Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Abstract: Background: A low ankle-brachial pressure index (an ABPI value <0.90) is considered predictive of
cardiovascular disease, and is widely thought to increase morbidity and mortality in the elderly. However, good
nutrition is beneficial both for the health and the ability to resist and recover from the disease. Objective: The aim
of the present study was to evaluate the relationship between the ankle-brachial pressure index and the nutritional
status of the elderly in a city of Kochi prefecture, Japan. Methods: This was a cross-sectional study in which a
total of 100 elderly people, both males and females, were screened for ankle-brachial pressure index (ABPI),
nutritional status (through the use of the short form of the mini nutritional assessment), activities of daily living,
lifestyle, gait speed (10MWT), postural stability (OLST), and functional mobility (TUg). Results: About 67% of
the participants were found to have a normal nutritional status, 27% were at risk of malnutrition, and six percent
were classified as malnourished. The mean ABPI of the participants was 1.08±0.10, and three participants had an
ABPI lower than 0.90. The ABPI was statistically higher in well nourished participants compared with those at
risk of malnutrition or the malnourished. The mean ABPI was significantly higher in non-smokers compared with
former smokers. The ABPI was found to correlate negatively with gait speed and with TUg score. Conclusion:
Well-nourished elderly had a higher normal ankle-brachial pressure index as compared with the malnourished
elderly. This study provides supportive evidence for the necessity of adequate nutrition for elderly people.
370
Received January 10, 2012
Accepted for publication August 20, 2012
The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging©
Volume 17, Number 4, 2013
JNHA: NUTRITION
to answer a questionnaire. A total of 180 elderly people agreed BP<120 mm Hg and diastolic BP<80mm Hg), prehypertension
to participate in the study, however, 80 of them (44.4%) were (systolic BP=120-139 mm Hg, or diastolic BP=80-89 mm Hg),
not available during our three day fieldwork period. The hypertension stage one (systolic BP= 140-159 mm Hg, or
primary reason for non-participation was due to the diastolic BP=90-99 mm Hg), and hypertension stage two
participants’ work schedules. Another reason for non- (systolic BP≥160 mm Hg or diastolic BP≥100 mm Hg).
participation was probably the absence of reminder invitation. The participants’ height and body weight were measured
The elderly interested in the study were instructed to visit the using a stadiometer, and a mechanical medical scale (subjects
local community centers once for a health check-up. wore normal indoor clothing without shoes), respectively.
Body mass index (BMI) was calculated by dividing weight in
Questionnaire kg by height in meters squared, and was categorized based on
The participants were instructed to fill out a questionnaire guidelines of the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute
(which took about 30 minutes), with visually impaired (26).
participants being assisted by our research team. The research This study was approved by the Research Ethics Committee
team included five medical doctors and two nurses. All the of Kochi Medical School, and all subjects were registered after
participants visited the local community center once during the giving their informed consent to participate in this study.
three days field work period. Information collected on their
lifestyle included food intake frequency, smoking habits, and Statistical analysis
alcohol consumption. In addition, participants were screened Data was analyzed using Stata software package version 10
for nutritional status, activities of daily living (ADL) (17), (STATACORP LP, 4905 Lakeway Drive, College Station, TX
instrumental activities of daily living (IADL) (18), medications, 77845, USA), and p<0.05 was considered to be statistically
current and past diseases, and living area. Nutritional status was significant. The Kolmogorov-Smirnov test was used to test for
evaluated using the mini nutritional assessment short form the normality of data distribution. The correlation between
(MNA-SF) and scores were classified as “normal” (12-14), “at ABPI and health parameters was conducted using Pearson’s
risk of malnutrition” (8-11) or as exhibiting “malnutrition” (0- correlation. The Student’s t-test and the Chi-squared test were
7) (19). used respectively to evaluate differences in ABPI between
different groups and categorical variables. Multiple regression
Measurements analysis was performed to evaluate the relationship between
The participants’ ankle-brachial pressure index, gait speed, ABPI and studied parameters. The results of quantitative
postural stability, basic functional mobility, and blood pressure, variables are presented both as the mean ± standard deviation of
height, body weight measurements were assessed in the local the mean.
health centers. The ABPI of both brachial arteries (arms) and
both dorsalis pedis and posterior tibial arteries (ankles) was results
measured by a trained orthopedist doctor according to
American College of Cardiology Foundation/American Heart General characteristics of the participants
Association (ACCF/AHA) guidelines (20). A device (VP-1000; As shown in Table 1, the study included more females (79%)
Colin Co., Komaki, Japan) that automatically measures ABPI than males (21%) and the mean age of the participants was
and pulse wave velocity was used for both validity and 76.7±6 years. Fourteen participants (14%) consumed alcohol
reproducibility of results (21). ABPI measurement was then everyday while twelve (12%) reported as consuming alcohol
classified as follows: “low” (ABPI ≤0.90), “normal” (0.91- occasionally. One participant (one percent) was a tobacco
1.30), and “high” (ABPI >1.30) indicating the presence of smoker, and eleven participants (11%) were former smokers.
medial arterial calcification (MAC). For each participant, the Fifty-four participants (54%) reported having regular physical
lowest ABPI was used for data analysis. activity. The mean BMI of participants was 23.5±3 kg/m2
gait speed was assessed by the 10-meter walk test (10MWT) (range, 12.3-30) and five percent of the participants were
(22), postural stability by the one leg standing test (OLST) (23), classified as underweight (BMI<18.5 kg/m2). The mean
and functional mobility by the Timed Up and go test (TUg). systolic blood pressure was 139±22 mmHg while the mean
The TUg was expressed in seconds, and was defined as the diastolic blood pressure was 71±11 mmHg. Pre-hypertension
time required for a participant to rise from an arm chair, walk was noted in forty-three participants (43%), hypertension stage
three meters, return to the chair and sit down again (24). one in thirty participants (30%), hypertension stage two in
Blood pressure (BP) was measured with a standard mercury sixteen participants (16%), while eleven participants (11%)
sphygmomanometer after the participants had had a ten minute were normotensive. A small number of participants (seven
rest. BP was classified in the following four categories percent) had a diastolic blood pressure greater than 90 mmHg.
according to the Seventh Report of the Joint National Ten percent of participants had a limitation in at least one item
Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation, and of ADL. There were no statistically significant differences
Treatment of High Blood pressure (25). Normal (systolic between men and women in terms of age, BMI, blood pressure
371
The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging©
Volume 17, Number 4, 2013
table 1
general characteristics of the study population
Variables normal nutrition risk of malnutrition malnutrition (n=6) total (n=100) p value (normal p value (normal
status (n=67) (n=27) nutrition vs risk of nutrition vs
malnutrition) malnutrition)
and ADL, though more women were found with impaired ADL. In regard to the relationship between the MNA score and
IADL. co-morbidities, among the six participants who were classified
Forty-seven participants (47%) were free of chronic as malnourished, five (83.3%) suffered from at least one
diseases. Five participants (five percent) reported a past history chronic disease. Fourteen participants (51.9%) who were at risk
of atherosclerosis, one participant (one percent) a past history of malnutrition reported having at least one chronic disease and
of asthma, one participant (one percent) a chronic obstructive thirty-one participants (46.3%) with normal nutritional status
pulmonary disease, while seven participants reported kyphosis. had at least one chronic disease.
Other chronic diseases such as diabetes, arthritis, anaemia, and
peptic ulcers were also reported. Forty participants (40%) Ankle-brachial pressure index
declared using more than three medications per day. The mean ABPI of the participants was 1.08±0.10 (range,
The mean gait speed, OLST, and TUg expressed in seconds 0.35-1.27), and it did not differ between right ABPI and left
was the following, respectively: 7.2±2.2 , 36.8±21.6, and ABPI (1.11±0.10 vs 1.10±0.10; P=0.251). An ABPI greater
8.9±5.0. gait speed and TUg were found to correlate than 1.30 that could have suggested the presence of MAC was
significantly (r= 0.470; P<0.001), while a negative correlation not observed. Three participants had an ABPI lower than 0.90,
was found between gait speed and OLST (r= -0.480; P<0.001). and these three participants were asymptomatic with past
medical conditions of hypertension, diabetes and smoking. The
Mini nutritional assessment ABPI was slightly higher in females than in males, but the
The mean of the MNA score was 12.2±1.8. About 67% of difference was not statistically significant (P=0.070).
the participants were found to have a normal nutritional status Participants who lived along the coast had a higher ABPI than
(MNA score, 13.2±0.8), 27% were at risk of malnutrition those living in the mountainous areas, and the differences were
(MNA score, 10.5±0.6), and six percent were classified as statistically significant (0.004). The mean ABPI in non-
malnourished (MNA score, 5.7±2.3). For all participants, the smokers was significantly higher than in former smokers
MNA were found to correlate positively with BMI and gait (p<0.001).
speed, while the MNA was negatively correlated with impaired
372
The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging©
Volume 17, Number 4, 2013
JNHA: NUTRITION
Correlation between ABPI and health assessment and age (r= -0.232; P=0.020). Postural stability was also
parameters positively correlated with ABPI (r=0.347; P=0.002). The ABPI
Figure 1 shows the ABPI of the participants according to had a negative correlation with gait speed (r= -0.355; P<0.001)
their nutritional status rated by MNA score. The ABPI was and TUg test (r= -0.237; P=0.010). A significant negative
statistically higher in well nourished participants compared correlation was found between systolic blood pressure and
with those at risk of malnutrition or malnourished. ABPI (r= -0.240; P=0.010) in the group of participants with an
ABPI lower than 1:00.
Figure 1
Ankle-brachial index of the participants according to their Multiple regression analysis for ABPI
nutritional status rated by mini nutritional assessment (MNA) Table 3 shows the results of multiple regression analysis
score (n= 100) with the explanatory set for ABPI. The model was adjusted for
the following parameters as predictors: age, sex, systolic blood
pressure, diastolic blood pressure, tobacco smoking, nutritional
status, ADL, past chronic diseases, the TUg score, the OLST
score, and gait speed. Among the predictors, smoking,
nutritional status and the TUg test were significantly associated
with ABPI; they accounted for 28% of the variation in ABPI.
After removing the TUg and the OLST in the model to avoid
multicollinearity, however, ABPI was negatively associated
with gait speed (beta= -0.260; p=0.023; adjusted R2=0.218).
table 3
Multiple regression analysis for ABPI
0.28
MNA scores 0.230 0.010
* ABPI in elderly at risk of malnutrition vs ABPI in elderly with normal nutrition status, Smoking - 0.380 0.007
p=0.005; ** ABPI in malnourished elderly vs ABPI in elderly with normal nutrition status,
Timed Up and - 0.420 0.001
p=0.020
go scores
373
The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging©
Volume 17, Number 4, 2013
community. The major findings of this study were that pressure control of the participants (average of 139/71mmHg)
nutritional status evaluated by MNA-SF, along with cigarette may have contributed to the normal mean ABPI found in this
smoking, gait speed, and the TUg scores were significantly study. This is in accord with the Framingham Offspring study,
correlated with ABPI, and the correlation remained even after which found that smoking and hypertension were significant
adjusting for confounding factors. Although, impaired ADL, correlates of lower ABPI (31).
age, and postural stability were correlated with ABPI; after
controlling for confounding factors, however, correlations were ABPI, cigarette smoking and alcohol consumption
not statistically significant. Non-smokers had a significantly higher mean ABPI
compared with former smokers and the difference remains
Mini nutritional assessment and ABPI statistically significant even after controlling for confounding
Twenty-seven participants (27%) were at risk of factors; this means that the threat of low ABPI remains years
malnutrition and six participants (6%) were classified as after cessation of tobacco smoking. This fact shows the need
malnourished, being of particular concern because malnutrition for programs that prevent people from starting tobacco
increases morbidity and mortality among elderly people. These smoking. These findings concur with previous reports
results highlight the importance of early detection of regarding ABPI and smoking (9, 32, 33). The study by Fowler
malnutrition or risk of malnutrition in the elderly, so that early et al. (33) found that previous smoking and current smoking
nutritional intervention can occur. were responsible for low ABPI in one-third of the 4470
The prevalence of the risk of malnutrition varies participants aged between 65 and 83 years. The Quebec
considerably depending on the population studied and the vascular study (32) found an inverse association between
criteria used for the diagnosis (27). Available data for the risk cigarette smoking and intermittent claudication (IC) among
of malnutrition worldwide indicates that the prevalence of the 4570 participants aged 47 to 76 years at the end of the study,
risk of malnutrition as rated by the MNA-SF in community- while the risk of IC in participants who cease tobacco smoking
dwelling elderly is 24 percent (19). In this study, 27% of the one year before had a similar risk compared to those who never
participants were at risk of malnutrition and 53% of the smoked. However, another study by Hooi et al. (9) observed
participants reported as suffering from at least one disease. This that former smokers had an increased risk of PAD but the
is in agreement with the report by the Japanese Ministry of difference was not statistically significant with non-smokers.
Health, Labor and Welfare, which reported that 30% of In this study, about 14% of the participants reported as
Japanese community-dwelling elderly are at risk of consuming alcohol everyday. However, their mean ABPI did
malnutrition, and 50% are suffering from at least one health not differ from both those who consumed alcohol occasionally
problem requiring medical attention (28). and those who never drank alcohol. These findings are
The findings in this study show that well-nourished consistent with a previous report which reported no significant
participants had significantly higher normal ABPI than other association between low ABPI and alcohol consumption (33),
participants. ABPI has traditionally been used as a non-invasive but are inconsistent with the Edinburgh Artery Study (34), a
marker of generalized atherosclerosis, since it may help to cross sectional survey which found higher levels of ABPI in the
detect the individuals in the general population who are at risk men with the highest alcohol consumption among 1592
of cardiovascular disease (6). Therefore, ABPI measurement participants aged 55 to 74 years.
had been recommended by the AHA (29) as it is highly
efficient for cardiovascular disease prevention programs. To ABPI, TUG score, and gait speed
interpret the relationship between ABPI and MNA, it is The TUg test and gait speed are used to evaluate a basic
important to consider the mechanism by which good nutritional functional mobility that may help to detect the elderly at risk of
status may protect against atherosclerosis. A study by health-related events (24, 35). The mean TUg score and gait
Chakrabarty et al. (30) reported that malnutrition exposes the speed observed in this study were 8.9±5 seconds and 7.2±2.2
endothelium to oxidative stress injury, while good nutritional seconds respectively, supporting the classification of
status leads to a better control of abnormal platelet participants as faster, thus confirming that participants in this
accumulation, helping to prevent or reduce endothelial injury, study were rather active. The mean TUg score found in this
improve the ability to recover in case of endothelial injury, and study is in line with the value reported in the literature
stop inflammatory response that may generate atheromatous describing healthy Japanese subjects (8.86 seconds) (36);
plaque. In the present study, the ABPI of most of the Steffen et al. also reported a mean TUg score of 9.1 seconds in
participants was within the normal range (1.08±0.10); however, 96 community dwelling elderly aged between 61 and 89 years
three participants had an ABPI lower than 0.90, the three (37). However, a study by Newton (38) reported a mean TUg
participants being advised to consult a vascular specialist for score of 15 seconds, ranged between 5.4 and 40.8. The reason
additional monitoring. for this discrepancy is that Newton included participants who
The fact of the number of tobacco smoker among the were using ambulatory devices but in our study none of the
participants being very small (only one), and the good blood participants used an ambulatory device.
374
The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging©
Volume 17, Number 4, 2013
JNHA: NUTRITION
Several studies have evaluated whether ABPI has an Author’s contribution: 1. Yasunori NAgANO: data collection, discussion of the study
375
The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging©
Volume 17, Number 4, 2013
376
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.