EVALUATION FORM

Is this a new and original contribution to the literature in this field?*

Excellent

Very good

Good

Average

Below Average

Is the paper clear, concise, and well organized?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Is the paper written in correct English?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

From an analysis and development viewpoint does the paper possess completeness and technical clarity?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Does the paper maintain reader's interest, and is it important to scientific-community knowledge?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average
Are the interpretations and conclusions sound and justifiable?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Does the Abstract contain a sufficient summary of the paper's contents to be useful and informative?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Does the title of the paper reflect sufficiently and clearly the contents?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Are the Illustrations and Tables all necessary and acceptable?*

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Are the References adequate and appropriate?

Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Overall Rating of Paper?*

 Excellent

Very Good

Good

Average

Below Average

Please summarize the main contribution of the paper.(Use as much space as is needed).*

Please give a frank account of the strengths and weaknesses of the article, including any suggested revision to be done by the author(s). (Use as much space as is
needed.)*

ented and observed.

Record your Decision*

Accept Submission

Revision Required

Resubmit for Review

Decline Submission