Você está na página 1de 13

REPLY TO THE FALSE CLAIM OF

SIMILARITIES BETWEEN HINDU AND MUSLIM.

Once a Hindu visited the dargah of Ajmer Sharif & found some similarities in
his religion.

Instead of explaining him, a Muslim brother due to lack of his knowledge,


created a mail comparing some pictures & giving some unrelated references
& proved his jahalat.
The innocent net users forwarded it without verifying & were trapped in
major sin of accusing others with shirk.

We shall now share his email highlighted in YELLOW & also provide
answers to the false claims.
CLAIM 1- Hindus worship idols/ Muslims worship graves.

ANS- This is a false claim, if the above claim is true then they should also
apply fatwa of shirk on

King Abdullah-the current king of Saudi (see the image below).


But for sure the claim is false, even a lunatic of Muslim doesn’t worship
anyone other than Allah because Muhammad s.a.w has clearly said that he
is not afraid of us worshipping other than Allah.
Reference-

Narrated 'Uqba bin 'Amir:


The Prophet went out and offered the funeral prayer for the martyrs of the (battle of) Uhud and then
ascended the pulpit and said, "I am your predecessor and I am a witness against you. By Allah, I am now
looking at my Tank-lake (Al-Kauthar) and I have been given the keys of the treasures of the earth (or the keys
of the earth). By Allah! I am not afraid that after me you will worship others besides
Allah, but I am afraid that you will start competing for (the pleasures of) this world."
(Bukhari, volume 8, book 76, Number 434)

Note: This reference itself should be enough to prove that the claims are
false, but just to make it crystal clear we shall answer it further.
CLAIM 2- Hindus & Muslims use incense sticks/ laban & also put flowers on graves.

ANS A- Incense sticks/loban is used as scent & has nothing to do with


shirk or even with any particular religion. Arabs also use OUD a lot.
ANS B- if the person knew who has prescribed plants/flowers & the amount
of benefits of keeping it on the graves, he would never have compared it.

As indicated by Saudi Arabian Sunni Islamic Scholar Shaykh As-Sayyid


Muhammad ibn `Alawi al-Maliki of Mecca al-Mukarramah
Reference-
Narrated Ibn Abbas:

The Prophet once passed by two graves, and those two persons (in the graves) were being tortured. He said,
"They are being tortured not for a great thing (to avoid). One of them never saved himself from being soiled
with his urine, while the other was going about with calumnies (to make enmity between friends). He
then
took a green leaf of a date-palm tree split it into two pieces and fixed one on
each grave. The people said, "O Allah's Apostle! Why have you done so?" He replied, "I hope that their
punishment may be lessened till they (the leaf) become dry."
(Bukhari, Volume2, Book 23, Number 443)
NOTE: PLEASE BE CAREFULL BEFORE ACCUSING ANY SUNNAT.
CLAIM 3- pundit sit in mandir/ khadim sit at dargah.

ANS - We also have sheikhs, imams, and maulanas in masjids

But he forgets all of them in his comparison.


CLAIM 4- Hindus have yatras/Muslims have urs every year.

ANS – but then he forgets the HAJJ, the largest gathering of Muslims
in his comparison.

May be he is not aware of it.


Note: if we use this standard of comparing religion then we will have

thousands of examples like it. Few are mentioned below.

1. Hindus circumbate around tree. 1. Muslims circumbate around Kaaba.


2. Hindus do Bali (sacrifice animal). 2. Muslims do Qurbaani.
3. Hindus think going to tirupati cleans 3. Muslims know going to hajj cleans
their sins. sins.
& so on……

This is not the way Muhammad s.a.w showed us to do DAWAH, Muslim

speaks with proof. Shame on such a Muslim who uses the Hindus way to

prove his point. May Allah protect us from such satanic thoughts.

That’s not all, he gets more


crazier….
Further with his evil ideas he tries to imply the verses of Quran and

hadis on Muslims, which were actually revealed for mushriks &

disbelievers(Astagfirullah). Let’s see some of the false quotes & their

answers.
QUOTE 1- Muslims worship awliya to get closer to allah.

ANS A- it is proved earlier that no Muslim worships other than Allah. The above
verse is for mushriks of Kaaba who had taken idol(boots/statues) as their
protectors & would lie that they believe in Allah, on which Allah says in same verse
‘Allah guides not him who is a liar’.

Verily Allah has forbidden us from taking idols & disbelievers as our
protectors (wali).
REF. 1 - O you who believe! Take not for 'Auliya' (protectors or helpers or friends) disbelievers instead of
believers. Do you wish to offer Allah a manifest proof against yourselves? (QURAN 4:144)

REF. 2 – QURAN 4:119, 4:139, 5:51, 60:1, 9:23 etc


ANS B- And it is Allah who tells/commands us to take the believers as our
protectors/wali.
REF. 1 - Verily, your Walî (Protector or Helper) is Allah, His Messenger, and the believers, - those who
perform As-Salât (Iqâmat-as-Salât), and give Zakât, and they bow down (submit themselves with obedience to
Allah in prayer). (QURAN 5:55)

REF. 2 - QURAN 9:71, 4:144, 8:73 etc.

Note: the above references proves that Allah commands us to take believers as
protectors & an example of how this misguided people apply wrong verses on
the believers.

QUOTE 2- These verses are regarding prophets & saints.

ANS – The famous Quran translator ABDULLAH YUSUF ALI clears it


very well in his translation.

QURAN 16:20- Those whom they invoke besides Allah create nothing and are themselves created.

QURAN 16:21- (They are things) dead, lifeless: nor do they know when they will be raised up.

Note: the above translation requires no further explanation that this verse is

for THINGS & not for PROPHETS & SAINTS. Verily Quran confirms “and

say not of those who are slain in the way of Allah: "They are dead." Nay,

they are living, though ye perceive (it) not. Quran 2:154)”.


QUOTE 3- Muslims take graves of prophets/saints as place of worship.

ANS A – This verse was clearly revealed for non-Muslims who worship their
prophets as god, like Christians worship Jesus as god.

THIS IS THE VERY BEST EXAMPLE OF HOW THIS MISGUIDED PEOPLE


APPLY THE VERSES OF NON- MUSLIMS ONTO THE INNOCENT
MUSLIMS(MAZALLAH).
Verily there passed a group called KHWARJITES.
"Ibn Umar R.A considered the Khawarij and the heretics as the worst beings in creation, and he said:
They went to verses which were revealed about the disbelievers and applied them to the
Believers.
Bukhari Chapter Khawarjites
Ibn Hajr al Asqalani (rah) said in Fath ul Bari: That its sanad is sahih
ANS B – verily Muhammad s.a.w warned us of such people accusing

other momins with shirk.


REF. 1 - Hudhaifa i.e. Ibn al Yaman (ra) said that the Prophet (saw) said: Verily, I fear about a man from you
who will read the Qur'an so much that his face will become enlightened and he will come to personify Islam.
This will continue until Allah desires. Then these things will be taken away from him when he will disregard
them by putting them all behind his back and will attack his neighbor with the sword accusing him
of Shirk. The Prophet was asked - which of the two will be deserving of such an accusation? - The attacker
or the attacked? The Prophet replied - the attacker (the one accusing the other of Shirk)

[Narrated by Ibn Hibban in his Sahih, Tahqiq Nasir Albani, Volume 001, Page No. 200, Hadith Number 81]
Wahabi scholar Nasir Albani said: 'this hadith is hasan' also see [Silsilat al-ahadith al-sahihah - Albani Volume
007-A, Page No. 605, Hadith Number 3201].

ANS C – verily if you study about khwarjites, you will find all their qualities
in this misguided people. The khwarjites believed that they are the only

followers of Tawheed, & accused ALI R.A with SHIRK(mazallah). When

the matter was explained to khwarjites, only few who repent were forgiven

& all the others were expelled out of Islam.

Hence all those who have been in link with the original
mail either in composing or in forwarding shall seek
forgiveness at the earliest possible & also send this
REPLY to whomsoever you might have sent the original
mail.
AS ACCUSING EVEN A SINGLE RIGHTEOS MUSLIM WITH SHIRK
MIGHT TAKE YOU OUT OF ISLAM.

May Allah keep us on right path & protect us from any disrespect of
his prophets & his righteous servants.

LAILAHA ILLALAH MUHAMMADUR RASULULLAH