In Defence of Alice Walker

1/7/2019 In defence of Alice Walker | Middle East | Al Jazeera
OPINION / MIDDLE EAST
In defence of Alice Walker

Alice Walker's real 'offence' is not anti-Semitism; it is her unwavering support for the
Palestinian cause.
by Susan Abulhawa
4 Jan 2019
Pulitzer-prize winning author Alice Walker talks with Palestinian women during a visit in Beit Hanoun in the
northern Gaza Strip on March 8, 2009 [File: AP Photo/Hatem Moussa]
Much has been said about Alice Walker in recent weeks, none of it good. It was her turn
to get churned through the gristmill of Zionist slander, pummelled with recycled
accusations
We use cookiesof
to anti-Semitism after she
give you the best possible mentioned
experience. Learnreading And
more about the
how weTruth ShallorSet
use cookies editYou
your
cookie preferences.
https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/defence-alice-walker-190104043720518.html 1/6
Free (1995) by David Icke, a book widely regarded as anti-Semitic. To be clear, Walker
never said she agreed with or embraced Icke's views. She said she was interested in his
writings and found him "brave" for saying things opposed by popular sensibilities.
I've never read Icke, save for recent excerpts plucked out by his critics, and I don't feel the
need to do so in order to state that guilt by association is wholly unfair. The excerpts are
terrible, but they do not reflect on Ms Walker simply because she read them.
The poem
"But did you read Alice Walker's poem?" People have said to me. "It's as anti-Semitic as it
gets."
I am reminded of Dareen Tatour, who was imprisoned by Israel for a poem she posted on
Facebook, on the fanciful claim it called for violence against Jews; and Gunter Grass,
whom Israel banned and lobbied to have his Nobel Prize in Literature rescinded because
he wrote a poem arguing that Germany should stop supplying Israel with nuclear
submarines. Even the work of Mahmoud Darwish, Palestine's greatest poet, was
denounced as the equivalent of Adolf Hitler's Mein Kampf.
In general, I think delineating and policing the boundaries of inquiry and artistic pursuit
is never a good idea. It is no exaggeration to say that Alice Walker is a cultural icon whose
intellectual labour and imaginative creativity contributed to the moral advancement of
American society. Yet the ways in which she has been simply dismissed and disposed of
as an anti-Semite have been stunningly swift, decisive, and defamatory.
It is for this reason that I feel compelled to respond, even at this late hour and despite the
attacks I am likely to receive. It is also because I have been asked, as a Palestinian writer
and member of several collectives, by some of our allies to denounce her; and because Ms
Walker is a thoughtful, compassionate and brilliant woman who deserves better from us.
Her poem begins with the shock of being called an anti-Semite for daring to suggest
universal human dignity belongs to Palestinians, too. It goes on to examine Israel's
We use cookies tocruel
unfathomably give you
andtheunrelentingly violent Learn
best possible experience. more about
treatment cookies or edit your
how we use Palestinians.
of indigenous From
cookie preferences.
there, Ms Walker searches the Talmud for answers. Then she calls out passages that
uphold Jewish supremacy and anti-Gentile (goyim) values.
According to Rabbi Rosen, the passages are real. All monotheistic religious texts span the
full spectrum of ideas, from the noblest to the vilest. The Bible and Quran have their own
versions of misogynistic, homophobic, and shockingly violent passages, which are
frequently called out, and in the case of the Quran, used to frame the destruction of
defenceless societies.
Walker's critics make a fair point

Those denouncing Walker have said that pulling out the worst texts from a religious
tradition to make sweeping statements about its adherents goes beyond critical analysis,
into xenophobia.
This is a fair point, one with which I agree wholeheartedly. But that's not what happened,
and the suggestions otherwise are dishonest.
Keeping in mind we're talking about a poem, not a political essay, Ms Walker certainly
did not make sweeping statements about Jews, but about a decidedly Jewish settler-
colonial theocracy, whose ministers and military frequently use rabbinic edicts and
religious texts to justify unspeakable oppression against Palestinians.
Weaponisation of Jewish texts

For decades, Israeli political, cultural and religious leaders have been shaping the social,
legal and psychological landscape with repugnant guidance - inhumanity they serve to
their public as divinely ordained truth. Some examples: In 2010, Rabbis Yitzhak Shapira
and Yosef Elitzur wrote The King's Torah, a rabbinical instruction manual outlining
acceptable murder of Gentile babies, children and adults in which it claimed that the
commandment "thou shalt not kill" applies only to Jews. The book was widely distributed
throughout Israel from their yeshiva, which was funded by the Israeli government and by
US tax-exempt charities.
We use cookies to give you the best possible experience. Learn more about how we use cookies or edit your
cookie preferences.
In 2016, Israel's chief Sephardic Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef declared publicly that non-Jews
should not be permitted to live in Israel except as servants to Jews. In March 2018, the
same chief rabbi compared black people with monkeys and later defended this racism as
being supported by the Talmud.
In April 2018, a translation of rabbi Ophir Wallas' lecture revealed he was teaching
upcoming soldiers that they are religiously permitted to commit genocide against
Palestinians, but that fear of international condemnation is preventing it.
These are not proclamations by fringe Israelis. They are not poems by writers with no
material power. Rather, they constitute a deeply embedded ethos of a huge swathe of
Israeli society, including politicians, generals and spiritual leaders with extraordinary
power - with planes, bombs, tanks, bulldozers, and toxic chemicals they use on
Palestinians regularly.
They aren't just hurting people's feelings, but spurring real and profound injury to
millions of human beings, every hour of every day, one generation after another,
producing the soul-crushing statistics of an ancient people's slow erasure from this world.
Selective condemnation
Yet those denouncing Alice Walker and calling on Palestinians to do the same did not
once take up space in the New York Times, New York Magazine, or other prominent
media venues to denounce the dissemination of the worst ideas from Jewish texts, which
continue to inspire violence against Palestinians, their properties and holy places,
including the increasing "price tag" assaults.
Nor have Palestinians called on allies to do so. We who are killed, humiliated, and
destroyed in visible and invisible ways by Israel's notions of Jewish supremacy do not
expect our allies to prove over and over where they stand.
We also never point to the religious teachings Israelis consistently use to justify their
barbarism. We take painstaking care to always make the distinction between the awful
We use cookies
political to giveofyou
ideology the best and
Zionism possible
theexperience.
religion toLearn more
which it about how we use cookies or edit your
clings.
cookie preferences.
That Alice Walker used literary creativity to highlight the specific religious sources
verifiably used to promulgate hatred does not make her racist and it is not a reason to
turn on a beloved elder.
The real offence

Ms Walker's real offence is her defiant support for Palestinian liberation. It is her
unapologetic endorsement of BDS, the international Boycott, Divest and Sanction
campaign against Israel.
Only weeks before the Zionist machines began clawing at Ms Walker, they were trying to
skewer Professor Marc Lamont Hill.
Before them, there was Jimmy Carter, Jeremy Corbyn, Desmond Tutu, Roger Waters,
John Mearsheimer, Stephen Walt, Helen Thomas, Richard Falk. And before them was a
whole generation of black revolutionaries. The list is too long to go on.
Their crime isn't that they're actually anti-Semitic. It is a sinister violation of public
imagination to put any of these individuals under the same word as the attacker who
opened fire in a Pittsburgh synagogue, or the white nationalists who chanted "Jews will
not replace us", or those who paint swastikas on their bodies and fly Nazi flags.
Alice Walker's legacy has been one of love, defiance, and living one's truth. She is a
towering cultural figure, a civil rights leader, an ardent feminist, and a brave champion of
human rights. She is also imperfect and not beyond criticism. But an anti-Semite she is
not.
The v iew s expr essed in this a r ticle a r e the a u thor 's ow n a nd do not
necessa r ily r eflect Al Ja zeer a 's editor ia l sta nce.
cookie preferences.
cookie preferences.

In Defence of Alice Walker - Middle East - Al Jazeera

Enviado por

Dados do documento

Título original

Direitos autorais

Formatos disponíveis

Compartilhar este documento

Compartilhar ou incorporar documento

Opções de compartilhamento

Você considera este documento útil?

Este conteúdo é inapropriado?

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

In Defence of Alice Walker - Middle East - Al Jazeera

Enviado por

Direitos autorais:

Formatos disponíveis

1/7/2019 In defence of Alice Walker | Middle East | Al Jazeera

OPINION / MIDDLE EAST

Walker's critics make a fair point

Weaponisation of Jewish texts

The real offence

Você também pode gostar