Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
ABSTRACT: This paper presents the results of piezocone tests (CPTUs) conducted at various penetration
rates in the two silty soils near Perth, West Australia. One of the soils was found on a tailings beach at Gingin
while the other was an estuarine deposit located in Bassendean on the banks of the Perth’s Swan River. The
standard CPTUs were carried out to investigate the site stratigraphy prior to the constant velocity tests which
involved rates down to 0.02 mm/s in Gingin and 0.002 mm/s in Bassendean; dissipation tests were also per-
formed. Cone end resistance resistances are shown to increase with reducing penetrometer velocity while ex-
cess pressures reduce. The results, which are shown to be generally consistent with other studies on the effect
of penetrometer rate, provide much needed data to extend the currently sparse database of variable rate piezo-
cone tests in the field.
qt (kPa)
4 PENETRATION TEST RESULTS 0 200 400 600 800
0.5
0.5 0.5
Depth (m)
1.0
0.02mm/s at
1.0 1.0
Depth (m)
0.96‐1.16m
1.5 1.5
1mm/s at 0.4mm/s at
0.67‐1.67m 0.67‐1.67m
2.0 2.0
1.5
(b)
2.5 2.5
Figure 2 Standard rate CPTU at the Gingin site Figure 3 Comparison for the rate tests at Gingin: (a) qt, (b) u2
This soft layer was investigated at various cone minimum distance apart of 1 m). It can be observed
penetration rates and the resulting qt and u2 profiles that, as expected, qt increases and u2 reduces as the
obtained are plotted on Figure 3. Each cone test was cone velocity reduces. qt values at 0.002 mm/s (i.e.
performed within a radius of 1.5 m. It is interesting 10,000 times slower than the standard CPT rate) are
to note that the qt values are not highly rate depend- about twice those recorded at 2 mm/s. Cone re-
ent within the 0.02 mm/s and 20 mm/s range. Alt- sistances at 0.002 mm/s and at 0.02 mm/s are com-
hough some local variations at the site complicate parable, which is consistent with the similarity be-
the inference of the actual rate effect, there is an av- tween their respective u2 values. These u2 values are
erage trend for qt to be roughly independent of rate essentially equivalent to the ambient pore pressure
between 0.4 mm/s and 20 mm/s and to be 60±20% (u0) of ~10 kPa suggesting that cone penetration in
larger at v=0.02 mm/s than that at the standard rate. this material was drained at cone velocities at or less
The u2 measurements mirror the qt data, showing than 0.02 mm/s. Conditions tend to become progres-
broadly similar u2 values between 0.4 mm/s and 20 sively more undrained above this velocity, as con-
mm/s and much lower u2 values at 0.02 mm/s. firmed by the large excess pores pressures developed
at a velocity of 0.2 mm/s.
4.2 The Bassendean site
qt (kPa)
Figure 4 shows the results from the three standard 0 100 200 300 400 500 600
rate tests conducted at the Bassendean site. Below an 2.8
upper 2.5m thick crust, the qt profiles generally in- 2mm/s at 0.02mm/s 0.002mm/s
crease linearly with depth and correspond with an 3.0
3‐4m at 3‐4m at 3.1‐3.5m
undrained strength varying from 13 kPa at 3 m to 25
kPa at 10 m (assuming a nominal Nkt value of 14).
3.2
The spikes in qt and accompanying drops in u2 are 0.2mm/s
at 3‐4m
indicative of more free draining sandier horizons,
Depth (m)
2 2 3.4
3.6
4 4
Depth (m)
3.8
6 6
4
8 8
4.2
(b)
10 10
Figure 5 Comparison for the rate tests at Bassendean: (a) qt, (b)
Figure 4 Standard rate CPTUs at the Bassendean site u2
An interesting observation from Figure 5 is the
160 Bassendean at 4m
‘wavy’ nature of the qt and u2 profiles, which is not Bassendean at 6m
evident in the standard rate test but is particularly Gingin at 1.5m
noticeable at velocities of 0.2 mm/s and 0.02 mm/s.
Pore pressure (kPa)
120
The ‘wavelength’ of these waves is typically about
150 mm, which may be indicative of the amount of
80
sediments deposited annually by the Swan River in
that area. The peaks in qt and trough in u2 indicate
slightly more free draining material than the soil 40
immediately above and below the peak and the local
troughs in qt must correspond to the finest material
present within the stratigraphy. Inspection of the 0
standard rate test data shown Figure 4 suggests that 1 10 100 1000 10000
Time (sec)
most of the material has a very similar grading while
Figure 5 points to subtle changes in these gradings. Figure 6 Dissipation tests results
The detection of these subtleties is evidently not 1 The & Houlsby (1991)
Teh & Houlsby (1991)
possible at this site using the standard rate CPTU. Bassendean at 4m; c 2
h=8mm /s
Bassendean at 4m; ch=8mm2/s
Bassendean at 6m; c 2
h=3mm /s
Bassendean at 6m; ch=3mm2/s
0.8 Gingin at 1.5m; c =2mm 2/s
Gingin at 1.5m; ch=2mm2/s
h
5 DISSIPATION TESTS
u/u_pred
0.6
Dissipation tests were also performed at the two u2 at t=0
0.4
sites to investigate in-situ coefficients of consolida-
u2 (kPa)
tion. The extended rods were left clamped and the
pore pressures recorded for periods of between 30 0.2
minutes and 3 hours. The theoretical dissipation Time (√sec)
curve proposed by Teh & Houlsby (1991) was em- 0
ployed to assess the in-situ coefficient of consolida- 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100
Normalised time, T* (Teh & Houlsby, 1991)
tion, ch, using the pore pressure dissipation data.
Figure 6 shows the results of the dissipation tests Figure 7 Normalized dissipation curves (Ir=150)
carried out at a depth of 1.5m at Gingin and at 4m
and 6m at Bassendean. It can be inferred that the rate Gingin and Bassendean. Averaged values of qt and
of dissipation is relatively fast at both sites, with on- u2 are plotted for each cone penetration velocity (v),
ly a small proportion of excess pressures remaining where averaging only included data recorded after
after 2000 seconds. The short delay to reach peak the cone had travelled a distance of 2 cone diameters
pore pressure (~30 seconds) is likely to be related to (71 mm) at a given speed.
the response time of the pore pressure transducer. It is apparent that the variations of qt with v are
The excess pore pressures are normalised by the similar at both sites and that cone resistance doubles
assessed initial maximum values and plotted against as v reduces by 5 orders of magnitude from 20 mm/s
the Teh & Houlsby (1991) time factor (T*) on to 0.002 mm/s at Bassendean. The qt values remain
Figure 7. The initial maxima were estimated, as in- relatively constant between 2 mm/s and the standard
dicated on the figure, by assuming a linear reduction rate of 20 mm/s and only increase by about 20%
in u2 with the square root of time. Assuming a soil from this constant value when v is reduced to 0.2
rigidity index (Ir) of 150, a ch value of 2 mm2/s was mm/s. Greatest changes in qt occur between v=0.2
derived at 1.5 m depth at the Gingin site while ch mm/s and v=0.02 mm/s with the resistance at the lat-
values of between 3 mm2/s and 8mm2/s provide the ter velocity being 50% greater than at the former.
best fit to the data at Bassendean. ch in the soil hori- Although tests at cone velocities less than 0.02mm/s
zons examined at both sites is therefore quite simi- were not conducted at Gingin, it can be inferred that
lar. The slightly higher value inferred at 4 m depth at qt at both sites is effectively independent of velocity
Bassendean is consistent with higher qt and lower u2 when v is less than 0.01 mm/s to 0.002 mm/s.
values (see Figure 5). The variations of u2 with cone velocity at both
sites are broadly similar, although they show more
variation than the qt values. The significant drop in
u2 as v reduces from 0.2 mm/s to 0.02 mm/s is con-
6 COMPARISON OF PENETRATION RATE sistent with the great increase in qt.
EFFECTS
7 DISCUSSION
5
It is of interest to compare the data measured at Bas-
sendean with the results obtained in another piezo-
cone rate effects study conducted at Burswood by 0
Schneider et al. (2004). The Burswood site is located 0.001 0.01 0.1 1 10 100
on the opposite bank of the Swan River in Perth to v (mm/s)
the Bassendean site (the distance between these two
(a)
sites is 8km). The properties of the Burswood clay 2.5
are summarized in detail by Low et al. (2011). This
clay has an average liquid limit of 85%, plastic limit 2
of 32%, clay fraction of 14% and silt fraction of
1.5
82%. Piezocone dissipation tests indicated ch values
u/'vo