Você está na página 1de 83

WORK IN PRCX!RF.

SS
PRELIMINARY
FINDINGS
A CONIENT ANALYSIS
. OF
TWO. DECADES of mE ADVOCATE
(July 5. 1972 - July 2. 1991)
AND
THE 1991 GAYELLOW PAGES
THE INSlTIUTE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
ARIlNG1UN. VIRG.INIA
c The Institute For Media Education
JUDe 199h
,
,
,
C5Ne:I'lAL P. X . KELLEY, U5MC(Rct.)
fl.' ' w"rnaillTl I .....
W .... SM1N(:T.) N . !:l.r.. :h,lI}OM
,
Qctcl\:ler 5, 1994
'1'0 WHOM IT MAY CONCERN:
Re: Dr. ' Judith Ref-rmalt's Advotate/Washinetonian Srudy and PrlWU4 Efforts to
Difend the Mtltrary Ban on Homose:r::r,sall
a former member ot the Joint Chiefs of Staff and Commandant of nie Marine
Corps I am very famiUar with military policy on and the many fU,!Or1S why homosexuality Is
incompJ,ti.ble with mllita.ry service , After my retire ment and in the winter of 15191-1992, 1
ruelved an early version of Dr. iid
Y
ocarelWQ..1hhtgtol1ian $tU4y. 1 am
familia! with het work on Pornosraph.y CommisSlon and her groundbrunna work In
Kfrue'j. Sa &: Fraud. I received her study at the same Lime that Oeneral CowfPowell
received the same. I reviewed the material aI1d, becau.se. I have known Colonel. Ron Ray
personally as a' Marine officer, B.S a former Defense official In the Reas;an AdmlniStfitiol'\, as
Member or U'le American BaWc MVIII.lIr.cnt J CQmmi u toll, and u an outstandin. Kentuclty
hwyer. I tumed Dr. R.eisman's study over to Colonel RAY beeause I knew he would know
bow to PUt it'to its best pos$lole use. He later relied upon her reseuth in"his seminal wOrk,
Mi1lta11 &: published in January 1m.
!ton by is uniquely qualified a3 an attorney to make thiJ ea.se, havin$ been Ltvolvcd
in leading cases including WasJon v. Commonwealth of Ktnrudt;l. 842 S. W.2d 487 (Ky
1992), lnvolvini the constitutionality and b:gality of Kentucky's sodomy statute; and earlier
cases, ',He has tJ,kcn the lead as a. private cld!:cn in dliJlencl.1n& the military in a
variety o( forums, including the Dist.dct of Columbia Court of Appc:als and before ho.stilc
a",dionccs 10 the media and on .Iuch national television eall-in shows IU La1ry KIna
and Peter rennin,'s Evel1fng News. To their credi t. Directou of the' Naval Aviation
October 5, 1994
Paie Two
Foundation, IJicludin, fanner ChB!rman of the loint Chief, and other distin,uishec! retiml
Naval Aviaton, cbose Ron Ray to represent them in the significant ease of Steffan ~ , Perry,
now pending before the District of Columbia, in which an openly homosexual Midshipman
seeks to b. readmitted to the United Statel Naval Academy.
Colon Ray and Dr. Reisman ate erninently qualified, and I hope you Ml.l give them
every favorable consideration and support this vital effort, which will not be made by
attorneys for the lustice Department, who are handling the military's defense of it! Int.re..ts
in this matter. If you require furttler information or I can answer any questions. please do
not besl .. ", to call.
Sincerely.
MLM
THEADVOCATE& THEGAYELLOWPAGES
OVERVIEW FOR MILITARY AND LEGAL CONSIDERATION
THE DEMAND FOR "FAcruAL RECORD" ON HOMOSEXUAL BEHAVIOR
Recent Califomiajudicial rulings challenge the Americanmilitary to justify their exclusion of homosexual
ci tizens from military service. While aU. S. District Court federal judge u phcld the Navy ban against homosexuals
in the annedservices, (The Washington Post, 12/ 11/91) Judge William Canby Jr . speaking for the U.S. 9th Circuit
Court of Appeals. was reponed as stating that tbe Army's policy of homosexual exclusion cannot be upheld "in
the absence of any supporting factual rccord" (The Los Angeles Times. 9/20/91).
Similar demands [or "scientific" data to justify homosexual exclusion continue to cite Dr. Alfred C.
Kinsey's purportedly reliable claims (Sexual Behavior in the Human Male, 1948) of a roughly 10% homosexll::l.l
population or "200,000 out of the 2 million merr.bers of the anned.forces" (as as proof of the "scientific
data" which would require an end to "discrimination" against homosexuals in the military. This attack on military
policy is echoed by similar c11allenges to existing civil laws which also exclude homosexuals from adoption,
marriage and other speciaJ privileges.
The attached "field study" of publicly preferred homosexual lifestyle beliefs and practices as evidenced
in THE ADVOCATE follows upon my recent book, Kinsev, Sex and Fraud: The Indoctrination of a People (co-
au thored wi th Edward W. Eichel) as a methodologically rigorous, scientific (research which can be replicated and
validated by independent study) answer to the not unreasonable demands in our era for evidence, for "factual
record" with which to determine public policy issues on homosexuality. As the largest circulation and longest
extant homosexual publication, THE ADVOCATE has carried interviews with congressmen as well as with
in tellectual, medical, entertainment and art luminaries (eg., see interviews with Congressman Garry S tudds in July
23. 1985, Larry Kramer, writer and director of television's "thirtysomething" in Apri123. 1991. aud July 16. 1991
interview wi:h writer, WilliamS. Burroughs), THE ADVOCATE has been cited in the mainline press as a credible
voice for the homosexual movemeut while major talk shows have cameod its representatives as legitimate
spokespeople for the homosexual community, ("Geraldo," 12/91).
Thus, while certainly some independent homosexuals may quietly have dislanced themselves from the
behaviors advanced in THE ADVOCATE, this periodical cannot be viewed as an unorthodox or fringe
publication of the homosexual movement, but rather as a unified voice of homo sexuality, "The National Gay and
Lesbian Magazine". Indeed. these same six core values and behaviors have beel) validated as bolding across all
of the key Slate homosexual publications. As such, the core values, the lifestyle openly displayed in TI::IE.
ADYOCATE must be seen as viable evidence which defines its readership and its overall constituency--
particularly due to its widespread visibility.
TABLE OF CON'IEN1'S
ABS1"R.Acr _ ........... . ................... , ........ , .. , .... , ................. , 1
L INTRODUCTION
Pederast Versus Pedophile Victimization Of Otildren ............................... 2
(Gay) Pederast Victims: 150.2 Boys Per Offender. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 4
5 TlIDe5 Greater. Averages Of Boy Victims '.IS. Girl VLCtims ~ . . 5
Up to 73 % Admission: Sex With Minors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 5
Cultural Values. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 5
The Present Study .............................. ',' . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 6
The Most Conservative HolllO:Seru.a.l Publication ............................. 6
On the Issue of Condoms .................................................... 6
II. BACKGROUND ............................................................. 8
m DEMOGRAPHICS & PSYCHOGRAPHICS
Simmons Market Research Data ................ r ' ' 8
IV. ADVOCATE -PULLOUT' CLASSIFIED: '7RADER D I C K S ~
A & B: Utiique Sex Structure Of THE ADVOCATE ............................ ',' .. 9
Gay Uncontracepted AnalOraI Sodomy Continuity ............................. : '.. 10
AIDS-Efficient Sex ................. 10
V. METHODOLOGY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 12
VI. SELECTED PRELIMINARY ADVOCATE FlNDrNGS
Basic Photo Facts ........................... '. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 13
. ,Basic Print Facts ..... ' ,' .... , ........ . ... ' ... ' ........... , ... , .. ,. . . . . . . .. 15
VII. WHAT THE ADVOCATE REVEALS AND CONCEALS
"Blaming The Child Victim" ............ . .................... . ............... 17
The Condom Taboo ...... '................................................ 17
VIII. SIX BASIC ADVOCATE MEASURES
SIX HYPOTIIESES: ...................................................... . 18
ONE: GAY SEX wrrn: "BOY LOVERS ............ . ..................... . 18
Unanticipated Finding: 10-20% Boys In Biweekly Prostitution Ads ............ 18
JULy 16,1991, nrE ADVOCATE' ' . ............... 18
JULY 5, 1972: nIE ADVOCATE . . ... . . .. . . . . .. 19
ADVOCATE Advice ................................................ 20
THE ADVOCATEJANUARY 3, 1973 .................................. 23
THE ADVOCATE: JUNE 3, 1974 ...................................... 23
Youth Are Vulnerable ............................................... 24
Recent Over-18 l..aws ........... 24
The AG's Commission Note "UNDER 21" Recommendation Evaporates......... 25
Teenagers' Lethal Experimentation With Gay Sex . . 2S
"Condoms" as Taboo Throughout 19 Years of Roughly 440,000 Sex Ads, . . . . .. 26
TIlE ADVOCATE; AUGUST 13, 1975 ................. :............... 27
August 13 1991 PUl.l..OU'r' Advertisement Samples ............ 28
Nearly Two Decades of "Pretty Boys- ...................... 28
TIiE ADVOCATE.: MARCH 10,1976 .................................. 29
nm I N ~ FOR MEDlA EDUCATION PO BOX 74004 ARLINGl'ON', VIRGINIA 1ZlD7 7a3-237-S4SS
"Chicken Lovet'l" Will Help Runaway Youths .......................... 29
Vectoring AIDS To Boys and Society ........................... 30
Prostitution Income for Young Bis, Marrieds., Straights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 31
Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 32-
TWO: GAY ON-GAY VIOLENCE ........................................ 33
Nineteen Years of Desensitization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 33
VIOLEN'T ADS APRIl.. 23. 1991 ...................................... 34
Violence Against Gays Violence Against Jews and Blacks . . . . . . . . . . . .. 34
Discri.m.inating Heteroserual Versus Homosemal Bashers ............. 35
"A Gay Slave Auction At The Mark IV Bath HotlSe-Was Raided" In the United
States, "SlavCry is a Felony- ..................... 3S
"All a Boy Could W'tsh For-Discrim.inating Customets" ....... 37
The GaylPederast and Murder. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 37
What is the Background on "Inlergay' Violence? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 38
THE ADVOCATE MURDER: April 9, 1991 ............................. 39
6,5()f) ADVOCATE "Hate Crime" ADS (1990) vs.l,588 Nationwide -JIate Crimes" .. 39
Gay Intergay "Hate Crimes
N
Against Gays ......................... 39
Conclusion ....................................................... 41
TllREE: GAY RACISM.. . ..... . .. .... . ...... .. .. .. .. ... .. . ........ .. ... 43
Socializing Insti rutional Racism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . -. . . . . .. 43
RBLACK M<\GIC: FOR MEN OF COLOR MID FOR 'MEN WHO -LOVE
................................................... 43
A Higher Rate of Black Homosexuality Is Anticipated ............. '. . . . . . . . .. 43
Invisible Gay Blach In A Dominant White Gay Culture ................... 44
Excluding Blacks From 5,COO ADVOCATE Bathhouses ................... :-.. 45
BLACK INVISmILITY: OUT OF l.COO "WHITE" SEX ADS ................. 45
Marketing While-On-White Bias . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 46
Blacks Say More Than Half Their Partners Are White ....................... 46
Internalizing The Values of 'White Gay-As-Beautiful' .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 47
Conclusion ........................................................ 47
FOUR: GAY Continuity of AIDS-EFFICIENT SEX . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 49
- ftRelationship" in Pan A:. Commercial Sex & Sadism in Part B ..... -. . . . . . . . . . .. 49
1 % BVMarried/Straight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 49
1 % Sought a Permanent, Monogamous Partner. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 50
Anonymous At-Risk Copulation As "Identily" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 50
Gay Bars ........................ , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. 51
Gay Baths . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 51
"Tea-rooms" - Public Toilets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 51
Glory Hole Aile! Peeping Tom Directories ...................... _ . . . . . . . . .. 52
.Anal Assault. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 53
Conclusion: . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 53
FIVE: GAY SEDUCTION OF STRAIGHTS .......................... . . . . . .. 55
THE ADVISOR: April 9, 1991 ........................................ 55
ConClusion ........................................................ 56
SIX: GAY FASCISM ....................... _.......... ..... ... . ...... .. 57
Conclusion ........................................................ 58
IX. CONCLUSIONS - WORK IN PROGRESS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 59
X. RECOMMENDATIONS - WORK IN PROGRESS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 60
ENDN01E.S .................................................................... 62
APPENDICES. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 66
TIm FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 70f04 ARllNGTON, VIRG1N1A 'ZZ11J7 703-237-5455
THE ADVOCA TE & THE GA YELLOW PAGES
ABSTRACf
Current science trends which "frnd
N
homosexuality to be immutable suggest ao especial need for replicable
scientific study such as this examination of THE GAYELLOW PAGES and THE ADVOCATE, the Jargest
selling, most conservative of "establishment
N
homosexual publications. A preliminary analysis of the seminal
features of gay culture
l
io THE GA YELLOW PAGESand THE ADVOCA TE( confirmed as homosexual print
norms across a randomized sampJe of state homosexual periodicals) werc found to support the same set of core
values. This study content analyzed THE GAYELLOW PAGESand 56 randomly selected issues covering two
decades (July 5,1972 to July 16, 1991) of THE ADVOCATE. The latter analysis uncovered evidence identifying
roughly eighl corc "gay" ADVOCATEvalues. The following eight behavioral values have been promoted to boys
and men via roughly 446,000 sex ads (up to 2,000 each month) in Part "B" (a high-gloss, full color
independently paginated "PULLOUT" section) of the main ADVOCATE, july 5, 1972 to July 16, 1.991:
One: Part B Eyidence finds up to 58% of roughly 446,000 ADVOCATEsex ads are fOIWle
homosexual at-risk paid sex (prostitution).
Two: Part B Evidence Hods up to 38% of roughly 260,000 ADVOCATEprostitution ads involve male
youthlboy 'cues' while up to 20% of these ads specify teen!youthlboy sex.
Three: Part B Evidence finds up to 20% of 446,000 ADVOCA TEsex ads seek male homosexual (gay-
on-gay, intergay) violence (i .e., "hale crimes" such as Whipping, spanking, pounding, cutting, verbal
humiliation).
Four: Part B Evidence ftnds up to 99% of 446,000 ADVOCATE sex ads seek male AIDS-ellident sex
(e.g., condomless multiple, anonymous partnering, violent anal-to-oral sodomy, etc) via
' gayslmarriedlbilstraights' .
Five: Part B Evidence finds up to 99% of 446,000 ADVOCATEsexads seek "straight" appearing male
adult or teenJyouthJboy sex partners (i.e. "macho males" with frequent reference to large sex organ).
Six: Part B Eyidence finds from 97-100% of446,OOO AD VOCA TEsex ads are read as soliciting 'white-
only,' while black males may constitute up to 20% or more of the male homosexual population.
Seven: Part B Evidence fmds up to 72% of 446,000 ADVOCA TEsex. ads seek fair, Aryan-like, hairless
male beauty (even including nazi termsldresslbrutality) and a male homosexual bias against what
advertisers call "ferns," "fats" or other non-white, non-macho males .
.eight: Part B Eyidence finds 00/0 of 446,000 ADYOCA TE sex ads require "condom users only" -
- even post AIDS (up to .004% inexplicit "safe sex" solicitations have recently appeared).
Similarly, only . o o ~ / o small, commercial condom product ADS surfaced in Part B suggesting the
male homosexual COndQm-Don-use-oattern to be widespread and condoned.. Additional data
should be collected on this surprising and worrisome finding due to its potential medical, public policy
and legal (especially military) implications.
NOTE CHANGE: The 1992 ADVOCATE recently upackaged its CLASSIFIED
section as hard-core photographic and cartooned pornography. separate and
available "on request" with each issue. The December I, 1992 ADVOCATE includes
a full page pederast illustration of a black-eyed, three-year-old boy with his killen.
In keeping with a "boy-lover- theme. THE ADVOCATE anist inserted an adult-
sized, tumescent phallus. visible under the child's pants.
THE ADVOCATE &. THE GAYEuOW PAGES 2
1 INTRODUcnON
James Madison argued that in order for democracy to survive, the public must have accurate
information to decide the important issues under consideration.
2
Our naUo.D - in politics, religion,
entertainment - is rightly concerned about "gay-bashing. AIDS, bigooy toward homosauaIs, youlhs who
commit suicide due to homosaual involvement, etc. However, while the nation knows what kind of m.a1e-
female conduct has been valued as normal. right and good, facts about what is normal, right and good in
homosema1 life have been Such a lack of knowledge seriously hinders public debate and decision
making about homosexuals in society.
In Gay and Lesbian Youth (1989) Dr. Gilben Herdt was concerned that boys recently:
shun older gays as role models or even as friends_. fear of AIDS contact has
seemingly alienated teenagers from younger and middle-aged adults (:4,32).
rOne boy told HerdtJ "r never wanted to be 'lJ1Y. Now, with AIDS, I have
even less reason" (:33). [Herdt felt teen resistance to homosexuality and
older gays requiredJ focusing upon gay youth. ... and the coming out proces.s
in teens (:4, 29).
Herdt's colleague Dr. Douglas Feldman admitted that AIDS will kill at least one iIi four_ ..
[gay t]eenagers [as theyjtend to be very susceptible to se:ru.ally transmined diseases" (:188). The scholars were
concerned that such (ears (of at least every founh "gar boy dying of AIDS). were discouraging youngsters from
experimenting with what might be their gay orientation.
To attract boys to homosexual life Herdt said. "gay culture began to institutionalize 'socialization'
techniques (or the transmission of its cullural knowledge to a younger generation- (:4). Gay culture Herdt
and other homosexual scholars firmly believe, merits legal protection from 'hate crirries.' which result, they feel,.
from ignorance about gays. The many DeW laws which bestow unique rights to AIDS carriers and
homosexuals suggested the need for an Objective analysis of precisely what kind of "gay cultural knowledge-
is being socialized to the boys that Herdt sees as "the younger generation. "
As the problem of child sex abuse overwhelms the nation, child protection has become a matter of
life and death. Laws which had prohibited homosexuals from working with children have been largely
abandoned based on a) the belief that homosexuals are roughly 10% of the population and thus normal b)
the notion that more heterosexual males abuse children than do homosexual males and c) the obvious
immorality of discrim.i.natmg against a harmless population.
PedenlSt Versus Pedophile VJdimintion Of Children
However, careful study has exposed the gay "10%" as a myth begun by Dr. Alfred Kinsey in Saual
Behavior in the Human Male (1948). The reader is referred to Kinsey, Sex and Fraud (Reisman and Eichel,
1990) (or extensive documentation proving Kinsey's data fraudulent - the actual percentage of gays is more
realistically estimated as between 1%-3%.3
This stwJ.y did not lJdd:ress h.cmcsauLJl ft!:rrUlk bd&avicr (lLSbimu) for two rt:DSOtU: to dau, lDbimu an
1I.Ol idmtified as AIDS Yt!d/:lr$ to Ik public, nor is nauiJmm.t of girl.r dLx::urnoJud. as conrmon ILsbian adtuTaJ
corubJ.ct.. In support of thi.r lkd.sion. We" found NO womDI iUlvotisin.g in TIlE ADV0C4.m for sa with girls -
in tJu 19 aarnind.
TIm lNS"lTlUIB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-4004 ARl..lNGTON, VIRGINlA z:t:lJ17
TJlEADVOCATE & 11iE GAYELLOW PAGES
3
While the massive enticement of boys into "gay" sex with men appears to be a pathology only of male
homose:ruals, the data do find worrisome trends among lesbians of sexually sadistic conduct rS&M-). It is not
impossible that furore studies may find woman-girl sex recruitment becoming common among lesbians.. To
date however, abuse of minors (both boys and girls) appears to remain largely a male pathology - for
pedophiles (generally men who abuse girls) and pedqasts (men who abuse boys).
Regarding child sa abuse., pro-gay literature generally cites child protection experts' data that 1 in
4 girls (25%) and 1 in 6 boys (16%) are sexua1Iy abused by age 18.
4
to argue that children are more likely
abused by straights than by "gays.- However in their FBI Report on "Ou1d Pornography and Sex Rings"
Lanning and Bw:gess (1984) cite the one in four" female estimate but say:
(t]he numbers for male victimi.z:ation are more hidden, perhaps because boys are reluctant to
admit to being victimjzed.. However, clinical data are increasingly suggesting that boys may
be at equal risk fbr se:ma.l yjdjrnjzation .since they are the ptekOllOO target of habitnal
pedophiles and Yiaims of child sa: rings. (: 10)
It is important to begin to distinguish between pedophiles (generally girl targets) and pederuSts (l'JOy
targets). For while not all homosexual or heterosexual males abuse children, a critical sub-population of each
targetS children. Funher on, this study examines the gay versus pederast issue based on the content of the
homosexual press. The following briefly addresses the data on numbers of victims for crimes of boy-man child
abuse (pederasts) versus crimes of girl-man child abuse (pedophiles).5 The wide discrepancy between the self
report of Abel's pederast population and Reisman's calculation from Gay population figures suggests thal the
pederast population is significantly more lethal and predatory than can be explained by population statistics
to sex abuse alone.
Abel;
14,700 Boys Vw:rimimi (figure from actual pederast self-report)
, -
By 98 Pederasts
Reisman: 1,225 Boys VJdimizrrl (estimate by percentage of g;ry population)
By 98 Pedetasts
If, as suggested by clinical data, r.ltes of boy and girl abtlSe are -equal- (one in four) at 101100 (10%
gays) 90 gays aver<lge 2.5 boy assaults per lnan
6
or, 193 victims at' 2% gays average 125 victims per ID<iil with
1,225 boys abused by 98 gays compared to 25 girls abused by 98 -straights." At the lower rate of boy sex abuse,
if -gays" are estimated at 2 (2%) of every 100 men, 98 gays abuse 784 boys (16%) for every 25 girls (25%)
abused by 98 -straights. - While these estimates appear impossible, Dr. Eugene Abel's clinical research suggests
they are too modest.
TABLE I: ABEL et at
RATES OF ASSAULT ON BOY v. GIRL VICfIMS
Offmdo:r TOU2l VJdion.r
Oass Number of Girl Boy
Offenders Victims Victims
Pederasts 153
- 24981
Pedophiles 224 4,435
-
nm ~ FOR MEDIAEDUCAnON PO BOX 7<404 AlUlNGI'ON, VlRGINIA 'Zl2D7 7a3-2J7-5455
THEADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
4
(Gay) Pedet3st VlCtims; 150.2 Boy.s Per OOeDda
Dr. Gene Abel, et aI. 1 found 153 typiC3l (gay) pederast offenders admitte4 to 22,981 victim.r, for an
average of 1SlJ.2 driJd victims per mtl1L This is supported by other research findings. The seminal work in the
area was reported by Abel a aI. based on their study of child abuse offenders. The researchers also found (gay)
pederasts.:
sauaIIy JIIIOIcst )'OUIl!: boys with an iDcidence that is occurring from me
times grcakZ than the molemltion of &irk- drild
moJesters [admitted to] from 23.2 acts to 281.7 acts per
were m4Ia (:32-50. 48. 44).
Note that at 150 victims each, SIS gay child moIestc::rs will abuse roa.piy "](X) boys - infiojtdy more
than the h.igber bon:ndary of 1;125 estimated from child abase data. Abel pointed out that men who targeted:
young boys outside the borne committed the greatest number of crimes._.Of
the total sample of child molesters, a relatively small number (44) targeted
boys within the home. (:44)
Given the lower or higher ratio - the rate of "gay" versus straight" child abuse is staggering. It
appears likely, based on Abel's work as well as the data on the average number of adult male homosexual
partners (500), that the higher bound estimate of boy victims is much nearer the real child victimization rate
than the lower or median estimates below. Abel's mean for boy versus girl victims of male offenders is 1.50..0
boys versus a mean of 19..8 girl victims.. (:46)
TABLE IT: ESTIMATES OF BOY - Versus 25 GIRL VICTIMS -
PER 100 MEN
%VJ:Ctims %<f.rys/l00 ;lMEN VlCtimVMan Total Boys
25 2 98 12.5 1,225
25 5 95 5 475
25 10 90 2.5 198
16 2 98 8 784
16 5 95 3.2 304
16 10 90 1.6 144
Were gays 2/100 (2%) then 98 gay child abusers (16 boys at 8 victims each) would violate 784 boys-
not the 25 girls allegedly violated by 98 straight" child abusers. Were gays 5/100 (5%) then 95 gay child
abusers (16 boys at 3.2 victims each) would violate 304 boys.
E....:n at 'the 10% (10/100) claimed by fY!Y activists, 90 gay child violate 144 boys (L6
victims per man) - fully 119 more boy than girl victims. At its most extreme,. as if boy/girl abuse 13b:$
TIm INS"'lTI1.rffi FOR MEOlA EDUCATION ro BOX 7404 ARllNGTON, VIRGINIA z:z:l1J7 703-237-5(SS
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
5
are equal. tben for every 98 strnghts who abuse 2S girh, 2 gays abu:sc 2S boys. 98 pys Z5$Jplring DOt 2S but
1,225 boy victims.. The lower -equal
W
c:sti:mates seen in Table II are 475 victims or 198 victims - an starisriaIly
sign.ificantly h.igber ratios of abuse than sustained by similarly pat:bologica.l -stJaigbC- abuscn.
5 TImes GrcU.cr. Of Boy VIdims vs.. Girl V'x:tims
The ra.mi:fications of such abuse rates - at the lowest or highest levels are serious. Moreover, while
these are disturbing estimates Abel reported:
Whm one amninD 1M cJrild fa it u surprising to NU tM
wry high IDUIl child molnttrtiau convnit:lal by dIarI: wIto taI'f:d
young boy:r 1M cJIiJd victim.r compmed
to who moU!tt girlr-[T]M JUgIt pm:.enr.age c:cmvnitud by iMlIdD
who molat young bop if a the IrigIr.
1f1DIL:rtations conrpleUd...whDI compmed with other of-mcIDten..
(:51)
The book, For Money or Love (1976) by Robin Uoyd, confirms similar boy abusein "Boy Prostitution
in America" An identical boy abuse pattern is found by others (eg., Jay & Young. 1972; Janus, 1981; Rueda,
1982; Harvey, 1987).8 These disturbing estimates of gay abuses of boys compon with other independent
validity checks. Kinsey co-author, Dr. Wardell Pomeroy claims to have interviewed an elderly man who bad
sex with "600 preadolescent boys" (Pomeroy, 1972: 122), and most surprising. the general gay literature and
press commonly define a man's adolescent victim as his "boy-lover:
Up to 73 % Sa: With Minors
Kinseyan researchers Alan Bell-and Martin Weinberg- report on the obsessive nature of gay sexual
conquest in Homoseru.aliries (1978). They note roughly 75% of the 5,C) white gays and 66% of black gays
interviewed, adm.i:tu.d between 100 and aver 500 sex partners. Some number of these were juveniles..
- .
Almosr one-half of tJu white homoseru.al males (WHMs) aruJ. one-third of the
black homosaual males (BHMs) said tht;j htuJ. had at least five hundred
clifferent sexual partn.eTs ... ..A.nother third of the WHMs and a quarter of the
BHMs reported having had between one hundred and five hundred
partners .... On.e-quartu of the WHMs and 14 percent of the BHMs said that aJry
[sic] of their sexual partners had been sixteen years old or younger (when the
respondents were at least twenty-one years old) (:85, emphasis added)
Boy obsession is seen in the New York teachers' mandate that sex be legal 'so long as it
occurs outside the and Magnuson (1985) notes "73 percent of homosexuals had at some time bad sex
with boys 16-19 or younger".'
Cultural Values
Behavior Today, July 22, 1991 (:4) reports: "On average, adult Americans had 1.6 sexual panners
during the year preceding the survey .... CUrrently married (O.96) .... About 22 percent of adult americans had no
sexual partners during the year preceding the survey .... Faithtulness within marriage is a widely shared
norm ... Just 1.5 percent of married people reported having a non-spouse as a part..i:ter in the previous year:
Without contrary evidence, 500 admitted sex partners per homosexual male suggests that Abel's finding of 150
boy victims per pederast is reasonable. And a 73% admission of sex with boys confirms an obsessive culture
TIm INrnTUT"B FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7-404 ARLINGlON, VIRGINIA 'Z22D7 7a3-237-StSS
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAY.ELLOW P.A.GES
6
favoring boy partners, which the g;ay press describes as "boy lovers." .M 9fS (DO( pedC2asts) demand an
end to age of coosent Jaws (Jay and Young, 1972, pp. 33Q..367) boys would be seen at high-risk from gays as
a class.
Bell and Weinberg claim less saually active gays have 48 to 400 sex partners, with average gays at 550
partners and AIDS vectors at 1,100.
11
While the US government recently proposed several million-doUar
AIDS research projects to aamine these issUes,l1 sec stucties commonly attract both unconventional subjeas
and unconventional researchers. This has commonly resulted in bizarre sexual behavior described as normal. It
With this background in mind., this study of THE ADVOCATE and G.4fELLOW PAGES
'
- was
undertaken. An malysis of tbe print and pidoria1 amtent of these two -cultural institutiom- yields a body
oiverifiable data about what the aitical AIDS population - ac:tivist honvlsernaJ males - think and do, h,nIe
done and h,nIe SlOpped doing sanally_
Before investing funds to advertise "X" in a magazine, marketers commonly study a publication's
'consumer data' to predict reader purchasing behavior. It has been found that use of a specialized publication
is a strong indicator of general acceptance of the values expressed in that publication. 13 This research effort
employed marketing research techniques to objectively measure the values to which homosexual males
adbere - to predict reader conduct.
Following preliminary studies and pilot testing at instruments, a content anal}'"5is was conducted on
THE ADVOCATE and on THE GAYELLOW PAGES. This analysis of the content of 19 years of
THE ADVOCATE (July 5, 1972 to July 2, 1991) 'WaS carried out by The Institute for Media Education,
Arlington, Virginja on randomly selected ADVOCATE magazines coded for 23
The Most CoDSelVatire Homa.se:ma1 Publication
The homosexual community sees THE ADVOCATE (70,000 circulation) as a mainline
which illustrates gay "cultural knowledge. The 'establishment' nature of the press is verified by nearly [wo
decades of publication and informaUy confirmed by the recent collapse of OUTWEEIC, the York based
homosexual magazine (30,CXXl circulation). AlthOUgh OUTWEEK's upscale readers should have attracted major
advertisers "they shled away apparently because the magazine's attitude was controversial even in the gay
community" (TIME. July 8, 47).
On the Issue of Condoms
Heterosexual pornography generally advertises condoms in full color ads, often in colors, textures and
flavors. Despite decades of widespread homosexual venereal diseases
l
statistically spea1ci.ng, neither gay
newsmagazines or gay newspapers are documented as accepting sex with condoms. In the roughly 446,CXXl sex
ads in 19 year.; of THE ADVOCATE, the word "condom" was taboo until recent issues. Beyond the single
I Original magazioc litle! 'TIiE ADVOCATE; NEWSPAPER OF AMERJCA'S HOMOPHILE COMMUNITY," (L.o& hgdes,
CA). Wbile tbe official publication dale is lisled a.3 January 1973 thi.a project azmiDc:s publicatioD.3 from July 5, 1972. The dala
dcsaibcd io this may be obLained by e:amUllng the maguine oollectioD at the United SlAtes Lib!"ll1Y or #80-644492
or (0)84/100.
nIB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
11fE ADVOCATE & THE GAYElLOW PAGES
7
CDC guideline announcement for "Safer Sex" the July 16, 1991 issue induded a "fun pack" ad for a man or
"girl" with an "active" lifestyle - 2 condoms, 2 lubricants, aspirins, 2 "towellets" and say ediblCi. This man or
"gi.rlw ad was not just for "condoms" and appeared to be direaed at bise:rua.l consumers.
One small ad amongst roughly 115 sex ads on page 36 said: CONDOMS Brand names. Free details.
Planning America [address]. No minors." This strange announcement was listed under
to the left, under the heading Attczltion!, THE .ADV0C4TE remonstrated on an issue they did see as
important:
W.ARN1NGI!!
There are serious risks involved in responding to mail-order ads from
foreign countries for......sexual images of The United States customs
authorities may ... file criminal charges against individuals receiving them.
The pederast WARNlNG!!! was directly opposite a small ad for "BcIys Qub" (pharo ot a young boy)
which sold "Videos, Leather, Lubes, Condoms, Toys" (:36-37). Another obscure "condom" mention appeared
in THE ADVOCATEs 170 pages, and but one small ad from a condom advertiser. Power Play" r12 for 15.95"
:23). We found no WARNING!!! in the roughly 1,000 sa ads that "condom-users-only" need apply.
July 16 included a De'i'i'S story about the rejection by -st:r.light" .America of a large AIDS street posta .-
a "safe ad with CONDOM" in. bold letters alongside two nude men in a sc:tuaI embrace.. While the
reporter said the ",AIDS- poster was "Way too Hot For Oty Streets" (:80), our preliminary data finds such
condom ads are created for straights" but are "way too bot" for the homosexual press itSelf. Based on
preliminary findings, this study tested seven hypotheses regarding gay cultural views expressed in
THE ADVOCATE.
1
2
3
4
5
6
HYPOTIiESES OF 6 PREY AIT...ING "GAY- CULnJRAL VALVES
.As and "teens" are sexually solicited in THE ADVOCATE, man-boy sex ("boy lovers") are
thus pan of prevailing "gay" cultural values.
As "gay-on-gay violence" is solicited in THE ADVOCATE (eg., "S&M" "spanking" slaves" etc..)
sexual violence is pan of prevailing "gay" cultural values.
As tbe substantial black gay population is sexually invisible in THE ADVOCATE, racism is pan
of prevailing "gay" cultural values.
As multiple, risky-public sex, prostitution, anal-to-oral sodomy, fistfu-ing and other unsanitary
sex acts are common in THE .ADVOCATE, sucb AIDS-effident sex is part of the prevailing
"gay" cultural values .
.As THE ADVOCATE solicits "straight" appearing men and censures "fems: obsession with
"straight boys and men is part of prevailing "gay" cultural values .
.As nazi costume fascist ads and ideas are circulated in THE ADVOCATE, these behaviors are
part of prevailing "gay. cultural values.
TIm INs-rrnrrB FOR MEDIA. EDUCATION PO BOX 7-404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA raJI7 703-237S<SS
THEADVOCATE& THEGAYELLOWPAGES 8

II. BACKGROUND
Due to the growing political power of homosexual ("gay") advocacy groups, the present study tested these:
six hypotheses. Mass media attention has focused on gay claims of "hate crimes" (discrimination or injury by
"anti-gays"). IS Recently contested federal reports, such as a Health and Human Services (HHS) study, claim
anti-gay views by churches and parents facilitate youthful suicide by suggesting homosexuality is abnormal
l6
Som statutes now require employment of, and rental to, homosexuals; gay child adoption is moving toward
acceptance; and, under the AIDS prevention umbreJla, school children are taught that homosexuality, is an
experimental choice. I' The Boy Scouts of America are struggling [0 continue services to needy youth as they
come under direct attack for "discriminating" against homosexual male. ...
18
The right to serve in the military as
well as marital rights for homosexual "couples" are sought. Legal and social denial of homosexual valucs is
compared to white abuse of blacks and the nazi massacre of the Jews.
19
If homosexual .males are innocent victims of American nazi brutality; if gays are unfairly accused of
soliciting children for sex; if the homosexual lifestyle is no threat to the nation's security, economy, health system
and the family, then justice requires the data be presented to support these truths.
If, on the other band, the six prevailing gay cultural values above deftne THE ADVOCATE and
THE GA YELL 0 W PA CES, these lifestyle behaviors const i tu te a threat Lo nationaJ sccuri ly-- wi thin the mili tary
and the overall society. If so, evidence must be put forward to fuJJy substantiate these flOdings. With these issues
in mind, the study ftrst examined: the theories and values presented in the pro-homosexual literature - both
homosexualscholarshipaswellaspopularmedia--and THE AD VOCATEand THE GA YELL 0 Wcont;tituency.
m. DEMOGRAPHICS &: PSYCHOGRAPHICS
There are two forms of marketing measurements long recognized >as critical tools of the advertising
industry: demographics (basic information about the public's gender, age, race, religion, location, reading,
buying and viewing habits, etc) and (basic information about the public's values and mores,
emotional and ethical conduct, etc.).
The bulk of this content analysis, in fact, establishes the psychographic profile of ADVOCATE
readers, and, by eXtension. of the larger "gay' community.
Just as ADVERTISING AGE serves as a mainsueam voice for the Ad industry, or THE CLEVELAND
JEWISH NEWS serves as the mainstream voice for Cleveland's Jewish Community, or THE DAILY WORKER
for the Communist community, THE ADVOCATE, THE NATIONAL GAY AND LESBIAN
NEWSMAGAZINE, serves as the mainstream voice for male (and recently female) homosexuals and
THE GAYELLOW PAGES serves as the business arm of that population. The racial composition of this
media group is unknown, but THE ADVOCATE largely serves White, Homosexual, Affluent, Single Males.
THE STANDARD PERIODICAL DIRECTORY, Uth Edition (1991) reported a circulation of 70,CXXl
for THE ADVOCATE (35,CXXI subscription and 35,000 nev.'SStand 'Sales, :735) representing a very small
population. At roughly 250 million Americans and about 175,000 million adults and 85 million men, this
readership accounts for .08 or less than 1 % Of the adult male population.
Simmons Markel Research Data
Another view of the readership finds none of the 150 major American magazines (Simmons Markel
Research, 1984) listing under 70,CXXI adult readers. As noted in the TIME article on OUIWEEJC, homosexual
males are largely an upsca!e population. Advertisements for expensive homes, clubs, tours and resorts support
TIm FOR MBD[A rmUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 2Z:lJJ7
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
9
the marketing data on THE ADVOCATE. A black and while 8 X 10 photo Ad costs S1,695, with color
exponentially higher.
The small readership justifies these pricey advertising costs almdu a111arge.ads.. especially color,
"are for variants of prostitution (oraVphone sex and "dating" services). While racial readersbip data is currently
being sought, empirical observation finds Dearly 100% white advertising and use: .AdYocate
Income runs roughJy 50% above the national average
68% to 70% percent are COllege graduates
28% completed graduate school
Almost all readers are employed
Almost all own at least one car, travel by plane four times a year and order drin..ks by brand
name.211
Ads for drug and alcohol addiction therapy appear regularly. No data was. found on the numbers
afflicted..
This limited marketing data
21
on the bargaining jXlwer of ADVOCATE readers. is largely sUpjXlned
by studying the growing body of homosexual writings and public policy decisions. For o::ample, while many
conservatives argue that failure to require AIDS parmer tracing is a glaring c:iLmple of gay bias, some
feminists have jXlinted to gay male misogyny in the failure to compel a rapist to be tested for AIDS.
IV. ADVOCATE "PUlLOUT'" CLASSIFIED! -rRADER DICKS"
Current ADVOCATEs carry two sections. Section A is roughly 90 pages of public policy, art,
emenainment, health and political copy. A few mildly acceptable sex "relationship' ads are included in Section
A which nongays would think were the only "sex' advertising. The publisher explained:
We divide advenising into "sexually oriented" and "Don-sexually oriented." The former
appears in [he main book while Trader Dick is a shopping center for more sexually
oriented advenising. We do not knowingly permit advertisements of.. .. material
involvihg peC'3Ons too young to know what they are doing or who have been coerced
into appearing in erotic materia1...(nor] things we have reason to belIeve are medically
harmful." (May 4, 1997: 5).
A & B: Uniqne Sex Structure Of THE ADVOCATE
In order to examine the promotion of AlDS-efficienl sex, a study of THE ADVOCATE finds what has
been called a 'schizoid' division in the press. Part A recommends -safe sex only" and pan B, instigates
anonymous, anal-oral sodomy and violent anal abuse to its consumers.
The "A" section - that which is generally seen by nongays.- bas urged readers since about 1m to
reduce gay promiscuity and in the 80s "safe sex" began to find A s.ection support.ln "A', April 21, 1976 THE
ADVOCATE presented a major article on J,lenereal disease. Publisher, D.B. Goodstein wrote:
In sex, as in eating or drinking, each of us must take personal responsibility for our
health .... (Although] the neglect of public health officials and medical professionals
have helped to contribute to the alarming spread of VD (:5, 14).
An "A" VD article by gay author, Randy Shilts (April 21, 1976) gave readers fearful Statistics; [hat
one half of American syphilis carriers are .gay; that gays are five times more likely to bave syphilis than
'!HE INS"1TnJl"8 FOR MEDIA RDUCAll0N
PO BOX 7-404 - ARLINGTON, VIRGIN1A 1ZlD7 'lm-ZJ7.S455
THE ADVOCAIT At THE GAYELLOW PAGES
10
straights with 150,000 gay men syphilitic.. Moreover, relying on the Kinsey 10% myth.. Shilts said every 30
seconds this year a gay man will contr:lct go no rrhea.. zz
Gay Uoronttaccpted.AD.al-Or3l Sodomy Continuity
Having said all this. -safe Sex Omy- is notably absent from the hundreds of thousands of prqstitution
and ads in THE ADVOCATEs -So sexually explicit section. These AIDS-
productive behavioral finding:; are supponed by data reported in Behavior Today, February 4, 1991 which notes
unprotected anal sodomy prevails - odm:ittLzl by roughly 40% of gay males and 66% of teen "gays" (:4). In 6
June 1991, 1"Iu Washington Tuna reported that two other studies admitted "up to 42 percent of young
homosexual men were found to engage in unprotected anal intercourse." Where do young boys ga AIDS?
The virus was found in 14.3 percent of 17-to-19 year olds-It was highest in the
youngest age group - the opposite of what we expected..... The trend is of
concern._.:".Jgh numbers of minority men still practice unsafe s.ex..
Prevailing an.a.l-to-<>ra1-AIOS sodomy aside, primary data identifies THE ADVOCATE instigating added
gay health hazards (0 individuals and society via socializing body fluids ingestion via enemas/feces and semen
(as in "PERSONALS" "w/S/s" "water sports" which is urine ingestion and the "scat scene" feces ingestion). And
while THE ADVOCATE prints every pornographic and scatological word in the lexicon, the word condom"
is ONLY found in the single AIDS safesex" ad placed by the magazine (see ?
Socia1jzinglIndting AIDS-E.fficient Se:r
.. Were gays 10% of 20-30 million J>eQple, their, major publication would not rely on a mere 70,(0)
circulation. With such a small population it is inevitable that ADVOCATE profits would largely derive from
whar unires this population - sex sales. This includes adult aDd boy prostitution and pornography sales. Many
gay activists bad written of the mafia control of their (especially see Jay and Young, 1978 and Hunter,
1972). JUSt prior to its recent collapse OUTWEEK warned:
the lesbian and gay press is heavily dependent on revenues from phone-sex [aural
prostitution] advenising .... OUTWEEK last year found that in the absence of phone-so:
many of the community's newspapers and magazines would simply go out
of business. (April 10, 1991: 26).
Therefore, Section A is now roughly 10-15 pages larger than Section B, the latter carrying between
1,000 and 1,.500 sex ads per issue. SectiOD B is the one which, OUTWEEK says, allows mE ADVOCATE to
continue publishing. .
Section B is a high color booklet between 7276 pages. In 1972 these sex ads occupied about 3 pages
of a 32 page press. By 1975 the section was a "pullout- for easier storage, reference and seclusion. Now it is
stapled in two places for fast removal from the A magazine envelop. The pullout section is the "heart" of the
magazine, both economically and sexually. Originally given a double-meaning tille, --rRADER DICKS" the
booklet is now called only -A PULLOUf SECIlON: nIB ADYOCAlE CLASSIFIEDS.-
In Section B THE ADVOCATE instigates prostitution deals via "ModelslMasseurs. Even in AIDS
1991, roughly 900 ads in one issue are for prostitution, with 525 of these for organized prostitutes (54% of
all sexually oriented ads). In addition to the over 500 professionals selling Illegal sex and violeDce, on average,
roughly 400 "informal- prostitutes offer anal-oral, and other sex services in the "PERSONALS section of THE
TIm INS'l'TI1.ITE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION PO BOX 7..f0.4 ARLINGTON, 7Z1JJ7 7&237.S4.SS
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
11
ADVOCATE. Over itS lifetime mE ADVOCA1E is pretimin.ari1y calculated as instigating SOO,<XXl anal-oral,
sexual solicitations. AIDS-efficient advertisementS.
While some of the latter 'ctisorganiU".d' sex offer.; appear to be freely given, most also involve illegal
financial exchange. In addition to these ads in nlE ADVOCATE PULLOUT sea:ion, nearly 100 aural (phone)
sa ads are displayed and almost double that number of bard homose::roa1 pornography is regularly sold. A few
bathhouses continue to advertise as do "penis enlargement- etc. While some ads are more frank
than other.; condoms are not sold to ADVOCATE gays. On this note, on page 8-58. April 23, 1991. THE
ADVOCATE announced:
I
WE TAKE MORE MEN TO BED nIAN ANY 01liER PUBUCATION IN AMERICAl I
1HE ADVOCA1E Cl.ASS1FJFOS.. _
1'HE lNSI'TI'tTIE FOR MEDIA EDUCIJION
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON., VIRGINIA "1Z1IJ7 7QJ..231-St55
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
12
v. MEIHODOLOGY
1. Prdiminmy SIwJy: Careful study of a cross section of homose:rual press and publications provided the
groundwork for the present investigation and instrument development. To determine
THE ADVOCA 1E as maiDSueam "typical," required in depth examination at the pro-homoscxu.al
professional literature as well as a study of similar iriforril.ation deUvety systems. With this in mind.
beyond the "GayeUow Pages., a random selection of two homosaual popular, high-gloss, male
homosexual magazines (OutwuJe iutd Frontiers) were reviewed for the prevalence of similar or different
cultural values and mores.
Among the homose:rual press: Outlin.es (Chicago), TM Washington Blatk (Washington, DC). Gay
Comnumiry News, Boston, Mass.., The Wu-consin Light, Milwaukee, WI, Bay Windows (New England)
and The Lavender Nawork, OR were examined for similarities and differences from THE ADVOCATE.
Our project "References" identify the broad spectrum of professional. pro-homose::rua.l literature
reviewed for this study.
2 DeYdopm.era Using standard conteD[ analysis merhodology a single "ADVQCAT'W
measuring instrument was designed, tested., refined and redesigned over several iterations until rhe
final instrument was completed.
3. Coding: Institute staff, trained in conte [analysis, applied the coding instruments to THE ADVOCATE
analysis. While most magazines ere coded by pen and pencil technique, a lap-top computer was
sometimes used at the Library of ngress, the data collected and their results downloaded onto the
main Institute computer te . 1 bard drive. Completed sheets were checked for accuracy,
completion and any initialed chan priQr to entering the data to establish distribution frequencies..
4. MatoU:ds: The final analySiS involves a ndom sample of two issues per year (including all publications
in 1972) representing all months a least 3 times for a population total of 56 magazines (a Significant
population of 1228 percent; 54% a these fulfilled 7,91) of roughly 446 magazines published. Selected
magazines were herein coded for enty-tbree key variables (July 5, 1972 to July 2. 1991) and the
results computed and entered in e database.
5. Distribution and ntemporary ADVOCATE issues held by the Institute were coded
on the premises and older issues ere reviewed on microfiche and coded at the Library of Congress
in Washington, DC. (0) 84/110, 92.
Ii buu-Rater Rdiobi1ity: FollOwing the se es of pilot tests and instrument iterations, the research instrument
was finalized. Trained Instituce s ff corers analyzed the 27 variables and inter-rater reliability was
computed at 0.87.
lHE INSITnJTB FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 74(W ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA ZZlD1 'J'Q3...2l7-54SS
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYElLOW PAGES
13
V1. SElECIED PREl..IMlNARY.ADVOCAn' FlNDINGS
THE ADVOCAT.E' as Honvw:mal CWtme
&me P1toto 'FQCD -CLASSIFIDES- "PUlLOUT'"
PHOTOS 1972:
3 pgs-to-l991: 76 pgs
Sa: 100 male
%
Race; 98% white
1% black
1% Asian (foreign underage)
-
Age:. 16% boys. 12to late teens
80% 20-30 years
5% 30-40 years
?% solicit teens (need to compare 72-84-91)
Photo Product
99% Sex Sales: as -dates" or as pornography
magazineslphoto/filOJ/cassette tapes _
51% 0Yert phone prostitution (1991)
Sample Physical Appear.mce (Nonadditive) -
4% fully clothed
96% upper body nudity - muscle display
79% hairless body
20% "boys" and teen youth cues
98% body-builders (boys excepted)
97% short hair
98% tough "straight" appearance - terms nsed are:
"Hot", "Sweaty" "Hunk" "Boy" "Man"
"Hard", "Fit To Be "Tied" "Bond" "Fast"
"Rough" "Obsessions" "Hardrore", etc.
"Young Guys' Play With The Big Boys
nm INS'ITIUI'E fOR MEDIA EDUCA'I10N
PO BOX 7404 ARlJNGTON, VIRGINIA 7Z1lJ7 '7Ol-n7-545S
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYEllOW PAGES
14
THE ADVOCAT.E as ~ HomoIc:%ual Cu.1nue
Basic F"Itao F JJCt;y "CLASSIFID ES- -PULLO tJ"r
PHOTOS 1m.:
:3 pgs-to-l991: 76 pgs
Sample Activity (NonadditNe)
16% holding or reaching for crotch
21% provocatively prone
Sample VIOlence Cues (Nonadditive)
15% torrure/brutality
05% nazi costume
16% blatant anal sodomy (98% assumed)
8% anal assault with object (ff)
r.
11% blatant child/teen sex explOitation
Sample Phallic Sm Obsession
12% claims of "hung" or well endowed
Oral Sodomy Aoxpted/PrOmoted
, .
100% photographically assumed
Sa: with "'Soaigh[ Looking" Model
98% photographically assumed, 5% dted
Multiple/Anonymous Partners Aa:epted,lPromoted
1
92% ' non-monogamous
Scatology Wanted.
90% photographically assumed
Disaimination Practiced
2% blacks - statistically unwanted
0% ~ f a t s or "fems" statistically unwanted
Condoms Advertised
0% sporatic appearance of 1 small condom ad in
later issues
TIm INSlTTUIE FOR MEntA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 .. ARllNGTON, VIRGINIA .. ZZ2In .. m.2l7-StiS
THE ADVOCATE &. THE GAmLOW PAGES
15
THE .ADVOCATE AS 1HE PREY AILING -socIAl.J2ED" HOMOSEXUAL CUL1URE
.Basic Print F act:r J972....91: Collapsing Ads from Im-1991: from 3 pages and 380 PERSONAL
ads in 1912 to 1,160 PERSONAL ads in a separately paginated 72
page "Pull-Out" - an ADVOCA1E cache-in-a-magaziDe by 1991
Sex: 99% male
Race:: 96% white
Desired: 2% black: (more uncommon: black wanting black)
1% Asian
1% Hispanic
Prostit: 58% Overall prostitution: agency and individual
(S)Age
Offer 20% "young" "boys" post '88 - late teens selling sex
:
Seeks 20% "young" "boys' teens sought for sex '
54% 20-25 sought for se:x
26% 30+, espec.. "financially secure older men'
Deal;
98 free & commercial sa: "dates, porno magazines, phone sex, photo sex, video sex, film
sex, etc.
1% permanent relationship wanted.
Seeks/Offers (Nonaddi[ive)
23% hairless body (as in a very young boy - including body shaving ads)
38% "boys" and youth cues
52% body-builders (boys excepted)
99% presumed to prefer 'straight" meo, no '(ems" 'fats'
98% want "white' male (1 % Black, Asian or Latin ok)
7% hairy male
Phallic aaims (Nonadditive)
32% :12'; tW; 9x61/r; bung; large or well endowed ...
8% 'uncut"; 'cut- (uncircumcised, circumcised)
4% wanred: '00 penis too large turned away; etc. ..
AIDS Eflicient Sex: Min.im.aI-To-Serions Injury (Nonadditive)
TIm INSITl1..Tl"E FOR MEDlA RDUCA nON
PO BOX 7404 ARUNGlUN. VIRGINIA ZZlITT
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYElLOW PAGES 16
11lE ADVOCATE .AS TIm PREV All..ING '"SOCIALIZED" HOMOSEXUAL aJLnJRE
lJasjc PriJtJ F IJCD 1972-91: Collapsing Ads from 1972-1991: from 3 pages and 380 PERSONAL
ads in 1m to 1,160 PERSONAL ads in a separately paginated 72
page 7ull-Out" - an ADVOCA1E cache-in-a-magazine by 1991
16% oral (ingestion of -oody fluids- eg. semen, feces)
.04% enema., diapers, soiled underwear, etc
.01% amputee, teeth braces, etc.
.04% amyl nitrate, etc: (drug use gen. accepted)
13% S&M; torture;brutalityislaves" and "masters"
5% nazi cosrumeJlanguageJS&M, whips/etc = 18% nazi cues
99% anal sodomy presumed - 1 % "Safe Sex Only" warnings
c
9% anal objectlff assault.: (13% S&M) = 22% anal injury
AIDS & 0TIiER SEXUAU. Y TRANSMII 11!U DISEASES
0% DO w:un.ing of arty SID but AIDS
.07% HIV - (no AIDS +)
.06% HIV + (want someone ..... am bealthY-)
..
1% 'couples" seek 3rd; straights" biJrnarrieds -wanted
1% seeks monogamous mate
0% " c o n d o m ~ requirementS, and SAFE SEX ONLY" by men seeking sex activity
nIB INS'1TIUIE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-04 ARl.lNGTON. VIROlNlA ZZ1D7 7aJ.237-s.t5.S
TIlE ADVOCATE &: THE GAl'ELLOW PAGES 17
VII. WHAT THE ADVOCA.TE REVEAlS AND CONCEALS
THE ADV0c.4TE reveals as mach about iis p ~ g gay CUJ'tca-al socialization in what it does not
show or say as it does in what it chooses to pubUcly encourage. For example, by avoiding reports, on gay child
sex abuse THE ADVOCATE implicitly blames "gay" victims, impeding effons to capture and punish pederast
offenders.'ZJ These data are in harmony with the notion of "boy lovers
A
and the gay call for an end to age of
consent in the 1972 AGay Rights ManifestOS"Z4.
The Condom Taboo
Moreover, in a full-page ad the most recent (July 16, 1991) ADVOCATE has begun to advertise penis
"toys substitutes (dildos) with suction cup plalforms, for men who are impctent or for other reasons.. And,
the same issue also sold a "fun" package, one of the 'fint ads to inclJJ.ck a c:.n(lom (p.49). NO condom" ads
appeared in the "A" (intellect) while only one (1) small photo and one (1) small print ad sold only condoms
in the "BO (sexual) sections. We found 110 sex ad specifying condom-user:r only. -
Note that the ad Play It Safe" is NOT for condoms. It is "for the man (or the girl) on the go!" This
suggests a bisexual consumer population, since lesbians have no need for condoms:
Easy to carry I fun
Great for gifts, travel, and your active life style!
Proper usage may help in AIDS & venereal disease prevention
"Kit" includes:
2 latex condoms wI nonoxynal 9
2 water based lubricants wI nonoxynol 9
toothbrush (disposable)
1 aspirin pack (when you're not in the mood)
2 antiseptic towellets (to clean up that mess)
2 joy jellies (for edible late night snacks)
TIm lNSlTIUI'B FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-404 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA '1Z11J7 103-237-$455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PA.GES 18
YIn. SIX BASIC.A.DYOCATE MEASURES
SOCIALlZING 'GAY- PUBUC POllCY ANDLAW: Attempting to create pride in and an advocaq
platform for homosaual culrura.l mOrality, eg: ending sodomy laws, etiminating age of alDSent and legalizing
all of "gay culture' nm ADVOCAm socializes gays as to how to reshape religion, SCI: law, health policies,
employment, education, entertainment, etc.
Believing that they represent roughly 20 million secreted Americans the 'gay rights movement" has
campaigned to identify homosexuality as a cultural norm. Indeed., recently a homosexual publication headlined,
"Making the Whole World Gay._ourwork._will only be finished when. .. we can say that the whole world is g;rt
(Gu.itU, May 1991: 6).:iS
The (ollowing addresses project findings on the "6 PREVAlllNG 'GAY' aJLnJRAL VALUES"
soci.alizi.ng 'a younger generation' found in a content analysis of THE ADVOCATE - 19721991.

ONE..- GAY SEX WITH "BOY LOVERS"
1
"Boys' 'dlicken" and are solicited and displayed se:mally in THE ADVOCATE.
Man-boy scis encon:raged by prevailing "gay" cu1ta:ra.l v.1lncs. 10-20% of
ADVOCA1E ads scrJUZlJy solit::itetJ within a 1argr.r pool of 58% prostitution
ad$.. Up to 23% of sex cnslOmers wanted. "hairless" or smooth bodies while 38% nsed
youth cocS ("boys" "yotmg- "son) to recro.it '"boy 1oYels."
Massive prostitution was an unforeseen finding in the ADVOCA TE. Its data diCtate that any discussion
of the findings on gay culture must address homosexual boy prostitution. Since prostitution is illegal it was
not that most ads in THE ADVOCATE were for paid sex acts.
Claims of asexual interest in boys for adoption and youth counseling (Big Brother, Scouts, school sex
counselor) are not supported by THE ADVOCATE data. On (he contrary, the evidence reveals a repeated
pattern from 1972 to 1991 of man-boy sex and "boy lovers' as a prevailing cultural gayJADVOCATE value..
Roughly 10-20% of ads since 1972 both blatantly and (post-1988) subtly, have solicited child/teen boy
entrapment.
JULy 14 1991. THE ADV0C4TE OICITES SEX WI71I BOYS
For fully 19 years (July 1m-July 1991) THE ADVOCATE has incited its readers into sa with 1>oy
Iovers
w
using American youths when legally possible and foreign youths when necessary. Ads (or Third World
trips often are accompanied by images ofwha( could be seen as -OOy lovers: Some argue that these repeated
ads confirm the need to aggressively recruit boys into gay life.
nIB INSITIUIE FOR MEDIA e:oUCAnON
PO BOX 7.04 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA Zl:11J7 7Q3-237.S(S5
THE ADVOCATE & THE GA.l"EU.OW PAGES
BOYS OF HOLLAND: HAWK PRODUCTIONS: 0W!r 30 bt!maiful )ODIg'
mm to bring Ioatb of pWmire (photo of boy Dhout 1 S-yt!an :33)
11lE IftJRKS: BOYS CLUB (Photo 37)
ASIA-OVER 5(J YOUNG lL4NDSOME MODElS (Two pbolos 0( boys: 51)
BOYS AND THEIR TOYS A Must for the Connoisseur of Male Youth and Beauty:
15 ... 15!! !.-.with an emphasis on dildo play" (Three photos of boys about 1S years: 59)
JULy 5, 1972' THE ADVOCATE INCITES SEX WII1l BOYS
19
The following are a of boy solicitations marketed in rl"iE ADVOCATEs mt recorded
issue: July 5, 1m on pages :37-38. All 1972 issues included scores of homose:rual films and all but two of
these used boys in the film as sex partners" for men. Due to the strengthening of penalties against adult sex
with children in 1984 and 1988, blatant boy sex enuapment found in the first ADVOCATE (1972-82) decade
are now necessarily subtle.
\Vh.ile illegal enticements to prostitute have rccenUy given way to st[cct solicitation of boys,
entrapment from 'neuual' play and study arenas and via difficult to trace computer bulletin board ads, etc,
the "18+" symbol which is now used in sex ads may be viewed as a technique for soliciting minors. There is
no indication that THE ADVOCATE validates the age of the 18+ advertisements or advertisers. The use of
such furtive symbols (for a fee) to designate sadism, anal assault, spanking, fat people and so on are part of
the magazine protocol
I
AlL OF TIrE FOILOWING ADS ARE FROM 7!Sm
I
'Dissatisfied at Home? Tued of hassling with parents? Lonely traveling exec wants
nice looking boy for penn. relationship and his heir. Offering fine new Fla home,
clothes, good time, no fin. cares or worries ... -Must be butch._No fats, fems,
hustiers .... Send photo.-
'Looking for yOUllg guy - 14-22 for fun times.
"Young boy ? - 18 wanted by sincere guy, 25 ... .1 have plenty of love for right boy.
Have my own pad. Love camping & the outdoors. Am well endowed. Send photo.-
'Pre-Teens - Girls or boys, nude ... photos, $5.00:
'Western Style Chicken: New sources - fresh from 4 of the world's great collectors ....
[A 'chicken is a boy used. for sex.]
'Want guys - The younger the better.
"Young Teens - Lonely .... White Male, mountain home, slim, gentle, warm,
wants._.young, slim, sensitive, white/teen boys or under ... fun, beach, travel, desert.
TIm INSlTIUJE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7.f0.4 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA ZZ11J7 7Q3..237-SlSS
THE .ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
"White bey 15-20 wanted.. Can adopt. White male, 3Os. Will provide home, career
for sincere, bonest boy."
Parents - white male, 42., would like to act as foster parent for boy to 14. Good
borne. care. "
-r.onely teen boys - up to 1eL.needing place to live..
"Will adopt young lad 14-17."
"Want 14-35 - "skinny guys. "
"Gay boys wanted [under]U/22.
Pfeen boys - meet young teen boys anywhere.'
lwO men in 20s looking for gay youth.
"Seek. .. white/chicano boy 13-16. Longhair orphan fine.
"Seeking Teen Youth who is lonely, lost, runaway ..
wW ANTED! Teen Boy to Bare Bottom SpankJSu-ap & [use anally]" [These last two
are samples from 8/16m: 38]
N01EAD FOR:
"GAY YOUTH GROUP - AlL GAYS
21 AND UNDER WELCOME"
["Socialized" by men, no age 100 young] (:38)
20
Moreover, while prostitution was not originally seen as part of the six hypotheses of homosexual
morality, up to 58% of ADVOCATE clients and advmisos involve zJu marketing of boys and or men as
As much as 38% of the ads involved youth cues, -ooys", "young", "youth", including customers
soliciting a hairless bo4y (like a young boy). Up to 10-20% of ads for boy prostitution are documented. Bey
abuse ir tJws TlOt accidenwi but an accepted - unchallenged - value in establishment gay culture.
ADVOCATE articles on "man-bey-love" have been uniformly positive. The Nonh American Man-Boy
Love Association is market- advertised in the 1990 "GayeUow while its bulletin, NAMBLA is sold a[
gay bookstores. Some homosexual magazines, such as Frontiers currently warn readers that police may entrap
pederasts and pedophiles who receive foreign -sexual images of minors" (March 1, 1991, C-46) through the
mail.
ADV0C4TE Advice
THE ADVOCATE ADVISOR, speaks in the editorial voice for both the publication and the 'moderate'
or 'ronservative' gay population. TheADVISOR has answered mail allegedly written by a boy worried aoou[
his possible homosexuality. The Advisor typically counseled the letter-writer to accept his homosexuality and
to meet wilh gays - not only olher boys - for supPOrL
nm INS'l'TlUlE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA ZZJJJ7 .. 7Q3.ZJ7-SolSS
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYEUOW PA.GES
21
An illu.m.inating example of what Herdt called "gay cultW"al bowledge" appeared in the
January 3, 1973 issue. The ADVISOR replied to a man whose strongest urges [are] to have serual relatioIlS
with young teenage boys":
l-:Don't fiddle around with a minor - DOt lOr monl ICIIIIOIIS, bat b Jq:aI 0D1- (:30) I
The materials found in THE ADVOCATE are viewed in the oontat of gay culture.. 111 tIriz SIJI.dy)pt'
found no objt:aiofl to clJiJdrrn 4J tJduJt saIUJl ptzT'lIIl!n. No JWn fowtd wItidI odJret:sed M:r Dbusr.
tTtIlDNJfot' and poiIrtt:d out thatyoutJu and drildrm art! 1IOt to odul13
etc., maJcing any rdmioru apIoitive prima jiM::iL
While the ADVISOR denied any moral reason to protect children from adult sema1 intrusion, that
same issue marketed child prostitution and child pornography along with a broad. spectrum of sadistic and
humiliating activities. These included: sets of piC't'l1reS of boys raoys in Bed:" "Teenage Sex" "Love Boys" of
beautiful teenage 00ys" and "Chicken Delight", etc. On the evidence, THE ADVOCATE - as the moderate
voice of the gay oommuniIy - instigates and recruits boys for sex with,adult men.
Ex: Navy Stud, S&M, Leather, Verso You Won't Forget!
Hung Like a Horse.
Let a Hot ltalia.n..Stallion Plow You Into Ecstasy
Well Endowed .... He.avily Endowed. ... WeU Hung
Hot, Hard Round Buns
Macho Top Dude X Large
Married & Novice Men Invited
NYC Porno Star: Hot, Hung Butch
Hot Buns/Deep Hot Throat
Craig & Skip ... Together or Separately ... Have Toys, Movies
Be a Rent-A-Man! Earn I Everywhere! Anonymity. Distretion
Huge Tools Discreet
Ojrnax Your Day With a Mind Blowing Hour
AIly sane/any time. Night or 'Day
No S&M. Out only
Hot, Horny. Muscle Stud: Humping Body, Wild Trip, Any
Time
nIB INSI1TIITE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA '1Z1Il7 7m-m-56S
THE .ADVOCATE & THE CUYELLOW PAGES
22
Black: Master - White Slave
Men For Trade
On this note, major gay bookstores cany pederast literature along with 'DlE ADVOCATE and ather
general gay offerings. For example. PAlDIKA: The JOW71Lll of Paedaph.iJ.UJ is sold in "I....amda Rising"-
Washington, Des, main gay bookstore. "Lambda Rising News" as recently as April-June 1991. had a full page
ad for "Erotica" using 'se:r/ photos of clearly teenage lads, "Euro-Boy #4, Euro-Boy :#5 and Euro-Boy #8-
(:19).
Out of the roughly 900 se::s.: act advertisements in this-publication (typical of cmn::nt
issues) only the following ad reflected my emphatic protection from AIDS or other
STDs; warning: WfIot Totro-F"1tlIl roaud butt & 1) SAFE-SEX ONLY."
Nearly a thousand ads both implidtly called for youngsters and/or enticed youthful readers into AIDS-
. productive sex 10 earn fast money in prostitution. No condom ad.s .
Jersey Fresh: Younger (18-21 yr.;). fresher faces with bodies to match. Serving NYC from S125 hour
20 Y/O .Angel. Pure, innocent looking ... .smooth body. Hot legs & butt! Near airport
SAD 0 MASTER; Uses ... fists to bring satisfaction to TITS, BALLS HOLES. Whine to Bruno.
Blond Hunk 10 Tool by 8" $120 in 5150 out
Former Anny sergeant, ends in climax S60 iD/S8O Out
Muscle Hunk. .. Hung thinkJ.,3/BB Extra big BB. In/Out
SEXY 20 YR OLD ... S150
Get A Grip on 11" X 7"
YOUNG GUY 23; Bi....hung & ready
European .... Large, Uncut And Hot. .. In And Out
TEXAS 22 y/o ... 9" and Thick Top only
HAND 'N FIST; FF. TITS, CBT, ere. Beginners Welcomed
nIB 1NSITI't..T1B FOR MEOlA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARllNGTON. VIRGINIA .. 'Z121:17
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
Orlando .... lWO full hands of uncut meat. You know you need it. Friendly but dominant
THE .A1JVOC.t1E-JANUARY 3, 1973
January 3, 1973, THE ADVOCATE displayed a close.up photo of a nude blind boy violently raped
(anally) by a nude man. The same issue also carried the following PERSONAL ads:
"Love Boys: 6 beautiful naked teenage boys" "Gay Youth Gconp" "Boys & Dogs" -reens
free gay listing service" leenage &x- "Boys in Bed" and "Chicken Delight" etc.
Since their first 1972 issue, THE ADVOCATE repeatedly gave e-";dence that "gay culture" was
dedicated to the public sale of naked boys for adult male entertainment. THE ADVOCATE also advocated
to its pederast constituency an upcoming business and personal opportUnity: .
"HELP FOUND BOYS HOME: I am founding a
boarding home for homeless and unwanted young boys
aDd need If you might lilce dDSI!
ouOOation with such a cause and would consider a
sig!ti:ficant co.sh or propaty COIIJ:ribvtion write: Box 24723,
Village Sta-, LA CA (213) (1/3/73:42)
THE ADVOCATE: ruNE 3, 1974
The next year, in June 3,1974 mE ADVOCATE displayed a bevy of photos of naked boys (genitals
covered). This issue also featured a gay bathhouse with a "YOUTH for "any BODY under age 25".
Scores of other such cultural child sex abuse features mvite and socialize pederasty. for ADVOCATE readers.
THE ADVOCATE offers S&M EQUIPMENr with which to torture ones sex victims, while they provide a
network for potential and current cb.iId molesters (:B-24).
"NEWSLEITER FOR PEDERASTS: .
Responsible persons, details, sample.
Better Life. 256 S. Robertson, Beverley Hills, CA 90211."
(:B-24)
No straight
W
American publication-is known to advertise Cor child sex abusers. Just below the ad Cor
child molesters THE ADVOCATE marketed -some small toys for play.
ntH INs-rrnrrB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 74G4 ARLINGTON, VIRGlNlA 2Z1tI7 703-237-5455
THE ADYOCA1E & THE GAY.ELLOW PAGES
"S4M EQUlPMENT: Dungeon equipment and SIfUIIl toys, racks,
pillories. whipping horses.. muJll restraining devises and novelties. ....
thoroughly field tested & guaranteed. Polaroid pictUreS.-Sl0." .
24
Oa:asionally THE ADVOCATE admits that some sman boJs -like the ones who would fit the "small
restraining devises" advertised above - have been violecL'Y ' raped :by -gays.- in July 3, 1972,
THE ADVOCATEs anonymous "Dr. RG" wrote that -WOOt gonorrhea" among gays was skyrocketing. "We
didn't used. to believe it existed." Hepatitis. he warned, "can be transferred by a simple kiss, sharing of a
drinking vessel, sexual contact. or a towel' Recall homosaual scholar Dr. Feldman had pointed out that
young boys do contract venereal diseases much easier than do adults.
ADVOCATE data reveals an awareness that youth are a) vulnerable b) easily prone to venereal disease
and c) generally used as the receiver of anal penetration. Despite this knowledge and tfust even in, 1972 anal
gonorrhea was known to be "now rampant' in the gay population, afflicting at least one in ten men, Dr. RG
reassured. ADVOCATE consumers that anal sOOomy was harmless. Dr. RG told ADVOCATE reat1.us that:
fistfucking is dangerous. I just saw a boy yesterday who had let someone [. words for brutal anal
sOOomy] and today he is in the hospital. It's going to take six months to repair the damage. I'm
sorry, the guy who did that is a criminal" (:6).
Dr. RG did not express alarm that an adult was having se:xwith a boy nor that the man was using the
boy anally. Dr. RGs public objection was that the man raped the child rectally withhis fist. causing obvious
damage to the anus. THE ADVOCATE ADVISOR, its ads for child prostitution and pornography and its
Penetrable Boy etc., establish its moral view of adult sex as proper with boys.
Until recent years when fear of aTTest led the magazine to employ the 18+ symbol, THE ADVOCATE
was a knowing participant in prostituting ch..ildren. As ads for children have slowed in THEADVOCATE, gay-
on-gay-bashing S&M ads appear to have increased dramatically. Such trend data will be available in the final
version of this preliminary report.
&ccu Ow.r-18 Ltrws
Soliciting very young boys for sex is a prominent gay cultural feature. Do to what THE ADVISOR
suggestS as repressive sex laws, THE ADVOCATE can not presently advenise sex for boys under 18.. However,
while the lowest age (publicly) solicited now is 18 years, the '18+" sign - says a 'gay" confidant - is a "street '
cue to younger boys that they are wanted by this customer.
The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (Child Pornography and Prostirution, 1987)
reported that runaways are "close to three quarters of a million children each year: They also pointed out tf1.at
even in 1977, wben THE ADVOCATE bad been marketing boy sex and pornography for five years, the U.S.
Senate Judiciary Committee found "child pomography and child prostitution [are] highly organized., multi-
millfon-dollar industries that operate on a nationwide scale. The connection with frequent complaints in the
homosexual literature that the gay bars are "mafia controlled- should be reviewed. Following this, a 1978
federal statute had prohibited the use of children in pornography (media prostitution).
nm lN5'ITIU.I'E FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 74(W ARLINGTON. VIRGINIA .. 'ZZ1JY1 703-2'$7-5455
THE ADVOCt1E &: THE GAYElLOW PAGES
2S
It has been difficult for the u.s. government to elimiDate adult-chi1d sex. After 1984 when the Child
Protection Act was passed only older teens were left as legal adult sex targets. This researc.h coded 18 and 19
year old teenage boys as "teens",
"I'M AG'.s NlM -UNDER 21- Jl&:a;nu,0ktim'1 EwJpatrdc
Especially related to the c:nrreut analysis, the National QUler for Missing CIlildren folly cited the
rea:>m.mendation of The Anorney General's Commission 00 Pornography (July 1986) which would prohibit
those under 21 from working in the sa industry, ReaJmmendation 38: "Congress showd enact legislation
prohibiting producers of certain sexually aplicit visual depictions from nsing performers under the age of
2I,-(:31) By the time the 21year-<Jld limit reached Congress however, it had mysteriously evaporated to under
the age of 18. This change was not due to a children's lobby which campaigned for the child's rigbt to
employment in the sa indUStry.211
Ads for "Young man wanted - 18 yrs and up' would suggest danger to all teenage runaways and
otherwise troubled youngsters. The data on gay males finds them continuing their AIDS-efficient scr activity
and this is even more disturbing among teenagers. In general, teen boys are used by adult'S as passive'
"bottoms" - receivers of anal assault, (the key cransm.ission for AIDS). Boys are not only more vulnerable to
adult manipulation. but. as Feldman noted., more suscepuole than adults to venereal diseases - especially
AIDS. And, the lack of condom sales is ominous for teenage fatalities.
Data reported in Behavior Today, February 4, 1991 notes unprotected anal sodomy is admitu.d bY'
roughly 40% of gay males and 66% of teen "gays" (:4). In 6 June 1991, The Washington Tmu.s reported thar
two other studies admitted "up to 42 percent of young homose:rual men were found to engage in unprotected
anal Where do young boys gd AIDS? . - . .
The virus was found in 14.3 percent of 17-to-19 year olds .... lt was highest in the
youngest age group - the opposite of what we expected.. .. The trend is of
concem. ... High numbers of minority men still practice unsafe .sex.
U 17 and 19-year-{)ld boys have AIDS, (with an incubation period of 5 to 7 years) these boys were
victimized when they were 12 14-yeacso{)f-age. There is nothing in either the mediClI cr even the
homosexual literature which suggestS that little boys give little boys AIDS. Adult gays infect little boys.
Because sexual obsession - especially for young boys - is part of the established gay "cultural knowledge"
passed on to "a younger generation" older gays have infected boys for decades aDd apparently will continue
to do so for decades to come.
n-m INS"ITnTIE FOR MEDIA EDUCA110N
PO BOX 7-404 ARLnolGTON. VIRGINIA ZZJ:IJ7 7Q3.237.S455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAm!.OW PAGES
26
"COruWms" as Taboo Throughoul19 YeaN oj Roughly 440,000 Sa Ads
THE SAFER
THE SEX,
THE BETTER!
THE ADVOCATE believes in and
supports informed personal choice
in sexual matters. During the AIDS
criSIS, we encourage you to
practice the safest sex possible. It
could save your lifel
CONSIDERED SAFE:
Hugaing. body rubbing
Maeuge
Social IdlY) kiasing
F8ntlllY
Light SIM Iwit:hout bleeding or
bruising)
Sex toy. (whon u.ed only on
yoursell)
CONSIDERED
POSSIBLY SAFE:
.AruII or In(Ol'ClllJfM wilCh
... \dl { ..... 01j
SUddnG jbut bttloro d,....u.l
w ........ "" I<lrtMNOI
CunnlJinou
CONSIDERED UNSAFE
Swallowod Bomon
Anal or vaginal Intercourse
wlthovt a condom
Waleraport. in mouth or on
.kln with .0 ..... or
Sharing IV neodl ...
Rating or rimming
Sharing enama equipment.
douchina equipment or
seX toy.
THE INmTUTE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
-A REMINDER: THE ADVOCAIE announcement in the 90s
(BOTH ANNOUNCEMENTS ACTUAL SIZE)
THE CONTEXT OF Safe Sex ADS: Directly across from The
ADVOCA1E "Safe Sex guidelines are ads for enemas, sadism, "kinky"
sex, an HIV + man who wants a "lean, younger, smooth aggressive top
to share the good life, and someone seeking young (lS+) ... bi men"
for sex, etc. (: 12). The data do not support the notion that the thousands
of men advertising prostitution services or unpaid sex adhere to the
Considered Safe" option. Moreover, as the ADVOCA1E does not
seriously market condoms, (even heterosexual pornography displays full
color, full page adds selling condoms in colors, flavors, etc.) this means
condom use is rare among adult gays. We found no sex ad which said
"condoms used, condoms only, etc.
CONDOMS
B<and nem ..... Free detail.:
PI..,,-nlng Amerlcana. Suila
lo45B Second-'ve.New
Yorl<,NV 10021 No
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 22207 703-237-5455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW' PAGES
THE ADV0C41E: AUGUST 13, 1975
Recall that May 4, 1977, the publisher o( THEADVOCATE explained that they did not show children
in the "sexually explicit" Pan B, and he said they will nOl advertise "erotic material [nor1 ads for things we have
reasons to believe are medically harmful?" (:5) Children dearly are shown" and sold T7r:ru rnontIu Toto, on
.Allgust 1975 (page 26) THE ADVOCATE sold an INFLATABLE: 'PENETRATABLE BOY DOLL'
On August 13, 1975 THE ADVOCATE marketed a blow-up boy "doll" to their (apparently many)
pederasts and potential pedjrasts. A half-page advertisement a young boy about 12-13-yeaI'S-<)f-age.
The nude boy. in silhouett leans back on his knees, buttocks tucl:ed under, head thrown back. hi$ neck: and
face directed upwards. The I offer leaves little to the imagination:
PENETRABLE BOY DOlL
A V AnABLE IN 3 PROVOCATIVE
POSmONS.
CHOSE THE MODEL THAT WILL FILL
YOUR NhhllS.

REALISTIC PENlS-S39.95

REALISTIC PENIS THAT VIBRATES
$44.95

REALISTIC PENlS THAT VIBRATES
AND EJACUlATES $49.95
ALWAYS UP AND READY!
Every doll Features: Durable, flesh-like, soft
vinyl body to yieid pleasure galore!

Penetrable open mouth (Deep Throat)
that works on the principle of air suction

Penetrable rectal area (Deep Ass)
HE CAN EJACUIATE AND VIBRATE
AND HE'S AlL YOURS TO LOVE.
Send money to BOSKO'S OSO
ENIERPRlSES, CULVER CI1Y CA, BOX
2988 90230 (:26)
nIB INS"I'TIUl'B FOR MEDlA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA '1Z1Ir1 103-237-s-&SS
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYELLOW PAGES
28
The significance of this "boy doll- ad, which was repeated in other issues of the magazine, caunot be
overstated. None of the subsequent issues printed an apology nor did any letters-to-the editor upbraid the
publisher and staff or threaten to cancel subscriptions.
While the above love doll mayor may not be -medically harmful- it is empirically asSUl7U!d thea
readers of TIME or NEWSWEEK, (equivalent mainstnam publications) would not permit a 13 old
"Penetrable Girl DoLr to so advertised. Such girl child abuse aJi.J are found in hardcore hetoosau.ar
pornography . .As THE ADVOCATE is 1M most conservative apression of the gay movement, its unabashed sale
of such a boy child sa abuse doll implicates rh.e larger society in antichiJd violence.
Near the "boy doll" were scores of child sex ads which youug boys (many now infected with AIDS).
would have seen:
VERY YOUNG GAY: w/m if you're lonely, unhappy at home and are afraid
to make your first move toward your basic needs, you must give yourself a
cbance to live ... wiU help right person with education and to meet others. (:24)
OllCKEN BONDAGE; Photo set of prime quality. Kids are Inventive,
WOW!....young Gay Loves Spanking.
Fresh Chicken .. . Fists Your Thing? .. Teens & Studs.
Millionaire wants young companion. (:29)
JAPANESE HOUSEBOY, Will train young man ... il yng man can meet aU
needs .... NUDE MODELS WANTED - under 25 ....
NUDE BOYS & MEN All types, sizes and Shapes. (:8)
FRESH CHICKEN! Chicken magazine; from Europe, USA delivery. Just in!
"Boy" (:5) "FOXY ORIENTAL-Looks 14" (:9)
(and) .... ANAL INTERCOURSE MANUAL AND PHOTOS (:7)
TheADV0C4TE also marketed for the GAY BATH HOUSE - often open all day and night, every
day and night, saying: "FREE LOCKER FOR 18 YR.OLDS: DISCOUNTS FOR "UNDER 21 YR. OLD,"
NeaTly Two Decodes of WPretty Boys-
Focusing on anal-oral sodomy of boys, THE ADVOCATE ran a cartoon of a nude boy who lay with
his backside up, an arrow pointing to the boys buttocks saying "OFFSHORE DRILLING" (:3).
A film series called: "Teenage Runaways ... the 'PRETTY BOYS' SERIES advertised 16 films. All 16
labeled as boys. In the same issue THE ADVOCA TE sold "official pollee handcuffs, double lock and 2 keys,
official police thumb cuffs, a ki,d whip (:8). Nearby is a photo of a naked man in a black nazi like-cap.
chained, bound, dressed in leather strips across his bare chest, advertising two sadistic fUms "BLACK
TIm INSTITUIB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 12JUl 703-237-5455
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYELLOW PAGES
29
AND BLUE S&M filmsw about children: "BOARDING SCHOOL HERO (CHICKEN RATED) and
PEDALING MUSCLES (CHICKEN RATED). (:7).
Across from this ad is a Chicken Bondage" ad, a "Southern Florida Boy," and a story on:
wSpanldng OF BOYISH MODEL, SHORT STORY OF YOUTH BEING PUNISHED, SPANKED BY
SCHOOL MASTER AT PRNATE ACADEMY." (:8)
Along with three other males apparently selling sex, THE ADVOCATE circulated a photo of
wJEFFERY: (nude, waist up) a boy about 14-years, no age given (:20). Beyond Jeffery, the naked boy doll,
the free bath house membership and the ads for boy prostitution like "COAST HOME FOR YOUNG GUY.
W/m (18 19 or yngr looking)" which promised youngsten a borne and financial5eC\lrity, scores of ads appeared
for wSLA VES WANTED" "SLAVE NEEDS MAS1ER" "BAD BOY needs to be spanked, young" "Young Guy
Loves Spanking" (:29) and the like. This is only August 13, 1975.
THE ADvoctT.E: MARCH 10, 1976
Briefly: the follOwing ads appeared in the same issue which carried an extensive photo story interview
with Dave !Copay, a famous NFL football player. Kopay had just revealed his hom.osexuality and he said he
did so becalllSe "younger people ... need to know the truth" about the nonnality of homosexuality.
"Chickn Lovers Will Help Runaway Youtiu
This same issue carried an full page ad citing the mythological Kinsey that at
least 10% of Americans are gay (the most recent NYC 1991 poll found 3% bi and gays - combined-
suggesting a high of 2% gays). In that same issue, alongside a scene of a film showing anal sodomy, a
homosexual filmmaker, Marc Stephens, requested that readers fill out a questionnaire so that he might make
better porn fi.I.ms. He asked if gays wanted more wS4cM, FF, B&D and group sex" and he asked "what role you
feel porn plays in gay (:3).
The Kopay issue also carried ads for wOo Go Boys.
NYC Joh for Runaway Male Youth. Earn while you learn, live
in. Send age, plwto to Box 638, Times Sq ....
Kid StufL.Scat, 4 b/w pics ... shows it coming out. .. w/s ... young
model (:4).
Like Chicken? You'll like Hennes! Each issue features
experiences, comments, art, poems, photos.
Spanlc.ing, Bondage, Stories, ... S&M story of a young
guy ... Bad student....youth being spanked., ravished by roomie
and schoolmaster at private academy. Photo5 ... mode) pants
down, tanned hide, red and welt-marked buns (:4).
CAmp CounseJa wanted 18-25 ... Pay is good. Have fun a.J weJ1. q
you have camping bod'1:rouNI, .... 303 Shady Ln. Joliet IL
60435 (:6)
s.F. CALL BOYS - get'em while their hOl_l80l) Just Inches.
$100 but worth. .. gOl it upstaini as weU as down (:6).
TIlE INS'ITl'UIE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, vmOINlA 1Z1JYJ 703-137-5455
THE ADVOCAIE & THE GAYElLOW PAGES
30
S&Mt Be informed.. Subsaibe lD-' montbJy [S&MJ DCWSIettec.
;6 S&M OIleadar 3$.
-BOY" FILMS: The Quality Magazine from
Denmark. .. Euromag. .. Life BoyH.BeaUtiful Boys of all ages
[photos of boys 6, 8, 10 years old. 16 different boy child
photos].
cr.JP sod SAVE 1HIS ADI!! We search the whole world for
fine chicken magazines ... passed US Customs.
March 24 mixed full frontal nudes of boys, with similar chicken ads" offering children. February 9,
1 rrJ7 an ad - placed often in other issues - read:
CIDCKEN! Choice Tenderlings of great bea1l1y! Golden peach fuzz on
tan cheeb, long eyelashes, that warm sun tan smelL. We offa you the
largest selection of Olick.en in tbe work1..Amsterdam [address]. (:9)
YOUTH J/O Film/Cheap Chicken I Why pay blackmail prices for
chicken material? We bought the entire Slack of BOY magazine ... (:lO)
Chicken Lover? Hermes is For You!
May 4, 1977, after the advertisementS for child pornography describing children, THE
ADVOCATE published a quarter-page photo ad for a film "Young & Ready" ... ."2 American buddies explore
each others young bodies from top to bottom .... Three California beach-boys ... in the prime of life in wild &
uninhibited scenes." The boys were a blond lad of about 14-years and another about 12 or 13-years, in semi-
nude poses with mouth at nipple and crotch area ... (:5)
Vectoring AIDS To Boys tuId SocieJ:y
Homosexual prostitution is recognized as an efficient technique to transmit AIDS - especially to boy
prostitutes penetrated without condoms. As ADVOCATE "Classified" ads sell sex while
they also promote homosexual bath houses, resorts, and the like. They promote anonymous, multiple
partner, anai-oral sodomy and condomless AIDS.
For an extra fee, THE ADVOCATE offers a series of logos to its advertisers which will attract readers.
These images are unique to the "gay" press. A body in a harness, tied, strapped, signals sadism (S&M). An ad
with a behind and a gage above reading "9" tells you at a glance that one can get "liot" anal sodomy here not
possible using "safe sex" condoms. An erect penis means the seller wants "active" sodomites, versus a horizontal
peniS announcing a "passive" sodomite. Toes beneath a scale warns that this person is fat and scissors show
if the man is "cut" or (circumcised or not), etc.
The logos instigate AIDS-efficient "hot" and violent (fisting) anal sodomy. Although the data find
nearly all active "gay" men suffering from a variety of venereal and other infectious diseases, none of these are
mentioned in THE ADVOCATE ads. Indeed, only _b6% of the sex solicitations cautioned that the advertiser
was an AIDS carrier. although the AIDS research suggests that up to 75% of the advertisers may be AIDS
infected. Writing in Are Gay Rights Right? (1985) Roger Magnuson, noted:
THE INSITI1ITB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 1Z1D7 703-zr7-5455
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYELLOW PAGES
Although homosexuals may be as small (some estimate Hl%) [note: this author still
reflects the false Kinsey data on homosexual population size - the figures tend to be
about 2%] of the U.S. population. they cany ...... gay bowel syndrome-, and
herpes .... over 44% of the nation's cases of syphilis, 51 % of gonorrhea of the throat,
and 53% of intestinal infections. Forty percent of homosexual admit [0 a gonorrhea
infecr::ion. ... 78% of homosexuals had had at least one se:rually transmitted disease- (:19-
20).
31
At any time the notion of easy money has appeal to both youngsters and to others. This is especially
the case when jobs are scarce. For some boys and men the lure of speedy sodomy with a few customers would
be almost irresislible. White gays are known to be an economically adwntaged population - and one whicb
is willing [0 pay large sums for sexual access 10 marrieds, bi'g and gtraights.
This Is discussed further in the section au enlrapment of str.dghu. For now n<Jttl lhat The
ADVOCATE does not discriminate against calls for "stnlights, bisexual or married men, so that it is facilitating
the spread of AIDS as well as other debilitating and lethal sex: diseases to warneD and to the general society.
Each issue carries roughly 1 % of sex ads appealing to nongays.
\
Moreover, since 1975 the magazine presented medical warnings about the above sexu.ally transmitted
diseases, and stated bluntly that these were due to the promiscuity" of SO many gay men (at 500 sex
one's health is sure to deteriorate). Yet, despite the roU knowledge of the publisher and staff regarding the
causes of these deadly diseases, the magazine seils condomless prostitutes and helps broadcast the fatal disease
of AIDS.
It may be helpful to conclude this section on sodomy, child prostitution and youths, with a 1948 qUOte
from Morris Plascowe, past Magistrate of the Magistrates' Court of New York Ciry:
Sodomy is one of the most severely punished felonies on the statute books .... Yet
arrests and pTOset::utions for sodomitic acts between adultS are rare. For example, in
ten years from 1930 to 1939 arrests for this offense averaged. only 139.6 a year in New
York City, which. has a population of over seven million. 100 gear majority of these
arresrs are based on ads of sodomy irwoIving juveniles and and db not
concern the sotUJmy of aduJJs. TI
A preliminary review of nationwide sodomy cases during the 19305 tends to support Magistrate
Ploscowe's observation that sodomy .laws were tools for the capture of adults wbo were vjctimjzing boys. New
York boasts the nation's largest homosexual popnlation
23
and the literary and arti';lic evidence suggests this
to bave been true during the 30s when New York was the nation's cultural bohem(an center. Hence, with a
seven million population, 12 arrests a month foe sodomy (only 3 arrests a week) tells us that the sodomy laws
seriously helped. in controlling homosexual child abuse (pederasty) from 1930-1939.
For his book, Sexual Behavior in the Human Male (1948) Dr. Kinsey had taken lengthy inteIViews of
roughly 1,400 imprisoned sex offenders. In hindsight, it seems that many of these men were incarcerated for
rape of women and girls or for sodomy with boys. This puts a different spin on Kinsey's whirlwind national
TOur of politicians and legislatures posl-1948, when he and hi! team campaigned to eliminate sodomy laws and
ro establish early parole ror sex oJlcmJcr:i.
TI-JE INS'II1'Ull! FOR MrIDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLJNOTON, VIRGlNIA 'lZ!ff1 7U3-231-5455
THE ADV0C4TE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES 32
Because of Kinsey's massive influence in terminating state sodomy laws it would be useful to discover
whether the goat of his team's legal sodomy crusade was to allow private sodomy between men - which was
rarely punished - or legal access to sodomy with boys. The analysis of THE ADVOCATE finds not only an
obsession wi1h youth and sa (sodomy) with young boys, but -gtly-M-gay bashing" - cnulty to gays, l1y gays-
which would brutaliu the most allegMJy "gay- population - young bays.
Concluding this review, the data do not support the claim that boys are as safe with homosexual as
with heterosexual males. When ADVOCATE juvenile prostitution data aCe considered together with the data
on gay male boy sex obsession and sexual obsession in general, a scholarly forecast would suggest unacceptably
elevated rates of boys sexually victimized by males.
The rate of 1 in 4 abused girls and boys suggests a worst-case scenario of 1,225 boy.s victjmj7ffi by gays
to every 2S girls by beteroseIuals. These data arc supported by the scholarly literature which finds
abuse of boys, "five times greater than the molestation of young girls- with a mean number of one
offender molesting 1SO.2 boy victims compared to a pedophile offendec moJating .19.8 girl victfms..
Blatant child pornography and child prostitution are dominant features of Wgay culture" as displayed
in THE ADVOCATE from its initial July 1m publication date to July 1991. The editorial position reflected
by the ADVOCATE ADVISOR and its advertisers, invites and favors man-boy sex. Criminalizalion of
homosexual copulation - sodomy - acts as the main control society currently has to restrain homosexual
abuse of boys.
1MB INSI1TIJ1:E FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
ro BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 'ZZlIJ7 703-737-5455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
TWO: GAY-ON-GAY VIOLENCB
2 WG3y-()n-gaJ vioIence
W
is instigated in THE ADY0C.41E as "spanking-
-S1aYcs wanted
W
etc. - and is thus IargcJy modoncd by prevailing Wgay" mltural
woes. FlItdiIrg: TOIlghly of ADY0C4TE M!r I1JIb snIicjtM or pronU.r#:d
bnmJlity, IIIImilistioII, Wgay-otI-t:aY btuhiIt(' or otIr6 fomt.r SI!ZIUIl inftoy..
33
The ftstraigbt" world had long rejected the Idea that brutaUty held a legitimate place in sexual relations
between women and men. Therefore, the nation responded positively when homosexual advocates ca.1lcd for
"hate crime legislation" to punish -gay-bashing.- It seemed fair to those outside the homosexual culture that
gays likened -gay-bashing" to Jewish and black fears of religioWl and racial brutality,
However, an examination of ADVOCATE sex ads found sexual violence solicited in roughly 13-22%
of ADVOCATE -Personal" ads biweekly from July 1972 to July 1991. Moreover, much of the solicitation takes
the form of illegal ads for prostitution, further complicating the nature of the violence.
"SLAVE WANTED, DOWNTOWN &P." "1HE MAD WELDER"
has the very best equipment built from leather, lumber, iron & steel,
shackJes, collars, whips, restraints, chains, stocks, brands, hoist
systems, racks & other Ihings for den or dungeon .... A $7.50
catalogue provides new devices for periodical up-dates. (7/5{l2: 37)
MALE SLAVE MARKET: JOE'S LESSON: A muscular young beauty trained for Slavery. Hard rope
bonllage, dominatioD. 1 hour color video. ('I1lis 3d. acmmpanJed by a pboto ot a youthlDl nude male.
strung up by his hands, gagged and bound) (7/16/91: 53)
In an interview on serial rape-murder, Robert O. Heck, chief police investigator of the Office of
Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, U.S. Department of Justice pointed out that many such victims
have been minors, usually young boys.30
The consistent solicitation of children (young!youthlboyl teens) is associated :with the planned brutality
of sadism (euphemistically defined as S&M"). Police reports nationwide confirm Heck's observation that
young boys are tortured, even murdered, by sadists who have recruited them via ads, or via street solicitation.
Beyond Dr. RJs testimony about the rectal battery ofa young lad who might never fully recover, rape-
murder of these boys too frequent occurrence, Once his youthful slave" is immobile, having earlier agreed to
be tied by rope or chains - some pederasts have killed their boy victims.
11m INSTITUTE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA Z1:lJf1
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYEUOW PAGES
34

SEEKS SLAVE. .. WANTED YOUNG GAY MASOCHIST IN TEENS"
"SLAVE WANTED" SLAVE WANTED- SLAVE WANTED, SAN DIEGO
"SLAVE WANTED, S.F." "DO IT YOURSELF SLAVERY- SLA YES WANTED"
"NEEDS YOUNG, GOODBOY SLAVES ... WHIPS, CHAINS, WATER,
TORTURE, PAIN ROPES, HANGINGS"
"LIVE-IN SLA VEBOY W ANlED-
"WELL BUll.T SLAVES WANTED"
"ENGLISH NOVICE SLA YE"
"EXPERIMENTING? SIM OR?"
"CHICAGO SLAVES W
"SEEKING TEEN YOUTH - FF WANTED UNDER 25"
"CAGE WANlED FOR ONE OR 2 ADULT SLAVES"
V/OLENI ADS APRIL 23, 1991
Of roughly 400 April 23, 1991 7ERSONAI...S, the follOwing ad was cameoed, center page and boxed
on page 5:
AD OF THE ISSUE:
Who wanlS to watch me make a fool of myself by aawlin around naked in a big mud-hole out
in the COUDUY? I want an audience to laugh Ie: mock. Am very masculjne madlo well-builL The
more the merrier, bring ur friends. rn provide the beer [Teas].
On the evidence, neither bLacks Dor lc::ws solicit personal violence. Neither The News nor Jet
or Ebony, etc., can be sbown to have printed ads soliciting and insullS from Jews, bbcks or other
intere.<;ted parties. A reasonable question is, can one compare racial and religious violence -with its chronicle
of mutilations and cross-bumings of Jews and blacks - to a people who publicly solicit violence
roughly 500 times per gay magazine per month annually.
On the other hand, there is no record nor any complaint expressed in THE ADVOCA TE regarding
gay males who harm young boys during the S&M rituals to which the children are on record as subjected. This
view of hoY" as object5 for men's sexual violence is seen in the child pornography and child prostitution
culture. Some number of gays being "bashed" will have 10 be men who 8re engaging in illegal conduct which
got out of hand. Or, the "hate crime" may be entrapment July 16, 1991, the AD OF THE ISSUE:
TIlE INSTIT1.J1E FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA ZZlffl 103-Z37-54SS
THE ADVOCATE &. THE GAYEILOW PAGES
.AD OF THE ISSUE
Getting Arrested TURNS ME ON!!! .... Activist Dookie is for mel I dig those multiple bod piercings,
that antma1 odor of old leather jackets .. ..and cool tattos. rve been arrested 5 times and each time I
get an erection when I think about taking the streets shoulder to shoulder with some buzz-cut
warrior/Stud. Apolitical disco-wimps and body-doll gym blow-ups C3l1 go the concentration camps ... !
have a HUGE EAGER ROD for the right hell-raiser. Pix or no answer! (:9)
35
On this note, an aUeged antisemitic "hate crime- has recently been traced back to the accuser. The
alleged now appears to have painted antisemitic graffiti on his own home in order to collect $31,000
in insurance money. (The Washington Post, July 17, 1991, B-1) Such misrepresentations would be a small
concern among gays who claim abuse by 8straighrs."
The finding on boy prostitution corresponds with stories in THE ADVOCATE about gays who were
murdered by (sexually abused) boys. The foUowing story about a -Gay Slave Auction" should contdbute to the
dialogue on "gay-bashing."
The Apri121, 1976 ADVOCATE included several photographs of the police raid on a common event;
a gay torture/slave auction. The photo shows several people (age and sex unknown) in black leather "S&M"
straitjacket devices from head to toe, chained in a row, being led away by police. The reporter described the
arrest scene:
40 auctioneers, buyers and slaves in cbains ... .It was a charitable event with the
proceeds to go to the Gay Community Services Club, and the slaves were au
volunteers .... [Tickets were sold through] wleatber fraternity and "buyers would
own tbe slaves for 24 hours to do with as they wisbed Slave 1 [had] a leather
bood. .. over his head ... [his hands] handcuffed behind his back. Clips were attached to
his nipples and twisted, wrists shackled, a cHp ... attacbed to his penis .... Slave 2 [was]
handcuffed, slapped, kicked .... amyl nitrate was given another .... [AlI] were paraded
through the crowd (:13).
The crowd of gay men "hooted, beat the gay "slaves" burled insults at them and generally
debased and injured the willing victims. Jeane Barney (a one-time ADVOCA TE ADVISOR) bought a woman
slave" (apparently the only woman). Barney said it was all in the "spirit of
In the United Stoles, -Slavery if a Felony"
THE ADVOCATE explained that the arresting officers mistakenly believed "most gays would thank
because the police tlwughJ the S&M folks were a "perverse, dangerous minority." "Slavery is a felony"
said onC officer. Can a slave say "no" when he would like? By definition he cannot. In this country, said the
officer, no one can be enslaved, voluntarily or no, even for five minutes.
urn IN:>ITIUIE FOR MIIDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA .. rasn ..
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYELLOW PAGES 36
THE ADV0C4TE disagreed.. They felt their culture - which legii:imizes prostitution, the
sexualization of violence, masters and slaves - was dealt with unfairly. THE ADVOCATE treated the battery
of these " s l a v e ~ men, boys, and women, and the insults poured upon them by their gay mates differentially from
similar abuse by nongays. Moreover, as the nation becomes more aware of the level of "hate crimes- against
police officers, some critiQi argue that since gays advertise for smuzl violence [rom police, miJi.tary and Olher
"tl)Ug/I" males in ads, gay claims of police abuse an questionable.
Last year, 146 police officers nationwide were killed in the line of duty. In that same
period 71,794 officers were assaulted on the mob, an average of nearly 200 a day.
More than a third of them sustained what the FBI categorized as serious
injuries .... about 70 police officers are seriously hun on the job every day of the week.
1'M Washingron Times, July 16, 1991
There are no data which suggest that pollce officers, as a culture, solicit violence from others, but
rather the data strongly suggest that this population attemptS to avoid personal harm. Yet, violence against
police officers increased -11 percent over the 64,251 reported in 1986." There has been a 63.3% increase in
"serious injuries" sustained by police from 1986 to 1990. It bas been proposed that a "gay culture of violence"
shares some pan of blame for the overall growth of violence nationwide - alongside the drug and pornography
culture.
It has been argued that as lbousands of gays '"iDstitnl:ionally- solicit and eDalnrage P'J abuse,
punfsbmenu against abuse by ooogays \baShing") are disaiminatory. That is. gays rarely report gay-oo-gay
torture, harassment., rape, ~ S&M gang rape, known to be fairly common among boys and men who are
pick.ed up at bars and who go the bomes of strangeI5 for sa. The argument has been that to repon gay-on-gay
assault risks rejection and funher abuse by the gay community.
Most violence against blacks is black:..oo-black crime. Critics would point out that the daLa on gay
bashing suggests the same thing - that most violence against gays is gay-on-gay crime, and that having police
arrest only "straights- for violence against gays is like having polire arrest only whites for violence against
blacks. If the law is to be applied at all, the argument goes, it must be applied equally. Thus, socializing slaves,
masters, brutal assaults, etc., encourages violence, leaving the question open: is this instigating hate crimes?
TIm INS'lTIUll! FOR MEIDIA IIDUCATlON PO BOX 7404 ARLINOIDN, VlllGINlA 7ZJJTI 7IB-217-S455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAl'TILOW PAGES
37
THE ADVOCATE centend and repeaud w "I want an lILI11imct! to laugh &: mock me- ad on the first
page of its PERSONALS- - as iu "AD OF THE ISSUE.' The following are a few of the April 23, 1991 ads
appearing on W SQJ1U page 5:
Wanted AggaessiYe, Uninhibited, straight..acttng levi-dad, 18-25 stud with a huge
supply of natural gas to fulfill aggressive date fantasy for generous W/executive,
3O ... forcing me into submission... Reply with photo, phone.
YOUNG LOVER WAN'IED FiIiancially secure, 30 yr old 21M professional, seeks
young (18-20) male for live in relationship in NW Pta beach town. College or work can
be provided. Prefer blond, smooth ... versatile. Send photo ...
DADJMENTOR Dynamic. hndsm. successful &. manied. .. seeks gorgeous yng man in
exch for educ & career, you commIt to monog relat with busy exec, 18-25, sexy .& Intel
AUSIRALIA CAlLING AK. AmpUlee:s-1 mold belp the right guy visit
downunder_photo (on jOur crutches if possible).
18 slim & smooth with hot tight butt needs dominant jock couch ciat or cop to take
me over.
Medical professionaL.seeks blthy men. I work natiomride..
Like mature men? UB VIC, 5'9- 18-21, free college.
HOT 2S YR OlD TOP. Looking for friends 18-30 for ???
Sks smooth, slim, passive, matue little brother, 18-.22 (or frndllover, no smkg. or drgs.
As gays admit to desiring sex with "straights" and soliciting harm from them, critics point out that
ordinary meu may sometimes be innocently entrapped to serve gay sexual-violent ends. The same April 21,
1976 "slave arrests" issue advertised a gay film, "Do Me Evil" which glamorized prostitution for a young boy
of about 16:
Rodney had everything an All American boy could wish for. A jealous brother, an
insane mother, beautiful cars...and few discriminating customers (:29).
Another gay (not pederast) film called Prison Rape" took pleasure in doing violence to boys
who were:
raped 60 limes a day one weekend in a Washington DC jail ... Jt begins jn ... schools and
orphanages where boys as young as four years of age are forced into submission (:9).
'The GayJPederast and Murdo
One of the most disturbing discoveries in this study of the Advocate was the manner in which the
advertisements and the magazine treat the male body. Advertisements for the "Meal Market", "Back Door
e
,
and specification Of body pans such as BB (bubble butt), and especially "well hung", "large tOOl", "hot rod",
TIm INS1TIUf'E FOR MEDIA IIDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 1Z1D7 7Il3-mS45's
THE ADVOCATE &: TflE GAYELLOW rAGES
8" by 5",9 lrr by 6", 9"-thick" and the like, contnlmte to the impression that boys and men are pieces of body
parts - each separate and utilitarian, each independent of the penon.
While this view of the human as many body parts exists in heterosexual "straight- pornography,
nowhere is the dysfunction more extreme than in gay pornograpby - inclu.ung The Advocate. Such
pathological arousal to pieces of the human body is found in every magazine issue from 1972 to 1991. The
kinds of rape-Murder-mutilations so typical of gay serial murderers tend to reflect this "body part" obsession.
As this monograph was being completed, the press reported on another gay serial-rape-murderer-mutilator,
Jeffrey L. Dahmer. Dahmer's home was found littered with decapitated body parts and photographs and
drawings of mutilated dead bodies." The gay press made no connection between the body parts. the photos
and drawings, and the fact that the suspect had been dted for indecent exposure in 1982 Apparently, shonJy
thereafter, he was also convicted of "offering a 13-year-old boy $50 to pose for nude photos. He served a year
in jail and was placed on a 5-year probation. (The Washington Post, 24 July 1991) The New York Times
reported that: "The police said the victims were black men." (NIT, 24 July 1991, A14)
The New York Times, covering tbe same story also noted that the body parts belonged to black
victims - but there is no information regarding the ages of the dead. This newest mass murder-mutilation
follows an ever increasing pattern.
John Gacy of Indiana raped and tortured to death 33 boys and buried them in
basement. Randy Steven Kraft drove around the freeways of Los Angeles picking up
young men, whom he then drugged, sodomized, tortured, killed and mutilated ... :l have
never seen a serial killer who is a happily married family man, or who had a long-term
successful relationship with a woman' .... says Bob Ressler, a former FBI agent who
was a leading figure in developing profiles of serial Killers at the FBI academy in
Quantico. (Sunday News, Lancaster, PA, June 9, 1991)
Ga(..'Y had raped, tortured and ldlled 33 boys and Kraft drove the LA freeways to pick up boy.; who
be sodomized, tortured, killed and mutilated. As noted earlier, Robert O. Heck pointed out that boy rape-
murders fill the police records_ The fact that THE ADVOCATE neither reveals nor vocally condemns the rape-
murder of boys - but that it instigates boy rape in films and prostiTUtion, further implies what some have seen
as a worrisome overlap between average gays and pederasts.
For example, in the "Prison Rape" issue, THE ADVOCATE also reported on the death of a famous
gay Italian filmmaker, Pier Paolo Pasoline - murdered by a 17-year-old boy. However, the magazine purged
infonnation about the sexual abuse the boy was said to have suffered at the hands of the 53 year-old filmmaker
in the making of a brutal film, "Sal0 .... an S&M film .... version of De Sade." (:13)
In June 1991 a murder was reported in Milwaukee, Wlsconsin of a gay man "By Openly Homophobic
Attacker" Milwaukee's homosexual newspaper, The WISCOnsin Light said, "Keven Dutcher was stabbed to death
in his kitchen by Stewart E1lanson who [his] young age, had been a frequent resident of alcohol rehab
centers." Enanson aUegedly told the police ftI wanted to kill this fag. My whole life is devoted to killing faggots
and child molesters." The young man was apparently in the apartment as Mr. Dutcher's guest (June 26, 1991
:1)_
When women and girls are raped and murdered in this fashion the press generally identifies how
victim and offender knew each other - where and how they met. Research is needed regarding who really
batten; and murdcn; gays. Such research would need to examine the possible role of adult child abuse victims
1lffi INS1TIlJ1E FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 1Z1I17 703-ZJ7-5455
THE ADVOCATE &, THE GAYELLOW PAGES
39
and/or boy prostitutes who kill -faggots and child molesters.- Dr. Huffman, a well known gay AIDS advocate,
was charged with "sexually assaulting two male patients. The patients, both apparently straight, allegedly bad
been given pain medication intravenously. Each man found Dr. HutIinan tried -performing a sex act on him..
Huffman was Medical Director of the Brady East SOT Clinic. The press report did not express alarm that a
physician may have victimized incapacitated patients. violaled their trust and even possibly infected them with
the lethal AIDS virus. This scenario will be referred to later when we address the entrapment of
males.
31
THE ADYOCAT.E MURDER; April 9, 1991
Statistically, more boys would be killed by pederasts then vice versa. THEADVOCATE (April 9, 1991)
wrote about a routine encounter leading to the death of a well known gay, a Bon Vivant who,
like Dutcher and Pasoline, was "beaten and stabbed- (:34). The press said the suspect, a "drifter hung out
with the boys at bus stops wbo patiently waft - but not for buses .... where prostitution
transactions are decidedly working-class. the boys still remember .... [him as] just trying
to make it out here like the rest of us.'
THE ADVOCATE showed no concern Cor the suspect's liCe as a boy prostitute but worried he might
get released by claiming:
mat he was forced to kill Henderson to fend off a sexual attack. ... invaluable to ldllers
of gay men in the past ... .a grand jury refused to indict a murder suspect when it was
revealed that he and the victim had met in a gay leather bar (35.37).
6,5()()ADVOCATE "Hate Crime ADS (1990) vs. Nationwide "Hale Crimes"
OUTWEEK, April 10. 1991, revealed that Boston, Minneapolis, St.Paul, New York City, San Francisco,
Los Angeles and Chicago reported,1 If "hate crimes" in 1990. from "harassment" to threats."
However, of ADVOCATE ads, during the same year encouraged roughly 6,500 intergay "hate crimes"
(about 540 abuse ads per month) including "harassment" "torture" "yubal insults" and other incitements to hann,
in its "Models and Masseurs"
Were all ADVOCATE intergay sadism encouragements recortkd as instigating "hate crimes" the paper
would be responsible for roughly 6,500 intergay hate crime promotions in 1990 (not just 1,588 allegations covering
millwf1S of citizens in seven major scates). Also, many of these same "hate crime" ads appear in other gay
publications. It would be useful to know how much more "intergoy" violence is annually incited by the gay press?
In April 10, 1991, OUTWEEK reported on gay hate crimes against gays:
Lamda is now being attacked and picketed. Its offices, its staff and volunteers
lhreatened .... Why have these 'queer activists' attacked only the two lesbian and gay
groups? (:22)
It may be confusing that 8 queer activists" are gay-bashing lesbian and gay groups. In the same issue
of OUIWEEK, a lesbian angrily noted that gays were bashing lesbians working on women-with-AIDS Issues:
1HE INSTfIUIB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 .. ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA .. 2ZJIJ7 718-23'7-5455
THE ADVOCATE THE a4YELLOW PAGES
Since the commencement of serious barassment - including. but not limited to.
threats of physical violence and threats against my life - coinciding with the beginning
of my publlc dissent against the tactics used toward other ACf UP members by
members of the 076 working group, rm not going to use my name. (:8)
The April issue also reponed from the co-founder at the Gay Male S/M Activists on the promotion
of sexual violence to gays bashing) and to the larger society (sexual violence):
For ten ,cam. GMSMA. and LSM [lesbian sadi51s] bawe e4vcafM, aptainr4,. Detwol'ked,
caused and marched to c:omey die rnessaF' that safe. sane, mllflC'DSJl81 SIM is sometbjol to cherish and
support, DOt fear_ ADd to a peat edeDt we haYe snmeeded We baYe brought SIN out of the doseL-tbc
of S/M-Complaining that tbe broadec aa:eptaDce of SIM taU:s the fun out of it is like
mmpIaining that uniYersalliteracy debases lit:el3ture or that demoaacy debases governa.oc.e [sic)_ (:5)
OllTWEEK, like THE ADVOCATE instigates sadism ("I want to surrender control" and -Leather a
musL.to put me in my place") as welJ as 1991-style teen prostitution, "19 "19 .. .Iooking for an older man
(23+) who can heJp me find the way" and general prostitution "HUNG 9"+ THICK" "tight buW etc. (:87-95).
SOCIALIZINGJENCOURAGING GAY Intergay BASlDNG/SADISM/HUMILIATION
BRUI'AllTY ... Attractive w/m 28, sics extreme masochist u/35 - any race, who seriously wants violent,
brutal pounding, no holds barred. Should be reasonably well put together & able to take excruciating
pain on aU parts of the body. Heavy scenes only.
Sample 0treriDgs from "MODELSIMASSEURS: April 23, 1991. P 62:
S & M PLAYROOM, FFaLeatheraGear*Mirrors*CBT*Training
S/M Daddy, Most scenes & F!F Playroom
You Need What I Got**HOT, HUNG MUSClEJOCK. ITALIAN 9 l!X'
HAND "N FIST, FF, TITS. CBT, ETC. Beginners welcomed
Discipline Given by towering rock-hard Blond/blue muscle stud with Fun leather & toys [sadism]
19 Inches Double trouble: 2 muscular horsehung studs.
TIm FOR MEDlA IIDUCAnON
PO BOX 7404 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA 7.Z1I17 703--2375455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
41
Offerings from Page 60 include:
FIF, Enemas. PLAYROOM WfIH SUNG, MATIJRE BLOND. SAFE, 2ND AVAIlABLE
AIL YOU CAN EAT, 9 1../1.- X r
Jersey Fresh, Younger (18-21 yrs) fresher faces with bodies to match. SeIVing NYC from $l25lhour
Black Top 24 YR.S. f/, 180# HUNG
GERMAN MUSCLE MASTER, rn, 123# HUNK
Sample Prostitution Solicitations from Page 64:
MAJOR DAD: Arrogant uniformed army man administers corporaJ./Verbal punishment [phone #] 3rd
also = Phone sex & photo sets $25 VISA
Hot Cop BB. ... Massive muscle .... Inunediate response.
StnLigbt dude into videos & service. Big thick 8 112: plunger, hairy, muscular, hung & serios. $100.
8 1!l X-TIna INCHES OF Manmeat need spilShine $110
Hot leather rubber stud has London's best playroom SIM, BID, C/Brr, Trr, FIF, WIS, cage, sling, etc.
Adam [phone#].
Prostrate Massage and/or enema
[porn Star: Dolph Crawford. [Pg#]
I
College Joeb [phone #]
Hot and Filling Italian-Eat in or to go
Conclusion
Intergay, gay-an-gay bashing is incited by THE ADVOCATE - in the guise of "S&M" "spanking"
"slaves wanted- "masochist wants to be dominated" "humiliate me" etc. Sexual violence to gays is institutionally
condoned and part of prevailing "gay cultural values. From 1972-1991, 13-22% of ADVOCATE estoblishment
ads solicited 01' bTUtalily, intergay -grry-on-gay bashing. n
Until the prominence of gay sexuality in the general society, the "straight" world had rejected the idea
that brutality held a legilimate place in sexual relations between women and men, or within what was called
a lOving relationship. Therefore, when homosexual advocates called (or "hate crime to protect gays
from what was said to be "gay-bashing," Americans could not envision that the gay subculture could itself value
and instigate gay bashing. Based on normal male-female sexual standards which condemn such abuse the
public largely supported punishment for intergay offenders.
However, the data Identify THE ADVOCA TE as instigating not only intergay violence against boy and
adult members of its subculture, but doing so en masse with THE ADVOCATE producing roughly 6,500
intergay "bate crime- advermements to every 1,588 '1late crime complaints against the public ( a ratio of
" to 1 aimes more instigated by one gay magazine than the alleged antigay abuse from the entire nation).
'IHB INSJ1TIJ'IE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION PO BOX 74001 ARLINOTON, VIRGINIA ZJ207
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
42
Moreover, threats aDd abuse of gays by more violent gay fBctlons sugges18 other sources of "bate
crimes .. Within the privacy of their own culture, OUTWEEK (now defunct) revealed that lesbian and gay
organizational (Lambda) volunteers and staff' as well as others seen as politically incorrect- were being
threatened and assaulted by a violent gay male faction.
The prostitution of boys established earlier, the numbers of victims per pederast and the abuse of boys
by gays (pederasts) also suggests the reasons for many crimes against adult gays. Some murders of gay adults
have already been traced to brutally abused boys who take their revenge against adult gays -who mayor may
not have been guilty of victimizing the boys earlier. Research in this area is urgently needed to shed light on
both the victimization of boys and on the role of once-victimized boys in (alai injury to other boys, adult gays
or otbers.
In sum, as distressing as the facts are, intergay, g a y ~ n - g a y bashing 15 identified as a cultural value
defining the gay population. Claims for special treatment as an abused -minority" would have to be balanced
against this gay cultural model. No Jewish. Catholic, black, or even Communist press is on record as instigating
a normative model of violence to its own people.
Unless the gay population rejects its current violence model - especially against vulnerable youths -
it would seem inappropriate for "straight" society to view violence to gays as mainly carried out by bigotS and
thus requiring special federal or state intervention. It seems more in keeping with gay cultural values to suggest
that intergay violence be analyzed individually, on a case-by-case basis, and each studied on its own merits.
1HE INSTITU'IE FOR MEDlA HDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 1Zl1J7 703-237-5455
THEADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
THREE: GAY RACISM
3 BIac:t bomoserual males are reDdered invisible ill THE .Al)V0c(1E aDd tIws raciU
maduc:t largely instigated by prevailing -pf adtural vahM:& FIIIIIinr; AIthotIgIa blKb
mmprise about 12% of the 0YeD1I public. empirial C'ridcDcc stroogly IagpIS lbaI
gay bIad:s hawe been oveI'-rqm:seoted (Ill up to 30%). For nearly t1W) dradcs (1972-
91) bJacb have been systemically purged to between ~ aDd ~ of tbe AlWOCt1E
desirable male populatioD; of 446 issues all arc seea _ bawiDg sociali7ei!l and
iDsIigated tJr1 ~ m by Clduding blact py males from Part B, its sc:mal world..
43
Gay males define themselves as "gay" by virtue of their sexual conduct - what they do and do not do
sexually and to whom they do it.
32
The exclusion of black males from homosexual photos and especially from
their all-important sex "desirable" Part B advertisements, exposes both visible and invisible gay racism. For all
446 magazines in 19 yeaIS (1972-91). blacks have been syslf:micaUy purged to between 0% and 2% ot the
-desirable- ADVOCATE male population. 'Ibis rada.I invisibiliiy also appears to hold true for other less
established bomosemal pub1ic:ations.
-BLACK MAGIC: FOR MEN OF COLOR AND FOR MEN WHO LOVE 'I1lEAr
The evidence of widespread gay cultural prejudice impacts on demands by the homosexual
establishment for privileges equivalent to those of the black "minority" (i.e., black rights). A small group within
the gay subculture called: "Black and White Men Together" condemns normative gay white male bigotry.
Within the small gay population, the existence of roughly six national organizations of black homosexuals,
substantiates the existence of a large black gay population.
THEADVOCATE, the WISCONSIN LIGHT, OUTWEEKand most other 1991 gay publications advertise
a lone, half nude, racist 'jungle' ad selling a Iight-skiTUU!d, caucasian-looking black man captioned as: "BLACK
MAGIC: FOR MEN OF COLOR AND FOR MEN WHO LOVE THEM." No similar ad: "White Magic for
White Men and Those Who Love Them" was located. The data find that all ADVOCATE sex ads are implicitly
"white only" unless JUJced (as i1t "all races welcome" or "blacks" etc). Moreover, interviews with recovering gays
confirms that ads which require a "pix" or "photo" are otten a ruse to avoid black responses.
From 97% up to 99% of THE ADV0C4TE "B" pages purged gay blacks. While blacks comprise
roughly 12% of the overall society, there is a very high proportion (30%) of black AIDS dead
33
which does
not seem to be accounted for by a verified higher black than white rate of intravenous (generally heroin) drug
use.
Based on the Department of Justice Statistics, Report to the Nation on Crime and Justice March 1988,
blacks are both over-represented as victims of crime and in prison - otten a key arena for "turning out" gays.
Black males are 46% of the prison population, a ratio of 4 to 1 to the general prison population (:47) with
a (male) lifetime risk of being a homicide victim 1 in 30.(:28) There is DO evidence that such over-
representation in deviant lifestyles does nOI apply to sexual conduct - including adultery, child molestation,
homosexuality - as well as nonsexual criminal activiry.
nm INSl.TIlTm FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 1Z1JJ7 700-237-5455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
This report is not designed to identify the many environmental factors which place the black male at
high risk of victimization from and participation in, lethal behavior - both sexual and nonsexuaL The nexus
of data does suggest that black men would be as seriously over-represented among gays as they are among
other unconventional groups and deviant populations. A strong indication ot higher rates of black male
homose:xua.l activity may be found in the new rash of AIDS victims: a majority of them, black women (51.9%)
and black chHdren. 304 Courtland Millroy, a black correspondent for TIu Washington Post delicately touched
on the significance of black male deviance for black women and children.
Black bisexuality is common. ... you meet many black men who have a family. but go
out to the clubs at nigbL..Black gays. .. are less likely to practice safe sex than white
gays, according to a study released last year by the National Task Force on AIDS
Prevention. Almost half of aU gay black men continue to engage in anal intercourse
without a condom - a percentage 2 1/2 times higher than that of the adult gay
population as a whole. ... black gay men are transmitting the AIDS virus to
unsuspecting black women and children - the groups with the fastest-growing rates
of infection in the United States. (July 18, 1991: eJ)
Bell and Weinberger found - in 1978 - that black gay males were almost double the number of
whites who admitted preference for anal sodomy (:108). Although Abel's pederast and pedophile data were
not revealed by race, blacks should also be over-represented beyond their national population nonns (12%)
in these two deviant populations. Millroy adds that "black gays generally agree that religion-rooted
homophobia in the black community keeps them closeted. Yet despite the religiOUS community, Abel's sex
offender population included 23.8% blacks (:41).
It is reasonable to extrapolate from the overall sex offender population to the child sex offender
group - that roughly 23.8% child molesters are black. H the size of deviant populations tend to reflect the
degree of toxicity in society, it is likely that blacks are also over-represented among gays and pederasts.
As recently as April 25, 1991 CUngressman Mitch McConnell stated that ~ 1 million children from 6
months to 16 years old are sexually molested and tben filmed or photographed." 35 He noted that this means
there are miUions of people addicted to child abuse/pornography.
Looking at the data confluences, while a compelling argument could be made that blacks may
constitute at least 20-30% of gays, in the premiere July 5, 1972 issue, only 3 of the 155 gays soliciting sex were
black. Moreover as gay males also define themselves by their sexual conduct,36 the gay "bathhouse" - as the
sex center - was largely the place where men gathered to "be men." As such, before AIDS awareness, the gay
bathhouse (even more than the anonymous sex found In gay "bars," "bookstores" and public toilets) was a
critical component of acceptance and of gay manhood. Bath houses:
are not for taking baths. That should be understood at the outset. Nobody pretends
they are for taking bathS; some of the houses have steam rooms, or sauDaS .... but that
is not why men pay their $5 or $10 for a locker or a tiny private room in a dimly lit
San Francisco bath house. Men use them to meet other men, to engage.sometimes in
what the clinical language calls "multiple, anonymous sexual contacts." There is no real
parallel in the Uves of most heterosexuals; straight sex clubs and houses of
prostitution exist, certainly, but they are not infused with cultural symbolism or
celebrated as institutions worth defending. WASHINGTON POST, April 19, 1984.
1HE lNSTITIJTB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7-404 ARLJNGlON, VIRGINIA ZZ)JJ7 703-237-$455
TffE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
45
Based on the choice of clients used to illusuateADVOCATE bathhouse, bathhouses are "white only".
Estimating from the project sample to roughly 446 and 446,000 ADVOCATE sex ads and gay sex
solicitations in nearly 19 years, none of about 5,()()() bathhouse ads wuefound to ws a blilck mille to advertise
their faci1iIy1 Blacks seem to hide in the gay racial closet due to white gay dominance. AImo&t an of tile
estimated. 446,lXX) SCI: ads sprrified or implied -..me- (G/WIM) only. Less than 2% inc1icated acceptance of
blacks. This is more 5ignifiotat since ads tend to be nce-based, protoaJl n:quiriDg that bIacb ICIIeaI their
JBe (G/BIM), wbi1e whites do not haw: to do 50.
To date however, while white males otten request acting and appearing white male sex
partners, it is statistically speaking, rare for whites to request nonwhite sex partners. On the other band, black
males wbo advertise for sex seldom request black partners. Indeed., a number ot "blacks- request white sex
partners and the sexual preference is seldom reciprocated. While blacks requesting sex may anticipate that any
race will respond, whites typically anticipate white responses. Characteristic of this racial atmosphere, in the
April 9, 1991 ADVOCAn:, Old of roughly l,()()() sa 11M, IW!n' Ioc:Dk:tl ill tlu! gPy sa cuJJun 12 (1 %)
tima.
BLACK INVISIB1LlTY: OUT OF l,()()(} SEX ADS
April 9, 1991
Numbt:r
of ad! Dacription
2
Phone sex ads with IightlLatino-like "blacks"
1
G/B/M ... seelcs GIW/M (:16)
1
Muscular Black Male ... seeks pretty Oriental men (:16)
1
TalI Black Modei ... EROTIC, VERSATILE. .. SMOOTH (:60)
1
Black Stud ... Uncut...top ... THICK ROD ... S/M ... S200
1
HUSKY Black Guy ... WELL HUNG (:64)
1
BLACK COLLEGE JOCK. .. Young, handsome & versatile
1
Black Top ... HUNG
1
Sensual Black BB ... No fats!fems ... any age/race.
1
BlACK SEX: True G/B sex stories by a White pig. (:6)
12
(Unsure if the last was a black advertiser.)
TIlE INSTITUTE FOR MEDlA P.r:>UCATION
PO BOX 7404 .. ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 1ZJJY1
THE .ADVOCAn: &: THE GAYElLOW PA.GES
Blacks wae soliciud by a whiu in

White Sks Black...8"
dark.(:12)
On the other hand., whites traditionally request white, and if not, either white is -assumed- or they will
say which races they will accept:
Slim houseboy 18-22 wantecLany race-. W/M.
Enemas' T..ean. young (18+) White men call Dr. A
GWM 53 ... WN 18-28 Wb..Ite/Asian.
Open to new aperiences ... :race, color, creed no barrier.
G(W 1M
G/W/M. . ..smooth, bung, esp. Latinos.
G;v.I wan ts.. G(W 1M
GfWfM-wants-G/W/M._G(W/M .. WaDts ... GIW(M. (etc)
WfM ... 11!Z ... BB ... huge nipples ... any race, HIV+OK! (:12)
GermanJAmerican. .. white and xxx handsome ... only & straight
Etc. White gays request sex with white gays..
Independent confumation of these observations are found in the "invisible- black gay - seldom indexed
in the homosexual press and sexually invisible in the establishment press. Bell and Weinberg (1982) reported
on white aDd black gay sex patterns (85-7).
While almost all of the WHMS said that none or only a minority of their
were black, about two-thirds of the blacks reported that more than half of their
partners had been white._.[AmongJ_ .. hundreds of sexual partners .... while the whites
tended to limit their sexu.aI contacts to [whites] __ blacks, by contrast, were apt to have
had mostly white partners. (:85, 92)
There is no explanation of why so few whiles admit black partners and so many blacks cl.aim white
panners. Either a few whites have sex with many blacks, or some race is lying about the race of their partners
for some uniform reasons.
11m INSim.rl'E FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 AlU.INGTON. VIRGINIA ZJ:2D7 1Q3.137.54SS
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYl.LOW PAGES
47
Most whites and a few blacb often had sex with "older" strangers. Many more blacks than whites had
older partners". These "older" gays were more likely to pay for the sa act. Moreover, 25% otwhites and 14%
of blacks admitted to sex with "Among the bUu:Jc pucml - wen nin.aun or younger aI
the start of rMir first ajJtD:r- (:86 J
&11 and db 1Wt wiuu age was; nor dD Ih.ey to reveal how I7U11'lJ gays Wtn
so:ually assau..lud as bays by hom.dsauals. (It is tJurt tMy, c.ollb::ted no data 011 '1M boy
prostitHres of wJwm wt' nod so oftot in the gay - boy.r who .!VOl WC'e advmisiJtg in THE ADVOCAIT
during the t:inu of the lkO and Wdnberg study.) Jazcw, iwwevt!T, tJr.aJ such 'affairs' tQO/c place after years
in tJu life" ckarly wrly sex abust:. 'Si::rry percent ofwhite.s and 75% of b/ackr Wen!' younger Wzn th.eir
(:87)
The racist findings suggest that black gay males inrernalize the -oeauty" 'r.:LIues of upscale lJiY white
men. And gay while men are cI.e2i' O!l what they feel constitutes beauty. "No fems or fats,' blond, blue eyes,
nordic, BB (bubble butt or Body Builder), and most of all well muscled youth. Young, slim white boys are
especially desired. Since this population is almost wholly focused on novelty, youth.md Nordic, or Germanic
physical "beaury" it would tend to require a degree of masoch.ism for black gays to identify with wllite gays.
Yet, they do.
Black males, often also suffer from early sex abuse, having largely lost their fathers and their families,
abandoned their church, and even being alienated -within their work environment, find themselves especially
dependent for acceptance on their new" family - the dominant white gay culture.
Funbermore, several have specified, in writing, their rejection of blacks, e.g., (as have some
blacks) "no fems, fats or blacks." Having identified this phenomena, an in depth data collection for frequencies
of such bigotry was beyond the scope of this study.
In a rare expose. May 3O-April 12,' 1991 the gay WISCONSIN LIGHT cited a black male artist
complaining about the "racism that confronts black men. ... refused entry to a Gay bar because ot.. color"
(6126,91 :3). That man, Marlon Riggs, creator of the gay pornogI2phic film, "Tongues United, said he was "an
invisible man' in the "great [white] gay mecca" of San Francisco. (THE WASHINGTON TIMES, July 16, 1991,
E-4).
In the same June WISCONSIN LIGHT issue of 19 pages, 23 ads (37% of the paper) sold sex, 26%
at these promising abuse (like to play roughr "are you man enough?"). The ads include the recent "Jungle
Magic" black for men of color, among the 22 other "macho' tough-guy men, including the ever-present pseudo-
nazi (but no "ferns or fats"). Women did not appear - white or black.
Concluding this brief review, despite gay claims for 'minority rights" likened to black rights, only
of blacks appear in the critical sex request aod advertisement "B" section of THE ADVOCATE. When blacks
do appear, they are usually light skin, caucasian featured and even "jungle" labeled.
AJthough blacks are almost 12% of American society, they make up 46% of prisoners, 30% of the
AIDS dead and the bulk of AIDS infected women and children. LooJdng at this confluence of statistics _
1HE INSITIUI'B FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 74004 ARLlNVION, VIRGINIA .. Zl2fJ7 .. 703-237.S4SS
THE ADVOCA.TE &. THE GAYEl1.0W PAGES
48
even despite the high percentage of blacks as intravenous drug users - it is reasonable to estimate that gay
males may be up to 20% Ot" more of "gay society.
Bisexu.a.1ity is allegedly practiced by some large number of blacks, with roughly half of black gays
(bisexuals included) admitting to anal sodomy practices, sans condoms. Along with intravenous drug use data, this
would help explain the high rate of black female AIDS infection. As with most sexological, sociological research,
the truly critical data - the percentage of black boys who have been sex.ually abused by adult men - information
critical to solving the AIDS crisis, may have been colluled, bur if so, il is not shared.
mE ADVOCA1E data find a statistically insignificant number of black gays included in either the visual
or print sex publication data. Moreover, of roughly 446,000 sex ads with about 5,000 bathhouses advertised during
that time, the models chosen to attract customers are "white onJy in ADVOCA1E ads.
As the bathhouses had long been the center of gay male "acceptance" the failure of the research sample to find
any black: gays pictured among roughly 5,000 bathhouse ads would confirm a sexual preference for exclusively white
gays in the bathhouses. Moreover, the preference and obsession with white, blond, young, slim. blue eyed male
customers places the gay black - split from his own community and family support system - in a vulnerable
position visa vis the dominant white gay culture.
Racism is visible in the sexual invisibility of up to perhaps 20% of the gay population, and it is manifest
as racial sexual preference bigotry in white gay society. These data are important in response to the recent Steffan
V. Cheney millitary decision which upheld the ban on homosexuals in the armed forces. Protestors compared this
decision to the old military ban against blacks. claiming a similar immutability (Washington Post 12/10/91:A4).
In this recent ruling. however, the chief authors expose of fraudulent Kinsey data was cited to challenge the
immutability argument (see Judith A. Reisman & Edward W. Eicbel, Kinsey, Sex and Fraud: The lnaoctrilUltion
oj a People: 12-13 f 12. US District Court for the District of Columbia No. 88-3669-00).
THE INSTITUTE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 22207 703-237-5455
11lE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
FOUR: GAY Continuity of AIDS-EFFIClENT SEX
4 Multiple, dsky-pabtic!CZ aDd p"WiID"'" is iMti'O',rd b711lE
AlWOCA1E lIItd tIau Itsrgdy ptJ11 of W aUJwrIl wWer. FINDING: Up
to 99% of d:att soriatizrd AIDS cflideot JC:( (q. vioIcat aDa! sodomy
etc) via matlicd,1)l"s: 1% 0( the T ItX adI -wa:pId" scdin& a
third panncr, 1% wen: to 1'X1 JOUpt a DlDOplll). wbiIc
rougb1y 58% of scz: ads were ilr pn .... it A' jo., savia::L Fany 99% of these ads may be
:scc:a as sceliDK DOll pcnnancnt, away __ SC[ in bip-ri:sk sit:oatiooL
49
As noted, about 99% of THEADVOCATE sodalizerl AIDS- efficient Sex: unprotected anal-oral
SO<!c.my were presumed almost all sex advertisements. Concomitant with that assumption,
SEX ONLY" appeared as a wam.i.ng to prospective customers sporadically since the late 80s in one or twO ads
an issue. Condom ads were noticeable by their absence within this massive sex format. While a few
advertisers included "safe" or "safe sa- warnings these disclaimers appeared to be negotiable - as opposed to
the rare "SAFE SEX ONLY" ad - in capital letters.
-&laz:iotuJrip- in Part A: Ccmrrtncial Sa &:: S4dism in Part B
It was mentioned that recent ADVOCATE issues carry roughly 30 ads under "Relationship in Part
A. the legitimate" magazine. In this separately paginated se.cuon the few ads are serious, friendly, with no
mention of violence, sadism. penis size, sodomy. etc. The readers appear then, to be reliable men seeking
permanent, loving, if sexual, companionship.
"Relationship appears alongside real estate, mail order, and other respectable commerce. With Trader
Dicks' PULLOUT" removed, a reader would believe gays to be misjudged regarding their reputation for
anonymous sex and sadistic conquests of young boys. While Pan A includes some salacious material overall,
it does not exhibit the pathology of part "B.
1 % Bi/MIIl7'i61/Slraight
A disturbing reality was thaI 1% of all. sex advertisements (part B) were to
"bi!married/straights-, April 9, 1991:
MGM CLUB: For married Gay/bi mala and Jovas of to mt:d tliscrtttly. For application. and
information souL
Sought by novice BiJW/M
Married men into hot Fr. J/O ... W3med by well-built bi male
UR married bearded and want safe discreet visits.
Bi/W/M wants to meet other Military ... espec. black for fun times
TI-IB INS"lTl1.rrn FOR MEOlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7.t04 ARllNGTON, VIRGINIA 7ZJIJ7 7Q3..ZJ7-S4S.5
THE ADVOCA1J! & THE GA}u'wW PAGES
50
II Bi/W/M seeking guys 19-30._g00d times
Also worrisome re: AIDS uansmission to the larger society were contemporary 'Dnsafe sa ads by
health care such as Wanted: real slave for pky::ticiaIt. Not usual pretend fantasies. SlaIIe mw:t
'IOttJJ1y._.Domination and CXlntrol required..-RL"
Among even the most recent advertisements - in Pan B - only 1 % of advertisers even sought a
monogamous relationship. Despite the c1.aim that homose:ruals wish to have marriage privileges. etc, this
research confirmed Bell and Weinberg's (1978) findings that very few homosexual couples" acrually practiced
se:rua1 fidelity. In this medium. 1 % were couples seeking a third sa partner, such as "G/W cpI seek 3rd for
safe fun set. Must.be HIV- Send photo.
Moreover, several of these monogamy only ads in many of the issues were from an HIV + man seeking
sex: and/or a long term partner. The ad generally informed the reader that the AIDS carrier was also "healthy"
and sex was presumed to be part of the conduct anticipated.
As noted, THE ADVOCATE mixed 58% prostitution ads and anal-aral sodomy ads in the magazine's
estimated sex advertisements with no serious warnings about the seller - or the buyer - engaging in
SAFE SEX ONLY."
Statistically, ADVOCATE consumers did not - aod do oot - seek a permanent, loving spouse for
safe sex. The gay violence ads (ads SOliciting brutality and slavery and the like) are part of a cultore of
multiple, anonymous, risky public sex and prostitution activities. Writing in the pro-homosexual book, Gay
and Lesbian Youth (1989) Debra Boyer observed the problem of young boys entering the "ga:f life and
accepting lhis pattern of unsafe sex as their "identity.
The increased number of adolescent males prostituting may be related to the greater
influence of the gay community. In contemporary times it has been possible to
organize one's entire life around the facts of homoerotic sexual onentation._[more]
a lifestyle than an individual condition. ... PartiaUy due to the success of the homophile
movement, the homosexual subculture provides nOl just sexual panners, but a total
identity. (174)37
Boyer found 363% of boy prostitutes admitted they were moiested by someone at least ten yean oldo
than they when they were children - over 42% had been raped. These youngsters were thus condemned
to Hves of continued abuse and dysfunction - including large numbers of panners, alcohol and drug abuse
problems and lethal sex practices.
Earlier the average number ofpanners per bomosexual male was defined in Bell and Weinberg (1978)
among others, as 500, Magnuson (1988) recording AIDS carriers, admitting to more than double that number.
nm INSlTIUI1! FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 'ZZ1tJ7 ?03-237-S4S5
THE ADYOCATE &. 11fE GAYELLOW PAGES
Sl
All ADVOCATE issues carried dozens of white men cuM::rtizing gay bars, bathhODSeS, slaves.
prostitutes- Reueda (1984) identified "no fewer than. 2.00" IJlY ban nationwide, citing bats which
-purposefully att::r3ct young people. prostitutes who SCIVe to att:raa oJder homosemak wbo in tum purcha$e
drinks for the youngsters while se:mal deals-are arranp (33-34) BeD and Weinberg report.:
Most of our homose:roal male respondents and some of the lesbians went out c::ruising -looking
for a sema.I partner_ While the gay bar functions as an important gathering place....it is....to ptmue
and find sexual partDers.
The combination of alcohol imbibed for hows at the bar, with sodomy and anonymoas sex contributes
to alcoholism and lethal sex. especia.Uy for the young boys who pass though the bar into the YJiY life.
In TM Gay Insider (1m), gay author John Hun[er admitted his own abuse of boys, noting boys
dancing in front of -the mirrored walls SUITou.uding most [gay] dance Doors._I have found that Sell: with them
(usually chicken) is something less th.an mutual masrurbation." (206-211) These youths were highly praised
however in bars, baths. tea-rooms (public toilets) and the like. Hunt's pro-homoserua.i book Celebrated the
bars and was one of the first directories [0 gays for bars., baths and other spOtS for anonymous risky and gay
AIDS efficient sex. - -'
Bell and Weinberg (1978) also described the gay bathhouse scene and Reueda noted that in 1981 there
were 168 homosexual baIhhouses in most major cities. He also cites Monon Hunt, a friendly pro-homosexual
author, who says:
Cruising in tbe baths is even more impersonal and nonsocial than in the bars: there
is practically no conversation, and sex acts take place right on the premises, often in
front of onlookers .... [or inJ small cabins where homosexuals get together to have sex.
There are also large rooms called "orgy rooms- or "mazes " .. _ foc group
sex. pomographic films.._[some) "dungeons- or -tortnre rooms" where homosexuals
who wisb to be degraded submit to sadists whose expertise is to inilict punishment
or humiliation. ... the regular "stave auct.ion".(:35)
A great deal of information exists regarding the gay bars and baths, key centers' for AIDS efficient
.sex - so we will briefly note tbe "tea-rooms" which are toilets in parks, colleges, shopping malls, and the like.
Even Bell and Weinberg admit that:
Public rest rooms, or -tea-rooms: are sometimes used' for cruising. They ... permit
immediate, somewhat private, sexual actMty._tea.room cruising is quite
dangerous._.[as theyJ are used by the general public, and OM 1IIJU iN rUle of cruising
a hderoso:u.al who migIrt be ~ DUJU.gh to TqJOrl or assault him..._Despite the
risks ... il does provide for quick consummation and preserves anonymity._.park5, travel
tenninals, theaters, or rcstaurants, or in office or univenity bUildings .. _ The wall
niB INS'ITlUI'I! FOR MEDIA FDUCAnOH
PO BOX 74004 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA Z12IY1 7Q3..Z37-S45S
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAYELLOW PAGES
between two....stalls might have a "glory hole" in it through which a man would insert
his penis to r falla. tio by his nen-sta.l.l neighbof_ (Emphasis added: 243-244)
52
National glary hole" directories are sold to consumers along with the cited unsanitary. hcmiliating and
pathological Encouragement of "enemas as semal conduct, and of the purchase and wearing of
other men's semen stained underwear, accounted fOf roughly .04% of solicitations and offerings in THE
ADVOCATE.
TIlE 9, 1991
PDfP 5-68
GLORYHOlE YIDE-OHl Huge! cut & UncuL Oral obsession! 100's og gtIyS-brochure:s..
TIiE BARE FACI'SI Compiling a list of places where men can be seen nude; windows., t-rooms,
porches, woods, beaches, etc. Donors get free copy. Send info: where, what type activity, if patrolled.
lASHMA1'ES; National whip/spank club. ' .
ENEMAS: Lean young (18+) While men call Dr. A
ENEMA VIDEOS: dOCtor & yng patient, enema scene. .. enemas, urinaling. ... 2 very yng men are
examined & humiliated by sadistic doc. enemas, urinatioD._
spm! Raunchy dudes who give or ta.ke thick hockers right in the face, Dem. VIA, etc.
COCKPIT: Over 1600 hot men waiting to get it on with you. Call.
COMPUTER SEX: Nationwide CrueL .. meet even more horny guys.
DIAPER. GUY: Wet pants/bed, WIS, spank fantasyltrue stories, Photos, Products.
F/F CLUB EUROPE: For more info send name, address.
SMElLY JOCKS PillS Stinky stained jocks $20 Smelly gym socks S20"
HOT & SWE'ATYl Jocks, briefs & bboxefS._ Worn to gym and on campus by hot college
stud/5Wimmer S20 each
RAINMAKERS: TTIi YEAR!!._ W1S and/or enemas.
UNDERCOVERMAN: 6TH YEAR! The Jockey shorts, jockstrap, boxer sborts .... a11 male underwear
club!
BlITT FUN CLUB: Nt! newsletter. All scenes.
As noted., more than 99% of ADVOCATE data socialized AIDS- efficient sex; that is, anonymons
unprotected (condomles.s) anal and oral sodomy were presumed throughout almost all sex advertisements.
lI
Concomitant with that assumption, SAFE SEX ONLY" appea.red as a warning to prospective customers
sporadically in their offerings since the lale 80s in puhops one ad an issue. While a few sex
regularly included -safe" or -safe sex; disclaimers appeared negotiable - as opposed to the rare SAFE
SEX ONLY" ad - in capital letters, and condoms only" never appeared.
TIm INs-rrnrm FOR MEDfA
PO BOX 7.0404 ARllNGTON, VIRGINIA "J:2J1J7 7aJ..m...s.c5S
THE ADVOCAT.E: & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
.53
As noted., homose:rua.llobbying efforts would center on keeping phone sex (aural prostitution) \egal-
s\.J'aighL as well a!I gay. Moreover, it is clear that a readersbip of 7O,(U) - almost totally dependent on
prostitution sales (ads for aural and manual sex) - does not reflect a 20 to 30 million homosexual population
(at 10%), Moreover, based on the en:essive advertizing focus on boys. this means that the smaller the general
"gay" population is. the larger the "pederast" population.
Also worrisome re: AIDS transmi..ssion to the larger society 'Were ooDremporary 'unsafe sex' ads by
health care providers such as "Wanted: real fio.>t!-iA slmIe 1m ~ Not usual pretend fantasies. Sl4w 1fVUt
~ 1DUUly .... Domination and control required. ... RL" ADd, the widespread use of drugs to blunt both
emotional and physical pain. Note THE ADVQCA TE ADVISOR:
The only time I enjoyed anal sex was with cocaine on my aDUS-. When [my lover] tries
to f - Ie me, he is patient and uses a lot at lubrication and massage, but the pain is
still intense because of my tension and my lover's endowmenL The only time I have
enjoyed passive anal sex was when a partner applied a light dusting of cocaine to the
outer and inner tissues of my anus ... .! do nO( know of any other way to relax my
rectum.
I cannOl advise you to commit an illegal an ... getting busted could ruin your
career. ... Nobody's - can relax if it is being hun .... buy a small butt plub .... Try inserting
it while you -. You caD even sleep willI it insened.. As time goes on you may be able
to graduate to a larger plug. April 9, 1991 (:90)
Not coincidentally, THE ADVOCATE sells "anal p l u ~ " The ADVISOR did nor warn the troubled
fellow not to commit sodomy without a condom (which THE ADVOCATE also does Dot advenise). His pain
would be exCT\lciating with the addition of a prophylactic. (Is this oDe reason condoms are not often sold or
used by gays?) ADVISOR5 answer "letters" which reflect the concerns of many COllSumers - the letter is a tool
to reach all child and adult readers.
Moreover, this Study was not able to address the empirically idenlified and common use of drugs to
attract young boys and to SOOthj the lonely. often angry, insecure. and sexually unsatisfied population of gay
males.
Various substances such as amyl n..itrate (which increases peripheral blood circulation, etc., giving tile
sense of a orgasm "rush") were r gularly advertised until very recently wben the law intervened.)9 Although
the magazine campaigns for the 11gitimacy of sodomy the above leHer to the ADVOCA TE ADVISOR admit led
the costly trauma of aDal sodom .
With 58% of its ads for ultiple, anonymous, risky-public sex and prostitution, THE ADVOCATE
encourages these "gay" cu.lrural V ~ l es. As 99% a fAD VOCA TE sam pie d.a La instiga ted AIDS efficient sa (es p.,
violent. non-contracepted anal omy, etc) with up to 1 % of all sex ads to '"bisexuals, marrieds and straights:
the data find gay cultural values a a instigate dissemination of sexually transmitted disease, including AIDS,
to innocent women and children.
,
TIIE INSITIUffi FOR MFD LA EnUCA nON
PO BOX 740-4 ARUNGTON, YlRGINLA - 222J'J7 703-237-5-(55
THE ADVOCATE &.17lE GAYElLOW PAGES
TheADVOCA TE data find AIDS-effident sex culturally encouraged.. From 19'72-1991 un protected anal
and oral sodomy wc:re advOClred prima facie throughout the sa advertisements films and other pornography
entertainment., "SAFE SEX ONLY," was invisible as a clearcnt rule.
The finding of the "pullout" section in THE ADVOCATE was worrisome. It bas no parallel in any
ordinary publication. Th.is separalely paginated section at the "heart- of the magazine snggested a parrern o(
withholding the faCtS about abnormal gay sema.l conduct from normal Americans.. This secretive se:J: was
compounded by the recent inclw;ion of a separau: -Relationships sectiOD at the conclusion of Pan A. There
appears to be no reasoD for these few ads (about 28). beyond the attempt to gay sexuality as
normal, that is, permanent and responsible, to unsuspecting nong3y reviewers or potential
The case for legaliz:ation of homoserual marriage is not sustained by the research data..
THE ADVOCATE data reveal a mere 1% of advertisers seeking a monogamow; relationship and even this
small group included dying AIDS men seeking care. This was offset by roughly1 % of "couples - who
solicited a third :sex panner.
This means that fully 98% of g;ay advert::i.se!S may be seen as pursuing non permanent, anonymous sex
in high-risk siruations via the prevailing gay cultural norm. of "fast" multiple-partner acts. This includes public
sex in bath houses, bars, public toilets, and parks (i.e., ads for "Glory Hole Guides" (7f3n4:B-26) as well as
prostitution via phone and ADVOCATE call-in contacts, anonymous "one night stands" and other anti-
monogamy conduct. From 1972 to 1991, such cultural values do not comport with the laws or meaning of
marriage for society.
The research findings do not support special legal protection for AIDS Anal sodomy. the
most efficient mode of AIDS transmission to individuals and society was implicitly anticipated in almost all
sex ads aDd explicitly requested from 1972 to 1991 in up to 13% of ADVOCATE so:: solicitations. This
included some 9% of PERSONAL ads for dangerous anal penetration ("fistfucking") by strallgers (including
health care providers). It is critical to note these thousands of lethal sex solicitations and w absence of any
statistically signiftcOJ'lt numbas" of co1u!om adve:rti.sements or "coruJom usas only"
In sum, the data find encouragement of scatological, violent AIDS-efficient anal sodomy. enemas and
other feces based acts, with massive, undifferentiated partners, including marrieds, bisexuals and gays (child
and adult) and little probability of sociocultural change.
TIm INSlTIl.TIE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7-404 ARLINGTON, VIRGIN1A 'ZD1l7 7U3-131-%5
THE ADYOCfn: " THE GAlnLOW PA.GES
FIVE: GAY SEDUCTION OF ~ G H I ' S
5
nm ADVOCATE dam socializerl a cu.1tun..1 nbvsFicm (mc:ludiq c:IlIrapmCIU) witJl ~
macho maks. FINDING: At /aut 99% c:(dte ~ inuIgr.z I1IIIl ~ itt THE ~
aJIibit a pn::fcn:na for -strai{jIt" mDCJw IIIIlk gay mDL Wbilc homo&crnal males JIC 011 ru:onl
as auaaptiDg to ~ eatr2p (straipl) boys, the data fiDd PJI WOI:tiug to cattap lIClDIal
,lstraigbt mc:D - Cal ~ the usc of ~ to permit rape of IIDmIIIdoas "ictims.
THE ADVISOR: April 9, 1991
55
A man writes to the ADVOCATE ADVISOR saying he desires straight men. THE ADVISOR replies:
Straight men can temble flirts ... I doubt that you are going to be able to get straight men to
change their manipulative ways. Seek counseling from the Gay & Lesbian Services Center
(p.72).
"HYPNOTIZE SlRAIGfIT GUYS. Force guys to obey your every whlm." (800m: 39).
While such "advice- appeared in early issues, a March 28, 1989 (38-41) cover story provided step.by-
step directions on bow [0 render normal men unconscious for a sexual attack. Titled: "How To Seduce A
Straight MAN," THE ADVOCATE instigation of adult-child sex entrapment clearly identifies the following
. quotes as applicable to young boys as well. . .
"Who hasn't dreamed of getting it on with a straight man? Their sleek,
tanned bodies, yes, but also their unself-conscious sexuality .... Getling a
straight into your bed is a bit like playing Russian roulette: Some are
loaded, some aren'L_Still, we all dream about the day whc:n we will finally
make it with a straight hunlt.-[Well] there are indeed ways to get than
hunk. You b.a"Ye to be clever, ready to more at a moment's notice-[most
men have faceless sex with women so] Just get in line, boys!
"How to start?_Get dose to that stud and keep)'Our hands off his [. word
for sa organ] for the time being. Be his [. word for rectum] buddy, as
they say, though they don't mean what we mean when we say it. Go to the
platts be got$, do the things be does-The guy plays leDIlis1 You play
tennis-Surling. jOu go snrfacing..JootbalJ,)'Ou play footbalL
-Why all the buddy-buddy stuff? Well, remember the elementary sex play
wben you were a ]dd? So does be .... you are going to build on that....More
on this later.
TIm INSTTroIB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA 7Z1I17 7Q3..237-S-lSS
THE ADVOCHE THE GAYEUOW PAGES 56
ADVOCATE writer, Jason Del Maris then explains how to lie until you.. Be "casual" and
get him to your spotless" home "as if Donna Reed" lived there. Feed him like "Christmas at Moms....stuff
this gOrilla to the brim." Then feed him regularly and help him in various ways. Soon)rou are ready to make
your move. Dim the lights and -uquor him ap."
-whal the pia.t ck::phDr1s pea- ooafQ n cs &u so slowly.
your secrets make their WlrJ-to Sci lJOa."t be afnid to lie as you tell about the
"WOIDCIl in JOUf pasLFrom sa, JO to lDlasual SCL P1ay 011. his cwiosity aDd
dJikfbood -oid JOb C!'tIIQ" play UOUDd with the other little boy5 wbca
:you were a tidr _ tboIe UldJ:ee days wiJ1 da:Dce into
his bain.. FiDaDy, he's prirnnt as bc'Il eva' be. c:booie ,our words as
you pJaoe ODe hand oa hi5 inna thigh - DOt 100 high, IIOt 100 high.! Ahoat 1iYc
inches from wbt:re really liU to pur: iLfI1e11 him .bow DCVet' bec:o
with 3DOther man before..
Del Maris teaches the entrapment step-by.step (if the victim is totally drunk, its stamtory rape. If he
gets AIDS, its murder). After compromising the victim THE ADVOCATE author explains that the
isn't over because you must "ease off his clothing." If the reader feels guilty:
-You most fight these guilt feelings., sniping them as they appear_
Scientists say that let alone, the awe:ragc man bise:roaL When be
stops struggling. yank another piece of apparel off his body .... Once be's
stark naked. ... maneuver him into your favorite position and go to town.
Due to the limited time frame, this section is only briefly treated. The magazine adds regularly solicit
straight looking" "straight acting" men and boys. A premium is clearly set on "normal- looking males with
roughly 5% of ads specifying the rejection of "feminine" appearing gays. "DO fems, no [ats. The repeated
requests (or "straight looking" males with whom to have sex can be seen as a love-hate relationship experience
by gays for what had been known as normal, straight" men.
When told how to get a normal male drunk so as to entrap him into gay sex, the author reveals his
anger with the victim. He says. when the victim sleeps, "you can [-oa] all over that beautHul bas-rd. Serves
him righL ... YoUU be getting your money's WOrth." It the victim rejects gay sex. the author speaks for THE
ADVOCATE data, saying: Still, after all this, visions of straight men will dance - naked of course - through
your most feverish fantasies .... Better luck next time!"
These observations were anecdotally validated in a interview with one homosexual subject in reparative
therapy who remarked: "I had no idea that everything I knew based on my life was already in these magazines.
I've read them for years and never noticed, but it ls true.
THE fUR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-404 ARLINGTON, VlRGOOA 2ZJJJ7 7Q3.237.S45S
THE .ADVOCATE &; THE GAfEL.LOW PAGES
SIX: GAYFASCISM
6 Homoscmal claims of fascist pcrscnrtic- - aDd IU{UiailC pJlnltbin ilr fascism -
arc DOt sust.in by tbc data. Fftlint; 111 aam&at io ....
lIl' to 5% ofT1lE.AlWOC.41'E' &Jan .. -i", spccifiaDy DaZi features aIIIIi CXC'yme
while the prt:vaiI:inJw toap IJlY aaJ1me (i.e.. c:motioos, m8D
i
W':lS.
Iaslt3. habit!, stills, art" [Wc:bReI', 1979)) fits me key bnuea of a fascist caIture.
57
Overall, roughly 72% of nm ADVOCA1E data socialized a set of core values - glorified nazi dress,
language and "blonde- Aryan male beauty and brutality; conlell1pt (or "fems, fats- and blacks; threats toward
"politically incorrect" non-gay homosemals, churches. and others - romanticizing "fascist" culture to a
"younger generation. " Nazi costume:s/faSC:is1. concepts are a oommon component of 11lE ADVCXATE and thus
largely condoned by prevailing "gay" cultural values..
II ANYONE? For Info write to: Natiooal Sociamt I....eag1w; Bar: 26496A, CA SOO26" 7f3(l4. :B-27
No equivalent sua-ight magazine (TIME, NEWSWEEK) has ever carried an advertisement to Join the
nazi party. A racist-violent, macho "male culture" fascist movement Beyond the general claims of
gay supremacy and focus on dominant white musde men in black leather (symbols of nazi power) issues of
- -
THE ADVOCATE often carry ads of men in fascist caps, wearing black SS-type hip boors or carrying the
inevitable SS whips and such. These culminate with ads like the Slave Ad" April 9, 1991:
II "ACHTONG! Teutonic Lord Muscle Master ....
This brutal gay supremacist above will Qlrty out acts aD a weaker gay. As noted in 1974
THE ADVOCATE instigated fascist power by advertising for gays to join the Nazi parry, providing the pa.rty's
address and phone number. Important, no protest letters followed this ad - or any other the other fascist ads.
A comic book series Desert Peach (as well as of paperback porno books) is sold at gay
bookstores. It provides a nazi homosexual hero, carrying the inevitable whip and wearing the inevitable black
hip boots, black cap, and black leather jacket.
The World War II notion of Hitlers persecution of homosexuals is based on his assault against "fems-
not gay nazi superman. 01 Many of Hitler's WInner Circle: and the key men who recruited for the party. and
who lead the parry. including the most brutal military brigades, the Storm Troopers, (SA) and the Infantry
School - were homosexual: Ernst Rohem, Rudolf Hess and Gerhard Rossbach, while the infamous Goring
was also said to be a type of transvestite. Captain Ernst Roehm served as military adviser to the chief of
Bolivian forces. Returning to Germany be was made "bead of the SA (Storm Troopers) .... However, his
qualities as a leader were vitiated by strong bomosexual desires which he indulged with brazen openness. He
surrounded himself with dissolute young men whose frequent orgies did the party's reputation no good." (:370)
Captain Roehm was so well known as a homosexual that articles in the press between him and his
doctor lover were widely read by the public. Walter Langer writing in The Mind of Adolf Hitler (1m) noted
TIm INS'lTlUI'E FOR MlIDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7--t04 ARl.lN<ITON, Zl2D7 7Q3..D7-54Sj
THE ADVOCAn' & THE GAYEILOW PAGES 58
that Rudolf Hess -was generally known as 'FruJein Anna.' There were also many other [gays close to Hitler]
and it was supposed, for this reason, that Hitler too belonged in this category:
Roehm made no attempt to bide his homosexual activitiCS-[Hitler said] The only
criterion for membership in the Party was that the applicant be 'Unronditionally
obedient and faithfully devoted to me! -
When someone asked it that applied to thieves and crimina
k
Hitler .said:
Their private lives don't Q)Qcern me-Why would I Q)ncem myself with the private
lives of my followers. Apart from Roehm's achievementS, I know that I can ab$olutely
depend on b.im....Ra.
l1
sch
n
ing says that the general attitude in the Party was: 'Do
anything you like but don't get caught at it (199).
LaIe in Hitler's rule Ernst Rboem was executed.. However, this follows Roehm's growth in power ,and
the possibility that he would use his storm troopers - many of whom would be gay, to overtake Hitler. Hitler
artempted dozens of times to Q)ITea Roehm's many challenges to Hitler's anthority. Rhoem died because
Hitler no longer could depend on him., and not because of Roehm's homose:malliaisons.
The German libertarian sexologist, Wilheim Reich, writing in 1928 on The Mass Psychology of Fascism
(1970) during Hitler'S rise to power observed: '
The male supremacy of the Platonic era is entirely bomose::ruaL...The same principle
governs the fascist ideology of the male strata of [03.2l1 leaders (Bluher, Roehm,
etc): (91)_ ..
It follows that fascistic gay supremacists would persecute "fems, regularly discriminating against 'soft'
males in all photo ads, in jokes, and most sex advertis.ements. This body of work on the history of
homosexuality in Germany is currently under way, but for now it needs only to be said that the conflux of six
values described above, aHlsk behavior, contempt for marital permanent relations, worship of white male
youth and brutality, racism and misogyny, fall into the gay fascistic/ supremacist model of politics and
governance.
nre ~ FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 1.f(H ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA Z1:2JY1 7In-237-5-tSS
THE ADVOCATE .It THE GAn:L.LOW PAGES
59
IX. CONa..usIONS - WORIC IN
The preliminary study of samplcs of THE ADVOCATE (N=440) July 1972.July 1991 tl1I.d o/THE 1991
GAYELLOW PAGES has involved an analysis of the print and pictorial oontent of these two "cu.1ruraJ
institutions. The ADVOCATE sample and the GAn1..LOW PAGES (work still in progress) have yielded a
body of verifiable data which identify a psychological profile of the :lYeI3ge hom.osemal ,ad\Iocate mnsumer
as unmoDitored self repon behavioru data, this analysis tells us what the aitical AIDS population - activist
homosexual males - think and do, have done and have stoppec:l doing sexually. This preLiminary study holds
critical information (or youth organizations, the military and other agendes organiud around -normal- male
conduct. A larger, full scale study both of THE ADVOCATE and all homose:nul media is urged..
Cftc up to 58% of ADVOCATE sex ads socialized prostitution (paid sa) by boys and adults while between
10-20% of ADVOCATE s.e:x ads also .socialized man-boy sa.
Two: between 10-20% ot ADVOCATE sex ads socialized iDtergay "hate crimes" "gay-<m-gay-violence";
gay men soliciting whipping, spanking, pounding. cutting. humiliation).
1'1tree.: roughly 99% of ADVOCATE sex ads ux (eg, multiple, anonymous pannering,
violent anal-to-oral sodomy. etc) via 'gays/marriedlbi/straights,' and
Four: up to 99% of ADVOCATE sex ads socialized an obsession with and glamOrization of "straight" males.
FlVt:: between 97-100% of ADVOCATE sex ads .socialized white superiority - racism - with black males
expunged from the all important gay sexual world (the "B" section) of the magazine and
Sir . overall, roughly 72% of ADVOCATE sex ads socialized a set of definitively fascist core values: (nazi
dress and language and "blond" Aryan male beauty aDd brutality; contempt for the weak, for "fems,
fats" and blacks) to a "younger generation:
Since this analysis is ongoing, while [be present findings accurately reflect the content sample, the
reader is cautioned that these are preliminary conclusions and the percentages within each category may be
altered slightly at project closure.
The idea that gays are "10%" of the population, a myth begun by Dr. Alfred Kinsey In Se:r:ual Behavior
in the Human Male (1948) bas been demolisbed in Kinsey, Sa and Fraud (Reisman and Eichel, 1990), the
actual percentage more realistically estimated as between 1 %-3%. The significance of the smaller gay sociery
is critical, since estimates of boy victimization per adult pederast - gay - offender relate strongly to the gay
percentage of society. .
.As gays accepted and inciled "boy lovus" in THE ADVOCATE, gay males become implicated in a view
of boys as targets tJy the lmger (non pederast) gay population. This possibiliEy' was supported by the fouling of NO
women advertising in THE ADVOCA TE for sex WM girls "18 +) - in rhe 19 }!ars examined.
Regarding child sex abuse, the pro-gay literature which accepts child protection experts that 1 in 4 girls
(25%) and 1 in 6 boys (16%) are sexually abused by age 18. means tbat tbe abuse of boys by men is
significantly higher than the abuse oC girls by men. For, Lanning and Burgess (1984), in their FBI repon, noted
that "boys may be at equal rist: for :;cruaJ yjd"imization since they are the preferred laIgel 'Of habitual
pedophiles and. victims of child sa: (:10)
iRE INS'TTI1..TI'B FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARUNGTON. VlRGlNIA ZZ1J17 703-237-5455
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYELLOW PAGES
60
The difference in boy-te-girl victimization is staggering: based OQ Abel"s pederasts in therapy. if gays
were 2% of rhe population. then at 150 victims per m..an. 14,700 boys would be victirn;zffi by 98 pederasts. This
and Reisman's estimation (1,225 boys victjmj1ed by 98 pederasts) are to be compared with the 25 girls on
record as victimized per 98 heteroserua1 men. While these numbers appear Dr. Eugene Abel's
research suggests Reisman's estimates are too modest.
Abel's mean tor boy versus girl victims of male offenders is 150.0 boys 'CfSUI a mean 0{ 19.3 girl
victims.. (:46) Since a subgroup of the larger homose:ma.l population is carrying out these crimes, the fact
emerges that that pederast subgroup is lcthallO oo,s.
Abel's data found that 153 pederasts sc:xual.ly violated 22,981 boys., while Z24 pedophiles sexually
violated oruy- 4,435 girls. Abel a said pederasts:
secually mokst :young boJs with an inddenc'e that is occurring from fiye t:inxs grca.Ia
than the molestation of JOUllg girls- .IlOIlincaIccnt child mok:stas [admitted to]
from 23.2 acts to 281.7 acts per offender _ .. 3 relatively smaU number (44) targeted boys
within the ho::ne. When one ex:ami.nes the child for a:ample, it is surprising
to note the very high percenrage of total child molestations committed by those who
target young ooys outside the home .... [pederasts have] the greatest number of child
victims compared to those who molest girls-.. [T]he high percentage of crimes
committed by adults who molest young boys is a true representation of the high
percentage of molestations completed .. when compared with other categories of
molesters. (;32-51)
Based on recent data normal women and men averaged one sex partner in 1988. Kinseyan researchers
Alan BeU and Martin Weinberg confirmed the obsessi .... e nature of gay sexual conquest in
Homoserualities (1978), saying about 75% of the 5,000 white gays and 66% of black gays interviewed., odmitteJ1
between 100 and OYer 5<X) set panners.. Some number of these -part:ncn- were young boys., and a roughly
25% admitting to sa with boys and another 73% of gays in a separnte report admitting to sex with boys, that
lethal peder.lst community becomes critical as gays are permitted employment as teachers and as youth
counselors.
Gay sexualization of violence and of lethal sex may be seen as a component of the recruitment and
entrapment of "straight" men and boys. By cameoing a recent ad in its press which sexualizes being arrcsted
by police, THE ADVOCATE lends credence to the notion that Wgay_bashingW has become a thrill-seeldng
activity for some gays: "Getting Arrested TURNS ME ON!W.
The data finds that for many gays sexual excitement has become so pathological that arousal depends
upon brutality and humiliation. The brutal fascist implications of incitement to boy abuse, violence and racism
are troublesome. This study has identified both a pederast taint to gay society and a lust for unprotected sex
and sexual violence - an at-risk combination (or American boys and society.
X. RECOMMENDATIONS - WORK IN PROGRESS
These preliminary findings strongly suggest that the problem of child sex abuse which overwhelms the
nation and puts children at life and death risk, requires that we examine the gay community for its agreement
with THE ADVOCATE positiOns on child sex abuse. A full scale random sample content analysis of all gay
press would tell us unequivocabaUy what homosexuals are thinking and doing. This "natural" unmonitored
self report data tens the nation what precisely aTe gay values, mores and conduct... Based on current gay
behavioral data, some have argued that it is time to abolish the sex laws which followed in Kinsey's wake and
and resulted in Iibralized bi/homosexual and sex offender conduct.
1HE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7404 ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA Z/2tJ7 1(B.237..,s.tSS
THE ADVOCATE &: THE GAY.ELLOW PAGES
61
They have said that. based on hard data. sex offenders are repeat offenders, often e:scalating their
violence into and the like and the parole for sex crimes should be ended.. It would
be useful to study the role oC THE ADVOCATE and other gay press, in facilitating both child sa abuse and
in showing returning offenders that their sexual offenses against boys are normal and should continue 10 be
acted upon.
Beyond the compromising law enforcement data. these research indicate that bi/homosc:mal
men - via THE ADVOCA. TE as their central arena of apression - can be arguable seen as either a) sanally
violent and pederast-inclined, or b) as men who 8Jen:dy permit the instigation of crimes against children and
violent se:rua.I abuse by other gays and by their most credibk press THE ADVOCATE.
In either case, it could be argued that the general 'lPY society is implicated as an at-risk group from
whom children require protection. Permission for THE ADVOCATE and similar materials in jails would seem
[0 be inappropriate. based on its instigation of sa crimes.. In particular. these data suggest that laws which bar
gays from positions of authority and influence over children must be reinstated The immorality of
discriminating against a harmless popu1ation remains in place - if the population is harmless.
We need more data on the racial composition of the gay population and of IV drug users. These data
should not he too difficult to obtain. While AIDS S6lll1l BeJurvior anti InI7avawus Drug Use (1989) by the
National Research Council, proported to teU us about AIDS, they reYea1ed DO data on child prostitution and.
not a word about male - espociaUy boy prostitution. Nor did there seem to useable racial data on IV drug
using.
The outcome of this media research suggests a critical need to protect our children from marauding
deviantS. Recognizing the prevalence o{ "toxic- media, our children must have a safe harbor which protects
them from the images of them as desirable sex targets. This suggests the idea. of a need also to resurrect the
orphanage. As bad as these institutions were, today's situation is totally unworkable. Children, boys and girls,
must be taken off the streets. It is argued that if they cannot safely reside with their parents, these.
youngsters must be remanded into protective orpbanage custody to be fed, clothed, educated and medically
repaired up to age 18.
The more difficult (i.e., illegal) public sex is, the greater protection for our most at-risk public sex
providers - prostituted children. Laws whkh legalize sodomy 'WOrk to increase victimization of c::hildren... For
the sma.lle5t }'Onngstcrs can (and they do) perform sodomy in semipublic space in a few moments for payment.
moving on to the nat CDStOmer. Risks to the child ofvenere:al disease as well as kidnapping and suh<;equent
abnsc are legion. When sodomy is severely punished, it offers an opportunity to what bas been called
in street parlance, -fast food- sex.
At least in genital sex, prostituting is slower and more romplie<:Hed, generally requiring a more private
area for "laying down-. To date. too many children start out experimenting with the food- sex service, only
to become prostituted individually and (or pornography. Our children are dying, both spirituallY and physically
and the media in question can be documented and identified as playing a role in instigating the current state
of affairs.
A severe monitoring system to assess any abuses of child residents in the orphanage system would have
to be undertaken. However, it is this authors view that children can no longer be left to the preying desires
of pimps, pedophiles, pederasts and other deviant and violent men or women. These data suggest that
materials like THE ADVOCATE (a milder version of most gay publications) and other pornographies
promoting adult sex with children, will continue to be published and distributed. Since we are unable to
restrict these materials, we must at least remove as many of the target population, boys (and girls) from easy
access to these deviant and cruel populations.
TIiE INSlTlUIE FOR NEOlA EDUCATION
PO BOX .ARUNGTON, VIR.GINIA 2Z1fJ7 7m--231-5-4SS
11lE ADVOCATE & THE GAYE1LOW PAGES
ENDN01ES
1. Web&Lc::r dc.fines cul tun:" as.: "tb e t.r.Iin.ing aDd refilling of. 1he IJlind, IIl8JlIlCn, taste., the n::su.Iu ol. t.hia-.; Iho:
cooa:pu. habits, sltills, an. instruments, in:Ui (U UoDS, etc. oC a g:M:u people ill giw:D lime period; c::iYil.i7:atioo..
2. l.ctt.a !rom James Madiaoa to W.T. Barty (August 4, la32), n=printerl in 'The Como!ete MJdiaoo 337 (S. ed..
1953).
3. In 1990 thc National Calter (or Health Statiatia, in tbra: survcya 01 aver 30,000 people, COIlDd Jaa than 1 to 3 pcra:m 0{
men daiminJ aootbcr IIW1 "at:lOlIle time siDc:e 1m, CYCIl 1 time.- (Sec. q., Deborah DaMon,AIDS KDawiedcc
aDd Anttudes Cor Ja.nuuy-March 1990, Provisional Data the Natioaa.l Health Suzvq, NCHS, USHHS P. lL No<e
several otllcr studies identified in Rdama.n &: Eicbd, Sa and Fr.lud (1990). HUDting10a Hoo.e, l..M)td:te. LA, sa
wd] sa the r=t of a N.Y. Ob.st:rva Poll oa homac:malizy. While NC"iIP Yod baa the natioa'.1aqcsl !wNwT"'!
pop1aOo!L Tbc::n::fore c:s.t.Imale that New Yon: bas IS to 20% pya. In f3d., of S<12l'U1odomJy sazupicd New
"0!1ly 16 individuals, or 3 pcra:nt, identified tbem3c:tves as I!omoacmal 0(' 1XIcmal." MorecY'Cr, the rapoodcnts were
willorm/y 11"bera1 in tbci.r views of. wi!h saying gays sbou..Id be able to !lYe they wah. Onty 13<;{'
felt IaDdlords sbould be able to refuse to rent or sell to pY! and 67% said p)'S abouId be able to teach in pub6c tcbooiL
Roughly disappl'OY01 of adoptioa or marriage for- pys mel 86% (dt AIDS inlo;:tcd doctor! should tc.:I.l their paticDtL
With only 3% replying - in that thq.themsdYeI were e:ithc:- or biJau.a.I - in NYC - tile .. _- ....
6pn: tppe:an to lIdd.. May 1991 Al.
4, See Thc National Resource Qnter oa Olild Saua1 Abux (undated), "SlBtiatia In Qilld Saua.I Abw.:.. The repon cites
AHA estimates of "35% of thc clJ..ild population. ... 6% to 62% of adult females and frollJ 3% to 31 % oiadult malc:t report
thaI they h.ad boell 5CXUally abused during childhood" (:12). Abo L= Trma, August 25, 1985, page 1, fts 0WIl
survey a.s well a.s the acadc:m.ic literature.. Alao D. FlIlkdbor, ScruaUy VictimiZed Dlildrcn (New Yon:: Fro:: Pre&, 1979) aod
C. Swift, "Sa Bc:rw= Adults and 0Jildren," The Journal o( PsvcbolWtory, WInter 1m. VVbilc: thai: are IIl3.IlY st.atistia
cited in this field, must be used with caution. Only by I:Olllhining the resc:01I'Ch data with case reports and single
intClVicws C31I we ani'Ye at estimates o( the pn:">'l!lCllCC o( child x::t abUlIC. A oC these stU4iics tc:oda
to suppon the: figures given bere. The 1 in " girls and 'equal" numbers of boy viC1lJM is a1so dted in K. l.a.nning acd AW
Burgess, Child PornograpiIy and 5c::I; Rings" F13T Law Eoforcement Bulletin. January 1984, :11.
S. Due to the in!luc:nce o( Dr. Kinsey on aod language; Ihe terms -normal" aDd "abnormal" oot CllrT=Uy ux:ablc.
Although the data collected bere on IRE ADVOCATE clearly defines "cfucoaae." or pathology. in the saual Uva ol its .
consumen, we hAlve cbcocn to accept tbe designations "gay" and "slr.!igbt" YenU3 to describe what would be dinical1y (()(U)d
as 'aboormar (eg . violent, seJ!abusive, pederast, ete) behavior. Als, notc that while there is rca:nt debate aa t.o wbetber-
'III homosexual rape (prison, etc) is carried out by "g;.y" lIIeD or "stn..ight" lDen, it is also acg\Ied that mall)' bele:rose=al
rapes are in condUCL This suggests, !.be argumeot goes, that when one finds anal.. oral other primarily
bomoso:u.al act.5 earried out on a femalc body, this often qualifies as homosaual, not rape. Until the-re is somc
evidcnce to the co0lr.U')', samegeodcr =1 acts arc: seen in this invotigation as homo:senW aDd other-gender acu
are seen as bc:tcrosauaL
6. Since certainly oeither <:'IIcry bomoscrual or belc:roscxual malc abuses children, this "aveTlIge" is gencric-a 3Ub-poup
will have most victims.
7. Sc-c. Gene Abel et aI., SelfRc:ported Sa: Crimes of Nonincm:erated Paraphiliac" Journal o( lnlC!"'!?gjK!nal Violence. Vol 2
No.1, March 1987, 525.
8. Note that it hM become Cashionablc to citc Dr. John Money o{ Johns Hopkins for- vtlnous tctm.S which would makc the
discUS3ion of child sex abuse more colDploc.. The term "cphcbophilicac" is often written (seldollJ spoken) when one wishes to
claim dislinction (or adolescent SCXtIaJ interot venus desire for prepubertaltu!a. This author suggests sucb terms
to be without vtllidity ill the daLa and to be constructioru which distr:ad from the issue-adult abuse o( .. vultlerable,
youthful population.
9. Roger- Magnuson. A= Gay Rights Right? (The Leaguc Fund, Minnc::solB, 1985): 41, IS.
10. Sec III International Conference on AIDS, Washington, D.C.. June 15, 1987, Abstract Volume, BIODATA, p. 213 on
average number of male panners, anal sodomy. etc. See also Roger Magnuson, Are Gay Righu RighI? (The
Leaguc Fund, MN. 1985); Sludy. CentCl'! (or Disease u,nlrol (CDC; ALlant.a 1982) in "'The Gay DUc:mm.a,"
'IHE INSITIl.J"rE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-04 ARLINGTON., Zl:lJY1 703-237.5455
THE ADVOCATE cSt THE GAYEILOW PAGES
PsvcholOl'l Tod:Jv. January 1984. p- 10. Especially 5Ce 31.1thon Bell and Wcingc:rg. Homosc:rualilic:s,
(Touc.bsIOQe, l'IY, 1978) pp. 70 and 85.
11. Sec, AIDS. Saua.J Ikhavior and IntnYC:D()U! Drue Uae (1989) NaUooa.l Rocardl Council, WaahinglOQ. DC.
12. Sec, (ar eqmplc, Abraham Ma&Jo. I.Dd J..M. Sal:oda.. "Volaatccr E=x iu the Kinsey Study: Journal ol Aboono.al and
Soc:ia.I PMhoIogy 47. 19S2, 259-262..
13. Sec II13rl:et researcllmatc:rials sucb 8:1 Simmolta MediamMt RCICal'Ch both in New Ycrl, and cspeciaIly
Philip Kotler, Marteting Managcme!:!I:: pla.a.nillg. and cootrnl. (Nt:I/P Jtney, Pn:ntic:e HalI; EngJewood 0i1fJ., NJ,
1967 to 1988) and Riclla.rd Wmett, Informatioll .and Bdlavior: Swtema ot InJluc:pce. Eribawn; HilbdaJe, NJ,
1986).
63
14. A review of bomOllCX1.l8lIit=l= Olabtiabc:s TIrE ADVOCAn 311 tbc Icadinf "3ooeptabW !lc:omc-=D.p' public:atioo;
5Ce John Frances HWltcr, The Qg, Insidc:r USA, (StODdI.i11 pPNiabinc; 1m): "Every Gtry in Amc:ric:a should
sul:aaibc to The Advocate aIld Q!r, (no Joc&cr pubUabed] I.Dd to a rqjcoal aDd rnaprinc paf'rOaizD:i by
business run by Gays, or thOle wf1id1 opc:nJy solicit P'I palroa.age-, The A.dvocate's _edllOriaI SUDce briDp dcow the wr:ath
oC nu1k:al [gay] papc:n who Ioyc to sfn&lc: it out as I::ltabliahmcnl.: 166, Note lbe "G3ye\low Pages" and Olher t:nI\1::I aDd
lOur boob 2S citing The AdYoc:ate a.od thcrCn, c:u:..
15. For =mpte, In Sao Jose, California, a bomOlatl3.l male.set up a vidco camera 10 record ba foctha:Jmiog abu:lc: by a)OOth.
The camer.! recorded "3 17-tcar-<lld by viciously pummeling a boa!oscxual ndghbor with btale klcD and 't'C:rba.l
insults (The Wa.sbington limo., July 4, 1991). The DOlion that homoIIc:wals bsYe been out {or pbysk:al attict: has
resulted i.D a whole new body or "bate aimes" legislation and law, desipcd 10 protect bomoec:xuah .... bo an; as abcJoroe,
insulted or assaulted by "straighu.." 1'b.i;s bas also triggen:d special prMlegcs ill employment. based 00 !be notion Wl
arc uaIairly and brutally u=ted due only to their pcno.n.al and private adult &elCW1l int=u..
16. Sec Paul Glbsol1, "Gay Male and tabiaJI Youth Suicide" in Reporl or tbe Seaetary's Task Foro: 00 Youth Suicide; Volume
He:aJth and HUIIlaJl Scrnc:a, WashiDgtOn, D.e. "Homoeexua.lity-is p oallll1ll aDd beaJlby o:pression of bUJJlan
se:cu.ality-Kinsey (ound a signific:ant amollDt of bomoscs:ual behmor among adolesocnts.....Rdlgiona [families alld sdlools]
Deed to_..acc:pt gay youth and make a place lor tbern [Those who] condemn homosc:xuality_conuibute to .. a..tJlODg
and VJ male: youtb" (3-115. 1.35). ' , . .
17. See Rita Mae Brown, One Teenager io 10. (Warner Boob; New Yort, 1983) and especially 5Ce Judith A Reisman and
Edwaro Eichel, KiIUCi. Sex And Fr.aud, (HWltiogtOD House; LA, 1m) (or Cull dOClJmClltalion or the "Kinsey scale:'"
homoserual programming In place natiouwidc.
18. '7be Uo..i(ed W;ry ol the B;ry Areafs) _ directors voted Tuesday to deny a $9,000 gnnt to the Mount Diablo Council ol
nay Scouts Ix:causc It desaimiD.1tcs apinst homosc:rua1&" and "will Corm, task ful'Cle 10 determine wbet.bct' the chariuble
group should COtItinue to provide $800,000 annually' lo kxaJ Boy Scout councils that reCuse 10 allow bomosc:xua.l you!hs to
join." (171.e Washington Friday.luly 26, 1991 :B8)
19. Sc:, Cor ccample, "A Time To Die, "'The shocking story or the Nazi Holocaust against Gay p>pJe 0( Gcrlllllny," (The
WISCOnsin Light; Milwaukee, WI. I2lune 19'91).
20. See Classified Advertisements in 1liE ADVOCATE and 5Ce Enrique T. Rueda, The HOalOSGnlllI Network (Dc'vin Adair
Company; Old Greenwich, eN, 198:2), 180-181.
21. Ibid, Rueda, oUen atemive documenlatioD of tbe impact DC activist homO$CXWlIs on society lllId public p:>Iicy. Also, a
c:arclul n:acling or the pro-bomosaual proCosioaalUter.lturc identities the powcrfuIln.!luence ot this wd.I educated and
media c:oDScious population.
22. As the ten pe.reent 8 gay" popUlation was CX3Ucnltcd 8 fold, It Is pouible that throat gonorrhea was contracted about
three SCQ)nds that year. Shilts pointed C)\.I( tbat "OilY VD woden" documented -45% oC Washltlgton sypbilIs eaniuI and
95% or amen in Hawaii as py. ODly ball o( male goDOrrbea Is pcwle pertt.nl shOM up in the anus with aPOtbct' 10-
14 pc:ra:tJ1 in the throat" (:14). Penile gonorrhea. he warned, can ClIdC anhriti1, k:Stide and proslnle infections, wit.b
syphilis ausing blindness, insanity. death. Other VDs :arc npldly tnmmltted, says THE ADYOCAIT, tbrou&h kissing and
even lhrou,h "usc oC the same tov.cl.-
'IHE INS"ITIUTE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-404 ARLINGTON. VIRGINIA ZDIJ7 7O'3-237-S4jS
THE ADVOCATE & THE GAYElLOW PAGES
64
23. 11IE .A.DVt:X::ATE also objoas to reparaUvc Ibc:npy rot" thole pys wbo 'ii'i:I.b to c:b.a.aie tlJcir IICIl1&lIM:s. Dr.
Nicolo&i (1991) addn:sacs the problema met by bot.b bomc,.,Tl1l! malca aod tbc:npiaa wbo an.c:mpt to bdp a
3SIIWIlC hla natural bdcrc8auallty aIId acb.icYe from the c:oafiDCI 0( bnnww=n,.1 bc:hsviot"_[md] dcspair."MDCIl 01.
WI &spair it due to czpcric:ncc:s of oqloCC1 and oftc:n orty ImIal abuIc, MY Nk:Ixlbi. Soc:aridea md othcn.. lbtll. wtziJc
vidima ol child let abua= an: ioaaaingIy praICICUDuJ their abuacn aud tbc:r.IIpcutioally their PMb. both
male aDd female bo
me
."
l1
a
l
'dWd aboac vidUDa arc sllCDI:cd:.:.u.d cx:ndemned to pcnDIIIICIU..!.eYcD
24.
25.
26.
27,
28.
29.
30.
31.
32
33.
34.
35.
36.
HOIDOlcrIlSJ&, by adYoating Cor adult gEj scbool COCIDIdon to otplli7J:: aDd COUDid py "youth grouP' (CJ., "Prc;ed 10:
Los AngeIc:s, CA; the HarYey Milk ScbooI Cor .vI' in NYC; and o.y RlgbIS ManiCCSUl&, 1ay Young.
1972). would a!w3ya indudc IDllI1Y who bdieYt: iQ adnlt Ie( 1Irith ch.iJdraJ. With roacJ1ly 110 2 mi11ioo people sayin& d1I1d
pornography.s.boukl be Icp1, it ia c1.:aI- that pc:dcru md pcdophiIa arc hBYinc All impac:l 011 childn:q aDd \aar irl .acidy.
The bome.,,,.,..! IIlOYC!DCD.t produced Krics ol "Manlr,...,,,, wIlict WCR: reprinted in Oul of 1M a:.r, Voicer of Gay
Lihm:riort, ediled by Karla 17'j and A/1I!:q YOWl! (1972, Douglas Linb, New Ycrl. Prominent atDOOJ tbcac
MJJU!e:u.o. la the cry (or llJI cad to the are 01. c:caacDt (pp.331367). A dole oC py danaDds Jlucd tmda that
nearly ew::ry demand, aa:pl the right to marriage, military wei cllild-adult baa been reali:zed.
This theme b.aa been ol't=. h o::ar!y AS Allgust 30,1972, an.A.DVOC.ATE anoooisl drew [our corporate
bwino:smcn. One male say:s to aIlot.her: "TIle Boss found out that Cart is maighr" aa a lb..Ird man stinb out the door, the
"1:>oM" pointing aogrily to the oil. Wuh major 1aws under a&.1wt by r;ay advocates, ic it timely to o:amine THE
.A.Dvoc.tTE {of 6 of ia gay moral CI.l.lJwe socializal to "u JOU1IF gcnerozion..
Flnt: Until the mid 50s voting was allowed only to pencns due to the recogniud immaturity o( youths.
R=t liquor ir;J.os tuM:: overturned the prior 18-year-oJd age. DOW rc:striaiog alcohol salea to 21and OYer. Tb.ia
the nation's growing awarctIc:::5$ of WIder 21 as at-risk youtha. Eap=c:ially rdevan! is the !act thar "py" organizatiooa
define pencIlS up to age 21 as "youtbs." Most "G2y and Lesbian Youth Groups" aaxpt "youth" up to age 21.
Mon1.s "Semal Patterns and the Law" in Sex Habits of American Men. Ed. by Albert ,Deutsch, Preutice HaJ1: New
Yoric. 1948) 131.
Sec mE 1991 GAl'ELLOW PAGES for sUle-by-IiUte bomoseruai population dau.
Ibid. to Abel, Eugene a tJJ.
PCI30nal interview February :23, 1986.
In The IVucOl\sin Ugiu (page 10) are (our larte s.ct: ads, oae 3 "d.alillg" "MEET YOUR MAN! Record your ad
today; Milke .. date: toni&bt1" Did Dutdicc "mea" b.i.s "date" through such. IDJIling (or pimping") scrvic:e? Three
other ads on the same page ad! scr ("Hard Bodies Need Stroking: Call 10 meeC mcu wIlo need you "Quick Release, Too
Hal to describe!) Twenry sellen ICY ads .appear in this 16 page: paper. And, above the "Malle a date" ad, is .a sm.aIl .article
about a py pby3iciaa "C!.arged in Two Sc::01aI A.s.t.auJts."
Sec, Cor c:xamplc, as noted Ibid: Jay and Young. 1972; Reuda, 1982; BcU and Weinberg, 1978 and 1M Goy huido, Joh.n
HUDter (1972) StODc.hill. Nc:w Yon.: and.An.d 1M &md Played 0/'1, Randy ShilLS. PenGuin: New York (1987).
Sec Morbidity md Morulity Weekly Report, June 7,1991, establishing the high pn:vaIence of blaclr: male AIDS arricn
(: 362). Hispanics carried 17% of the Cae in of Iheir numbcn in the CM:r.!n population.
Ibid, :358, witb Hispanic u.omen canying 22% o{ AIDS CISCI..
O:>ngn:ssiOJ\ll1 Record, Senate.. S S298, April 2'i, 1991.
Ibid.
TIlE INSTI"IlfIE FOR MEOlA FDUCATION
PO BOX 7-404 ARI.lNGTON, VIRGJNlA Z12D7 7Il3-237-.s-t55
THE ADVOCATE THE GAYELLOW PA.GES
6.5
37. Boyer was one oC lbe few pro-hOll1OlCC.la.l scbohn who mc:atioacd early K:[ abule u a Cac10r in bor'n<w=nl "lIcy and
especially in boy proWtution/\m.vfc She doaibc:d ODe boy molested at age 7, raped at age 10, and 3gain 2S a pro&titutc
by his aatomcr. She ootc:s anotbcr bey abused a1 age 8 by bis tS-yc:ar-oid maJc c:ouain, and later by two adult mc:n, aDd by a
He _ also n.ped by a nJal"'DCr'. Anolhc:r, John. _ raped by his unde, a few ye:an older, f.on:z:d to haw: Jell'
with two mal It patty. aDd IDOIatcd by a mmiatcr. David was drugcd by a cmtomcr and a.boaui !.or three wcdI, Eddie
- moIcsu:d at 9 yean by hia IDOlbc:r"I boyfrfcDd, another boy molested. (rom ace 7 to 10 by allCp-UDdc, ace 19, aDd tben
by Ilia stepfather. (172-173)
38. The notioa oC AIDS pcmLiYe permitted into the coantry co leIIJponl)' viaaa would 3IC':m to be grotmdc:d in the
ida !hat PYI b.ve cb.antcd r..bcir !ICm.I.I coadUC1 aDd arc pndicing Wcr lei c:D ma.e. While fJ:w pya o::rtainJy have
doDC this, the data do DOt support the idea that deYia.at s.:r habiLi have c.cao:f or CYCD slawa1 amDC1t: the gcocraI py
populatio.o.. And, al-ri:s.t anaJ aodomy with stnngera IppealS to be tbe I11k, IlDtiJ aDd I1llk::ss Icpl KtioQ rcruma to the pre-
IGnaey era.. .
39. The pro-llomoscwaJ lit=l.tun: commcDts offhandedly about tho! IlIIC 01. marijuana, "powcn- conainc aDd other stimuJanJs
and brain-altering The nitn.lc:s h.ve been found to be xnd highly inflammatory.
40. See Berthold Hinz, An in the Third Rdch (pantbcoD Booi::s: New' YOl'X, 1979) in the display oC braz.e:nly hol'Il<l5Cnlal o.azi
male image)' and CODCqlts, and see e:specially S. William Halperin. writing in Germany Tried DemogKy; A Political
History of the Rcicll from (Nortoa Booi::s: New York, 1946).. Here, Halperin desatCcs the role of public
howoscrual activists within HiLler's aazi party, even to m.1jor posts at import-
nIB INSrr'I1.TrB FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA Z1207 7m-237-S4SS
APPENDIX k. DRAFT OF G.tl'EU.OW' PAGE! PREl.tMIKARY DATA
A-l
I F1RST DRAFT I
A PRELIMINARY CONTENT ANALYSIS
'IHE 1991 NATIONAL eGAYEI.LOW PAGES- I..ISiED:
1. 1,464 STAlE-BY -STATE "GAY- CUL TURA1)POLITICAL AGENTS
105 NATIONAL "GAY" CULTURAIJPOLmCAL AGENTS
2. 477 STATE-BY-STATE "GAY" s&MJPORNOIEROTICA'AGENTS
83 NATIONAL -GAY" S&MJPORNOIEROTICA AGENTS
3. 43 STA1E-BY-STATE A G ~ ' " ' T S SOCIALIZING MINORS
4 NATIONAL AGENTS SOCIALIZING MINORS
TIm STATE-BY-STATE GROUP RATIOS WERE:
l. 1:3 "GAY/AIDS MOVEMENT" TO SEX SADISMJPORNO GROUPS
2- 1:11 CHILD SOCIALIZATION TO SEX SADISMJPORNO GROUPS
3. 1:34 CHlLD SOCIALIZATION TO "GAY/AIDS MOVE.MENT"" GROUPS
TIm rNSI'TIUIE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX: 74Q.C ARliNGTON, VIRGINIA '1Z21J7 7Q3.237.S4S5
APPENDOC Ie. DRAFT OF GAlElLOW PAGES PREl..DoIlNAR'Y DATA
nIB ntREB TOP USA HOYOSEXUAL CUL'IUR.AL V AlJJB."S
WERB RANK ORDERED BY QUAN1Tl"Y
IN 'IHE 1991 GAl'ElLDW PAGES
L HOMOSEXUAL ADVOCACY/POLrllCAL WOVEMENTS - lCk5 C'1"ES
46 AIDS ADVOCACY GROUPS
26 011iERS (INa. YOlIn-I RECRuITMENT EO. NAMBLA)
10 FAMn.. Y/yOtm-l ACl1VISTS
23 BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL GROuPS
2. SEXUAL SADISM (s.t:M) I PORNO I "'EROTICA- = 83 O'I"ES
31 "EROTICAlPORN" NATIONAL ENIERPRISES
14 VIDEO/FILMS (EXCLUDING 1 CITED "NON-PORNOORAPHIq
24 SM/FETISH CONTACI'S/PUBUCATIONS
(1 LEGENDS CITED AS "SEE ALSO LEA"IHER/FETlSH")
14 TR..ANSSEXUAL MA1CRlAL &:
(NOTE.: 23 "BOOKS" CrIED AS "SEE ALSO EROTICA,,)
r.
3. REUGIOUS ORGANIZATIONS{PUBUCATIONS = 41 cr:rns
4. SUMMARY OF GA YEllOw HOMOSEXUAL ACTIVIST NATIONAL RESOURCES:
ACADEMIC 17 colleges dtc .py" help organizations
AIDS SUPPORT ADVOCA.CY (5 gay only)
GROUPS
ALCHOHOL;SUBSTANCE 6 agenda . . ..
ADDICTIONS
ARCHIVES/l.IBRARIES 15 agencies
/HISTORY PROJECTS
BROADCAST MEDIA 2 progra IDS ci ted
RADIOrrv
HOMOSEXUAL SHOWS
BUSINESS &: PROFESSIONAL 23 23 py" (5 both)
ORGANIZATIONS
BUSINESS &: FINANCIAL 1 only gay owned (befCTO ad)
COMPUTERJBUu.ETIN 6
BOARD/HELPLINE.S
DISTRIBUTORS 1
EDUCATION &: RESEARCH B
ETHNIC HOMO RESOURCES 16 (half induding black)
FAMILY/YOl.JTI{ AS "GAY" 11 (4 "youth; NAMBLA elsewhere)
HEALTIl CARE 6
LEGAL SERVICES 9
MAILING LISTS
4
THE INSITlUTE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-4OoC ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA ZZ1IJ7 7OJ..2J7-5455
APPEl'ID1X A: DRAFT OF GAY.EU.OW PAGES PREI.JMINARY DATA
A-3
nIB l1IREE TOP USA HOWOSHXUAL aJLnJRAL V AUJES
WERE RANK ORDERED BY QUAN'lTI'Y
IN lHE 1991 GO'El.LOW PAGES
MEET MEN ONLY 10
MEET WOMEN ONLY 6
MILITARY 3 (mdud.i..D.g aXwnJttci: to 'Ilia miJ.l.:uy 1dVic:e)
MOVEMENr. POUTICAL 26 (including NAMBlA and its bu1letin)
MUSIQRECORDS/THEATER 22
PORN "EROTICA"jS&M 83 (31 "crotio\., 15 vidcoIlilms minua 1 "DoIl-POrn0gr3phic",
(Mail Order &: Film &: Video) and 2.4 S&M {I7 SIM cites, and 7 "3cc !.lao
(CithcrJ[et.i:t.b.") N01'E: DOt cited 23
31 "3cc abo eroticaj
PRISONER RESOURCES 4
PUBUCATIONSrrRA VEL 23 guide to gay oclebratiou dalCl nationwide; world
GUIDES guides (or gay mat.; where to meet young 3IJd old;
DIREcroRlES{IRAVEL -njuana TOtm"; "Venus .Advenrurcs"; etc:.
PUBLICA nONS GENERAL 29
[Male] [34J
[Female] [26]
RECREATION 13 (stamps, naturists, bod:ey. science fiCtiOD and Cantasy,
illlcru.atiOil.a.l hobby, dazlee, airii.oe stull. raelio,
car, Dud ists, cl.iD:! bas, women cyc:Iisls)
RELIGIOUS 41 (MOrtDOPA, Methodists, B.aptists, Axios7, Mennonites.,
ORGA.NlZATIONS Christian, J ebovah', Wi Uless, D !.bali 0., J c:Ws, Otris.t i.a.o
/PUBLICATIONS Scien tists, EY:lIl gclical1, QU!lkcn, La t ta-Day Saints,
Episcopal, NlItion.al Council of Chun:hc:s,
Pentecost, Reformed Church, 7tb Day
.Adventists, Unitarians, United Cbur.;h, UoiveJW
FeU.,...,.,.h.ip, Witches)
TRANSSEXUAL SERVICES 14 (including 10bbyinGJ
TIlE 1NSTIlU'IE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7*4 ARUNGTON, VIRGINIA Zl207 103-231-545S
A-4
nIREB TOP VALUED HOWOSEXUAL aJL1tJR.AL ACIWrI1ES
RANX. ORDERED BY INaDSJOH IN "'GAYBlLO...- rAGES. 1991
~ USA MA110NAL RBSOURc:m
L l . ~ fiA'I"B.ay -S'I'A"rn CULn.JR.ALtIOUl'1C INS'lTl'UIl()NS
82 NAl'lONAL "GAr O J : L ~ INSlTIUI'IONS
AL 9
AX .s
AZ 19
AR 11
CA 1&3
cr 34
DE 6
DC 22
FL 39
c
GA 21
HI 10
rD 2
IL 46
IN 23
lA 14
KS 5
KY 11
LA 2A
ME 21l
MD 24
MA 66
MI 29
MN SO
MS 10
MO 24
MT 7
NE 14
NV 10
NH 11
TIm INS1TIVIE FOR MEDlA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7-t04 AR.l..INOTON, VIRGINlA lZJSJ7 703-237-5455
APPENDIX A:. DRAFT OF GA.YE1LOW' PAGES PRPl..DmIARY DATA
1HREB TOr v AI..lJE[) HOWOSBXlJAL CUL'l'UR.AL ACIlVrl"lBS
RANX. ORDEltED BY INa.I.JSJON IN "CiA YElLOW- P AGm, 1991
AS USA
L
1.'"1 aJL1URAI.A"Ql..1' IM.'nTlU'l1OK'S
82 NAnONAL "GAY" aJL1URAI.A"Ql..1' INSTl1Ul1ONS
NJ 42
NM 15
NY 189
NC 52
NO 2
OH as
OK 9
OR 32
PA 53
PR 1
7
RI 9
I
SC 9
I
SD 1
TN 12
TIC 61
UT 8
VI' 20
V1 0
VA 45
WA 42
wv 4
WI 38
WY 3
TOTAL 1,401
2- .. n STAlE-BY -SI"ATB S&:M PORNOJROTICA INS1TIUl10NS
a3 NATIONAL SEX SADISM (S&:MYPORNorERanCA" INS"ITll..rI10NS
AL 8
AX. 5
AZ 15 (1 SM)
AR 1
TIm JNSTTIUTE FOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX AlUJNurnH, VIRGINIA '122117 7Q3..ZJ7.,S4.S5
2. fiAm-BY-SrATB M.W PORNOttiRancA lNSIIl'UIlONS
!l3 NA.11ONAL SEX SADISM
CA 70 (6SM)
CN 11 (1 SM)
DE 1
DC 3 (ISM)
FL 26 (2 SM)
GA ..
HI 0
ID ..
(1 SM)
IT. 12
IN 6 (SM)
_.
- -
IA 12 (1 SM)
KS 3
KY 0
LA 3 (2 SM)
ME 7 (15M)
MD 9
MA 14 (4 SM)
Ml 15 (3 SM)
MN 4 (3 SM)
MS 3
MO 8
MT 6
NE 3 (1 SM)
NY 5
NH 2
NJ 11
NM 4 (2 SM)
NY 51 (85M)
Ne 1.5
ND 1
OH 18 (4 SM)
OK 6
TIm INS1TlUI'E FOR MIIDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX 7404 ARLlNGTON, 'VmGINIA ZZ1JY7 703-Z37-S4SS
APPENDIX A: DRAFT OF GAYElLOW PAGES PREl..JlllNAR.Y DATA A-7
2- m STAl'E.BY -STAl'E S.I:Jo( PORNOtEROI1CA lNS1TIUI1ONS
!3 NATK>HAL SEX MDlSM IKnTIUl'1ONS
OR 9 (4SM)
PA 24
PR 0
RJ 1
SC 3
SO 2
IN 11 (lSM)
TX 27 (3SM)
lIT 0
. ,.
-
vr 3
VI 0
VA 4
"
WA 10 (1 SM)
WV 6
WI 10
-,
W"{
0
.--- - - ,- - ,-
TOTAL 477 --
-(50 SM) -- .. ". . - ... . 1,,,_" . , .
--- --
3- 43 S"rA'IE INS1TIUl101'lS "SOCIALlZE" MlNORS
'"
NATIONAL INSITIl.rrIONS MlNORS
AL 1 "GAY AND LESBIAN TEENAGERS - LOG CABIN CHURCH'"
AZ 1 WARIZONA GAY YOUTH"
AR 1 "GAY AND LESBtAN STUDENT ASSOC U OF ARKANSAS'
CA 3 "LAGUNA OU1REAGI, INC., YOUTH, WOMEN'S MEN'Sft "GAY YOt.JTI-I
Al.l.lANCE, SAN DrEGO" "GAY AREA YOUTH SWITCHBOARD, 386-GAYS
CN 1 YGPAlYOUNG GAY PEOPLE IN AcnON, lN1ERNAll0NAL"
DL 0
DC 2 LESB IAN YOlJIli Ot..J1REACH OF SEXUAL MINORITY YOl.lTI:l ASSISTANCE
LEAGUE (SMYAL)" & "SEXUAL MINORITY YOUTH ASSISTANCE LEAGUE
(SMYAL)"
FL 1 GAY AND LESBIAN SlUDENT SOc.uu. AND SUPPORT'
GA 0
HW 0
ID 0
THE INS'1l1VIE FOR MEDIA EDUCAnON
PO BOX 7-404 AlU.lNGTON. VlRGINlA '1ZJI17
APPENDIX A:. DRAFT OF GA.Y.!:lLOW PAGEr I"RFl.JWINARY DATA A-9
3. C STA"I'B INSTlTt1tlONS "SOC1A1J7E" 1llNORS
"
NATIONAL lNnTIUI'IONS "SCX:lAI.l2l!' WIHORS
R1 1 RHODE ISUND GAYJ1.E,SBtAN YOl.m-l (RGLyr
sc 0
SD 0 -
TN 0
TIC 4 GAY STUDENT NE"IWORK" "YOUNG ADULT POSITIVE SUPPORT," "DAllAS
GAY YOUTH GROUP," "GAY .t: LESBIAN YOUNG ADtn.:rs-
UT 1 TIiE YOUTH GROUP"
VI' 1 Ol..TIR.IGrIT VERMONT_YOUNG GAY, 1..ESBtAN &: BISEXUAL PEOPLE"
VI 0
VA 1 "YOUTI-I OUT &. UN1'IED (YOU)"
} ....
WA 2 yotrrn RAP GROUP C/O GAY COMMUNITY SOCIAL
"OASIS_YOUNG ADULT SUPPORT GROUP'"
WV 0
r
WI 2 GAY AND LESBIAN YOt..m-l OFMADISON"j "CAY YOUTH Mll...WAU'KEE"
WY 0
TOTAL 43
4. "SOCIALlZlNG" CANADIAN YOUTH:
1 LESBIAN &. GAY YOlJTIi./CALGARY (ALBERTA)
2 OA Y & LESBIAN YOUTH GROUP (EDMONTON)
3 VANCOUVER GAY/LESBlAN YOUTI-I GROUP
4 WINNIPEG GA Y/LESBIAN YOUTH
S OPEN DOOR, GAlA (YOUTH GROUP)
'0'
6 HAMILTON UNITED GAY SOCIETIES YOtm-l GROUP
7 GAY YOlJTI-ULONDON, C/O HALO
8 LESBIAN & GAY YOUTI-UOTTAWA-HULL
9 GAY &. I...E.SBiAN ASSOC. SUDBURY (GL-\D) "INCLUDE YOUTH GROUP"
10 LESBIAN &. GAY YOUTH TORONTO
TIre INSITIUIE fOR MEDIA EDUCATION
PO BOX ARLINGTON, VIRGINIA z;aQ1 703-237-54SS
APPENDIX B: SAMPLE OF GAY -OH-llA Y BJ,SHING
THE ADVOCATE April 9, 1991 (:42)
- - . """.-0- ., '. __ In' ,.', __ _ -
HARD CORE
1(900) 303-3333
1itlk, Meet, or j1Ht lliten to men in
Los Angeles San Francisco San Diego
B-1
THE INS'1TlUrH f'OR MlIDlA EDUCA noN PO BOX ARLfNGfON, VlR GOOA Z12I11 70:3-237-S45S
Cl
THE ADVOCATE April 9, 1991 (:29)
VISA/Me
. ~
APPENDIX D: RECENT SAMPlE OF BOY-sEX AD
.:,
THE ADVOCATE July 16, 1991 (:33)

..
Join lI\e ERO-VIOEO mall ordB" club. Be dlacr_
II.r1d your products m8JI&d. Monthly tty ......
o SS tI.JJI Fe: DIC.mlI Wt ... , o.l\UO s,_ ra/u"" Col "354
u.at'

on ______________ _
ST __ 'lI' ______ _
JIIOUTU.lE mull O. loQn""
By my SlQn,ttui. I stale U'\ill I ..". O-Wel 2'\ ,n. ot 10- &lid
yau 10 "..nCl me .II) Ot btOCnu' .....
'-
0-1
nIB IN"S1TIUIB FOR MEDIA EDUCATION PO BOX 7-4Q.( ARllNOTON, VIRGINIA ZXJIJ