Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
tern
atio
nalJ
o u
rnalo
fAfricaN
ursin
gScienc
e s9(2
018
)11–
111
4
ARTICLEINFO ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Nursing documentation reflects the quality in patient care. It promotes effective communication
Keywords:
Indonesia between caregivers. However, although its significance has been discussed in numerous articles, nursing doc-
Nursing documentation umentation remains problematic in Indonesia.
Nurses competency Objective: This research was the first of its kind in Indonesia which aim to identify issues with nursing doc-
Patient report umentation.
Quality Method: A qualitative approach through focus group discussions (FGD) with head nurses and staff was con-
ducted to identify problems that hinder nurses’ abilities to follow proper documentation procedure in an urban
hospital in Indonesia. The nurses who have more than one year work experience were recruited through simple
random technique. There were 35 participants involved. The open-ended questions regarding the nursing doc-
umentation process were administered. The group discussions were held two times on each teams and conducted
separately between the head nurses and their staff. The data for this descriptive qualitative study were re-
cognized through content analysis methods.
Results: The results of the study were captured in three themes: (1) Inadequate supervision for nurses on nursing
documentation; (2) Competency issues in documentation; (3) Lack of confidence and motivation on doc-
umentation.
Conclusion: Education is amongst the top listed contributing factors for quality nursing documentation. This is
confirmed with this research. The findings of the study suggest the need for continuous support and educational
intervention to ensure adherence to the nursing documentation procedure.
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-MAIL ADDRESS: ellywardani@unsyiah.ac.id (E. Wardani).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijans.2018.09.002
Received 8 December 2017; Received in revised form 26 September 2018; Accepted 27 September 2018
Av ailableon lin
e2 9Septe mb er2 018
22 14 -1391/© 2 0
18Th eA uth o rs.Publishedb yE
lsevierLtd
.T hisisanope na cce
ssa rticleunderth
eC CB Y
-NC
-NDlic
e n
se
(http :/
/cre
a tivecommon s.o
rg /licenses/B Y
-N C-ND/4.0/
).
H. KAMIL et AL. In
terN
AtioNlJo
A u
rNlo
A fA
fricAN
ursin
gScien
ces9(20
18)1
11–
1 14
barriers on proper report that extensively reported include time con- Table 1
straints, disproportion between staffing resources and workload, in- FGD guide.
sufficient guidelines for completing documentation, institutional po- Questions
licies (Kärkkäinen & Eriksson, 2005; Laitinen, Kaunonen, & Åstedt-
Kurki, 2010), and discontinuity on education as underlying problem 1. What do you understand by nursing documentation?
2. What effort that has been done to ensure proper documentation?
related to documentation was also found (Blair & Smith, 2012); thus
3. What do you think about the quality of documentation you have now?
education is amongst the top listed contributing factors to en- 4. Is there any challenges you encounter for this?
sure quality nursing reports which is aimed at improving and main- 5. What should we do to overcome such challenges?
taining the standard of documentation (Noorkasiani, Gustina, &
Maryam, 2015).
Evidence on hurdles around patient care documentation is globally protect the participants, permission obtained include consent for par-
identified. These, however, were mostly reported findings in developed ticipation in the study as well as for recording the FGDs. The FGDs were
countries. Limited studies are available on nursing documentation in conducted during the nurses’ lunch break. One of the researchers who is
developing countries compared to other issues such as inadequacy of experienced in the methodology, led the FGD discussions. Open-ended
nurses or workplace facilities (Nakate, Dahl, Petrucka, Drake, & questions were used as FGDs guide to ensure the discussion is on its
Dunlap, 2015). Indonesia, as one of developing country in Asia is yet track (see Table 1). Each participant was allocated a random number to
struggling with this issue. Nursing as professional relatively new in the ensure their anonymity. There were 35 participants involved including
country. In terms of nursing availability, Shields et al. found that there 14 head nurses (i.e., HN team) and 21 staff nurses (i.e., SN team). We
were about 50 nurses per 100,000 people in Indonesia (Shields & divided the selected head nurses and staff into two groups which make
Hartati, 2003). Most of these nurses were educated at diploma level, four groups in total for the FGDs. Each of the HN teams consisted of
known as AKADEMI KEPERAWATAN, in both private and public institutions. seven head nurses. For the staff nurses, the first group consisted of 10
More recently, the nursing profession in Indonesia has been striving to nurses and the second one was 11 nurses. Separate FGDs were con-
develop competency assessments and accreditation procedures. Each ducted for head nurses and their staff. The intention to interview them
level of nursing education has been standardized and accredited for separately, was to provide comfort for nurses in expressing their opi-
decades by referring to Presidential Act No. 8, 2012, regarding the nions and thoughts. It was also anticipated that participants may feel
Indonesian National Qualification Framework. The aforementioned Act pressurised if the leaders and staff are mixed together. The duration for
is a general rule for all Indonesian professionals. After a significantly the FGDs was 40–50 min and took place at a large urban hospital in a
long process, the Nursing Law (UNDANG-UNDANG KEPERAWATAN) was province in Indonesia. This hospital was purposefully selected because
passed by the country’s legislature under Bill No. 38/2014. The law it is the main health referral and education center in the province.
addresses several critical areas such as legal protection for nursing Content analysis was conducted after coding and categorizing data into
professionals, the organization, and professional education for nurses. thematic areas. Three themes of nurse perspectives on obstacles hin-
In addition to this, nurses in Indonesia are expected to adhere to a code dering them from proper nursing documentation were derived. We
of conduct standardized by the PERSATUAN PERAWAT NASIONAL INDONESIA checked the transcribed data verbatim for reliability of data. To escalate
(PPNI) or Indonesian National Nurses Association (INNA). These pro- the findings trustworthiness, we conducted peer debriefing. An ex-
fessional standards involve nurses’ responsibility for clients, nurses and perienced colleague was asked to check over the study for credibility
their best practice, community, colleagues, and their own profession and determine if the results align with the data obtained from partici-
(PPNI, 2012). Nursing documentation is therefore on the priority list in pants.
conducting quality nursing care. Nurses in Indonesia have been taught
to prepare appropriate nursing records during their education. This was 3. Results
reemphasized again during their clinical training. On the other hand,
despite the availability of evidence on the impact of insufficient doc- 3.1. DEMOGRAPHIC description
umentation of patient care, nursing documentation problems in this
context exist. Recent national publications have been clearly stated that All participants involved in the research were the staff nurses and
nursing documentation in a number of hospitals in Indonesia is far from head nurses in the hospital. They were all female nurses and their age
ideal. Studies report that most nurses only fulfill 50% or less of the total were between 29 and 52 years old. Educational backgrounds vary
target of 80% required documentation as mandated by the ministry of amongst them, and range from the diploma level (n = 23 nurses), ba-
health; this, unfortunately, indicates the low quality of nursing care chelor in nursing (n = 10 nurses) to master degree (n = 2 nurses).
(Noorkasiani et al., 2015). Reflecting on this problem and the paucity of
research with regard to nursing documentation in the country, this 3.2. Problems with nursing DOCUMENTATION
study sought to further identify problems faced by these nurses that
lead to inadequate documentation in nursing. Primary problems encountered by nurses in documentation from the
perspective of head nurses and their staff can be viewed within these
2. Methods themes: (1) Inadequate supervision for nurses on nursing documenta-
tion; (2) Competency issues in documentation; (3) Lack of confidence
Ethics approval for the research was obtained from the Faculty of and motivation on documentation.
Nursing, University of Syiah Kuala Ethics Committee with certificate
number: 113001180517, as well as permission from the Research and (1) INADEQUATE supervision for nurses on nursing DOCUMENTATION
Development Center of the hospital where the study took place. This
study adopted a qualitative approach by undertaking focus group dis- The greatest problem encountered by the nurses is primarily caused
cussion (FGD) with head nurses and staff nurses. After obtaining a list of by inadequate supervision in the documentation process. The nurses
staff and head nurses in the hospital supplied by the Hospital’s Human were asked to complete the documentation procedure but rarely as-
Resource Department, participants for the study were randomly re- sessed on how they completed its process. One head nurse complained:
cruited. The inclusion criteria were nurses who have more than one
“We do know that documenting nursing process is important for a
year experience. The selected participants were contacted to seek for
patient during his time with us in the hospital, but, what I have seen
their consent to participate to this study. All the contacted head nurses
is that the staff do not know how to fill that in. They need more
and staff were able and willing to have FGDs with the researchers. To
1
1
2
H. KAMIL et AL. In
terN
AtioNlJo
A u
rNlo
A fA
fricAN
ursin
gScien
ces9(20
18)1
11–
1 14
1
1
3
H. KAMIL et AL. In
terN
AtioNlJo
A u
rNlo
A fA
fricAN
ursin
gScien
ces9(20
18)1
11–
1 14
(Björvell et al., 2003). Furthermore, it often affects the nurses’ moti- 24–29.
vation to complete proper nursing documentation. The theme poten- Björvell, C., Wredling, R., & Thorell-Ekstrand, I. (2003). Improving documentation using
a nursing model. JOURNAL of ADVANCED Nursing, 43(4), 402–410.
tially introduced the role of nursing leadership and their commitment Blair, W., & Smith, B. (2012). Nursing documentation: Frameworks and barriers.
to documentation. Head nurses, along with their staff, admitted that CONTEMPORARY Nurse, 41(2), 160–168.
there were an absence of leadership among them. All tasks and duties Blake-Mowatt, C., Lindo, J., & Bennett, J. (2013). Evaluation of registered nurses'
knowledge and practice of documentation at a Jamaican hospital. INTERNATIONAL
were regarded simply as regular activities, likely leading to a deva- Nursing Review, 60(3), 328–334.
luation of nursing documentation. Although nurses previously ac- Cheevakasemsook, A., Chapman, Y., Francis, K., & Davies, C. (2006). The study of nursing
knowledged the significance of documentation in nursing care, there documentation complexities. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of Nursing PRACTICE, 12(6), 366–374.
Darmer, M. R., Ankersen, L., Nielsen, B. G., Landberger, G., Lippert, E., & Egerod, I.
must be an urgent call for hospital management and leadership to
(2004). The effect of a VIPS implementation programme on nurses’ knowledge and
strengthen nurses’ patient reporting and the quality of care (Müller- attitudes towards documentation. SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL of CARING Sciences, 18(3),
Staub, Needham, Odenbreit, Ann Lavin, & Van Achterberg, 2007; 325–332.
Darmer, M. R., Ankersen, L., Nielsen, B. G., Landberger, G., Lippert, E., & Egerod, I.
Thoroddsen & Ehnfors, 2007; Wardani, 2017).
(2006). Nursing documentation audit–the effect of a VIPS implementation pro-
gramme in Denmark. JOURNAL of CLINICAL Nursing, 15(5), 525–534.
5. Conclusion Edelstein, J. (1990). A study of nursing documentation. Nursing MANAGEMENT , 21(11), 40–
46.
Gillund, M. V., Rystedt, I., Wilde-Larsson, B., Abubakar, S., & Kvigne, K. (2013). Building
Though the performance remains rudimentary, the nurses ac- competence through cross-cultural collaboration in the aftermath of a tsunami:
knowledged that nursing documentation is a crucial element that builds Experiences of Indonesian teachers. Nurse EDUCATION TODAY, 33(3), 192–198.
positive linkage between nurses and their ability to provide high- Hager, L., & Munden, J. (2008). Complete guide to DOCUMENTATION. Ambler, PA: Lippincott
Williams and Wilkins.
quality care to their patients. Lack of supervision, competency issues, Heartfield, M. (1996). Nursing documentation and nursing practice: A discourse analysis.
and problems of confidence and motivation affect the way they conduct JOURNAL of ADVANCED Nursing, 24(1), 98–103.
documentation. Increasing support and improvement of nursing skills Hennessy, D., Hicks, C., Hilan, A., & Kawonal, Y. (2006). The training and development
needs of nurses in Indonesia: Paper 3 of 3. HUMAN Resources for HEALTH, 4(1), 10.
across nursing education at all levels are essential for the successful Higginbotham, E., & McCarthy, R. (2001). Elements of nursing negligence. Nursing PRACTICE
adherence to proper nursing documentation. The study was an initial AND the LAW: Avoiding MALPRACTICE AND other LEGAL risks (pp. 118–131). Philadelphia:
attempt to identify the problems with documentation among nurses in FA Davis Co.
Hoban, V. (2003). How to... improve your record keeping. Nursing Times, 99(42), 78–79.
Indonesia. The mixed perspective of staff nurses and their proximal Iyer, P. W., & Camp, N. H. (2004). Nursing DOCUMENTATION: A nursing process APPROACH.
leaders generated a larger view rather than single approach participant Med
(e.g., staff nurses only). The use of randomized selected participants has League Support Services, Incorporated.
Jefferies, D., Johnson, M., & Griffiths, R. (2010). A meta-study of the essentials of quality
helped to avoid bias during discussions. The results of this research,
nursing documentation. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of Nursing PRACTICE, 16(2), 112–124.
however, remains somewhat limited. The data was generated from Kärkkäinen, O., & Eriksson, K. (2005). Recording the content of the caring process.
hospital based nurses, therefore it is less likely generalizable across JOURNAL of Nursing MANAGEMENT , 13(3), 202–208.
Indonesia at large. Single approach of focus group discussion, time Laitinen, H., Kaunonen, M., & Åstedt-Kurki, P. (2010). Patient-focused nursing doc-
umentation expressed by nurses. JOURNAL of CLINICAL Nursing, 19(3–4), 489–497.
constraints, and nurses as participants only did not allow the re- Lindo, J., Stennett, R., Stephenson-Wilson, K., Barrett, K. A., Bunnaman, D., Anderson-
searchers to fully engage in the organizational culture and may have Johnson, P., ... Wint, Y. (2016). An audit of nursing documentation at three public
limited the study’s interpretations. Future research is therefore war- hospitals in Jamaica. JOURNAL of Nursing SCHOLARSHIP, 48(5), 499–507.
Lock, L. R. (2011). Selecting examinable nursing core competencies: A Delphi project.
ranted by incorporating hospitals’ supervisory board and leaders per- INTERNATIONAL Nursing Review, 58(3), 347–353.
spective to investigate further on institutional oversight which may Mbabazi, P., & Cassimjee, R. (2006). The quality of nursing documentation in a hospital
enhance the quality of future studies on nursing documentation in the in Rwanda. AFRICA JOURNAL of Nursing AND Midwifery, 8(1), 31–42.
Müller-Staub, M., Needham, I., Odenbreit, M., Ann Lavin, M., & Van Achterberg, T.
country of Indonesia. (2007). Improved quality of nursing documentation: Results of a nursing diagnoses,
interventions, and outcomes implementation study. INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL of Nursing
6. Ethics Knowledge, 18(1), 5–17.
Nakate, G. M., Dahl, D., Petrucka, P., Drake, K. B., & Dunlap, R. (2015). The nursing
documentation dilemma in Uganda: Neglected but necessary. A case study at Mulago
Ethics approval from the University of Syiah Kuala Ethics National Referral Hospital. Open JOURNAL of Nursing, 5(12), 1063.
Committee. Noorkasiani, N., Gustina, R., & Maryam, S. (2015). Faktor-Faktor yang Berhubungan
dengan Kelengkapan Dokumentasi Keperawatan. JURNAL KEPERAWATAN INDONESIA,
18(1), 1–8.
Conflict of interest Owen, K. (2005). Documentation in nursing practice. Nursing STANDARD, 19(32), 48–49.
Persenius, M. W., Hall-Lord, M.-L., Bååth, C., & Larsson, B. W. (2008). Assessment and
documentation of patients’ nutritional status: Perceptions of registered nurses and
We confirmed that there is no conflict of interest to disclose in this their chief nurses. JOURNAL of CLINICAL Nursing, 17(16), 2125–2136. https://doi.org/10.
research. 1111/j.1365-2702.2007.02202.x.
PPNI. (2012). Retrieved 18 May, 2012, from www.ppni.or.id.
Shields, L., & Hartati, L. E. (2003). Nursing and health care in Indonesia. JOURNAL of
Acknowledgements
ADVANCED Nursing, 44(2), 209–216.
Strength, D., & Cagle, C. S. (1999). Indonesia: An assessment of the health state, health
The research is part from PENELITIAN UNGGULAN UNIVERSITAS (University care delivery system, and nursing education. JOURNAL of CULTURAL Diversity, 6(2), 41.
Thoroddsen, A., & Ehnfors, M. (2007). Putting policy into practice: Pre-and posttests of
Excellent Research) funding scheme, grant number: 73/UN11.2/PP/
implementing standardized languages for nursing documentation. JOURNAL of CLINICAL
PNBP/SP3/2017, Syiah Kuala University, Indonesia. Our thanks to all Nursing, 16(10), 1826–1838.
the nurses involved for their time and knowledge on this study. Wang, N., Hailey, D., & Yu, P. (2011). Quality of nursing documentation and approaches
to its evaluation: A mixed-method systematic review. JOURNAL of ADVANCED Nursing,
67(9), 1858–1875. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2011.05634.x.
References Wardani, E. (2017). Nursing LEADERSHIP: A CASE of INDONESIA (PhD thesis)University of
Sheffield.
Asamani, J. A., Amenorpe, F. D., Babanawo, F., & Ansah Ofei, A. M. (2014). Nursing Whittaker, A. A., Aufdenkamp, M., & Tinley, S. (2009). Barriers and facilitators to elec-
documentation of inpatient care in eastern Ghana. British JOURNAL of Nursing, 23(1). tronic documentation in a rural hospital. JOURNAL of Nursing SCHOLARSHIP, 41(3),
Austin, S. (2011). Stay out of court with proper documentation. Nursing2016, 41(4), 293–300.
1
1
4