Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
4, APRIL 2006
Abstract—In this paper, we consider UHF radio wave propa- different types of vegetation between 30 MHz and 60 GHz. A
gation in vegetated residential environments. The attenuating ef- semi-empirical model (dual gradient model) was presented for
fects of trees as well as those due to diffraction over the build- the millimeter spectrum [3]. Considering measurement geome-
ings are investigated. A new radio wave propagation prediction
model based on the combined method of ray tracing and diffrac- tries, this model gives better fit to measured data than purely
tion (CMRTD) is proposed. A row of trees is modeled as a two-di- empirical models. Attenuation through the canopies of single
mensional (2-D) cylinder. It is then represented by an equivalent trees was found to be between 10 to 20 dB for measurements
phase object (EPO); a row of buildings is replaced by an absorbing conducted at 869 MHz for low elevation angles [4]. Measure-
screen. The position and size of the EPO as well as the ampli- ments conducted by Cavdar [5] showed that the average value
tude and phase distributions of the input field at the EPO are de-
termined by ray tracing. Next the scattered field is computed by of the tree attenuations was 8.6 dB at UHF band, with the av-
the Kirchhoff diffraction theory. Among the numerical results are erage specific attenuation dB/m. The empirical
those of the scattering from a row of trees with circular or elliptic and semi-empirical models are simple and easy to use. How-
canopies and the scattering from a row of trees/buildings configu- ever, they are only applicable to specific measured data sets and
ration. The calculations treat both plane- and cylindrical-incident fail to reveal the underlying physical mechanisms affecting the
waves. By comparing the results with those obtained from the exact
eigenfunction expansion method, we show that the CMRTD is an propagation.
accurate and efficient method to calculate the scattering from a 2-D By contrast, theoretical models are based on various mech-
cylinder. Moreover, the range of the validity of using the CMRTD anisms of radio wave propagation through vegetation. They
to model the scattering from one row of trees is determined. can be classified into three categories. The first is known as the
Index Terms—Diffraction, ray tracing, elliptic cylinder, radio radiative transfer model, based on the radiative energy transfer
wave propagation, scattering. theory [6]. Ulaby et al. developed such a model [7] for radar
backscattering. To overcome the shortcomings of the traditional
I. INTRODUCTION EXD and the MED models, a radiative transfer model was
presented to predict the attenuation effects by the trees [8].
(1)
(6)
(7a)
Fig. 4. Diagram of a row of trees with circular canopies located in front of a
(7b) row of buildings.
(7c)
with
(8)
III. MODELING PROPAGATION THROUGH TREES AND
BUILDINGS
The size of the EPO is again determined by an iterative algo-
In this section, we will discuss the combined attenuation ef-
rithm. We can readily show that the position of EPO, , is given
fects of a row of trees/buildings, as shown in Fig. 3. In the figure,
by
the single tree represents a row of trees and the single building
denotes a row of buildings with uniform height . The planes
(9) of these rows are perpendicular to the paper and the incident
wave is from the left.
where is the ray incident upon the circumcircle of the The transmission loss through a building (i.e., into and out
cylinder at point . is the slope of ray , and of a building) is 18.7 dB at 900 MHz and higher at higher fre-
is the slope of the refracted ray . quencies [25]. For simplicity, a row of buildings is replaced by
In this case, the amplitude can also be calculated after (5), a perfect absorbing screen located at the plane , as shown
with given by in Fig. 4. Note that the penetration through the buildings needs
to be included at lower frequencies because of the smaller atten-
(10) uation. If the threshold of received power is set to be 20% of the
input power ( dB in path loss), then the penetration through
Furthermore, the phase of the incident field at the EPO is the buildings should be considered at or below 300 MHz for a
row of buildings with dielectric constant and
(11) width 2.5 m [25].
HUANG et al.: RADIO-PROPAGATION MODEL BASED ON CMRTD 1287
(13)
Fig. 5. Power of the total field behind a row of trees with circular canopies
for a 900-MHz incident plane wave. The tree canopy has a radius of 4 m, and
(14) the distance from the observation point to the center of the canopy is 50 m. The
refractive index of the tree canopy is n 1:014, and the absorption coefficient
Here, is the incident field at the top of the buildings. is 0:103 nep/m at 900 MHz [16].
is the scattered field propagating onto the top of the
buildings; it can be computed by (1). Substituting (14) into (13),
we have
(15)
where
(16)
(17) Fig. 6. Comparison of the field scattered from a 2-D circular cylinder for
a 900-MHz incident plane wave. The radius of the cylinder is 4 m, and the
observation point is 50 m from the center of the canopy. In the figure, the curve
(18) with solid line denotes the result of the CMRTD; the curve with character
corresponds to the result of the exact eigenfunction expansion method; the curve
(19) with dotted line represents the result of the TBL.
The scattering from a row of trees/buildings is addressed in canopies, the received power is small because of the scattering
this section. The combined attenuation effects of a row of and absorption from the trees, as shown in Fig. 5.
trees/buildings can be evaluated by (15). To verify the use of the CMRTD to compute the scattering
from a 2-D circular cylinder, the scattered field obtained by the
IV. NUMERICAL COMPUTATIONS CMRTD is compared with those obtained by the exact eigen-
function expansion method and the TBL method. Note that the
The power distributions of the scattered and total fields be- result of the TBL method is obtained from [10, (15)]. As illus-
hind a row of trees with circular or elliptic canopies are given trated in Fig. 6, the CMRTD agrees with the exact eigenfunction
for both plane- and cylindrical-incident waves. In addition, the expansion method in the forward-scattering direction but less
range of the validity of using CMRTD to model the scattering accurate for the side lobes. Also note that the CMRTD does not
from a row of trees is determined by comparing the results with agree with TBL. This may be due to the different descriptions
those of two empirical models and the TBL method [10]. of a row of trees. TBL regards a row of trees as a partially ab-
sorbing phase screen which describes the phase shift and attenu-
A. A Row of Trees With Circular Canopies ation from the trees with an exponential factor [16]. In contrast,
1) Plane-Wave Incidence: The power of the total field CMRTD describes a row of trees by an EPO which accounts for
behind a row of trees with circular canopies is plotted in not only the phase shift and attenuation but also the variation in
Fig. 5. When the receiver is placed in the shadow region of tree amplitude of the incident field traveling through a row of trees.
1288 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON ANTENNAS AND PROPAGATION, VOL. 54, NO. 4, APRIL 2006
Fig. 7. Power of the total field behind a row of trees with circular canopies for Fig. 8. Comparison of the power calculated by the CMRTD and the TBL
a 900-MHz incident cylindrical wave. The tree canopy has a radius of 4 m, and behind a row of buildings with/without trees for a 900-MHz incident plane wave.
the distance between the observation point and the center of the canopy is 50 The radius of the tree canopy is 4 m, the height of the building is 8 m, and the
m. The refractive index n 1:014, and the absorption coefficient 0:103 distance between the building and the observation plane is 20 m.
nep/m at 900 MHz.
Fig. 10. Power of the total field behind a row of trees with elliptic canopies Fig. 11. Scattering from a row of trees with elliptic canopies for a 900-MHz
for a 1.8-GHz incident plane wave. incident plane wave.
TABLE I
PARAMETERS FOR A ROW OF TREES WITH ELLIPTIC CANOPIES
TABLE II
AVERAGE POWER BEHIND A ROW OF TREES
Fig. 12. Scattering from a row of trees with elliptic canopies for a 1.8-GHz
incident plane wave.
Bingquan Chen received the Ph.D. degree in optics Jakob J. Stamnes received the M.Sc. degree in
from the University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway, in applied physics from the Norwegian Technical Uni-
1996. versity, Trondheim, Norway, in 1969 and the Ph.D.
From January 1997 to September 1999, he worked degree in optics from the University of Rochester,
as Postdoctoral Fellow at the Geophysical Institute, Rochester, NY, in 1975.
University of Alaska. Since October 1999, he has He is a Professor of physics in the Department
been a Research Professor in the Department of of Physics and Technology at the University of
Physics and Engineering Physics, Stevens Institute Bergen, Bergen, Norway. He has published a total of
of Technology, Hoboken, NJ. His current research more than 120 papers, mostly on wave propagation,
interests include modeling and simulation of ra- diffraction, and scattering, but recently on remote
diowave propagation for wireless communication sensing of the atmosphere and ocean as well as of
systems; biomedical optics, optical imaging techniques in random media as biological tissue. He is the author of Waves in Focal Regions (London, U.K.:
well as its applications in medical diagnoses; fiber optical sensors for nonde- Adam Hilger, 1986) and Editor of the SPIE Milestone Series on Electromag-
structive monitoring, imaging, testing and evaluation; diffraction theory and netic Fields in the Focal Region (SPIE Optical Engineering Press, Bellingham,
diffraction tomography; ocean optics, atmospheric optics, radiation transport WA: 2001).
in planetary media including the coupled atmosphere-snow/ice-ocean system, He is a fellow of the Optical Society of America (OSA), a member of Inter-
optical/satellite remote sensing. national Society for Optical Engineering (SPIE), and a founding member of the
European Optical Society (EOS).
Hong-Liang Cui (M’93) received the B.E. degree Robert Pastore, photograph and biography not available at the time of publi-
in applied physics from Changchun Institute of cation.
Optics and Fine Mechanics, Changchun, China, in
1982 and the Ph.D. degree in theoretical condensed
matter physics from Stevens Institute of Technology,
Hoboken, NJ, in 1987.
Since 1987, he has been on the faculty at Stevens Mark Farwell, photograph and biography not available at the time of publica-
Institute of Technology where he is currently a Pro- tion.
fessor of physics and directs the Applied Electronics
Laboratory. His research efforts are concentrated in
the areas of solid-state electronics/nanoelectronics,
optical communications and sensing, electromagnetic wave propagation and Wilbur Chin, photograph and biography not available at the time of publication.
interaction with matters such as bio-agents, and high-performance computing
approach to modeling of physical devices and phenomena. He has published
more than 150 research papers in peer-reviewed scientific journals, holds five
U.S. patents, and has guided 20 Ph.D. dissertations to completion.
Prof. Cui is a member of the American Physical Society, Optical Society of Jennifer Ross, photograph and biography not available at the time of publica-
America, and Sigma Xi. tion.