Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Background: A significant proportion of the elderly are affected by chronic pain, resulting in
a decreased quality of life. Opiate use has become increasingly common in older adult patients. This
article reviews both well-established current and novel therapies for management of chronic pain in
older adults.
Areas of Uncertainty: The number of studies involving management of chronic pain in elderly
patients is limited. Managing pain alongside multiple chronic, comorbid conditions presents thera-
peutic and appropriate drug dosing challenges.
Conclusions: Management of chronic pain in older adults remains challenging with current medi-
cation regimens. In facing the opiate epidemic, providers must use multicomponent strategies to find
the most effective and safest combinations of pain medications to achieve adequate pain control.
Regardless of the variety and complexity of pain medications available, prescribing physicians
should start with low doses, titrate slowly, and monitor pain control frequently. Treating chronic
pain is a complex and difficult issue that hopefully will become more manageable as pain medication
regimens improve and new therapeutics are developed.
BACKGROUND
Pain plays a significant role in the lives of older adults.
Up to 50% of community-dwelling older adults report
Division of Hospital Medicine, Department of Medicine, Hofstra pain that interferes with normal function, and half of
Northwell School of Medicine, Northwell Health, Manhasset, NY. nursing home patients report pain daily.1 The term
The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare. chronic pain has been used to describe pain that con-
*Address for correspondence: Division of Hospital Medicine, tinues longer than expected for healing, or pain lasting
Department of Medicine, Hofstra Northwell School of Medicine,
longer than 3–6 months.2 The reasons for increased
Northwell Health, Manhasset, NY 11030. E-mail: Nmurphy2@
northwell.edu
pain in the elderly are numerous. One proposed rea-
son is homeostenosis, which is the loss of homeostatic
1075–2765 Copyright © 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. All rights reserved. www.americantherapeutics.com
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Management of Chronic Pain in the Elderly e37
reserve of organ systems that come with aging. This used. The oral route is preferable because of steadier
loss of reserve is manifested as liver and renal function blood concentrations and convenience. Second, as with
decline, decreased muscle mass and increased frailty younger adults, shorter acting medications should be
that can lead to falls, decreased appetite, sleep distur- used for episodic pain, with scheduled doses before
bances, depression, delirium, agitation, and overall events that incite pain. Third, least toxic medications
debility.3 In addition, physiological changes occur in should be used first, starting with nonpharmacological
the elderly, which impact their ability to sense pain treatments if possible. Fourth, “rational poly-phar-
compared with younger adults. Some contributing fac- macy” should be considered, which consists of com-
tors include a decrease in the number of peripheral bining drugs with complementary mechanisms of
nociceptive neurons, increased pain thresholds, actions to cause greater relief when 1 single agent
reduced endogenous analgesic responses, and cannot accomplish this goal without adverse side
a decrease in neurotransmitters, such as GABA, sero- effects. This is especially important for providers to
tonin, noradrenaline, and acetylcholine. Despite the be cognizant of in geriatrics, where polypharmacy is
logical assumption that a decrease in neurotransmit- an important consideration.4
ters would decrease pain in the elderly, often the oppo- A comprehensive treatment program should also
site is seen.1 include functional restoration and psychosocial sup-
Several treatments for chronic pain are available for port. Often, providers follow the World Health Organ-
use in the elderly, as in their younger adult counter- ization’s analgesic ladder (Table 2), although there is
parts. These consist of nonpharmacological measures, little evidence to support this approach.1
nonopioid medications, opioid medications, pain- Furthermore, opioids prompt concern about addic-
modulating drugs, topical medications, and the novel tion, even when given for the intent of pain control.
therapeutics, which are below (Table 1). The American Geriatrics Society has 2 sets of ques-
When deciding on treatment of chronic pain in the tions to help guide opioid therapy in the elderly
elderly, some general principles apply.2 First, the least (Table 3).2
invasive method of drug administration should be Although older people have increased sensitivity to
opioids, they are a heterogeneous population, and
optimal dosing and side effect profiles are not easy
Table 1. List of new and current therapeutics
to delineate. It is important to remember that com-
pletely stopping pain is often an unachievable goal.
Current therapeutics Novel therapeutics Clinical trials often consider a 50% reduction in pain
to be significant, along with an increase in functional
Acetaminophen Micronized NSAIDs status and decrease occurrence of adverse effects.1
NSAIDs: oral and topical Targeted Opioids: Some chronic diseases, such as dementia, make a reli-
TRV130 able pain diagnosis difficult; certain scales, such as
Lidocaine patches Mixed MOP/NOP PAINAD (Pain Assessment in Advanced Dementia)
agonists: SR16435, and CNPI (Checklist on Nonverbal Pain Indicators)
BU08028
Capsaicin Cannabinoids
Weak opioids: tapentadol,
Table 2. WHO pain ladder
tramadol
Strong opioids: morphine, WHO’s pain relief ladder
hydromorphone,
oxycodone, fentanyl, 3 Freedom from cancer pain
buprenorphine Opioid for mild-to-moderate pain
Coanalgesics: TCAs, SNRIs +/2 nonopioid
Antiepileptics: +/2 adjuvant
carbamazepine, gabapentin, 2 Pain persisting or increasing
pregabalin
Opioid for mild-to-moderate pain
Muscle spasm: baclofen,
+/2 nonopioid
benzodiazepines,
cyclobenzaprine, +/2 adjuvant
methocarbamol 1 Pain persisting or increasing
Bone pain: calcitonin, Use a nonopioid +/2 an adjuvant
bisphosphonates
Source: http://www.who.int/cancer/palliative/painladder/en/.
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
e38 Murphy et al
1) What is the conventional practice for this type of pain 1) Am I able to treat this patient without help?
or patient?
2) Is there an alternative therapy that may offer a better 2) Do I need the help of a pain specialist or other
therapeutic index for pain control, functional consultant to co-manage this patient?
restoration, and improvement in quality of life?
3) Does the patient have medical problems that may 3) Are there appropriate specialists and resources
increase the risk of opioid adverse effects? available to help me co-manage this patient?
4) Is the patient likely to manage the opioid therapy 4) Are the patient’s medical, behavioral, or social
responsibly? circumstances so complex as to warrant referral to
a pain medicine specialist for treatment?
can help by assessing nonverbal signs of pain. Despite side effects are known. As of now, acetaminophen
patient’s self-report being the best indicator for pain, can be continued with a goal of up to 4 g/d, and with
these simple screening tools have proven to be dose reductions in patients with liver failure or those
effective.5 who are severely malnourished.8 Of note, our litera-
ture review is in concordance with the literature
review from the British Geriatrics Society (BGS), which
AREAS OF UNCERTAINTY did not find any studies primarily investigating
the effectiveness of Tylenol in a geriatric population.9
Many medications are used for chronic pain, but a chal-
However, both the American Geriatrics Society (AGS)
lenge in older adults is identifying the best agents for
and the British Geriatrics Society (BGS) recommend it
this specific patient population. Unfortunately, the
as the first-line agent for pain in the elderly.2
amount of studies involving elderly patients is limited,
as well as studies involving diverse populations of
elderly patients.6 In addition to the lack of a compre- NSAIDs
hensive evidence base, additional challenges arise in NSAIDs are not recommended in older adults for
treating pain among the elderly. Some patients or pro- long-term pain management, given the increased risk
viders may feel that pain is “natural,” and thus pain is of GI, cardiovascular, and renal side effects. NSAIDs
often undertreated. Managing pain alongside multiple should be used for the shortest time possible and only
chronic, comorbid conditions presents therapeutic and used for flare-like inflammatory pain.1 NSAIDs are
appropriate drug dosing challenges, whereas the fears often better for short-term pain in certain conditions,
of addiction and poly-pharmacy affect both doctors such as osteoarthritis (OA). A study of adverse drug
and patients alike. New therapeutic advances have reactions leading to hospitalizations in the elderly (age
attempted to address some of these concerns. 65 or older) showed NSAIDS to be the culprit in 23.5%
of cases, obviating the need for caution in dosing and
THERAPEUTIC ADVANCES usage.10 Common side effects in the elderly include GI
toxicity, especially when patients are on cardioprotec-
tive doses of aspirin. Prescribing a gastroprotective
Acetaminophen
agent, such as a proton pump inhibitor, H2 blocker,
Nonopioid analgesics are often the first medications or misoprostol can reduce GI ulcer risk in chronic
used in pain treatment in the elderly. Acetaminophen NSAID use.11 Selective COX-2 inhibiting NSAIDs have
has been used for many years as the first-choice agent fewer GI side effects, but can lead to renal failure and
for chronic pain, given its good side effect profile when thrombosis, warranting caution for use in the elderly.12
used in therapeutic doses. However, it is not a potent Overall, NSAIDs should be used in caution if acet-
analgesic, and recent studies have raised concerns aminophen is ineffective in the older patient. An indi-
about its safety because of small increases in mortality vidual decision needs to be made, based on their
as well as cardiovascular, gastrointestinal (GI), and comorbidities, medications, and risk factors. The
renal adverse effects.7 These studies, however, American and British Geriatric Societies and the Beers
included patients concurrently using nonsteroidal List recommend cautious use in the elderly given the
anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), for which these side effect profile of this class of medications.2,9,13
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Management of Chronic Pain in the Elderly e39
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
e40 Murphy et al
doses should be reduced with longer time intervals coanalgesics are the serotonin–norepinephrine reup-
between doses. Starting low and titrating the dose take inhibitors (SNRIs), particularly venlafaxine and
slowly upward is essential in elderly patients.23 One duloxetine. Both drugs are commonly used for neu-
review article analyzed the literature on short- versus ropathic pain secondary to diabetes or fibromyalgia.
long-acting opioids. The authors found both forms of However, a Cochrane review in 2015 noted that ven-
opioids to be efficacious with neither being more effec- lafaxine does not have enough compelling evidence to
tive than the other. The main takeaway was that be recommended for neuropathic pain.28 One ran-
opioids need to be tailored to the patient and their domized controlled trial showed that 56% of patients
state of pain. Some patients prefer the immediate pain receiving venlafaxine 150–225 mg had a 50% reduction
relief of short-acting agents, whereas others prefer the in pain, when compared with a group receiving
convenience of sustained pain relief with long-acting placebo.29 Despite this benefit, the authors noted that
agents.24 When comparing long-acting agents, a ran- increased hypertensive episodes at the above doses,
domized crossover study found that transdermal fen- which in light of the Cochrane review above and these
tanyl was preferred to sustained release morphine. Of findings, may limit the use of venlafaxine in the
212 patients (age 26–82), 138 (65%) preferred transder- elderly.30 Duloxetine, however, does not have cardio-
mal fentanyl, 59 (28%) preferred sustained release vascular effects and has been shown to reduce diabetic
morphine, and 15 (7%) had no preference. Transder- peripheral neuropathic pain by 50% compared with
mal fentanyl was preferred because of better pain placebo.31 Given the risk of dose-dependent side
relief. Adverse effect incidence was similar between effects mentioned previously, co-analgesics (SNRIs,
the 2 groups, with more constipation reported in the TCAs, etc.) should be titrated carefully and monitored
morphine group.25 Overall, the literature on opioid frequently.
therapy in the elderly consists mainly of uncontrolled Antiepileptic drugs are also used, mainly for neuro-
case series, which show that patients can achieve pathic pain. Carbamazepine is first-line for facial neu-
acceptable levels of analgesia without significant ropathic pain, seen in trigeminal neuralgia.
impairment of cognitive or psychomotor function.23 Gabapentin and pregabalin have been well studied
However, evidence on improvement in functional sta- in short courses (2–4 months) and in certain condi-
tus and quality of life is inconclusive with different tions, such as postherpetic neuralgia, diabetic neurop-
outcomes for patients secondary to different levels of athy, central neuropathic pain after spinal cord injury,
pain relief or adverse effects.26 and fibromyalgia.32 One meta-analysis assessed the
Adverse effects of opioids are important to recog- efficacy of using pregabalin daily for neuropathic pain
nize. Respiratory depression is a significant concern, caused by postherpetic neuralgia. The authors found
although tolerance develops quickly. Caution is espe- that a dose of at least 300 mg daily could achieve 50%
cially advised with methadone, given its variable phar- or more in pain reduction on an 11-point pain scale.33
macokinetics. In addition, awareness of respiratory Furthermore, pregabalin has proven to have a small
depression is also important when other central nervous benefit compared with placebo when used in fibro-
system depressants are used in combination with myalgia.34 The antiepileptics have significant adverse
opioids, such as benzodiazepines. Long-term opioid effects, including eyesight, balance, cognitive function,
therapy may also suppress the production of several and weight gain. Other agents used have limited evi-
hypothalamic, pituitary, gonadal, and adrenal hormones, dence to support them, including phenytoin, lamotri-
with symptoms including depression, fatigue, and gine, topiramate, and valproate.1
decreased libido.2 Various tools are available to assess Agents used for muscle pain include benzodiaze-
risk for problematic drug use, including the Opioid Risk pines and baclofen. Caution should be advised because
Tool (ORT) and the SOAPP-R (revised Screener and Opi- of their propensity to cause falls in the elderly, and
oid Assessment for Patients with Pain), the use of which especially for benzodiazepines, which have high-risk
is beyond the scope of this article.27 profiles that often preclude any potential benefit for
pain relief. Use should be justified on an individual
Adjuvant analgesics
basis for anxiety or muscle spasms. Benzodiazepines
Several coanalgesics are also used in the treatment of are on the Beers List, including both long- and short-
pain. Tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs), which affect acting agents.13 About a third of those aged 65 years or
serotonin and noradrenergic reuptake, are not often older living in the community are estimated to fall at
recommended for the elderly because of increased risk least once per year.35 Among these community-
of confusion or delirium. However, small doses of dwelling elders, about 10%–12% use benzodiazepines,36
TCAs, such as amitriptyline or nortriptyline, are often despite evidence that both long- and short-acting ben-
used for neuropathic pain. Other commonly used as zodiazepines have been shown to increase the fall risk
American Journal of Therapeutics (2018) 25(1) www.americantherapeutics.com
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Management of Chronic Pain in the Elderly e41
in the elderly. One observational study assessed the fall currently being tested. Most of the traditional opioids
risk of both short- and long-acting agents. Both short- are MOP agonists.44 Animal studies of NOP agonists
and long-acting agents increased the risk of falls. have shown effective analgesia with decreased abuse
(adjusted odds ratio 1.32; 95% confidence interval, potential in comparison with traditional opioids.45,46
1.02–1.72, and adjusted odds ratio 1.45; 95% confidence Therefore, derivatives of buprenorphine became an
interval, 1.00–2.19, respectively).37 Other muscle relax- area of interest, given that the drug is an MOP agonist
ants available include cyclobenzaprine, methocarbamol, and a weak NOP agonist.47 Furthermore, unlike MOP
and others. These do not specifically relieve muscle selective agents, MOP/NOP agonists have been
spasms, despite their name, and should not be given shown to treat neuropathic pain.44 Two novel mixed
for this purpose specifically.38 MOP/NOP ligands that have been developed,
SR16435 and BU08028 effectively decreased neuro-
NEW THERAPIES pathic pain in mouse models.48,49 One study tested
the safety and efficacy of BU08028 in nonhuman pri-
mates. BU08028 was found to provide long-lasting
Micronized NSAIDs
analgesia. After self-administering the drug on a progres-
Nano-formulations of low dose NSAIDs are currently sive ratio schedule, the reinforcing strength of BU08028
being developed and tested in clinical trials. These new was lower compared with buprenorphine, remifentanil,
formulations have similar efficacy when compared and cocaine. When compared with traditional MOP ag-
with traditional oral NSAIDs, while minimizing onists, BU08028 at 10–30-fold higher doses did not cause
adverse effects. This is achieved by optimizing the adverse cardiological events or respiratory depression.
pharmacokinetic profile. Nanotechnology increases When studying withdrawal, determined by changes in
drug surface area, which increases absorption with vitals such as increase in heart rate and respiratory rate,
lower doses to generate the same clinical effect.39 Cur- the nonhuman primates ended up withdrawing after
rently, there are 2 FDA-approved micronized NSAIDs, repeated administration of morphine. No withdrawal
diclofenac (Zorvolex)40 and indomethacin (Tivorbex)41 or vital sign changes were seen after discontinuing
for the use of mild-to-moderate pain. Although these BU08028.50 Overall, the current data available regarding
new formulations show promise given their compara- efficacy, tolerance, and abuse-free potential of MOP/
ble efficacy and potential for lower adverse effects, NOP agonists are promising, and further studies are
more clinical data will be needed overtime to assess needed to further validate the therapeutic profiles of
how these new formulations will fit into current pain these dual agonists.
medication regimens. As more elderly patients con-
Cannabinoids
tinue to use them without serious GI or cardiac events,
these new formulations may become a mainstay med- Cannabinoids are now more widely used legally for
icine that could limit the utilization of opioids in this medical reasons, but their use has proven to be more
population. beneficial for nausea, spasticity, and neuropathic
pain. Dronabinol and nabilone, synthetic tetrahydro-
Targeted opioids
cannabinoids analogs, have shown minimal analgesic
Currently, there is growing interest in developing benefits and have been mostly used for chemotherapy
opioids that target specific pathways of known opioid induced nausea and vomiting. Sativex, an oral spray
receptors. Since the DOR and MOR receptors were consisting of cannabinoid plant extract consisting of
cloned in 1992 and 1993 respectively, there has been a 1:1 ratio of tetrahydro-cannabinoids and cannobi-
an increased understanding of how these receptors noids, is licensed in the United Kingdom for
work at the molecular level.42 Specifically, the MOR multiple sclerosis-related spasticity.32 Of the 2 classic
activation has 2 signaling pathways, a G-protein path- cannabinoid receptors, CB1r and CB2r, central CB1r
way responsible for analgesic affects and a B-arrestin receptors are mainly responsible for the addiction and
recruitment pathway responsible for the respiratory psychotomimetic adverse effects seen with cannabi-
depression and GI adverse effects. TRV130 is a new noids. Current research is now focusing on the effec-
agonist that targets the G-protein signaling pathway. tiveness of CB2r agonists, developing peripherally
In a phase 2 study, the drug has proven to have similar restricted cannabinoids, targeting cannabinoid-
analgesic effects as morphine with less opioid–induced metabolizing enzyme inhibitors, or activating other
adverse effects.43 nonclassic receptors within the cannabinoid system.51
In addition to targeting specific pathways, mixed For now, current data mainly support the use of
opioid agonists that target combinations of the mu cannabinoids for the treatment of spasticity and
(MOP), delta (DOP), and ORL1 (NOP) receptors are chronic neuropathic pain.26
www.americantherapeutics.com American Journal of Therapeutics (2018) 25(1)
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
e42 Murphy et al
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Management of Chronic Pain in the Elderly e43
33. Snedecor SJ, Sudharshan L, Cappelleri JC, et al. System- 43. Viscusi ER, Webster L, Kuss M, et al. A randomized,
atic review and meta-analysis of pharmacological thera- phase 2 study investigating TRV130, a biased ligand of
pies for pain associated with postherpetic neuralgia and the m-opioid receptor, for the intravenous treatment of
less common neuropathic conditions. Int J Clin Pract. acute pain. Pain. 2016;157:264–272.
2014;68:900–918. 44. Bird MF, Lambert DG. Simultaneous targeting of multi-
34. Üçeyler N, Sommer C, Walitt B, et al. Anticonvulsants for ple opioid receptor types. Curr Opin Support Palliat Care.
fibromyalgia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013;CD010782. 2015;9:98–102.
35. Stel VS, Smit JH, Pluijm SMF, et al. Consequences of falling 45. Kiguchi N, Ding H, Ko MC. Central N/OFQ-NOP recep-
in older men and women and risk factors for health service tor system in pain modulation. Adv Pharmacol. 2016;75:
use and functional decline. Age Ageing. 2004;33:58–65. 217–243.
36. Blazer D, Hybels C, Simonsick E, et al. Sedative, hyp- 46. Ko MC, Woods JH, Fantegrossi WE, et al. Behavioral
notic, and antianxiety medication use in an aging cohort effects of a synthetic agonist selective for nociceptin/or-
over ten years: a racial comparison. J Am Geriatr Soc. phanin FQ peptide receptors in monkeys. Neuropsycho-
2000;48:1073–1079. pharmacology. 2009;34:2088–2096.
37. Landi F, Onder G, Cesari M, et al. Psychotropic medica- 47. Lutfy K, Cowan A. Buprenorphine: a unique drug with
tions and risk for falls among community-dwelling frail complex pharmacology. Curr Neuropharmacology. 2004;2:
older people: an observational study. J Gerontol A Biol Sci 395–402.
Med Sci. 2015;60:622–626. 48. Sobczak M, Cami-Kobeci G, Sa1aga M, et al. Novel
38. Billups SJ, Delate T, Hoover B. Injury in an elderly pop- mixed NOP/MOP agonist BU08070 alleviates pain
ulation before and after initiating a skeletal muscle relax- and inhibits gastrointestinal motility in mouse
ant. Ann Pharmacother. 2011;45:485–491. models mimicking diarrhea-predominant irritable
39. Manvelian G, Daniels S, Altman R. A phase I study eval- bowel syndrome symptoms. Eur J Pharmacol. 2014;
uating the pharmacokinetic profile of a novel, proprie- 736:63–69.
tary, nano-formulated, lower-dose oral indomethacin. 49. Sukhtankar DD, Zaveri NT, Husbands SM, et al. Effects
Postgrad Med. 2012;124:197–205. of spinally administered bifunctional nociceptin/orpha-
40. FDA: ZORVOLEX (diclofenac) capsules for oral use. Avail- nin FQ peptide receptor/m-opioid receptor ligands in
able at: http://www.accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatfda_ mouse models of neuropathic and inflammatory pain.
docs/label/2013/204592s000lbl.pdf. January 17, 2017. J Pharmacol Exp Ther. 2013;346, 11–22.
41. FDA: TIVORBEX (indomethacin) capsules for oral 50. Ding H, Czoty PW, Kiguchi N, et al. A novel orvinol
use. Available at: https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/ analog, BU08028, as a safe opioid analgesic without
drugsatfda_docs/label/2014/204768s000lbl.pdf. Jan- abuse liability in primates. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2016;
uary 17, 2017. 113:E5511–E5518.
42. Chen Y, Mestek A, Liu J, et al. Molecular cloning and 51. Davis MP. Cannabinoids in pain management: CB1, CB2
functional expression of a mu-opioid receptor from rat and non-classic receptor ligands. Expert Opin Investig
brain. Mol Pharmacol. 1993;44:8–12. Drugs. 2014;23:1123–1140.
Copyright Ó 2018 Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.