Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
On
A comparative analysis of financial performance
between Woodlands Multispecialty Hospital and
Apollo Gleneagles Hospital Kolkata
at
Submitted by
Mita Das
MBA (MAJOR- FINANCE, MINOR- MARKETING)
Declaration
I, Ms. Mita Das hereby declare that this project is the record of
authentic work carried out by me during the academic year 2018-
2020.This project is plagiarism free and has not been submitted to any
other university or Institute towards the award of any degree.
Preparing this project was a great chance for learning and professional
development. Therefore I consider myself as a lucky individual as I was
provided with this opportunity to be associated with Woodlands Multispeciality
Hospital which taught me a lot of things and where I got the chance to meet
wonderful people who helped me by sharing their knowledge.
I use this opportunity to express my deepest gratitude and special Thanks to Dr.
Ananda Mohan Pal (University of Calcutta) who took keen interest and guided
me all along, till the completion of my project work by providing all the
necessary information for making this project grand.
I wish to express my sincere thanks to ptoject guide Mr. Rajib Roy (Deputy
General Manager ,Finance) and Mr.Supratim Auddy (Deputy General Manager,
Finance) for their ceaseless effort for making this project a grand success.
Table of contents
Chapter Particulars Page
No. No.
1. Executive Summary 1
2. Introduction
3. Objective
4. Healthcare industry in India
5. Company Profile
Company History
Vision Mission
Achievements accolades, Ratings
Other details
Service/product profile
SWOT Analysis
6. Literature Review
7. Research Methodology
9. Observation / Findings
11. Conclusion
13. Limitation
14. Bibliography
15.
Chapter 1
Executive Summary
Analysis is the process of critically examining in detail information given in the
financial statement. For the purpose of analysis individual items are studies.
The scope of the study involves the various factors that affect the
financial efficiency of the company to increase the profit and sales
growth of the company.
The study finds out the operational efficiency of the organization and
allocation of resources to improve the efficiency of the organization.
The data of both the companies for the financial year 2018-19 are taken
into account for the study. The performance of Woodlands Multispeciality
Hospital is compared with Apollo Gleneagles Hospital Kolkata. This
study finds out the financial performance of the company with its major
competitor Apollo Gleneagles Hospital.
Chapter 2
Introduction :
Woodlands Hospital is as old as India herself. Ever since its inception,
Woodlands Hospital have nursed a dream of becoming one of the leading
healthcare provider of free India by providing global standards with advanced
technology.
In 1947, we began as a tertiary care unit. And today, we've grown much larger
to become a Multispeciality hospital. Over the years, our global quality of
treatment has enabled us to become the hospital of trust for patients not only of
Kolkata and eastern India, but also of neighboring countries.
In its 70+ year long journey, it have touched millions of lives and with that, also
the dream it nursed. Woodlands is part of the large and diversified business
conglomerate RP-SG group.
Statutory Compliance:
Bio-Medical Waste is not be mixed with any other waste. The collected
waste is temporarily stored in a designated Bio-Medical Waste room.
To know about the sources of incomes and expenses of both the companies.
To know more about private healthcare sector how it operates and all. WHO has
estimated that India will need an additional 80000 hospital beds each year for the next
five years to meet the demand of the Indian population.
Chapter 5
Healthcare industry in India
India is a land full of opportunities for players in the medical devices
industry. India’s healthcare industry is one of the fastest growing sectors
and it is expected to reach $280 billion by 2020.
The country has also become one of the leading destinations for high-end
diagnostic services with tremendous capital investment for advanced
diagnostic facilities, thus catering to a greater proportion of population.
Company Profile
HISTORY & ORIGIN:
East India Clinic Ltd was shifted to Woodlands Nursing Home. The
name Woodlands was derived from the name of the Palace.
The set up of Elgin Road as well as the pharmacy in Russel Street were
closed immediately after the opening of the Woodlands Nursing Home.
QUALITY POLICY:
Woodlands Hospital, Kolkata, is established with the purpose of providing
international standards of healthcare. We are further committed to achieve
patient centric care, clinical excellence and safety of patients, their relatives and
staff with the aid of trained medical, non-medical and paramedical
professionals.
AWARDS,ACCOLADES,CERTIFICATIO
N
WOODLANDS HOSPITAL IS NOW NABH
ACCREDITED****
"A public recognition of the achievement of accreditation standards by a
healthcare organisation, demonstrated through an independent external
peer assessment of that organisation's level of performance in relation to
the standards".
CERTIFICATION NUMBER - PEH -2019-0715
HIGHLIGHTS OF ACHIEVEMENT OF NABH
ACCREDITATION –
Empathetic Patient care and scientific treatment outcome.
High quality of care and patient safety
Patients get services by credential Medical& Support staff.
Rights of patients are respected and protected
Patient satisfaction is regularly evaluated
Accreditation provides an objective system of
empanelment by insurance and other third parties.
Accreditation provides access to reliable and certified
information on facilities, infrastructure and level of care.
THE ONLY HOSPITAL IN EASTERN INDIA
WITH ‘PHARMACIE-DE-QUALITIE’
CERTIFICATION -
The hospital offers Cardiac health Check Up, Executive Health Check
Up; Health Screening Schemes I, II & III; Customized Corporate
Diagnostics; Renal, Hepatic, Cardiovascular and Urological &
Gastrointestinal Test Packages.
There are Intensive Therapy Unit, Intensive Cardiac care Unit, Critical
care Unit, Neo-natal Intensive Therapy Unit and Special Care Units.
Procedures like Laparoscopies, Lithotripsy, URS / Uroslometry,
Cystoscopy & Allied Procedures, Cardiotocography; Burn, Trauma &
other cosmetic treatment and Smile Correction are carried out.
The Hospital provides 24-hour service.
It consists of a Blood Bank. It offers Dialysis, Imaging and Emergency
Intervention services.
The Hospital provides outpatient as well as in-patient care. It treats and
cures a wide range of maladies and complicated.
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
Highly qualified and Limited presence
experienced doctors High costs
Patient care
Focus on continuous
improvement
Quality Accreditations
Corporate Tie-ups.
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
Growing health concerns Competition
Underdeveloped healthcare Prohibitive healthcare costs
availability
Medical Tourism.
Strengths:
Highly qualified and experienced doctors – the doctors and
facilities are what make a hospital good. This is something that is
readily available in Woodlands Hospital. Every single appointed
doctor is highly qualified with impeccable experience which
ensures that you are in good hands and not just callous ones. This is
what segregates this hospital from the sea of other hospitals.
Weaknesses :
Limited presence – At present only providing services in
Kolkata with one and only branch.
High Costs -Even with the world-class services that they
provide, they charge a hefty amount of money which is not
always affordable by the common people. This is why this
hospital is not always the first option for the ordinary
people, even with the kind of services that they provides.
Opportunities:
Growing health concerns: With more and more
information available over the Internet, people are highly
conscious of their health today. They are also aware that
after 40 they need to keep track of the signals that their
body gives them. This is making people approach
specialists even for small ailments providing a plethora
of opportunities for hospitals.
Underdeveloped healthcare availability – India is that
third world country that is evolving in terms of hospitals
and healthcare. This is definitely one of the main reasons
which account for positive opportunities for the Apollo
Hospitals. The lesser amount of developed healthcare
service providers around the country pose as one of the
best opportunities for this hospital.
Medical Tourism: India is popular globally not just for
the quality of its healthcare but also for the quality of the
professionals who provide them. The nurses of India are
wanted globally for the prowess. The healthcare facilities
in India are also relatively cheaper. All this makes India a
prime target for medical tourism.
Threats:
Competition –With the advancing technology and newer
medical interventions, several hospitals are evolving with
their services as well. This is one of the primary threats
that Woodlands Hospital might encounter in the coming
future. Newer technologies are being added and most of
the high-end hospitals are incorporating the same into
their services to be able to successfully serve people with
their added and advanced services. This is one of those
threats that this establishment might face along the way.
Chapter 7
Literature Review
Literature review was done y referring previous studied, articles,
journals , books to know areas of the study and analyze the gap or
study not done so far. There are various studies were conducted
relating to operational performance of the company from which most
relevant literature were reviewed.
Susan Ward (2008) , emphasis that financial performance analysis
using ratios between key values helps investors to cope with the
massive amount in company financial statements.For example – they
can compute the percentage of net profit a company is generating on
the funds it has deployed. All other things remaining the same , a
company that earns a higher percentage of profit compare to other
companies is a better investment option.
M Y Khan and P K Jain (2011) , have explained that the financial
statements provide a summarized view of the financial position and
operations of a firm. Therefore much can be learnt about a firm from a
careful examination of its financial statements as invaluable
documents performance reports. The analysis of financial statements
is , thus an important aid to financial analysis.
Elizabeth Duncan and Eliott(2004) , had stated that the paper in the
title of efficiency ,customer service and financial performance among
Australian financial institutions show that all financial performance
measures as profit margin, return on assets are positively correlated
with customer service quality scores.
Jonas Elmeraji (2005) , tries to say that ratios can be an inevitable tool
for making an investment decision .Even so many new investors
would rather leave their decisions to fate than try to deal with the
intimidation of financial ratios. The truth is that ratios aren’t that
intimidating ,even if you don’t have a degree in business or finance.
Using ratios to make informed decisions about an investment makes a
lot of sense , once you know how to use them.
Carlos Coreaa (2007) , had explains that any analysis of the firm
whether by management, investors , or other interested parties, must
inclue an examination of te company’s financial data. The most
obvious and readily available source of this information is the
company’s annual report. The financial statement shall, in conformity
will generally accepted accounting practice, fairly present the state of
affairs of the company and the results of operations for the financial
year.
Rachell Minakxi .A (2011) have suggested that the financial statement
analysis involves analyzing the financial statements to extract
information that can facilitate decision making .It is the process if
evaluating the relationship between component parts of the financial
statements to obtain a better understanding of an entity’s position and
performance.
T.S Reddy and Y. Hari Prasad Reddy (2009) have stated that “The
statement disclosig status of investments is known as balance sheets
and statement showing the result is known as profit and loss account”.
I.M. Pandey had stated that the financial statements contain
information about the financial consequences and sources and uses of
financial resources, one should be able to say whether the financial
condition of a firm is good or bad, whether it is improving or
deteriorating One can relate financial variables of financial statements
in a meaningful way which will suggest the actions which one may
have to initiate to improve the firm’s financial condition.
Chapter 7
Research Methodology
This study is conducted to ascertain the comparative financial
performance of Woodlands Multispeciality hospital and Apollo
Gleneagles Hospital.
Research Design:
In this study I am going to analyze the financial
performance by using relevant tools and techniques
,quantitative and analytical research design is used.
Type of data:
The paper is based on basically secondary data. Datas
are collected from various sources i.e. annual report of the companies,
Govt published reports and various journals.
Chapter 8
Data analysis & interpretation
%OF TOTAL REVENUE OF WOODLANDS MULTISPECIALITY
HOSPITAL
6.95% 0.910 %
Return on Assets
16.85% 12.36%
Net Profit Ratio
0.081331661 0.019
Return on Equity
30.46 21.76
Earnings Per Share
1.170407
Asset to Equity Ratio 2.17
Liquidity ratio
Liquidity ratios measure a company's ability to pay debt obligations and its
margin of safety through the calculation of metrics including the current
ratio, quick ratio, absolute liquidity ratio.
Current Ratio:
The current ratio is a liquidity ratio that measures a company's ability to pay
short-term obligations or those due within one year. It tells investors and analysts
how a company can maximize the current assets on its balance sheet to satisfy its
current debt and other payables.
Interpretation
This ratio shows the current assets available to cover current liabilities at the
balance sheet date. There should be a reasonable buffer of current assets over
current liabilities as an indication of the ability of the firm to pay its debts as and
when they fall due.
In the year 2018-19 Woodlands Multispeciality Hospital shows
current ratio of 1.71 which implies that the firm has the current
assets of 1.71 times of its debts to pay off when they fall due.
Whereas, Apollo Gleneagles Hospital shows current ratio of 1.2264
which implies that the firm has currents assets of 1.2264 times of
its debts to pay off when they fall due.
Quick ratio :
The quick ratio is an indicator of a company’s short-term liquidity position and
measures a company’s ability to meet its short-term obligations with its most
liquid assets other than inventories.
Interpretation
As a supplement to current ratio, quick or acid test ratio aims to show the more
Liquid assets.With reference to current assets, the results are not significantly
affected since only inventories are not considered here.
Initially in the year 2018-19 Woddlands Multispeciality Hospital
recorded 1.65 which is more than that of Apollo Gleneagles
Hospital (0.8828) which implies more liquid assets are available to
Woodlands Multispeciality Hospital to pay thr more immediately
payable liabilities.
Absolute liquidity ratio:
Interpretation
An absolute liquid ratio of 0.5:1 is considered ideal for most of the companies.
Interpretation:
Interpretation
Interpretation
The return on equity ratio is a profitability ratio that measures the ability of a
firm to generate profits from its shareholders’ investments in the company.
Interpretation
This ratio indicates the ability of the firm’s assets to generate operating income.
Interpretation:
So it can stated that the total amount of debt is more for Woodlands
Multispeciality Hospital relative to its assets which shows there is an
inefficiency in managing debtors.
Debt-to-EBITDA Ratio:
The net debt-to-EBITDA ratio is a debt ratio that shows how many years it
would take for a company to pay back its debt if net debt and EBITDA are held
constant. If a company has more cash than debt, the ratio can be negative. It is
similar to the debt/EBITDA ratio, but net debt subtracts cash and cash
equivalents while the standard ratio does not.
Interpretation
Woodlands Multispeciality Hospital shows Debt to EBITDA ratio for the
year 2018-19 is 11.75 approx 12 years which implies that it would tale for
the company to payback its debt and EBITDA are held constant.
Whereas ,for Apollo Gleneagles Hospital it will take 10.35 aopprox 11 years
for the company to payback its debt if EBITDA held constant.
Asset-to-Equity Ratio:
The asset to equity ratio reveals the proportion of an entity’s assets that has been
funded by shareholderss. The inverse of this ratio shows the proportion of assets
that has been funded with debt.
Interpretation
Initially in the year 2018-19 Woodlands Multispeciality Hospital recorded
Assets to Equity ratio of 1.17 which is less than that of Apollo Gleneagles
Hospital wich has assets to equity ratio of 2.17.
Chapter 9
Observation /Findings
Based on the Statement of profit and loss of both the companies it can be stated
that-
So, we can state that Woodlands Multispeciality Hospital needs to focus on the
area of improving sales.
Woodlands Hospital spends more for employee benefits expenses approx. 41%
of its total expenses, 24% on cost of material consumed, 0.44% on purchase of
traded goods ,0.34% on decrease or increase in traded goods.
Based on the Balance sheet of both the companies we can state that
there is an inefficiency of managing inventories of Apollo Gleneagles
Hospital as the end of the year 2018-19 it stands for Rs.56115 whereas
for Woodlands Hospital it stands for 140.72.
Chapter 10
Suggestion & Reccomendation
On the basis of P/L analysis it can be suggested to the Woodlands
Multispeciality Hospital that-
Based on factors like liquidity ratios, profitability ratios and leverage ratios ,it
can be concluded that Woodlands Multispeciality Hospital is the most sought-
after company, which have shown tremendous financial result in the year
2018-19.
Chapter 11
Conclusion
Chapter 12
Contribution to the organization
As a two month finance intern I have learned here
• How to prepare bank reconciliation statement,
• The entire billing process which involves preparation of
purchase order then Goods received note which is issued by the
security after all this process the vendor’s bill is matched with the
purchase order , then the amount whichever is lower that is paid to
the respective vendors.
• How to do entry in their own software Hospital Management
System (HMS).How to operate it and make entry in it.
Chapter 13
Limitation :
The study has the following limitations-
Chapter 14
Bibliography
1. Annual report of Woodlands Hospital for the year 2018-19
2. Annual report of Apollo Gleneagles Hospital for the year
2018-19.
3. www.slideshare.net
4. www.woodlandshospital.com
5. www.ibef.org
6. www.olympiabenefits.com
7. www.scribd.com
8. Classnotes of Dr. Rajni Gupta on ratio analysis.
9. www.investopedia.com
ROUGHWORK
RATIO ANALYSIS FOR THE YEAR 2018-19 WOODLANDS
HOSPITAL
LIQUIDITY RATIO :
= 1.103064388
PROFITABILITY RATIO :
= 16.85913386
=8.80%
Return on Equity = Profit after Tax / Net worth
= Profit after Tax /Equity share capital, and Reserve and Surplus
= 934.45/18462.06
=0.081331661
LEVERAGE RATIO :
Debt-to-Assets Ratio = Total Debt / Total Assets
= (Short-term debt + Long-term debt) - (Cash + Cash equivalents)
/ Total Assets
= (196.86+ 140.75) -2771.35/ 21608.12
= - 0.11263
=21608.12/18462.06
=1.170407
COVERAGE RATIO :
= 7678/388340
=0.019
Earnings Per Share = Net Profit /Total no of shares outstanding
= 21.76
Debt-to-Assets Ratio = Total Debt / Total Assets
= 259733+45569-27766/842846
= 0.329284
Debt-to-EBITDA Ratio =Total Debt / EBITDA
= 259733+45569-27766/26806
=10.35
Asset-to-Equity Ratio = Total Assets / Total Equity
= 842846/388340
=2.17
Asset Coverage Ratio = (Assets – Intangible Assets) – (Current
Liabilities – Short-term Debt)) / Total Debt
= (842846-9483-3032)(16332145569)/(259733+45569-27766)
= 2.57
Notes to financial statements for the year ended 31-
3-2019
Woodlands Multispecialty hospital Limited (“the company”) was
incorporated on 29th December ,2009 and necessary certificate for
commencement of business was issued by the Registrar of
Companies, West Bengal on 11th January,2010.The company is
engaged in the business of healthcare and other related services.
Pursuant to a Scheme of Arrangement (“the scheme”) sanctioned by
the Hon’ble High Court Of Calcutta on 29th November, 2010, the
undertaking of Woodlands Medical Centre Limited (“transferor
company”) including inter alia all its properties, assets and liabilities
as on 1st April 2010 (“Transfer Date”) stood transferred to and vested
in the company as going concern effective the transfer date without
further act or deed.
The Scheme, upon sanction by the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta
became operative on 11th January 2010.IIn consideration of the
scheme the company has issued Equity shares to members and
Debenture holders of the transferor company:
To the extent the Equity shares have remained unallotted by the
company as on 31st march, 2019, either because application in the
requisite format has not been received or otherwise , the value thereof
computed at Rs.10 per equity share has been credited to and
considered under “Share Capital suspense account – Pending
allotment”. The amount of Rs.47.02 Lacs (previous year –Rs. 47.88
lacs)disclosed in share capital suspense account – pending allotment
and considered in the company’s Balance sheet as on 31st march ,
2019, has evolved out of the above and this will be transferred to
share capital account as and when the procedural issues stipulated in
the scheme are completed.