Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
It was my first semester after seven years of dealing with the English
speaking faculty and students in a Western culture; consequently,
bringing new thoughts and ideas to a traditional context was not
easy. However, my pedagogical learning experience, as well as
my academic education in the United States, helped me to apply
observational strategies as a methodology for my teaching from
the first semester. I decided to learn from my students as much
as they learn from me, as I strongly believe that the philosophy of
education cannot be successful without the educator’s ability to
put her/himself in the student’s shoes and exchange positions
with the student. This process of exchanging positions enables the
teacher to understand where the student is coming from.
After about three weeks of mingling with students, trying to
measure their level of English speaking and English writing through
one-page essay assignments, I applied the following methodology:
89
First: The Questionnaire:
I designed a questionnaire that I used in the beginning of each
semester for all the courses I taught since February 2005. In the first
meeting of each of my courses, I give my students the questionnaire,
and ask them to take 15 minutes to respond to the questions. This
gives each student the opportunity to get oriented to the course
and to the body of the class. The Questionnaire is very basic and
easy, but it has some complexity. The questions are as follow:
1. Name:…………………………………………………………………..
2. Major: …………………………………………………………………..
2. Academic Year: …………………………………………………………
3. Expected graduation date: ……………………………………………
4. The most important three things that made you joined the
university:
A………………………………………………………………………….
B. ………………………………………………………………………….
C. ………………………………………………………………………….
7. Identify three weaknesses, and how this class could help you to
overcome them:
A………………………………………………………………………….
B. ………………………………………………………………………….
C.………………………………………………………………………….
90
8. Describe three things that you would like to learn or accomplish in
this class or that you wish that this class could provide you:
A………………………………………………………………………….
B.………………………………………………………………………….
C.………………………………………………………………………….
Result:
First: At first I found it difficult to get clear written responses
from students. Some students asked me if they could take the
questionnaire home, so I decided to give the students the chance
to answer the questions at home and bring with them the written
answers in the next meeting.
Second: The responses I usually got from the students helped me to
moderate my syllabus and adjust it to the needs of the students.
Problem:
The usual problem that I faced since the beginning of this teaching
experience is the weakness of the English speaking and writing
skills of most of the students that take the class. Unfortunately,
the weakness of the students could discourage the enthusiastic
professor because it is very hard to teach a four-level English course
to students who barely read and write English. I discovered during
my last four years of teaching that most of the students who were
enrolled in the fourth-level course of English for Mass Communication
did not take the required introductory English language Courses
such as Eng100, Eng101, Eng102. Some students find it difficult
to pass the introductory English courses and depend on luck to
pass the fourth-level English Communication course. The behavior
of those students with low English performance has continued to
put pressure on professors to lower the standard and the context
of the course to match their level, leaving no challenge to those
whose performance is matching the level of the course. I remember
91
that one of the students I taught in the first semester declared
that he does not recognize the English alphabetic. I noticed that
some weak students are good in memorizing English-like pictures,
without knowing the meaning, just to pass the class. It was a
shocking experience to realize that those students had succeeded
in graduating from high school with about seven years of English
courses, and yet revealed they had no real English-speaking/writing
skills. I learned from students that the orientation program that the
University of Bahrain provides does not help them to prepare to pass
English classes. I attended one meeting of the faculty members at
the English Department in 2007, and I raised this problem. I found
agreement about the need for a re-evaluation of the orientation
program for first year>s students. However, I still had not heard
about any change in the orientation program. In November, 2008,
the issue was raised again through a general meeting between the
President of the University of Bahrain and the collective body of
university professors at the College of Arts. There was an agreement
that a new developed orientation program should introduced within
the new strategy of quality assurance at the University of Bahrain.
92
their total points according to a royal decree.
93
«poor» students. This «mercy» policy pushes those weak students
to graduate with a Bachelors degree and become a burden on the
growing global market of Bahrain. I strongly oppose such an approach
and find it unethical to distinguish between students according
to their economic or religious background. Even when it sounded
only fair to adjust our national system to help the disadvantaged
students fit in, it is unhealthy to provide the society with low-level
achievers. That policy obviously resulted in doing more harm than
good to students. Instead of pushing students forward, some
students lobby using different methods to get their way to lower the
standard of the courses, and consequently, lowering the standard
of the education at the University of Bahrain. One of those methods
that some students use to lobby over their grads was telling the
professor that this is their last semester in the university, and that
they could not graduate with a low G.P.A., making it seems like it is the
professor>s responsibility, not theirs, to gain a better grade. I found
out that not all students are always honest. Some of those students
who claimed in February 2005 that they were in their last semester,
have continued taking courses until now, which means that they
remained more than three years at the university after their previous
claim. Another pressure that is practiced by students is to seek
revenge on the professors who do not listen to their claims by giving
him/her very low student evaluation in the end of the semester. The
evaluation of professors by students empowers the students, and is
a way to leverage demands from the professor. While this method is
applied internationally, sometimes it is abused by students, and it is
used to bribe some professors, especially professors who need the
evaluation to renew their teaching contracts with the university.
Solution:
94
fact that most of the time, the same students are also weak in their
Arabic writing has contributed to my decision to use the resources
at the University of Bahrain to benefit the students. I keep trying
different methods of teaching and registering the progress and the
responses of my students.
95
students with a box with small cards. I had about forty students. So I
had to divide the class into eight groups. Each group has a maximum
of five students. Each student randomly selected a number and
that will be his group. I tried to be flexible with student choices, and
accepted switching from a group to a group in the first meeting only.
I gave students a sheet of paper to list their names and their group
number. I also asked each group to select a leader for the group. Then
I asked the leader to have the student write their names, their e-mail
addresses and their contact number on a separate sheet, then copy
this sheet and give each person in the group a copy of this sheet.
96
against the issues. Each group has to demonstrate their analytical
skills to support their views. Creating a clear purpose for writing and
communication is considered “a meaningful rhetorical act” (Flower,
1989, p. 749), which helps students focus and find the significance
in their act of communication.
The more I used groups, the more I found that students were gaining
important benefits. For example, by 2007, I noticed that the
students benefited heavily from working together as a team. I also
introduced web design as a way to encourage students to use media
technology. However, the students who attended the morning
class received a better chance in benefiting from the lab. There was
a problem in securing computer labs for the evening classes, as this
class not scheduled as a lab class.
In the courses that followed, I tried to book the computer lab for
the class in the beginning of the course and fought to secure the
computer lab for the students in all my classes, both Arabic and
English classes. In the beginning, my students in the beginning were
able to use the Computer lab once a week. However, in the last two
years, I succeeded in teaching all my courses at the computer labs
of the E-Learning Center. The E-Learning lab has a smart screen
linked to the professor>s computer, a projector, and a computer
for each student. The E-Learning lab also has a connection to the
world-wide internet network, which makes the teaching material
that is available online easily accessible for the professor. Some
students in this class never used the internet before. They learned
97
for the first time how to fight their fears and deal with the technology
successfully. My students also could connect with me and with
their classmates through multiple ways. As described by Brown
(2006) my students discovered that they “can use communication
technologies as a means for breaking down barriers that might
otherwise exclude them from particular learning environments” (p.
1). Instead of a group of individual writers and communicators, the
classroom becomes a community of writers, and the use of online
and computer resources facilitates the development of community
relations. “The term community is used often to describe class
dynamics associated with networked or online writing classrooms,
particularly in response to the potential for these technologies to
overcome material signifiers and geographic boundaries, creating
potential for more democratic and sustained participation among
class members online” (Brown, 2006, p. 2).
I will illustrate this method in detail. Students at the smart classes are
able to learn their English for Mass Communication course through
the following methods:
98
group at this stage. The choice this time should be final, since the
students have enough time to mingle with each other in the class.
6.I asked students to prepare a dictionary for the class that I call «My
Own Dictionary». Each student lists the new words they learn from
each lesson in his/her dictionary according to alphabetical order.
99
students that helped them to expand their latitudes in technology,
in English language, and in communicating internationally using
different methods of communication technologies.
100
They are trained in this class to focus on the job they find themselves
in, even if it is tentative.
14.Students are given extra credits for publishing their work in the
English newspapers. Only three students succeeded in publishing
articles in the daily newspapers and received extra grades for their
work. In addition to the communication skills that they acquired in
this class, which could qualify most of them to succeed in applying
for a good job and pass the job interview successfully. The students
were happy to learn how to use a website and were happy to have
created a good C.V.
The class is divided from the first week into groups of four or five
students. Each group was asked to come up with a topic that deals
with economic issues, to be produced in a10 minute video-tape. I
reserved an editing lab and used a technical support person to teach
my students how to use the camera and the lighting, and later how
101
to do video editing. Students received simplistic illustration of how
to film their video. The most important lesson is to learn how to get
involved in media technology, as well as how to succeed in working
in a team. Students also learn how to communicate using their
eye contact, their voice tone, their verbal clarity and their body
language. Each student is asked to give a small presentation, and
the rest of the class participates in the evaluation of the speech
presentation. This helps students to build their confidence and their
self esteem.
In the end of the semester, each group has to stand before the whole
class, and each member in the group has to talk about the whole
experience from his/her point of view. Each student is required to
produce a written report about the experience of the group. The
report about how to evaluate his work team and his role in it has to
be done individually. The report has to evaluate the teamwork from
a personal perspective. It has to describe the contribution of each
individual to the whole production from the beginning to the end.
Students have to research their topic before they write the script.
After this experience, I realized that professors should encourage
students, especially media students to work in a team, as the media
production is mostly an outcome of a team work.
102
Mirroring the type of experience they will have in the world of media
is critical to the student’s learning and ability to problem solve as
a group. People in communication and media never operate in a
vacuum, and so having the students collaborate on the challenges
facing them will help prepare them for future experiences. As
described by Fishman and Lief (2008), …writing, if taught with an eye
toward transfer of learning and with an explicit acknowledgement
of the context of freshman writing itself as a social practice, can
set students on a course of life-long learning so that they know how
to learn to become better and better writers in a variety of social
contexts” (p. 2).
103
with my students to some districts to supervise them during the
administration of the questionnaire. Each student in my class had to
fill six questionnaires. In the end, the class was able to gather about
400 questionnaires. Most students became engaged with the public
for the first time. Some students, including me were emotional
when hearing about each other’s experiences. I was happy that my
students grew up a great deal during this experience of studying
the people>s attitudes and learn about their own citizens in the
actual contexts. Some students talked about the generosity of the
people in some districts who treated them with all respect and dealt
with them as professionals. The course was an actual training for
students to learn how to communicate in a practical sitting. Besides,
the students in this course learned how to transcend their attitudes
of religious divisions as She’ah and Sunni, and learn to work together
as a team.
104
Conclusion:
105
students is being embraced in educational theory, being identified
as “place-based teaching.” Knepler (2006) describes the attraction
to place-based teaching as, “…Students discover, explore, and
research local spaces, examining their communities in order to
better understand both the history of the places and the catalysts
behind both physical and social changes…. We believe that students
need to engage the multiple communities that surround them and
also that communities benefit from the energy and enthusiasm that
students can bring to active citizenship, where citizenship means
recovering, critiquing, and actively engaging the world around
them” (Knepler, 2006, p. 2).
For the last four years, both the Arabic classes and the English classes
I taught helped me to realize that I can not teach my students alone
because the majority of my students learned from the previous
educational experiences at the primary and the secondary school,
and later at the university level that they are protected by some
professors and sometimes by their own families. This feeling of
protection continued to make them feel insecure. Their insecurity
made it hard for any new method to succeed; therefore, those weaker
students fight back by giving good professors bad evaluations.
Some of the professors who receive bad evaluations, no matter how
much efforts they invested on the students, become indifferent to
the teaching process and instead of improving their teaching skills,
they become a burden on the teaching environment.
106
Finally, I would like to add that our students could live up to the
challenge when they are given the right opportunity to discover their
own worth. They need to pass a dependable orientation program to
help them succeed in the transition from the secondary education
to the university level. Through the application of the new media in
education, our students could acquire multiple experiences.
107
References:
108