Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
PRAJAKTA PATIL
AT
A REPORT
Training And Development at TACO -IPD Page 1
ON
TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT
AT TACO-IPD
BY
PRAJAKTA PATIL
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I also take this opportunity to acknowledge and appreciate the project given to me by
TACO-IPD (Hinjewadi unit).
Working with the HR department, TACO-IPD for the summer project was definitely a lot
of value addition in terms of exposure to the complete gamut of Training and
Development activities.
I thank my project guide Mr V Suresh for his guidance throughout this project study. I
am greatly indebted to my mentor, Mrs. Sonia Rathore for all her support and
encouragement. A teacher in the truest sense, he has guided me at each step.
I would also like to express my gratitude to Mr. Sujit Jagtap (Deputy Manager-HR) who
has guided me with the Training Need Identification exercise carried out during the latter
part of this project study.
I would also like to thank Mr. Shivaji Choundkar (Assistant Manager-HR) & all HOD
for there help in getting the training needs identification forms.
I would also like to thank Sayali Khedkar and Shweta Laturkar for there splendid help in
my project work without there help my project would not have been a success.
I would also like to thank my co- summer trainees Sayali Joshi, Aishwarya
Deshmukh,Bhavya Shah and Salil Bhosale who made the journey at TACO-IPD all the
more fun.
Last but not the least my deepest gratitude to my Family, whose prayers & faith in me has
always helped perform to the best of my abilities.
ABSTRACT
Training And Development at TACO -IPD Page 3
Globalization and liberalization have made companies across the world face cutthroat
competition from one another .The customer demands and the expectations from the
companies are on a consistent rise. This compelling situation gives organizations every
reason to feel the great need for tailoring more effective ways of delivering value to the
organization by way of developing people. This demands attention to be paid to the
activity of Training and Development in the company and to treat it as an inherent part of
the organizational strategies and policies.
This project is a study on the Training & Development practices followed at TACO-IPD
(Hinjewadi unit), a wholly owned subsidiary of TATA Auto comp systems Ltd and the
largest player of interior and exterior automotive plastics business in the Indian market.
Any training process involves Training Need Identification, Training Design, Training
Delivery and finally, Training Evaluation
Based on the above training needs, both short term and long term training plans are
developed on an individual as well as departmental basis. The annual calendar is then
made which is usually available by the end of March or First week of April.
The next step would be to obtain the right training sources and deliver the training
programs. Chiefly, the types of training programs are conducted are: Technical,
Behavioral. , Organization specific and Training on Imbibing Values.
The last phase in any training process is the Training evaluation. The main thrust of the
project study was on the evaluation of the effectiveness of the program. Evaluation of a
training program is very critical to ensure that training input is effective. The amount of
time and money involved in training calls for effective evaluation of training programs.
The programs should be such that the trainer and the trainee are benefited.
Data Collection: Collection of the relevant information from the participant’s who have
attended the training program. The participants of the training program belong to the
cadre of D1 and above Grade. It also involves collection of information from the
superiors who evaluate their subordinates on the training program attended; this is usually
done 3 months from the date of the training program. This was done through feedback
forms in the form of questionnaires to evaluate the effectiveness of the training program.
Analysis & Interpretation: The collected data was analyzed and interpreted both
statistically and qualitatively in order to measure the training effectiveness
As stated earlier, one of the methods of identifying Training Needs’ at TACO-IPD was
through the Knowledge and Skill matrix. The latter part of the project study was an
understanding of how exactly training needs are identified from the Knowledge and Skill
matrix. This involved a detailed Quantitative analysis which included calculation of a
figure known as the Capability Index, Skill /Competency level and Demand. The
Capability index is basically a measure of the potential that an employee possesses
regarding a particular competency which he/she requires to perform his day to day tasks.
It examines the difference between the actual and desired competency levels of
employees and helps in identifying training needs. The Capability index was calculated
for every employee across different departments.
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Training And Development at TACO -IPD Page 5
“Companies have access to the same tools, raw materials and markets as their
competitors. One of the few remaining advantages that businesses retain is their ability to
squeeze more out of the input by applying another input-knowledge-in a more cost
effective, productive fashion.”[P,Block (1991)]
Today with almost all companies providing some or the other type of training to their
employees, employee training has become far more prevalent than it used to be earlier.
For some companies training is a very familiar process, where entire departments are
devoted to conducting both initial and ongoing employee training programs, while others
bring in outside consultants to conduct employee training sessions.
A few companies are genuinely committed to enhancing the skills and competencies of
their work force while others conduct training primarily to meet job safety regulations.
Sadly, many companies are not serious about the purpose of conducting training.
Regardless of the reasons or level of commitment to the process, the need for employee
training has increased significantly in recent years. This increase is directly related to the
rapidly expanding use of technology within society in general and business industry in
particular. Companies are beginning to recognize that learning truly is a lifelong
endeavor and developmental activities such as employee training have a profoundly
positive impact on job satisfaction, productivity, and ultimately , overall profitability. The
fact is that training, when carefully developed and appropriately implemented, can have a
desirable impact on the bottom line.
No matter where, when, why, how and for whom the training program is conducted, an
effective training exercise must be a teaching method that advocates principles and
practices of learning as its core focus. The act of training, by way of effective learning
,should always work in a macro perspective with a view to help employees acquire skills
relating to basic knowledge and expertise ,skills to handle complex problems
departmental problems and organizational problems as a whole. Every employee believes
in seeing a better tomorrow-and that is why a knowledge worker always seeks training
opportunities for career development and, thereby gain advantage in his area of
specialization.
This project study named “Training and Development at TACO-IPD” was carried out in
TATA Autocomp Systems Ltd-Interiors and plastics division. Chapter 2 gives a brief
description about the company and their business.
Chapters 3,4,5,6 and 7 deal with the concept of Training and Training evaluation where
as Chapters 8,9,10, 11 deal with Training Need Identification.
What exactly is training? What are the various steps involved in a training process?
These Questions are dealt with in Chapter 3.
Chapter 4,”Training evaluation”, discusses how to evaluate training programs and how
exactly the process of training evaluation is carried out at TACO-IPD. Chapter 5
“Quantitative Analysis”, includes a quantitative approach to monitor the training
effectiveness of the Training programs. Chapter 6 is a graphical representation of the
numbers that were crunched in chapter 5.
In order to monitor the Training effectiveness, the Data collected had to be analyzed not
only quantitatively but qualitatively as well. The Qualitative feedback that was obtained
from the participants as well as the superiors is discussed in Chapter 7.
The Second phase of the project study involved an understanding of how training needs
are identified from the Knowledge and Skill matrix.
Chapter 9 briefly discusses the concept of Capability Index and how it has been used to
Identify Training needs.
Chapter 12-“Other Assignments” briefly discusses additional exercises which were done
during the course of the project study.
1.1 OBJECTIVES
The primary objective of this project study was to get a rich understanding and get hands
on experience of the Training and Development practices of employees at TACO-IPD.
The project also aims at learning how to coordinate and facilitate the actual execution of
training programs-deciding the time, the venue, the faculty and other administrative
arrangements and preparing training calander. Another objective of this study was to
understand the concept of training evaluation and to monitor the training effectiveness of
the training programs conducted. As a coordinator of the training and development
activities at TACO-IPD it is necessary to ensure that the target of 100 man days per
month are achieved and that every employee in the organization has an opportunity to
attend the training programs.
1.2 SCOPE
For the Participants:
The participants can derive the maximum benefit from the training programs conducted.
The techniques and the concepts talked about in the training programs are of much
relevance to the participants and can be applied back on their current jobs, as well as it
leads to their overall development.
The participants belong to the cadre from the D1 and above Grade.
It was evident from the interactions with the superiors, that the training programs which
help in the overall development of the participant, also helps them in their current jobs in
line with enhancement in the divisional/departmental productivity, work efficiency,
The scope of Needs Assessment depends on various “pressure points” such as legislation,
lack of basic skills, poor performance, higher performance standards etc. If the points
seem to be local and has a potentially small impact on the business then the information
gathering part of needs assessment should consist of a few interviews with managers and
employees. If the points have a larger impact on the business, then more information
gathering should be conducted. By being attuned to business problems, technological
advancements, and other issues facing the organization, one will be able o anticipate
Training needs.
Mostly reaction-level evaluations are used to asses training effectiveness; hence when the
immediate reactions of the participants are captured right after the training program, it is
very important that they fill in the feedback forms carefully. However this rarely the case,
with participants sometimes leaving many fields entirely blank.Also, Employees
(trainees) have a tendency to underestimate their skills before training and over estimate
their skills post training to validate their participation in the training program. In this way
it is seen that it is difficult to comprehensively evaluate or capture the effectiveness of a
training program.
With Respect to the Training Need Identification, it was found that the competencies in
the Knowledge and Skill matrix for different employees within the same department and
same grade differed. This made calculations related to the Capability Index very tedious.
1. DATA COLLECTION:
The first milestone for any research is the data collection work. In order to make this
journey more effective, the course contents of the program were referred to get an idea of
the training provided. Also, some of the training programs were attended. A
questionnaire was used for the participants, in order gather information regarding the
effectiveness of the training programs, their relevance to the participant’s current job
profile, an edge to enhance their skills and ability etc, Data was also collected from the
superiors regarding the training programs attended by their subordinates- Aspects like
Learning, Behavioral Change , Impact on organizational effectiveness with respect to the
employees(who attended the training)are looked into. For Superiors a different
questionnaire was used.
The term method of data collection refers to how the researcher obtains the data to be
used for answering the research question.
At TACO-IPD, Primarily, the data for monitoring training effectiveness was collected
from the feedback forms (both for the participants as well as the superiors) which were in
the form of a questionnaire.
The immediate reactions of the trainees (participants) regarding the training program and
the trainer are collected and the training is rated on a 5 point likert rating scale. The
participants have to give feedback on areas such as -program evaluation, related to the
program content and the administrative arrangements, the faculty evaluation related to the
trainers. Feedback was also collected regarding the overall evaluation of the training
program.
The long term outcomes of the training programs are evaluated through a superior
feedback form. A superior feedback form is a method of evaluation of the training
programs where in which the superiors of various departments act as evaluators and rate
the training effectiveness of the employee on a 4 point rating scale.
This is done after a reasonable span of time (usually 3 months i.e., every quarter) .In the
superior feedback form attributes like Learning, Behavioural change, Skill enhancement,
Impact on organizational effectiveness of the employee are evaluated in order to measure
how effective the training program has been and whether it has actually benefited the
employee and whether it has a made any impact on his/her current job.
2. QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS:
By calculating the overall satisfaction, overall faculty evaluation and Overall satisfaction
index, the overall Faculty evaluation index from the Feedback forms filled by the
participants immediately after the training program.
Qualitative Analysis:
By Analyzing the Superior Feedback form where the Superior rates the employee on
attributes such as learning, skill enhancement, impact on organizational effectiveness on
a 4 point scale.
Mean X is defined as
X= f1.x1+f2.x2+f3.x3+……fn.xn..
F1+F2+……+fln
3. DATA INTERPRETATION :
Overall Satisfaction & faculty evaluation:
A score of 3.5 and above for overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation is
considered very good, that the program was successful and the participants could grasp
the concepts and techniques imparted in the training programs in their current job. It
suggests that the participants were satisfied with the content of the training program as
well the coordination and administrative arrangements for the training program. With
respect to the overall faculty evaluation, it implies that the participants felt that the
trainers had adequate knowledge on the subject and that the trainers communicated the
matter in an effective manner.
An Index of 75% for overall satisfaction index and overall faculty evaluation index is
considered very good and implies that imparted training was effective and that the
participants were satisfied with the training program as well as the faculty who conducted
the training program.
Collection of the Relevant from the knowledge and skill matrix for each employee across
the various departments in the organization. The knowledge and Skill matrix of each
employee across all departments like Paint Shop, mould shop, Tooling, Engineering and
business development etc was referred to in order to calculate the Capability Index and
identify the Training Need.
2. Quantitative Analysis:
Proficient P 3
The Capability index was calculated for each employee in a department across all the
departments in the organization
(ii)Calculation of Demand:
3. Data interpretation:
If an employee has a Capability index that is less than 60 –it shows that he is still not
sufficiently competent to handle the tasks that his job requires. Hence he should be given
Training in order to improve his skills.
While calculating Demand if a particular competency has a Demand of greater than 1.5-
it is considered to be a highly demanded competency/ skill.
While calculating the sill and competence level , if the Skill and Competency level is
greater than 75 it shows that the employees in a particular department are relatively
strong in that particular competency.
If the Skill and Competency level is less than 60 it goes to show that the employees in a
particular department are relativity weak in that particular competency.
Only if a particular skill is BOTH a weak skill AND a highly demanded skill, does it
constitute a Training Need.
COMPANY PROFILE
“What advances a nation or community is not so much to prop up its weakest and most
helpless members, as to lift up the best and most gifted, so as to make them of the
greatest service to the country.”
With a long heritage of 123 years and a constant endeavor for national progress, the Tata
Business House is one of the most widely known and trusted business houses in India. A
group compromising of 80 diversified companies and 3 million shareholders, the Tatas
generate revenue of 36000 crores. The TATA’s have been a pioneer in varied fields that
include steel, power plant, civil aviation, insurance, quartz watches, chain of luxury
hotels, passenger cars, commercial vehicles and labor welfare activities as well.
The emphasis has been on building not just assets but internal resources for the nation.
The Tata Group has succeeded in inculcating a new paradigm for growth and as a result
has infused a new business culture. A culture that is committed to giving value for money
as well as to the practice of good corporate citizenship. Social concern has been a prime
motivator, as the TATA believe that community is a stakeholder.
The Tata Group has 80 businesses in 7 core sectors. Group Turnover of USD 70.8 Bn in
2008‐09.The Tata Group of companies is India’s leading conglomerate in the private
sector with total income topping US $ 10.4 billion. It is the largest employer in private
Sector employing around 357000 employees worldwide. International Income 65% of
Group Revenue. Businessweek ranked the Group sixth amongst the ‘World’s Most
Innovative Companies’and the Reputation Institute, USA recently rated it as the ‘World’s
sixth Most Reputed Firm.’ Products and Services exported to 85 Countries.The Group’s
total income is equivalent to 2.4% of India’s GDP and is one of the largest net foreign
exchange earners in the private sector employer with over 200,000 people.
No other business group in India touches people’s lives like the Tata Group. The group’s
business covers seven diverse sectors- materials, engineering, energy, chemicals,
consumer products, services and communication and information systems.
For over 130 years, the Tata name has stood for leadership with Trust. As a business
group that has traversed three centuries, we are proud of the heritage that has enabled us
to emerge as India’s most respected corporate group, confident of a future in which India
is expected to take leadership role in the world’s knowledge economy.
TACO-IPD:
ORGANIZATIONAL DESCRIPTION:
TACO – IPD was set up in 1998, as a wholly owned subsidiary company of TATA
AutoComp Systems Limited (TACO) then called as TATA Auto Plastic Systems Limited
(TAPS). It operates in the auto component industry as an Auto Interior and Plastics
solution provider.
In the year 2004-05, TAPS merged with Tata AutoComp Systems Limited & now
operates as the Interiors & Plastics Division of TACO.TACO-IPD has recorded a
compounded annual growth rate of 35%. With sales going up from Rs.459 million in
1999-00 to over Rs.200 million in 2005-06.
Starting as supplier of plastic parts to TATA Motors (for Indica), TACO-IPD has, within
a short span, built a global customer base ranging from TATA Motors, General Motors
India, Toyota Kirloskar, Ford India, John Deere, Mahindra Renault in Domestic Market
and Ford Motor Company Europe and General Motors and Faurecia in Export Market.
TACO-IPD PRODUCTS:
Products:
The Company manufactures a variety of products at its state-of-the-art plant in technical
collaboration with Faurecia Industries, France. It can provide world-class interior and
exterior products with contemporary styling and finish.
Interiors:
Cockpit Assembly.
Exteriors:
Bumpers
Spoilers
Bumper guards
Hoods
Spare wheel covers
Body side moldings Grills
Footsteps
Tailgates
CUSTOMER BASE
Organizational Culture:
TACO-IPD derives its value system from TACO values of simplicity, Integrity, Frugality,
Respect and Harmony. TACO-IPD has adopted well defined steps for inculcation of these
values in the organization.
The Vision & Mission of TACO-IPD was revisited in 2009-10 to ensure alignment with TACO
vision and in an outcome of a systematic group exercise of employees and their ideas.
Vision:
“We shall endeavor to provide innovative solutions and benchmark operational performance in
Auto Interiors and functional plastic parts to help our customers succeed in the Global
Automotive Market, thereby achieving a profitable growth to a turnover of $ 1 Billion by 2015”.
Mission:
“We shall enhance the value to our stakeholders through Profitable Growth in Auto Interior &
Plastics Business;
In achieving the above, we shall be guided by our core values of Integrity, Frugality,
Simplicity, Respect and Harmony and our concern for environment and society”.
“We at TACO-IPD shall strive to continuously exceed the expectations of our customers. We
shall achieve this with products, and services that – in quality, cost and delivery – shall be the
best in the Indian auto component industry.
To be the best, we shall commit ourselves to excellence in technology and engineering, and we
shall inculcate in our organization and in all that we do the core values to simplicity, frugality,
integrity, respect and harmony.
We shall endeavor to motivate all our employees to uphold this quality policy and excel through
teamwork, continuous training, transparency in all activities, and with a participative style of
management that cuts across the boundaries of levels and functions.
Further, in all our efforts, our guiding principles shall be the protection of environment and
services to society”. TACO-IPD endeavors to build its culture around three key focus areas,
namely Customer focused agility, Low cost and Learning through networking. TACO-IPD
works closely with its customers on new programs that encompass all activities of Value-Chain
from Design, Development and Manufacture & Just-in-time Supply.
To support this business-model, TACO-IPD has adopted a ‘Process Approach [by complying
with Quality (TS16949) & Environment (ISO 14001) Management Systems] and achieves
‘Customer Focus through a dedicated EBD structure to support new programs & Operations
Groups to support the customers’ daily operations. These groups are supported by engineering,
finance, IT & HR functions. This ‘customer focused’ approach is further reinforced by our
Performance Management System with functional KPAs derived from strategic objectives.
WHAT IS TRAINING?
-Training Desire: Training needs identified through training effectiveness feedback forms which
gives provision to the employee to indicate training requirements.
TRAINING DESIGN:
A training design is a blueprint for a training event or experience. It is a detailed plan for what
we will do, why we will be doing it, and the best ways to reach our training objectives. Any
training design would include the following eight steps:
Identify Training
Needs.
Evaluate the
Training.
TRAINING EVALUTION
Training effectiveness refers to the benefits that the company and the trainees receive from
training. Benefits for trainees may include learning new skills or behavior. Benefits for the
company may include increased sales and more satisfied customers. A training evaluation
measures specific outcomes or criteria to determine the benefits of the program. Training
outcomes or criteria refer to the measures that the trainer and the company use to evaluate
training programs.
Training evaluation refers to the process of collecting the outcomes needed to determine whether
training is effective. The evaluation design refers to the collection of information –including
what, when, how and from whom-that will be used to determine the effectiveness of the training
program.
1. To identify the programs strengths and weaknesses. This includes determining if the program
is meeting the learning objectives, if the quality of the learning environment is satisfactory and if
transfer of training to the job is taking place.
2. To assess whether the content, organization, and administration of the program-including the
schedule, accommodation-contribute to learning and use of the training content on the job.
4. To assist in marketing programs through the collection of information from participants about
whether they would recommend the program to others, why they attended the program, and their
level of satisfaction with the program
1. At this stage the immediate reactions of the trainees regarding the training program and the
trainer are collected and the training is rated on a 5 point rating scale which includes areas such
as program evaluation, faculty evaluation and an overall evaluation of the training program.
2. In the second stage, the long term outcomes of the training programs are evaluated through a
superior feedback form. A superior feedback form is a method of evaluation of the training
programs where in which the superiors of various departments act as evaluators and rate the
training effectiveness of the employee on a 4 point rating scale. This is done after a reasonable
span of time (usually 3 months i.e., every quarter.) In the superior feedback form attributes like
Learning,Behavioural change, Skill enhancement, Impact on organizational effectiveness of the
employee are evaluated in order to measure how effective the training program has been and
whether it has actually benefited the employee and whether it has a made an impact on his/her
performance.
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS-I
This section includes the Quantitative analysis on the Data collected. The Calculated values for
overall satisfaction, overall faculty evaluation and overall satisfaction index and overall faculty
evaluation index for the different training programs conducted over the 4 quarters is shown in the
tables below. A calculation sheet is available for reference in Annexure 1.
I. The Quantitative analysis below is for overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation.
QUARTER 1
SPC
APQP
Team building
FMEA
Maintenance Hydraulics
Name of training
Program
Overall satisfaction 4.5 4.0 4.1 4.3 4.0 4.1 4.1 3.9
overall faculty evaluation 4.7 4.3 4.3 4.6 4.2 4.1 4.2 4.1
QUARTER 2
ISO / IEC 17025 : 2005
for The Competence of
General Requirements
Laboratories And
Systems
testing
APQP
MSA
Name of
G8D
G8D
Training
7 QC tools
systems
FMEA
APQP
Name of the
PDT
training
Overall
satisfaction 4.45 4.1 4.75 4.1 4.3 4.16 3.9
Overall
faculty
evaluation 4.77 4.2 4.5 4.2 4.43 4.35 4
QUARTER 4
Hydraulics advanced
PLC based control
14001:2004 (EMS)
Internal Auditors
Auditor - ISO/TS
Trouble shooting
Maintenance
FMEA
APQP
69469
Name of
G8D
Training
Overall
satisfaction 4.2 4.23 4.29 4.3 4.09 4.12 4.05
Overall
faculty
evaluation 4.125 4.52 4.7 4.25 4.5 4.5 4.5
Interpretation:
As seen from the above calculations for overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation, the
values for all the programs are well above the target of a score of 3.5. This implies that the
program was successful and the participants could grasp the concepts and techniques imparted in
the training programs in their current job. With respect to the overall faculty evaluation, it
implies that the participants felt that the trainers had adequate knowledge on the subject and that
the trainers communicated the matter in an effective manner.
QUARTER 1:
KANBAN
Program
FMEA
APQP
SPC
Name of training
overall satisfaction index 90.0 79.0 81.2 85.0 80.0 82.0 82.5 78.0
overall faculty evaluation index 94.0 85.0 85.2 92.5 84.0 82.0 84.0 82.0
.
QUARTER 2:
& Calibration Laboratories
The Competence of Testing
APQP
Name of
MSA
G8D
G8D
Training
Overall
satisfaction
index 88.0 90.0 85.0 88.0 85.0 85.0 85.0
Overall faculty
evaluation index 88.0 90.0 87.0 88.0 89.4 85.0 90.0
Team buliding
7 QC tools
FMEA
APQP
PDT
Name of the
Training program
Overall satisfaction
index 89.0 82.0 95 82.0 86 83.2 78
Overall Faculty
Evaluation index 95.4 84.0 90 84.0 88.6 87 80
QUARTER 4:
14001:2004 (EMS)
Internal Auditors
Hydraulics advanced
Training for ISO
Auditor - ISO/TS
systems & its Trouble
Internal Quality
Maintenance
PLC based control
FMEA
APQP
Name of
G8D
69469
shooting
training
Overall
satisfaction
index 84.0 84.6 85.8 86 81.8 82.4 81
Overall
faculty
evaluation
index 82.5 90.4 94 85 90 90 90
INTERPRETATION:
An Index of above 75% for overall satisfaction index and overall faculty evaluation index is
considered very good. It is seen from the above tables that both the indexes are well over 75 %
which implies that the imparted training was effective and that the participants were satisfied
with the training program as well as the faculty who conducted the training program.
GRAPHICAL REPRESENTATION-I
Note:
Graphical Representation 1: is with respect to the overall satisfaction and faculty evaluation.
Graphical Representation 2: is with respect to the overall satisfaction index and the overall
faculty evaluation index.
The Analysis has been done for the year 2009-10 and has been segregated into 4 quarters:
Graphical representation 3: shows two Trend Charts- Chart 1-Depicting the Adherence to the
Training calendar and Chart 2-Depicting the Number of Training man days.
Fig 1.1- Overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation for Quarter1.
Fig 1.2- Overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation for Quarter 2
Fig 1.3- Overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation for Quarter 3.
Fig 1.4- Overall satisfaction and overall faculty evaluation for Quarter 4.
Fig 2.1- Overall satisfaction index and overall faculty evaluation index for Quarter 1.
Fig 2.3- Overall satisfaction index and overall faculty evaluation index for Quarter 3.
Fig 2.4- Overall satisfaction index and overall faculty evaluation index for Quarter 4.
TREND CHARTS
CHAPTER 7
QUALITATIVE FEEDBACK
For the above programs, qualitative feedback was also collected from the participants as well as
the superiors in terms of:-
In case of Participants:-
Relevance of the program to their work- whether the training session would help them develop
skills that would facilitate their work. Feedback was also collected in terms of how the
participants would actually apply what they learnt and what project they would propose to take
up as a result of the training.
Whether any learning took place i.e. whether concepts, ideas explained during the training were
assimilated by the employee Feedback was taken from the superiors as to whether there was any
enhancements in the skills during the participant’s day to day execution of the work. Feedback
was also collected in terms of whether the training program helped Contribute to positive results
such as increase in Divisional/Departmental productivity, quality, work efficiency and cost
effectiveness.
Training Need can be defined as the gap between the actual performance and the desired
performance of the employee. It can also be described as the gap between current abilities and
job requirements that can be closed by training.
As the name suggests the TNA is an attempt to understand the training needs in an organization.
The analysis presents an approach to identify the gap between the existing performance level in
the employees and the desired level of performance to achieve the organizational goals. In other
words, it identifies the gaps in the knowledge, skills and attitudes of the work force and indicates
the training inputs required to improve the employee performance. It is essentially the diagnostic
tool for the trainers. Ideally, approach to training need analysis is customer oriented .A structured
TNA is an iterative process, it starts with a problem and returns to the problem at the end.
Throughout the analysis, the chief point of reference of TNA is the problem and how to solve it.
The customer approaches the trainer because he would like to solve the problem there is always a
desired outcome and the recommendations made at the end of the TNA should permit the
outcome to be materialized. Broadly speaking the TNA will be expected to address a mismatch
between the actual performance and the desired performance .Another variation is to take a long
term view- a mismatch between anticipated performance (based on current trends) and desired
future performance. The role of TNA would be to suggest strategies, tactics and techniques to
address the identified training needs.
Desired
Lev Skill level
el GAP=
Training
Need
Actual skill
level
CHAPTER 9
CAPABILITY INDEX
The performance of an organization depends largely on the capability and talent of its personnel,
and how high their motivation levels are. The Capability of a person depends on his ability to
work and the type of training he receives. Hence an organization should focus on training and
development to enhance their employees’ capabilities.
In today’s global and competitive business environment, many companies are finding that it is
difficult to determine whether the employees have the capabilities needed for success. The
necessary capabilities may vary from one business unit to another and even across roles within a
business unit. As a result many companies have started to use competency models to help the
identify knowledge, skills and personal characteristics.
One of the competency models used at TACO-IPD, is known as the Knowledge and Skill
Matrix.
The format of the knowledge and skill matrix structure used in TACO-IPD is shown in the
annexure.
This involved calculation of a figure known as the Capability index. Calculation of the
Capability index involved identifying the gaps between the actual and desired skill levels of the
employees. It includes determining which competencies are highly demanded or desired from a
particular task.
Wherever the skills /competencies were BOTH highly demanded as well as when it was
determined it was a weak skill, it constituted Training Need. This is depicted below in the table.
Apart from the Identification of Training Needs a lot of useful information can be extracted
from the Capability index calculations.
Since Capability is directly linked to potential, the Capability Index can be used to determine
whether a person possesses high or low potential. Employees having high Capability Index can
be considered for a promotion, higher responsibility etc.
When we club the Capability Index of the employees of a particular department we obtain the
departmental capability Index. Departments with Low Capability Index are areas where Training
can be administered and a Development plan can be made on a departmental basis.
Once the Capability Index is calculated for the different departments, we can determine the
Organizational Capability Index.
By Calculating the Organizational Capability Index we can determine whether the capability of
the Organization as a whole is increasing, whether it is stable or whether it is decreasing.
If the Capability Index is remaining stable it implies that the desired skill set of the Employees
should be increase. If the Capability Index is decreasing it implies that Training is essential for
all employees across different departments in the Organization.
CHAPTER 10
QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS II
The calculations for Skill and Competence level as well as Demand have been shown below.
Due to space constraint only 2 Departments - Paint shop and Mould shop & Assembly have
been shown.
Knowledge Skills
TS16949,ISO14000/Improv
Pretreatment in Plastics
Effective communication
Flow In Paint Shop
Planning&Organising
Shade Matching
Painting Systems
Co-coordinating
Interpersonal
Cost Control
Leadership
ements
Competency
Skill/Competence
Level 72.9 63.4 70.5 69.0 57.9 70.7 70.2 66.7 67.4 68.3
Demand 2.8 2.4 2.6 2.5 2.2 2.4 2.8 3.0 2.5 2.4
As seen earlier only those competencies which are both highly demanded and weak, constitute
Training Needs. For the Paint Shop Department it is seen that only one competency i.e,
Plastic injection&Moulding
TS16949,ISO14000&TAE
Assembly Techniques
Computer Operation
Lean Manufacturing
Interpersonal Skills
Presentation Skills
Managerial Skills
Trouble Shooting
Six sigma
Process
M
Competencies
Skills/ Competence level 72.5 55.6 56.1 50.9 28.3 100.0 62.3 81.7 83.6 64.3
Demand 1.9 1.5 1.6 1.5 1.3 0.1 1.9 2.0 1.5 1.9
From the above calculated values for Skills /competence level and Demand we can see that3
competencies, namely,Assembly Techniques, Lean Manufacturing and TS16949,
ISO14000&TAEM are areas which are both highly demanded and weak competencies. Hence
Training programs should be conducted in those areas.
The above Calculations were done for all the departments in the organization.
CHAPTER 11
GRAPHICAL REPRESENTATION II
The Graphical depiction of the Individual Capability index calculation for 2 Departments namely Paint shop and
Mould shop & Assembly are shown below.
Interpretation:
Since Capability is directly linked to potential, the calculation of the individual capability index
can be used to determine whether a person possesses high potential or low potential. Employees
having high capability index can be-considered for a promotion, higher responsibility etc.
A Capability index which is greater than 75 is considered to be high, whereas a Capability index
less than 60 is considered to be low. When the Capability Index of an employee is low it implies
that Training can be imparted in order to achieve the desired skills so that the employee can
perform his task better and in turn improve his Capability Index. Also the overall Departmental
Capability index for the above 4 departments were calculated as:
Paint Shop=70.9
EBD=74.1
Tooling=65.6
One of the employee motivational Tools used at TACO-IPD is an event known as Ayushman
Bhava which is the birthday celebration of the employees at TACO-IPD.Ayushman Bhava is
celebrated at the end of each month where the Birthdays of employees which fall in a particular
month are celebrated. The project involved organizing the event in the months of June and July.
It involved making arrangements regarding venue, refreshments, organizing games, Gift
distribution etc.
A coded identity for the participant in order to facilitate a more open feedback.
Training implementation by participants to be displayed in a motivational manner in
order to motivate the future participants.
A training brochure covering the details of all the programs in brief.
Customized programs for different divisions.
Customized questionnaire for different programs.
Contents of the training program should also be communicated to the superiors
Apart from the feedback forms, an informal feedback session should be conducted
immediately after the program with the trainer, the HR coordinator and the participants so
that their suggestions can be considered for improving the course.
While preparing the Knowledge and Skill matrix, Employees within the same department
under the same grade should have the same competencies. This makes any analysis based
on the knowledge and skill matrix simpler.
This project study titled-“Training and development at TACO-IPD” has been an excellent
learning venture all the way, with respect to understanding Training and Development practices
followed in Manufacturing set ups.
Training and Development activities are designed, considerable cost withstanding, to impart
specific skills, abilities and knowledge to employees. After a training program has been
implemented, the organization should evaluate the program. This evaluation helps the
organization identify the areas for improvement, which can help in designing future training
programs. The basic yardstick to measure the success of a training program is the learning
benefits that have accrued to the trainees.
The data obtained from the participants and the superiors for the program they attended could
provide a platform as to how effective the programs were. As per the scores obtained, the
programs were quite effective. The participants could put into implementation the techniques and
concepts on their current jobs. The attitude of the participants changed after attending the
training program. Both the participants and their superiors made certain suggestions regarding
the training program they attended, which were very useful and more stress could be put forth to
work on them and make the program more effective.
Organizations must conduct a Training Need Analysis (TNA) to understand the training needs
of the organization. Once a TNA is done in a structured way, it will facilitate cost effective
working with no time wasted in asking irrelevant questions. Precise questions will be in line with
the organizations needs. This, in turn, leads to a clear, understandable analysis of data and
specific action plans can be designed so as to help an organization achieve its mission.
www.google.com
www.hrfolks.com
www.tacogroup.com
www.hrvillage.com
www.info@ftindia.com
www.scribe.com
http://www.scribd.com
www.wikipedia.com/ers
www.khoj.com
CALCULATIONS:
Overall Satisfaction and Overall Satisfaction Index:
Overall satisfaction:
In a particular training program, Average of the points rated by the employees (who attended that
training program) in the ‘program & faculty evaluation’ feedback form, pertaining to the
attribute “overall satisfaction” is calculated.
Or
In a particular training program, Average of the points rated by the employees (who attended
that training program) in the program & faculty evaluation feedback form, pertaining to the
attribute “Faculty evaluation” is calculated.
Or
Please take time to complete this training form, it provides valuable information which will help
us improve the effectiveness of our programs & give you a way of letting us know how we are
doing.
Program Dates
Name
Faculty names Venue
Duration of
the program
Emp No Name
Department
PROGRAM EAVALUATION
Please rate according to the 5- point scale
5- Strongly agree 4- Agree 3- No opinion 2-Disagree 1- Strongly
disagree
PROGRAM CONTENT
Was relevant to my work
Will help me to develop skills that will facilitate my work
CO-ORDINATION & FACILITIES
The coordination / communication before & during the training was well
managed.
Administrative arrangements were well managed.
Training aids provided were adequate
Course Material / handouts were adequate and relevant
Overall satisfaction of the program (5=very high)
FACULTY EVALUATION
Please rate according to the 5- point scale
5- Strongly agree 4- Agree 3- No opinion 2-Disagree 1- Strongly
disagree
OVERALL EVALUATION
The duration of the program
Too short Just Too Long
Right
The pace of the program
Too short Just Too Long
Right
Program objectives were met
Totally Partially Not at all
Would you recommend this course to your
colleagues? Yes Not sure No
Which Project do you propose to undertake to implement the learning of this training? What will
be the duration of the project?
_____________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________
OTHER
Yes No
_______________________________________________________________
• How do you think this new program will help you in the work?
___________________________________________________________
ANNEXURE 3
4
Evaluation5rating : The evaluator should rate the training effectiveness of the employee in following manner:
2 = To little4extent.
5
3 = To a significant extent.
4 = To a great extent.
For scale
F–
E-Excellent
VG-Very
Good
G-Good
NI-Needs
Improvemen
List training needs of the employee to be addressed in the year 2007
ANNEXURE 4
Knowledge
Training And Development and Skill
at TACO -IPDMatrix Page 62
Method to fulfill this
Type of need training need
Name of the Training requirement/ (Technical/ (classroom, external,
Sr No need Behavioural) reading books, etc)
Scale of rating
Under Training UT
Aware A
User U
Proficient P