3 Heirs vs CA, 371 SCRA 587 4 Acebedo vs CA, 329 SCRA 315 5 International vs CA, 343 SCRA 674 6 Home vs Commission, 432 SCRA 126 7 Polytechnic vs CA, 368 SCRA 691 8 Cuenca vs Atas, 535 SCRA 49 9 Tayag vs Benguet, 26 SCRA 242 10 Delima vs Gois, 554 SCRA 731 11 Edsa vs BF, 556 SCRA 25 12 Sarona vs NLRC, 663 SCRA 394 13 Prudential vs Alviar, 464 SCRA 353 14 Tupaz vs CA, 475 SCRA 398 15 Petron vs NLRC, 505 SCRA 596 16 Elcee vs NLRC, 512 SCRA 602 17 Phil. American vs Gramaje, 442 SCRA 274 18 Alba vs Yupangco, 622 SCRA 503 19 Yasuma vs Heirs, 499 SCRA 466 20 Heirs vs CA, 537 SCRA 96 21 San Juan vs CA, 296 SCRA 631 22 People vs Fernandez, 452 SCRA 736 23 PCGG vs Sandiganbayan, 290 SCRA 639 24 Traders vs CA, 177 SCRA 788 25 Saw vs CA, 195 SCRA 740 26 Pantranco vs NLRC, 581 SCRA 598 27 Borromeo vs CA, 550 SCRA 269 28 Crystal vs BPI, 572 SCRA 697 29 Filipinas vs Ago, 448 SCRA 413 30 ABS-CBN vs CA, 301 SCRA 572 31 MERALCO vs T.E.A.M, 540 SCRA 62 32 Lascano vs Universal, 431 SCRA 248 33 APT vs CA, 300 SCRA 579 34 NYK vs NLRC, 397 SCRA 607 35 Rabecca vs CA, 211 SCRA 470 36 ARB vs CA, 332 SCRA 427 37 Robledo vs NLRC, 238 SCRA 52 38 Kukan vs Reyes, 631 SCRA 596 39 Prisma vs Menchavez, 614 SCRA 590 40 PNB vs Andrada, 381 SCRA 244 41 Bautista vs Auto, 561 SCRA 223 42 Velarde vs Lopez, 419 SCRA 422 43 Martinez vs CA, 438 SCRA 130 44 Concept vs NLRC, 257 SCRA 149 45 NASECO vs National, 629 SCRA 90 46 Republic vs Estate, 476 SCRA 20 47 Heirs vs Uy, 344 SCRA 238 48 Mariano vs Petron, 610 SCRA 487 49 D.R vs Ramos, 477 SCRA 18 50 Sicam vs Jorge, 529 SCRA 443 51 PCIB vs Custodio, 545 SCRA 367 52 Reahs vs NLRC, 271 SCRA 247 53 Pamplona vs Tinghil, 450 SCRA 421 54 Secosa vs Heirs, 433 SCRA 273 55 Guatson vs NLRC, 230 SCRA 815 56 Reynolds vs CA, 169 SCRA 220 57 Phil. Veterans vs CA, 181 SCRA 669 58 CKH vs CA, 272 SCRA 333 59 Lafarge vs Continental, 443 SCRA 522 60 De Leon vs NLRC, 358 SCRA 274 61 Reynoso vs CA, 345 SCRA 335 62 First vs CA, 252 SCRA 259 63 Apex vs Southeast , 492 SCRA 355 64 Enriquez vs Cabotaje, 496 SCRA 169 65 Sta. Monica vs DAR, 555 SCRA 97 66 R&E vs Latag, 422 SCRA 698 67 Rovels vs Ocampo, 391 SCRA 176 68 Francisco vs Mejia, 362 SCRA 738 69 Development vs CA, 363 SCRA 307 70 Remo vs IAC, 172 SCRA 405 71 Umali vs CA, 189 SCRA 529 72 Padilla vs CA, 370 SCRA 208 73 Laguio vs NLRC, 262 SCRA 715 74 Yu vs NLRC, 245 SCRA 1340 75 Francisco vs CA, 309 SCRA 72 76 Vlason vs CA, 310 SCRA 26 77 Filmerco vs IAC, 149 SCRA 193 78 Compania vs CA, 318 SCRA 169 79 Marubeni vs Lirag, 362 SCRA 620 80 Tan vs CA, 408 SCRA 470 81 NAPOCOR vs Alonzo-Legasto, 443 SCRA 342 82 NAFLU vs Ople, 143 SCRA 124 83 Azcor vs NLRC, 303 SCRA 26 84 Alhambra vs SEC, 24 SCRA 269 85 PBCom vs CA, 279 SCRA 364 86 Industrial vs CA, 390 SCRA 252 87 Ang mga Kaanib vs Iglesia, 372 SCRA 171 88 Bulos vs Yasuma, 527 SCRA 727 89 Nunga vs Nunga, 574 SCRA 760 90 National vs PVB, 192 SCRA 257 91 Feliciano vs COA, 419 SCRA 363 92 Camporedondo vs NLRC, 312 SCRA 47 93 PNB vs Pabalan, 83 SCRA 595 94 Malong vs PNRR, 138 SCRA 63 95 Bliss vs Calleja, 237 SCRA 273 96 Bagatsing vs Committee, 246 SCRA 335 97 NAPOCOR vs City, 401 SCRA 259 98 Sawadjaan vs CA, 459 SCRA 516 99 Pioneer vs CA, 175 SCRA 668 100 Albert vs University, 13 SCRA 84 101 Lim vs Philippine, 317 SCRA 728 102 Christian vs NLRC, 174 SCRA 681 103 Hydro vs National, 441 SCRA 614 104 Westmont Bank vs Inland Construction, 582 SCRA 230 105 DBP vs Ong, 460 SCRA 170 106 Yamane vs BA Lepanto, 474 SCRA 258 107 Republic vs Sandiganbayan, 199 SCRA 39 108 Caram vs CA, 151 SCRA 372 109 Strategic vs Radstock, 607 SCRA 413 110 Tolentino vs Shenton, 590 SCRA 24 111 Mediserv vs CA, 617 SCRA 284 112 Gokongwei vs SEC, 89 SCRA 336 113 Valle Verde vs Africa, 598 SCRA 202 114 Magaling vs Ong, 562 SCRA 152 115 National vs CA, 378 SCRA 194 116 Urban vs Pena, 659 SCRA 418 117 Lowe vs CA, 596 SCRA 140 118 Espiritu vs Petron, 605 SCRA 245 119 Francisco vs Mallem, 631 SCRA 118 120 Penaflor vs Outdoor, 618 SCRA 708 121 Cebu vs Elizagaque, 542 SCRA 65 122 Seaoil vs Autocorp, 569 SCRA 387 123 D.M vs Readycon, 433 SCRA 251 124 Price vs Innodata, 567 SCRA 269 125 AMA vs Ignacio, 590 SCRA 633 126 Traders vs CA, 269 SCRA 15 127 Naguiat vs NLRC, 269 SCRA 15 128 Prudential vs IAC, 216 SCRA 257 129 Benguet vs NLRC, 209 SCRA 55 130 APT vs Sandiganbayan, 360 SCRA 437 131 WPP vs Galera, 616 SCRA 436 132 Union vs NLRC, 314 SCRA 531 133 Pamplona vs Acosta, 510 SCRA 249 134 Tavera vs Phil. Tuberculosis, 112 SCRA 243 135 Barayuga vs Adventist, 655 SCRA 640 136 De Asis vs CA, 136 SCRA 599 137 Toh vs Solid, 408 SCRA 544 138 Gomez vs PNOC, 606 SCRA 187 139 Okol vs Slimmers, 608 SCRA 97 140 People vs Garcia, 271 SCRA 621 141 Carrascoso vs CA, 477 SCRA 666 142 Cruzvale vs Eduque, 589 SCRA 534 143 Prime vs IAC, 220 SCRA 103 144 Inter-Asia vs CA, 403 SCRA 452 145 Commissioner vs Express, 589 SCRA 253 146 Ong vs CA, 401 SCRA 648 147 Ong vs Tiu, 401 SCRA 1 148 Yamamoto vs Nishino, 551 SCRA 447 149 Halley vs Printwell, 649 SCRA 116 150 SMC vs Sandiganbayan, 340 SCRA 289 151 NTC vs CA, 311 SCRA 508 152 PLDT vs NTC, 539 SCRA 365 153 Commissioner vs CA, 301 SCRA 152 154 Republic vs Agana, 269 SCRA 1 155 Phil. Coconut vs Republic, 600 SCRA 102 156 Motoomul vs Dela Paz, 187 SCRA 743 157 Lao vs Lao, 567 SCRA 558 158 Tan vs SEC, 206 SCRA 740 159 Makati vs Cheng, 621 SCRA 103 160 Ponce vs Alsons, 393 SCRA 602 161 Hacienda vs Presidential, 653 SCRA 154 162 Bitong vs CA, 292 SCRA 503 163 Lim vs Continental, 69 SCRA 349 164 Rural vs CA, 210 SCRA 510 165 Baguio vs CA, 226 SCRA 366 166 Raquel-Santos vs CA, 592 SCRA 169 167 Batangas vs Bitanga, 362 SCRA 635 168 Trieste vs Sandiganbayan, 145 SCRA 508 169 Labrador vs CA, 180 SCRA 266 170 Neugene vs CA, 303 SCRA 295 171 Thomson vs CA, 298 SCRA 280 172 Razon vs IAC, 207 SCRA 234 173 Batong Buhay vs CA, 147 SCRA 4 174 Delpher vs IAC, 157 SCRA 349 175 Rural vs CA, 366 SCRA 188 176 Garcia vs Jomouad, 323 SCRA 424 177 Nava vs Peers, 74 SCRA 65 178 Chemphil vs CA, 251 SCRA 257 179 Monserrat vs Ceron, 58 Phil 469 180 Apodaco vs NLRC, 172 SCRA 442 181 China vs CA, 270 SCRA 503 182 Calatagan vs Clemente, 585 SCRA 300 183 Lanuza vs CA, 454 SCRA 54 184 Gala vs Ellice, 418 SCRA 431 185 Philips vs CA, 206 SCRA 457 186 SMC vs Mandaue, 467 SCRA 107 187 Grace vs CA, 281 SCRA 133 188 Chung vs IAC, 163 SCRA 534 189 Loyola vs CA, 276 SCRA 681 190 Phil. First vs Hartigan, 34 SCRA 252 191 P.C vs CA, 462 SCRA 36 192 Iglesia vs Lazaro, 624 SCRA 224 193 Poliand vs National, 467 SCRA 500 194 Mcleod vs NLRC, 512 SCRA 222 195 Associated vs CA, 291 SCRA 511 196 BPI vs BPI, 627 SCRA 590 197 Reyes vs RTC, 561 SCRA 593 198 NATU vs Secretary, 109 SCRA 139 199 Nautica vs Yummul, 473 SCRA 415 200 Sy vs Sy, 582 SCRA 517 201 Gonzales vs PNP, 122 SCRA 489 202 Ang-Abaya vs Ang, 573 SCRA 129 203 Puno vs Puno, 599 SCRA 585 204 Bataan vs PCGG, 150 SCRA 181 205 San Pablo vs CIR, 492 SCRA 192 206 NPC vs Vera, 170 SCRA 721 207 Woodchild vs Roxas, 436 SCRA 235 208 Manila vs PNB, 511 SCRA 444 209 Premium vs CA, 264 SCRA 11 210 Cagayan vs Commissioner, 545 SCRA 10 211 Associated vs Pronstroller, 558 SCRA 113 212 Keeler vs Rodriguez, 4 Phil 19 213 Firme vs Bukal, 414 SCRA 190 214 CMH vs CA, 378 SCRA 545 215 SSS vs COA, 384 SCRA 548 216 Monfort vs Monfort, 434 SCRA 27 217 Nacpil vs Intercontinental, 379 SCRA 653 218 Aguenza vs IAC, 271 SCRA 1 219 Pena vs CA, 193 SCRA 717 220 Sales vs Sales, 169 SCRA 109 221 BPI vs First, 429 SCRA 30 222 People's vs CA, 237 SCRA 170 223 Banate vs Phil. Countryside, 625 SCRA 21 224 Central vs Tibe, 33 SCRA 593 225 Premiere vs CA, 427 SCRA 686 226 Philippine Rabbit vs Aladdin, 494 SCRA 358 227 Yao vs CA, 209 SCRA 763 228 J.G vs CA, 450 SCRA 169 229 Gamboa vs Victoriano, 90 SCRA 40 230 MMDA vs Gancayno, 658 SCRA 853 231 Lopez vs Fontecha, 247 SCRA 183 232 Atrium vs CA, 353 SCRA 23 233 Zomer vs International, 581 SCRA 115 234 Board vs Heirs, 20 SCRA 987 235 Safic vs Imperial, 355 SCRA 559 236 Bache vs Ruiz, 37 SCRA 823 237 BASECO vs PCGG, 150 SCRA 181 238 Buan vs Alcantara, 127 SCRA 824 239 Heirs vs CA, 422 SCRA 101 240 Sy vs Tyson, 119 SCRA 367 241 Young vs CA, 223 SCRA 670 242 Clavecilla vs Antillon, 19 SCRA 379 243 Villarosa vs Benito, 312 SCRA 65 244 Filoil vs Marine, 117 SCRA 86 245 Delta vs Mangosing, 70 SCRA 598 246 Trimica vs Polaris, 60 SCRA 321 247 ATM vs Buencamino, 124 SCRA 434 248 Talsan vs Baliwag, 310 SCRA 156 249 Far vs Francisco, 146 SCRA 197 250 Mapa vs CA, 214 SCRA 417 251 Pabon vs NLRC, 296 SCRA 7 252 United vs Ongpin, 368 SCRA 464 253 Digital vs CA, 328 SCRA 286 254 Zulueta vs Asia, 354 SCRA 100 255 Metropolitan vs Adala, 526 SCRA 465 256 Munoz vs People,548 SCRA 475 257 Median vs Metrobank, 561 SCRA 622 258 BA vs Sia, 336 SCRA 484 259 Eslaban vs Vda de Onorio, 360 SCRA 230 260 Public vs Uy, 372 SCRA 180 261 BPI vs CA, 416 SCRA 4 262 Grand vs Genuine, 406 SCRA 688 263 Expertravel vs CA, 459 SCRA 147 264 Bahia vs Litonjua, 30 Phil 624 265 PNB vs CA, 83 SCRA 237 266 Ching vs Secretary, 481 SCRA 609 267 Cometa vs CA, 301 SCRA 459 268 People vs Chowdury, 325 SCRA 572 269 Sales vs SEC, 169 SCRA 109 270 Castillo vs Balinghasay, 440 SCRA 442 271 Republic vs Sandiganbayan, 402 SCRA 84 272 Trans Middle vs Sandiganbayan, 490 SCRA 455 273 Republic vs COCOFED, 372 SCRA 462 274 Lee vs CA, 205 SCRA 752 275 Aurbach vs Sanitary, 180 SCRA 266 276 Raniel vs Jochico, 517 SCRA 221 277 Nielson vs Lepanto, 26 SCRA 540 278 Aranas vs Tutaan, 127 SCRA 828 279 Madrigal vs Zamora, 151 SCRA 355 280 Guanco vs Antolo, 497 SCRA 273 281 Caltex vs PNOC, 498 SCRA 400 282 Turner vs Lorenzo, 636 SCRA 13 283 Republic vs Estate of Menzi, 476 SCRA 20 284 Gochan vs Young, 354 SCRA 207 285 Yu vs Yukayguan, 589 SCRA 588 286 Hi-Yield vs CA, 590 SCRA 548 287 R.N vs Santos, 467 SCRA 312 288 SMC vs Kahn, 176 SCRA 447 289 Republic vs Cuaderno, 19 SCRA 671 290 PPSTA vs Quisumbing, GR NO. 72193, Nov. 17, 1990 291 Tan vs Quiambao, 513 SCRA 243 292 Yujuico vs Quiambao, 513 SCRA 243 293 Keller vs COB, 141 SCRA 86 294 Espiritu vs Petron, 605 SCRA 256 295 Pacific vs CA, 242 SCRA 493 296 In re: Petition for Assistance vs BIR, 511 SCRA 123 297 Avon vs NLRC, 246 SCRA 733 298 Paramount vs A.C, 561 SCRA 327 299 Bank vs Commissioner, 363 SCRA 840 300 Philippine vs CFI, 209 SCRA 294 301 PVB vs Vega, 360 SCRA 33 302 President vs Reyes, 460 SCRA 473 303 New Frontier vs RTC Branch 39, Iloilo, 513 SCRA 601 304 Pacific vs Puerto Azul, 605 SCRA 503 305 Castillo vs Uniwide, 619 SCRA 641 306 Wonder vs PBCom, 676 SCRA 489 307 Express vs Bayan, 687 SCRA 50 308 Equitable vs DNG, 627 SCRA 125 309 BDO vs JAPRL, 551 SCRA 342 310 Consuela vs Planters, 555 SCRA 465 311 Clemente vs CA, 443 SCRA 580 312 Pepsi vs CA, 443 SCRA 580 313 Chung vs IAC, 163 SCRA 534 314 Reburiano vs CA, 301 SCRA 342 315 316 317 318 319 320 321 322 323 324 325 326 327 328 329 330 331