Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
INTA 489
The Affect of War-Related Trauma on the Mental, Emotional, and Behavioral Health
of Children
I. Introduction:
The researcher for this paper seeks to understand the affects of war-related
trauma on the mental and emotional health of children. For the purpose of this
child due to armed conflict in the area in which they live. War-related traumatic
events include but are not limited to witnessing acts of violence (such as seeing a
and personal traumatic events (such as being personally shot, beaten, or injured in
some way)i. The main mental and emotional health issues that are focused on in this
paper are anxiety, depression, and post-traumatic stress disorder. The Middle East,
mostly Israel, Palestine and Lebanon, are the focus of this paper. The researcher is
studying this topic to better understand the affect of war-related trauma on children
and Anxiety among Palestinian Children in the Gaza Strip” by Abdelaziz M. Thabet,
the researcher studied a sample of 251 children from 3 summer camps located in
the Gaza Stripii. This article studied the affect of war on the mental health of
between war trauma and depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorderiv.
The children ranged in age from 6-16v. The study used five scales:
Children Revised Manifest Anxiety Scale, and Child Depression Inventoryvi. 59% of
Areas of Armed Conflict in the Middle East”, a study by Lydia Dimitry, focuses on
several nations in the Middle Eastix. It seeks to understand the affect war has on the
mental, emotional, and cognitive health of children in the Middle Eastx. The word
used to describe war is “armed conflict”xi. The study sought to see how exposure to
experiences include but are not limited to personal exposure, near-miss exposure,
gassed, seeing wounded people and mutilated bodies on TV, bereavement, being a
witness to violent acts, emigration, separation from parents/family members,
physical injuries, lack of basic needs, water shortage, electricity cuts, changed
scholarly papers to create the review. There were 52, 977 participants total in the
There are many factors that contribute to the mental, behavioral, and
emotional problems children face after traumatic experiencesxvi. For this reason, the
researcher of this article split these factors into two groups: risk factors and
problemsxviii. Protective factors showed that certain factors involving a child’s safety
impact of war on the comorbidity of PTSD, ADHD, and oppositional defiant disorder
was researchedxxi. The study was called “Comorbidity of Post Traumatic Stress
in Palestine 6 months after the war on Gaza, which lasted for 23 daysxxiii. They
surveyed the entire Gaza stripxxiv. 410 Palestinian children between the ages of 8
and 18 were surveyed in this studyxxv. 224 were boys and 186 were girlsxxvi. The
Gaza Strip has experienced war and conflict for the past 4 decadesxxvii. Because of
this, Palestinian children are often exposed to traumatic experiences due to the
conflictxxviii. Many have lost family members and friends and have experienced the
affects of war-related incursions directlyxxix. This study used the “Gaza Traumatic
They also used a PTSD index to measure levels of PTSDxxxi. To measure ADHD
prevalence, they used the “ADHD scale for parents and self”xxxii. Additionally, they
used scale for conduct disorder and oppositional disorderxxxiii. It is important to note
that they took into consideration all the various types of trauma that children might
leaving home for better safety, and hearing loud jet fighter planesxxxv. They also
sociodemographic information along with other information using the War on Gaza
Traumatic Events Checklist, the PTSD Index for DSM-IV Diagnosis: Adolescent Version,
the ADHD Structured Clinical Interview of Mothers and Fathers for DSM-IV Diagnosis,
the Conduct Disorder Questionnaire DSM-IV Diagnosis, and the Oppositional Defiant
across the First Decade of Life”, the researchers sought to assess the affects of war-
The article looked at factors such as maternal uncontained style and maternal
ODD or conduct disorder, and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorderxli. The study
was conducted with a unique cohort over the course of 10 yearsxlii. They did three
tests of each child, one during early childhood (1.5-5 years of age), one during
middle childhood (5-8 years of age), and one during late childhood (9-11 years of
age)xliii. They surveyed children Sderot, Israel, a town very near the border with
Gaza. The article explained that there have been “repeated, unpredictable missile
attacks for over 15 years” in Sderotxliv. This means that children are consistently
experiencing traumatic events. Children in this study came from the same
community competencexlix.
The various studies discuss many factors that may influence a child’s
number of exposures a child had to armed conflict was positively correlated with
were losing one’s home, witnessing a friend being beat, day raids, being tear-gassed,
and suffering violent acts, among several otherslv. These are examples referred to as
of objective exposurelxiii. Some studies show that boys have higher levels of objective
exposure and researchers suggest that this is likely due to cultural gender roles in
strategies that might be used to help decrease the likelihood of children developing
article suggests that both preventive and post-disaster interventions are key in
producing the highest rates of resiliency and recoverylxvii. They suggest that five
sectors of the community should be involved in this process (local schools, social
institutions, medical centers, community leadership, and welfare units)lxviii. The use
interventions prove to have the most positive effect on increasing a child’s resiliency
trauma in the form of missile attacks and other conflict-related security offenseslxxi.
The Gulf War, Second Lebanon War, and the War in Gaza have all created a sense of
instability and lack of safetylxxii. Many children have found themselves displaced to
the conflictslxxiii.
cities in Israellxxiv. Through this program, researchers have found that by creating
run by the Home Front Defense Ministry in Israel, and is based off of the Cohen-
personnel and school staff to be trained as mental health mediatorslxxviii. When these
people, who are already established in leadership roles in children’s lives, are
trained to intervene by providing mental health support within their given context,
children have increased resiliencylxxix. These mediators work under the supervision
respectivelylxxx. Another factor that has shown positive association with increased
organizations, run these well-baby clinicslxxxii. Pediatric health clinics, such as these,
are an example of the use of social capital to enhance the resilience of children after
intervention because they are an active part of large populations of children in the
already established structure and safety that was present before the traumatic
experience, so children are more likely to seek and be willing to receive helplxxxvi.
resiliencylxxxviii.
papers related to the topic of war-related trauma and it’s relation to mental and
In December 2008, Israeli forces attacked the Gaza Strip for 23 dayslxxxix. This
long strike resulted in the death of 1420 Palestinians (including 446 children)xc.
to note the large number of children directly affected by this violent conflict. The
conflict also affected homes—4,000 homes were completely destroyed and 16,000
Gaza is a place where nearly half of the population is children (under age
15)xciii. The annual rate of population growth indicates that this percentage may
increase in the near futurexciv. Children in the Gaza Strip are at high risk for
developing mental health problems because many of them have experienced war-
related traumaxcv.
PTSD, depression, and anxiety rates in children were high in Palestine after
the conflictxcvi. PTSD alone had rates ranging from 40% to 71% according to their
researchxcvii. Their study noted that there was significant comorbidity between
ADHD and PTSD, anxiety, and oppositional defiant disorderxcviii. There was also
Gaza were likely to show symptoms related to Post Traumatic Stress Disorder as
that many children display symptoms of both of these disorders, showing that war
puts children at higher risk for developing one or both of these disordersci.
Among children in the Gaza Strip, 50.6% of children had depressionciii. The
stress disorder, anxiety, and depressionciv. Political violence and war trauma is
have already provided support and aid in ways that are culturally appropriate, and
therefore have legitimacy and can provide additional support and services
experiences were divided into three domains of trauma: witnessing acts of violence,
includes seeing a relative killed, seeing people injured, watching one’s home be
the Gaza Stripcxii. 85.4% of children had heard shelling of the area by artillery, 81.5%
had heard the sonic sounds of jetfighters, 78.2% had seen mutilated bodies on TV,
and 76.7% had heard bombardment and shootingscxiii. 148 out of the 251 children
were above the cut-off range indicating that they may be diagnosed with post-
between sexes or between agescxv. 55 children out of the 251 were above the cut-off
range for anxiety, indicating that they had anxietycxvi. There were no statistically
significant differences between sexes or between ages here eithercxvii. 127 out of the
251 children in the study were above the cut-off for depression, indicating that they
with particular types of traumatic eventscxx. Children who witnessed a close relative
being killed or who witnessed a friend’s home destroyed were more likely to
and shootings were more likely to develop anxietycxxiii. Two traumatic events also
predicted depressioncxxiv. Children who witnessed their own home being destroyed
supportive familycxxvii. Stress was also positively correlated to how much stress
one’s parents/friends/etc. hadcxxviii. For instance, the more stressed the parents
were, the more stressed the child wascxxix. Maternal anxiety correlated with the
associated with things like living with a single parent, having less than 2 siblings, or
experiencing punitive parentingcxxxi. Children were more resilient when they had
activitiescxxxii. Boys were more likely to have outdoor relaxation activities and seek
friend support, while girls were more likely to be studious and seek self-
reliancecxxxiii. Religious adolescents tended to have less PTSS than those who were
notcxxxiv.
and emotional problems”cxxxv. The results must be viewed within the context of
culture and “specific aspects of the conflicts”cxxxvi. Israel, for instance, is relatively
stable as a country and has preserved its infrastructure pretty well, while Palestine
is not stable and has poor infrastructurecxxxvii. These things are important to take
into account when discussing the results of the studycxxxviii. In Lebanon, the civil war
This affects how much conflict-related exposure children experiencecxl. Iraq has
suddenlycxlii.
Older children tend to have more PTSScxliii. They also have higher exposure
levels than do the younger onescxliv. Boys tend to have higher or equal levels
objective exposure, perhaps due to the fact that boys tend to have more exposure to
the outdoors in Middle Eastern culturecxlv. Additionally, girls tend to have more
boyscxlvi. Boys tend to have more behavior issues, hyperactivity, and aggressioncxlvii.
This may be because girls are considered/expected to be more caring in the culture,
while boys are expected to be more protective and providing for the familycxlviii.
These differing gender responses would be consistent with the cultural gender
rolescxlix.
anxiety levels were positively correlated to the anxiety levels of the childcl. This may
family and community are very important aspects of the culture in the Middle
Eastcliv. Additionally, when there is social support, people can relate to each other’s
This study found that psychopathology does not heal itself over time. It
states, “chronic stress does not heal naturally, and its effects appear to exacerbate
and chronic mental health diagnosesclviii. When children experience chronic stress
early in life, it often has lasting effects on both physical and mental healthclix.
Therefore, it is important to study various factors that may predict individual risk
and resilience trajectories. In this study, the researchers studied specific maternal
and child factors to help shed light on this issue. The article states, the effect of
chronic trauma in early childhood appears to intensify over time as it depletes the
The children in this study, from Sderot, Israel, have experienced repeated
and unpredictable traumatic eventsclxi. The children were exposed to the same
wartime stressors, as they were all from the same area neighborhoodsclxii. Risk and
developmental processes depend on both the individual child and on the child’s
contextclxiv. This study followed four trajectories that a child might experienceclxv.
The first was that the child never developed symptoms of any disorderclxvi. The
second trajectory was that the child developed symptoms early on, but then
recovered laterclxvii. The third trajectory was that a child had symptoms early on and
continued to have symptoms at later testsclxviii. The fourth trajectory was that a child
had no symptoms early on but then developed symptoms when they were olderclxix.
This study found that maternal behavior affected a child’s risk/resilience in regards
can affect the quality of parenting she is able to give a childclxxi. It is important to
note that many mothers experience depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress
mother from providing the best quality of parenting to her childclxxiii. She may be
fearful herself, and unable to contain her child’s fearsclxxiv. When a child’s fears are
uncontained, they are more likely to experience more fear and uncertainty, causing
their symptoms to worsen and raising the likelihood of developing mental health
issues after being exposed to trauma is the child’s temperamental factorsclxxvii. The
engagementclxxviii. The study sought to identify whether a child was active in social
interactions or notclxxix.
This article uses the word “disaster” to refer to what I am calling “war-related
systemic and disruptive impact on the social network and basic daily routines of
Disasters are made up of four stagesclxxxiv. The first stage is the pre-disaster
stage, where “an imminent threat is identified and the population alerted”clxxxv. The
second stage is the event itself, where there are “efforts to minimize damage by
protecting human life and meeting the population’s basic needs”clxxxvi. The third
These lead to “regression and lost norms”clxxxviii. The fourth stage is the collective
They may also experience grief and dissociationcxci. Children are more vulnerable
than adults because they are undergoing natural developmental changes at this
sense of self and identitycxciii. They are also learning to regulate impulses and
traumacxcv. When these changes are not allowed to grow and develop as they should,
attachments to people and a feeling of safety and securitycxcviii. Social support has
health issuescxcix.
related traumacc. Social capital is defined as “mutual trust and social networking
collective actioncci. Children tend to have better mental health outcomes when there
are higher levels of social capital in their community following a disasterccii. Social
individual, familial, communal, and institutional levelscciii. This allows for a child’s
VI. Conclusion:
support and interventions in order to ensure the well-being and resiliency of the
childrenccvi. They are the next generation. Children who experience war-related
the emotional, mental, behavioral, and psychological support they need to overcome
these be addressed during times of war to ensure that the next generation is able to
grow and develop healthily so they can have the most positive futureccviii. It should
be a goal to help children thrive despite the hard circumstances they and their
of providing these additional services for childrenccx. These agencies have already
therefore can better provide the care and support needed by the children in their
areasccxi. It is important to help work towards providing a sense of stability and help
given resources to help children who are affected by these disordersccxiii. Medical
personnel and school staff can act as mental health mediators to increase child
resiliencyccxiv. These disorders can affect how students perform in school and at
home, and it is important to help them develop positive coping strategies and help
them to work through the difficult events they have experienced from conflict in
collaborate in the use of social capital to aid children who have developed mental
and emotional health problems and to decrease the susceptibility in those who have
the necessary care for children through the already-existing local agenciesccxvii
and Anxiety among Palestinian Children in the Gaza Strip." Health Science
Journal, 3rd ser., 10, no. 5 (July 22, 2016): 1-8. Accessed March 29, 2017.
doi:10.4172/1791-809X.1000100503.
ii Ibid.
iii Ibid., 1
iv Ibid.
v Ibid., 2
vi Ibid., 3
vii Ibid., 5
viii Ibid.
ix Dimitry, Lydia. "A systematic review on the mental health of children and
adolescents in areas of armed conflict in the Middle East." Child: Care, Health
2214.2011.01246.x.
x Ibid.
xi Ibid.
xii Ibid.
xiv Ibid.
xv Ibid.
xvi Ibid., 156
xvii Ibid.
xviii Ibid.
xix Ibid.
xx Ibid.
xxi Thabet, Abdelaziz M., Ahmad Abu Tawahina, Eyad El Sarraj, David Henely,
xxiv Ibid.
xxvi Ibid.
xxviii Ibid.
xxx Ibid.
xxxi Ibid.
xxxii Ibid.
xxxiv Ibid.
xxxv Ibid.
xxxviii Halevi, Galit, Amir Djalovski, Adva Vengrober, and Ruth Feldman. "Risk and
life." Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 57, no. 10 (2016): 1183.
doi:10.1111/jcpp.12622.
xxxix Ibid.
xl Ibid., 1187
xli Ibid.
xliv Ibid.
xlv Ibid.
xlvi Hamiel, Daniel, Leo Wolmer, Smadar Spirman, and Nathaniel Laor.
and Disaster." Child & Youth Care Forum 42, no. 4 (March 21, 2013): 263.
xlvii Ibid.
xlviii Ibid.
xlix Ibid.
l Halevi, 1187
li Dimitry, 153-161
Halevi, 1183-193
Thabet, The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression, and Anxiety
liii Ibid.
liv Ibid.
lv Ibid.
lvi Ibid.
lvii Ibid.
lviii Ibid.
lix Ibid.
lx Ibid.
lxi Ibid.
lxii Ibid.
lxiii Ibid.
lxiv Ibid.
lxvi Ibid.
lxvii Ibid.
lxviii Ibid.
lxix Ibid.
lxxii Ibid.
lxxiii Ibid.
lxxv Ibid.
lxxvi Ibid.
lxxix Ibid.
lxxx Ibid.
lxxxi Ibid.
lxxxii Ibid.
lxxxiii Ibid.
lxxxv Ibid.
lxxxvi Ibid.
lxxxvii Ibid.
lxxxviii Ibid.
lxxxix Thabet, Comorbidity of post traumatic stress disorder, attention deficit with
xc Ibid.
xci Ibid.
xcii Ibid.
xciii Thabet, The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression, and Anxiety
xciv Ibid.
xcv Ibid.
xcvi Thabet, Comorbidity of post traumatic stress disorder, attention deficit with
xcix Ibid.
c Ibid.
ci Ibid.
cii Ibid.
ciii Thabet, The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression, and Anxiety
civ Ibid., 6
cv Ibid., 6
cvi Ibid., 7
cvii Ibid.
cviii Ibid., 3
cix Ibid.
cx Ibid.
cxi Ibid.
cxii Ibid., 4
cxiii Ibid.
cxiv Ibid., 5
cxv Ibid.
cxvi Ibid.
cxvii Ibid.
cxviii Ibid.
cxix Ibid.
cxx Ibid., 6
cxxi Ibid.
cxxii Ibid.
cxxiii Ibid.
cxxiv Ibid.
cxxv Ibid.
cxxvii Ibid.
cxxviii Ibid.
cxxix Ibid.
cxxx Ibid.
cxxxi Ibid.
cxxxii Ibid.
cxxxiii Ibid.
cxxxiv Ibid.
cxxxvi Ibid.
cxxxvii Ibid.
cxxxviii Ibid.
cxxxix Ibid.
cxl Ibid.
cxli Ibid.
cxlii Ibid.
cxliii Ibid.
cxliv Ibid.
cxlv Ibid.
cxlvi Ibid.
cxlvii Ibid.
cxlviii Ibid.
cxlix Ibid.
cl Ibid., 158
cli Ibid.
clii Ibid.
cliv Ibid.
clv Ibid.
clxi Ibid.
clxii Ibid.
clxiii Ibid.
clxiv Ibid.
clxv Ibid.
clxvi Ibid.
clxvii Ibid.
clxviii Ibid.
clxix Ibid.
clxx Ibid.
clxxiii Ibid.
clxxiv Ibid.
clxxv Ibid.
clxxvi Ibid.
clxxvii Ibid.
clxxviii Ibid.
clxxix Ibid.
clxxxi Ibid.
clxxxii Ibid.
clxxxiii Ibid.
clxxxiv Ibid.
clxxxv Ibid.
clxxxvi Ibid.
clxxxvii Ibid.
clxxxviii Ibid.
clxxxix Ibid.
cxc Ibid.
cxci Ibid.
cxcii Ibid.
cxciii Ibid.
cxciv Ibid.
cxcv Ibid.
cxcvi Ibid.
cxcvii Ibid.
cxcviii Ibid.
cxcix Ibid.
cc Ibid., 263
cci Ibid.
ccii Ibid.
cciii Ibid.
cciv Ibid.
ccv Thabet, The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression, and Anxiety
ccvi Ibid., 7
ccviii Ibid.
ccix Ibid.
ccx Thabet, The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression, and Anxiety
ccxi Ibid.
ccxii Ibid.
ccxiii Thabet, Comorbidity of post traumatic stress disorder, attention deficit with
ccxvii Thabet, The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression, and Anxiety
Dimitry, Lydia. "A systematic review on the mental health of children and
adolescents in areas of armed conflict in the Middle East." Child: Care, Health
2214.2011.01246.x.
Halevi, Galit, Amir Djalovski, Adva Vengrober, and Ruth Feldman. "Risk and
life." Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 57, no. 10 (2016): 1183-193.
doi:10.1111/jcpp.12622.
Hamiel, Daniel, Leo Wolmer, Smadar Spirman, and Nathaniel Laor. "Comprehensive
Learned from Communities Exposed to War, Terrorism and Disaster." Child &
Youth Care Forum 42, no. 4 (March 21, 2013): 261-74. Accessed April 13,
2017. doi:10.1007/s10566-013-9200-7.
Thabet, Abdelaziz M., "The Relationship between War Trauma, PTSD, Depression,
and Anxiety among Palestinian Children in the Gaza Strip." Health Science
Journal, 3rd ser., 10, no. 5 (July 22, 2016): 1-8. Accessed March 29, 2017.
doi:10.4172/1791-809X.1000100503.
Thabet, Abdelaziz M., Ahmad Abu Tawahina, Eyad El Sarraj, David Henely, Henrick