Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Introduction
individual identity, and personal worldview. Such factors will either be present or
and religious beliefs (S/R’s) could have a significant effect on their daily lives and inner
world. When absent as an important identified aspect of a client’s life, spiritual and
religious experiences may still be pertinent to the individual through generational trauma
(such as the religious genocide during the Holocaust, or family members having
experiences (with parents who were or were not religious), or through daily life
experiences with family members, friends, media, and beyond. Studies have indicated
that S/R (as well as its absence) can significantly bolster wellbeing or lead to distress.
integral aspect of spiritual/ religious based practice; these same states can often occur, or
experienced within multiple DSM diagnoses. These issues must therefore be regarded as
important clinical social work concerns and as such demand significant research.
towards disclosing spiritual/religious faith and experiences with their therapist, and how,
if disclosed, therapists responded and to what extent this response met clients’ identified
needs. The questions I hope to answer from this thesis study are: Are clients who
why or why not? What factors affect their perception of the quality of care in this
regard? I hypothesize that many may report experiences of stigma at the intersection of
There has been some research done on the topic of therapist attitudes towards S/R
in therapy, as well as studies that delineate types of spiritual interventions used, but there
have been no studies that focus on client-needs and attitudes during or after therapy.
Given that 75% of the adult population in the United States endorses some form of
religious identification, this thesis topic has high relevance in the field of social work. If
roughly three out of every four adults in the United States have some sort of S/R belief it
is ethically sound to train therapists who are competent and statistically helpful in
supporting and aiding those clients. Furthermore, religious prejudice and stigma remain
“culturally competent” clinicians who come from myriad religious and ethnic
backgrounds and work with clients who range similarly. Finally, the topic of stigma and
best practice methods is of paramount importance to those who are at highest risk for
maltreatment from the medical establishment through traumatic experiences with forced
common. Is it ethical, therefore, for a person who has been given a diagnosis of
considerations in the future of social work, specifically what is and is not useful to S/R
oriented clients who seek therapy, as well as specific ways to aid clients who experience
the most stigma and trauma within and by the mental health system.
Literature Review
Sheridan, Bullis, Adcock, Berlin, & Miller (1992) were the leading proponents of
quantitative studies on social workers’ personal beliefs and professional attitudes towards
spiritual/religious perceptions and beliefs, but also defined what types of interventions are
most utilized and correlated these findings with social workers’ attitudes about said
interventions. They offer multiple surveys and measuring scales related to spiritual and
There is a general consensus found in the research that clinical social work
training may not be adequate for future clinicians, and that there is likely a serious lack of
application or conversation between clinician and client regarding clients’ spiritual and
religious worldviews (Sheridan, Bullis, Adcock, Berlin, & Miller, 1992, Stewart, Koeske,
& Koeske 2008, & Dwyer, 2010). It has been shown that a clinician’s personal
1992, Stewart, Koeske, & Koese, 2008, & Dwyer, 2010). In earlier research such
utilization also predicted positive attitudes and self-reported competency regarding these
types of interventions (Sheridan et al. 1992, Stewart et al. 2008, Cummings, Ivan, Carson,
Stanley & Pargament, 2014). Dwyer (2010), however, noted a trend in her study that
have decreased, yet the percentage of practice of interventions remains the same. She
suggests that ethical considerations between social work values and individual social
workers’ rights and opinions may be at odds (Dwyer, 2010). These studies each note
and client perceptions of interventions (Sheridan et. al 1992, Stewart, Koeske, & Koeske
2008, & Dwyer, 2010). Thus there is a clear need for the research I am proposing, which
religious and spiritual belief was undertaken in 2014; out of 560 articles only 29 matched
inclusion criteria for the review. The inclusion criteria were: original empirical research,
and the study was published in the English language (Cummins et al., 2014). This review
revealed multiple correlations and themes that are pertinent to this proposal, such as but
not limited to the effect of religious belief on therapeutic attitudes towards clients, the
and its relationship to positive outcome, and whether therapist religious/spiritual values
are related to their theoretical orientation. This article reinforces findings from previous
articles mentioned, and offers additional insight into future directions, such as supporting
the need for studies to include client perceptions, highlighting the lack of longitudinal and
experimental studies of this nature with therapist-client dyads, improving the validity
or spiritual belief and practice on the mental health status of participants. Stewart et al.
(2008) cite multiple studies in which lower levels of depression, anxiety, and pessimism
are correlated with personal spiritual and religious values and experience. Calhoun,
Cann, Tedeschi, & McMillan (2000) discuss the healing potential of spiritual and
religious based practices in posttraumatic growth when coupled with a type of cognitive
“rumination” that searches for personal meaning within the trauma, highlighting the
useful and healing potential of what spirituality is commonly defined as: a feeling of
connection to something beyond the self and a sense of deep personal meaning. More
research must be done to determine the protective value of religious or spiritual belief and
Religious and spiritual based practice and its effect on mental health and
Spiritist healers who worked with patients diagnosed with schizophrenia in Puerto Rico
and Brazil. They note that a spiritually based etiology had positive benefits for patients
and their families as it externalized the causes of psychosis and schizophrenia, which
increased hopefulness that the illness would not remain chronic; this was correlated with
needed relief and support in a way that medication and hospitalization cannot necessarily
religion most practiced by social workers and other counselors in studies done in the
United States (Stewart et al., 2008, Dwyer 2010). Christian therapists are more likely to
introduce prayer or spiritually based interventions in their work with clients, though
clients who are not religious or spiritually inclined would consider such interventions
and unhelpful or stigmatizing attitudes, for example Wesselmann & Graziano (2010) note
the role of spiritual and religious belief in creating stigmatic bias towards individuals
with a psychiatric diagnosis due to Christian notions of sin, retribution, and possession.
religious/spiritual beliefs affect their choice of treatment. Cummings et al. (2014) cited a
religious or spiritual beliefs. Rosmarin, Green, Pirutinsky, & McKay (2013) found
results that CBT oriented therapists are less religious than the general population,
replicating previous findings. This result may be related to the spiritual and religious
affiliation of the early proponents of CBT and its associated therapies, suggesting that the
underlying values of theorists may relate to the types of therapy developed, which could
also attract similarly minded individuals (Rosmarin, et al., 2013). This possibility further
highlights the importance of religious and spiritual beliefs on the ways in which human
beings interact in the world and with each other, and suggests that practitioners who do
identify as spiritual or religious could aid individuals who have a similar identification
and need.
These studies endorse the necessity of further study on the efficacy and value of
spiritually based attitudes and interventions, especially when tailored to or at odds with
clients’ cultures and belief systems. Complexity arises when social workers either
attempt to practice such interventions but do not share a similar belief, conviction, or
faith in the practice, or refuse to act because of personal bias or discomfort (Weselmann
& Graziano 2010, Dwyer, 2010, Cummings, et al., 2014). Best practice methods are
faiths and cultural-spiritual worldviews (Sheridan et al. 1992, Dwyer, 2010). Many
clients who are spiritually/religiously identified may not come into treatment at all, or
may be resistant to aid that could help them because of their spiritual/religious
convictions; in some cases a person’s faith may harm them rather than help them. An
empathic, informed therapist must be able to understand these clients’ spiritual needs and
perceptions before healing work can be done. More research on survivor-led movements
and the benefits and limitation of different modes of treatment, such as the Open
medical model practices to promote the highest levels of healing and decrease the levels
of chronicity and disability that stem from mental health struggles. Focusing on current
practice with clients who endorse spiritual or psychotic/organic based experiences and
beliefs could help to illuminate and change harmful practices today that cause individuals
religion, analyses of historical trends, case study examples, needs assessments, and
clinical considerations in working with clients who have religious or spiritual values.
Trends in psychoanalysis, for example, show that analysts are no longer embracing the
idea that religious belief is a defense of the mind, and are instead able to hold ambiguity
and work with a client within the client’s own worldview (Josephson, Nicholi, &
Tasman, 2010). Cummins, et al. (2014) touch on the topic of specific religious or spiritual
understandings and how they may affect an individual’s psychological well-being or vice
versa, while Schafranske (2005) writes a detailed case study depicting the development
Comprehensive Resource from Intake to Termination, is a useful tool for therapists who
would like to be more attuned to therapeutic ways of working with religion and
spirituality in therapy. This topic is being taken into greater consideration by the APA,
which has now written a handbook on psychology, religion, and spirituality (Hathaway,
2013).
Methodology
The purpose of this research is to explore, describe, and evaluate clients’ attitudes
towards disclosing their spiritual/religious beliefs and experiences with their therapist,
and if they have done so then explore the clients’ perceptions of their therapist’s
relational and professional abilities in responding. This writer hopes that through such
research the field of clinical social work will gain a greater understanding of how
clients’ needs are being met, determine what is useful and beneficial currently, and
discuss what is lacking or could be improved upon. The question this research will
attempt to answer is: Are clients who endorse religious/spiritual beliefs or experiences
receiving what they need in therapy, why or why not? What factors affect their
perception of the quality of their care in this regard? This question is based on a
hypothesis that clients may likely report experiences of stigma at the intersection of their
There are some biases inherent within this study due to my own mental health
depression and anxiety related symptoms, and one method of coping I use is various
spiritual practices stemming from my spiritual/religious beliefs. I have also had some
spiritual experiences and convictions that others who have not practiced meditation or
prayer may not understand. I identify as a multi-faith practitioner and focus on more
the divine. I determined this research question after experiencing my own discomfort
with the idea of sharing these beliefs or experiences with therapists or psychiatrists, and
my distaste with aspects of the medical model; I believe many may feel similarly. I am
training to become a clinical social worker, and I am very aware of the missing spiritual
dimension within the academic curricula, as well as the religious prejudice inherent in the
my studies— Sigmund Freud. Therefore I was resolved to learn more about this rich and
important subject, and create a space for clients of many faiths to share their own stories.
Due to the exploratory nature of this proposal a mixed methods study is proposed.
interviews from participants who are mental health clients over the age of 18, that
identify as spiritual/religious, and who have been in therapy for at least six months at
some point in time. I prefer that clients define their spirituality or religious beliefs and
experiences for themselves, however, a working definition of spirituality that I will use
atheistic yet remain sacred. There will be a section in the survey portion for individuals to
choose or label for themselves what tradition they are a part of, or how they describe their
own belief system and form of practice. The time period in therapy was chosen so that
individuals have had, hopefully, an amount of time long enough to form a relationship
A mixed methods study was chosen because it provides the possibility for
empirical data and empirically based conclusions, while also giving participants the
ability to voice in detail their own experiences, thoughts, and feelings. The quantitative
data will be found through survey use, and will include data such as: number of
participants, median and mean of age, race, gender, time in therapy, therapist credentials
therapy today using Likert scales or yes/no/other format for questions such as “Do you
consider your clinical training in spiritual/religious considerations satisfactory?” The
qualitative data will include data from comment boxes in the surveys and from personal
theories of psychology of religion and clinical practice; it may include survey questions
or statements and variables used in other research, which will be cited as used. Examples
- Do you identify as spiritual or religious? Please check a box that most closely resembles your
spiritual/religious identification, or write your own in the space provided.
- During the past year, how often did you participate in religious services at a place of worship
(once a day or more, almost daily, once a week, once a month, rarely, never) (Rosmarin, et al., 2013)
- Which statement best describes your beliefs about God? (I know that God really exists and I have
no doubt about it, while I have some doubts I feel I do believe in God, I don’t believe in God but I believe
in a higher power, I don’t believe in God, I don’t know) (Rosmarin, et al., 2013)
- Do you believe in or hold sacred any of the following (please check all that apply and define or
explain any terms further in the space provided if you need): (this list will include common theological
beliefs and themes and will be grouped by the major religions of the world) Please add anything important
to you that is not on this list.
- Do you practice any of the following: yoga, meditation, chanting, prayer, reading scriptural or
sacred texts (please describe which ones). Please describe how often (once a day or more, almost daily,
once a week, once a month, rarely, never). If there is any practice you participate in that is missing from the
above list, please describe below.
- How important is religion to you? (very important, important, moderately important, of little
importance) (Rosmarin, et al., 2013)
- How important is spirituality to you? (very important, important, moderately important, of little
importance)
- Have you ever received a psychiatric diagnosis? If so, what was it?
- Have you ever had any experiences that you consider spiritual or religious in nature? Please
describe below and/or check any of the following:
- Have you ever had a spiritual/religious experience that caused you distress?
- Have you ever had a spiritual/religious experience that caused you joy?
- Spiritual and religious experiences can often appear similar to symptoms found within many
psychiatric diagnoses. Have you had any experiences that you consider to be related directly to your
psychiatric diagnosis which you do not consider to be spiritual/religious in any way? Please describe if you
feel comfortable to do so.
- Have you had beneficial experiences as a consumer within the mental health system in general? If
so, please describe.
- Have you had negative experiences as a consumer within the mental health system in general? If
so, please describe as you are comfortable.
- Have you ever spoken with your therapist about your spiritual/religious beliefs?
- Have you ever spoken with your therapist about spiritual/religious experiences?
- If yes, how did your therapist respond?
- Was this response beneficial to your wellbeing, why or why not?
- If no, what was your reason for not sharing this information?
- What kind of response do you believe would be most helpful for you if you did share? What kind
of response might be the least helpful or harmful?
- Have you ever experienced stigma due to your S/Rs? Please describe if you are comfortable. For
example, you may describe where, when, how, or why this occurred.
- Have you ever experienced stigma due to your mental health struggles or psychiatric diagnosis?
Was it ever related to your S/Rs in any way? Please describe if you are comfortable. For example, where,
when, how, or why? This can be as general or as specific as desired.
- Do your mental health struggles hold meaning for you? Please describe the meaning to the best of
your abilities if so.
- Does your psychiatric diagnosis (or diagnoses) hold meaning for you? Please describe the
meaning to the best of your abilities if so.
- Do your spiritual/religious beliefs have meaning to you? Please describe to the best of your
abilities if so.
- If you have had any spiritual/religious experiences, do they hold meaning for you? Please describe
if so.
- If you have any spiritual/religious practices, do they hold meaning for you? Please describe to the
best of your abilities if so.
-
Others questions I may introduce to clients could include: please rate your level of
comfort in talking with your therapist about religious or spiritual concerns (quantitative),
values and experiences (qualitative and quantitative), can you describe an experience
with your therapist where they were helpful regarding religious/spiritual concerns?
(qualitative) can you describe an experience with your therapist where they were
The interviews will be recorded and saved in a way that protects participants’
The survey will include comment spaces for qualitative data, which will then be coded
written surveys are used I can guarantee those participants’ identities to be protected and
confidential. The demographics of my participants will be clients who are being seen by
licensed therapists and who identify as spiritual or religious. Efforts will be made to
secure a more racially diverse group of participants than in previous studies, and I hope to
receive clients with diverse gender identities, ethnicities, socioeconomic status, and
religious convictions as well. Past studies have primarily consisted of Christian or Jewish
participants and I would like to recruit participants from a greater variety of traditions if
possible. I believe that the data from the survey can provide descriptive, correlational,
and cross-sectional results. The qualitative data can offer important themes and
connected to the mental health field as consumers or practitioners; for those who choose
to participate in both the survey and the interview portion of the study I will offer $5 as
online forums directly related to mental health needs and intersectional identities through
personal websites and on Facebook (The Icarus Project Forums, Center for Clinical
Identified Forums and Groups, Racial Solidarity Forums and Groups, Various Faith
Forums and Groups). I will also reach out to important individuals who are studying and
organizing for social justice and change in the mental health system, such as but not
included to: Julie Exline, Phil Borges, Sandra Ingerman, Lisa J. Miller, Dr. Susan
Mitchell, Will Hall, Monica Cassani, Dr. David Lukoff, Paul Levy, and Mary Olson. I
will send advertisements to clinicians that I know personally who could refer participants
to the study. I will also personally speak with agencies in NYC area to see if I could post
information in their lobbies or waiting rooms. Finally, I will recruit with permission to
and personal experiences with mental health, stigma, and spiritual/religious beliefs and
experiences.
Conclusion
This study could result in important research for the future of clinical social work,
and fulfills a need stated in the literature, that of client’s own perceptions. If participation
is at a high rate then this study could hold meaningful or generalizable data on the topic
of clients’ needs in therapy, their experiences with mental health stigma as related to
when discussing spiritual/religious topics in therapy. This will help inform the field of
what practices are working therapeutically as perceived by clients, and what ways of
being could be improved upon when working with clients who identify as
spiritual/religious, especially for those individuals who experience stigma and trauma
within the medical model due to the nature of their extreme states and the varieties of
their experiences. Most importantly, the qualitative nature of this study will allow many
individuals, who are not always granted the opportunity to use their voice or share their
stories, to reach the larger academic and professional world. This study will additionally
offer informed discussions of theoretical constructs within clinical and psychodynamic
relational work with clients who identify as S/R, suggestions of best practice methods,
and discussion regarding the education of clinical social workers in the future.
References
Calhoun, G., L., Cann, A., Tedeschi, R., G, & McMillan, J. (2000) A correlational test of the
relationship between posttraumatic growth, religion, and cognitive processing. Journal of Traumatic
Stress 13(3), 521-527.
Cummings, J. P., Ivan, M. C., Carson, C. S., Stanley, M. A., & Pargament, K. I. (2014) A systematic
review of relations between psychotherapist religiousness/spirituality and therapy-related variables.
Spirituality in Clinical Practice 1 (2), 116-132.
Dwyer, M. M., (2010) Religion, spirituality, and social work: a quantitative and qualitative study on the
behaviors of social workers in conducting individual therapy. Smith College Studies in Social Work
80(2-3), 139-158.DOI: 10.1080/00377317.2010.486359
Hathaway, W. (2013). Pathways toward graduate training in the clinical psychology of religion and
spirituality: A spiritual competencies model. In K. I. Pargament, A. Mahoney, & E. Shafranske
(Eds.), APA handbook of psychology, religion, and spirituality: Vol. 2. An applied psychology of
religion and spirituality, 635-649.
James, W. (1902) The Varieties of Religious Experience London: Collins Fontana Library
Josephson, A. M., Nicholi, A. R., & Tasman, A. (2010). Religion and psychoanalysis: Past and present.
In P. J. Verhagen, H. M. van Praag, J. R. López-Ibor, J. L. & Cox, D. Moussaoui (Eds.) , Religion
and psychiatry: Beyond boundaries (pp. 283-303). Wiley-Blackwell.
doi:10.1002/9780470682203.ch16
Moreira-Almeida, A. & Koss-Chioino, J.D. (2009) Recognition and treatment of psychotic symptoms:
spiritists compared to mental health professionals in Puerto Rico and Brazil. Psychiatry 72(3), 268-
283.
Rosmarin, D. H., Green, D., Pirutinsky, S., McKay, D. (2013) Attitudes toward spirituality/religion
among members of the association for behavioral and cognitive therapies. Professional Psychology:
Research and Practice, 44(6), 424-433.
Sheridan, M. J., Bullis, R. K., Adcock, C. R., Berlin, S. D., & Miller, P. C. (1992) Practitioners personal
and professional attitudes and behaviors toward religion and spirituality: issues for education and
practice. Journal of Social Work Education 28(2), 1-18.
Wesselmann, E. D, & Graziano, W. G. (2010) Sinful and/or possessed? Religious beliefs and mental
illness stigma. Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 29 (4), 402-437.