Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
\s=b\ During1987-1989,14(14.6%) of the 96 children who optimal therapy and treatment of the complex problems
tested positive for the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) that characterize children with AIDS.
and were followed up by the Duke University (Durham, NC) During this period, 14 children from the AIDS popu¬
pediatric acquired immunodeficiency syndrome team were lation were confirmed to have been sexually abused. The
confirmed to have been sexually abused. Every sexually medical and social conditions of the lives of the abused
abused child was evaluated for each of five modes of HIV children were reviewed for known risk factors for the ac¬
transmission, and in nine children the pathway was iden- quisition of HIV and for child sexual abuse (CSA). This
tified. Four of the study children acquired HIV from child study describes the results of the evaluation of the sexually
sexual abuse and in six, abuse was a possible source. Trans- abused children, the circumstances surrounding the abu¬
mission by child sexual abuse was the most frequent of the sive experiences, the perpetrators, and the data regarding
proven modes of acquisition of HIV in this population. The the means by which the children had acquired HIV.
other proven modes of acquisition were vertical transmis- PATIENTS AND METHODS
sion (n=3) and HIV\p=n-\contaminatedblood transfusion Evaluation Process
(n 2). Twelve males were identified (n 8) or suspected
= =
All children seen by the AIDS team who presented with or
(n=4) of being perpetrators. Three knew themselves to developed indications of possible abuse or neglect were referred
have HIV at the time of an assault and eight were aware that to the child protection team for evaluation. Data for this study
the child had HIV at the time of an assault. There was no were collected at the time of the assessment of each child and
indication from any child that "safe sex" precautions had represent cumulative information regarding the child's environ¬
been observed. Children with HIV infection had multiple ment from the family, child, child protection team, AIDS team,
risk factors for abuse or neglect. The sociological descrip- social service agencies, schools, and, often, charitable agencies.
Child sexual abuse was defined in 1977 as the involvement of
tors of the lives of the 14 abused children showed multiple
known risk factors for sexual abuse that also overlapped dependent developmentally immature children and adolescents
in sexual activities that they do not fully comprehend, to which
with known risk factors for or sequelae of the acquisition they are unable to give informed consent, or that violate the social
of HIV infection. These included drug abuse and alcoholism taboos of family roles.1 Child sexual abuse includes rape, pe¬
in the home, prostitution of a parent, lack of parenting, pov- dophilia, child prostitution, child pornography, child sex rings,
erty, and chronic illness of the child. Prevention efforts and incest.
should recognize that children as well as adults are at risk Multiple issues often led to referral to the child protection team.
for sexually transmitted HIV infection. The instigating events included (1) the suspicion of or disclosure
of CSA volunteered by the child or a caretaker (n 2); (2) ab¬
(AJDC. 1991;145:137\p=n-\141)
=
he Duke University (Durham, NC) pediatrie acquired of CSA ( 5); (5) children older than 6 years at onset of HIV
=
immunodeficiency sydrome (AIDS) team began ac¬ disease, or with no known risk factor for HIV (n 3); and (6) the
=
to the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) antibody test prior to the diagnosis of CSA.
and were known to the AIDS team social worker. These Evaluation for CSA
children were at all stages of HIV-related illness and The evaluation of a child for CSA began with a family interview
ranged in age from newborn to 17 years. All children re¬ regarding the family constellation, patterns of care for the child,
ceived integrated multidisciplinary services that delivered interactions of family members, behavioral characteristics of the
child, and concerns or knowledge that the caretaker may have
Accepted for publication November 6, 1990. had regarding possibly abusive events. The following five groups
From the Department of Pediatrics, Duke University Medical Cen- of data needed for adequate evaluation of possible CSA were then
ter, Durham, NC. obtained: (1) a review of the behavioral history of the child; (2)
Presented in part at the annual meeting of the Society for Pediatric a review of the medical history of the child; (3) diagnostic in¬
Research, Anaheim, Calif, May 11, 1990. terview^) with the child; (4) results of physical examination; and
Reprint requests to Box 3971, Duke University Medical Center, (5) assessment for other sexually transmitted diseases.2"4
Durham, NC 27710 (Dr Gutman). The diagnostic interviews followed a standard format. Draw-
HIV positive 6 or more months after delivery; disproven, the tears, notches, or significant distortions of the hymen
mother was HIV negative 6 or more months after delivery; and (n 5); recurrent or persistent vaginal discharge and odor
=
unknown, the mother's HIV seroactivity was unknown. or vaginal bleeding (n 6); hymenal opening size greater
=
Criteria to define the categories for transmission by transfusion than or equal to 8 mm in a prepubertal child or a significant
were as follows: proven, the mother was HIV negative at or after
delivery and the child was known to have received an HIV- change in the genital examination results on serial eval¬
contaminated transfusion; possible, the mother was first known
uations (n 8); -perianal scars (n 2); significant and rapid
= =
to be HIV positive 6 or more months after delivery and the child anal dilation (n 4); and perianal lesions (n l). Neither
= =
received an HIV positive transfusion; disproven, the child either gonorrheae nor C trachomatis was isolated from the va¬
received no transfusion, or it was HIV negative; and unknown, gina, throat, or rectum of any study child. Three children
the child received a transfusion and retrospective surveillance had a sexually associated disease other than HIV; two had
was not able to trace the unit. bacterial vaginosis14; and one had condylomata acumina¬
The criteria to define the categories for transmission of HIV timi.15
through CSA were as follows: proven, either all other risk factors Eight children were able to disclose their abuse. Two
were disproven or the child was older than 12 years when HIV
was first diagnosed, sexual contact had involved high risk for
made partial disclosure and four were unable to disclose.
The forms of sexual abuse described by the eight children
HIV, and no other factor had been proven; possible, the per¬ who were able to disclose are listed in Table 1.
petrator was either HIV positive or unknown, and no other risk All identified or suspected perpetrators were male. The
factor was proven; disproven, identified perpetrator was HIV
negative; and unknown: an additional risk factor was proven. number of known or suspected assailants and their rela¬
Inclusion in this report required that sexual abuse of the child had tionship to the child when information was available are
Vertical transmission 3 5 5 1 CASE 4.—This child was diagnosed at age 6 years and
Transfusion 2 ... 12 2 months to be H1TV positive by ELISA and Western blot,
and classified as CDC P-2 subclass C. At the time of the
'Acquisition of human immunodeficiency virus by clotting factor
concentrate and by intravenous drug use was disproven in all cases. diagnosis, the mother was HIV-negative, the child had
never had a transfusion, and the child was not hémophilie.
The genital examination revealed definitive evidence of trau¬
shown in Table 2. For four children, the number and iden¬ matic abuse, as did the medical history. Two assailants were
tity of perpetrator(s) was unknown. A single perpetrator identified, one of whom was known to be HIV positive. It
was identified for three children, and for three children was concluded that the child had acquired HIV infection dur¬
multiple perpetrators were identified. For two children a ing child sexual abuse by an HIV-positive assailant.
single perpetrator was suspected. For one child, one per¬
petrator was identified and additional perpetrators were Knowledge by the Assailant of the Possibility
also suspected. For another child, one perpetrator was of HIV Transmission to or From the Child
suspected while the multiple perpetrators known to have Three of the assailants who were identified or suspected
abused the child were unidentified. were HIV positive and knew of their HIV status at the time
Acquisition of HIV they assaulted the child. There was no indication from the
Using the criteria stated in the "Patients and Methods" children that "safe sex" precautions had been taken.
section, an assessment was made of the mode of trans¬ Eight identified or suspected assailants were aware that
mission of HIV when all data were considered. The results the child was HIV positive at the time of the assault. Five
are shown in Table 3. For four (29%) of the 14 children, of these eight were themselves either HIV negative or their
CSA was the only means of transmission of HIV to the status was unknown when the child was assaulted. Again,
child. A brief synopsis of the histories of these children there was no indication from the children that "safe sex"
follows. To protect the identities of the children, gender precautions had been taken.
identification is not provided. COMMENT
CASE 1.—The child was an emotionally abused, phys¬
In a recent review of the data from the 1987 National
ically healthy child who lived in fear of the stepfather. At Survey of Children, social settings were identified that in¬
age 13 years, the child ran away from home and lived as creased the risk of CSA.13 All but one child in the present
a child prostitute for 3 months, during which time sexual
practices included unprotected anal-receptive intercourse study had two or more of these risk factors, and the pro¬
with multiple high-risk adults. Intravenous drugs were portion of children who hada given risk factor ranged from
never used. The child had never had a transfusion and was
43% to 71%, as shown below.
not hémophilie. The mother was not tested but had no risk Social Conditions No. (%) of Children
factors for HIV. Atage 15years, the child requested an HIV Lived apart from
both biological parents 6 (43)
assay because of the high-risk history. Results of enzyme- Raised in poverty* 10 (71)
linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and Western blot Child was handicappedt 9 (64)
were positive, and the disease was CDC class P-l, subclass Alcoholic family member* 7 (50)
B. It was concluded that the child had acquired HIV as a Drug abusing family member* 10 (71)
Prostitution at home 4 (29)
child prostitute. Transient adults living at home 8 (57)
CASE 2.—At age 3 years 9 months, this child was HIV Mentally ill caretaker 5 (36)
positive based on ELISA and Western blot test results; the AIDS-related disability of caretaker 2 (14)
disease was CDC class P-2, subclass A. The child's mother *Risk factors for CSA identified by National Survey of Children.13
was HIV negative. The child had not received a transfu- tHandicap was probably apparent before onset of CSA.