Você está na página 1de 48

Breaking Boundaries /

The Empowerment of Women


Through Architecture

A thesis submitted to the Graduate School of the University


of Cincinnati in partial fulfillment of the requirements for
the degree of

Master of Architecture

in the Department of Architecture of the College of


Design, Architecture, Art, and Planning

2015

by

Lauren Petrakis
B.S. University of Cincinnati, June 2011

Committee Chair: Michael McInturf, M.Arch.


Committee Member: Aarati Kanekar, Ph.D.
My thesis demonstrates the opportunity for archi-
tecture to empower the social progress of women. This
theory is defined by identifying those spatial constructs
which foster sexism through social inhibitions, and using
this knowledge to create a new type of space that is whol-
ly different. There are three subcategories I have identi-
fied as contributing to my research; they are: boundaries,
space and violence, and domesticity.

My research is primarily composed of the experi-


ences of participants and administrators involved in do-
mestic violence intervention programs, designers who
have created women’s centers throughout the world, and
resources documenting the causes and treatment for those
affected by domestic abuse. This information has been
gathered through meetings and interviews with women’s
crisis organizations, finding successful precedents in simi-
lar typologies, and assimilating seemingly disparate sourc-
es to provide innovative approaches to this topic.

A new approach to designing rehabilitative spaces


for victims of domestic violence will focus on research in
boundaries (physical, emotional, societal); struggles with
identity; components of crisis housing and flexibility in
resident needs; maintaining security and safety of clients
and administrators; gendered spaces; and perhaps most
challenging, providing outreach and a sense of commu-
nity while simultaneously providing privacy during a very
intimate experience. An understanding of gendered spac-
es shapes our perception of gender, power, and identity
through control of our spaces.

Within the field of architecture, it may not be dis-


puted that women interact with space in a manner different
than men. I would like to further this concept by provid-
ing an example where this consideration is the means by
which the building is designed. Perhaps, instead of men
designing spaces for men; through this thesis I may pro-
pose an opportunity for men and women to design spaces
for men and women.

ABSTRACT

ii
iii
If we are a product of our spatial experiences, then from these cultural expectations. The school I attended as-
it is not surprising that I have chosen to focus my thesis signed me to classes that taught cooking, sewing, art, and
research on the empowerment of women through archi- floral arranging. The students in these courses were most-
tecture. Long before my academic pursuit of architecture, ly female, but there were also a few male homosexual and
though perhaps not preceding my fascination in construct- transgender students. Perhaps the most impactful experi-
ing with Lego building blocks, my life experiences were ence of Thai culture from my trip was that despite a strict,
shaping my future interests in the relationship of gender militaristic educational environment - it was very open and
and space. Unbeknownst to me at the time, every signif- accepting in terms of sexuality. In this way the culture was
icant catalytic event in my life has provided me with the much more progressive than the high school culture of the
opportunity to critically examine the role of gender, and Midwestern United States.
specifically the role of women, in our spatial interactions.
When I returned from Thailand, I used my experi-
Few experiences have influenced my life as much ences as inspiration for the artwork included in my senior
as the separation of my parents when I was four. As the portfolio. Initially, I began my art by replicating the detail
eldest child, I was suddenly propelled into the role of care- of the ancient wats (Buddhist temples) I had visited during
taker for my younger sister and I; not that my parents were my study abroad. While reviewing the hundreds of photos
absent, but rather both were consumed by the require- I had taken during my trip, it became increasingly apparent
ments of occupation and the responsibilities of being a sin- that there was a distinct difference in the gender of spac-
gle head-of-household for a family. Growing up, I was able es within Thailand. The many images of wats showed only
to observe my parents each functioning independently male monks, which as a female visitor I was forbidden to
within their own spaces and assuming the roles typical as- have contact with. The images of the school I attended
signed to both genders in a nuclear family. As time passed, showed stark classrooms where the boys attended military
they both remarried and again, their roles within the home training and colorful classrooms where girls were taught
transitioned. This comparison was reinforced by my tran- how to arrange flowers. My portfolio work transitioned
sient sense of “home” which I never really defined as an from a collection of architectural details into a body of fem-
address, or specific house, but rather as a sense of place. inist work comprising of paintings exploring maternity and
Home was defined differently at my father’s house rather printmaking demonstrating the role of women within the
than at my mother’s house. workplace.

With a childhood that encouraged me to be in- Whether at home, school, work, or in public spac-
dependent, I applied for a scholarship to study abroad in es, each of these spaces affects our perception of the
Thailand during high school. While living there, I enrolled empowerment or hindrance of gender. If we understand
in classes at a local school and lived with a host family. To these connections, then as architects, we are enabled to
my surprise, the classes at the school were often divided create spaces that empower each gender. My intent is to
by gender, which was not something common in public design a space that empowers the most victimized group
schools within the United States. Upon graduation, all of women - a domestic violence shelter, in an effort to un-
men were expected to serve in the military while women derstand the capabilities of the empowerment of women
would assume post-secondary education or work in their through architectural design and also to demonstrate the
family’s business. There was little toleration for deviatio distinct spatial needs of each gender group.

PREFACE

iv
Abstract .................................................................................. ii

Preface .................................................................................... iv

Table of Contents ................................................................... v

List of Figures ........................................................................ vii

Lines of Control ................................................................ 8 - 9

Architecture That Empowers ...................................... 10 - 19

Project Introduction ........................................................... 21

Client / Culture ............................................................ 22 - 25

Site / Context ............................................................... 26 - 31

Precedents / Types ..................................................... 32 - 37

Spaces / Experiences ................................................. 39 - 43

Conclusion ........................................................................... 45

Bibliography ................................................................. 46 - 47

TABLE OF CONTENTS

v
Figure 1.1 (Left) - Digital Collage of historic Covington Figure 3.4 - Image of Mount Athos monastary. Accessed
photographs showing domesticity, by author. January 21, 2015. Nicolas Economou Photography. http://
whc.unesco.org/pg.cfm?cid=31&l=en&id_site=454&gal-
Figure 1.2 - Dadi, Iftikhar. Lines of Control: Partition as a lery=1&&maxrows=30
Productive Space. London: Green Cardamom; 2012.
Figure 4.1 - Rendered site plan and diagram by author.
Figure 2.1 - Photographer Unknown. October 2013. Equal
Rights Amendment. http://nomoremisandry.blogspot. Figure 4.2 - Historic Image of Covington. Accessed Online
com/2013/10/the-feminist-movement-changes-name-of. from Kenton County Library.
html
Figure 4.3 - Development Opportunity Map. Accessed
Figure 2.2 - Author Unknown. Photoshopped image of April 3, 2014. http://www.gateway.kctcs.edu/About_Us/
Covergirl advertisement. Accessed September 2014. Our_Campuses/Urban_Center.aspx.
http://www.latimes.com/fashion/alltherage/la-ar-cover-
girl-nfl-ads-protest-the-league-20140915-htmlstory.html Figure 4.4 - Rendered site plan diagram by author.

Figure 2.3 - Digital Collage showing the role of women Figure 4.5 - Photograph collage by author.
within public/private space, by author.
Figure 4.6 - Photograph collage by author.
Figure 2.4 - CBF Women’s Health Centre. Photography by
FAREstudio. http://www.farestudio.it/cbf/ Figure 4.7 - Photograph collage by author.

Figure 2.5 - CBF Women’s Health Centre. Photography by Figure 5.1 - Image by Neri and Hu Design.
FAREstudio. http://www.farestudio.it/cbf/
Figures 5.2 to 5.4 - Images by Pwferretto.
Figure 2.6 - CBF Women’s Health Centre. Photography by
FAREstudio. http://www.farestudio.it/cbf/ Figures 5.5 to 5.7 - Images by Robert Maschke Architects.

Figure 2.7 - Photography by Neri and Hu Design. http:// Figure 6.1 - Program diagram by author.
enthepractice.neriandhu.com
Figure 6.2 - Spatial diagrams by author. Images (Left to
Figure 3.1 - Photographer unknown. “Domestic Violence right): Author Unknown, PWFERRETTO, Neri and Hu, Neri
Victim”. Accessed November 1, 2014. http://imgkid.com/ and Hu, PWFERRETTO.
domestic-violence-victims-women.shtml.

Figure 3.2 - Photograph by author.

Figure 3.3 - Image of Mount Athos monastary. Accessed


January 21, 2015. http://www.ouranoupoli.com/athos/

LIST OF FIGURES

vii
Figure 1.2 This image shows a still from
Surekah’s video of an ant trapped within
a pen drawn boundary.

8
“A mere marker pen traces a random boundary. An ant is
caught within this drawn frame, unable to get out, because
it imagines the drawn line is a boundary. It hesitates to cross
the line, but never stops walking towards it and away, in an-
ticipation of the unpredictable. Finally, at the end of the
video – by choice or chance – it [the ant] comes out or cross-
es the boundary. In this spontaneous one shot work, the
artist contemplates the being’s behavior when confronted
with boundaries: real, imagined, and metaphoric. Bound-
aries are made by human conditions. They are often im-
posed, assumed, accepted, and acknowledged. Surekah’s
video addresses several implications of a boundary, which
acts as an agency of power, control, and bifurcation be it of
geography, color, gender, religion, or otherwise. This par-
ticular work discusses the ambiguity of our choice to be in
or out, our indecisiveness, and out euphoric awareness of
and against something which we have been deeply condi-
tioned into. Through the discourse and practice of art, one
becomes aware that the boundary is a construct – like the
pen line to the ant.”

LINES OF CONTROL
EXCERPT FROM SUREKAH, FOR EXHIBIT

9
We often neglect the others’ perspective until it af-
fects us personally. That’s the harsh reality, and my interest
in this topic is similarly entrenched in a deeply personal
experience. My parents divorced when I was four, and I
was catapulted into a role of caregiver for my younger sis-
ter and myself while my mother took on additional hours
working for financial support, and my father tried to figure
out how to deal with two young girls. At times, my child-
hood memories are those of a broken, but functioning
family. At other times I can’t help but remember our strug-
gle to co-exist, and the eruption of emotional and physical
fighting between my parents, my sister, and myself.

Despite the obvious challenges of growing up


in a family structure that was not even remotely nuclear,
formally; this experience has more deeply affected my un-
derstanding of the relationship between gender and place
than would be possible in a traditional instructional envi-
ronment. From a young age, I became accustomed to the
transient experience of shifting from place to place, void
of a sense of “home,” as I traveled between each of my
parent’s houses. Growing up, I was aware of the changes
between the way my parents functioned together inside
of a house, together in a public space, individually in each
of their houses, and still different in their houses once they
remarried. At times, they were each required to assume
the role of both traditional parents when each were single.
I also learned from an early age that these roles (and thus
the violence that followed) were conditional based upon
the setting of exterior versus interior or public versus pri-
vate.

Though I may not have been able to articulate it at


the time, these childhood experience developed an under-
standing that the relationship between gender and space
is an important one. I will further discuss this relationship

ARCHITECTURE THAT EMPOWERS

Figure 2.1 Women protestors supporting the


Equal Rights Ammendment, first introduced to
Congress in 1923, failed to receive necessary
support for ratification in the 1970s. The
ERA still has not been passed, almost a cen-
tury after it was first introduced.

11
between the experience of architecture and gender. search, numerous stories have surfaced about violence
against women in public spaces, the most popular by far
For as long as people have co-existed in civiliza- being the case of Ray Rice. Rice, a now-former NFL payer
tions, a social hierarchy has been maintained within these for the Baltimore Ravens was suspended after a video-tape
places. From the design of the suburban home; to the surfaced of him punching his then-fiancée in a hotel ele-
modern office building as portrayed in the popular TV se- vator (Wilson, 2015). The severity of this case was not in
ries, Mad Men (AMC, 2007); and even the occupation by the occurrence of domestic violence, which is almost ex-
women activists of public spaces, such as streets; we are cusable for the deity-like status of professional athletes in
constantly aware of a social hierarchy as it exists between our culture (after all Rice was only temporarily suspended);
genders and space. This social stratification emphasizes instead, the real significance of this case was the fact that
the disjointed relationship between gender interactions in this took place in an elevator where it was publicly doc-
private and public environments. Unfortunately, this dis- umented. What cues do we, as a collective society, take
tinction between public and private has allowed a differing from our built environment that allows something like this
treatment of women to occur in each environment. In the to happen in a semi-private elevator in a pubic hotel? If we
most extreme cases, resulting in domestic violence. The can compare this to other common locations of violence,
issue is that these actions originate in a private space but such as a bedroom, parking garage, or alley; we may con-
are permeated in our public spaces, though rarely publicly clude that these are all spaces that feel private, but can be-
discussed or acknowledged. come unsafe.

It is challenging to credit architecture solely, as A comparison of these types of spaces can begin
being responsible for the advantage or disadvantage of to form a description of places where violence against or
a particular social group. However, architecture provides infringement upon the rights of women occurs. The fol-
the framework within which all social interactions occur, lowing texts aim to uncover these specific spatial qualities,
and thus, it is not solely influenced by society, but to some in hopes that if we gain a better understanding of what
extent we may assume it also influences our interactions. elements from the built environment exist where the op-
In this paradoxical relationship, it is imperative that we crit- pression of women occurs, we may inversely conclude the
ically explore the social framework that we are providing types of spaces where women may be empowered. In my
through architecture. What message are we, as designers, research thus far, I have uncovered a variety of texts, vid-
sending when we design a space and who are we design- eos, articles, policies, and websites dedicated to gender
ing for? If all of our societal cues imply that gender in- in architectural design. Specifically, I have selected works
equalities exist in our surrounding environment, then is it which focus on the relationship of gender and space, do-
really possible to design one space that serves each gen- mesticity, and feminism in architecture. The works select-
der equally? Unfortunately, the majority of architectural ed for review below come from disparate insights and of-
compositions give little consideration to the way each sex fering varying points of view on the subject of women and
inhabits a space differently from the other. architecture.

Historically, research and interest in the role of The book, Space, Place, and Violence: Geogra-
architecture in sexism has varied along with changes in phies of Embodied Race, Sex, and Gender, by James A.
policies and the popular culture. Since beginning my re- Tyner explores issues of violence through the contexts of

Figure 2.2 (Left) This photoshopped image


surfaced online during a CoverGirl NFL cam-
paign, and in response to the Ray Rice case.

Figure 2.3 (Right) This collage was created


to represent the public / private relation-
ship of gender and space.

12

Gender is an identity
tenuously constituted in
time, instituted in an exterior
space through a
stylized repetition
of acts. “

Quote by Judith Butler


home, school, streets, and the community. Tyner explores the street as a woman in anything other than a trench coat
our obsession with violence as both part of our ordinary and sweat pants you have likely at some point encountered
lives and extraordinary fantasy, such as the fascination with cat-calling (if you haven’t been so lucky, there are plenty
serial killers. The normalizing of violence is what allows in- of videos that have recently surfaced Online documenting
cidents to occur everyday on the street, in the office, or at the experience first hand). This is an example of control
school without notice. We are inundated with information over public space, and the struggle for women’s rights to
from the news, crime shows, even fictional plots of movies public spaces to be infringed upon (Tyner, pg. 135). Tyner
and books that communicate the normalization of violence states:
(Tyner, pg. 5).
“Places, in other words, come into being through
Given the discourse of my thesis, I was most inter- social relations and social interactions. However,
ested in learning about Tyner’s interpretation of violence in these relations and interactions are morally informed.
the home. Tyner quotes Lynda McDowell and comments: Who, or which group, for example, is granted or de-
nied access to a particular place? What activities are
“‘Home must be one of the most loaded words deemed appropriate or not?
in the English language.’ What does she mean by this
statement?...Or are we missing something when we The book, Gender Studies in Architecture: Space,
focus too much on the physical structure that we call Power, and Difference, by Dørte Kuhlmann, discusses the
home?...We often think of home as a place of shelter, historic architectural, fashion, and cultural influences on
of security.” gender in architecture today. Kuhlmann references sever-
al historic examples, such as churches, homes, and public
Tyner discuss the both ironic and tragic reality that baths that featured separate, inferior areas dedicated sole-
for many women and children, the notion of ‘home’ which ly to women. Two strategies for expressing sexual hierar-
so many people recall fondly, becomes a dangerous place. chy in architecture are by using women’s bodies as alluring
This relationship between space and violence demon- embellishments (in advertisements, renderings, ornamen-
strates the ability of an otherwise ‘refuge’ to become a tation) or excluding them entirely from specific areas (Kuhl-
nightmare. Tyner highlights the relationship between vio- mann, pg. 4). Kuhlmann also discusses the importance of
lence at ‘home” and domesticity (Tyner, pg. 33) stating: spatial arrangement in the control of women:

“...Women have throughout history been over- “Space, the fundamental aspect of material cul-
whelmingly consigned to child-rearing, household ture, is... of central importance in constituting gender.
upkeep, and family nurturance; however, under cap- It determines how men and women are brought to-
italism the cultural artifact of home and work, the pri- gether or kept apart; it participates in defining a sex-
vate and public, became particularly acute.” ual division of labour; its organization produces, re-
produces, and represents notion about sexuality and
This cultural confinement of women to and in the the body. Space determines and affects behaviour,
home has reinforced a fear of violence in more public spac- just as the organization of space is produced by and
es, particularly streets. Fundamentally this becomes an is- in relation to behaviour.”
sue of control. If you’ve had the please of walking down

15
While the previous texts discuss the possible so- Health Survey, 2010). This resource center provides med-
cietal and psychological cues in the relationship between ical, legal, psychological, and awareness services to the
gender and space, Richard Williams’ Sex and Buildings, affected women and their families within the surrounding
instead looks at particular architectural indicators. I men- community.
tioned previously that the set of Mad Men demonstrates
a social hierarchy within an office space. Williams further The site is enclosed by a low wall, which creates
explores this concept through pages 99-106 where he dis- a sense of safety for the center’s patrons, and also pro-
cusses the setting for the fictional advertising agency of vides a threshold into a very different environment from
New York City, set in the 1960s. Williams offers a critique the surrounding community. Within the perimeter are
of the spatial experience of the office depicted and the two primary structures. One structure contains the public
layout of the office, which is an accurate representation of programmatic elements: a Training Center, dedicated to
many workplaces, still today. In Mad Men, The main pub- management and awareness-rising activities, and a Con-
lic space is inhabited by female workers, primarily recep- sultancy Centre, where medical visits, legal assistance and
tionists, and the private offices with views out and over the psychological counseling are provided to the community
city are reserved for their male counterparts, and a female almost free of charge. According to FARE Studio’s web-
switchboard room. Every detail of the set, down to the fur- site:
niture, reinforces the ideas of gender and who occupies “The volumes that contain the different rooms
each space. Williams states: are independent from the umbrella roof structure,
placed atop the platform and freely articulated
“But it is the interior that stays in the memory, around a series of shaded and ventilated patios that
describing with marvelous clarity the complexities, ensure privacy from the exterior.
subtleties, and sexual politics of the modern open-
plan office....It is a spectacle of sexual domination in The modular configuration of the structure al-
which the architecture is complicit.” lows future expansion while preserving the general
framework of the building.”
Williams stresses to readers that the architectural
significance of Mad Men and the International Style is to The success of this project can be attributed to the
convey explicitly what it means to work and live in a mod- thoughtful design, which uses several strategies to create
ern office building (Williams, pg. 104). This idea is not lim- an environment that feels “safe” and a successful partner-
ited to television, as in recent years the architects design- ship with a local organization, AIDOS (Associazione Itali-
ing towers have become arguably more phallic, such as ana Donne per lo Sviluppo). While a thoughtful program
Fosters and Partners in London. should not be underestimated, the reality is that the archi-
tectural manifestation of a well-developed program deter-
In my research, I have found a few examples of mines whether or not it is successful, as demonstrated by
spaces that empower women. One example, which is also this project.
programmatically similar to the project that I will discuss in
later sections, is the CBF Women’s Health Centre by FARE The preceding literature reviews and architectur-
Studio. This project is a located in Burkina Faso, where al works demonstrate the capability for improvement of
the female genital mutilation rate is 76.6% (Demographic architecture designed specifically for women. From the

Figure 2.4 (Left) This photogrpah shows an


exterior view of the CBF Women’s Health Cen-
tre, surrounded by a low wall.

Figure 2.5 (Right Upper) This floor plan


shows the division of the programmatic ele-
ments into public and private.

Figure 2.6 (Right Lower) The elevated roof


on the center allows for ventilation and pas-
sive cooling in the rural, African site.

16
17
texts, we can see the examples of sexual hierarchy in archi- fluctuate between the number of tenants per unit, client
tecture is present in the home, streets or community, and needs, and the demand for emergency housing.
workplace. The selected architectural work of FARE Stu- The project description is continued in further de-
dio exemplifies the application of these principles through tail in the following sections. While it may seem disheart-
simple, affordable design adjustments to achieve a more ening to account for all of the instances in which gender
successful project. All of these works provide a compre- is apparent in architecture (home, office, community, etc.),
hensive frame within which I may situate my thesis. it is also encouraging to see all of the opportunities to im-
prove the current architectural standards.
As the incidence of violence against women gains
publicity and awareness, it is increasingly important to
address the causes and provide meaningful design solu-
tions. The current standard of professional architecture
ignores these concerns, and reinforces societal standards
rather than challenging them. If we continue to produce
the same type of architecture and reject any opportunity
for progress, architecture will only permeate the problem
rather than provide opportunities for improvement. I can’t
image a culture that wouldn’t benefit from safer environ-
ments that empower women.

To accompany my thesis, I have completed a de-
sign for a domestic violence shelter that utilizes the good
design principles obtained through my research. The
design solution respectfully contributes to the surround-
ing urban context, provides a co-habitable environment
for visitors and residents, integrates into the surround-
ing community seamlessly, and provides the opportunity
for resident control over personal space. This building
type will be composed of a series of public and private
spaces arranged in varying degrees of privacy through
an integrated spacial sequence, delineated by thoughtful
thresholds. The site of the building is considered the most
public space (given the urban context), with programmed
elements that address the needs of the building residents.
The relationship of the building to the surrounding context
is also considered in the design proposal. The majority of
the building will be composed of housing units of two or
three bedrooms. The units will be designed to be flexible,
and adapt to the changing needs of the tenants as they

Figure 2.7 A monumental threshold example,


with thoughtful detail to scale, materiality,
and personal experience.

18

She could just pack up and
leave, but
she does not
visualize what’s
beyond ahead.

Quote by Núria Añó


The following is a collection of parameters for the
project to accompany my thesis document. The project
will be presented as a design iteration demonstrating the
application of the principles discussed in previous sections
of this document. The principles explored in this project
with regard to gender in architecture include, but are not
limited to:

- Boundaries
- Space and Violence
- Domesticity

To fully implement my research for the empower-


ment of women through architecture, I found it necessary
to develop a project that is focused on the empowerment
of the most disadvantaged group of (mostly) women - do-
mestic violence victims. The proposed design component
of my thesis research will be a new, expanded facility for the
Women’s Crisis Center of Northern Kentucky. This mixed-
use facility, containing both private and public functions,
will be located at 601 Scott Street in Covington, Kentucky.

Due to limited funding and awareness, minimal


effort has been dedicated to the design of domestic vio-
lence shelters. These facilities are often run by well-intend-
ed organizations in inadequate or out-dated facilities that
lack the proper measures for accessibility, safety, security,
temporary housing, and resources needed to encourage
successful rehabilitation. The key strategies implemented
in my design, which will be highlighted in the following
sections are:

- Integration with the surrounding neighborhood


- Public versus private control of space
- Camouflage, or hidden in plain sight

PROJECT INTRODUCTION

21
For my thesis, I am proposing a domestic violence
shelter in Covington, Kentucky. This type of project will
align with the mission of several types of interests groups.
This project would be located at a key intersection within
Covington, which is currently undergoing an urban trans-
formation along with many other northern Kentucky com-
munities, which provides economic incentives for local and
regional planning entities. This project will also provide
a social service, and therefore, is aligned within the goals
for the targeted non-profit organization and their clients
served. For these reasons, there are both regional and lo-
cal stakeholders for this project.

Regionally, the Northern Kentucky Area Planning
Commission (NKAPC) is an organization that combines the
planning departments for the Northern Kentucky munici-
palities and provides a cohesive master plan. The intent
behind the formation of this commission, was to create
larger projects that span the Northern Kentucky area, and
are not confined within the smaller cities. My proposed
site at the intersection of 6th and Scott streets and the pro-
gram of my project align with the goals of this organiza-
tion and are fully integrated into the regional master plan,
which supports the redevelopment of the urban cities lo-
cated along the Ohio River’s edge..

Another regional stakeholder for my project is


Gateway Community and Technical College. This institu-
tion offers associate degrees and technical certifications
at multiple campuses throughout the northern Kentucky
area. As part of the institution’s goal to reach more stu-
dents, they have implemented a master plan to redevelop
a scattered-site campus throughout downtown Covington.
The masterplan calls for new infill structures as well as ren-
ovated existing structures, as precedented by other urban
campuses throughout Louisville, Savannah, and Charles-
ton. After years of research and planning, they have pro-
posed a series of developments within downtown Cov-
ington that will support a campus life - such as pedestrian

CLIENT / CULTURE

Figure 3.1 Image from domestic violence


awareness campaign, released in response to
allegations of NFL players’ domestic abuse
towards family members.

23
ways, renovated storefronts in the neighborhood business tive director of The Women’s Crisis Center, Marsha Crox-
district, two-way streets, and bicycle lanes. My project site ton. She was incredibly polite, and seemed interested to
is located within the Gateway Urban Campus which implies learn more about my project and research, because this is
an opportunity for programmatic connections between my a topic that despite its prevalence, is not often publicly dis-
project and the surrounding campus; however, the signif- cussed. Marsha offered to meet me at the organization’s
icance of this location and connection will be further ex- administrative offices in Hebron, Kentucky. When I arrived
plored in the site analysis portion of this document. at her office, I was a little surprised to find the facility in the
center of an office park. The building appeared to be new-
One local interest group is the Covington Depart- er, and an appropriate design for an office building, less
ment of Economic Development. This group may provide specifically an office for a battered women’s organization.
incentives for housing projects to be developed in Coving- Aside from the friendly demeanor of the building’s occu-
ton because it is serving a population need. Additionally, pants, there was little other indication that the facility also
my project will include a public programmatic component served as an outreach center.
of Gateway College classrooms that will provide economic
incentives for the Covington community, creating a more While meeting with Marsha, we discussed the or-
financially sustainable project. While it is important that ganizational structure of The Women’s Crisis Center, the
my project meets the needs of the public interest groups spatial and programmatic requirements (discussed later in
listed above, the project would likely be commissioned by Spaces / Experiences), and the specific design consider-
a local non-profit group that is currently serving the needs ations for a domestic violence shelter. While discussing
of domestic violence victims - The Women’s Crisis Center the planning and long-term goals for the organization,
of Northern Kentucky. Marsha mentioned that the administrative office, where we
were meeting, while a nice design is somewhat removed
The Women’s Crisis Center is 501(c)(3) social ser- from the majority of the population they serve. The offices
vice agency that was founded in 1979 as the Rape Crisis are only accessible by car, and for this reason the outreach
Center of Northern Kentucky. The organization was found- center doesn’t provide as many services as other locations
ed to provide the following services to women in north- which are accessible by walking and public transit. Also,
ern Kentucky: a 24-hour crisis hotline, crisis intervention, Marsha expressed a desire to offer emergency and tran-
counseling, community education, advocacy, and support sitional housing in all of their facilities, because “we never
for rape victims. The organization originally provided shel- have enough housing.” This is a concern that is echoed
ter to victims be placing them in private homes within the throughout other sources I’ve researched on this topic,
community. Today, their only emergency housing is of- which have lead me to the decision to incorporate both
fered in a shelter located in Maysville, Kentucky (approx- forms of housing into my project. According to one nation
imately 90 minutes south of Covington). They also have survey of domestic violence shelters and services, there
outreach centers (without housing) located in Covington are 9,641 unmet requests for services every day, of which
(Figure 3.1), Carrollton, Vanceburg, Williamstown and He- 60% (5,778) are for housing (Domestic Violence Counts,
bron. Although their primary clients are battered women, 2013); and another states that 12.7 million people experi-
the center also helps males and children, along with vic- ence domestic violence every year (NoMore.org).
tims in homosexual relationships.
During my initial research, I contacted the execu- After my interview with Marsha, she arranged for

Figure 3.2 (left) The Women’s Crisis Center existing


facility located at 835 Madison Avenue in Covington,
Kentucky.

Figure 3.3 (center) One example of monastic archi-


tecture is The Holy Great Monastery of Megesti Lavra
located on the island of Mount Athos, Greece.

Figure 3.4 (right) A monastery located on Mount


Athos, Greece.

24
me to tour the Covington facility and provide an assess- non-residential services such as legal services, counseling,
ment of the opportunities for renovation or new construc- and children’s support groups. These statistics demon-
tion within the existing structure. The current site for the strate not only the prevalence of domestic violence, but
Covington Outreach Center is a typical mixed-use, neigh- also the importance of designing a facility to specifically
borhood business district building from the 19th century address the unmet needs: the social services and housing
with a first floor commercial spaces, and formerly residen- required to successfully rehabilitate domestic violence vic-
tial units above. To maximize their outreach opportuni- tims back into their surrounding communities.
ty within the Covington area, the Women’s Crisis Center
would need to upgrade the existing facility to meet ac- Designing (and for that matter, researching) a do-
cessibility, security, privacy, and parking needs. With these mestic violence shelter provides very few precedents, and
considerations, I have chosen to recommend a relocation even fewer well-designed examples. For this reason, I have
to a nearby Covington site for a new facility, because I be- had to look at other building typologies that have similar
lieve that the required modifications would be inefficient spatial requirements based upon differing, but similar pro-
and compromise the integrity of the historic structure on grammatic elements. One similar typology is monastic
the current, smaller site. Ultimately, I need to demonstrate architecture. In this example, the formal arrangement of
the ability to provide housing and outreach facilities that spaces is pushed to the perimeter of the site, which creates
are specific to the requirements of a domestic violence a fortress, a barrier, a boundary. This perimeter is charac-
shelter. terized by a thickened wall of inhabitable space. In gener-
al this typology has a few key points of controlled entry, but
Arguably the most important stakeholder for this public access is not continuous around the site. Addition-
project, and the one with the greatest potential gain / loss ally, this typology is characterized by simplicity where by
are the victims of domestic abuse. The residents within the ornamentation is limited to enhancement of the building’s
community of Covington, Kentucky who would utilize the construction.
Women’s Crisis Center, would do so in response to vio-
lence they’ve experienced from someone they know. They While the clients of a domestic violence shelter
would potentially call the center to gather information may not be seeking religious isolation, they do require a
about resources as they are preparing to flee a domestic similar environment for introspective reflection, personal
abuser, which can be the most frightening experience as a growth, security, and to free themselves from the restric-
woman is 70 times more likely is to be murdered in the few tions of the surrounding environment or their past. Some
weeks after leaving her abusive partner than at any other aspects of monastic architecture, such as Mount Athos that
time in the relationship (National Sexual Violence Resource could influence my design of a domestic violence shelter
Center, 2014). Despite the fact that 1 in 3 women or 1 in include: the idea of a formal barrier or separation from the
4 men will experience violence from their partner at some surrounding area, controlling the access of portions of my
point in their life, very few will be able to find the services site for public patrons and residents, creating a layout with
they need available in their community (NoMore.org). In the most private and personal program elements internal-
Kentucky alone, 1,097 victims are served every day, and ized for security and experience, and a simplistic form that
of those seeking emergency housing to escape a danger- is expressive of function without ornamentation.
ous living situation, only 40% of needs are met (Domestic
Violence Counts, 2013). 503 of those served were seeking

25
Figure 4.1 Site Plan of project, located in
Covington, Kentucky.

26
For my thesis, I am proposing a new and expanded
facility for the Women’s Crisis Center’s outreach center in
Covington, Kentucky. The new facility, located at 601 Scott
Street will replace the current branch of Women’s Crisis
Center located at 825 Madison Avenue in Covington. The
current site is small, is located within the business district,
doesn’t offer the appropriate privacy for patrons (there are
full-length curtains covering the storefront entry), and has
no room for expansion. The new site could offer the ability
to house and help more victims of abuse, better adjacen-
cy to resources for education / employment, and enough
space to offer community resources that may be an outlet
for helping additional victims – a women’s medical clinic,
and a daycare. Both of these new services could serve the
public, as well as the victims at the Women’s Crisis Center.

The new site selection was based upon research


on the masterplan for the City of Covington; the recent
housing development and new college campus locations;
adjacency to neighborhood resources; public transpor-
tation, vehicular, pedestrian access; and site zoning. 601
Scott Street is bounded by three streets – Scott, East Pike,
and East 6th. The west boundary of the site is adjoining
another property. This site is currently underutilized as a
surface parking lot with a small shed. This site is located
within a pedestrian shed of the Kenton County Library, the
new Gateway College Urban Campus (a local college asso-
ciated with Northern Kentucky University), across the street
from the Kenton County Adult Education Center, only one
block from the Madison commercial district, and nearby
numerous employers.

The area surrounding the site is currently a com-


mercial district adjoining the residential neighborhood
of Eastside and supporting the Madison Business District.
This area of Scott Street has been newly developed in re-
cent years and will likely see even more development in
the near future. The site will be part of the targeted de-
velopment zone for the Gateway Urban Campus. This

SITE / CONTEXT

27
will be a scattered site college campus, similar in concept creating a domestic violence shelter that is hidden in plain
to SCAD in Savannah, Georgia. The new campus will in- sight. This type of design may be formally manifested as a
clude the renovation of several existing buildings and the shell, perimeter, or barrier that blends into the surrounding
addition of one new building. As the campus becomes context (see Figure 4.4-4.8) from the exterior. By creating
more developed, it would be likely that the few remain- an inventory of the facades surrounding my site, I am able
ing underdeveloped sites in this are would become either to use these as inspiration for similar strategies within the
expansions for the campus or supporting facilities for the exterior elevations of my building. This allows the interior
campus, such as student housing, cafes, or shops. of the building/site to take on an entirely different charac-
ter. Combined, this strategy allows for the accessibility of
The site at 601 Scott Street is currently zoned “CG- an urban site with the privacy of a secluded, agrarian site.
3P” which according to the Northern Kentucky Area Plan-
ning Commission, is a mixed-use land use zone intended
to be first floor commercial space with residential units
above. This zone also requires the structure be built up
to the street front and the only vehicular access must be
from an adjoining secondary street or alley. Parking must
be located behind the building on the lot. Scott Street
would be considered the primary access for this site, while
East 6th Street and East Pike Street would be considered
the secondary access. These secondary streets would be
best suited for the vehicular access to the site. This zone
also requires a minimum of 700 square feet per dwelling
unit, with a maximum building height of 5 stories and no
setbacks required on any side (because the site is not ad-
joining an R Zone). This zone also dictates that the street
frontage of my building should have approximately 65%
transparency, which is appropriate for a mixed-use build-
ing, but will need to be taken into design consideration
and placement of the structure on the site.

Due to the public nature of a site located within an
urban core, great consideration must be given to imploring
strategies that successfully integrate the public program-
matic elements into the surrounding neighborhood; while
simultaneously providing the necessary means for privacy
for the residents, as required for their safety. At a mini-
mum, this strategy requires separate entries and designat-
ed areas for each. In a more sophisticated strategy, this
could be demonstrated through the use of camouflage, or

Figure 4.2 (Left) Historic Image of Cov-


ington advertisement, highlighting both the
prevalence and longevity of sexism within
this region.

Figure 4.3 (Right) Development Opportunities


Map showing the new location for the Gateway
Urban Campus

Figure 4.4 (Next Page) Site Plan Analysis


showing adjacencies to surrounding areas of
development within the Gateway Development
Opportunities Map.

28
SITE PLAN DIAGRAM
INTEGRATION WITH GATEWAY URBAN CAMPUS

30
Images
Figure
From
4.5
Top to Bottom:
Pike Street South Elevation
SITE CONTEXT ELEVATIONS
Figure 4.6 Sixth Street North Elevation COVINGTON, KENTUCKY
Figure 4.7 Madison Road West Elevation

31
POLLEN STREET SOCIAL
NERI + HU DESIGN

32
While researching precedents for my accompany-
ing project, it was challenging to find well-designed exam-
ples of domestic violence shelters. For this reason, I have
included precedents from a variety of program types but
with elements that could also be implemented in a domes-
tic violence shelter.

The style precedent I have selected is Neri and Hu


architects from Shanghai, China. As a design firm, their
collection of projects are characterized by simple finishes
and forms that define spatial transitions. The transitions are
created by transparency, change in material, and changes
in spatial heights. Their style may be characterized as min-
imalist, industrial, and wabi-sabi (the principle of materials
naturally decaying).

PRECEDENTS / TYPES

33
Figure 5.2 (Above) Rendering of the ex-
terior of the Women’s Recovery Center.

Figure 5.3 (Left) Photograph of center


before and elevation drawing showing the
integration of the new facade onto the
existing structure.

Figure 5.4 (Right) Diagrams showing the


relationship of the facade to interi-
or spaces to create privacy, variety of
spaces, and daylight shading.

34
The precedent I have selected to illustrate building type is the Women’s Recovery Center designed by Robert Maschke
Architects. This facility is located in a low-income urban neighborhood of Cleveland, Ohio. The facility houses resources
supporting women that are victims of domestic violence. The otherwise uninteresting single-story commercial building
has been transformed by an ivy clad mesh facade that provides privacy while still allowing daylighting into the interior
spaces.

WOMEN’S RECOVERY CENTER


ROBERT MASCHKE ARCHITECTS

35
The site precedent I have selected is the Active Monument by Pwferretto. This project is a monument in Seoul, South
Korea for the Catholic martyrs. The project is characterized by the treatment of the site’s boundary as an active space
that is both inclusive and exclusive. The site is exposed on all sides in an urban location, and programmatically becomes
increasingly private and reflective toward the center of the site.

Figure 5.5 (Above) Rendering showing ae-


rial view of monument.

Figure 5.6 (Left) Rendering of exterior


space within monument.

Figure 5.7 (Right) Site plan for mon-


ument showing thickened perimeter wall
within dense urban context.

36
ACTIVE MONUMENT
PWFERRETTO

37

Loft living is the
antithesis of suburban
domesticity,
if only because the
open spaces don’t easily
accommodate family life.
Lofts also offer residents
the opportunity (and
responsibility) to structure
their own space to reflect
what’s important to them. “
Quote by Virginia Postrel
In general, the programmed elements of my thesis
project include: a daycare facility utilized by residents and
also available to community members, a women’s medical
clinic open to the public, and a new facility for the Wom-
en’s Crisis Center. The Women’s Crisis Center will consist
of new administrative offices for the center; 12 individu-
al units for residents; and communal resident facilities for
cooking, dining, and meeting. The Women’s Crisis Center
will also operate the daycare facility as a potential source
of revenue to support the facility, an outreach opportunity,
and a service for residents.
I have compiled the following as a list of experi-
ences for my facility:
Daycare; outreach; discreet.
Covington families; Gateway students; resident’s children;
daycare; income.
Children; playing; laughing; exploring; safe.

SPACES / EXPERIENCES

39
Public spaces: public view; Private spaces: controlled vis-
ibility. The arrangement of these spatial experiences is
Daycare; playground; outdoor. determined by both the relationships between experienc-
Daycare; play area; kitchen; restrooms; sleeping area. es and the varying degrees of privacy for each activity, as
Nap time; quiet, dark; undisturbed; employee break-time. is necessary for a client such as the Women’s Crisis Cen-
Children; grow; learn; explore; investigate. ter. The attached sheets provide potential spatial arrange-
Vehicular access; daycare drop-off; women’s center resi- ments for the program. In general the more public facil-
dents; medical clinic; side street. ities, such as the daycare and medical clinic are located
Pedestrian access; primary street front. along the more public access (Scott Street) and the more
Public transportation; bus-stop; movement private function, the Women’s Crisis Center is accessed via
Pause; integration; safety; privacy; access. a secondary street to protect the identity of patrons.
Bus-stop; well-lit; sheltered; transparent; eyes on street;
safe. The daycare component of the project must be
Women’s Medical Clinic; serves community; outreach. designed to achieve the following qualitative properties:
Medicine; private; healing; internal. it should address the needs of children of varying ages;
Clinic; current; technology; evolving. provide a safe environment for exploration and instruction,
Clinic; reception; waiting room; exam rooms. and provide the necessary spaces for the staff to complete
Exam Rooms; sterile; clean; private. required tasks. The daycare should meet the needs of
Housing; privacy; flexibility; adaptability. different age / ability children by providing adaptability
Organization offices; ease of access; private. in access to different components of the space. The re-
Staff kitchen; restrooms; storage; convenient. strooms should be designed for access and ease of use by
Staff available all day; every day; space for sleeping; wait- a child by having sinks and toilets located at the appropri-
ing; working. ate height or providing a step stool to access the sink. The
Storage; residents; staff; short-term; long-term. bookshelves, storage components, and resources target-
Resident access should be private; discreet; side street; ed toward the client, should all be located so that they are
alley. easily accessible.
Victims arriving 24 hours / day; visitability; safety; well-lit.
Resident units; safe; welcoming; accommodating. With respect to the specialized needs of domes-
Pet-friendly facilities; residents; safe. tic violence victims, providing specific spaces and pro-
Daylighting; views out; restricted / screened views in. grammatic relationships that allow individualized control
Private outdoor space; balconies; recessed; operable win- of space is imperative. Similarly, it is important that these
dows; fresh air. spaces are clearly distinguished and the progression of
Courtyard; sheltered; safe; free. private to public is both apparent and discouraging of un-
Shared cooking / dining space; indoor; community. welcomed visitors in the private spaces, such as bedrooms.
Resident units configured for support; stability; safety.
Connected; shared; supporting.
Outdoor courtyard; freedom; fresh air; healing.
Gathering space; multi-function; instructional space; tech-
nology; flexible seating.

Figure 6.1 (Above) Program diagram showing


the relationships between public / private
spaces.

Figure 6.2 (Next Page) Images and diagrams


showing range of public to private spaces.

40
BED + BATH PUBLIC MTG BED + BATH

KITCHEN / PRIVATE MTG / KITCHEN /


BED + BATH BED + BATH DAYCARE BED + BATH BED + BATH
DINING DINING

LIVING ROOM / PLAYGROUND / LIVING ROOM /


MEETING SPACE GARDEN / DOG MEETING SPACE
BOARDING

KITCHEN / KITCHEN / BED + BATH


BED + BATH BED + BATH BED + BATH
DINING DINING
CLINIC / ADMIN.
OFFICES

BED + BATH INTAKE BED + BATH

PROGRAM DIAGRAM

41
1 2 3

BATHROOM THERAPY AREAS BEDROOM


INTAKE AREA ROOF GARDEN SECURE ENTRY
MECHANICAL SPACE LIVING AREA
STORAGE PRIVATE MEETING
OFFICES

PRIVATE SPACES

42
4 5 6

BALCONY CIRCULATION EXTERIOR SPACES


DINING AREA KID’S PLAY AREA PUBLIC ACCESS
MEETING ROOMS PUBLIC CLASSROOMS PET BOARDING
EMERGENCY SHELTER COMMUNITY SERVICES PARKING
WORKSPACES

PUBLIC SPACES

43

Progress or lack of it, can only
be judged by a measuring
rod, and if the rod is
placed low enough the
standard will never
threaten you. “

Quote by Sara Niles, From “Torn From the Inside Out”


As domestic violence shelters continually see
an acceleration in request for services every year, it has
become increasingly important to provide spaces that
demonstrate good design principles and meet the needs
of domestic violence victims. This may be accomplished
through a more thorough understanding of boundaries,
the relationship of space and violence, and domesticity.

Designing a space for domestic violence victims


provides the opportunity to empower a group of women
accustomed to constraint. This thesis provides the oppor-
tunity for a challenging design dealing with issues of safe-
ty, trust, rehabilitation, independence, and integration with
the community. A balanced solution is required.

The same principles implored here could also be


utilized in the design of homes for all family structures,
workplaces that demonstrate equity, and safe public spac-
es. If these considerations can be made for all architecture,
perhaps a new type of architecture can emerge, where all
genders are considered equally. Every time.

CONCLUSION

45
Adamopoulos, J. “Mount Athos”. 2010. http://www.oura- Heynen, Hilde. Negotiating Domesticity: Spatial Produc-
noupoli.com/athos/athos.html tions of Gender in Modern Architecture. London: Rout-
ledge, 2005.
Agrest, Diana. The Sex of Architecture. New York: Harry N.
Abrams, 1996. Irvine, Robert. The Architecture of Stability: Monastaries
and The Importance of Place in a World of Non-Places. Uni-
Coleman, Debra. Architecture and Feminism. New York: versity of Cambridge. Etnofoor, Architecture, volume 23,
Princeton Architectural Press, 1996. issue 1, 2011, pp. 29-49.

Danzie, Elizabeth and Debra Coleman. Architecture and Israel, Toby. Some Place like Home: Using Design Psychol-
Feminism. 1997. Yale Publications on Architecture. ogy to Create Ideal Places. Chichester, West Sussex, En-
gland: Wiley-Academy, 2003.
Department of Economic Development, “City of Coving-
ton.” Accessed February 4, 2014. http://www.covingtonky. Johnston, Lynda, and Robyn Longhurst. Space, Place, and
gov/government/departments/department-of-develop- Sex: Geographies of Sexualities. Lanham: Rowman & Lit-
ment. tlefield, 2010.

Dimen, Muriel. Gender in Psychoanalytic Space: Between Kuhlmann, Do. Gender Studies in Architecture: Space, Pow-
Clinic and Culture. New York: Other Press, 2002. er and Difference. New York: Routledge, 2013.

Edi, Katerina. Desiring Practices: Architecture, Gender, and Levitt, David. The Housing Design Handbook: A Guide to
the Interdisciplinary. London: Black Dog Pub., 1996. Good Practice. New York: Routledge, 2010.

Ellin, Nan. Architecture of Fear. New York: Princeton Archi- Mezei, Kathy. The Domestic Space Reader. Toronto: Univer-
tectural Press, 1997. sity of Toronto Press, 2012.

FAREstudio. CBF Women’s Health Centre. Accessed Sep- National Network to End Domestic Violence, Inc. Domestic
tember 2014. http://www.farestudio.it/cbf/ Violence Counts 2013 National Survey. Published in 2014.
www.nnedv.org/census
Faust and Colquhoun. Housing Design: An International
Perspective. London: B. T. Batsford Ltd., 1991. Northern Kentucky Area Planning Commission, “Planning
and Zoning Administration.” Accessed February 4, 2014.
Gateway Community and Technical College. “Urban/Met- http://www.nkapc.org/.
ro Campus Project”. Accessed 12 January 2015. http://
gateway.kctcs.edu/en/Visitors_and_Community/Urban_ The No More Project. “Resources”. Accessed February 10,
Metro_Campus_Project.aspx 2015. http://nomore.org/resources/

46
Oberhauser, Ann M., and Ibipo Anumonwo. Global Per- Towers, Graham. An Introduction to Urban Housing De-
spectives on Gender and Space: Engaging Feminism and sign: At Home In The City. Oxford: Architectural Press,
Development. New York, New York: Routledge, 2014. 2005.

Rivedal, Karen. “Building a Better Domestic Violence Tyner, James A. Space, Place, and Violence: Violence and
Shelter”. Wisonsin State Journal. 11 August 2013. http:// the Embodied Geographies of Race, Sex and Gender. New
host.madison.com/business/building-a-better-domes- York: Routledge, 2012.
tic-violence-shelter/article_e1e91373-5f81-55c1-b823-
810aef5bf524.html Williams, Richard J. Sex and Buildings: Modern Architec-
ture and the Sexual Revolution. London: Reaktion Books,
Roberts, Marion. Living in a Man-made World: Gender As- 2013.
sumptions in Modern Housing Design. London: Routledge,
1991. Women’s Crisis Center, “About Us.” Accessed April 2,
2014. http://www.wccky.org/about_us/about_us.php
Rothschild, Joan. Design and Feminism: Re-visioning Spac-
es, Places, and Everyday Things. New Brunswick, N.J.: Rut-
gers University Press, 1999.

Stratigakos, Despina. “Why Architects Need Feminism.


The Design Observer”. September 12, 2012. http://plac-
es.designobserver.com/feature/why-architects-need-fem-
inism/35448/

Stratigakos, Despina. A Women’s Berlin: Building the Mod-


ern City. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 2008.

Sulek, Julia. “#WhyIStayed Twitter hashtag goes viral after


Ray Rice domestic violence episode”. Contra Costa Times.
11 September 2014. http://www.contracostatimes.com/
breaking-news/ci_26508935/whyistayed-twitter-hashtag-
goes-viral-after-ray-rice

Summers, Randal W. Domestic Violence a Global View.


Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 2002.

The Housing Authority of Covington, “Community Re-


source Housing Group.” Accessed March 31, 2014. http://
www.hacov.org/.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

47

Você também pode gostar