On behalf of the Air Marshal National Council and all of the flying Federal Air Marshals we represent, please allow this letter to serve as our complaint of unsafe, unhealthy, and hazardous conditions of employment created and fostered by the Federal Air Marshal Service.
The Federal Air Marshal Service is the law enforcement component of the Transportation Security Administration and as such falls under the purview of the Office of Special Counsel.
The Federal Air Marshal Service has created a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety, and by doing so is responsible for gross mismanagement of its workforce by causing the following:
1) Most flying Federal Air Marshals (FAMS) are scheduled to work all three shifts, day, evening, and midnight just about every week. 2) Most air marshals cross between 5-10 time zones a week. 3) Last minute schedule changes are routine, thus there is very little consistency in the start times. 4) The Agency does not employ policies when scheduling air marshals, instead the agency uses “guidelines” that have resulted in some cases where Air Marshals have been forced to work over 20 hours without rest. In fact, in some cases these guidelines do not call for a maximum length to a duty day. (See the Federal Air Marshal Mission Scheduling Guidelines). 5) TSA commissioned a sleep study on air marshals where it found that the vast majority of Air Marshals most likely suffer from acute and undiagnosed sleep disorders. The study also cited a disturbingly high abuse of alcohol amongst Air Marshals due to the extreme sleep deprivation. The study also found about 80% of Air Marshals are sleep deprived. 6) The Agency has in the past felt the need to send TSA Office of Inspection agents overseas to conduct sobriety checks of Air Marshals. 7) The agency actually gave training classes where it recommended Air Marshals use alcohol and melatonin to assist with sleeping. 8) Most air marshals report having to use sleeping pills in order to get sleep. 9) Federal Air Marshals schedules are not regulated by the FAA or any other agency like airline flight crews are. 10) The Federal Air Marshal Service leads all federal agencies in medical retirements percentage wise. 11) The Federal Air Marshal Service spends in excess of twenty million dollars a year in OWCP, workers compensation costs. According to TSA there are only several thousand air marshals. 12) Although not currently required by law to be recorded the agency averages about 3-5 air marshal suicides a year. Given the small workforce that would be one of the highest suicide rates amongst any federal law enforcement agency. 13) The sleep study commissioned by TSA stated “air marshals suffering from fatigue have increased risk of self-injury”. 14) Recently there has been an unprecedented number of psychotic episodes suffered by Air Marshals, to include a recent murder suicide. (See description of incidents below). 15) Recently the agency suffered its first in the line of duty death of a female Air Marshal while in flight due to blood clots. 16) The Agency medical branch has significant evidence of numerous Air Marshals afflicted with DVT, Deep Vein Thrombosis or blood clots. 17) The number of medical illnesses have reached epic proportions amongst flying Air Marshals. (See specific descriptions below). 18) TSA Administrator Pekoske was given an email dated June 9, 2018 entitled “Concerned FAMS” where he was warned that unless immediate action was taken more tragedies would occur. Since that warning the agency has seen 4 suicides, a murder suicide, and its first on duty death.
Specific recent examples of serious reported psychotic episodes suffered by Air Marshals:
A. February 2018 Broward County Florida, a 38-year-old Federal Air Marshal came home after work and opened fire with his issued firearm in his house, shooting four to five shots at what he thought were two home invaders. In fact, he was hallucinating he later testified. The Air Marshal went on to say “he was suffering from psychosis due to sudden withdrawal from alcohol and sleeping pills he’d been taking for years to cope with his job’s demanding schedule”. B. June 18, 2018 Newark New Jersey, Julian Turk a medically retired Air Marshal was indicted for allegedly plotting to blow up his former field office. C. October 26, 2018 New Jersey, Air Marshal Mario Vanzetta shot his wife and then shot himself in an apparent murder suicide, leaving his three kids orphaned. D. Fall of 2018 San Francisco Ca, a recently retired air marshal shot himself in the head in an apparent suicide. E. Fall of 2018 New Jersey, a recently medically retired air marshal was found dead of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. F. Summer of 2018 Boston Mass., a 20-year veteran Air Marshal Kevin Molan returned home from working a red eye flight. He said he was physically and mentally exhausted when he heard voices in his head saying he should kill himself. He then took out his issued weapon and placed the barrel of the gun to the side of his head. He began to depress the trigger, but then the thought of his young daughters stopped him. He said later that his psychologist after seeing his flight schedule said “you all are headed for a breakdown”, referring to air marshals. G. July 20, 2019, Washington D.C., Supervisory Air Marshal William Sondervan found dead of an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound.
Recent serious and fatal medical issues suffered by Air Marshals:
• Michelle (2018) a Washington based air marshal dies on duty in the bathroom of an aircraft of a suspected blood clot. • Clayton (2018) a Chicago based air marshal suffers a major cardiac event believed to be blood clot related on duty. • Joseph (2018) a Charlotte based air marshal suffers a major cardiac event believed to be blood clot related on duty. • Jackie (2018) a Baltimore based air marshal suffers a major cardiac event believed to be blood clot related on duty. • Nelson (2018) an Orlando based air marshal suffers a major cardiac event believed to be blood clot related on duty. • Barry Burch (2019) a recently retired air marshal suffers a major cardiac event. • Frank Galambos (2019) a San Francisco based air marshal suffers a fatal cardiac event believed to be blood clot related just leaving his field office.
Transportation Security Administrator David Pekoske was put on notice with evidence of the unsafe, unhealthy, and hazardous conditions of employment when he received and acknowledged an email titled “Concerned FAMS”, dated June 19, 2018. The air marshal that wrote that email gave examples of several disturbing cases of psychotic episodes and an attempted suicide, allegedly caused primarily by the air marshals flight schedule. The air marshal went on to say, “These incidents are not anomalies. They are just a glimpse into the toxic culture that exists in the agency today and we feel is only getting worse”.
The TSA Administrator in violation of Presidential order 12196 failed to conduct an audit or inspection of the Air Marshals report of an unsafe, unhealthy, and hazardous condition of employment. Several months after being notified of the dangerous conditions, the agency suffered its first in the line of duty death, an air marshal suicide and a murder suicide involving an air marshal, the incidents occurring within weeks of each other. As the air marshal predicted It indeed got worse.
We respectfully request that the Office of Special Counsel investigate the complete lack of proper independent oversight and policies governing Air Marshal scheduling and rest that has caused this substantial and specific danger to the public and its workforces health and safety. Further we respectfully request OSC investigate the management officials that are responsible for creating the gross mismanagement of the agencies resources.
The agency was put on notice by its own commissioned sleep study and the recent report from one of its own air marshals about the recognized hazard of its scheduling practices and the conditions it forces its agents to work under.
The Air Marshal National Council and it representatives fear that if immediate action is not taken then more tragedies and loss of life will occur.
Respectfully submitted,
Sonya Hightower LaBosco President Air Marshal National Council 407-733-6700 slabosco@airmarshalnc.com
David Londo Vice President Air Marshal National Council 757-784-3007 dlondo@airmarshalnc.com
Copy of email delivered to the TSA Administrator:
From: Londo, David <David.Londo@tsa.dhs.gov<mailto:David.Londo@tsa.dhs.gov>> Date: Tuesday, Jun 19, 2018, 12:17 PM To: Pekoske, David <David.Pekoske@tsa.dhs.gov<mailto:David.Pekoske@tsa.dhs.gov>> Subject: Concerned FAMS
Honorable David Pekoske
Sir, I am writing to you today knowing that I maybe violating policy by skipping several layers of command, but I feel you need to be made aware of several disturbing recent incidents in the Federal Air Marshal Service. Recently my good friend and a FAM with twenty (20) years of federal service came home from a trip. He told me he was exhausted both mentally and physically and that all of a sudden he began to hear voices inside his head. Voices that told him to put his gun to the side of his head and pull the trigger. Its important to note my friend has been a dedicated law enforcement officer for 20 years without any history of mental illness. Suddenly feeling completely overwhelmed and exhausted from flying several recent international missions where he all three shifts, a typical flight schedule for us. A schedule his psychologist later said would make anyone have a breakdown. He drew his duty weapon, pressed the barrel to the side of his head and began to depress the trigger. Right before pulling the trigger and ending his life, the thought of his two young daughters flashed through his mind. The thought of his two daughters growing up without their father was able to suppress the voices of extreme exhaustion and confusion. His career is now over but his children still have their father. If you ask most FAMs can tell you of a former colleague who has attempted or committed suicide. In Florida recently a FAM whom became addicted to sleeping pills and alcohol, a problem that is widespread in the agency from flying an unsustainable schedule, hallucinated that four people were breaking into his house. He opened fire on these imaginary people with his duty firearm, thankfully not injuring anyone. If you ask most FAMs can tell you of situations where they’ve had hallucinations from sleep depravation. The FAM in this case has recently filed a whistle blower complaint with OIG. The link below is a news article that describes the hallucinations and the firing of his weapon. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcmiami.com/news/Broward-Police-Using-New-Law- to-Seize-Guns-Like-Nowhere-Else-in-Florida-481421931.html%3famp=y Yesterday a retired Air Marshal was indicted for allegedly planning to blow up and attack his former field office EWK. https://www.google.com/amp/s/articles.nj.com/essex/index.ssf/2018/06/retired_air_marshal_ plotted_revenge_on_agency_sought_explosives_info_fed_say.amp These incidents are not anomalies. They are just a glimpse into the toxic culture that exists in the agency today and we feel is only getting worse. We know you are attempting to bring long needed reforms to the agency but we are not sure your voice is being heard within the agency. I obviously can’t get into details because that will make this SSI, but I would love a chance to speak with you about the current culture and direction of the agency. We feel the counsel you may be getting from FAMs upper management may not paint an accurate picture of where we are today and what needs to be done.