Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
OBJECTIVES: To confirm the safety of using acetaminophen for febrile seizures (FSs) and to abstract
assess its efficacy in preventing FS recurrence during the same fever episode.
METHODS: In this single-center, prospective, open, randomized controlled study, we included
children and infants (age range: 6–60 months) with FSs who visited our hospital between
May 1, 2015, and April 30, 2017. The effectiveness of acetaminophen was examined by
comparing the recurrence rates of patients in whom rectal acetaminophen (10 mg/kg) was
administered every 6 hours until 24 hours after the first convulsion (if the fever remained
>38.0°C) to the rates of patients in whom no antipyretics were administered. No placebo
was administered to controls. The primary outcome measure was FS recurrence during the
same fever episode.
RESULTS: We evaluated 423 patients; of these, 219 were in the rectal acetaminophen group,
and 204 were in the no antipyretics group. In the univariate analysis, the FS recurrence
rate was significantly lower in the rectal acetaminophen group (9.1%) than in the no
antipyretics group (23.5%; P < .001). Among the variables in the final multiple logistic
regression analysis, rectal acetaminophen use was the largest contributor to the prevention
of FS recurrence during the same fever episode (odds ratio: 5.6; 95% confidence interval:
2.3–13.3).
CONCLUSIONS: Acetaminophen is a safe antipyretic against FSs and has the potential to prevent
FS recurrence during the same fever episode.
Drs Murata, Okasora, and Tanabe conceptualized and designed the study, drafted the initial WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: The current study is the
manuscript, and reviewed and revised the manuscript; Drs Ogino, Yamasaki, Oba, Syabana, first randomized controlled trial to assess the
Nomura, Shirasu, and Inoue created the sampling and analysis protocols, supervised the data ability of acetaminophen to prevent febrile seizure
collection, were involved in the data interpretation and discussion, and critically reviewed and recurrence during the same fever episode with
edited the manuscript; Drs Kashiwagi and Tamai were involved in the study design and data bivariate and multiple logistic regression analyses.
acquisition and contributed to the writing of the manuscript; and all authors approved the
manuscript as submitted and agree to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
This trial has been registered with the UMIN Clinical Trials Registry (https://upload.umin.ac.jp/cgi-
open-bin/ctr/ctr_view.cgi?recptno=R000032366) (identifier UMIN000028272).
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2018-1009
Accepted for publication Aug 20, 2018
Address correspondence to Shinya Murata, MD, PhD, Department of Pediatrics, Hirakata City
To cite: Murata S, Okasora K, Tanabe T, et al. Acetaminophen
Hospital, 2-14-1 Kinya-honmachi, Hirakata, Osaka 573-1013, Japan. E-mail: wildwind1980@live.jp
and Febrile Seizure Recurrences During the Same Fever
Episode. Pediatrics. 2018;142(5):e20181009
2 MURATA et al
mild gastroenteritis (CwG).11 For
patients with diarrhea, we checked
the seizure recurrence rate during
the same fever episode and compared
it with the rate from patients without
diarrhea who were included in our
randomized trial.
Statistical Analysis
We used JMP version 13 software
(SAS Institute, Inc, Cary, NC) for
the statistical analyses. Statistical
significance was set at P < .05.
The primary outcome was seizure
recurrence during the same fever
episode. We estimated the sample
size for the multiple logistic
regression analysis using standard
methods; at least 10 cases were
presumed to be necessary for each FIGURE 1
independent variable. As the FS Study enrollment.
recurrence rate within the same
fever episode was estimated to be logistic regression analysis was in the no antipyretics group were
15%,5 400 children with FSs were performed with all variables showing excluded from the analysis because
required to perform a multiple P < .05 in the bivariate analysis. We of nonadherence to the protocol or
logistic regression analysis with 5 determined the final multivariate loss to follow-up. Finally, the data
independent variables. logistic regression model by from 423 patients, 219 in the rectal
Patients’ characteristics and hierarchical background elimination. acetaminophen group and 204 in the
laboratory data were compared We also assessed the linearity of no antipyretics group, were analyzed
between the rectal acetaminophen variables in the final multivariate (Fig 1). None of the patients used
and no antipyretics groups. We logistic regression model to verify diazepam suppositories during the
stratified the patient characteristics the validity of the model using the study period.
and laboratory data by age (6–21 and statistical software R (version 3.2.5).
No significant differences in the
22–60 months). Continuous variables
patient characteristics or laboratory
were compared by using Mann–
RESULTS data were identified between
Whitney U test. Binary variables were
the rectal acetaminophen and no
compared by using Pearson’s χ2 test. Patient Characteristics antipyretics groups, regardless of
We first conducted bivariate analyses During the study period, a total of stratification by age (6–21, 22–60
and then used a multiple logistic 794 children visited our hospital months, and all patients). The rate
regression analysis to identify the for FSs. Of these, 279 children were of FS recurrence during the same
factors that contributed to the excluded (188 who used diazepam fever episode was 16.0% (68 out
decrease in FS recurrence within suppository to prevent FSs, 34 who of 423 patients). All FS recurrences
the same fever episode. Bivariate had taken antihistamines, and 57 occurred within 24 hours after the
analyses were performed by others), and the parents of another initial FS. The rate of FS recurrence
comparing the patient characteristics 17 children declined to participate during the same fever episode
and laboratory data according in this study. Sixty children with was significantly lower in the
to the presence or absence of FS diarrhea were not included in the rectal acetaminophen group
recurrence during the same fever study protocol. Therefore, 438 than in the no antipyretics group
episode. Continuous variables were patients were allocated to 1 of for all age groups (Table 1). When
compared by using Mann–Whitney the following 2 groups: the rectal including all patients regardless
U test. Binary variables were acetaminophen group (229 children) of age, the recurrence rate was
compared by using Pearson’s χ2 and the no antipyretics group (209 9.1% in the rectal acetaminophen
test. Thereafter, in consideration children). Ten patients in the rectal group and 23.5% in the no
of potential interactions, a multiple acetaminophen group and 5 patients antipyretics group (P < .001).
In children 6 to 21 months of age, experienced FS recurrence showed 56% of patients with and without FS
the recurrence rate was 13.2% neurologic sequelae. recurrence, respectively, used rectal
in the rectal acetaminophen acetaminophen (P < .001).
group and 24.3% in the no Bivariate Analyses
antipyretics group (P = .0297). In the bivariate analyses, we Multiple Logistic Regression Analysis
In children 22 to 60 months of identified significant relationships A multiple logistic regression
age, the recurrence rate was between FS seizure recurrence and analysis was performed with the
4.1% in the rectal acetaminophen rectal acetaminophen use, age, and following 3 variables, which showed
group and 22.6% in the no duration of seizure (Supplemental significant differences in the bivariate
antipyretics group (P < .001). Table 3). Age was significantly lower analyses, with consideration of
No serious complications related to and the duration of seizure was interactions: rectal acetaminophen
acetaminophen, such as hypotension, significantly shorter in children with use, age, and duration of seizure.
hypothermia, or anaphylaxis, were versus without FS recurrence (P < We selected the variables for
observed. None of the patients who .05 for both). We found that 29% and the final multivariate logistic
4 MURATA et al
regression model using hierarchical TABLE 2 Multiple Logistic Regression Analysis
background elimination starting Odds Ratio (95% Confidence Interval) P
from the following 6 variables: rectal Rectal acetaminophen
acetaminophen use, age, duration Yes Reference <.001
of seizure, rectal acetaminophen No 5.6 (2.3–13.3) —
use and age, rectal acetaminophen Age, mo
use and duration of seizure, and age 1 mo decrement 1.08 (1.03–1.11) <.001
Duration of seizure, min
and duration of seizure. As a result 1 min decrement 1.15 (0.99–1.32) .0481
of this selection, the 4 variables Rectal acetaminophen and age — .0026
of rectal acetaminophen use, age, —, not applicable.
duration of seizure, and rectal
acetaminophen use and age were regression analysis also revealed that of antipyretics. Therefore, the
retained. The continuous variables, a younger age and shorter duration effectiveness of acetaminophen
namely duration of convulsion as of seizure were associated with was likely underestimated in the
well as age, satisfied the criteria for higher FS recurrence rates during the previous study.
linearity. We reanalyzed the final same fever episode.
model with the 4 variables of rectal The results of the current study
acetaminophen use, age, duration of In our comparison of the support that acetaminophen can
seizure, and rectal acetaminophen recurrence rates between the rectal effectively prevent FS recurrence
use and age using a multivariate acetaminophen and no antipyretics within the same fever episode,
logistic regression test (Table 2). groups, it was demonstrated that despite the fact that acetaminophen
All 4 variables were independently acetaminophen has the potential has long been considered ineffective
and significantly associated with FS to prevent FS recurrence during for preventing FS recurrence both
recurrence. Among these variables, the same fever episode. This in the same and different fever
rectal acetaminophen use had the is in contrast to the findings of episode(s). Indeed, in the randomized
highest odds ratio of 5.6 (95% Schnaiderman et al12 who examined controlled trials performed by
confidence interval: 2.3–13.3). the effectiveness of acetaminophen Uhari et al13 and Strengell et al14
during the same febrile illness by to evaluate the effectiveness of
Patients With Diarrhea comparing the FS recurrence rates acetaminophen during separate
between a regular usage group fever episodes, no significant
The FS recurrence rate during the
(4-hour intervals; n = 53) and a differences in the FS recurrence
same fever episode was 35% in the
sporadic usage group (n = 51; rates were observed between
60 children with diarrhea, which was
sporadic use contingent on a body the acetaminophen and placebo
significantly higher than the rates in
temperature >37.9°C) in 104 children groups in either trial. In addition,
the rectal acetaminophen group and
presenting with simple FS. In that Rosenbloom et al15 concluded that
no antipyretics group (Supplemental
study, 4 children in the regular acetaminophen was ineffective
Fig 2).
usage group (7.5%) and 4 children for preventing FS recurrence in a
in the sporadic usage group (7.8%) meta-analysis of these randomized
experienced a second FS. The authors controlled trials.13,14 As such, our
DISCUSSION
concluded that the prophylactic data should be interpreted with
This is the first randomized administration of acetaminophen caution, particularly because the
controlled trial to indicate that in children with FS was ineffective included patients were children
acetaminophen could prevent the for preventing FS recurrence given who visited our hospital after FS
recurrence of FSs during the same the lack of a significant difference in had already occurred. Therefore,
fever episode. In this study, the FS the FS recurrence rate between the in the current study, we could not
recurrence rate was significantly 2 groups, although a larger amount determine the preventive effects
lower in the rectal acetaminophen of acetaminophen was administered of acetaminophen in children who
group than in the no antipyretics to the regular usage group. The had not yet had a FS during a fever
group. In our multiple logistic different findings between our study episode.
regression analysis it was suggested and the study by Schnaiderman et al12
that, among the variables in the final can be explained by the inclusion of There may be several explanations
model, rectal acetaminophen was the different control groups; whereas of the mechanisms by which
largest contributor to the prevention no antipyretics were used in our acetaminophen reduces the
of FS recurrence during the same study, the study by Schnaiderman recurrence of FS. First,
fever episode. The multiple logistic et al12 permitted the sporadic use acetaminophen may reduce FS
6 MURATA et al
REFERENCES
1. Hauser WA. The prevalence and 10. Takano T, Sakaue Y, Sokoda T, et al. 17. Verrotti A, Tocco AM, Coppola GG,
incidence of convulsive disorders Seizure susceptibility due to Altobelli E, Chiarelli F. Afebrile benign
in children. Epilepsia. 1994; antihistamines in febrile seizures. convulsions with mild gastroenteritis:
35(suppl 2):S1–S6 Pediatr Neurol. 2010;42(4):277–279 a new entity? Acta Neurol Scand.
2009;120(2):73–79
2. Sillanpää M, Camfield P, Camfield C, 11. Kawano G, Oshige K, Syutou S, et al.
et al. Incidence of febrile seizures Benign infantile convulsions 18. Komori H, Wada M, Eto M, Oki H,
in Finland: prospective population- associated with mild gastroenteritis: Aida K, Fujimoto T. Benign convulsions
based study. Pediatr Neurol. a retrospective study of 39 cases with mild gastroenteritis: a report
2008;38(6):391–394 including virological tests and of 10 recent cases detailing
efficacy of anticonvulsants. Brain Dev. clinical varieties. Brain Dev.
3. Vestergaard M, Pedersen CB,
2007;29(10):617–622 1995;17(5):334–337
Sidenius P, Olsen J, Christensen J.
The long-term risk of epilepsy after 12. Schnaiderman D, Lahat E, Sheefer T, 19. Uemura N, Okumura A, Negoro T,
febrile seizures in susceptible Aladjem M. Antipyretic effectiveness Watanabe K. Clinical features of benign
subgroups. Am J Epidemiol. of acetaminophen in febrile convulsions with mild gastroenteritis.
2007;165(8):911–918 seizures: ongoing prophylaxis versus Brain Dev. 2002;24(8):745–749
sporadic usage. Eur J Pediatr. 20. Okumura A, Uemura N, Negoro T,
4. Tsuboi T. Epidemiology of febrile and
1993;152(9):747–749 Watanabe K. Efficacy of antiepileptic
afebrile convulsions in children in
Japan. Neurology. 1984;34(2):175–181 13. Uhari M, Rantala H, Vainionpää L, drugs in patients with benign
Kurttila R. Effect of acetaminophen convulsions with mild gastroenteritis.
5. Hirabayashi Y, Okumura A, Kondo T, et al. Brain Dev. 2004;26(3):164–167
and of low intermittent doses
Efficacy of a diazepam suppository at
of diazepam on prevention of 21. Okumura A, Kato T, Watanabe K.
preventing febrile seizure recurrence
recurrences of febrile seizures. Clinical features of convulsions with
during a single febrile illness.
J Pediatr. 1995;126(6):991–995 mild gastroenteritis. Jpn J Pediatr.
Brain Dev. 2009;31(6):414–418
14. Strengell T, Uhari M, Tarkka 1999;48:51–55
6. Okumura A. Antipyretics induce
R, et al. Antipyretic agents for 22. Kajiyama T, Hukuyama Y. Convulsions
recurrence of febrile seizure? Jpn J
preventing recurrences of febrile with diarrhea in infants. J Jpn Pediatr
Pediatr Med. 2014;46(11):1696–1698
seizures: randomized controlled Soc. 1984;88:883–889
7. Natsume J, Hamano SI, Iyoda K, et al. trial. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.
23. Ichiyama T, Matsufuji H, Suenaga N,
New guidelines for management of 2009;163(9):799–804
Nishikawa M, Hayashi T, Furukawa S.
febrile seizures in Japan. Brain Dev.
15. Rosenbloom E, Finkelstein Y, Adams- Low-dose therapy with carbamazepine
2017;39(1):2–9
Webber T, Kozer E. Do antipyretics for convulsions associated with mild
8. Zolaly MA. Histamine H1 antagonists prevent the recurrence of febrile gastroenteritis [in Japanese]. No To
and clinical characteristics of febrile seizures in children? A systematic Hattatsu. 2005;37(6):493–497
seizures. Int J Gen Med. 2012;5:277–281 review of randomized controlled trials
24. Tanabe T, Okumura A, Komatsu M,
and meta-analysis. Eur J Paediatr
9. Miyata I, Saegusa H, Sakurai Kubota T, Nakajima M, Shimakawa S.
Neurol. 2013;17(6):585–588
M. Seizure-modifying potential Clinical trial of minimal treatment
of histamine H1 antagonists: a 16. Morooka K. Convulsions and mild for clustering seizures in cases of
clinical observation. Pediatr Int. diarrhea [in Japanese]. Shonika convulsions with mild gastroenteritis.
2011;53(5):706–708 Rinsho (Tokyo). 1982;23:131–137 Brain Dev. 2011;33(2):120–124