Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
А.А. Stepashkin, D.I. Chukov, F.S. Senatov, A.I. Salimon, A.M. Korsunsky, S.D.
Kaloshkin
PII: S0266-3538(18)30087-3
DOI: 10.1016/j.compscitech.2018.05.032
Reference: CSTE 7235
Please cite this article as: Stepashkin АА, Chukov DI, Senatov FS, Salimon AI, Korsunsky AM,
Kaloshkin SD, 3D-printed PEEK-Carbon Fiber (CF) composites: Structure and thermal properties,
Composites Science and Technology (2018), doi: 10.1016/j.compscitech.2018.05.032.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to
our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all
legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED
3D-printed PEEK-Carbon MANUSCRIPT
Fiber (CF) composites: structure and thermal
properties
Stepashkin А.А.1, Chukov D.I.1, Senatov F.S.1, * Salimon A. I.1, Korsunsky A.M.2,
Kaloshkin S.D.1
1
- National University of Science and Technology «MISIS», 119049, Leninskiy pr. 4,
PT
Moscow, Russian Federation
RI
2
- Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Parks Road, Oxford,
SC
* - corresponding author, a.salimon@misis.ru, 119049, Leninskiy pr. 4, Moscow,
U
Russian Federation
AN
Keywords: A. Carbon fiber A. Polymer-matrix composites (PMCs) B. Thermal
Highlights
D
reported
EP
• Large pores lie at the interfaces between consequently deposited layers and lead
AC
• Fine imperfections formed within individual deposited layers likely to arise due
load
• Hierarchical porosityACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
of PEEK matrix induces additional thermal conductivity
Abstract
methodology and customized printer and were compared with their cast counterparts.
PT
The characterization of composite thermal properties in the range 25-300 ºC revealed
RI
than cast composites. Short carbon fibers used for reinforcement showed orientation
SC
along the polymer flow both in cast and 3-D printed samples causing the anisotropy of
thermal properties. The hierarchical nature of 3DP CF-PEEK porosity was observed by
U
SEM imaging, which allowed the identification of large scale inter-layer gaps and
AN
cracks, and fine scale intra-layer defects that are likely to be induced by the thermal and
mechanical gradients within the deposit that arise during fabrication. Purpose lay-up of
M
long continuous carbon fibers during 3D-printing opens a way to fabricate tailored
D
Introduction
EP
complex metal, ceramic and polymer-based components from digital computer models,
C
obviating the need for costly tool and workpiece fabrication, producing near net-shape
AC
objects, thus minimizing the requirement for further machining [1]. Various ‘flavors’ of
Additive Manufacturing exist, ranging from Selective Laser Sintering (SLS) to Fused
expanding the range of printable materials, enhancing the manufacturing precision and
modulus fibers can follow the same trend [2]. The application of 3D printing to the
PT
possessing high chemical resistance, good mechanical characteristics and heat
RI
resistance, opens unprecedented possibilities for successful manufacturing of high
SC
made with biocompatible unfilled PEEK has recently been reported [3-6].
U
AN
task, since the high temperature of printing requires oxidation protection before and
during the process. Furthermore, good adhesion between the carbon fibers and the
M
has been the approach addressed by the researchers [9] for PEEK/HA composites. In the
present study we concentrate on the use of FDM as the means of creating fiber-
EP
porosity within these structures. This serves both to improve our understanding of the
hierarchical structure of the resulting 3DP CF-PEEK composite and its inherent porosity
growth; B) at the interface of nozzle passes within a single deposited layer – i.e. in the
fibers within a single nozzle pass – i.e. in the direction of nozzle movement. The
surmise that different physical mechanisms are responsible for each system of
PT
imperfections, each requiring specific investigation.
RI
The coarsest system A) is likely formed mainly due to the shrinkage of polymer
at solidification (that reaches 1.3%, as reported in [10]) that occurs on top of the cold
SC
substrate composed of a previously deposited layer. The mismatch of specific volumes
of hot and cold layers results in material separation that is manifested as porosity.
U
AN
The contribution of thermal shock and temperature gradient that cause tensile
stresses in the core zone of the underlying cold layer needs to be carefully quantified
M
with the help of a numerical model considering many factors (nozzle speed, mass flow
deposited layer, somewhat removed from the layer interface. It is obvious that both
mechanisms are more pronounced in the direction vertical growth, where the highest
EP
the shorter time between forward and reverse nozzle passes, the system of imperfections
The system C) is closely related to the wetting of the interface between polymer
matrix and carbon reinforcement that is present either in the form of single short fibers
having thickness of tens microns, or as much thicker yarns of continuous carbon fibers.
The latter generate specific coarse inter-yarn porosity caused by the imperfect
printing manufacturing technology affects the thermal and mechanical properties of CF-
Russia by Professor S.G. Psakhye was used to produce the samples of CF-PEEK
PT
composites filled with discrete or continuous carbon fibers. Unfilled PEEK and CF-
RI
PEEK composite filaments (20 % of carbon fibers; the mass % are used hereinafter)
having diameter 1.7 mm were produced by means of extrusion and the discrete fiber
SC
content was achieved through the dilution of ready CF-PEEK composite Victrex 150
CA30 (30 % of discrete carbon fibers) [11] with unfilled PEEK Victrex [12]. In this
U
AN
series of experiments it was not possible to print CF-PEEK composites with fiber
content higher than 20 %, since fiber content exceeding this threshold caused excessive
M
melt viscosity of melt at temperatures in the range 350 – 370 оС. Higher printing
regime when printer nozzle was fed with continuous carbon fibers Tenax –J HTA40
EP
applied to produce the plates which were machined afterwards to obtain specimens of
AC
The reference samples of unfilled PEEK grade Victrex 150UF and CF-PEEK
composite Victrex 150 CA30 were injection-molding cast using the Thermo Scientific
Haake MiniJet machine in accordance with the instructions from material manufacturer
(Victrex), namely, injection piston temperature 390 оС, injection pressure 500 bars,
mold temperature 190 оС. All measurements were carried out for a series of at least 5
specimens cut from different sample zones. The averaged data is given in Results.
ACCEPTED
Density measurements MANUSCRIPT
[13] were performed using high precision analytical
balance AND GR 202 equipped with the set up for hydrostatic weighting in distilled
25°С was determined in accordance with Method 1 [14]. The measurements of thermal
diffusivity were carried out in the range of 25-300 ºC in accordance with [15] by the
Flash Method using NETZSCH LFA447 NanoFlash device using cylindrical (Ø12.7 x
PT
1..1,5 mm) and prismatic (8х8х2 mm) specimens, carefully cut from bigger samples.
RI
When strong anisotropy of thermal diffusivity was expected, as in the case of
SC
also prepared as a set of 2х2х8 mm bars. A film of thermally conductive carbon (0.3 -
0.4 mm thick) was deposited on the surface of the plate sample (KONTAKT CHEMIE
U
AN
® GRAPHIT 33 spray). This allows assuming that the energy deposited by the laser
flash is distributed in the carbon film first, and heat is further transmitted by conduction
M
λ (t ) = a(t ) ⋅ d k ⋅ C p (t ) (1)
TE
accordance with [16] using differential scanning calorimeter NETZSCH DSC 204
SEM structure studies were conducted using Hitachi TM-1000 and Tescan Vega
(the spectral range 4000-450 cm-1 with a resolution of about 0.9 cm-1, the accuracy of
the wave number 0.01 cm-1) in attenuated total reflection (ATR) mode.
parts with complex shapes (see Figure 2 a and b). Cut specimens are exemplified in the
PT
Figure 2 c. This technology, as previewed, induces both pores in the matrix polymer
RI
(Figure 3 a-d) and discontinuities at matrix and carbon fiber yarn interfaces (Figure 3 e-
SC
The density of 3D printed samples is lower than that of cast composites; the
latter have density in accurate accordance with the supplier technical specifications as
U
AN
seen in the Table 1. The decrease of density in 3D printed samples is related with
additional porosity of about 1,0 – 1,15 %. This additional porosity as seen in the Figure
M
is 20-40 µm) at the interfaces of fused deposited layers and the fine tracks (thickness is
D
1-5 µm) within a single fused deposited layer (the layer thickness is about 250 µm).
TE
measured), g/cm3
Density of 3-D printed 1,266 – 1,281 1,276 – 1,289 1,365 – 1,371 1,168 – 1,266
samples, %
Water absorption of 3-D 0,05 – 0,06 0,05 – 0,06 0,06 – 0,07 0,08 - 0,09
printed samples, %
Since the values of water absorption reveal almost no difference between cast
(0,04-0,05 as specified by supplier [16]) and 3D printed composites one can presume
that the predominantly close-cell type of porosity is formed in 3D printed samples. This
PT
conclusion is supported by microscopy data on flaw’ appearance in Figure 4.
The exceptionally high value of water absorption (up to 0,09 %) for the unidirectional
RI
composite reinforced with continuous carbon fibers is believed to be caused by the
SC
imperfect impregnation of yarns with polymer matrix that leaves easier access of
moisture along the yarn filler. The latter, obviously, might be a detrimental factor in the
of mechanical failure as seen in the Figure 4 c and d. The coarse and wide cracks are
M
separating fused deposited layers having thickness about 250 µm, while thinner cracks
D
and shear steps within a single layer are likely related with the system of fine tracks.
TE
Figure 3 shows a satisfactory wetting of short carbon fibers with PEEK. Although SEM
reveals some delamination at the matrix-fiber interface and pulling of fibers from the
EP
matrix it is not believed to affect the strength of composites. The length of discrete
carbon fibers in the range 60 - 100 µm may not be sufficient to interconnect the layers
C
of the multilayered structure with the thickness of layers about 250 µm. Moreover, the
AC
partial alignment of discrete fibers along the polymer flow causes the anisotropy and
of layers even less than that in case of stochastic spatial distribution of fiber orientation.
The characteristic FT-IR peaks in 3D-printed and cast PEEK samples are
vibrations at 1594, 1490 and 1413 cm-1, C–C(=O)–C bending vibrations at 1305 cm-1,
ACCEPTED
asymmetric stretching of C–O–C MANUSCRIPT
at 1280 and 1185 cm-1, aromatic hydrogen in-plane
deformation bands at 1157 and 1103 cm-1, diphenyl ketone band at 927 cm-1 [17]. The
presence of these peaks manifest that the oxidation level of both cast and 3D printed
samples is almost the same and, moreover, there was no noticeable difference in the
oxidation level between the core zones in cast samples and sites of increased porosity in
3D printed samples. FT-IR does not provide reliable evidences of localized oxidation.
PT
Since we did not firmly detect any localized oxides their contribution in fracture
RI
behaviour is questionable. Taking into account than the spatial resolution of FT-IR
device, i.e. about 2-3 µm, it can be concluded that the thickness of suggested oxidized
SC
layers is much smaller than the thickness of coarse porosity system and therefore
localized oxidation does not seem to contribute to coarse cracks. One can however
U
AN
speculate about comparable contribution of fine tracks (thickness is of 1-5 µm) and
Cp(t) for CF-PEEK composites is represented in Figure 6 where in the range 25-300 ºC
DSC curves reveal the only peculiarity upon heating – the jump at glass transition
TE
temperature Tg (in the interval 144,9 -151,9 ºC). The transition of basic polymer to
EP
The slope of Cp(t) curves remains unchanged at temperatures below and above
AC
Tg. Some increase of heat capacity in the vicinity of 300 ºC is related with the pre-
melting processes in the polymer [18]. The heating-cooling cycling in inert atmosphere
did not lead to any change of heat capacity dependence. The values of Cp of composites
were in good accordance with the general rule of mixture for all filler contents studied.
The data on thermal diffusivity a(t) which are represented in the Figure 7
Since this decrease is more pronounced in unfilled PEEK (for about 20-25 %) than in
CF-PEEK composite (for about 8-13 %) having equal porosity it is suggested that
partial percolation of highly conductive carbon fibers may compensate the detrimental
PT
Figure 7 b also shows that thermal diffusivity at 25 ºC in the specimens cut from
RI
the thick (15 mm) cast samples of PEEK + 30 % CF composite is for 50 % higher than
in specimens cut from 2 mm thick cast plate (0,6 and 0,4 mm2/s respectively). It is
SC
believed that the predominant alignment of short carbon fibers along the direction of
polymer flow causes the significant difference in the values of measured thermal
U
AN
diffusivity. In thin cast samples polymer flow is laminar and obviously parallel to the
sample plane. The predominant fiber alignment parallel to the sample plane returns in
M
the direction perpendicular to the sample plane the values of thermal diffusivity of about
overturned lamellae the values of thermal diffusivity at 25 ºC reach 0,6 – 0,63 mm2/s
TE
that is close to values of thermal diffusivity (about 0,6 mm2/s) in the specimens cut from
thick cast samples where laminar type of polymer flow is less expressed. Therefore,
EP
high viscosity of highly filled composites becomes an important factor for casting as
C
technology. Correct design and service of both composite parts and casting molds must
AC
3D-printed CF-PEEK composite filled with 5% of continuous carbon fiber yarns. Figure
7b depicts close values of thermal diffusivity in thin cast CF-PEEK filled with 30% of
short discrete carbon fibers and in unidirectional 3D-printed CF-PEEK composite filled
conductive carbon fibers are aligned parallel to the sample plane and in the direction
perpendicular to the thermalACCEPTED
flow directionMANUSCRIPT
– purposely in 3D-printed composite and
The percolation threshold for thermal diffusivity takes place at filler content
discrete carbon fibers leads to the modest increase of thermal diffusivity for about 20-25
PT
% (from 0,17 to 0,22 mm2/s at 298 K) in comparison with unfilled PEEK that is in good
RI
agreement with the general rule of mixture. The filler content of 30 % leads to triple
value of thermal diffusivity (about 0,5 mm2/s if averaged between the values measured
SC
in parallel and perpendicular to polymer flow direction in thin samples) in comparison
U
AN
The a(t) dependence (downward trend) demonstrates a peculiarity in the vicinity
saturate close to the melting temperature for unfilled PEEK and all composites.
composites due to the higher porosity in the range of 25-300 ºC. Thermal conductivity
grows for 11-19 % in unfilled PEEK over the temperature range for both technologies,
EP
e. g. for 3D-printing it rises from 0,21 to 0,25 W/m·K, and for casting it rises from 0,27
C
to 0,30 W/m·K.
AC
The increase of filler content leads to weaker growth of λ against temperature for
both technologies - only for 3 – 9% depending on the filler content (the decrease of
density due to the thermal expansion was taken into account). The calculated value of
thermal conductivity of 0,92 W/m·K for thick samples of cast PEEK+30 % CF filled
with 50-100 µm long discrete carbon fibers is in good agreement with the values found
in Cambridge Engineering Selector database [19] for the same composition but filled
with much shorter carbon fibers (5 µm) – 0,87-0,97 W/m·K. This presumes rather
uniform spatial distribution ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
of fiber orientation and sufficient percolation in the thick
smoother with the increase of filler content that obviously reflects smaller contribution
composites highly filled with discrete carbon fibers we consider the use of continuous
PT
carbon fibers as a promising option. In particular, thermal diffusivity and conductivity
RI
of the composite containing 5 % of continuous fibers is almost equal to the same of cast
SC
mixture we can estimate the value of thermal conductivity for unidirectional CF-PEEK
composite filled with 5% of continuous carbon fibers (having own thermal conductivity
U
AN
as high as 10 W/m·K [20]) in the direction of fiber orientation as 0,67 W/m·K.
Somewhat lower measured value about 0,6 W/m·K suggests insufficient impregnation
M
of yarn with matrix polymer and existing brakes of single carbon fibers inside yarns.
Provided the latter technology problems are solved we forecast the level of
D
thermal conductivity in the range of 5 – 6 W/m·K for Tenax –J HTA40 H15 1k yarn
TE
(and even up to 10-15 W/m·K for other carbon yarns) in desirable direction for
modulus continuous carbon fibers and peck carbon fibers having high thermal
C
conductivity along the fiber and higher filler contents will allow to reach this
AC
challenging target. This sort of 3D-printable lightweight, strong and refractory materials
can be useful for numerous ground and aerospace applications as well as for
Conclusions
set-up applicable for highly filled polymers that allows introducing continuous carbon
yarns into nozzle. The density of 3D-printed CF-PEEK composite is lower than for its
cast counterparts due to the ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
additional porosity (about 1 %) and imperfections
introduced into the material between consequently deposited layers and within single
deposited layers. The additional porosity is closed and does not result in additional
water absorption. On the other hand, additional water absorption in 3D printed CF-
PEEK composites reinforced with continuous carbon yarns does take place, and is
related to the lack of impregnation of continuous carbon yarns with matrix polymer that
PT
provides moisture access to the core of material.
RI
The thermal diffusivity and conductivity of 3D-printed composites are 25 – 30
% smaller than in cast composites due to the presence of additional porosity and
SC
imperfections.
U
AN
anisotropy due to the predominant alignment of carbon fibers along the direction of
continuous carbon yarns allows directed control over the anisotropy of thermal
Acknowledgement
TE
(RFMEFI58114X0005).
AC
References
2. Xin Wang, Man Jiang, Zuowan Zhou, Jihua Gou, David Hui . 3D printing of polymer
matrix composites: A review and prospective. Composites Part B 110 (2017) 442-458.
ACCEPTED
3. W. Z. Wu, P. Geng, J. Zhao, MANUSCRIPT
Y. Zhang, D. W. Rosen & H. B. Zhang. Manufacture
3D printing. Materials Research Innovations. Volume 18, 2014 - Issue sup5: ICAMDM
2014. http://dx.doi.org/10.1179/1432891714Z.000000000898
PT
for biomedical applications. Virtual and Physical Prototyping, 10:3, 123-135, DOI:
RI
10.1080/17452759.2015.1097053.
5. Chuncheng Yang, Xiaoyong Tian, Dichen Li, Yi Cao, Feng Zhao, Changquan Shi,
SC
Influence of thermal processing conditions in 3D printing on the crystallinity and
U
mechanical properties of PEEK material, Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 248
AN
(2017) 1–7
carbon fiber filled poly(ether ether ketone). Polymer Degradation and Stability 143
EP
(2017) 20-25.
10. https://www.victrex.com/~/media/literature/en/material-properties-guide_us-4-
20.pdf
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
11. https://www.victrex.com/~/media/datasheets/victrex_tds_450ca30.pdf.
12. https://www.victrex.com/ru/products/victrex-peek-polymers
13. ISO 1183-1:2012 Plastics - Methods for determining the density of non-cellular
plastics - Part 1: Immersion method, liquid pycnometer method and titration method.
14. ISO 62:2008 Plastics. Methods for the determination of water absorption.
PT
15. ASTME1461-07 Standard Test Method for Thermal Diffusivity.
RI
Determination of specific heat capacity.
SC
17. Mei Lv, Yanming Wang, Qihua Wang, Tingmei Wang and Yongmin Liang. Effects
of individual and sequential irradiation with atomic oxygen and protons on the surface
U
structure and tribological performance of polyetheretherketone in a simulated space
AN
environment / RSC Adv., 2015, 5, 83065-83073.
https://doi.org/10.1016/S1573-4374(02)80004-8
TE
19. CES EduPack software, Granta Design Limited, Cambridge, UK, 2016
(www.grantadesign.com).
EP
PT
RI
U SC
AN
Figure 1. The model of imperfection hierarchy in 3D-printed CF-PEEK composites.
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
Figure 2 – The outlook of 3D printed CF-PEEK articles (a,b) and specimens (c) cut
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
EP
PT
RI
SC
Figure 4 – The appearance fracture surfaces of 3D-printed PEEK+20 % CF composite.
U
White arrows correspond to the axes given in the Figure 1. The surface a) and b) were
AN
obtained after mechanical delamination of layers visible in c) and d).
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
PT
RI
U SC
AN
Figure 6 – Heat capacity of cast CF-PEEK composites.
M
D
TE
EP
C
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
PT
RI
U SC
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC