Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Donald B. Roberts, MD
From the Department of Pediatrics, Trip/er Army Medical Center, Hawaii 96859
DEFINITION
Total 16 1
* Abbreviations used are: PPLO, pleuropneumonia-like organisms; FA, fluorescent antibody.
Total 13 1
Abbreviations used are: MK, rhesus monkey kidney; Hep-2, human epidermoid carcinoma oflarynx; DF, WI-26 strain
of human diploid fibroblasts.
Totals 21 9 10 3 43 23 66
Percentages 32 14 15 5 65 35 100
were grown in percentages similar to the percent- Table 4 summarizes the cultures for Mycoplasma
ages obtained from a voluminous literature on cul- from ears with abnormalities of a nonbullous na-
tures from AOM. A search of the English language ture. These were considered by the various authors
literature failed to find any other reports of cultures to be either acute otitis media or serous otitis media.
of any kind from ears with MB. Out of a total of 858 such cultures there was one
positive for M pneumoniae. That was a culture of with meningitis after his fourth attack. Karelitz did
an external canal swab following a myringotomy not do cultures of the ears.
and was not bacteriologically sterile.26 A study by Yoshie is frequently cited as evi-
There is, then, only one published case of the dence that MB can be caused by influenza virus.
aspirate of an ear with MB growing Mpneumoniae Since the study has been quoted so often, it will be
and one growing a virus, in contrast to the 40 of 66 examined in some detail here. Yoshie’s report con-
which grew one or more of the three most common cerned “influenzal otitis media,” which he defined
pathogens in acute purulent otitis media. It is not as .an acute
“. . hemorrhagic otitis media accompa-
known whether the one case positive for M pneu- nied by severe otodynia.” During “a small epidemic
moniae was sterile for the usual bacterial patho- of influenza-like febrile infection. . . .“ there were
gens. 876 outpatients seen in a clinic, 97 of whom had
In spite of the available evidence summarized “otitis media,” and 27 of these had what was
above, many authors continue to state that MB is thought to be “influenzal” otitis media. Yoshie
caused by Mpneumoniae, and that Mpneumoniae chose ten cases to culture out these 27 and isolated
is one of the agents causing AOM. The reasons for viruses in four; he does not state the collection
these statements will be the subject of the following method. Although he states that bacteriologic ex-
discussion. aminations were done, there is no mention of the
results in any of the ear discharges examined; thus
it is impossible to determine whether these were
DISCUSSION OF THE LITERATURE also positive for pathogenic bacteria.
Because of the unspecified appearance of the ears
Role of Viruses
studied, the criteria for selecting the cases for study,
Long before the first description of the Eaton the uncertainty of method of sample collection
agent (pleuropneumonia-like organisms (PPLO), used, and the lack of standard bacteriology reports,
Mycoplasma pneumoniae), MB was thought to be the case for a viral etiology for the otitis itself,
caused by “influenza.”32 There were a number of separate from the accompanying respiratory infec-
published observations that MB accompanied cases tion, is a weak one. The study says nothing about
of clinical influenza. Indeed, MB was sometimes the viral etiology of bullous myringitis.
called “influenzal otitis.” That MB was not neces- Tilles et al24 cultured needle aspirates from nine
sarily specific for influenzal disease was noted over patients with MB and grew an adenovirus 3 from
40 years ago by Karelitz.’ He described the clinical the bacteriologically sterile otitic fluid of one of
appearance, symptoms, and course of 147 cases of them from an 8-year-old child. (In the same study
“myringitis bullosa hemorrhagica” in 87 patients. they grew known bacterial pathogens in five of the
He found that “myringitis bullosa hemorrhagica” nine.)
occurred with a variety of upper respiratory tract
infections including measles. In addition, 17 of Ka-
Role of M pneumoniae
relitz’s patients had purulent drainage, either spon-
taneously or after myringotomy. There were three A study reported by Rifkind et al25 first raised
cases of mastoiditis in children, and one child died the possibility of Mpneumoniae as a cause of MB.
PEDIATRICS
Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on FebruaryFOR THE
19, 2019 CLINICIAN 763
This study is widely reported as demonstrating the Couch et al found two cases of MB among 27
Mycoplasma etiology of MB, and has been the volunteers inoculated with tissue culture-propa-
impetus for many subsequent studies. As is often gated M pneumoniae and none in 42 cases inocu-
the case in medical literature, the original study lated with agar-grown M pneumoniae. The ears
was done well, carefully controlled, adequately re- were not cultured. Numerous other cases of natu-
ported, and rationally discussed. The conclusions rally occurring and experimentally-induced Eaton
reached are somewhat tentative, and are so stated. agent ifinesses have had a lower reported incidence
It is the interpretation of this study by subsequent of MB.34#{176}
authors that has been largely responsible for the Table 5 lists six studies of the epidemiology and
belief that a mycoplasmal etiology for MB has been clinical course of Mycoplasma infections. Thirty-
proven. seven of 612 cases were reported to have ear in-
Riflund et al inoculated 52 men, 21 to 36 years of volvement (6%) and at least six of these had MB
age, with an Eaton agent inoculum. Twenty-seven (at least 1%). These figures are certainly lower than
of these men had no prior demonstrable Eaton 13 of 52 in Rifkind’s study alone who developed
agent antibody (titer < 1:10) and 25 had titers of 1: myringitis (25%), and the two of 52 with MB (3.8%).
10 to 1:80. In the group without antibody, 12 devel- There is no obvious explanation for the difference
oped “myringitis” and in the group with antibodies, in the incidence of eardrum involvement among
one developed “myringitis.” The authors state: these studies. Perhaps it was overlooked in some
(yet pharyngitis, posterior cervical adenopathy, ex-
The myringitis was usually bilateral and was accompa-
nied by throbbing pain. Posterior cervical lymphadenop- udate, and mucoid rhinorrhea were duly noted), or
athy was present in four subjects. Ear involvement varied the conditions of or around the experimental sub-
from a mild injection of the tympanic membranes to a jects differed in some unspecified way.
severe inflammatory reaction with edema. In five patients Whatever the reasons for the differences noted,
hemorrhagic areas appeared over the drums and adjacent two of Rifkind’s and two of Couch’s subjects did
membranes. In two of these,
preceded hemorrhage
the develop MB after upper airway inoculation of M
appearance of serous-filled blebs which also later filled pneumoniae. The only sample taken from one of
with blood. There was neither bulging of the membrane the involved ears itself, however, was negative for
nor fluid behind the drum, and spontaneous perforation
M pneumoniae, suggesting, but not proving, that
did not occur.
the M pneumoniae upper airway involvement es-
A bleb in one case was ruptured and cultured- tablished an inflammatory reaction that involved
without success-for Eaton agent. Bacterial cul- the ears, but that Mpneumoniae was not in the ear
tures of the same fluid grew Staphyloccoccus albus itself.
and diphtheroids. The remainder of the ears with Sob#{232}slavsk et al26 are also widely quoted in the
myringitis were not punctured for culture because literature as having demonstrated that M pneumo-
no fluid was seen behind the membrane. The au- niae can cause MB. They reported the Rificind
thors stated that the absence of suppurative disease study as demonstrating that the myringitis ob-
and “the aggregation of these illnesses in the anti- served was “due to” Mpneumoniae. They did state
body-free group support the contention that Eaton that Mycoplasma was not recovered from the ears
agent was responsible for this complication.” of any of Ritkind’s cases, but only from other por-
Thus, Rificind et al found two cases of MB in 27 tions of the respiratory tract. Sob#{233}slavsk then
antibody-negative men inoculated with Eaton reported three cases observed while examining 20
agent. A bleb on one of these ears was cultured for children with the diagnosis of “acute otitis media.”
Eaton agent. It was not grown. One of these three patients had blebs on his ear-
In experimentally-induced respiratory infections, drum, and the other two had eardrums that were
Updated Information & including high resolution figures, can be found at:
Services http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/65/4/761
Permissions & Licensing Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or in its
entirety can be found online at:
http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xhtml
Reprints Information about ordering reprints can be found online:
http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtml
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on
the World Wide Web at:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/65/4/761
Pediatrics is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it has
been published continuously since 1948. Pediatrics is owned, published, and trademarked by the
American Academy of Pediatrics, 141 Northwest Point Boulevard, Elk Grove Village, Illinois, 60007.
Copyright © 1980 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 1073-0397.