Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
1551–1555
Gene therapy in renal diseases. Kidney-targeted gene therapy identification of the responsible genes encouraged us to
could be an ideal treatment for renal diseases since the thera- attempt to treat the hereditary diseases. Understanding
peutic molecule is limited in the kidney and the systemic effect the pathophysiology of the hereditary diseases became
may be minimized. The technical development of the gene de-
livery to kidney and the identification of the responsive gene a driving force to promote the development of the gene
for a particular disease encourage the challenge to hereditary therapy.
diseases. Collagen type IV reassembling was reported to be Alport syndrome is a representative case since the
succeeded in Alport syndrome model by introduction of ex- pathophysiology was recently revealed. The underlying
ogenous COL4A5 gene. Many gene therapies are evaluated cause of the disease is a defective structure of the type
in various glomerulonephritis models and unilateral ureteral
obstruction (UUO) model, and favorable results are accumu- IV collagen framework of the GBM [1]. It has been es-
lated. Transplant kidney is an ideal target for gene therapy, by timated that 85% of cases are caused by mutations in
which ischemia reperfusion, acute rejection and chronic allo- the X chromosomal gene encoding the a5(IV) collagen
graft nephropathy can be treated. The importation of the novel chain (COL4A5). Type IV collagen is a triple-helical pro-
technology, for example hybrid stem cell-gene therapy could tein consisting of three a chains. In fetus, the GBM is
promote the gene therapy of renal diseases toward clinical
application. composed of two a1(IV) collagens and one a2(IV) colla-
gen. After birth, these GBMs are replaced with adult-type
GBM composed with a3(IV), a4(IV), and a5(IV) chains.
Kidney-targeted gene therapy could be an ideal treat- In Alport syndrome, the defect of a5(IV) chain results
ment for renal diseases because the effect of therapeu- in disassembling the adult-type GBM and embryonic-
tic molecule is limited in the kidney. The harmful effects type GBM substitutes. However, since the embryonic-
to other tissues can presumably be limited. The kidney type GBM does not provide sufficient strength against
is, however, a well-differentiated organ with specialized the mechanical strength as a filter and sufficient resistance
compartments, composed of glomerulus, tubule, vascula- against proteolysis, the consequence is deterioration
ture, and interstitium. These anatomic compartments are of the structure and development of progressive renal
separated by basement membranes and associated cells. failure.
The glomerular basement membrane (GBM) separates Alport syndrome is not believed to be an attractive
the blood flow from urine flow and the tubular base- candidate for gene therapy because it seems to be dif-
ment membrane separates urine flow from interstitial ficult to deliver COL4A5 gene selectively to podocytes
fluid. These barriers make the gene tranfection difficult by passing the GBM. Heikkila et al [2] developed a new
because the vectors are hard to pass through the anatomic gene transfer technique, that is, a perfusion of adenoviral
barriers. This review discusses the recent progress of gene vector for 2 to 12 hours, which allows gene transfer exclu-
therapy for renal diseases by focusing on Alport syn- sively to glomerular cells. They succeeded in the delivery
drome, glomerulonephritis, and transplantation. of the a5(IV) collagen gene to the glomerular cells by
renal perfusion of adenovirus vector [3]. They further ap-
plied this technique to gene therapy in canine model Al-
MONOGENIC HEREDITARY RENAL DISEASE
port syndrome. The introduced gene for a5(IV) collagen
Until 5 years ago, no one believed that the hereditary expressed in the glomeruli and assembled triple-helical
renal diseases could be a target of gene therapy. How- type IV collagen fiber composed of a3(IV), a4(IV), and
ever, the technical development of the gene delivery and a5(IV). Currently, they are continuing experiments to
isolate the clinical application. A major issue remaining is
1 Participant and speaker.
how the administration of COL4A5 gene can be repeated
in clinical case. Generally, treatment of monogenic hered-
itary diseases is not so attractive from the viewpoint of
Key words: gene therapy, renal disease, glomerulonephritis.
industry. Gene therapy might be a less expensive alterna-
C 2004 by the International Society of Nephrology tive therapy for rare diseases.
1551
1552 Imai et al: Gene therapy in renal diseases
then induced in these mice. Renal function and histology gene overexpression prolonged the renal survival [32]. In
were preserved in the mice whose bone marrow was contrast, there is no report to show that IL-10 gene ther-
reconstituted with IL-1 receptor antagonist–producing apy prolongs the survival of the renal allograft, although
cells. The survival rate after a second challenge with cardiac and liver allografts were reported to improve the
nephrotoxic antibody was significantly improved in the survival [33, 34].
IL-1 receptor antagonist chimera. These results suggest Allo-MHC is the main target for alloimmune re-
that reconstitution of bone marrow for continuous supply sponse, exposure of these donor MHC antigens through
of anti-inflammatory cells may be a novel strategy for the hematopoietic stem cells could serve as a strategy for in-
treatment of chronic inflammation. ducing antigen-specific tolerance. DNA-mediated gene
transfer of MHC classes I and II molecules to recipi-
ent bone marrow cells prolong the survival of cardiac
TRANSPLANTATION allograft [35]. Kohn et al [36] demonstrated that efficient
Reduction of ischemia-reperfusion injury has been transduction and expression of a retrovirally transduced
challenged by gene therapy. Noiri et al [26] intracardia- MHC class I gene [H-2K(b)] in bone marrow–derived
cally injected antisense for inducible nitric oxide syn- cells, resulting in the life-long expression of the retrovi-
thase (iNOS) in rats. The rats were protected from the ral gene product on the surface of bone marrow–derived
subsequently inflicted ischemic renal injury. This study hematopoietic lineages including Sca-1(+), lineage neg-
showed the direct evidence of the toxic effect of iNOS ative, hematopoietic progenitors. T cells from the mice
in ischemic insult of kidney. Haller et al [27] injected receiving MHC-transduced bone marrow were unable to
ICAM-1 antisense oligonucleotides with lipofectin into reject H-2K(b) mismatched skin graft. They acquired the
vein 6 hours before renal artery occlusion. They showed tolerance but were able to respond to third-party controls.
the improvement of the ischemia-induced infiltration of This approach could be a promising strategy to induce
granulocytes and macrophages, and less cortical renal tolerance in transplant kidney.
damage and renal function. Furuichi et al [28] injected HGF is known as a renotropic growth factor and pro-
plasmid coding 7ND into skeletal muscle 7 days before tects tubular cells from toxic and ischemia/reperfusion
ischemia. The 7ND gene therapy inhibited acute tubular injury [14]. In the early phase of kidney transplantation,
necrosis in mouse model in concomitant with reduction when the transplanted kidney is exposed to insults by
of macrophage infiltration. However, these gene modifi- ischemia/reperfusion and high dose of immunosuppres-
cations were prophylactic therapeutics. sant, HGF may afford protection against the acute re-
Acute rejection occurs as a consequence of T-cell acti- nal injury and may enhance regeneration. After adding a
vation. In the process of interaction of T-cell and antigen- calcineurin inhibitor, the short-term outcome of survival
presenting cell (APC), the engagement of T-cell receptor rate of transplant kidney improved significantly. How-
and alloantigens presented by major histocompatibility ever, chronic allograft nephropathy remains as an impor-
complex (MHC) molecules is essential but also needs cos- tant issue to be resolved. Chronic allograft nephropathy is
timulatory signals. The interaction of CD28 with B7 is the characterized by the deterioration of renal allograft func-
most important one. A chimeric fusion protein, cytotoxic tion and is associated with typical morphologic change,
T-lymphocyte antigen-4 Ig (CTLA4Ig), binds to B7 but such as glomerulosclerosis, arterial intimal thickness and
blocks the signal. Tomasoni et al [29] injected adenoviral smooth muscle cell proliferation, tubular atrophy, and
vector coding CTLA4Ig gene into renal artery of Brown interstitial fibrosis. Azuma et al [37] demonstrated that
Norway rat kidney ex vivo. Then, they transplanted the only 4 weeks of HGF injection into penile vein improved
kidney to a Lewis rat, which normally rejects the Brown the graft survival in rat chronic allograft nephropathy
Norway rat kidney and abolishes the renal function in model, in which Fisher 344 rat kidneys were transplanted
10 days. The CTLA4Ig gene transfected to transplanted to Lewis rats, whose own kidneys were removed. Half of
kidney improved graft survival more than 50 days by in- control rats died in 32 weeks, while no graft loss occurred
hibiting the T-cell activation. in HGF-treated rats. Tubular cell death was significantly
Induction of immunologic tolerance to alloantigens is suppressed in HGF-treated allograft in concomitant with
a major goal in the field of transplantation. Graft toler- the significant improvement of morphologic change. The
ance may be induced by apoptosis of alloreactive T cells. early change including tubular necrosis and macrophage
Fas antigen-Fas ligand interaction triggers the apoptosis infiltration was reduced and the late change of interstitial
in activated T cells. Adenoviral vector–mediated FasL fibrosis was also blocked by HGF treatment. These results
gene transfer to the transplanted kidney prolonged the strongly suggest that the HGF treatment may provide a
graft survival [30, 31]. Suppression of Th1 cytokines and new therapy for transplant organs. We are currently per-
up-regulation of Th2 cytokines are often observed in the formed HGF gene therapy as a preclinical study for pre-
setting of tolerance induction. Overexpression of Th2 cy- serving transplant kidney. HGF gene was introduced into
tokines, IL-10 and IL-4, may induce the tolerance. IL-4 pig kidney ex vivo by electroporation and transplanted
1554 Imai et al: Gene therapy in renal diseases
to the same pig and then removed the other one. The optimistic for clinical application of the gene therapy of
kidney-introduced HGF gene significantly reduced inter- renal diseases in future.
stitial fibrosis (unpublished data). Interestingly, the graft-
Reprint requests to Enyu Imai, Suita 565–0871, Osaka, Japan.
versus-host disease (GVHD) is suppressed by skeletal E-mail: imai@medone.med.osaka-u.ac.jp
muscle gene therapy with HGF [38] in conjunction
with interferon-c (IFN-c) and tumor necrosis factor-a
REFERENCES
(TNF-a) expression in the intestine and liver, and de-
creasing the serum IL-12 and prolonging the survival, 1. HUDSON B, TRYGGVASON K, SUNDARAMOORTHY M, NEILSON E: Al-
port’s syndrome, Goodpasture’s syndrome, and type IV collagen. N
suggesting HGF may modulate the immune system to Engl J Med 348:2543–2556, 2003
induce the tolerance. 2. HEIKKILA P, PARPALA T, LUKKARINEN O, et al: Adenovirus-mediated
gene transfer into kidney glomeruli using an ex vivo and in vivo kid-
ney perfusion system—First steps towards gene therapy of Alport
syndrome. Gene Ther 3:21–27, 1996
3. HEIKKILA P, TIBELL A, MORITA T, et al: Adenovirus-mediated trans-
CONCLUSION fer of type IV collagen alpha5 chain cDNA into swine kidney in vivo:
Deposition of the protein into the glomerular basement membrane.
The ethical issue of gene therapy limited its application Gene Ther 8:882–890, 2001
to incurable and life-threatening diseases, like advanced 4. AKAGI Y, ISAKA Y, ARAI M, et al: Inhibition of TGF-beta 1 ex-
cancer, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection pression by antisense oligonucleotides suppressed extracellular ma-
trix accumulation in experimental glomerulonephritis. Kidney Int
and lethal inherited diseases. In the field of cardiovascu- 50:148–155, 1996
lar diseases, however, a gene therapy for severe ischemic 5. CARL M, AKAGI Y, WEIDNER S, et al: Specific inhibition of Egr-1
limb diseases shows prominent impact on the improve- prevents mesangial cell hypercellularity in experimental nephritis.
Kidney Int 63:1302–1312, 2003
ment of the quality of life by induction of angiogene- 6. MAESHIMA Y, KASHIHARA N, YASUDA T, et al: Inhibition of mesangial
sis. This success built up a consensus of the application cell proliferation by E2F decoy oligodeoxynucleotide in vitro and
of gene therapy to nonlethal diseases with low activi- in vivo. J Clin Invest 101:2589–2597, 1998
7. TOMITA N, MORISHITA R, TOMITA S, et al: Transcription factor decoy
ties of daily living. The innovative therapy for halting the for NFkappaB inhibits TNF-alpha-induced cytokine and adhesion
progress of chronic renal failure is anticipated from the molecule expression in vivo. Gene Ther 7:1326–1332, 2000
patient. The consideration of the risk and benefit through 8. CHOI Y, KIM Y, PARK H, et al: Suppression of glomerulosclerosis
by adenovirus-mediated IL-10 expression in the kidney. Gene Ther
lifelong activities of daily living and expanding medical 10:559–568, 2003
expense for treatment of the end-stage renal disease may 9. MUNGER K, MONTERO A, FUKUNAGA M, et al: Transfection of rat
permit the clinical application of gene therapy for pro- kidney with human 15-lipoxygenase suppresses inflammation and
preserves function in experimental glomerulonephritis. Proc Natl
gressive kidney diseases. Assurance of safety is, of course, Acad Sci USA 96:13375–13380, 1999
the major hurdle of the gene therapy for chronic kidney 10. ISAKA Y, TSUJIE M, ANDO Y, et al: Transforming growth factor-beta
diseases as well. 1 antisense oligodeoxynucleotides block interstitial fibrosis in uni-
lateral ureteral obstruction. Kidney Int 58:1885–1892, 2000
In contrast, kidney transplantation is an ideal target 11. NAKAMURA H, ISAKA Y, TSUJIE M, et al: Introduction of DNA en-
for gene therapy. At least three strategies are envisioned, zyme for Egr-1 into tubulointerstitial fibroblasts by electroporation
which are reduction of ischemia/reperfusion injury, inhi- reduced interstitial alpha-smooth muscle actin expression and fi-
brosis in unilateral ureteral obstruction (UUO) rats. Gene Ther
bition of acute rejection. and induction of tolerance. The 9:495–502, 2002
clinical application of gene therapy to transplant kidney is 12. LAN HY, MU W, TOMITA N, et al: Inhibition of renal fibrosis by gene
promising. Furthermore, the application of gene therapy transfer of inducible Smad7 using ultrasound-microbubble system
in rat UUO Model. J Am Soc Nephrol 14:1535–1548, 2003
to xenotransplantation is also expected. 13. TERADA Y, TANAKA H, OKADO T, et al: Ligand-regulatable erythro-
Gene repair is the ultimate purpose of gene therapy. poietin production by plasmid injection and in vivo electroporation.
The targeting gene repair has several advantages over Kidney Int 62:1966–1976, 2002
14. MATSUMOTO K, NAKAMURA T: Hepatocyte growth factor:
the gene augmentation or gene silencing. As the repair Renotropic role and potential therapeutics for renal diseases. Kid-
within a cell only needs to occur in the homologous re- ney Int 59:2023–2038, 2001
combination once. It is not necessary to construct the ex- 15. MIZUNO S, MATSUMOTO K, NAKAMURA T: Hepatocyte growth fac-
tor suppresses interstitial fibrosis in a mouse model of obstructive
pression vector system and relatively easy to synthesize nephropathy. Kidney Int 59:1304–1314, 2001
a large amount of the therapeutic small DNA molecules. 16. GAO X, MAE H, AYABE N, et al: Hepatocyte growth factor gene
In addition, the gene expression is regulated by its own therapy retards the progression of chronic obstructive nephropathy.
Kidney Int 62:1238–1248, 2002
promoter. Small fragment homologous replacement [39] 17. YANG J, DAI C, LIU Y: Hepatocyte growth factor gene therapy and
and RNA/DNA chimeric oligonucleotides [40] are possi- angiotensin II blockade synergistically attenuate renal interstitial
ble for use in gene repair of the monogenic diseases. fibrosis. J Am Soc Nephrol 13:2464–2477, 2002
18. SHIMIZU H, MARUYAMA S, YUZAWA Y, et al: Anti-monocyte chemoat-
The importation of the novel technology for gene ma- tractant protein-1 gene therapy attenuates renal injury induced
nipulation such as stem cells technology must be essential by protein-overload proteinuria. J Am Soc Nephrol 14:1496–1505,
for development of hybrid cell-gene therapy. The hurdle 2003
19. TAKASE O, HIRAHASHI J, TAKAYANAGI A, et al: Gene transfer of trun-
is still high to clinically introduce the gene therapy in re- cated IkappaB alpha prevents tubulointerstitial injury. Kidney Int
nal diseases except renal cancer. We are, however, very 63:501–513, 2003
Imai et al: Gene therapy in renal diseases 1555
20. IMAI E, ISAKA Y: New paradigm of gene therapy: Skeletal-muscle- 30. SWENSON K, KE B, WANG T, et al: Fas ligand gene transfer to re-
targeting gene therapy for kidney disease. Nephron 83:296–300, nal allografts in rats: effects on allograft survival. Transplantation
1999 65:155–160, 1998
21. ISAKA Y, BREES D, IKEGAYA K, et al: Gene therapy by skeletal muscle 31. KE B, COITO A, KATO H, et al: Fas ligand gene transfer prolongs rat
expression of decorin prevents fibrotic disease in rat kidney. Nat renal allograft survival and down-regulates anti-apoptotic Bag-1 in
Med 2:418–423, 1996 parallel with enhanced Th2-type cytokine expression. Transplanta-
22. ISAKA Y, AKAGI Y, ANDO Y, et al: Gene therapy by transforming tion 69:1690–1694, 2000
growth factor-beta receptor-IgG Fc chimera suppressed extracellu- 32. KATO H, RITTER T, KE B, et al: Adenovirus-mediated gene transfer
lar matrix accumulation in experimental glomerulonephritis. Kid- of IL-4 prolongs rat renal allograft survival and inhibits the p21(ras)-
ney Int 55:465–475, 1999 activation pathway. Transplant Proc 32:24506, 2002
23. NAKAMURA H, ISAKA Y, TSUJIE M, et al: Electroporation-mediated 33. SHINOZAKI K, YAHATA H, TANJI H, et al: Allograft transduction of
PDGF receptor-IgG chimera gene transfer ameliorates experimen- IL-10 prolongs survival following orthotopic liver transplantation.
tal glomerulonephritis. Kidney Int 59:2134–2145, 2001 Gene Ther 6:816–822, 1999
24. YOKOO T, OHASHI T, UTSUNOMIYA Y, et al: Prophylaxis of antibody- 34. ZUO Z, WANG C, CARPENTER D, et al: Prolongation of allograft
induced acute glomerulonephritis with genetically modified bone survival with viral IL-10 transfection in a highly histoincompati-
marrow-derived vehicle cells. Hum Gene Ther 10:2673–2678, 1999 ble model of rat heart allograft rejection. Transplantion 71:686–691,
25. YOKOO T, OHASHI T, UTSUNOMIYA Y, et al: Genetically modified 2001
bone marrow continuously supplies anti-inflammatory cells and 35. MADSEN J, SUPERINA R, WOOD K, MORRIS P: Immunological unre-
suppresses renal injury in mouse Goodpasture syndrome. Blood sponsiveness induced by recipient cells transfected with donor MHC
98:57–64, 2001 genes. Nature 332:161–164, 1988
26. NOIRI E, PERESLENI T, MILLER F, GOLIGORSKY M: In vivo targeting 36. KOHN D, SADELAIN M, GLORIOSO J: Induction of T-cell tolerance
of inducible NO synthase with oligodeoxynucleotides protects rat to an MHC class I alloantigen by gene therapy. Nat Rev Cancer
kidney against ischemia. J Clin Invest 97:2377–2383, 1996 3:477–488, 2002
27. HALLER H, DRAGUN D, MIETHKE A, et al: Antisense oligonucleotides 37. AZUMA H, TAKAHARA S, MATSUMOTO K, et al: Hepatocyte growth
for ICAM-1 attenuate reperfusion injury and renal failure in the rat. factor prevents the development of chronic allograft nephropathy
Kidney Int 50:473–480, 1996 in rats. J Am Soc Nephrol 12:1280–1292, 2001
28. FURUICHI K, WADA T, IWATA Y, et al: Gene therapy expressing 38. KUROIWA T, KAKISHITA E, HAMANO T, et al: Hepatocyte growth
amino-terminal truncated monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 pre- factor ameliorates acute graft-versus-host disease and promotes
vents renal ischemia-reperfusion injury. J Am Soc Nephrol 14:1066– hematopoietic function. J Clin Invest 107:1365–1373, 2001
1071, 2003 39. GONCZ K, PROKOPISHYN N, CHOW B, et al: Application of SFHR to
29. TOMASONI S, AZZOLLINI N, CASIRAGHI F, et al: CTLA4Ig gene transfer gene therapy of monogenic disorders. Gene Ther 9:691–694, 2002
prolongs survival and induces donor-specific tolerance in a rat renal 40. YOON K, IGOUCHEVA O, ALEXEEV V: Expectations and reality in
allograft. J Am Soc Nephrol 11:747–752, 2000 gene repair. Nat Biotech 20:1197–1198, 2003