Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Abstract: - Parboiling is a set of operations needed for the production of a gelatinized product. Scientifically it is a thermal treatment process done on
rice and other cereals. Water and heat are two essential elements to transform the natural cereal into “parboiled” cereal. In rice, it is done to produce
gelatinized or parboiled rice. Parboiling, if examined carefully has other scientific benefits beyond easy milling and reducing broken grains. Unfortunately,
the technology has received little attention in terms of research as far as food processing or preservation is concern. As part of an ongoing research to
assess the extent to which parboiling affect the migration of vitamin B1, a preliminary survey was conducted between October, 2012 and December,
2012 in the three northern regions of Ghana to elucidate the scientific principles behind the practice and to what exte nd processors understand these
principles. This work also aimed at high lighting the practice so as to encourage people to adapt indigenous technologies which may have more
beneficial health effects. Eighty (80) processors in the three northern regions drawn by purposive sampling methods were interviewed using structured
and semi structured questionnaires. The results showed that 100% of the people engaged in parboiling business are women with over 70% of them
having no formal education and therefore are unaware of any effects of parboiling on nutritional elements. It became clear that parboiling increased the
flavour and taste of the rice thus making it attractive to eat. However, the respondents only mentioned less broken grains, easy dehusking, ease of
cooking, increase quantity, better prices, and parboiling being a norm as some of the reasons why they carry out rice parboilin g. From the outcome of
this survey it’s recommended more studies be done on the subject to ascertain the nutritional impact of the practice. Also, the processors need to be
trained on parboiling and nutrition to build their knowledge on the scientific advantages of the process to enable them improves their practices.
Index Terms: - Parboiling, Gelatinized, Paddy rice, Physical qualities, Northern regions
————————————————————
1 INTRODUCTION the steeped rice at 100°C to gelatinize the starch. The grain
Parboiling of paddy rice is carried out in the three Northern expands until the hull's lemma and palea start to separate
and Volta regions of Ghana. This indigenous technique is (Gariboldi, 1984). The parboiled rice is then cooled and sun-
done to have easy milling as well as reduce breakages during dried before storage or milling. The degree of starch
milling. The processes involve soaking the paddy in hot water gelatinization is responsible for many of the attributes of
usually between 10 to 24 hours in order to saturate the paddy parboiled rice (Marshall et al., 1993). During the process of
with moisture. The soaked paddy is then steam heated till they gelatinization, alpha-amylose molecules leach out of the
gelatinized. They are then dried and milled. Paddy rice micellar network and diffuse into the surrounding aqueous
parboiling process is an old practice done several years ago. medium outside the granules (Hermansson and Svegmark,
More than 1000 years ago parboiling was done in simple clay 1996). The granules become fully hydrated, producing a
pots to improve ―shelf life‖ and resistance against insects maximum in the measured viscosity (Eliasson, 1986; Helbig et
(Joachim, 2011). The treatment is practiced in many parts of al., 2008). The starches in parboiled rice become gelatinized,
the world such as India, Bangladesh, Pakistan, Myanmar, and then retrograded after cooling. The parboiled rice kernels
Malaysia, Sri Lanka, Guinea, South Africa, Italy, Spain, should be translucent when wholly gelatinized. Retrogradation
Thailand, Switzerland, USA and France (Pillaiyar, 1981). West is where amylose molecules re-associate with each other and
Africa and the Caribbean African diasporas are also form a tightly packed structure. This increases the formation of
accustomed to parboiling rice. Parboiled rice has cross culture type 3-resistant starch which can act as a probiotic and benefit
relevance and is accepted by a number of tribes (Joachim, gut health in humans (Helbig et al., 2008). Marshall et al..,
2011). In India and Paskistan it’s noted for its good storage (1993) reported that incomplete parboiling result in partial
properties and special taste. It is also appreciated in North surface starch gelatinization. The dried kernels produced
America and Europe for easy cooking properties and low translucent outer layers and an opaque or white centre from
breakage during the milling process. African countries have the non-gelatinized starch (Kaddus Miah et al., 2002).
adopted parboiled rice in their local recipes because of the Although the effectiveness of proper parboiling in improving
good storage properties which reduces storage losses. In the physical quality of milled rice is well known (Bhattacharya
many African countries where rice production and and Subba Rao, 1966a; Juliano et al., 1981; Marshall et al.,
consumption are assuming an increasing rate, parboiling is 1993), this may not be so in the case of the rural poor
also practiced alongside production. In Nigeria parboiling of processors who are into parboiling as a business to cater for
paddy rice is done in the Oyo, Denu and Goweri states using themselves and their families.
traditional techniques with manual equipments (Kaddus Miah
et al., 2002). In the northern part of Ghana, especially in the 2.0 MATERIALS AND METHODS
Upper East region, not only rice that is parboiled but also The study was carried out in the three northern regions of
millet, sorghum and shea nuts. Whatever the situation, Ghana where rice parboiling is practiced most. Rice cultivation
parboiling is an important practice to the rural folks in the area in this part of Ghana is being encouraged by several policies
of food preparations, processing or preservation. The process of the government aim at boosting local rice production and
of parboiling is likely to drives nutrients, especially thiamine, consumption. with support from NGOs and other
from the bran to endosperm according to Tzia and organizations, parboiling of paddy rice has now become a
Karathanos, (2011), hence parboiled white rice is 80% commercial business activity where rural women are
nutritionally similar to brown rice. The traditional parboiling organized into groups and are supported with funds to
process involves soaking rough rice overnight or longer in undertake parboiling in commercial quantities. Parboiling is
water at ambient temperature, followed by boiling or steaming also carried out almost in every home that cultivates rice for
13
IJSTR©2013
www.ijstr.org
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 2, ISSUE 4, APRIL 2013 ISSN 2277-8616
home consumption. Purposive sampling was used to get the Table 2: Educational status of respondents
study areas and the respondents as well.
The study districts were; Tamale Metropolis and Tolon-
Kumbungu district in the Northern Region, Bolgatanga Educational status of respondents
Municipal in the Upper East Region and Wa municipal in the District/
Upper West Region. One processing group and fifteen Primary
Metropolis No
households were selected in each district. Five processors / JSS/JH SSS/ Terti
educatio
were interviewed at each processing group and one processor Elemen S SHS ary
n
at every household. Structured and semi-structured tary
questionnaires were administered to respondents to get an 1
Bolga- 1
overview on how parboiling process is done and the objectives 12 (30) 4 (10) 2 (5) (2.5
Municipal (2.5)
of the practice. After which an observation was made on the )
parboiling activities and the steps recorded. 1
Tamale 1
14 (35) 3 (7.5) 1 (2.5) (2.5
Metropolis (2.5)
2.1 Statistical Analysis )
The data collected was analysed using a descriptive statistic Tolon- 1
16 (40) 2 (5) 1 (2.5) 0
package (Statistical Package for Social Scientist or SPSS) and Kumbungu (2.5)
the results interpreted and presented on tables and charts.
Wa- 15
4 (10) 1 (2.5) 0 0
3.0 Results and Discussions Municipal (37.5)
The survey showed that parboiling business is a feminine 3 2
dominated activity as all respondents (100%) were females 57 13
Total 5 (6.25) (3.75 (2.5
(Table1). (71.25) (16.25)
) )
Figures in parenthesis are percentages
Table 1: Sex of rice processors in the three northern
regions. It was clear that the literate population in Northern Ghana was
low especially amongst women. It is therefore not surprising
Sex that majority of the respondents (71%) have not formal
Metro/Municipal/ education. Eighteen (18) of them representing 22.5 % had
District basic education while 5 respondents representing 6.25 % had
Males Female post basic education. This high number of illiteracy could have
a negative effect on their activities and the final product as
well. Also, the low number of literates’ persons in the
parboiling business might be explained to mean, the few
Bolga Municipal 0 (0) 20 (25)
literate women don’t consider parboiling as a satisfactory job
Tamale metro 0 (0) 20 (25)
and therefore will not engage in it hence the low level of
Tolon Kumbungu 0 (0) 20 (25)
literates among the practitioners (Table 2). The respondents
Wa Municipal 0 (0) 20 (25)
gave the advantages of parboiling to include; easy milling,
Total 0 (0) 80 (100) better pricing, easy cooking etc. Eighty percent (80%) was
Values in parenthesis are percentages attributed to easy milling as the main reason why they
undertake parboiling. They said, parboiled rice does not break
In the northern part of Ghana males tried to refrain from when milled or pounded and it takes less time to mill as
kitchen activities as much as possible as a norm. Since compared to none parboil rice. Marketability was next (60%)
parboiling is a kitchen activity males are not directly involved as reason for parboiling. According to them, parboiled rice sell
in rice parboiling process. Females practice the processes as faster and therefore reap in more returns than straight milled
they learn how to cook from their mothers. Most of the rice, may be due to the less broken grains of parboiled rice
respondents’ therefore have over 20 years experience in when milled. However, straight milled rice looks whiter and
parboiling. They therefore conduct this activity base on thus attracts more consumers who look at appearance rather
experience than on facts and guidelines. This can cause them than nutrients availability. Also respondents said parboiled rice
to at times ignore certain steps that can have an effect on the increased in quantity and therefore making returns on sales
final product. As a feminine dominated activity, it has not higher. Thus if you dehusk 10 kg of paddy raw, the quantity of
attracted much attention of the researchers who are grains you will get shall be less compared to the same 10 kg
predominantly males. This might account for parboiling not paddy parboiled before dehusking. About 27.5% and 12.5%
having guidelines developed to suit the northern local were attributed to easy cooking and taste improvement
circumstances. It also became clear from the survey that respectively for being the reasons of parboiling. According to
formal education was very low among the respondents. About them, parboiled rice takes less time to cook, and the cooking
71% of them had no formal education and about 16% attained is easier to the extent that even men can cook it. This agrees
primary or elementary education. (Table 2.) with Joachim (2011) who said, one advantage of parboiling to
the consumer is, the less knowledgeable house wives (and
men) in Northern Europe and North America can easily
prepare good granular rice on the plate. None-parboil rice has
lots of broken grains after milling and when cooked, the
broken ones get over cooked and stacked together, whiles the
14
IJSTR©2013
www.ijstr.org
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 2, ISSUE 4, APRIL 2013 ISSN 2277-8616
Steaming
(Vapour heating
Drying
15
IJSTR©2013
www.ijstr.org
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 2, ISSUE 4, APRIL 2013 ISSN 2277-8616
3.2.4 Soaking: The paddy rice is left to stay in the warm water
overnight (10-24 hours) for the paddy to imbibed water and
become moisture saturated. The scientific principles here are
Paddy rice
enzymes activation. A conducive environment is created after
content is cooled down for enzymes and pigments
transformation. Toxins are diluted and microbial pathogens
may be inactivated or removed at such high moisture level.
Soaking in The saturated grains expand and fill the hull’s lemma making it
cold/warm water lose in the process.
16
IJSTR©2013
www.ijstr.org
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 2, ISSUE 4, APRIL 2013 ISSN 2277-8616
processors who parboil for home consumption or for sale were inactivation or killing of microbes, and dilution of possible
the people who practiced the traditional methodology most poisons. Since it takes academic knowledge at a certain level
(Table 3). These individual processors explained that the to comprehend nutritional characteristics of food, especially
improved methodology was laborious and wastes more water vitamins, the low level of formal education among the
than the traditional methodology. However, the low processors, would surely have an effect on nutritional issues
educational level among them might have influenced their on their product. Though not mentioned, nutritional
choice of the traditional methodology, since they cannot easily improvement, especially vitamin B1 (thiamine) enrichment
conceive the advantages of the improved methodology as might be one of the important advantages of parboiling
against it challenges. In the case of grouped processors who process. In 2001, Otegbayo et al studied the effect of
are usually organized by NGOs, they observed these pre- parboiling on physico-chemical qualities of two local rice
soaking treatments seriously. varieties in Nigeria. According to Ibukun, (2008) their results
indicated that parboiling reduced the breakages, fat, protein
Table 3: Category of processors and type of methodology and amylose content of the rice while the water uptake and
used. thiamine contents were increased. Also the pre-treatments
Methodology given to the rice before the parboiling process help remove
Category of factors that could antagonized the nutritional qualities of the
Respondent Traditional Improved rice. Firstly, washing paddy rice in water removes dirt,
Method Method microbes and their toxins in the rice. The long hours of
soaking in warm water do not only facilitate water absorption
Organised group but also further reduces the substances like afflatoxins that
0 (0%) 20 (25%)
processors are in the rice during storage (old stock). This is because the
absorption of water to a saturation point would dilute and
Individual processors reduces the concentration of toxic substances in the rice. The
28 (35%) 0 (0%)
(self consumption) soaking might also cause certain enzymes or pigments
transformation and their movement inwards to the endosperm.
The steaming to a temperature of 80oC supplies heat enough
Individual processors
24 (30%) 8 (10%) to kill pathogens still found in the rice. The activity of
(Commercial)
pressurized steaming enabled vitamins notably thiamine to
move inward onto the endosperm. It further deactivates
Total 52 (65%) 28 (35%)
enzymes and make available substances like vitamins that
Figures in parenthesis are percentages otherwise could have been inaccessible. The transformation
and concentration of enzymes and pigments could be the
Traditional way of parboiling means pre-treatments processes reason why parboiled products such as millet, groundnuts, rice
like washing, floatation, separation of immature seeds, de- etc tastes better than non-parboiled ones. In rice parboiling
stoning, sieving etc are not done to the paddy before soaking. the important nutritional and physiological change is the active
There were some variations in the traditional methodology as movement of soluble molecules. Much of the rice nutrients are
practiced in the various districts. For instance, individual concentrated at the embryo (the germ) and during the
processors in Bolga Municipality soak their paddy in warm steaming process, the partial pressure created by covering
water and the paddy was left in the warm water overnight. But directs solutes movement inwards onto the endosperm
in Tamale metropolis, the paddy boiled in hot water till it was through the aleurone layer that surrounds the endosperm.
about to cook. Also, at the steaming stage processors in Bolga Other advantages are easy milling of parboiled paddy rice
Municipality will use little water, just enough to line the surface because the amylose starches retrograde and stack together
of the steaming container while those in Tamale will use more in a compact manner that pulls away from the husk when
water that was enough to further cook the paddy. The dried. This makes the kernel becomes somewhat delocalised
improved methodology which was an improvement of and now moves freely inside the husk. This makes it easier for
traditional procedure was uniformly practiced among grouped husk to be removed when milled or pounded on mortar and
processors in all the studied areas. Also, processing groups pestle. Since the point of attachment between the husk and
do undertake post milling practices like separating discoloured the endosperm is also loosened, the husks can easily get
grains, sorting into grades and packaging before sales. removed without breaking off the germ. Non-parboil rice has it
According to respondents, the procedures in the improved husk intimately attached to the embryo where all the nutrients
methodology started in Bolgatanga in the Upper East region are concentrated. Forceful removal of the husk will usually
and spread to other regions where organized groups adopted breaking away the germ with the husk, thereby losing all the
it. Thus this improved methodology or procedure is termed vital nutrients including thiamine. And such rice will certainly
Bolga – Bolga procedure (Bolga-methodology). not taste the same as rice that retains its germ or embryo after
parboiling. Thus the process of parboiling inadvertently cures
3.4 Scientific principles (reasons) behind parboiling. nutrient deficient-diseases or has the ability to supply certain
Apart from the above reasons, processors could not give other nutrients that otherwise could have lost to consumers. A
scientific benefits of parboiling. Even nutritional improvement, number of NGOs and some government agencies have begun
a common idea as far as food processing is concern was not training women to improve their parboiling activities. Their
mentioned because they cannot get the synergy between efforts all along has been on how to improve head rice yield
parboiling and nutrition let alone movement of water soluble (HRY) and eliminate stones in the rice in order to get good
vitamins in rice. This could be traced to the low level of formal market but not the nutritional aspect.
education of processors hence their inability to figure out the
scientific principles and advantages behind parboiling like
17
IJSTR©2013
www.ijstr.org
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 2, ISSUE 4, APRIL 2013 ISSN 2277-8616