WIPO/P/MOW/00/9 ORIGINAL: Russian DATE: October 2000 [RUSSIAN AGENCY FOR PATENTS WORLD INTELLECTUAL AND TRADEMARKS (ROSPATENT) PROPERTY ORGANIZATION MOSCOW INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY FORUM organized by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) in cooperation with the Russian Agency for Patents and Trademarks (Rospatent) Moscow, October 13 to 19, 2000 COMMERCIALIZATION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY; VALUATION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS; MANAGEMENT OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS. Paper prepared by Mrs. Galina Solovieva, Scientific Expert, Division of Analytical Evaluations and Patent System Development, Federal Institute of Industrial Property, ‘Moscow morpeeshae dein o00escow foram deemed: doeWIPO/P/MOW/00/9 page 2 YVeaxaewmte gamet 1 rocnoza! Konzert! Buecttm neo uachopsaniio 06 olleHKe oOxeKTOB mntTe:LIeKryaTbHOll coOcTHEHHOCTH - pani waconoHt TeKIUTH, KOHIeWHO, HeROSMOXHO, Dra TeMa BMENIAET B CeO MHOTO actlextoB, NOoTOMY B ceTORHAIIHeH sIekIUM aBTOp HOCTapaeTcs HOKaSATS Gasy, Ha KOTOPOH octopania ouenra, Cpasy we azo oroBopiTics, 410 B SKOHOMMSECKH pasBHTSIX CTPAHAX, B KOTOPENK HcTopueckm psHowBie OTHOMEHHA CIOKIUINC 1aBH0, UpAkTHKa OeHKM Mpab Ha MaoGpereniua W upyrie OGbeKTSI HHTE-TEKTYAMBHO! COOCTBCHHOCTH TAKKE AlABHO copopmponana m nocrpoenta Ha paIHOSHENK mpusuax, B Tex 2€ cTpanax, Te 10 HenaBstero [BpeNeHH Ha Take OOBEKTEI OsUIa B OCHOBHOM Focy:tapeTBENHAs COOCTBEHHOCTE, HME, FE OTHOCHTENBHO HeMABHO TORBHIaCb HANHONAMIBHAR MPOMBILIEHHOCTS H BBL Ha MHPOBDIE AINKG, ONEHONAA MpaKTUKa CTATKUBACTCR C TPYSIHOCTAMH, KOTOPLIX HE 3HAIOT B pASBHTOM [MpoMBIULIeHHOM WAH NOCTARAYCTPHATEHON oOUIecTBe. OxIHH MpOOIEMB CBA3AHEI ¢ ‘MeqocTaTKON MeTOLOTOTHseCKOH MATepaTypsl H MeTORHYECKHX paspaboTOK (cTapat oveHoumas dupa na Jaane we HYkIaeTCR B YHEOHUKAX, TAK KAK Y HEC €CTH ONBIT CBOHX COrpyaHuKon, HOBKI! COTPYHK OGYSAETCA KOHKPETHIIM mpiteMaM PaGOTBr Ha CBOEM pabouen wecte Ha 6a3e comtizHoro 2KoNoMHYecKoTO O6pasonaHs). [Ipyras rpymia mpobest Ccnanaiia c OTAWSHEM peaTbHBIX CONHATSHO-SKOHOMHMECKHX YCTOBI CTPAH ¢ MepEXONEEINIL 1H pasomBaiommmaes cucTesanet OT YCiOBH paSBITTSIX CTpasl NO MOGOMY NapaNeTpy, ‘HasuHas oT HayaHBIX TPasIMIUtll, SaXOHONATENBCTBA Ht 3AKAHTHBAR YPOBHEM PHCKA CEHOK, slocTynHoCTSIO Mi opMalkHi. Hirax, «ro nonMMaeres on TepMHHOM conenKa OOKeKTOB METEILICKTY AT HO! coBcrnenHocTin», Hmm Go.tee cTporo log TepMuHOM «omeHKa MHTesLTeKTya.TbHOH coGcrseunoctim? Ouenxa unmennexmyansnoil cobemsennocmu - 3t0 KOMTUIeKC MepOMpHATH jopiumraecKoro, 2KOHOMIMECKOTO, OPraHHSALMOHHO-TeXHHYECKOTO H HHOTO XapaxTepA, HanpanseHHBIX Ha YeTaHOBeNHe LeHHOCTH OGBEKTA OTENKE (@ HMEHHO, HITesLIEKTYaTSHOT coBcreeHHocru ) KaK ToBapa lp PaTHMVINEIX cTOCOGaX WCHONSIOBAHHS, BBENEHUR ‘usTesttextyasiboii cOOCTBEHHOCTH B XosalicTBeHtbIH OOOPOT. SaxononaTeMscTBO PasHLIX CTpaH B OTHOUICHRH OeHONHOH MpaAKTHKH OTIMATCR, O6ummo saKou moGoMl crpauist YeTaHABTHMBACT ETHIE NPABINIA IX UPOBENEHHR OueHKH pas o6sextos. H mpexkie BceTo 3aKOH YeTaHAnAHBACT B KAKHX CAY¥AAX OWeHKY ‘MarentexTyamsHoHt cOBCTREHHOCTH HAO MPOBODLTS OO3ATE:TEHO, TO CCT mpeatyewarpusactea OBs3aTeNbHad OueHKA H HeOGA3ATENSHAS ONEHKA. B Poceni nponentenie OueHKH HiTeneKTYaTEHOt COBCTBENHOCTH SBIAETER HE o6mzamenousim m ocyutecTaseTCs nO YeMOTpeHHO saKassmKo8 (rpanooGranaTesel, hnarenTooGnauaTeneii, aBTOPoB, MHBECTOPOR, FOCYApCTRENBIX OPTAHOB Ht HHBIX "Mpennpusrail oprasursannt, npemnpmmnowareneli w ApyTHx rpaxaaH) BO BCEX CnyTAAX, 34 nneemO¥eHHeM YeTAHOBAEHHNLIX AeliCTBYIOMUM saKOHOATEALCTBOM cny'aeD OGASATEABHOTO npopenen. Tlponeenne onenk wresiekryansioit coGcTaeunocTH 8 Pocenm spaxercs ObnzamenbHbIM B CHETYIONIEK CHYAIX:WIPOMP/MOW/00/9 page 3 «© py nonresensi mo6ylo cxemky mpaB wa OOweKTH MHTEATEKTYaIIbHOH COOCTBEHHOCTH, npaniagiexamux nonsoctbio wm wacTHIHO Poceutickoll Deaepaui, cyOKeKTAM Poceuitexott Benepaminn mGo MyHUTasHBIM O6pA2ORAIIEM; © nmput poottakHonenrm criopa 0 CTOMMOCTH IpaB Ha OGbeKTs! HHTEILTEKTYaBHOH coGersentocT#; "mpi posixsioBens cropa 06 HcsHcneHuu HanorooGuaraeMol 623bI; a TaKKe B CTY'ae, eC HONIEHANSHAR CTOHNOCTS pas Ha OObEKTH MHTENLTeKTYANEHO‘ coBcrsenHocTy Kax skiana yupemTeNs 8 YCTABHBtH HORA OpraNratNN, YupeAEHHOH xkax oGmecTBO c OrpaHHenitoll oTReTCTBEMHOCTHIO, cocTaRAeT Gollee ABYxCOT MMHUMATBHBIX PaaMepos OILIAT TPYAa, YCTaHOBTEHHAIX (PeslepATBHBIM 3aKOHOM Ha AaTY InpesicrasseHna OKYMeHTOR ;UUx TocymapeTBeHHOM peruerpaAntt; Kora HONMHaTbHax CTOHMOCTK Mpap Ha OGBeKTSI MHTeNTeKTYaTbHO!H COBCTREHHOCTH, [BHOcHNEDS B OMLTaTY aKuM M MBOX nesEBIX Oywar oprasuisailHN, cocranaer Gonee [IDyXCOT YoTANOBLEHEBIX enepanbHBIN 3AKOHOM MHHUMAMBHBIX PABMepoR OTLIAT TPYAA; ‘¢ pu Gessosmesasio nonysenum oprannsauell npaB Ha OGweKTHI MHTEMNeKTYaIDHOH coScrsennocTa; + mpa conepinenun Gaprepux cxeI0K, Korda NpeaMeTOM TaKHX CX€OK ABRITOTCR Mpapa Ha ‘oGexrsi HETesLTeKTyaIbHOH cOOcTBeHHOCTH. Obvexmom ouenku senmores npunaanexanute 1opizecKnM HAM (HTH) (}usuecrar milan HMyeCTREHHGIE HCKTHOSHTENBHBIC WI HMYULECTREHEIE HewckmospTembuBle npasa Ha O6KEKTM MnITesLNeKTyATBHOH coBcTBeHHOCTH, nopripes npas Ha passe OObexTHI MHTeMTeKTYANbHOH! COOCTBEHHOCTH, a TAKE MpeNOCTARMEHEBIE ‘mpanooG1anaTenaMu TpeTsuM HUM Ipaza Wa HemOmB30RaNTHe OOBEKTOB MHTENTEKTYaAIGHOH coGersenHocTa. [Lua xpaTkOCTH STOT KOMMLEKE Mpas MpHeNsieMO HA3BIBATS caurreniextyambHoit coBcTREHHOCTEIOY. Tpedmemom ouenxu spaserca UeHHOCTe OObeKTA OEHKH, BEIPAKCHHAA B NEHOKHON uae (cTORMOCTS, HeHa) HHI B OTHOCHTeMBHOM BuLNE (NOXORHOCTE, OKYNAEMOCTE Ht HHTBIE noKasatem) K weniocTm p aevextion pnuze oTHocsres crexyiounie NOxasaTemH: PuHONAR crouMocTs, HBecTILMOHHIad CTOHMOCTS, MeppOHAYAIsHas OaaHiCOBaK CTOEMOCTS, ocraToanax Gatasicosan crouMocTs, GaKTHNCCKAK JHKBHLIALUONaN CTOEMOCTD, OTMPARHas iueHa neperosopos, HanGoslee neposrias peammsannOwHan CTOHMOCTS, Hea THES, mmessuonnnte mare. Teopis TaGKe K BHLTAM {eHe-KHOM eNHOCTH OTHOCHT 3a70TOBYIO CcrouMocrb M cTpaxoByIo CTOHMOCTS, O7HHAKO Ha NpaxTHKe B PoCcH HNTENIEKTYANBHAK coBcrpeHHOCTS He MpHHUNAETER KaK OGECTIENEHHE GXeI0K Hi KPesIITOB, H NpaBA Ha (OGsexs1 MHTeATeKTYaNEHOL coBcrREHHOCTH He CTPaxyIOTeR To cXeMaM CTPAXORAHNA Matepuasnioro ustyiecTsa, Poccalickoe SaxKOHOIaTEECTBO YCTaHABHBACT, WTO B CAy‘ae ‘oGasarersHoll oueHKH MiTesLTeKTy@mEHOM COOCTBERHOCTH MpeaMeTOM OMEHKH ABIAETCR e& PPINOsHas cTOMMOCTE. Ha octonaumn cratsu 3 Denepamsioro saxoHa PO «O6 ouetosnoll aesTemsHOCTH B PoccuitcKott Denepausnyn oT 29 moss 1998 r. Ne135-03, pamounan cmoumocms - 270 anGomee seposTHaa tela, Ho KOTOPO! AHHH OGEeKT OCHKH Ha ATY ONEHEH MOXET ObIT ‘OTyAGIeH Ha OTKPHITOM PEIEKE B YCNOBHRX KOHKYPEHLH, KOTHa CTOPOHBI NelicTBYIOT paayno, pacriomaras nceli weoGxommMol KEXbOPManUrel, a Ha BENTH HEH! CHEIKH He OnpaxaloTos Kakite-m160 upessutualiubte OSCTOSTETSCTBA, TO ECTS Kora: OWIHA H3 CTOPOH culekn ne o6s3aHa OTHYARNATS OFEKT ONCHKH, a Apyran cTopoHa He OOm3aHa NPHEHMATS