Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Home / Technical Articles / Advices in choosing the right neutral earthing system for your installation
Don’t forget that the choice of the neutral earthing system has a direct
effect on the electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) of the installation, so that
will be covered too.
Table of contents:
1. Characteristics of neutral earthing systems
1. TT system
2. TN system
3. IT system
2. Neutral earthing system and EMC
1. TT system
2. IT system
3. TN-S
4. So, which system is the best?
1. Characteristics of neutral
earthing systems
The following paragraphs summarize the advantages and the
disadvantages of each neutral earthing system.
1.1 TT system
General principle
Detection of a fault current running through the earth and disconnection of
the power supply by a residual current device (RCD).
Advantages of TT system
Simplicity (very few calculations when installing).
Extension with no need to calculate the lengths.
Low fault currents (fire safety).
Very little maintenance (apart from regular testing of the RCDs).
Safety of people when portable devices are supplied or if earthing is
defective (with 30 mA RCDs).
Operation on a source at low prospective current i k (generator set).
Disadvantages of TT system
No differential discrimination if only one device at supply end of
installation
Need for RCDs on each outgoing line to obtain horizontal
discrimination (cost)
Risk of false tripping (overvoltages)
Interconnection of exposed conductive parts to a single earth
connection (widespread installations) or RCD needed for each group
of exposed conductive parts
Level of safety dependent on the value of the earth connections
The system is called TN-C when the neutral function is combined with that
of the protective conductor, which is then called PEN. See the connections
of TN-C system here. If these conductors are separated, the system is
named TN-S. See the connections of TN-S system here.
When both variants cohabit in the same installation, the term TN-C-s can
be used (see connections), remembering that the TN-C system must
always be upstream of the TN-S system.
Zs × Ia ≤ U0
Where:
Zs – impedance of the fault loop comprising the power supply line, the
protective conductor and the source (transformer windings).
Ia – operating current of the protection device within the specified time
U0 – nominal phase/earth voltage
Advantages of TN system
Low cost (protective devices are used for fault currents and over
currents)
The earth connection has no effect on the safety of people
Low sensitivity to disturbance (good equipotentiality, neutral earthed)
Low sensitivity to high leakage currents (heating, steam, computing
equipment)
Disadvantages of TN system
High fault currents (generation of disturbance and risk of fire in
particular with TN-C system)
Need for accurate calculation of lines
Risk in the event of refurbishment extensions or uncontrolled use
(qualified staff)
1.3 IT system
General principle
Keeping the 1st fault current at a very low value limits the voltage rise of the
exposed conductive parts, and there is thus no need for disconnection.
However, 2nd fault is a different story.
Let’s see what happens with the 1st fault in this neutral earthing system.
The current of the 1st fault (If) is limited by the sum of the resistances of the
earth connections of the power supply (RB), the exposed conductive parts
(RA) and the impedance (Z).
The non-breaking condition must be checked, ensuring that the current will
not increase the exposed conductive parts to a voltage higher than the
voltage limit UL. The following is therefore required: RA × If < 50 V, i.e. in
the example: 30 × 0.112 = 3.36 V.
The exposed conductive parts will not reach a dangerous voltage and non-
breaking is permitted.
In the event of a 2nd fault affecting another phase, on the same or another
exposed conductive part, a loop is created by the exposed conductive parts
of the faulty receivers, the protective conductors and the power supply
conductors.
This will cause a high short-circuit current to circulate for which the
elimination conditions are those of the TN or TT system. It should be noted
that this double fault situation is totally independent of the situation of the
neutral in relation to earth, which may be isolated or impedance earthed.
The IT double fault current is often lower that it would be with a TN system.
The protected line lengths will be reduced accordingly.
If there is a fault, the voltage of the neutral may increase to that of the
faulty phase (phase-to-neutral voltage). The voltage of the other phases
will tend to increase towards the value of the phase-to-phase voltage.
Disadvantages of IT system
Installation cost (protected neutral, Pim, voltage surge protectors).
Operating cost (qualified staff, location of faults).
Sensitivity to disturbance (poor equipotentiality with earth).
Risks on 2nd fault:
Short-circuit overcurrents.
Disturbance (rise in earth voltage).
Appearance of a phase-to-phase voltage (if neutral distributed).
Standalone installation
2.1 TT system
Advantages
The neutral voltage is fixed.
The fault currents are low.
Disadvantages
Source earth connection and load earth connection are separated and
less equipotential. impedance of the load earth connection can be
high.
PE conductor does not constitute a reliable voltage reference,
resulting in the need for additional equipotential links.
Lightning strike giving differential mode overvoltage (dissymetry of the
system).
Go back to Content Table ↑
2.2 IT system
Advantages
The fault currents are low.
Good protection against conducted lightning, but risk of sparkover
on the neutral impedance, resulting in the need for a surge voltage
protector.
Disadvantages
“Load” earth voltage not fixed in relation to the source and
consequently not fixed in relation to that of the exposed conductive
parts.
Increase in earth voltage (direct lightning strike) or after the 1st fault:
loss of reference for electronic devices.
Circulation of permanent currents by capacitive coupling between live
and earth conductors.
Go back to Content Table ↑
2.3 TN-S
Advantages
A single “source” and “load” voltage reference, the earth is not
used as a conductor, and good equipotentiality of the exposed
conductive parts.
Low impedance of the protection circuit due to the need to carry
high fault currents.
Disadvantages
Specific installation rules and equipment (5 wires).
Possible rejection of disturbance on the neutral if the equipotentiality
is uncertain between the neutral and the Pe conductor or if their paths
are different.
High fault currents.
Lightning strike giving differentiel mode overvoltage (dissymetry of the
system).
Go back to Content Table ↑