour ago

No don't compromise, author like prakash sing are JNu products with Naxalite
sympathisers , they want to give breathing space for Naxalites so that Naxalism can
become active under congress government in future
Read more

Like Reply

Whoami 1.1K points


W
an hour ago

The persons responsible for such bankruptcies should face trial.....and


overexpediture should be recovered from them...

Like Reply

Whoami 1.1K points


W
an hour ago

Loan defaulter and bankrupt states in north west India is the biggest problem......

Like Reply

Ramesh Nittoor 20K points


RN
2 hours ago

Naxal represent an alternate mode to Constitutional democracy, there can be no


institutional interface with these outfits. However, justice dispensation, when done
per policy framework builds trust at local level, never smacks of vendetta or
oppression. This policy implementation challenge has not been adequately met.
Mostly due to lack of adequate resources and training. As per capita income
improves, governance quality shall also improve to address this challenge more
effectively.
Read more
Like Reply 1 Reply

Ramesh Nittoor 20K points Ramesh Nittoor


RN
2 hours ago

Besides governance there is a political aspect that has not been adequately met
by both left and right polity. Politics of hinterland unfortunately mostly splinters
along the caste lines, this offers little scope for left and right polity to work
simultaneously on different aspects of the complex political challenges faced
there. Enabling dual-mode politicization is perhaps the key to sustainable
development of regions where Naxals holds sway, and this shall drive Naxalism
away.
Read more

Like Reply 1 Reply

Ramesh Nittoor 20K points Ramesh Nittoor


RN
an hour ago

There is a strategic aspect to Naxal phenomenon that has now been tacked.
China masterminded and facilitated Naxal movement, however thanks to new
Sec-Arch with developed Constitutional democracies, and particularly after
Doklam, the Sino-factor has been neutralized. This makes it bit easier for
political and governance modes to operate bit more safely and work towards
superior justice dispensation for delivering on development.
Read more

Like Reply

Load more comments

TALK OF THE TOWN

Guess who India thinks is Kerala floods: Why foreign


the best prime minister of donations have triggered a
all time controversy

132 comments 54% 95 comments 40%

Winsome diverted $750 PM Modi takes a dig at Rajiv


million to promoterʼs firms Gandhi: ‘If our govt releases
abroad: Probe Rs 1, all 100 paisa reaches
the house of poorʼ
78 comments 70%
62 comments 60%

Arun Jaitley to resume ‘No chance at allʼ: Chief


charge as finance minister Election Commissioner on
today holding simultaneous polls

38 comments 90% 25 comments 87%

Show more articles

Vuukle

Add Vuukle to your site Privacy


ADVERTISEMENT

LIVE BLOG

BEST OF EXPRESS

Kerala Uoods: Nothing


oWcial yet, no amount
of Xnancial aid has
been announced, says
UAE
Sports
Asian Games 2018
LIVE: India win one
gold, two bronze
medals in Rowing

Govt panel: ‘Johnson &


Johnson buried key
facts on faulty hip
implant surgeries, kept
regulator in dark’

Government today
again holds upper hand
vis a vis Naxals. It’s the
best time to make
peace

Empowering existing
institutes holds the key
to creating institutes of
eminence

WATCH NOW

Splitsvilla 11 Hosts Rannvijay Singha and


Sunny Leone Reveal What They Hate
Abou

ADVERTISEMENT

BUZZING NOW
Entertainment
Happy Phirr Bhag
Jayegi movie review:
The writing is
determinedly juvenile

Entertainment
Ghoul review: This NetUix web series is
unnerving because it is unafraid
Entertainment
Merku Thodarchi Malai
movie review: A brilliant,
rooted slice-of-life fare

Trending
BJP retweets Rahul
Gandhi's photos... yeah,
you read that right!

Trending
Internet's latest
obsession with Dele
Alli's hand challenge is
quite creepy

ADVERTISEMENT

The ExpressGroup The Indian Express The Financial Express Loksatta Jansatta inUth Ramnath Goenka Awards
Privacy Policy Advertise with Us Contact Us Subscribe Statutory provisions on reporting (sexual offenses)

Copyright © 2018 The Indian Express [P] Ltd. All Rights Reserved

Você também pode gostar