Você está na página 1de 7

LeonLard S.

lKenlworthy: A:n Early


Source of Ideas and Activities for
Teachinrlg Social Studies
DONNA A. BEARDSLEY- i

eonard Stout Kenworthy was born American Friends Service Committee in the Social Studies (Kenworthy 1977).
to Quaker parents in Richmond, Philadelphia asked Leonard to direct a He also wrote scores of books and arti-
Indiana, in 1912. His father, Murray relief agency in Berlin for the aid of Jew- cles on education issues, the teaching of
Kenworthy, was a faculty member in the ish people who wanted to emigrate from social studies, events in world affairs,
religious studies department at Earlham Germany, he accepted the position. and Quaker practices. Unfortunately,
College in Richmond. After spending After Kenworthy ended his yearlong others have written little about him
time in New York, Ohio, and Washing- stay in Berlin, he returned to the United (Beardsley 1993, 159).
ton, DC, Kenworthy enrolled in a Quak- States, where, before long, he was Among his many books, his Guide to
er boarding school not far from drafted. As a conscientious objector, he Social Studies Teaching in Secondary
Philadelphia. After graduation, he spent the next few years in the Civilian Schools (1973) is a particularly rich
attended Earlham College. In 1933, Public Service, a Friends program for source of interesting ideas and activities
Kenworthy enrolled at Columbia Uni- pacifists. In the Civilian Public Service, for teaching social studies. Although no
versity in New York and received a mas- Kenworthy worked with emotionally longer in print, it is still in most libraries
ter's degree in U.S. history. For several disturbed children for a year and then at the collegiate level and remains a use-
years, he was a faculty member at the volunteered in medical experiments at ful and popular reference among preser-
Friends Select School in Philadelphia, Yale University. vice and inservice teachers. Of particu-
the Brunswick School in Greenwich, At the end of the war, Kenworthy lar interest are the lesson starters and
Connecticut, and the Friends Central took a position with the United Nations extensions. He frames his suggestions
School in Overbrook, Pennsylvania. Educational, Scientific, and Cultural and beliefs about good teaching within
Kenworthy, his father, and his brother Organization (UNESCO) in Europe. He the larger context of aims: the behavior
spent many years working in other coun- was the first head of its Division on to be affected, the attitudes to be
tries for humanitarian causes. His father Education for International Understand- changed, the skills to be developed, and
led relief work in the Soviet Union dur- ing and wrote the first book commis- the knowledge to be learned (Kenwor-
ing the blight of the Volga region in sioned by UNESCO. After his work at thy 1973, 225-26).
1922, and his brother Carroll worked for UNESCO, he taught social studies
two years during the 1920s in the Far methods and international education for Aims of the Social Studies
East on the staff of the English-based thirty years as a professor of education
newspaper in Tokyo. In 1940, when the at Brooklyn College of the City Univer- Kenworthy states that if the guiding
sity of New York. He died in 1991. He purpose of teaching social studies is to
was active on the international relations encourage social and civic participation,
DONNA A. BEARDSLEY is a professor of committees of the National Education
secondary education at Southwest Missouri then the focus in teaching should center
State University in Springfield, Missouri. Association, the Association for Cur- on behavioral aims. He notes that for
riculum, and the National Council for their entire lives, individuals choose
THIE SOCIAL STUDIES JULY/AUGUST 2004 155
leaders, whether in social situations or opportunity, the aims should be the the effect of the New Deal. If the stu-
in political arenas. Therefore, the social focus of the lessons. dents believe that any political activity
studies should have as one of its guiding Kenworthy identified fostering skills is suspect and that individuals enter pol-
principles the study of the qualities as a separate goal. He stated that many itics only for personal gain, the teacher
needed for different leadership posi- skills need to be emphasized in the needs to point out that Roosevelt was an
tions. The school and the community social studies, ranging from understand- aristocrat and yet related easily to the
should be places in which the outcomes ing map symbols to leading a panel. For poor. If the students believe that Roo-
of those efforts are applied. their entire life, individuals use maps, sevelt was universally supported, they
In a similar manner, students will whether flight maps or road maps, maps need to learn about the backlash, even
participate as members of informal from an architect or a geologist, or maps from a number of his most impassioned
groups, as individuals in a family, in of a neighborhood or a city. The maps supporters, when he attempted to
the workplace, in labor organizations, may be polar projection maps or Merca- change the composition of the Supreme
in business associations, and in social tor projection maps. Teachers need to Court. According to Kenworthy, these
situations. To prepare students for these familiarize students with the specifics of points need to be brought out in any dis-
aspects of everyday living, it is impera- maps and give them the time needed to cussion of the New Deal and Roosevelt,
tive that teachers provide students with acquire the skills for understanding and but he believed that the ideas empha-
opportunities in which they take part in successfully using maps. sized do change or should change with
the skills of cooperative living. In addi- Throughout their lives, people must the makeup of the students in class,
tion, students will need to act as people think critically and make choices, which must be intelligently and
of moral character, good judgment, and whether at the store or in the voting unselfishly recognized by the teacher.
clear conscience. Teachers will have to booth for a local tax levy. They have to Kenworthy offered many strategies
teach them to honor themselves, to judge the credibility of their sources of through which the teacher can affect
form basic beliefs about life that will information and make decisions on can- behavior, change attitudes, develop
be important to social and civic didates at election time. They must skills, and teach content (Kenworthy
improvement, to focus on their assess the merits of an issue and decide 1973, 231-33, 252-58).
strengths, and to understand their whether they agree with the position of
weaknesses as individuals. an editorial in the newspaper. They must Starting a Lesson
Kenworthy believed that those pur- take a stand on issues in their social
poses should always be in the forefront groups and their professional lives. Kenworthy noted that teachers, espe-
of social studies teachers' thinking and Kenworthy believed that all lessons in cially new teachers, often discuss their
should be viewed as necessary aspects the social studies classroom include cer- concerns about motivation. He found
in teaching, rather than as aims in com- tain skills that are either central to the that acceptable because it indicates that
petition with content. He tied to the day's lesson or are an implied outcome, they are interested in teaching well, yet
behavioral aims the numerous attitudi- making skill development an important worrisome because it suggests that they
nal purposes to be addressed in social part of good social studies teaching. believe that a powerful beginning means
studies classes, ranging from courtesy The final category in social studies that the rest of the lesson will go
and consideration for people of diverse aims is the learning of knowledge. Ken- smoothly. In their concern to get a les-
backgrounds to respect for legal author- worthy believed that the knowledge to son off to a good start, teachers often
ity when democratically determined. be emphasized ought to be selected on turn to a gimmick and then stop the
An attitude on which individuals are the basis of the behavior to be affected, effort. With purposeful motivation, a
usually in consensus is the need for the attitudes to be changed, and the teacher endeavors to inspire students
respect of people of various religious skills to be developed. For example, throughout a lesson.
persuasions. Kenworthy wrote that it is when a teacher plans to spend two days Students can be motivated to learn
imperative for teachers to encourage on the contributions of Franklin D. Roo- when they are relaxed yet ready to
understanding and respect for all peo- sevelt and the impact of the New Deal, learn; when they choose or help choose
ple. He also believed that teachers need the teacher's task is to choose from the issues and objectives of a lesson whose
always to be on guard to thwart the idea accumulation of major points about topic interests them; when they can
that all individuals involved in politics Roosevelt and the New Deal and to pre- learn through real-life experiences;
are inherently corrupt, although he sent them to the students. Any number when they are asked to do things within
acknowledged that some dishonest peo- of points can be made, and hundreds of their capabilities; when they are aware
ple may be in public service. Kenworthy sources can be consulted. If the students with their hearts as well as with their
maintained that the teacher had opportu- have negative views about the New heads; when a new idea is connected to
nities for attitudinal influence every day Deal, the teacher needs to present infor- an old idea; when they have pondered
in the classroom, whether those were mation about why people in large num- the implications of their actions and
written into the lesson or whether the bers supported Roosevelt so that stu- engaged in an assessment of them;
teacher was conscious of them. At every dents acquire a deeper appreciation of when their learning leads to a social

156 JULY/AUGUST 2004 THE SOCIAL STUDIES


consequence related to it; when a con- and begin the lesson by having them are to research ways to improve its eco-
cept is made clear through repetition; describe what they see of interest on the nomic outlook. The important questions
when they have a sense of individual or map or by asking where they would like are: What do you do in the short and
group success; and when there is an ele- to live, work, or play and explain why. long terms? and Why? In another class,
ment of newness or surprise. In its other Showing the class a polar projection the teacher asks the students to identify
sense, motivation is the means that the with Russia and the former Soviet ten people from Greece for a Greek Hall
teacher uses to start a lesson. Union in the center catches most stu- of Heroes. For the remainder of the peri-
dents' attention. After the teacher men- od, the students can do research to sup-
Starting with MaterialThings tions that this map might be the kind port their choices.
used in Russian classrooms for social
When the teacher's friend brings a studies or history classes, he or she can Beginning a Class with a Tape
five-Reich mark German stamp from the lead into a discussion of how students in Recording or Music
1920s surcharged at five thousand Reich Russia view other countries and begin a
marks to class, the teacher invites several lesson on the relationship between a A recording of a famous speech or a
students to look at the stamp and explain nation's political life and its geography. stirring piece of music can catch stu-
their observation. To answer questions dents' attention. When studying the Mid-
about the reasons for the surcharge, the Starting with a Role Play dle East, the class can listen to Ben-
students do research about the causes and Gurion's speech when Israel became a
consequences of inflation. When starting a lesson about the sovereign nation and then discuss the
The teacher and the students assem- Supreme Court, the teacher explains the meaning of his words, their context, and
ble a variety of personal and household plan to serve on the mock court and then the eventual conflict that arose. If a stu-
items on a table in the classroom. The asks the following questions before dent in class plays a guitar or some other
items include gold jewelry, silver flat- assembling the group for a role play: instrument for the folk music, the
ware, copper wiring, steel wool, lead teacher can arrange for that student to
piping, nickel plating, zinc tubing, and How many volunteers will be needed?
What are the necessary job qualifica- accompany the class as they sing a folk
aluminum siding. They place the items song. Should the song be "The Erie
on a table and discuss them, focusing on tions?
Who nominates the judges? Canal," the teacher continues the class
their uses and origins. Then they place with a discussion of why the canal was
each item at the base of the chalkboard Who confirms them?
What are the responsibilities of the built, what it cost to construct the canal,
and string colored yarn from each object where it was located, and what its impact
to the places on a map where the raw justices on the court?
was on the American people at the time.
material is found. If some students do not participate, the
teacher can ask them why they do not Beginning with a Chalkboard
Starting with ProvocativeStatements want to be justices of the Supreme Court Presentation
or Questions or why they do not believe they are qual-
ified. The teacher can also use the role- Students arrive in the classroom and
At the start of the lesson, the teacher play method to have the students assume find an equilateral triangle drawn on the
announces that Franklin D. Roosevelt the roles of famous Supreme Court board. The teacher begins class by
was one of the most loved as well as judges or of great inventors of the past or telling the class that the triangle sym-
most despised figures in U.S. history. present and make presentations about bolizes the social hierarchy of French
For the remainder of the period, the how they came to invent the reaper, the society at the beginning of the French
teacher and the students examine why telephone, and the cotton gin. They can Revolution. The students complete the
that assertion is true. On another day, explain the impact associated with their chart, with the peasants at the base, the
the teacher begins with the statement, inventions now or in the past. For this nobility in the middle, and the king at
"Imperialism is dead, but it hasn't been technique to work well, the teacher the top. Through a series of questions,
buried yet:' Then the students respond should assign students to learn about one the teacher can show how the French
to the statement and give examples of its of the inventors in advance of the role- Revolution had the effect of turning the
validity. Teachers can write such state- playing. Throughout the lesson, students visual upside-down. As a follow-up, the
ments on the board so that students may remain in their roles. class can discuss whether the French
refer back to them throughout the dis- Revolution actually had that effect.
cussion period. Involving Students in Problem Solving
Beginning a Class with Controversial
Opening with Maps and Globes At the start of the period, the teacher Statements
explains the problem. For example, the
For a unit on South America, the teacher announces that the state is in Certain statements can serve as
teacher can refer the students to a map serious financial trouble, so the students openers to a lively class discussion.
THE SOCUL STUDIES JULY/AUGUST 2004 157
The students receive the statements in The Northwest Ordinance (Eighth- explained that he had a compact disc
one class and prepare to discuss them in Grade U.S. History Class) player in it, which he would be willing to
the following class. Statements such as sell to anyone who had enough money.
For students reading about the Ordi- Several students said that they wanted to
the following can spur students to a live-
ly discussion: nances of 1784 and 1785 and the North- buy the player but did not have the cash
west Ordinance of 1787, it is difficult to for it. The teacher then took on the role of
The Crusades were the most success- understand the terms because the North- a salesperson. explaining that a student
ful failure in history. west of today is not the Northwest of could get the player for a small amount
A single bullet has cheated history. old and because space relationships are down and a dollar a week. Several stu-
The future of Italy is in the past. the same. The teacher in this report dents were interested, and the teacher
asked one to come to the front where the
teacher tried to get her to agree to a con-
tract. Before long, the other students
Kenworthy hoped that by describing noteworthy were telling her not to be swayed by his
lessons, he would inspire teachers to make better manner. After the role playing, the
lesson plans. He urged teachers to adapt the teacher discussed the positive side of
installment buying and then the negative
ideas of others to fit their own situations. side, listing the advantages and disadvan-
tages on the board.

The Life of Napoleon (Tenth-Grade


The League of Nations was not a fail- began the lesson by putting construction World History Class)
ure of machinery but of men. paper over the area of the Northwest of
Those who use the tactics of the old on a U.S. map. The paper corre- When an interested group of students
enemy become the enemy themselves. sponded to the map that the teacher was was about to study the triumphs and
Franklin Roosevelt salvaged capital- using. The action immediately caught tragedies of Napoleon and his influence
ism rather than destroying it. the students' attention, and they saw the on world affairs, the teacher gave out
area affected by the ordinance. As the copies of two statements about
There is no Asia.
lesson continued, boundaries were Napoleon. One glorified him to the end;
Latin Americans are prisoners of their
added to the paper to show the states the other vilified him as one of the crim-
geography.
that had once been territories. inals of history. For the next several
Kenworthy also reminds his readers days, the students' task was to collect
that not all lessons need a powerful information supporting each statement.
Propaganda(Ninth-Grade Civics Class)
beginning. His aim is to motivate teach- The students spent some of their time in
ers to tum an ordinary lesson into an Halfway through a lesson, the the library and some working in class.
interesting one. teacher asked the students if any state- In a formal discussion on the last day,
ments made in the past twenty minutes the students presented their research in
were examples of propaganda. The stu- support of the two statements, citing
Extending the Learning
dents looked at one another for a sources for their opinion. The students
Over the course of his long career, moment, then began to consider the had gained knowledge in the context of
Kenworthy taught thousands of lessons possibility. The teacher waited until the critical thinking.
in secondary schools, supervised hun- students mentioned the uses of propa-
dreds of lessons taught by inexperi- ganda. Instead of lecturing about the Discoveringthe Mediterranean
enced teachers, and participated in topic, the teacher gave the students the Countries (Seventh-Grade World
lessons taught by veteran teachers. He opportunity to do some careful thinking Geography Class)
judged several lessons to be particularly about the practices of deception that
interesting and the type that would be were being discussed. After three days of reading about
appreciated by students. He recognized Mediterranean countries, a teacher
that one cannot reproduce exactly the came to class with a set of thirty pic-
Installment Buying (Twelfth-Grade
lesson of another teacher but can adapt Economics Class) tures with the captions removed. Once
ideas from the lessons to fit the situa- the students received the pictures, they
tion and teaching preferences. Kenwor- A group of students not especially discussed the pictures and the country.
thy hoped that describing noteworthy interested in social studies came to a bet- Most of the students were convinced
lessons such as the following would ter appreciation of the subject one day that the photographs were scenes from
inspire teachers to make better lesson when a young teacher entered the room Spain, but there were several pictures
plans. carrying a large box. The teacher that a few students thought could have

158 JULY/AUGUST 2004 THE SOCIAL STUDIES


come from that part of the Mediter- major divisions of the United Nations students the uses of flowers in Japanese
ranean. The assignment for the following and rectangles denoting the other agen- design and decoration. Although she was
day was to determine whether any of the cies. Over a few days, the circles and not fluent in English, she was able to
pictures could be photographs of Spain. rectangles were added to the display as gesture effectively to communicate with
study focused on the major divisions the class. The children had their first les-
The Accomplishments of John E and agencies. By the end of the week, son in the culture of another people.
Kennedy (Eleventh-Grade U.S. History all UN divisions and agencies received
Class) attention, and the class could discuss the Poverty in the United States (Tivelfth-
function of the United Nations. Grade ContemporaryIssues Class)
Before class, the teacher drew a stone
monument on the board with John F. Health in the United States (Eighth- or Several students in an advanced place-
Kennedy's name and dates of birth and Eleventh-Grade U.S. History Class) ment class on problems in American
death. The arriving students wondered democracy developed a television docu-
about the marker. Their teacher The teacher began the lesson with a mentary for their class, along with
explained to them that Thomas Jeffer- bar graph to show life expectancy in the charts, graphs, maps, and other visuals to
son's stone included the inscription, United States in 1800 (age forty-five), show the points they wanted to make
"Here was buried Thomas Jefferson, in 1850 (age thirty-nine), in 1900 (age about an American problem. One student
author of the Declaration of Indepen- forty-seven), in 1970 (age seventy), and in the group was assigned to each seg-
dence, of the Statute of Virginia for in 2002 (age seventy-eight). Next, the ment of the program, which included the
Religious Freedom, and Father of the teacher asked the students to explain following topics: What is meant by
University of Virginia," an inscription why the change in life expectancy was poverty? Why should we be concerned
that Jefferson directed be placed on his occurring, and they spent the next sev- about poverty in the United States?
stone. The teacher then asked the stu- eral days answering the question. Where are the concentrations of poverty?
dents to decide three accomplishments Appalachia, a case in point, and an intro-
that might be placed on Kennedy's ClassroomArchaeology (Ninth-Grade duction to poverty programs were also
marker. After a spirited debate, the stu- Ancient History Class) addressed. For information, the students
dents reached little consensus on the used books and articles from newspapers
accomplishments that best reflect his The teacher gave students a handout and magazines. At the end of the docu-
place in history. about archaeologists finding artifacts on mentary, the class discussed the problem
an expedition to an area of the country of poverty and its solutions.
The Versailles Treaty (Eleventh-Grade where it was assumed people lived cen-
U.S. History Class) turies ago. Among the artifacts were the Music in American History (Eighth-
bones and tusks of an elephant, hand- Grade U.S. History Class)
Students conducted research on a sculptured stone figurines, pieces of
head of state who attended the Versailles earthenware, ashes and charcoal, stone Late in the school year, when stu-
Conference after World War I, gathering arrowheads, seeds of grain, fragments dents are restless as the days of summer
information about the person, his phi- of flint, a person's skeleton, and stone vacation near, a teacher was starting a
losophy, and his impact on the outcome implements and instruments, a flint axe, review of course content and decided to
of the meeting. At the start of the class, and the skeletons of a dog and a cat. The review the significant periods of Ameri-
four students were selected for the roles teacher told the students to work alone can history through the use of music.
of Orlando, Lloyd George, Clemenceau, for part of the period, organizing the With the help of students, he planned a
and Wilson. Others were chosen to be artifacts into strata as they thought they four-day program of entertainment and
journalists to question the individuals would have been found in an excavation education. They assembled sheet music
about their views. The question-and- of the area. When they finished, the stu- and recordings. Several students and
answer session lasted through the peri- dents explained how they organized the parents were invited to perform.
od, and on the following day, the stu- items according to geologic time. From Beginning with the early colonial
dents participated in an open discussion the questions raised, the students con- piece "Old One Hundred," the students
and review. ducted research to explain the location sang, listened to recordings, and
of the artifacts. watched their fellow students and
The United Nations (Seventh-Grade guests play and sing songs about the
World History Class) JapaneseDesign and Decoration railroads and the sea. They sang Negro
(Tenth-Grade World History Class) religious songs, work songs, and the
To teach about the organization of the Depression song "Brother, Can You
United Nations and its administrative While reading about Japan, the Spare A Dime?" The teacher asked the
agencies, a teacher set up a display with teacher invited the Japanese spouse of students to identify ways in which the
circles of different colors denoting the an American serviceman to show the songs helped them better appreciate
THE SOCIAL STUDIES JULY/AUGUST 2004 159
history. The program helped maintain determine the number and kinds of Conclusion
the students' involvement, made them problems faced by the first administra-
take a second look at their heritage, tion when it came into power in 1789. I believe that the ideas presented here
and demonstrated the parallels between When the study was finished, the stu- are helpful because they reflect the
music and history. dents had identified the absence of a sys- behavioral, attitudinal, skill, and knowl-
tem of political parties, the lack of a edge aims of good social studies teaching
common language, the friction between in any time period, whether Kenworthy's
Products ofAfrica (Ninth-Grade World time or the present day. As Kenworthy
Geography Class) France and England in which the United
States remained involved, the inability of put it, if the major purpose of social stud-
Because the teacher thought that many people to read or write, transporta- ies teaching is to encourage social and
Africa was only a vague idea to stu- tion and communication problems, the civic participation, then the focus in
dents with learning disabilities, he Alien and Sedition Acts, the Whiskey teaching should be on behavioral aims.
planned to make the products of that Rebellion, and the selection of a military Those aims should dominate the thinking
continent real. He brought to school a officer to lead the new nation. of social studies teachers and should be a
chocolate bar, a bar of soap, a lemon, As a result of their research, Ameri- critical part of teaching.
an orange, a gold ring, a piece of cop- can independence took on a new impor- Many attitudinal goals also need to be
per, a sheet of aluminum, and a photo- tance to the students, and they had a bet- considered in social studies classes. The
graph of a nuclear bomb. As he ter appreciation of the problems of broad aim of developing skills overlaps
removed each item, he talked to the emerging nations. with behavioral and attitudinal purposes.
students about the farming of cacao, Every lesson in the social studies reflects
palm oil, and citrus fruits and the min- some emphasis on skills, making skill
World Religions (Tenth-Grade World development critical in good social stud-
ing of copper, bauxite, and uranium. History Class)
He then placed the items on an outline ies teaching. The final aims are the
map of Africa made of tagboard and A new teacher of a remedial group acquisition of knowledge, which should
placed it in one corner of the room. was having concerns about teaching the be selected on the basis of the behavior
The students' research assignment was similarities and differences between the to be affected, the attitudes to be
to discover what other products were major world religions. After consider- changed, and the skills to be developed.
farmed, mined, or produced in Africa able thought, she decided to make a The ideas and activities presented here
and to find visuals to put on the map by large drawing to take to class. She titled can help teachers achieve those aims.
the end of the week. it "The Tree of Western Religions." The
foot of the tree was labeled Judaism Key words: ideas for teaching social
and Greek Philosophies. A heavy studies, Kenworthy's theories, tips for
The United States as a New Nation social studies teachers
(Twelfth-Grade World Cultures Class) branch near the base was labeled Chris-
tianity. Above it, to one side, she put
For several weeks, the students had another branch labeled Islam. She REFERENCES
been focusing on the nation-states that could have continued in this manner for Beardsley, D. A. 1993. An early source of
emerged after World War H. They had some time, but for this class she kept information on American immigrants. The
made a list of obstacles to early state- the ideas simple. In another world his- ClearingHouse 68 (3): 159-62.
hood as a start to individual and group tory class focusing on a study of Asia, Kenworthy, L. S. 1973. Guide to social stud-
study of several countries. To establish a second teacher sketched a picture of ies teaching in secondary schools. Bel-
mont, CA: Wadsworth.
that the United States also had problems Asian religions, with trees used to - 1977. Worldview: The autobiogra-
of a similar nature when it became an show the dominant religions of that phy ofa social studies teacherand Quaker.
independent nation, the students were to part of the Pacific Rim. Richmond, IN: Friends United Press.

ERRATUM
In the article about examples of architecture as illustrations of civic virtue (TSS
May/June 2004, pages 107-14), the correct w ord to'describe the architectural detail
in figure' 8, page 11l is dentils.'That'correct term should also be inserted in line 10,
column 3 of'page 110.
The editor regrets the lapse.'

160 JULY/AUGUST 2004 THE SOCIAL STUDIES


COPYRIGHT INFORMATION

TITLE: Leonard S. Kenworthy: An Early Source of Ideas and


Activities for Teaching Social Studies
SOURCE: Soc Stud 95 no4 Jl/Ag 2004
WN: 0418800640003

The magazine publisher is the copyright holder of this article and it


is reproduced with permission. Further reproduction of this article in
violation of the copyright is prohibited. To contact the publisher:
http://www.heldref.org/

Copyright 1982-2004 The H.W. Wilson Company. All rights reserved.

Você também pode gostar