Você está na página 1de 156

For more information visit

McREL at www.mcrel.org

Thank you for downloading

The Future of Schooling:


Educating America in 2014

from the McREL Web site.

Skip introduction

Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning (McREL) is a private nonprofit


corporation located in Denver, Colorado. We provide field tested, research-based
products and services in the following areas:

• Assessment, Accountability, • Mathematics


and Data Use
• Professional Development
• Curriculum
• Rural Education
• Diversity
• School Improvement and
• Early Childhood Education Reform

• Education Technology • Science

• Instruction • Standards

• Leadership and Organization • Teacher Preparation and


Development Retention

• Literacy

PDF download
For more information visit
McREL at www.mcrel.org

Copyright Information

u This site and its contents are Copyright © 1995–2006 McREL except where otherwise
noted. All rights reserved.

The McREL logo and “Converting Information to Knowledge” are trademarks of McREL. Other
trademarks are the properties of the respective owners, and may or may not be used under license.

Permission is granted to reproduce, store and/or distribute the materials appearing on this web
site with the following limits:

• Materials may be reproduced, stored and/or distributed for informational and educational
uses, but in no case may they be used for profit or commercially without McREL’s prior
written permission.

• Materials may not be modified, altered or edited in any way without the express permission
of Mid-continent Research for Education and Learning. Please contact McREL.

• This copyright page must be included with any materials from this web site that are
reproduced, stored and/or distributed, except for personal use.

• McREL must be notified when materials are reproduced, stored and/or distributed, except
for personal use.

PDF download

! T-ID CONTINENT2ESEARCHFOR%DUCATIONAND,EARNING-C2%, WEDRAWUPONTHEBESTOFNEARLYYEARS
OFEDUCATIONRESEARCHTOCREATEPRACTICAL USER FRIENDLYPRODUCTSTHATHELPEDUCATORSCREATECLASSROOMSTHAT
PROVIDEALLSTUDENTSWITHOPPORTUNITIESFORSUCCESS

"ASEDIN!URORA #OLORADO -C2%,WASINCORPORATEDINAS-ID CONTINENT2EGIONAL%DUCATIONAL,ABORATORY


ANONPROlTORGANIZATIONCREATEDTOHELPEDUCATORSINTHENATIONSHEARTLANDBRIDGETHEGAPBETWEENRESEARCHAND
PRACTICE

-C2%,CONTINUESTOFULlLLTHISMISSION SERVINGASTHE2EGIONAL%DUCATIONAL,ABORATORYAND%ISENHOWER2E
GIONAL#ONSORTIUMFOR-ATHEMATICSAND3CIENCEFORTHESTATESOF#OLORADO +ANSAS -ISSOURI .EBRASKA .ORTH
$AKOTA 3OUTH$AKOTA AND7YOMING

(OWEVER OURWORK FUNDINGANDCLIENTS ANDIMPACTNOWEXTENDWELLBEYONDTHESESEVENSTATES4ODAY OUR


PLUSSTAFFMEMBERSPROVIDEACOMPREHENSIVEPACKAGEOFTOP QUALITYSCHOOLIMPROVEMENTPRODUCTSANDSERVICESTO
EDUCATORSFROMACROSSTHENATIONANDAROUNDTHEWORLD

/URRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTWORKPROVIDESTEACHERSANDADMINISTRATORSWITHVALUABLEINFORMATIONABOUT
PROVEN EFFECTIVEAPPROACHESTOTHECHALLENGESINEDUCATIONTODAY"YBUILDINGONRESEARCHTOSOLVESPECIlCPROB
LEMS -C2%,DEVELOPSWIDELYACCLAIMED0RE+ EDUCATIONALPRODUCTSTHATAREUSEDINCLASSROOMSNATIONALLYAND
INTERNATIONALLYTOHELPEDUCATORSMAXIMIZESTUDENTLEARNING-OREINFORMATIONABOUTOURPRODUCTSANDSERVICESIS
AVAILABLEON LINEATWWWMCRELORG

Ú-C2%,
!LLRIGHTSRESERVED
3ELECTIONSFROMTHISMANUALMAYNOTBEREPRODUCEDORTRANSMITTEDINANYFORMORBYANYMEANS ELECTRONICOR
MECHANICAL INCLUDINGPHOTOCOPYING RECORDING ORANYINFORMATIONSTORAGEORRETRIEVALSYSTEM WITHOUTWRITTEN
PERMISSIONFROM-C2%,2EQUESTSTODOSOSHOULDBEDIRECTEDTOINFO MCRELORG
4ABLEOF#ONTENTS
4ABLEOF#ONTENTS I

!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS II

0REFACE  III

)NTRODUCTION 

4HE3CENARIOS4HE3TORIES7ITHINTHE3TORY  

2ESEARCHAND$EVELOPMENT/RGANIZATION3CENARIOS 
h3CHOOLOPOLYGOV4HE-ORE4HINGS#HANGEv  
h3CHOOLOPOLYCOM7HEREAN POUND'ORILLA3LEEPSv  
h3CHOOLSUNLIMITEDGOV7HAT$OESNT+ILL9OUv  
h3CHOOLSUNLIMITEDCOM)F9OU7ANT3OMETHING$ONE2IGHTv 
$ISCUSSION1UESTIONS  

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIOS  
h0ARTY4IMEv  
h(ARD4IMESv 
h2AINING-ONEYAND2ULESv  
h!,AST2ESORTv  
$ISCUSSION1UESTIONS  

,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIOS  
h!LL )NCLUSIVE ,UXURY2ESORTv  
h2OADSIDE#HAIN-OTELv 
h"EDAND"REAKFAST#OUNTRY)NNv 
h2EST3TOP#AR#AMPINGv 
$ISCUSSION1UESTIONS 

.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIOS  


h9OU#ANT!LWAYS'ET7HAT9OU7ANTv
h)#ANT'ET.O3ATISFACTIONv 
h)MAGINEv 
h,IVEAND,ET$IEv 
$ISCUSSION1UESTIONS 

4AKINGTHE.EXT3TEPS  

I
!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS

4 HISPUBLICATIONISTHECULMINATIONOFAYEAR LONGEFFORTBYSENIORSTAFFMEMBERSOF-C2%,TO
DEVELOP WRITE EDIT ANDCRITIQUESCENARIOSFORTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATIONIN%ACHSETOFSCENARIOS
BENElTEDFROMTHEWORKOFALEADWRITERWITHREVISIONSMADEBYOTHERKEYCONTRIBUTORSFROMTHETEAM
4HETEAMSCRITIQUEDTHEIROWNANDOTHERTEAMSSCENARIOSFORPLAUSIBILITYANDRELEVANCEANDPROVIDED
MANYHELPFULSUGGESTIONSWHICHHAVEFOUNDTHEIRWAYINTOTHElNALPRODUCT7EWOULDLIKETOACKNOWL
EDGETHEFOLLOWINGINDIVIDUALS

,EAD7RITERS
,INDA"RANNAN3TATEEDUCATIONAGENCY
"RYAN'OODWIN2ESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTORGANIZATION
3ALLY'RUBB,OCALEDUCATIONAGENCY
!DRIENNE3CHURE.ATIONALMEMBERSHIPASSOCIATION

+EY#ONTRIBUTORS
3USAN!DAMS.ATIONALMEMBERSHIPASSOCIATION
:OE"ARLEY,OCALEDUCATIONAGENCY
#ERI$EAN,OCALEDUCATIONAGENCY
$AVID&ROST.ATIONALMEMBERSHIPASSOCIATION
*ENNIFER.ORFORD.ATIONALMEMBERSHIPASSOCIATION
(OWARD0ITLER.ATIONALMEMBERSHIPASSOCIATION
'LEN4AYLOR,OCALEDUCATIONAGENCY
4IM7ATERS2ESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTORGANIZATION
*OHN7ETHERINGTON,OCALEDUCATIONAGENCY

/THER-EMBERSOFTHE3CENARIO"UILDING4EAM
,OU#ICCHINELLI
*OHN+ENDALL
"RIAN-C.ULTY
$ANETTE0ARSLEY
*AN4UOMI
#AROLYN7OEMPNER

)NTRODUCTIONBY
,AURA,EFKOWITS

%DITEDBY
,AURA,EFKOWITSAND6ICKI5RQUHART

$ESKTOPPING'RAPHIC$ESIGNBY
$ON"YRTUS
"RIAN,ANCASTER

II 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
0REFACE
0REPAREDFORANUNCERTAINFUTURE
4HELEGACYOFRESPONSIBLELEADERSHIP

7 HATARETHEGLOBAL DEMOGRAPHIC ECONOMIC TECHNOLOGICAL POLITICAL ANDGENERATIONALTRENDSTHATWILL


SHAPETHEWORLDINWHICHWEWILLLIVEANDWORKINTHEYEAR7HATARETHECHANCESTHATALLORSOME
COMBINATIONOFTHESETRENDSWILLCONVERGEINWAYSTHATCREATEAFUTUREFUNDAMENTALLYDIFFERENTFROMOURPAST
EXPERIENCESANDCURRENTREALITIES7HATMIGHTBETHEEFFECTOFTHESETRENDSON!MERICASEDUCATIONSYSTEM7HAT
ARETHEIMPLICATIONSFORORGANIZATIONS LIKE-C2%, THATPROVIDESERVICESANDORSELLPRODUCTSTOTHEEDUCATION
MARKET(OWSHOULDLEADERSANTICIPATEANDPREPARETHEIRORGANIZATIONSFORAFUTURESHAPEDBYTHEPOTENTIALCON
VERGENCEOFTHESETRENDS4HESEAREJUSTSOMEOFTHEQUESTIONSTHATMOTIVATED-C2%,SLEADERSHIPTEAMTOINITIATE
THEPROCESSTHATPRODUCEDTHEMATERIALSOFFEREDHERE
-C2%,ISANON PROlTORGANIZATIONWITHAMISSIONTOhMAKEADIFFERENCEINTHEQUALITYOFEDUCATIONAND
LEARNINGFORALLTHROUGHAPPLIEDRESEARCH PRODUCTDEVELOPMENT ANDSERVICEv/URCONTRACTSWITHTHE53$E
PARTMENTOF%DUCATIONANDOTHERSOVERTHELASTYEARSALLOWUSTOCARRYOUTPROGRAMSOFAPPLIEDRESEARCHAND
TODEVELOPPRODUCTSANDSERVICESFOR+nEDUCATORSBASEDONTHATRESEARCH4HEFUTUREOFOURORGANIZATIONRELIES
HEAVILYONTHELEVELOFAVAILABLEFUNDINGFOREDUCATIONRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENT ASWELLASTHECONDITIONOF
!MERICASEDUCATIONSYSTEM!SIGNIlCANTCHANGEINEITHERWILLREQUIREOURORGANIZATIONTOREPOSITIONITSELFINTHE
EDUCATIONMARKET

)N WEBEGANWONDERINGABOUTTHEQUESTIONSABOVEANDHOWWESHOULDPREPAREFORTHEYEARAND
BEYOND7HY YOUMIGHTASK DIDWEFOCUSONTHEYEAR#ONSIDERTHEFOLLOWING

s WILLBETHElNALYEAROFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTASSUMINGITISREAUTHORIZEDIN ANDWE
WILLKNOWHOWMANYSCHOOLSIN!MERICAMADEORFAILEDTOMAKEhADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESSv

s )N BABYBOOMERS THOSEMILLION!MERICANSBORNBETWEENAND WILLBERETIRINGINSIG


NIlCANTNUMBERS ANDTHEIRRETIREMENTSCOULDLEADTODISTURBINGSHORTAGESINTHESUPPLYOFQUALIlEDTEACHERS
ANDADMINISTRATORS

s ISTHEYEARINWHICHMANYECONOMISTSFORECASTTHE3OCIAL3ECURITYTRUSTFUNDWILLBEGINTODISBURSE
MOREFUNDSTHANITRECEIVESINORDERTOACCOMMODATETHEHIGHNUMBEROFRETIRINGBABYBOOMERS

s !STHEBABYBOOMERSRETIRE MEMBERSOFANEWGENERATION 'ENERATION8 WITHADIFFERENTSETOFCHARACTERIS


TICSANDPRIORITIES WILLTAKEPOSITIONSOFPOWERANDAUTHORITY

s CLOSELYCOINCIDESWITHTHEPERIODDURINGWHICHSOMEECONOMISTSPREDICTTHEMOSTDRAMATICECONOMIC
DOWNTURNSINCETHE'REAT$EPRESSIONOFTHEEARLYS

s )NFORMATIONANDDIGITALTECHNOLOGIESAREINCREASINGLYMOVINGTHECONTROLOFLEARNINGAWAYFROMINSTITUTIONS
ANDTOWARDINDIVIDUALSTUDENTS"Y THESETECHNOLOGIESWILLEXPANDTHEOPTIONSANDCHOICESINDIVIDU
ALSANDFAMILIESHAVEINALLASPECTSOFTHEIRLIVES INCLUDINGEDUCATION

s !ROUND MEMBERSOFOURMANAGEMENTTEAM COMPRISEDALMOSTENTIRELYOFBABYBOOMERS WILLBEOF


TRADITIONALRETIREMENTAGE CREATINGANOBVIOUSNEEDFORSUCCESSIONPLANNING

III
!NYONEOFTHESEDEVELOPMENTSPOTENTIALLYCOULDMAKEANIMPACTONOURCLIENTS OURFUNDERS ANDOURWORK
4HECOMBINATIONOFANYOFTHEMCOULDCREATEFUNDAMENTALCHANGESINTHEBUSINESSENVIRONMENTANDTHEMARKET
PLACE ANDTHATWOULDIMPLYSIGNIlCANTCHANGESFOR-C2%,
)N WEKNEWLITTLEABOUTTHEIMPLICATIONSOFANAGING!MERICANWORKFORCEANDTHEASSOCIATEDSTRESSESIT
COULDPLACEONPUBLICANDPRIVATERESOURCESFOREDUCATIONRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENT4HESAMEWASTRUEOFOUR
UNDERSTANDINGOFTHEIMPACTOFRAPIDADVANCEMENTSININFORMATIONANDDIGITALTECHNOLOGY ANDOFTHEINHERENT
CHALLENGESTOTHEGOALOFLEAVINGNOCHILDBEHINDINOURINCREASINGLYCOMPETITIVEGLOBALECONOMY9ET ONETHING
WASCLEARTOALLOFUS THINGSWERECHANGING ANDTHETENYEARSFROMTOJUSTMIGHTBEUNLIKEANYEXPERI
ENCEDINRECENTHISTORY
3O WEBEGANCOLLECTINGDATAONWORKFORCEANDSTUDENTDEMOGRAPHICS FORECASTEDCOSTSOFENTITLEMENTPRO
GRAMSANDHEALTHCAREFORSENIORS EMERGINGTECHNOLOGIESANDTHEIRLIKELYIMPACTONSCHOOLINGANDLEARNING GEN
ERATIONALCHARACTERISTICS ECONOMICS THEIMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT GLOBALIZATION ENERGY
CONSUMPTION ANDSCHOOLCHOICE4HEMOREDATAWECOLLECTED ANALYZED ANDSYNTHESIZED THEMOREAPPARENTIT
BECAMETHATWEMUSTPREPARENOWFORANUNCERTAINFUTURE!SALEADERSHIPTEAM WECONCLUDEDTHATPREPARINGOUR
ORGANIZATIONFORWHATEVERUNCERTAINTIESLIEAHEADWOULDBEOURLEGACY
4HUS WEEMBARKEDONADELIBERATEJOURNEYTOTHEFUTURERESULTINGINTHESCENARIOSWEOFFERHERE/URAP
PROACHBEGANBYIDENTIFYINGTRENDSOFCONCERNTOUSANDEXPERTSWHOCOULDBRINGUSNEWKNOWLEDGEANDPROVOKE
THOUGHTFULANDCRITICALINQUIRYABOUTCERTAINTIESANDUNCERTAINTIESBETWEENAND/URSENIORMANAGE
MENTANDPROGRAMSTAFFNEARLYONE THIRDOFOURORGANIZATION ENGAGEDINARIGOROUSPROCESSOFLEARNING DELIB
ERATING ANDARCHIVINGKEYINSIGHTSABOUTTRENDSANDTHEIMPLICATIONSFORGOVERNMENTANDPOLITICS WORKAND
THEWORKPLACE HOMEANDLIFESTYLES ANDSCHOOLINGANDLEARNING/URBOARDOFDIRECTORS COMPRISEDOFSTATEAND
NATIONALEDUCATION POLICY ANDBUSINESSLEADERS INFORMEDOURDELIBERATIONSANDCRITIQUEDTHESTAFFSWORKTOBE
CERTAINITWASPLAUSIBLEANDUSEFUL7EDEVELOPEDINTERNALEXPERTISEINTHEPROCESSOFWRITINGANDUSINGSCENARIOS
OFFEREDBYTHE'LOBAL"USINESS.ETWORKAND ULTIMATELY ENVISIONEDNOTONEBUTATOTALOFPOSSIBLEFUTURES
EACHOFWHICHWILLPROVIDEUSGUIDANCEASWECHARTOURORGANIZATIONALCOURSEINTHEYEARSAHEAD/UROBJECTIVE
WASTOCREATEARESOURCEFOR-C2%, ASWELLASFORTHELEADERSOFOTHERORGANIZATIONS WHOSEESCENARIOSASATOOLTO
AIDTHEIROWNPREPARATIONSFORANUNCERTAINFUTURE
4HOUGHWEHAVENOTANSWEREDALLOFTHEQUESTIONSTHATMOTIVATEDTHISWORK WEHAVEDEVELOPEDARESOURCE
THATWEBELIEVEWILLSERVEUSWELLINWHATEVERFUTUREWEEXPERIENCE4HROUGHTHESESCENARIOSWEARECONlDENT
WECANANTICIPATETHEWORLDINWHICHWEMIGHTLIVEANDWORKIN MONITORWHATUNFOLDSINhREALTIME vAND
DEVELOPTIMELY APPROPRIATESTRATEGIESTOPOSITIONOURORGANIZATIONTOSURVIVEANDTHRIVEASWEREALIZEOURMISSION
OFMAKINGADIFFERENCEINTHEQUALITYOFEDUCATIONANDLEARNINGFORALL
/URLEADERSHIPTEAMAPPRECIATESTHESUPPORTOFTHE-C2%,"OARDOF$IRECTORSANDTHEIRINVOLVEMENTINTHIS
EFFORT7EAREGRATEFULASWELLFORTHEHARDINTELLECTUALWORKOFTHE-C2%,STAFFMEMBERSWHOBRILLIANTLYCON
TRIBUTEDTOTHISPRODUCT&INALLY WEAREPLEASEDTOSHARETHESEMATERIALSWITHOURCLIENTS PARTNERS FUNDERS AND
COMPETITORS7EALLHAVEMUCHATSTAKEASWEANTICIPATETHEWORLDOFANDBEYOND)TISINALLOFOURINTERESTS
TOTHOUGHTFULLYPREPAREFORTHATWORLDANDTHATTIME)FTHESEMATERIALSCONTRIBUTETOYOURPREPARATION THENTHE
WORLDINWHICHWELIVENOW ANDTHEONEINWHICHWEWILLLIVEANDWORKIN WILLBEBETTERSERVED

*4IMOTHY7ATERS %D$
#%/AND%XECUTIVE$IRECTOR
-C2%,

IV 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
)NTRODUCTION
h4HENARRATIVESOFTHEWORLDAREWITHOUTNUMBERTHENARRATIVEISPRESENTATALLTIMES INALLPLACES INALL
SOCIETIESTHEHISTORYOFNARRATIVEBEGINSWITHTHEHISTORYOFMANKINDTHEREDOESNOTEXIST ANDNEVERHAS
EXISTED APEOPLEWITHOUTNARRATIVESv
^"ARTHES

4 HROUGHOUTHISTORY STORIESHAVERECORDEDTHEPASTANDSHAPEDTHEFUTURE4HISPUBLICATIONOFFERSTHREESUCH
STORIES)TISTHESTORYOFONEORGANIZATIONSJOURNEYINPREPARATIONFORACHANGINGWORLD4HATJOURNEYRESULTED
INANOTHERSETOFSTORIESABOUTTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATIONINOFFEREDHERE&INALLY ITMAYBETHElRSTCHAPTERIN
THESTORYOFOUROWNFUTURESASSTAKEHOLDERSINTHE!MERICANEDUCATIONALENTERPRISEˆASTORYTHATWILLBESHARED
ASHISTORYWITHFUTUREGENERATIONS
,IKEMOSTSTORIES THEREISNOSINGLEhTRUTHvWITHIN2ATHER READERSWILLDRAWINDIVIDUALINTERPRETATIONSOFTHE
STORIESMEANINGSANDWILLRESPONDINKIND)NSHARINGTHESESTORIES WEHOPETOCHALLENGE INSPIRE ANDMOTIVATE
THEEDUCATIONINDUSTRYTOPREPAREFORACHANGINGWORLD)NDEED WEBELIEVETHATIFWEDONTACTNOWINRESPONSETO
THEANTICIPATEDCHANGESAHEAD THELEGACYWELEAVEFORFUTURELEARNERSWILLBEINSUFlCIENTTOMEETTHECHALLENGES
AHEAD
4OSAYTHEOBVIOUS THEFUTUREWILLCOME4HEONLYQUESTIONIS WILLWEBEPREPAREDTOSURVIVEANDTHRIVEIN
THEFUTUREORWILLWEBECOMEOBSOLETEANDIRRELEVANTINTHENEWWORLD7ECHOOSETOBEPREPAREDANDHOPEYOU
WILLJOINUS

/UR3TORY
!T-C2%, WEAPPROACHALLOFOURSCHOOLIMPROVEMENTEFFORTSFROMTHREEBASICASSUMPTIONS

7EMUSTGETTHEMOSTPOSSIBLEOUTOFOURCURRENTEDUCATIONALSYSTEMFORTHEBENElTOFEVERYSTUDENT

(OWEVER 53SCHOOLS ASCURRENTLYDESIGNED ARENOTLIKELYTOMEETTHEEXPECTATIONTHATNOCHILDISLEFT


BEHIND

4HEREFORE WENEEDTOPREPAREFORTHEINEVITABLECHANGESINTHESYSTEMOFSCHOOLINGTOCOME

!FRANKEVALUATIONOFOURCURRENTSYSTEMOFSCHOOLINGREADILYREVEALSITSWEAKNESSESWHENFACEDWITHTHEGOAL
OFBRINGINGALLSTUDENTSTOPROlCIENCYONCHALLENGINGSTANDARDS!SSTATESSTRUGGLEWITHIMPLEMENTINGTHE.O
#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT QUESTIONSABOUTTHEVERYNATUREOFSCHOOLINGHAVEEMERGED)STHELENGTHOFTHESCHOOL
DAYADEQUATEFORALLCHILDREN3HOULDPUBLICSCHOOLINGBEGINATAGETHREEORYOUNGERFORSOMEORALLCHILDREN!RE
THESYSTEMSFORPREPARINGANDDEVELOPINGOURTEACHERSANDPRINCIPALSSUFlCIENTTOPROVIDETHENUMBERSOFHIGH
QUALITYSCHOOLPROFESSIONALSWEWILLNEED#ANSTATEANDLOCALBUDGETSAFFORDTHEKINDSOFINCREASESTHATMIGHTBE
NEEDEDIFTHECURRENTSYSTEMISTOSUCCEED!NDWHATISTHEMOSTESSENTIALSETOFKNOWLEDGEANDSKILLSSTUDENTS
NEEDTOACHIEVEINORDERTOTHRIVEINTHEFUTURE
7EMAYNOTBEABLETOKNOWWITHCERTAINTYTHEANSWERSTOTHESEQUESTIONS BUTBYASKING h7HATIFvINA
DISCIPLINEDWAY WECANIMAGINETHEPOSSIBILITIESOFTOMORROWANDTHENTAKEACTIONTODAYTHATWILLPOSITIONUSFOR
SUCCESSINTHEFUTURE!CCORDINGLY -C2%,ISPREPARINGFORTHEFUTUREUSINGAPROCESSCALLEDhSCENARIOPLANNINGv


7HY3CENARIOS
h3TORIESARETHEWAYTOCAPTURETHEHOPES DREAMSANDVISIONSOFACULTURE4HEYARETRUEAS
MUCHASDATAARETRUE4HETRUTHOFTHEPOWERFULANDIRRESISTIBLESTORYILLUSTRATESINAWAYDATA
CANTBEGINTOCAPTURE)TSTHESTORIESTHATMAKEYOUUNDERSTANDv
^#ARL3ESSIONS3TEPP PROFESSOR 0HILIP-ERRILL#OLLEGEOF*OURNALISM

3CENARIOSARESTORIESABOUTTHEFUTURETHATTAKEINTOACCOUNTKEYDRIVERSOFCHANGEANDHOWTHOSE
DRIVERSMAYINTERACTWITHONEANOTHERTOCREATEALTERNATIVEFUTURES4HESEALTERNATIVEFUTURES ORSCENAR
IOS ARENOTPREDICTIONSOFTHEFUTUREBUT RATHER PLAUSIBLEFUTUREREALITIESTHATCANGUIDESTRATEGICORGA
NIZATIONALDECISION MAKINGINTHEPRESENT4HUS SCENARIOPLANNINGISASTRATEGICPLANNINGTOOLBASEDON
THEPREMISETHAT ALTHOUGHTHEFUTUREISUNCERTAIN ORGANIZATIONSMUSTACT3CENARIOSCANHELPORGANIZA
TIONSTAKEACTIONSNOWTHATWILLMAXIMIZETHEIRCOMPETITIVEADVANTAGEINTHEFUTURE
&ORMANYYEARSNOW BUSINESSLEADERSALLOVERTHEWORLDHAVEBENElTEDFROMENGAGINGINTHEPROCESS
OFWRITINGSCENARIOS4HEYUSETHESETODEVELOPRESPONSESTOPOTENTIALFUTURECONDITIONSINORDERTO
GAINACOMPETITIVEEDGEINANUNCERTAINMARKET%DUCATIONALLEADERS WEBELIEVE CANBENElTFROM
THISPROCESSASWELLASTHEYSEEKTOENSURETHEIRORGANIZATIONSRELEVANCEANDSUSTAINEDCONTRIBUTIONTO
HELPINGALLSTUDENTSSUCCEEDINACHANGINGWORLD
7RITINGSCENARIOSABOUTTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATIONREQUIREShREPERCEIVINGvTHEFUTUREANDIMAGININGALL
ASPECTSOFTHEWAYTHEWORLDMIGHTBE NOTJUSTTHOSEFACTORSTHATRELATESPECIlCALLYTOEDUCATION)NDEED
THEPOLITICALENVIRONMENT THEECONOMY SECURITYISSUES TECHNOLOGICALINNOVATIONS ANDSOCIALVALUES
WILLALLIMPACTANDCONTRIBUTETOTHEUNFOLDINGOFTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATION)TISFORTHISREASONTHATWE
HAVESTUDIEDANDCATALOGUEDFUTURETRENDSINALLOFTHESEAREASASPOTENTIALh$RIVERSOF#HANGEv

%XPLORATIONOFTHE&UTURE
h0LAUSIBLEIMPOSSIBILITIESSHOULDBEPREFERREDTOCONVINCINGPOSSIBILITIESv
^!RISTOTLE

!T-C2%, WEBEGANOURJOURNEYTOTHEFUTUREBYINVITINGSIXNATIONALLY KNOWNEXPERTSINAWIDE


ARRAYOFDISCIPLINESTOSHAREWITHUSTHEIRKNOWLEDGEABOUTTHEKEYDRIVERSOFCHANGEANDTHEIRANTICI
PATEDIMPACTSONMAJORSOCIALINSTITUTIONS4HEDATAGATHEREDFROMTHESEEXPERTSWASDOCUMENTEDAND
ISCONTINUALLYINCORPORATEDINTOOURDISCUSSIONSABOUTWHATTHEWORLDMIGHTBELIKE  ORYEARS
FROMNOW
'LEN(IEMSTRA FOUNDEROF&UTURIST#OM LAUNCHEDOUREXPLORATIONINTOTHEFUTUREWITHINFORMATION
ABOUTTHEPOTENTIALFORRADICALANTI AGINGTECHNIQUES GENETICTHERAPIES NANO TECHNOLOGY ANDCHANGES
INTHENATUREOFWORKANDRETIREMENT#HRIS$EDE CHAIR ,EARNINGAND4EACHINGATTHE(ARVARD'RADU
ATE3CHOOLOF%DUCATION EXPOSEDUSTOCONCEPTSOFhUBIQUITOUSLEARNINGvMADEPOSSIBLEBYAVARIETYOF
BREAKTHROUGHTECHNOLOGIES.OTEDEDUCATIONALDEMOGRAPHER(AROLD"UD (ODGKINSONTAUGHTUSABOUT
THEIMPACTOFMAJORDEMOGRAPHICCHANGESAGING RACIALDIVERSITY IMMIGRATION ONOURFUTURELIFESTYLES
WORKPLACES SCHOOLS ANDOTHERPUBLICINSTITUTIONS
&ROM.EIL(OWE HISTORIAN ECONOMIST ANDDEMOGRAPHER WEALSOLEARNEDABOUTTHECHARACTERISTICS
ANDHISTORICALIMPACTOFDIFFERENTGENERATIONSANDASWELLASTHEDIFFERENTLEADERSHIPSTYLESWEMIGHT
EXPECTASBABYBOOMERSRETIRE*ACK*ENNINGS PRESIDENTAND#%/OFTHE#ENTERON%DUCATION0OLICYIN
7ASHINGTON $# ANDAFORMERSUBCOMMITTEESTAFFDIRECTORANDGENERALCOUNSELFORTHE53(OUSEOF
2EPRESENTATIVES#OMMITTEEON%DUCATIONAND,ABOR PROVIDEDAGLIMPSEINTOTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATION

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
POLICYANDTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT INPARTICULAR&INALLY WELEARNEDABOUTTHEECONOMICIMPACTS
OFCONSUMERBEHAVIORANDTHEh'REAT7INTERvFORECASTEDBYTHE(ARRY3$ENT&OUNDATIONFROMITS
PRESIDENT 2ODNEY*OHNSON
4HESESPEAKERSPROVIDEDTHEINSPIRATIONFORUSTOBEGINADISCIPLINEDAPPROACHTODISCOVERINGTRENDS
OFTHEFUTUREINMANYDIFFERENTAREAS7EARCHIVETHESETRENDSINAMATRIXSHOWINGTHEINTERACTION
BETWEENVARIOUSDRIVERSANDTHEFOLLOWINGKEYINSTITUTIONSOFOURLIVESHOMESANDLIFESTYLESJOBSAND
WORKPLACEGOVERNMENTANDPOLICYANDEDUCATIONANDSCHOOLS7EIDENTIFYARTICLESINTHEDAILYPRESS
ANDINPROFESSIONALJOURNALSANDCATEGORIZETHEMBASEDONWHATTHEYTELLUSABOUTHOWDIFFERENTDRIVERS
SUCHASTECHNOLOGY ECONOMICS DEMOGRAPHICS ANDGLOBALIZATION ARELIKELYTOIMPACTANYORALLOFTHESE
INSTITUTIONS!SWEBUILDTHEARCHIVE WEARECONSTANTLYREMINDEDOFTHEMANYWAYSINWHICHFORCESTHAT
AREBEYONDOURCONTROLMAYHAVEANIMPACTONTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATION!TTHESAMETIME WEDRAWINFER
ENCESFROMTHISINFORMATIONANDINCORPORATETHOSEINSIGHTSINTOOURONGOINGSTRATEGICPLANNINGPROCESS

!SKINGh7HATIFv
h7ETELLSTORIESINORDERTOFEELATHOMEINTHEUNIVERSEv
^2OGER"INGHAM HISTORIAN

3CENARIOSANSWERTHEQUESTIONS7HATIFTHEMANYDRIVINGFORCESOFCHANGECONVERGETOCAUSEEVENTS
WEDIDNOTEXPECT7HATIFTHEFUTUREISNOTASWEIMAGINEBUTIS INSTEAD DIFFERENT REQUIRINGDIFFER
ENTRESPONSESFROMUS(OWDOESTHISFUTUREWORLDLOOK7HOHASPOWER7HATPOLICIESAREINPLACETO
SUPPORTSCHOOLS7HATCANWEDOTOPREPARETOSURVIVEANDTHRIVEINTHISWORLD(OWCANWEMANAGE
THEMULTITUDEOFUNCERTAINTIESAHEAD
3CENARIOSARERICHWITHIDEASABOUTHOWTHEMANYUNCERTAINTIESWECANIDENTIFYTODAYMAYUNFOLDTO
MORROWANDITISIMPORTANTTOCASTOUREXPLORATIONNETASWIDELYASPOSSIBLESOASNOTTOMISSDRIVERSTHAT
MAYNOTSEEMOBVIOUSBUTWHICH UPONCLOSERCONSIDERATION ARELIKELYTOHAVEANIMPORTANTIMPACT
!TTHESAMETIME ALTHOUGHUNCERTAINTYABOUTTHEFUTUREABOUNDS THEREARESOMEFORCES EVENTS OR
CONDITIONSTHATWECANhPREDICTvWITHAFAIRDEGREEOFCERTAINTYWILLEXIST7EDElNETHOSECONDITIONS
AShPREDETERMINEDvAND FORTHEPURPOSESOFWRITINGSCENARIOS ASSUMETHATTHEYAREHIGHLYLIKELYTOOCCUR
4HESEPREDETERMINEDELEMENTSHELPTOGROUNDTHESCENARIOSINREALITYANDINCREASETHEIRPLAUSIBILITY&OR
EXAMPLE WEFOUNDTHATLENGTHENINGLIFESPANS AGINGBABYBOOMERS ANDINCREASINGETHNICDIVERSITYWERE
AMONGTHEPREDETERMINEDELEMENTSWEAGREEDNEEDEDTOBEACCOUNTEDFORINTHESTORIESWEWOULDWRITE


#RITICAL5NCERTAINTIESAND0REDETERMINED%LEMENTS
"ELOWISASAMPLEOFSOMEOFTHEPREDETERMINEDELEMENTSANDCRITICALUNCERTAINTIESWEUSEDINOUR
SCENARIOSCATEGORIZEDACCORDINGTOTHEKEYDRIVERSOFCHANGEWEHAVEBEENWORKINGWITHDEMOGRAPHICS
TECHNOLOGY ECONOMY GLOBALISSUES VALUESANDPOPULARCULTURE ANDPOLICY

%#/./-9

0REDETERMINED 5NCERTAIN
 7ORKINCREASINGLYWILLBEmEXIBLE STINT  7HATWILLBETHEIMPACTOFTHEWARON
BASED ANDNOTDEPENDENTONLOCATION TERRORONTHEECONOMY
 !SBABYBOOMERSAGEANDSPENDLESS  7HATWILLBETHEIMPACTOFDElCIT
THEECONOMYWILLDECLINE SPENDINGONTHEECONOMY
 4HEREWILLBESIGNIlCANTLYMOREWORK (OWWILLTHESOCIALSECURITYAND
AVAILABLEINELDERCARE RANGINGFROM HEALTHCARECRISESBERESOLVED
PROVIDINGPERSONALhLIFESTYLEvSERVICES
TOHEALTHYOLDERADULTSTOSUPPORTINGTHE
TRANSITIONTODEATH

4%#(./,/'9

0REDETERMINED 5NCERTAIN
 4ECHNOLOGYWILLENABLECUSTOMIZED  7ILLTHE)NTERNETREMAINFREEANDPUBLICLY
LEARNINGTOOCCURANYTIME ANYPLACE ACCESSIBLE ORWILLTHEhDIGITALDIVIDEv
PERSIST
 ,EARNERSWILLDEMANDANDHAVE
SIGNIlCANTLYGREATERACCESSTO  7HATCHANGESINCURRICULUMWILLNEW
INFORMATIONOFALLKINDSANDFROMALL TECHNOLOGIESREQUIREEG SCIENCE
SOURCES WILLINCLUDENANOTECHNOLOGY HUMAN
GENETICSANDARTIlCIALORGANS 
 0ORTABLE WIRELESSTECHNOLOGICALDEVICES
WILLBEUBIQUITOUSANDINTEGRATEDINTO  7HATWILLTHEIMPACTOFADVANCESIN
EVERY DAYLIFE TECHNOLOGYBEONOURSECURITYnWILLWE
BEMORESECUREORMOREVULNERABLETO
HACKERSANDTERRORISTS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
$%-/'2!0()#3

0REDETERMINED 5NCERTAIN
 4HEPROPORTIONOFELDERLYINTHE  7ILLTHEREBEADIFFERENCEAMONG
POPULATIONWILLINCREASE IMMIGRANT MINORITYANDWHITE'EN8ERS
AND-ILLENIALS
 $IVERSITYEG CULTURE LANGUAGE ABILITY
AMONGSTUDENTSANDGENERALPOPULATION  7ILLTHE-ILLENIALGENERATIONFULlLLITS
WILLINCREASE PROMISEASTHEhHEROvGENERATION OR
WILLITBESEENASTHEhENTITLEMENTv
 'EN8ERSWILLMOVEINTOPOSITIONSOF GENERATION
AUTHORITY
 7HATWILLTHEIMPACTOFHOMELAND
SECURITYMEASURESBEONIMMIGRATION
ANDSTUDENTVISAPOLICIES

0/,)#9)335%3

0REDETERMINED 5NCERTAIN
 4HEDEMANDFORACCOUNTABILITYIN  (OWWILLTHECURRENT2%$",5%DIVIDE
EDUCATIONWILLCONTINUE BERESOLVED
 'ERIATRICISSUESHEALTHANDRETIREMENT  7ILLAVIABLETHIRDPOLITICALPARTY
BENElTS WILLBECOMEARISINGPOLITICAL EMERGE
PRIORITYANDDRAINONGOVERNMENT
BUDGETS  7HATWILLBECOMEOFTHOSESCHOOLSTHAT
AREhRECONSTITUTEDvUNDER.O#HILD,EFT
 -ORESTATESWILLBEFACEDWITHADEQUACY "EHIND
ANDEQUITYSCHOOLlNANCELAWSUITS

',/"!,)335%3

0REDETERMINED 5NCERTAIN
 4HE53WILLEXPERIENCEINCREASED  7ILL#HINADEVELOPASASUPERPOWER
COMPETITIONFROM#HINAAND)NDIA
 7ILLTHELOSSOFINTERNATIONALSTUDENTS
 4HEACADEMICPERFORMANCEOF53 RESULTINA53LOSSOFINTERNATIONALBRAIN
STUDENTSWILLCONTINUETOBECOMPAREDTO POWERANDASHIFTININNOVATIONTOOTHER
THEIRINTERNATIONALPEERS COUNTRIES#HINA )NDIA 
 )NCREASINGGLOBALDEMANDFORFOSSILFUELS  7ILLALTERNATIVESOURCESOFENERGY
BECAUSEOFINDUSTRIALIZATIONOF#HINA BECOMETHENORMORWILLTHEENDOF
WILLLEADTOINCREASESINENERGYPRICES hCHEAPOILvLEADTOAN!MERICANCRISIS


6!,5%3 -%$)! AND0/05,!2#5,452%

0REDETERMINED 5NCERTAIN
 0EOPLEWILLEXPECTANDDEMAND  7ILLCOMPETITIVENESSAMONGSTUDENTS
IMMEDIATERESPONSES CUSTOMIZED ANDTHEIRPARENTSFORACCESSTOGOOD
SOLUTIONS ANDACCESSTOINFORMATION SCHOOLS RESOURCES ETC INCREASEOR
DECREASE
 4HEREWILLCONTINUETOBEVALUECONmICTS
AMONG!MERICANSINTERMSOFRELIGION  7ILLMORALITYBELEGISLATEDOR
ANDTHEROLEOFGOVERNMENTINTHE ADJUDICATEDORLEFTTOPERSONALCHOICE
INDIVIDUALSLIFE
 7ILLCOMMUNITIESBECOMEMOREORLESS
 4HEREWILLBEABLURRINGOFTHEBOUNDARIES FRAGMENTED
BETWEENREALITYANDUNREALITYEG
ENTERTAINMENTANDREALLIFE REALITY46 TALK
SHOWS 

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
$EVELOPINGTHE&RAMEWORK DEPENDSENTIRELYONTHEFRAMEWORKCREATEDINTHISSTEP
3CENARIOSEMERGEFROMAFRAMEWORKCREATEDBY 5LTIMATELY THETEAMMUSTNARROWITSSELECTIONTOJUST
SELECTINGTWOhCRITICALUNCERTAINTIESvTOFOCUSUPON TWOCRITICALUNCERTAINTIES4HESEFORMTHEhXvANDhYv
#RITICALUNCERTAINTIESAREGENERATEDFROMTHEEXPLORA AXESOFA#ARTESIANPLANE WITHTHERESULTINGFOURQUAD
TIONPROCESSTHATYIELDSALONGLISTOFUNCERTAINTIES SUCH RANTSOFTHEGRAPHREPRESENTINGFOURPOSSIBLESCENARIOS
ASYOUSEEONPAGES )NORDERTODEVELOPAUSEFUL FORTHEFUTURESEE&IG 
SCENARIOFRAMEWORK ONEMUSTDETERMINEWHICHOFTHE
MANYFACTORSTHATCOULDDRIVETHEFUTUREINDIFFERENT
DIRECTIONSARETHEMOSTCRITICALTOTHETOPICATHAND !BUNDANT
(OWDOWEDETERMINE OUTOFSOMUCHUNCERTAINTY

2ESOURCES
WHATISMOSTCRITICALLYUNCERTAIN)NBUILDINGSCENARIOS
CONTEXTISEVERYTHING&OREXAMPLE ALTHOUGHLOCALAND

3TRONG

7EEK
STATEEDUCATIONAGENCIESMAYBEEQUALLYCONCERNED
ABOUTTHEFUTUREOFEDUCATION THEMOSTIMPORTANT 'OVERMENT2EGULATION
FACTORSIMPACTINGTHEINDIVIDUALFUTURESOFEACHTYPEOF
AGENCYMAYBEDIFFERENT4HATIS ASTATEAGENCYMAYBE
CONCERNEDWITHTHEFUTUREROLEOFTHEFEDERALGOVERN
MENTINEDUCATIONWHILEASCHOOLDISTRICTISMORECON 3CARCE
CERNEDABOUTTHECHANGINGNATUREOFITSSTUDENTPOPU &IGURE
LATIONANDHOWBESTTOSERVEADIVERSEENROLLMENT!S
WECONSIDEREDOUROWNORGANIZATIONSFUTURE WEWERE 4HESCENARIO BUILDINGTEAMSMUSTIDENTIFYTHECRITI
NATURALLYINTERESTEDINTHEFUTURESOFTHEWHOLERANGE CALUNCERTAINTIESASWELLASTHEENDPOINTSOFEACHON
OFEDUCATIONALENTITIESWESERVE)NADDITION WEWERE THEAXIS&OREXAMPLE OURSCENARIO BUILDINGTEAMALL
INTERESTEDINBROADENINGTHERELEVANCEOFOURWORKTO AGREEDTHATANIMPORTANTFACTORINmUENCINGTHEFUTURE
THELARGEREDUCATIONALCOMMUNITY4HUS WEDIVIDED OFEDUCATIONWILLBETHEEXTENTTOWHICHRESOURCES
OURSTAFFINTOFOURWORKINGGROUPS EACHREPRESENTINGA BOTHHUMANANDlNANCIAL AREAVAILABLEFOREDUCATION
DIFFERENTHYPOTHETICALEDUCATIONALENTITY EACHWITHITS 4HATIS ITISUNCERTAINASTOWHETHER INTHEFUTURE
OWNhFOCALISSUEvOFCONCERNTOGUIDETHEDEVELOPMENT EDUCATIONALRESOURCESWILLBEABUNDANTORSCARCE AND
OFASETOFSCENARIOSTAILOREDTOTHECHARACTERISTICSOF UNDOUBTEDLY THISUNCERTAINTYISCRITICALTOTHEFUTURE
EACHRESPECTIVEENTITY OFOURCLIENTAGENCIES!ND FORAVARIETYOFREASONS
/URFOURHYPOTHETICALORGANIZATIONS WHICHWE WECANIMAGINEAFUTUREWORLDINWHICHRESOURCES
REFERTOAShCLIENTS vAREASFOLLOWS ASTATEEDUCATION GROW ANDWECANALSOIMAGINE FORDIFFERENTREASONS A
AGENCY ASCHOOLDISTRICT ARESEARCHANDDEVELOP WORLDINWHICHRESOURCESSHRINK4HUS hRESOURCESFOR
MENTORGANIZATIONLIKEOURSAND ANATIONALPARENT EDUCATION vWITHTHECHARACTERISTICSATEACHENDOFTHE
ADVOCACYASSOCIATION.ATURALLY EACHOFTHESEENTI AXISBEINGLABELEDhABUNDANTvORhSCARCE vPROVIDEDA
TIESISCONCERNEDWITHTHEBROADTOPICOFTHEFUTUREOF REASONABLEAXISFORTHEFRAMEWORK
EDUCATIONAND THUS MANYFEATURESOFTHESCENARIOSETS "UTWHATABOUTTHEOTHERAXIS7EDISCUSSEDA
WEHAVECREATEDOVERLAP!NDYET EACHSETALSOHAS RANGEOFPOSSIBILITIESINCLUDING
UNIQUEFEATURESTHATRELATETOTHECLIENTSOWNCONTEXT  2OLEOF'OVERNMENT)NTHEFUTURE WILLGOVERN
ANDPROVIDERICHANDRELEVANTINDICATORSFORDETERMIN MENTPLAYABIGROLEINDETERMININGWHAT WHERE
INGIMPLICATIONSANDOPTIONSFORTHECLIENTSORGANIZA WHEN ANDHOWSTUDENTSLEARN ORNOT7ILLTHERE
TIONALPLANNING BEMOREREGULATIONOFEDUCATIONBYGOVERNMENTAL
)DENTIFYINGCRITICALUNCERTAINTIESISTHEhHARDWORKv AUTHORITIES ORWILLTHEFREEMARKETPREVAIL#LEARLY
OFTHEPROCESS/URTEAMSSTRUGGLEDOVERTHECOURSE FOROURCLIENTGROUPS THEWAYINWHICHGOVERNMENT
OFSEVERALWORKSHOPSESSIONSINANATTEMPTTOGETTHIS CONTROLS SUPPORTS ORIGNORESEDUCATIONWILLMAKEA
RIGHTBECAUSETHERESTOFTHESCENARIOBUILDINGPROCESS


DIFFERENCEINTHEWAYSINWHICHEACHENTITYWORKS  #HOICEOF3CHOOLS4HEEXTENTTOWHICHPARENTS
4HUS FORTHISAXIS WECOULDIMAGINETWOEXTREMES ORSTUDENTSCANCHOOSEHOW WHEREANDWHENTO
OFGOVERNMENTALINmUENCEOVEREDUCATION EG RECEIVEEDUCATIONASWELLASTHEAMOUNTANDVARIETY
hSTRONGGOVERNMENTREGULATIONvORhWEAKGOVERN OFCHOICESAVAILABLEHASALREADYCHANGEDDRAMATI
MENTREGULATIONv CALLYWITHINTHELASTDECADE"UTTHEREISSIGNIlCANT
CONTROVERSYABOUTTHISTRENDANDVARIOUSFORCESARE
 4ECHNOLOGY$EVELOPMENT7ILLTECHNOLOGY EXTANTWHICHEITHERPROMOTEORHINDERTHENOTION
ADVANCEEXPONENTIALLY OFFERINGAWIDEARRAYOF OFhCHOICEvINPUBLICEDUCATION4HUS hSCHOOLING
LEARNINGOPTIONSFORSTUDENTSANDTEACHERS ORWILL CHOICES vWHETHERhMANYvORhFEW vORhPUBLICvOR
DEVELOPMENTSINTECHNOLOGYSLOWDOWNORSTAGNATE hPRIVATE vORhCUSTOMIZEDvORhMASS PRODUCED vPRES
4HEENDSOFTHISAXISMIGHTBELABELEDhACCELERATINGv ENTSANOTHERPOSSIBLEAXISFORTHEMATRIX
ANDhSTAGNANTv

!BUNDANT
!BUNDANT

2ESOURCES
2ESOURCES
!CCELERATING

-ANY

&EW
3TAGNANT

3CHOOLING#HOICES
4ECHNOLOGY!DVANCEMENTS

3CARCE
3CARCE
 #ONTROLOF,EARNING7HODECIDESTHECURRICULUM
 3OCIAL6ALUES4HEQUESTIONOFWHATTHEPUBLIC THEINSTRUCTIONALDELIVERYMETHOD THETIMEAND
WILLVALUEMOSTADECADEFROMNOWWILLCERTAINLY PLACEOFLEARNING4ODAY INGENERAL WEHAVEANIN
INmUENCETHEFUTUREOFSCHOOLING4HISFACTORWAS STITUTIONALLYCONTROLLEDSYSTEMINWHICHSTATESAND
RAISEDBYEVERYWORKINGGROUP BUTIDENTIFYINGTHE LOCALDISTRICTSDETERMINESTANDARDSANDTHESTRUC
AXISENDSWASDIFlCULT4HEREAREMANYDIMEN TURESFORENSURINGTHATCHILDRENHAVEANOPPORTUNITY
SIONSOFSOCIALVALUESTHATCOULDHAVEANIMPACTON TOGAINPROlCIENCY!LTHOUGHINDIVIDUALCLASSROOM
THEFUTURE3OMESUGGESTIONSWEREhCONSERVATIVE TEACHERSDOTHEIRBESTTOFOCUSLEARNINGOPPORTUNI
LIBERAL vhSUPPORTIVEOFPUBLICEDUCATIONNOTSUP TIESONEACHSTUDENT THESYSTEMISCERTAINLYMORE
PORTIVE vANDhCOMMUNITY FOCUSEDINDIVIDUALLY OFAhONE SIZE lTS ALLvMODELTHANAhTO EACH HIS
FOCUSEDv OWNvDESIGN"UT INANERAOFMASSCUSTOMIZATION
PROVIDEDBYTECHNOLOGICALADVANCES ALONGWITH
INCREASINGDIVERSITYINTHESTUDENTPOPULATION WILL
!BUNDANT SUCHAUNIFORMSYSTEMCONTINUETOPREVAILORWILL
2ESOURCES

THEREBEMOREPRESSURETOINDIVIDUALIZEANDCUSTOM
#OMMUNITY FOCUSED

)NDIVIDUALLY FOCUSED

IZELEARNINGTOMEETTHEUNIQUENEEDSANDTALENTSOF
STUDENTS4HUS ANAXISINWHICHhCONTROLOFLEARN
INGvISDElNEDAShINSTITUTIONALvORhINDIVIDUALvISA
3OCIAL6ALUES
LIKELYCRITICALUNCERTAINTY

!SYOUSEE EACHSCENARIOFRAMEWORKYIELDSFOUR
QUADRANTS EACHOFWHICHDElNESAPARTICULARWORLD
3CARCE

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
!BUNDANT

2ESOURCES
)MPLICATIONSAND/PTIONS
3CENARIOSAREWRITTENNOTONLYTOENGAGEANDCHAL
)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
LENGETHEYAREINTENDEDTOPROVIDEORGANIZATIONSWITH
#ONTROLOF,EARNING STRATEGICGUIDANCEFORADDRESSINGKEYISSUESAHEAD!S
SUCH WHATISDONEWITHEACHSTORYAFTERITISCOMPLETED
ISASIMPORTANT ORMOREIMPORTANT THANTHEPROCESSOF
3CARCE CREATINGTHEM/NCEANORGANIZATIONHASCREATEDTHESE
FUTUREWORLDS ITMUSTASKITSELF WHATDOESITMEANFOR
US&OREXAMPLE WHATWOULDAWORLDINWHICHPARENTS
OFTHEFUTURE&OREXAMPLE IN&IGURE THEUPPER
HAVEACCESSTOVOUCHERSANDAPLETHORAOFHIGH QUALITY
LEFTQUADRANTWILLBECOMEASCENARIOINWHICHTHE
EDUCATIONALCHOICESMEANFORALOCALSCHOOLDISTRICT
GOVERNMENTHASVERYLITTLE ORNO CONTROLOVERTHE
(OW FOREXAMPLE SHOULDALOCALSCHOOLDISTRICT
PROVISIONOFEDUCATION ANDRESOURCESFOREDUCATION
RESPONDSOMEWOULDSAY COMPETE INSUCHAWORLD
AREABUNDANT4HESCENARIOWRITERSMUSTCONSIDER
7HATVALUECANITPROVIDE
HOWSUCHAWORLDCOULDHAVEDEVELOPED7HAT
5NDERSTANDINGHOWTHATWORLDCAMETOBEAND
CAUSEDTHEGOVERNMENTTOLOSECONTROLOVEREDU
WHATOTHERFACTORSMAYBEINPLAYHELPSTHEORGANIZA
CATION$IDTHESO CALLEDhREVOLTvAGAINSTTHE.O
TIONCONSIDEROPTIONSFORTHEFUTURE&OREXAMPLE ONE
#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT BEGUNWITHAVARIETYOFSTATE
EXPLANATIONFORANINCREASEINSCHOOLINGCHOICESCOULD
LEGISLATIVEACTIONSANDLAWSUITSAGAINSTTHEFEDERAL
BETHATADVANCESINTECHNOLOGYLEDTOTHECREATIONOF
DEPARTMENTOFEDUCATIONIN RESULTINAWHOLE
MORECHOICESINEDUCATIONALOFFERINGS!SCHOOLDISTRICT
SALEREJECTIONOFGOVERNMENTINVOLVEMENTINPUBLIC
FACINGTHISSCENARIOMIGHTREmECTONTHECURRENTSTATE
EDUCATION$IDTHEHIGHCOSTOFMEETINGTHENEEDS
OFTECHNOLOGYINTHESCHOOLDISTRICT!RETECHNOLOGY
OFALLSTUDENTS MADEMORECRITICALASTHEOUTCOME
ANDITSAPPLICATIONSSTRENGTHSORARETHEYUNTAPPED
OFSCHOOLlNANCEADEQUACYLAWSUITSINCREASEDTHE
RESOURCESWAITINGTOBEDEVELOPED4HEIMPLICATIONS
SCHOOLFUNDINGBILLFORSTATES DISSUADETHEGOVERN
OFTHESCENARIORELATINGTOTHESTATEOFTECHNOLOGYMAY
MENTFROMMAINTAININGITSINVOLVEMENT/RDID
PROVIDESOMECLUESASTOHOWTHEFUTUREDEVELOPED
THEPRIVATESECTORSIMPLYPROVIDEMOREEFFECTIVEOR
THISWAYANDWHATOPPORTUNITIESCURRENTLYEXISTFORTHE
DESIRABLEALTERNATIVESTOTHEPUBLICSYSTEM CAUSINGA
DISTRICTTOIMPROVETHEDELIVERYOFEDUCATIONTOLOCAL
MASSIVEEXODUSOFSTUDENTSFROMTHEPUBLICSCHOOLS
STUDENTS4HELATTERBECOMEhOPTIONSvFORACTIONSTHAT
3IMILARLY THISISAWORLDINWHICHRESOURCESFOREDU
MAYBETAKENTODAYBYTHESCHOOLDISTRICTINANTICIPA
CATIONAREABUNDANT(OWDIDTHATHAPPEN7HATIS
TIONOFTHISSORTOFWORLDUNFOLDING
THERELATIONSHIPBETWEENALOSSOFGOVERNMENTCONTROL
ANDANINCREASEINFUNDING!NDWHEREDIDTHEMONEY
COMEFROM4HESCENARIOMUSTANSWERTHESEANDMANY
OTHERQUESTIONSINORDERTOPAINTAFULLPICTUREOFTHE
WORLDADECADEFROMNOW
5LTIMATELY ASYOUWILLSEE EACHOFOURSCENARIO
TEAMSSETTLEDONTHEFRAMEWORKWITHTHEGREATESTREL
EVANCETOTHEIRISSUEANDONETHATWOULDPROVIDETHEM
WITHRICHANDCHALLENGINGSTORIESOFTHEFUTURE


4HE3CENARIOS4HE3TORIES7ITHINTHE3TORY
h3CENARIOSARESTORIES4HEYAREWORKSOFART RATHERTHANSCIENTIlCANALYSES4HERELIABILITYOFTHEIR
CONTENT ISLESSIMPORTANTTHANTHETYPESOFCONVERSATIONSTHEYSPARKv
ˆ!RIEDE'UES 4HE,IVING#OMPANY

4 HEFOLLOWINGFOURSECTIONSOFTHISREPORTAREOUR
STORIESOFTHEFUTURE9OUWILLNOTESIMILARITIESAND
DIFFERENCESAMONGTHEMTHATREmECTTHECONTEXTOFTHE
!TTHEBEGINNINGOFEACHINDIVIDUALSCENARIO THERE
ISASUMMARYOFTHEhDEEPCAUSESvTHATCOULDLEADTO
THISPARTICULARSCENARIO4HESECAUSESAREINTENDEDTO
EDUCATIONALENTITYTHEYWEREWRITTENFOR THECHARAC STRENGTHENTHEPLAUSIBILITYOFTHESCENARIOANDPROVIDE
TERISTICSOFTHEINDIVIDUALMEMBERSOFEACHTEAMOF CLUESTOTHEREADERABOUTHOWCERTAINEVENTSINTHE
WRITERSANDTHESPIRITEDDEBATESTHEYREQUIREDTOREACH STORYMAYHAVECOMEABOUT4HEACTUALSCENARIO OR
CONSENSUS ASWELLASTHELOGICALOUTCOMESOFTHEWORLDS STORYOFTHEFUTURE FOLLOWS
CREATEDBYTHEPARTICULARCRITICALUNCERTAINTIESCHOSEN !TTHEENDOFEACHSTORY WEPROVIDEANh!NALY
BYEACHGROUP SISv4HISISHOWWEMAKETHESTORIEShACTIONABLEvAND
SHOWHOWTHEYCANBEUSEDINSTRATEGICPLANNINGFOR
%ACHSETUSESADIFFERENThVEHICLEvFORTELLING
THEORGANIZATION4HEREARETHREEPARTSTOTHE!NALYSIS
THESTORY4HE3ANDIA3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY FOR
SECTION)MPLICATIONSOFTHESCENARIOFORTHEORGANIZA
EXAMPLE DESCRIBESFOURDIFFERENTSCENARIOSTHROUGHTHE
TION)NDICATORSTHATTHEFUTUREISMOVINGINTHEDIREC
VOICEOFASINGLEIMAGINARYCHIEFSTATESCHOOLOFlCER
TIONIMAGINEDBYTHESCENARIOAND/PTIONSFORACTIONS
WHOHASATTEMPTEDTOLEADHERAGENCYTHROUGHTHE
THEORGANIZATIONMIGHTTAKETODAYTOPREPAREFORTHE
VARIOUSHIGHSANDLOWSIMAGINEDWITHINTHESCENARIO
WORLDAHEAD4HESEANALYSESARENOTINTENDEDTOBE
FRAMEWORK-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSSTORYISTOLD
PRESCRIPTIVEOREXHAUSTIVE2ATHER THEYDEMONSTRATE
THROUGHTHEEYESOFANEDUCATIONREPORTERWHOATTENDS
THEKINDOFLEARNINGTHATCANBEEXTRACTEDFROMTHE
BOARDMEETINGSANDWRITESABOUTTHEPOSITIONSAND
SCENARIOSTOASSISTANORGANIZATIONINPLANNINGFORTHE
ACTIONSOFTHESCHOOLBOARDASWELLASTHERESPONSESTO
FUTURE
THOSEFROMTHEBROADERCOMMUNITY0ARENTSFOR%DUCA
&INALLY ATTHEENDOFEACHOFTHEFOURSETSOFSCE
TIONTELLSITSSTORIESTHROUGHANEWSLETTERTOMEMBERS
NARIOS YOUWILLlNDASETOFDISCUSSIONQUESTIONSTO
WRITTENBYTHEASSOCIATIONSPRESIDENT&INALLY OUR
HELPYOUlNDCONNECTIONSINTHESCENARIOSTOYOUROWN
RESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTORGANIZATIONENVISIONSPO
ORGANIZATIONANDWORK3CENARIOSAREALWAYSBESTWHEN
TENTIALCHANGESINTHEEDUCATIONMARKETPLACETHROUGH
WRITTENWITHDEEPKNOWLEDGEOFTHEACTUALCONTEXTOF
hKEYNOTEvSPEECHESDELIVEREDBYAREPRESENTATIVEOF
THEORGANIZATIONANDANUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEPARTICU
ANORGANIZATIONTHATHASSUCCEEDEDINTHATPARTICULAR
LARISSUETHEORGANIZATIONISFACING/URSCENARIOSARE
WORLD
WRITTENFORHYPOTHETICALORGANIZATIONS WHICHAREUN
!LTHOUGHTHESTORIESVARY WEHAVEFOLLOWEDA
DOUBTEDLYFARLESSCOMPLEXTHANYOUROWNORGANIZATION
COMMONFORMATTOMAKETHEMEASIERTOREADAND
!NDYET WEBELIEVE ANDHOPE THATYOUWILLlNDTHAT
COMPAREWITHONEANOTHER%ACHSETBEGINSWITHSOME
THECURRENTANDFUTUREWORLDSFACEDBYTHESEIMAGINARY
BACKGROUNDINFORMATIONTOORIENTTHEREADERTOTHE
EDUCATIONALLEADERSARENOTFAROFFTHEMARKFROMWHAT
CHARACTERISTICSOFTHEORGANIZATIONANDTHEPURPOSEOF
YOUCANEXPECTTOFACEINYOUROWNWORKINTHEYEARS
THESCENARIOSFORTHEORGANIZATION4HISISFOLLOWEDBY
AHEAD
ADIAGRAMANDDESCRIPTIONOFTHEPARTICULARCRITICALUN
CERTAINTIESTHATFORMEACHGROUPSSCENARIOFRAMEWORK

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
!.OTE!BOUT'ENERATIONS
)NOUREXPLORATIONOFTHEFUTURE WELEARNEDAGREAT 4HESTORIESYOUAREABOUTTOREADINCLUDECHAR
DEALABOUTGENERATIONSFROMECONOMISTANDHISTORIAN ACTERSFROMDIFFERENTGENERATIONSWHOSEACTIONSAND
.EIL(OWE7EFOUND(OWESEXPLANATIONOFTHE RESPONSESTOEVENTSINTHESCENARIOAREEXPLAINEDBASED
VARIOUSCHARACTERISTICSANDMOTIVATIONSOFPEOPLEBORN ON(OWESGENERATIONALFRAMEWORK"ELOW FORYOUR
DURINGDIFFERENTPERIODSOFHISTORYCOMPELLINGINFACT REFERENCE ISATHUMBNAILSKETCHOFEACHOFTHELIVING
(OWESTHEORIESPROVIDEDCOGENTEXPLANATIONSFOR GENERATIONSREFERREDTOINOURSTORIES
VARIATIONSINBEHAVIORAMONGOUROWNSTAFFREPRESENT
INGDIFFERENTBIRTHCOHORTS

'ENERATION "IRTH9EARS %XAMPLES #HARACTERISTICS

') n *OHN+ENNEDY 'OODKIDSHEROESENDURED$EPRESSIONWON


2ONALD2EAGAN 77))BUILTBIGTHINGSMOONLANDING 'REAT
*UDY'ARLAND 3OCIETY
*OHN7AYNE

3ILENT n *OHN-C#AIN (ELPERSSUPPORTERSANDIMPROVERSOFTHESYSTEM


'LORIA3TEINEM MARRIEDANDHADCHILDRENATAYOUNGAGEEXPERI
-ARTIN,UTHER+ING *R ENCEDhMID LIFECRISESv
%LVIS0RESLEY

"ABY"OOM n "ILL(ILLARY#LINTON $R3POCKBABIESREBELLIOUSFOCUSEDONINNER


'EORGE7"USH FULlLLMENTARBITERSOFCULTURALVALUESANDPOLITICAL
3TEVEN3PIELBERG CORRECTNESS
/PRAH7INFREY

'ENERATION n 2OSIE/$ONNELL "ALANCEDBETWEENIDEALISMANDPRAGMATISM


*ONES
"ARACK/BAMA ANONYMOUSLOOKINGFORECONOMICSUCCESSAND
*OHN3TEWART MEANINGFULWORK
*ODIE&OSTER

'EN 8 n 3ALMA(AYEK ,ATCH KEYCHILDRENBORNDURINGDROPINBIRTHRATE


+URT#OBAIN PRAGMATICSKEPTICALTOUGHRESILIENTNON INSTITU
4IGER7OODS TIONALLYALIGNED
#HRIS2OCK

-ILLENIALS n 3ARAH(UGHES h"ABIESONBOARDvPROTECTEDBYPARENTSANDSOCIETY


*ESSICA,YNCH HIGHEXPECTATIONSANDSTANDARDSTEAM ORIENTED
-ICHELLE7IE hGOODKIDSvLARGESTANDMOSTDIVERSEGENERATIONIN
HISTORY


'ENERATION*ONES ATERMCOINEDBY*ONATHAN0ONTELLHTTP BETWEENTHESEYEARSFEELISAMOREACCURATEREPRESENTATIONOFTHEIR
GENERATIONJONESCOM ISNOTPARTOFTHE(OWEFRAMEWORKBUT OWNCHARACTERISTICSTHANEITHERTHE"ABY"OOMOR'EN 8MODELS
ISACONSTRUCTTHATPROVIDESWHATMANYOFOUROWNSTAFFBORN


 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
'OVERNMENT

3CHOOLOPOLYGOV 3CHOOLSUNLIMITEDGOV
h4HEMORETHINGS h7HATDOESNT
KILLYOUv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
CHANGEv

3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
3CHOOLOPOLYCOM 3CHOOLSUNLIMITEDCOM
h7HEREAN h)FYOUWANT
POUNDGORILLASLEEPSv SOMETHINGDONERIGHTv

.ON 'OVERNMENT

2ESEARCHAND$EVELOPMENT/RGANIZATION3CENARIOS
)NTRODUCTION

4HEFOLLOWINGFOURSCENARIOSPORTRAYFORPROVIDERSOFEDUCATIONRESEARCH DEVELOPMENTANDTECHNICAL
ASSISTANCESERVICESIE ORGANIZATIONSSIMILARTO-C2%, WHATTHEEDUCATIONMARKETMIGHTLOOKLIKEIN
THEYEAR

7EBASEDTHESESCENARIOSONTHEINTERACTIONOFTWOCRITICALUNCERTAINTIES

 THEEXTENTTOWHICHSCHOOLINGWILLBEPROVIDEDBYPUBLICINSTITUTIONSORPRIVATEINSTITUTIONS

 THEEXTENTTOWHICHSUCHAMARKETWILLPRESENTEDUCATIONCONSUMERSIE PARENTSANDSTUDENTS


WITHMANYORFEWCHOICES

!SSHOWNABOVE WEHAVELABELEDTHEFOURQUADRANTSCREATEDBYTHEINTERSECTIONOFTHESEAXES

 3CHOOLOPOLYGOVh4HEMORETHINGSCHANGEv
 3CHOOLSUNLIMITEDGOVh7HATDOESNTKILLYOUv
 3CHOOLSUNLIMITEDCOMh)FYOUWANTSOMETHINGDONERIGHTv
 3CHOOLOPOLYCOMh7HEREANPOUNDGORILLASLEEPSv

4HEFOLLOWINGFOURSCENARIOSAREhSTORIESvDELIVEREDFROMTHEPOINTOFVIEWOFASPEAKERINTHEYEAR
)NEACHCASE THESPEAKERREPRESENTSANORGANIZATIONORENTITYTHATHASACHIEVEDSUCCESSINTHE
SCENARIOTHUS EACHSPEAKERTAKESAPOSITIVEVIEWOFTHESCENARIO2EADERSMAYORMAYNOTAGREETHATTHE
FUTUREDEPICTEDISTHEhPREFERREDvFUTURE ANDTHESCENARIOSARENOTINTENDEDTOPERSUADEINTHATREGARD
2ATHER THEYAREMEANTTOPORTRAYFOURDISTINCTLYDIFFERENTWORLDSANDTHEWAYSINWHICHDIFFERENTPRO
VIDERSOFEDUCATIONALPRODUCTSANDSERVICESHAVERESPONDED
5NDERLYINGTHESCENARIOSARESOMEKEYASSUMPTIONSABOUTDEEPCAUSESOREVENTSTHATMIGHTCREATE
EACHOFTHESESCENARIOS$ESCRIPTIONSOFTHESECAUSESANDTHECRITICALUNCERTAINTIESTHATTHESCENARIO
CONSIDERSAPPEARINAPREFACETOEACHSCENARIO!LLOFTHESEDEEPCAUSESAREEVIDENTINTHEFOLLOWINGSCE
NARIOS WHICHPROVIDESOMESUPPORTINGEVIDENCEINTHEFORMOFFOOTNOTESTODEMONSTRATE WHEREPOSSIBLE
HOWCURRENTTRENDSANDEVENTSCOULDINmUENCETHEFUTUREOFEDUCATION


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

3CHOOLOPOLYGOV4HE-ORE 'OVERNMENT

4HINGS#HANGE h4HEMORETHINGS
CHANGEv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
$EEP#AUSES
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
)NTHISSCENARIO PUBLICINSTITUTIONSARETHEKEYPROVID

&EW
ERSOFSCHOOLINGANDOFFERLIMITEDCHOICESTOPARENTS
ANDSTUDENTS4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTO
THISSCENARIO

 3CHOOLSAREINCREASINGLYPERCEIVEDASDEMON .ON 'OVERNMENT


STRATINGSIGNIlCANTIMPROVEMENTONAVARIETYOF
ACADEMICANDNON ACADEMICINDICATORSUNDERTHE
.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT.#," THUS PUBLIC
SUPPORTFORPUBLICSCHOOLSASWELLASFORSTRONG
FEDERALCONTROLOFEDUCATIONGROWS h4HE-ORE4HINGS#HANGEv

 $ISCREPANCIESINACADEMICRIGORANDDATACOLLEC 4ODAY AS)STANDBEFOREYOU PREPAREDTOREPORTON


THEPROGRESSOFTHISGREATNATIONSPUBLICSCHOOLS )AM
TIONACROSSSTATESANDDISTRICTSCOUPLEDWITHCON
TINUEDSTUDENTMOBILITYDRIVESTHENEEDFORMORElLLEDWITHPRIDEATWHATWEHAVEACCOMPLISHEDTOGETH
STANDARDIZEDEDUCATIONATTHENATIONALLEVEL ER(ERE ONTHESTEPSOFTHISHIGHSCHOOL ITSIMPOS
SIBLENOTTOFEELTHEHISTORYOFTHISPLACE!SYOUKNOW
 !SARESULTOFlNANCIALANDOTHERSCANDALSAND YEARSAGOTHISNIGHT 'OVERNOR/RVAL&AUBUSCALLED
ANINABILITYTODEMONSTRATEEFFECTIVENESSON OUTTHE.ATIONAL'UARDTOKEEPNINE!FRICAN !MERI
AVARIETYOFINDICATORS ALTERNATIVESTOPUBLIC CANSTUDENTSFROMRECEIVINGTHESAMEQUALITYOFEDUCA
SCHOOLSBECOMELESSATTRACTIVETOPARENTS TIONASTHEIRWHITEPEERS&ORTUNATELYFORTHEMˆAND
USˆHEWASULTIMATELYUNSUCCESSFULINHISEFFORTS!ND
 !h&OURTH4URNING vORPROLONGEDPERIODOFCRISIS
SINCETHATTIME OURNATIONSPUBLICSCHOOLS TOBORROW
CREATESAMORECULTURALLYCONSERVATIVESOCIETY
FROMANOLDADVERTISINGSLOGAN HAVECOMEALONGWAY
ONETHATCLAMPSDOWNONCHILDRENANDINDIVIDUAL
BABY
FREEDOMS
h4HE-ORE4HINGS#HANGEv
 0UBLICSCHOOLSINCREASINGLYREmECTTHESECONSERVA
TIVEVALUES PROMPTINGSOCIALCONSERVATIVESWHO 4IME3EPTEMBER 
INRECENTYEARSHAVEGROWNINCREASINGLYDISEN 0LACE#ENTRAL(IGH3CHOOL ,ITTLE2OCK !RKANSAS
CHANTEDWITHPUBLICSCHOOLS TOBECOMEMORE 3CENE3YLVIA"ROWN THE533ECRETARYOF
SUPPORTIVEOFPUBLICEDUCATION %DUCATION ISGIVINGTHE3TATEOF%DUCATION
 'LOBALPRESSURESANDSTUDENTMOBILITYCREATEA ADDRESS
NEEDFORAUNIlEDAPPROACHTOEDUCATION ONE
WHICHAIMSTOPRODUCEEQUITABLERESULTSANDFORGE
4HEROADHASBEENROCKY TOBESURE ANDOUR
ACOHESIVECULTURALIDENTITYFORSTUDENTSINSHORT
JOURNEYWILLNEVERTRULYEND"UTAS)REmECTUPONTHE
HIGH QUALITYEDUCATIONBECOMESAMATTEROFNA
TREMENDOUSSTRIDESWEHAVEMADETOGETHERANDTHE
TIONALSECURITY
STATUREOURSCHOOLSENJOYBOTHHEREANDAROUNDTHE
 'LOBALTHREATSFROMTERRORISMANDCOMPETITION WORLD )FEELWEAREFARCLOSERTOTHETOPOFTHEMOUN
FROMEMERGING!SIANECONOMIESEG #HINAAND TAINTHANTOTHESHADOWSOFTHEVALLEY
)NDIA CAUSETHE!MERICANPUBLICTOSEEKGOVERN
MENTSOLUTIONSTOPUBLICPROBLEMS ASTHEYDID
DURINGTHEh.EW$EALvERAOFTHES
 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

*USTYEARSAGO OURNATIONSLAWMAKERSFOUND UPONTHEIRMEMBERSTOBOYCOTTPUBLICSCHOOLS!S%D


THEWILL OVERTHECOMPLAINTSOFSOMEEDUCATORSAND 'AMBLE EXECUTIVEDIRECTOROFTHE3OUTHERN"APTIST
SO CALLEDEXPERTS TOPASSTHEGROUND BREAKING.O !SSOCIATIONOF#HRISTIAN3CHOOLS SAIDATTHETIME
#HILD,EFT"EHIND.#," LAW9OUMAYRECALLTHAT h7HATHASHAPPENEDISNOTSOMUCHTHATTHE#HRIS
ATTHETIME MANYWORRIEDTHAT.#,"WOULDCAUSEAS TIANSARELEAVINGTHEPUBLICSCHOOLSASTHATTHEPUBLIC
MANYASTHREE QUARTERSOFOURSCHOOLSTOBELABELEDAS SCHOOLSHAVELEFTTHE#HRISTIANSv
hFAILINGv )N THE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTWASPASSED
7ELL HISTORYPROVEDTHESEhCHICKENLITTLESvWRONG BY#ONGRESS4HELAWORIGINALLYSTIPULATEDTHATSCHOOLS
4HESKYDIDNTFALL/URNATIONSSCHOOLSWERENTALL THATFAILEDTODEMONSTRATEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESS
SHUTDOWNORTAKENOVERBYSTATES)NSTEAD EXACTLY TOWARDENSURINGACADEMICPROlCIENCYOFALLTHEIRSTU
WHATTHEFRAMERSOFTHISLAWHOPEDWOULDHAPPEN DID DENTSFORFOURCONSECUTIVEYEARS WOULDBETAKENOVER
HAPPENˆOURSCHOOLSGOTBETTER BYTHEIRSTATESORSHUTDOWN)TALSOSTIPULATEDTHATFOR
SCHOOLSRECEIVINGFEDERAL4ITLE)FUNDS THECLOCKHAD
STARTEDTICKINGTWOYEARSEARLIER
)TSANINSPIRINGSTORYTHATISWELLWORTHREPEATING
3OIFYOUALLWILLINDULGEME )DLIKETOTAKEYOUON
A YEARTRIPDOWNMEMORYLANE STARTINGINTHEYEAR


#RACKSINTHE3YSTEM
)N YOUSAWMANYCONSERVATIVEGROUPS FEDUP
WITHTHELACKOFSAFETY DISCIPLINE ANDCHARACTERˆAS
WELLASTHESECULARTEACHINGINPUBLICSCHOOLS CALLING

)NSOMESTATES WHICHWEREAHEADOFTHEFEDERALLAW
WASTHElRSTYEARTHAThFAILINGvSCHOOLSWEREELIGI
BLEFORTAKE OVER&OREXAMPLE IN#OLORADO AHANDFUL
OFSCHOOLSWERECONVERTEDINTOCHARTERSONACCOUNTOF
THEIRSTATEACCOUNTABILITYSYSTEMS!TTHETIME SOME
PREDICTEDTHATMANYMORESCHOOLSWOULDSOONFOLLOW
THESESCHOOLSINTOSTATETAKEOVERANDRECONSTITUTION


/LSON ,!PRIL  h@)NADEQUATE9EARLY'AINSARE0REDICTED v%DUCATION7EEK   

-ANSlELD $&EBRUARY  h3OUTHERN"APTISTS3EE3CHOOL-OVEMENT'ROW v&ORT7AYNE*OURNAL'AZETTEHTTPWWWFORTWAYNECOM
MLDJOURNALGAZETTELIVINGHTM

3HERRY !!UGUST  h#3!0SSHOW@MINISCULEIMPROVEMENTS#OLE-IDDLE3CHOOL&IRSTTO&ACE#HARTER&IX$ENVER0OST P! 

)N!PRIL 533ECRETARYOF%DUCATION-ARGARET3PELLINGSANNOUNCEDTHATTHE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONWILLENTERTAINPROPOSALS
FROMSTATESTOWAIVERULESUNDERTHEFEDERAL.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTSOLONGASTHEYCANPROVETHEIRSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTISRISINGh)TISTHE
RESULTSTHATTRULYMATTER NOTTHEBUREAUCRATICWAYTHATYOUGETTHERE v-S3PELLINGSSAID3PELLINGSANNOUNCEDTHATDEPARTMENTALSOWILLSOON
PROPOSENEWRULESMAKINGITEASIERTOASSESSSTUDENTSWITHDISABILITIES3OURCE(OFF $ !PRIL h3TATESTO'ET.EW/PTIONSON.#,"
,AW-ORE&LEXIBILITY0ROMISEDAS3PEC%D2ULES%ASED v%DUCATION7EEK  


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

!NEMERGINGSCIENCEOF 'OVERNMENT
EDUCATION
h4HEMORETHINGS
"YEARLY HOWEVER WESAWTHATTHESKYWASNT CHANGEv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
REALLYFALLINGDOWNONOURPUBLICSCHOOLS&ORSTART
ERS THE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONRELAXEDSOMEOFTHE 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW

RULESANDREGULATIONSREGARDING.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
0ARTLYASARESULT ANDALSOASARESULTOFALOTOFHARD
WORKINSCHOOLS STUDENTACHIEVEMENTIMPROVEDIN
MANYSTATESˆSOMUCHSO THATFEWERSCHOOLSTHAN
WEREEXPECTEDWEREINDANGEROFBEINGTAKENOVEROR .ON 'OVERNMENT
CLOSEDBYTHEIRSTATES)NDEED SOMEBIGCHANGESWERE
HAPPENINGINSIDEOURNATIONSSCHOOLS4HEYWERE
GETTINGMOREFOCUSEDONALLTHEIRSTUDENTSANDUSING
RESEARCH NOTJUSTHUNCHESORFOLKWISDOM TOHELPTHEIR HARD BUTINSOMECASESTHEYWEREWORKINGHARDUSING
STUDENTS MISGUIDED UNSCIENTIlCTECHNIQUES3OBYRELYINGONRE
SEARCHANDUSINGGRANTPROGRAMSSUCHAS2EADING&IRST
SCHOOLSBEGANWORKINGhSMARTERv!SARESULT ACHIEVE
MENTBEGANRISINGACROSSTHEBOARD
)NMANYWAYS THE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION
HASBECOMETHE&OODAND$RUG!DMINISTRATIONOF
EDUCATION9OUKNOW EDUCATIONUSEDTOBEALOTLIKE
MEDICINEBACKINTHEEARLYS WHENTHElELDWAS
STILLlLLEDWITHQUACKSANDROVINGSNAKEOILSALESMEN
PEDDLINGTHEIRWARESONANUNSUSPECTINGPUBLIC5P
UNTILTHESTARTOFTHISCENTURY EDUCATIONWASTHESAME
WAY9OUHADmY BY NIGHTPROFESSIONALDEVELOPERSWHO
WOULDBREEZEINTOTOWN HAWKINGSOMENEWFAD%DUCA
TORSREALLYHADNOWAYOFKNOWINGWHETHERANYOFTHIS
4HE7HAT7ORKS#LEARINGHOUSESTARTEDGETTING STUFFWORKED BUTNOWTHEYDO7EHAVEALOTFEWER
lLLEDWITHMOREANDMOREHELPFULINFORMATIONONITS SERVICEPROVIDERSTHANADECADEAGO BUTTHEONESWE
WAYTOBECOMINGTHERICHRESOURCEITISTODAY!TTHE DOHAVE AREONTHEWHOLE ALOTBETTER
SAMETIME THE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONREALLY
STARTEDGROWINGINTOTHEROLEWEPLAYTODAYˆPRO
VIDINGQUALITYASSURANCEFOREDUCATIONPROGRAMSBIG
ANDSMALL HELPINGEDUCATORSKNOWWHICHPROGRAMS
ANDSERVICEPROVIDERSTHEYCANTRUST0UBLICSCHOOLS
HADALWAYSHADALOTOFGOODPEOPLEWHOWORKEDVERY


2OUSE +$ECEMBER  h3CHOOL2EPORT#ARDS)MPROVE v$ENVER0OST P" 

!STUDYRELEASEDIN!PRILBYTHE#OUNCILOFTHE'REAT#ITY3CHOOLSREPORTEDTHATURBANDISTRICTSWEREMAKINGSTEADYPROGRESSONSTATE
MATHANDREADINGTESTSANDTHATPERFORMANCEGAPSBETWEENSTUDENTSOFVARIOUSRACIALANDETHNICGROUPSWERENARROWING3OURCE'EWERTZ #
!PRIL  h5RBAN$ISTRICTS2EPORT3TEADY!CADEMIC'AINS v%DUCATION7EEK P

'OODWIN "-AY $IGGING$EEPER7HERETHEPUBLICSTANDSONSTANDARDS BASEDEDUCATION !URORA#/ -C2%,

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

9ET DESPITETHESEIMPROVEMENTSINTESTSCORESAND !TTHESAMETIME ANEWGENERATIONOFPRAGMATIC


THEKNOWLEDGEBASEFORGUIDINGSCHOOLANDCLASSROOM PUBLICSCHOOLLEADERSEMERGEDWHOWEREWILLINGTO
IMPROVEMENTS PUBLICSCHOOLSWERESTILLMISSINGSOME CREATESCHOOLSTHATAPPEALEDTOLOCALVALUES3OME
THINGPARENTSSAIDWASEVENMOREIMPORTANTTOTHEM FOUNDITIRONIC IFNOTALITTLEHYPOCRITICAL THAT'EN
THANACADEMICSˆVALUESANDCHARACTER-ORETHAN 8ERS WHOHADBEENREGARDEDINTHEIROWNYOUTHAS
ANYTHINGELSEREALLY PARENTSWANTEDTOKNOWTHATTHEY ROWDY hBADKIDS vWERESOWILLINGTOIMPOSERULESAND
WERESENDINGTHEIRCHILDRENTOAPLACEWHERETHEYDBE RELIGIONONTHEIROWNKIDS)STILLREMEMBERONEFATHER
SAFE ADULTSWOULDPAYATTENTIONTOTHEM ANDTHEYD
GROWUPTOBEGOODPEOPLE

"ACKTOTHEFOLD
)N !MERICANSBEGANTOSENSEASEACHANGE
INOURCULTURE7ITHONGOINGCONmICTSABROADANDTHE
UNFORTUNATETERRORISTATTACKSIN,AS6EGASAND/RLANDO
OURSENSEOFSECURITYANDOURECONOMYSUFFERED"UTAS
OFTENHAPPENSINAPEOPLESDARKESTHOUR WEBEGANTO
PULLTOGETHERASANATIONANDSEETHEVALUEINPROVID
INGOURCHILDRENWITHASAFE ORDERLYPLACETOLEARN
3ODESPITEBUDGETCUTSATTHEFEDERAL STATE ANDLOCAL WHOHADTATTOOSUPANDDOWNHISARMSˆHEWASAREAL
LEVELS LAWMAKERSFOUNDWAYSTOKEEPFUNDINGOUR SIGHT BELIEVEMEˆTELLINGME h)MHARDLYRELIGIOUS
NATIONSSCHOOLS"ABYBOOMERS WHOHADONCEBEEN BUT)DONTMINDYOUPUTTINGTHETENCOMMANDMENTS
LABELEDTHEhMEGENERATION vSHOWEDANUNEXPECTED UPINTHESCHOOLS)FITLLSCARESOMEKIDSSTRAIGHTAND
WILLINGNESSTOSACRIlCEFORTHEIRCHILDRENANDGRANDCHIL KEEPTHEMFROMMAKINGTHESAMEMISTAKESMEANDMY
DREN FRIENDSMADE )MALLFORITv
-OREOVER !MERICASPEOPLEOFFAITHˆEMBOLD *OHN0ARKS A"APTISTMINISTERINTHESAMETOWN
ENEDBYPOLITICALVICTORIES AGROWINGNUMBEROFMEDIA WHERE)WASASUPERINTENDENT PUTITTHISWAY(ESAID
OUTLETSCATERINGTOTHEIRVALUES ANDA3UPREME#OURT h7HATYOUNOTICERIGHTOFFABOUTTHESEYOUNGERPRINCI
LESSPRONETOSTRIKEDOWNLAWSREmECTINGLOCALVALUES PALSISTHEYHAVENOAXETOGRIND4HEYRENOTOUTTHERE
ˆDECIDEDTHATINSTEADOFABANDONINGPUBLICSCHOOLS PUSHINGFORPRAYERINSCHOOLSORABSTINENCE ONLY NOR
THEYSHOULD TOQUOTELOOSELYFROMTHElRSTBOOKOFTHE ARETHEYSTANDINGINTHEWAY4HEYRENOPREACHERS
"IBLE hSHAPETHEMINTHEIRIMAGEv THATSFORSUREBUTTHEYMAKEMIGHTYlNEDEACONSv


)NTHEIRBOOK 4HE&OURTH4URNING7HATTHE#YCLESOF(ISTORY4ELL5S!BOUT!MERICAS.EXT2ENDEZVOUSWITH$ESTINY 7ILLIAM3TRAUSSAND.EIL
(OWEPREDICTTHATAPERIODOFCRISISIN!MERICANCULTURE WHATTHEYCALLAhFOURTHTURNINGvMAYOCCURSOMETIMEAROUND PROPELLEDBYA
CATALYSTEVENTSUCHASATERRORISTATTACK4HEYARGUETHATSUCHCRISISPERIODSAREMARKEDBYARISINGhDEMANDFORORDERvANDCIVICAUTHORITY$URING
THESEPERIODS THEYASSERTTHATPEOPLEhREDISCOVERTHEVALUEOFUNITY TEAMWORK ANDSOCIALDISCIPLINEvPP  

3TRAUSSAND(OWEALSOPREDICTTHATASBABYBOOMERSENTERELDERHOODAGES  THEYWILLSEEKAhPRESERVATIONOFVALUESTHATWILLSEEM
ANTIQUATEDTOOTHERSvP 7HEREASTHEIR3ILENTAND')GENERATIONPREDECESSORSEXACTEDAlNANCIALBURDENONYOUTHWHILECEDINGMORALAU
THORITY BOOMERSWILLDOTHEOPPOSITEˆMAKElNANCIALSACRIlCEWHILEIMPOSINGTHEIRMORALSONYOUTH SEEKINGhETHICALPERFECTIONISMvP 

3TRAUSSAND(OWECONJECTURETHATAS'EN 8ERSENTERMID LIFEAGES  THEYWILLLIKELYhCLAMPDOWNONCHILDRENvANDhSENSETHENEED
TORESTORECOMMUNITYvP !SAGENERATION THEIRWEAK hWEARENOTWORTHYvSENSEOFSELF ESTEEMWILLMAKETHEMMOREAPTTHANTHEIR3ILENT
')ANDBOOMERELDERSTOSACRIlCEFORTHEGREATERGOODP &INALLY 3TRAUSSAND(OWEPREDICTTHATMILLENNIALYOUNGADULTSAGES  WILL
BEMUCHMORELIKELYTHANTHEIR'EN 8ERPREDECESSORSTOBEhMANNERLY CIVIC SPIRITED ANDEMOTIONALLYPLACIDvPP 


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

)NLATE THECONSERVATIVEIDEOLOGYOFMANY 'OVERNMENT


BOOMERSANDTHEPRAGMATICSIDEOF'EN 8PARENTS WHO
WEREANXIOUSTODOWHATEVERITTOOKTOKEEPTHEIRKIDS h4HEMORETHINGS
CHANGEv
OUTOFTROUBLE REACHEDATIPPINGPOINTASAGROWING

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
NUMBEROFMINISTERS PARENTS ANDPEOPLEOFFAITHBEGAN 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
CALLINGFORCONSERVATIVESTOhTAKEBACKTHESCHOOLSv
/VERTHENEXTSEVERALYEARS INMOREANDMOREPLACES
PRAYERRETURNEDTOSCHOOLSMORALLYRELATIVISTIChCHARAC
TEREDUCATIONvPROGRAMSWEREREPLACEDBY"IBLE BASED
CHARACTEREDUCATIONhINTELLIGENTDESIGNvWASADDEDTO
.ON 'OVERNMENT
SCIENCESTANDARDSINSEVERALSTATESANDABSTINENCE ONLY
PROGRAMSBECAMETHERULE NOTTHEEXCEPTION!ND
lNALLY ASTHISlNELOOKINGBUNCHOFSTUDENTSINFRONTOF
MEHERETONIGHTDEMONSTRATES MOREANDMOREPUBLIC BYCHARTERSCHOOLSARENTSTILLWITHUSˆTHEYARE BUT
SCHOOLSBEGANTOREQUIRESTUDENTSTOWEARUNIFORMS MOSTOFTHEMHAVEBEENFOLDEDINTOOURPUBLICSCHOOLS
INONEWAYORANOTHER4HE#HARTERGATESCANDALALSO
$ERAILINGDEREGULATION PROMPTEDUSTOGETlRMWITHCHARTERSCHOOLS ACADEMI
CALLY DEMANDINGTHATTHEYMEETTHETERMSOFTHEIR
)NTHESANDS !MERICANSWEREFONDOF
CHARTERSAND IFNOT FACEAVERYPUBLICEXECUTION/NCE
DEREGULATIONh4ELLMEWHATTODOANDTHENSTAYOUTOF
AGAIN WHILEWEMAYHAVEFEWERCHOICESTHANWEDID
MYWAYvˆTHATWASTHEATTITUDE!NDWHILEEXCESSIVE
ADECADEAGO WEHAVEBETTERCHOICES4HEGOODIDEAS
REDTAPENEVERHELPEDANYONE INAND THE
HAVEREMAINEDANDBEENABSORBEDBYTHESYSTEMTHE
h#HARTERGATEvSCANDALˆTHERASHOFCHARTERSCHOOLS
BADIDEAS WELL THEYVEBEENLEFTINTHEDUSTBINOF
ACROSSTHECOUNTRYTHATWENTBANKRUPTANDCLOSED
HISTORY
MID WAYTHROUGHTHESCHOOLYEAR LEAVINGPARENTSAND
STUDENTSHIGHANDDRYˆTAUGHTUSALLANIMPORTANT
LESSONABOUTTHENEEDFORGOVERNMENTTOKNOWWHATS 0UBLICSCHOOLSOFFTHEROPES
HAPPENINGWITHITSTAXDOLLARS)NLIGHTOFTHECHARTER )FYOUHADTRIEDTOPREDICTTHEFUTUREOFPUBLIC
SCHOOLSCANDALS ITSNOSURPRISETHAT#ONGRESSVOTED EDUCATIONINTHELATE
TOREAUTHORIZETHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTIN SANDEARLYYEARS
AND INDOINGSO STRUCKABALANCEBETWEENGIVING OFTHESTCENTURY YOU
SCHOOLSENOUGHFREEDOMTODOWHATTHEYNEEDEDTO MIGHTVEPREDICTEDTHAT
DOTOCREATESAFE SUPPORTIVEPLACESOFLEARNINGAND ITWOULDSOONGOTHEWAY
CONTINUINGTOPROVIDEENOUGHOVERSIGHTTOMAKESUREA OFTHEDODOBIRDBECAUSE
SCHOOLTHATOPENEDITSDOORSIN3EPTEMBERWOULDSTILL PUBLICSCHOOLSWOULD
BEAROUNDIN-AY SOONBUCKLEUNDERTHE
)NALLFAIRNESSTOTHOSEMANYCHARTERSCHOOLOPERA COMPETITIVEPRESSURE
TORSWHODIDRUNTIGHTSHIPSANDPROVIDETHEIRSTUDENTS FROMCHARTER PRIVATE
WITHAGOODEDUCATION #HARTERGATECAMEALONGATTHE ANDHOMESCHOOLS7E
WRONGTIME WHENTHESOFTENINGECONOMY COUPLED KNOWNOW OFCOURSE
WITHSOMENATURALDISASTERSˆ(URRICANE-AURICEON THATDIDNTHAPPEN
THE%AST#OASTCOMESTOMINDˆLEDTOBANKRUPTCIES /NEBIGREASONWAS
AMONGSOMELARGEINSURANCEANDMORTGAGECOMPANIES THATPUBLICSCHOOLS
!LLOFTHATCAUSEDTHEPUBLICTOPLACELESSFAITHINFREE QUICKLYLEARNEDFROM
MARKETSOLUTIONSANDMOREINGOVERNMENTSOLUTIONS THESUCCESSESOFPUBLIC
4HATSNOTTOSAYTHATALOTOFGOODIDEASlRSTPIONEERED

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

SCHOOLALTERNATIVES NOTJUSTINTERMSOFACADEMIC INDIVIDUALS!NDTHROUGHOUTTHEIRLIVES THEYHAVENT


SUCCESSBUTALSOINTERMSOFLEARNINGWHATPARENTS DISPLAYEDTHEWILDSTREAKOFBOOMERSOR'EN 8ERS
WERESEEKINGWHENTHEYSENTTHEIRKIDSTONON PUBLIC !STEACHERS THEYDONTPUTUPAFUSSWHENTHEYRE
SCHOOLSORDECIDEDTOTEACHTHEMATHOME ASKEDTOTEACHCURRICULUMALIGNEDTOTHE.ATIONAL
"UTMANYSOCIOLOGISTSHAVEOBSERVEDTHATSOME !SSESSMENTOF%DUCATIONAL0ROGRESS SOMETHINGWHICH
THINGELSEIMPORTANTHAPPENEDINOURCULTUREHERE WOULDVEBEENUNTHINKABLETOTHEPREVIOUSGENERA
IN!MERICA/VERTHEPASTFEWYEARS WEHAVEBEGUN TIONOFTEACHERSSOOBSESSEDWITHhLOCALCONTROLvAND
TOREVERSEA YEARTRENDOFEVERYBODYGOINGTHEIR ACADEMICFREEDOM)VEFOUNDTHATMOSTOFTODAYS
OWNWAYSˆTHEWHOLEhMEvGENERATIONTHINGˆAND TEACHERSSEEMTOLIKEKNOWINGTHATALLACROSSTHE
BEGUNTOPULLTOGETHERAS!MERICANS!LOTOFTHATHAS COUNTRY OURSCHOOLSANDTEACHERSAREALLWORKING
TODOWITHTHEFACTTHATFEWOFUSHAVEBEENUNTOUCHED TOGETHERONTHESAMEPAGE!NDASPARENTS THEYARE
BYTHETRAGEDIESOFTERRORISTATTACKSANDECONOMICHARD VERYDIFFERENTTHANTHEGENERATIONSTHATCAMEBEFORE
SHIPSINRECENTYEARS7EVEBEENDRAWNTOGETHERBY THEM&ORSTARTERS THEYGOTMARRIEDANDSETTLEDDOWN
MUTUALADVERSITY YOUNG SOTHEYREYOUNGPARENTS"UTTHEYRECOMMITTED
7EALSOHAVEANEWGENERATIONOFYOUNGPARENTS TOTHEIRKIDS4HEYVOLUNTEERTHEYCOMETOSCHOOLON
ANDTEACHERS"OOMERSESTABLISHEDAREPUTATIONFOR 3ATURDAYSTOCLEANUPTHEPLAYGROUNDS4HEYLIKETHE
BEINGASELF CENTEREDhMEvGENERATION'EN 8ERSFOR IDEAOFACOMMUNITYSCHOOL WHEREALLTHEKIDSINTHE
BEINGACYNICAL DETACHEDGENERATIONTHATREALLYDIDNT NEIGHBORHOODCOMETOGETHERTOLEARN!NDTHEYLIKE
CARETOJOINANYTHING9OUPUTTHOSETWOGENERATIONS KNOWINGTHATTHEIRKIDSARELEARNINGTHESAMETHINGAS
TOGETHERASPARENTSANDEDUCATORSANDYOUCANALMOST OTHERKIDS!NDMOSTIMPORTANT THEYREHAPPYLEAVING
PREDICTTHERESULTˆOURSCHOOLSSTARTEDFALLINGAPART SCHOOLINGUPTOTHEEXPERTSˆARIGHT WHICH)MIGHT
-YOWNGENERATIONOFBABYBOOMERSWEREATEACH ADD SCHOOLSHAVEEARNEDBYSHOWINGTHEYKNOWWHAT
OTHERSTHROATSABOUTEVERYTHINGUNDERTHESUN LIKE THEYREDOING
HOWTOTEACHREADINGPHONICSORWHOLELANGUAGE -YSON WHOISOFTHAT-ILLENNIALGENERATION GOT
SCIENCEEVOLUTIONORINTELLIGENTDESIGN MATHEMATICS MARRIEDAT JUSTTWOMONTHSAFTERHEGRADUATEDFROM
NEWMATHORmASHCARDS SEX EDCONDOMSORABSTI COLLEGE(ERECENTLYENROLLEDMYGRANDDAUGHTERINKIN
NENCE 9OUNAMEITWEFOUNDAWAYTOlGHTABOUTIT
'EN 8PARENTS MEANWHILE WERETOOCYNICALTOSTICK
AROUNDTOlXPUBLICSCHOOLSTHEYJUSTWANTEDWHATWAS
BESTFORTHEIROWNKIDSANDDOUBTEDTHATPUBLICSCHOOLS
WERECAPABLEOFhSAVINGvTHEIRORANYONEELSESKIDS
&ORTUNATELYFOROURPUBLICSCHOOLS ANEWGENERA
TION THE-ILLENNIALS STARTEDTEACHINGINOURSCHOOLS
ANDBRINGINGTHEIRKIDSTOOURSCHOOLSINTHELATE
DECADE!SAGENERATION THESE-ILLENNIALSSEEMTO
BELIEVEMUCHMORESTRONGLYTHANTHEIRELDERSTHAT
THEYCANACCOMPLISHMORETOGETHERTHANTHEYCANAS


4HEh#HILD 7ELL"EING)NDEX vRELEASEDIN-ARCHBYTHE&OUNDATIONFOR#HILD$EVELOPMENT REPORTEDTHATSINCE CHILDRENHAVE
BEENENGAGINGINLESSRISKYBEHAVIOR-OSTNOTABLY THETEENBIRTHRATEHASNEARLYBEENCUTINHALF FALLINGFROMBIRTHSPER GIRLSIN
TOANESTIMATEDBIRTHSPER GIRLSIN,IKEWISE THENUMBEROFYOUTHSAGES WHOWEREVICTIMSOFCRIMEFELLFROMPER 
CHILDRENINTOPER IN*EFFREY"UTTSOFTHE5RBAN)NSTITUTE COMMENTEDTOTHE!0 h-AYBEWEHAVETHENEXT@GREATESTGENERA
TIONCOMINGALONGHEREv4HEREPORTSAUTHOR $UKE5NIVERSITYPROFESSOR+ENNETH,AND EXPLAINEDTHETREND INPART DUETOTHEFACTTHATPARENTS
WHOGREWUPINTHESANDEARLYSWHOSAWOREXPERIENCEDTHEEFFECTOFDRUGUSEAREMOREASSERTIVEABOUTCONTROLLINGTHEIROWNCHILDRENS
BEHAVIOR3OURCE4HE!SSOCIATED0RESS-ARCH  h#HILDREN4ODAY$OING"ETTERTHAN0ARENTS7ERE+IDS%NGAGINGIN,ESS2ISKY"E
HAVIOR BUT3TILL%ATINGTOO-UCHvHTTPWWWMSNBCMSNCOMID


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

DERGARTENOVERIN,AKE*ACKSON 4EXAS7HEN)WENT 'OVERNMENT


DOWNTOSEEHIMLASTWEEKEND HETOLDME h7HEN)
WASINSCHOOL PARENTSWEREDIFFERENTTHEYDCOMEIN h4HEMORETHINGS
CHANGEv
HOLLERINGANDSHOUTING RAISINGASTINKIFATEACHERSO

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
MUCHASLOOKEDATTHEIRKIDWRONG-OSTPARENTSMY 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
AGEARENTLIKETHAT)TSEEMSLIKEMOSTOFUSlGUREITS
BESTTOSTAYOUTOFTHESCHOOLSWAYANDLETTHEMDO
THEIRJOBS)MEAN WHOAM)TOTELLTHEMHOWTOTEACH
MYCHILD4HATSWHATTHEYWENTTOSCHOOLFOR ISNT
IT)WOULDNTWANTTHEMCOMINGINTOMYOFlCEAND
.ON 'OVERNMENT
TELLINGMEHOWTODOMYJOB WOULD)v
-YSONISRIGHT4ODAYSSCHOOLSARERUNBYWELL EDU
CATEDEXPERTS WHOKNOWWHATTHEYREDOING.OW )
KNOWTHEREARESOMEPEOPLEWHOSAYTHATOURSCHOOLS 3CHOOLSONTHERISE
ARETOOMUCHALIKEANDDONTCREATEAhUNIQUEvEXPERI
)N NEARTHEMIDWAYPOINTOFTHE.O#HILD
ENCEFOREVERYKID!ND)KNOWTHEREARESOMELOCAL
,EFT"EHINDLEGISLATION THENATIONTOOKSTOCKOFTHE
CONTROLZEALOTSˆ)TENDTOTHINKOFTHEMASSOLDIERS
LAWANDFOUNDMOSTOFTHEEARLIERKINKSINITHADBEEN
ONANISLANDWHODONTKNOWTHEWARISOVERˆWHO
WORKEDOUT ANDMOREIMPORTANTLY STUDENTTESTSCORES
SAYTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTPLAYSTOOSTRONGAROLEIN
WEREONTHERISEONAVARIETYOFINDICATORS!TTHESTATE
EDUCATION DICTATINGCURRICULUMTOSCHOOLSANDSTATES
LEVEL SCORESWERERISINGSTEADILYONANEWGENERATIONOF
7ELL TOTHOSEPEOPLE )POINTOUTTHATFORTWOCEN
COMPUTERIZEDhSMARTvASSESSMENTS ATTHENATIONALLEVEL
TURIESWELETSTATESANDDISTRICTSASSUMETHELEADROLE
.!%0SCORESWERESHOWINGSTEADYGROWTHˆPARTLY
INEDUCATIONANDWHATDIDWEGET5NSCIENTIlCAP
BECAUSEAGROWINGNUMBEROFSTATESHAVEALIGNEDTHEIR
PROACHESTOLEARNING DROPOUTS ILLITERACY ANDCHILDREN
OWNASSESSMENTSWITH.!%0ˆAND ATTHEINTERNA
UNPREPAREDFORLIFESUCCESS-OREOVER BYSTANDARDIZING
TIONALLEVEL SCORESWEREUPASWELL
DATAREPORTINGANDTESTINGWEVEMADEITALOTHARDER
)NDEED AFTERYEARSOFBADPRESSABOUT53STUDENTS
FORSTATES DISTRICTS
UNFAVORABLECOMPARISONSTOTHEIRINTERNATIONALPEERS
ANDSCHOOLSTOGAME
WElNALLYSTARTEDTONOTICETHAT!MERICANSTUDENTS
THESYSTEM!SA
MORETHANTHOSEINANYOTHERCOUNTRY HADBEENQUIETLY
RESULT SCHOOLSNEARLY
CLIMBINGTHECHARTSININTERNATIONALCOMPARISONS
ACROSSTHEBOARDWERE
4HETESTSCORESSEEMEDTOCONlRMTHEIMPRESSIONOF
FORCEDTOPERFORMOR
MANYPARENTSANDTAXPAYERSTHATOURSCHOOLSWERENOT
PERISH!SYOUKNOW
ONLYGETTINGBETTER BUTWERETRULYBECOMINGASOURCEOF
NOW MOSTHAVERISEN
CIVICANDINTERNATIONALPRIDE
TOOURHIGHEREXPECTA
TIONSANDPERFORMED
!LLINTHEFAMILY
WONDERFULLY
)N THE53#ENSUS"UREAUREPORTEDTHAT ASA
NATION WEHADBEGUNTOREDISCOVERFAMILY OFTENOUTOF
NECESSITY4HECENSUSFOUNDTHATMOREOFUSWERELIVING

&OREXAMPLE BETWEENAND 53THGRADERSRESULTSONTHE4)--3SCIENCETESTINCREASEDSIGNIlCANTLYFROMANAVERAGESCOREOF




TOˆWHILETHEINTERNATIONALAVERAGEFELLFROMINTOIN7HILE53SCORESARESTILLWELLBELOWTHETOPSCORER 3INGA
PORE ITISONEOFTHEFEWCOUNTRIESWITHSUSTAINEDIMPROVEMENTINITS4)--3SCORES

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

2ETURNTOTHEhCOMMON
SCHOOLv
3TARTINGIN BLOGGERSANDREPORTERSBEGAN
NOTICINGANEWSEACHANGEIN!MERICANLIFE3EVERAL
YEARSEARLIER SOCIOLOGISTSHADOBSERVEDTHATPEOPLEWERE
hBOWLINGALONEv4ODAY HOWEVER !MERICANSAREMUCH
MORECIVIC MINDED ANDOURSCHOOLSAREATTHECENTER
OFOURNEWSENSEOF
COMMUNITY!S!MERI
CANS WEHAVEREDISCOV
EREDACOMMONSENSE
OFPURPOSEANDLEARNED
INTHREE GENERATIONHOUSEHOLDSASlNANCIALLYSTRAPPED THATWEAREFARMORE
YOUNGPARENTSEITHERMOVEDINWITHTHEIRPARENTS OR ALIKETHANDIFFERENT7E
INVITEDTHEIRPARENTSˆMANYOFWHOMHADEITHER HAVEBUILTOURSCHOOLS
FAILEDTOSAVEADEQUATELYFORRETIREMENTORSEENTHEIR AROUNDSHAREDVALUESOF
PENSIONAND3OCIAL3ECURITYBENElTSCUTˆTOLIVEWITH DEMOCRACY HARDWORK
THEMTOHELPOUTWITHTHEBILLSANDCHILDCARE-YOWN ANDEQUALITY)NDEED
FAMILYISAGOODEXAMPLE-YDAUGHTERANDSON IN LAW SOMESAYTHATOURSCHOOLSREPRESENTTHEBESTVALUESOF
ARELIVINGWITHMEIN!RLINGTONWHILEHElNISHESUP YESTERDAYˆTHESENSEOFINDIVIDUALMORALITYANDPRO
LAWSCHOOLAT(OWARD)MONTHEROADALOT SOITSNICE PRIETYOFTHESWITHTHESENSEOFSOCIALJUSTICEAND
TOHAVESOMEONEATHOME WATCHINGTHEHOUSEAND EQUALITYOFTHES
FEEDINGMYDOG!NDTHEBESTTHINGOFALLISTHAT)GET !TTHESAMETIME FORMANYOFUS THEOLDMETA
TOSEEALOTOFMYNEWBABYGRANDDAUGHTER WHOGETS PHOROF!MERICAASAhTOSSEDSALADvˆSEPARATERACES
TOSPENDTHEDAYWITHHERGRANDDADWHORETIREDAFEW ANDCULTURESJUMBLEDTOGETHERBUTNOTREALLYMIXING
YEARSAGO/URNESTISPRETTYFULL BUT)WOULDNTHAVEIT ˆDOESNTHOLDASMUCHCURRENCYASTHEOLDERIDEAOF
ANYOTHERWAY AhMELTINGPOTvWHEREPEOPLEOFDIFFERENTRACESAND
/VERTHEPASTSEVERALYEARS !MERICAHASBEENA CULTURESCOMETOGETHER
KINDER GENTLERPLACEFOROURCHILDREN4HEDIVORCERATE TOCREATEANEW BLENDED
ISDOWN TEENAGEPREGNANCIESARENOWJUSTONE TENTHOF CULTURE9OUCANSEETHAT
WHATTHEYWEREIN ANDMOREOFOURCHILDRENARE FACEINOURFACES4HE
LIVINGWITHTWOPARENTSˆANDSOMETIMESMORE WHEN NUMBEROFMIXED RACE
YOUCOUNTTHEIRGRANDPARENTS.OTSURPRISINGLY WITH FAMILIES EITHERFROM
MOREADULTSAROUNDTOOFFERTHEMGUIDANCE OURKIDS MIXED RACEMARRIAGESOR
AREDOINGBETTERINSCHOOL MULTI CULTURALADOPTIONS
CONTINUESTOGROWMORE
RAPIDLYTHANANYOTHER
ETHNICORCULTURALCATEGO
RY-YGRANDDAUGHTERIN
,AKE*ACKSON FOREXAMPLE


!SOF INADOPTEDCHILDRENWEREOFADIFFERENTRACETHANTHEIRPARENTS ANDINMARRIAGESWEREMIXED RACEMARRIAGES UPFROM
ININ$ATASHOWASIGNIlCANTRISEINMIXED RACEFAMILIESDUETOINTERRACIALMARRIAGESANDMULTIRACIALADOPTIONSh!LLINTHEMIXED RACE
&AMILYA534RENDv7ILTENBURG - 0AULSON !!UGUST  #HRISTIAN3CIENCE-ONITOR


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

ISPART"LACK #HEROKEE 'OVERNMENT


ISH -EXICAN AND
IETNAMESE3HEDGETA h4HEMORETHINGS
CHANGEv
RAMPTRYINGTOCHECK

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
FFHERETHNICITYONA 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
ENSUSFORM7HEREDID
ERPARENTSMEET)N
UBLICSCHOOLS9OUSEE
URSCHOOLSREALLYARE
MELTINGPOTTHROUGH
.ON 'OVERNMENT
HICH!MERICANSARE
OTLOSINGTHEIRIDENTI
ES BUTRATHERCREATING
ANEWONE ,EAVINGNOCHILDBEHIND
!SYOUKNOW THISSUMMER THEVASTMAJORITYOFOUR
3ILVERHAIRED LINING SCHOOLSGOTGREATNEWS-ORETHANOFOURNATIONS
4HEPASTFEWYEARSHAVEBEENHARDONEVERYONE SCHOOLSHAVERISENTOTHECHALLENGESETBYLAWMAK
ECONOMICALLY BUTFOROURSCHOOLS THEREHASBEENA ERSYEARSAGOWHENTHEYPASSEDTHE.O#HILD,EFT
SILVERLININGˆORACTUALLY IFYOULLEXCUSETHEPUN A "EHIND!CTOF3URE THEREAREPOCKETSOFDISAP
SILVER HAIREDLINING3EMI RETIREESARElNDINGOUT OR POINTMENTˆPERCENTOFSCHOOLSNOTACHIEVINGTHIS
PERHAPSRE DISCOVERING THATSCHOOLSAREAGREATPLACE GOALISSTILLTOOMANY"UTLETSREmECTFORAMOMENT)N
TOWORKANDVOLUNTEER)WASRECENTLYVISITING,OS  PEOPLESAIDOURSCHOOLSWOULDNEVERRISETOMEET
!NGELES0UBLIC3CHOOLSWHERE)LEARNEDTHATSEMI RETIR THISAUDACIOUSGOAL"UTACROSSTHECOUNTRY OURSCHOOLS
EESNOWCOMPRISEAQUARTEROFTHATDISTRICTSWORKFORCE ANDTHEHARDWORKINGSTUDENTSANDTEACHERSAND
/NElRST GRADER)SPOKEWITH HERNAMEWAS!NGEL SEMI RETIREES INTHEMHAVERISENTOMEETTHISCHAL
WHICHCOULDNTHAVEBEENMORElTTING TOLDMESHEHAS LENGE3URE THEREARESTILLAFEWVOICESOUTTHEREWHO
THREEhGRANDMASvWHOWATCHAFTERHERˆONEINTHE SAYOURSCHOOLSARETOORIGIDORDONTALLOWSTUDENTSTO
MORNING ONEINTHEAFTERNOON ANDONESHELIVESWITH EXPRESSTHEMSELVESLIKETHEYDIDINTHEOLDDAYS4O
WHOGREETSHERWHENSHECOMESHOMEAFTERSCHOOL) THOSEPEOPLEWHOWOULDPREFERTOGOBACKTOTHEPAST
THOUGHTTHATWASAREALSIGNOFTHETIMES ˆWHENSTUDENTSWERELEFTBEHINDINUNSAFE UNPRODUC
TIVESCHOOLS WHICHWEREINTURNSERVEDBYmY BY NIGHT
4HE-ARSRACEISON COMPANIESANDPROVIDERSWHOWEREBETTERATMARKETING
THELATESTFADTHANDEVELOPINGPRODUCTSANDPROGRAMS
)N THE0RESIDENTCHALLENGEDTHECOUNTRYIN
BASEDONSCIENTIlCRESEARCHˆ)SAY ITSAFREECOUNTRY
HERINAUGURALADDRESSTOENSURETHAT!MERICANSARETHE
YOUCANTEACHYOURCHILDATHOMEORSENDTHEMTOA
lRSTTO-ARSˆINSEVENSHORTYEARS(ERESACOMPEL
PRIVATESCHOOL"UTIFYOUWANTYOURCHILDTOGOTOA
LINGTHOUGHTONEOFTHElRST!MERICANSTOSETFOOT
SAFE STRUCTURED RIGOROUSENVIRONMENTWHERETHEYCAN
ON-ARSINMAYBEAHIGHSCHOOLSTUDENTTODAY
RECEIVETHEBESTEDUCATIONINTHEWORLD SENDTHEMTO
INONEOFOURPUBLICSCHOOLS4OGETTHEMTHERESAFELY
ONEOF!MERICASlNEPUBLICSCHOOLS
AHEADOFTHE#HINESEAND%UROPEANS WEKNOWTHATOUR
SCHOOLSMUSTBECOMETHEBESTINTHEWORLDATTEACHING
SCIENCE MATHEMATICSANDTECHNOLOGY4HISISNOEASY
TASK BUT) AND)AMSUREYOUALLHERETONIGHTWILLAGREE
WITHME AMCONlDENTTHATOURNATIONSPUBLICSCHOOLS
AREUPTOTHETASK

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

!NALYSISOF3CENARIO
)MPLICATIONS )NDICATORS
)NTHISWORLD THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTEXERCISES 4HEFOLLOWINGTRENDSANDDATAPOINTSAREPOSSIBLE
EXTENSIVECONTROLOVERSCHOOLINGANDTHEPROGRAMS INDICATORSTHATTHEFUTUREMAYBEMOVINGTOWARDTHIS
SCHOOLSUSETOMAINTAINLEVELSOFACHIEVEMENT"ECAUSE SCENARIO
ASTRONGFEDERALPRESENCEINSCHOOLSLEDTOIMPROVED
MEASURESOFPRODUCTIVITY AHIGHVALUEISPLACEDON s )MPROVINGACHIEVEMENTSCORESATTHESTATE NA
CONFORMITYTOFEDERALGUIDELINESANDEXPECTATIONS TIONAL ANDINTERNATIONALLEVELS
0ROVIDERSOFPRODUCTSANDSERVICESTOTHEEDUCATION s $ECREASEDSTATEANDLOCALRESISTANCETO.#,"
MARKETMUSTDELIVEREVIDENCE BASEDSOLUTIONS DEMON PERHAPSASARESULTOFMODIlCATIONSTOTHELAW
STRATINGTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFTHEIRSTRATEGIES TOOLS AND INCREASEDFUNDING ANDORFEWERSCHOOLSBEING
RELATEDMATERIALS)TISALSOPOSSIBLETHEFEDERALGOVERN IDENTIlEDFORSANCTIONS
MENTWILLESTABLISHLISTSOFhAPPROVEDPROGRAMSANDOR
PROVIDERSvWHOMEETTHEIRSTANDARDS)TWILLBEINTHE s )NCREASINGPARENTSATISFACTIONWITHSCHOOLSONTHE
STRATEGICBUSINESSINTERESTOFANYPROVIDEROFPROGRAMS 'ALLUP0$+ANNUALSURVEY
ANDORSERVICESSELLINGTOTHEEDUCATIONMARKETTOBE
s )NCREASINGUTILITYOFANDRELIANCEUPONTHE7HAT
ONTHESELISTS4HESTANDARDSWOULDLIKELYINCLUDEA
7ORKS#LEARINGHOUSE
SCIENTIlCRESEARCHBASEEVIDENCEOFQUALITY UTILITY AND
IMPACTEFlCACYCONSISTENCYACROSSVARIOUSEDUCATIONAL s ,EVELORINCREASEDFEDERALFUNDINGFOREDUCATION
SETTINGSURBAN SUBURBAN RURAL LARGE SMALL ETC AF
FORDABILITYSCALABILITYANDSUSTAINABILITY s )NCREASINGSTANDARDIZATIONOFSTATEWIDEASSESS
4OSURVIVEINTHISWORLD SERVICEPROVIDERSWILLNEED MENTPROGRAMS EITHERTHROUGHREGIONALCOMPACTS
STRONGADVOCACYATBOTHSTATEANDFEDERALLEVELS)TWILL AMONGSTATESORTHROUGHEFFORTSTOALIGNSTATETESTS
NOTBEENOUGHTOSIMPLYFOCUSONANDTOMEETTHESE TOTHE.!%0TESTORTOADOPTTHE.!%0FORSTATE
STANDARDS0ROVIDERSMUSTMAINTAINHIGHVISIBILITYAND TESTINGPURPOSES
CREDIBILITYWITHFEDERALANDSTATEOFlCIALSWHOAPPROVE
s #ONSERVATIVERELIGIOUSVALUESEG POSTINGOF
THELISTSOFAPPROVEDPROVIDERS4HESEFEDERALANDSTATE
THETENCOMMANDMENTS ALLOWINGSCHOOLPRAYER
OFlCIALSAREAKEYAUDIENCEFORPROVIDERMESSAGES )N
PROVIDINGABSTINENCEONLYEDUCATION INCLUD
ADDITION BECAUSEEDUCATIONRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENT
INGhINTELLIGENTDESIGNvINSCIENCECURRICULA ARE
INTHISWORLDISFUNDEDALMOSTENTIRELYBYTHEFEDERAL
INCREASINGLYREmECTEDINTHEPUBLICSCHOOLS
GOVERNMENT ORGANIZATIONSRECEIVING2$FUNDINGWILL
NEEDTOMAINTAINSTRONGRELATIONSHIPSWITHKEYEXECU s )NCREASINGPUBLICCONlDENCEINGOVERNMENTAND
TIVELEADERSANDPROGRAMOFlCERSINFUNDINGAGENCIES PUBLICSCHOOLS
EG .3&AND)%3 


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

/PTIONS
7ITHTHEEMPHASISONhEVIDENCE BASEDvAPPROACHES
SCIENTIlCRESEARCH ANDCONFORMITY PROVIDERSINTHIS
WORLDCOULDCONSIDERTHEFOLLOWINGPOSSIBLESTRATEGIES
ANDORACTIONS

s 3TEPUPADVOCACYEFFORTS MAKINGSTRATEGICUSE
OFEVIDENCEALONGWITHTHETESTIMONIALSOFKEY
CLIENTSUSERSOFPRODUCTSANDSERVICES

s -AINTAINPOSITIVERELATIONSHIPSWITHTHE
EXECUTIVELEADERSHIPANDPROGRAMOFlCERSINKEY
FUNDINGAGENCIES

s -AKEEFFECTIVEUSEOFRESEARCHFUNDINGTO
EVALUATETHEEFFECTIVENESSOFEXISTING RESEARCH
BASEDSOLUTIONSINTERVENTIONS

s 4OENSURElDELITYTOAGOVERNMENT APPROVED
PROGRAM SERVICEPROVIDERSMAYNEEDTODEVELOP
ASTANDARDAPPROACHTOhTRAININGOFTRAINERSv
ALIGNEDWITHARIGOROUSQUALITYASSURANCEPROCESS
ANDQUALITYSTANDARDS

s 'IVENTHENEEDTOCREATEAFFORDABLEANDSCALABLE
SERVICES EDUCATIONSERVICESPROVIDERSMAY
CONSIDERRECRUITINGEXTERNALCONSULTANTSWHOWILL
CONTRACTTOUSEPROVIDERPRODUCTSANDDELIVER
PROVIDERSERVICESAShPROJECTSTAFFvUNDERTHE
SUPERVISIONOFREGULARPROVIDERSTAFF

s %XPLOITTHEUSEOFhMIXEDMEDIAvFACETOFACE
E CAMPUS WEBCAMS TOSUPPORTHIGH QUALITY
SCALABLE SUSTAINABLE AFFORDABLESERVICEDELIVERY

s $EVELOPANDNURTURERELATIONSHIPSWITHKEYPOWER
BROKERSˆNAMELY POLITICALANDGOVERNMENT
OFlCIALS

s #ONSIDERWAYSTOALIGNPROGRAMSANDSERVICES
WITHWHATMAYINCREASINGLYBECOMEADEFACTO
NATIONALCURRICULUMTHATWILLLIKELYCONTAINA
STRONGEMPHASISONMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

3CHOOLOPOLYCOM7HEREAN 'OVERNMENT

 'ORILLA3LEEPS

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
$EEP#AUSES
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
)NTHISSCENARIO PRIVATEINSTITUTIONSARERESPONSIBLE

&EW
FORSCHOOLINGTHEVASTMAJORITYOFCHILDREN YETOFFER
LIMITEDCHOICESTOPARENTSANDSTUDENTS4HEFOLLOWING h7HEREAN
DEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO POUNDGORILLA
SLEEPSv

4HEFAILUREREALORPERCEIVED OFPUBLICSCHOOLS .ON 'OVERNMENT


TOADEQUATELYEDUCATEALLCHILDRENANDORTHE
SUCCESSOFPRIVATIZEDMODELSSPURSTHEPRIVATIZA
TIONOFEDUCATION
h7HEREAN POUND'ORILLA
0ERCEIVEDFAILURESOFGOVERNMENTCAUSETHEPUBLIC
3LEEPSv
TOBLAMEGOVERNMENTFORTHEIRPROBLEMSANDSEEK
NON GOVERNMENTALSOLUTIONSTOAVARIETYOFISSUES
INCLUDINGEDUCATION 4IME$ECEMBER 
0LACE+EY7EST &LORIDA
)NCREASINGGOVERNMENTOBLIGATIONSTOSUPPORT
OTHERENTITLEMENTPROGRAMSEG 3OCIAL3ECURITY 3CENE3AM0ATEL #%/OF#HALLENGE3CHOOLS )NC
ANDHEALTHCARE PROMPTLAWMAKERSTOTURNTO ISDELIVERINGTHEKEYNOTEADDRESSTOTHETH!NNUAL
PRIVATIZATIONASASTRATEGYFORREDUCINGEDUCATION #ONFERENCEOFTHE%DUCATION0ROVIDER)NDUSTRY
SPENDING !SSOCIATION

,ARGE SUCCESSFULCOMPANIESMOVEINTOTHEEDUCA 9OUSEE THROUGHOUTTHESANDS BUSINESS


TIONMARKETPLACEANDQUICKLYGAINDOMINANCE PEOPLECOMPLAINEDTHATSCHOOLSNEEDEDTOBERUNMORE
RESULTINGINLIMITEDCHOICESFORPARENTSAND LIKEBUSINESSESFOCUSEDONTHEBOTTOMLINEˆINTHEIR
STUDENTS CASE STUDENTACHIEVEMENT4ONIGHT MORETHAN
3TUDENTMOBILITYCREATESAMARKETFORSCHOOL YEARSAFTERTHE.ATIONAT2ISK2EPORTANDYEARSAFTER
FRANCHISESASPARENTSSEEKOUTCONSISTENTEDUCA THEPASSAGEOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDLAW.#,"
TIONOPPORTUNITIESWHENTHEYMOVETODIFFERENT )THINKWEDALLAGREETHATSCHOOLSHAVEBECOMEMORE
LOCATIONS LIKEBUSINESSES)NFACT ASTHELARGECROWDHERETONIGHT
ATTESTS SCHOOLSHAVEBECOMEBUSINESSESˆANDNOTJUST
4ECHNOLOGYCREATESEDUCATIONEFlCIENCIES PRO ANYBUSINESS BUTBIGBUSINESSESˆ POUNDGORILLA
VIDINGSUFlCIENTMARGINSTOENTICELARGECOMPA BUSINESSES
NIESTOENTERTHEMARKET )NSIDETHISROOM )MSUREMOSTOFUSSEETHISISAS
APOSITIVEDEVELOPMENT/UTSIDETHISROOM THOUGH
)MSUREYOUVEALLHEARDTHEOLDJOKEABOUTTHE
THEREMAYBESOMEDIFFERENCEOFOPINION/KAY THATSA
POUNDGORILLA9OUKNOWTHEONEˆWHEREDOESAN
BITOFANUNDERSTATEMENT)KNOWTHEREARESOMEPEOPLE
 POUNDGORILLASLEEP4HEPUNCHLINE!NYWHEREIT
WHOARENTHAPPYWITHTHEWAYTHINGSHAVETURNEDOUT
WANTS
BUT)SAYTHATOURSCHOOLSMAYNOTBEPERFECT BUTFORUS
(EREINTHISROOMTONIGHT WEHAVEMANY
HERETONIGHT THERESONEBIGDIFFERENCE7ECANNOW
POUNDGORILLAS)MEANTHATlGURATIVELY OFCOURSE
DOSOMETHINGABOUTIT
)DONTWANTTODISSUADEANYONEFROMEATINGYOUR
7HEN!NNAT%DUCATION0ROVIDERS)NDUSTRY!SSO
TIRAMISU WHICHISVERYGOODˆMYCOMPLIMENTSTOTHE
CIATION%0)! lRSTASKEDMETOPROVIDESOMEHISTORI
CHEF
CALCONTEXTFORTHISCONFERENCEBYREVIEWINGTHEHISTORY


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

OFOURINDUSTRYOVER #HALLENGE#ENTER
THEPASTYEARS ) !TTHATTIME 0HILADELPHIAWASREALLYTHEVAN
TOLDHER h9OUVEGOT GUARDOFTHEMOVEMENTTOPRIVATIZEEDUCATION%DISON
THEWRONGGUY )MNO 3CHOOLS ASYOUMAYRECALL HADWONAHUGECONTRACTTO
HISTORIANv3HESAID RUNTHECITYSSCHOOLSAND+APLAN AYEARLATER LANDEDA
h3AM JUSTTELLYOUR BIGCONTRACTTODEVELOPANDPROVIDEAUNIlEDCURRICU
OWNSTORYˆYOUVE UMTOTHEDISTRICT)TWASANEXCITINGTIMETOBEIN
LIVEDTHEHISTORYAND THEEDUCATIONBUSINESS!LLTHESEBIGPLAYERSMOVING
BEENAMAJORPARTOF NTOTHEMARKET ANDME WITHMYLITTLEAFTER SCHOOL
THETRANSFORMATION READINGCENTERNEXTTOTHETATTOOPARLORSON3OUTH
OFEDUCATIONFROM 3TREET
GOVERNMENTSCHOOLSTO !LSOIN YOUSAWALLTHESEONLINESCHOOLS
CORPORATIONSCHOOLSv REALLYSTARTTOTAKE
3OHEREITIS MY OFF GIVINGPUBLIC
ARGUABLYUNSCIENTIlC PERSONALRETROSPECTIVEOFTRANS SCHOOLSARUNFORTHEIR
FORMATIONOFTHEEDUCATIONMARKETFROMAGOVERNMENT MONEY7ELL SOME
MONOPOLYTOANINDUSTRYDOMINATEDBYLARGECORPORA OFTHEMWEREPUBLIC
TIONS MANYOFWHICHDIDNTEVENEXISTYEARSAGO SCHOOLSˆRURAL
!NDTHEONESTHATDIDWEREHARDLYGORILLASATBEST THEY SCHOOLSWAYOUTINTHE
WEREMAYBESQUIRRELMONKEYS MIDDLEOFNOWHERE
WHICHHADlGURED
#RACKSINTHEGOVERNMENT OUTHOWTOSHOREUP
MONOPOLY THEIRDWINDLINGENROLLMENTBYBRINGINGINKIDShVIR
-YCAREERINTHEEDUCATIONINDUSTRYAND THUS THIS TUALLYvFROMALLAROUNDTHECOUNTRY-YFRIEND 2ICK
HISTORY REALLYBEGINSINTHEYEAR THEYEARTHAT) 2OMANO WHOOWNEDASMALL STRUGGLINGEDUCATIONAL
SEIZEDONABUSINESSOPPORTUNITYANDOPENEDMYlRST SOFTWARECOMPANY AND)SAWABIGOPPORTUNITYTHERE
TUTORINGCENTERIN0HILADELPHIA-YREASONSFORDOING ANDWENTFORIT)N WESTARTEDINCORPORATINGHIS
SOWEREFARFROMNOBLE)SAWTHATTHE.O#HILD,EFT EDUCATIONALGAMESFORKIDSINTOOURREADINGPROGRAM
"EHIND!CTHADCREATEDAHUGEOPPORTUNITYFORPEOPLE ANDPUTTHEMONLINE7ESTARTEDGETTINGPARENTSFROM
WHOCOULDPROVIDEAFTER SCHOOLSUPPLEMENTALSERVICES  ALLAROUNDTHECOUNTRYINTERESTEDINTHE#HALLENGE
AND)HADREADSOMEWHERETHATONEOFTHEBESTFRAN 2EADINGPROGRAM!NDTHEKIDS WELLTHEYWEREALREADY
CHISESTOOPENWASA3YLVAN,EARNING#ENTER!TTHE INTERESTED BECAUSEASFARASTHEYKNEW THEYWEREJUST
TIME )DIDNTHAVE TODROPONTHEFRANCHISE PLAYINGCOMPUTERGAMES
FEE SO)DECIDEDTOOPENMYOWNBUSINESS THElRSTEVER


#."#REPORTEDIN$ECEMBERTHATINVESTMENTANALYSTSWEREGIVINGSTRONGMARKETSTOSUPPLEMENTALSERVICEPROVIDERS REPORTINGTHATTHE
hBILLIONMARKETFOR+ TUTORINGSHOULDCONTINUETOGROWATAPERCENTCLIPFORTHENEXTlVETOTENYEARSv3OURCE4HOMPSON -$ECEM
BER  h4UTORING'ETS'OOD-ARKSFROM)NVESTORS0RIVATE,EARNING#ENTERS3EE2APID3ALES'ROWTHv/NLINEATHTTPMSNBCMSNCOM
ID

3NYDER 3&EBRUARY  h0HILA3CHOOLSTO(IRE&IRMSTO2UN.EW(IGH3CHOOLS v0HILADELPHIA)NQUIRER

)N.OVEMBER THE$ENVER0OSTREPORTEDTHATTHENUMBEROFSTUDENTSSWITCHINGFROMTRADITIONALBRICK AND MORTARCLASSROOMSTOFULL TIME
VIRTUALSCHOOLSIN#OLORADOHADSOAREDFROMTO OVERTHEPASTlVEYEARS4HOSElGURES WHICHDIDNOTINCLUDESTUDENTSWHOARETAKING
ONEORTWOONLINECOURSESTOSUPPLEMENTTHEIRCLASSROOMEDUCATION WEREMAKINGOFlCIALSINTHESTATESSMALLESTDISTRICTSJITTERY3OURCE2OUSE +
.OVEMBER  h/NLINE%D0UTS3CHOOLSINA"IND v$ENVER0OST! 

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

.#,"AGAINSTTHEROCKS 'OVERNMENT

9OUREMEMBER.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND)NALOT
OFWAYS WASREALLYTHEBEGINNINGOFTHEENDOF

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
THE.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDLAW EVENTHOUGHITSORTOF
LIMPEDALONGFORSEVERALMOREYEARSAFTERTHAT)NFACT 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
ITWASREALLYONLYALLOWEDTOSUNSETACOUPLEYEARSAGO
&ORTHOSEOFYOUWHODONTRECALL .#,"WASINITIALLYA
h7HEREAN
HUGEBOONTOGUYSLIKEME)TCREATEDAMARKETFOROUR POUNDGORILLA
SLEEPSv
SERVICESTHATHADNEVEREXISTEDBEFORE"UTONEOFTHE
.ON 'OVERNMENT

SCHOOLCHOICESANDSUPPLEMENTALSERVICES ANDTHE
GRANDDADDYOFTHEMALL RECONSTITUTION)NFACT A
QUARTEROFTHENATIONSSCHOOLSNOWAPPEAREDTOBE
WELLONTHEPATHTOBEINGTAKENOVERBYTHEIRSTATES
ORSOMESIMILARCONSEQUENCE4HEPUBLIC NOTFULLY
WHICHWEREALREADYSTRAPPEDFORCASH BEGANTOPUSH UNDERSTANDINGWHYSCHOOLSHADSUDDENLYGOTTENSOBAD
BACKAGAINSTTHELAWINEARNEST SAYINGITWASUNDER GREWDOUBTFULTHATPUBLICSCHOOLSWOULDEVERBEABLE
FUNDEDANDUNWORKABLE7HERETHEREALRESISTANCE TOlXTHEMSELVES!TTHESAMETIME SUBURBANPARENTS
CAMEWASNTFROMLIBERALSTATES WHATWEWERECALLING WERENTEXACTLY
hBLUEvSTATESBACKTHEN BUTRATHERCONSERVATIVESTRONG THRILLEDTHAT
HOLDS hREDvSTATES LIKE5TAH URBANKIDSWERE
STARTINGTOENTER
THEIRSCHOOLSIN
4HETAKEOVERMAKEOVER
FAIRLYSIGNIlCANT
)N THE.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDLAWREQUIRED NUMBERS THANKS
STATESTORAISETHEBARONSCHOOLSANDMORETHAN TOTHECHOICE
PERCENTOFTHENATIONSSCHOOLSSUDDENLYFOUNDTHEM SANCTIONSINTHE
SELVESFACINGSANCTIONSLIKEPROVIDINGPARENTSOTHER LAW!SYOUMIGHT


)N/CTOBER 4RIMARAN#APITAL0ARTNERS ANINVESTMENTGROUPWHICHOWNS2EDDY)CEDISTRIBUTING 5RBAN"RANDSCLOTHINGCOMPANY
AND.ORCRAFT#OS WHICHMAKESKITCHENCABINETS PURCHASEDACHAINOF&LORIDAPRIVATESCHOOLSTHATCATERTOCHILDRENWITHSPECIALNEEDSANDARE
FUNDEDLARGELYTHROUGHSCHOOLVOUCHERS4RIMARAN-ANAGING$IRECTOR*AY"LOOMTOUTEDTHELACKOFSIGNIlCANTCOMPETITIONINTEACHINGDISABLED
STUDENTSASONEOFTHEREASONSFORHISCOMPANYSMILLIONPURCHASEOF.ASHVILLE BASED%DUCATIONAL3ERVICESOF!MERICA3OURCE-ILLER +
&EBRUARY  )NVESTMENTlRMSEESPROlTINDISABLEDSTUDENTS0ALM"EACH0OSTHTTPWWWPALMBEACHPOSTCOMNEWSCONTENTNEWSEPAPER
MA?6/5#(%2?HTML

/N&EBRUARY  ASPECIALTASKFORCECREATEDBYTHE.ATIONAL#ONFERENCEOF3TATE,EGISLATURESRELEASEDABIPARTISANREPORTTHATRECOM
MENDEDFUNDAMENTALCHANGESTO0RESIDENT"USHS.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDEDUCATIONREFORMLAWTOINCREASEITSEFFECTIVENESS4HE.#3,REPORT
INCLUDEDSPECIlCRECOMMENDATIONSTOREVISETHEACT WHICHITCRITICIZEDASAhONESIZElTSALLvSYSTEMTHATSTImESINNOVATIONATTHESTATELEVEL
3OURCE-OTLAGH *&EBRUARY  3TATESWANTCHANGESTO.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND5NITED0RESS)NTERNATIONAL

2EPUBLICANLEGISLATORSˆANDPROFESSEDSUPPORTERSOF0RESIDENT"USHˆLEDAWELL PUBLICIZEDPUSHFOR5TAHTOOPTOUTOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT
"EHIND!CT/N&EBRUARY  %DUCATION7EEKREPORTEDTHATMANYREDSTATE2EPUBLICANSAREOPPOSEDTOWHATTHEYSEEASTHELAWShRAFTOF
PRESCRIPTIONSASENCROACHINGONSTATEANDLOCALTURFANDIMPOSINGUNWARRANTEDCOSTSv$AVIS - &EBRUARY  h5TAH)S5NLIKELY&LYIN
"USHS3CHOOL/INTMENT v%DUCATION7EEK PP 


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

EXPECT WASAGROWTHYEARFORPRIVATE PARO FOCUSGROUPSANDLEARNEDTHATPUTTING#OLUMBIAAND


CHIAL ANDCHURCHSCHOOLENROLLMENT)KNOWITWAS #HALLENGEINTHESAMEPHRASEMADETOOMANYPEOPLE
AHUGEYEARFORTHE#HALLENGE3CHOOLS7EJUMPED THINKABOUTTHETRAGICACCIDENTSTHATOCCURREDTO
INTOTHECHARTER .!3!SPACESHUTTLESWITHTHESAMENAMES
MARKETWITHBOTH
FEET OPENING
CHARTERSCHOOLS
N0ENNSYLVANIA
-ARYLANDAND
$ELAWARE)TWAS
ACTUALLYAFAIRLY
EASYSELLFORUS
SINCEPARENTS
ANDKIDSWEREALREADYFAMILIARWITHOURPRODUCTS7E
HADALSOBEENSCRAMBLINGLIKEMADTOGETTHEDATAWE
NEEDEDTOPROVEITALLWORKEDANDWERElNALLYABLETO
PUTUPSOMEPRETTYCONVINCINGNUMBERS
&ORSERVICEPROVIDERSLIKE#HALLENGE3CHOOLS THE
MID DECADEWASATHRILLINGTIME7ECOULD %DUCATIONONTHECHOPPING
ALLFEELTHATTHEGOVERNMENTSCHOOLSYSTEMnnTHIS BLOCK
MONOLITHICSYSTEMTHATHADBEENBUILTOVERTHE .EARTHELATTERHALFOFTHELASTDECADE SEVERAL
CENTURYnnWASABOUTTOCOLLAPSEUNDERITSOWNWEIGHT TRENDSCONVERGEDTOLEADTOSOMEPRETTYDRASTICCUTS
"UTNOONEWASSUREWHATWOULDREMAINORRISEOUTOF INPUBLICFUNDINGOFEDUCATION.OTONLYWAS.#,"
THEASHES"UTALREADY YOUCOULDSEEAFEWCOMPANIES INCREASINGLYCOMINGUNDERlREFROMBOTHTHELEFTAND
LIKE#HALLENGE3CHOOLS GAININGSOMEPRETTYGOOD THERIGHT ANDMOREANDMORESCHOOLSWEREFAILING BUT
MARKETSHARE ESTABLISHINGAREALNAMEFORTHEMSELVES WEALSOSAWTHAT INGENERAL EDUCATIONCONTINUEDTO
MOSTLYTHROUGHMULTIPLECHARTERS"ECAUSEOF.#," SLIDEDOWNTHELISTOFPOLITICALPRIORITIES4HISWASNO
YOUHADARASHOFNEWCHARTEROPPORTUNITIES"UT SURPRISECONSIDERINGTHAT!MERICASLARGESTGENERA
YOUALSOHADSTATESTHATWEREINCREASINGLYUNWILLING TION THEBABYBOOMERS NOWHADMOSTOFTHEIRKIDS
TOGIVECHARTERSTOUNPROVENPROGRAMSORPROVIDERS OUTOFSCHOOL4HATMEANTTHEIRPRIORITIESWERESHIFTING
3OTHEVASTMAJORITYWENTTOAHANDFULOFTHEUSUAL ASWELLnnTOWARDCONCERNSABOUTHEALTHCARE 3OCIAL
SUSPECTSnn+)00 %DISON +APLAN #HALLENGE 3YLVAN 3ECURITYANDlGHTINGTERRORISM
ANDSOMEUNIVERSITIES5NIVERSITIES INFACT HADABIG "ASICALLY POLITICIANSSTARTEDTOREALIZETHAT.#,"
ADVANTAGECOMINGOUTOFTHEGATE)MEAN WHATPARENT WASALAWTHATTHEYCOULDNTSUPPORTPOLITICALLY NOR
WOULDNTWANTTOSENDTHEIRCHILDTOTHE(ARVARDOR AFFORDlNANCIALLY4HATWASTHEKISSOFDEATHFOR.#,"
3TANFORDCHARTERSCHOOL3OMEUNIVERSITIESFOUNDTHEY "Y BOTHPARTIESPRESIDENTIALCANDIDATESGAVE
COULDPOCKETSOMEQUICKCASHBYSIMPLYSELLINGRIGHTS .#,"ACOOLRECEPTION4HATYEAR #ONGRESSMADE
TOTHEIRNAME#HALLENGE3CHOOLSALMOSTINKEDADEAL MAJORALTERATIONSTOTHELAW WHICHBY 
WITH#OLUMBIA5NIVERSITYUNTILWETOOKITTOSOME WOULDLEAVEITBASICALLYWITHOUTTEETHnnANDNEARLY
WITHOUTFUNDS


0UBLICOPINIONPOLLSSUGGESTTHISTRENDMAYALREADYBEUNDERWAY!SOF&EBRUARY THEVASTMAJORITYOFTHEPUBLICACCORDINGTOTHE
'ALLUPORGANIZATION CONTINUEDTOAGREETHATEDUCATIONISANEXTREMELYVERYIMPORTANTISSUEFOR#ONGRESSANDTHE0RESIDENTTOADDRESS(OWEVER
WHENASKEDTONAMEWHICHISSUEISMOSTIMPORTANTTOTHEM FARFEWERPEOPLEACCORDINGTOA&EB(ARRISAND*AN!0POLL AND
ACCORDINGTOA&EB.EW9ORK4IMES#"3.EWS0OLL LISTEDUCATIONASTHEIRHIGHESTPRIORITYCONCERN3OCIAL3ECURITY TERRORISMINTERNATIONAL
AFFAIRS ANDTHEECONOMYARECITEDFARMOREOFTEN

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

'OVERNMENT

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
h7HEREAN
-ERGERMANIABEGINS POUNDGORILLA
SLEEPSv
.EARTHEENDOFTHEDECADE THETOPlVEEDUCA
TIONFRANCHISORSALLEXPERIENCEDPHENOMENALGROWTH .ON 'OVERNMENT

SIGNINGUPMOREANDMOREFRANCHISEESASPUBLICSCHOOLS
WERECONVERTEDTOCHARTERS"UTWEALSOSTARTEDTOFEEL THEIRINDEPENDENCE SORTOFBECOMINGTHE*$0OWERS
THESTRAINOFMAINTAININGTHElDELITYTOOURMODELS OFEDUCATION OFFERINGRESPECTED OBJECTIVEEVALUATIONS
)NALOTOFCASES WEDHIRETEACHERSWHODSITINAJOB OFEDUCATIONPROGRAMS WHICHASWEALLKNOW SAVVY
INTERVIEWANDSAY h9EAH YEAH WELLDOITYOURWAYv PARENTSARETUNEDINTOANDDEMANDTOSEEFROMSCHOOL
!NDTHENTHEYDGOTOTHEIRCLASSROOMSANDTEACHJUST PROGRAMS
LIKETHEYDALWAYSDONE WHICH YOUKNOW )HATETOSAY "ASICALLY WHATSTARTEDHAPPENINGWASTHATTHERED
IT USUALLYWASNTSOHOT TAPEOFTHEOLDBUREAUCRATIChACCOUNTABILITYvSYSTEM
)N #HALLENGE3CHOOLS FORONE BEGANBUYING SLOWLYBEGANTOBEREPLACEDBYANEWFORMOFACCOUNT
OUT RAIDINGSTAFFFROM ANDMERGINGWITHOTHERORGA ABILITYˆMARKETFORCES3OMEPEOPLEWEREPREPARED
NIZATIONSANDPROVIDERS/VERTHENEXTFEWYEARS YOU FORTHISNEWREALITYANDOTHERSWERENT/BVIOUSLY
SAWTHISLONGLISTOFABOUTEDUCATIONKNOWLEDGE TESTINGDIDNTGOAWAY BUTTHANKSTOTECHNOLOGY ITDID
COMPANIESnnCHARTERSCHOOLPROVIDERS SCHOOLREFORM GETALOTSMARTERANDMORECOST EFlCIENT)TSHARDTO
MODELDEVELOPERS PUBLISHERS FEDERALREGIONALLABSAND BELIEVETHATJUSTAFEWYEARSAGO REALLY KIDSWERESTILL
COMPREHENSIVECENTERS TESTCOMPANIESˆTHEYALLGOT TAKINGPAPER AND PENCILTESTS
WHITTLEDDOWNTOALISTOFABOUTAHALFDOZENBIGPLAYERS )NCREASINGLY STATEASSESSMENTSWEREMERGEDINTO
)NTHOSEYEARS ITFELTLIKEEVERYBODYWASFRANTICALLY SINGLE LARGEREGION
LOOKINGFORADATETOTHEPROM ALASSESSMENTSAS
#OMPANIESBEGANLOOKINGFORSYNERGIESANDMERGING STATESCREATEDMULTI
INTOAHANDFULOFBIGPLAYERSONTHEIRWAYTOBECOMING STATETESTINGCOM
THECONTROLLERSOFMOSTOFTHEEDUCATIONMARKETTODAY PACTS!TTHESAME
!FEWPUBLISHERSANDPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTPROVID TIME THE#OLLEGE
ERSTRIEDTOSTICKITOUTONTHEIROWN HOPINGTOPROVIDE "OARDSNEWGENERA
SERVICESTOALLTHESENEWCOMPANIES"UTIFTHEYWERE TIONOFCONTENT ORI
GOODENOUGH THEYOFFEREDTOOMUCHCOMPETITIVE ENTEDTESTSBECAME
ADVANTAGEFORTHEBIGBOYSTOJUSTLETTHEMSITTHERE THESTANDARDFOR
ANDHELPOUTTHEOTHERGUY AND ASARESULT ALMOSTALL MOSTCOLLEGESAND
OFTHEMEVENTUALLYGOTSNAPPEDUPBYSOMEBODY! UNIVERSITIES THUSCREATINGADEFACTONATIONALNOT
FEWRESEARCHlRMS LIKE2!.$ANDSOMEUNIVERSITY FEDERALnnABIGDISTINCTION OFCOURSE TEST3OTHEN
ANDREGIONALLABSPIN OFFSHAVE OFCOURSE MAINTAINED SCHOOLSALLHADACOMMONMEASUREANDPARENTSHADA


)N THESTATESOF2HODE)SLAND .EW(AMPSHIRE AND6ERMONTANNOUNCEDPLANSTOPOOLRESOURCESTOCREATETHE.EW%NGLAND#OMMON
!SSESSMENT0ROGRAM3TUDENTSINALLTHREESTATESWILLTAKETHESAMETEST WHICHSHOULDREDUCETHECOSTOFTESTINGFROMABOUTPERSTUDENTTO
PERSTUDENT4HELOWEREDCOSTALLOWSFORAHIGHERQUALITYOFTESTWITHMOREOPEN ENDEDQUESTIONS MOREOPEN RESPONSEOPTIONSFORTESTTAKERS
ANDFEWERMATCHINGANDMULTIPLE CHOICEQUESTIONS3OURCE'OLDSTEIN -/CTOBER  h.(2EVAMPING3TANDARDIZED4EST v"OSTON
'LOBE


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

WAYTOCOMPARETHEM"Y THEONLYPIECEMISSING AMONTHAFTERTHE3EPTEMBERNEWSTHATSCHOOLS


INACHIEVING-ILTON&RIEDMANSDREAMOFCREATINGA HADTWICEFAILEDTOMEASUREUP)MSUREYOUKNOWWHAT
MARKET ORIENTEDEDUCATIONSYSTEMWASTHEDEMANDSIDE )MTALKINGABOUTˆTHEhPERFECTSTORMvMELTDOWNOF
OFTHEEQUATIONTHATIS GIVINGCONSUMERS INTHISCASE /CTOBER WHENRISINGOILPRICES FEDERALDEBTS 
PARENTS CONTROLOVEREDUCATIONDOLLARS"UTTHATWAS ANDTHEFALLINGDOLLARCAME
JUSTOVERTHEHORIZON TOGETHERTOCAUSETHECOLLAPSE
OFTHESTOCKMARKET MASSIVE
4HElNALNAILINTHECOFlN LAYOFFS ANDBANKRUPTCIES
!FTERTHATPOINT NOTONLY
4HEDEATHKNELLFOR.#,"ANDPUBLICSCHOOLSASWE
WASTHERENOMOREPUBLIC
HADONCEKNOWNTHEMRANGIN WHENHUNDREDSOF
SUPPORTFORPUBLICSCHOOLS
SCHOOLSTHATHADBEENRECONSTITUTEDFOURYEARSEARLIER
THEREWASASHRINKINGPOOLOF
NOWFACEDRECONSTITUTIONAGAINBECAUSETHEYHADFAILED
PUBLICFUNDS4OSOMEEXTENT
ONCEAGAIN TOMAKEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESS-ORE
PUBLICSCHOOLSFELLVICTIMTO
IMPORTANT THIShDOUBLEvFAILUREOFSCHOOLSPROMPTED
BUTALSOMAYHAVECONTRIB
INCREASINGNUMBERSOFLAWMAKERSTOTHROWINTHE
UTEDTO THEPUBLICSLARGER
TOWELWITHPUBLICEDUCATIONINGENERALAND.#," IN
LOSSOFFAITHINGOVERNMENT
PARTICULAR3OMEhOLDSCHOOLvEDUCATORSHOPEDNAIVELY
INGENERAL9OUKNOW SOMEPEOPLEHAVESCRATCHED
THATWITH
THEIRHEADSATWHYOURCOUNTRYHASNTRESPONDEDTHE
.#,"GONE
WAYITDIDAFTERTHESTOCKMARKETCRASHOFWHEN
THEFEDERAL
WEIMPLEMENTEDASYSTEMOFGOVERNMENTCONTROLSAND
GOVERNMENT
SAFETYNETS"UTHERESTHEBIGDIFFERENCEBACKTHEN
WOULDlNALLY
PEOPLEFELTTHATUNCHECKEDCAPITALISMANDANUNREGU
GETOFFTHEIR
LATEDSTOCKMARKETHADCAUSEDTHEDEPRESSION)NSHORT
BACKSAND
BUSINESSWASTOBLAME SOWETURNEDTOGOVERNMENTFOR
THINGSWOULD
SUPPORTANDPROTECTIONˆASYSTEM OFWHICHPUBLIC
RETURNTO
SCHOOLSWEREAPARTˆTHATLASTEDFORSEVENDECADES
NORMALFOR
4HISTIMEAROUND THOUGH ITSDIFFERENT)TSTHE
THEMˆTHE
OPPOSITE REALLY-OSTPEOPLEBLAMENOTBUSINESS BUT
OLDhTHISTOOSHALLPASSvNOTIONTHEYHADCLUNGTOSINCE
GOVERNMENT FORTHISMELTDOWN&IVEDECADESOFDElCIT
THEPASSAGEOFTHELAW
SPENDING POLITICIANSLACKINGTHESPINETOTOUCHTHE
"UTREALLY ASMUCHASSOMEEDUCATORSRESENTEDIT
hTHIRDRAILvOF3OCIAL3ECURITY ANDTHENUNABLETOAGREE
ANDASSUMEDITWASACONSPIRACYTORUINPUBLICSCHOOLS
WHETHERPRIVATIZATIONORPRESERVATIONWASTHERIGHT
ITSEEMSNOWINHINDSIGHTTHAT.#,"HADBEENPUBLIC
APPROACHTOSOLVINGTHEPROBLEM LEDTOTHEDRASTIC
SCHOOLSLASTHOPEˆALASTDITCHEFFORTTODEMONSTRATE
DEVALUATIONOFTHEDOLLARANDSUBSEQUENTMARKETCRASH
THATAGOVERNMENT CONTROLLEDSYSTEMOFEDUCATION
)HEARDA.EW9ORKSTOCKBROKERWHOLOSTHISJOBAFTER
COULDPROVIDEHIGH QUALITYLEARNINGFORALLKIDS
THE/CTOBERMELTDOWN SUMUPTHESENTIMENTOFTHE
4HEDEMISEOFPUBLICSCHOOLS THOUGH CAMEJUST


/N&EBRUARY  REPORTSTHATTHECENTRALBANKOF3OUTH+OREAWASSHIFTINGRESERVESFROM53DOLLARSINTOSOUNDERCURRENCIESCAUSED
THEDOLLARANDSTOCKMARKETTOPLUNGEˆUNTILTHEREPORTSWEREEVENTUALLYDENIED.ONETHELESS $AVID-7ALKER THEACCOUNTANTINCHARGEOF
THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTSBOOKSHASWARNEDTHATIFFEDERALDElCITSCONTINUEUNCHECKED hITSINEVITABLEvTHATTHE!SIANBANKSWHOARECURRENTLY
lNANCING53FEDERALDElCITSWILLLOSECONlDENCEINTHE53DOLLARANDDEMANDHIGHERINTERESTRATESFROMTHE53GOVERNMENTh4HECRUNCHIS
COMING v7ALKERWARNSh7EAREATRISK7EAREATSERIOUSRISKv3OURCE&ARRELL *!&EBRUARY  h53$ElCIT"UILDS(OUSEOF#ARDS v
$ENVER0OST

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

COUNTRY WHENHESAID h)FYOUWANTSOMETHINGDONE 'OVERNMENT


RIGHT DOITYOURSELF)FYOUWANTSOMETHINGROYALLY
SCREWEDUP GETTHEGOVERNMENTINVOLVEDv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
$OLLARSINPARENTSHANDS 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
"Y SEVERALSTATESHADFOLLOWED&LORIDASLEAD
OFCREATINGSTATEWIDEVOUCHERPROGRAMS&ORALOTOF h7HEREAN
STATELAWMAKERS VOUCHERSSEEMEDLIKETHEONLYLOGICAL POUNDGORILLA
SLEEPSv
RESPONSETOEVIDENCETHATNEITHERPUBLICSCHOOLSNOR
CHARTERSCHOOLSWEREMAKINGTHEGRADE!FTERTHE .ON 'OVERNMENT
CRASH ALOTOFLAWMAKERSBECAMEINCREASINGLYCON
VINCEDTHATPRIVATEPROVIDERSCOULDPROVIDEEDUCA
TIONFARMOREEFlCIENTLYTHANPUBLICSCHOOLSBECAUSE MONTHTOSENDTHEIRKIDSTOTOP QUALITYSCHOOLS3OALL
THEYCOULDBETTERlGUREOUTHOWTOUTILIZEECONOMIES INALL THEVOUCHERSANDTAXCREDITSWEREAHUGEBOON
OFSCALEANDGETRIDOFTHEhADMINISTRATIVEBLOBvTHAT TOCHARTERFRANCHISORSˆNOTTOMENTIONCHURCHAND
FORMERSECRETARYOFEDUCATION 7ILLIAM"ENNETT AND PAROCHIALSCHOOLS WHICHHAVEBECOMETHELOW COST
OTHERS HADCLAIMEDBOGGEDDOWNPUBLICSCHOOLS EDUCATIONALTERNATIVEFORLOWER INCOMEPARENTS YOU
!TTHESAMETIME THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTEXTENDED KNOW BECAUSEMOSTHAVEFREERENTANDASTEADYSUPPLY
CHILDCARETAXCREDITSTO+nTUITIONEXPENSES PUTTING OFVOLUNTEERSANDOFFERINGPLATECOLLECTIONS!TANY
UPTO PERCHILDINTHEHANDSOFPARENTS)NSOME RATE BY WHATHADBEENUNTHINKABLEJUSTADECADE
STATES PARENTSNOWHADMORETHAN INTHEIR BEFOREˆASYSTEMOFEDUCATIONPROVIDEDMOSTLYBY
HANDS THROUGHSTATEVOUCHERSANDFEDERALTAXCREDITS NON GOVERNMENTALINSTITUTIONSˆWASNOWBECOMING
THATTHEYCOULDSPENDANYWHERE FROMPRIVATETOPARO COMMONPLACE
CHIALTOHOME !T#HALLENGE3CHOOLS WEWEREBUSYBEYONDBELIEF
SCHOOLS3URE SIGNINGUPNEWFRANCHISEESLEFTANDRIGHT7EHADBEEN
ITWASNTQUITE FRANKLY ALITTLEWORRIEDTHATAFTER.#,"WENTAWAY
ENOUGHˆMOST SOTOOWOULDOURBUSINESS SINCETHEREWOULDNTBEAS
FRANCHISORS MANYCHARTERCONVERSIONS"UTWITHPARENTSNOWmUSH
OPERATINGCOSTS WITHVOUCHERDOLLARS THEMARKETWASWIDEOPEN
WERECLOSER 3OMEPEOPLENEVERSAWITCOMINGˆTHEYASSUMED
TO PER THATTHE!MERICANPUBLICWOULDNEVERGOFORVOUCH
STUDENT7ITH ERSLIKETHEYDID"UTIFYOUHADREADTHEOPINIONPOLLS
SOMEHELPFROM CLOSELYENOUGH YOUWOULDVESEENTHATVOUCHERSWERE
FUNDRAISERSAND JUSTWAITINGTOHAPPEN7HILEPOLLSSHOWEDMIXED
hSWEATEQUITYvˆOURPAINTINGANDLANDSCAPING3AT RESULTSINTERMSOFPUBLICSUPPORTFORVOUCHERPROGRAMS
URDAYS THATSORTOFTHINGˆWECANUSUALLYBRINGTHE MOSTPARENTS WHENPOLLED SAIDIFTHEYHADAVOUCHER
DIFFERENCEDOWNTOLESSTHAN  ANDWElNDTHAT THEYDENROLLTHEIRCHILDRENINAPRIVATESCHOOL)N
ALOTOFPARENTSAREWILLINGTOPAYANEXTRAORSOA OTHERWORDS WHILETHEPUBLICINGENERALHADNTYET


4ODATE RESEARCHONCHARTERSCHOOLSHASYIELDEDMIXEDRESULTS3OMESTUDIESHAVEPRODUCEDPOSITIVElNDINGSA2AND#ORPSTUDYFOUND
#ALIFORNIACHARTERSPERFORMASWELLASORBETTERTHANTRADITIONALSCHOOLS ANDA(ARVARD5NIVERSITYSTUDYFOUNDCHARTERSCHOOLSTUDENTSWERE
MOREPROlCIENTINREADINGANDMATHEMATICSTHANSTUDENTSATNEARBYTRADITIONALSCHOOLS"UTOTHERSTUDIESHAVEREPORTEDNEGLIGIBLEORNEGATIVE
OUTCOMESA-ARCH%CONOMIC0OLICY3TUDYFOUNDTHATTHEhAVERAGEIMPACTvOFCHARTERSCHOOLShISNEGATIVEvANDA!MERICAN&EDERA
TIONOF4EACHERSSTUDYFOUNDFOURTH GRADECHARTERSCHOOLSTUDENTSWEREPERFORMINGABOUTAHALF YEARBEHINDSTUDENTSINTRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLS


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

MADEUPITSMINDABOUTWHATWASBESTFORTHESYSTEM LOOKINGTOGOVERNMENTTOSOLVEOURPROBLEMS WELOOK


ASAWHOLE PARENTSHADALREADYMADEUPTHEIRMINDS TOBUSINESSES4HROUGHTHEIRPLACESOFWORK PARENTS
ABOUTWHATWASBESTFORTHEIROWNKIDS INPARTICULAR HAVEBANDEDTOGETHERTOCREATEON SITESCHOOLS FROM
)TWASALSOABOUTTHISTIMETHATTHEFEDERALWELL PRE +TO-OSTBUSINESSES OFCOURSE HAVENOBUSI
lNALLYRANDRYFORALOTOFORGANIZATIONSTHATHADONCE NESSBEINGINEDUCATION3OTHEYTURNEDTOTHEESTAB
RELIEDONGOVERNMENTFUNDINGTOPROVIDESERVICESTO LISHEDPROVIDERSOFSCHOOLINGTOCREATETHEIRCORPO
STATES DISTRICTS ANDSCHOOLSLEADINGTOAMAJORSHAKE RATE SPONSOREDSCHOOLS)KNOWALOTOFPEOPLEINTHIS
OUTOFRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTORGANIZATIONSAND ROOMHAVEBENElTEDFROMSUCHRELATIONSHIPS,ASTYEAR
SERVICEPROVIDERS4HEFEWTHATSURVIVEDˆTHOSETHAT #HALLENGE3CHOOLSSIGNEDBIGCONTRACTSWITH-ICROSOFT
LEARNEDHOWTOMARKETTHEIRSERVICESANDCOMPETEEF 3ATURN AND4YSON&OODSTOPROVIDESCHOOLSFORTHEIR
FECTIVELYˆEMERGEDBIGGERANDSTRONGER4HERESTHAVE EMPLOYEESˆTALKABOUTANINTERESTINGMIX
BEENACQUIREDORJUSTPLAINSHUTTERED 9OUMAYHAVEHEARDTHATDURINGTHELASTGREAT
DEPRESSION MOREMILLIONAIRESWERECREATEDTHANATANY
OTHERTIMEINOURHISTORY)SUSPECTTHESAMETHINGMAY
HAPPENDURINGTHISDOWNTURN WHICHHOPEFULLYWONT
TURNINTOAFULL BLOWNDEPRESSION

#ONSOLIDATIONVERTICALINTE
GRATION

"USINESSSTEPSINTOlLLTHE 7HEN)lRSTGOTINTOTHECHARTERSCHOOLBUSI
VOID NESS )NAIVELYlGUREDTHATAT PERKIDWECOULD
AFFORDTOPROVIDEANOUTSTANDINGEDUCATIONANDOFFER
)REMEMBERAFTERTHEhPERFECTSTORMvTHINKING
GREATDIVIDENDSTOOURSHAREHOLDERS7EDBUYUPAN
@4HANKGOODNESSFOROURNEWSYSTEMOFENTREPRENEURIAL
OLDBUILDING MAYBEGETSOMETAXCREDITS4HENWED
SCHOOLLEADERS)TSTHEPEOPLEINTHISROOMTONIGHT
PAYTEACHERSWELLˆ OR AYEARˆAT
WHOWEREABLETOQUICKLYADAPTTOTHECHANGINGREALITY
 PERKIDITWOULDONLYTAKEKIDSTOCOVERTHEIR
)KNOWAT#HALLENGE3CHOOLS THEECONOMICDOWNTURN
SALARIES ANDTHEREMAININGCOULDCOVERTHEOTHER
FORCEDUSTOCOMEUPWITHINVENTIVEWAYSOFLOWERING
STUFF WHICH)WRONGLYASSUMEDCOULDNTCOSTTHATMUCH
TUITIONCOSTS!S)ALLUDEDTOEARLIER WE FOREXAMPLE
4HATWASBEFORE)FULLYACCOUNTEDFORALLTHEOTHER
BORROWEDTHEhSWEATEQUITYvNOTIONFROM(ABITATFOR
NECESSARYEXPENDITURESˆBOOKS SOFTWARE COMPUT
(UMANITY THROUGHWHICHPARENTS MANYOFWHOMWERE
ERS SCHOOLFURNITURE PROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT DATA
NOWUNEMPLOYED DONATEDSERVICESATOURSCHOOLSIN
MANAGEMENT ASSESSMENTS YOUNAMEIT)NITIALLY )HAD
EXCHANGEFORREDUCEDTUITION)NSOMEWAYS WEVEREC
NOIDEAHOWMUCHTHOSETHINGSCOSTBUTSOONLEARNED
REATEDTHATOLD OLDNOTIONOFPUBLICSCHOOLSˆWHEN
ANDSOONSAWALLMYPROlTSANDDIVIDENDSGOINGRIGHT
SETTLERSCAMETOGETHERWITHTHEIRLUMBERANDNAILSTO
OUTTHEDOOR
BUILDASCHOOLANDOFFERBOARDINGTOTHETEACHER
3O)ADOPTEDANAGGRESSIVElVE YEARVERTICALINTE
4ODAY OFCOURSE THEBIGGESTDIFFERENCEISTHAT
GRATIONPLAN)NSTEADOFPAYINGOTHERCOMPANIESFOR
INSTEADOFPEOPLECOMINGTOGETHERANDCREATINGGOVERN
ALLTHATSUPPORTSTUFF #HALLENGE3CHOOLSWOULDOWN
MENTALENTITIES WECREATECORPORATIONS!NDINSTEADOF


4HE0HI$ELTA+APPAN'ALLUPPOLLOFPARENTSATTITUDESABOUTSCHOOLSFOUND FOREXAMPLE THATWHILEPERCENTOFRESPONDENTSOPPOSED
VOUCHERS PERCENTOFRESPONDENTSSAIDTHEYWOULDUSEAVOUCHERTOSENDTHEIRCHILDTOAPRIVATESCHOOL)N OFRESPONDENTSOPPOSED
VOUCHERSANDSAIDTHEYWOULDSENDTHEIRCHILDRENTOAPRIVATESCHOOLIFTHEYHADAVOUCHER3OURCE2OSE ,# 'ALLUP ! h4HE
TH!NNUAL0HI$ELTA+APPA'ALLUP0OLLOFTHE0UBLICS!TTITUDES4OWARDTHE0UBLIC3CHOOLS v0HI$ELTA+APPAN  

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

'OVERNMENT

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
h7HEREAN
POUNDGORILLA
SLEEPSv

.ON 'OVERNMENT
THEM/URSTRATEGYISNOWMOSTLYCOMPLETE4EXTBOOK
PUBLISHER'OTIT3OFTWAREDEVELOPER!LREADYHADIT
0ROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT'OTIT$ATAMANAGEMENT
'OTOUROWNSOFTWARE#HALLENGE3CHOOLSCANNOW HOURSAFTERSCHOOLGRADINGTESTSANDQUIZZES%VEN
ALMOSTOUTlTANENTIRESCHOOL WELL EXCEPTFORCLASS BETTER THEhSMARTTESTSvIMMEDIATELYIDENTIFYPATTERNS
ROOMFURNITURE BUTWEMAYSOONCHANGETHAT INSTUDENTERRORSANDRECOMMENDINSTRUCTIONALCHANGES
(ERESTHEOTHERTHINGTHATHASREALLYCHANGEDTHAT
EQUATIONˆTECHNOLOGY)VEHEARDITSAIDTHATINTHE 3HAKEOUT
S !MERICANBUSINESSESSPENTBILLIONSOFDOLLARSON
9OUMAYHAVERECENTLYREADIN%DUCATION7EEKTHAT
COMPUTERTECHNOLOGY BUTITWASNTUNTILTHESTHAT
THENATIONSTOPlVEEDUCATIONPROVIDERSNOWEDUCATE
THEYlNALLYlGUREDOUTHOWTOUSETECHNOLOGYTOCREATE
MORETHANPERCENTOFTHENATIONSSTUDENTS4HINK
PRODUCTIVITYGAINS3CHOOLS WHICHWEREABOUTn
ABOUTTHATFORAMINUTE4HERESAHANDFULOFUSINTHIS
YEARSBEHINDBUSINESSESINADOPTINGTECHNOLOGY HAVE
ROOMTONIGHTWHOARERESPONSIBLEFORHALFTHEKIDSIN
REALLYONLYRECENTLYlGUREDOUTHOWTOUSECOMPUTERS
!MERICA)WOULDVENTUREAGUESSTHAT COLLECTIVELY ALL
ANDOTHERCOMMUNICATIONTECHNOLOGIESTOIMPROVE
OFUSINTHISROOMTONIGHTARERESPONSIBLEFOREDUCATING
STUDENTLEARNINGANDREDUCECOSTS
ASMANYASTOPERCENTOFTHENATIONSSTUDENTS
9OUKNOW ORIGINALLY SCHOOLSWOULDJUSTBUYCOM
"UTTHATMEANSWEHAVEAHUGERESPONSIBILITY WHICHIS
PUTERSANDSTICKTHEMINTHEBACKOFTHECLASSROOM"UT
WHY)OPENEDMYREMARKSTONIGHTWITHTHEJOKEABOUT
OVERTIME THEYlGUREDOUTHOWCOMPUTERSCOULDAID
THE POUNDGORILLA
WITHASSESSMENT DATATRACKING REPORTINGTOPARENTS
!LLKINDSOFSTUFFTHATDISTRICTSANDSCHOOLSUSEDTOHAVE
TOHIREPEOPLETODO OURTEACHERSCANNOWTAKECARE 4HENEEDFORCORPORATERE
OFWITHTHECLICKOFABUTTON7EHAVESWIPECARDSSO SPONSIBILITY
OURTEACHERSNEVERHAVETOTAKEATTENDANCE7EHAVE )KNOW)PROBABLYSHOULDNTDOTHIS BUT)MGOING
COMPUTERIZEDASSESSMENTSSOTHEYDONTHAVETOSPEND TOANYWAY)MGOINGTOCALLOUTTHEELEPHANTINTHE
ROOMPOORRURALANDURBANKIDS4HEYRETHEBIGGEST
BLEMISHONTHEOTHERWISEAMAZINGTRANSFORMATIONOF
THEEDUCATIONINDUSTRYWEVEHELPEDCREATE4HECRITICS
OFTHISTRANSFORMATIONACCUSEUSOFCREATINGTWOEDUCA
TIONSYSTEMSINTHISCOUNTRYˆONEFORTHEHAVES AND
ONEFORTHEHAVE NOTS
4OTHOSEFOLKS)WOULDPOINTOUTTHATWEVEALWAYS
HADTWOEDUCATIONSYSTEMSINTHISCOUNTRYTHATS
NOTHINGNEW"UTHERESWHATSNEW7ECANDOSOME
THINGABOUTIT7EARETHE POUNDGORILLAS)FWE
REALLYWANTSOMETHINGTOGETDONE WECANGETITDONE


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

.OW )KNOWTHERESNOPROlTINSERVINGBLIGHTEDURBAN WILLBEANESSENTIALMEANSOFDELIVERINGTHISTRAINING


COMMUNITIESORPOOR ISOLATEDRURALCOMMUNITIES) 2ESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTINTHISWORLDISFUNDED
KNOWTHATTHEIRVOUCHERSDONTCOMECLOSETOCOVER BYTHEPRIVATESECTOR4HEREISSTRONGSUPPORTFOR
INGTHEIRCOSTS ESPECIALLYIFTHEYHAVESPECIALNEEDSOR TESTINGSOLUTIONSANDDEVELOPINGEVIDENCEOFIMPACTS
NEEDEXTRAHELPLEARNING%NGLISHORNEEDTHEIRSCHOOL ANDOUTCOMESTOSUPPORTTHEAPPROACHESUSEDBYTHE
TOPROVIDETHEMWITHFREEBREAKFASTANDLUNCH  POUNDGORILLAORGANIZATIONS
"UTTHOSEKIDSARENOLESSSPECIALTHANTHEKIDSIN
THEEXURBS,OOK )THINKALOTOFUSGOTINTOTHISBUSI
)NDICATORS
NESSBECAUSEWEBELIEVEDITWASIMPORTANT3OTONIGHT
)MANNOUNCINGTHAT#HALLENGE3CHOOLS )NCISCREAT 4HEFOLLOWINGTRENDSANDEVENTSAREPOSSIBLE
INGANEW NONPROlTFOUNDATIONCALLED%XPANDINGTHE INDICATORSTHATTHEFUTUREMAYBEMOVINGTOWARDTHIS
#HALLENGE THROUGHWHICHWELLCOLLECTDONATIONSAND SCENARIO
STARTOPENINGSCHOOLSINIMPOVERISHEDAREAS)DASK
s 2APIDEXPANSIONOFAHANDFULOFWELL DElNED
YOUALLTOCONSIDERHOWYOURCOMPANIESMIGHTALSOlND
SCHOOLMODELSEG +)00 #ORE+NOWLEDGE
NEWWAYSTOSERVEALLKIDS SOWHENSOMEONESTANDSAT
-ONTESSORI
THISPODIUMYEARSFROMNOW THEYLLBEABLETOSAY
WITHCONlDENCETHATWEWEREALLPARTOFTHESOLUTION s #HARTERSCHOOLSORPUBLICSCHOOLALTERNATIVES
FORLEAVINGNOCHILDBEHIND DEMONSTRATIONOFCOMPELLINGEVIDENCEOFTHEIR
EFFECTIVENESS

s 2APIDEXPANSIONOFVOUCHERANDORPRIVATESCHOOL
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO TAXCREDITPROGRAMS
)MPLICATIONS s 2APIDGROWTHINTHENUMBEROFCHILDRENEDUCATED
)NTHISWORLD STRONGFEDERALPRESENCEANDINTER INPUBLICSCHOOLALTERNATIVES ESPECIALLYIFA
VENTIONINEDUCATIONISAFAILEDSTRATEGY!SARESULT LARGEPORTIONOFTHISGROWTHISCONCENTRATEDINA
STRATEGICALLIANCESHAVEFORMEDBETWEENPROVIDERS RELATIVELYLIMITEDNUMBEROFSCHOOLMODELSˆFOR
OFEDUCATIONPROGRAMS PRODUCTS ANDSERVICESWHICH EXAMPLE IFAFEWPLAYERSAPPEARTOCORNERTHE
NOWDOMINATETHEMARKET/RGANIZATIONSTHATPROSPER MARKETONCHARTERSCHOOLCONVERSIONS
INTHISWORLDHAVEEITHERBECOME POUNDGORILLAS
ORHAVEALLIEDTHEMSELVESWITHONEORMORE 4HESE s 4HEPERCENTAGEOFCHILDRENEDUCATEDIN
ALLIANCESWILLBESHAPEDANDFORMALIZEDBASEDONTHE ALTERNATIVESETTINGSREACHINGAhTIPPINGPOINTvIN
VALUETHATEACHALLYADDSTOTHEPROPOSITION0ARTOFTHE BELLWETHERAREASEG SUBURBSANDEXURBS WHERE
hVALUEPROPOSITIONvWILLBEBASEDONTHEVISIBILITY CRED SUPPORTFORPUBLICSCHOOLSHASTRADITIONALLYBEEN
IBILITY ANDREPUTATIONOFTHEPARTICIPANTS!CCORDINGLY STRONGˆFOREXAMPLE EVENARELATIVELYSMALL
BRANDINGANDCO BRANDING WILLBECOMEANINCREASING PERCENTAGEEG  OFPARENTSREMOVINGTHEIR
LYCRITICALSTRATEGYANDASSETINMARKETINGANDSELLINGTO CHILDRENFROMPUBLICSCHOOLSINTHESESAREASCOULD
CONSUMERSOFEDUCATIONPROGRAMS DRAINNEEDEDRESOURCESFROMPUBLICSCHOOLSAND
4HEREARETWOKEYAUDIENCESINTHISWORLD4HElRST RAPIDLYTIPTHEBALANCEINFAVOROFALTERNATIVE
AREDECISIONMAKERSINTHE POUNDGORILLAORGANIZA MODELS
TIONSANDTHEIRALLIES4HESECONDAREPARENTS WHOWILL s 0ROlTSPOSTEDBYPRIVATEEDUCATIONCOMPANIES
BEDECIDINGINTOWHICHhFRANCHISEvSCHOOLTHEYWILL LEADINGTOANINmUXOFCAPITALNEEDEDTOSUPPORT
ENROLLTHEIRCHILDREN THEDEVELOPMENTANDEXPANSIONOFPRIVATE
7ITHONLYAFEW POUNDGORILLASPROVIDING MODELSOFEDUCATION
PROGRAMSINTHISWORLD FRANCHISINGSCHOOLSISAKEY
BUSINESSSTRATEGY4HISREQUIRESSCALABLETRAININGAND
DEVELOPMENTFORFRANCHISEES4HEUSEOFhMIXEDMEDIAv

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

s #ONTINUEDDECLINESINPUBLICCONlDENCEIN 'OVERNMENT
GOVERNMENTSABILITYTOSOLVEPROBLEMS

s #ONTINUEDDECLINESINPUBLICCONCERNABOUT

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
EDUCATIONIE OTHERISSUES SUCHASHEALTHCARE
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
AND3OCIAL3ECURITYCONTINUETOSURFACEASMORE
IMPORTANTPOLITICALPRIORITIES
h7HEREAN
POUNDGORILLA
/PTIONS SLEEPSv

/PTIONSINTHISWORLDARELIMITED0ROVIDERSCAN .ON 'OVERNMENT


EITHERWORKTOBECOMEAN POUNDGORILLA ORALLY
THEMSELVESWITHONEORMOREORGANIZATIONSLIKELYTO
EMERGEINTHISWAY0OSITIONINGPROVIDERORGANIZATIONS
TOALLYWITHMORETHANONEOFTHE POUNDGORILLA
ORGANIZATIONSWILLREQUIRETHEFOLLOWINGACTIONS

s 3HARPENANINTERNALUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEVALUE
PROVIDERSADDTOPROGRAMSOFFEREDBYOTHERORGA
NIZATIONS

s %MPHASIZETHEUSEOFMIXEDMEDIAINTHEDESIGN
ANDDELIVERYOFALLPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT
OFFERINGS

s )NCREASETHEUSEOFMAINSTREAMANDEDUCATION
MEDIANEWSANDEDITORIALCOVERAGETOINCREASE
BRANDVISIBILITY

s $EVELOPANDDEMONSTRATEEVIDENCEOFTHEIMPACT
ANDOUTCOMESOFPRODUCTSANDSERVICES

s ,OOKFORANDESTABLISHRELATIONSHIPSWITH
POTENTIALGORILLASEG SOFTWARECOMPANIES
SUPPLEMENTALSERVICEPROVIDERS UNIVERSITIES
SUCCESSFULCHARTERSCHOOLMODELPROVIDERS AND
OTHERORGANIZATIONSWITHRECOGNIZABLEEDUCATION
RELATEDhBRANDSvSUCHASMUSEUMSANDMEDIA
COMPANIES 

s "ECOMEARECOGNIZEDPROVIDEROFINDEPENDENT
EDUCATIONRESEARCHANDEVALUATIONWITHVISIBILITY
WITHBOTHEDUCATIONCOMPANIESANDPARENTSEG
Ah*$0OWEROFEDUCATIONv 

s 0REPARESUPPLEMENTALMATERIALSTOSUPPORT
INSTRUCTIONONANDDEVELOPMENTOFLEARNINGSKILLS
FORTHESTCENTURYIE INLITERACY MATHEMATICS
ANDSCIENCE 


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

3CHOOLS5NLIMITEDGOV7HAT 'OVERNMENT

$OESNT+ILL9OU h7HATDOESNT
KILLYOUv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
$EEP#AUSES
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
)NTHISSCENARIO GOVERNMENTHASSTRONGCONTROL

&EW
OVERTHEEDUCATIONMARKET WHICHOFFERSMANYCHOICES
FORSCHOOLINGTOPARENTSANDSTUDENTS4HEFOLLOWING
DEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO

0UBLICSCHOOLCHOICEMODELSEG CHARTER .ON 'OVERNMENT


SCHOOLS DEMONSTRATEEFFECTIVENESSANDGAIN
STRONGSUPPORTFROMTAXPAYERSANDPARENTS

0ARENTSACCUSTOMEDTOCHOICESANDCUSTOMIZATION
h7HAT$OESNT+ILL9OUv
INOTHERMARKETS INCREASINGLYEXPECTTHESAME
LEVELOFCHOICEANDCUSTOMIZATIONINTHEEDUCA 4IME3EPTEMBER 
TIONMARKETPLACE 0LACE7INTER0ARK #/

!NINCREASINGLYDIVERSEANDFRAGMENTEDPUBLIC 3CENE-IGUEL'ARCIA #%/OF3CHOOL3UCCESS


WHICHISUNABLETOAGREEONCOMMONVALUESOR #ORPORATION ISGIVINGTHEKEYNOTEADDRESSATTHE
OUTCOMESFORSCHOOLS NECESSITATESTHECREATIONOF 3CHOOLSOFTHE&UTURE#ONFERENCE
MULTIPLEMODELSOFSCHOOLING "UTWHAT)CANOFFERISTHISAHISTORYOFTHEPAST
YEARSOFEDUCATION)STARTEDOUTINEDUCATIONYEARS
!NEWCOALITIONPOSSIBLYATHIRDPARTY OF
AGOASAHISTORIAN TEACHINGHISTORYINTHE,OS!NGELES
POLITICALMODERATESSUPPORTSTHEPROLIFERATION
PUBLICSCHOOLS3OTHATSWHAT)DO)CONSTANTLYLOOK
OFCHARTERSCHOOLSASACOMPROMISESOLUTIONFOR
BACKANDANALYZEHOWMUCHTHINGSHAVECHANGEDAND
OFFERINGAWIDEARRAYOFCHOICESTOAFRAGMENTED
WHY
PUBLICWHILENONETHELESSMAINTAININGSOMEGOV
3O)THINKITMAYBEIMPORTANTFORUSHEREATTHIS
ERNMENTCONTROLOVEREDUCATION
CONFERENCETORETRACEOURSTEPS"YDOINGSOWELLSEE
4ECHNOLOGYENABLESGOVERNMENTTOMONITOR AND HOWMUCHOURWORLDHASCHANGEDINTHEPASTYEARS
HOLDACCOUNTABLE MULTIPLEMODELSOFSCHOOLING ANDMAYGETABETTERIDEAOFHOWMUCHCHANGEWE
COULDEXPECTTOSEEINTHENEXTYEARS
)VEBEENASKEDTOOFFERMYTHOUGHTSONWHAT 3O CLASS OPENYOURTEXTBOOKSTOPAGEONE3EE
SCHOOLSMAYLOOKLIKEYEARSFROMNOW)KNOWTHAT RIGHTTHERE HOW
YOUPROBABLYlGURETHATASTHE#%/OFAWELL KNOWN ODDTHATSOUNDED
NONPROlTEDUCATIONRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTORGANI 7ELL ITDIDNT
ZATIONTHATSERVESSCHOOLSAROUNDTHECOUNTRY )WOULD SOUNDSOSTRANGE
HAVEMYlNGERONTHEPULSEOFCHANGE7ELL )HATETO YEARSAGO/KAY
DISAPPOINTYOU BUT)MGOINGTOSUMUPMYTHOUGHTS OBJECTLESSONOVER
ONWHATWILLHAPPENWITHEDUCATIONINTHEFUTUREIN 0LEASETURNOFFYOUR
FOURWORDS)HAVENOIDEA PERSONALCOMPUTERS
9OUSEE THEPASTYEARSHAVEBROUGHTSOMANY ANDJOINMEINA
PROFOUNDANDUNEXPECTEDCHANGESTOEDUCATION THAT WALKTHROUGHRECENT
)MHESITANTTOMAKEAFOOLOFMYSELFBYSAYINGSOME HISTORY STARTINGIN
THINGHERETHISAFTERNOONTHATWEDALLGETAGOODLAUGH THEYEAR
ABOUTINYEARS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

3EEDSARESOWN
,OOKINGBACK YOUCANSEETHATALLOFTHESEEDSOF
CHANGEFORTHEPASTYEARSHADALREADYBEENSOWN
IN&OREXAMPLE THE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT
.#," WASMOVINGMOREANDMORESCHOOLSCLOSERTO CALLYBASEDEVIDENCE9OUMAYRECALLTHATTHE7HAT
BEINGTAKENOVERORCONVERTEDINTOCHARTERSBYTHEIR 7ORKS#LEARINGHOUSEHADJUSTBEGUNANDTHEREWAS
STATES/NLINEANDDISTANCELEARNINGWASBURGEON VERYLITTLEINITTOGIVEEDUCATORSANDPOLICYMAKERS
ING4HENUMBEROFHOMESCHOOLERSHADPASSEDTHE MUCHGUIDANCE)SHOULDADDTHATBACKIN THE
MILLIONMARK4HECHARTERMOVEMENTWASSTRONGAND FUTUREOFTHECHARTERSCHOOLMOVEMENTREALLYAPPEARED
GROWING2ELIGIOUSCONSERVATIVESWEREBEINGCALLEDTO TOBEUP FOR GRABS ASTHEYWEREPRODUCINGMIXED
LEAVEPUBLICSCHOOLS/FCOURSE ATTHETIME LIKETHE RESULTS3OMESCHOOLSWERESHOWINGSTRONGGAINS BUT
"IBLICALPARABLE ITWOULDVEBEENHARDTOKNOWWHICH ONTHEWHOLE MOSTCHARTERSCHOOLSDIDNOTAPPEARTO
SEEDSWOULDFALLONHARDGROUND WHICHWOULDBE BEADDINGMUCHVALUETOTHEIRSTUDENTSLEARNING3O
CARRIEDAWAYBYTHEWIND ANDWHICHWOULDSPROUTINTO THEFEWPROGRAMSAROUNDTHECOUNTRYTHATWEREABLETO
SUBSTANTIVECHANGES DEMONSTRATESUCCESSREALLYSTARTEDTOCATCHON
!LSOIN STATESBEGANTOPUSHBACKFORCIBLY
AGAINSTTHELAW CALLINGITUNDER FUNDEDANDINNEEDOF
SEVERALREVISIONS7HATWASPERHAPSMOSTSTRIKINGIS
THATTHEREALRESISTANCETOTHELAWCAMENOTONLYFROM
MORETRADITIONALLYLIBERALSTATES BUTALSOFROMCONSER
VATIVESTATESLIKE5TAHANDOTHERPLACESTHATWERE
#HARTERSTAKEROOT STRONGSUPPORTERSOF'EORGE7"USH

$URINGTHESUMMEROF WESAWTHElRSTWAVE
OFUNDER PERFORMINGSCHOOLSˆSCHOOLSTHATHADFAILED
TOMEETADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESSASDElNEDBY.#,"
ˆBEINGCONVERTEDINTOCHARTERSCHOOLS)MMEDIATELY
STATESBEGANLOOKINGAROUNDFORSUCCESSFULMODELSOF
SCHOOLING
!TTHETIME THEREREALLYWERENTTOOMANYTO
CHOOSEFROM ATLEASTNOTIFYOUHELDTHEMTOTHEHIGH
STANDARDOFEFFECTIVENESSASDEMONSTRATEDBYSCIENTIl


!SNOTEDEARLIER RESEARCHONCHARTERSCHOOLSHASGENERATEDMIXEDRESULTSTODATE3OMESTUDIESHAVEPRODUCEDPOSITIVElNDINGSA2AND
#ORPSTUDYFOUND#ALIFORNIACHARTERSPERFORMASWELLASORBETTERTHANTRADITIONALSCHOOLS ANDA(ARVARD5NIVERSITYSTUDYFOUNDCHARTER
SCHOOLSTUDENTSWEREMOREPROlCIENTINREADINGANDMATHEMATICSTHANSTUDENTSATNEARBYTRADITIONALSCHOOLS"UTOTHERSTUDIESHAVEREPORTED
NEGLIGIBLEORNEGATIVEOUTCOMESA-ARCH%CONOMIC0OLICY3TUDYFOUNDTHATTHEhAVERAGEIMPACTvOFCHARTERSCHOOLShISNEGATIVEvANDA
!MERICAN&EDERATIONOF4EACHERSSTUDYFOUNDFOURTH GRADECHARTERSCHOOLSTUDENTSWEREPERFORMINGABOUTAHALF YEARBEHINDSTUDENTSIN
TRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLS

/N&EBRUARY  ASPECIALTASKFORCECREATEDBYTHE.ATIONAL#ONFERENCEOF3TATE,EGISLATURES.#3, RELEASEDABIPARTISANREPORT
THATRECOMMENDEDFUNDAMENTALCHANGESTO0RESIDENT"USHS.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDEDUCATIONREFORMLAWTOINCREASEITSEFFECTIVENESS4HE.#3,
REPORTINCLUDEDSPECIlCRECOMMENDATIONSTOREVISETHEACT WHICHITCRITICIZEDASAhONESIZElTSALLvSYSTEMTHATSTImESINNOVATIONATTHESTATE
LEVEL3OURCE-OTLAGH *&EBRUARY  3TATESWANTCHANGESTO.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND5NITED0RESS)NTERNATIONAL

2EPUBLICANLEGISLATORSˆANDPROFESSEDSUPPORTERSOF0RESIDENT"USHˆLEDAWELLPUBLICIZEDPUSHFOR5TAHTOOPTOUTOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT
"EHIND!CT/N&EBRUARY  %DUCATION7EEKREPORTEDTHATMANYhREDSTATEv2EPUBLICANSAREOPPOSEDTOWHATTHEYSEEASTHELAWShRAFTOF
PRESCRIPTIONSASENCROACHINGONSTATEANDLOCALTURFANDIMPOSINGUNWARRANTEDCOSTSv$AVIS - &EBRUARY  h5TAH)S5NLIKELY&LYIN
"USHS3CHOOL/INTMENT v%DUCATION7EEK PP 


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

&INALLY ONAPERSONALNOTE )SHOULDADDTHATTHE 'OVERNMENT


FRAMEWORKFORTHE3CHOOL3UCCESS#ORPORATIONWAS
SKETCHEDOUTONANAPKINLATETHATFALL!TTHETIME ) h7HATDOESNT
KILLYOUv
WASWORKINGFORAREGIONALLABORATORYANDAGOODFRIEND

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
OFMINE ,ANGSTON$AVIS WASTHINKINGOFOPENINGA 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
CHARTERSCHOOLININNERCITY3T,OUISˆONEWHICHHE
WANTEDTOBEBASEDONRIGOROUSRESEARCH YETBEINDI
VIDUALIZEDTOTHENEEDSOFITSAT RISKSTUDENTS(EASKED
MEIF)COULDHELPHIMDESIGNSUCHAPROGRAMANDSAID
NOTHINGWASOFFTHETABLEh)FITWORKS ITWORKS vHE
.ON 'OVERNMENT
SAID(ISQUESTIONWASSOMETHINGTHAT)FELTLIKE)HAD
SPENTTWODECADESWAITINGTOBEASKED SO)GLADLYTOOK
HIMUPONHISCHALLENGE
h0RUNINGvPUBLICSCHOOLS
$IVIDESREMAIN CHARTERSGROW "YTHEFALLOF FULLYONE lFTHOFTHENATIONS
"Y ITBECAMEAPPARENTTHATWEWERENO KIDSHADENROLLEDINCHARTERSCHOOLSˆTHREE FOLD
CLOSERTOSOLVINGTHEBITTERPARTISANANDCULTURALDIVIDE GROWTHINTHREEYEARS-OREANDMORE BIGPUBLIC
THATHADSPLITTHECOUNTRY$EMOCRATS HOPINGFORA SCHOOLSWEREBEING
MID TERMBOUNCEPOUREDMILLIONSINTOINCREASINGLY REPLACEDBYSMALL
CANTANKEROUS#ONGRESSIONALBATTLES WHICHBROUGHTAC CHARTERSCHOOLS SOME
CUSATIONSOFFRAUDFROMBOTHSIDES)NTHISENVIRONMENT TIMESOPERATINGWITHIN
PUBLICSCHOOLSWERELIMPINGALONG GENERALLYIMPROV THESAMEFOURWALLS)T
ING YETNOTFASTENOUGHTOOUTPACETHERISINGBAROF WASNOTUNLIKEWHAT
ADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESS!90 TARGETS)NTHESUMMER HAPPENSWHENYOU
OF ASSTATESWEREREQUIREDTORAISETHEBARON!90 PRUNEABUSHINYOUR
ANOTHER MUCHLARGERWAVEOFLOW PERFORMINGSCHOOLS YARD9OUCUTABRANCH
WASTAKENOVERBYTHEIRSTATESANDTURNEDINTOCHARTERS ANDTWOORTHREEGROW
/NCEAGAIN EDUCATORSWEREINAMADSCRAMBLETOlND BACKINITSPLACE"ACK
EFFECTIVEMODELSOFSCHOOLING INTHOSEDAYS FOR
)MPLEASEDTOSAYTHATTHEKIDSINMYFRIEND EACHBIG UNSUCCESSFUL
,ANGSTONSSCHOOLPERFORMEDVERYWELL ATTRACTINGSOME OVERGROWNSCHOOLWE
CONSIDERABLEMEDIAATTENTION0EOPLESTARTEDCALLING TRIMMED THREEORFOUR
,ANGSTONANDASKINGHIMHOWHEDDONEIT4HElRST NEWONESWOULDSPROUT
THINGOUTOFHISMOUTHWAShRESEARCHv4HESECOND INITSPLACE
THINGWASMYNAME-YPHONESTARTEDRINGINGOFFTHE 'ENERALLYSPEAKING
HOOKAND)HUNGOUTMYSHINGLEASTHE3CHOOL3UCCESS ASTHESEFRAGMENTED
!SSOCIATESANDHIREDSOMEOFMYOLDREGIONALLABORA SCHOOLSTOOKTHEPLACE
TORYFRIENDSTOANSWERTHECALLS9OUSEE THEREWASA OFLARGERSCHOOLS THEY
GROWINGBODYOFEVIDENCEINTHOSEDAYS4HE7HAT REmECTEDTHEINCREASING
7ORKS#LEARINGHOUSEWASSTARTINGTOTAKEOFF"UTEDU BALKANIZATIONOFOURCOUNTRYANDCOMMUNITIES!L
CATORSNEEDEDPEOPLETOHELPTHEMSIFTTHROUGHALLTHE THOUGHSOMEPEOPLERESISTEDIT SAYINGTHATOURSCHOOLS
EVIDENCE!NDTHATSWHEREWECAMEIN7EDSEPARATE SHOULDBEhCOMMONSCHOOLSvWHEREOURKIDSWOULD
FACTFROMlCTIONANDTRAINTEACHERSANDSCHOOLLEADERS LEARNTOCOMETOGETHERAS!MERICANS INREALITY SOME
TOAPPLYTHERESEARCHTOTHEIRCLASSROOMSANDSCHOOLS TIMESBREAKINGASCHOOLUPINTOABUNCHOFSMALLER

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

UNITSWASTHEONLYSENSIBLESOLUTION9OUHADPARENT )NCASEYOUREWONDERING )JUSTTURNEDLASTWEEK


GROUPSNEARLYCOMINGTOBLOWSOVERWHICHMODELTHEY WHICHTECHNICALLYMAKESMEAMEMBEROFhGENERATION
WANTEDFORTHEIRKIDS3OMEWANTEDETHNIC CENTERED *ONESvˆTHEGENERATIONSANDWICHEDBETWEENBOOMERS
CURRICULUMOTHERSWANTEDCOREKNOWLEDGE3OME AND'EN 8ERS!CTUALLY )FEELVERYMUCHLIKEA
WANTEDACONSTRUCTIVISTAPPROACHOTHERSDIRECTINSTRUC HYBRIDOFBOOMERIDEALISM)MDEEPLYMOTIVATEDBY
TION3OMEWANTEDALAPTOPINEVERYBACKPACKOTHERS ADESIRETOHELPALLKIDS BUT)ALSOHAVETHAT'EN 8ER
WANTEDTOBANCALCULATORS3OMEWANTEDATHLETICS PRAGMATISM)NEVERGOTCAUGHTUPINTHEREADINGOR
OTHERSWANTEDARTS3OMEWANTEDEVOLUTIONOTHERSIN MATHWARSORANYOFTHATSTUFF,IKEMYFRIEND,ANGS
TELLIGENTDESIGN3OMEWANTEDBILINGUALOTHERSWANTED TON WHOISA'EN 8ER MYATTITUDEISVERYMUCH hIFIT
IMMERSION)TWASIMPOSSIBLETOPLEASEEVERYONE WORKS ITWORKSv
)NTHISFRAGMENTEDENVIRONMENT THEBESTSOLUTION
FORDISTRICTSORSTATECHARTERBOARDSWASTOSAY @&INE
SHOWMETHEEVIDENCEYOURAPPROACHWORKSANDYOU
CANGOOFFANDDOYOUROWNTHING!TONEPOINT
3CHOOL3UCCESSCONSIDEREDDEVELOPINGAhFRANCHISE vA
MODELFORSCHOOLINGTHATWEWOULDSELLTOCHARTEROP
ERATORS7EDIDNTGETVERYFARWITHTHATPLAN THOUGH
BECAUSEINTHISENVIRONMENTEVERYONEBASICALLYWANTED
TODOTHEIROWNTHING9OUSAWAFEWORGANIZATIONSTRY
9OUALSOHADANEWGENERATIONOFSCHOOLLEADERSˆ
TOMAKEAGOOFTHEFRANCHISECONCEPTˆ)MTHINK
SO CALLED h'EN 8ERSvˆWHOWEREANENTIRELYDIFFER
INGOF%DISONAND+)00ANDSOMEOTHERSˆBUTASTHE
ENTBREEDTHANTHEIRBOOMERPREDECESSORS4HEYWERE
MARKETBECAMEINCREASINGLYFRAGMENTEDANDLOCALLY
FARMOREPRAGMATICANDMUCHLESSFOCUSEDONTHEBIG
DRIVEN ITBECAMEHARDERANDHARDERTOMAKETHAT
PICTURE)DUGUPAQUOTEFROM$AVID-ASTERSON WHO
MODELWORK)JUSTREADSOMEWHERETHAT+)00 %DISON
RANAlNEARTS ORIENTEDCHARTERSCHOOLINTHE"RONX
AND3YLVAN THETHREEMOSTPOPULARCHARTERMODELSIN
THATNICELYSUMSUP'EN 8ERSMOREPRAGMATICAND
THECOUNTRY REPRESENTLESSTHANPERCENTOFTHETOTAL
ARGUABLYLESSPHILOSOPHICAL APPROACHTOEDUCATION)N
ENROLLMENTOFTHECOUNTRY#HURCHSCHOOLSACCOUNTFOR
RESPONSETOAREPORTERASKINGHIMWHETHERHETHOUGHT
ABOUTANOTHERPERCENT%VERYBODYELSEISORDERING
INTHELONGRUN ITWASGOODFORTHECOUNTRYTOHAVEALL
FROMTHEALACARTEMENUWHENBUILDINGTHEIRSCHOOL
THESESCHOOLSGOINGOFFINTHEIROWNSEPARATEDIRECTIONS
PROGRAMS
GIVINGKIDSVERYDIFFERENTEXPERIENCES HEREPLIED h)SIT
GOODFORTHECOUNTRY-AYBENOT"UTISITGOODFORMY
2EMOVINGTHORNSFROM.#,"
KIDSTOGOTOASCHOOLTHATNURTURESTHEIRTALENTSAND
CHALLENGESTHEM!BSOLUTELY)MTRYINGTOHELPTHE "Y THETIDEBEGANTOTURNONSCHOOLTAKEOVERS
KIDS)CANHELPˆTHEONESRIGHTHEREINTHISSCHOOL DUEINPARTTOALOTOFSCHOOLS ESPECIALLYALOTOFTHE
4HEALTERNATIVE YOUKNOW ISTRYINGTOPROVIDEALL NEWLYCONVERTEDCHARTERSCHOOLS MAKINGSOMESIGNIl
THINGSTOEVERYONE ANDINREALITY PROVIDINGNOTHINGTO CANTPROGRESS BUTALSODUETOSOMEREGULATORYANDLEGIS
ANYONE4HATSHOWOURSCHOOLSUSEDTOOPERATEANDIN LATIVECHANGESTOTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDLAW7ITH
MYOPINION ITDIDNTGETUS OROURKIDS VERYFARv THEELECTIONSEASONINFULLSWING NEITHERPARTY
WANTEDTONECESSARILYCOMEOUTINFAVOROFTHELAW NOR

$EMOGRAPHER*ONATHAN0ONTELLCOINEDTHETERMh'ENERATION*ONESvFORTHISAGEGROUP BORNBETWEENAND WHICHHENOTES

COMPRISESTHELARGESTADULTGENERATIONINTHE534HENAMEh*ONESvDENOTESBOTHTHEFACTTHATTHISGENERATIONHASREMAINEDLARGELYANONYMOUS
AGENERATIONh3MITHvORh$OEv ANDREPRESENTSANAVERAGEFAMILYNEXTDOORBALANCEBETWEENBOOMERSIDEALISMAND'EN 8ERSCYNICISM3OURCE
'ENERATION*ONES7EBSITEHTTPGENERATIONJONESCOMINDEX?OLDHTM


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

'OVERNMENT

h7HATDOESNT
KILLYOUv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
AGAINSTIT SOMEMBERSOFBOTHPARTIESREALIZEDTHEBEST
SOLUTIONWASTOTAKEITOFFTHETABLEALTOGETHER4HEY .ON 'OVERNMENT
TWEAKED.#,"JUSTENOUGHTOQUIETTHEMOSTSTRIDENT
CRITICSˆCREATING FOREXAMPLE MOREACCOMMODATIONS
FORSPECIALNEEDSKIDSANDTRACKING%NGLISH,ANGUAGE
#OMPROMISEGROWSINTHE
,EARNERSASASUBGROUPTHROUGHOUTTHEIRENTIREACADEM
FURROWS
ICCAREERS9ETTHEYKEPTENOUGHOFTHELAW LIKETHE
TESTINGANDREPORTINGREQUIREMENTSANDANEWLYMODI 4HEOUTCOMEOFTHE0RESIDENTIALELECTION
lED!90SYSTEM INPLACETOKEEPITSSUPPORTERSHAPPY CAUGHTMANYPUNDITSBYSURPRISE"UTITSHOULDNTHAVE
MOREORLESS 3INCETHE
-OSTEDUCATORSANDSTATELAWMAKERSAPPLAUDED S APLURAL
THESECHANGESASBRINGINGANEEDEDDOSEOFCOMMON ITYOFVOTERS
SENSETOTHEFEDERALLAW!FEWPEOPLEWORRIEDTHAT HADIDENTIlED
THEREMIGHTBESOMESHENANIGANSFOREXAMPLE THEY THEMSELVES
WORRIEDTHATTHERANKSOFSPECIALNEEDSKIDSMIGHTSWELL ASINDEPEN
ASSCHOOLSSOUGHTTOGETMOREKIDSOUTOFTHE!90SPOT DENT&OR
LIGHT"UTFORTHEMOSTPART SUCHGAMINGOFTHESYSTEM THEMOSTPART
HASBEENTHEEXCEPTION RATHERTHANTHERULE THESEVOTERS
)SUPPOSEINAWAY CHARTERSCHOOLSWEREINTHERIGHT WEREMODER
PLACEATTHERIGHTTIMEˆASSOMEOFTHEFANGSWERE ATE SWING
REMOVEDFROM.#," TESTSCORESSTARTEDTOCLIMB-OST VOTERS3UCH
MEMBERSOFTHEGENERALPUBLICDIDNTUNDERSTANDTHE VOTERSNEITHER
REGULATORYNUANCES ANDSO CHARTERSCHOOLSGOTMOSTOF IDENTIlEDWITH
THECREDITFORSAVINGTHEDAY"UTALSO ASMOREPARENTS RELIGIOUSCONSERVATIVES WHOBEGANASSERTINGTHEM
ENROLLEDTHEIRKIDSINCHARTERSCHOOLS WHICHHAD SELVESMORESTRONGLYINTHE2EPUBLICANPARTYAFTERTHE
ALSOALWAYSENJOYEDHIGHLEVELSOFPARENTSATISFACTION ELECTION NORWITHTRADITIONALLIBERALS WHOBEGAN
SCHOOLAPPROVALRATINGSCLIMBEDASWELL ASSERTINGTHEMSELVESMORESTRONGLYINTHE$EMOCRATIC
PARTYAFTERITS7HITE(OUSEAND#ONGRESSIONALLOSSES
3OITSHOULDVESURPRISEDNOONETHATSOMEMODER
ATESFROMBOTHPARTIESLOOKEDACROSSTHEAISLEANDWON
DEREDIFTHEYHADMOREINCOMMONWITHONEANOTHER
THANWITHTHEIROWNPARTIES&OREXAMPLE $EMOCRATS

,OSTINRECENTMEDIACOVERAGEOFTHESPLITBETWEEN2EPUBLICANAND$EMOCRATSANDhREDSTATEvANDhBLUESTATEv!MERICAISTHEFACTTHAT

!MERICANSAPPEARTOBEEVENDIVIDEDINTOTHIRDSWITHEVENPERCENTAGESOFADULTSREPORTINGTHATTHEYCONSIDERTHEMSELVESTOBE2EPUBLICAN
$EMOCRAT OR)NDEPENDENTˆFOREXAMPLE 2EPUBLICANS $EMOCRATSAND)NDEPENDENTSWEREEVENLYTIEDATPERCENTINAN/CTOBER!"#
.EWS7ASHINGTON0OSTPOLL3OURCE0OLLING2EPORTˆHTTPWWWPOLLINGREPORTCOMINSTITUTHTM

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

SUCHAS*OE,IEBERMAN -AX"AUCUS "EN.ELSON -ARK THINGSYOUlNDINTHEMIDDLEOFTHEROADAREhAMODER


0RYOR AND"ARACK/BAMA ASWELLASTHEh"LUE$OG ATEANDADEADSKUNKvˆANDDIDNTWANTTOBEEITHER
$EMOCRATSvINTHEHOUSE ALLFELTSLIGHTEDBY(OWARD )NTERMSOFEDUCATION -C#AINANDTHE2EFORMERS
$EANSWINNINGTHEPARTYCHAIRMANSHIPBACKIN hLIVEANDLETLIVEvAPPROACHTOGOVERNANCEQUICKLYDEM
!NDCONSERVATIVE YETSOCIALLYMODERATE2EPUBLICANS ONSTRATEDTHEYWEREHAPPYTOOVERSEETHEFURTHERPRO
LIKE*OHN-C#AIN /LYMPIA3NOWE #HUCK(AGELAND LIFERATIONOFCHARTERSCHOOLS WHICHTHEYSAWASAGOOD
!RLEN3PECTERBEGANTOSPLITWITHTHEADMINISTRATION COMPROMISESOLUTIONˆONETHATALLOWEDFORMANY
ONANUMBEROFISSUES INCLUDINGSTEMCELLRESEARCH ASPECTSOFSCHOOLINGTOBEDEREGULATEDBYWAIVING FOR
!NDSO WHEN*OHN-C#AIN WHOSEHEROHAD EXAMPLE REQUIREMENTSONTEACHERCERTIlCATION IN
ALWAYSBEEN4EDDY2OOSEVELT FATHEROFTHERENEGADE EXCHANGEFORDEMONSTRATIONOFSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT
h"ULL-OOSEvPARTYINTHEEARLYS FAILEDTOSECURE ANDlSCALPROBITY#HARTERSAPPEALEDTOMODERATES WHO
HISPARTYSNOMINATIONINTHESUMMEROF WE WEREMOREINTENTONPRESERVINGTHEPUBLICSYSTEMOF
SHOULDVEALLSEENWHATWASCOMINGNEXT!SAMAV EDUCATIONTHANPUBLICSCHOOLSTHEMSELVES)THINKTHEY
ERICK -C#AINHADSTRONGAPPEALWITH'EN 8VOTERS ALSOlGUREDOUTTHATGETTINGBEHINDCHARTERSCHOOLSWAS
WHOASASMALLGENERATIONDEMOGRAPHICALLY HADNEVER SIMPLYPOLITICALLYEXPEDIENTASTHEYHADLONGENJOYED
WIELDEDMUCHPOLITICALPOWER3O TOO 3ILENTGENERA HIGHLEVELSOFPARENTSATISFACTIONWHILEVOUCHERPRO
TIONVOTERS ASMALLERVOTINGBLOCKTHANBOOMERS THE GRAMSCONTINUEDTOHAVEMIXEDPUBLICSUPPORT
NATIONSLARGESTAGEGROUP HADALSOBEENECLIPSED 2EED(ANSON AFRESHMAN#ONGRESSMANFROM
BYBOOMERSATTHEPOLLSˆWITHNOMEMBEROFTHEIR .EVADA WHOWASELECTEDASA$EMOCRAT BUTDEFECTED
GENERATIONEVERMAKINGITTOTHE7HITE(OUSE"UT TOTHE2EFORM0ARTYEVENBEFOREHEWASSWORNIN
BYCOMBININGFORCESINTHERESURRECTED2EFORM0ARTY BLUNTLYSTATEDTHENEWPARTYSPOSITIONONEDUCATION
MIDDLE AGED'EN IN.EWSWEEKh-YPHILOSOPHYISTESTTHEM;SCHOOLS=
8ERSANDELDERLY ANDGOOVERTHEIRlNANCIALS BUTOTHERWISE LEAVETHEM
hSILENTSvFOUNDTHEY ALONE/URSOCIETYISTOODIVERSEANDDIVIDEDFORA
COULDASSERTPOLITI ONE SIZE lTS ALLAPPROACHTOEDUCATIONTOWORK!ND
CALAUTHORITYOVER FRANKLY )REALLYDONTCAREIFASCHOOLWANTSKIDSTO
THEIDEOLOGICALLY SINGTHE(ALLELUJAH#HORUSEVERYMORNINGSTANDING
DIVIDEDBOOMERS ONTHEIRHEADSASLONGASTHEIR;TEST=SCORESSHOWTHEIR
!SYOUKNOW KIDSARELEARNINGANDTHEIRBALANCESHEETSSHOWTHEYRE
ALLTHESEFACTORS NOTSPENDINGTHEIRMONEYONANTIQUELAVALAMPSAND
ADDEDUPTO*OHN TRIPSTOTHE"AHAMASv7HENASKEDIFHESUPPORTED
-C#AINWINNING VOUCHERS (ANSONQUIPPED h&RANKLY VOUCHERSSCARE
THE7HITE(OUSE ME)DONTWANTMYTAXDOLLARSGOINGJUSTANYWHERE
IN-C#AINWONHANDILYAMONG'EN 8ERSAND 0UBLICDOLLARSSHOULDSTAYINTHEPUBLICSYSTEM WHICH)
-C#AINSOWN3ILENTGENERATIONPEERS-EANWHILE MIGHTADD WILLGETTHEJOBDONEIFWEJUSTLETIT!SMY
(ILLARY#LINTONAND"ILL&RISTSPLITTHEVOTEOFTHEMORE GRANDMAUSEDTOSAY LETSNOTTHROWOUTTHEBABYWITH
IDEOLOGICALBOOMERS WHOAPPARENTLY LIKEFORMER!T THEBATHWATERv
TORNEY'ENERAL*OHN!SHCROFT FELTTHATTHEONLYTWO


#HARTERSCHOOLSAPPEARTOOCCUPYTHEPOLITICALMIDDLEGROUNDBETWEENTRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLS SUPPORTEDBYTHELEFT ANDFREE MARKETORI
ENTEDVOUCHERPROGRAMS SUPPORTEDBYTHERIGHT)N-AY %RIC2OFESAND,ISA3TULBERG TWOSELF DESCRIBEDPROGRESSIVESWHOSUPPORTEDCHARTER
SCHOOLS EXPRESSEDCONCERNATAFORUMSPONSOREDBYTHEPOLICYWINGOFTHECENTRIST$EMOCRATIC,EADERSHIP#OUNCIL THAT$EMOCRATSAREBECOMING
INCREASINGLYHOSTILETOCHARTERSCHOOLSOUTOFDEFERENCETOTEACHERSUNIONS4HEIRBOOK 4HE%MANCIPATORY0ROMISEOF#HARTER3CHOOLS4OWARDA
0ROGRESSIVE0OLITICSOF#HOICE EMBRACESCHARTERSCHOOLSASAMEANSOFIMPROVINGEDUCATIONFORDISADVANTAGEDCHILDREN3OURCE(ENDRIE #-AY
  h!UTHORS5RGE,EFT LEANING!DVOCATESTO"ACK#HARTERING v%DUCATION7EEK  P


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

4HESENEWCENTRISTS WHILESTILLRELATIVELYSMALLIN 'OVERNMENT


NUMBERˆMEMBERSINTHE(OUSE ANDINTHE
3ENATE WIELDDISPROPORTIONATEPOWERIN#ONGRESS h7HATDOESNT
KILLYOUv
BECAUSETHEYRETHESWINGVOTES"YDRIVINGAMODERATE

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
AGENDAˆONEWHICHRESISTSBOTHTAXCUTSANDSPEND 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
INGINCREASESˆTHEYVEHELPEDTOGETTHEGOVERNMENTS
lNANCIALHOUSEINORDERBYMAKINGSOMETOUGHCHOICES
WITHOURENTITLEMENTPROGRAMSˆSUCHASRAISINGTHE
ELIGIBILITYAGEFOR3OCIAL3ECURITYTOULTIMATELY ASYOU
KNOW BYANDMEANS TESTINGTHEPROGRAM
.ON 'OVERNMENT
4HEYALSOPUSHEDTHROUGHSOMETOUGHCHOICESON
-EDICARE WHICH)KNOWNOTEVERYONEISHAPPYABOUT
ˆESPECIALLYIFYOUREONEOFTHE YEAR OLDSWHO ABITOFARUSE OFCOURSE BECAUSEINMANYCASES THE
NEEDSATHIRDHEARTSURGERY"UTMAKINGALLTHESElSCAL HEAVILYRELIGIOUSNATUREOFTHESCHOOLANDORSTRICT
lXESHASAVERTEDAFEDERALBUDGETDISASTERANDFREEDUP PARENTINVOLVEMENTREQUIREMENTSTENDEDTOWEEDOUT
SPENDINGATTHEFEDERAL STATEANDLOCALLEVELSFOROTHER KIDSWHOWOULDNTQUITEhlTINv
PRIORITIES SUCHASEDUCATION !LMOSTOVERNIGHT ENROLLMENTSKYROCKETEDIN
"UTBEFORE)GIVEMODERATESALLTHECREDITFORGETTING PAROCHIALCHARTERSCHOOLS!YEARLATER WHENSECTARIAN
GOVERNMENTENTITLEMENTSUNDERCONTROL )SHOULDPOINT SCHOOLSWEREGRANTEDWAIVERSFROMTEACHINGANDTESTING
OUTTHAT-3!SMEDICALSAVINGSACCOUNTS HAVEALSO THEIRCHILDRENONSTATESCIENCESTANDARDS THEIRENROLL
MADEFOLKSALOTMOREFRUGALWHENITCOMESTOHEALTH MENTALSOSHOThHEAVENWARD vINTHEWORDSOFAPASTOR
SPENDING4HATSHELPEDALOT7ELL ANDSOHASTHE WHOOPENEDARELIGIOUSCHARTERSCHOOLIN"ENTONVILLE
BLACKMARKETFORPHARMACEUTICALS%VENTHOUGHNO !RKANSAS!T3CHOOL3UCCESS OURCLIENTSSPANNEDTHE
ONELIKESTOTALKABOUTITMUCH )SAWARECENTSTORYON WHOLEGAMUTˆFROM#ORE+NOWLEDGETO-ONTES
#..THATESTIMATEDTHATNEARLYONE THIRDOFTHEMEDI SORI BILINGUALTOIMMERSION RELIGIOUSTOSECULAR4OBE
CINESCONSUMEDINTHISCOUNTRYWEREOBTAINEDILLEGALLY HONEST SOMEOFOURPEOPLEFOUNDTHEMSELVESUNABLETO
ˆIMPORTEDFROMLABSIN#HINAANDOTHERPLACESTHAT CHECKTHEIROWNIDEOLOGIESATTHEDOORWHENWORKING
HAVERIPPEDOFF53AND%UROPEANCOMPANIESPATENTS WITH ONTHEONEHAND ASCHOOLWHERETHEKIDSSTART
4HEREPORTERDOINGTHESTORYQUIPPEDTHATTHEGENERA THEDAYOFFINPRAYER ORONTHEOTHERHAND ASCHOOL
TIONOF*IMI(ENDRIX (UNTER34HOMPSON AND*IM WHERETHEYENDTHEDAYWITHAGAYAWARENESSRALLY)N
-ORRISONAREBACKTOUSINGILLEGALDRUGSONLYTHISTIME SHORT NOTEVERYBODYCOULDGETONBOARDWITHOURhIFIT
AROUNDTHEYREMEDICINAL NOTRECREATIONAL WORKS ITWORKSvMANTRA

&AITH BASEDSCHOOLSSPROUTUP "UDDINGSUCCESS


EVERYWHERE
9OUVEPROBABLYALSO
)N AMORECONSER EENTHELATESTRESULTSFROM
VATIVE3UPREME#OURTRULED 4)--3TEST/URKIDS
THATFAITH BASEDORGANIZA CONTINUETOGAINGROUNDON
TIONSCOULDOPENCHARTER 3INGAPORE ANDNOWRANK
SCHOOLS SOLONGASTHEY ANYWHEREFROMTHIRDTO
COULDDEMONSTRATETHATNO SEVENTHˆDEPENDINGON
TAXDOLLARSWEREUSEDTO WHICHSUBJECTAREAANDGRADE
SUPPORTRELIGIOUSEDUCATION EVELYOURELOOKINGAT*UST
ANDTHEIRDOORSWEREOPEN THINK LESSTHANYEARSAGO
TOANYCHILDWHOWANTED THESEKIDSPARENTSWERETOLD
TOATTENDTHESCHOOL)TWAS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

THATTHEIRLACKOFEDUCATIONWASPUTTINGTHEhNATIONAT 4HEBLOOMISBACKONTHEGOV
RISKv!NDNOWWEHAVECOUNTRIESALLAROUNDTHEWORLD ERNMENTROSE
WORRYINGABOUTHOWTHEYAREGOINGTOKEEPUPWITHTHE 9OUMAYHAVE
!MERICANS4ENYEARSAGOTHATWOULDNTHAVESEEMED SEENTHEHEADLINES
POSSIBLE THOUGHITMAYBESHOULDHAVECONSIDERINGTHAT ASTYEAR&ORTHE
!MERICANKIDSSCORESONINTERNATIONALCOMPARISONS lRSTTIMEIN
ACTUALLYSTARTEDINCREASINGINTHEMID S YEARS SINCE
THEMAJORITYOF
7EATHERINGTHEDROUGHT !MERICANSREPORTED
)KNOWTHELASTFEWYEARSHAVEBEENATOUGHTIME ASTYEARTHATTHEY
FOREVERYONE4HESTAGNANTECONOMYHASHITALOTOF TRUSTGOVERNMENT
PEOPLEHARD4HEUPSHOTOFTHERISEINUNEMPLOYMENT N7ASHINGTONTO
ISTHATSCHOOLSHAVEHADNOTROUBLElNDINGGOODTEACH DOWHATISRIGHT
ERSWHOAREWILLINGTOWORKFORVERYLITTLE7EREALL 4HATSATREMENDOUS
LEARNINGTOMAKEDOWITHLESS)KNOWWEVEALLBEEN CHANGE-ANYPUNDITSSAYTHATOURREVIVEDEDUCATION
ASKEDTOWRINGMOREPENNIESOUTOFOURBUDGETS/UR SYSTEM WHILENOTREALLYCONTROLLEDBY7ASHINGTON
KIDSNEVERCEASETOAMAZEME4HEY TOO ARELEARNING NONETHELESSISABIGPARTOFWHYPEOPLENOWFEELGOOD
TOhMAKEDOv-OREIMPORTANTLY THEYRELEARNINGTO ABOUTGOVERNMENT!LSO DElCITSPENDINGISBACKUNDER
REDISCOVERCOMMUNITYINTHEIRSCHOOLS(AVEYOUSEEN CONTROLANDWEREMAKINGREALPROGRESSONTRANSITIONING
THENEWFASHIONTREND4ODAYINTHEAIRPORT EVERY 3OCIAL3ECURITYOUTOFTHEPAY AS YOUGOSYSTEM9OUALL
WHERE)LOOKED)SAWTHEMˆSCHOOLLETTERJACKETS HERETHISAFTERNOONSHOULDFEELEQUALLYPROUDOFYOUR
#ANYOUBELIEVETHAT-OSTBOOMERSANDESPECIALLY ACCOMPLISHMENTS
'EN 8ERSWOULDNTHAVEWORNALETTERJACKETONA !MAJORITYOFCOLLEGEKIDSNOWSAYTHEYHAVEA
DARE BUTTHATSTHENEWTHINGFORTHESEKIDS$ONTGET POSITIVEVIEWOFGOVERNMENTANDWOULDLIKETOWORK
MEWRONG)MNOTMAKINGFUNOFTHEM)WISH)DHAD FORGOVERNMENT4HATSADRAMATICSHIFTFROMADECADE
THATKINDOFSCHOOLPRIDE9OUKNOWTHEMOSTPOPULAR AGOWHENONLYPERCENTOFCOLLEGESTUDENTSWERE

SONGLASTWEEKh"E4RUETO9OUR3CHOOL vNOKIDDING INTERESTEDINGOVERNMENTJOBS 4HESEKIDSNEW FOUND
7ELL ITSOUNDSALITTLEDIFFERENTˆOKAY ALOTDIFFERENT INTERESTINCIVILSERVICECOULDNTCOMEATABETTERTIME
ˆTHANTHEWAYTHE"EACH"OYSSANGIT BUTTHESENTI !SOURSCHOOLSAREFACEDWITHAMASSIVEWAVEOFRETIRE
MENTISTHESAME MENTS WENOWHAVELOTOFBRIGHT EYED EAGERYOUNG
TEACHERSREADYTOlLLTHERANKS


!SNOTEDEARLIER BETWEENAND 53THGRADERSRESULTSONTHE4)--3SCIENCETESTINCREASEDSIGNIlCANTLYFROMANAVERAGESCORE
OFTO)NDEED THE53ISONEOFTHEFEWOFTHECOUNTRIESPARTICIPATINGINTHEASSESSMENTTHATHASDEMONSTRATEDSUSTAINEDIMPROVE
MENTINITS4)--3SCORES

3INCE 4HE.ATIONAL%LECTION3TUDIESATTHE5NIVERSITYOF-ICHIGANHASCONSTRUCTEDACOMPOSITEhTRUSTINGOVERNMENTvINDEXBASED
ON!MERICANSRESPONSESTOTHEFOLLOWINGQUESTIONS (OWMUCHOFTHETIMEDOYOUTHINKYOUCANTRUSTTHEGOVERNMENTIN7ASHINGTONTODO
WHATISRIGHTˆJUSTABOUTALWAYS MOSTOFTHETIMEORONLYSOMEOFTHETIME 7OULDYOUSAYTHEGOVERNMENTISPRETTYMUCHRUNBYAFEWBIG
INTERESTSLOOKINGOUTFORTHEMSELVESORTHATITISRUNFORTHEBENElTOFALLTHEPEOPLE $OYOUTHINKTHATPEOPLEINTHEGOVERNMENTWASTEALOT
OFMONEYWEPAYINTAXES WASTESOMEOFIT ORDONTWASTEVERYMUCHOFIT4HEHIGHERTHESCOREONTHEINDEX THEMOREPOSITIVE!MERICANSFEEL
ABOUTTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENT!FTERPEAKINGINATASCOREOF THEINDEXFELLOVERTHENEXTQUARTERCENTURYTOALOWOFIN3INCE
THATTIME ITHASBEENCLIMBINGAGAIN RISINGTOIN3OURCE.ATIONAL%LECTION3TUDIES HTTPWWWUMICHEDU^NESNESGUIDETOPTABLE
TABA?HTM

!SURVEYCONDUCTEDFORTHE0ANETTA)NSTITUTEFOUNDTHATOFCOLLEGESTUDENTSREPORTEDBEINGVERYORFAIRLYINTERESTEDINWORKING
FORGOVERNMENTˆASTATISTICALLYINSIGNIlCANTCHANGEFROMWHENTHECORRESPONDINGPERCENTAGEWAS3OURCE0ETER$(ART2ESEARCH
!SSOCIATES-AY !TTITUDES 0OLITICS AND0UBLIC3ERVICE!3URVEY/F!MERICAN#OLLEGE3TUDENTS7ASHINGTON $#0ANETTA)NSTITUTEFOR
0UBLIC0OLICY


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

3CHOOLDISTRICTSWITHERONTHE 'OVERNMENT
VINE
h7HATDOESNT
4HEPASTSEVERALYEARSHAVEBEENHARDONMANY KILLYOUv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
SCHOOLDISTRICTS7ITHSTATESINCREASINGLYSEEKINGTO
REPLACEEDUCATIONFUNDINGTHROUGHLOCALPROPERTYTAXES 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
WITHMOREEQUITABLEMEANS THEYHAVEBEGUNTOCONTROL
INCREASINGLYLARGEPERCENTAGESOFSCHOOLFUNDINGˆAS
MUCHASPERCENTINSOMESTATES-ANYSTATES ASYOU
KNOW HAVEINCREASEDSALESTAXES WHICH INTURN HAVE
PUTTREMENDOUSPOLITICALPRESSUREONLOCALAUTHORITIES .ON 'OVERNMENT
TOSIGNIlCANTLYREDUCETHEIROWNPROPERTYTAXES!SA
RESULT STATESARETHENEWLOCUSOFCONTROLINEDUCATION
SINCETHEYHOLDMOSTOFTHEPURSESTRINGS
3CHOOLBOARDSHAVEALSOBECOMEINCREASINGLYMAR &ORDISTRICTS THEOLDPHRASEˆNECESSITYISTHE
GINALPLAYERSINEDUCATION)NSOMEPLACES THEYSIMPLY MOTHEROFINVENTIONˆCERTAINLYRINGSTRUE/R
SERVEASOMBUDS PERHAPS NECESSITYISTHEMOTHEROFRE INVENTION MIGHT
MENˆPLACES BEMOREACCURATE7EVESEENDISTRICTSRE INVENTTHEM
WHEREPARENTS SELVESASPURCHASINGCO OPS!NDSOMEOFTHEMORE
CANLODGECOM ENTREPRENEURIALONESˆ)MTHINKINGOFACOUPLEIN
PLAINTSABOUT !RIZONAˆHAVEFOUNDNEWWAYSTOSTAYAmOATBYPRO
SCHOOLFRAUD VIDINGCONSULTINGANDTRAININGSERVICESTOSCHOOLSBOTH
ORWRONGFUL INSIDEANDOUTSIDEWHATHADONCEBEENTHEIRDISTRICTS
EXPULSION THAT $ISTRICTSHAVE INFACT BECOMESOMEOFMYBIGGEST
SORTOFTHING COMPETITORSFORCONSULTINGSERVICESINALOTOFMARKETS
!FEWBOARDS 3ONOWWE
ESPECIALLYTHOSE RETURNTOTHEPRESENT
WHOGRANTED DAY WHEREWECAN
CHARTERSTHEMSELVESINSTEADOFHAVINGTHEMGRANTED OOKOVERAlELDOF
THROUGHSTATEAGENCIES HAVERETAINEDSOMECONTROL EDUCATIONTHATLOOKS
OVERSCHOOLS SERVINGASAUDITORSWITHTHEAUTHORITYTO FARDIFFERENTTHAN
REVOKE ORRECOMMENDSTATESREVOKE ASCHOOLSCHARTER TDIDYEARSAGO
)NALOTOFPLACES THEYSERVEMOREASPROPERTYMANAGERS #LEARLY THEMOSTIN
RENTINGBUILDINGSTOCHARTERSCHOOLS!SARESULTOFTHEIR ERESTINGCHANGETHAT
DIMINISHEDSTATURE AGROWINGNUMBEROFSCHOOLBOARDS HASOCCURREDOVERTHE
CANTEVENlNDPEOPLETOSERVEONTHEM PASTYEARSISTHAT
3OMEMOURNTHISLOSSOFhLOCALCONTROL vWHILE PUBLICSCHOOLCHOICE
OTHERSCELEBRATEITSINCETHEYFEELITMAKESSCHOOLS HASCOMETOFULLFRUITION.OW)KNOWTHATMANYOFUS
LESSSUBJECTTOTHEWHIMSOFLOCALPOLITICS)NREALITY ) INPUBLICEDUCATION MYSELFINCLUDED ORIGINALLYVIEWED
THINKTHATWEVESEENTHATPLENTYOFLOCALPOLITICSSTILL CHOICEPROGRAMS INCLUDINGCHARTERSCHOOLSASASERIOUS
REMAINSINEDUCATION/NLYNOWADAYSITSATTHESCHOOL THREATTOPUBLICEDUCATION
LEVELINTHEFORMOFCHARTERSCHOOLBOARDS7EAREALSO -ANYDECADESAGO SOMEPEOPLEINTHISCOUNTRY
SEEINGMORELOCALCONTROLOFEDUCATIONTODAYTHANAT HELDASIMILARLYDIMVIEWOFLABORUNIONS WHICHTHEY
ANYTIMEINHISTORY SAWASTHEBEGINNINGOFASLIPPERYSLOPETOWARD#OM
MUNISM)NHINDSIGHT THOUGH MANYHISTORIANSˆIN
CLUDINGSOMEFRUSTRATED)TALIAN-ARXISTSWHODEVELOPED

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

THETHEORYOFHEGEMONYTOEXPLAINWHY#OMMUNISM FORPROVIDERSOFRESEARCH BASEDPRODUCTSANDSERVICES


NEVERTOOKROOTIN7ESTERN%UROPEANDTHE5NITED 4HEKINDSOFBRANDEDPRODUCTSTHESESCHOOLSMIGHTlND
3TATESˆHAVECONCLUDEDTHATBYRAISINGLIVINGCONDI ATTRACTIVEAREMATERIALSTOOLSFORTEACHINGCONTENTAREA
TIONSFORWORKERSANDDIFFUSINGTHEIRANGST LABORUNIONS READINGSKILLS MATHANDSCIENCEKNOWLEDGE ANDST
MAYHAVEHELPEDTOPREVENTTHERISEOF#OMMUNISMIN CENTURYLEARNINGSKILLS4HESECONDAUDIENCEISPARENTS
THOSECOUNTRIES TOWHOMPROVIDERSWILLNEEDTOPROMOTETHEIRPRODUCTS
3O TOO ITSEEMSTHATINHINDSIGHT CHARTERSCHOOLS ANDSERVICESASTHEhADDEDVALUEvTHEYARESEEKINGIN
RATHERTHANSENDINGUSDOWNASLIPPERYSLOPETOWARD THESCHOOLSINWHICHTHEYENROLLTHEIRCHILDREN
PRIVATIZEDEDUCATION ASTHETEACHERUNIONSHADARGUED )NTHISWORLDROLESOFTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTARETO
MAYHAVEACTUALLYDIFFUSEDTHEPUBLICANGSTABOUT FUNDEDUCATIONRESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTANDTODES
PUBLICSCHOOLSTHATHADBEENBREWINGFORSEVERALYEARS IGNATEPREFERREDPROVIDERSOFRESEARCH BASEDPRODUCTS
ANDINSODOING INCREASEDSUPPORTFORPUBLICFUNDINGOF ANDSERVICES4HEEXPECTEDRESULTOF2$PROGRAMS
EDUCATIONˆWHICHINTHEEND )WOULDARGUE ISREALLY WILLBETHEKINDOFLOW COST EASILYUTILIZED RESEARCH
WHATWEWEREALLlGHTINGTOSAVE BASEDPRODUCTSANDSERVICESTHATINDIVIDUALSCHOOLSCAN
3OINCLOSING)OFFERTHEFOLLOWINGOBSERVATION AFFORD
WHICH CLICH£DTHOUGHITMAYBE NONETHELESSSEEMSTO
SUMMARIZETHEPASTDECADEFORPUBLICLYFUNDEDEDUCA )NDICATORS
TIONPROVIDERSh7HATDOESNTKILLYOUxONLYMAKES
4HEFOLLOWINGTRENDSANDEVENTSAREPOSSIBLE
YOUSTRONGERv
INDICATORSTHATTHEFUTUREMAYBEMOVINGTOWARDTHIS
SCENARIO
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO s 2APIDGROWTHOFCHARTERSCHOOLS MOSTLIKELY
)MPLICATIONS CREATEDBYAGROWINGNUMBEROF.#," RELATED
STATETAKEOVERSOFhFAILINGvSCHOOLS
4HISISAWORLDINWHICHPARENTSARETHEPRIMARYAU
DIENCEFORSCHOOLSASTHEYSEEKTOENROLLTHEIRCHILDREN s 2E AUTHORIZED.#,"RETAINSADEQUATESANCTIONS
INSCHOOLSPROGRAMSMOSTCLOSELYALIGNEDWITHTHEIR TOPROMOTETHEEXPANSIONOFALTERNATIVE PUBLICLY
ASPIRATIONSFORTHEIRCHILDRENANDTHEIRPERSONALVALUES FUNDEDMODELSOFEDUCATION
4HISISNOTAWORLDINWHICHTIMEANDENERGYISSPENT
ONhSCHOOLIMPROVEMENTvASITHASBEENUNDERSTOOD s )NCREASINGEVIDENCETHATCHARTERSCHOOLSARE
THROUGHTHE@S @S ANDlRSTHALFOFTHECURRENT EFFECTIVEINRAISINGSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTAND
DECADE3CHOOLSOFVARIOUSTYPESARECOMMITTEDTO SATISFYINGSTUDENTANDPARENTNEEDS
CONTINUOUSIMPROVEMENT LIKEOTHERBUSINESSESINTHE s 2APIDEXPANSIONOFSTRUCTURED REGULATEDVOUCHER
SERVICESECTOR2ATHERTHANSCHOOLSPROMOTINGTHEM ANDORPRIVATESCHOOLTAXCREDITPROGRAMS
SELVESTOTHEGENERALPUBLIC THEYMARKETANDSELLTO DESIGNEDTOPROMOTEEQUITABLEEDUCATIONFUNDING
NICHESWITHINTHEEDUCATIONMARKET
)NTHISWORLD THEREARETWOAUDIENCESFORPROVID s 0OLITICALASCENDANCYOFMODERATEPOLITICIANSWHO
ERSOFRESEARCH BASEDPRODUCTSANDSERVICES&IRSTARE VIEWLESSDIRECTIVEEDUCATIONPOLICYASASOLUTION
THOSERUNNINGTHEVARIETYOFSCHOOLSTHATHAVEEMERGED TOTHENATIONSCULTURALWARSEG SCHOOLRESULTS
4HEYWILLBEINTERESTEDINLOW COST KNOWLEDGE EM MATTERMORETHANREGULATIONS 
BEDDED hPLUGANDPLAYvRESOURCESFORINCREASING
s 3HIFTINGPUBLICANDPOLITICALDEBATETOWARDSAVING
PRODUCTIVITY)TISLIKELYSCHOOLSWILLSEEKTODISTINGUISH
PUBLICFUNDINGOFSCHOOLS RATHERTHANSAVING
THEMSELVESFROMOTHERSBASEDONPUBLICLYACCEPTEDEN
PUBLICSCHOOLS
DORSEMENTS THEEQUIVALENTOFAh'OOD(OUSEKEEPING
3EALOF!PPROVALvANDORTHEBRANDSOFPRODUCTSAND s )NCREASINGPUBLICCONlDENCEINGOVERNMENTAND
SERVICESTHEYAREUSING4HISMAYPROVIDEOPPORTUNITIES INNEWMODELSOFPUBLICSCHOOLS


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

/PTIONS 'OVERNMENT

0ROVIDERSOFRESEARCH BASEDPRODUCTSANDSERVICES
h7HATDOESNT
MUSTDETERMINEINTHISWORLDIFTHEYINTENDTOCOMPETE KILLYOUv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
ASSCHOOLSORSELLTOALLORASETOFTHECOMPETITORS0RO
VIDERSTHATCHOOSETOCOMPETEASASCHOOLEDUCATIONAL 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
PROGRAMWILLHAVETOMAKEDECISIONSONALLOFTHE
VARIABLESTHATIMPACTLEARNINGINFORMALEDUCATIONAL
SETTINGS
0ROVIDERSTHATCHOOSETOSELLTOSCHOOLSRATHERTHAN
COMPETEWITHTHEMWILLNEEDTOBECLEARONHOWTHEIR .ON 'OVERNMENT
PRODUCTSANDSERVICESADDSUFlCIENTVALUETOSCHOOLSTO
MAKETHEMMORECOMPETITIVE&OREXAMPLE THEYMIGHT
ADDVALUEBY
)NTHISWORLDPROVIDERSWILL
s %STABLISHINGTHEIROWN RECOGNIZABLEBRANDAND
CUSTOMERIE PARENT DEMANDFORTHEIRPRODUCTS s $EVELOPSALES FULlLLMENT ANDDISTRIBUTION
ANDORSERVICES CAPACITYORESTABLISHRELATIONSHIPSWITHPUBLISHERS
OROTHERSWITHTHECAPABILITYTOREACHNATIONAL
s #O BRANDINGTHEIRPRODUCTSANDSERVICESWITH ANDINTERNATIONALCUSTOMERS
RECOGNIZABLESCHOOLBRANDSˆMUCHLIKE)NTELDID
WITHTHEh)NTELINSIDEvLOGOANDMOTTO s 0ROMOTETHEIRPRODUCTSANDSERVICESTOPARENTS
WHOWILLUSETHEMTODETERMINEWHICHSCHOOLS
s 0ROVIDINGOUTSIDEEVALUATIONACCREDITATION PROVIDETHEHIGHESTQUALITYPROGRAMSEGhWE
PROCESSESTHATEMULATEPROGRAMSLIKETHE"ALDRIGE DONTMAKETHESCHOOLS WEMAKETHEMBETTERv
AWARD
s /FFERLOW COSTPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTTO
s $ELIVERINGPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTTOSCHOOL SCHOOLPERSONNELINTERESTEDINPURCHASINGTHEIR
BOARDSANDSUPERINTENDENTSONHOWTOFULlLLTHE PRODUCTSFORUSEINTHEIRSCHOOLS
NEWROLESINWHICHTHEYWILLlNDTHEMSELVESAS
CORPORATEDIRECTORSANDPORTFOLIOMANAGERS s $EMONSTRATEANABILITYTOSATISFYGOVERNMENT
STANDARDS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

3CHOOLS5NLIMITEDCOM)F 'OVERNMENT

9OU7ANT3OMETHING$ONE
2IGHT

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
$EEP#AUSES
)NTHISSCENARIO GOVERNMENTHASLIMITEDORNOCONTROL
OVERTHEEDUCATIONMARKET WHICHOFFERSMANYCHOICES h)FYOUWANT
SOMETHINGDONE
TOPARENTSANDSTUDENTS4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSES RIGHTv
COULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO
.ON 'OVERNMENT
0UBLICSCHOOLSFAILORAREPERCEIVEDTOFAILINEF
FECTIVELYEDUCATINGSTUDENTS WHILENON PUBLIC
SCHOOLMODELSARESEENASSUCCESSFUL
-YMOTHER WHOWASASUCCESSFULCORPORATEATTORNEY
0ARENTS ACCUSTOMEDTOCHOICESANDCUSTOMIZA HEREIN#HICAGO ALWAYSUSEDTOSAY h)FYOUWANTSOME
TIONINOTHERMARKETS INCREASINGLYEXPECTTHE THINGDONERIGHT DOITYOURSELFv-EANWHILE MYFATHER
SAMELEVELOFCHOICEANDCUSTOMIZATIONINTHE WHOWASTIREDOFHERCOMINGINTHEDOORATPM
EDUCATIONMARKETPLACE ALWAYSUSEDTOSTAY h)FYOUWANTYOURDINNERWHILEITS
STILLWARM DELEGATEv
%CONOMICDOWNTURNANDORINCREASINGGOVERN 4HERESSOMETRUTHPROBABLYINBOTHSAYINGS"UTAS
MENTOBLIGATIONSINOTHERAREASEG 3OCIAL )PREPAREDMYREMARKSFORTONIGHT )KEPTCOMINGBACK
3ECURITYANDHEALTHCARE CAUSESEDUCATIONTO TOMYMOTHERSWORDSˆWHICH)BELIEVEAREBOTHGOOD
BECOMELESSOFAFUNDINGPRIORITYFORGOVERNMENT ADVICEANDACALLTOACTIONFORUSHEREATTHE4HIRD
RESULTINGINCUTSTOPUBLICFUNDINGOFEDUCATION
h)F9OU7ANT3OMETHING$ONE
0RAGMATIC'EN 8PARENTS MORECONCERNEDABOUT 2IGHTv
THEIROWNCHILDRENTHANABSTRACTPRINCIPLESSUCH 4IME3EPTEMBER 
AShTHEPUBLICGOOD vWALKAWAYFROMPUBLIC
SCHOOLS 0LACE#HICAGO ),
3CENE4HE#%/OF!CCELERATED,EARNING-ATERIALS
6OUCHERSWEIGHTEDACCORDINGTOSTUDENTNEED +RISTEN*ENSEN ISGIVINGTHEKEYNOTEADDRESSATTHE
BECOMETHEPREFERREDMECHANISMFORCREATING 4HIRD!NNUAL%DUCATION#URRICULUMAND3OFTWARE
EQUITABLEFUNDINGOFEDUCATION %XPO
/FF THE SHELF HIGH QUALITYEDUCATIONRESOURCES !NNUAL%DUCATION#URRICULUM3OFTWARE%XPO
ENABLESTUDENTSTOLEARNINAVARIETYOFSETTINGS )TSHARDTOBELIEVETHISISOURTHIRDEVENT3OMUCHHAS
AND CHANGEDOVERTHEPASTTHREEYEARSTHECHANGESINEDU
,IMITEDFUNDINGFOREDUCATIONDISSUADESLARGE CATIONHAVEBEENTRULYASTOUNDING)KNOWTHESEARE
COMPANIESFROMENTERINGANDDOMINATINGTHE UNCERTAINTIMESFORMANYOFUS)SAYTHATASABUSINESS
MARKETASARESULT SCHOOLINGISDELIVEREDBYA PERSON ANEDUCATOR ANDAPARENT
HODGE PODGEOFGENERALLYSMALLPROVIDERSEG 3OMETIMES WHENCHANGEISSWIRLINGALLAROUNDYOU
FAITH BASEDINSTITUTIONS PARENTS EDUCATIONAL THEBESTTHINGTODOISTAKEADEEPBREATHANDGETSOME
SOFTWARECOMPANIES ETC  CONTEXTFORWHATSHAPPENING)NOTHERWORDS ITSHARD
TOKNOWWHEREYOUREGOINGIFYOUDONTREMEMBER
WHEREYOUVEBEEN3OTOHELPUSALLTAKESTOCKOFTHE


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

CHANGESWERESEEINGANDMAYCONTINUETOSEEINTHE SCHOOLSWERECLOSED  STUDENTSPULLEDOUTOFTHEIR


WORLDOFEDUCATION )DLIKETOREVIEWTHEPASTYEARS NEIGHBORHOODPUBLICSCHOOLS RESULTINGINONEPRO
OFEDUCATIONAND VIDEROPENINGNEWCHARTERSCHOOLSINASINGLEYEAR
DESCRIBEHOWOURlELD h#HARTERS HAVEAMORESTRUCTUREDENVIRONMENT)TIS
HASGONEFROMONE MOREPERSONABLE vPARENT,A3ONYA"UCKINESTOLD4HE
DOMINATEDBYAGOV $ETROIT.EWS,IKEWISE IN#INCINNATI AGROWING
ERNMENT CONTROLLED NUMBEROF!FRICAN !MERICANS DISSATISlEDWITHTHE
MONOPOLYTOAFULLY SERVICESTHEIRCHILDRENWERERECEIVINGINPUBLICSCHOOLS
PRIVATIZEDMARKET WEREJOININGTHEBURGEONINGHOME SCHOOLMOVEMENT
ONEFULLOFPOSSIBILI !LLOFTHISISTOSAYTHATASEARLYASAND
TIESFORTHEFUTURE PARENTSWEREASSERTINGMOREANDMORECONTROLOVER
SCHOOLS hVOTINGWITHTHEIRFEETvASTHEYSAY-OREOVER
DESPITEMIXEDRESULTSFORCHARTERSCHOOLS THEPUBLIC
DEMANDFORALTERNATIVESTOREGULARPUBLICSCHOOLSWAS
FAREXCEEDINGSUPPLY

0UBLICSCHOOLALTERNATIVESON
THERISE
)N THE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONRE
LEASEDASTATISTICTHATMAYHAVESTARTLEDSOMEPUBLIC
SCHOOLEDUCATORSTHENUMBEROFCHILDRENHOME
SCHOOLEDINTHECOUNTRYHADPASSEDTHEONEMILLION
MARK GROWINGPERCENTINFOURYEARS7HENSUR
VEYED PARENTSOFTHESECHILDREN WHOREPRESENTED
DEMANDvSERVICES
PERCENTOFTHESCHOOL AGEPOPULATION CITEDTHREEMAIN
REASONSFORDECIDINGTOEDUCATETHEIRCHILDRENATHOME )NEVERYOTHERASPECTOFTHEIRLIVESˆDINING
 CONCERNSABOUTTHEENVIRONMENTOFREGULARSCHOOLS CLOTHING TRANSPORTATION ENTERTAINMENTˆYOUNAME
  mEXIBILITYTOTEACHRELIGIOUSORMORALLESSONS IT PEOPLEWEREGROWINGMOREANDMOREACCUSTOMED
 ANDDISSATISFACTIONWITHACADEMICINSTRUCTIONAT TOMULTIPLECHOICESANDGETTINGWHATTHEYWANTED
OTHERSCHOOLS  WHENTHEYWANTEDIT4HEYWEREALSORECEIVINGINCREAS
!TTHESAMETIME AGROWINGNUMBEROFPARENTS INGLYINDIVIDUALIZEDSERVICES!MAZONAND.ETmIX FOR
WEREPUTTINGTHEIRCHILDRENINTOCHARTERSCHOOLS&OR EXAMPLE WERECREATINGTAILOREDSUGGESTIONSFORBOOKS
EXAMPLE IN$ETROIT WHEREARECORDREGULARPUBLIC TOBUYANDMOVIESTORENT RESPECTIVELY


0RINCIOTTA $ "IELICK 3 %33) AND#HAPMAN #!UGUST -ILLION(OMESCHOOLED3TUDENTSINTHE5NITED3TATESIN
7ASHINGTON $#.ATIONAL#ENTERFOR%DUCATION3TATISTICS 53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONHTTPNCESEDGOVPUBSEARCHPUBSINFOASPPUBID


)BID

-AC$ONALD #-ARCH  h-ORE0ARENTS0ULL+IDS/UTOF$ETROIT3CHOOLS 4RY#HARTERS v4HE$ETROIT.EWSHTTPWWWDETNEWSCOM
SCHOOLS$ HTM

)N-ARCH THE#INCINNATI)NQUIRERREPORTEDTHATNATIONWIDE  BLACKCHILDRENLEARNEDATHOMEINˆROUGHLYPERCENTOFTHE
NATIONSMILLIONHOMESCHOOLERS&RUSTRATEDWITHPUBLICSCHOOLS BLACKPARENTSJOINTHEMOVEMENTTOEDUCATECHILDRENTHEMSELVES*OYCE"URGES
FOUNDEROFTHE.ATIONAL"LACK(OME%DUCATORS2ESOURCE!SSOCIATIONIN"AKER ,A SAIDTHATHOMESCHOOLINGHASBECOMEACIVILRIGHTSMOVEMENT
FORBLACKPARENTSTRYINGTOTAKEBACKTHEIRCHILDRENSEDUCATIONh7ITHINlVEYEARS THERESGOINGTOBEANEXPLOSIONxOFPARENT DIRECTEDLEARN
ING vSHEPREDICTED3OURCE3MITH!MOS$ -ARCH  h-ORE!FRICAN !MERICANS4URNTO(OME3CHOOLING v#INCINNATI)NQUIRERHTTP
NEWSENQUIRERCOMAPPSPBCSDLLARTICLE!)$.%73NEWS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

)NADDITION MOREANDMORERETAILSERVICESWERE 'OVERNMENT


BECOMINGhONDEMANDv.APSTER I4UNES ANDOTHER
MUSICVENDORSWERESATISFYINGAMUSICLISTENERSWHIMS
BYPROVIDINGPLACESFORTHEMTOBUYAFAVORITESONGFOR

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
LESSTHANADOLLARANDBELISTENINGTOITAMINUTELATER 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
ONTHEIRI0OD3IMILARLY CABLE SATELLITE ANDCOM
PUTERCOMPANIESWEREMAKINGITINCREASINGLYSIMPLE
ANDCHEAPTOPURCHASEMOVIESONDEMAND.OMORE h)FYOUWANT
SOMETHINGDONE
RIGHTv

.ON 'OVERNMENT

SCHOOLEDUCATORSTRIEDTOEXPLAINWHATTHEYDEEMEDTO
BETHEUNREASONABLEEXPECTATIONSOF.#," ANINCREAS
INGLYSKEPTICALGENERALPUBLICSAWTHEIREXPLANATIONS
MERELYASEXCUSESFORBEINGUNABLETODELIVERWHATTHE
PRIVATESECTORAPPEAREDTOBEPOISEDTODELIVERˆA
HIGHER QUALITY TAILOREDEDUCATIONFOREVERYSTUDENT

WAITINGINALONGLINEATTHEVIDEOSTOREONA&RIDAY 2IGHTSOLUTION WRONGPROBLEM


NIGHT3IMPLYDOWNLOADAMOVIEONTOYOURMULTI )NALLFAIRNESSTOPUBLICSCHOOLS WHICHWERERUNBY
MEDIACOMPUTER TURNONYOUR46 ANDDIMTHELIGHTS MANYWELL INTENTIONED INTELLIGENTPEOPLE OURSCHOOLS
)NSHORT TECHNOLOGYWASHELPINGOTHERSECTORS WEREDESIGNEDTOPROVIDESOMETHINGWHICHWASREALLY
PROVIDEHIGHLYRESPONSIVESERVICESTOCONSUMERS)N NOLONGERDESIRABLETOTHEGENERALPUBLICˆASTANDARD
CONTRAST PUBLICSCHOOLSWERESLOWTOOFFERTHESAME IZEDEDUCATION4HESTANDARDSMOVEMENTOFTHES
NUMBEROFCHOICESANDTAILOREDRESPONSIVENESS!NDSO ANDEARLYSWASDESIGNEDTOIMPROVETHEACADEMIC
BY THEFORCESTHATWOULDLEADTOTHERAPIDDEMISE RIGOROFPUBLICSCHOOLS BUTPARENTSCHIEFCONCERNSWITH
OFPUBLICSCHOOLSWEREALREADYINPLACE INCLUDING
PARENTSDISSATISFACTIONWITHTHESAFETYANDACADEMICS
INPUBLICSCHOOLSASWELLASANINCREASINGPLETHORAOF
CHOICESAVAILABLEINOTHERINDUSTRIESANDTECHNOLOGY
DRIVENhONDEMANDvSERVICES
&INALLY THELASTNAILINTHECOFlNFORPUBLICSCHOOLS
WHICHWASALREADYINPLACEEARLYONINTHEDECADE WAS
THE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT.#," 0UBLICSCHOOLS
EVENTHOSEINAFmUENTSUBURBS FOUNDTHEYWEREIN
CREASINGLYUNABLETOMEASUREUPTOTHERISINGBAROF
ADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESS.OMATTERHOWMUCHPUBLIC


4HROUGHASERIESOFFOCUSGROUPSCONDUCTEDINAND -C2%,LEARNEDTHAThPEOPLESCHIEFCONCERNSABOUTSCHOOLSWEREGENERALLY
ABOUTNON ACADEMICISSUESSUCHASSAFETY DISCIPLINE CHARACTER ANDVALUES0ARENTSWEREFARMOREWORRIEDABOUT@CHAOSONTHEPLAYGROUNDS @BUL
LYINGORAGENERAL@LACKOFCONTROLINPUBLICSCHOOLS THANTESTRESULTSvP 'OODWIN " $IGGING$EEPER7HERE$OESTHE0UBLIC3TANDON
0UBLIC%DUCATION!URORA #/-C2%,


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

SCHOOLSCENTEREDMOREONNON ACADEMICISSUES SUCHAS OUTRAGEDSUBURBANPARENTSASTHEIRSCHOOLSWEREPLACED


VALUESANDTHEEXTENTTOWHICHSCHOOLSHELPCHILDREN ONWATCHLISTSNEVERMATERIALIZED
DEVELOPTHEIROWNUNIQUE ANDOFTENNON ACADEMIC )NSTEAD PARENTSAPPEAREDALLTOOANXIOUSTOENROLL
TALENTS THEIRCHILDRENINPAROCHIAL CHURCH ORPRIVATESCHOOLS
3OWHILEPUBLICSCHOOLSWORKEDFRANTICALLYAND h)TWASADECENTSCHOOL)LIKEDSOMEOFTHETEACHERS
FORTHEMOSTPART SUCCESSFULLY TOIMPROVETESTSCORES "UTITWASTOOBIGFORITSOWNGOOD)KNOW+ATIEWAS
PARENTSGENERALLYHADOTHERPRIORITIES4HEYWERELESS STARTINGTOFALLTHROUGHTHECRACKS v$IANE2OSEN A
CONCERNEDABOUTGOODTESTSCORES ANDMOREWITH MOTHERFROM$ENTON 4EXAS TOLDTHE$ALLAS-ORNING
WHETHERSCHOOLSPROVIDEDASAFEPLACEFORTHEIRCHILDREN .EWSAFTERHERDAUGHTERSPUBLICSCHOOLWASCLOSED
WHERETHEYCOULDDEVELOPSTRONG POSITIVEVALUES AND h)VEENROLLEDHERINACHURCHSCHOOLDOWNTHESTREET
THEIROWNUNIQUETALENTS0UBLICSCHOOLS MEANWHILE WHICHSHOULDBEGOODFORHER)MEAN SHENEEDSTOGET
WHICHREMAINEDFOCUSEDONRAISINGTESTSCORES WERE RELIGIONSOMEWHERE AND,ORDKNOWSSHESNOTGETTING
ESSENTIALLYJOUSTINGWINDMILLSASFARASTHEPUBLICWAS ITFROMHOMEv
CONCERNED
0UBLICEDUCATIONSDEATHBYA
THOUSANDCUTS
"Y ANUMBEROFFACTORSSTARTEDTOCONVERGE
&ORSTARTERS PARENTSWEREINCREASINGLYLOSINGFAITHIN
PUBLICSCHOOLSˆFOSTERED INPART BYACONTINUED
STRINGOFHEADLINESSAYINGTHATPUBLICSCHOOLSWERE
FAILING!SYOUKNOW MOSTPEOPLEWEREJUSTSKIMMING
THEHEADLINESANDFAILEDTOREADTHEACTUALARTICLES
BELOWTHEMWHICHSAIDTHAT OVERALL STUDENTTEST
SCORESWEREIMPROVING YETBECAUSEOFTHERISINGBAROF
!90ANDLOWPERFORMANCEOFAFEWSUBGROUPSˆENTIRE
SCHOOLSWEREGETTINGLABELEDAShFAILINGv
!LSO PEOPLEHEARDWHATTHEYWANTEDTOHEAR
WHICHWASTHATIFTHEIRSCHOOLACTUALLYFAILEDALTO
GETHER THEYDGETANEWSCHOOLORMORECHOICES!ND
THATSREALLYWHATTHEYWANTEDˆMORECHOICES4HEY
WANTEDTHESAMEFREEDOMANDNUMBEROFCHOICESIN
THEEDUCATIONMARKETTHATTHEYFOUNDINOTHERMARKETS
3OASMOREANDMORESCHOOLSˆINCLUDINGTHOSE )NFACT YOUSTARTEDSEEINGPARENTSACTUALLYPULLINGTHEIR
INAFmUENTSUBURBSˆFAILEDTOMEETTHE!90PROVI KIDSOUTOFSCHOOLONTESTDAY SOTHATTHEIRKIDSWOULD
SIONSOF.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND PARENTSANDTHEGENERAL GETCOUNTEDASAZEROONTHESTATETESTANDTHESCHOOL
PUBLICSEEMEDCONTENTTOSTANDIDLYBY LIKE.ERO WOULDGETCONVERTEDINTOACHARTER
PLAYINGTHElDDLEAS2OMEBURNED ASTHEYWATCHED 2EBECCA(ERNANDEZ AWOMANINTERVIEWEDBY53!
PUBLICSCHOOLSCOLLAPSEUNDERTHEWEIGHTOF.#," 4ODAYMAGAZINEPUTITTHISWAYh)CANGOTOTHEGROCERY
4HEHUEANDCRYTHATSOMEEDUCATORSEXPECTEDFROM STOREANDCHOOSEFROMDIFFERENTVARIETIESOFLAUNDRY


)N-ARCH THE!URORA#OLORADO 3UN3ENTINELREPORTEDTHATPARENTS ANGEREDBYTHE!URORA0UBLIC3CHOOLSDECISIONTOCLOSEADUAL
IMMERSIONSCHOOLONACCOUNTOFNOTBEINGABLETOSTAFFTHESCHOOLWITHHIGHLYQUALIlEDTEACHERS PULLEDTHEIRCHILDRENOUTOFSCHOOLDURINGTHE
STATEWIDEASSESSMENT)NALL STUDENTSMISSEDTHETESTANDWERECOUNTEDASZEROES ENSURINGTHATTHESCHOOL WHICHHADALREADYFAILEDTOMEET
THEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESSFORTWOYEARSINAROW WASONEYEARCLOSERTOBEINGCONVERTEDTOCHARTERSTATUS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

DETERGENT SOITSNICETOHAVEATLEASTAFEWDIFFERENT 'OVERNMENT


CHOICESWHENITCOMESTOTHEMOSTIMPORTANTDECI
SION)CANMAKEINMYLIFEˆWHERETOSENDMYKIDSTO
SCHOOLv

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
!TTHESAMETIMETHATSCHOOLSWERESTRUGGLING 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
TOMEETTHEREQUIREMENTSOF.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
GOVERNMENTATALLLEVELSWASHAVINGAHARDERTIME
MAKINGENDSMEET3OCIAL3ECURITY WHICHHADBEEN h)FYOUWANT
SOMETINGDONE
PUTONTHENATIONALRADARTWOYEARSBEFOREBY0RESIDENT RIGHTv
"USH WASFARFROMBEINGSOLVEDANDWITHEVERYPASSING
.ON 'OVERNMENT

WASGROWING
MOREACUTE!T
HESAMETIME NEGLECTEDBYTHEIRELDERSWASHARDLYANYTHINGNEW3O
-EDICAREAND WEDIDNTPROTESTNEARLYASLOUDLYASBABYBOOMERS
-EDICAIDWERE WOULDVEIFPOLITICIANSHADMADETHESAMEDEEPCUTSTO
AKINGEVERLARGER EDUCATIONBACKWHENTHEIRKIDSWEREINSCHOOL
BITESOUTOF
TATEANDFEDERAL 6OUCHERSSPREADLIKEWILDlRE
BUDGETS2OADSWEREDETERIORATING OURMILITARYEFFORTS
9OUMAYRECALLTHE
WEREEXPANDINGTHROUGHOUTTHE-IDDLE%AST AND
FORESTlRESTHATPOPPEDUP
RISINGINTERESTRATESWERESUPPRESSINGTHEGROWTHOFTHE
EVERYWHEREOUT7ESTDURING
ECONOMY#OMBINETHISWITHTHEFACTTHATTHEYOUNGEST
HEDRYSUMMEROF
KIDSOFBABYBOOMERSWERENOWGRADUATINGFROMHIGH
4HEOTHERTHINGSTHATSPREAD
SCHOOLANDTHATTHENEWPARENTSOFSCHOOL AGECHILDREN
IKEWILDlREWEREVOUCHER
'EN 8ERS WEREAFARSMALLER ANDLESSPOLITICALLYACTIVE
PROGRAMSIN.EVADA
GROUPOFVOTERS!LLOFTHESETRENDSADDEDUPTOEDUCA
!RIZONA 5TAH #OLORADO
TIONNEARLYSLIPPINGOFFTHEPOLITICALRADARSCREEN
AND)DAHO0ERHAPSTHEMOST
3TARTINGINˆEARLIERINSOMESTATESAND
URPRISINGWASTHE#ALIFORNIA
LOCALESˆPUBLICEDUCATIONBEGANTODIEAhDEATHBY
REFERENDUMWHICHCREATED
ATHOUSANDCUTSv!TTHETIME SOMECOMMENTATORS
AVOUCHERPROGRAMINTHAT
EXPRESSEDFRUSTRATIONTHAT'EN 8ERSCOULDSOQUIETLY
TATEˆARGUABLYONEOFTHE
STANDBYASTHEYWATCHEDTHEIRSCHOOLFEESRISEAND
MOSTLIBERALSTATESINTHE
SUBSIDIZEDEDUCATIONFADEAWAY"UTFORALOTOF'EN
COUNTRY3OMEPROTESTEDTHATVOUCHERSWEREACTUALLY
8ERS WHOWERE LIKEME FORMERLATCH KEYKIDS BEING
ASHELLGAMEˆDESIGNEDTOBUYOFFPARENTSBYPUTTING


)N 4ED(ALSTEADAND-ICHAEL,INDOFTHE'EN 8THINKTANK 4HE.EW!MERICA&OUNDATION PROPOSEDASIMILARPOLICYINTHEIRPOLITI
CALMANIFESTO 4HE2ADICAL#ENTER(ALSTEADAND,INDARGUEDTHATATRUEVOUCHERPROGRAMˆONETHATCOVERSTHEFULLCOSTOFAHIGH QUALITY
EDUCATION ORMORE WOULDOVERCOMETHEINHERENTDISPARITIESOFANEDUCATIONSYSTEMFUNDEDTHROUGHLOCALPROPERTYTAXES)NLIGHTOFINEQ
UITIESAMONGSTATESWITHIMPOVERISHEDSTATES FOREXAMPLE SPENDINGFARLESSPERPUPILTHATWEALTHIERSTATES THEYCALLEDFORANATIONALIZEDVOUCHER
SYSTEM"UTSUCHASYSTEMWOULDREQUIREACOMPLICATED ANDPOTENTIALLYPOLITICALLYUNFEASIBLE SYSTEMOFFEDERALTAXCOLLECTIONANDRE DISTRIBUTION
(OWEVER (ALSTEADAND,INDNOTETHATANUMBEROFSTATESHAVEALREADYBEENFORCEDTHROUGHLITIGATIONTOEQUALIZEFUNDING THUSONEPOSSIBLE
SCENARIOTHATMIGHTUNFOLDISTHATSTATES NOTTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENT WOULDCREATEWEIGHTEDVOUCHERPROGRAMSINRESPONSETOCOURTORDERSTO
PROVIDEEQUITABLEFUNDINGOFEDUCATION3OURCE(ALSTEAD 4AND,IND - 4HE2ADICAL#ENTER4HE&UTUREOF!MERICAN0OLITICS.EW9ORK
$OUBLEDAY


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

MONEYINTHEIRHANDS USUALLYAROUND ˆWHILE SENDTHEIRCHILDRENTO


INEFFECT TAKINGMONEYOUTOFTHEIRPOCKETSBYDEPRIV REGULARSCHOOLSˆNOR
INGTHEIRCHILDRENOF PERCHILDWORTHINFREE DIDTHEYWANTTOAFTER
PUBLICSCHOOLING3TILL MOSTPARENTSSEEMEDCONTENTTO THETERRORISTATTACK
TAKETHEMONEYANDRUNTOAPRIVATESCHOOL ONTHEHIGHSCHOOL
-ORETHANANYTHINGELSE THEIDEAOFh2OBIN(OODv IN#RAWFORD 4EXAS
VOUCHERSˆVOUCHERSWEIGHTEDACCORDINGTOSTUDENT ˆSOTHEYNEEDEDHIGH
NEEDˆACCELERATEDTHEPROLIFERATIONOFVOUCHER QUALITYMATERIALSTHAT
PROGRAMS/NONEHAND THEIDEAAPPEALEDTOLIBERALS COULDBOTHTEACHTHEIR
BYCREATINGAMECHANISMFORENSURINGTHATSCHOOLSWITH CHILDRENANDTEACH
STUDENTSWITHHIGHERNEEDSˆFOREXAMPLE WITHMANY THEMHOWTOTEACH
KIDSRECEIVINGFREEANDREDUCED PRICEDLUNCHES ORWITH THEIRCHILDREN)THINK
LIMITED%NGLISHPROlCIENCY ORLEARNINGDISABILITIES THE#RAWFORDATTACKS
ˆHADADEQUATEINCENTIVESTOSERVEALLSTUDENTSWELL WHILELESSDEVASTATING
/NTHEOTHERHAND ITAPPEALEDTOCONSERVATIVES WHO INTERMSOFNUMBERS
HADLONGBEENINFAVOROFSCHOOLCHOICEANDVOUCHER ˆSTUDENTSANDFACULTYMEMBERSˆACTUALLYDID
ALOTMOREDAMAGETOTHE!MERICANPSYCHETHAN 
)FSOMETHINGLIKETHISCOULDHAPPENINSMALLTOWN
!MERICAˆJUSTMILESFROMTHE0RESIDENTSRANCH NO
ONEFELTSAFE!SYOUMAYRECALL THENEXTDAYNEARLY
PERCENTOFTHENATIONSSTUDENTSWEREREPORTEDABSENT
FROMSCHOOL-ANYOFTHEMNEVERCAMEBACKTOTHEIR
PUBLICSCHOOL
!T!CCELERATED,EARNING WEUNDERSTOODPARENTS
OFVIEW
CONCERNSFORTHESAFETYOFTHEIRCHILDREN ASWELLAS
h2OBIN(OODvVOUCHERSHELPEDMANYSTATESGETRELEASED
THEIRDESIRETOENSURETHATTHEIRCHILDRENGOTAGOOD
FROMCOURTORDERSREQUIRINGTHEMTOSPENDSIGNIlCANTLY
EDUCATIONATHOME3OWEBROUGHTTOGETHERCURRICULUM
MOREPUBLICDOLLARSTOPROVIDEADEQUATEANDEQUITABLE
DESIGNERS SOFTWAREENGINEERS EDUCATIONRESEARCHERS
EDUCATION
ANDFORMERTEACHERS LIKEMYSELF TOCREATEWHATWE
6OUCHERSWEREALSOCOUPLEDWITHTAXCREDITSTO
CALLEDhSELF EXECUTINGvMATERIALS4HEKEY OFCOURSE
OFFSETSOMEOFTHEADDITIONALEXPENDITURES BUTON
WASMAKINGOURCLASSROOMMATERIALSINTERESTINGFOR
AVERAGE STUDIESATTHETIMEFOUNDTHATPARENTSWERE
STUDENTSANDEASYFORPARENTSTOUNDERSTAND7EADDED
PAYING MOREPERCHILDOUTOFPOCKETEACHYEAR
COMPUTERIZED ADAPTIVEONLINEASSESSMENTSTHATKIDS
7HILEMOSTMIDDLEANDUPPER CLASSHOUSEHOLDSCOULD
COULDTAKEDURINGTHEYEARTOSEEHOWTHEYSTACKEDUP
lNDAWAYTOPAYANOTHERPERMONTHFORTHEIR
AGAINSTOTHERKIDSACROSSTHECOUNTRY
KIDS WORKINGPOORFAMILIESWEREPARTICULARLYHARDHIT
#HURCHESANDOTHERORGANIZATIONSTRIEDTOSTEPINAND
'OLDRUSH
SAVETHEDAY BUTMANYPARENTS ESPECIALLYTHOSEWITH
LARGERFAMILIES SMALLERINCOMES ORBOTHDECIDEDTHEY !SLATEAS CLOSETOPERCENTOF53STU
WEREBETTEROFFEDUCATINGTHEIRCHILDRENATHOMEˆOR DENTSATTENDEDPUBLICSCHOOLS&IVEYEARSLATER NEW
INSCHOOLINGhCO OPSv WHERENEIGHBORSWOULDCOME lGURESFROMTHE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONWOULD
TOGETHERTOTEACHTHEIRKIDSINEACHOTHERSBASEMENTS SHOWTHATLESSTHANTWO THIRDSOFSTUDENTSWERENOW
4HATSWHERE!CCELERATED,EARNING-ATERIALSSAW ATTENDINGPUBLICSCHOOLS)NSHORT INJUSTlVEYEARS
ABIGOPPORTUNITY0ARENTSNOWHAD INTHEIR NEARLYAQUARTEROFTHENATIONSPUBLICSCHOOLSTUDENTS
HANDSFOREACHCHILD!LOTOFTHEMCOULDNTAFFORDTO HADMOVEDFROMAPUBLICSCHOOLSETTINGTOAPRIVATE
ORHOME SCHOOLSETTING-EANWHILE ATTHELOCALLEVEL

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

SCHOOLDISTRICTS FACEDWITHMULTIPLESCHOOLCLOS 'OVERNMENT


INGS FOUNDTHEMSELVESINANEWBUSINESSREALESTATE
ˆEITHERSELLINGTHEIRSCHOOLSOUTRIGHTORRENTINGTHEM
OUTTOPRIVATECOMPANIES

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
!LTHOUGHANUMBEROFNEWSPAPEREDITORIALBOARDS 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
LAMENTEDTHELOSSOFPUBLICSCHOOLSANDTHERISEOF
INCREASINGLYINEQUITABLEEDUCATIONOPPORTUNITIES SOME
EDUCATIONENTREPRENEURSLIKE$AVID.ANCE WHORANA h)FYOUWANT
SOMETINGDONE
STRINGOFSCHOOLSINTHE3AN&RANCISCO"AYAREA NOTED RIGHTv
THAT h3OMEPEOPLESAYTHATWEVECREATEDTWOSCHOOL
.ON 'OVERNMENT
SYSTEMSˆONEFORTHEHAVESANDONEFORTHEHAVE NOTS
"UTFRANKLY WEVEALWAYSHADTWOSCHOOLSYSTEMSWE
JUSTHADADIFFERENTWAYOFDISTRIBUTINGTHEDOLLARS.OW
INSTEADOFBEINGFORCEDTOSENDTHEIRKIDSTOPARTICULAR ONTHEIRPENSIONPAYMENTS ANDSTATELAWMAKERS
SCHOOLSORPAYINTOASYSTEMTHEYDONTSUPPORT PEOPLE HADWELCHEDONTHEIRVOUCHEROBLIGATIONSTOPARENTS
CANCHOOSEWHERETHEIRKIDSLEARNANDWHICHSCHOOLS REPLACINGTHEMWITHFARLESSGENEROUSSTATEANDFEDERAL
TOSUPPORT'OODSCHOOLS LIKEOURS RAISELOTSOFDOLLARS TAXCREDITS4HEENTIRECHAINOFEVENTSPROMPTED4IME
INCHARITABLEFUNDINGBECAUSEPEOPLEBELIEVEINWHAT MAGAZINETOPUTASINGLEWORDONTHECOVEROFTHEIR
WEDO9OUCANTSAYTHESAMETHINGFORMOSTPUBLIC *ANUARY ISSUEh7ELCHv
SCHOOLSv )NTHEPLACEOFVOUCHERS MANYSTATESANDTHE53
)N YOUSAWALOTOFBIGCOMPANIESCOMINGIN #ONGRESSCREATEDTAXCREDITSFOREDUCATION WHICHWERE
HOPINGTORINGUPBIGSALESFROMTHENEWFREEMARKETOF NOTABADDEAL PROVIDEDYOUHADAJOB!T!CCELER
EDUCATION3OMELIKENED#ALIFORNIASVOUCHERPROGRAM ATED,EARNING-ATERIALS ANDOTHERSIMILARCOMPANIES)
ANDTHEMADRUSHTOTHEMARKETTHATFOLLOWEDTOTHE IMAGINE WEFOUNDPARENTSWEREBECOMINGINCREASINGLY
GOLDRUSHDAYSOFTHES"UTWITHTHECRASHOF FRUGALWITHTHEIRDOLLARS4HESEhEDUCATIONPAWNSHOPSv
THEMARKETINLATE THEEDUCATIONMARKETDRIED ˆUSEDEDUCATIONALMATERIALSSTORES SUCHASh"ACK
UPANDTHEhGOLDINTHEMTHARHILLSvSEEMEDTOTURN 3CHOOLvFRANCHISESˆWEREPOPPINGUPEVERYWHERE)N
ALMOSTOVERNIGHT INTOFOOLSGOLD  )NCMAGAZINERATEDh"ACK3CHOOLvFRANCHISES
THEhBESTBETv
&OOLSGOLD FORFRANCHISORS
!SYOUNODOUBTRECALL THEECONOMICCRASHOF
BROUGHTANOLDSLANGWORDBACKINTOTHE!MERICAN
VERNACULARhWELCHvˆASINTHE53HASWELCHEDON
ITSFOREIGNDEBTSBLUECHIPCOMPANIESHADWELCHED


)N-ARCH THE/RLANDO3ENTINELREPORTEDTHATNEARLYONE THIRDOF&LORIDASCHARTERSCHOOLSENDEDTHE SCHOOLYEARINTHERED
ˆUPFROMLESSTHANONE lFTHIN -OREOVER ITNOTEDTHATMOSTOFTHESCHOOLSINTHEREDWERERUNBYFOR PROlTMANAGEMENTCOMPANIES
!REVIEWCONDUCTEDBYTHESTATEOF&LORIDACONCLUDEDTHATHIGHSTART UPCOSTS INACCURATEENROLLMENTPROJECTIONS ANDADEARTHOFlNANCIAL MAN
AGEMENTEXPERTISEANDADMINISTRATIONBYMANAGEMENTCOMPANIESCONTRIBUTEDTOTHElNANCIALDIFlCULTIES3OURCE-C#LURE 6-ARCH  
2EPORTh#HARTER3CHOOL$EBT2ISES v/RLANDO3ENTINELHTTPWWWORLANDOSENTINELCOMNEWSLOCALSTATEORL LOCCHARTERMAR  
STORYCOLLORL NEWS HEADLINES STATECTRACKCSETTRUE

%DISON3CHOOLS)NCˆONEOFTHEVANGUARDSOFSCHOOLPRIVATIZATIONˆHASEXPERIENCEDAROCKYROAD)TSSTOCKPRICECLIMBEDTOPERSHARE
BEFOREPLUMMETINGINTOLESSTHANCENTSAFTERSKITTISHINVESTORSBOLTEDWHEN%DISONSEFFORTSTORUNMORETHANSCHOOLSINTHE0HILADEL
PHIAAREAENCOUNTEREDlERCEOPPOSITION RESULTINGINITSCONTRACTGETTINGPAREDDOWNTOJUSTSCHOOLS3OURCE&RONTLINE*ULY  h0UBLIC
3CHOOLS)NCvHTTPWWWPBSORGWGBHPAGESFRONTLINESHOWSEDISON


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

/VERTHEPASTFEWYEARS WEVESEENANUMBEROF &ORTUNATELY FORUSANDOURKIDS (ANSEN WHOM


BIGPLAYERSWHOHADORIGINALLYHOPEDTOMAKEALOTOF )KNOWISAVERYINTELLIGENTMAN TURNEDOUTTOBE
MONEYINTHEEDUCATIONMARKETBACKOUT DECIDING WRONG%DUCATIONISNTCONTROLLEDBYAFEWCORPORA
THATWHATLOOKEDLIKEAGOLDRUSHAFEWYEARSBEFORE TIONSITSCONTROLLEDBYPARENTS WHOAREEACHFREETO
HADTURNEDINTOFOOLSGOLD3IMPLYPUT ASEVERYONE MAKETHEIROWNDECISIONSABOUTWHATKINDOFEDUCA
INTHISROOMKNOWS WHILEWEASANATIONSTILLSPENDA TIONTHEYWANTFORTHEIRCHILDRENANDWHATTHEYWANT
SIGNIlCANTAMOUNTOFMONEYINEDUCATION THEMARGINS THEIRCHILDRENTOBELEARNING/URKIDSHAVEBENElTED
ARETERRIBLE7EDONTGETINTOTHISBUSINESSBECAUSE TOO7ENOWHAVEEVERYTHINGUNDERTHESUNWHENIT
WEWANTTORETIREINTHE"AHAMASWEDOITBECAUSEWE COMESTOCHOICESFOREDUCATION7EHAVEHIGH TECH
WANTWHATSBESTFOROURKIDSˆANDOTHERKIDS)GOT CURRICULARPROGRAMS ARTSPROGRAMS CARPENTRYANDOTHER
INTOTHEBUSINESSBECAUSE)WASPASSIONATEABOUTCREAT TRADESPROGRAMS RELIGIOUSPROGRAMS SECULARPROGRAMS
INGSOMETHINGBETTERFORMYKIDS)SOONREALIZEDTHAT) EVOLUTION INTELLIGENTDESIGNxYOUNAMEIT)NSTEAD
WASNTALONE!LOTOFPARENTSWANTEDSOMETHINGBETTER OFCONSTANTLYTRYINGTOlTSQUAREPEGSINTOROUNDHOLES
FORTHEIRKIDS TOO)KNOWAT!CCELERATED-ATERIALS PARENTSCANNOWSHOPINACOMPLETEEDUCATIONMARKET
ALLOFUS ANDNOTJUSTTHEACCOUNTANTS ARECONSTANTLY PLACETOPURCHASEhHOLESvTHATlTTHEIRKIDS
LOOKINGFORWAYSTOLOWERCOSTSBECAUSEWEKNOWIF .OW)KNOWTHEREARESOMEPEOPLEWHOLAMENTTHE
WECANSQUEEZEANOTHERDOLLARHEREANDTHEREOUTOF
PRODUCTIONCOSTS WECANHELPMOREKIDS

!BOUTFACEONVOUCHERS
"Y #ONGRESSANDSTATEHOUSESAROUNDTHE
COUNTRYWERElNDINGITINCREASINGLYDIFlCULTTOFUND
PUBLICEDUCATIONˆEITHERTHROUGHTRADITIONALDIRECT
FUNDINGMECHANISMSORVOUCHERS-ANYMORESTATE
LEGISLATURESRESORTEDTOBUDGETARYSLEIGHTOFHAND
ˆhBUYINGOFFvPARENTSBYGIVINGTHEMVOUCHERS WHICH
WHENADDEDTOGETHER REPRESENTEDDRAMATICCUTSIN FACTTHATWENOLONGERHAVELARGEPUBLICSCHOOLSWHERE
EDUCATIONFUNDING!SARESULT EDUCATIONGROUPSTHAT KIDSMUSTLEARNHOWTOGETALONGWITHONEANOTHER4O
HADONCEFOUGHTVIGOROUSLYAGAINSTCHARTERSANDVOUCH THOSEPEOPLE )DSAY THINKBACKTOWHENYOUWERE
ERSNOWFOUNDTHEMSELVESWITHTHEIRBACKSAGAINSTTHE ATEENAGERANDASKYOURSELF HOWWELLDIDTHEKIDSIN
WALL lGHTINGTOMAINTAINFUNDINGFORVOUCHERS YOURHIGHSCHOOLGETALONGWITHONEANOTHER(OW
MANYPEOPLEDOYOUKNOWWHOLOOKBACKONTHEIRHIGH
4OEACHHISOWN SCHOOLEXPERIENCEWITHFONDNESS-OSTPEOPLE)TALKTO
/KAY SOTHATSTHEBADNEWSˆTHERESNOTMUCH REMEMBERCLIQUES CLASHES ANDCLAUSTROPHOBIA
MONEYINEDUCATION4HEGOODNEWS OFCOURSE IS +IDSTHESEDAYSHAVEFOUNDNEWWAYSTOCONNECT
THATTHEREISLOTSOFOPPORTUNITY!TlRST THOSETWO ˆTHROUGHSPORTS BALLET ANDOTHERACTIVITIESTHAT
STATEMENTSMAYSEEMCONTRADICTORY BUTHERESWHAT USEDTOBESPONSOREDBYSCHOOLS BUTFRANKLY NEVER
)MEAN&OURYEARSAGO )READACOMMENTARYONTHE SHOULDHAVEBEENˆITWASSUCHASDISTRACTIONTOTHEIR
BACKPAGEOF%D7EEK INWHICH'EOFFREY(ANSEN THEN MISSION3PEAKINGFROMPERSONALEXPERIENCE )VEGOT
SUPERINTENDENTOF"OSTON0UBLIC3CHOOLS WARNEDTHAT TWOTEENAGEDAUGHTERSATHOMEWHO)CANTELLYOUARE
EDUCATIONWOULDSOONBECONTROLLEDBYAFEW GIGANTIC HARDLYDEPRIVEDBECAUSETHEYRENOTBEINGSHUFmED
COMPANIESh&ORTHOSEWHOCOMPLAINEDTHATEDUCA THROUGHAHIGHSCHOOLWITH OTHERKIDSˆAND
TIONWASINTHEHANDSOFAGOVERNMENTMONOPOLY LETS BELIEVEME THEIRPHONESSTILLRINGOFFTHEHOOK EVEN
SEEHOWTHEYLIKEITWHENITSINTHEHANDSOFAPRIVATE THOUGHTHEREAREONLYKIDSINTHEIRSCHOOL WHICH
MONOPOLYˆONETHATSACCOUNTABLETONOONE vWROTE ISNOWHELDINJUSTFOURROOMSOFTHEOLDHIGHSCHOOL
(ANSEN DOWNTHESTREET

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

#LOSINGTHEBOOKON.O#HILD 'OVERNMENT
,EFT"EHIND
,ASTYEAR #ONGRESSQUIETLYREPEALEDTHE.O#HILD

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
,EFT"EHIND!CT WHICHWOULDHAVEREQUIREDTHAT
BYTHISYEAR ALLSCHOOLSDEMONSTRATETHATALLOFTHEIR 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
STUDENTSWEREPROlCIENTONSTATEEDUCATIONTESTS
/BVIOUSLY THEREWASNTMUCHPOINTANYMORETOASKING
h)FYOUWANT
PUBLICSCHOOLS MOSTOFWHICHNOLONGEREXIST TOPASS SOMETHINGDONE
TESTSTHATSTATESCANNOLONGERAFFORDTOADMINISTER AND RIGHTv

MOSTPARENTSANDSTUDENTSNEVERCAREDMUCHABOUT .ON 'OVERNMENT


ANYWAY TOBEHELDACCOUNTABLETOASTRIPPED DOWN
FEDERAL$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONWHICHNOLONGERHAS
THEABILITYTOENFORCETHELAW 7HITHERPUBLICSCHOOLS
)TSIRONIC )SUPPOSE AFTERALLTHEDEBATESINTHE
4HISYEAR )READAHEADLINE)WOULDVENEVER
SANDSABOUTFEDERALTESTING THATWEVE
EXPECTEDTOSEE OREVENlVE YEARSAGOPERCENT
CREATED THROUGHPRIVATEINDUSTRY THEEQUIVALENTOFA
OFOURKIDSNOWLEARN
NATIONALTESTˆTHE#OLLEGE"OARDEXAMINATION)TS
ATHOME PRIVATEOR
THEONETESTTHATMOSTPARENTSCAREABOUTˆNOTSTATE
CHURCHSCHOOLS4HATS
TESTSTHAT WITHTHEEXCEPTIONOFAHANDFULOFSTATESTHAT
ALMOSTA DEGREE
REQUIREDSTUDENTSTOPASSEXITEXAMSINORDERTOGRADU
URNAROUNDFROM
ATEFROMHIGHSCHOOL HADFEWSTAKESORRELEVANCEFOR
YEARSAGO4HELATEST
PARENTSANDSTUDENTS)FYOUDONTAGREEWITHTHATAS
lGURES)READBREAK
SESSMENTˆASKYOURSELF DIDYOUEVERHEAROFAPARENT
TDOWNTHISWAY
PAYINGTOHELPTHEIRKIDSSCOREBETTERONASTATEWIDE
PERCENTOFKIDSAREIN
ASSESSMENT
CHURCHORPAROCHIAL
)KNOWTHATFORMOSTEDUCATIONPROVIDERSTODAYˆ
SCHOOLS PERCENT
WHETHERTHEYCREATEEDUCATIONALMATERIALSOREDUCATE
AREINPRIVATE SECULAR
STUDENTSDIRECTLYˆTHEONEQUESTIONEVERYPARENTASKS
SCHOOLS PERCENTARE
ISHOWMANYKIDSAREAT#OLLEGE"OARDGRADELEVELOR
NHOME SCHOOLSET
ABOVEINYOURPROGRAM
INGSˆEITHERINTHEIR
OWNHOMESTAUGHT
BYTHEIRPARENTSOR
HROUGHONLINECOURSE
WORK ORANIN HOMESCHOOLnnANDTHEREMAINING
PERCENTAREENROLLEDINPUBLICSCHOOLS


)N-ARCH #OLLEGE"OARDRELEASEDLONG AWAITEDREVISIONSTOTHE3!4TESTˆTHEBIGGESTCHANGESTOTHETESTINMORETHANADECADE
"YDROPPINGTHEANALOGYSECTIONSANDQUANTITATIVECOMPARISONS ANDADDINGANESSAYANDALGEBRA)) TYPEMATH #OLLEGE"OARDTOUTSTHETESTAS
MEASURINGSTUDENTSACTUALLEARNINGANDCONTENTKNOWLEDGE NOTSIMPLYINNATEAPTITUDE WHICHCRITICS INCLUDINGCOLLEGEADMISSIONSOFlCIALS HAD
CONTENDEDWASAMAJORmAWOFEARLIERVERSIONSOFTHEEXAMINATION3OURCE+UMAR +-ARCH  h2EVAMPED3!4-AKES$EBUT v3T
,OUIS0OST$ISPATCHWWWSTLTODAYCOMSTLTODAYNEWSSTORIESNSFEDUCATIONSTORY%"%"#&#"/PEN$OCUMENT

!SOF MARKETANALYSTSSAIDTESTPREPARATIONˆFORTHE3!4AND!#4TESTSˆWASAMILLIONINDUSTRY WHICHHADBEENGROWINGBY
TOPERCENTDURINGPREVIOUSYEARS(OWEVER ASARESULTOFTHENEW3!4 THEMARKETNOWAPPEARSTOBEEXPERIENCINGPERCENTGROWTH)BID


2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO


-OSTOFOURREMAININGPUBLICSCHOOLSAREININNER PUTTHECONTROLOFEDUCATIONWHEREITBELONGSˆNOT
CITIESORISOLATEDRURALAREASWHERE APARTFROMONLINE WITHUNIONS BUREAUCRATSORPOLITICIANS BUTRATHERIN
ANDHOMESCHOOLS THEPUBLICSCHOOLTENDSTOBETHE THEHANDSOFPARENTS)COMEBACKTOTHEWORDSOFMY
ONLYGAMEINTOWN MOTHERˆIFYOUWANTSOMETHINGDONERIGHT DOIT
3URE )KNOWTHEREARESOMEWHOLAMENTTHEPASSING YOURSELF4HATSWHATPARENTSALLOVERTHISCOUNTRYHAVE
OFTHETRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOL"UT)LOOKATTHEKIDS DONEDURINGTHEPASTYEARS!NDINMYMIND THATS
THAT!CCELERATED,EARNINGISHELPINGTOTEACHAND TRUEDEMOCRACY
ASKMYSELFIFTHEYAREBETTEROFFINALARGE IMPERSONAL
PUBLICSCHOOL WHERENOONECAREDIFTHEYSUCCEEDED
ORFAILED/RARETHEYBETTEROFFBEINGTAUGHTBYTHEIR
PARENTSANDOTHERSWHOCAREABOUTTHEM
-YOWNKIDS FOREXAMPLE ATTENDAhMICRO SCHOOL v
AHIGHSCHOOLWITHJUSTKIDSRUNBYFOURFORMER
TEACHERSˆAN%NGLISHTEACHER AMATHTEACHER A
SCIENCETEACHER ANDASOCIALSTUDIESTEACHERˆWHO
RENTOUTFOURCLASSROOMSINTHEHIGHSCHOOLCOMPLEX
DOWNTHEROADFROMOURHOME4HEYDOALOTOFTEAM
TEACHINGWITHINTEGRATEDCURRICULUMTHANKSTOOUR!C
CELERATED,EARNINGMATERIALS!DULTSALSOPITCHINALOT !NALYSISOF3CENARIO
DONATINGSUPPLIESANDTIMEASGUESTLECTURERS THATSORT )MPLICATIONS
OFTHING
4RUE THETEACHERSWILLREADILYTELLYOUNONEOFTHEM )NTHISWORLDEDUCATIONHASBECOMEACOTTAGEINDUS
AREGETTINGRICHTHEYREBASICALLYJUSTPADDINGTHEIR TRY CHARACTERIZEDBYTEACHINGCO OPS HOME SCHOOL
RETIREMENTINCOMES WHICHAREPRETTYSLIMBECAUSEOF ING ANDNEIGHBORHOODORCOMMUNITY BASEDPROGRAMS
THESOLVENCYPROBLEMSWITHTHESTATEPENSIONFUND 4HEPRIMARYAUDIENCEFORPROVIDERSISPARENTSWHO
7ELL ONETEACHERISYOUNG SOSHEGETSFREETUITIONFOR AREDRIVINGTHEEDUCATIONMARKET0RODUCTSFORUSE
HERTHREEKIDS WHICHISAPRETTYGOODDEALSINCEAFTER INHOMESORFORSTUDENTSTOTAKEFROMHOMETOUSE
VOUCHERTUITIONISSTILLABOUT PERYEARPERCHILD INSCHOOLWILLBETHEHIGHESTPRIORITYFORPROVIDERSOF
-YKIDSANDTHEIRFRIENDSLOVETHEIRSCHOOL4HEYRE PRODUCTSANDSERVICES-ANYOFTHESEPRODUCTSWILLBE
CHALLENGEDANDENGAGEDˆTHEYHAVETOBEBECAUSE WEBBASEDANDMAYBEPURCHASEDONASUBSCRIPTION
INSTEADOFDIFFERENTTRACKSFORSMART AVERAGE AND BASIS
STRUGGLINGKIDS EVERYKIDINTHESCHOOLISEXPECTEDTO 'OVERNMENTPLAYSAVERYSMALLROLEINTHISWORLD
TAKERIGOROUSCOURSES INCLUDINGCALCULUS!NDALLTHE DEFERRINGTOPARENTSANDLOCALCOMMUNITIESDECISIONS
KIDSGETSOMUCHATTENTIONFROMTHEIRTEACHERSTHATITS ABOUTWHATISBESTFORTHEIRCHILDREN2ESEARCHAND
NEARLYIMPOSSIBLETOFALLTHROUGHTHECRACKS DEVELOPMENTISSELF FUNDEDWITHPROlTSFROMTHESALEOF
)HAVENOQUESTIONWHENITCOMESTOMYKIDS PRODUCTS4HEREWILLBEASMALLGROUPOFPROVIDERSWHO
ˆANDMOSTKIDSOUTTHEREˆTHATOURCURRENTSYSTEM PROSPERINTHISENVIRONMENT4HESEWILLBETHEPROVID
ASMESSYANDUNEVENASITMIGHTBE ISDOINGABETTER ERSWITHMARKETINGSAVVY ANDLOW COST HIGHVOLUME
JOBMEETINGTHEEDUCATIONNEEDSOFTHEVASTMAJORITY WIDELYUSEDPRODUCTS THESALESOFWHICHGENERATESUF
OFOURSTUDENTS)NSHORT OVERTHEPASTDECADEWEHAVE lCIENTMARGINSTOFUNDONGOINGRESEARCHANDDEVELOP
MENT


"YWAYOFCOMPARISON PARENTSOFFEREDTHEFOLLOWINGRESPONSESTO4HE'ALLUP0$+SURVEYQUESTION3UPPOSEYOUHADASCHOOL AGECHILD
ANDWEREGIVENAVOUCHERCOVERINGFULLTUITIONTHATWOULDPERMITYOUTOSENDTHATCHILDTOANYPUBLIC PRIVATE ORCHURCH RELATEDSCHOOLOFYOUR
CHOICE7HICHKINDOFSCHOOLDOYOUTHINKYOUWOULDCHOOSEOFPARENTSWHOSECHILDRENWEREENROLLEDINPUBLICSCHOOLSAIDTHEYWOULD
CHOOSEACHURCH RELATEDPRIVATESCHOOLOFPUBLICSCHOOLPARENTSSAIDTHEYWOULDKEEPTHEIRCHILDRENINPUBLICSCHOOLSANDSAIDANON
CHURCHRELATEDPRIVATESCHOOLSAIDTHEYDIDNTKNOW3OURCE2OSE ,# 'ALLUP ! h4HETH!NNUAL0HI$ELTA+APPA'ALLUP0OLL
OFTHE0UBLICS!TTITUDES4OWARDTHE0UBLIC3CHOOLS v0HI$ELTA+APPAN  

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
2$/RGANIZATION3CENARIO

)NDICATORS 'OVERNMENT

4HEFOLLOWINGTRENDSANDEVENTSAREPOSSIBLEINDICATORS
THATTHEFUTUREMAYBEMOVINGTOWARDTHISSCENARIO

3CHOOL0ROVIDERS
s #ONTINUED RAPIDGROWTHOFENROLLMENTINNON 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
&EW
PUBLICSCHOOLSETTINGSIE HOME PRIVATE AND
PAROCHIALSCHOOLS 
h)FYOUWANT
s 2APIDEXPANSIONOFVOUCHERANDORPRIVATE SOMETHINGDONE
RIGHTv
SCHOOLTAXCREDITPROGRAMSORLOOPHOLESALLOWING
PARENTSTOMAKEhTUITIONDONATIONSvTOCHURCH .ON 'OVERNMENT

BASEDSCHOOLS 

s 3CHOOLCLOSURESINURBAN RURAL ANDSUBURBAN s #REATENAMEVISIBILITYWITHPARENTS


AREASDUETODECLININGENROLLMENTBROUGHTABOUT
s #REATEINEXPENSIVEPRODUCTSTHATCANSELLINMASS
BYPARENTSREMOVINGTHEIRCHILDRENFROMPUBLIC
SCHOOLS s -AKESUBSTANTIALINVESTMENTSINMARKETING
s ,ONGWAITINGLISTSFORPRIVATEANDCHURCHSCHOOLS s 0RODUCEANDSELLSELF EXECUTINGPRODUCTS
DEMONSTRATINGHIGHDEMANDFORPUBLIC SCHOOL COMPLETEPACKAGES
ALTERNATIVES
s 4AILORTHEIRPRODUCTSTOBEWEB BASED JUST IN
s 3AFETYANDCULTURALCONCERNSCONTINUINGTOTOP TIME ANDINMULTIPLELANGUAGES
PARENTSLISTOFCONCERNSABOUTSCHOOLS
s 0ARTNERWITHOTHERRECOGNIZEDENTITIES CO
s ,ACKOFEVIDENCETHATCHARTERANDPUBLICSCHOOLS BRANDINGSELECTEDPRODUCTS
ARECAPABLEOFRAISINGSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT
s 3EEKFOUNDATIONFUNDINGTOADDRESSTHENEEDSOF
s #ONTINUEDEDUCATIONBUDGETCUTSATFEDERAL STATE UNDERSERVEDPOPULATIONS
ANDLOCALLEVELS
s #REATEMATERIALSALIGNEDWITHDEFACTONATIONAL
s $ECLININGPUBLICCONCERNABOUTEDUCATIONIE CURRICULUMEG #OLLEGE"OARDEXAMINATIONS 
OTHERISSUES SUCHASHEALTHCAREAND3OCIAL
3ECURITYCONTINUETOSURFACEASMOREIMPORTANT $ISCUSSION1UESTIONS
POLITICALPRIORITIES  !RETHECRITICALUNCERTAINTIESTHATFORMTHE
s $ECLININGPUBLICCONlDENCEINGOVERNMENT SCENARIOFRAMEWORKTHOSETHATYOUWOULDCHOOSE
ORARETHEREOTHERUNCERTAINTIESTHATSEEMMORE
CRITICALTOYOU
/PTIONS
6ISIBILITYWITHPARENTSISESSENTIALINTHISWORLD !RETHESTORIESPLAUSIBLE#OULDTHEYTURNOUTTO
4HEYARETHEPRIMARYAUDIENCEFORPROVIDERSOFPROD BETRUE)FNOT WHATWOULDYOUCHANGE
UCTSANDSERVICES!CCORDINGLY ADVERTISINGNEEDS
#ANYOUTHINKOFOTHERIMPLICATIONSANDOPTIONS
TOTARGETPARENTSINTHESAMEWAYSTHEYARETARGETED
FORTHEORGANIZATIONINADDITIONTOTHOSEWRITTEN
BYPRODUCERSOFOTHERCONSUMERGOODSANDSERVICES
INTHE!NALYSISSECTIONS
0ROVIDERSNEEDTOPRODUCEINEXPENSIVERESEARCH BASED
PRODUCTSTHATCANBESOLDONAMASSBASIS$EVELOPING )FYOUWERELEADINGANORGANIZATIONOFTHISTYPE
PUBLISHING SALES DISTRIBUTION ANDFULlLLMENTCAPACITY WHATWOULDYOUDONOWTOPREPAREFORTHESE
ANDORRELATIONSHIPSWITHPUBLISHERSWITHTHESECAPA IMAGINEDFUTURES
BILITIESWILLBEESSENTIAL0ROVIDERSWHOPROSPERINTHIS
ENVIRONMENTWILL

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
!BUNDANT

h2AINING-ONEY
h0ARTY4IMEv
AND2ULESv

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL

2ESOURCES
h(ARD4IMESv h!,AST2ESORTv

3CARCE

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIOS
)NTRODUCTION

3 ANDIAISAGEOGRAPHICALLYLARGE SPARSELYPOPULATEDSTATEINTHE'REAT0LAINS4HEREARETWO
MEDIUM SIZEDURBANCENTERSWHICHACCOUNTFORPERCENTOFTHESTATESPOPULATION4HE
REMAININGPOPULATIONISSCATTEREDACROSSTHESTATESNEARLY SQUAREMILESOFAGRICULTURAL FOREST AND
DESERTLANDS3ANDIASPOPULATIONREmECTSRECENTLARGEINmUXESOFIMMIGRANTSFROM-EXICOANDOTHER
3PANISH SPEAKINGCOUNTRIES
4HEMAJORINDUSTRIESIN3ANDIAAREAGRICULTURE MINING ANDLOGGING4HESEEXTRACTIONINDUSTRIES
HAVETRADITIONALLYBEENATTHEMERCYOFWORLDDEMANDFORRAWMATERIALSANDREPEATEDBOOMORBUSTECO
NOMICCYCLES4HISHASLEDTOWIDELYmUCTUATINGREVENUESTREAMSFORTHESTATE
4HE3ANDIA$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION3$% SERVESTHEENTIRESTATESPUBLIC+nEDUCATIONCOM
MUNITY!SSTATEDEPARTMENTSOFEDUCATIONGO ITISSOMEWHATSMALL DUETOTHELOWSTATEPOPULATIONAND
ACONSERVATIVESTATEBUDGET"ECAUSEOFTHEUNCERTAINTYINSTATEREVENUESFROMYEARTOYEAR STATEINVEST
MENTINAGENCYINFRASTRUCTURESHASBEENLEAN3$%EMPLOYSAPPROXIMATELYFULL TIMESTAFF7HILE
SALARIESAREMODEST THESTATERETIREMENTSYSTEMPROVIDESABETTERTHANAVERAGEPENSIONANDTHUSISAN
INCENTIVEFORINDIVIDUALSTOCONSIDEREMPLOYMENTWITH3$%4HE#HIEF3TATE3CHOOL/FlCERIN3ANDIA
$R!NDREA#OREY ISASTRONGLEADER BUTSHEHASINDICATEDSHEMAYBERETIRINGSOON(ERAPPROACHTO
MANAGINGTHEDEPARTMENTISTOMAINTAINFOCUSONWHATISMOSTIMPORTANTˆSERVINGTHECHILDRENOFTHE
STATE
4HEMAJOROPERATINGDEPARTMENTSOF3$%FOCUSONSCHOOLANDDISTRICTACCREDITATION EDUCATORLICENS
ING STATE WIDEASSESSMENTANDSTANDARDS FEDERALPROGRAMSMANAGEMENTANDMONITORING ANDEDUCATION
lNANCEADMINISTRATION4HETWOLARGESTOFlCESARE4ITLE)AND3PECIAL%DUCATION/VERHALFOFALL3$%
STAFFAREFEDERALLYFUNDED4HEDEPARTMENTALSOHOUSESTHESTATEBOARDOFEDUCATION THESTATELIBRARY AND
ADULTBASICEDUCATIONPROGRAMS
!SWITHMOSTSTATEDEPARTMENTSOFEDUCATION 3ANDIAFACESMANYCHALLENGINGISSUES INCLUDINGLACK
OFlNANCIALRESOURCES CHALLENGESOFIMPLEMENTINGTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT.#," COMPLEXITY
OFMANYSCHOOLCHOICEINITIATIVES MAINTAININGAHIGHLYQUALIlEDCADREOFTEACHERS ANDADDRESSINGTHE
SPECIALDEMANDSOFTHEIRGROWINGMIGRANTANDNON NATIVE%NGLISHSPEAKINGPOPULATIONS


%DUCATION&INANCE
!SINMOSTSTATES EDUCATIONISTHELARGESTSINGLEITEMINTHESTATEBUDGET)NPASTYEARS THENEWSPA
PERANDLOCAL46STATIONSHAVECALLEDTHESTATETOTASKOVERITSDISTRIBUTIONOFFUNDS WHICHSOMEVIEW
ASINEQUITABLE.OWTHESTATEISFACINGSCHOOLlNANCELITIGATIONQUESTIONINGTHEEQUITYANDADEQUACYOF
STATEAIDDISTRIBUTIONSYSTEMS#ONSEQUENTLY STAFFEXPECTSTOBEGINWORKINGONANEXTENSIVEMODIlCA
TIONOFEDUCATIONFUNDINGFORMULASASTHESTATELEGISLATUREADDRESSESTHEADEQUACYOFOVERALLlNANCING
OF+nEDUCATION4HECHALLENGEWILLBETODEVISEAMETHODFORALLOCATINGFUNDSINWAYSTHATFULlLL
CONSTITUTIONALREQUIREMENTSANDPRODUCEDESIREDRESULTSINLINEWITH.#,"0RESSUREFROMOTHERSOURCES
ONTHESTATESGENERALOPERATINGBUDGET INCLUDINGSPIRALINGTRANSPORTATIONANDHEALTHCARECOSTS MEANS
THAT3$%CANNOTEXPECTTOSEESUBSTANTIALINCREASESINFUNDINGINTHENEARFUTURE

.#,"
3$%HASSTRUGGLEDWITHTHEACCOUNTABILITYPORTIONSOF.#,"$EVELOPERSOFTHESTATEASSESSMENT
ADDRESSEDFOURLEVELSOFPROlCIENCYRATHERTHANTHETHREECALLEDFORIN.#," WHICHREQUIREDAREVAMP
INGOFTHESYSTEMSHORTLYAFTERITWASLAUNCHEDTOACCOMMODATETHISFEDERALLAW/VERTHEPASTTWOYEARS
NEARLYHALFOFTHESTATESSCHOOLSHAVEFAILEDTOMAKEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESSASMEASUREDBYTHESTATE
ASSESSMENT3UPPLEMENTARYSERVICESARESCARCEANDCOSTLYTOPROVIDEINRURALAREASANDINTHESTATESTWO
URBANCENTERS$UETOLIMITEDCAPACITYWITHINTHEAGENCYITHASBEENACHALLENGETOMONITORQUALITYAND
IMPACTAMONGTHEAVAILABLESUPPLEMENTARYSERVICEPROVIDERS

3CHOOL#HOICE
3ANDIAHASENACTEDAVOLUNTARYSTATEWIDESCHOOLCHOICEPROGRAM4HEVOLUNTARYNATUREOFTHE
PROGRAMTOGETHERWITHTHELACKOFFUNDINGFORTRANSPORTATIONANDWIDEDISPARITIESINPER PUPILSPENDING
AMONGDISTRICTSHAMPERTHESUCCESSOFTHEPROGRAM)NRURALAREAS CHOICEISANEARPRACTICALIMPOSSIBILITY
DUETOTHELONGDISTANCESBETWEENATTENDANCECENTERS3TUDENTSAREMORELIKELYTOWANTTOTRANSFERFROM
ASCHOOLDISTRICTWITHLESSLOCALREVENUETOADISTRICTWITHHIGHERPERPUPILSPENDINGRATES4HESTATES
FUNDINGFORMULAUSESTHEhSENDINGvDISTRICTSCONTRIBUTION SOTHEREISLITTLEINCENTIVEFORASCHOOLDISTRICT
TOACCEPTTHESESTUDENTS

4EACHER1UALITY
3$%FACESATWO FOLDPROBLEMWITHTHESTATESTEACHERWORKFORCE!SUBSTANTIALPERCENTAGEOFTEACH
ERSARENEARRETIREMENTAGE4HOSEWITHFEWERTHANlVEYEARSINTHEPROFESSIONCOMPRISETHENEXTLARGEST
GROUPOF3ANDIATEACHERS4HEREAREPROPORTIONALLYFEWEREXPERIENCEDTEACHERSWHOAREMANYYEARSFROM
RETIREMENT4EACHERSALARIESINTHESTATEHAVETYPICALLYBEENONTHELOWENDOFTHENATIONALAVERAGE
WITHEVENLOWERSALARIESPAIDTOTEACHERSINRURALAREAS4HIS COUPLEDWITHTHEISOLATIONOFMANYRURAL
COMMUNITIESANDLIMITEDOPPORTUNITIESFORADVANCEMENT PROMPTSMANYEXPERIENCEDTEACHERSTOMOVE
TOMORElNANCIALLYREWARDINGJOBSINLARGERTOWNSANDCITIES4HESEFACTORSALSOINHIBITTEACHERRECRUIT
INGANDLIMITTHEPOOLOFEXPERIENCEDCANDIDATESFORLEADERSHIPANDADMINISTRATIVEPOSITIONS

-IGRANTAND.ON .ATIVE%NGLISH3PEAKING0OPULATIONS
"ECAUSE3ANDIASPOPULATIONREmECTSRECENTLARGEINmUXESOFIMMIGRANTSFROM-EXICOANDOTHER3PANISH
SPEAKINGCOUNTRIES 3ANDIASSTATEGOVERNMENT AND3$%INPARTICULAR FACEPOLITICALLYCHARGEDQUESTIONS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
ABOUTTHEEXTENTTOWHICHTAXPAYERSERVICESSHOULDBEEXTENDEDTOIMMIGRANTS PARTICULARLYTHOSEWHO
DONOTHAVELEGALSTATUS5NCERTAINTYABOUTTHENATIONSDIRECTIONONIMMIGRATIONPOLICYFUELSUNCER
TAINTYIN3$%ANDTHESCHOOLDISTRICTSITSERVESABOUTTHENATUREANDEXTENTOFEDUCATIONSERVICESTHAT
WILLBEREQUIREDFORIMMIGRANTANDSECONDLANGUAGESTUDENTS5NTILTHEREISAGREEMENTANDCLARITYON
THISISSUE 3$%ANDLOCALSCHOOLDISTRICTSCONTINUETOPROVIDESERVICESTOTHEDEGREEPOSSIBLEGIVENTHE
LIMITEDFUNDINGTHEYRECEIVE

&OCAL)SSUE
!NEWLYFORMEDTASKFORCEWILLEXAMINETHELONG TERMIMPLICATIONSOFEMERGINGDEMOGRAPHICAND
ECONOMICTRENDSIN3ANDIAASWELLASONTHENATIONALANDINTERNATIONALSCENE4HETASKFORCE CONSIST
INGOFSENIORANDMID LEVELSTAFF BOARDANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERSWILLFORMULATESTRATEGIESFORANTICIPAT
INGANDRESPONDINGTOPOTENTIALCHANGESINGOVERNMENTREGULATIONANDRESOURCESTHATWILLSHAPE3$%S
AGENDAADECADEFROMNOW INTHEYEAR


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY !BUNDANT

3CENARIO h0ARTY4IMEv
$EEP#AUSES

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATGOVERNMENTANDPRIVATE
lNANCIALSUPPORTFOR+nEDUCATIONISABUNDANTAND

2ESOURCES
THATFEDERALREGULATIONHASDIMINISHEDCONSIDERABLY
3TATEDEPARTMENTSOFEDUCATIONlNDTHEMSELVESINA
COMPLETELYNEWKINDOFENVIRONMENTWHERETHEIRROLE
ASMONITORSANDENFORCERSOFFEDERALEDUCATIONREGULA 3CARCE
TIONSHASDIMINISHED-EANWHILE THELEVELOFFUNDING
AVAILABLETOPUBLICEDUCATION FROMBOTHPUBLICAND
PRIVATESOURCES HASINCREASEDSUBSTANTIALLY3TATEDE
s 0RIVATETECHNOLOGYCOMPANIESCREATEPROGRAMS
PARTMENTOFEDUCATIONSTAFFAREFACEDWITHRE ENVISION
SPECIlCALLYTOFUNDINNOVATIONINTECHNOLOGY
INGTHEIRROLESANDLEARNINGHOWTOASSERTINmUENCEIN
SOLUTIONSFORSCHOOLS4HISCREATESMARKETS
ANENVIRONMENTWHEREMAJORFUNDINGFOR+nEDUCA
FORTHESESOLUTIONSANDMOREBUSINESSFORTHE
TIONCOMESFROMSOURCESOUTSIDETHEIRPURVIEW&UR
TECHNOLOGYCOMPANIES
THERMORE THEYWILLNEEDTOPAYPARTICULARATTENTIONTO
MAINTAININGORGANIZATIONALCOHERENCE'IVENTHESHIFT s -ANYFORPROlTANDNONPROlTCOMPANIESOPEN
INTHEREGULATORYENVIRONMENT MANYNEWOPTIONSARE SCHOOLSTHATDELIVERCUSTOMIZEDLEARNINGAND
AVAILABLETOTHOSEWHOARECREATIVEANDAGILEENOUGHTO ASSESSMENTSERVICESTOSPECIlCSEGMENTSOFTHE
TAKEADVANTAGEOFTHEM EDUCATIONMARKET
4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO s )NVESTMENTSCANDALSPERPETRATEDBYSOME
EDUCATIONSERVICEPROVIDERSRESULTINTHEPUBLIC
s 3TATESSUCCEEDINOBTAININGRELIEFFROMREGULATIONS
NEEDINGSOMEINDEPENDENTASSURANCETHAT
UNDER.#,"
EDUCATIONALCHOICESAREREPUTABLEANDHIGH
s &EDERALREGULATIONSSHIFTFROMGOVERNINGPUBLIC QUALITY
EDUCATIONTOENSURINGQUALITYEDUCATIONPRODUCTS
s "USINESSINTERESTSPREVAILINTHEIMMIGRATION
ANDSERVICESFORALL
DEBATE OPENINGTHEDOORSTOINCREASEDNUMBERS
s 6OTERDISAPPROVALOFASTRONGFEDERALROLEIN OFNEWWORKERSFROM-EXICOAND#ENTRAL
EDUCATIONCOUPLEDWITHPRAGMATICTHINKINGFROM !MERICA
THE'EN 8ERSWHOASSUMENEWCONGRESSIONAL
SEATSLEADSTOADIFFERENTFEDERALAPPROACHTO
FUNDINGEDUCATION4HISNEWAPPROACHFOCUSES
ONSETTINGSTANDARDS DESIGNINGUSEFULASSESSMENT
SYSTEMS ANDENSURINGQUALITY

s 4HEWARINTHE-IDDLE%ASTENDS REDUCINGTHE
DRAGONTHEFEDERALTREASURYANDFREEINGUPFUNDS
FOROTHERPURPOSES

s 3TATEAGENCIESAREGIVENMORELATITUDEINHOW
THEYACHIEVETHEIRMISSIONS OPENINGTHEDOOR
FORMOREmEXIBLEAPPROACHES INCLUDINGPUBLIC
PRIVATEPARTNERSHIPS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

4HOSEOLDBOUNDARIESlRSTBLURREDANDTHENWENTAWAY
h0ARTY4IMESv COMPLETELYASAmURRYOFINNOVATION FUELEDBYREDUCED
4IME REGULATION INCREASEDlNANCIALRESOURCES ANDGREATER
COLLABORATIONACROSSPUBLICANDPRIVATESECTORS CREATED
0LACE4HE&OURTH!NNUAL&UTUREOF%DUCATIONIN
ANEWWORLDOFOPPORTUNITIESFORBOTHPURVEYORSAND
3ANDIACONFERENCEBEINGHELDATANUPSCALERESORTINTHE
CONSUMERSOFEDUCATIONPRODUCTSANDSERVICES
NORTHERNMOUNTAINS
!SYOUKNOW lVEYEARSAGO IN THE3ANDIA
3CENE$R!NDREA#OREY CHIEFEXECUTIVEOFlCEROF 3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION3$% JOINEDWITH
THEPUBLIC PRIVATEPARTNERSHIP%DUCATIONFOR3ANDIAS ACONSORTIUMOFPRIVATEBUSINESSESANDFOUNDATIONS
&UTURE ISDELIVERINGTHEKEYNOTEADDRESSTOASSEMBLED TOCREATETHEPUBLIC PRIVATEPARTNERSHIP%DUCATION
CONFEREES4HEAUDIENCEINCLUDESMANYPUBLICAND FOR3ANDIAS&UTURE4HISUNIQUEVENTUREEMBRACEDA
PRIVATESCHOOLLEADERSASWELLASREPRESENTATIVESFROM MISSIONTOHARNESSTHEBESTTHATPUBLIC CHARITABLE AND
NUMEROUSPRIVATESECTORCOMPANIESTHATHAVESPRUNG PRIVATEORGANIZATIONSHAVETOOFFERFORTHEEDUCATIONOF
UPOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSTOADDRESSTHEDEMANDFOR OURCHILDREN4HEPARTNERSHIPHASCREATEDAPLATFORM
HIGHLYCUSTOMIZED DECENTRALIZEDEDUCATIONSOLUTIONS FORBUSINESSANDINDUSTRYTOPOOLTHEIRRESOURCESTO
)NADDITIONTOTHECONFERENCE THEREISALARGETRADE FUNDANDGUIDEEDUCATIONDEVELOPMENTTHATSUPPORTS
SHOWWITHEXHIBITORSFROMALLOVERTHECOUNTRY THEFUTUREWORKFORCENEEDSOFTHISCOUNTRY4HECHARI
TABLEANDPHILANTHROPICMEMBERSOFTHEPARTNERSHIP
VIGILANTOVERTHEhSOCIALGOODvTHATMIGHTCOMEOFOUR
'OODMORNINGANDWELCOMETOTHEFOURTHANNUAL
WORK ENSUREDTHATOUREFFORTSDIDNOTBECOMESIMPLY
&UTUREOF%DUCATIONIN3ANDIACONFERENCE)WANTTO
THETOOLOFBUSINESSINTERESTS4HEROLEOFGOVERNMENT
THANKCONFERENCEORGANIZERSFORONCEAGAINCHOOS
THROUGH3$% EVOLVEDFROMREGULATIONTOTHATOFRE
INGASPLENDIDVENUEFORTHISEVENT ANDFORDOINGAN
SEARCH EVALUATION ANDQUALITYCONTROLPROVIDER
OUTSTANDINGJOBOFORGANIZINGTHEEDUCATIONALAND
3UCHAPARTNERSHIPWOULDNOTHAVEBEENFORMED
SOCIALEVENTSWELLBEENJOYINGTHROUGHOUTTHECOURSE
HADITNOTBEENFORALOOSENINGOFTHEREINSIN
OFTHECONFERENCE"EFOREYOURETURNHOME PLEASEBE
7HENSTATEREGULATIONSABOUTTHEKINDSOFENTERPRISESA
SURETOSPENDTIMEINTHEEXHIBITHALL WHEREYOUWILL
STATEAGENCYCOULDPARTICIPATEINWEREEASED 3$%WON
EXPERIENCETHEBIGGESTTRADESHOWWEHAVEEVERHAD
THERIGHTTOBEACHARTERAUTHORITY OPENINGTHEDOORFOR
INCONJUNCTIONWITHTHISCONFERENCE!S)WASWALKING
MORECHARTERSCHOOLSANDSTATE CHARTEREDDISTRICTS4HIS
THROUGHTHEHALLEARLIERTHISMORNING )SAWMANYFA
WOULDNOTHAVEBEENPOSSIBLEHADITNOTBEENFORTWO
MILIARVENDORS NAMES ANDFACES PLUSLOTSOFINTRIGUING
OTHERDRAMATICCHANGES&IRST THEREWERECHANGESIN
NEWONES7HOWOULDHAVETHOUGHTTHATTHERECOULD
FEDERALANDSTATEREGULATIONSGOVERNINGHOWTAX GENER
BESOMANYDIFFERENTPRODUCTSANDSERVICESAVAILABLETO
ATEDFUNDSFOREDUCATIONCOULDBEUSEDTOACHIEVETHE
ASSISTINOURCHILDRENSEDUCATION-Y WELIVEINEXCIT
ULTIMATEGOALOFLEAVINGNOCHILDBEHIND!NDSECOND
ING REWARDING ANDSOMETIMESSURPRISINGTIMES
PRIVATEENTERPRISE FUELEDBYPUBLICSPIRITANDOFCOURSE
4HISMORNING )BEGINBYREmECTINGUPONWORLD
SELF INTEREST SEIZEDTHEOPPORTUNITYTOINJECTNEW
EVENTSOVERTHEPASTTENYEARSTHATHAVESHAPEDEDUCA
VITALITYINTOTHEMORIBUNDSECTOROFTHEECONOMYTHAT
TIONINTOWHATITISTODAY)NDEED THEEDUCATIONAL
PRODUCEDGOODSANDSERVICESFOREDUCATIONCONSUMERS
ENTERPRISEISVERYDIFFERENTNOWTHANITWASlFTEEN
4HEIMPETUSFORTHESECHANGESCAMEFROMSOME
YEARSAGOWHEN)lRSTASSUMEDTHEROLEOFCHIEFSTATE
LIKELYANDUNLIKELYPLACES,ETSSTARTWITHTHELIKELY
SCHOOLOFlCERIN3ANDIA&ORME ITHASBEENACHAL
"EGINNINGIN THESTATES LEDBY5TAH MOUNTEDA
LENGINGANDSOMETIMESBUMPYRIDE)VEHADTOLEARN
REVOLTAGAINSTTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT.#,"
NEWWAYSOFTHINKINGANDWORKINGINORDERTOSERVE
BYPASSINGLEGISLATIONTHATPUTSTATEEDUCATIONREGULA
ASANEFFECTIVELEADERFOROURENTERPRISE.OLONGERDO
TIONABOVEFEDERALREGULATION)TWASTHElRSTOFMANY
WESPEAKOFhPUBLICEDUCATIONvORh+nEDUCATIONv
SUCHACTIONSTORESTORETHECONCEPTOFFEDERALISMTO


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

OURWAYOFGOVERNING4HESTATESWEREEMBOLDENEDBY !BUNDANT
THEREPORT4ASK&ORCEON.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
&INAL2EPORTRELEASEDBYTHE.ATIONAL#OUNCILOF3TATE h0ARTY4IMEv
,EGISLATURES.#3, )NTHATREPORT .#3,URGEDTHE
FEDERALGOVERNMENTTOREMOVEOBSTACLESINTHELAWTHAT

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
STImEDINNOVATIONANDTOCREATEAWAIVERSYSTEMFOR

2ESOURCES
INNOVATIVEPROGRAMSTHATHADDEMONSTRATEDEFFECTIVE
NESS.#3,ALSOURGEDTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTTOFULLY
FUND.#,"ANDREDUCETHEREGULATORYBURDENPASSED
ALONGTOSTATESSOTHATTHEYCOULDEXERCISElNANCIAL
3CARCE
mEXIBILITYINMEETINGTHEIRUNIQUENEEDS)NADDITION
.#3,RECOMMENDEDTHATTHEGOVERNMENTREMOVE
THEONE SIZE lTS ALLMETHODFORMEASURINGSTUDENT
PERFORMANCEANDENCOURAGETHEDEVELOPMENTOFMORE FEDERALEDUCATIONDEPARTMENTDESIGNEDABETTERMOUSE
SOPHISTICATEDANDACCURATESYSTEMSTHATGAUGETHE TRAP ANDTHENATIONBEATAPATHTOITSDOOR4HENEW
GROWTHOFINDIVIDUALSTUDENTS9OUWILLRECALL )MSURE NATIONALTESTSWEREGOOD ANDLASTYEAR PRIVATECOLLEGES
THATMANYSTATESWERESHOCKEDBYTHE'OVERNMENT!C ANDUNIVERSITIESBEGANTOACCEPTTHEMASENTRANCE
COUNTABILITY/FlCESlNDINGTHAT.#,"DIDNOTVIOLATE EXAMSFORTHElRSTTIME
THE5NFUNDED-ANDATE2EFORM!CT 2ELIEVEDOFTHEMASSIVEADMINISTRATIONANDEN
7HATENSUEDWASAlGHTOVERWHETHERTHEFEDERAL FORCEMENTCOSTSASSOCIATEDWITHFEDERALEDUCATION
GOVERNMENTCOULDWITHHOLDFUNDINGFROMDISSENTING REGULATIONSOFTHEPAST THE$EPARTMENTNOTONLY
STATES$UETOVOTERDISAPPROVAL COUPLEDWITHPRAG FOCUSEDITSRESOURCESONTHEQUALITYANDUTILITYOFTHE
MATICNEWTHINKINGFROM'EN 8ERSWHOWEREASSUMING NATIONALTESTINGPROGRAM BUTITALSOSETASIDEMORE
CONGRESSIONALSEATS THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTRELENTED DOLLARSFORhNO STRINGS ATTACHEDvBLOCKGRANTSTOSTATES
ONITSPLANTOWITHHOLDFUNDINGFROMSTATESTHATHADNT !TABOUTTHESAMETIME ONTHEINTERNATIONALSCENE
TOEDTHELINE4HESELECTIONOF-ARGARET3PELLINGSAS THE5NITED3TATESWITHDREWITSTROOPSFROMTHE-IDDLE
3ECRETARYOF%DUCATIONINSIGNALEDTHEBEGINNING %ASTAFTERHELPINGTOSTABILIZEDEMOCRATICREGIMESIN
OFTHISTREND.OLONGERWOULDTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENT )RAQ )RAN 3YRIA !FGHANISTAN AND0ALESTINE7ITHOUT
TELLSTATESANDLOCALSCHOOLDISTRICTSHOWTOIMPROVE THEWARTIMEDRAGONTHENATIONALTREASURY TAXRATESDE
OUTCOMESFORALLCHILDREN)NSTEAD THEGOVERNMENT CLINEDBUTREVENUESINCREASEDANDBUSINESSmOURISHED
BEGANTOASSUMETHEROLEOFGUARANTEEINGQUALITYPROD SOTHEREWEREMOREFEDERALDOLLARSAVAILABLEFORSOCIAL
UCTSANDSERVICESFORALL ANDCREATINGANATIONALSYSTEM PROGRAMS3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARERESCUE ISSUES
OFTESTINGTHATWASSECONDTONONE!STHEhQUIDvTO THATWEREONCEINTHEFOREFRONTBECAUSEOFTHETREMEN
THEFEDERALhPROQUO vTHESTATESAGREEDTOACCEPTTHE DOUSlNANCIALCHALLENGETHEYPRESENTEDFORTHECOUNTRY
NATIONALTESTRESULTSASTHEBASISUPONWHICHDIPLOMAS NOLONGERWORRIEDUS
WOULDBEGRANTED ASWELLASHOWADMISSIONSTOSTATE !SFORSTATES WITHTHEIRNEW FOUNDmEXIBILITYIN
SUPPORTEDCOLLEGESWOULDBEDETERMINED ADMINISTERINGFEDERALBLOCKGRANTS THEYPLUNGED
!STHEEXISTENCEOFANATIONALTESTSUGGESTS ADE WHOLESALEINTOMODIlEDVOUCHERPROGRAMS ALLOCATING
FACTONATIONALCURRICULUMHADSLOWLYBUTTHOUGHTFULLY BOTHFEDERALANDSTATEFUNDSTOINDIVIDUALSRATHERTHAN
EMERGED BORNOUTOFTHESTANDARDSMOVEMENTFROMTHE INSTITUTIONS4HISSPARKEDAmURRYOFLAWSUITS HOWEVER
S4OITSCREDIT THE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION ANDTHESUCCESSOFMANYOFTHESESUITSAGAINSTSTATE
INITSNEWROLEOFPROMULGATINGTHECURRICULUMWHILE SCHOOLlNANCESCHEMESRESULTEDINMANYSTATESSIMPLY
MONITORINGTESTDEVELOPMENTANDADMINISTRATION DIDA RETREATINGFROMINVOLVEMENTINREGULATINGSCHOOL
BANG UPJOBOFBOTH4OBORROWAWELL WORNPHRASE THE lNANCEATALL4HISCREATEDEVENMOREmEXIBILITYATTHE
LOCALLEVEL

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

!NUNLIKELYCATALYSTFORTHEBLOSSOMINGOFENTRE !SYOUHAVELISTENEDTOTHISRETROSPECTIVE YOU


PRENEURSHIPSANDTHEDEVELOPMENTOFNEWEDUCATION HAVEHEARDHOWTHELIFTINGOFREGULATIONSONSCHOOL
PRODUCTSANDSERVICESWASTHE"USHADMINISTRATIONS ING FUELEDBYPRESSUREFORMORECHOICEFROM'EN 8
PROPOSALINTOELIMINATEFUNDINGFORTHE%N AND-ILLENNIALPARENTS SENTTHEDEMANDFORAVARIETY
HANCING%DUCATIONTHROUGH4ECHNOLOGYSTATEBLOCK OFEDUCATIONALOPPORTUNITIESSKYROCKETING&ROMTHE
GRANTPROGRAM THEPRIMARYSOURCEOFFEDERALFUNDING TRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLBUILDINGDOWNTHESTREET
FORSCHOOLTECHNOLOGY4HISACTIONHADTHESURPRISING TOTHESTOREFRONTMINI SCHOOLTOONLINESCHOOLSAND
EFFECTOFACTUALLYBEINGABOONTOEDUCATIONALTECH INTERACTIVEVIRTUALENVIRONMENTSTOSCHOOLSINCHURCH
NOLOGY2ECOGNIZINGTHELOSSOFSCHOOLBUSINESSTHIS BASEMENTSANDCORPORATEDAYCARECENTERS TODELUXE
CUTWOULDPRECIPITATE TECHNOLOGYCOMPANIESBANDED hSEE THE WORLDnWHILE YOU LEARNvTOURS THEMULTIPLICITY
TOGETHERTOFUNDTHEIROWNSCHOOLTECHNOLOGYPROGRAMS OFWAYSINWHICHEDUCATIONISNOWBEINGDELIVEREDIS
-ICROSOFT )"- !PPLE ANDAHOSTOFOTHERCOMPANIES STAGGERING
POOLEDTHEIRRESOURCESTOCONTINUESCHOOLTECHNOLOGY 4HISPROFUSIONOFINNOVATIONINTHEEDUCATIONMAR
PROGRAMSBASEDONNEWMODELSTHAT-ICROSOFTHADDE KETPLACEHASNOTBEENWITHOUTITSDOWNSIDE HOWEVER
VELOPED4HEIRMOTIVATIONMIGHTHAVEBEENTOREPLACE !SWITHMOSTBOOM TIMEINDUSTRIES THEEXPLOSIONIN
REVENUEFROMTHEPROGRAMSTHEYWOULDLOSEWHENTHE THEEDUCATIONMARKETPLACEATTRACTEDTHEBESTANDTHE
FEDERALFUNDINGWASELIMINATED BUTINREALITY THEY WORSTOFENTREPRENEURSANDBUSINESSMEN)NTRUTH THE
CREATEDSOMETHINGMUCHLARGERˆAMARKETFORNEW VASTMAJORITYOFNEWEDUCATIONBUSINESSESHAVEDELIV
PRODUCTSANDSERVICES3INCE HUNDREDSOFTECHNOLOGY EREDONTHEIRPROMISES3OME INFACT HAVEPRODUCED
COMPANIESHAVELAUNCHEDNEWDEVELOPMENTPROGRAMS TREMENDOUSVALUEFORCONSUMERS/NTHEOTHERHAND
AIMEDATCREATINGANDMARKETINGALLMANNEROFHARD MANYOFTHENEWCOMPANIESWEREESTABLISHEDBYWELL
WARE SOFTWARE ANDSERVICESFORSCHOOLS MEANINGINDIVIDUALSWHOWEREVERYPOORBUSINESS
9ETANOTHERMARKETOPENEDFORTECHNOLOGYCOMPA PEOPLE!SARESULT THEIRVENTURESQUICKLYCAMEAND
NIESASTHENUMBEROFHOMESCHOOLERSINCREASEDWHEN WENT ASCONSUMERSWHOPURCHASEDTHEIRPRODUCTSAND
THEREGULATIONSWERELIFTED%DUCATIONCONSUMERSFOUND SERVICESFOUNDTHATTHETECHSUPPORTLINEWASDISCON
THEMSELVESWITHMOREDISPOSABLEINCOMEASARESULTOF NECTEDORTHEIREFFORTSTOCONTACTTHECOMPANYWERE
THEIMPROVINGECONOMYANDLOWERTAXES4HEYBECAME UNSUCCESSFUL
MOREINTERESTEDINPURCHASINGPRODUCTSANDSERVICES 7ORSEYET OTHERCOMPANIESWERELITTLEMORETHAN
THATWOULDALLOWTHEMTOPROVIDESUPPLEMENTAL CUS BAIT AND SWITCHSCHEMES PROMISINGTHEWORLDANDDE
TOMIZEDEDUCATIONOPPORTUNITIESFORTHEIRCHILDRENAT LIVERINGNOTHING4HENTHEREWERETHE0ONZISCHEMES
HOME ONVACATION ORINTHEBACKSEATOFTHEFAMILY WHEREENTREPRENEURSSOLICITEDNEWINVESTORS USING
MINIVAN#ONTINUEDINCREASESINRESOURCESSPURREDTHE PROMISESOFGREATRETURNS)NFACT OLDINVESTORSWERE
TECHNOLOGYINDUSTRYTOINVESTINNEW CREATIVEAP SIMPLYBEINGPAIDWITHMONEYFROMNEWINVESTORS
PROACHESTOLEARNING FUELINGADVANCESINVIRTUALLEARN THEREWASNOACTUALNEWBUSINESSDEVELOPMENT%VEN
INGTECHNOLOGYNEVERSEENBEFORE TUALLYTHEPYRAMIDCOLLAPSEDANDEVERYONELOSTMONEY
4HEEXPLOSIONOFINNOVATIONINEDUCATIONWASNOT EXCEPTTHEORGANIZERSOFTHESCHEME SOMEOFWHOM
LIMITEDTOTECHNOLOGYlRMS-ANYRETIREDANDSEMI ARENOWENJOYINGTHEHOSPITALITYOFTHESTATEPRISON
RETIREDBABYBOOMERS STILLCOMMITTEDTOSUPPORTING
THEDEMOCRATICPURPOSESOFEDUCATION PURSUEDENTRE
PRENEURIALVENTURESINVESTINGINTHEDEVELOPMENTOF
MANYOFTHENEWPRODUCTSANDSERVICESDISPLAYEDINTHE
ADJOININGEXHIBITHALL!SASIDEBENElT BOOMERSWHO
HAVESTAYEDINTHEWORKFORCEHAVECONTINUEDTOPAY
INTO3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARE THUSRELIEVINGSOME
OFTHEPRESSURESONTHESESYSTEMS


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

SYSTEMWHILEOTHERSARESUNNINGTHEMSELVESONDISTANT !BUNDANT
BEACHES
)NTHEMIDSTOFALLOFTHISBUSINESSACTIVITY MANY h0ARTY4IMEv
COMPANIES BOTHGOODANDBAD hWENTPUBLICv4HIS
CREATEDAWHOLENEWINVESTMENTSECTOR ATTRACTINGHUGE

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
SUMSOFMONEYFROMPRIVATEANDINSTITUTIONALINVESTORS

2ESOURCES
4HESEPUBLICLYTRADEDCOMPANIESFOUNDTHEMSELVES
UNDERTHEJURISDICTIONOFTHE3ECURITIESAND%XCHANGE
#OMMISSION)NAFEWISOLATEDBUTNOTORIOUSCASES
MORECOMPANYOFlCIALSFOUNDTHEMSELVESSTAYINGATTHE
3CARCE
GRAYBARHOTEL
#ONCERNEDABOUTTHEQUALITYOFSOMEOFTHEEDU
CATIONPRODUCTSANDSERVICESAVAILABLETOCONSUMERS
THE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONSOUGHTAUTHORITY FORPOSITIONSWITHIN3$%THANEVERBEFORE ANDTHE
FOR ANDEVENTUALLYESTABLISHED THE%DUCATION1UALITY CALIBEROFAPPLICANTSISTRULYASTOUNDING4ENYEARSAGO
#OMMISSION+NOWNASTHE%1# ITISFUNDEDBYA WEWOULDHAVELOSTTHISCALIBERPERSONTOOTHERPROFES
VALUE ADDEDTAXONALLEDUCATIONPRODUCTSSOLD7HILE SIONS SUCHASMEDICINE
ITHASNOACTUALREGULATORYAUTHORITY THISCOMMISSION )VETALKEDQUITEABITTHISMORNINGABOUTTHEMANY
MAKESGOODUSEOFITShBULLYPULPITvBYINSISTINGTHAT NEWEDUCATIONALPRODUCTSANDSERVICESBUTVERYLITTLE
THE$EPARTMENTFUNDANDDISSEMINATERESEARCHON ABOUTTHECONSUMERSOFTHESEPRODUCTSANDSERVICES
THEEFFECTIVENESSOFEDUCATIONPRODUCTSANDSERVICES /NEOFTHELARGESTISSUESWEFACEDASASTATEANDA
THROUGHAREVITALIZED7HAT7ORKS#LEARINGHOUSE)T NATIONDURINGTHEPASTDECADEWASTHETREMENDOUS
TURNEDTOSTATEDEPARTMENTSOFEDUCATIONASINDE INmUXOFIMMIGRANTS MOSTOFWHOMDIDNTSPEAK
PENDENT PUBLICSECTORORGANIZATIONS TOCONDUCTTHE %NGLISH)NTHEFACEOFCOMPETINGPUBLICCONCERNS
RESEARCHANDEVALUATIONNECESSARYTODETERMINEEF ABOUTLEGALANDILLEGALIMMIGRATION BUSINESSINTERESTS
FECTIVENESS THUSCREATINGAWHOLENEWLINEOFBUSINESS WONOUT HEADINGOFFRESTRICTIONSONIMMIGRATIONIN
FORSTATEAGENCIES!LONGTHEWAY 3$%REALIZEDTHAT ORDERTOENSURETHEMSELVESTHESTEADYSUPPLYOFLABOR
WHILEMANYCONSUMERSWERESAVVYENOUGHTOPROTECT NEEDEDTOFUELTHEGROWINGECONOMY)TWASINCUM
THEMSELVESFROMSHODDYPRODUCTSANDSERVICESAND BENTUPONTHEEDUCATIONCOMMUNITYTOPROVIDETHE
CONlDENCESCHEMES OTHERSNEEDEDAHELPINGHAND OPPORTUNITYFORSECOND LANGUAGELEARNERSTOBECOME
%VENTUALLY WECREATEDANDPRODUCEDANEWPRODUCT PROlCIENTIN%NGLISHANDINOTHERSUBJECTSSOTHATTHEY
#ONSUMER2EPORTSFOREDUCATIONPRODUCTS COULDFUNCTIONEFFECTIVELYINOURSOCIETYANDASANES
.EWLINESOFWORKLIKETHISONEHAVEKEPTOUR SENTIALPARTOFOURWORKFORCE4HISCREATEDTHENEEDFOR
AGENCYVIABLE!FTERALL MUCHOFOURFORMERBUSINESS AWHOLENEWRANGEOFPRODUCTSANDSERVICESTOADDRESS
RELIEDONADMINISTERINGANDMONITORINGFEDERALPRO THEPARTICULARNEEDSOFTHESESTUDENTS4HEINDUSTRY
GRAMS7ITHTHISWORKLARGELYDRIEDUP WEHAVEGONE ANDWORKFORCEDEVELOPMENTPARTNERSINOURPUBLIC
FROMBEINGPROVIDERSOFTECHNICALASSISTANCETOBEING PRIVATEPARTNERSHIPPROVIDEDMANYOFTHERESOURCES
RESEARCHANDEVALUATIONlRMS!LONGWITHTHISCHANGE TODEVELOPTHESENEWTOOLS)NSPIREDBYTHECHALLENGE
INOURCOREBUSINESS WEREFOCUSEDOURSTAFlNGEFFORTS THEYTURNEDTHEIREVER MOUNTINGINVENTORIESOFBARELY
SEEKINGNEWEXPERTISE-OSTOFOURRECENTLYHIREDSTAFF OBSOLETECOMPUTEREQUIPMENTINTOWELL EQUIPPED
MEMBERSWERERECRUITEDFROMUNIVERSITIESANDPRIVATE STOREFRONTLEARNINGLABORATORIESFORLANGUAGELEARNERS
RESEARCHORGANIZATIONS7ENOWHAVEMOREAPPLICANTS ANDOTHERNON TRADITIONALSTUDENTS
!S)CONCLUDETHISLOOKATTHECHANGESOVERTHELAST
DECADEANDHOWTHEYAFFECTEDTHEBUSINESSSECTOR )CAN

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

ONLYASK WHOWOULDHAVETHOUGHTIT!WHOLENEW !NALYSISOF3CENARIO


INDUSTRYHASARISENFROMTHENEEDFORPERIODICTESTING
TODETERMINEWHETHEROURCHILDRENWEREACHIEVINGTHE )MPLICATIONS
GOALSINTHEIRINDIVIDUALPLANSANDDIAGNOSINGTHEIR 2EDUCEDGOVERNMENTREGULATIONINGENERALISLIKELY
ONGOINGLEARNINGNEEDS.OW THEREARETESTINGCENTERS TORESULTINANINCREASEINBUSINESSACTIVITYANDIN
ONSEEMINGLYEVERYSTREETCORNER ASWELLASAMULTITUDE CREASEDTAXREVENUES!SSTATESREDUCETHEIRREGULATORY
OFSECUREONLINETESTINGCENTERS4HETESTSTHEYADMIN CONTROLOVERPUBLICSCHOOLING MOREDECISIONSWILLBE
ISTERAREAVAILABLEINARANGEOFLANGUAGESANDMODESIN LEFTTOPARENTS3OMESTATESMAYFAREBETTERECONOMI
ORDERTOADDRESSTHEDIFFERENCESINHOWCHILDRENLEARN CALLYTHANOTHERS4HISCOULDRESULTINDIFFERENCESIN
!SYOUKNOW THESECENTERSNOTONLYREPORTRESULTS THEQUALITYANDVARIETYOFEDUCATIONOPPORTUNITIESFROM
RELATEDTOACHIEVEMENTOFSPECIlCINDIVIDUALLEARNING STATE TO STATE&EDERALEFFORTSTOENSUREQUALITYWILL
GOALS THEYALSOPROVIDEDETAILED INDIVIDUALDIAGNOSTIC SERVETOPROMOTESOMECONSISTENCY
ANDPRESCRIPTIVEINFORMATION!TLASTWEHAVEASSESS 4HEREWILLBEINCREASEDOPTIONSFORCUSTOMIZEDEDU
MENTSTHATACTUALLYHELPUSDELIVERBETTERINSTRUCTION CATIONFORSPECIlCSEGMENTSOFTHESCHOOLPOPULATION
)TWASAWELCOMEDEVELOPMENTTHATWASALONGTIME INCLUDINGIMMIGRANTSREQUIRINGSPECIALIZEDSERVICES
COMING 3CHOOLCHOICEWILLBETHERULE NOTTHEEXCEPTION
3O HEREWEARETODAY LIVINGINAVASTLYDIFFERENT #OMMERCIALCOMPANIES ESPECIALLYTECHNOLOGYlRMS
WORLDFROMJUSTADECADEAGO,EARNINGANYTIMEANY WILLBEBIGPLAYERSANDFUNDERS3%!SWILLHAVEADIF
WHEREISAREALITYANDINDIVIDUALIZEDLEARNINGISNOW FERENTROLE MOREFOCUSEDONENSURINGQUALITYTHROUGH
THENORMANDISNOTJUSTFORACHOSENFEW!SANATION RESEARCHANDEVALUATION!SARESULT 3%!STAFFWILL
OURLITERACYANDNUMERACYRATESAREUP#HILDRENARE NEEDADIFFERENTMIXOFSKILLS!SSESSMENTTESTINGWILL
LEARNING0UBLICANDPRIVATEORGANIZATIONSHAVEFOUND BEEVENBIGGERBUSINESSTHANITISNOW
NEWWAYSTOWORKTOGETHERFORTHEBETTERMENTOF 4HEPOTENTIALEXISTSFORTHE3%!TOBECOMEFRAG
SOCIETYANDCOMMERCE)NTHISNEWWORLDOFLEARNING MENTEDANDNOTSYSTEMICINITSAPPROACH ANDFORIT
OPPORTUNITIESABOUND4ODAY)INVITEALLOFYOUTOJOIN TOLOSETOUCHWITHITSCUSTOMERS#OMMUNICATION
MEINTHISGRANDNEWENTERPRISE4HEFUTUREISOURS BETWEENDIFFERENTSECTIONSOFTHE3%!COULDDECREASE
AND3%!PROGRAMSCOULDBEGINTOOPERATEINDEPEN
DENTLYORATCROSSPURPOSESWITHONEANOTHER


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NDICATORS /PTIONS
%VENTSANDTRENDSTHATCOULDSIGNALTHEDEVELOP &OR3%!STOCONTINUETOBERELEVANTANDEFFECTIVE
MENTOFTHISSCENARIOINCLUDE INTHISENVIRONMENT THEYMUSTCLEARLYUNDERSTAND
THEIRCUSTOMERSNEEDSANDACTONTHATKNOWLEDGETO
s 3TATESPREVAILINGAININGRELIEFFROM.#,"RE
PLANTHEIRWORKANDDELIVERCOORDINATED HIGH QUALITY
QUIREMENTS
SERVICES4HEYWILLNEEDTOWORKWITHSTATELEGISLATURES
s 3TATEAGENCIESGAINMOREmEXIBILITYINHOWTHEY TOENSURETHATTHEYHAVEmEXIBILITYTOCOLLABORATEWITH
AREALLOWEDTOOPERATEASORGANIZATIONS OTHERPUBLICANDPRIVATEORGANIZATIONSINCREATIVEWAYS
!LONGWITHTHIS 3%!SSHOULDENCOURAGEPARTICIPATION
s 4HEREISREDUCEDPRESSUREONFEDERALEDUCATION OFCOMMERCIALlRMS INCLUDINGTHETECHNOLOGYSECTOR
FUNDINGDUETOREDUCTIONSINDEFENSESPENDING WHENEVERPOSSIBLE WHILEAVOIDINGSELLINGOUTTOCOM
REFORMSIN3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARE AND MERCIALINTERESTS
INCREASESINTAXREVENUES 4HEREWILLBEANINCREASEDNEEDFORSTAFFWITH
RESEARCHANDEVALUATIONSKILLS ASWELLASTHOSEWHO
s 4HEFEDERALROLEINEDUCATIONSHIFTSAWAYFROM
UNDERSTANDTHENEEDSOFSECOND LANGUAGELEARNERS#OL
DICTATINGOUTCOMESANDFUNDINGPROGRAMSATTHE
LABORATIONWITHHIGHEREDUCATIONANDPRIVATERESEARCH
STATEANDLOCALLEVELTOBEINGMOREOFANATIONAL
ORGANIZATIONSWILLBOLSTERRESEARCHANDEVALUATIONCAPA
LEADERINENSURINGQUALITY
BILITIES&UTURESTAFlNGREQUIREMENTSSHOULDBEEXAM
s 3TATEECONOMIESBEGINTOGROWANDLEGISLATURES INEDCONTINUALLYTOENSURETHAT3%!STAFFSKILLSAREA
AREWILLINGTOSPENDONEDUCATION MATCHWITHCUSTOMERSERVICENEEDS)TWILLBEVITALTO
BROADENTHEDElNITIONOFPUBLICEDUCATIONINORDERTO
s #OMMERCIALlRMSINCREASETHEIRINVESTMENTIN ENCOMPASSAWIDERANGEOFSTRATEGIESFORDELIVERY4O
EDUCATIONTHROUGHDIRECTFUNDINGOFPROGRAMS REMAINCOHERENTANDFOCUSED THE3%!MUSTENGAGEIN
ANDTHROUGHAGGRESSIVEPRICINGOFPRODUCTSAND RIGOROUSORGANIZATION WIDELONG TERMPLANNINGANDIN
SERVICESTOSCHOOLS CREASECOMMUNICATIONACROSSTHEAGENCY&URTHERMORE
s .ATIONALSURVEYSSHOWANINCREASEDINTERESTIN 3%!SSHOULDLOOKFORANDEXPLOITOPPORTUNITIESFOR
EDUCATIONBYTHEGENERALPUBLIC COLLABORATIONANDLEVERAGINGACROSSAGENCYPROGRAMS

s #ONSUMERSOFEDUCATIONPRODUCTSANDSERVICES
BEGINTOSELECTALTERNATIVEPROVIDERSATAGREATER
PACE LEAVINGTHEPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEM

s 3%!STAFFANDPROGRAMSBEGINTOGROW

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY !BUNDANT

3CENARIO
$EEP#AUSES

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATGOVERNMENTlNANCIAL
SUPPORTFOR+nEDUCATIONISLIMITEDANDTHATGOV

2ESOURCES
ERNMENTREGULATIONOF+nEDUCATIONHASDECLINED
CONSIDERABLYATBOTHFEDERALANDSTATELEVELS,IKEWISE h(ARD4IMESv

STATEDEPARTMENTSOFEDUCATIONHAVESEENTHEIRROLES
ASMAJORCONDUITSANDMANAGERSOFFEDERALFUNDINGFOR 3CARCE
+nEDUCATIONDECLINE)NTHEPAST ASMUCHASHALFOF
THEFUNDINGmOWINGTOTHESEAGENCIESHASBEENTHROUGH
THEFEDERAL4ITLE)AND)$%!PROGRAMS3TAFFASSIGNED
TOTHESEPROGRAMSISNOLONGERNEEDEDFORTHESESPECIlC
TASKS4HESESTATEAGENCIESARESTRUGGLINGTOlNDAROLE h(ARD4IMESv
INTHENEWENVIRONMENT 4IME
4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO 0LACE4HECONFERENCEROOMOFTHEOFlCESOF3ANDIAS
3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION
s !MERICAEXPERIENCESAGENERALECONOMICDECLINE
DUETOTHEHIGHCOSTSOFTHEWARIN)RAQANDITS 3CENE$R!NDREA#OREYHASCONVENEDASTRATEGIC
AFTERMATH HOMELANDSECURITY 3OCIAL3ECURITY PLANNINGSESSIONWITHHERSENIORSTAFFTOIDENTIFYHOW
AND-EDICARE ANDSOARINGOILPRICESRESULTINGIN THEAGENCYWILLCONTINUETOSUPPORT3ANDIASEDUCATORS
CUTSTOEDUCATIONSPENDING ANDSTUDENTS
s 3TATESSUCCEEDINOBTAININGRELIEFFROMREGULATIONS
UNDER.#,"ORSIMPLYOPTOUTOFTHEPROGRAM
DECLININGTHEFEDERALDOLLARSASSOCIATEDWITH 4HANKYOUALLFORCLEARINGYOURSCHEDULESTOBEHERE
COMPLIANCE TODAY!SYOUKNOW WEVEPLANNEDADAY LONGSESSION
TODOTHEIMPORTANTWORKOFIDENTIFYINGOPPORTUNITIES
s !SONEWAYOFADDRESSINGTHELACKOFRESOURCES
FOR3$%TOFOCUSONINTHECOMINGYEARS4OGETHER WE
STATESREDUCETHEIROWNREGULATORYCONTROLOVER
WILLDETERMINEHOWTOTAKEADVANTAGEOFTHOSEOP
PUBLICSCHOOLSBYWATERINGDOWNACCREDITATION
PORTUNITIESINAWAYTHATWILLHAVEAREAL MEASURABLE
STANDARDS
IMPACTON3ANDIANS
s %CONOMICDECLINELEADSTOREDUCTIONSINSPENDING )FYOUHAVENTALREADY PLEASEHELPYOURSELFTOTHE
FOROTHERSOCIALPROGRAMS INCLUDINGEARLY CONTINENTALBREAKFASTINTHEBACKOFTHEROOM"ECAUSE
CHILDHOODEDUCATION PREVENTIVEHEALTHPROGRAMS OFTHESERIOUSNATUREOFTHISMEETING )RECEIVEDSPECIAL
ANDOTHERSERVICESFORDISADVANTAGEDFAMILIES APPROVALFROMTHEBOARDTREASURERTOWAIVEOURPOLICY
RESULTINGININCREASEDNUMBERSOFSCHOOL AGE OFNOTUSINGDISTRICTFUNDSTOPROVIDEFOODATMEET
CHILDRENGOINGWITHOUTBASICHEALTHCARESUCHAS INGS(OWEVER CONTINENTALBREAKFASTWASASMUCHOFA
IMMUNIZATIONSANDVISIONANDHEARINGSCREENINGS hMEALvAS)WASABLETOGETCOVEREDANDSO ASYOUKNOW
YOUWILLHAVETOPAYFORYOUROWNLUNCH WHICHWILL
s 3CHOOLENROLLMENTDROPSDUETONEW MORE ARRIVEATNOON7E@VESCHEDULEDA MINUTEBREAKAT
RESTRICTIVEIMMIGRATIONPOLICIESATTHENATIONAL MID MORNINGANDMID AFTERNOON)HAVETURNEDOFFMY
LEVELANDAGENERALLOSSOFFAITHBYTHEPUBLICIN CELLPHONEANDTRUSTTHATYOU TOO HAVETURNEDOFFYOUR
THESAFETYANDQUALITYOFPUBLICSCHOOLS CELLPHONES PAGERS 0$!SANDOTHERELECTRONICDEVICES


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

7EAREATACROSSROADSINOURLIFEASANAGENCY"Y ˆWITHALLTHEOTHERDEMANDSONTHEFEDERALBUDGET
RETHINKINGOURROLEANDFOCUSINGONTHENEEDSOFOUR FEDERALFUNDINGFOREDUCATIONWASSTEADILYDECLINING
CUSTOMERS WECANIMPROVEPUBLICEDUCATIONFORALL ANYWAY)NTHEEND STATESREGAINEDCONTROL INPART
OFTHECHILDRENOF3ANDIAASWELLASSECURETHEFUTURE BECAUSETHEFEDSDIDNTHAVETHEMONEYTOSTAYINTHE
OF3$%)FWEDONTSUCCEEDINCLEARLYIDENTIFYINGOUR GAME)NSOMECASES ASAPRACTICALANDFACE SAVING
GOALSANDWAYSTOACHIEVETHEMINTHECOMINGYEARS MEASURE THEFEDSAGREEDTOhALLOWvSTATEREGULATIONSTO
WERUNTHERISKOFBECOMINGATBESTANANACHRONISM ASSUMEPRIMACYASLONGASONPAPERTHEYWEREEQUALTO
ANDATWORSTAFOOTNOTEINHISTORY7ENEEDTOFOCUS ORMORESTRINGENTTHANTHEIRFEDERALCOUNTERPARTS)N
OURATTENTIONSQUARELYONTHEBUSINESSOFTHEDAY OTHERCASES STATESSIMPLYELECTEDTOWALKAWAYFROM
)WILLBEGINBYRECOUNTINGEVENTSOVERTHEPASTTEN FEDERALFUNDINGRATHERTHANCOMPLYWITHTHEMANY
YEARSTHATHAVEBROUGHTUSTOOURSITUATIONTODAY4HIS REQUIREMENTSTHATACCOMPANIEDIT
ISMORETHANSTORYTELLING SOBEARWITHMEAS)REVISIT 4HEDEVOLUTIONOFAUTHORITYFORMANYPROGRAMS
EVENTSTHATYOUMIGHTREMEMBERONLYTOOWELL9OUSEE BACKTOTHESTATESWASADOUBLE EDGEDSWORD3TATES
)BELIEVETHATBYUNDERSTANDINGOURPAST WECANBETTER INCLUDING3ANDIA DIDREGAINSOMEAUTHORITYAND
PLANOURFUTURE AUTONOMY"UT ATTHESAMETIME YOUTHCRIMEAND
,ETSBEGININ THEYEARTHE.O#HILD,EFT DELINQUENCYRATESWENTUPASFEDERALFUNDINGFORLAW
"EHIND!CT CALLED.#,"FORSHORT WENTINTOEFFECT ENFORCEMENTATTHESTATEANDLOCALLEVELSWASCUT"Y
4OSOME .#,"WASTHESINGLELARGESTINTRUSIONON THESAMETOKEN ASTHEFEDSRETURNEDMOREANDMORE
LOCALCONTROLEVERPERPETRATEDONPUBLICEDUCATIONBY RESPONSIBILITYANDAUTHORITYTOTHESTATES -EDICAID
THEFEDERALGOVERNMENT4OOTHERSITWASADEMONSTRA COVERAGEFORCHILDRENDECREASEDRESULTINGININCREASING
TIONOFSTRONGCOMMITMENTTOEDUCATIONFROMTHE RATESOFCHILDHOODINFECTIOUSDISEASESANDOTHERPREVI
HIGHESTLEVELSOFOURGOVERNMENT7EARENOTHERE OUSLYPREVENTABLEILLNESSES
TODEBATEWHICHVIEWWASRIGHTBUTTODEALWITHTHE )NCREASEDOUTSOURCINGINMAJORECONOMICSECTORS
OUTCOMESOFTHISLEGISLATIONANDTHEIMPACTITHASHAD PUTDOWNWARDPRESSUREONSALARIESANDBENElTSAND
ONOURSTATE#OINCIDENTALLY .#,"CAMEINTOEFFECT CAUSEDSIGNIlCANTUNEMPLOYMENTINSOMEINDUSTRIES
ATTHESAMETIMETHATOURCOUNTRYEMBARKEDUPONA 3TATETAXESWENTUPTOREPLACEDECLININGFEDERALDOLLARS
HUGEANDCOSTLYNATIONALSECURITYANDDEFENSEPROGRAM BUTWITHTHOSEDOLLARSGOINGOUTOFOURPAYCHECKS WE
INCLUDINGFOREIGNINCURSIONSIN)RAQAND!FGHANISTAN ALLHADLESSTOSPEND3ALESTAXREVENUESWENTDOWN
AND LATER )RANAND.ORTH+OREA!SYOUWILLRECALL ASARESULTANDOTHERTAXESWEREINCREASEDTOMAKEUP
THEDOLLARSOURNATIONSPENTONTHESEWARSWERENEARLY FORTHELOWERSALESTAXREVENUES!ND)DONTHAVETO
MATCHEDBYTHECOSTOFSECURITYMEASURESATHOME7E TELLYOUTHATHIGHERPROPERTYTAXESMADEHOUSINGLESS
ALSOWATCHEDASOILPRICESSAPPEDDOLLARSOUTOFTHE AFFORDABLE DO)7EVESEENFAMILIESMOVINGINTO
ECONOMYANDPUBLICANDPRIVATEPENSIONFUNDSMELTED GETHERTOREDUCEEXPENSES)NSOMECASES HOMEOWNERS
AWAY4HEPENSIONDEBACLETHROUGHOUTTHEAIRLINE HAVERESORTEDTOTHETIME HONOREDPRACTICEOFTAKINGIN
INDUSTRYTHATERUPTEDINWHEN5NITED!IRLINES BOARDERS
WASDESPERATELYTRYINGTOSTAYINBUSINESSWASONLYTHE !STHESEEVENTSHAVEPLAYEDOUT WEVESEENA
BEGINNING3OMETHINGHADTOGIVE7HATGAVE ASYOU STEADYDECLINEINTHESIZEANDINmUENCEOFOUROWN
ALLKNOW WASFEDERALSUPPORTFORPUBLICEDUCATION AGENCY7ITHOUTFEDERALDOLLARSTODISTRIBUTE MANAGE
)N 3ANDIAWASAMONGTHESTATESTHATlRST ANDMONITOR OURIMPORTANCETOLOCALEDUCATIONAGEN
REVOLTEDAGAINSTTHEUNFUNDEDMANDATESOF.#," CIESHASDECLINED"ECAUSEWECANTPROVIDERESOURCES
5TAHLEDTHEREVOLTBYPASSINGLEGISLATIONTHATPUT TOSCHOOLDISTRICTSASWEDIDBEFORE THEYNOLONGER
STATEEDUCATIONREGULATIONABOVEFEDERALLAW ANDTHE THINKOFUSASARESOURCEWHENANEWNEEDARISES7ITH
RESTOFUSFOLLOWED ATTEMPTINGTORESTORETHECONCEPT THELOSSOFSTATEANDFEDERALREVENUES WEVEHADTOCUT
OFFEDERALISMTOOURWAYOFGOVERNING!lGHTENSUED STAFFAGAINANDAGAINUNTILWEARENOWATLESSTHANA
OVERWHETHERTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTCOULDWITHHOLD THIRDOFOURSIZEIN,ETMESTOPHERETOACKNOWL
FUNDINGFROMDISSENTINGSTATES"UTHEREWASTHERUB EDGETHATTHOSEOFYOUWHOARELEFTHAVEDONEYEOMANS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

DUTYATSERVINGOURSTATESCHILDRENANDTHEIRSCHOOLS) !BUNDANT
AMINAWEOFYOURCOMMITMENT AND)AMCOMMITTED
TOLEAVINGNOSTONEUNTURNEDASWESEEKOUTWAYSTO
REVIVEOURAGENCYTOMEETOURMISSIONOFPROVIDING
QUALITYEDUCATIONTOALLTHECHILDRENOFTHISGREATSTATE

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
)VEPAINTEDAPRETTYBLEAKPICTUREOFTHESESHIFTING

2ESOURCES
FEDERALPRIORITIESBUTNOTALLOFTHEEVENTSOFTHEPAST
TENYEARSCANBEATTRIBUTEDTOTHEFEDERALFALLOUT4HE h(ARD4IMESv
VERYNATUREOFOURPOPULATIONHASSERVEDUPITSOWNSET
OFCHALLENGES,IKEASETOFBOOKENDS TRENDSINBOTH
3CARCE
OURYOUNGANDOLDPOPULATIONSHAVEPUTTHESQUEEZEON
OURSOCIALANDECONOMICSYSTEMS
&OREXAMPLE THEREARETHEELDERLY4HINKABOUTIT
"EGINNINGIN NEARLYMILLIONBABYBOOMERS
7HEREAREOURCHILDREN4OANSWERTHIS LOOKBACK
BEGANTURNING-ANYHADALREADYLEFTTHEWORKFORCE
TO WHENAPOPULARBACKLASHAGAINSTLAXENFORCE
THROUGHEARLYRETIREMENTS&ORTUNATELY AGOODSHARE
MENTBYTHE)MMIGRATIONAND#USTOMS%NFORCEMENT
HASSTAYEDINTHEWORKFORCE CONTINUINGTOCONTRIB
AGENCYREDUCEDTHENUMBEROFBOTHLEGALANDILLEGAL
UTETO3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICAREANDPUTTINGOFF
IMMIGRANTS4HE-INUTE-ENCIVILIANBORDERPATROL
COLLECTINGBENElTS"OOMERS MYGENERATIONINCIDEN
WASJUSTTHEOPENINGSALVOINMANYVIGILANTEEFFORTS
TALLY WERETHESINGLELARGESTGENERATIONINOURHISTORY
TOTURNBACKILLEGALIMMIGRANTS"ECAUSEOFTHIS OUR
4HROUGHOURCONTRIBUTIONSTOTAXREVENUES THEFEDERAL
SCHOOL AGEPOPULATIONHASDECLINEDANDBECOMEMUCH
GOVERNMENTWASABLETODESIGNANDIMPLEMENTMAJOR
LESSDIVERSEINTERMSOFCULTUREANDLANGUAGE
PROGRAMSTOADDRESSTHENEEDSOFSTUDENTSWHOFOR
3ERVINGTHENEEDSOFTHECHILDRENWEDOHAVEHAS
AVARIETYOFREASONSREQUIREDADDITIONALEDUCATIONAL
BECOMEMOREDIFlCULTEACHYEAR7EHAVELONGBEEN
SERVICES4ITLE)ASSISTEDGENERATIONSOFLOW INCOME
AWAREOFTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENSTUDENTACHIEVE
STUDENTSBYPROVIDINGADDITIONALRESOURCESTOTHEIR
MENTANDPOVERTY BUTWESTILLSTRUGGLEWITHTHE
SCHOOLS4HE)NDIVIDUALSWITH$ISABILITIES%DUCA
PERCENTAGEOFCHILDRENLIVINGBELOWTHEPOVERTYLINE
TION!CTWASATREMENDOUSSOURCEOFHELPFORSTUDENTS
MANYOFWHOMLIVEINHOUSEHOLDSHEADEDBYASINGLE
WITHPHYSICALANDMENTALHANDICAPS ANDANESSENTIAL
MOTHER7HEN-EDICAIDFUNDINGWASCUT PRENATALAND
SOURCEOFREVENUEFORTHESCHOOLSWORKINGHARDTOMEET
WELLBABYCAREWASLESSAVAILABLEFORTHOSEMOTHERSAND
THENEEDSOFTHESESPECIALSTUDENTS.OWTHATAHUGE
CHILDRENWHONEEDEDITMOST!SARESULT MORECHIL
PORTIONOFOURFEDERALTAXDOLLARISDEVOTEDTOSUP
DRENCOMETOSCHOOLTHESEDAYSWITHSPECIALNEEDS$E
PORTINGRETIREESANDPROVIDINGFORTHEIRMEDICALCARE
CLINESINIMMUNIZATIONRATESHAVERESULTEDINEPIDEM
THEREAREFARFEWERDOLLARSAVAILABLEFOROTHERTHINGS
ICSOFMEASLES MUMPS ANDWHOOPINGCOUGH3CARLET
4HESTATESHAVEBEENLEFTHOLDINGTHEBAGINTERMSOF
FEVERISAGAINONTHERISE7EFEARTHEDAYTHElRSTCASE
SERVINGITSYOUNGERCITIZENS
OFSMALLPOXISDIAGNOSED
(EREIN3ANDIAWEHAVEANEVENGREATERPROBLEM
4HEREISNODENYINGTHATTHEGROWINGGAPBETWEEN
-ANYRETIREESAREMOVINGTOOURSTATETOTAKEADVAN
THEHAVESANDTHEHAVE NOTSREVEALSITSELFINTHEFACES
TAGEOFTHEWONDERFULCLIMATEANDLOWSTATETAXES4HE
OFOURPUBLICSCHOOLSTUDENTS!SPUBLICEDUCATION
CENSUSCONlRMEDTHISSHIFTINOURPOPULATION)N
BECOMESMORESTARVEDFORRESOURCES PARENTSWHO
THENEXTELECTION ITWILLBEAHARDSELLTOCONVINCE
CANAFFORDITARESENDINGTHEIRCHILDRENTOPRIVATEOR
THESEPEOPLETOPARTWITHMOREOFTHEIRlXEDINCOMES
PAROCHIALSCHOOLS7HEN3ANDIAPASSEDITSSCHOOL
TOPAYFORSCHOOLBONDISSUES!TTHESAMETIMETHAT
CHOICELEGISLATIONIN ITOPENEDTHEDOORFORAN
THEELDERLYAREMOVINGTO3ANDIA YOUNGPEOPLEARE
EXODUSOFSTUDENTSFROMPUBLICSCHOOLS.OTONLYDID
LEAVINGTHESTATE LOOKINGFORBETTERJOBSANDNEWOP
THISFURTHERREDUCETHElNANCIALRESOURCESAVAILABLE
PORTUNITIES


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

TOPUBLICSCHOOLS ITTYPICALLYLEFTPUBLICSCHOOLSWITH ENCE COMMITMENTTOTHEFUTUREOFOURCHILDREN AND


HIGHERPERCENTAGESOFHARD TO SERVESTUDENTS!SSTATE COMMITMENTTOTHEIDEAOFPUBLICSERVICE!NDJOYIN
RESOURCESTOSUPPORTHIGHEREDUCATIONHAVEDECLINED SEEINGTHEDAWNOFUNDERSTANDINGINACHILDSEYES THE
TUITIONATOURSTATECOLLEGESANDUNIVERSITIESHASGONE EXCITEMENTOFACHEMISTRYPROJECTGONEINCREDIBLYRIGHT
UP MAKINGHIGHEREDUCATIONLESSACCESSIBLETOMANYOF ANDTHESATISFACTIONOFHAVINGAFORMERSTUDENTGIVE
OURYOUNGPEOPLE!GAIN )DONTNEEDTOREMINDYOU CREDITTOATEACHERFORHELPINGHIMORHERlNDDIREC
OFTHESTATISTICSABOUTEARNINGPOWERASTHEYRELATETOA TIONINLIFE!NDYET DESPITETHEREWARDSOFTEACHING
POST SECONDARYEDUCATION FORSOMETHERISINGCOSTSOFOBTAININGTHECERTIlCATE
7EALTHIERFAMILIESARENOTTHEONLYhREFUGEESvFROM ANDTHELOWPROJECTEDLIFETIMEEARNINGSOFTHEJOBARE
PUBLICSCHOOLS%VENLOW INCOMEPARENTS ALREADYFRUS FORCINGTHEMTOPURSUEMORELUCRATIVECAREERS!SMORE
TRATEDBYLOWTESTSCORES ALSONOWWORRYABOUTSCHOOL ANDMOREBABYBOOMERSHEADINTORETIREMENT THEDIF
SAFETYnPARTICULARLYAFTERTHESO CALLED#OLUMBINE)) lCULTYOFREPLACINGTHEMLOOMSLARGE
MASSACREIN4ENNESSEE!SARESULT MANYHAVETURNED /FCOURSEATTRACTINGANDKEEPINGTHEBESTAND
TOHOMESCHOOLING PAROCHIAL OROTHERPRIVATESCHOOLS BRIGHTESTINTHETEACHINGWORKFORCEHASALWAYSBEEN
4HISISWHYWEMUSTRETHINKOURMISSIONANDROLE#AN ONEOF3ANDIASBIGGESTCHALLENGES7HENTHESTATELEG
WEMAINTAINOURMISSIONOFIMPROVINGLEARNINGFORALL ISLATUREPASSEDTHETUITIONFORGIVENESSPROGRAMIN
CHILDRENIN3ANDIAANDSTILLSUPPORTTHEPUBLICEDUCA ITWENTALONGWAYTOWARDENCOURAGINGYOUNG BRIGHT
TIONSYSTEM)KNOWSOMEOFYOUHAVESEENMEASA TECHNOLOGY SAVVYTEACHERSTOSTAYINOURRURALAND
BABYBOOMDINOSAURAS)HAVECONSISTENTLYWORKED ECONOMICALLYDEPRESSEDURBANSCHOOLSBUTUNLESSWE
TOUPHOLDOURTRADITIONALSYSTEMOFPUBLICEDUCATION CANDOMORETOIMPROVETHEIRSALARIES )BELIEVEEVEN
"ELIEVEITORNOT )NOWBELIEVETHATOURFUTUREASA THATSIGNIlCANTBREAKONTUITIONWILLNOTBESUFlCIENT
STATEAGENCYANDOURONLYHOPEOFMEETINGOURMISSION INCENTIVEFORMANYYOUNGPEOPLETOGOINTOTEACHINGIN
LIESINMEETINGOUROBLIGATIONTOOURCHILDREN REGARD THEFUTURE
LESSOFWHERETHEYATTENDSCHOOL )TSTRUETHAT)VEBEENDESCRIBINGALANDSCAPEAS
)CANSEESOMEOFYOUTHINKING WELL WELL MAYBE BLEAKANDDARKASA$ICKENSNOVEL SOLETMEPOINTTO
ANOLDDOGCANLEARNNEWTRICKS7ELL THEIMPACTOF SOMEBRIGHTSPOTS/NTHEPLUSSIDE MOREANDMORE
ALLOFTHESECHANGESON3ANDIASPUBLICSCHOOLSISPRETTY SCHOOLSANDDISTRICTSARECREATIVELYSOLVINGSOMEOF
OBVIOUS EVENFORANIDEALISTLIKEME&IRST OURDECLIN THEIRPROBLEMSBYBANDINGTOGETHERTOSHARESERVICES
INGENROLLMENTHASREQUIREDUSTOREDUCEOURTEACHER ANDTHUSREDUCEEXPENSES
WORKFORCE RESULTINGINLARGERCLASSSIZESFORMANY )NADDITION THROUGHOUTTHESTATE SMALLBUSINESS
CHILDREN3ECONDLY EVENTHOUGHTECHNOLOGYCONTINUES HASBLOSSOMED DUEINPART SOMESAY TODECREASED
TOIMPROVEINQUALITY SOPHISTICATION ANDAFFORDABIL FEDERALREGULATIONANDTHEFACTTHATMANYLARGECOR
ITY PRESSURESONBUDGETSHAVELIMITEDTHEABILITYOF PORATIONSHAVEMOVEDTHEIROPERATIONSOFFSHOREFOR
SCHOOLSTOTAKEADVANTAGEOFTECHNOLOGYASAMEANSOF LOWERLABORCOSTS3MALLBUSINESSOWNERS AWAREOFTHE
ENRICHINGINSTRUCTIONANDCREATINGNEWOPPORTUNITIES NEEDFORVIBRANTLOCALECONOMIESTOSUSTAINTHEM ARE
FORSTUDENTS4HIRD BECAUSEELDERLYVOTERSARERELUCTANT FARMOREWILLINGTHANBEFORETOSUPPORTTHEIRPUBLIC
TOPASSBONDISSUESFORSCHOOLFACILITIESANDEQUIPMENT SCHOOLS IFNOTWITHCASH ATLEASTWITHTIME ASMORE
BUILDINGSAREDETERIORATING ANDMORECOMPANIESAREPROVIDINGPAIDLEAVEFOR
4HROUGHOUTMYLONGCAREERINTHISINDUSTRY )HAVE PARENTSWHOVOLUNTEERINTHESCHOOLS
ALWAYSVIEWEDOURTEACHERANDADMINISTRATORWORK &OLLOWINGTHELOSSOFFEDERALFUNDSFOR+nEDUCA
FORCESASTHESAVINGGRACESFORTHESYSTEM%VENINHARD TION MANYOFTHEBURDENSOMEFEDERALREGULATIONSTHAT
TIMES HIGHQUALITYPEOPLECONTINUETOJOINTHEPROFES COMPLICATEDOURJOBS SAPPEDRESOURCES ANDSTImED
SIONANDWEKNOWITSNOTTHESALARY FRINGEBENElTS OR CREATIVITYALSOFELLAWAY7ITHFEWERANDLESSBURDEN
OTHERPERKSTHATCOMEWITHACAREERINEDUCATIONTHAT SOMEREGULATIONS WEAREINABETTERPOSITIONTOTAPTHE
ATTRACTSTHEM.O ITISCOMMITMENTˆCOMMITMENT CREATIVITYANDINNOVATIONINOUROWNCOMMUNITIES
TOTHEBELIEFTHATASTEACHERSTHEYCANMAKEADIFFER 2ESEARCHHASSHOWNTHATHIGH QUALITYELEMENTARY

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

ANDSECONDARYEDUCATIONRESULTSINHIGHERLIFETIME !BUNDANT
INCOMES LOWERCRIMERATES ANDAHIGHERQUALITYOF
LIFE2ESEARCHALSOSHOWSTHATNOTALLPROGRAMSPRODUCE
POSITIVERESULTSˆPROGRAMQUALITYISKEY)NTHE
ABSENCEOFFEDERALOVERSIGHTOFOURPROGRAMS ITISUPTO

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
USTOGUARANTEETHEQUALITYOFTHEEDUCATIONEXPERIENC

2ESOURCES
ESWEPROVIDETOOURCHILDRENITISUPTOUSTOADVOCATE
FORACADEMICRIGORITISUPTOUSTOENSURETHATOUR h(ARD4IMESv
NEEDYANDMENTALLYANDPHYSICALLYCHALLENGEDSTUDENTS
GETTHESUPPORTANDSERVICESTHEYNEEDTOREACHTHEIR
3CARCE
POTENTIAL
3O WEAREATACROSSROADSINOURROLEASANAGENCY
7ECANCONTINUEBUSINESSASUSUALORWECANSEIZETHE
OPPORTUNITYTORESHAPEOURSELVESANDOURPROGRAM
EDUCATIONISLESSAFFORDABLEASTAXSUPPORTFORPUBLIC
PLANSFORTHEFUTURE7ECANBECOMEANAGENCYTHAT
COLLEGESANDUNIVERSITIESHASDECLINED
FOCUSESEFFECTIVELYONIMPROVINGALLSCHOOLSBYENHANC
4EACHERSCOULDBEINSHORTSUPPLYDUETOTHE
INGTEACHERQUALITY ENSURINGQUALITYPROGRAMS ENGAG
EXPENSEOFOBTAININGTHENECESSARYEDUCATIONASWELLAS
INGLOCALBUSINESSCOMMUNITIESINEFFORTSTOSUPPORT
THELOWSALARIESOFFEREDEVENEXPERIENCEDTEACHERS4O
PUBLICEDUCATION ANDLEVERAGINGINNOVATIVETECHNOL
MITIGATEPRESSURESONFUNDING THEREWILLBEAGREATER
OGYTOIMPROVELEARNINGOPPORTUNITIESFORALL7EVE
NEEDFORSERVICEINTEGRATIONACROSSHUMANSERVICE
GOTALOTOFWORKAHEADOFUS SOLETSGETSTARTED
HEALTH ANDEDUCATIONAGENCIES3OMELOCALECONO
MIESCOULDBEHEALTHIERINCOMPARISONTOTHENATIONAL
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO ECONOMY OFFERINGSOMEAVENUESFORADDITIONALSUPPORT
FORTHOSEPUBLICSCHOOLS
)MPLICATIONS
)NTHEWORLDDESCRIBEDINTHISSCENARIO STATESHAVE
MOREFREEDOMFROMFEDERALREGULATIONBUTDONOTHAVE
AWEALTHOFRESOURCESWITHWHICHTOEXERCISETHISNEW
AUTHORITY3TATEAGENCIES IFTHEYHAVEAROLEATALL MAY
BECOMEBYDEFAULTTHEGUARANTORSOFQUALITYINEDUCA
TION
4HE3%!HASEXPERIENCEDSUBSTANTIALCUTSINSTAFF
DUETOREDUCEDREVENUES!TTHESCHOOLLEVEL AWEALTH
OFSOCIALILLSAREIMPACTINGEDUCATIONANDLEARNING IN
CLUDINGINCREASESINCHILDHOODILLNESSES MORELATCHKEY
CHILDREN ANDFEWERHOMERESOURCESFORPURCHASING
SCHOOLSUPPLIESANDOTHERNECESSITIES*UVENILECRIME
RATESANDDISCIPLINEPROBLEMSINSCHOOLARELIKELYON
THERISE4HEREAREFEWERCHILDRENINGENERALBECAUSE
OFSMALLERIMMIGRANTPOPULATIONSWHICHWEREFORMERLY
RESPONSIBLEFORHIGHERBIRTHRATES0ARENTSARELOSING
CONlDENCEINTHEQUALITYANDSAFETYOFTHEPUBLIC
EDUCATIONSYSTEM ASDEMONSTRATEDBYINCREASING
NUMBERSOFSTUDENTSMOVINGTOPRIVATE PAROCHIAL AND
HOMESCHOOLS"ECAUSEOFSTATEBUDGETPRESSURES HIGHER


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NDICATORS /PTIONS
%VENTSANDTRENDSTHATCOULDSIGNALTHEDEVELOP 0UBLICSCHOOLS INGENERAL WILLSTRUGGLEWITHLIMITED
MENTOFTHISSCENARIOINCLUDE RESOURCESANDGREATERPERCENTAGESOFHIGH NEEDS
STUDENTS&OR3%!STOCONTINUETOBERELEVANTAND
s 3TATESPREVAILINGAININGmEXIBILITYIN.#,"RE EFFECTIVE THEYMUSTBECOMEADEPTATCOORDINATINGAND
QUIREMENTS CAUSINGFEDERALOVERSIGHTFORACCOUNT INTEGRATINGRESOURCESACROSSTHEIROWNPROGRAMS4HEY
ABILITYTODECLINE WILLALSONEEDTOREACHOUTTOOTHERHUMANSERVICE
s 3TATESLOOSENTHEIROWNREGULATORYCONTROLOVER HEALTH ANDEDUCATIONAGENCIESINORDERTOLEVERAGE
PUBLICEDUCATION LIMITEDRESOURCESANDMEETTHENEEDSOFTHELARGEPOPU
LATIONSOFHIGH NEEDSSTUDENTS#ONTINUEDADVOCACY
s 4HEREISCONTINUEDDOWNWARDPRESSUREONFEDERAL ANDENGAGEMENTWITHSTATELEGISLATURESCOULDRESULTIN
EDUCATIONFUNDINGDUETOCOMPETINGPRIORITIES AGREATERCOMMITMENTTOSUPPORTEDUCATIONFROMTHE
ANDORLOWERREVENUES STATELEVEL,OOKINGBEYONDSTATEBORDERSFOROPPORTU
NITIESTOWORKWITHOTHER3%!SCOULDRESULTINCOOPERA
s 3%!REVENUESDECREASEANDSTAFFLAYOFFSINCREASE
TIVEAGREEMENTSFORSHARINGSERVICES!TTHESAMETIME
s 7ELFAREAND-EDICAIDSPENDINGDECLINESINTHE LOCALBUSINESSESCOULDBEASOURCEOFADDITIONALSUPPORT
FACEOFINCREASINGNEED SO3%!SMUSTCONNECTWITHTHOSECOMMUNITIESAND
COMMUNICATEKEYMESSAGESABOUTTHEIMPORTANCEOF
s 0UBLICHEALTHINDICATORSSLIDE GOODPUBLICSCHOOLS
s 4HECHILDPOVERTYRATEINCREASES )NORDERTOREGAINhMARKETSHAREvANDTOMAIN
TAINQUALITY 3%!SANDPUBLICSCHOOLSMUSTIDENTIFY
s #RIMERATESINCREASE ESPECIALLYJUVENILECRIME THEMOSTEFFECTIVESTRATEGIESFORSCHOOLIMPROVEMENT
ANDIMPLEMENTTHEM)TWILLBEVITALFORTHE3%!TO
s 0ROPONENTSOFLIMITEDIMMIGRATIONPREVAILnRULES
CHOOSEAFEWKEYPRIORITIESANDFOCUSONTHEMRATHER
ANDENFORCEMENTTIGHTEN
THANATTEMPTTODOALITTLEBITOFEVERYTHING"ECAUSE
s 4HEOVERALLBIRTHRATEDECLINES 3%!STAFFCOMPLEMENTSWILLBEDECLINING ITWILLBE
IMPORTANTTODEVELOPPLANSFORKEEPINGTHEBESTSTAFF
s #ONSUMERSOFEDUCATIONSERVICESBEGINTOSELECT ONBOARD"ECAUSEOFANTICIPATEDSHORTAGESOFNEW
PRIVATEPROVIDERSATAGREATERRATE TEACHERS 3%!SWILLNEEDTOHELPDISTRICTSDEVELOP
STRATEGIESFORATTRACTINGANDKEEPINGGOODTEACHERS4O
s $ISTRICTSREPORTGREATERDIFlCULTYINRECRUITING
ADDRESSDECLINESINNEWTEACHERS THE3%!WILLNEEDTO
TEACHERS
WORKWITHHIGHEREDUCATIONANDTHESTATELEGISLATURE
s 'OVERNMENTDEREGULATIONOFMAJORBUSINESS TODEVELOPWAYSOFMAINTAININGAFFORDABILITYINTEACHER
SECTORSRESULTSINRAPIDGROWTHOFLOCALSMALL PREPARATIONPROGRAMS INCLUDINGPOSSIBLYSCHOOLLOAN
BUSINESSES FORGIVENESSANDSUBSIDIZEDEDUCATIONINEXCHANGEFOR
REQUIREDSERVICEININNERCITYORRURALCOMMUNITIES
3TATESCOULDALSOCONSIDERWAYSTOENTICERETIREDBABY
BOOMERSBACKINTOTHETEACHINGWORKFORCE

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY !BUNDANT

3CENARIO h2AINING-ONEY
AND2ULESv
$EEP#AUSES

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATGOVERNMENTlNANCIAL
SUPPORTFOR+nEDUCATIONISABUNDANT ASARETHE

2ESOURCES
REGULATIONSATTACHEDTOTHEAWARDINGANDDISTRIBUTION
OFTHESERESOURCESBYTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENT3TATEDE
PARTMENTOFEDUCATIONSTAFFAREFACEDWITHTHECOMPLEX
TASKOFADMINISTERINGTHEWIDERANGEOFRESOURCESALLOT 3CARCE
TEDTOTHEMANDMAINTAININGCOMPLIANCEWITHFEDERAL
REGULATIONSATTACHEDTOTHOSERESOURCESWHILEENSURING
THATTHEBULKOFTHEFUNDSPROVIDEDIRECTSERVICESAND
PHYSICALRESOURCESTOSCHOOLSANDSTUDENTS4HETASK h2AINING-ONEYAND2ULESv
FACING3%!MANAGERSISTOMANAGETHEmOWOFSTATE
4IME
ANDFEDERALREVENUESANDREGULATIONSASEFlCIENTLYAS
POSSIBLE 0LACE4HEVIRTUALMEETINGROOMOF3ANDIAS3TATE
$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION3$%
4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO
3CENE$R!NDREA#OREYISBRIElNGNEW3$%STAFF
s 0EACEINTHE-IDDLE%ASTRESULTSINREDUCED
ONTHEDEPARTMENTSROLEANDRESPONSIBILITIES-OST
PRESSUREONTHEFEDERALBUDGETANDLOWEROIL
OFTHEASSEMBLEDSTAFFMEMBERSARESITTINGINVIRTUAL
PRICES THUSFREEINGUPFUNDSFOROTHERPURPOSES
MEETINGROOMSATREGIONALhHUBSvCREATEDBY3$%TO
s "REAKTHROUGHSINSURVEILLANCETECHNOLOGYREDUCE MOVESTAFFASCLOSEASPOSSIBLETOTHECONSTITUENTSTHEY
HOMELANDDEFENSEEXPENDITURESWHILEINCREASING SERVE
BORDERSECURITY
7ELCOMETO3ANDIA3TATE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION
s 2EALISTICPLANSFORSAVING3OCIAL3ECURITYAND
!SPARTOFYOURNEWEMPLOYEEORIENTATION WEWILLMEET
-EDICAREAREINPLACE
THISWAYONCEAMONTHFORTHENEXTSIXMONTHSINORDER
s 53INmUENCEATTHEINTERNATIONALLEVELIS TOPROVIDEYOUWITHTHEBESTINDUCTIONEXPERIENCE
REVITALIZEDLEADINGTOARENEWALOFNATIONALPRIDE POSSIBLE9OUAREASELECTGROUP)KNOWYOUALLHAD
ANDCONlDENCE OTHERCHOICESABOUTWHERETOWORK)MGLADYOUCHOSE
3$% AND)INTENDTODOEVERYTHING)CANTOMAKEYOUR
s 4HE'UEST7ORKERPROGRAMINCREASES TENUREHEREPRODUCTIVEANDREWARDING7EDOIMPOR
IMMIGRATIONFROMTHESOUTHANDCHANGESHOW TANTWORKHERE ANDYOUNOWHAVETHEOPPORTUNITYTO
IMMIGRANTCHILDRENARESERVEDBYPUBLICSCHOOLS CONTRIBUTETOIT
7EREUSING3$%SNEWVIRTUALMEETINGROOMSAS
s )NCREASEDINCOMEALLOWSMOREPARENTSTOSEND
AWAYTOCOMETOGETHERWHILEBEINGMINDFULOFTHE
THEIRCHILDRENTOPRIVATESCHOOLS FORCINGTHE
TIMEANDMONEYITWOULDHAVETAKENTOBRINGYOUALL
PUBLICSCHOOLSTOBECOMEBETTERINORDERTO
TOGETHERPHYSICALLY7EHOPETHATOURVIRTUALMEETING
MAINTAINMARKETSHARE
ROOMSWILLINCREASEOURPRODUCTIVITYANDREDUCETHE
s )NCREASEDQUALITYANDCHOICEINPUBLICEDUCATION TRAVELWEARANDTEARONOURSTAFF!NDFORTHOSEOFYOU
RESULTSININCREASEDPUBLICTRUSTINTHESYSTEM WHOWANTEDTOWORKFOR3$%BUTDIDNOTWANTTOMOVE
TO0ORTALES VIRTUALMEETINGSHAVEBEENAWIN WINFOR
YOUANDTHEAGENCY!Sh'EN 8ERSvANDh-ILLENNIALSv


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

YOUALLGREWUPWITHTHISSTUFFANDPROBABLYFEELRIGHTAT CATIONLIKE3$%TOTHELOCALLEVEL!STHOSEPROGRAMS
HOME!SATRAILINGMEMBEROFTHEhBOOMERvGENERA GREWANDBECAMEMORECOMPLEX OURJOBMANAGINGTHE
TION ITSSTILLALITTLEINTIMIDATINGFORME)HOPEYOU mOWOFMONEYANDTHEREGULATIONSATTACHEDTOTHOSE
WILLBEARWITHMEIF)PUSHTHEWRONGBUTTONFROMTIME FUNDSINCREASEDINSIZEANDCOMPLEXITY
TOTIME $URINGTHEEARLYPARTOFTHESTCENTURY PUBLIC
!LLOFYOUHAVEBEENHIREDBY3$%WITHINTHEPAST EDUCATIONWENTTHROUGHAROUGHPATCHWITHREGARDTO
MONTHANDAREJOININGOTHERSTAFFHIREDOVERTHEPAST FEDERALFUNDING4HEREWASAWAR SEVERALINFACT AND
COUPLEOFYEARSWHENWEBEGANRAMPINGUPOURRECRUIT HOMELANDSECURITYDRAINEDTHEFEDERALTREASURY&EDERAL
INGEFFORTS3OMEOFYOUWILLBEINTHElELD WORKINGDI FUNDINGFOREDUCATIONDECLINEDINTHEFACEOFRISING
RECTLYWITHTEACHERSANDSCHOOLADMINISTRATORS/THERS COSTS/URAGENCYWENTTHROUGHAPERIODOFRETRENCH
WILLBEBEHINDTHESCENESINMANAGEMENT RESEARCH MENTDUETODECLININGREVENUESFROMFEDERALPROGRAMS
ORADMINISTRATIVEANDTECHNICALPOSITIONS!S)HOPE /URJOBSWEREGREATLYCOMPLICATEDBYTHERE EN
YOULLAGREE WEOFFERACHALLENGING STIMULATINGWORK ACTMENTOF%3%! NAMEDTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
ENVIRONMENT EXCELLENTBENElTS ANDTHEOPPORTUNITY !CTOF4HROUGHTHISACT FEDERALCONTROLOF+n
FORYOUTOAPPLYYOUREXPERTISEINPURSUITOFAPERSON EDUCATIONWASINCREASEDTHROUGHAGREATEREMPHASIS
ALLYMEANINGFULMISSION ONACCOUNTABILITY TESTING ANDTEACHERQUALITY4HESE
0LEASEINDULGEAFORMERHISTORYTEACHERAS)RECAP REQUIREMENTSWEREATTACHEDTOTHEEVERDECREASINGmOW
THESIGNIlCANTEVENTSINOURHISTORYTHATHAVEBROUGHT OFDOLLARSTHROUGH%3%!7EHADFEWERDOLLARSWITH
OURAGENCYTOWHEREITISTODAY)HOPETHROUGHSHARING WHICHTOPROVIDETHEREQUIREDLEVELOFREGULATORYOVER
THISHISTORYTHATYOUWILLHAVEAGREATERUNDERSTANDING SIGHT MONITORINGANDREPORTING)TWASNOTAHAPPY
ANDAPPRECIATIONFORTHEORGANIZATIONYOUVEJOINED TIMEFOR3$%
ANDTHEWORKWEDO!SYOUBUILDYOURUNDERSTANDING 4HREETHINGSHAPPENEDTHATTURNEDTHETIDE ONE
OFTHEINmUENCESTHATHAVESHAPEDOURAGENCYANDITS FAIRLYOBVIOUSINITSIMPACTANDTHEOTHERSNOTSO
WORK YOUWILLBEABLETOTHINKMORESTRATEGICALLYABOUT OBVIOUS&IRSTOFALL ASWEALLKNOWNOW THEPRE
YOUROWNWORKANDHOWITFURTHERSTHEMISSIONOF3$% EMPTIVEWARDOCTRINEOF0RESIDENT'EORGE7"USH
/URAGENCYWASlRSTESTABLISHEDEARLYINTHETH lRSTEMPLOYEDINTHEOVERTHROWOF3ADDAM(USSEIN
CENTURYTOASSISTTHE3ANDIASTATEGOVERNMENTMEETITS IN)RAQ LEDTODRAMATICCHANGESINTHEPREVIOUSLY
EDUCATIONOBLIGATIONSTOTHECHILDRENOFOURSTATE7E DESPOTICSTATESOFTHE-IDDLE%AST3INCE DEMO
BEGANSMALL MAINLYFOCUSEDONGRANTINGTEACHERLI CRATICELECTIONSHAVEBEENHELDINANUMBEROFFORMER
CENSES!STHEYEARSWENTBYANDTHESTRUCTUREOFPUBLIC INTERNATIONALHOTSPOTS!STHENEWDEMOCRACIESHAVE
EDUCATIONBECAMEMORECOMPLEX WEGREWINSIZE ASSUMEDMOREANDMORERESPONSIBILITYFORTHEIROWN
THOUGHNOTNECESSARILYININmUENCE$URINGTHEAD SECURITY THE53HASBEENABLETOBRINGOURTROOPS
MINISTRATIONOF0RESIDENT,YNDON"AINES*OHNSON WE HOMEANDREDUCEOURlNANCIALEXPENDITURESINTHAT
SAWTHElRST%LEMENTARYAND3ECONDARY%DUCATION!CT PARTOFTHEWORLD3OMEOFYOUMAYNOTBEOLDENOUGH
KNOWNAS%3%!4HEPRIMARYFOCUSOFTHISLANDMARK TOREMEMBEROURWORLDBEFORETHEFORMATIONOFASTABLE
LEGISLATIONWASTOIMPROVEEDUCATIONALOPPORTUNITYFOR PEACEFUL0ALESTINIANSTATE BUTUNTIL0,/#HAIRMAN
ECONOMICALLYDISADVANTAGEDSTUDENTS 9ASSER!RAFATSDEATH CHANCESFORSOVEREIGNTYFOR0AL
)N EDUCATIONFORhHANDICAPPEDvCHILDRENWAS ESTINIANSWASGRIM7ITH!RAFATSPASSINGFOLLOWEDBY
AUTHORIZEDSEPARATELYTHROUGHTHE%DUCATIONOFTHE !RIEL3HARONSDEATH )SRAELISAND0ALESTINIANSFORGEDA
(ANDICAPPED!CT LATERRENAMEDTHE)NDIVIDUALSWITH NEWPACTFOCUSEDONSAFETYFORALL
$ISABILITIES%DUCATION!CT OR)$%!)TWASTHROUGH 0RESIDENT"USHSNAMINGANAMBASSADORTOTHE
THESETWOLAWS UPDATEDANDAMENDEDOVERTHEYEARS 5NITED.ATIONSWHOWASKNOWNFORHISCRITICISM
THATTHEMAJORITYOFFEDERALSUPPORTFOR+nEDUCATION OF5.POLICIESANDPRACTICESRESULTEDINITIALLYINA
CAMEABOUT)NTHEINTERVENINGYEARSTHEFUNDINGFOR GREATERBREACHINTHERELATIONSHIPBETWEENTHE53
THEVARIOUSPROGRAMSAUTHORIZEDUNDERTHESELAWSFOR ANDTHE5.3OMEOFUSBABYBOOMERSWEREVERYCON
THEMOSTPARTPASSEDTHROUGHSTATEDEPARTMENTSOFEDU CERNEDOVERTHENOMINATIONBECAUSEWEDIDNTLIKETHE

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

UNILATERALISMIMPOSEDBYTHE53INITSDEALINGSWITH !BUNDANT
THE5.(OWEVER WHENTHE53REFUSEDPAYMENTS
INSUPPORTOFSOME5.INITIATIVES THE5.RECON h2AINING-ONEY
AND2ULESv
SIDEREDITSSTANCEONSEVERALOFOURREQUESTS4HISLED
TOMUCH NEEDEDREFORMSANDANINCREASEINRESPECTFOR

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
THE53INTHEWORLDGOVERNINGBODY)TSHARDTOARGUE

2ESOURCES
THATTHEWORLDISNTSAFERANDSOUNDERNOWBECAUSE
OFTHISHARDLINE4HEFACTISTHATTHEUNILATERALISM
EXPOUNDEDBYTHE"USHADMINISTRATIONHELPEDTHE53
MAINTAINITSSTATUSASAWORLDPOWERANDALLOWEDOUR
3CARCE
COUNTRYTOFOCUSMOREOFOURRESOURCESASWESAWlT
4HESECONDKEYFACTORINTHECHANGETHATTOOK
PLACEDURINGTHATTIMEWASASUDDENBREAKTHROUGHIN HADALREADYLEFTTHEWORKFORCETHROUGHEARLYRETIRE
SURVEILLANCETECHNOLOGY ALLOWINGTHE$EPARTMENT MENTS&ORTUNATELY MANYHADALSOCONTINUEDTOWORK
OF(OMELAND3ECURITYTOACHIEVEMANYOFITSGOALS THUSCONTINUINGTOCONTRIBUTETO3OCIAL3ECURITYAND
WITHOUTTHEHUGEEXPENDITURESOFTAXDOLLARSORIGI -EDICAREANDDELAYINGCOLLECTINGBENElTSFROMTHESE
NALLYANTICIPATED7HILECIVILLIBERTARIANSANDTHOSE PROGRAMS4HEBOOMERSWERETHESINGLELARGESTGENERA
CONCERNEDABOUTPRIVACYISSUESOPPOSEDTHEUSEOF TIONINOURHISTORY EVENTUALLYTOBEEXCEEDEDONLYBY
THESENEWTECHNOLOGIES BYANDLARGETHECITIZENSOF THEIROFFSPRING THE-ILLENNIALS!DVANCESINHEALTH
THISCOUNTRYWEREWILLINGTOGIVEUPSOMEPRIVACYIN CAREANDHEALTHIERLIFESTYLESMEANTTHATTHISGENERATION
EXCHANGEFORMORESAFETY WOULDEXPERIENCEINCREASESINAVERAGELIFEEXPECTANCY
4HESECHANGESINFOREIGNPOLICYANDDOMESTIC NOTEVERSEENBEFORE.OTONLYWERETHERELOTSOFTHEM
SECURITYEXPENDITURESFREEDUPMOREDOLLARSFOROTHER THEYWEREGOINGTOLIVEhFOREVERv)KNOWˆ)MONEOF
PURPOSES ANDHELPEDUSTOREDUCETHENATIONALDEBT THEMAND)PLANTOLIVETOBE
7ITHOUTTHEPRESSUREOFATOWERINGNATIONALDEBT THERE 7EWEREFACINGTHELIKELIHOODTHATMORETHAN
WASMOREMONEYINTHECIVILIANECONOMY"USINESSAND PERCENTOFTHENATIONALELECTORATEWOULDBEOVER
INVESTMENTGREW WAGESINCREASEDASUNEMPLOYMENT ANDMOSTLYRETIRED WITHALLTHEATTENDANTCOSTSOF
DECLINED ENTREPRENEURSHIPBLOSSOMED ANDTHEENGINE KEEPING3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICAREAmOAT4HE
OFOURNATIONALECONOMYSPRANGTOLIFEAGAIN4AXREVE #ONGRESSIONAL"UDGET/FlCEPREDICTEDSTEADYDECLINES
NUESWENTUP ANDEVERYONEHADMOREMONEYTOSPEND INTAXREVENUESALONGWITHHUGELYINCREASEDCOSTSFOR
FORDISCRETIONARYPURPOSES INCLUDINGEDUCATION!S SUPPORTINGOURELDERGENERATION4HANKFULLY THEREDUC
FAMILIESOFSCHOOL AGECHILDRENBECAMEWEALTHIER MORE TIONSINWARANDNATIONALSECURITYEXPENDITURESTHAT)
ANDMOREOFTHEMWEREABLETOSENDTHEIRCHILDRENTO DESCRIBEDEARLIERALLOWEDLAWMAKERSTOCRAFTANDFUND
PRIVATESCHOOLS)NORDERTOMAINTAINMARKETSHARE REALISTICPLANSFORHEADINGOFFTHEIMPENDINGCOLLAPSE
PUBLICEDUCATIONNEEDEDTOREDOUBLEITSEFFORTSTO OF3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICAREWITHOUTDEVASTATING
PROVIDETHEQUALITYANDRANGEOFCHOICESTHATPARENTS OTHERSECTORSOFTHEECONOMYINTHEPROCESS#ONTRI
WEREDEMANDING)TREQUIREDMUCHINGENUITYAND BUTIONSTOTHESESYSTEMSBYBURGEONINGNUMBERSOF
FORESIGHTONOURPARTTOCREATEATTRACTIVEANDVIABLE IMMIGRANTWORKERSALSOHAVEPROVIDEDAFRESHINmUXOF
OPTIONSWITHINTHEPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEMTOADDRESS REVENUE
THECHOICEISSUE)NRESPONSETOCUSTOMERDEMAND 3$% 4HETHIRDANDPERHAPSLEASTOBVIOUSCATALYSTFORTHE
INCREASEDITSSUPPORTFORTHECREATIONOFMAGNETSCHOOLS CHANGESINTHEFORTUNESOF+nEDUCATIONANDTHE
CHARTERSCHOOLS ANDTECHNICALSCHOOLS AGENCIESSERVINGITWASTHESCIENTIlCALLYBASEDRESEARCH
4HISSHIFTINFEDERALPRIORITIESANDSPENDINGHADTHE REQUIREMENTCONTAINEDIN.#,"%VENBEFORETHE
ADDEDEFFECTOFDIFFUSINGADEMOGRAPHICTIMEBOMBTHAT PASSAGEOFTHElRST.#,"IN THEREWASGENERAL
LOOMEDONTHEHORIZONFORALLOFUS"EGINNINGIN AGREEMENTAMONGEDUCATORSTHATSCHOOLIMPROVEMENT
MILLIONBABYBOOMERSBEGANTURNING-ANY PRACTICESNEEDEDTOBECOMEMOREEVIDENCE BASED"UT


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

THEREWASCONSTERNATIONABOUTHOWTHATCOULDHAPPEN SUPPORTEDTHE'UEST7ORKERPROGRAMWEREGIVENTO
GIVENTHECOMPLEXNATUREANDHUGEEXPENSEOFCON THESTATESTOADMINISTER)NCREASEDSTATEREVENUESFOR
DUCTINGRIGOROUSSOCIALSCIENCERESEARCH7ITHANINmUX EDUCATIONSERVICESFORTHESEPOPULATIONSCONTRIBUTED
OFNEWDOLLARSTOTHEFEDERALDEPARTMENTOFEDUCATION EVENMORETOTHERESOURCES3$%HADATITSDISPOSALFOR
THEREWASARE DEDICATIONTOTHEGOALOFEVIDENCE BASED MEETINGTHENEEDSOFIMMIGRANTWORKERSCHILDREN
SCHOOLIMPROVEMENTPRACTICES ANDAREFOCUSINGON 7EWEREEXPERIENCINGCONTINUOUSCHANGE!DE
IMPROVINGTHEQUALITYOFEDUCATIONFORALL)NORDERTO FACTONATIONALCURRICULUMHADCOMEABOUTASARESULTOF
CONDUCTTHENECESSARYSTUDIES GATHERANDANALYZETHE THESTANDARDS BASEDEDUCATIONMOVEMENT!DDRESSING
DATA ANDREPLICATERESULTS THEFEDERALDEPARTMENTOF THENEEDSOFAMOREDEMANDINGANDDISCERNINGCUSTOM
EDUCATIONGREATLYINCREASEDITSALLOCATIONSTOPROGRAMS ERBASEWITHINTHECONTEXTOFTHISCURRICULUM COUPLED
THATDEMONSTRATEDTHEYCOULDCARRYOUTTHESEACTIVI WITHTHEREQUIREMENTSOF.#," WASANADDEDCHAL
TIES4HESEPROGRAMSWEREDESIGNEDANDMANAGEDBY LENGE4HISFORCEDUSANDOTHERAGENCIESLIKEOURSTO
THE)NSTITUTEFOR%DUCATION3CIENCESANDIMPLEMENTED TAKEAHARDLOOKATTHEPRODUCTWEWEREDELIVERINGAND
THROUGHSTATEAGENCIESSUCHAS3$% INCOLLABORATION TODEDICATEOURSELVESANEWTOPROVIDINGTHEBESTPUBLIC
WITHTHEREVITALIZED7HAT7ORKS#LEARINGHOUSE3UD EDUCATIONEXPERIENCESPOSSIBLETOOURCHILDREN)NFACT
DENLYWEANDAGENCIESLIKEUSFOUNDOURSELVESINTHE THEREQUIREMENTFORSCIENTIlCALLYBASEDRESEARCHON
POSITIONOFNEEDINGTOHIRESTAFFANDDEVELOPCAPACITY EFFECTIVENESSTURNEDOUTTOBEAHUGEECONOMICBOON
TODOTHISWORK)TMAYCOMEASASURPRISETOYOUTHAT TOTHISAGENCYANDANINCREDIBLEBENElTTOTHECHILDREN
IN 3$%HADNORESEARCHANDDEVELOPMENTSTAFF WESERVEINTHATITHELPEDUSDOABETTERJOBOFDELIVER
ATALL.OWITISOURLARGESTANDMOSTWELL RESOURCED INGPROGRAMSANDSTRATEGIESTHATWORKED"YADOPTING
DEPARTMENT PROVENMODELSOFSYSTEMICREFORMWEHAVEBEENABLE
.OW)LLTAKEAMOMENTTOTALKABOUTATOPICTHAT TOPROMOTEMOREEFFECTIVEUSEOFDATAANDIMPROVED
YOUMIGHTNOTTHINKABOUTVERYMUCHBUTTHATHAS ACCOUNTABILITY"YRE EXAMININGTHEROLEOFTECHNOL
QUITEANIMPACTONOURWORKHEREAT3$%ˆDEMO OGY WEHAVEBEENABLETOREDUCEPAPERWORKANDSHIFT
GRAPHICS(EREAGAIN OUTSIDEEVENTSTRANSPIREDTO RESOURCESTOFOCUSONIMPROVEMENTEFFORTS
CREATEYETANOTHERGROWTHINDUSTRYFOROURAGENCY !NOTHERKEYTRENDTHATHASSHAPEDOURWORKHAS
7ITHTHEINSTITUTIONOFTHE'UEST7ORKERPROGRAM BEENTHEINCREASEDFOCUSONHIGHSCHOOLREFORM"EGIN
INTOHELPMEETTHEPRESSINGLABORNEEDSOFOUR NINGIN GOVERNORS CHIEFEXECUTIVES ANDEDUCA
GROWINGECONOMY THEREWASALARGEINmUXOF3PANISH TIONLEADERSHAVEMETANNUALLYATTHE.ATIONAL%DUCA
SPEAKINGCHILDRENINTOOURPUBLICSCHOOLSYSTEM4HIS TION3UMMITON(IGH3CHOOLSTODISCUSSTHENEEDTO
POPULATIONGROWTHCONTRIBUTEDTOFURTHERECONOMICEX STRENGTHENREQUIREMENTSFORRIGOROUSCOURSEWORK BRING
PANSION WHICHCONTRIBUTEDREVENUESTOSTATEGOVERN COLLEGESANDUNIVERSITIESTOGETHERWITH+nEDUCATION
MENTS WHICHTHENINCREASEDAVAILABLEMONEYTOSPEND TOSETCOMMONEXPECTATIONS IMPROVETEACHINGAND
ONEDUCATION PRINCIPALLEADERSHIP ANDEXPANDEDUCATIONOPTIONSFOR
3OMEDISTRICTSRELIEDUPONNATIVELANGUAGEPRO STUDENTS3OMEOFTHEADDITIONALFUNDINGTHATHASBEEN
GRAMSWHERECHILDRENWERETAUGHTANDTESTEDINTHEIR AVAILABLETOUSOVERTHEPASTFEWYEARSHASALLOWEDUS
NATIVELANGUAGE4HISWASDONEBASEDONTHEPRESUMP TOFOCUSONCREATIVESOLUTIONSTOTHISNEED INCLUDING
TIONTHATTHESECHILDRENWOULDEVENTUALLYRETURNTO STRONGERARTICULATIONOFREQUIREMENTSACROSSTHE0n
THEIRNATIVECOUNTRIESANDTHUSNEEDEDTOBEPROl CONTINUUM MOREOPPORTUNITIESTOEARNCOLLEGECREDIT
CIENTINTHEIRNATIVELANGUAGESASWELL/THERDISTRICTS INHIGHSCHOOL RESTRUCTURINGTHElNALYEAROFHIGH
PURSUEDTRADITIONALBILINGUALAND%NGLISHASA3ECOND SCHOOLTOASSUREASMOOTHERTRANSITIONTOCOLLEGE AND
,ANGUAGEPROGRAMS2EGARDLESSOFTHEAPPROACHTAKEN GREATERATTENTIONTOPOST HIGHSCHOOLEDUCATIONAND
TOADDRESSING%NGLISH LANGUAGELEARNINGANDSECOND TRAININGOPTIONSFORNON COLLEGE BOUNDSTUDENTS!D
LANGUAGEPOPULATIONS THEREWASANINCREASEDNEEDFOR DITIONALLY WEHAVEBEENABLETOSUPPORTORESTABLISHA
TEACHERSPROlCIENTINOTHERLANGUAGESANDCULTURES VARIETYOFEXTENDEDLEARNINGOPPORTUNITIES INCLUDING
&EDERALEDUCATIONANDLABORDEPARTMENTPROGRAMSTHAT AFTERSCHOOLPROGRAMSAND3ATURDAYACADEMIES

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)MUSTSAYTHATOUREFFORTSTOIMPROVETHEQUALITYOF !BUNDANT
PUBLICEDUCATIONHAVEBEENMETWITHSOMEMEASURE
OFSUCCESS2ECENTPOLLSSHOWTHATTHELEVELOFPARENT h2AINING-ONEY
AND2ULESv
TRUSTOFPUBLICEDUCATIONHASINCREASEDSUBSTANTIALLY
9OUNGPEOPLEAREmOCKINGTOTHETEACHINGPROFESSION

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
AGAINASTEACHERSALARIESHAVEINCREASEDANDTHEPROFES

2ESOURCES
SIONHASTAKENONADDEDRESPECTINPARTBECAUSEOFTHE
KINDSOFRESULTSWEVEBEENABLETODELIVER4HISINmUX
OFNEWTEACHERSHASPLACEDADDEDREQUIREMENTSONOUR
AGENCY ASWEVECONTINUEDTOMANAGETHECREDENTIAL
3CARCE
INGPROCESS4HEINCREASEDEMPHASISONPROFESSIONALISM
AMONGYOUNGANDVETERANTEACHERSALIKEHASMEANT
THATOURAGENCYHASHADTOINCREASEBOTHTHESCOPEAND
QUALITYOFITSPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTOFFERINGS7HAT INIMPLEMENTATIONFROMONESITETOANOTHER4HESE
HASBEENTHERESULTOFALLOFTHISCHANGE)MHAPPYTO STAFFALSOMONITOREDHOWPROGRAMSWEREIMPLEMENTED
SAYTOYOUTODAY THATWEHAVEBECOMEABETTERORGANI !STHENEEDFOREXPERIENCEDRESEARCH TECHNICAL
ZATION ASSISTANCE ANDTECHNOLOGYSTAFFINCREASED SODIDTHE
/URSTAFFHASNEARLYDOUBLEDINSIZEOVERTHEPAST NEEDFORSUPPORTSTAFF.EWMANAGEMENTPOSITIONS
lVEYEARSASWEADDEDTECHNICALASSISTANCEEXPERTS WERENEEDEDTOOVERSEEANDGUIDETHISGROWINGENTER
SKILLEDINWORKINGWITHDISTRICTSANDSCHOOLSTO PRISE!CCOUNTANTSWEREHIREDTOMANAGETHEmOWOF
IMPROVELEADERSHIP CURRICULUM INSTRUCTION ANDAS DOLLARSTOTHELOCALSITES'RANTWRITERSWERENEEDEDTO
SESSMENTPRACTICESTOINCREASESTUDENTACHIEVEMENT WRITETHEAPPLICATIONSTHATPRODUCEDTHEFEDERALAWARDS
3PECIALNEEDSSTUDENTSHAVERECEIVEDRENEWEDATTEN 0OLICYANALYSTSWEREHIREDTOADVISEME THECHIEF
TION REQUIRINGUSTOHIREMORESTAFFWITHSPECIALEDUCA EXECUTIVEOFlCEROFTHISORGANIZATION ABOUTTRENDSIN
TIONEXPERTISE4HEAPPLICATIONOFNEWTECHNOLOGIES POLICYDEVELOPMENTATTHEFEDERALANDSTATELEVELSTHAT
ASTOOLSFORDELIVERYANDMANAGEMENTOFINSTRUCTION WOULDHAVEANIMPACTONHOWTOPROCEED
ASSESSMENT ANDPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTCREATEDA 4HEGROWTHWEEXPERIENCEDWASPHENOMENAL BUTIT
NEEDFORACADREOFTECHNOLOGYCONSULTANTSWHOCOULD WASNOTWITHOUTITSDRAWBACKS#OMMUNICATIONBREAK
WORKWITHSCHOOLSTAFF)NTHEPAST WEHADTORELYON DOWNSOCCURREDANDDIFlCULTIESAROSEINMANAGINGSTAFF
EXTERNALPROVIDERSFORTHESESERVICES.OW WEEMPLOY ING FACILITIES ANDQUALITYCONTROL-OSTCRITICALAMONG
THISEXPERTISEWITHIN3$% GUARANTEEINGCONTINUOUS OURCHALLENGESHASBEENREMAININGFOCUSEDANDINTE
ACCESSTOTHEKNOWLEDGENEEDEDBY3ANDIAEDUCATORS GRATED'IVENTHEINCREASEDARRAYOFRESOURCESAVAILABLE
4HEREQUIREMENTFORRIGOROUSRESEARCHTODETERMINE TOUSANDTHESIZEOFSOMEPROGRAMS ITWOULDHAVE
THEEFFECTIVENESSOFSCHOOLIMPROVEMENTPRACTICES BEENEASYTOWORKINSILOS ISOLATEDFROMONEANOTHER
RESULTEDINTHENEEDFORSTAFFWITHRESEARCHSKILLSTO ANDFARLESSEFFECTIVETHANWEWOULDBEBYLEVERAGING
DESIGNANDIMPLEMENTSTUDIESANDINTERPRETRESULTS7E OUREFFORTSACROSSPROGRAMS7EDIDLOSEOURBEARINGS
CONTINUETOHAVEANEEDFORSTAFFSKILLEDINTHEAPPLICA FORAWHILE BUTBYCREATINGCROSS PROGRAMSTEERING
TIONOFRESEARCHlNDINGSTOEDUCATIONPRACTICES$ATA COMMITTEESANDWORKTEAMS WEHAVETOALARGEDEGREE
ENTRYSTAFFANDANALYSTSWERENEEDEDTOENTER MANAGE BEENABLETOREGAINOURFOCUS EVENTHOUGHTHEREISSTILL
ANDMAKESENSEOFTHEDATA3TILLMORETECHNOLOGY WORKTODO,OOKINGBOTHTOOURPASTANDTOTHEFUTURE
STAFFWEREREQUIREDTOSUPPORTTHERESEARCHANDANALYSIS WEKNOWTHATOURAGENCYHASGONETHROUGHPERIODSOF
TEAMS4OCONDUCTRIGOROUSSTUDIESWITHEXPERIMENTAL BOOMANDBUST$EVELOPINGSTRATEGIESTOMAINTAINOUR
ANDCONTROLGROUPS MORETECHNICALASSISTANCESTAFF PROGRAMSTHROUGHPERIODSOFAUSTERITYISACHALLENGE
WERENEEDEDTOTRAINSCHOOLSTAFFINTHEPROPERIMPLE THATWILLALWAYSBEWITHUS
MENTATIONOFTHEPROGRAMSBEINGSTUDIEDSOTHATRE
SEARCHRESULTSWOULDNOTBECONFOUNDEDBYDIFFERENCES


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

7ITHTHISDETAILEDACCOUNTOFTHEHISTORYOFTHE )NDICATORS
AGENCYYOUVEJUSTJOINED )VEGIVENYOUAFOUNDATION %VENTSANDTRENDSTHATCOULDSIGNALTHEDEVELOPMENT
THAT)HOPEWILLSERVEYOUWELLASYOUHELPUSTAKE3$% OFTHISSCENARIOINCLUDE
INTOTHEFUTURE.OW LETSTURNTOTODAYSEVENTSAND
GETONWITHYOURORIENTATION s $EFENSEANDHOMELANDSECURITYBUDGETSCONSUME
ASMALLERPERCENTAGEOFFEDERALOUTLAYS
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO s 4HEECONOMYBEGINSTOGROWATAFASTERTHAN
AVERAGEPACE
)MPLICATIONS
)NTHEWORLDDESCRIBEDINTHISSCENARIO THEREIS s &EDERALANDSTATEFUNDINGFOREDUCATIONBEGINSTO
TREMENDOUSOPPORTUNITYTOBESYSTEMICANDEFFECTIVE GROW
BUTTHEREISANEQUALLYSTRONGPOTENTIALTOLOSECOHER
s 3%!STAFFANDPROGRAMSBEGINTOGROW
ENCEANDBECOMEFRAGMENTED4HEPOTENTIALEXISTS
FORTHE3%!TOLOSETOUCHWITHLOCALEDUCATIONAGEN s 'OVERNMENTREQUIREMENTSFORANNUALTESTINGAND
CIESANDTOVIEWFEDERALANDSTATEFUNDINGAGENCIES REPORTINGANDEVIDENCE BASEDPRACTICESINCREASE
ASITSCUSTOMERS3%!STAFFWILLINCREASESUBSTANTIALLY
#OMMUNICATIONBETWEENDIFFERENTSECTIONSOFTHE s 'UESTWORKERPROGRAMORSIMILARIMMIGRATION
3%!COULDDECREASEAND3%!PROGRAMSCOULDBEGIN FRIENDLYMEASURESGAINSUPPORTIN#ONGRESS
TOOPERATEINAVACUUMORATCROSSPURPOSESWITHONE s #ONSUMERSOFEDUCATIONPRODUCTSANDSERVICES
ANOTHER4ECHNOLOGYCOULDOFFEREFFECTIVESOLUTIONSFOR BEGINTOSELECTPRIVATEPROVIDERSATAGREATERPACE
MAINTAININGCOMMUNICATIONANDCOHESIVENESSBOTH
ACROSS3%!STAFFANDWITH3%!CUSTOMERS&EDERALAND
STATEGOVERNMENTWILLHAVEEXPANDEDINmUENCEBY
VIRTUEOFABUNDANTFUNDINGBEINGCHANNELEDTHROUGH
THE3%! ACCOMPANIEDBYSIGNIlCANTRULESANDREGULA
TIONS4HEREWILLBEASTRONGEMPHASISONACCOUNTABIL
ITY WITHSTRONGSANCTIONSFORFAILURETOCOMPLY!DE
FACTONATIONALCURRICULUMCOULDEMERGE(IGHSCHOOL
REFORMWILLCONTINUETOBEAKEYCONCERN4HEREWILL
BEGREATEREMPHASISONRESEARCH BASEDPRACTICEANDLESS
LATITUDEFORLOCALEDUCATIONAGENCIESTOCHOOSEINTER
VENTIONSTHATLACKARESEARCHBASE PARTICULARLYWHEN
THEREISFEDERALORSTATEMONEYINVOLVED4HEREWILL
BEANINmUXOFIMMIGRANTSNEEDINGSPECIALIZEDSER
VICES-ANYCONSUMERSWILLHAVERESOURCESTOPURCHASE
PRIVATESCHOOLINGFORTHEIRCHILDREN FORCINGPUBLIC
SCHOOLSTOBECOMEMOREINNOVATIVEANDMARKETDRIVEN
INORDERTOMAINTAINENROLLMENT4HETEACHERWORK
FORCECOULDGROW REQUIRING3%!STOSTEPUPCAPACITYTO
DEALWITHTEACHERCREDENTIALING

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

/PTIONS !BUNDANT

&OR3%!STOREMAINEFFECTIVEINTHISENVIRONMENT
h2AINING-ONEY
THEYMUSTANTICIPATETHEEFFECTSOFSIGNIlCANTGROWTH AND2ULESv
ONCOMMUNICATION COHESIVENESS ANDMORALEAMONG

3TRONG
THEIRSTAFF4HEYSHOULDEMBRACEFOCUSED RIGOROUS OR

7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL

GANIZATION WIDELONG TERMPLANNINGINORDERTOCOMBAT

2ESOURCES
APOTENTIALLOSSOFFOCUSINTHEAGENCYSMISSION)NPAR
TICULAR AGENCYMANAGERSSHOULDACTIVELYLOOKFORAND
EXPLOITOPPORTUNITIESFORCOLLABORATIONANDLEVERAGING
ACROSSAGENCYPROGRAMS 3CARCE
4HEAGENCYMUSTWORKHARDTOUNDERSTANDITSLOCAL
EDUCATIONAGENCYCUSTOMERSANDTHEIRNEEDS ANDACT
ONTHEKNOWLEDGEGAINED7HILEATTENDINGTOTHE
NEEDSOFLOCALCUSTOMERS THE3%!SHOULDNOTLOSE
SIGHTOFTHENEEDSOFAGENCIESSUPPLYINGFUNDINGFOR
ITSPROGRAMS4OBUILDCONSUMERCONlDENCEINPUBLIC
EDUCATION 3%!SMUSTBUILDSTATEINFRASTRUCTURESFOR
ACCOUNTABILITYTHATPROVIDETHEPUBLICWITHACCURATE
RELIABLEINFORMATIONABOUTTHEQUALITYOFLOCALSCHOOLS
3TATECREDENTIALINGOFTEACHERSMUSTENSUREQUALITYIN
THETEACHERWORKFORCE&URTHERMORE 3%!SMUSTCLEARLY
ADDRESSTHEQUALITYANDRELEVANCEOFPUBLICEDUCATION
OFFERINGS ESPECIALLYATTHEHIGHSCHOOLLEVEL
!GENCIESSHOULDCONSIDERCOLLABORATINGWITHHIGHER
EDUCATIONANDPRIVATERESEARCHORGANIZATIONSTOBOLSTER
RESEARCHANDEVALUATIONCAPABILITIESTOPROMOTEIN
CREASEDQUALITYINTHEPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEM!LONG
WITHINCREASEDACCOUNTABILITYANDQUALITY INCREASED
CHOICEWITHINTHEPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEMWILLATTRACT
PARENTSWHOARESEEKINGOPTIONSFORTHEIRCHILDREN
,ARGERSECONDLANGUAGELEARNERPOPULATIONSWILL
REQUIREMORESPECIALIZEDSERVICES REQUIRINGTHAT3%!S
HAVETHECAPACITYTOPROVIDEEFFECTIVETECHNICALAS
SISTANCEINSUPPORTOFTHESEPROGRAMS-AINTAININGAND
ENHANCINGTECHNOLOGYINFRASTRUCTUREFORCOMMUNICA
TIONANDSERVICEDELIVERYWILLBEIMPORTANT


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY !BUNDANT

3CENARIO
$EEP#AUSES

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATGOVERNMENTlNANCIAL
SUPPORTFOR+nEDUCATIONISLIMITED BUTTHATFEDERAL

2ESOURCES
ANDSTATEGOVERNMENTSCONTINUETOSEEKTOINmUENCE
EDUCATIONTHROUGHREGULATION3TATEDEPARTMENTOF h!,AST2ESORTv

EDUCATIONSTAFFCHARGEDWITHADMINISTERINGANDMONI
TORINGFEDERALPROGRAMSATTHESTATEANDLOCALLEVELS 3CARCE
FACEADAUNTINGTASK.OTONLYMUSTTHEYADMINISTER
THEMEAGERRESOURCESALLOTTEDANDMAINTAINCOMPLIANCE
WITHSTATEANDFEDERALREGULATIONSATTACHEDTOTHOSE
RESOURCES BUTTHEYALSOMUSTBECAREFULTOBALANCE h!,AST2ESORTv
THEAMOUNTSPENTONADMINISTRATIVEACTIVITIESWITH
4IME
THEAMOUNTSPENTONSERVICESFORTHEINTENDEDBENEl
CIARIESOFTHEFUNDS-ANYAFmUENTFAMILIESHAVEmED 0LACE3MITTYS7AFmE(OUSEIN0ORTALES 3ANDIA
THEPUBLICSYSTEM LEAVINGSCHOOLSTOSERVEONLYTHOSE
STUDENTSWHOHAVENOOTHEROPTIONS)NTHISSCENARIO 3CENE$R!NDREA#OREYISDELIVERINGHERANNUAL
#HIEF3TATE3CHOOL/FlCER!NDREA#OREYENCOURAGES END OF THE YEARh3TATEOFTHE3ANDIA3TATE$EPARTMENT
HERSTAFFTOSTAYFOCUSEDONWHATSIMPORTANTINTHEFACE OF%DUCATIONvMESSAGETOHERSTAFFAND3TATE"OARD
OFDWINDLINGRESOURCES OF%DUCATIONMEMBERSWHOHAVEASSEMBLEDFORTHE
BREAKFASTMEETING
4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESLEADTOTHISSCENARIO
s 7EALTHIERFAMILIESANDSOCIALCONSERVATIVES
s 7ARS HOMELANDSECURITYCOSTS 3OCIAL3ECURITY
BECOMEDISSATISlEDWITHPUBLICEDUCATIONANDARE
AND-EDICARE ANDSOARINGOILPRICESPUTSEVERE
ENROLLINGTHEIRCHILDRENINPRIVATEANDPAROCHIAL
PRESSUREONFEDERALANDSTATEBUDGETS RESULTINGIN
SCHOOLSINGREATERNUMBERS
CUTSTOEDUCATIONSPENDING
s &IRSTANDSECONDGENERATIONIMMIGRANTSARE
s 3TATESFAILTOOBTAINSUBSTANTIALRELIEFFROM
ASSUMINGMOREPROMINENTROLESINBUSINESSAND
REGULATIONSUNDER.#," WHICHREMAINSFOCUSED
POLITICS
ONONE SIZE lTS ALLTESTINGANDUNREALISTIC
PROlCIENCYGOALS s 4ECHNOLOGYOFFERSCOST EFFECTIVESOLUTIONSTO
MANAGINGASSESSMENTANDACCOUNTABILITYDATA
s 3TATESSTRENGTHENDISTRICTANDSCHOOLACCREDITA
TIONREQUIREMENTSANDIMPLEMENTOTHERMEASURES )WANTTOTHANKALLOFYOUFORGETTINGUPEVENEARLIER
TOINCREASECONTROLOVERHOWPUBLICEDUCATIONIS THANUSUALTOCOMEHERETHISMORNING)NYEARSPAST
PROVIDED THISEVENTWASHELDATALOCALSTEAKHOUSE BUTTHISYEAR
WEVECUTBACKONEXPENSES,UCKILY 3MITTYSWASABLE
s (IGHSCHOOLREFORMINITIATIVESPLACEADDITIONAL
TOACCOMMODATEUSANDPROVIDEABOUNTIFULBREAKFAST
lNANCIALPRESSUREONSTATEEDUCATIONAGENCIES
BUFFET SO)HOPEYOULIKEWAFmES
WITHNOCOMPENSATINGFEDERALSUPPORT
4HISISTHETENTHTIME)VECOMEBEFOREYOUATTHE
s )MMIGRATIONPOLICIESRESULTINHIGHLEVELSOFLEGAL ENDOFTHEYEARTOREPORTONTHECONDITIONOFEDUCATION
ANDILLEGALIMMIGRANTSFROM-EXICOAND#ENTRAL INOURGREATSTATEANDTOREmECTONTHEROLEOF3ANDIAS
!MERICA $EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONASITSEEKSTOMEETTHENEEDS
OFTHECHILDRENOFOURSTATE4HEPASTYEARHASBEEN

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

ATIMEOFOPPORTUNITIESANDCHALLENGES&AITHINOUR TIONAL ANDGLOBALEVENTSANDTRENDSTHATHAVEBROUGHT


MISSION TOENSURETHEBESTPOSSIBLEEDUCATIONFORTHE USTOWHEREWEARETODAY
CHILDRENOF3ANDIA ATTIMESSEEMSTOBEALLTHATHAS 3INCETHEPASSAGEOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT
SUSTAINEDUS IN 3ANDIA ALONGWITHOTHERSTATES HASSTRUGGLED
4HEREAREFEWEROFYOUHERETODAYTHANTHEREWERE TOACHIEVETHEGOALSSETOUTINTHELEGISLATION"ECAUSE
LASTYEAR4HELAYOFFSEARLIERTHISYEARHITHARD ANDWE OFTHEEVER INCREASINGCOSTSOFHOMELANDSECURITY
ALLMISSOURFRIENDSANDCOLLEAGUESWHOARENOLONGER HEALTHCAREFOROURAGING ANDTHEONGOINGWARONTERROR
WITHTHEDEPARTMENT7EHOPETHATTHENEWYEARWILL THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTHASNEVERBEENABLETOFULLY
NOTBRINGANOTHERROUNDOFSTAFFREDUCTIONSBUT ASYOU FUNDTHEACT NORHASITGRANTEDSTATESTHEmEXIBILITY
KNOW THESTATELEGISLATUREISDISCUSSINGCAPPINGOUR NECESSARYTOMEET.#,"GOALSTHROUGHTHEIROWN
FUNDINGATLASTYEARSLEVELS4HEFEDERALGOVERNMENT INNOVATION)NPARTICULAR THEONE SIZE lTS ALLMETHOD
HASONCEAGAINHELDSTEADYWITHITSALLOCATIONSTO4ITLE FORMEASURINGSTUDENTPERFORMANCECOUPLEDWITHTHE
)AND3PECIAL%DUCATIONPROGRAMSANDHASREDUCED PERCENTPROlCIENCYGOALHASMEANTUNACHIEVABLE
FUNDINGFOROTHERPROGRAMS3EVERALPROGRAMSTHATPRO EXPECTATIONSFORMANYOFOURSCHOOLS!ND ESPECIALLY
VIDEDSUBSTANTIALFUNDINGFOROURWORKAREZEROEDOUTIN SIGNIlCANTTO3ANDIA ISTHATTHESEFEDERALREGULATIONS
THEPRESIDENTSPROPOSEDBUDGET$ESPITEREDUCTIONSIN DONOTCONSIDERTHESPECIALCHALLENGESOFADEQUATELY
FUNDING THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTHASNOTBACKEDOFFTHE TEACHINGSTUDENTSWITHDISABILITIESAND%NGLISH LAN
REGULATORYBURDENTHATACCOMPANIESFUNDING4OCOM GUAGELEARNERSNORDOTHEYADDRESSTHEDIFFERENCES
POUNDTHEPROBLEM STATEFUNDINGFORPUBLICEDUCATION AMONGRURAL SUBURBAN ANDURBANSCHOOLS
ISEQUALLYTIGHT/UROBLIGATIONSTO3ANDIASSTUDENTS 7EMUSTFACETHEFACTS&ORTWELVEYEARSWEVE
HAVENOTDECLINED)FANYTHING THEYNEEDMOREFROM STRIVENTOMEETTHEGOALSOF.#,"INTHEFACEOFEVER
USTHANEVERBEFORE7EAREFORCEDTOCHOOSEBETWEEN INCREASINGREGULATIONANDSANCTIONSCOUPLEDWITHLESS
SPENDINGOURLIMITEDFUNDSONSCHOOLIMPROVEMENTOR ANDLESSlNANCIALSUPPORT4ODAY TENPERCENTOFTHE
ONMAINTAININGREGULATORYCOMPLIANCE)TISADIFlCULT STATESSCHOOLSHAVEBEENCLOSED ANDOVERPERCENT
LINETOWALK OFTHEREMAININGPUBLICSCHOOLSIN3ANDIAARESTILLCLAS
4HEGOODNEWSISTHATWHILEWEREGRETTHELOSSOF SIlEDASINNEEDOFIMPROVEMENT)NTHEFACEOFDECLIN
OURCOLLEAGUESANDFRIENDS THOSEOFYOUHERETODAYARE INGPERSONNELANDlSCALRESOURCES OURAGENCYISBARELY
THEVERYBESTANDBRIGHTESTANDMOSTCOMMITTEDSTAFF ABLETOPROVIDETHEREQUIREDPROGRAMADMINISTRATION
)HAVEEVERHAD!SARESULTOFTHECHALLENGES)JUST ANDMONITORINGFOROUREXISTINGSCHOOLSANDDISTRICTS
MENTIONEDˆFUNDINGSHORTAGES DECLININGSTAFF AND LETALONEHELPFAILINGSCHOOLSTOGETBACKONTRACK
HIGHEXPECTATIONS WEARERE EXAMININGOURROLEASAN .ORAREOURREGULATORYCONCERNSLIMITEDTOTHE
AGENCYANDTHEWAYWEWORKTOGETHERASCHAMPIONSOF FEDERALLEVEL"ACKIN 3ANDIASSTATELEGISLATURE
QUALITYPUBLICEDUCATION VOTEDTOSTRENGTHENACCREDITATIONREQUIREMENTSFORDIS
)NTHEPASTWESTRUGGLEDWITHMAINTAININGCOHE TRICTSANDSCHOOLS4HEYIMPOSEDMORERULESABOUTHOW
SIVENESSACROSSTHEVARIOUSFUNDINGSTREAMS4OOOFTEN DISTRICTSCANSPENDTHEIRSTATEALLOCATIONSANDMADE
BARRIERSBETWEENCATEGORICALPROGRAMSSEPARATEDUS ITPOSSIBLEFORTHESTATETOACTUALLYTAKEOVERFAILING
ANDWEWENTOURINDIVIDUALWAYSRATHERTHANCOLLABO SCHOOLSANDDISTRICTS4HEYEVENDRAMATICALLYREDUCED
RATINGONBEHALFOF3ANDIASSCHOOLSANDFAMILIES7E THELISTOFSTATE APPROVEDTEXTBOOKS FURTHERDAMPENING
MUSTRE EXAMINETHESEHABITSOFTHINKINGANDWORKING LOCALDISTRICTSABILITYTOINNOVATE
3PECIlCALLY WEMUSTTHINKCREATIVELYABOUTHOWTO !TTHEHEARTOFOURNATIONSlNANCIALPRESSURESIS
MAINTAINBASICCOMPLIANCEWHILEFOCUSINGOURRESOURC THEFALLOUTFROMTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTSBORROWING
ESONSCHOOLIMPROVEMENT7ENEEDTOKEEPOURPUBLIC BINGEOFTHEEARLYS)N THEADMINISTRATIONS
SCHOOLSALIVE EFFECTIVE ANDRELEVANTTOOURCUSTOMERS ESTIMATESFORTHATlSCALYEARSHOWEDARECORDDElCITOF
7EWILLDOTHERIGHTWORK DESPITEANYCHALLENGESAND BILLION4AXCUTSFROMPREVIOUSYEARSWEREKEPT
RISKS KNOWINGTHATTHEWORKWILLBEHUGELYREWARDING INPLACE ANDCONTINUEDINVOLVEMENTINFOREIGNWARS
4OBEGIN )WOULDLIKETOREVIEWSOMEOFTHELOCAL NA PLACEDAFURTHERDRAGONTHEECONOMY3O HEREWEARE


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

INWITHAFEDERALBUDGETDElCITDOUBLEWHATIT !BUNDANT
WASINANDEVENLESSMONEYAVAILABLEFORDOMES
TICPROGRAMS ESPECIALLYEDUCATION4HELONG TERMlSCAL
PICTUREISBADANDGETTINGWORSE%VENMOREIMPORTANT
EVERYTHINGTHECURRENTADMINISTRATIONISPROPOSING

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
INTERMSOFADDITIONALHOMELANDSECURITYMEASURESIS

2ESOURCES
GOINGTOHAVEANEVENGREATERNEGATIVEIMPACTONOUR
lSCALPICTURE h!,AST2ESORTv
!NOTHERlNANCIALBURDENWEVEBEENFACINGHAS
COMEWITHTHEINCREASEDFOCUSONHIGHSCHOOLREFORM
3CARCE
"EGINNINGINANDEVERYYEARTHEREAFTER GOVERNORS
CHIEFEXECUTIVES ANDEDUCATIONLEADERSHAVECOME
TOGETHERTHROUGHTHE.ATIONAL%DUCATION3UMMITON
HIGHSCHOOLSTODISCUSSWAYSTOSTRENGTHENREQUIRE CONTINUITYACROSS0nPROGRAMSANDREDOUBLEDOUR
MENTSFORRIGOROUSCOURSEWORK BRINGCOLLEGESANDUNI ATTENTIONONPOST SECONDARY NON COLLEGEEDUCATION
VERSITIESTOGETHERWITH+nEDUCATIONTOSETCOMMON ANDTRAININGCHOICESSOTHATALLOFOURSTUDENTSHAVE
EXPECTATIONS IMPROVETEACHINGANDPRINCIPALLEADER THEOPPORTUNITYTOPURSUEEDUCATIONPASTHIGHSCHOOL
SHIP ANDEXPANDEDUCATIONOPTIONSFORHIGHSCHOOL 4HEREAREEARLYINDICATIONSTHATOUREFFORTSAREPAYING
STUDENTS7EAT3$%HAVEWORKEDHARDTOSUPPORTOUR OFF)AMHAPPYTOSAYTHATDECLININGGRADUATIONRATES
CONSTITUENTSASTHEYSTRIVETOIMPROVETHEIRHIGHSCHOOL HAVELEVELEDOFFANDINAFEWINSTANCESHAVEREBOUNDED
PROGRAMS7EVEWORKEDWITHCOMMUNITYORGANIZA SLIGHTLY!GAIN THEHARDCHALLENGESWEHAVEFACED
TIONSANDHIGHEREDUCATIONTORAISEAWARENESSOFTHE HAVEHELPEDUSFOCUSONDOINGTHERIGHTWORK
NEEDFORCREATIVESOLUTIONS INCLUDINGSTRONGERARTICULA .ATURALLY PARTOFTHECHALLENGEWEVEFACEDOVER
TIONOFREQUIREMENTSACROSSTHE0nCONTINUUM MORE THEPASTTENYEARSANDWILLCONTINUETOFACEINTHE
OPPORTUNITIESTOEARNCOLLEGECREDITINHIGHSCHOOL FUTUREISDUETONATIONALDEMOGRAPHICS"EGINNING
RESTRUCTURINGTHElNALYEAROFHIGHSCHOOLTOASSUREA IN NEARLYMILLIONBABYBOOMERS THESINGLE
SMOOTHERTRANSITIONTOCOLLEGE ANDGREATERATTENTION LARGESTGENERATIONINOURHISTORY BEGANTURNING
TOPOST HIGHSCHOOLEDUCATIONANDTRAININGOPTIONSFOR &ORTUNATELY AGOODNUMBEROFUSBOOMERS INCLUDING
NON COLLEGE BOUNDSTUDENTS5NFORTUNATELY INSPITEOF ME HAVECHOSENTOCONTINUEWORKING THUSCONTINU
THESUSTAINEDINTERESTOFOURPOLITICIANS THEREHASBEEN INGOURCONTRIBUTIONSTO3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARE
NOADDITIONALFUNDINGAVAILABLETOSUPPORTTHESEINITIA ANDDELAYINGCOLLECTINGBENElTS"UT BELIEVEITOR
TIVES NOT WECANTWORKFOREVERANDSOON THELEVELOFTAX
9ET THECHALLENGEOFREFORMINGHIGHSCHOOLSISAN REVENUESGENERATEDBYOURHIGHSALARIES WHICHHAS
OPPORTUNITYTOMAKEAREALDIFFERENCEINTHEPERSONAL OVERTHEYEARS ALLOWEDTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTTO
LIVESOFOURSTUDENTSANDINTHEECONOMICLIFEOFOUR DESIGNANDIMPLEMENTHUGEPROGRAMSTOADDRESSTHE
COUNTRY5NTILTHESTCENTURY THE53ECONOMY NEEDSOFSTUDENTSWHOFORAVARIETYOFREASONSREQUIRED
INCLUDEDAHEALTHYMANUFACTURINGSECTORTHATPROVIDED ADDITIONALEDUCATIONALSERVICES WILLDIMINISH4ITLE)
GOODLIVINGWAGEJOBSFORPEOPLENOTEDUCATEDPASTTHE ASSISTEDGENERATIONSOFLOW INCOMESTUDENTSBYPROVID
HIGHSCHOOLLEVEL4HATHASALLCHANGEDASMANUFACTUR INGADDITIONALRESOURCESTOTHEIRSCHOOLS4HE)NDI
INGJOBSHAVEGONEOVERSEAS LEAVINGBEHINDMOSTLY VIDUALSWITH$ISABILITIES%DUCATION!CT WHATWECALL
LOW PAYINGSERVICEJOBSFORTHOSEWITHONLYAHIGH )$%! WASATREMENDOUSSOURCEOFHELPFORSTUDENTS
SCHOOLDIPLOMA/URCHILDRENNEEDAQUALITYEDUCA WITHPHYSICALANDMENTALHANDICAPSANDANESSENTIAL
TIONTHATGOESBEYONDHIGHSCHOOLTOSURVIVEINTHE SOURCEOFREVENUEFORTHESCHOOLSWORKINGHARDTOMEET
NEWECONOMY7EAREOBLIGEDTOPROVIDETHEKINDOF THENEEDSOFTHESESPECIALSTUDENTS)NFACT SOON OVER
EDUCATIONTHEYNEEDTOSUPPORTTHEIRFAMILIES)NRECENT PERCENTOFTHENATIONALELECTORATEWILLBEOLDERTHAN
YEARSWEHAVEPLACEDGREATEREMPHASISONPROMOTING  RETIREDFROMTRADITIONALWORKPLACES ANDPURSUING

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

THEIRINDIVIDUALINTERESTSORVOLUNTEERINGANDLIVINGON IMMEASURABLEASSISTANCEINEXPLORINGHOWWEALLCAN
SAVINGSANDMEAGERPENSIONS!SARESULT THE#ONGRES INTEGRATEOURSERVICESTOGETMOREBANGFOROURCOLLEC
SIONAL"UDGET/FlCEISPREDICTINGSLOWBUTSTEADYDE TIVEBUCKS
CLINESINTAXREVENUES#OMBINEDWITHEVER INCREASING 0ARENTSTHEMSELVESHAVEBEENANOTHERRESOURCE
DEMANDSONTHEHEALTHCARESYSTEMFROMAGINGBOOMERS -ANYSECONDGENERATIONIMMIGRANTSHAVEMOVED
WELL YOUCANSEETHATTHElNANCIALSCENEAHEADISNOT INTOTHEMAINSTREAM OPERATINGSUCCESSFULBUSINESSES
ENCOURAGING RUNNINGFORCITYCOUNCIL MANAGINGSTATEANDLOCAL
(EREIN3ANDIAWEFACEANEVENGREATERCHALLENGE AGENCIES ANDOCCUPYINGSEATSINTHESTATEHOUSE!S
-ANYRETIREESAREMOVINGTOOURSTATETOTAKEADVAN ADVOCATESFORTHEIROWNCHILDRENSEDUCATION ASWELL
TAGEOFTHEWONDERFULCLIMATEANDLOWSTATETAXES)N ASFORNEWARRIVALSINTHISCOUNTRY THEYAREINAUNIQUE
THENEXTELECTION ITWILLBEAHARDSELLTOCONVINCE POSITIONTOHELPBRIDGETHEGAPBETWEENWHATTHEIR
THESEPEOPLETOPARTWITHMOREOFTHEIRlXEDINCOMES KIDSNEEDANDWHATTHEFEDERALPROGRAMSCANNOLONGER
TOPAYFORSCHOOLBONDISSUES!TTHESAMETIMETHAT DELIVER
THEELDERLYAREMOVINGTO3ANDIA YOUNGPEOPLEARE !SPUBLICEDUCATIONBECOMESMORESTARVEDFOR
LEAVINGTHESTATE LOOKINGFOROPPORTUNITIESELSEWHERE RESOURCES PARENTSWHOAREABLETOMAKEACHOICEARE
3O YOUMIGHTASK WHEREINALLOFTHISISTHERE SENDINGTHEIRCHILDRENTOPRIVATEORPAROCHIALSCHOOLS
OPPORTUNITYFORUS&IRST OURINCREASINGPOPULATION 7HEN3ANDIAPASSEDITSSCHOOLCHOICELEGISLATIONIN
OFRETIREESCANBEATREMENDOUSRESOURCEIFWEVIEW  ITOPENEDTHEDOORFORANEXODUSOFSTUDENTS
THEMASALLIESANDPARTNERSINEDUCATINGOURCHILDREN FROMPUBLICSCHOOLS.OTONLYDIDTHISFURTHERREDUCE
-EMBERSOFTHEBOOMERGENERATIONPOSSESSASTRONG THElNANCIALRESOURCESAVAILABLE ITTYPICALLYLEFTPUBLIC
SOCIALCONSCIENCE'ROWINGUPINTHES BELIEVING SCHOOLSWITHHIGHERPERCENTAGESOFHARD TO SERVE
THATWECOULDCHANGETHEWORLDFORTHEBETTERTHROUGH STUDENTSANDMORECROWDEDCLASSROOMS)NFACT NOW
POLITICALACTION WEHAVEALWAYSBEENATTRACTEDTO ONLYABOUTPERCENTOFALLSTUDENTSATTENDPUBLIC
hTHECAUSEv#OUPLETHISALTRUISMANDBELIEFWITHTHE SCHOOL MAINLYININNER CITYANDRURALDISTRICTS4HISIS
FACTTHATBOOMERSTENDTOBEWEALTHIER HEALTHIERAND ADROPOFALMOSTPERCENTFROMADECADEAGO/NTHE
hYOUNGERvTHANPREVIOUSGENERATIONSOFRETIREES ANDYOU PLUSSIDE THOSEPARENTSWHOSTILLSENDTHEIRCHILDREN
HAVEAREADYSOURCEOFVOLUNTEERS WAITINGONLYFORTHE TOPUBLICSCHOOLAREMOREINVOLVEDTHANEVER AND
RIGHTCAUSETOINSPIRETHEMTOSERVICE ITSNOTJUSTTHEANNUALBAKESALE#OMMITTEDTOTHEIR
.OWLETSCONSIDERFORAMOMENTOURSCHOOL AGE CHILDRENSFUTURESANDUNABLETOAFFORDPRIVATESCHOOLS
POPULATION)NTHEFACEOFSTEADYDECLINESINREVENUES THEYVEBANDEDTOGETHERTOFORCETHEPUBLICSYSTEMTO
AVAILABLETOSUPPORTPUBLIC+nEDUCATION OUR DOBETTER)TSNOTALWAYSFUN BUTONTHEOTHERHAND
SCHOOL AGEPOPULATIONISMOREDIVERSEANDHARDERTO WEKNOWTHATPARENTINVOLVEMENTISONEOFTHESINGLE
SERVE"ECAUSEFEDERALPOLICIESENCOURAGEIMMIGRATION BIGGESTCONTRIBUTORSTOIMPROVEDOUTCOMESFORCHILDREN
MOREANDMOREOFOURCHILDRENDONOTHAVE%NGLISHAS 0ARENTSHAVESERVEDASASTRONGMOTIVATIONALFORCETO
THEIRlRSTLANGUAGE-ANYCHILDREN BOTH%NGLISH AND IMPROVEALLOFOURSCHOOLSFORALLOFOURCHILDREN
NON %NGLISHSPEAKING LIVEATORBELOWTHEPOVERTYLINE /URYOUNGTEACHERPOPULATIONISANOTHERVALUABLE
AND)DONTHAVETOTELLYOUWHATKINDSOFSPECIALNEEDS RESOURCETHATREPRESENTSYETANOTHEROPPORTUNITYFOR
THESEKIDSBRINGTOSCHOOLWITHTHEMEVERYDAY OURSTATE/NEOF3ANDIASBIGGESTCHALLENGESINTHE
4HEGOODNEWSISWEARENOTALONE(UMANSERVICE PASTHASALWAYSBEENTOATTRACTANDKEEPTHEBESTAND
AGENCIESTHROUGHOUTTHESTATEHAVEEXPERIENCEDSIMILAR BRIGHTESTINTHETEACHINGWORKFORCE7HENTHESTATE
BUDGETARYPRESSURESWHILEATTHESAMETIMEHAVESEEN LEGISLATUREPASSEDTHETUITIONFORGIVENESSPROGRAMIN
INCREASINGDEMANDSFORTHEIRSERVICES)NRESPONSE  ITWENTALONGWAYTOWARDENCOURAGINGYOUNG
SOMESTATEAGENCIESHAVEBANDEDTOGETHERTOLEVER BRIGHT TECHNOLOGY SAVVYTEACHERSTOSTAYINRURALAND
AGETHEIRRESOURCESINSERVICEOFTHEGREATERGOOD)M ECONOMICALLYDEPRESSEDURBANSCHOOLS4ECHNOLOGYHAS
PLEASEDTOSAYTHATOURPARTNERSINTHE$EPARTMENTSOF CONSISTENTLYOFFEREDIMPROVEDCAPABILITIESATALOWER
#HILDRENAND&AMILIESAND0UBLIC(EALTHHAVEBEENOF PRICE)TISTHROUGHTHEUSEOFTECHNOLOGYTHATWEARE


3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

ABLETOBRINGCUTTING EDGEPROGRAMSANDOTHERRESOURC !BUNDANT


ESTOOURISOLATEDANDECONOMICALLYCHALLENGEDSCHOOLS
4ECHNOLOGYISTHEVEHICLETHATTAKESOURLEARNERSTO
PLACESNEVERBEFOREPOSSIBLE7HENMOSTOFUSINTHIS
ROOMGREWUP COLORTELEVISIONWASHIGHTECH3IXTEEN

3TRONG
7EAK
'OVERNMENT#ONTROL
BITCOMPUTERSSHOWEDUPABOUTTHETIMEWEHITHIGH

2ESOURCES
SCHOOL!4-S 5 SCANGROCERYLINES WIRELESSNETWORK
ING VIRTUALREALITYˆTHESEWEREALLAMAZING ANDFOR h!,AST2ESORTv
MANYOFUS JUSTABITUNCOMFORTABLEATlRST4HEYOUNG
PEOPLECOMINGOUTOFOURSCHOOLSOFEDUCATIONTODAY
3CARCE
WEREBORNWITHMICROCHIPSINTHEIRCRADLES4HEYARE
WHATWECALLhDIGITALNATIVESv!LLTHISTECHNOLOGYIS
PARTOFEVERYDAYLIFEFORTHEM(AVINGATEACHERWORK
FORCEWHOKNOWSWHATTODOWITHTHESERESOURCESHAS OPPORTUNITYLIESINOURABILITYTOENERGIZEBUSINESSAND
BEENABLESSINGANDANECESSITY COMMUNITYGROUPSTORALLYAROUNDPUBLICSCHOOLSIN
4ECHNOLOGYALSOHASPROVIDEDSOMEOFTHESOLU THEIRHOMETOWNSANDPROVIDETHENECESSARYRESOURCES
TIONTOOURACCOUNTABILITYPROBLEMS.EWSYSTEMSFOR FORQUALITYLEARNING2ESEARCHFROMTHESSHOWS
ASSESSMENTANDFORCAPTURINGANDUSINGINDIVIDUAL THATWHENASMALLTOWNLOSESITSPUBLICSCHOOL THEREST
STUDENTDATAHELPUSTAILOREDUCATIONALEXPERIENCESTO OFTHETOWNDIESASWELL)NURBANANDSUBURBANAREAS
MEETINDIVIDUALNEEDS ANDTOTESTSECONDLANGUAGE PROPERTYVALUESDECLINEWHENNEIGHBORHOODSCHOOLS
STUDENTSINTHEIRNATIVELANGUAGES4HEYALSOALLOWUS CLOSEDOWNORAREPLACEDONACADEMICWATCHLISTS)TIS
TOREPORTSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTINTHEWAYSREQUIREDBY INOURCOLLECTIVEBESTINTERESTSTOMAINTAINOURSCHOOLS
THEFEDERALGOVERNMENT)TISSADTOSAY THOUGH THAT )HAVELONGBEENAMEMBEROFVARIOUSCIVICGROUPS
TWOOFTHESTAFFLAIDOFFLASTSUMMERWEREFROM3ANDIAS ANDHAVEALWAYSADVOCATEDINTHOSEGROUPSFORGREATER
TECHNOLOGYCONSULTANTTEAM4HESCHOOLSINOURSTATE PUBLICSUPPORTFORSCHOOLS)AMASKINGYOU MEMBERS
MUSTLEARNTOGROWTHEIROWNTECHNOLOGYEXPERTISEOR OFTHE3TATE"OARDOF%DUCATION TOLIKEWISEENCOUR
RELYONTHATAVAILABLEINTHEIRLOCALCOMMUNITIES AGEYOURCONSTITUENTSTOSEEKOUTWAYSOFSUPPORTING
3OWHATDOESTHISALLMEANFOR3$%ANDOURCUS SCHOOLS7ENEEDMATERIALS7ENEEDEQUIPMENT7E
TOMERS/URPARENTSEXPECTTEACHERSTOBECLEARER NEEDVOLUNTEERS7ENEEDYOURHELPTOPREPAREALLOF
ABOUTWHATWESHOULDBETEACHING4HEYAREDEMAND OURYOUNGPEOPLEFORTHEFUTURE
INGTHATTHEYEMPLOYTHEMOSTEFFECTIVEINSTRUCTIONAL !NDYOU STAFFOFTHE3ANDIA3TATE$EPARTMENTOF
PRACTICESINOURCLASSROOMS4HEYEXPECTTHATTHEYWILL %DUCATION OURSISANOBLEMISSIONFRAUGHTWITHDIFl
USEQUALITYRESEARCHTOGUIDESELECTIONOFCURRICULUM CULTY)NEEDYOUTOREMEMBEROURMISSION DOTHERIGHT
ANDINSTRUCTIONALPRACTICES(EREAT3$%THATMEANS WORK ANDKEEPTHEFAITH
WENEEDTOBEMORESKILLEDATUNDERSTANDINGRESEARCH
ANDHELPINGTEACHERSTRANSLATEITINTOPRACTICE7E
NEEDTOBEFARMORECOLLABORATIVEANDCUSTOMERORI !NALYSISOF3CENARIO
ENTEDTHANINTHEPAST DESPITECONTINUEDREGULATORY )MPLICATIONS
OBLIGATIONS7ENEEDTOBECLEARERABOUTWHATWENEED
TODOTORECRUITANDRETAINTHEBESTTEACHERS7ENEED )NTHEWORLDDESCRIBEDINTHISSCENARIOTHEREWILLBE
TOBEMORECREATIVEINLEVERAGINGOURRESOURCESACROSS FEWRESOURCESANDLITTLEmEXIBILITYINHOWTOUSETHEM
PROGRAMSTOPRODUCETHEBIGGESThBANGFORTHEBUCKv 4HESIZEOFTHE3%!SSTAFFWILLDECREASESUBSTANTIALLY
!NDWENEEDTOBEVERYSKILLEDATUSINGTECHNOLOGYTO ANDTHEREMAININGSTAFFWILLNEEDTODOMOREWITHLESS
SUPPORTALLOFOUREFFORTS 3TAFFMORALEISLIKELYTODECLINE&EDERALANDSTATEGOV
7HATDOESTHECOMINGYEARHOLDFORUS4HEREISAN ERNMENTWILLPROMULGATEMANYREGULATIONSBUTHAVE
OLDSAYING h.ECESSITYISTHEMOTHEROFINVENTIONv/UR LITTLEABILITYTOENFORCETHEM POTENTIALLYLEADINGTO

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

CYNICISMAMONG3%!STAFFCHARGEDWITHASSURINGREGU s ,OCALECONOMICINDICATORSAREMOREPOSITIVETHAN
LATORYCOMPLIANCE/NTHEOTHERHAND THEPOTENTIAL NATIONALINDICATORS
EXISTSFORTHE3%!TOFOCUSONREGULATORYCOMPLIANCEAT
THEEXPENSEOFSCHOOLIMPROVEMENT /PTIONS
-ANYSCHOOLSWILLBEIDENTIlEDASINNEEDOF )NORDERTOBEEFFECTIVEINTHISSCENARIO 3%!SMUST
IMPROVEMENT3%!SWILLNEEDTOBECLEARABOUTTHEIR BECOMEADEPTATCOORDINATINGANDLEVERAGINGRESOURCES
MISSIONORRUNTHERISKOFLOSINGSIGHTOFWHOTHEYARE ACROSSPROGRAMS4HEYSHOULDPICKAFEWKEYPRIORITIES
EXPECTEDTOSERVE"ECAUSEOFECONOMICCONDITIONSAND ANDFOCUSONTHEM2EGULATORYCOMPLIANCEWILLBE
ATIGHTJOBMARKETINOTHERINDUSTRIES TEACHERSUPPLY ANISSUEBUTITWILLBEUPTOTHE3%!TOSTREAMLINEITS
COULDBEREASONABLYHEALTHY PROCESSESANDRELYONTECHNOLOGYASMUCHASPOSSIBLE
4HEREWILLBEANINmUXOFIMMIGRANTSANDSPECIAL TOREDUCETHECOSTOFMONITORINGCOMPLIANCE
NEEDSCHILDRENINTOTHEPUBLICSCHOOLSYSTEM CREAT )NORDERTODELIVERNECESSARYSERVICES ESPECIALLY
INGTHENEEDFORSOLUTIONSTARGETEDATTHESEPOPULA TOFAILINGSCHOOLSANDSPECIALNEEDSSTUDENTS 3%!S
TIONS THUSDRAININGRESOURCESFOROTHERNEEDS,OCAL WILLNEEDTOCOORDINATETHEIRWORKWITHOTHERHUMAN
ECONOMIESCOULDBEHEALTHIERTHANNATIONALECONOMIES SERVICE HEALTHANDEDUCATIONAGENCIESINORDERTO
ANDPOSSIBLYBEDOMINATEDBYlRSTGENERATIONIMMI LEVERAGERESOURCESANDAVOIDDUPLICATIONOFSERVICES
GRANTS,OCALSCHOOLBOARDSCOULDBECOMEDOMINATED 0OLITICALSUPPORTFORMAKINGTHEHIGHSCHOOLCURRICU
BYlRSTANDSECONDGENERATIONIMMIGRANTS DRIVING LUMRELEVANTTOPRESENTANDFUTUREWORKFORCENEEDSWILL
LOCALEDUCATIONAGENCIESTOFOCUSMOREONTHENEEDSOF REQUIRE3%!STOTAKEAMORESYSTEMICVIEWOFTHE0n
THEIRCHILDREN3TRONGLINKSTOLOCALCOMMUNITYGROUPS CONTINUUMWHILENOTLOSINGSITEOFTHENEEDSOFNON
COULDBETHESAVINGGRACEFORPUBLICEDUCATION9ET COLLEGEBOUNDSTUDENTS
THISCOULDRESULTINABACKLASHAGAINSTPUBLICSCHOOLS 4OSUPPLEMENTHUMANRESOURCESATTHELOCALLEVEL
FROMOTHERPARENTSWHOFEELTHATTHEIRCHILDRENARENOT 3%!SWILLNEEDTOWORKWITHOTHERSTATEANDLOCAL
BEINGWELLSERVED AGENCIESTODEVELOPWAYSTOHARNESSTHEENERGY SKILLS
ANDCOMMITMENTOFRETIREESANDOTHEROLDERMEMBERS
)NDICATORS OFSOCIETY4HEYWILLALSONEEDTOREACHOUTTOPARENTS
%VENTSANDTRENDSTHATCOULDSIGNALTHISSCENARIO OFSCHOOLCHILDRENTOENSURERELEVANCETOTHISKEY
UNFOLDINGINCLUDE STAKEHOLDERGROUP HARNESSTHEIRECONOMICSUPPORTAND
INGENUITYTOIMPROVELOCALEDUCATION ANDMAINTAIN
s 3TATESDONOTPREVAILINSEEKINGMOREmEXIBILITYIN THEIRCOMMITMENTTOPUBLICEDUCATION
.#,"REQUIREMENTS
$ISCUSSION1UESTIONS
s #ONTINUEDDEMANDFORFEDERALFUNDSFROMFOREIGN
!RETHECRITICALUNCERTAINTIESTHATFORMTHE
POLICY HOMELANDSECURITY 3OCIAL3ECURITYAND
SCENARIOFRAMEWORKTHOSETHATYOUWOULDCHOOSE
-EDICARE
ORARETHEREOTHERUNCERTAINTIESTHATSEEMMORE
s 3%!REVENUESDECLINEANDSTAFFLAYOFFSINCREASE CRITICALTOYOU

s /THERSTATEAGENCIESCOMEUNDERSIMILAR !RETHESTORIESPLAUSIBLE#OULDTHEYTURNOUTTO
PRESSURES BETRUE)FNOT WHATWOULDYOUCHANGE

s #OLLEGEATTENDANCERATESDECLINE #ANYOUTHINKOFOTHERIMPLICATIONSANDOPTIONS
FORTHEORGANIZATIONINADDITIONTOTHOSEWRITTEN
s 0UBLICHEALTHINDICATORSSLIDE INTHE!NALYSISSECTIONS
s )MMIGRATIONPOLICIESDONOTREDUCETHEINmUXOF )FYOUWERELEADINGANORGANIZATIONOFTHISTYPE
LEGALANDILLEGALALIENS WHATWOULDYOUDONOWTOPREPAREFORTHESE
IMAGINEDFUTURES


 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
!MPLE

h!LL )NCLUSIVE h"EDAND"REAKFAST


,UXURY2ESORTv #OUNTRY)NNv

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
#ONTROLOF,EARNING

2ESOURCES
h2OADSIDE#HAIN h2EST3TOP
-OTELv #AR#AMPINGv

,IMITED

,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIOS
)NTRODUCTION

(ISTORICAL"ACKGROUND
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTISONEOFTHEOLDESTDISTRICTSINTHEWESTERN5NITED3TATES&ORMEDON
*UNE  THEDISTRICTORIGINALLYCONSISTEDOFAONE ROOMSCHOOLNAMED-IDDLETOWN(ISTORICALLY
COMMUNITYMEMBERSHAVEPLACEDHIGHEMPHASISONTHEIMPORTANCEOFEDUCATION ANDTHEDISTRICTHAS
BEENCENTRALINSUPPORTINGTHECITYSEDUCATIONINITIATIVES-ANYGRADUATESFROMTHEDISTRICTARECOMMU
NITYANDSTATELEADERS
-ISSION3TATEMENT
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT INCOLLABORATIONWITHPARENTSANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERS ISCOMMITTED
TOACOMMONPURPOSE%DUCATINGEVERYCHILDFORABETTERTOMORROWˆPROMOTINGDEMOCRACYTHROUGH
PUBLICEDUCATION

'OALS
4HEPRIMARYGOALOFTHE-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTISTOPRESERVETHEDEMOCRATICPRINCIPLESUPON
WHICHOURCOUNTRYWASFOUNDEDBYIMPROVINGSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTFORALLSTUDENTSREGARDLESSOFRACE
ETHNICITY SOCIO ECONOMICSTATUS GENDER OREDUCATIONALBACKGROUNDANDTOCLOSETHEACHIEVEMENTGAP
BETWEENLOW ANDHIGH PERFORMINGSTUDENTS

'OVERNANCE
!SINGLEBOARDGOVERNS-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTANDCONSISTSOFSEVENELECTEDMEMBERS EACH
SERVINGAFOUR YEARTERM)TISTHEPOLICYOFTHEBOARDOFEDUCATIONTOPROVIDEHIGHQUALITYEDUCATIONFOR
ALLSTUDENTS4HEBOARDENCOURAGESCOMMUNITYMEMBERSTOATTENDBOARDMEETINGSANDSCHEDULESASET
TIMETOHEARPUBLICCOMMENTSATMEETINGS HELDONTHElRST-ONDAYOFEACHMONTHFROMnPM
ATTHE-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTOFlCELOCATEDAT&RONT3TREETINDOWNTOWN-IDDLETON
4HESUPERINTENDENTREPORTSTOTHE-IDDLETON"OARDOF%DUCATION4HESUPERINTENDENTISRESPONSIBLE
FORTHEOVERALLOPERATIONSOFTHESCHOOLDISTRICTANDTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFBOARDPOLICIESANDPROCEDURES
4HISYEAR THEDISTRICTEMPLOYSTEACHERS CLASSIlEDSTAFF ANDMANAGEMENTPERSONNEL


"OUNDARIESAND%NROLLMENT
4HE-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTCOVERSAPPROXIMATELYSQUAREMILESANDISLOCATEDINTHECITYOF
-IDDLETON4HEDISTRICTSERVESADIVERSESTUDENTPOPULATIONOFABOUT STUDENTSINKINDERGARTEN
THROUGHTHGRADE7ATERS%DGE TOTHEEASTOFTOWN ISANEARBYBURGEONINGCOMMUNITYTHATISRAPIDLY
BUILDINGNEWHOMES PARKS ANDALONGWITHTHEM SCHOOLS

3CHOOLS
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTMAINTAINSANDOPERATESSCHOOLSTWELVEELEMENTARYSCHOOLS SIXMIDDLE
SCHOOLS ANDFOURHIGHSCHOOLS%LEMENTARYSCHOOLSAVERAGESTUDENTS MIDDLESCHOOLSAVERAGE
STUDENTS ANDHIGHSCHOOLS STUDENTS4HEBOARDOFEDUCATIONADOPTEDANOPENENROLLMENTPOLICY
PERMITTINGPARENTSTOENROLLINTHESCHOOLOFTHEIRCHOICEIFTHEREISSPACE

#HALLENGES
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTFACESMANYCHALLENGESRELATEDTOENROLLMENT STAFlNG STUDENTACHIEVE
MENT ANDBUDGET4HESTUDENTPOPULATIONHASCHANGEDDRASTICALLYDURINGTHEPASTlVEYEARSDUETOTHE
INCREASEOFIMMIGRANTWORKERSEMPLOYEDBYLOCALAGRICULTURALANDMANUFACTURINGCOMPANIES4HISIS
REmECTEDINANINCREASEOFIMMIGRANTSFROMSOUTHEAST!SIAAND-EXICOWHOAREPREDOMINANTLYFROMLOW
SOCIO ECONOMICLEVELS)NADDITION ENROLLMENTATTHEELEMENTARYLEVELHASBEGUNTODECLINE
4HE-IDDLETON4EACHERS!SSOCIATIONSCONTRACTINCLUDESASTRONGTRANSFERPOLICY WHICHANINCREASING
NUMBEROFTEACHERSEXERCISEINORDERTOTEACHATTHEHIGH PERFORMINGEASTSIDESCHOOLS!TTRACTINGAND
RETAININGNEWTEACHERSANDSTAFFTOLOWERPERFORMINGSCHOOLSISINCREASINGLYDIFlCULTANDCOMPLICATEDBY
THEFACTTHATMANYTEACHERSARENEARINGRETIREMENTINTHENEXTTWOYEARS
!LTHOUGHALLBUTTHREEELEMENTARYSCHOOLSMET!NNUAL9EARLY0ROGRESS!90 INn -ID
DLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTDIDNOTMEETTHEDISTRICT!90FOR%NGLISH ,ANGUAGE,EARNERS (ISPANICS AND
SPECIALEDUCATIONSTUDENTS3OMEBOARDMEMBERSAREQUESTIONINGWHETHERTHEPRIMARYFOCUSOFTHE
DISTRICT WHICHISIMPROVINGACADEMICACHIEVEMENTFORALLSTUDENTS MIGHTBEHAVINGANEGATIVE RATHER
THANAPOSITIVEIMPACTONITSOVERALLSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTSCORES
&INALLY THEDISTRICTCONTINUESTOREDUCEITSSPENDINGASITEXPERIENCESSTATEANDFEDERALBUDGETCUTS
7ITHNOHOPEFORINCREASEDFUNDINGONTHEHORIZON THEBOARDOFEDUCATIONHASESTABLISHEDAlNANCE
COMMITTEEFORTHElRSTTIMEINITSHISTORY
&/#!,)335%7HATSTEPSCAN-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTTAKENOWTOENSURETHATITISAHIGH PER
FORMINGDISTRICTIN
)N THEBOARDOFEDUCATIONAPPROVEDTHEFORMATIONOFA MEMBERDISTRICTSTRATEGYTEAM
WHICHINCLUDESADMINISTRATORS TEACHERS PARENTS ANDBOARDANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERS TOGENERATE
STRATEGIESFORTHRIVINGINTHEFUTUREANDREALIZINGTHEDISTRICTVISIONOFBEINGAHIGH PERFORMINGDISTRICT
4HETEAMHASFOCUSEDITSWORKONEXPLORINGTHEPOTENTIALFORCHANGESINTHELOCUSOFCONTROLOFLEARNING
FROMINSTITUTIONSTOINDIVIDUALS ASWELLASPOSSIBLEINCREASESORDECREASESINTHEAVAILABILITYOFRESOURCES
FORPUBLICSCHOOLS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY !MPLE

3CENARIO h!LL )NCLUSIVE


,UXURY2ESORTv
$EEP#AUSES

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
#ONTROLOF,EARNING
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATTHETRADITIONALINSTI
TUTIONALCONlGURATIONSTHATHAVEDElNED!MERICAN

2ESOURCES
PUBLICSCHOOLSOVERTHEPASTTHREECENTURIESREMAINTHE
PRIMARYFORMOFSCHOOLINGANDTHATRESOURCESFOREDUCA
TIONAREABUNDANTASARESULTOFTHEFOLLOWINGCAUSES
,IMITED
s 4HESUCCESSOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT
OFINDRAMATICALLYIMPROVINGSTUDENT
ACHIEVEMENTFORALLSUBGROUPSEXCEPTEXCEPTIONAL h!LL )NCLUSIVE ,UXURY2ESORTv
NEEDSSTUDENTS
4IME
s .ATIONALATTENTIONFOCUSEDON#HINASEMERGING 0LACE-IDDLETON 53!
ECONOMICDOMINANCEATTRIBUTEDINPARTTOTHE
3CENE%$ -/.4(,9COVERSEDUCATION RELATED
STRONGMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCESKILLSOFTHEIR
TOPICSOFINTERESTTOTHEWESTERNSTATES)NADDITIONTO
STUDENTSASREPORTEDIN4)--3
LEGISLATIVEUPDATESANDNEWSARTICLES ITRUNSOP EDS
s !DEQUATEFUNDINGFOREDUCATIONATTHEFEDERAL ANDFEATURESECTIONS&ORTHEPASTCOUPLEOFMONTHS
STATE ANDLOCALLEVELSASARESULTOFTHEPUBLICS AN%$ -/.4(,9REPORTERHASBEENATTENDING
REALIZATIONTHATMONEYUSEDINTHEhRIGHTWAYSv -IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSMONTHLYBOARDMEETINGS
CANLEADTOIMPROVEDSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT HOPINGTOBETHElRSTWITHhBREAKINGNEWSvTOREPORT
ASWELLASSCHOOLlNANCELITIGATIONTHATLEDTO 3HESBEENTIPPEDOFFTOEXPECTAPOSSIBLEPARTNERSHIP
CHANGESINSCHOOLFUNDING WITHAVERYBIGCORPORATEPLAYER4ONIGHTSHEGETS
LUCKYˆTHEBOARDMAKESITSSURPRISEANNOUNCEMENT
s )NCREASEDPARTNERSHIPSWITHCORPORATIONS ABOUTACORPORATEPARTNERSHIPWITH-ICRO4ECH#OM
PROVIDINGSUPPLEMENTALFUNDINGTOLOCAL PUTINGTOIMPROVEMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCEFOR+n
EDUCATIONAGENCIES STUDENTSINTHEDISTRICT(EREDITORINTENDSTORUNTHE
hHOTvSTORYONTHENEWSPAPERS7EBSITERATHERTHAN
,IKEVACATIONERSTOh#LUB-ED vSTUDENTSENJOY
HOLDITFORNEXTMONTHSISSUE
MANYEDUCATIONALLUXURIESWITHINAHIGHLYSTRUCTURED
ENVIRONMENTINTHISSCENARIO4HESUPPLEMENTALhBELLS
ANDWHISTLESvMAKETHISWELL DElNEDANDSTANDARDIZED
EDUCATIONATTRACTIVE /N&EBRUARY  -IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT
"OARD0RESIDENT-ICHELLE#OULEYANNOUNCED-IDDLE
TONSh0ARTNERSHIPFOR)NNOVATIONvWITH-ICRO4ECH
#OMPUTINGTOAPACKEDGYMNASIUMOFNEARLYCOM
MUNITYMEMBERS4HE-IDDLETON -ICRO4ECHPARTNER
SHIPWASlNALIZEDON&EBRUARY  WHEN-ICRO
4ECH#%/*OSHUA2HODES 3UPERINTENDENT'UADALUPE
-ARTINEZ AND"OARD0RESIDENT-ICHELLE#OULEYSIGNED
ALANDMARKlVE YEARAGREEMENT WHICHSIGNIlESANEW
ERAFORTHE-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NADDITIONTODONATINGMILLIONDOLLARSOVER STUDENTACHIEVEMENTANDHASINCREASEDPUBLICSUPPORT
THECOURSEOFlVEYEARSTOIMPROVEMATHEMATICS FORFUNDINGSCHOOLS)NADDITION MOSTSTATESINCREASED
ANDSCIENCEINSTRUCTIONINTHEDISTRICT A-ICRO4ECH FUNDINGFORSCHOOLSASARESULTOFTHESPATEOFSCHOOL
REPRESENTATIVEWILLSERVEASANEXOFlCIOMEMBEROF lNANCELAWSUITSINTHElRSTDECADEOFTHESTCENTURY
THE-IDDLETON"OARDOF%DUCATION4HEPARTNERSHIP #OULEYEXPLAINEDTHATTHEFUNDINGPROVIDEDBY-I
WILLFUNDNEWEXTRACURRICULAR0RE+ SCIENCEAND CRO4ECHWILLALLOWTHEDISTRICTTOGOTHEEXTRAYARDIN
MATHEMATICSACTIVITIES VIRTUALAPPRENTICESHIPSFORHIGH PROVIDINGADDITIONALTRAININGFORTEACHERSANDINBOOST
SCHOOLSTUDENTS ANDEXTENSIVEPROFESSIONALDEVELOP INGSTUDENTSINTERESTINMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE
MENTFORTEACHERS PRINCIPALS ANDSTAFF )NOTHERBUSINESSOFTHEEVENING #OULEYWELCOMED
*OSHUA2HODESTOTHE-IDDLETON"OARDOF%DUCATION
2EACHINGOUTTO"USINESS STATING
-IDDLETONDISTRICTOFlCIALSENTHUSIASTICALLYCOMMENTED -ICRO4ECHSPRESENCEONTHISBOARDREPRESENTSA
ONTHE)NNOVATION0ARTNERSHIP3UPERINTENDENT-AR BREAKTHROUGHINTHEKINDOFTHINKINGTHATHASTRADI
TINEZWASTHElRSTTOSPEAK(ERREMARKSBELOWPROVIDE TIONALLYCONSTRAINEDOURPROGRESS,ESSTHANADECADE
INSIGHTINTOTHEBOARDSMOTIVATION AGO EDUCATORSTALKEDABOUTMAKINGSCHOOLRELEVANT
TOTHE@REALWORLD ANDBUSINESSESTALKEDABOUTTHE
)TISWITHGREATPLEASURETHATWEENTERINTOTHIS
NEEDFORAWELL PREPAREDWORKFORCE4ODAY WEKNOW
PARTNERSHIPWITH-ICRO4ECH)TISNOCOINCIDENCETHAT
THATEDUCATIONANDBUSINESSNEEDTOENGAGEINTHAT
WElNDOURSELVESINTHISUNIQUEPOSITIONTODAY/VER
CONVERSATIONTOGETHERASPARTNERSTHATISWHATTHIS
THEPASTDECADE STUDENTACHIEVEMENTIN-IDDLETON
PARTNERSHIPREPRESENTS
3CHOOL$ISTRICTHASDRAMATICALLYIMPROVED)N
WEWEREAWARDEDTHEh.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDˆ! -ARTIN%SCOBAR PRESIDENTOF-IDDLETONS,ATINO
$ECADEOF3UCCESSvAWARDFROMTHE5NITED3TATES #HAMBEROF#OMMERCESPOKENEXT%SCOBARVOICED
$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONFORMEETING!DEQUATE HISORGANIZATIONSSUPPORTFORTHEPARTNERSHIPAND
9EARLY0ROGRESSINALLOFOURSCHOOLSFORALLSUBGROUPS
REMINDEDLISTENERSABOUTTHEVALUEOFPARTNERSHIPSTHAT
$ISTRICTSACROSSTHE5NITED3TATESLIKE-IDDLETON PROVIDECONTINUEDECONOMICGROWTHTO-IDDLETON THE
HAVEDEMONSTRATEDTREMENDOUSIMPROVEMENTIN STATE ANDTHECOUNTRY(EEXPRESSEDHISHOPETHATALL
STUDENTLEARNING ANDWEHAVEMADEGREATSTRIDES STUDENTSWOULDBENElTEQUALLYFROMTHEPARTNERSHIP
NATIONALLY!LTHOUGHTHISNATIONALHONORCOMMEMO BEFORE-IDDLETON4EACHERS!SSOCIATION-4! 0RESI
RATESOURSUCCESS WEHAVEFARTHERTOGOINORDERTO DENT -ARY3HELTON TOOKTHEPODIUM3HELTONEX
THRIVEINANINCREASINGLYCOMPETITIVEGLOBALECONOMY PRESSEDTEACHERSAPPRECIATIONFORTHEFUNDSTHATWOULD
WEMUSTACHIEVEINTERNATIONALEXCELLENCE7EKNOW SUPPORTPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTBUTADDEDTHATALL
FROMTHE4RENDSIN)NTERNATIONAL-ATHEMATICS AREASOFTHECURRICULUMNEEDSIMILARSUPPORT
AND3CIENCE3TUDY4)-33 RESULTSTHATOURINCRE (ERBERT!RMSTRONG RETIREDPRINCIPALOF-IDDLE
MENTALIMPROVEMENTINMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE TON(IGH3CHOOLANDCURRENTPRESIDENTOF-IDDLE
ISINSUFlCIENTCOMPAREDTOTHETREMENDOUSGROWTH TON3ENIOR#ENTER EXPRESSEDGENERALSUPPORTOFTHE
THATCOUNTRIESLIKE3INGAPOREAND#HINACONTINUETO PARTNERSHIPBUTCONCERNABOUTALLOWINGA-ICRO4ECH
MAKE REPRESENTATIVEANEXOFlCIOSEATONTHESCHOOLBOARD
!RMSTRONGASKEDTHESCHOOLBOARDTOKEEPINMIND
&OLLOWING$R-ARTINEZSREMARKS "OARD0RESIDENT
THAT hSCHOOLSARENOTBUSINESSESANDSHOULDNTBERUN
#OULEYREMINDEDTHEAUDIENCETHATFEDERAL STATE AND
BYBUSINESSRULES4ENMILLIONDOLLARSAYEARSHOULDNT
LOCALFUNDSHAVEBEENADEQUATETOSUPPORTTHEDISTRICTS
GIVE-ICRO4ECHTHERIGHTTOMAKEDECISIONSTHATAFFECT
EDUCATIONPROGRAMINPARTBECAUSEUNDER.#,"
ALLTHEDIFFERENTASPECTSOFSCHOOLINGv
EDUCATORSLEARNEDHOWTOEFFECTIVELYALLOCATEFUNDSTO
DIRECTLYSUPPORTSTUDENTLEARNING4HISHASPUTTOREST
THEARGUMENTTHATMONEYDOESNTMAKEADIFFERENCEIN

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

-ICRO4ECH2ESPONDSTO)TS(OME !MPLE
TOWNS#ALL
h!LL )NCLUSIVE
-ICRO4ECH#OMPUTINGISANATIONALLEADERIN ,UXURY2ESORTv
MOLECULARELECTRONICS%STABLISHEDIN THECORPO

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
RATIONISBESTKNOWNFORITSDEVELOPMENTOF3AFE3ENSOR #ONTROLOF,EARNING
ˆAPERSONALSECURITYDEVICETHATDETECTSBIOLOGICAL

2ESOURCES
HAZARDS,OCATEDINTHEINDUSTRIALPARKONTHEOUTSKIRTS
OF-IDDLETON -ICRO4ECHEMPLOYSAPPROXIMATELY
 STAFFMEMBERS-ORETHANPERCENTOFTHE
CORPORATIONSEMPLOYEESHOLDADVANCEDMATHEMATICS ,IMITED
ANDSCIENCEDEGREES
&INDINGQUALIlEDCANDIDATESTOlLLPOSITIONSAT-I
CRO4ECHHASBECOMEINCREASINGLYDIFlCULT 2HODESSAID
DESCRIBINGTHE-IDDELTON -ICRO4ECH)NNOVATION0ART 0ARTOFOURLONG TERMCORPORATESTRATEGYTO
NERSHIPAS hALOCALSOLUTIONTOAGLOBALPROBLEMv/VER ATTRACTTOPSCIENTISTSANDRESEARCHERSISTOSTRENGTHEN
THEPASTDECADETHENUMBEROFJOBSREQUIRINGMATHE 0RE+nMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCEEDUCATION7E
MATICSANDSCIENCEDEGREESHASINCREASEDBYPERCENT MUSTPREPAREMORESTUDENTSTOENTEROURTOPRESEARCH
ANDISEXPECTEDTOCONTINUETORISEDUETOTHEADVANCES UNIVERSITIESWHERETHEYWILLGAINTHESKILLSTHEYNEED
INNANOTECHNOLOGY YETTHENUMBEROF53STUDENTS TOWORKININDUSTRIESTHATKEEPOURNATIONSECONOMY
MAJORINGINSCIENCE MATHEMATICS ORENGINEERINGHAS STRONG!NDTOBETTERPREPAREOURSTUDENTS WEMUST
BEENDECREASINGFORTHEPASTDECADE!TTHESAMETIME BETTERPREPAREOURTEACHERS7EINTENDTOWORK
INCOUNTRIESSUCHAS#HINAAND)NDIA UNDERGRADUATE ALONGSIDETHECOMMUNITYANDHAND IN HANDWITH
ENROLLMENTHASEXPLODEDANDTHESIGNIlCANTINVEST LOCALCOLLEGESTOSEETOITTHATOURTEACHEREDUCATION
MENTSTHATFOREIGNCOUNTRIESHAVEMADEINTHEIREDUCA PROGRAMSAREAMONGTHElNESTINTHENATION7E
TIONALANDRESEARCHINFRASTRUCTUREHAVEPAIDOFF&EWER HAVESEENTHEINCREDIBLEPROGRESSTHAT-IDDLETON
ANDFEWERFOREIGNSTUDENTSAREENROLLINGINADVANCED 3CHOOL$ISTRICTHASMADEOVERTHEPASTYEARS
DEGREEPROGRAMSINTHE5NITED3TATES!NDTHOSETHAT ANDWEBELIEVETHATWITHOURSUPPORT THEYWILLHELP
DOOFTENLEAVEASSOONASTHEYGRADUATEBECAUSEOUR$E PRODUCETHENATIONSTOPNANOTECHNOLOGISTS
PARTMENTOF(OMELAND3ECURITYHASMADEITSODIFlCULT
FORTHEMTOSECUREVISASTOWORKINTHE5NITED3TATES 4HEFOCUSONIMPROVINGMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE
!MERICANCORPORATIONSlNDTHEMSELVESLOOKINGFOR EDUCATIONINTHE5NITED3TATESHASINTENSIlEDSINCE
HOMELANDSOLUTIONSTOTHISGLOBALPROBLEM$EVELOP WHENTHE"USINESS (IGHER%DUCATION&ORUM
INGCORPORATEPARTNERSHIPSWITHEDUCATIONISASOLUTION PUBLISHEDITSSEMINALREPORT!#OMMITMENTTO!MERI
THATJUSTMIGHTWORK/BVIOUSLY *OSHUA2HODESAGREES CAS&UTURE2ESPONDINGTOTHE#RISISIN-ATHEMATICSAND
(ISREMARKSFROMTHEBOARDMEETINGFOLLOW 3CIENCE%DUCATION4HISREPORTIDENTIlEDIMPROVED
MATHEMATICSANDSCIENCEEDUCATIONASESSENTIALTO
MAINTAINOURNATIONSCOMPETITIVEEDGEINANINCREAS
INGLYGLOBALECONOMY3IMILARTOTHEEFFECTTHAT!
.ATIONAT2ISKHADIN THISREPORTHASSTIMU
LATEDCRITICALCONVERSATIONSABOUTTHEVIABILITYOFOUR
ECONOMYATTHENATIONALANDLOCALLEVELS


"USINESS (IGHER%DUCATION&ORUM !#OMMITMENTTO!MERICAS&UTURE2ESPONDINGTOTHE#RISISIN-ATHEMATICS3CIENCE%DUCATION
7ASHINGTON $#"USINESS (IGHER%DUCATION&ORUM


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

4HEFEDERALGOVERNMENTRESPONDEDTOTHECRISISIN TESTED/VERTHEPASTDECADE .!%0HASBEENADMIN


 WHENTHETH#ONGRESSAPPROVEDACORPORATE ISTEREDONLYINREADINGANDMATHEMATICSANDONLYTOA
TAXCODEPROVIDINGCORPORATIONSWITHAPERCENTDE SAMPLEOFSTUDENTSINGRADES  ANDATTHENATION
DUCTIONONANYLONG TERMDONATIONSTOPUBLICSCHOOLS ALLEVELANDGRADESANDATTHESTATELEVEL3CIENCE
4HISMEANSTHATCORPORATIONSLIKE-ICRO4ECHTHAT ANDWRITINGHAVEBEENTESTEDEVERYFOURYEARSATTHE
INVESTINEDUCATIONFORlVEORMORECONSECUTIVEYEARS NATIONALANDSTATELEVELS)NTHE*ANUARY PRESS
CANCLAIMAGREATERDEDUCTIONONTHEIRCORPORATETAXES RELEASEABOUT!.%! $R-ANUEL'ARCIA 3ECRETARY
)NAFOLLOW UPINTERVIEW *OSHUA2HODESDESCRIBEDTHE OF%DUCATIONSINCE SPOKETOTHISISSUESAYING h)F
NEWTAXPROVISIONASAhWIN WINv WEAREGOINGTOCOMPETEINTERNATIONALLY PARTICULARLY
INMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE WEHAVETOMEASURE
&EDERAL-ANDATESIN2ESPONSETO STUDENTLEARNINGNATIONALLYONAREGULARBASIS(AVING
)NTERNATIONAL#OMPETITION MORECOMPLETEANDFREQUENTSTATE LEVELDATAWILLHELP
$ESPITETHEIMPROVEMENTSINEDUCATIONASA USBETTERUNDERSTANDWHATWENEEDTODOTOIMPROVE
RESULTOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTOFAND STUDENTACHIEVEMENTINTHESECRITICALCONTENTAREASv
!MERICASRENEWEDCONlDENCEINOURPUBLICSCHOOLS 0ERHAPSTHEGREATESTCONTROVERSYREGARDINGTHE
ANDDISTRICTS THE5NITED3TATESCONTINUESTOSTRUGGLE !.%!LIESNOTINITSSUBSTANCEBUTINITSFUNDING)N
EDUCATIONALLYONANINTERNATIONALLEVEL4HEFEDERAL THEIRANNUALSTATESUMMITMEETING !LLIANCEOF3TATES
GOVERNMENTHASMADEDRASTICCHANGESINFEDERAL %XECUTIVE$IRECTOR !LEXIS3TARLING SUGGESTEDTHAT
EDUCATIONALPOLICIES SHIFTINGTHEFOCUSFROMINDIVIDUAL THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTWOULDNOTMEETSITSlNANCIAL
SCHOOLSANDDISTRICTSTOTHENATION4HISYEAR THE OBLIGATIONRELATEDTO!.%!EVENTHOUGH!.%!
5NITED3TATES$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONWILLBEGIN INCLUDESAFUNDINGMANDATE3TARLINGSTATED h7EHAVE
IMPLEMENTATIONOFTHE!CHIEVING.ATIONAL%XCELLENCE ALLBECOMEACCUSTOMEDTOTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTSUSE
!CT!.%! WHICHWASPASSEDBY#ONGRESSLASTYEAR OFUNFUNDEDMANDATES3ECRETARY'ARCIARECOMMENDED
4HEINTENTOF!.%!ISTOIMPROVETHE.ATIONS2EPORT THAT#ONGRESSFULLYFUNDTHENATIONALCURRICULUMAND
#ARDAND5NITED3TATESSCORESONTHE4)-33 ANIN THEANNUAL.!%07EHAVEHEARDTHISBEFOREFROM
TERNATIONALMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCEASSESSMENTGIVEN THE53$/%WITHTHE)NDIVIDUALWITH$ISABILITIES
TOTH ANDTH GRADESTUDENTSINOVERCOUNTRIES %DUCATION!CT)$%! AND.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
EVERYFOURYEARS4HE5NITED3TATESHASCONTINUEDTO .#," v53$/%REPRESENTATIVE -ARK5LRICH COM
MAKEONLYINCREMENTALGROWTHONTHE4)-333INCE MENTED h0OLICYMAKERSANDPRACTITIONERSWILLSOONSEE
THE4)--3 OURSCORESHAVECONTINUEDTOHOVER THATIMPLEMENTINGANATIONALCURRICULUMANDNATIONAL
JUSTSLIGHTLYOVERTHEINTERNATIONALAVERAGEFORBOTH ASSESSMENTSAREMORECOSTEFFECTIVETHANOURCURRENT
THANDTHGRADERSINMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE)N SYSTEMv
CONTRAST OTHERCOUNTRIESSUCHAS3INGAPOREAND#HINA $ESPITETHECONTROVERSYTHATWILLINEVITABLYENSUE
HAVEINCREASEDTHEIRSCORESBYOVERPOINTSSINCE REGARDINGANYNEWFEDERALMANDATELIKETHE!CHIEV
 LEAVINGTHE5NITED3TATESFARTHERBEHIND4HE ING.ATIONAL%XCELLENCE!CT ITISCERTAINTHATWEMUST
5NITED3TATES$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION53$/% MAKEFUNDAMENTALCHANGESTOCOMPETEWITHCOUN
PLANSTORESPONDTOTHISINTERNATIONALEDUCATIONALCRISIS TRIES SUCHAS#HINA THATCONTINUETOOUTPERFORMUS
INWITHTWONEWFEDERALMANDATES EDUCATIONALLY ECONOMICALLY ANDEVENPHYSICALLY AS
4HE53$/%WILLINCREASEACCOUNTABILITYATTHE EVIDENCEDINTHERECENT/LYMPICS$ONALD-C"URNS
FEDERALLEVELTHROUGHTHEIMPLEMENTATIONOFANNUAL #HAIROFTHE5NITED3TATES/LYMPICS#OMMITTEE AT
.ATIONAL!SSESSMENTOF%DUCATIONAL0ROGRESS.!%0 TRIBUTESTHEPOORPERFORMANCEOF53ATHLETESTOA
TESTINGINREADING WRITING MATHEMATICS ANDSCIENCE DECISIONINTOELIMINATEPHYSICALEDUCATIONPRO
FORSTUDENTSINRDnTHGRADESINEVERYDISTRICTIN GRAMSFROMPUBLICSCHOOLSINANEFFORTTOMEETTHEAC
EVERYSTATE4HISREPRESENTSASIGNIlCANTCHANGEIN COUNTABILITYPROVISIONSANDFUNDINGDEMANDSOF.#,"
TERMSOFTHEGRADES CONTENT ANDNUMBEROFSTUDENTS -C"URNSBELIEVESTHATPUBLICSCHOOLSMUSTRE ASSUME

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

RESPONSIBILITYFORPHYSICALEDUCATION!FTERTHECLOSING !MPLE
CEREMONYOFTHE/LYMPICS HEHADTHISTOSAY
&ORTHElRSTTIMEINHISTORY #HINATOOKMOREMEDALS h!LL )NCLUSIVE
,UXURY2ESORTv
THANTHE5NITED3TATES/NLYEIGHTYEARSAGO WETOOK

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
MEDALSANDTHEYTOOK)F#HINASPERFORMANCETHISYEAR #ONTROLOF,EARNING
ISANYINDICATIONOFWHATISTOCOMEIN WENEEDTO

2ESOURCES
TAKEAHARDLOOKATOURSELVESASANATION#HINAOBVIOUSLY
ISCONTINUINGONITSPATHTOBECOMINGASUPERPOWER)FWE
DONTTAKEACTIONNOW WELLBELEFTINTHEDUST
&ORDECADES !MERICAWASABLETOMAKEPROGRESS
,IMITED
BYATTRACTINGTHEBESTANDBRIGHTESTFROMOTHERCOUN
TRIESTOITSUNIVERSITIESANDINDUSTRIES.OWTHATOTHER
NATIONSEDUCATIONSYSTEMSAREOUTPERFORMINGTHE53
SYSTEMANDTHEIRECONOMIESAREGROWING THERESNO BECAUSETHEYFEELTHECURRICULUMDOESNOTADDRESSTHEIR
REASONFORTHESETALENTEDINDIVIDUALSTOFORSAKETHEIR INTERESTSANDTALENTS
HOMELAND!SMORENATIONSKEEPTHEIRBESTANDBRIGHT 0OORSHOWINGSININTERNATIONALCOMPARISONSOF
ESTFROM!MERICASSHORES )NNOVATION0ARTNERSHIPSLIKE MATHEMATICSANDSCIENCEPERFORMANCELEADTONEW
THEONETHAT-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTAND-ICRO ACCOUNTABILITYMEASURESTHATAREDESIGNEDTOIMPROVE
4ECH#OMPUTINGESTABLISHEDOFFERACREATIVELOCALSOLU PERFORMANCE4EACHERSWANTTODOWHATSNEEDEDTO
TIONTOTHISGROWINGNATIONALPROBLEM HELPSTUDENTSSUCCEED BUTTHERESIMPLYARENTENOUGH
TEACHERSWITHDEGREESINMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCETO
TEACHTHEADVANCEDCOURSES/THERS THOUGHEXPERI
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO ENCEDTEACHERS LACKTHESPECIlCCONTENTKNOWLEDGE
)MPLICATIONS ANDSKILLSTOTEACHAROBUSTMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE
CURRICULUMTHATFOCUSESONDEVELOPINGSTUDENTSUN
)NAWORLDLIKETHEONEDESCRIBEDINTHISSCENARIO
DERSTANDINGRATHERTHANROTEMEMORIZATIONOFFACTS
THEREAREENOUGHRESOURCESTOPROVIDESTUDENTSWITHAN
ANDPROCEDURES#URRENTPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT
hADEQUATEvEDUCATIONBUTTHATEDUCATIONISFALLINGSHORT
PROGRAMSAREINSUFlCIENTINCONTENTANDDESIGNTOHELP
OFTHENEEDSOFBUSINESS4HISLEADSBUSINESSES ESPE
TEACHERSACQUIRETHECONTENTKNOWLEDGEANDPEDA
CIALLYTHOSEWITHNEEDSFOREMPLOYEESWITHMATHEMAT
GOGICALSKILLSTHEYNEEDTOPREPARETHEIRSTUDENTSTO
ICSANDSCIENCEKNOW HOW TOFORMPARTNERSHIPSWITH
COMPETEWITHSTUDENTSINOTHERCOUNTRIES
SCHOOLS4HESEPARTNERSHIPSAREADOUBLE EDGEDSWORD
/NONEHAND THEYBRINGINCREASEDRESOURCESTOSCHOOLS
ANDHELPSCHOOLSBETTERPREPARESTUDENTSTOMOVEINTO
THEHIGHTECHWORKFORCE/NTHEOTHERHAND SCHOOLS
MAYEXPERIENCEALOSSOFCONTROLASBUSINESSREPRESENTA
TIVESASSUMEPOSITIONSONSCHOOLBOARDSANDINmUENCE
DECISIONSABOUTCURRICULUMANDINSTRUCTION(AVING
BUSINESSREPRESENTATIVESONTHESCHOOLBOARDCAUSES
CHANGESINRELATIONSHIPSAMONGBOARDMEMBERSAND
BETWEENTHEBOARDANDTHECOMMUNITY4HEBUSINESS
PRESENCEFOCUSESATTENTIONONINTERNATIONALCOMPETI
TIONANDFORCESSCHOOLSTOEMPHASIZEMATHEMATICSAND
SCIENCE4HISMAYTENDTONARROWTHEFOCUSOFTHECUR
RICULUMANDCAUSESTUDENTSWHODONOTEXCELINMATH
EMATICSANDSCIENCETOLOSEINTERESTINDISTRICTSCHOOLS


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NDICATORS /PTIONS
%VENTSANDTRENDSTHATARELIKELYTOSIGNALTHEDEVELOP 3UCCESSFOR-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTINTHIS
MENTOFTHISSCENARIOAREASFOLLOWS SCENARIOWILLDEPENDONTHEABILITYOFDISTRICTLEADERSAT
ALLLEVELSTOhTHINKOUTSIDETHEBOXv&OREXAMPLE THE
s -ANYSCHOOLSMAKE!90 AND.#,"ISPERCEIVED DISTRICTCOULDLEARNABOUTOTHERCOUNTRIESAPPROACHES
ASASUCCESS TOEDUCATION PARTICULARLYMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE
s 4HEECONOMYIMPROVESGENERALLY PERHAPSDUE EDUCATION ANDINITIATEATEACHERANDSTUDENTEXCHANGE
TOCHANGESIN3OCIAL3ECURITY -EDICARE AND PROGRAMWITHTHESECOUNTRIES4HEEXCHANGEPROGRAM
-EDICAID ANDORTECHNOLOGICALADVANCEMENTS COULDBEONEPARTOFAPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENT
INTHEFUELCELLINDUSTRYLEADINGTOAREDUCTIONIN PROGRAMTHATPROVIDESAVARIETYOFWAYSFORTEACHERSTO
!MERICANDEPENDENCEONOILFORENERGY ACQUIRETHEKNOWLEDGEANDSKILLSTHEYNEEDTOTEACHIN
WAYSTHATINCREASESTUDENTSUNDERSTANDINGOFTHECRITI
s 534)--3SCORESCONTINUETOLAG BYASMALL CALCONCEPTSINMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE
PERCENTAGE BEHINDOTHERCOUNTRIES 4OSTRENGTHENITSCAPACITYTORESPONDTOCHANGING
CONDITIONSANDTOCONNECTWITHCOMMUNITYMEMBERS
s #ONTINUEDCONCERNSABOUTNATIONALSECURITYLEND
ANDBUSINESSES THESCHOOLBOARDCOULDENGAGEINA
SUPPORTTOTHENOTIONOFANATIONALCURRICULUM
SERIESOFRETREATS!TTHESERETREATS THEBOARDWOULD
s #ONCERNSABOUTSTUDENTSMATHEMATICALAND DEVELOPSTRATEGIESTHATWILLPOSITIONTHEIRSCHOOL
TECHNICALSKILLSBEGINTODOMINATETHEPOLITICAL DISTRICTASANATTRACTIVEPOTENTIALBUSINESSPARTNER4HE
RHETORICINMUCHTHESAMEWAYASCONCERNSABOUT BOARDALSOSHOULDCLARIFYITSMISSION ROLE ANDOPER
LITERACYDOTODAY ATINGPRINCIPLESESTABLISHPROCEDURESFORINDUCTING
NEWMEMBERSANDENSURETHATTHECOLLECTIVEAGENDA
s 3UPPORTFORTESTINGATTHENATIONALLEVELINCREASES FOCUSESONSERVINGALLSTUDENTSWELL-OSTIMPORTANTLY

s "USINESSESPRESSFORMOREINVOLVEMENTIN THEBOARDSHOULDREGULARLYDEMONSTRATETHATITIS
EDUCATION PARTICULARLYMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCE EQUALLYCOMMITTEDTOSUPPORTINGPARENTSANDSTUDENTS
ANDFORMPARTNERSHIPSWITHSCHOOLS WITHINTERESTSANDTALENTSINOTHERACADEMICAREAS
"ECAUSETESTINGWILLBEPERVASIVEINTHISSCENARIO
s "USINESSESRECEIVEINCENTIVESFROMFEDERALORSTATE DISTRICTLEADERSSHOULDEDUCATESTAFFANDCOMMUNITY
GOVERNMENTFORPARTNERINGWITHSCHOOLS ABOUTTHEPURPOSEOFSTANDARDIZEDSUMMATIVEASSESS
MENTS4HEYALSOSHOULDENSURETHATTEACHERSUSE
s 53COLLEGESTUDENTENROLLMENTINMATHEMATICS
FORMATIVEASSESSMENTSTOGAUGEANDPROMOTESTUDENT
SCIENCEANDRELATEDMAJORSDOESNOTINCREASESUF
PROGRESSANDSUMMATIVEASSESSMENTSTOMEASURETHE
lCIENTLYTOMEETTHEDEMANDSOFBUSINESS
SUCCESSOFTHECURRICULUMRATHERTHANTONARROWITS
s #HINABEGINSTOREAPTHEBENElTSOFITSSTUDENTS SCOPE
SUCCESSINMATHEMATICSANDSCIENCEASEVIDENCED 4OPROVIDENEEDEDPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTIN
BY#HINASADVANCESINTECHNOLOGYANDOTHER ALLAREAS ANDSPECIlCALLYINASSESSMENT MATHEMATICS
INNOVATIONS ANDSCIENCE THEDISTRICTCOULDDESIGNATESOMEONEASA
LIAISONTOHIGHEREDUCATIONWHOWOULDENCOURAGELOCAL
COLLEGESTODEVELOPANDOFFERFAST TRACK ONLINE AND
WEEKENDCOURSESFORTEACHERS$ISTRICTSMIGHTSUPPORT
THISPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTEFFORTBYOFFERINGRECERTI
lCATIONCREDITS BONUSES ANDOTHERINCENTIVES

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

3TATE%DUCATION!GENCY !MPLE

3CENARIO
$EEP#AUSES

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
#ONTROLOF,EARNING
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATTHETRADITIONALINSTI
TUTIONALCONlGURATIONSTHATHAVEDElNED!MERICAN

2ESOURCES
PUBLICSCHOOLSOVERTHEPASTCENTURYREMAINTHE
h2OADSIDE#HAIN
PRIMARYFORMOFSCHOOLINGANDRESOURCESFORSCHOOLSARE -OTELv
INADEQUATEASARESULTOFTHEFOLLOWING
,IMITED
s 3IGNIlCANTLYDIMINISHEDRESOURCESFORSCHOOLING
DUETOINCREASINGPRESSUREONTHENATIONAL
ECONOMYTOPAYFORHEALTHCAREANDPENSIONSFOR
h2OADSIDE#HAIN-OTELv
THEAGINGPOPULATIONANDTOMEETTHECOUNTRYS
4IME
INSATIABLENEEDFORENERGY
0LACE-IDDLETON 53!
s 4HEFAILUREOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT
3CENE%$ -/.4(,9COVERSEDUCATION RELATED
OFTODRAMATICALLYIMPROVESTUDENT
TOPICSOFINTERESTTOTHEWESTERNSTATES)NADDITIONTO
ACHIEVEMENTFORSTUDENTSFROM(ISPANICAND
LEGISLATIVEUPDATESANDNEWSARTICLESFROMAROUNDTHE
OTHER%NGLISH ,ANGUAGE,EARNERGROUPSANDSOCIO
NATION ITRUNSOP EDSANDFEATURESECTIONS&ORTHE
ECONOMICALLYDISADVANTAGEDSUBGROUPS
PASTCOUPLEOFMONTHS AN%$ -/.4(,9REPORTER
s !STRONGFEDERALPRESENCEIN!MERICANSCHOOLS HASATTENDED-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSBOARD
INCLUDINGANATIONALCURRICULUM NATIONAL MEETINGS2ECENTLY SHEHASWATCHEDBOARDMEMBERS
ASSESSMENT ANDSANCTIONSFORALLSCHOOLSFAILING STRUGGLEWITHSOMETOUGHDECISIONS4ONIGHT THEBOARD
TOMAKEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESSREQUIRINGTHEM APPROVESAPLANTOELIMINATEALLNON COREACADEMIC
TOALLOCATEALLRESOURCESTOTHECOREACADEMIC CLASSES PROGRAMS ANDEXTRACURRICULARACTIVITIES
SUBJECTS FROMTHEBUDGETINRESPONSETONEWMANDATESINTHE
REAUTHORIZATIONOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT
,IKETRAVELERSSTAYINGINTODAYSROADSIDECHAIN .#," 3HEEXPECTSTHEANNOUNCEMENTTOSETOFF
MOTEL PARENTSANDSTUDENTSINTHISWORLDWILLKNOW SOMElREWORKSANDTHINKSTHATTOMORROWHEREDITOR
WHATTOEXPECT3TUDENTSRECEIVEARELIABLE STANDARD WILLHAVEONESIZZLINGSTORY
IZEDEDUCATION WITHOUTANYFRILLS
!TTHEIR&EBRUARY MEETING THE-IDDLETON
"OARDOF%DUCATIONAPPROVEDCUTSTOTHEn
BUDGETINAVOTEOFTO ELIMINATINGALLNON CORE
ACADEMICCLASSES PROGRAMS ANDEXTRACURRICULARACTIVI
TIESIN-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSSCHOOLS4HE
DISTRICTEXPECTSANDISBRACEDFORCOMMUNITYOUTRAGE
OVERTHISDRAMATICDECISION/VERPARENTSWEREIN
ATTENDANCEFORTHEBOARDVOTE


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

&OLLOWINGTHE0LEDGEOF!LLEGIANCE "OARD0RESI 4HE%#0!WASBASEDONRESEARCHEVIDENCETHAT


DENT-ICHELLE#OULEYMADETHEOPENINGCOMMENTS LOW PERFORMINGSCHOOLSMUSTFOCUSTHEIREFFORTSIF
DESCRIBINGTHESTATEOFTHEDISTRICT THEYARETOSUCCEED!ND3ENATOR+WAME7ASHING
TON CHAMPIONOFTHEBILL EXPRESSEDITSUNDERLYING
7EHAVEREACHEDAPOINTWHENWEASABOARDARE PRINCIPLESPRETTYWELLWHENHESAID h,ETSGETALLKIDS
FACEDWITHSOMEOFTHETOUGHESTDECISIONSWEWILL READINGATGRADELEVELANDABLETOADDANDSUBTRACT
MAKEINOURTERMS4HESTAFF STUDENTS ANDPARENTS BEFOREWEGOANYFURTHERv4HEPROVISIONSOF%#0!
OF-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTHAVEWORKEDEXTREMELY ARETOBEIMPLEMENTEDDURINGTHEnSCHOOL
HARDTOIMPROVESTUDENTLEARNINGFORALLSTUDENTS YEAR"ECAUSEWEDIDNOTMEETTHEDISTRICT!90GOALS
3INCE WHEN)WASlRSTELECTEDTOTHEBOARD WE UNDER.#," THENEWLAWREQUIRESUSTOUSEALLOF
HAVEMADEINCREDIBLEPROGRESS&OREXAMPLE OVERTHE OURFEDERALANDSTATEFUNDINGFORACADEMICS4HAT
PASTFEWYEARS OURPERFORMANCEDATAHASHELDSTEADY ISWHYWEARECUTTINGALLNON COREACADEMICCLASSES
ORSLIGHTLYIMPROVED3EEKINGGREATERIMPROVEMENTS PROGRAMS ANDEXTRACURRICULARACTIVITIES4HISISTHE
INSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTMEASUREMENTS WEPROVIDED HARDESTDECISION)HAVEMADEINMYCAREER AND)
PROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTTOTEACHERSON#LASSROOM BELIEVETHAT)SPEAKONBEHALFOFTHEBOARD
)NSTRUCTIONTHAT7ORKSFOR%NGLISH ,ANGUAGE,EARN
ERS7EALSOBEGANREMEDIALPROGRAMSANDANAFTER *UAN:AMORA THEBOARDSMOSTVETERANMEMBER
SCHOOLTUTORINGPROGRAM(OWEVER ASYOUKNOW WE THANKED#OULEYFORHERCOURAGEINADDRESSINGTHE
HAVENOTSUCCEEDEDINMAKINGTHEKINDSOFIMPROVE AUDIENCEINSUCHAFORTHRIGHTMANNER(ISFURTHERCOM
MENTSNEEDEDFORSOMEOFTHEMORERECENTLYARRIVED MENTSFOLLOW
STUDENTSINOURDISTRICTSPECIlCALLY OURSTUDENTSWHO
)SHAREYOURCONCERNFORTHEGRAVITYOFTHISDECISION
ARE(ISPANIC OTHER%NGLISH ,ANGUAGE,EARNERS AND
7E ASABOARD HAVEDEDICATEDMANYHOURSTOFULLY
THOSEFROMLOWERSOCIO ECONOMICSITUATIONS!L
UNDERSTANDINGALLOFTHEINFORMATIONNEEDEDTOMAKE
THOUGHTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTMADEMAJORREVISIONS
THISDECISION INCLUDINGTALKINGTOLEGISLATORSANDTO
TOTHEACCOUNTABILITYPROVISIONSIN.#,"FORSPECIAL
YOU7EAREWELLAWARETHATTHISDECISIONISNOTA
NEEDSSTUDENTSIN THEYDIDNOTGRANTTHESAME
FAVORABLEONEFORTHECOMMUNITYOF-IDDLETON AND)
LATITUDEFOROTHERSUBGROUPS AND-IDDLETONHAS
SUSPECTWEWILLHEARTHATSENTIMENTFROMTHEAUDI
CONTINUEDTOSTRUGGLETOMEETOUR!DEQUATE9EARLY
ENCETONIGHT
0ROGRESS!90 TARGETS
!FTERSEVERALOTHERBOARDMEMBERSCOMMENTED
!SYOUALSOAREAWARE FEDERALFUNDINGFOR.#,"
ONTHEISSUE THEBOARDHEARDTWOHOURSOFPUBLIC
WASFURTHERCUTINWHENEDUCATION WHICHONCE
COMMENTS#OMMUNITYMEMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERNS
DOMINATEDTHECOUNTRYSPOLICYAGENDA WASTHOR
THATRANGEDFROMISSUESRELATEDTOIMMIGRANTSTUDENTS
OUGHLYECLIPSEDBYHEALTHCAREANDNATIONALSECURITY
TOCHILDHOODOBESITY!NUNIDENTIlEDPARENTASKED
ISSUES!NDNOWWEFACEASERIOUSNEWCHALLENGE
WHATITWOULDMEANTOIGNORETHEFEDERALREQUIREMENT
ˆTHENEW3ECRETARYOF%DUCATION $R-ANUEL
0RESIDENT#OULEYRESPONDEDTHATBECAUSEOFINCREAS
'ARCIA SENTUSALETTERELABORATINGONTHEREQUIRE
INGNUMBERSOFSUBGROUPSTUDENTSWHONEEDADDITIONAL
MENTSOFTHEREAUTHORIZATIONOF.#," TITLEDTHE
ASSISTANCEANDTHESUPPLEMENTALFEDERALFUNDSAVAILABLE
%VERY#HILD0ROlCIENT!CT%#0! ENACTEDINLATE
TOSUPPORTTHEM ITWOULDNOTSERVETHEDISTRICTWELLTO
&ORTHOSEOFYOUINTHEAUDIENCEWHOARENT
TRYTOCREATEABUDGETBASEDSOLELYONLOCALRESOURCES
FAMILIARWITHTHISHISTORY LETMElLLYOUIN
4HECOMMUNITYSTAXPAYERSWHODONOTHAVECHILDREN
INTHESCHOOLSWOULDNOTBELIKELYTOSUPPORTTHENECES
SARYTAXINCREASES

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

!BOUTONETHIRDOFTHESPEAKERSWERE-IDDLETON !MPLE
TEACHERSWHOPROVIDEDTHEMOSTARDENTARGUMENT
AGAINSTTHEPROPOSEDBUDGETCUTS-IDDLETON4EACH
ERS!SSOCIATION-4! MEMBERSmANKED!SSOCIATION

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
0RESIDENT -ARY3HELTON ASSHEADDRESSEDTHEBOARD #ONTROLOF,EARNING
DENOUNCINGTHEMFORTHEIRhPOORlSCALPLANNINGvAND

2ESOURCES
THEIMPACTONSTAFlNG!NEXCERPTFROMHERREMARKSIS
BELOW h2OADSIDE#HAIN
-OTELv
4HEPROPOSEDELIMINATIONOFCLASSESFORART PHYSICAL
EDUCATION ANDMUSICWILLRESULTINAWORKFORCERE ,IMITED

DUCTIONOFTENPERCENTOFOURCERTIlCATEDSTAFF-OST
OFOURTEACHERS WHOAREALSOMEMBERSOFTHE-IDDLE
TONCOMMUNITY WILLBEUNEMPLOYEDBY*UNEOFTHIS -YOLDESTDAUGHTER !NNALIESE GRADUATEDWITH
YEAR/NBEHALFOF-4! )SAYTHATTHISISPREPOSTER HONORSFROM-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOLIN3HE
OUS PARTICULARLYAS)THINKABOUTTHEMANYTIMESYOU WASTHE!SSOCIATED3TUDENT"ODYPRESIDENTANDWAS
ASABOARDHAVEVOTEDUNANIMOUSLYTOIMPLEMENT THEVARSITYSWIMTEAMCAPTAIN"ECAUSEOFHEREDUCA
REMEDIALPROGRAMSFOROURSUBGROUPS EVENWHENTHE TIONIN-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT SHENOWATTENDS
BUDGETWASINCRISIS 2HODE)SLAND)NSTITUTEOF4ECHNOLOGY)NOWHAVE
TWINBOYSWHOWILLBEENTERINGlRSTGRADENEXTYEAR
-OSTOFTHECOMMUNITYMEMBERSCOMMENTEDON )ASKYOU HOWCANYOUEXPECTPARENTSTOCHOOSETO
THELONGLISTOFPROGRAMCUTSTHATINCLUDEDART MUSIC STAYINADISTRICTTHATPROVIDESAWORSEEDUCATIONOVER
ANDPHYSICALEDUCATIONCLASSES ALLAFTER SCHOOLPRO TIME
GRAMS ANDALLSPORTSPROGRAMS-S"RITTANY#LARK
SON 7ONG -IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOL04!PRESIDENT "UT*ASON!NDERSON PRESIDENTOFTHE-IDDLETON
EXPRESSEDOUTRAGEABOUTTHEDISTRICT WIDEREMEDIAL "ANK PRESENTEDADIFFERENTVIEWPOINTFROMTHATOF
%NGLISHPROGRAMFORNEWCOMERIMMIGRANTSTUDENTS EARLIERSPEAKERS7HENHEMADEHISCOMMENTS HEWAS
WHICHWASNOTREPRESENTEDONTHECUTLIST CALLINGTHE INTHEMINORITY
INCREASEOFPROGRAMSFORSOCIO ECONOMICALLY DISADVAN /URCOMMUNITYWILLONLYBEABLETOMOVEINTOTHE
TAGED NON 7HITESTUDENTShREVERSERACISMv#LARKSON FUTURESUCCESSFULLYIFALLOFOURHIGHSCHOOLGRADUATES
7ONGSCOMMENTSAPPEARHERE CANREADANDDOMATHEMATICSWELL7ECANNOTAFFORD
!SITIS MYDAUGHTER-ORGANCANNOTEVENGETINTO TOHAVEHIGHSCHOOLDROPOUTSANDEVENGRADUATESIN
AN!0CHEMISTRYCLASSTHISYEARBECAUSESHEDIDNOT -IDDLETONWHOCANNOTACQUIREANDKEEPADECENT
MAKETHELOTTERY3HEWASNUMBERANDTHECUTOFF PAYINGJOB)SUPPORTTHESEREQUIREMENTS ATLEAST
WASSTUDENTS.OWITISLESSLIKELYTHATOURBEST UNTILWECANDELIVERTHEBASICSFORALLKIDS
STUDENTSWILLGETTHEQUALITYEDUCATIONTHEYNEEDTO /THERCOMMUNITYMEMBERSEXPRESSEDCONCERN
GETINTOCOLLEGE WHILEWESPENDOURFEWPRECIOUS ABOUTTHEELIMINATIONOFTHEDISTRICTSPORTSPROGRAMS
DOLLARSONSTUDENTSWHOARENOT!MERICAN -IDDLETON*UNIOR(IGH3CHOOLPARENT -R*OHN3MITH
CITIZENSANDDONTEVENPAYPROPERTYTAXES ARGUEDFORKEEPINGATLEASTTHESPORTSPROGRAMSANDSAID
-S#AREY7ILLIAMS MOTHEROFA-IDDLETON%L h-YSON0ETERISJUSTLIKEEVERYOTHERJUNIORHIGHKID
EMENTARY3CHOOLSTUDENT EXPRESSEDAGREATERCONCERN )CANGETHIMUPANDTOSCHOOLEVERYDAYBECAUSEOF
FORTHEINEQUITYBETWEENTHEEDUCATIONHEROLDEST SPORTS7ITHOUTFOOTBALL )DONTKNOWHOWTHETEACH
DAUGHTERRECEIVEDANDWHATSHEBELIEVESHERKINDER ERSAREGOINGTOKEEPSTUDENTSLIKEMYSONFOCUSEDv
GARTENERWILLGETUNDER%#0!3HETOLDTHESTORYTHAT 4HE-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOL2AIDERSHEADFOOTBALL
FOLLOWS COACHWASNTHESITANTTOLABELTHEDECISIONAMISTAKEIN
HISREMARKS


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)HAVEBEENAFOOTBALLCOACHINTHISDISTRICTFOROVERATTENDINGTOTHENEEDSOFCURRENTSTUDENTS-IDDLETON
THIRTYYEARS3PORTSARECRITICALFORMANYSTUDENTS)3CHOOL$ISTRICTSASSISTANTSUPERINTENDENTOFCURRICULUM
CANTELLYOUTHATIFHALFOFOURVARSITYTEAMWASNOT ANDINSTRUCTION $R6ICTOR0ADIA SAID h7EAREUSEDTO
INVOLVEDINFOOTBALLORSOMEOTHERSPORT THEYWOULD BUILDINGTHEAIRPLANEWHILEWEAREmYINGIT(OWEVER
PROBABLYDROPOUTOFSCHOOLORBEINVOLVEDINDRUGS)EVERYTIMEWECHANGEDIRECTIONS WELOSEGROUND/UR
DONTMEANTHATOURTEAMISFULLOFDERELICTS BUTYOUCHALLENGEISTOCONTINUETOMAKEPROGRESS WHILEATTHE
ALLREMEMBERHIGHSCHOOL+IDSNEEDDISCIPLINEANDA SAMETIMEIMPLEMENTINGHUGECHANGES)APPLAUD3U
SENSEOFBELONGINGTHATTHEYWONTGETFROMSCHOOLIF PERINTENDENT-ARTINEZANDTHEBOARDFORBEINGPROAC
THEREARENOSPORTS)THINKTHISISABIGMISTAKE TIVEANDFORRESPONDINGIMMEDIATELYTOTHESECRETARYS
MEMOv
!$ISTRICT#AUGHTINTHE-IDDLE 4HEOTHERMAJORPROVISIONIN%#0!ISANANNUAL
ASSESSMENTFORSTUDENTSINGRADESn5NDER.#,"
(OWDIDTHEDISTRICTGETTOTHISPOINT4ORECAP
EACHSTATEHADITSOWNACCOUNTABILITYPROGRAM INCLUD
RECENTEVENTS ON*ANUARY  THE5NITED3TATES
INGSTANDARDIZEDSTATEASSESSMENTS APPROVEDBYTHE
$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION3ECRETARY $R-ANUEL
5NITED3TATES$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION53$/% 
'ARCIA SENTAMEMORANDUMTOALLSTATEANDDISTRICT
4HE53$/%PLANSTOEXPANDTHECURRENTNATIONALAS
OFlCIALSANNOUNCINGTHEREAUTHORIZATIONOF.#,"
SESSMENTPROGRAM .ATIONAL!SSESSMENTOF%DUCATIONAL
ANDTHEMAJORACCOUNTABILITYPROVISIONSOFTHEACT
0ROGRESS.!%0 FROMTESTINGTH TH ANDTH
3ECRETARY'ARCIAOPENEDTHEMEMOBYSAYING h4HE
GRADESTUDENTSINREADINGANDMATHEMATICSTOTESTING
COURSEOURCOUNTRYHASUNDERTAKENTOIMPROVESTUDENT
RDnTHGRADESTUDENTSINREADING WRITING MATHEMAT
ACHIEVEMENTFOREVERYCHILDASWEPREPAREFUTURE
ICS ANDSCIENCEONANANNUALBASIS4HISSTREAMLINED
GENERATIONSOF!MERICANSISANOBLEANDWORTHYONE
APPROACHTOASSESSMENTWILLSAVEMILLIONSOFDOLLARS
!LTHOUGHWEHAVEIMPROVEDTHEQUALITYOFEDUCATION
OVERTHECOSTOFEACHSTATECREATINGANDIMPLEMENTING
FORMANYOFOURSTUDENTS WEHAVEYETTOACHIEVETHE
ITSOWNUNIQUETEST
GOALOFLEAVINGNOCHILDBEHINDv
4HISNEWPROVISIONWILLHAVESERIOUSIMPLICATIONS
4HEACCOUNTABILITYPROVISIONSOF%#0!ARESTRIN
FORSTATESTHATHAVEADOPTEDASTATEASSESSMENTPROGRAM
GENTANDSTANDARDIZEDONANATIONALLEVEL3ECRETARY
THATONLYTESTSSTUDENTSATPARTICULARGRADELEVELS
'ARCIASMEMOOUTLINEDTHEMAJORPROVISIONS WHICH
$ISTRICTSTHROUGHOUTTHE5NITED3TATESWILLINCREAS
INCLUDEADHERENCETOTHELONG DEBATEDNATIONALCUR
INGLYlNDTHEMSELVESCAUGHTBETWEENTHELOCALNEEDS
RICULUMTHATHASJUSTBEENCOMPLETED AMANDATORY
OFTHEIRSTUDENTSANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERSANDTHENEW
FEDERALASSESSMENTPROGRAMFORSTUDENTSINGRADESn
FEDERALMANDATESINTHE%#0! THEREAUTHORIZA
ANDNEWSANCTIONSFORSCHOOLSANDDISTRICTSTHATCONTIN
TIONOFTHE.#,"!
UETOFAILTOMEET!904HEGOALOFTHERE AUTHORIZATION
4HEMOSTCHALLENGINGASPECTOF%#0!WILLBE
OF.#," ACCORDINGTO3ECRETARY'ARCIA ISTOENSURE
THEhDRACONIANvSANCTIONSFORDISTRICTSLIKE-IDDLETON
THATBYhEVERYCHILDISPROlCIENTv
THATHAVEFAILEDTOMEETTHEIRDISTRICT!90GOALS&OR
%#0!INCLUDESANATIONALCURRICULUMFORCORE
EXAMPLE INADDITIONTOFOCUSINGALLFEDERALANDSTATE
SUBJECTSREADING WRITING MATHEMATICS SCIENCE AND
FUNDINGONCOREACADEMICCLASSES DISTRICTSAREREQUIRED
SOCIALSTUDIES !FTERYEARSINCOMMITTEE #ONGRESS
TOACCELERATELEARNINGFORSUBGROUPSOFSTUDENTSWHO
WASlNALLYABLETOAGREEONTHEBASICCURRICULUMWHICH
DONOTMEET!904HISMEANSTHATASDISTRICTSREDUCE
STATESANDDISTRICTSAREEXPECTEDTOADOPTIN-AYAND
PROGRAMSLIKEART MUSIC ANDPHYSICALEDUCATION THEY
FULLYIMPLEMENTBY*UNE4HISWILLLIKELYBE
WILLBEREQUIREDTOINCREASESPENDINGONPROGRAMSTHAT
CHALLENGINGFORDISTRICTSTHATHAVELESSTHANSIXMONTHS
IMPROVELEARNINGFOROURNATIONSUNDERSERVEDPOPULA
TODISMANTLETHEIRCURRENTCURRICULUMANDASSEMBLEA
TION
NEWCURRICULARINFRASTRUCTURE WHILEATTHESAMETIME

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

!NALYSISOF3CENARIO !MPLE

)MPLICATIONS
)NTHEWORLDDESCRIBEDINTHISSCENARIOTHEREARE

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
LIMITEDRESOURCESFORTHESCHOOLDISTRICTWHILEENROLL #ONTROLOF,EARNING
MENTOFNON %NGLISH SPEAKINGSTUDENTSANDOTHERS

2ESOURCES
NEEDINGEXTRAHELPISINCREASING"UTEVENMOREDIF
lCULTFORTHEDISTRICTANDITS"OARDARETHENEWCON h2OADSIDE#HAIN
-OTELv
STRAINTSONTHEIRABILITYTORESPOND CREATEDBYMAN
DATEDNATIONALCURRICULUMANDASSESSMENTS4HEREWILL ,IMITED
BEAHUGETURNOVERINTHETEACHINGSTAFFlRSTBECAUSE
OFTHEELIMINATIONOFALLNON ACADEMICCOURSESAND
SECONDBECAUSEOFTHEINHOSPITABLETEACHINGENVIRON
MENTWITHKIDSCONSTRAINEDTOONLYACADEMICCLASSES
THROUGHOUTTHESCHOOLDAYANDWITHANINCREASEDEM
PHASISONPREPARINGFORANDTAKINGASSESSMENTS3OME
TEACHERSWILLFEELTRAPPEDˆTHEONLYESCAPEWOULDBE
TOMOVEAWAYˆANDTHEIRRESENTMENTWILLADDTOLOW
MORALE4OADDTOTHEIMMEDIATEBURDEN TEACHERSWILL
NEEDTOGEARUPTOADOPTTHENEWNATIONALCURRICULUM
WHICHMAYREQUIRETHEMTOMASTERNEWKNOWLEDGEAND
SKILLS
4HECOMMUNITYANDESPECIALLYPARENTSALSOFEEL
TRAPPED#OLLEGESCONTINUETOSEEKSTUDENTSWITHA
BROADRANGEOFEXPERIENCESOUTSIDETHEACADEMICCUR
RICULUM"USINESSESSEEKEMPLOYEESWITHWORKANDLIFE
VALUESTHATGOBEYONDSIMPLYFOCUSINGONPASSINGTESTS
INACADEMICCONTENT4HEBRIGHTSPOTSWILLBEIFlNALLY
NOCHILDISLEFTBEHINDUNABLETOREADANDBEFULLY
EMPLOYEDABOVESUBSISTENCELEVELFORLACKOFTHEBASIC
SKILLS4HISCOULDBESEENASANONEROUSBUTNECESSARY
RITEOFPASSAGEINTOANEWFUTUREWHENALLOF!MERICAS
KIDSAREPREPAREDTOFULLYPARTICIPATEINTHESOCIETY


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NDICATORS /PTIONS
%VENTSANDTRENDSTHATCOULDSIGNALTHEDEVELOPMENT )NORDERTOSURVIVEINTHISSCENARIO THELOCAL
OFTHISSCENARIOINCLUDETHESE SCHOOLDISTRICTWILLNEEDTOBEHIGHLYCREATIVEINHOWIT
MANAGESITSTEACHERWORKFORCEANDTHEIMPLEMENTATION
s #ONTINUEDFAILUREOFSCHOOLSANDDISTRICTSTOMOVE OFTHENATIONALCURRICULUM ANDHOWITUNDERSTANDS
NUMBERSOFTHEIRCHILDRENTOPROlCIENCYLEVELS ANDINTERPRETSSUCCESSFORITSCONSTITUENCIES)FITSIMPLY
ESPECIALLYSPECIALGROUPS KNUCKLESUNDERTOTHENEWMANDATESANDCARRIESTHEM
s !NINCREASEINIMMIGRANTANDOTHERAT RISK OUTWITHSTOICISM THEWORSTOFTHEIMPLICATIONSWILLBE
STUDENTSINSCHOOLENROLLMENTlGURES TRUE)FINSTEAD ITUNDERTAKESSOMEVERSIONOFA37/4
3TRENGTHS 7EAKNESSES /PPORTUNITIESAND4HREATS
s 2ESEARCH BASEDLINKSBETWEENSPECIlC ANALYSISANDTHENBUILDSASTRONGCREATIVEPLANTOMAIN
WELL DElNEDCURRICULAANDGAINSINSTUDENT TAINBALANCEWHILESTILLMOVINGTHESUBGROUPSTOWARD
ACHIEVEMENT PROlCIENCY SURVIVALANDARESTORATIONOFAFULLBALANCED
EDUCATIONISATTAINABLE)NFACT HAVINGFACEDACRISIS
s 3TRONGERPUBLICFAITHINASSESSMENTSASINDICATIVE
POINTANDHAVINGPREVAILEDSHOULDRESULTINAFARBETTER
OFASCHOOLSACCOMPLISHMENT
SYSTEMTHANBEFORE
s #ONTINUINGLACKOFA@CREDIBLERESEARCHBASETO "RINGINGPARENTSREPRESENTATIVEOFTHEVARIOUS
SUPPORTTHEVALUEOFNON ACADEMICEXPERIENCES GROUPSWITHINTHEDISTRICTINTOMUCHCLOSERINVOLVE
MENTINBOTHDETERMININGTHEDIRECTIONSBUTALSOAS
s &AILURESOFLOCALSCHOOLBOARDSTOASSURETHEIR AUXILIARYRESOURCESISAVALUABLEOPTION$OINGTHE
COMMUNITIESOFTHEIRABILITYTOMANAGETHESCHOOL SAMEFORBUSINESSCANALSOHAVEHUGEPAYOFFS0ARENTS
TOWARDHIGHERSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT ANDBUSINESSESCANBECRITICALTOSHAPINGAFTERSCHOOL
s )NCREASINGFRUSTRATIONOFEDUCATORSANDPARENTS WEEKEND ANDSUMMERPROGRAMSTOENRICHTHEIMPOV
WITHDISCREPANCIESINCURRICULAACROSSSCHOOLS ERISHEDCURRICULUM4HEYCANALSOHELPMOTIVATETHOSE
DISTRICTS ANDSTATES STUDENTSWHOHAVETHELONGESTDISTANCETOPROlCIENCY
!RRANGINGTEACHERSCHEDULESTOALLOWABALANCEOF
s #OLLEGESANDBUSINESSESREFUSINGTOCONTINUE WHOLE CLASSINSTRUCTIONANDINDIVIDUALIZEDWORKWITH
REMEDIATIONFORENROLLEESORNEWEMPLOYEES STUDENTSINNEEDWHETHEROFBASICSORADVANCEDPROJ
ECTSISALSOANOPTION)NRESPONSETOTHISSCENARIO ITIS
IMPORTANTTOOPENTHEDOORSTOJOINTPROBLEMSOLVING
RATHERTHANHUNKERDOWNDEFENSIVELY

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY !MPLE

3CENARIO h"EDAND"REAKFAST
#OUNTRY)NNv
$EEP#AUSES

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
#ONTROLOF,EARNING
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATTHETRADITIONALINSTI
TUTIONALCONlGURATIONSTHATHAVEDElNEDSCHOOLING

2ESOURCES
ˆSCHOOLS DISTRICTS STATEEDUCATIONAGENCIESˆHAVE
DEVOLVEDINTONEWFORMSOFSCHOOLINGTHATARECON
TROLLEDMOREDIRECTLYBYTHELEARNER)NADDITION THERE
AREABUNDANTRESOURCESAVAILABLEFOREDUCATION4HIS ,IMITED
DEVOLUTIONOCCURREDOVERTHECOURSEOFADECADEASA
RESULTOFTHEFOLLOWING
h"EDAND"REAKFAST#OUNTRY)NNv
s /VERWHELMINGEVIDENCEOFTHEFAILUREOFTHE 4IME
.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTOFTOACHIEVE 0LACE-IDDLETON 53!
ITSINTENDEDOUTCOMEˆENSURINGHIGH QUALITY
3CENE&ORTHEPASTFEWMONTHS AN%$
EDUCATIONFORALLCHILDRENREGARDLESSOFETHNICITY
-/.4(,9REPORTERHASROUTINELYATTENDED
RACE SOCIO ECONOMICSTATUS EDUCATIONAL
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSBOARDMEETINGS4ONIGHT
BACKGROUNDOREXCEPTIONALNEEDS
THEBOARDAPPROVESITSlRST EVERMARKETINGDIRECTOR
s #ONGRESSESDECISIONTOhGIVEBACKvTO POSITION4HEREPORTERISINTRIGUED GIVENTHEBOARDS
STATESTHEIRCONSTITUTIONALAUTHORITYOVER PREVIOUSPATTERNOFKEEPINGARELATIVELYLOWPROlLE
EDUCATIONFOLLOWINGSUCCESSFULGRASSROOTSEFFORTS 4HEDISTRICTHASALWAYSRELEASEDTESTDATAAND
BYMODERATES WHOHAVEGROWNINNUMBERSAND ANNUALREPORTS BUTITHASNEVERBEENINTERESTEDIN
POLITICALCLOUT PUBLICLYPOINTINGlNGERSORSERVINGUPKUDOS4HE
REPORTERTHINKSTHEREISMORETOTHESTORYANDWANTS
s 3TEADYGROWTHINTHEECONOMY PARTICULARLYAS TODIGDEEPERˆWHATEXACTLYISTHISBOARDUPTO
EVIDENCEDINNEWJOBS HEWONDERS ANDWHATWILLITMEANTO-IDDLETONS
s 'REATERPUBLICWILLINGNESSTOFUNDEDUCATION PARENTSANDSTUDENTS
DUETOTHEPOSITIVEPUBLICPERCEPTIONSOFNEW /N-AY  INANUNPRECEDENTEDMOVE THE
SCHOOLINGOPTIONS SUCHASENHANCEDOPPORTUNITY SEVEN MEMBER-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT"OARDAP
SCHOOLS PROVEDTHEHIRINGOF#ORBIN!SSOCIATESTOPROVIDE
,IKEOWNERSOFABEDANDBREAKFASTTHATPROVIDESVA CONSULTATIVESERVICESTOTHEDISTRICT#ORBIN!SSOCI
CATIONERSWITHAUNIQUEANDOFTENCUSTOMIZEDCOUNTRY ATESISANATIONALlRMTHATHASmOURISHEDSINCE
INNEXPERIENCE SCHOOLSCATERTOFAMILIESWHOWANTAN WHENSTATESPASSEDTUITION CREDITPROGRAMS4HEY
EDUCATIONALEXPERIENCETHATISALITTLEOUTOFTHEORDI SPECIALIZEINADVISINGTRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLSYSTEMS
NARYBUTSTILLOFFERSALL ONHOWTOBETTERMARKETTHEIRSCHOOLSINWHATHAS
THEBASICAMENITIES BECOMEAHIGHLYCOMPETITIVEENVIRONMENT!LTHOUGH
&AMILIESlNDEXACTLY THEBOARDANDDISTRICTOFlCIALSAGREETHATTHEYNEEDTO
WHATTHEYRELOOKING lNDNEWWAYSTOhSELLvTHEMANYPROGRAMSTHEYNOW
FORASTHEYSELECTFROM OFFER SOMEPARENTSANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERSWHO
AWIDERANGEOFAP ATTENDEDTHEBOARDMEETINGWEREOUTRAGED DESCRIBING
PEALINGOPTIONS THEDISTRICTAShSELLINGOUTv
!BOUTPARENTSANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERSAT
TENDEDTHEBOARDMEETINGON7EDNESDAYNIGHT AND
ASMALLBUTVOCALGROUPAMONGTHEMDIDNTHOLDBACK


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

WHENGIVENTHECHANCETOSPEAK#HARGINGTHATTHE STATEWITHOUTRESORTINGTOHIRINGMARKETINGAGENTS
DISTRICTWASABANDONINGITSFUNDAMENTALPURPOSEASA TOPUTASPINONTHEMANYGOODPROGRAMSWEHAVE
PUBLICEDUCATIONINSTITUTIONˆPREPARINGCHILDRENTO WORKEDSOHARDTOESTABLISH
BEEFFECTIVECITIZENSANDPROMOTINGDEMOCRACYˆTHE
3HELTONSCOMMENTSRALLIEDTHOSEOFLIKEMIND BUT
GROUPCRITICIZEDTHEBOARDSMOTIVATIONANDETHICS
THENEXTSPEAKERSAWTHINGSDIFFERENTLY,ATICIA(ER
INWHATTHEYVIEWEDASADRAMATICCHANGEINFUTURE
NANDEZHADTHISTOSAY
DIRECTIONS(OWEVER WHILENOTASANIMATEDINVOICING
THEIROPPOSINGOPINIONS SEVERALOTHERPARENTSSPOKEIN )AMNOTHERETODEBATEAPASTTHATISGONE)AMHERE
SUPPORTOFHIRING#ORBIN!SSOCIATES A,ITTLETOWN TOENSURETHATMYYOUNGCHILDRENWILLHAVEAFUTURE
BASEDMARKETINGlRM THATISTIEDTOTHESUCCESSOF-IDDLETONPUBLICSCHOOLS
)AMASINGLEMOTHEROFTWOCHILDRENWHOWILLATTEND
3AMEEND DIFFERENTMEANS ,INCOLN(EIGHTS%LEMENTARY)MLIKEALOTOFOTHER
0OSITIONSFORANDAGAINSTTHEDECISIONSPLITALONG FOLKSWHOHAVEBEENLUCKYTOlNDSTEADYEMPLOYMENT
GENERATIONALLINES WITHOPPOSINGVOICESCOMINGLARGELY INTHISGOODECONOMY BUTITSSTILLASTRUGGLE%VEN
FROMOLDER"ABY "OOMERS WHILEYOUNGER'EN 8ERS WITHTHENEWTUITION CREDITPROGRAM )CANTAFFORDTO
AND-ILLENNIALSSUPPORTEDTHECHANGE-S-ARY SENDMYTWOSONSTOANENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOL
3HELTON -IDDLETON4EACHERS!SSOCIATION-4! EVENTHOUGH)VEHEARDSOMANYGOODTHINGSABOUT
PRESIDENTANDAVETERANHIGHSCHOOLTEACHERWASTHE THEM)NSTEAD )NEED,INCOLN(EIGHTSTOSUCCEED)F
lRSTTOAPPROACHTHEPODIUMANDADDRESSTHEBOARD -IDDLETONSCHOOLSDONTCHANGEWITHTHETIMES THEN
THEONLYPEOPLETHATWILLSENDTHEIRCHILDRENTOPUBLIC
)NMYYEARSINTHISDISTRICT )HAVENEVERBEENSO SCHOOLSWILLBEPARENTSLIKEMEWHODONTHAVEA
COMPELLEDTOSPEAKUPAS)AMTONIGHT4ONIGHT ) CHOICE4HATSWHYWENEEDHELPFROM#ORBIN!S
SPEAKTOYOUASAPARENT TEACHER ANDREPRESENTATIVE SOCIATES-S3HELTONDOESNTLIKETHEIDEAOFSCHOOLS
OFOTHERTEACHERSINTHISDISTRICT"OTHOFMYCHILDREN COMPETINGFORSTUDENTS BUTTHATSTODAYSREALITY
GRADUATEDFROM-IDDLETONPUBLICSCHOOLSANDWENT #ORBINCANHELPOURSCHOOLSINCREASETHEIRENROLL
ONTOGRADUATEFROMCOLLEGE!SAPARENT )HAVE MENTSANDBRINGEVENMORERESOURCESINTOINDIVIDUAL
BEENEXTREMELYPLEASEDWITHTHEQUALITYOFEDUCATION SCHOOLBUILDINGSSOTHATALLOFOURKIDSCANHAVEA
THEYRECEIVEDHERE!SATEACHER )AMINCONTACT GOODEDUCATION
WITHMANYPARENTSWHOFEELTHESAMEWAY BUT)
ALSOAMAWAREOFPARENTSWHOHAVELEFT-IDDLETON !FTERANHOURANDAHALFOFPUBLICCOMMENTS THE
SCHOOLS7HYLEAVE4HESEPARENTSTELLMETHATTHEY BOARDENGAGEDINALENGTHYDISCUSSIONABOUTTHEISSUE
MADETHEIRDECISIONTHEDAYTHATTHISBOARDMADE "OARD0RESIDENT-ICHELLE#OULEYURGEDBOARDMEMBERS
THEIRSˆWHENTHEBOARDDECIDEDNOTTOTESTIFYTOTHE TOTAKEAhHARDLOOKATTHECURRENTREALITYOFSCHOOLINGv
STATEBOARDABOUTTHETUITION CREDITPROGRAM!SYOU 3HEHINTEDABOUTHEROWNPOSITIONWHENSHEDESCRIBED
WILLRECALL MANYPARENTSFELTTHISPROGRAMWASIN THENEEDFOR-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTTOlNDITS
EQUITABLEANDUNSOUND4EACHERSANDPARENTSSPOKE hCOMPETITIVEEDGEvDUETOTHEINCREASINGNUMBERSOF
BEFORETHELEGISLATURE BUTBOARDMEMBERSREMAINED ENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLSTHATWEREDRAWINGMORE
SILENT)ASKYOUTODAY WHEREWEREYOU)FWEARE ANDMORESTUDENTSFROMTHEDISTRICTUNDERTHESTATES
GOINGTOPRESERVEPUBLICSCHOOLS WENEEDOURELECTED NEWTUITION CREDITPROGRAM
LEADERSTOSPEAKUPANDNOTTOTURNOVERYOURRESPON !LTHOUGH*UAN:AMORA THEMOSTVETERANMEMBER
SIBILITYTOAPROlT FOCUSEDOUTSIDEAGENCY$OINGSOIS OFTHEBOARD ACKNOWLEDGEDTHEEFFECTIVENESSOFTHE
NOTHINGSHORTOFGIVINGINANDSELLINGOURSCHOOLSOUT DISTRICTSSTRATEGICPLANFORTHEHIGHSCHOOLS HERAISED
TOTHEMARKET)URGEYOUTOCONSIDERJOININGWITHUS CONCERNSABOUTTHEINEFFECTIVENESSOFTHEPLANATTHE
ANDOTHERBOARDSANDASSOCIATIONSTHISTIME4OGETHER ELEMENTARYANDMIDDLESCHOOLS WHEREENROLLMENTIS
WECANWORKWITHOURLEGISLATORSTOlNDANDIMPLE DECLININGATWHATHECALLED hANALARMINGRATEv(E
MENTALTERNATIVEWAYSTOFUNDPUBLICSCHOOLSINOUR SAID h4HEENROLLMENTDATATHAT$R-ARTINEZPROVIDED

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

THEBOARDINOURWEEKLYUPDATEINDICATETHATWEHAVE !MPLE
ASERIOUSPROBLEM ANDASABOARDWEAREOBLIGATEDTO
RESPONDv"OARDMEMBER:AMORAALSOTALKEDABOUTTHE h"EDAND"REAKFAST
#OUNTRY)NNv
PLANSOF-IDDLETONS,ATINO#HAMBEROF#OMMERCE

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
TOOPENANELEMENTARYSCHOOLINh4HESTATEHAS #ONTROLOF,EARNING
GIVENPARENTSTHElNANCIALMEANSTOPUTTHEIRMONEY

2ESOURCES
WHERETHEYWANTTHEIRKIDS)FWEWANTTOSTAYINBUSI
NESS WEHAVETOCREATESCHOOLSTHATPARENTSWANTTHEIR
KIDSTOATTEND4ODOTHAT WENEEDHELP vHESAID
0ETER2OLAND 3MITH BOARDMEMBERANDRETIRED
,IMITED
TEACHER SCOFFEDAT:AMORASIDEAS REFERRINGTOTHEM
ASTHEhEPITOMEOFBIGBUSINESSTHINKINGv(ESAID h)T
APPEARSTOMETHATWEARESTRAYINGSOFARFROMOUR
MISSIONTHATWEAREBECOMINGABUSINESS4HENEXT (YBRIDSOFTHEPUBLICANDPRIVATESCHOOLSOFADECADE
THINGYOUKNOW WEWILLBEDISCUSSINGHOWTOINCREASE EARLIER THESESCHOOLSATTRACTIVELYPACKAGEANDMARKET
OURPROlTS!REWEABOUTTHEKIDSORTHEDOLLARv THEIRPROGRAMS ALONGWITHTHEIRSTUDENTSTESTSCORES
3UPERINTENDENT-ARTINEZSHAREDHERSUPPORTFOR 3OMEPERCEIVETHESESCHOOLSASPROVIDINGABETTER
THENEWCONSULTANTCONTRACTINHERREPORTTOTHEBOARD EDUCATION BUTOTHERSARGUETHATTHEONLYDIFFERENCE
SAYING h4HEINSTITUTIONOFEDUCATIONISCHANGINGAS BETWEENSUCHSCHOOLSANDEXISTINGPUBLICSCHOOLS
WESPEAK4HEQUESTIONISNOTWHETHERORNOTWEAGREE ISTHEMONEYSPENTONMARKETING2EGARDLESSOFTHE
WITHIT BUTHOWWEWILLPROCEED/VERTHELASTSEVERAL PERCEPTION THEFACTISTHATTHEAVAILABILITYOFTUITION
YEARS WEHAVEADDEDLOTSOF@FRILLSTOOURPROGRAMS YETCREDITSALONGWITHMORESCHOOLCHOICESFORPARENTSHAS
WESTILLREFUSETOTHINKOFOURSELVESASCOMPETINGFOR LEDTOALOSSOFENROLLMENTINMANYEXISTINGSCHOOLS
FAMILIES&IVENEWSCHOOLSHAVEOPENEDTHEIRDOORS ANDDISTRICTS)NADDITION TUITION CREDITFUNDINGISNOT
INOURCOUNTYALONESINCETHESTATEPASSEDTHETUITION SUFlCIENTTOCOVERTHETUITIONATMOSTENHANCEDOP
CREDITLEGISLATIONIN)FWEWANTTOSURVIVETHESE PORTUNITYSCHOOLS LEAVINGDISADVANTAGEDFAMILIES ONCE
CHANGINGTIMES WEHAVETOATTRACTANDRETAINSTUDENTS AGAIN WITHLIMITEDCHOICES
ATALLLEVELSv 3IMILARPROGRAMSHAVEBEENINSTITUTEDINOTHER
STATESAND CONSEQUENTLY PUBLICSCHOOLSANDDISTRICTS
4UITIONCREDITCHANGESTHELANDSCAPE ALLAROUNDTHECOUNTRYHAVEHADMAJORDROPSINEN
4HESTATESENACTMENTOFTUITION CREDITFUNDING ROLLMENT)N THE5NITED3TATES$EPARTMENTOF
CANBETRACEDBACKTOWHENTHE.O#HILD,EFT %DUCATIONREPORTEDINTHEANNUAL.ATIONAL#ENTERON
"EHIND!CTOFLAYINRUINSANDTHEFEDERALEDUCA %DUCATIONAL3TATISTICS.#%3 REPORTTHATPERCENT
TIONBUDGETlNALLYDRIEDUP"Y #ONGRESSHAD OFTHESTUDENTSINOURSTATEAGESnATTENDEDPUBLIC
DISTRIBUTEDWHATLITTLEFEDERALFUNDSREMAINEDFOREDU SCHOOLS)NCONTRAST TODAYONLYPERCENTATTEND
CATIONTOSTATESTHROUGHBLOCKGRANTS ANDMOSTSTATES PUBLICSCHOOLS ANDPERCENTAREENROLLEDINEN
RESPONDEDBYREVISINGTHEIREXISTINGSCHOOLFUNDINGFOR HANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLS ACCORDINGTOTHE3EPTEM
MULASTOPROVIDETUITIONCREDITSFORINDIVIDUALSTUDENTS BERTH ISSUEOF%DUCATION7EEK-IDDLETONIS
PROVIDINGPARENTSWITHANANNUALCREDITTHATTHEYCAN FACEDWITHTHEREALITYTHATPARENTS ARMEDWITHTUITION
USETOPAYFORTHEEDUCATIONOFTHEIRCHOICE CREDITFUNDING AREOPTINGTHEIRCHILDRENOUTOFTHEDIS
)NOURSTATE TUITION CREDITFUNDINGDISTRIBUTES TRICTSCHOOLSANDINTOENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLS
MONIESTOPARENTS GUARDIANSANDCAREGIVERSOFCHIL
DRENINGRADES+nTOATTENDSCHOOLSOFTHEIRCHOICE
WHETHERPUBLICORPRIVATE4HESERESOURCESHAVE
SPURREDTHECREATIONOFANEWCOTTAGEINDUSTRYOF
SCHOOLS KNOWNAShENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLSv


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

(OLESLEFTBYFAILEDREFORM ,ASTINGREPERCUSSIONS
4HE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTWASNOT #RITICSOFENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLSARGUETHAT
REAUTHORIZEDWHENTHETH#ONGRESSCONVENEDIN THEGREATEREMPHASISONINDIVIDUALRIGHTSHASRESULTED
,ARGENUMBERSOFSCHOOLSHADFAILEDTOMEETTHE INANUNRAVELINGOFPROGRESSFOLLOWINGTHE"ROWN
!CTSREQUIREMENTFOR!DEQUATE9EARLY0ROGRESS!90  VS"OARDOF%DUCATIONDECISIONTOINTEGRATESCHOOLS
3TATEGOVERNMENTSFEAREDTHATWITHOUT&EDERALFUNDING WITHSTUDENTSFROMDIFFERENTRACIALBACKGROUNDS
THElNANCIALANDADMINISTRATIVEBURDENOFMANAGING 0ROFESSOR'ERALDINE-ELBOURNE FOUNDEROFTHE#IVIL
THESEFAILINGSCHOOLSWOULDBEOVERWHELMING4HEONLY 2IGHTS#ENTERAT.EW(AMPSHIRE)NSTITUTEOF4ECHNOL
COURSEWASTODISREGARDTHE!CTSEDICTS)NRESPONSE OGY SAID h4HESCHOOLCHOICEMOVEMENTSUPPORTED
THE&EDERALGOVERNMENTREFUSEDTOPROVIDElSCALRELIEF BYTUITION CREDITSTATESPENDINGHASCREATEDGREATER
TOSTATES-EANWHILE THEPUBLICOUTCRYBUILTTOA INEQUITYTHANDIDTHE3EPARATE#AR!CTOF4RA
CRESCENDOANDTHEHIGHLY REGARDED2EPUBLICAN3ENATOR DITIONALSCHOOLSAREOCCUPIEDBYLOWSOCIO ECONOMIC
!LICIA"ARRYCAPTUREDTHEPOPULOUSFRUSTRATIONIN MINORITYSTUDENTSANDENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLS
WHENSHEDECLARED h#ONGRESSHASSTRANDEDOUR ARElLLEDWITHWHITESTUDENTSWHOHAVETHEECONOMIC
SCHOOLSBYWITHHOLDINGCRITICALFUNDING!SONEOFTHE MEANSTO@BUYUPTHEIREDUCATIONv
3ENATORSWHOORIGINALLYVOTEDFORTHE!CT )AMNOW
COMPELLEDTOPERSONALLYAPOLOGIZETOMYCONSTITUENTS )RRESISTIBLEAPPEAL
ANDTHE!MERICANPEOPLEv3ENATOR"ARRYSCOMMENTS $ESPITETHECONTROVERSYAROUNDENHANCEDOPPOR
PORTENDEDTHENAILINTHECOFlNFOR.#," TUNITYSCHOOLS PARENTSWHOSECHILDRENATTENDTHEM
)NTHENEXTCONGRESSIONALCAMPAIGN 3AHID2AON BELIEVETHATTHEYAREGETTINGTHEBESTEDUCATIONPOSSI
RANSUCCESSFULLYFOR#ONGRESSONTHEPREMISEOFRETURN BLEFORTHEIRCHILDREN4IFFANY*ACKSON APARENTOFTHREE
INGCONTROLOVEREDUCATIONTOSTATEGOVERNMENTSAND CHILDRENWHOATTEND"EST"ET,EARNING HASNOTICEDA
OFFERINGFAMILIESTUITION CREDITFUNDINGTHAT HESAID DRAMATICDIFFERENCEINHERSON"RANDONSLEARNINGSINCE
hWILLEMPOWERTHEMTOMAKEINFORMEDDECISIONSABOUT HETRANSFERREDFROM,EWISAND#LARK3CHOOLIN-IDDLE
WHERETHEIRCHILDRENATTENDSCHOOLv)NHISFRESHMAN TON3CHOOL$ISTRICTLASTYEARh"RANDONNEVERLIKED
YEAR 3ENATOR2AONWORKEDTOPUTCONTROLOVEREDUCA SCHOOLBEFORE(ESTRUGGLEDINEVERYSUBJECT)USEDTO
TIONBACKINTHEHANDSOFSTATES(ETHENCAMPAIGNED HAVETODRAGHIMOUTOFBEDEVERYMORNING ANDNOW
ACROSSTHECOUNTRYINSUPPORTOFSTATESRIGHTSFOR HESEAGERTOGOTOSCHOOL vSAID*ACKSON-S*ACKSON
TUITION CREDITFUNDING4ODATE STATESHAVEPASSED BELIEVESTHATTHEmEXIBLESCHEDULE USEOFTECHNOL
SUCHLEGISLATION OGY ANDTHECORECURRICULUMAT"EST"ET,EARNINGIS
WORKINGFORHERENTIREFAMILYh)HAVETHEmEXIBILITYTO
4HERISEOFEDUCATIONCONSUMERISM SCHEDULESCHOOLBASEDONOURNEEDS vSHESAID
7HILE.O#HILD,EFT"EHINDFAILEDTOMEETITSIN *AMES0IERSON THEFATHEROFTWOFORMER-IDDLE
TENDEDOUTCOMES ITDIDMANAGETOPRODUCEANATIONAL TON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSTUDENTS HASDIFFERENTREASONSFOR
PREOCCUPATIONWITHINDIVIDUALSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT CHOOSINGANENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOL(IS YEAR
RESULTSTHATSPAWNEDMYRIADSOFNEWSCHOOLSTHROUGH OLDDAUGHTER3AMANTHAAND YEAR OLDSON#RAIGNOW
OUTTHE5NITED3TATES4ODAY THEREAREMOREEDUCA ATTENDTHE3YMMATHIUM6IRTUAL3CHOOLh-IDDLETONS
TIONALOPPORTUNITIESTHANEVER ANDPARENTS ARMEDWITH SCHOOLSOFFEREDAVERYGOODENVIRONMENT vSAID0IERSON
TUITION CREDITFUNDING AREASSERTINGTHEIRINDIVIDUAL h4HEYWEREWELL MAINTAINEDANDHADEXCELLENTTECH
RIGHTSTOSELECTTHESCHOOLOFTHEIRCHOICEFORTHEIRCHIL NOLOGICALFACILITIES"UTMYWIFEAND)BOTHTELECOM
DREN MUTETOJOBSIN-ETROPOLIS AND3YMMATHIUM6IRTUAL
3CHOOLOFFEREDmEXIBILITYFOROURCHILDRENv)NADDITION
3AMANTHAAND#RAIGRECEIVEAPRESCRIBEDLEARNINGPLAN
WITHINDIVIDUALIZEDINSTRUCTIONANDHIGHLYQUALIlED
INSTRUCTORSWHORESIDEALLOVERTHECOUNTRYANDWORLD

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

2OOMFOREVERYONE !MPLE

7HILETHE&EDERALFUNDINGFORPUBLICEDUCATIONHAS
h"EDAND"REAKFAST
BEENMETHODICALLYCUTSINCE THEAVAILABLE #OUNTRY)NNv
RESOURCESFORTHEPLAYERSINTHE-IDDLETONEDUCATION

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
MARKETARESTILLBRIGHT-IDDLETON LIKEMANYRELATIVELY #ONTROLOF,EARNING
SMALLERCOMMUNITIESIN!MERICA HASBENElTEDFROM

2ESOURCES
ANINmUXOFURBANMIGRANTSWHO THROUGHTECHNOLOGI
CALBREAKTHROUGHS CANENJOY-IDDLETONSSMALLERTOWN
ATMOSPHEREWHILESTILLMAINTAININGTHEIRHIGHER SALARY
EMPLOYMENTWITHCITYCORPORATIONS-IDDLETONSTAX ,IMITED
BASEHASGROWNASARESULTOFATTRACTINGFAMILIESWITH
CHILDREN(OWEVER THESAMETECHNOLOGIESTHATENABLE
PARENTSTOWORKFROMHOMEALSOGIVETHEMALTERNATIVE
CHOICESFOREDUCATINGTHEIRCHILDREN4HETUITION CREDIT !NALYSISOF3CENARIO
HASFUELEDTHECOMPETITIONFORTHEABUNDANTEDUCATION )MPLICATIONS
MONIES ANDTHE-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTWASILL PRE
4HEIMPLICATIONSFOR-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT
PAREDTODEALWITHTHECOMPETITIONh4HEIMPACTOFTHE
INTHISSCENARIOAREALLTIEDTOTHEINCREASINGSTRAINOF
ENHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLSHASFORCED-IDDLETON
COMPETITION)NAWORLDLIKETHEONEDESCRIBEDHEREIN
TOTAKESTOCKOFOURMISSIONTOEDUCATEEVERYCHILDFOR
WHICHTHEINDIVIDUALSHAVEALLTHECONTROLINDETERMIN
ABETTERTOMORROWˆPROMOTINGDEMOCRACYTHROUGH
INGWHEREANDBYWHOMTHEYWILLBEEDUCATED INSTITU
PUBLICEDUCATION vSAID-S#OULEY -IDDLETON"OARD
TIONSLIKEPUBLICEDUCATIONMAYBECAUGHTOFF GUARD
0RESIDENTh7EMUSTFACETHEHARDFACTTHATMOREAND
ANDILL PREPAREDTOhCOMPETEvFORENROLLMENT)NORDER
MORE-IDDLETONFAMILIESAREOPTING OUTOFTHEDISTRICTS
TOMEETTHEPRESSURESOFTHISCOMPETITIONANDATTRACT
SCHOOLS)NORDERTOSUCCEED WEMUSTMARKETTHE
ENROLLMENT PUBLICSCHOOLSLIKE-IDDLETONWILLNEEDTO
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTANDCOMPETEFORTHEYOUNG
GETHELPINRESTRUCTURINGTHEIRCONNECTIONTOTHECOM
MINDSOFTHISCOMMUNITY4HEHIRINGOFACONSULTING
MUNITIESTHEYSERVE
lRMWILLENSURETHATWEHAVEANAUDIENCEINTHEFUTURE
%NHANCEDOPPORTUNITYSCHOOLSWILLCONTINUETO
TOPERPETUATETHATMISSIONv
GROWATARAPIDRATE ANDDISTRICTSWILLSCRAMBLETOlND
WAYSTOSURVIVEINANEDUCATIONALWORLDTHATVALUES
INDIVIDUALIZEDLEARNING0UBLICSCHOOLSWILLCONTINUETO
EXISTBUTMUSTREINVENTTHEMSELVESASTHEY
FACEDO OR DIESITUATIONS
%DUCATIONWILLBELESSLIKEONE SIZE lTS ALLANDMORE
SPECIALIZEDTOMEETINDIVIDUALNEEDS)NADDITION THE
DEVELOPMENTOFTECHNOLOGYANDITSUSEBYINDIVIDUALS
TOFORMTHEIROWNCOMMUNITIESOFONLINESCHOOLSWILL
MAKETHEIDEAOFPLURALITYANDPUBLICEDUCATIONLESS
PALATABLETOPARENTALGENERATIONSWHOHAVEGROWNUP
INADIGITALAGE4HESEPARENTSWILLFEELEMPOWERED
TOUSETHESETECHNOLOGIESTOTAILORSCHOOLINGTOTHEIR
CHILDRENSNEEDSANDTHEIRFAMILIESLIFESTYLES EVENAT
THEEXPENSEOFhSOCIALIZATIONvIFNECESSARY


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NDICATORS
4HISSCENARIOSEEMSLIKELYTOHAPPENGIVENTHEFOLLOW
INGINDICATORS

s )MPROVEMENTSINTECHNOLOGYTHATMAKESITEASIER
FORONLINEVIRTUALIZEDSCHOOLSTOEMERGE

s )NCREASINGDISSATISFACTIONWITHPUBLICEDUCATION

s &AILUREOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTTO
ACCOMPLISHITSINTENDEDOUTCOMES

s )NCREASINGNUMBEROFALTERNATIVESCHOOLING
CHOICESTHATCOMPETEFORENROLLMENTINCLUDING
EVERYTHINGFROMHOMESCHOOLTOVIRTUALSCHOOLS

s 0ASSAGEOFLEGISLATIONEITHERTHROUGHMANYSTATES
ORTHROUGHTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTTHATPROVIDES
MONIESTOINDIVIDUALSTOCHOOSETHEIREDUCATION
CHOICE

/PTIONS
"ASEDONTHEIMPLICATIONSFOR-IDDLETONINTHIS
SCENARIO THEYSHOULDBEGINTODEVELOPAROBUSTTECH
NOLOGYINFRASTRUCTURETHROUGHOUTTHEDISTRICTSOTHAT
THEYCANOFFERINNOVATIVELEARNINGOPTIONSFORSTUDENTS
THATINCLUDEPROVIDINGONLINEINSTRUCTION!LLINSTRUC
TIONSHOULDBECONTENT ANDMEDIA RICH)NORDERTO
INNOVATEANDBEPREPAREDTOCOMPETEINTHISENVIRON
MENT SCHOOLSNEEDTOTHINKOUTSIDETHEPUBLICSCHOOL
PARADIGM CO OPWITHNON PUBLICSCHOOLS ANDFORGE
PARTNERSHIPSWITHLOCALBUSINESSES4HESECOOPERATIVE
FORAYSWILLKINDLENEWIDEASFROMMANYDIFFERENTPARA
DIGMSANDOPENUPPOSSIBILITIESTONEWWAYSOFLEADING
ANDCONDUCTINGTHEBUSINESSOFEDUCATION3CHOOLSIN
THISSCENARIOWOULDBEBOLSTEREDBYENLISTINGTHEHELP
OFCURRENTDISTRICTSTUDENTSANDRECENTGRADUATESINAN
ONGOINGFOCUSGROUPTOHELPDRIVETHESTRATEGYOFDELIV
ERINGEDUCATIONTOTHISINDIVIDUALISTIC CENTEREDSOCIETY

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY !MPLE

3CENARIO
$EEP#AUSES

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
#ONTROLOF,EARNING
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATTHETRADITIONALINSTITUTIONAL
CONlGURATIONSTHATDElNEDSCHOOLINGˆSCHOOLS DIS

2ESOURCES
TRICTS STATEEDUCATIONAGENCIESˆHAVEDEVOLVEDINTO
h2EST3TOP
NEWFORMSOFSCHOOLINGFOCUSEDONPROVIDINGMANY #AR#AMPINGv
CHOICESTOMEETBASICINDIVIDUALNEEDSOFSTUDENTS
4HESENEWFORMSEXISTINANENVIRONMENTOFDIMIN ,IMITED
ISHEDFUNDSFORSTUDENTS4HISDEVOLUTIONOCCURREDOVER
THECOURSEOFADECADEASARESULTOFTHEFOLLOWING

s 3IGNIlCANTLYDIMINISHEDFEDERALANDSTATE h2EST3TOP#AR#AMPINGv
RESOURCESFORSCHOOLINGASTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENT 4IME
REDIRECTSFUNDSTOCOVERTHESKYROCKETINGCOSTSOF
0LACE-IDDLETON 53!
HEALTHCAREFORANAGINGPOPULATION
3CENE%$ -/.4(,9COVERSEDUCATION RELATED
s 4HEOPPOSITIONOFOLDER!MERICANSTOTAX TOPICSOFINTERESTTOTHEWESTERNSTATES)NADDITIONTO
INCREASESANDPRE KINDERGARTENFUNDINGINITIATIVES LEGISLATIVEUPDATESANDNEWSARTICLES ITRUNSOP EDS
REDUCINGAVAILABLELOCALRESOURCESFOREDUCATION ANDFEATURESECTIONS&ORTHEPASTSEVERALMONTHS
s 4HEFAILUREOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTOF AN%$ -/.4(,9REPORTERHASBEENATTENDING
TOIMPROVEACHIEVEMENTFORALLSTUDENTS -IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTSMONTHLYBOARDMEETINGS
ASEVIDENCEDBYCONTINUEDACHIEVEMENTGAPS INWHICHTHEBOARDISREVIEWINGTHESTATUSOFITSSCHOOLS
BETWEENWHITEANDMINORITYSTUDENTSANDHIGHER ANDSEARCHINGFOROPTIONSTOMEETTHECHALLENGESOF
DROPOUTRATES ALTERNATIVEOPPORTUNITIESFORSTUDENTS4HEEDITOR
INTENDSTORUNASERIESABOUT-IDDLETONSWORKANDTHE
s -OUNTINGPRESSUREFROM'EN8AND-ILLENNIAL PRECARIOUSFUTUREOFTHEDISTRICT
PARENTSFORABETTER DIFFERENT ANDMOREINDIVIDU
ALIZEDEDUCATIONFORTHEIROWNSTUDENTS
!TA-ARCH WORKINGSESSION THE-IDDLE
,IKETRAVELERSWANDERINGFROMPLACETOPLACE REST TON"OARDOF%DUCATIONMETWITH-IDDLETONPARENTS
STOPCARCAMPING STAFF ANDCOMMUNITYMEMBERSTODISCUSSHOWTO
OFFERSAVERYBASIC REVERSETHETRENDOFDECLININGENROLLMENTBYATTRACTING
MINIMUMEDUCATION ANDRETAININGSTUDENTSIN-IDDLETONSATTENDANCEAREA
WITHAVARIETYOF 7ITHTHEEXPANSIONOFCHOICEOPTIONSCREATEDBYTHE
BACKDROPS%VENTU STATESh!LL#HILDREN-OVING5PvLEGISLATIONIN
ALLY EVENDIE HARD PARENTSHAVEBEENUSINGSTATE ISSUEDVOUCHERSTOMOVE
CAMPERSCANTHELP THEIRCHILDRENTOOTHERPUBLICSCHOOLDISTRICTS PRIVATE
BUTWONDER ISTHIS SCHOOLS ANDNEWLY CREATEDh(OME "ASEDvSCHOOLS
WHATCAMPINGISSUP 4HEDISTRICT WHICHHASCLOSEDTHREEELEMENTARY
POSEDTOBE SCHOOLS ONEMIDDLESCHOOL ANDONEHIGHSCHOOLSINCE
 ISLOOKINGTOTHECOMMUNITYFORANSWERS!C
CORDINGTO"OARD0RESIDENT-ICHELLE#OULEY THEBOARD
WILLHOSTASERIESOFSPECIALMEETINGSTHROUGHOUTTHE
SPRINGTOENGAGEKEYSTAKEHOLDERSINDISCUSSIONSABOUT


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

HOWTORENEWINTERESTIN-IDDLETONSSCHOOLS )THINKTHATTHEKEYTO-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOLS
&OURINVITEDGUESTSANDAHANDFULOFPUBLICATTEND SUCCESSISPARENTINVOLVEMENT!SYOUKNOW WE
EESJOINEDTHElRSTDISCUSSIONABOUTTHECONSEQUENCES RAISEDMORETHAN LASTYEAR ASWEDOMOST
OFDECLININGENROLLMENTANDPOSSIBLEWAYSTOREVERSE YEARS FROMPRIVATEANDCORPORATEDONATIONS4HIS
IT!CCORDINGTO0RESIDENT#OULEY THEBOARDINVITED ENABLESUSTOGIVESTUDENTSALLOFTHEEXTRASTHATMAKE
hKEYSTAKEHOLDERSWHOAREWELLCONNECTEDANDHAVE SCHOOLSPECIAL7EOFFERSTUDENTSADVANCEDPLACE
APULSEON-IDDLETONv'UESTSWERE"RITTANY#LARK MENTCOURSES ATHLETICPROGRAMS ANDEVENmOURISH
SON 7ONG 04!PRESIDENTAT-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOL INGMUSICANDARTDEPARTMENTS ASWELLAVARIETYOF
#ESAR2OMERO PARENTAT,INCOLN(EIGHTS%LEMENTARY EXTRACURRICULARACTIVITIES)KNOWTHATYOUHAVECUT
3CHOOL-ARTIN%SCOBAR PRESIDENTOFTHE-IDDLETON EVERYTHINGINTHEDISTRICTTHATISNOTTHEBASICSTUFF)T
,ATINO#HAMBEROF#OMMERCEAND#ARMEN!RZUELO ISSUCHASHAME)DONTTHINKTHATPARENTSATOTHER
3MITH PRINCIPALOFREGION WHICHINCLUDESONEJUNIOR SCHOOLSSHARETHESAMECOMMITMENTASTHE-IDDLETON
HIGHANDTHREEELEMENTARYSCHOOLS-ARY3HELTON THE (IGHPARENTS
-IDDLETON4EACHERS!SSOCIATION-4! PRESIDENTWAS
#ESAR2OMEROSDESCRIPTIONOF,INCOLN(EIGHTS
INTHEAUDIENCE
%LEMENTARY3CHOOLWASASHARPCONTRASTTO-IDDLE
#ONTRASTING0OINTSOF6IEW TON(IGH3CHOOL,INCOLN(EIGHTS LOCATEDONTHE
SOUTHWESTBOUNDARYOFTHEDISTRICT PROVIDESWHAT-R
4HESEVEN MEMBER-IDDLETON"OARDOF%DUCATION 2OMERODESCRIBEDAShASOLIDBASICEDUCATIONvTOA
AND3UPERINTENDENT-ARTINEZLISTENEDFORTHREEHOURS DWINDLINGENROLLMENTOFSTUDENTS(ESAID
ASGUESTSANDOTHERSINTHEAUDIENCEDISCUSSEDTHEIR
CONCERNSABOUTTHEVIABILITYOFTHEDISTRICT!LTHOUGH 7EBELIEVETHATTHETEACHERSANDPARENTSAT,INCOLN
INHEROPENINGREMARKS -S#OULEYDESCRIBED-ID (EIGHTSREALLYCAREABOUTOURKIDS BUTITISNOTFAIR
DLETONSDECLININGENROLLMENTAS hTHEUNRAVELINGOF THATMYSON !UGUSTIN DOESNTHAVETHECHANCETO
!MERICASGREATESTSOCIALINSTITUTIONˆPUBLICSCHOOLS v PLAYSPORTSORLEARNMUSICORART)TISNOTTHATTHE
KEYSTAKEHOLDERSDIDNOTAPPEARTOSHARETHEBOARD PARENTSDONTCAREWEDO7EJUSTDONTHAVEMONEY
PRESIDENTSLEVELOFCONCERN2ATHER THEIRCOMMENTS TOPAYFORTHEEXTRAS-OSTOFUSWORKTWOAND
REVOLVEDAROUNDISSUESOFQUALITYANDEQUITY THREEJOBSJUSTTOGETBY)THINKTHATITISTHEDISTRICTS
4HE"OARDSINVITEESOFFEREDCONTRASTINGPOINTSOF RESPONSIBILITYTOSEETHATALLOFTHEKIDSHAVETHESAME
VIEWABOUT-IDDLETONSENROLLMENT"RITTANY#LARK OPPORTUNITIES
SON 7ONG PARENT LONG TIME-IDDLETONRESIDENT AND
(EWENTONTOSAY h$R:AMORA YOUSAIDINYOUR
CURRENT-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOL04!PRESIDENT SPOKE
CAMPAIGNTHATYOUWEREGOINGTOMAKETHISBETTER
ATLENGTHABOUTTHESUCCESSOF-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOL
FORUS)CANSEETHATTHOSEWEREPURASPALABRASv
DESCRIBINGAWAITINGLISTOFANXIOUSPARENTSANDSTU
DENTS)NCONTRAST #ESAR2OMERO A,INCOLN(EIGHTS
#AUGHTINTHE#YCLE
%LEMENTARYPARENT DESCRIBEDHISSONSSCHOOLASHAVING
AHIGHSTUDENTTEACHERRATIO ADILAPIDATEDBUILDING 4HELOSSOFFUNDINGDUETODECLININGENROLLMENTIS
ANDASHORTAGEOFQUALIlEDTEACHERS"OTHSPEAKERS AVICIOUSCYCLEFORSCHOOLS!STHEYGAINSTUDENTS THEY
VIEWEDTHESITUATIONTHROUGHTHEIROWNEXPERIENCES ALSOGAINRESOURCESWHICH INTURN HELPTHEIRSCHOOLS
ANDTHATISPARTOFTHEDILEMMA4HESESCHOOLSREmECT BECOMEMOREATTRACTIVETONEWSTUDENTS-ANYSTU
THECHANGINGDYNAMICSANDSTUDENTDEMOGRAPHICS DENTSTRANSFERREDTOTHENEIGHBORING%ASTMOORE3CHOOL
ACROSSTHEDISTRICT WHICH$R*UAN:AMORA THE"OARDS $ISTRICTWITHITSNEWERBUILDINGSANDSTRONGARTAND
MOSTVETERANMEMBER DESCRIBEDAShPOLARIZATIONv ATHLETICPROGRAMS ALLFUNDEDTHROUGHDONATIONSTOTHE
!TTHE"OARDSREQUEST -S#LARKSON 7ONGDE PARENT ESTABLISHED%ASTMOORE#OMMUNITY&OUNDATION
SCRIBEDHOW-IDDLETON(IGH3CHOOLHASBEENABLETO ,INCOLN(EIGHTS%LEMENTARY ONTHEOTHERHAND WHILE
RETAINITSSTUDENTSANDATTRACTNEWONESOVERTHEPAST SUPPORTEDWITHSMALLGRANTSFROMTHE,ATINO#HAMBER
SEVERALYEARS(ERCOMMENTSFOLLOW OF#OMMERCE NOWHASSIXVOUCHER FUNDED(OME

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

"ASEDSCHOOLSOPERATINGWITHINTWOMILESOFTHESCHOOL !MPLE
CAUSINGAFURTHERDRAINONENROLLMENT
-ARTIN%SCOBAR 0RESIDENTOF-IDDLETONS,ATINO
#HAMBEROF#OMMERCE SHARED#ESAR2OMEROSSENTI

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
MENTSANDSPOKEDIRECTLYTOTHEBOARD #ONTROLOF,EARNING

2ESOURCES
)FTHE"OARDREALLYWANTSTOMAKEADIFFERENCE THEN
YOUCANNOLONGERALLOWPARENTSTOSEGREGATETHEIR
h2EST3TOP
KIDS7HEN)LOOKACROSSTHISDISTRICTATENROLLMENT #AR#AMPINGv
ANDACHIEVEMENTDATA )SEETHATTHESCHOOLSTHATARE
THRIVINGARElLLEDWITHRICHWHITEKIDS ANDTHEONES ,IMITED

THATARESTRUGGLINGORCLOSINGAREFORPOOR,ATINOS!S
LONGASTHEBOARDPERMITSTHIS WEWILLCONTINUETO
HAVEINEQUITABLEEDUCATION9OUKNOWTHATOUROR 3EARCHINGFOR7ORKABLE3OLUTIONS
GANIZATIONHASGIVENWHATWECANTO,INCOLN(EIGHTS
%LEMENTARYOVERTHEPASTTWOYEARS BUTTHESEGRANTS 4HEBOARDSINVITEESOFFEREDSEVERALPOSSIBILITIES
HAVEBEENINSUFlCIENTCOMPAREDTOWHATTHE%AST FORSOLUTIONS INCLUDINGCORPORATEPARTNERSHIPSAND
MOORE#OMMUNITY&OUNDATIONCANPROVIDE7EARE INCREASEDVIRTUALLEARNINGCOURSESFORHIGHSCHOOL
TRYINGTOBUILDASTRONG PROUDSCHOOL BUTATTRACTING STUDENTS-R%SCOBARSSUGGESTIONTHATTHEDISTRICT
TEACHERSANDNEWSTUDENTSISASTRUGGLE/URENROLL IMPOSEAPOLICYMANDATINGTHATTHEDISTRICTINTEGRATE
MENTCONTINUESTODECLINEANDSOMECLASSESARESTILL ITSSCHOOLSTHROUGHASSIGNINGSTUDENTSTOCROSS TOWN
TAUGHTBYSUBSTITUTETEACHERS SCHOOLSPROVOKEDTHEMOSTSPIRITEDDEBATE0ETER
2OLAND 3MITH RETIREDTEACHERANDBOARDMEMBER
0RINCIPAL!RZUELO 3MITH WHOSERVESTHREEELEMEN RESPONDED
TARYSCHOOLSANDONEMIDDLESCHOOL OFFEREDANOTHER
PERSPECTIVE 7ITHDUERESPECT -R%SCOBAR )DONTTHINKTHAT
YOUUNDERSTANDTHEPOSITIONWEAREINASADISTRICT
/URDISTRICTISINATIMEOFCHANGE&UNDSARELIMITED 0ARENTSHAVEALLOFTHECONTROLBECAUSETHEYRECEIVE
/URSTUDENTPOPULATIONISCHANGING7ERECEIVELESS STATEVOUCHERSANDTAXCREDITSFORDIRECTDONATIONS
SUPPORTFROMFEDERALANDSTATEGOVERNMENTSTHAN TOPUBLICSCHOOLS4HEDAYSOF"ROWNVERSUSTHE
EVER4HISISATIMEWHENWEHAVETOCOMETOGETHER "OARDOF%DUCATIONAREOVER7ESURVEYEDPARENTS
TOMAKETHINGSWORKASADISTRICT4HESTATEVOUCHER ANDFOUNDEDUCATIONINADIVERSESTUDENTSETTINGIS
PROGRAMHASSHIFTEDTHEFOCUSFROMSCHOOLSANDCOM VERYLOWONTHEIRLISTOFPRIORITIES4HEMINUTEWE
MUNITIESTOINDIVIDUALSTUDENTS0ARENTSHAVEALWAYS MANDATEWHERESTUDENTSSHOULDATTENDSCHOOL WE
WANTEDWHATISBESTFORTHEIRCHILDREN.OW THOUGH WILLLOSEEVENMORESTUDENTS!SITISNOW WEHAVE
THEREISNOSENSEOFLOYALTYTOASCHOOLORDISTRICT CLOSEDlVESCHOOLSINTHREEYEARS3OMEYEARS AS
4HEFOUR2EGIONSCHOOLSTHAT)AMINCHARGEOFARE MANYASATHIRDOFOURHIGHSCHOOLSTUDENTSARE
ALLVERYDIFFERENT BUTINEVERYONEOFTHEM )SEE ENROLLEDINTHEVIRTUALLEARNINGPROGRAMAT-IDDLETON
PARENTSWHOREALLYCAREANDWHOWANTTHEBESTFOR (IGH3CHOOL ANDWEHAVEAGROWING(OME "ASED
THEIRKIDS5NFORTUNATELY THEYDONTALLHAVETHE SCHOOLPOPULATION THANKSTOTHESTATESDECISIONTHAT
SAMEMEANSTOCONTRIBUTETOTHEIREDUCATION WHICH PARENTSCANBECOMECERTIlEDTEACHERSONCETHEYHAVE
MEANSTHATOURDISTRICTISBECOMINGMOREANDMORE COMPLETEDASHORTCOURSEANDlLLEDOUTSOMEPAPER
SEGREGATED AND-IDDLETONISNOTTHECOMMUNITY WORK7ECANTREALLYMANDATEVERYMUCH7EARE
ITWASTENYEARSAGO7EHAVETOOVERCOMETHISBY INCOMPETITIONFORTHEPARENTSINOURDISTRICT7E
WORKINGTOGETHERASADISTRICT HAVETOATTRACTTHEM


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

.O3UPPORTFROM53$/% STATE MOSTSTATESOFFERANANNUALPER CHILDEDUCATIONAL


-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICT LIKEMANY!MERICAN VOUCHER4OOBTAINAVOUCHER PARENTSMUSTENROLL
SCHOOLDISTRICTS ISEXPERIENCINGMAJORCHANGESTHATARE THEIRCHILDINASTATE APPROVEDPROGRAMANDHAVEPROOF
LIKELYTOHAVEANIMPACTONFUTUREGENERATIONSOFSTU OFENROLLMENT6OUCHERSBEGANTOMAKESENSETOAN
DENTS%DUCATIONPUNDITSATTRIBUTETHECURRENTDETERIO ECONOMICALLY STRAPPEDPUBLIC PARTICULARLYTOTHOSE
RATIONOFPUBLICEDUCATIONTOTHEWOEFULLYINADEQUATE AGING"ABY"OOMERSWHOAREFARMORECONCERNEDABOUT
FEDERALANDSTATEFUNDINGFORMULAS)N PARTLYIN PAYINGFORTHEIRPRESCRIPTIONDRUGSTHANBUYINGTEXT
RESPONSETOTHERISINGCOSTOFDELIVERINGHEALTHCARE BOOKSFORSOMEONEELSESCHILDREN)NADDITION SUC
TOAGING"ABY"OOMERS ASWELLASTHEUNCONTAINABLE CESSFULTAXREDUCTIONBALLOTINITIATIVES SCHOOLlNANCE
COSTSOFTHE7ARON4ERROR THETH#ONGRESSPASSED LAWSUITS ANDTHEREALESTATEBUSTOF ALLCONSPIRED
LEGISLATIONTHATSTRIPPEDPOWERANDFUNDINGFROMTHE TOCONVINCEVOTERSTOPROVIDEEACHSTUDENTWITHA
5NITED3TATES$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION53$/%  VOUCHERANDTHENLEAVETHERESTTOTHEMARKET
4HEFEDERALEDUCATIONBUDGET WHICHONCEPROVIDEDAS -OSTDISTRICTSTHROUGHOUTTHE5NITED3TATESARE
MUCHASPERCENTOFFUNDINGFORINDIVIDUALSCHOOL STRUGGLINGTOADAPTTOTHECHANGESINPUBLICEDUCATION
DISTRICTS NOWCOVERSLESSTHANTWOPERCENTOFTHECOST WHICHISNOWPRIMARILYCONTROLLEDBYPARENTS0ARENTAL
OFEDUCATING!MERICANSCHOOLCHILDREN!LTHOUGHTHE CHOICE WHICHWASANINCREMENTALCHANGEINTHEEARLY
VIABILITYOFTHE53$/%HASCOMEINTOQUESTIONAGAIN S HASEXPLODED.OTONLYCANPARENTSCHOOSETHEIR
ANDAGAINOVERTHEPASTlVEDECADES THESTREAMLINED CHILDRENSSCHOOLS THEYALSOCANBETHETEACHERORTHE
DEPARTMENTISASCLOSEASITHASEVERBEENTOBEING PRINCIPAL4HANKSTOSTATELEGISLATION MOSTSTATESALLOW
ELIMINATED ANYONEWITHABACHELORSDEGREEWHOCANPASSACRIMI
4HE53$/%HASTWOMAJORFUNCTIONSNATIONAL NALBACKGROUNDCHECKTOBECOMESTATE APPROVEDTEACH
ASSESSMENTANDDISTRIBUTIONOF4ITLE)FUNDS&OR ERSABLETORUNA(OME "ASEDSCHOOL!SLOW PAYING
 THEDEPARTMENTIMPLEMENTEDANATIONALONLINE SERVICEJOBSINCREASEANDCOLLEGE EDUCATED!MERICANS
STANDARDS BASEDASSESSMENTPROGRAMTHATALLSTUDENTS lNDTHEMSELVESCHOOSINGBETWEENUNEMPLOYMENT
ENROLLEDINSECONDTHROUGHEIGHTHGRADESMUSTCOM ANDWORKINGFORREDUCEDPAY TEACHINGHASBECOMEAN
PLETEANNUALLY3INCESTATESAREREQUIREDTOTESTEVERY ATTRACTIVECHOICEFORMANY(OME "ASEDSCHOOLSARE
STUDENTWHOATTENDSAPUBLICSCHOOLORWHORECEIVESA TYPICALLYFOUNDINWHITE UPPERMIDDLE CLASSNEIGHBOR
VOUCHER THISSTANDARDIZEDTESTINGSYSTEMSAVESSTATES HOODS WHERECOLLEGE EDUCATEDMOMSOBTAINLICENSES
THEEXPENSEOFCREATINGTHEIROWNASSESSMENTSAND TOTEACHNEIGHBORHOODSTUDENTSOUTOFTHEIRHOMEIN
PROVIDESCROSS STATECOMPARISONSOFSTUDENTACHIEVE EXCHANGEFORTHESTUDENTSVOUCHER
MENTˆSOMETHINGSTATESWITHDECLININGPOPULATIONS 3HARON+ING ANUNEMPLOYEDTECHNICIANWITHA
ARENOWUSINGTOLURENEWRESIDENTS4HE$EPART "ACHELORS$EGREEFROMTHE.EW-EXICO)NSTITUTEOF
MENTALSOHASCONTINUEDTOPROVIDE4ITLE)FUNDSTO 4ECHNOLOGY RUNSASTATE APPROVED(OME "ASEDSCHOOL
SOCIO ECONOMICALLYDISADVANTAGEDSTUDENTSTHROUGH FROMHERHOME4ENNEIGHBORHOODSTUDENTSBETWEEN
ENHANCEDVOUCHERS ALTHOUGHTHENEWREQUIREMENT THEAGESOFlVEANDEIGHTARRIVEATHERHOMEEVERY
THATFAMILIESDEMONSTRATETHEIRELIGIBILITYTHROUGHTAX MORNINGTOSPENDASMUCHASSIXHOURSLEARNINGTHE
RETURNSAMOVESOMECYNICSBELIEVEISANINTENTIONAL STATE APPROVEDCURRICULUM BUTTHEYARENOTREQUIREDTO
EFFORTTOREDUCETHElNANCIALBURDENOF4ITLE)ONTHE BETHEREFORANYSETLENGTHOFTIME-S+INGHADTHIS
FEDERALGOVERNMENT ISLIMITINGTHENUMBERSOFVOUCH TOSAYINARECENTINTERVIEW
ERSISSUED !TlRST WHEN)GOTLAIDOFF )WASLOST!TTHESAME
TIME THEOTHERMOMSINTHENEIGHBORHOODAND)HAD
3TATESAND0ARENTS3WAP2OLES
GROWNQUITEFRUSTRATEDWITHTHELACKOFRIGORINOUR
4HEROLEOF3TATE$EPARTMENTSOF%DUCATIONHAS PUBLICSCHOOL7ELOVEDTHETEACHERS BUTWEWANTED
ALSOCHANGEDINRECENTYEARSWITHTHEADVENTOFSTATE THESCHOOLTOBEMOREACADEMIC/NEOFTHENEIGHBORS
VOUCHERPROGRAMS!LTHOUGHTHEPROGRAMSVARYBY SUGGESTEDTHAT)STARTASCHOOLSINCE)HADBEENTHE

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

"ROWNIELEADERANDKNEWSOMETHINGABOUTWORKING !MPLE
WITHKIDS4HATSWHEN)lRSTSERIOUSLYTHOUGHTABOUT
IT4HEN WHENTHESTATEOFFEREDVOUCHERSANDTAX
BREAKSFORDIRECTDONATIONSTOSCHOOLS ITJUSTMADE

)NSTITUTIONAL

)NDIVIDUAL
SENSE)TSGREAT)TEACHKIDSEVERYDAY4HEY #ONTROLOF,EARNING
COMEFORTHETIMETHATTHEYNEEDTOLEARNWHATTHEY

2ESOURCES
NEEDTOKNOW4HEYARESELF DIRECTEDANDMOTIVATED
ANDTHEIRPARENTSAREINTERESTEDANDINVOLVED4HE h2EST3TOP
#AR#AMPINGv
KIDSSETTHEPACETHEMSELVESANDDOMOSTOFTHEIR
WORKONCOMPUTERS7EFOLLOWTHESTANDARDSTHAT
,IMITED
MOSTSCHOOLSUSE OFCOURSE AND)GETTHEM ALONG
WITHLESSONPLANSUGGESTIONS RIGHTOFFOFTHE-C2%,
7EBSITE2EALLY )JUSTHELPKIDSLEARN)LIKETOTHINK
OFITASh-ONTESSORIGONETECHNOv FORTHESESCHOOLSAREEXPECTEDTOCOMEFROMNONTRADI
TIONALSOURCESUSINGALTERNATIVECERTIlCATIONS EXISTING
TEACHERSWITHANENTREPRENEURIALATTITUDEANDWHO
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO ARETIREDOFTHEIREXISTINGSCHOOLENVIRONMENTS MAY
)MPLICATIONS LEAVETRADITIONALSCHOOLSTOCREATEADDITIONAL(OME
"ASEDSCHOOLSANDTAKESELECTEDSTUDENTSWITHTHEM
)NTHISWORLD THEREARELIMITEDRESOURCESFROMTHE
(OME "ASEDSCHOOLSAREANAFFORDABLEECONOMIC
STATEFORTRADITIONALPUBLICEDUCATIONANDSCHOOLSOFALL
MODELBECAUSEOFLIMITEDOVERHEADCOSTS*USTASPUBLIC
KINDSMUSTCOMPETEWITHEACHOTHERFORSTUDENTSAND
SCHOOLSWILLINCREASEINEQUITIESBETWEENCOMMUNITIES
THEIRSTATE FUNDEDVOUCHERS4HEMORESTUDENTSTHAT
(OME "ASEDSCHOOLQUALITYWILLBEGREATLYDIFFERENTI
ASCHOOLCANATTRACT THEMORELIKELYITISTOBEABLE
ATED3OMEWILLHAVETHEADVANTAGESOFTHEBESTTEACH
TOPROVIDETHEQUALITYOFEDUCATIONPARENTSDEMAND
ERSANDASMALLCLASSSIZE ANDSOMEWILLLACKPROPER
"ECAUSEVOUCHERSARENOTADEQUATEINANDOFTHEM
TEACHING4HEROLEOFTHEPARENTWILLBEINCREASINGLY
SELVESTOSUPPORTTRADITIONALSCHOOLS INEQUITYAMONG
IMPORTANTTOMAKESURECHOICEOPTIONSPROVIDEBETTER
PUBLICSCHOOLSISINCREASING BOTHINTERMSOFTHE
QUALITYTHANTRADITIONALALTERNATIVES4HROUGHVOUCH
QUALITYANDQUANTITYOFTHEIROFFERINGS4ITLE)FUNDSARE
ERS FAMILIESATTHELOWERENDOFTHEINCOMESPECTRUM
DISTRIBUTEDINTHEFORMOFVOUCHERENHANCEMENTSTO
WILLNOWBEABLETOFUNDOPTIONSPREVIOUSLYUNAVAILABLE
LOW INCOMESTUDENTSBUTDONOTPROVIDEAHIGHENOUGH
TOTHEM4HISCREATESAVERYNEWWORLDOFCOMPETITION
LEVELOFFUNDING3PECIALFUNDINGFORLOW INCOME
FORSCHOOLDISTRICTSTHATHAVEBEENSHELTEREDFROMTHIS
STUDENTSISPROVIDEDTHROUGH4ITLE)VOUCHERENHANCE
INTHEPAST
MENTSWHICHDONOTAMOUNTTOENOUGHTOPROVIDETRUE
EQUITY3CHOOLSBECOMEAUTONOMOUSFROMTHEDISTRICT
INMANYWAYS ESPECIALLYINFUNDING BUTTHISDISPARITY
INRESOURCESCREATESADDITIONALCHALLENGESFORSCHOOL
BOARDSASTHENEEDIESTSCHOOLSFALLFURTHERBEHINDTHOSE
OFRELATIVELYHIGHQUALITY&AMILIESTHATAREINTERESTED
INEDUCATIONANDCANACCESSALTERNATIVESWILLDESERTTHE
UNDER PERFORMINGSCHOOLSLEAVINGANINCREASINGLYDES
PERATEENVIRONMENTBEHIND)NADECLININGENROLLMENT
ENVIRONMENT TEACHERSWILLLOSEJOBSECURITYANDBEGIN
TOPURSUEALTERNATIVECAREERSATAFASTERRATE
4HENEWLYCREATED(OME "ASEDSCHOOLSPROVIDE
ALTERNATIVESFORTEACHERS7HILETHEINITIALTEACHERS


,OCAL%DUCATION!GENCY3CENARIO

)NDICATORS INTHECOMMUNITY#ONTINUINGTOINVOLVEPARENTSIN
%VENTSANDTRENDSTHATCOULDSIGNALTHEDEVELOPMENT BOTHAPUBLICDISCUSSIONANDINTHEENDEAVORITSELFIS
OFTHISSCENARIOINCLUDETHESE ESSENTIALTOMAINTAINTHEIRSUPPORTANDTHEIRSONSAND
DAUGHTERSASPUBLICSCHOOLSTUDENTS$OINGTHESAME
s #ONTINUEDFAILUREOFSCHOOLSANDDISTRICTSTOMOVE WITHBUSINESSANDCOMMUNITYGROUPSISALSOESSENTIALTO
HIGHNUMBERSOFTHEIRCHILDRENTOPROlCIENCY SECURETHEIRlNANCIALSUPPORTANDTOLIMITTHEFRAGMEN
LEVELS ESPECIALLYSPECIALGROUPS TATIONTHATCANOCCURINACOMPETITIVEWORLDOFCHOICE
4EACHERSWILLNEEDTOBEBROUGHTINTOTHEPROCESS
s )NCREASEDPUBLICSUPPORTFORALTERNATIVEEDUCATION
ASTHEFRONTLINEOFCONTACTWITHTHENEWLYEMPOWERED
OPTIONSANDTHEWILLINGNESSOFLEGISLATURESTO
STUDENTSPARENTS3TUDENTSWILLEXPECTQUALITYCLASS
CREATEmEXIBLEFUNDINGMECHANISMSTOPROVIDEFOR
ROOMEXPERIENCES ANDBOTHPARENTSANDSTUDENTSWILL
CHOICESFORMOREFAMILIESWHOCANNOTAFFORDTO
BELESSWILLINGTOTOLERATEDISSATISFACTIONOFANYTYPE
PAYONTHEIROWN
BECAUSETHEYHAVETHEPOWERTOEXERCISEOTHEROPTIONS
s )NCREASEDAVAILABILITYOFTECHNOLOGYANDOFF
THE SHELFMATERIALSAVAILABLEFORUSEOUTSIDEOF $ISCUSSION1UESTIONS
TRADITIONALCLASSROOMS  !RETHECRITICALUNCERTAINTIESTHATFORMTHE
s $ECLINEINEDUCATIONFUNDING ATNATIONAL STATE SCENARIOFRAMEWORKTHOSETHATYOUWOULDCHOOSE
ANDLOCALLEVELS CAUSEDBYTHEHIGHPRICEOF ORARETHEREOTHERUNCERTAINTIESTHATSEEMMORE
SETTLINGSCHOOLlNANCELAWSUITSANDMEETINGTHE CRITICALTOYOU
HEALTHCARENEEDSOFAGING"ABY"OOMERS  !RETHESTORIESPLAUSIBLE#OULDTHEYTURNOUTTO
s -OREPUBLICACCEPTANCEOFAhONE SIZE lTS ALLv BETRUE)FNOT WHATWOULDYOUCHANGE
APPROACHTOASSESSMENTANDACCOUNTABILITY  #ANYOUTHINKOFOTHERIMPLICATIONSANDOPTIONS
FORTHEORGANIZATIONINADDITIONTOTHOSEWRITTEN
/PTIONS INTHE!NALYSISSECTIONS
)NORDERTOTHRIVEINTHISSCENARIO THELOCALSCHOOL
 )FYOUWERELEADINGANORGANIZATIONOFTHISTYPE
DISTRICTWILLNEEDTOBEHIGHLYCREATIVEANDPROACTIVETO
WHATWOULDYOUDONOWTOPREPAREFORTHESE
MAINTAINITSSTUDENTBASE)TMAYEVENNEEDTOSELEC
IMAGINEDFUTURES
TIVELYDEFENDITSBASEBYABANDONINGTHETRADITIONAL
PATTERNOFOFFERINGSCHOOLSTOCHILDRENONAGEOGRAPHIC
BASIS4OSURVIVE THEDISTRICTMIGHTNEEDTOABANDON
SCHOOLSINSOMEGEOGRAPHICAREASWITHSOMEINITIAL
LOSSOFSTUDENTS ANDFOCUSONBUILDINGPROGRAMSWITHIN
REMAININGSCHOOLSTHATMATCHPARENTANDSTUDENT
INTERESTS)NADDITION THEDISTRICTMIGHTATTEMPTTO
hMIRRORvTHEMORE ATTRACTIVE(OME "ASEDANDPRIVATE
SCHOOLSBYALLOWINGTHEPUBLICSCHOOLSSIGNIlCANTLY
MOREAUTONOMY
-IDDLETON3CHOOL$ISTRICTMIGHTCONSIDERUNDER
TAKINGSOMEVERSIONOFA37/43TRENGTHS 7EAK
NESSES /PPORTUNITIESAND4HREATS ANALYSIS ANDTHEN
BUILDASTRONGCREATIVEPLANTOMAINTAINITSPOSITION

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
!BUNDANT

h9OU#ANT!LWAYS
h)MAGINEv
'ET7HAT9OU7ANTv

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
2ESOURCES
h)#ANT'ET.O
h,IVEAND,ET$IEv
3ATISFACTIONv

3CARCE

.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIOS
)NTRODUCTION

0 ARENTSFOR%DUCATION0&% ISANATIONALPARENTGROUPWHOSEMISSIONISTOINmUENCEANDSUPPORT
HIGH QUALITYPUBLICEDUCATIONFORALL!MERICANCHILDREN7ITHHEADQUARTERSIN7ASHINGTON
$# 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONWORKSTHROUGHNATIONAL STATE ANDLOCALCHAPTERSTOENSURETHATTHEVOICES
OFPARENTSABOUTTHEIRCHILDRENSEDUCATIONAREHEARDANDACTEDUPONBYLOCAL STATE ANDNATIONALPOLI
CYMAKERS0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONISANONPROlTASSOCIATIONWITHSIXMILLIONMEMBERSWHOAREORGANIZED
INTOMORETHAN CHAPTERSTHROUGHOUTTHE5NITED3TATESANDTHE$ISTRICTOF#OLUMBIA
&ORMANYYEARS THEMEMBERSHIPOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONHOVEREDAROUNDTHEMILLIONMARK BUT
DURINGTHELASTDECADE MEMBERSHIPHASSTEADILYDECLINEDASMANYPARENTSINMOREAFmUENTSCHOOLDIS
TRICTS WHODIDNOTWANTTOFOLLOWTHEDICTATESOFANATIONALORGANIZATION BROKEOFFANDSTARTEDTHEIROWN
LOCALORGANIZATIONS4HESEORGANIZATIONSFOCUSEDONLYONLOCALISSUESANDDIDNOTPARTICIPATEATTHENA
TIONALLEVEL(OWEVER THISTRENDNOWISREVERSING APPARENTLYASAREACTIONTOTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
!CTOF.#," 4ODAYSPARENTSREALIZETHATNATIONALORGANIZATIONSPLAYIMPORTANTROLESWHENLAWS
ABOUTTHEIRCHILDRENSEDUCATIONAREPASSEDATTHEFEDERALLEVEL ANDMEMBERSHIPISONTHERISE
-EMBERSHIPIN0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONISCLIMBINGFORANOTHERREASON2ESEARCHSUPPORTSTHECRITICAL
IMPORTANCEOFPARENTSINTHEACADEMICACHIEVEMENTOFTHEIRCHILDREN AND0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONHAS
LONGCHAMPIONEDTHEISSUEOFPARENTALINVOLVEMENT2ECENTSTUDIESHAVESHOWNTHATTHEKEYFACTORIN
THELIVESOFCHILDRENWHOhBEATTHEODDSvAREPARENTSWHOAREINVOLVEDINTHEIREDUCATION0ARENTSFOR
%DUCATIONWELCOMESTHISRESEARCHITSLEADERSHIPISCOMMITTEDTOONCEAGAINGROWINGTHEIRMEMBERSHIP
INTHEBELIEFTHATLARGERNUMBERSWILLMEANGREATERINmUENCEINIMPROVINGCHILDRENSEDUCATIONANDLIVES
4HELEADERSHIPALSOISVERYAWAREOFTHEUPHILLCLIMBTHISEFFORTPOSES

.ATIONAL0ROGRAMS
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONPROVIDESPARENTSANDFAMILIESWITHAPOWERFULVOICETOSPEAKONBEHALFOFEVERY
CHILD7ITHANETWORKOFPARTNERSHIPS 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONEXPRESSESITSCONCERNSREGARDINGCHILDREN
INSTATELEGISLATURESANDON#APITOL(ILL!NYLOCALDISTRICTORSTATE0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCHAPTERCAN
BRINGMATTERSOFLEGISLATIVECONCERNTOTHEATTENTIONOFTHE.ATIONAL0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION4HROUGH
ITSSEPARATEPOLITICALACTIONCOMMITTEE 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONENDORSESCANDIDATESFORPUBLICOFlCEWHO
SUPPORTITSGOALS


,OCAL0ROGRAMS
"ECAUSE0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONISTHEONLYPARENTORGANIZATIONINTHECOUNTRYTHATISCENTRALIZEDAND
HASASTAFF ITHASTHECAPACITYTOKEEPPARENTSINFORMEDABOUTPRESSINGISSUESINTHESCHOOLSINTHEIR
AREAOFTHECOUNTRY.OTONLYDOES0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONPROVIDEINFORMATIONONTHEISSUES ITPROVIDES
ACCESSTOLOCALLYELECTEDREPRESENTATIVESASWELLASTHEAPPROPRIATESCHOOLDISTRICTADMINISTRATORSWHO
NEEDTOBECONTACTEDWHENCRUCIALDECISIONSAREBEINGMADE4HESTAFFALSOCANPROVIDESAMPLELETTERS E
MAILMESSAGES ANDTEMPLATESTHATCONCERNEDPARENTSCANUSETOVOICETHEIROPINIONS0ARENTSFOR%DUCA
TIONISABLETOMOBILIZEPARENTSQUICKLYANDEFlCIENTLYONISSUESOFIMPORTANCE

-EMBER"ENElTS
-EMBERSOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONHAVEACCESSTOA7EBSITERECEIVETHEMONTHLYMAGAZINE /UR
3CHOOLSATTENDTHEYEARLYCONVENTIONATDISCOUNTEDRATESANDRECEIVEANELECTRONICNEWSLETTERFROM
THEPRESIDENTONISSUESOFSPECIALCONCERN$UESCOLLECTEDBYLOCALCHAPTERSGODIRECTLYTOTHENATIONAL
CHAPTERTOMEETSTAFlNGANDADMINISTRATIONOBLIGATIONSTHATSUSTAINTHEORGANIZATIONWHILEFULlLLINGITS
COMMITMENTTOLOCALCHAPTERSANDITSLARGERMISSIONTOSERVEASTHEVOICEOFPARENTSANDCHILDRENOFTHE
NATIONONEDUCATIONISSUESTHATAFFECTEVERYHOUSEHOLD

.ATIONAL0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION'OALS
s 3UPPORTEXCELLENCEINTEACHINGANDSUPERBACADEMICOUTCOMESINSTUDENTLEARNING

s 3UPPORTINCREASEDSTATEANDFEDERALFUNDINGFOREDUCATION

s (ELPPARENTSDEVELOPTHEKNOWLEDGEANDSKILLSTHEYNEEDTOWORKFORTHEIMPROVEMENTOFTHEIR
CHILDRENSSCHOOLS

s %NCOURAGEPARENTALANDPUBLICINVOLVEMENTINSCHOOLSATAGRASSROOTSLEVEL

&OCAL)SSUE
(OWCAN0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONREMAINARELEVANT VIBRANTORGANIZATIONOVERTHENEXTTENYEARS
!STHEYLOOKTOWARDTHEFUTURE THELEADERSOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONKNOWTHEYFACESOMESERIOUS
CHALLENGES7ITHTHEPOPULATIONBECOMINGMORERACIALLYANDETHNICALLYDIVERSEANDTHEPROPORTIONOF
ELDERLYINCREASING 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCOULDONCEAGAINFACEADECLININGMEMBERSHIP DESPITETHE
CURRENTUPSWING4HISCOULDPRESENTAPOTENTIALLYSERIOUSCRISISINFUNDING4ODAY ONLYONEINFOUR
HOUSEHOLDSHASSCHOOL AGEDCHILDREN!STHEPROPORTIONOFHOUSEHOLDSWITHCHILDRENDECLINES ANDMORE
OFTHOSECHILDRENAREBORNINTOPOVERTY THELEADERSHAVEEMBARKEDUPONASCENARIO PLANNINGPROCESS
FOCUSEDONTHEEXTENTTOWHICHPARENTSHAVESCHOOLINGCHOICESFORTHEIRCHILDRENANDTHEAVAILABILITYOF
RESOURCESFOREDUCATION

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP !BUNDANT

!SSOCIATION3CENARIO h9OU#ANT!LWAYS
'ET7HAT9OU7ANTv
$EEP#AUSES

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATPARENTSHAVEEXTREMELY
LIMITEDCHOICESOFWHERETOSENDTHEIRCHILDRENTO

2ESOURCES
SCHOOL BUTPARENTSAREHAPPYWITHTHESITUATIONSINCE
THE&EDERALGOVERNMENTISFULLYFUNDINGTHEPUBLIC
SCHOOLSANDTHESTUDENTACHIEVEMENTLEVELISHIGH
3CARCE
4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO

s !MAJORECONOMICUPTURNHASMADEITPOSSIBLEFOR
THE&EDERALGOVERNMENTTOFULLYFUND.#," NURTURINGCOMMUNITIES ANDQUALITYPUBLICEDUCATION
s 0UBLICSCHOOLSARERECEIVINGFULLFUNDINGBUTTHE FORCHILDRENTHROUGHOUTTHE5NITED3TATES
GOVERNMENTHASINSISTEDONANATIONALCURRICULUM 4ODAY)CANHAPPILYSAYTHAT)HAVEACHIEVEDMY
NATIONALASSESSMENTS ANDNATIONALSTANDARDS GOALSAS0RESIDENTOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONANDASMOST
OFYOUALREADYKNOW )AMSTEPPINGDOWNIN3EPTEM
s #ONTINUEDCONCERNABOUT!MERICANSTUDENTS BERTOJOIN0RESIDENT-C#AINS#ABINETAS3ECRETARY
POORSHOWINGONINTERNATIONALASSESSMENTSSUCH OF%DUCATION4HISISANHONORTHATWOULDNEVERHAVE
AS4)--3 BEENPOSSIBLEWITHOUTTHEEXPERIENCEANDSUPPORT)
HAVEGAINEDASYOURLEADER4HEPASTTENYEARSHAVE
BEENEXHILARATINGAND0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONHASMADE
h9OU#ANT!LWAYS'ET7HAT ANINVALUABLECONTRIBUTIONTOTHEIMPROVEDSTATEOF
9OU7ANTv PUBLICSCHOOLSINTHE5NITED3TATES
4IME*UNE  7HEN)lRSTCAMEONAS0RESIDENTIN THE
FUTUREOFOURSCHOOLSANDOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONDID
0LACE7ASHINGTON $#
NOTLOOKHOPEFUL/URORGANIZATIONHADEXPERIENCED
3CENE3PECIAL.EWSLETTERFROMTHEPRESIDENTOF ACONTINUALDECLINEINMEMBERSHIP4HEFOCUSOF
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONTOITSMEMBERS 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONWASONSURVIVINGASANORGANIZA
TIONRATHERTHANONADVOCATINGFORSTUDENTS-OREAND
MORECHILDRENWEREBEINGENROLLEDINPRIVATEANDPARO
$EAR-EMBERS CHIALSCHOOLSORBEINGHOMESCHOOLED-ANYCHILDREN
WEREBEINGEDUCATEDTHROUGHONLINESCHOOLS SOME
3INCE MILLIONSOFPARENTSLIKEYOUHAVE
REPUTABLEANDOTHERSNOTSOREPUTABLE/URCOUNTRY
BELONGEDTOANORGANIZATIONTHATMAKESADIFFERENCE
WASEMBROILEDINAWARIN)RAQANDHADABUDGETDElCIT
ˆ0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION0&% AVISIONARYCOMMUNITY
INTHETRILLIONSOFDOLLARS4HE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
COMMITTEDTOIMPROVINGTHELIVESANDEDUCATIONOF
!CTOF.#," WHICHSHOULDHAVEBEENAFORCE
ALLCHILDREN7EAREAFORCEFORTHEGOODOFCHILDREN A
FORSCHOOLIMPROVEMENT WASCAUSINGARIFTWITHIN
SOURCEOFINFORMATIONANDSUPPORTFORPARENTS ANDA
STATESANDSCHOOLS ANDMUTINYWASONTHEMINDSOF
STRONGADVOCATEFORPUBLICEDUCATION0ARENTSFOR%DU
MANYSCHOOLPERSONNELANDSTATELEGISLATORS4OOMANY
CATIONWORKSFOREFFECTIVEPARENTINVOLVEMENT SAFEAND


)N THE!MERICAN%NTERPRISE)NSTITUTEFOR0UBLIC0OLICYWROTETHATMEMBERSHIPINTHE.ATIONAL04!HADDECLINEDFROMAHIGHOF
MILLIONINTOALOWOFMILLIONINHTTPWWWAEIORGPUBLICATIONSPUB)$ lLTERALLPUB?DETAILASP


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

SCHOOLSWEREFAILINGTOMAKEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESS 4HENEWLAWREPLACED.#,"ShONE SIZE lTS ALLv


!90 EVENTHEMOREAFmUENTSUBURBANSCHOOLS!S PROlCIENCYTARGETSWITHAMBITIOUSACHIEVEMENTTARGETS
DISTRICTSCONTINUEDTOMISS!90TARGETS STATEDE BASEDONRATESOFSUCCESSACTUALLYACHIEVEDBYTHEMOST
PARTMENTSOFEDUCATIONWERELEGALLYOBLIGATEDTOhDO EFFECTIVEPUBLICSCHOOLSANDALLOWEDSTATESTOMEASURE
SOMETHINGvBUTWEREILLEQUIPPEDTODEALWITHTHE PROGRESSBYUSINGSTUDENTSGROWTHINACHIEVEMENTAS
GROWINGNUMBEROFSCHOOLSIDENTIlEDASFAILING3TATES WELLASTHEIRPERFORMANCEINRELATIONTOPRE DETERMINED
ESPECIALLYTHEKEYELECTORALSTATESOF#ALIFORNIA &LORIDA LEVELSOFACADEMICPROlCIENCY.#,"))ALSOREQUIRED
4EXAS /HIO AND.EW9ORK HADNOMONEYTOFUNDTHE STATESTOUSEANATIONALASSESSMENTANDPROVIDEDIAG
NEEDEDIMPROVEMENTS ANDTHEFUTUREOFPUBLICEDUCA NOSTICINFORMATIONTOSCHOOLSTOIMPROVESTUDENTLEARN
TIONLOOKEDGRIMINDEED4HEREQUIREMENTOFFUNDING ING4HELAWALSOENSUREDTHATIMPROVEMENTPLANSHAD
EDUCATIONTOMEETTHEMANDATESOF.#,"WASMOVING SUFlCIENTTIMETOTAKEHOLDBEFOREAPPLYINGSANCTIONS
MANYSTATESTOTHEBRINKOFBANKRUPTCY ANDSTIPULATEDTHATSANCTIONSSHOULDNOTBEAPPLIEDIF
4HEINCREASINGLYANGRYMOODOFTHEVOTERSBROUGHT THEYUNDERMINEEXISTINGEFFECTIVEREFORMEFFORTS4HIS
AMOREMODERATEGROUPOFLEGISLATORSINTOOFlCEIN MAJORREVISIONTO.#,"HELPEDTHELAWACCOMPLISH
THE#ONGRESSIONALELECTIONSOF6OTERSWEREFED WHATITWASSUPPOSEDTOACCOMPLISHˆENSURETHATALL
UPWITHPOLITICALPOSTURINGIN#ONGRESS%VENTHOUGH CHILDRENLEARNEDTOREAD WRITE ANDCOMPUTEATLEAST
THE(OUSE 3ENATE AND7HITE(OUSEWERECONTROLLED ATGRADELEVELREGARDLESSOFRACE SOCIO ECONOMICSTATUS
BY2EPUBLICANS POLITICSHADBECOMEMORERANCOROUS NATIVELANGUAGE SPECIALNEEDS ORCOUNTRYOFORIGIN
ASTHEMAJORITYMOVEDFURTHERTOTHERIGHTWHILETHE 4HENEEDEDREVISIONSCONTAINEDIN.#,"))WOULD
MINORITYPARTYMOVEDTOWARDTHELEFT4HISCEN NOTHAVEBEENPOSSIBLEIFNOTFORTHEDRAMATICUPSWING
TRISTMAJORITYIN#ONGRESS LEDBY#ONGRESSMEN4IM INTHE53ECONOMY&OLLOWINGTHEHISTORIC)RAQI
*OHNSON2 ), AND3TEVE)SRAEL$ .9 WASABLETO ELECTIONSOF THE)RAQIGOVERNMENTHADREACHEDA
WORKINABIPARTISANFASHIONTOADDRESSTHESPIRALING STABILITYTHATALLOWEDFORTHEPULLOUTOFTHEMAJORITYOF
NATIONALDEBT0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCAMPAIGNEDHARD 53TROOPS4HEHISTORIC#AMP$AVID!CCORDOF
FORTHENEWCENTRISTLEADERS)TWASGRATIFYINGTOSEE BETWEEN0,/0RESIDENT-AHMOUD!BBASAND)SRAELI
OURCHOICESFOR#ONGRESSWORKINGTOGETHERTOWARDA 0RIME-INISTER!RIEL3HARONHADESTABLISHEDA0ALES
COMMONGOAL#ONGRESS WITHSIGNIlCANTINPUTFROM TINIAN3TATEANDANINCREASINGLYPROMISINGANDSTABLE
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION PASSEDINTOLAW.#,"))IN PEACEINTHEREGION4HEESTABLISHMENTOFADEMOCRATI
4HE*OINT/RGANIZATIONAL3TATEMENTON.O CALLYELECTEDGOVERNMENTIN,EBANON ALONGWITHTHE
#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTOFPROVIDEDAFRAMEWORK DEVELOPMENTSIN)RAQAND0ALESTINE GAVESUPPORTTO
FORTHE.#,")) THE2ICE0LANIN7ITHTHEINTERNATIONALCOM
MUNITYSUPPORTING3ECRETARY2ICESPLANFORECONOMIC
SUPPORTFORTHEDEVELOPINGGOVERNMENTSINTHE-IDDLE


$AVID3HREVE ANEDUCATIONPOLICYEXPERTATTHE.ATIONAL#ONFERENCEOF3TATE,EGISLATURESREPORTEDONCURRENTANDPROJECTED!90ISSUESIN
2ETRIEVED -AY  HTTPWWWNSBAORGSITEDOC?COSAASP42!#+)$#)$$)$

!PIVOTALEVENTCAMEIN-ARCH WHEN0RESIDENT"USHANDMANYCONSERVATIVESIN#ONGRESSATTEMPTEDTOINTERVENEINA&LORIDA
CONTROVERSYINVOLVINGTHEREMOVALOFAFEEDINGTUBEFOR4ERRI3CHIAVO&ULLYOFVOTERSFELTTHAT#ONGRESSANDTHE0RESIDENTHADOVERSTEPPED
THEIRBOUNDSHTTPABCNEWSGOCOM0OLITICS0OLL6AULTSTORYIDPAGE

4HEELECTIONOF(OWARD$EANAS#HAIROFTHE$EMOCRATIC.ATIONAL#OMMITTEEINALIENATEDMANY)NDEPENDENTANDEVENTRADITIONAL
$EMOCRATICVOTERS

)N&EBRUARY  2EPRESENTATIVES*OHNSONAND)SRAELFORMEDTHE#ONGRESSIONAL#ENTRIST#AUCUSHTTPWWWSIGNONSANDIEGOCOMUNIONTRIB
NEWS?NCIVILITYHTML

/VERNATIONALEDUCATIONANDRELIGIOUSORGANIZATIONSSIGNEDTHE*OINT/RGANIZATIONALSTATEMENTHTTPWWWNSBAORGSITEPRINTASP42!#
+)$6)$!#4)/.02).4#)$$)$

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

%ASTAND3OUTH!SIA THElNANCIALBURDENONTHE !BUNDANT


5NITED3TATESWASGREATLYREDUCED
4HEFOLLOWINGYEAR  SAWANUNPRECEDENTED h9OU#ANT!LWAYS
'ET7HAT9OU7ANTv
UPSWINGINTHEGROSSNATIONALPRODUCT'.0 ANDRE
DUCTIONINTHETRADEDElCITBROUGHTONBYTWORELATED

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
EVENTS!LONGSOUGHTAFTERGEOLOGICALBREAKTHROUGH

2ESOURCES
LEDTOANECONOMICALWAYTORECOVERTHEMASSIVE
AMOUNTSOFOILTRAPPEDINSHALEDEPOSITSINTHE7ESTERN
5NITED3TATES#OUPLEDWITHTHELARGE SCALEADOPTION
OFTHENEW CLEANBURNINGDIESELLEDTOENERGYSELF SUF
3CARCE
lCIENCYINTHE5NITED3TATES4HESETWODEVELOPMENTS
LEDTOADRAMATICREDUCTIONINTHECOSTOFOIL4HE
PRICEPERBARRELOFOILDROPPEDBELOWFORTHElRST
TIMESINCETHEADOPTIONOFTHE PRICEBANDFOR BOTHTHEEDUCATIONALNEEDSOFSTUDENTSTOCOMPETEON
/0%#CRUDEIN4HEREDUCTIONINENERGYCOSTS THEINTERNATIONALLEVELANDONNATIONALSECURITY)N
ALLOWED!MERICANINDUSTRYTOGAINAPRICEADVANTAGE EXCHANGEFORAGUARANTEEOFADEQUATEANDEQUITABLE
INTERNATIONALLY DRIVINGDOWNTHETRADEDElCIT FUNDINGFORALLSCHOOLS 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONAGREED
)N *OHN-C#AINWASELECTED0RESIDENT TOSUPPORTTHENATIONALCURRICULUM(ARKENINGBACK
#ANDIDATE-C#AINHADRUNONAPLATFORMOFCONTINUED TOTHE.ATIONAT2ISKREPORT POLITICIANSSEIZED
ECONOMICGROWTHANDTHECREATIONANDADOPTIONOF ONTHEMANTRA h)FANUNFRIENDLYFOREIGNPOWERHAD
ANATIONALCURRICULUM!FTERHISELECTION HEANDHIS ATTEMPTEDTOIMPOSEON!MERICATHEMEDIOCREEDU
#ABINETWEREDETERMINEDTOELIMINATEBUDGETDElCITS CATIONALPERFORMANCETHATEXISTSTODAY WEMIGHTWELL
ANDTHEIRADMINISTRATIONSETTHECOURSEFORANECO HAVEVIEWEDITASANACTOFWARv4HOUGHTHEDEBATEON
NOMICUPTURN2ELAXEDIMMIGRATIONPOLICIESFORFOREIGN THENATIONALIZATIONOFEDUCATIONWASHEATED ACOALI
SCIENTISTSANDENGINEERS ANDARISEINTHEVALUEOFTHE TIONOFORGANIZATIONSINCLUDING0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION
53DOLLARLEDTOASURGEINOURECONOMY AIDEDBY THE.ATIONAL%DUCATION!SSOCIATION .ATIONAL3CHOOL
THEGROWTHOFTHEBUSINESSOFNANOTECHNOLOGY BREAK "OARDS!SSOCIATION AND#OUNCILOF#HIEF3TATE3CHOOL
THROUGHSINSTEMCELLRESEARCH ANDTHERESURGENCEOF /FlCERSJOINEDINOVERWHELMINGSUPPORT4HE.A
THEHIGHTECHINDUSTRY4HEGROWTHSTARTEDSMALL BUT TIONAL'OVERNORS!SSOCIATIONOVERWHELMINGLYADDED
BYTHESTOCKMARKETHADREACHEDNEWHEIGHTSAND THEIRSUPPORTASEDUCATIONSPENDINGATTHESTATELEVEL
THEJOBLESSRATEHADREACHEDNEWLOWS-OREFAMILIES HADMOVEDOVERATHIRDOFTHESTATESTOTHEBRINKOF
THANEVERBEFOREWEREHOMEOWNERS CONTRIBUTINGTO BANKRUPTCY4HEDECIDINGFACTORWASTHEPROVISIONTHAT
THEPROPERTYTAXBASE EVENINLESSAFmUENTCOMMUNI MOVEDEDUCATIONFUNDINGTOTHENATIONALLEVELAND
TIES)TWASNOSURPRISETHAT0RESIDENT-C#AINWAS STATED h.OEDUCATIONLAWORPOLICYSHALLBEENACTED
EASILYRE ELECTEDTHATYEAR WITHOUTTHEFUNDINGNEEDEDTOIMPLEMENTSAIDPOLICYv
0RESIDENT-C#AINALSOKEPTHISCAMPAIGNPROMISE 4HEREHAVEBEENMULTIPLECOURTCHALLENGESBYAFEW
OFADVOCATINGFORANATIONALCURRICULUM ACCOMPA 7ESTERNSTATESANDTHE!MERICAN,IBERTARIAN0ARTY BUT
NIEDBYNATIONALASSESSMENTSANDANATIONALTEACHER TODATE NOCOURTHASISSUEDANINJUNCTION
LICENSE7HILE0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONWASINITIALLYQUITE
LEERYOFTHISIDEA WElNALLYDIDSEETHENEEDBASEDON


742'%NERGY%CONOMICS.EWSLETTER /CTOBER 2ETRIEVED-ARCH  FROMHTTPWWWWTRGCOMPRICESHTM

.ATIONAL#OMMISSIONOF%XCELLENCEIN%DUCATION !.ATIONAT2ISK4HE)MPERATIVEFOR%DUCATIONAL2EFORM7ASHINGTON $#53
'OVERNMENT0RINTING/FlCE


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

!SACONDITIONFORFULLYFUNDING.#," #ONGRESS PAROCHIALSCHOOLSBEGANTOCOMPETEFORPLACESINTHESE


HADINSISTEDONASINGLESETOFSTANDARDS ANATIONALCUR PUBLICSCHOOLS
RICULUM ANDANATIONALASSESSMENTSYSTEM!TlRSTTHIS !SPARENTSHADLOSTCONlDENCEINTHEQUALITYOF
STRUCKOURMEMBERSASTOOCONTROLLING.OBODYWAS !MERICANPUBLICSCHOOLS ENROLLMENTHADDECLINED
HAPPYABOUTGIVINGUPLOCALCONTROLOFTHEIRSCHOOLS FROMPERCENTINTOANALL TIMELOWOF
ORLEAVINGTHEIRCHILDRENSEDUCATIONINTHEHANDSOF PERCENTIN7EAREPLEASEDTOREPORTTHATENROLL
7ASHINGTON $#(OWEVER AFTERAFEWYEARSITBECAME MENTINPUBLICSCHOOLSISAGAINONTHERISE WITH
CLEARTHATTHERESULTSWEREWORTHTHECOMPROMISE4HE PERCENTOFALLSTUDENTSENROLLEDINPUBLICSCHOOLSIN
ADVANTAGESOFANATIONALCURRICULUMSOONBECAME 
EVIDENT.OLONGERWOULDMULTIPLICATIONBETAUGHTIN 5SINGTHEMODELFORFREECITYWIDEWIRELESSCON
SECONDGRADEINONECOMMUNITYANDINTHIRDGRADEIN NECTIVITYlRSTIMPLEMENTEDBY0HILADELPHIAIN
THENEXTNORWOULDELECTRICITYBETAUGHTINTHIRDGRADE COMMUNITIESACROSSTHECOUNTRYSAWTHEECONOMIC
INONECITYANDINFOURTHINTHENEXT7ITHTHEEXCEP ADVANTAGEINPROVIDINGACCESSTOEVERYONE4HEUBIQ
TIONOFLOCALHISTORYANDHOLIDAYS STUDENTSWHOWORK UITYOFWIRELESSTECHNOLOGYANDSTUDENTSABILITYTOTAKE
THEIRWAYTHROUGHTHECOUNTRYSPUBLICSCHOOLSNOW ADVANTAGEOFITMADEITPOSSIBLEFORSTUDENTSTOACCESS
COVERTHESAMEMATERIALATAPPROXIMATELYTHESAME THEIRCURRICULUM THEIRTEACHER ANDTHEIRASSIGNMENTS
TIMEOFYEAR REGARDLESSOFWHATSCHOOLTHEYAREIN4HIS FROMWHEREVERTHEYMIGHTBE3OASTHEPOPULATION
ISGOODNEWSFOROURINCREASINGLYMOBILESOCIETYAS SHIFTSANDCHANGES STUDENTSMOVINGFROMSTATETOSTATE
CHILDRENMOVEFROMONETOWNTOANOTHERORONESTATE ORCOMMUNITYTOCOMMUNITYLOSEVERYLITTLEINTHE
TOANOTHER THEYWILLNOLONGERHAVETOSUFFERTHROUGH TRANSFERASSCHOOLSMOVETOWARDSACURRICULUMINWHICH
THESAMECURRICULUMTHEYDIDTHEYEARBEFORE NOR THESAMEBASICKNOWLEDGEANDSKILLSARECOVEREDIN
WILLTHEYHAVETOSTRUGGLETOKEEPUPBECAUSETHEYVE EVERYCOMMUNITY4HE3CHOOL)NTEROPERABILITY&RAME
MOVEDTOANEWSCHOOLINTHEMIDDLEOFCHALLENGING WORK3)& DEVELOPEDINANDMANDATEDBYTHE
CONTENTTHEYHAVENEVERSEENBEFORE4HISISAVERY 53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONIN COUPLEDWITH
DIFFERENTSITUATIONTHANTHEONEYOUAND)GREWUPWITH THISUBIQUITOUSACCESSTOTHE)NTERNET ALLOWEDSCHOOLS
ANDITTAKESOURSTANDARDS BASEDCURRICULUMTOAWHOLE DISTRICTS ANDSTATESTOMAINTAINACOMMONDATABASEOF
NEWLEVEL STUDENTINFORMATION
"YPUBLICSCHOOLSHADBEENRECEIVINGAD &ORTHEMOSTPART OURFEARSABOUTALLCHILDRENBEING
EQUATEFUNDINGFROM.#,"))FORTWOYEARSANDMOST LUMPEDTOGETHER DOINGTHESAMEWORKATTHESAME
SCHOOLSWERETHRIVING4HEDIVIDEWASNOLONGER TIMEWITHNOINDIVIDUALIZEDINSTRUCTION HAVENOTCOME
BETWEENGOODSCHOOLANDBADSCHOOLS BUTRATHER GOOD TOPASS7HILETHENATIONALCURRICULUMANDASSESSMENT
SCHOOLSANDGREATSCHOOLS/URORGANIZATIONFOCUSEDON INSURETHATALLSTUDENTSARELEARNINGTHESAMEMATERIAL
WORKINGWITHSCHOOLSTOINSURETHATTHENATIONALIZATION ATAPPROXIMATELYTHESAMETIME NATIONALTEACHERLI
OFEDUCATIONDIDNOTLEADTOAhONESIZElTSALLvEDUCA CENSUREHASREQUIREDALLTEACHERSBETRAINEDINRESEARCH
TION/URMEMBERSWEREABLETOUSETHOSESUCCESSFUL BASEDINSTRUCTIONALSTRATEGIES4HESESTRATEGIESHAVE
SCHOOLSASMODELSANDTHEYBEGANTOMOUNTPRESSURE HELPEDTEACHERSREACHSTUDENTSWITHDIFFERINGLEARNING
ONTHESCHOOLLEADERSINTHEIRCOMMUNITIESTOINSTITUTE STYLES3CHOOLSOFEDUCATIONHAVEBEENENCOURAGEDTO
SOMEOFTHESAMEREFORMSGOALSETTINGTRAININGFOR TEACHTHESETEACHINGSTRATEGIESTOTHEIRTEACHERCAN
SCHOOLLEADERSINDIVIDUALIZEDINSTRUCTIONFORSTUDENTS DIDATESSOTHEYCANGAINAPPRENTICELICENSURESTATUS
ONGOINGANDHIGH QUALITYPROFESSIONALDEVELOPMENTFOR UPONGRADUATION4EACHERLICENSUREISNOWBASEDONA
TEACHERS3OON THEPARENTSOFSTUDENTSINPRIVATEAND TEACHERSABILITYTOAPPLYRESEARCH BASEDTEACHINGSTRAT


3/52#%53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION .#%3 3CHOOLSAND3TAFlNG3URVEY3!33 h0UBLIC 0UBLIC#HARTER AND0RIVATE3CHOOLS
3URVEYS v 0REVIOUSLYPUBLISHEDASTABLEONPOF0RIVATE3CHOOLS!"RIEF0ORTRAIT;.#%3 =

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

EGIESTHROUGHANAPPRENTICESHIPPROGRAMLOOSELYBASED !BUNDANT
ON.ATIONAL"OARDFOR0ROFESSIONAL4EACHING3TANDARDS
."043  h9OU#ANT!LWAYS
'ET7HAT9OU7ANTv
,ETMEREVIEWONCEAGAIN JUSTHOWFARWEVECOME
SINCEMYlRSTTERMAS0RESIDENTOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCA

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
TION$URINGMYlRSTTERM OURMEMBERSHIPDROPPED

2ESOURCES
PRECIPITATIVELYDUETOAFALLINGBIRTHRATEANDANAGING
POPULATION4HEBABYBOOMERSWEREVOTINGAGAINST
RAISINGTAXESORPASSINGBONDISSUESFORTHESCHOOLSTHE
BIRTHRATEWASDROPPINGANDTHOSEWOMENWHOWERE
3CARCE
HAVINGBABIESWEREMOREOFTENTHANNOTYOUNGAND
POOR)TLOOKEDASTHOUGH0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONMIGHT
GOTHEWAYOFTHEDESKTOPˆOBLIVION"UTTHANKSTO
THEGRASSROOTSEFFORTSOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONSLOCAL CHALLENGESINCLUDEPARENTSTIMECONSTRAINTS INCREAS
CHAPTERSANDOURh3CHOOLSFOR!LLvPARTNERSHIPWITH INGCULTURALDIFFERENCES ANDANINSIDIOUSNEWFACTOR
THE!MERICAN!SSOCIATIONFOR2ETIRED0EOPLE WEHAVE COMPLACENCY4HEPUBLICSCHOOLSWORKBETTERTHAN
BROUGHTTHEhSIXTIESvGENERATION NOWINTHEIRSIXTIES THEYHAVEINALONGTIME4HEREUSEDTOBEAVASTGULF
INTOTHEPUBLICSCHOOLSASORGANIZERS TUTORS VOLUNTEERS BETWEENTHEhGOODvSCHOOLSANDTHEhBADvSCHOOLS
ANDCONTINUINGLEARNERS9OUREFFORTSCREATEDREALISTIC 4HATGULFHASBEENSIGNIlCANTLYREDUCED4HETALKNOW
INCENTIVESFORBABYBOOMERSTOHAVEAREALSTAKEINTHE ISNOTOFGOODANDBADSCHOOLS BUTGOODANDGREAT
EDUCATIONOFCHILDRENANDSEETHEIMPORTANCEOFTHE SCHOOLS-OSTPARENTSAREVERYSATISlEDWITHTHEEDUCA
LOCALSCHOOLBUILDINGASAHUBFORALLGENERATIONS!ND TIONOFTHEIRCHILDRENANDWEARENOWINDANGEROF
)AMTHRILLEDTOREPORTTHATOURSENIORMEMBERSARE LOSINGTHEMTOCOMPLACENCY0ERHAPSWEVEDONEOUR
MAKINGANENORMOUSDIFFERENCE!FULLTHIRDOF0ARENTS JOBTOOWELL
FOR%DUCATIONSCURRENTMEMBERSAREOVER4HEY )FWECONTINUEWORKINGTOGETHERWECANMAKEIT
CLEARLYUNDERSTANDTHEVALUEOFAGOODEDUCATIONAND EASIERFORBUSYPARENTSWHOARECURRENTLYNON MEMBERS
THEIMPORTANCEOFCOMMUNITY!SMUCHASANYADDI ANDEVENMORESENIORSTOBECOMEINVOLVEDWITHOUR
TIONALFUNDINGTHESCHOOLSARERECEIVING THEIMPROVE ORGANIZATION7ECANREACHOUTTOWIDELYDIVERSECOM
MENTINPUBLICEDUCATIONISDUETOTHESELmESSNESS MUNITIESINWAYSTHATCANMAKEADIFFERENCETOTODAYS
CREATIVITY ANDENERGYOFOURMEMBERSWHOAREAND TRADITIONALANDNON TRADITIONALFAMILIES ANDWECAN
OLDER)HAVERECOMMENDEDTO0RESIDENT ELECT3ANCHEZ PROVIDETRAININGANDRESOURCESTOSTRENGTHENMEMBERS
ANDYOUREXECUTIVEBOARDTHATOURORGANIZATIONSNAME LEADERSHIPANDADVOCACYSKILLS/URORGANIZATIONHAS
BECHANGEDFROM0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONTO!MERICANS DEMONSTRATEDTHEPOWERTOCREATECHANGEANDBUILDA
FOR1UALITY%DUCATIONTOREmECTTHISPOSITIVECHANGEIN BETTERFUTUREFOROURNATIONSCHILDREN
OURORGANIZATION)HOPETHATWILLBEONEOF$R3AN
CHEZSlRSTACTIONSASYOURNEW0RESIDENT
4ODAYITISWITHGREATPLEASURETHAT)AMABLETO
REPORTTOYOUTHEEXCELLENTSTATEOFOUR!MERICAN
PUBLICSCHOOLS THANKSINLARGEPARTTOTHEDILIGENTWORK
OFOURMEMBERS"UTOURWORKISNOTDONE/URNEW


4HElVECOREPRINCIPALSOFTHE."043ARE4EACHERSARECOMMITTEDTOSTUDENTSANDTHEIRLEARNING TEACHERSKNOWTHESUBJECTSTHEYTEACH
ANDHOWTOTEACHTHOSESUBJECTSTOSTUDENTS TEACHERSARERESPONSIBLEFORMANAGINGANDMONITORINGSTUDENTLEARNING TEACHERSTHINKSYSTEMATICALLY
ABOUTTHEIRPRACTICEANDLEARNFROMEXPERIENCE ANDTEACHERSAREMEMBERSOFLEARNINGCOMMUNITIES


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

)HAVEBEENHONOREDTOBE0RESIDENTOF0ARENTSFOR POLITICALPRESSURETOCHANGETHESYSTEMTOBETTERMEET
%DUCATIONFORTHEPASTTENYEARS)FEELCONlDENTTHAT) THENEEDSOFTHESEPOPULATIONS
AMLEAVINGITASTRONGERANDMOREVIBRANTORGANIZATION !SSCHOOLSINCREASINGLYOPENTHEIRDOORSTOTHE
THANITWASWHEN)ARRIVED)BELIEVETHAT)AMLEAVING PUBLICANDBECOMECOMMUNITYHUBS SUPPORTFOR
ITINSUPREMELYCAPABLEHANDS)WISH$R3ANCHEZAND SCHOOLSSHOULDALSOINCREASE7HILETHEPERCENTAGEOF
THEINCOMING%XECUTIVE"OARDALLTHEBESTAND)HAVE FAMILIESWITHSCHOOL AGESTUDENTSWILLDECLINE SUPPORT
CONlDENCETHATTHEYWILLCONTINUETOHELPPARENTS FORSCHOOLSANDSCHOOLINGSHOULDREMAINHIGHIFALL
SCHOOLS ANDCOMMUNITIESUNDERSTANDNOTONLYTHE STAKEHOLDERSFEELCONNECTEDTOTHESCHOOL
IMPORTANCEOFPARTNERSHIP BUTHOWEACHINDIVIDUAL &INALLY HISTORYHASSHOWNTHEECONOMYTOBECYCLIC
CANBECOMEINVOLVEDTOIMPROVETHELIVESOFALLOUR 7HILERESOURCESARECURRENTLYVERYABUNDANT WHATWILL
CHILDREN HAPPENASTHEECONOMYDECLINES

"ESTWISHES )NDICATORS
-ARY2OLLINS7ASHINGTON $# 4HISSCENARIOSEEMSLIKELYTOHAPPENGIVENTHEFOLLOW
.ATIONAL0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION0RESIDENT n INGINDICATORS

s )NCREASINGDISSATISFACTIONWITHPUBLICEDUCATION
!NALYSISOF3CENARIO
s &AILUREOFTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTTO
)MPLICATIONS ACCOMPLISHITSINTENDEDOUTCOMES
4HEIMPLICATIONSFOR0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONINTHIS
s $RAMATICUPTURNINTHE53ECONOMY
SCENARIOAREPRIMARILYPOLITICAL7HILERESOURCESARE
ABUNDANT SCHOOLWERESTILLNOTABLETOMEETTHENEEDS s 0ASSAGEOFLEGISLATIONTHATESTABLISHESANATIONAL
OFALLSTUDENTS4HISBROUGHTABOUTTHEADOPTIONOFA CURRICULUM COUPLEDWITHNATIONALASSESSMENTS
NATIONALCURRICULUM NATIONALASSESSMENT ANDNATIONAL
TEACHERLICENSURE INEXCHANGEFORFUNDING! s .ATIONALTEACHERLICENSURE
NATIONALCURRICULUMHASTHEPOTENTIALTOIMPROVETHE
EDUCATIONALEXPERIENCESOFMANYCHILDREN BUTATTHE /PTIONS
SAMETIME LEVELINGTHEEDUCATIONALLANDSCAPEMIGHT "ASEDONTHEIMPLICATIONSINTHISSCENARIO ITIS
ALSOREMOVETHEHIGHPOINTSASITREMOVESTHEVALLEYS IMPORTANTTHATTHEORGANIZATIONSEEKNOWTOBROADEN
)NTHISSCENARIO BOTHGIFTEDANDSEVERELYHANDICAPPED THEIRMEMBERSHIPBASE%FFORTSNOWTOBUILDSTRONGAL
STUDENTSAREUNDERSERVED4HISLIKELYWOULDLEADTO LIANCESWITHOTHERNATIONALORGANIZATIONSREPRESENTING
SENIORS SPECIALNEEDSSTUDENTS ANDGIFTEDSTUDENTSWILL
MAKETHEORGANIZATIONSTRONGERANDMORERESPONSIVE
TOTHEDIVERSENEEDSOFALLPOPULATIONS4HEORGANIZA
TIONSHOULDBEANACTIVEVOICEFORALLSTUDENTSASTHE
NATIONALCURRICULUMISDEVELOPEDANDIMPLEMENTED)T
SHOULDBETHEGOALOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONTOLOBBYFOR
ALLSTUDENTS NOTMOSTSTUDENTS
!STHEECONOMYBEGINSTOIMPROVE 0ARENTSFOR
%DUCATIONSHOULDBEASTRONG CLEARVOICEFOREDUCATION
HELPINGSHAPETHENATIONALAGENDARATHERTHANREACTTOIT

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP !BUNDANT

!SSOCIATION3CENARIO
$EEP#AUSES

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
)NTHISSCENARIO THE53+nEDUCATIONSYSTEMIS
hONE SIZE lTS ALLv4HEREISONESETOFNATIONALSTANDARDS

2ESOURCES
THEPUBLICSCHOOLSDELIVERONENATIONALCURRICULUMALL
h)#ANT'ET.O
PUBLICSCHOOLTEACHERSMUSTADHERETOANATIONALSET 3ATISFACTIONv
OFINSTRUCTIONALPRACTICESANDALLSTUDENTSAREREQUIRED
TOPASSONENATIONALTESTEVERYTWOYEARSANDANEXIT 3CARCE
EXAMTOGRADUATEFROMHIGHSCHOOL0ARENTSPOSSESS
VERYFEWSCHOOLCHOICESUNLESSTHEYWANTTOSPENDTHEIR
OWNMONEYFORPRIVATESCHOOLS4HEGOVERNMENTHAS
MINIMALDOLLARSTOSPENDIMPROVINGSCHOOLS h)#ANT'ET.O3ATISFACTIONv
4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO 4IME*UNE 
0LACE7ASHINGTON $#
s )NTHEELECTIONSOF THENEW0RESIDENTAND
MEMBERSOF#ONGRESSRUNONCAMPAIGNPROMISES 3CENE3PECIALNEWSLETTERFROMTHEPRESIDENTOF
TOREPEALTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTOF 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONTOITSMEMBERS
.#," WHICHHASFALLENINTODISFAVORAMONGA
MAJORITYOF!MERICANS

s #ONGRESSREPEALS.#,"INAND FOLLOWING $EAR-EMBERS


ANASTONISHINGLYRAPIDADOPTIONOFACONSTITU
&ORALMOSTlFTYYEARS 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION0&%
TIONALAMENDMENT MANDATESASETOFNATIONAL
HASBEENMAKINGABENElCIALDIFFERENCEINTHELIVES
ACADEMICSTANDARDS ANATIONALCURRICULUM ASET
OFPARENTS THEIRCHILDREN ANDTHEIRSCHOOLS4HROUGH
OFNATIONALINSTRUCTIONALSTANDARDS ANDNATIONAL
GOODTIMESANDBAD WEHAVEBANDEDTOGETHERAROUND
EXAMINATIONS
SEVERALBASICGOALSTHATHAVEGUIDEDOURWORK4HE
s /WINGTOTHEEXPENDITUREOFBILLIONSOFDOLLARSIN GOALSOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONARETHESE
DEFENSEAGAINSTTERRORATHOMEANDABROAD THE
s 3UPPORTEXCELLENCEINTEACHINGANDSUPERB
COUNTRYCONTINUESTOSTRUGGLEWITHLARGEBUDGET
ACADEMICOUTCOMESINSTUDENTLEARNING
DElCITSANDDIMINISHINGDISCRETIONARYSPENDING
s 3UPPORTINCREASEDSTATEANDFEDERALFUNDINGFOR
s "YTHEYEAR lERCE INTERGENERATIONAL
EDUCATION
ELECTORALCOMPETITIONBREAKSOUTBETWEENTHE
YOUNGANDTHEOLD ANDBECAUSEOFTHEIRNUMERIC s (ELPPARENTSDEVELOPTHEKNOWLEDGEANDSKILLS
SUPERIORITY THEGOVERNMENTBACKSTHEOLDER THEYNEEDTOWORKFORTHEIMPROVEMENTOFTHEIR
GENERATIONANDPAYSOUTWHATLITTLEFREEMONIES CHILDRENSSCHOOLS
ITHASTO3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARERECIPIENTS
LEAVINGEVERDECREASINGAMOUNTSFOR+n s %NCOURAGEPARENTALANDPUBLICINVOLVEMENTIN
EDUCATION SCHOOLSATAGRASSROOTSLEVEL


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

!,OOK"ACK AMOUNTSOFFOREIGNINDEBTEDNESS THEWARAGAINSTTERROR


4ODAY 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONFACESANUNPRECEDENT ANDWIDESPREADPUBLICDISSATISFACTIONWITH.#,"
EDDILEMMAINITSHISTORY ANDTHESIGNSFORITSFUTURE PRODUCEDADOMESTICPOLITICALBLOWBACKINTHEDOMAIN
AREDISCOURAGING7HEN)lRSTWASELECTEDPRESIDENT OF+nEDUCATION)TSEASYTOFORGETTHATSINCETHE
INTHEFUTUREOFOURSCHOOLSANDOF0ARENTSFOR FOUNDINGOFOURCOUNTRY UNTILTHISCURRENTADMINISTRA
%DUCATIONWASNOTPROMISING BUTTHECURRENTSTATEOF TION STATESWERERESPONSIBLEFOR+nEDUCATION AND
AFFAIRSISEVENMOREUNCERTAIN%ARLYINMYTENURE WE ALLSTATESDELEGATED+nEDUCATIONTOLOCALSCHOOLDIS
WERELOSINGMEMBERS4HEREWASLITTLECOMMITMENT TRICTS4HROUGHTIME OFCOURSE THISMEANTDIFFERENT
ONTHEPARTOFTHEDWINDLINGNUMBERSOFPARENTSOF EDUCATIONSYSTEMS ANDATLEAST PERMUTATIONS
SCHOOL AGEDCHILDRENTOADVOCATEFORTHEBENElTSOF BASEDONTHENUMBEROFSCHOOLDISTRICTSINTHE5NITED
PUBLICEDUCATION-OREANDMORECHILDRENWEREBEING 3TATES MOSTLYFUNDEDBYLOCALPROPERTYTAXES4HIS
ENROLLEDINPRIVATESCHOOLS PAROCHIALSCHOOLS ORBEING SITUATIONWASGOVERNEDBYTHETH!MENDMENTTOTHE
HOME SCHOOLED3OMECHILDRENWEREALREADYRECEIV #ONSTITUTION MEANINGTHATAUTHORITYNOTDELEGATEDTO
INGTHEIREDUCATIONONLINE/URCOUNTRYWASHEAVILY THEFEDERALGOVERNMENTWASRESERVEDTOTHESTATES
INVESTEDINTHEWARIN)RAQANDOTHERANTI TERRORIST "YTHETIMETHEN 3ENATOR&RISTRANFORPRESIDENT
INITIATIVES ANDWASSUSTAININGSERIALBUDGETDElCITS THE!MERICANPUBLICWASALARMEDBYTHEAPPARENT
INTHEBILLIONSOFDOLLARS4HE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND DECLINEINOURCOMPARATIVEACADEMICACCOMPLISHMENTS
!CT.#," WHICHWASPASSEDWITHMUCHBI PARTI VIS Ü VISOURPRINCIPALTRADEPARTNERSˆANALARM
SANGOODWILLIN SHOULDHAVEBEENAFORCEFOR INGDECLINEINFOREIGNNATIONALSTAKINGADVANTAGEOF
GOOD5NFORTUNATELY ITSAPPLICATIONANDENFORCEMENT !MERICAN0H$PROGRAMS ESPECIALLYINMATHEMATICS
CAUSEDABACKLASHBETWEENMANYSTATESANDTHEFEDERAL SCIENCE ANDENGINEERINGTHOUSANDSMORE#HINESEAND
GOVERNMENT RIFTSWITHINSTATES ANDDIVISIONSWITHIN )NDIANENGINEERINGGRADUATESTHANSIMILAR!MERICAN
SCHOOLCOMMUNITIES4OOMANYSCHOOLSWEREFAILING GRADUATESANDCONTINUEDPOORTESTRESULTSINMATH
TOMAKEADEQUATEYEARLYPROGRESS!90 EVENTHE EMATICSANDSCIENCEAMONG!MERICAN+nSTUDENTS
MOREAFmUENTSUBURBANSCHOOLS/THERSCHOOLSWERE COMPAREDWITHMANYOFOURMOSTCOMPETITIVETRADING
BEINGTAKENOVERORSHUTDOWNCOMPLETELY4HESTATES PARTNERS!TTHESAMETIME OURSENSEOFVULNERABILITY
ESPECIALLYTHEMOSTHIGHLYPOPULOUSSTATES HADVERY TOACTSOFTERRORISM BOTHATHOMEANDABROAD HADNOT
LITTLEMONEYTOFUNDIMPROVEMENTSNECESSARYTOMEET ABATED6OTERSWEREREADYFORAFUNDAMENTALCHANGEIN
THEREQUIREMENTSOF.#," SODISCONTENTWITHTHELAW THESYSTEM
ANDTHE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONROSETOANEARLY $URINGHISPRESIDENTIALCAMPAIGN INANOFF THE CUFF
MUTINOUSLEVELAMONGTHESTATES REPLYTOABLOGGERSQUESTIONABOUTTHEPOORSTATEOF
!TTHESAMETIME ECONOMICCOMPETITIONWITHOUR EDUCATIONINTHECOUNTRY 3ENATOR&RISTCOMMENTED
MAJORTRADINGPARTNERSBEGANTOESCALATE!SYOUKNOW THATPERHAPSITWASTIMETOREVISITTHETH!MEND
ATTHEENDOFTHETHCENTURY AFTERYEARSOFSTRENU MENTANDTHEFEDERALROLEINEDUCATION7HENPRESSED
OUSNATIONALEFFORT THE5NITED3TATESHADWONTHE THECANDIDATEEXPLAINEDTHATHEBELIEVEDTHEOLD
#OLD7AR!LMOSTIMMEDIATELYTHEREAFTER ATTHESTART SYSTEMOFLOCALCONTROLOF+nEDUCATIONWASOUTDATED
OFTHESTCENTURY WEENTEREDAPERIODOFUNPARAL BECAUSETHENEWCENTURYBROUGHTWITHITEDUCATIONAL
LELEDTRADEWARSWITHCOUNTRIESWHODIDNOTANDDONOT CHALLENGESTHATCOULDBEADDRESSEDBESTONLYBYFEDERAL
SHAREOURPOLITICALANDCULTURALVALUES3OMEOFTHOSE EFFORT)NSTEADOFTRYINGTOIMPLEMENTEDUCATIONAL
COUNTRIES PARTICULARLY)NDIAAND#HINA WEREGRADUAT REFORMSPIECE MEALTHROUGHTHETRADITIONALMEANSOF
INGTHOUSANDSMOREENGINEERSANDSCIENTISTSTHANTHE FEDERALCARROTSANDSTICKS HESAID WESHOULDAMEND
5NITED3TATES FURTHERHEIGHTENING!MERICANSFEARS THE#ONSTITUTIONTOPERMITTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTTO
CONCERNINGOURSTRATEGICTRADECOMPETITIVENESSAND ASSUMERESPONSIBILITYFOR+nEDUCATION
PRIMACYINTHEWORLD .ATURALLY 3ENATOR&RISTSCOMMENTSWEREFUELFOR
4HISNATIONALANXIETY COMBINEDWITHINCREAS AMEDIAlRESTORMWITHPEOPLEEXPRESSINGASTONISH
INGBUDGETDElCITS CURRENTACCOUNTDElCITS MASSIVE MENTTHATACONSERVATIVE2EPUBLICANWASPROPOSINGTO

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

ABANDONTHELONG CHERISHEDSYSTEMOFhLOCALCONTROLv !BUNDANT


OFEDUCATION0UNDITSATlRSTTHOUGHTTHISWOULDBE
THEDEATH KNELLFORTHE&RISTCAMPAIGN BUTTHEOP
POSITEOCCURRED5NEXPECTEDLY VOTERSSTEADILYWARMED
TOTHEIDEA)TGAVETHEMASENSEOFSECURITYTHATWE

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
WERElNALLYGOINGTOGETOUREDUCATIONALSYSTEMUNDER

2ESOURCES
CONTROLANDREGAINOURSUPERIORITYINTHEWORLD3OME
CONGRESSIONALCANDIDATESANDMEMBERSOF#ONGRESS h)#ANT'ET.O
3ATISFACTIONv
JUMPEDONTHEBANDWAGON SETTINGANEXAMPLEFOR
OTHERSTOFOLLOW0UBLICSUPPORTSLOWLYBUILT AND
3CARCE
3ENATOR&RISTWASELECTEDPRESIDENT DESPITETHERISKHE
HADTAKEN1UICKLYFOLLOWINGHISELECTION #ONGRESS
PASSEDACONSTITUTIONALAMENDMENTFEDERALIZING+n
EDUCATIONINTHE5NITED3TATES3TATES INTURN RATI s !SEEMINGINABILITYTOTRAINTEACHERSPROPERLYTO
lEDTHEAMENDMENT)NTHEWAKEOFTHEAMENDMENTS MEETTHENEEDSOF!MERICANSTUDENTSFACINGTHE
PASSAGE FEDERALAUTHORIZINGLEGISLATIONABOLISHEDLOCAL COMPETITIVERIGORSOFTHESTCENTURY
PROPERTYTAXESEARMARKEDTOFUNDLOCALSCHOOLS ANDIN
THEIRSTEADESTABLISHEDANATIONALSALESTAXTOPAYFOR )TISNOTMYINTENTIONINTHISLETTERTOPAINTAHOPELESS
+nSCHOOLING PICTUREOFOUREDUCATIONSYSTEM/NTHECONTRARY )
lRMLYBELIEVEINOURNATIONSFUTURE"UTAS)TAKEMY
4HE#URRENT3ITUATION LEAVE )MUSTSPEAKTHETRUTHAS)SEEITANDACKNOWL
EDGEOPENLYTHECONSTRAINTSWEFACE/NLYWITHACLEAR
7ITHSOMUCHSUPPORTFORTHISNEWAPPROACH
VIEWOFWHEREWEHAVEBEENCANTHOSEOFYOUWHOWILL
TO!MERICANEDUCATION WHYISTHEPICTURETODAYSO
CONTINUETHElGHTFORHIGH QUALITYPUBLICEDUCATION
GLOOMY!S)TAKEMYLEAVEOFTHISlNEORGANIZATION
CHARTYOURPATHTOTHEFUTURE
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONFACESDAUNTINGCHALLENGESTOITS
MISSION!MONGTHEMARETHESE
$EMOGRAPHICS %CONOMICS AND.ATIONAL3ECURITY
s !RAPIDLYAGINGPOPULATIONWITHWANING 0ERMITMETOELABORATEONTHEDEMOGRAPHICCHAL
COMMITMENTTOTHEEDUCATIONOFOURCHILDREN LENGEFACINGOURORGANIZATIONANDOURPUBLICSCHOOLS
4HENUMBEROFCHILDRENPERHOUSEHOLDCONTINUESTO
s !FEDERALGOVERNMENTSTRUGGLINGTOBALANCE
DROPANDTHENUMBEROFCHILDRENBORNTOMARRIED
SPENDINGBETWEENTHENEEDSOFOURSENIORCITIZENS
COUPLESISLEADINGTHATDROP)NMOSTFAMILIESWITHTWO
ANDOURYOUNG
PARENTS BOTHPARENTSAREWORKING4HENUMBEROFCHIL
s #OLOSSALEXPENDITURESREQUIREDTOlGHTTHE DRENBEINGRAISEDBYSINGLEMOTHERSINPOVERTYISRISING
CONTINUINGWARONTERRORANDPERSISTENTBUDGET !CCORDINGLY THERESIMPLYAREFEWERPARENTSTHANTHERE
ANDTRADEDElCITS ALLOFWHICHCOMPETEFOR ONCEWERETOJOINANDSUPPORT0ARENTSFOR%DUCA
DOMESTICDISCRETIONARYSPENDING TION7EAREGRATEFULFORTHOSEPARENTSWHORECOGNIZE
THEIMPORTANCEOFBEINGINVOLVEDINTHEIRCHILDRENS
s 0ARENTSWHOAREWORKINGLONGERHOURSANDIN EDUCATIONANDWHOAREABLETOJOINBECAUSETHEYHAVE
SOMECASESAREHOLDINGDOWNTWOANDTHREEJOBS THETIMEANDTHEMONEY5NFORTUNATELY THEYDONOT
INORDERTOMAKEENDSMEET REPRESENTTHEBROADSPECTRUMOFCHILDRENINOURSCHOOLS
s !NOVERWHELMINGANDBEWILDERINGDIVERSITYOF TODAY0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONISINDANGEROFBECOMING
LANGUAGESANDCULTURESINOURSCHOOLSAND ANORGANIZATIONTHATNOLONGERREPRESENTSALLFAMILIES
ANDALLSTUDENTS BUTRATHERONLYTHOSEWHOAREMIDDLE
ANDUPPERMIDDLECLASS


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

-ORETHANPERCENTOFTHE!MERICANPOPULA IZEDTESTSTHROUGHOUTTHECOUNTRY4HEONLYDIFFERENCES
TIONISNOWOVERANDONLYPERCENTAREUNDER AMONGSTUDENTSSHOWUPINTHETESTINGREPORTSRETURNED
YEARSOFAGE4HEPEAKSPENDINGYEARSFORTHELARGEST TODISTRICTSANDTHE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONIN
SEGMENTOFTHEPOPULATIONAREOVER4HISHASMEANT WHICHSCORESAREDISAGGREGATEDBYRACIAL ETHNIC AND
ASUBSTANTIALDROPINCONSUMERSPENDINGANDAMAJOR SOCIO ECONOMICSUBGROUPS2ESEARCHHASYETTODETER
DECLINEINTHEECONOMY7ORSE THEOVER GENERATION MINEWHETHERTHISGREATNATIONALEXPERIMENTWILLHELP
ISRECEIVINGADISPROPORTIONATELYLARGEPERCENTAGEOF MOSTSTUDENTSLEARNORBECOMEBETTERLEARNERS.ORHAS
OURNATIONALBUDGETFOR3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICARE EXPERIENCEYETSHOWNWHETHERTHISNEWEDUCATIONAL
WHICHHASBECOMEAHUGE UNPRODUCTIVEDRAINONTHE REALITYWILLIMPROVEOURINTERNATIONALCOMPETITIVENESS
ECONOMY!DDTOTHATOURNATIONALSECURITYSPENDING 7ITHSCANTSUPPORTFROMTHEIRDISTRICTSANDTHE
ANDINTERESTEXPENSEONTHENATIONSINDEBTEDNESS AND NATION OURMOSTTALENTEDTEACHERSHAVEBEENmEEING
WERELEFTWITHCOMPARATIVELYLITTLEFEDERALFUNDINGFOR THEPROFESSION CHOOSINGINSTEADTOMAKEALIVINGBYTU
OURSCHOOLS DESPITETHECONSTITUTIONALSHIFTIN+n TORINGORENTERINGOTHERPROFESSIONSENTIRELY INASMUCH
RESPONSIBILITYFROMTHESTATESTOTHEFEDERALGOVERN ASTHEMARKETFORPRIVATEANDCHARTERSCHOOLSCONTRACT
MENT5NCOMFORTABLY OURGOVERNMENTISCAUGHTINTHE EDALONGWITHECONOMICACTIVITY7ITHFEWERTEACHERS
UNENVIABLEPOSITIONOFHAVINGTOCHOOSEBETWEENTWO ANDLARGERCLASSES THEPOSSIBILITIESFORINDIVIDUALIZED
POPULATIONSˆTHEYOUNGORTHEOLD4HEGOVERNMENT INSTRUCTIONANDCHOICEWITHINSCHOOLSVIRTUALLYHAVE
HASREPEATEDLYPOSTPONEDOPPORTUNITIESTOINVESTIN DISAPPEARED
FUTUREGENERATIONS BOWINGTOTHEPRESSURESEXERTEDBY 4HENEWEDUCATIONALREALITYDELIVEREDANEXTREME
THEBABYBOOMERS LEAVINGOURYOUNGSTERSINMEDIOCRE BLOWTOTHEHEALTHOFEXISTINGSCHOOLREFORMMOVE
SCHOOLSWITHRUN DOWNBUILDINGS)NSOMESITUATIONS MENTS&OREXAMPLE EVENTHEFOUNDATIONMOVEMENTTO
SCHOOLSSUFFERFROMADEARTHOFSUPPLIESANDTECHNOLOGY IMPROVEOURSCHOOLS LEDBYTHEWORLDSRICHESTINDIVID
ANDSTUDENTSROUTINELYRECEIVELACKLUSTERINSTRUCTION UAL -ICROSOFTS"ILL'ATES WASDRASTICALLYSCALEDBACK
!SYOUMIGHTEXPECT PUBLICSCHOOLSHAVEADOPTED 4HISISNOTABLEBECAUSEITWAS'ATESWHO IN
ANEXPEDIENTVIEWOFWHATITMEANSTOPROVIDEASUIT CALLEDOURHIGHSCHOOLShOBSOLETEvANDRALLIEDTHESTATE
ABLEEDUCATION3TRIPPEDOFTHEIRHISTORICALAUTHORITY GOVERNORSTOAVISIONOFHIGHSCHOOLSTHATWOULDBE
BYCONSTITUTIONALAMENDMENT LOCALSCHOOLBOARDS SMALLER MOREINDIVIDUALIZED ANDlLLEDWITHADVANCED
HAVEBECOMEMEREPURCHASINGAGENTS CONTRACTINGWITH LEARNINGENVIRONMENTS4HEHIGHSCHOOLREFORMSUN
LOCALANDNATIONALSUPPLIERSFORCURRICULUM TESTS AND DERWAYINWEREBROUGHTTOAHALTBYTHEADOPTION
INSTRUCTIONALSERVICESTHATPURPORTEDLYMEETFEDERAL OFTHECONSTITUTIONALAMENDMENT
REGULATORYREQUIREMENTS )N 0RESIDENT&RISTCONTINUEDTHE"USHPOLICIES
5NDEROURNATIONALIZEDREGIMENFOR+nEDUCA OFPRE EMPTIVEMILITARYACTIONWITHSTRIKESON.ORTH
TIONANDDUETOBUDGETARYCONSTRAINTSINTHECOUNTRY +OREAAND)RAN INCURRINGAFURTHERDRAINONOURNA
SCHOOLSNOWOFFERVERYLITTLEINDIVIDUALATTENTIONFOR TIONALTREASURYANDINCREASINGTHEDElCITBYHUNDREDS
THOSESTUDENTSWITHSPECIALGIFTS SPECIALNEEDS LAN OFBILLIONSOFDOLLARS4HESEMILITARYACTIONS WHILETAC
GUAGEDElCITS OREMOTIONALPROBLEMS7ENOWHAVE TICALLYSUCCESSFULINTHESHORT TERMˆELIMINATINGTHE
APUBLICSCHOOLSYSTEMTHATEMPHASIZEShTHETHREE2Sv NUCLEARTHREATREPRESENTEDBYTHESETWOROGUENATIONS
ANDSCIENCE BUTSPONSORSFEWSPORTS PHYSICALEDUCA ˆCREATEDSOMANYENEMIESFORTHE5NITED3TATESTHAT
TION lNEARTS INDUSTRIALARTSORHOMEECONOMICS&AMI WEARENOWINTHEPOSITIONOFHAVINGTOSPEND INREAL
LIESWITHTHEINCOMEANDMOTIVATIONTOPROVIDETHEIR TERMS MOREMONEYONANTI TERRORISMMEASURESTHANWE
CHILDRENWITH@NON STANDARDACTIVITIESANDRESOURCES DIDINTHElRSTDECADEOFTHESTCENTURY!SARESULT
DOSO BUTOTHERSSIMPLYCANNOTAFFORDIT&URTHER ALL OFTHESEPOLICIES THEKILLINGANDMAIMINGOFCITIZENS
53SCHOOLCHILDRENSTUDYTHESAMESUBJECTMATTERAT OFTHEINDUSTRIALIZEDCOUNTRIESBYTERRORISTGROUPSHAS
THESAMETIME ARETASKEDWITHUNIFORMASSIGNMENTS BECOMEAGRIMBUTALMOSTROUTINEDISRUPTIONTOOUR
REGARDLESSOFTHEIRSTRENGTHSANDWEAKNESSES AND DAY TO DAYLIVES
SIMULTANEOUSLYTAKETHESAME COMPUTERIZED STANDARD

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

%LECTIONOF !BUNDANT

0RESIDENT&RISTSRE ELECTIONCAMPAIGNBROUGHTMANY
OFTHESEISSUESINTOTHEPUBLICARENAFORDEBATE6OTERS
WERETORNBETWEENTHEVERYREALLIFE AND DEATHISSUESOF

,IMITED
NATIONALSECURITYANDDOMESTICPRIORITIES ASWELLASTHE 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
INTERGENERATIONALlSCALTENSIONBETWEENOLDANDYOUNG

2ESOURCES
)NSPITEOFANESPECIALLYSTRONGCHALLENGEFROMTHE
$EMOCRATICPRESIDENTIALCANDIDATE -ARK7ARNER AND h)#ANT'ET.O
3ATISFACTIONv
AWEAKTHIRDPARTYCANDIDATE 0RESIDENT&RISTWASRE
ELECTEDINBYATHINMARGINOF%LECTORAL#OLLEGE 3CARCE
VOTES
(OWEVER ALONGWITHTHERE ELECTIONOF0RESIDENT
&RISTCAMEAREVOLTAMONGOLDERVOTERSAGAINSTTHE
NATIONSTAXBURDEN,IKEVOTERSIN#ALIFORNIAIN FUNDINGWENEEDTOINmUENCEMEMBERSOF#ONGRESSTO
WHOSUPPORTED0ROPOSITION WHICHCUTPROPERTY SUPPORTREFORMSFOROURPUBLICSCHOOLS
TAXESBYPERCENTLIKEVOTERSIN-ASSACHUSETTSIN #LEARLY OURAPPROACHANDTACTICSNEEDTOCHANGE
WHODEMANDEDLOWERPROPERTYTAXESTHATRESULTED 7EHAVETWOYEARSBEFORETHENEXTELECTION AND
INLESSFUNDINGFORSCHOOLSANDLIKEVOTERSIN#OLORADO WENEEDTOSPENDTHEMCOURTINGTHEOVER VOTERS
WHOPASSEDTHE4!"/2AMENDMENTTOTHESTATES 7ITHOUTTHESUPPORTOFTHEPEOPLEWHOMAKEUPTHE
CONSTITUTION LIMITINGTAXINCREASES INOURSENIOR LARGESTPOPULATIONBLOCKINTHECOUNTRY OURAGENDAFOR
CITIZENSSUCCESSFULLYMOBILIZEDAVOTERREVOLTAGAINST PARENTINVOLVEMENT SUPPORTFORPUBLICSCHOOLS AND
ANYFURTHERINCREASESINTAXATIONBYTHEFEDERALGOVERN ASSISTANCEFORPARENTSINPROMOTINGTHEHEALTH SAFETY
MENT ANDEDUCATIONOFTHEIRCHILDRENISNOTGOINGTOSUCCEED
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONANDITSMEMBERSHAVEWORKED !S)DEPARTASPRESIDENTOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION )ASK
HARDTOCONVINCE#ONGRESSTOALLOCATESMALLINCREASES ALLOFOURMEMBERSTOWORKTOGETHERTOlNDNEWSOLU
INFUNDINGFORTHEPUBLICSCHOOLSBUTSADLY WITHOUT TIONSTHATADDRESSTHESECONTINUINGPROBLEMS9OURNEW
EXCEPTION SUCHPROPOSALSHAVEBEENVOTEDDOWN LEADERSHAVEAHARDROADINFRONTOFTHEM ANDTHEYARE
OFTENNOTEVENSURVIVINGCOMMITTEEVOTES4HEREIS GOINGTONEEDYOURHELP/URCONTINUEDEXISTENCEAS
LITTLEENTHUSIASMAMONGTHEELDERLYTOADDTOTHEIRTAX ANORGANIZATIONANDASATISFACTORYFUTUREFORTHENEXT
BURDENTOPAYFORACROSS THE BOARDSPENDINGINCREASES GENERATIONOF!MERICANSDEPENDSUPONIT
FORSCHOOLSTHATTHEYDONOTAPPROVEOFORUSE
"ESTWISHESFORNEWSUCCESSES -ARY2OLLINS7ASHINGTON
.EW2OLEFOR0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION $#0RESIDENT 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION 
7HATDOESTHISMEANFORTHEFUTUREOF0ARENTS
FOR%DUCATION)TSBECOMEVERYDIFlCULTTORALLYGRASS !NALYSISOF3CENARIO
ROOTSSUPPORTFOR#ONGRESSIONALFUNDINGINITIATIVES TAX
INCREASES ORSPECIALIZEDNATIONALDEBTINSTRUMENTSTHAT )MPLICATIONS
WOULDHELPIMPROVETHEQUALITYOFOURSCHOOLBUILDINGS  4HEFEDERALGOVERNMENTASSUMESRESPONSIBILITY
THETRAININGOFTEACHERS ANDTHEAVAILABILITYOFHIGH FOR+nEDUCATIONINTHE53PURSUANTTOTHE
QUALITYTEACHINGMATERIALS/URWORKISMADEEVEN ADOPTIONOFACONSTITUTIONALAMENDMENT
MORECHALLENGINGBYTHEDRASTICREDUCTIONINMEMBERS
OVERTHEPASTDECADE)NWEENJOYEDSIXMILLION  3CHOOLSAREUNDER FUNDED
MEMBERSTODAYTHEREAREABOUTTHREEMILLIONONOUR
 /URBESTTEACHERSARELEAVINGTHEPROFESSION AND
MEMBERSHIPROLLS7ITHOUTADRAMATICANDSUDDEN
ITISINCREASINGLYDIFlCULTTORECRUITNEWONES
BOOSTINOURMEMBERSHIP WECANNOTPROVIDETHE


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONISABLETOEXERTLESSINmU  /WINGTODECREASINGBUDGETSFORTHEM FEWER


ENCEONMEMBERSOF#ONGRESS FEDERALREGULATORS NON ACADEMICMUSIC lNEARTS INDIVIDUALSPORTS
ANDSTATELEGISLATORS SUBJECTSANDACTIVITIESAREOFFEREDINTRADITIONAL
SCHOOLSANINCREASINGNUMBEROFCHARTERSCHOOLS
 &EWEREXTRACURRICULARACTIVITIESANDFEWERSUBJECT OFFERACURRICULUMLIMITEDTOACADEMICSUBJECTS
MATTERCHOICESWITHINSCHOOLSMEANGRADUATESARE ONLYCOLLEGESANDUNIVERSITIESVOICEMOREAND
LEAVINGTHE+nSCHOOLSYSTEMWITHANARROW MORECOMPLAINTSABOUTTHEINTELLECTUALARIDITYOF
ANDLIMITEDVIEWOFTHEWORLD INCOMINGFRESHMEN
 3CHOOLBOARDSARELITTLEMORETHANPURCHASING  !NINCREASINGNUMBEROFCHARTERSCHOOLSFUNDED
AGENTS BYPUBLICSCHOOLDISTRICTBUDGETSAREMANAGEDBY
 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONFAILSTOBUILDITSMEMBER PRIVATESECTORFOR PROlTANDNONPROlTENTITIES
SHIPQUICKLYENOUGH ANDITSBUDGETSUFFERSAC SCHOOLSSUBJECTTORE CONSTITUTIONBY.#,"ARE
CORDINGLY MANAGEDBYPRIVATESECTORFOR PROlTANDNONPROF
ITENTITIESANDSUBJECTMATTERCURRICULUMINTRADI
 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONISINDANGEROFREPRESENTING TIONALSCHOOLSISHIGHLYSCRIPTEDANDFURNISHEDBY
THEMIDDLEANDUPPERCLASSES COMMERCIALPUBLISHERS

 0&%CANNOTATTRACTNEWMEMBERSTOITSRANKSIN
)NDICATORS
ALLOFTHESTATESANDCANNOTAFFORDWIDESPREADLOB
 )NTERNATIONALCOMPARISONSOFTESTSCORESINMATH BYINGEFFORTSITUSEDTOENJOYINITSHEYDAY
EMATICSANDSCIENCECONTINUETOSHOW!MERICAN
STUDENTSLAGGINGBEHINDTHOSEOFOURMOSTCOM  4HEDEMOGRAPHICPROlLEOFITSCURRENTMEMBERS
PETITIVETRADINGPARTNERS ISPRIMARILYMIDDLETOUPPERMIDDLECLASSITHAS
NOTSUCCESSFULLYATTRACTEDSUBSTANTIALMEMBERSOF
 3CHOOLlNANCELAWSUITSAGAINSTSTATEGOVERN LESSERMEANSANDTHECONCERNSOFITSMEMBERSARE
MENTSCONTINUETOBEPURSUEDBYFRUSTRATED NOTFOCUSEDONLOWERINCOMEFAMILIES
PARENTS3TATESUPREMECOURTSCONTINUETOlND
THATTHEIRLEGISLATURESHAVEUNCONSTITUTIONALLY
/PTIONS
UNDER FUNDEDSTATEAIDTOEDUCATION
"ECAUSEITCANNOTINCREASEITSDWINDLINGMEMBERSHIP
 4URNOVERINTHETEACHINGRANKSINCREASES FEWER BASEBYITSTRADITIONALAPPEALSTOPARENTSOFSCHOOLAGED
OFTHEBESTHIGHSCHOOLSTUDENTSENTERCOLLEGE CHILDRENINEVERYSOCIO ECONOMICCATEGORY 0&%MAY
PLANNINGACAREERIN+nTEACHING ANDTEACHER NEEDTOCONSIDERENLARGINGITSMEMBERSHIPBASEBYWID
PAYDOESNOTKEEPPACEWITHTHECOSTOFLIVING ENINGITSMISSIONANDWORKINGTOATTRACTAMOREDIVERSE
ANDTHEPAYOFOTHERKNOWLEDGEWORKERS SETOFMEMBERS&OREXAMPLE THEREMIGHTBEANICHEOF
OLDER!MERICANSWHOWOULDJOIN0&%IFITAPPEALEDTO
 0&%FEDERALLEGISLATIVEPRIORITIESARENOTENACTED
THATGROUPSSENSEOFPATRIOTISMANDTRADITIONALVALUES
BY#ONGRESS NORISSTATEFUNDINGCOMMENSURATE
ESPECIALLYIFTHEREWEREALESSERMEMBERSHIPFEEBASED
WITHTHEEDUCATIONALCHALLENGESPOSEDBYTHE
ONTHEAGEOFTHATPROSPECTIVECLASSOFMEMBERS!SIT
STRATEGICCOMPETITIONEXERTEDBYOURINTERNA
STRIVESTOENLARGEITSBASE THEORGANIZATIONWILLPROB
TIONALTRADINGPARTNERS0&%SINABILITYTOQUICKLY
ABLYNEEDTOCHANGEITSNAMEINORDERTOEXPRESSTHE
INCREASEITSMEMBERSHIPANDlLLITSCOFFERSDEPRIVE
BROADERMISSIONITWILLHAVETOUNDERTAKE)TALSOWILL
THEORGANIZATIONOFTHERESOURCESTOLOBBYSTATES
NEEDTOINVESTINAMARKETINGCAMPAIGNTOINCREASEITS
ANDTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTEFFECTIVELY
VISIBILITYAMONGPARENTANDTHEGENERALPUBLIC

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP !BUNDANT

!SSOCIATION3CENARIO h)MAGINEv
$EEP#AUSES

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATMOSTSCHOOLSAREADEQUATELY
FUNDED ANDTHATMANYDIFFERENTTYPESOFSCHOOLSARE

2ESOURCES
AVAILABLETOPARENTS!VARIETYOFSCHOOLSANDPRIVATE
ORGANIZATIONSHAVERECEIVEDFUNDINGFROMTHESTATESTO
ESTABLISHSCHOOLSDESIGNEDTOSERVETHENEEDSOFCHIL
DRENWITHEVERYLEARNINGSTYLEANDEVERYTALENT 3CARCE

4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO

s 4HENUMBEROFSCHOOLSNEEDINGIMPROVEMENT $EAR-EMBERS
UNDERTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CT.#,"
!S0RESIDENTOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONFORTHEPAST
CONTINUESTOINCREASEANDDISTRICTSARENOT
YEARS )HAVEBEENHONOREDTOSERVEYOUˆPARENTS
SUCCESSFULINTURNINGAROUNDTHESESCHOOLS
ANDMEMBERSOFTHEPUBLICWHOAREDEDICATEDTOTHE
s .#,"ISSUBJECTTOSOMANYLAWSUITSFROMSTATES EDUCATION HEALTH ANDSAFETYOFALLCHILDREN4OGETHER
DISTRICTS ANDNATIONALORGANIZATIONSTHATTHE WEAREENTERINGAPOSITIVENEWERAFORTHEEDUCATIONOF
FEDERALGOVERNMENTISFORCEDTOBACKOFFFROM OURCHILDREN4HISNEWERAISDUEINLARGEPARTTOTHE
ITSDEMANDS)NSTEAD #ONGRESSVOTESTOPROVIDE EFFORTSOFTHISORGANIZATION SO)AMWRITINGTHISLETTER
FEDERALFUNDINGFORDISADVANTAGEDSTUDENTSTOTHE TOTHANKYOUFORYOURHARDWORKANDCONGRATULATEYOU
STATESINTHEFORMOFBLOCKGRANTSWITHMINIMAL ONYOURSUCCESS
STRINGSATTACHED 4HISSPECIALNEWSLETTERISDEVOTEDTOTHREETOPICS
&IRST )REVIEWOURORGANIZATIONSEFFORTSTOCREATEOUR
s 3TATESDECIDETOUSETHEIRNEWFUNDINGTOISSUE CURRENTPUBLICSCHOOLSYSTEMTHATOFFERSAWIDEARRAY
2EQUESTSFOR0ROPOSALSFROMAVARIETYOFENTITIES OFADEQUATELY FUNDEDSCHOOLINGCHOICESFORMOST
INTERESTEDINRUNNINGTHESCHOOLS4HEYWILL STUDENTS)SAYhMOSTvBECAUSE ASYOUKNOW WESTILL
CONSIDERPROVIDINGFUNDINGONLYTOTHOSEENTITIES HAVEANUNACCEPTABLYHIGHNUMBEROFSCHOOLSTHATARE
WHOHAVEDEMONSTRATEDSUCCESSINIMPROVING NOTDOINGAGOODENOUGHJOBOFPREPARINGSTUDENTSFOR
STUDENTACHIEVEMENT HIGHEREDUCATIONORAVOCATION ANDTHEREFORE WESTILL
s %CONOMICCONDITIONSINTHECOUNTRYHAVE HAVEWORKTODO3ECOND )DESCRIBETHETRAJECTORYOF
IMPROVEDMAINLYDUETOIMPROVEDTECHNOLOGY POLITICALEVENTSTHATPLAYEDACONSIDERABLEPARTINTHESE
FORRETRIEVINGEXISTINGOILDEPOSITSINTHE5NITED CHANGES4HIRD )OUTLINEAVISIONFORTHEROLE)BELIEVE
3TATESANDTHEDEVELOPMENTOFALTERNATIVESOURCES THISORGANIZATIONSHOULDPLAYASOURSCHOOLSCONTINUE
OFENERGYLEADINGTO53CITIZENSENJOYING TOGROWANDEVOLVE
ABUNDANTENERGYATLOWCOST
4HE2OLEOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION
)NSPITEOFTHEOPTIMISTICSTATEOFOURPUBLICSCHOOLS
h)MAGINEv TODAY )MUSTBEGINBYSAYINGTHATTOOMANYCHILDREN
4IME*UNE  ARESTILLBEINGLEFTBEHIND)AMSURETHOSEWORDSBRING
0LACE7ASHINGTON $# BACKMEMORIESOFATIMEINTHISCOUNTRYWHENSCHOOL
DISTRICTSANDSTATESWEREFACINGOFFWITHTHE0RESIDENT
3CENE3PECIALNEWSLETTERFROMTHEPRESIDENTOF
AND#ONGRESSOVERTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND.#,"
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONTOITSMEMBERS


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

LEGISLATION4HEYEARSnWEREADIFlCULT TOSTATESRIGHTSFROMTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTSINTERFER
PERIODTHATINCLUDEDARASHOFSCHOOLlNANCELAWSUITS ENCE4HEPUBLIC IN HADALREADYLOSTPATIENCE
SCANDALSOVERUSING!MERICANTAXDOLLARSTOFUNDOVER WITHTHEOVERREACHINGOF#ONGRESSIN FOREXAMPLE
SEASTUTORINGCOMPANIESWITHQUESTIONABLECREDENTIALS THEhRIGHTTODIEvCASEOFBRAIN INJURED4ERRY3CHIAVO
ANDEXPERTISE ANDMOUNTINGCRITICISMOFTHEFEDERAL ANDTHEADMINISTRATIONSPROPOSALTOTRANSFORM3OCIAL
GOVERNMENTSINTRUSIONINTOLOCALEDUCATIONWITHOUT 3ECURITYINTOAPERSONALINVESTMENTPLANTHATMANY
PROVIDINGCOMMENSURATERESOURCESTOTHESTATES VIEWEDASTOORISKY)NADDITION THESUSPECTEDMISDEEDS
.#,"HADTHEBESTINTENTIONSITAIMEDTOENSURE OFTHELEADEROFTHE(OUSEOF2EPRESENTATIVESANDTHE
THATALLCHILDREN REGARDLESSOFRACE COUNTRYOFORIGIN 3ENATESIMPASSEOVERCONlRMATIONOFJUDICIALNOMI
ORSOCIO ECONOMICSTATUS WOULDSUCCEED(OWEVER NEES LEDTOWIDESPREADDISTRUSTAND EVEN DISGUSTWITH
BECAUSEOFTHERELENTLESSREQUIREMENTSFORhADEQUATELY THEFEDS
YEARLYPROGRESSv!90 ANDSANCTIONSFORMISSINGTHESE 2ESPONDINGTOPUBLICSENTIMENT WEFOCUSEDOUR
TARGETS MANYSCHOOLSWERETAGGEDAShFAILINGvAND ATTENTIONONTHECONGRESSIONALELECTIONSOF/UR
CLOSEDORRECONSTITUTEDINSOMEFASHIONBECAUSEONEOR 0!#WORKEDHARDTORAISEMONEYTOSUPPORTTHOSE
TWOSUB GROUPSDIDNOTATTAINACCEPTABLEPROGRESS4HIS CANDIDATESFORTHE3ENATEANDTHE(OUSEOF2EPRESEN
HADADIRECTEFFECTONOURCHILDRENSEDUCATION!STHEIR TATIVESWHOAGREEDWITHUSABOUTTHENEEDFOREFFEC
LOCALSCHOOLSWERECLOSED OURCHILDRENRODEBUSESTO TIVESCHOOLSTHATWOULDRESPONDTOTHENEEDSOFLOCAL
SCHOOLSINDISTANTNEIGHBORHOODS4HESESCHOOLSSOON COMMUNITIES$URINGTHOSEELECTIONSWEMADEAMAJOR
BECAMEOVERCROWDEDANDPLAGUEDBYMANYOFTHESAME ISSUEOFSTATESRIGHTS WHICHWASANIRONICTWISTˆTHE
PROBLEMSOFTHEFAILINGSCHOOLSTHEYREPLACED3AD SAMEBABYBOOMERSWHOFOUGHTAGAINSTSTATESRIGHTS
DENED ANDTHENANGRYATTHISDEVELOPMENT MEMBERS DURINGTHE#IVIL2IGHTS-OVEMENTWERENOWACTIVE
OF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONDECIDEDENOUGHWASENOUGH INOURlGHT4HISTIME THEISSUEWASPERCEIVEDDIFFER
4HROUGHOUTTHESEPASTYEARS WEUSEDOURVOICEAND ENTLY ANDTHEPUBLICRAISEDTHEQUESTION IFTHEFEDERAL
OURVOTETOMAKETHECHANGESNEEDEDONBEHALFOFOUR GOVERNMENTSTARTEDTELLINGSTATESANDLOCALCOMMUNI
CHILDREN#ONSEQUENTLY WENOLONGERHAVEASYSTEM TIESHOWTORUNTHESCHOOLS WHATWOULDBENEXT4HE
THATISBUILTONFAILUREANDLIMITATIONS BUTONETHAT SCHOOLISSUECOULDBETHEBEGINNINGOFASLIPPERYSLOPE
FOCUSESONSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTANDHASTHERESOURCES OFTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTUSINGITSPOWERSTOTAKEOVER
TOMAKEADIFFERENCE MANYFUNCTIONSTHATWEREASSIGNEDTOTHESTATESBYOUR
)N WESTARTEDLEVERAGINGOURSECRETWEAPON #ONSTITUTION
THEBABYBOOMERS%XPERIENCEDPROTESTERSFROMTHE
S THENOW IN THEIR SIXTIESBOOMERSSPEARHEADED 4HE.EW6ISIONFOR0UBLIC3CHOOLS
POLITICALPROTESTSLOCALLYANDIN7ASHINGTON $# /URCAMPAIGNSWEREVERYSUCCESSFUL!FTERTHEELEC
DEMANDINGTHAT#ONGRESSADDRESSTHEASPECTSOFTHE TIONSOF THEBALANCEOFPOWERIN#ONGRESSSHIFTED
.#,"LEGISLATIONTHATWERECAUSINGTOOMANYSCHOOLS 4HENEW#ONGRESS WHOKNEWTHEYWEREDEALINGWITH
TOBELABELEDASFAILING(OWWEREWEABLETOGETTHE ASECOND TERMADMINISTRATION SEIZEDTHEOPPORTUNITY
BABYBOOMERSSOINVOLVED4HEEARLYRETIREESWHOHAD TOQUESTIONMANYOFTHEPROGRAMSTHAT0RESIDENT"USH
SPENTTHEIRCAREERSINBUSINESS LAW PUBLISHING HIGH ANDHIS#ABINETADVOCATED ANDTHEIRJUDICIALNOMI
TECHNOLOGY ORRUNNINGTHEIROWNSMALLBUSINESSESWERE NATIONS&ORTHElRSTTIMESINCE3EPTEMBER 
READYTODOSOMETHINGTHEYCONSIDEREDMOREhMEAN MEMBERSOF#ONGRESSFROMTHEPRESIDENTSOWNPARTY
INGFULv/NCEWEMADECONTACT THEMEMBERSOFTHIS PROPOSEDIDEASANDPROGRAMSWHICHWEREINDIRECTOP
BOOMERGENERATIONWEREDELIGHTEDTOCHANNELTHEIR POSITIONTOTHOSEOFTHEADMINISTRATION/NEOFTHOSE
TIMEANDENERGYINTOACAUSETHEYCONSIDEREDIMPOR PROGRAMSWASTHECREATIONOFBLOCKGRANTSTOTHESTATES
TANTANDWORTHWHILE TOFUNDPUBLICEDUCATION/FCOURSE THEREWASPLENTY
/URTIMINGWASFORTUNATE4HESEPROTESTSANDA OFRESISTANCE BUTAFTERMANYCOMPROMISESONALLSIDES
MASS)NTERNETCAMPAIGNSUCCEEDEDINRAISINGTHELEVEL BY#ONGRESSHADAGREED ATLEASTINPRINCIPLE
OFAWARENESSAMONGTHEGENERALPUBLICABOUTTHETHREAT UPONAPLANTHATLEFTTHEEDUCATIONOFOURCHILDREN

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

ENTIRELYTOTHESTATESANDLOCALCOMMUNITIES)TTOOK !BUNDANT
ANOTHERFEWYEARSTOPUTTHATPLANINTOACTION BUTWITH
OURHELP BY #ONGRESSHADLAIDTHEBASICFOUNDA h)MAGINEv
TIONFOROUREXISTINGSCHOOLSYSTEM
)N #ONGRESSOUTLINEDAPLANTHATWOULDSET

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
UPBLOCKGRANTSFORTHESTATES&EDERALFUNDING WHICH

2ESOURCES
ATTHATTIMEMADEUPONLYSEVENPERCENTOFTHESTATES
EDUCATIONBUDGETSANDALLOWEDTHESTATESVERYLITTLE
CONTROLOVERHOWTOSPENDTHATMONEY WOULDBEFUN
NELEDINTOTHEBLOCKGRANTS!LLENTITLEMENTMONIES
3CARCE
ANDMONEYTHATHADPREVIOUSLYBEENUSEDTOPAYFOR
THEIMPLEMENTATIONOF.#,"WOULDGOTOTHESTATES
4HESTATESWOULDADDTHATMONEYTOTHEIRLOCALPROP
ERTYTAXDOLLARSANDCAREFULLYFUNDONLYTHOSEENTITIESRIAFORAPPLICANTS REVIEWEVERYAPPLICATION ANDCHECK
THATOFFEREDTHEGREATESTPROMISETOCREATETHEMOST EVERYREFERENCE
EFFECTIVESCHOOLS4HEGUIDELINESTHAT#ONGRESSLAIDOUT
/NEOFTHEMAINDECISIONSFACINGTHESTATESWAS
ESSENTIALLYDEREGULATEDSCHOOLS CREATINGAFREE MARKETHOWTHEYWOULDHOLDTHESCHOOLSACCOUNTABLE4HEDE
SYSTEMFORPUBLICSCHOOLS3TATESWOULDHOLDWHAT CISIONTOMAINTAINASYSTEMOFANNUALTESTINGWASMADE
AMOUNTEDTOACOMPETITIONFORPUBLICSCHOOLFUNDING MUCHEASIERWHENTHEMAJORTESTPUBLISHERSPERFECTED
BUTONLYTHOSEENTITIESWITHAPROVENTRACKRECORD ONLINEVERSIONSOFTHEIRINSTRUMENTS"Y TESTSOF
FORSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTNEEDAPPLY%XISTINGSCHOOL PROlCIENCYONINDIVIDUALSCHOOLDISTRICTSSTANDARDS
DISTRICTSCOULDAPPLYFORFUNDINGALONGWITHPRIVATE COULDBEADMINISTEREDONLINEANDINREALTIMEATANY
COMPANIES UNIVERSITIES ANDEVENINDIVIDUALS"UTALL TIMEDURINGTHESCHOOLYEARDEEMEDAPPROPRIATEBYTHE
APPLICATIONSWOULDBECAREFULLYREVIEWEDACCORDINGTO SCHOOLITSELF4HERESULTS INCLUDINGEXTENSIVEDIAGNOS
STRICTCRITERIA TICINFORMATIONABOUTEACHSTUDENTSUNDERSTANDING
&OUNDATIONSANDCORPORATIONSWOULDBEENCOUR OFEVERYSTANDARD WEREGIVENTOTHESCHOOLSWITHIN
AGEDTOSTARTPUBLICSCHOOLSWITHTHEIROWNFUNDING HOURSSOTHEYCOULDUSETHEMTOCREATEINDIVIDUAL
BUTALLPUBLICSCHOOLSWOULDBEREQUIREDTOTURNIN STUDENTLEARNINGPLANS)NADDITION TESTRESULTSPROVID
THEIRSTUDENTACHIEVEMENTDATAANDPARENTSATISFAC EDINFORMATIONABOUTPROGRESSBEINGMADEBYINDIVIDU
TIONSURVEYS)FANYPUBLICSCHOOLS REGARDLESSOFTHEIR
ALSTUDENTS ALLOWINGSTATESTOHOLDSCHOOLSACCOUNTABLE
FUNDINGSOURCE WERENOTACHIEVINGACCORDINGTOTHE FORGROWTHINSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT ASOPPOSEDTOONLY
CRITERIALAIDOUTBYTHESTATES ORIFPARENTSWEREDIS WHETHERORNOTALLSTUDENTSHADREACHEDAPRESCRIBED
SATISlEDWITHTHEIRCHILDRENSEDUCATION THESCHOOL LEVELOFPROlCIENCY4HISCHANGEINASSESSMENTANDAC
WOULDBEREQUIREDTOCREATEANDIMPLEMENTA3CHOOL COUNTABILITYSYSTEMSHASRESULTEDINFEWERSCHOOLSBEING
)MPROVEMENT0LAN/NTHEOTHERHAND THOSESCHOOLS LABELEDASINNEEDOFIMPROVEMENT
WHOSESTUDENTSACHIEVEDBEYONDTHEPROlCIENTLEVEL )NADDITIONTOACADEMICACHIEVEMENT THANKSTO
ANDWHOSEPARENTSGAVETHEIRSCHOOLSHIGHMARKS OURADVOCACYFORPARENTS SCHOOLSNOWMUSTADMINISTER
WOULDBEELIGIBLEFORBONUSES PARENTSATISFACTIONSURVEYSANDREPORTTHERESULTSTOTHE
STATES!HIGHLEVELOFPARENTSATISFACTIONCANMILITATE
)MPLEMENTINGTHE6ISION AGAINSTTHECONSEQUENCEFORLOWACHIEVEMENTLEVELS
/NCETHESTATESRECEIVEDTHISPROGRAMOUTLINEFROM ASLONGASTHESCHOOLISDEMONSTRATINGOVERALLPROGRESS
#ONGRESSATTHEENDOF THEYBEGANLOOKINGFOR !TTENTIONTOTHESATISFACTIONOFPARENTSHASHELPED
PARTNERSTOHELPTHEMIMPLEMENTTHEDETAILS7EWERE PREVENTMANYFAMILIESFROMmEEINGTHEIRNEIGHBORHOOD
ONEOFTHEAGENCIESTHATPLAYEDAPROMINENTDECISION SCHOOLSOUTOFSHEERFRUSTRATIONANDHASEMPOWERED
MAKINGROLEINMANYSTATES/URMEMBERSWORKEDWITH THEMTOMAKEINFORMEDDECISIONSABOUTWHATISBESTFOR
3TATE$EPARTMENTSOF%DUCATIONTOCREATESPECIlCCRITE THEIROWNCHILDREN/FCOURSE IMPROVEMENTPLANSARE


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

STILLREQUIREDFORTHOSESCHOOLSNOTACHIEVINGACCEPT BECOMINGINCREASINGLYMULTICULTURAL AND%,,PRO


ABLEMARKSONTHETESTSANDTHEPARENTSURVEYS BUTTHE GRAMSFORTHOSENON NATIVE%NGLISHSPEAKINGSTUDENTS
TOTALNUMBEROFSCHOOLSINNEEDOFIMPROVEMENTHASSO WHONEEDEDTOLEARNTOSPEAK READ ANDWRITEITWELL
DRAMATICALLYDECLINED DUETOTHENEWACCOUNTABILITY ENOUGHTOSUCCEEDINTHEWORLDOFWORK
METHODS THATSTATEDEPARTMENTSANDOTHERCONSULTING 4HERESULTOFALLTHISEFFORTISTHATINMANYAREASOF
AGENCIESCANMEETTHENEEDWITHRESEARCH BASEDTECH THECOUNTRYTHEREISAWEALTHOFCHOICESFORPARENTS
NICALASSISTANCE MANYPROGRAMSFORGIFTEDSTUDENTS STUDENTSWITH
/NEDISADVANTAGETOTHISPLANHASBEENTHELACK SPECIALNEEDS ARTISTICSTUDENTS ANDSTUDENTSWITH
OFDATATOCOMPARESTUDENTSFROMSTATETOSTATEAND SPECIALATHLETICABILITIESANDHIGH QUALITYINSTRUCTION
FROMTHE53TOOTHERCOUNTRIES3INCETHE$EPART FORMOST4HEREARE UNFORTUNATELY STILLSTATESINTHIS
MENTOF%DUCATIONABANDONEDTHE.!%0AND4)--3 COUNTRYTHATHAVENOTBEENSUFlCIENTLYPRO ACTIVEIN
TESTSANDTURNEDTHATFUNDINGOVERTOTHESTATES WENO SEEKINGAPPLICATIONSANDSCREENINGFORTHEBESTANDTHE
LONGERHAVEANYWAYTOCOMPAREACHIEVEMENTOFSTU BRIGHTESTPROVIDERSOFEDUCATION)TISINTHEBIGCITIES
DENTSFROMSTATETOSTATEORCOUNTRYTOCOUNTRY3OME ASWELLASTHERURALAREASOFTHESESTATES THATMUCH
STATESAREBEGINNINGTOADDRESSTHISPROBLEMBYCONSID WORKREMAINSTOBEDONE
ERINGOTHERWAYSTOCOLLECTTHISTYPEOFDATA
!STHISPLANEVOLVED OURMEMBERSWORKEDWITH 4HE0OLITICS
THEPRESSTOMAKESURETHEYUNDERSTOODHOWPOSITIVE "ACKIN THE"USHADMINISTRATION THROUGH
THISPROCESSWASGOINGTOBEFORTHEPUBLICSCHOOLS 3ECRETARYOF%DUCATION-ARGARET3PELLINGS AGREEDTO
.EARLYDAILY LOCALNEWSPAPERSRANARTICLESABOUTTHIS ALLOWTHElRSTMODIlCATIONSOF.#,"4HECHANGES
REVOLUTIONARYNEWAPPROACHTOSCHOOLINGANDHOWIT WEREFEWANDSLOWHOWEVER ANDAFTERTHECONGRESSIONAL
WOULDLEADTOHIGHERSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT ANDTHERE ELECTIONOF .#,"LOSTALLTRACTIONANDWASRE
FORE AMORELITERATEANDINFORMEDELECTORATE4HEY PLACEDBYTHEBLOCKGRANTSTOSTATES)TWASDURINGTHIS
WROTEARTICLESABOUTTHEUNIVERSITY RUNSCHOOLSAND TIMETHAT"USHSPOPULARITYSANKTOTHELOWESTLEVELOF
THESPECIALSCHOOLSTHATLARGECORPORATIONSWITHEDUCA ANYSECONDTERMPRESIDENTINHISTORY.02!LL4HINGS
TIONALFOUNDATIONSWEREFUNDING SUCHASTHE"ILLAND #ONSIDERED !PRIL  0OLLSSHOWEDTHATCITIZENS
-ELINDA'ATESHIGHSCHOOLSFORTECHNOLOGYANDTHE WEREFARMOREWORRIEDABOUTTHEECONOMY THEPRICE
-ICHAELAND3USAN$ELLMIDDLESCHOOLSFORMATHEMAT OFOIL THEENVIRONMENT ANDTHEWARIN)RAQTHANTHE
ICS SCIENCE ANDTECHNOLOGY4HEYALSOWROTEABOUTTHE 0RESIDENTSEEMEDTOBE.02-ORNING%DITION !PRIL
WAYSEXISTINGPUBLICSCHOOLSWEREPROVIDINGPROFESSION   
ALDEVELOPMENTFORTEACHERSONTHELATESTEDUCATIONAL )NTHENEW#ONGRESSOF ACENTRISTCOALITION
RESEARCHONINSTRUCTIONALSTRATEGIESANDTHEEFFECTSOF LEDBY3ENATOR"ARACK/BAMAOF)LLINOIS STATEDITSGOAL
THOSESTRATEGIESONSTUDENTLEARNING OFCREATINGAMOREBIPARTISANGOVERNMENT4HEYSUC
/NATLEASTAWEEKLYBASIS STORIESAPPEAREDINTHE CEEDEDINLESSENINGTHEGREATDIVIDEBETWEEN2EPUB
NATIONALPRESSABOUTTHEIMPRESSIVECREDENTIALSOFTHE LICANSAND$EMOCRATSINTHE#ONGRESS ANDSOUGHTOUT
ENTITIESAPPLYINGFORSTATEGRANTSTOOPENANEWSCHOOL ISSUESTHATWOULDBRINGARAPPROCHEMENTBETWEENTHE
!SARESULTOFHEIGHTENEDNATIONWIDEINTERESTSURROUND SO CALLEDREDSTATESANDBLUESTATES3ENATOR/BAMA
INGTHENEWPUBLICSCHOOLS MORELARGECOMPANIES ONEOFTHEMOSTADMIREDPOLITICIANSINTHECOUNTRYAS
BEGANSEEINGTHISPLANFORPUBLICSCHOOLSASAVEHICLE ARESULTOFHISSPEECHATTHE$EMOCRATICCONVENTIONIN
FORINVESTINGINTHEIRFUTUREWORKERS#ORPORATIONSAS THESUMMEROFINWHICHHETALKEDABOUT hTHEAU
DIFFERENTAS-C$ONALDS $ISCOVERY#HANNEL -ERCK DACITYOFHOPEvANDTHEhINSISTENCEONSMALLMIRACLES v
)"- AND.IKEDONATEDHUNDREDSOFMILLIONSOFDOLLARS WASTHEMOSTVISIBLEADVOCATEOFBIPARTISANSHIP(E
FORTHESTATESTODEVELOPINTENSIVEREADINGPROGRAMS HADALREADYPROVEDHISSKILLINTHE)LLINOISSTATELEGISLA
ANDTRAINLITERACYCOACHESFORTHOSESTUDENTSWHOWERE TURE GARNERINGSUPPORTFROMBOTHPARTIESFORALAWTHAT
INDANGEROFFAILING CULTURALDIVERSITYPROGRAMSTOHELP WOULDREQUIRETHEPOLICETOVIDEOTAPECAPITAL CRIME
ALLSTUDENTSLEARNTOWORKTOGETHERINASOCIETYTHATWAS INTERROGATIONS

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

)N THIS3ENATORWHOWASSOSKILLEDATUNITING !BUNDANT


NOTDIVIDING ANDWHOPROMOTEDTHEIMPORTANCEOF
lSCALRESPONSIBILITY LESSGOVERNMENTINTRUSIONINOUR h)MAGINEv
PERSONALLIVES ANDSENSIBLECONSTRAINTSONTHEGROWTH
OFGOVERNMENT WASELECTEDTHElRST!FRICAN !MERICAN

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
0RESIDENTOFTHE5NITED3TATES

2ESOURCES
)N WITHTHENEW#ONGRESSINAMOODTOAC
COMPLISHGREATTHINGSANDTHENEWPRESIDENTREADYTO
LEADTHECOUNTRYINANEWDIRECTION OURGOVERNMENT
lNALLYFACEDOURMOUNTINGECONOMICPROBLEMS4HE
3CARCE
WARIN)RAQ WHICHHADDRAGGEDONSINCE CONTIN
UEDTOBEAHUGEDRAINONOURECONOMY ALONGWITHTHE
PRICEOFOIL&INALLY IN AFTERINTENSIVEBEHIND THE
SCENESNEGOTIATIONS A0ALESTINIANSTATEWASESTABLISHED THOSEWHOFOLLOW THATCARINGFOROURSENIORCITIZENS
ANDWEWEREABLETOGRACEFULLYEXTRICATEOURSELVESFROM WILLNOTBECOMEANUNREASONABLElNANCIALBURDENFOR
)RAQ THEIRGENERATIONS
!LSOIN TWOMAJORTECHNOLOGICALBREAK
THROUGHSMADETHE5NITED3TATESVIRTUALLYINDEPEN 7HERE$O7E'OFROM(ERE
DENTOFTHE!RABCOUNTRIESAND/0%#!FTERYEARSOF !TTHETIMETHESTATESWERECREATINGTHEIRPLANS
RESEARCH SCIENTISTSlNALLYTAPPEDTHERICHOIL BEARING FORTHENEWORGANIZATIONOFPUBLICSCHOOLS THEFEDERAL
SHALEINTHE&OUR#ORNERSAREAOFTHE5NITED3TATES GOVERNMENTWASCONTRIBUTINGSEVENPERCENTTOTHE
#OLORADO !RIZONA 5TAH AND.EW-EXICO WITHOUT TOTALNATIONALEDUCATIONBUDGET&OURYEARSAGO WHEN
REQUIRINGCOLDWATEREXTRACTIONTECHNIQUES3ECOND THE THEWARIN)RAQENDEDANDTHEPRICEOFOILDROPPED THE
DEVELOPMENTOFHYBRIDGAS ELECTRICPROPULSIONSYSTEMS GOVERNMENTTOOKSTOCKOFITSlNANCIALSITUATION ITS
ANDHYDROGENCELLFUELTECHNOLOGIESINAUTOMOBILES COMMITMENTTOEDUCATION ANDTHEACCOMPLISHMENTS
WHICHHADBEGUNINEARNESTINTHEEARLYS lNALLY OFTHENEWPUBLICSCHOOLSANDDOUBLEDITSAPPROPRIA
WEREPERFECTED"ECAUSETHESETECHNOLOGIESWERESO TIONTOEDUCATION/NCEWESEETHEEFFECTSOFTHENEW
MUCHMOREREADILYAVAILABLEANDEASYTOUSE THEIR 3OCIAL3ECURITYREGULATIONS THEREMIGHTBEEVENMORE
POPULARITYINCREASEDEXPONENTIALLY THEREBYDRASTICALLY FUNDINGFORTHESCHOOLS
REDUCINGTHE5NITED3TATESNEEDFOROILANDGAS )NSPITEOFTHISINCREASEDFUNDINGANDTHENEW
!LTHOUGHTHEECONOMYIMPROVEDASTHEPRESIDENT SMARTERATTITUDEABOUTWHATMAKESASCHOOLAGOOD
WORKEDTOBRINGDOWNOURDEBT THEREWASSTILLTHEHUGE ONE THEREARESTILLTOOMANYSCHOOLSINTHISCOUNTRY
BURDENOF3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICAREFORTHEBABY MAINLYINURBANANDRURALAREAS WHERESTUDENTSARENOT
BOOMERS%ARLIERTHISYEAR 0RESIDENT/BAMAMANAGED RECEIVINGANADEQUATEEDUCATION4HESEARETHESCHOOLS
TOWORKOUTADIFlCULTANDCOURAGEOUSCOMPROMISEIN NOBODYCOMPETEDTOTAKEOVERANDCHANGEBECAUSE
WHICHSENIORCITIZENSWITHINCOMESOFOVER  THEPREVAILINGPERCEPTIONWASTHATTHECHILDRENWERE
PERYEARFROMSTOCKS SAVINGS REALESTATE PENSIONS AND TOOPOOR THEFAMILIESDIDNTCARE ANDORITWOULDBE
OTHERASSETSRECEIVELOWERBENElTSANDCANEVENOPT IMPOSSIBLETOATTRACTTOPTEACHERSANDADMINISTRATORS
TORECEIVENOBENElTS(EALSOISADVOCATINGASLIGHT DESPITEADEQUATEFUNDINGBECAUSETHESCHOOLSWERESO
INCREASEOFPERCENTINPAYROLLTAXESDESIGNATEDFOR DEEPLYRURAL4HESEARETHESCHOOLSTOWHICHWENOW
3OCIAL3ECURITYBEGINNINGNEXTYEAR TOBEINCREASED NEEDTOTURNOURATTENTION
EVERYlVEYEARSATTHERATEOFPERCENT4HISSLOWSTHE )N!UGUSTOFTHISYEAR )WILLSTEPDOWNASYOUR
DRAINONTHERESOURCESOF3OCIAL3ECURITYFORTHETIME 0RESIDENT TORUNONEOFTHESESCHOOLS)WILLSTAY
BEING ANDALLOWSTHEPOOLOFMONEYTOBEGININCREAS HEREIN7ASHINGTON $#ANDSERVEAS(EADMASTER
ING4HEGOVERNMENTHASSUCCEEDEDINASSURINGTHE OF!NACOSTIA(IGH3CHOOLINTHESOUTHEASTSECTIONOF
YOUNG-ILLENNIALSWHOARENOWINTHEWORKFORCE AND THECITY-YlRSTSTEPWILLBETOCREATEAPROGRAMTHAT


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

WILLBRINGPARENTSINTOTHESCHOOLONAREGULARBASIS TODEMANDIMPROVEDSCHOOLSFORTHEIRCHILDRENTHAT
ANDTHENTEACHTHEMHOWTOBEADVOCATESFORTHEIR THEYWILLBEHEARD/URJOBISTOGIVETHEMTHETOOLS
CHILDRENSEDUCATION)HAVETHE*AMES#OMERSCHOOLS THEYNEEDTOBEGINORGANIZING
IN.EW(AVENASAMODELANDWILL )AMSURE HAVEA )TSATOUGHJOB BUTTHEMEMBERSOFTHISORGANIZA
STEEPLEARNINGCURVE-YHOPEISTHAT)WILLBEABLETO TIONHAVENEVERSHRUNKFROMEVENSEEMINGLYIMPOSSI
CREATEANEWANDSUCCESSFULPARENTINVOLVEMENTAND BLETASKS7EHAVEBEENANINTEGRALPARTNERINTHEVAST
TRAININGPROGRAMANDTHENSHARETHATPROGRAMWITH IMPROVEMENTSINTHEPUBLICSCHOOLSINTHISCOUNTRY
OTHERSCHOOLSINSIMILARSITUATIONS0ARENTINVOLVEMENT AND)PREDICTTHATWEWILLEXTENDTHATWORKUNTILALL
ASWEWELLKNOW ISPERHAPSTHEKEYFACTORINTURNING SCHOOLSOFFERALLOURCHILDRENTHEBESTPROGRAMSWITH
AROUNDCHILDRENANDTHEIRSCHOOLSANDINTRULYLEAVING THEBESTCHOICES)THASBEENMYHONORTOWORKWITH
NOCHILDBEHIND YOUOVERTHEPASTTENYEARS AND)WISHYOUASMUCH
!S)SEEIT THEWORKOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONGOING SUCCESSINTHENEXTTENYEARSASWEHAVEENJOYEDINTHE
FORWARDSHOULDMOVEINTWODIFFERENT BUTCOMPLEMEN PASTTEN
TARYDIRECTIONS
7ARMREGARDS
s &IRST WENEEDTOREFOCUSOURACTIVITIESATTHE -ARY2OLLINS
STATELEVEL7ENEEDTOBEGINTOPLAYMOREOFA 7ASHINGTON $#
hCONCERNEDSTAKEHOLDERvROLE CONVINCINGSTATE .ATIONAL0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION0RESIDENT n
GOVERNMENTSTHATASLONGASTHEREARESCHOOLS
INTHEINNERCITIESANDRURALAREASTHATHAVENOT
BEENIMPROVED THATTHEIRNEWPUBLICSCHOOL !NALYSISOF3CENARIO
PROGRAMISNOTSUCCESSFUL7EMUSTPERSUADETHE )MPLICATIONS
STATEGOVERNMENTSTOSETASIDEAPOOLOFMONEY
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONHASBEENVERYSUCCESSFULIN
TOREWARDTHOSEORGANIZATIONSWHOAREWILLING
THISABUNDANTFUTUREWITHMANYSCHOOLINGOPTIONSFOR
TOTACKLETHESCHOOLSWITHTHEMOSTINTRACTABLE
PARENTSANDTHEIRCHILDREN4HEORGANIZATIONSMEM
PROBLEMS)TWILLBEUPTOTHESTATESTOlNDTHE
BERSHIPISSTRONG THEIRINmUENCEISWIDE ANDTHEY
RIGHTORGANIZATIONS BUTIFTHEYOFFERTHERIGHT
ARETHRIVING(OWEVER WHETHERBYDESIGNORNOT THE
lNANCIALINCENTIVESANDCREATETHERIGHTRELATION
ORGANIZATIONHASCOMETOREPRESENTTHEhHAVESvINTHIS
SHIPSWITHTHEBUSINESSCOMMUNITY THEREWILLBE
SCENARIO-EMBERSTENDTOBEMIDDLEANDUPPER MIDDLE
MANYAPPLICANTSFORTHEJOB/URJOBISTOLOBBY
CLASSANDTHEIRCHILDRENAREINTHESUCCESSFULSCHOOLS
THESTATESTOSENDTHEMESSAGE ANDTOPUTTHEIR
3OTHISSCENARIOHASWORKEDFORSOMEPARENTS BUTNOT
MONEYWHERETHEIRMESSAGEIS THATINTHISFREE
ALL(ASTHEORGANIZATIONCONTRIBUTEDTOTHATSITUATION
MARKETECONOMY NOSCHOOLSWILLBELEFTBEHIND
ANDSHOULDTHEYWORKTOCORRECTIT7HATARETHERISKS
s 3ECONDLY ATTHEGRASSROOTSLEVEL WENEEDTOREACH OFADDRESSINGTHENEEDSOFTHEHAVE NOTS
OUTTOTHEPARENTSOFCHILDRENINFAILINGSCHOOLS "ECAUSEOFTHEINmUENCETHAT0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCANNOTANDSHOULDNOTBEAN HASMANAGEDTOWIELD THEIRMEMBERSHIPNOWINCLUDES
ORGANIZATIONTHATREPRESENTSONLYTHEMIDDLECLASS MEMBERSWHOARENOTPARENTSBUTWHOWANTTOHAVE
7ENEEDTOACKNOWLEDGEOURINCREASINGLYDIVERSE AVOICEINANDHELPTHEPUBLICSCHOOLS&OREXAMPLE
SOCIETYANDEMBRACETHOSEPARENTSWHOARETOO MANYRETIREDBABYBOOMERSJOINEDWITHTHEINTENTION
AFRAIDOROVERWORKEDTOSPEAKOUTONBEHALFOFTHEIR OFhDOINGGOODv)NORDERTOCONTINUETOGROWAND
CHILDREN7ENEEDTOSEEKOUTTHENEWIMMIGRANTS ATTRACTAVARIETYOFMEMBERS PERHAPSTHENAMEOFTHE
ANDTEACHTHEMHOWOUR!MERICAN$EMOCRACY ORGANIZATIONSHOULDBECHANGEDTO h0UBLIC#ITIZENSFOR
WORKS ANDTHATIFWEWORKTOGETHERANDSPEAKOUT %DUCATIONv

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

)NDICATORS !BUNDANT

4HELEADERSANDTHEMEMBERSOF0ARENTSFOR%DUCA
TIONWOULDNEEDTOWATCHCERTAINTRENDSNOWTOSEE h)MAGINEv

IFTHISPARTICULARFUTURESCENARIOORELEMENTSOFTHIS

,IMITED
SCENARIOAREWHERETHEFUTUREISHEADING 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
2ESOURCES
s /NEMAJORINDICATORISTHESUCCESSORFAILUREOF
.#,")FTHE&EDERALGOVERNMENTLOSESTHESE
LAWSUITSTOTHESTATESANDTHE.%! 0ARENTSFOR
%DUCATIONCOULDBEGINAGITATINGFORTHISNEWhFREE
3CARCE
MARKETvFORPUBLICSCHOOLS

s !NOTHERINDICATORTOWATCHISTHEPERCENTAGEOF
SCHOOLSNOTMAKING!90ANDWHETHERORNOTTHE
/PTIONS
CHARTERGROUPSTHATTAKEOVERTHEMARESUCCESSFUL
#URRENTLY THEREISMUCHCONTROVERSYOVERTHE s )F0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCONTINUESDOINGWHATIT
SUCCESSOFTHECHARTERSCHOOLSANDUNLESSTHEYCAN ISDOINGNOW UNDERTHISSCENARIOITWILLPROBABLY
IMPROVETHEIRSUCCESSRATESWITHSTUDENTSTEST GROWANDPROSPER4HEORGANIZATIONHASPLENTY
SCORES THEFUNDINGENTITIESARENOTGOINGTOBE OFMEMBERSANDENOUGHMONEY!LTHOUGHTHE
WILLINGTOMOVETOASYSTEMTHATPROVIDESGREATER MEMBERSHIPISMAINLYMIDDLE ANDUPPER MIDDLE
CHOICE CLASSPEOPLE ITISWORKINGFORTHEM SOTHEYNEED
TOTHINKCAREFULLYABOUTCHANGINGTACTICS
s &INALLY 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONNEEDSTOWATCHTHE
POLITICALSITUATION)F IN NEWMEMBERSOF s 4HEREISSOMEDANGEROFABACKLASHTOTHETWO
#ONGRESSAREELECTEDWHOWANTTOCONTINUEON TIEREDSYSTEMOFEDUCATIONDESCRIBEDINTHIS
THEPATHOFFEDERALCONTROLOFTHESCHOOLS ITIS SCENARIO0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONSHOULDCONSIDER
NOTLIKELYTHATTHISSCENARIOWILLUNFOLD(OWEVER BUILDINGRELATIONSHIPSWITHTHECOMMUNITY
IFTHEELECTORATECHOOSESTOSENDTO#ONGRESS ORGANIZATIONSTHATSERVETHEGROWINGIMMIGRANT
REPRESENTATIVESWHOAREOPENTOOTHERWAYSTO POPULATIONS7ITHTHEDEMOGRAPHICSOFTHIS
IMPROVETHENATIONSSCHOOLS THISSCENARIOCOULD COUNTRYRAPIDLYCHANGINGOVERTHENEXTTENYEARS
TAKEPLACE4HESAMEISTRUEFORTHEPRESIDENTIAL ANDTHE-ILLENNIALPARENTSCOMFORTABLEWITH
ELECTIONOF4HENEXTPRESIDENTWILLBEA DIVERSITY 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONNEEDSTOCAREFULLY
DECIDINGFACTORINWHETHERCONTROLOFTHESCHOOLS CONSIDERHOWITWILLBRINGTHENEW!MERICANS
ISRETURNEDTOTHESTATESORWHETHERTHEFEDERAL INTOTHEFOLDANDASSISTTHEMINBECOMINGFULL
GOVERNMENTCONTINUESTOSETPOLICY mEDGEDCITIZENS4HEORGANIZATIONNEEDSTOTHINK
HARDABOUTWHOTHEYAREGOINGTOSERVE
s 4HENEXT#ONGRESSANDADMINISTRATIONWILL
ALSOBETHEMAJORINmUENCESONTHEECONOMY)F s 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCOULDFORMAPANELOF
THEYCHOOSETOSERIOUSLYINVESTINALTERNATIVE MEMBERSANDhCRITICALFRIENDSvTOHELPCREATEA
ENERGYSOLUTIONSANDORIFTHEYSEEKANEVEN STRATEGICPLANFORTHEFUTURE7ITHINPUTFROMNOT
HANDEDSOLUTIONTOPEACEANDPROSPERITYINTHE ONLYMEMBERS BUTKNOWLEDGEABLEANDIMPORTANT
-IDDLE%AST ITISPOSSIBLETHATTHEREWILLBE MEMBERSOFTHELOCAL STATE ANDNATIONAL
ADDITIONALFUNDINGFORTHESCHOOLS(OWEVER IF COMMUNITY 0&%COULDMAKEMOREINFORMED
THEGOVERNMENTCONTINUESSPENDINGMONEYON DECISIONSABOUTEXACTLYWHICHPOPULATIONSITIS
WARSANDMILITARYOPTIONSAROUNDTHEWORLD ITIS GOINGTOSERVE
UNLIKELYTHATTHEFUNDINGFOREDUCATIONWILLBE
ADEQUATE MUCHLESSABUNDANT


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP !BUNDANT

!SSOCIATION3CENARIO
$EEP#AUSES

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
4HISSCENARIOASSUMESTHATCOMPETITIONAMONG
PUBLICSCHOOLSHASDRAMATICALLYINCREASEDBECAUSE

2ESOURCES
PARENTSCONTINUETODEMANDMORECHOICESINSCHOOLING
THEIRCHILDRENANDTHEPUBLICSCHOOLhMARKETvHASRE h,IVEAND,ET$IEv

SPONDED(OWEVER SCARCEFEDERALRESOURCESFORSCHOOL
ING LIMITEDACCOUNTABILITYFORSOMESCHOOLSOFCHOICE 3CARCE
ANDTHEVAGARIESOFASEMI FREEMARKETECONOMYHAVE
PRODUCEDUNEVENQUALITYINTHEPUBLICSCHOOLS

4HEFOLLOWINGDEEPCAUSESCOULDLEADTOTHISSCENARIO #OMPAREDTOADECADEAGO PARENTSIN HAVE


MORECHOICESTHANEVERFORSCHOOLINGTHEIRCHILDREN
s 4HENUMBEROFSCHOOLSNOTMEETINGADEQUATE h3UPPLYANDDEMANDvARETENETSTHATPUBLICEDUCATION
YEARLYPROGRESS!90 UNDERTHE.O#HILD,EFT ISSTILLTRYINGTOGROWACCUSTOMEDTOˆEVENYEARS
"EHIND!CT.#," INCREASES LEADINGTOMORE AFTERWESAWTHETRENDSHIFTINGTOWARDPARENTALCHOICE
SCHOOLSENTERINGRESTRUCTURING OFSCHOOLING%VENTHOUGHTODAYPERCENTOFALLPUB
s )NRESPONSETOSOMANYSCHOOLSBEINGRESTRUC LICLYENROLLEDSTUDENTSATTENDSCHOOLSOFCHOICE MANY
TURED PARENTSSEIZEONTHEhCHOICEvPROVISIONSIN IFNOTMOST PEOPLEINTHEPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEMSTILL
THELAWANDDEMANDMORECHOICESFORSCHOOLING HAVENOTEMBRACEDhCHOICEvASPARTOFTHEPUBLICEDU
THEIRCHILDREN CATIONLEXICON!NDYET THEREISNODOUBTTHAT TODAY
THEPUBLICSCHOOLhMARKETvRESEMBLESAFREEMARKET
s )NSPITEOFGROWINGDISSATISFACTIONWITHTHELAW WHERECONSUMERSMAKECHOICESBASEDONTHEIRNEEDS
#ONGRESSANDTHEADMINISTRATIONDIGINTHEIR ANDDESIRESANDTHEMARKETRESPONDSANDPUBLICSCHOOLS
HEELSON.#,"ANDTHELAWISREAUTHORIZED lNDTHEMSELVESCOMPETINGFORTEACHERSANDSTUDENTS
LARGELYUNCHANGED !STHENATIONALLEADEROFPARENTSCONCERNEDABOUT
EDUCATION OURWORKLIESINHELPINGPARENTSUNDER
STANDHOWTHEYCANMAKEADIFFERENCEINTHEIRCHILDS
SCHOOLING3CHOOLINGNOWISMOREABOUTMAKINGYOUR
h,IVEAND,ET$IEv CHOICESCOUNTTHANLIVINGWITHINABROKENDOWN
4IME*UNE  SYSTEMORlGURINGOUTHOWTOESCAPEIT)NTHISCONTEXT
0LACE7ASHINGTON $# OFMORECHOICES 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONSROLEWILLBE
TOHELPPARENTSMAKESMARTCHOICES4HENEW#HARTER
3CENE0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION 3PECIAL.EWSLETTER
3CHOOL!CCOUNTABILITY!CT WHICHWASPASSEDBY
TH!NNIVERSARY2ETROSPECTIVE
#ONGRESSWITHYOURHELP WILLPROVIDESOMESTABILITYTO
THECHARTERSCHOOLMOVEMENTANDTHERELATIVELYNEW
!S0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONCELEBRATESITSTHYEAR MARKET DRIVENPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEMINTHE5NITED
ANDLOOKSFORWARDTOTHECHALLENGESAHEAD THENEWS 3TATES!SWELOOKFORWARDTOMORESUCCESSFULYEARS
LETTEREDITORIALSTAFFOFFERSTHISRETROSPECTIVELETTERIN AS0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION LETSTAKEALOOKBACKATHOW
ANEFFORTTOMAKESENSEOFTHETREMENDOUSCHANGESIN THEPASTYEARSHAVEDElNEDTHISNEWANDEXCITING
PUBLICEDUCATIONWEHAVESEENSINCEWECELEBRATEDOUR DIRECTIONFORPUBLICEDUCATION7ECALLTHESEYEARS
THANNIVERSARY FROMnTHEh#HOICE$ECADEv

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

!4URNING0OINT  0ARENTSOFTHISGENERATIONWERETHEMOSTEDU


&ACEDWITHADWINDLINGMEMBERSHIPANDINCREAS CATEDANDTHEMOSTINDEPENDENTGENERATIONOF
INGLYAGITATEDANDINVOLVEDPARENTS IN 0ARENTS PARENTSEVER
FOR%DUCATIONREALIZEDTHATASANORGANIZATIONWEWERE  4ECHNOLOGYANDTHERISEOFTHEINFORMATIONAGE
ATACROSSROADSˆBECOMERELEVANTORGOTHEWAYOF MADETHISGENERATIONOFPARENTShTHEMOSTCOM
THEDINOSAUR!SANATIONALORGANIZATION WEHADLOST MUNICATEDTOvANDTHEMOSThSCHOOLSAVVYv
SIGHTOFOUROBJECTIVETOSUPPORTANDENCOURAGEPAREN
TALINVOLVEMENTINTHEEDUCATIONOFTHEIRCHILDREN ONE  2ESEARCHESTABLISHEDADIRECTCORRELATIONBETWEEN
OFOURFUNDAMENTALANDFOUNDINGGOALS0ARENTSWERE PARENTALINVOLVEMENTANDSTUDENTPERFORMANCE
LEAVING0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION BUTTHEYWERENOTABAN
 4HERANGEOFOPTIONSFORSCHOOLINGPLACEDPARENTS
DONINGINVOLVEMENTINTHEIRCHILDRENSEDUCATION)F
INTHEhEDUCATIONALDRIVERSSEAT vOFTENREQUIRING
ANYTHING THEYWEREMOREINVOLVEDTHANEVER BUTTHEY
TOTALPLANNINGFROMPRESCHOOLTHROUGHCOLLEGE
WEREJOININGLOCALORGANIZATIONS UNAFlLIATEDWITHOUR
NATIONALASSOCIATION ANDTHEYWEREPLAYINGSIGNIlCANT  &INALLY PARENTSWEREBECOMINGINVOLVEDIN
ROLESINTHEIRINDIVIDUALSCHOOLS SCHOOLREFORMEFFORTSANDLEAVINGTHEIRMARKAS
7HATWEBELIEVEDTHEN ASWEDONOW WASTHATSOLE LEADERSINTHESEEFFORTS
CONCENTRATIONONINDIVIDUALSCHOOLSWOULDULTIMATELY
HARMPUBLICEDUCATION0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONSTILLHAD !SWEENTEREDOURTHYEAR 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION
AROLETOPLAYASANADVOCATEATTHENATIONALLEVELFOR LOOKEDBACKTOOURORIGINALGOALSANDFORWARDTOTHE
THEHEALTH SAFETY ANDQUALITYOFEDUCATIONFOROURCHIL FUTURENEEDSOFPARENTSANDTHEIRCHILDRENTOEMERGE
DREN BUTWEHADOURWORKCUTOUTFORUS7EHADTO WITHANEWAGENDAFORINmUENCINGANDSUPPORTINGTHE
DETERMINETHEINTERSECTIONBETWEENPARENTSHAVINGAN EDUCATIONOFCHILDREN0ARENTSWANTEDASAYINTHEIR
IMMEDIATEIMPACTONTHEIROWNCHILDSSCHOOLINGAND CHILDRENSSCHOOLING ANDTHEYWANTEDTHEIRCHILDREN
PARENTSBECOMINGhADVOCATESFORALLvSCHOOLCHILDREN TOHAVESUCCESSFULEXPERIENCESATSCHOOL!SCONSE
!NANALYSISOFTHEhPARENTARIATvˆTHERISINGCLASS QUENCESFROMTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND!CTOF
THATEMERGEDASTHEMOSTIMPORTANTPLAYERSINTHElELD .#," MOVEDMORESCHOOLSCLOSERTOSANCTIONSAND
OFEDUCATIONˆREVEALEDSEVERALCOMMONFACTORSTHAT POSSIBLERESTRUCTURING OURSTRATEGYWASTOHELPPARENTS
WEREDRIVINGTHECENTRALITYOFPARENTSINTHEEDUCATION UNDERSTANDTHECHOICESAVAILABLETOTHEMUNDERTHE
OFTHEIRCHILDRENATATIMEWHENOURMEMBERSHIPWAS LAWANDREMAININVOLVEDINSAVINGANDTRANSFORMING
DECLINING!SREPORTEDIN%DUCATION7EEKIN/CTOBER THEIRCOMMUNITYSCHOOLS
OF


/N/CTOBER  THE7ASHINGTON0OSTREPORTEDTHATTHENATIONALMEMBERSHIPOFTHE04!DECLINEDFROMAHIGHOFMILLIONIN
TOAPPROXIMATELYMILLIONIN!NDREW2OTHERHAM DIRECTOROFEDUCATIONPOLICYFORTHE0ROGRESSIVE0OLICY)NSTITUTE SUMMEDUPOUR
SITUATIONRATHERCONCISELYh0EOPLELOOKATWHATIMPACTSTHEMMOSTIMMEDIATELYv

0ALEY !2 /CTOBER h04/S,URE0ARENTS3ICKOF3PLIT04!$UES v7ASHINGTON0OST2ETRIEVED/CTOBER  FROM
HTTPWWWWASHINGTONPOSTCOM

)BID !NDREW2OTHERHAM DIRECTOROFEDUCATIONPOLICYFORTHE0ROGRESSIVE0OLICY)NSTITUTE SUMMEDUPTHESITUATIONOFTHENATIONAL04!
LOSINGITSMEMBERSHIP STATINGh0EOPLELOOKATWHATIMPACTSTHEMMOSTIMMEDIATELYv

!SREPORTEDINh4HE2ISEOFTHE@0ARENTARIATvBY)RVING("UCHENINTHE/CTOBER  EDITIONOF%DUCATION7EEK


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

n3TATES'ROUSEAND#HOICE#OMES !BUNDANT
"EGGING
)N WESAWANUNPRECEDENTEDSURGEOFSTATE
MOVEMENTAGAINST.#,"&RUSTRATEDWITHWHATTHEY

,IMITED
CONSIDEREDAFEDERALINTRUSIONINTOSTATEANDLOCAL 3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
RIGHTS LEGISLATURESFROM5TAHTO&LORIDAˆMANYOF

2ESOURCES
WHOMWERESTRONGSUPPORTERSOFTHEARCHITECTOFTHE
LAW 'EORGE7"USHˆPUSHEDBACKAGAINSTTHE h,IVEAND,ET$IEv
REQUIREMENTSOFTHELAW!LMOSTSTATELEGISLATURES
MADESOMEATTEMPTATCHALLENGINGIT AND5TAHSGOV 3CARCE
ERNORACTUALLYSIGNEDABILLPRIORITIZINGTHESTATESAC
COUNTABILITYSYSTEMOVER.#,")N!PRILOF THE
.ATIONAL%DUCATION!SSOCIATIONSUEDTHE53$EPART
MENTOF%DUCATIONUNDERTHEPREMISECALLEDhIRONICv !LTHOUGH IN ASTHEYHADBEENFORDECADES
BYSOME THATTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTWASFORCING PUBLICSCHOOLSWERETHEOVERWHELMINGOPTIONFORMOST
hUNFUNDEDMANDATESvONTOSTATEANDLOCALEDUCATION CHILDREN INCREASINGNUMBERSOFPARENTSENROLLEDTHEIR
AGENCIES FORCINGTHEMTOSPENDTOOMUCHMONEYON CHILDRENINPRIVATESCHOOL ANDMANYPARENTSTURNEDTO
EDUCATION HOMESCHOOLING.OLONGERACHOICESOLELYOFGROUPS
4HESTATESWERELARGELYUNSUCCESSFULINTHEIRAT ATOPPOSITEENDSOFTHEPOLITICALSPECTRUMˆPRIMAR
TEMPTSTOOVERTURNORCHANGE.#,"HOWEVER THEY ILYWHITE RELIGIOUSCONSERVATIVESONTHEONEEND AND
DIDlNDSUCCESSINRULECHANGESTHATALLOWEDMORE ANTI ESTABLISHMENTFREE THINKERSONTHEOTHERˆBY
SCHOOLSTOMEETTESTSCORETARGETSAND!90FROM  APPROXIMATELYMILLIONCHILDRENWEREHOME
n$ESPITETHESESUCCESSES DRIVENBYRELAXED SCHOOLED-OREKIDSWEREBEINGTAUGHTATHOMEBY
STANDARDSFORMEETING!90 THENUMBEROFSCHOOLSIN THEIRPARENTSTHANTHENUMBEROFPUBLICSCHOOLSTU
CREASEDINTHENEEDINGIMPROVEMENTCATEGORYFORTWO DENTSIN7YOMING 6ERMONT $ELAWARE .ORTH$AKOTA
CONSECUTIVEYEARS)N WEBEGANTOSEESCHOOLS !LASKA 3OUTH$AKOTA 2HODE)SLAND -ONTANA AND
THATHADFAILEDTOMEET!90FORlVECONSECUTIVEYEARS (AWAIICOMBINED3TILL FORMOSTPARENTS HOMEOR
ENTERRESTRUCTURING3OMEWERETAKENOVERBYTHEIR PRIVATESCHOOLINGWASNOTANOPTION
STATES SOMEBYPRIVATECOMPANIES ANDOTHERSWERE &ORTHOSEWHOWEREPAYINGATTENTIONANDNOT
REOPENEDASCHARTERSCHOOLS MANYPEOPLEWERE THEMOVEMENTAFOOTINWAS


3EE-ARGARET3PELLINGSCOMMENTARYIN53!4ODAYON-AY ATHTTPWWWUSATODAYCOMPRINTEDEDITIONNEWS
OPLEDEARTHTMAND%DUWONK"LOGFOR!PRIL ATEDUWONKCOM

#ENTERON%DUCATION0OLICY /CTOBER 2ULECHANGESCOULDHELPMORESCHOOLSMEETTESTSCORETARGETSFORTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
!CT!CCORDINGTOTHISREPORT h3OMEOFTHECHANGESREQUESTEDBYSTATESAREINTENDEDTOTAKEADVANTAGEOFREVISIONSMADEBYTHE53$EPARTMENT
OF%DUCATIONINFEDERALGUIDELINESFORTESTINGSTUDENTSWITHDISABILITIES TESTING%NGLISHLANGUAGELEARNERS ANDCALCULATINGTHEPERCENTAGE
OFSTUDENTSTAKINGSTATETESTS/THERCHANGESPROPOSEDBYSTATESWOULDPROVIDEMOREmEXIBILITYINAREASNOTADDRESSEDBYTHEREVISEDFEDERAL
GUIDELINESORWOULDALLOWSTATESTOADOPTPOLICIESTHE$EPARTMENTHADALREADYAPPROVEDFOROTHERSTATESvP )N STATESHADREQUESTED
CHANGESTOTHEIR.#,"ACCOUNTABILITYPLANSˆTYPICALLYCHANGESTHATWOULDMAKEITEASIERFORSCHOOLSANDDISTRICTSTOMEET!90REQUIREMENTS
4HE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONGRANTEDMANYOFTHESEREQUESTEDCHANGESANDEASEDSOMEOTHERTESTINGREQUIREMENTSFORSTUDENTSWITHDISABILITIES
AND%NGLISHLANGUAGELEARNERSANDFORCALCULATINGTESTPARTICIPATIONRATES

)N SLIGHTLYOVERAPPROXIMATELY   OFALLSTUDENTSWEREENROLLEDINPUBLICSCHOOLSˆBUTOTHEROPTIONSWEREBECOMING
MOREPOPULARWITHPARENTS!LTHOUGHTHEYACCOUNTEDFORLESSTHANTWOPERCENTOFTHETOTALPUBLICSCHOOLPOPULATION SOMEWHEREBETWEEN
 AND  STUDENTSATTENDEDAPUBLICCHARTERSCHOOLIN0RIVATESCHOOLSACCOUNTEDFORLITTLEMORETHANAPPROXIMATELY
   OFENROLLMENTS$ATACOMPILEDFROM.#%3PROJECTIONSFOR&ALLENROLLMENTSINPUBLICSCHOOLSHTTPNCESEDGOV THE#ENTER
FOR%DUCATION2EFORM HTTPWWWEDREFORMCOM AND#HARTER3CHOOL,EADERSHIP#OUNCILHTTPWWWCHARTERSCHOOLLEADERSHIPCOUNCILORG 

$ATAFROMA.#%3REPORTINDICATESTHATMILLIONCHILDRENWEREBEINGHOMESCHOOLEDINHTTPNCESEDGOVNHESHOMESCHOOL

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

PARENTALCHOICEOFSCHOOLS4HETRENDFORCHOICEWAS INFRASTRUCTURESTHEYNEEDEDALREADYINPLACE!FTER
ESTABLISHEDINTHEDECADEFROMn2ATHER YEARSINTHELEGALSYSTEM THE.%!SLAWSUITAGAINST
THANSTICKINGWITHTHEIRNEIGHBORHOODSCHOOLS PARENTS THE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONANDTHEhUNFUNDED
ASKEDTHEQUESTION h7HATSTHEBESTPUBLICSCHOOL MANDATESvOF.#,"WASTHROWNOUTOFCOURT.#,"
CHOICEFORMYCHILD4HEANSWER OFTEN WASSOMETHING ITSEEMED WASHERETOSTAY4HELAWREMAINEDINTACTAS
OTHERTHANTHECHILDSDESIGNATEDPUBLICSCHOOL)NFACT THE0RESIDENTAND#ONGRESSFOCUSEDONOTHERPRIORITIES
INA YEARSPAN THEPERCENTAGEOFPARENTSENROLLING ˆSUCHAS3OCIAL3ECURITY2EFORM
THEIRCHILDRENINACHOSENPUBLICSCHOOLINCREASEDBY &UELEDBYANAGGRESSIVECAMPAIGNTHATBEGANEARLY
PERCENT IN 0RESIDENT"USHAND#ONGRESSlNALLYPASSED
THE0RESIDENTSPLANTOREFORM3OCIAL3ECURITYBY
n#HOICE(ERETO3TAY INSTITUTINGANINDEXEDPAYOUTSYSTEMANDVOLUNTARY
4HEELECTIONSOFLEFT2EPUBLICANSINCONTROL PERSONALRETIREMENTPLANSFORYOUNGERWORKERSWHILE
OFBOTHTHE(OUSEANDTHE3ENATE ANDDESPITECONTIN MAINTAININGTHESAFETYNETOF3OCIAL3ECURITYFORTHOSE
UEDPROTESTSFROMTHESTATES VERYLITTLECHANGEDWITH WORKERSBORNBEFORE"EGINNINGIN YOUNGER
.#,")NDEED ITAPPEAREDTHATTHESTRONGERTHEOUTCRY WORKERSWEREALLOWEDTOPLACEPARTOFTHEIRPAYROLL
AGAINSTTHELAW THEMORE#ONGRESSDUGINITSHEELS TAXESINTOACONSERVATIVEMIXOFBONDANDSTOCKFUNDS
ADDINGANEWTERMTOTHEEDUCATIONLEXICONWHEN THATHADTHEPOTENTIALTOEARNAHIGHERRATEOFRETURN
THESECRETARYOFEDUCATIONLABELEDDETRACTORSOFTHE THANANYTHINGTHECURRENTSYSTEMCOULDPROVIDE
LAWh4HE5NACCOUNTABLESv$URING'EORGE7"USHS -EANWHILE INTHEWORLDOFPUBLICEDUCATION THE
LASTYEARINOFlCE TRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLSSTRUGGLED INCREASEINTHENUMBERSOFSCHOOLSMEETING!90FROM
TOMEETTHENEEDSOFTHEIRSTUDENTSWITHSTAGNANTAND nTURNEDOUTTOBEASHORT TERMPHENOMENON
SLIGHTLYDECREASEDFUNDINGFROMTHEFEDERALLEVEL4HE !90CONTINUEDTOBECOMEHARDERTOMEETBECAUSETEST
CONmICTIN)RAQCONTINUEDTOSTRAINTHEECONOMY AND SCORETARGETSROSEOVERTIMETOWARDTHEULTIMATEGOAL
MOREMONEYWENTTOTRANSFORMINGTHEMILITARYFORTHE OFPERCENT ANDSOMEOFTHECHANGESGRANTEDBY
STCENTURY DEFENDINGTHEHOMELAND SUPPORTINGTHE THE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONONLYBROUGHTTEMPORARY
TROOPSASTHEYFOUGHTTHE7ARON4ERROR SPREADING RELIEF)NTHEnSCHOOLYEAR MANYMORE
FREEDOMTHROUGHOUTTHEWORLD ANDCONTINUINGPRO SCHOOLSFAILEDTOMEET!90 ANDTHEPERCENTAGEOF
GROWTHECONOMICPOLICIES.ON SECURITYDISCRETION SCHOOLSENTERINGSANCTIONSAFTERMISSING!90FORTWOOR
ARYSPENDING INCLUDINGEDUCATIONFUNDING DECLINED MORECONSECUTIVEYEARSCONTINUEDTOINCREASEASWELL
INBYPERCENT!LTHOUGH0RESIDENT"USHAND 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONPLAYEDANACTIVEROLEINHELPING
#ONGRESSWERESATISlEDWITHTHEPROGRESSOF.#," PARENTSUNDERSTANDTHEIRSCHOOLCHOICEOPTIONSWHEN
ANDPROMOTEDTHELAWSRECORDOFACHIEVEMENT STATES SCHOOLSENTEREDNEEDSIMPROVEMENTSTATUS ANDMORE
CONTINUEDTOSTRUGGLETOlNANCEITSTESTINGANDREPORT PARENTSTOOKADVANTAGEOFTHEOPPORTUNITYTOTRANSFER
INGREQUIREMENTS0ROTESTSANDCHALLENGESFROMSTATE THEIRCHILDRENTODIFFERENTSCHOOLSˆANOPTIONTHAT
LEGISLATURESSURFACEDAGAININ BUT3ECRETARY-AR PARENTSANDSTUDENTSHADRESISTEDATlRST)NTHESESITU
GARET3PELLINGSSTUCKTOHERhCOMMONSENSEvAPPROACH ATIONS MANYPUBLICSCHOOLSBECAMESCHOOLSOFCHOICE
TOTHELAWANDMAINTAINEDTHATSTATESHADTHETESTING


4HETOTALNUMBERSREMAINEDRELATIVELYSMALLAPPROXIMATELYOFALLPUBLICLYENROLLEDSTUDENTS BUTTHEPERCENTAGEINCREASESWERE
SUBSTANTIAL4HE#ONDITIONOF%DUCATIONINDICATEDTHATFROMn THEPERCENTAGEOFSTUDENTSINGRADESnATTENDINGA@CHOSEN
SCHOOLINCREASEDFROMTOWHICHREPRESENTSACHANGE

&ROM&EBRUARYn!PRIL 0RESIDENT"USHVISITEDDIFFERENTSTATESTOATTENDATLEASTEVENTSTODISCUSSHIS3OCIAL3ECURITYPLAN3OURCE
WWWWHITEHOUSEGOV

#ENTERON%DUCATION0OLICY /CTOBER 2ULECHANGESCOULDHELPMORESCHOOLSMEETTESTSCORETARGETSFORTHE.O#HILD,EFT"EHIND
!CT!CCORDINGTOTHISREPORTTHERELIEFBROUGHTONBYCHANGESINACCOUNTABILITYMODELSMIGHTBESHORT TERM


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

WHETHERORNOTTHEYLIKEDIT-ANYSCHOOLSTHATFACED !BUNDANT
RESTRUCTURINGTURNEDTOTHECHARTERSCHOOLCONVERSION
OPTION
/FTEN PARENTSWEREHAPPYWITHTHECHARTERSCHOOL
OPTION0ARENTSWITHINmUENCEORTHOSEWHOLIVEDIN

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
COMMUNITIESWITHSTRONGLEADERSHIPHADASAYINWHAT

2ESOURCES
THETRANSFORMEDSCHOOLLOOKEDLIKE HOWITOPERATED
WHATSTUDENTSLEARNED ANDWHATVALUESTHESCHOOL h,IVEAND,ET$IEv
WOULDIMPARTh)FMYCHILDSPUBLICSCHOOLISSOBADTHAT
ITNEEDSTOBETOTALLYOVERHAULED YOUREDARNRIGHT)
3CARCE
WANTASAYINWHATHAPPENSTOIT vSAID3EAN-ACKEY
AFATHERIN-ILWAUKEE EXPRESSINGASENTIMENTSHARED
BYMANYPARENTS0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONPLAYEDALARGE SCHOOLFACEDSOMETRADE OFFS!SAPUBLICLYFUNDED
ROLEINMOBILIZINGPARENTSANDTHECOMMUNITYINTHESE CHARTERSCHOOL THEONCERELIGIOUSPRIVATESCHOOLWOULD
SITUATIONS/URABILITYTOPROVIDECLARIlCATIONABOUT NOLONGERBEATOTALLYh#ATHOLICSCHOOL vBUTITWOULD
THELAWANDSTRATEGIES RESOURCES ANDTOOLSTHATPARENTS BEABLETOSTRUCTURETHECURRICULUM INSTRUCTION AND
COULDUSETOINmUENCETHESCHOOLTRANSFORMATION CULTUREOFTHESCHOOLASSUBSTANTIALLY#ATHOLIC EM
PROCESSHELPEDUSTOGROWOURMEMBERSHIPFORTHElRST PHASIZINGMORALDEVELOPMENTALLDAYEVERYDAY!ND
TIMEINOVERYEARS ACCORDINGTOLAW THESCHOOLWOULDBEALLOWEDTOGIVE
%VENPRIVATESCHOOLSFOUNDTHEMSELVESGETTINGIN STUDENTSRELEASETIMETOATTENDRELIGIOUSEDUCATION
ONTHECHARTERSCHOOLACTION)N$ETROIT FOREXAMPLE CLASSES THUSMAINTAININGITSTIESTOTHEPARISH
MANYPRIVATE#ATHOLICSCHOOLSWERESTRUGGLINGWITH &UNDINGWASANISSUEFORMANYCHARTERSCHOOLS ASIT
LOWERENROLLMENTS-ORESTUDENTSWERELEAVINGTHEIR WASFORTRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLS BUTCHARTERSHADTWO
PRIVATESCHOOLSTOATTENDPUBLICCHARTERSCHOOLS THE KEYFACTORSWORKINGINTHEIRFAVOR ABOOSTFROMTHE
DEMOGRAPHICSOFTHECITYWERECHANGING ANDTHE 53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONTHATREMAINEDSTABLE
SCHOOLSCOULDNOTSURVIVElNANCIALLY3UDDENLYTHE INTHEFEDERALEDUCATIONBUDGET AND INVENTIVENESS
CHARTERSCHOOLOPTIONBECAMEVERYAPPEALING!S ACHARACTERISTICFREQUENTLYASSOCIATEDWITHCHARTER
2EV*OHN4URNER PASTOROF3T-ARYS EXPLAINED h!S SCHOOLS4HE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONHADA
ACHARTER WEDONTHAVETOCHARGETUITION SOFEWER RECORDOFFUNDINGCHARTERSCHOOLSASPARTOFTHEhSTRA
STUDENTSLEAVEFORlNANCIALREASONS ANDWEHAVEMORE TEGICPLANTOUSESCHOOLCHOICEASATOOLFORIMPROVING
MONEYTOPROVIDEMOREOPTIONS SUCHASART MUSIC STUDENTACHIEVEMENT vANDSO DESPITEOVERALLCUTSIN
ANDATHLETICSv/FCOURSE INTHISCASE THE#ATHOLIC THEEDUCATIONBUDGET MANYESTABLISHEDPROGRAMSFOR
CHARTERSCHOOLSRETAINEDLEVELFUNDING


3OMEPRIVATE#ATHOLICSCHOOLSFACEDTHISDILEMMAANDBEGANEXPLORINGTHECHARTERSCHOOLOPTIONIN3EE0RATT # -ONTEMURRI 0 AND
(IGGINS , -ARCH h#ATHOLIC3CHOOL#LOSINGS0ARENTS +IDS3CRAMBLEAS%DUCATION/PTIONS.ARROWv$ETROIT&REE0RESS2ETRIEVED
-ARCH  FROMHTTPWWWFREEPCOMNEWSEDUCATIONSKULSE?HTM

&IRSTFUNDEDIN THE#REDIT%NHANCEMENTFOR#HARTER3CHOOL&ACILITIESPROGRAMWASCREATEDTOPROVIDEASSISTANCETOHELPCHARTER
SCHOOLSMEETTHEIRFACILITYNEEDS4HEPROGRAMWASDESIGNEDTOFURTHERTHE$EPARTMENTShSTRATEGICPLANTOUSESCHOOLCHOICEASATOOLFOR
IMPROVINGSTUDENTACHIEVEMENT vANDSO DESPITEOVERALLCUTSINTHEEDUCATIONBUDGET THE#REDIT%NHANCEMENTSPROGRAMREMAINEDLEVEL
FUNDEDATAPPROXIMATELY-PERYEAR PROVIDINGMUCHNEEDEDLEVERAGEFORCHARTERSCHOOLSTOESTABLISHANDMAINTAINPHYSICALSPACESFROM
WHICHTOOPERATE4HE0UBLIC#HARTER3CHOOLS0ROGRAMALSORETAINEDLEVELFUNDINGFROMTHE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION4HISPROGRAMWAS
DESIGNEDTOSUPPORTTHEPLANNING DEVELOPMENT ANDINITIALIMPLEMENTATIONOFCHARTERSCHOOLS'RANTEESˆPRIMARILYSTATEEDUCATIONAGENCIES
ˆRECEIVEDFUNDINGFORATHREEYEARPERIODTOSUPPORTQUALIlEDCHARTERSCHOOLDEVELOPERS3OMESTATES SUCHAS#OLORADO ALSOUSEDTHEFUNDINGTO
ASSISTPUBLICSCHOOLSTHATWANTEDTOIMPLEMENTSYSTEMICREFORMEFFORTSTOCONVERTTOCHARTERSTATUS

)N 7ASHINGTON $#"OARDOF%DUCATIONINSTITUTEDACOMPREHENSIVEPLANTOLEASEUNDERUSEDSPACETOCHARTERSCHOOLS3EE
(AYNES 6$!PRIL  h,EASING0LAN!DOPTED&OR#HARTER3CHOOLS v7ASHINGTON0OST2ETRIEVED-AY  FROMHTTP
WWWWASHINGTONPOSTCOMWP DYNCONTENTARTICLE!2HTML

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

)NADDITION CREATIVEOPTIONSFORSECURINGFUNDING 4HEDEBATEABOUTCHARTERSCHOOLEFlCACYRAGED


ANDLOWERINGCOSTSREMAINEDPRIMARYSTRATEGIESFOR ASITHADSINCE5PUNTILTHISPOINT CHARTER
CHARTERSCHOOLS)NSOMEDISTRICTS INCLUDING7ASH SCHOOLSWEREREALLYAMIXEDBAGˆSOMESHOWEDSTRONG
INGTON $# SCHOOLBOARDSESTABLISHEDPLANSTOLEASE GAINS BUTOTHERSDIDNOTAPPEARTOBEGREATOPTIONSFOR
UNDER USEDPUBLICSPACETOCHARTERSCHOOLS-ANY SCHOOLING$ESPITESTUDYAFTERSTUDYONCHARTERSCHOOLS
PLANSINCLUDEDINCENTIVESFORSCHOOLSIFTHEYSHARED THERESEARCHDIDNOTPROVIDEADElNITIVEANSWERTOTHE
SPACEWITHACHARTERSCHOOL4HESESHARINGARRANGE QUESTION$OCHARTERSCHOOLSWORK
MENTSWEREAWIN WIN#HARTERSGOTEASIERANDCHEAPER
ACCESSTOFACILITIES FOODSERVICES ANDRESOURCES SUCH n3OMETIMES4HEY$O3OMETIMES4HEY
ASATHLETICSANDBANDCLASSES4HETRADITIONALPUBLIC $ONT
SCHOOLHADEASIERACCESSTOSTUDENTSANDAPORTIONOF !SWECAMETOlNDOUTOVERTIME THEANSWERTOTHE
THEIRPER PUPILFUNDING WHOWANTEDTOPARTICIPATE QUESTION DOCHARTERSCHOOLSWORK WASMORECOMPLEX
INSPORTSANDOTHEROPPORTUNITIES SUCHASORCHESTRA THANhYESvORhNOv!STHEEVIDENCEBASEGREW WITH
)NOTHERWORDS THEPUBLICSCHOOLSACTUALLYRECEIVED SOMECERTAINTY YOUCOULDSAY h9ES CHARTERSCHOOLS
REVENUEFROMTHECHARTERTOHELPCOVERTHEREVENUES WORKˆUNDERCERTAINCONDITIONSv
THEYHADLOSTTOCHARTERSINTHElRSTPLACE #HARTERSREPRESENTTHETENETSOFAFREEMARKETLIMIT
#HARTERSCHOOLSALSOUSEDTHEIRmEXIBILITYTOLEVER GOVERNMENTINTERFERENCEANDTHEYWILLTHRIVEUNDER
AGERESOURCES!TLOWERSALARIES THEYHIREDNON UNION THEIMPERATIVESOFAMARKET DRIVENCLIMATEˆSUPPLY
TEACHERSNON TRADITIONALTEACHERS SUCHASRETIREDENGI ANDDEMAND COMPETITION ANDSURVIVALOFTHElTTEST
NEERSORACCOUNTANTSANDTEACHERSWHOHADBEENLAID )DEALLY CHARTERSCHOOLSWOULDFOCUSONESTABLISHING
OFFFROMTRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLS#HARTERSFREQUENTLY PLANSTOIMPROVESTUDENTACADEMICACHIEVEMENT
EXTENDEDTHESCHOOLDAYANDSCHOOLYEARANDUSED REPLACERULES BASEDGOVERNANCEWITHPERFORMANCE
DISTANCELEARNINGTECHNOLOGIESTOTHEIRADVANTAGE&IFTY BASEDACCOUNTABILITY ANDRENEWTHECREATIVITYAND
VIRTUALLY ENROLLEDSTUDENTSGENERATEDTHESAMEREVENUE COMMITMENTOFTEACHERS PARENTS ANDCOMMUNITIES
BUTWITHMUCHLESSOVERHEADCOSTSASDIDSTUDENTSIN "Y CHARTERSCHOOLSOFEVERYmAVORWEREPOPPING
DESKSINAROOMINABUILDING4HISmEXIBILITYWASPART UPALLOVERTHECOUNTRYINRESPONSETORESTRUCTURING
OFTHECHARTERDESIGNGIVEPARENTSMORECHOICE ALLOW SANCTIONSANDTOMEETDEMANDFROMPARENTS-ANYOF
FREEDOMFROMMANYSTATUTORYANDREGULATORYREQUIRE THECHARTERSCHOOLSWERERUNBYWELLKNOWNPROVIDERS
MENTS AND THEREASONINGWAS CHARTERSCHOOLSWILL INCLUDING+)00 %DISON +APLAN AND-OSAICA%DUCA
SERVETOSTIMULATECOMPREHENSIVEEDUCATIONREFORM TION )NC(OWEVER WEBEGANTOSEEASHIFTINSOME
#HARTERSCHOOLSWEREPUBLICSCHOOLSFORTHEFREEMARKET COMMUNITIESWHERECHARTERSCHOOLSTARGETEDPARENTS
ECONOMY ANDCHILDRENWITHNICHEMARKETSNOTTYPICALLYSEEN&OR
EXAMPLE ANEWGROUPCALLED0ATHTO3UCCESSFORMED
INANDSTARTEDTWOCHARTERSCHOOLSˆONEIN


3EE FOREXAMPLE THEDEBATECREATEDBYTHE.EW9ORK4IMES!UGUST  FRONTPAGESTORYTHATDISCUSSEDTHE.!%0#HARTER3CHOOL
REPORT!STHE$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATIONSEE0RESS2ELEASE !UGUST  HTTPWWWEDGOVNEWSPRESSRELEASESHTML THE
0ROGRESSIVE0OLICY)NSTITUTESEDUCATIONBLOGEDUWONKCOM ANDOTHERSREPORTED THE4IMESONLYREPORTEDPARTOFTHESTORYBEHINDTHEDATAh4HE
!MERICAN&EDERATIONOF4EACHERSFEDTHE4IMES.ATIONAL!SSESSMENTOF%DUCATIONAL0ROGRESS.!%0 DATATHATINCLUDEDASAMPLEOFCHARTER
SCHOOLS4HETHRUSTOFTHEARTICLE#HARTERSCHOOLSDONTDOASWELLASOTHERSCHOOLS EVENOTHERURBANSCHOOLS/FCOURSE ITSNOTTHATSIMPLEx
;7=HENONECONTROLSTHEGRADEDATAFORRACEITTURNSOUTTHEREISNOSTATISTICALLYSIGNIlCANTDIFFERENCEBETWEENCHARTERSCHOOLSANDOTHERPUBLIC
SCHOOLS"UT YOULLSEARCHINVAININTHE4IMESSTORYFORTHATCONTEXT)NFACT TOTHECONTRARY ACHARTACCOMPANYINGTHESTORYFAILSTOOFFERREADERS
ANYSIGNIlCANCETESTSFORTHENUMBERSTHEYRELOOKINGAT INACCURATELYINDICATINGTHATTHEREARESIGNIlCANTDIFFERENCESBYRACEv4UESDAY !UGUST
  EDUWONKBLOGATHTTPWWWEDUWONKCOMARCHIVES???ARCHIVEHTML

,ANGUAGETAKENFROMTHE53$EPARTMENTOF%DUCATION7EBSITEATHTTPWWWEDGOVPROGRAMSCHARTERFACILITIESINDEXHTML


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

#HICAGOANDONEIN,OS!NGELES4HE0ATHTO3UCCESS !BUNDANT
SCHOOLSTARGETEDYOUNGATHLETESANDTHEIRPARENTS
PROMISINGRIGOROUSATHLETICTRAININGANDCOACHINGIN
BASKETBALLORFOOTBALLANDAhGOOD ALL AROUNDvEDUCA
TIONINTHECORESUBJECTS"Y 0ATHTO3UCCESSHAD

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
SCHOOLSLOCATEDINSTATESACROSSTHECOUNTY

2ESOURCES
!NENTIRECHAINOF(ARVEY-ILK#HARTER3CHOOLS
OPENEDINSTATESFROM#ALIFORNIATO7ISCONSINTO.EW h,IVEAND,ET$IEv
*ERSEY0RIMARILYATTENDEDBYGAY LESBIAN ORTRANSGEN
DEREDSTUDENTS THESECHARTERSALSOBECAMESCHOOLSOF
3CARCE
CHOICEFORSTUDENTSWHOSUFFEREDHARASSMENT THREATS
ANDABUSEINTHEIRREGULARPUBLICSCHOOL-ANYPEOPLE
WERENTQUITESUREWHATTOMAKEOFASCHOOLLIKE
(ARVEY-ILK BUTALOTOFFOLKSHADSTRONGOPINIONSˆ RELEVANTTOALLSTUDENTS/FCOURSE THEYNEVERWERE
FROMTHERIGHTWHOCALLEDTHECHARTERSPUBLICAPPROVAL BUTTHEYTENDEDTOFEELLIKETHEYWERE.OW PARENTS
OFhGAYVALUES vTOSOMEHOMOSEXUALACTIVISTSWHO WERESENDINGTHEIRKIDSTOPUBLICSCHOOLSWITHALLKINDS
FEAREDTHESCHOOLSWEREASTEPBACKFORGAYSTUDENTS OFVALUE LADENAPPROACHESˆSCHOOLSTHATEMPHASIZED
AKINTOSEGREGATION-OSTPARENTSOFCHILDRENWHO (MONGCULTUREANDACADEMICSBASKETBALLANDBASIC
ATTENDTHESCHOOLSCITESTUDENTSAFETYANDSUCCESSAS LITERACYSAFETYFROMBULLYINGANDACADEMICANDPER
THEIRPRIMARYMOTIVATIONh,UKECANGOTOSCHOOLNOW SONALEXPRESSION#HRISTIANVALUESANDCOREACADEMICS
"EFOREHEWASSKIPPINGCLASSESORHIDINGINTHEBACKOF 4EACHERSWERECHOOSINGCHARTERS ASWELL)NCHARTER
THEROOMSOHEDIDNTGETBEATUPJUSTFORBEINGDIFFER SCHOOLS THEYMIGHTWORKLONGERHOURSANDALONGER
ENTFROMTHEOTHERKIDS vSAID-ARCIA"ROWDER MOTHER SCHOOLYEAR BUTTHEYTYPICALLYDEALTWITHSMALLERCLASS
OFASTUDENTWHOATTENDSTHENEW(ARVEY-ILKSCHOOL SIZES DIDNTNECESSARILYNEEDFULLSTATECERTIlCATION
IN-ILWAUKEEh9OUBET)WANTHIMTOGOTOTHISSCHOOL ANDWEREMOREINVOLVEDINSCHOOLGOVERNANCEISSUES
(ECANBEHIMSELF(ESNOTSCARED!ND HESLEARN #HARTERTEACHERSWEREMORESATISlEDINTHEIRJOBS
INGv3TILL OTHERSFELTTHATTHEKIDSWHOWEREDOINGTHE 4OSOMEITWASANAFFRONTTOEVERYTHINGPUBLICEDU
BULLYINGINTHETRADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLSWERETHEONES CATIONSTOODFORˆTEACHINGWITHARELIGIOUSSLANTINA
WHOSHOULDHAVETOLEAVEFORADIFFERENTSCHOOL0UBLIC PUBLICSCHOOLANDSATISlEDTEACHERS4OMOSTPARENTS
EDUCATIONINTHE5NITED3TATESRESEMBLEDAFREEMARKET IN HOWEVER THISWASTHEWAYITWASSUPPOSEDTO
SOCIETYCOMPLETEWITHTHEPERKSANDTHEDOWNFALLSOFA BE ANDTHEYDEMANDEDTHATTHEIRELECTEDSCHOOLBOARD
MARKET DRIVECLIMATE MEMBERSACCOMMODATETHEIRVARYINGNEEDSANDDESIRES
4RADITIONALPUBLICSCHOOLSFOUNDTHEMSELVESIN BYAPPROVINGALLKINDSOFCHARTERSCHOOLS0ARENTSWHO
ASITUATIONWHERETHEYHADTOCOMPETEFORSTUDENTS UNDERSTOODTHEIROPTIONSANDHADTHEWHEREWITHAL
ANDTEACHERS!SCUSTOMIZATIONANDCHOICEBECAME TOCARRYTHEMOUTOFTENFOUNDORCREATEDPROMISING
APARTOFTHECULTUREOFPUBLICSCHOOLING THEDEBATES SCHOOLSFORTHEIRCHILDRENTHATFOCUSEDONTHEVALUES
WERElERCE&ORGENERATIONAFTERGENERATION PEOPLE ACADEMICS ANDNON ACADEMICFACTORSIMPORTANTTO
IN!MERICAHADGROWNACCUSTOMEDTOACERTAINIDEA THEM4HEIRDISAPPOINTMENTWITHTHEFAILUREOFTHEIR
ABOUTPUBLICSCHOOLSTHEYWERESUPPOSEDTOBENEUTRAL TRADITIONALCOMMUNITYPUBLICSCHOOLSDIDNOTCREATE
ZONES FREEOFRELIGIONORVALUESORBIAS ANDEQUALLY THEHUGEPUBLICOUTCRYTHATSOMEFEARED7HATDID


%VIDENCEOFHIGHLEVELSOFJOBSATISFACTIONFORCHARTERTEACHERSWASDOCUMENTEDASEARLYAS3EE6ANOUREK '-AY 3TATEOFTHE
#HARTER-OVEMENT4RENDS ISSUES ANDINDICATORS#HARTER3CHOOL,EADERSHIP#OUNCIL$OWNLOADED-AY  FROMHTTPWWWCHARTERSC
HOOLLEADERSHIPCOUNCILORG

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

CREATEANOUTCRYWASTHEREALIZATIONTHATSOMEOFTHE APPROACHANDBECAUSECHARTERSCHOOLSHADFORTHEPAST
SCHOOLSTHESEPARENTSHADCHOSENFORTHEIRCHILDREN DECADEBEENPROVIDINGWHATPARENTSWANTEDALLALONG
WEREJUSTASBAD IFNOTWORSE THANTHEFAILINGPUBLIC ˆCHOICESFORTHEIRCHILDREN&IGHTINGFORVOUCHERS
SCHOOLTHEYHADLEFTBEHIND HADNTBEENWORTHALLTHETROUBLEITCREATEDWHENTHE
SYSTEMPROVIDEDCUSTOMIZEDEDUCATIONWITHLESSCOST
n(ELLO 6OUCHER'OODBYE 6OUCHER .OWTHATCHARTERSCHOOLSWEREFAILINGATANALARMING
#HARTERSCHOOLSWORKED ANDWORKEDWELL UNDER RATE THENOWFAMILIARCRYAGAINSOUNDED,ETMEOUTOF
CERTAINCONDITIONS!SWITHANYSCHOOL CHARTERS THISCRUMMYPUBLICSCHOOL
REQUIREDmEXIBILITYANDAUTONOMYCOUPLEDWITHAC ,ATEIN 3EN4OM4ANCREDO2 #/ INTRO
COUNTABILITYCLEARANDMEASURABLEEXPECTATIONS DUCEDABILLTHATWOULDREQUIREAFAILINGPUBLICSCHOOL

STRONGFUNDINGANDSTRONGLEADERSHIP 4HEYNEEDED TOPROVIDESTUDENTSWITHVOUCHERSEQUIVALENTTOTHE
QUALITYTEACHERSHIGHSTANDARDSASSESSMENTSALIGNED PERPUPILAMOUNTOFSTATEANDFEDERALFUNDINGALLOCATED
WITHSTANDARDS CURRICULUM ANDINSTRUCTIONGOODDATA TOTHESCHOOLANDALLOWTHEMTOTRANSFERTOAPRIVATE
SYSTEMSANDFEEDBACKLOOPS-ANYCHARTERSCHOOLSDID SCHOOL+NOWNASTHE5NIVERSAL6OUCHER0LAN THE
NOTHAVETHESEELEMENTSINPLACE4HEYWERENTALLBAD BILLSPARKEDHEATEDDEBATEIN#ONGRESSANDACROSSTHE
BUTTHEYWERENTALLGOOD COUNTRY$ESPITETHECOMPELLINGARGUMENTSFROMTHE
)N JUSTFOURYEARSAFTERTHElRSTSCHOOLOPENED PRO VOUCHERCAMPABOUTTHEPOWEROFVOUCHERSTO
AGROUPOFANGRYPARENTSSUED0ATHTO3UCCESSCHARTER INCREASETHEQUALITYOFALLSCHOOLSBECAUSETHEYWOULD
SCHOOLSBECAUSETHEIRKIDSCOULDTOSSAMEANFOUL ESSENTIALLYBECOMPETINGINAFREEMARKETPLACEORAT
SHOT BUTTHEYCOULDNTREADORCALCULATETHEIROWN LEASTMOREFREETHANTHECURRENTSYSTEM THEBILLWAS
FREETHROWSHOTPERCENTAGES-ANYPARENTSWEREINFOR DEFEATEDAFTERAPROLONGEDBATTLE-ANY!MERICANS
ASHOCKWHENTHEIRCHILDSCHARTERSCHOOL BORNASA STILLBELIEVEDTHATVOUCHERSWOULDENCOURAGERELIGIOUS
RESULTOF!90FAILUREANDRESTRUCTURINGOFATRADITIONAL DISCRIMINATIONANDERODEPUBLICACCOUNTABILITYAND
PUBLICSCHOOL POSTEDLOWTESTSCORES MISSPENTFUNDS CONSTITUTIONALPROTECTIONS-ANYPARENTSSTILLBELIEVED
ORDIDNTPROVIDETHEEDUCATIONALATMOSPHERETHEY THAT EVENIFVOUCHERSPASSED THEYWERENOTTHEANSWER
WANTEDFORTHEIRKIDSh.OWWHATvPARENTSTHOUGHT TOTHEPROBLEMWITHPUBLICEDUCATION
4HECHARTERSCHOOLWASNOTTHESILVERBULLET
!SMALL BUTVOCALGROUPOFPARENTSSEIZEDTHEIR n)TS!CCOUNTABILITY
OPPORTUNITYTOBRINGBACKTHEVOUCHERSYSTEMWHEN !LTHOUGH0RESIDENT"USHHADIMPLEMENTEDAPLAN
THElRSTRASHOFCHARTERSCHOOLSCOLLAPSED0OPULAR INTHATWASEXPECTEDTOSAVE3OCIAL3ECURITY THE
ASFARBACKASTHELATESWITHMANYGROUPS THE PERSONALRETIREMENTACCOUNTSDRAINEDMOREMONEY
VOUCHERMOVEMENTHADFAILEDTOGATHERMOMENTUM FROMTHESYSTEMTHANITNEEDEDTOKEEPUPWITHTHE
BECAUSETHEREWASNOTENOUGHRESEARCHTOSUPPORTTHE GROWINGNUMBEROFRETIREESBORNBEFORE#OSTS


4HESElNDINGSBEGANTOEMERGEASEARLYASn3EE FOREXAMPLE ,E # -ARCH h#HARTER3CHOOLS0RAISEDIN
2EPORT-IDDLE AND(IGH 3CHOOL3TUDENTS0ERFORM3LIGHTLY"ETTERTHAN0EERSv4HE.EWS*OURNAL2ETRIEVED-ARCH  FROMHTTP
WWWDELAWAREONLINECOMNEWSJOURNALLOCALCHARTERSCHOOLSPHTML4HE#ENTERFOR%DUCATION2EFORMHTTPWWWEDREFORMCOM
ˆADECIDEDLYPRO CHARTERORGANIZATIONˆDISTINGUISHESBETWEENSTATESWITHhSTRONGvCHARTERSCHOOLLAWSANDhWEAKv4HEYIDENTIFYCRITERIAFOR
ASTRONGCHARTERLAW INCLUDINGLEGALOPERATIONALlSCALAUTONOMY EXEMPTIONFROMDISTRICTWORKRULES NEWSTARTS ANDGUARANTEEDFUNDING

!CCORDINGTO4HE#ENTURY&OUNDATION h$IVERTINGPAYROLLTAXESINTOPRIVATEACCOUNTSWOULDCAUSEAMUCHMOREIMMEDIATEANDSEVERE
@CRISISTOARISE;THANIFWELEFTTHECURRENT3OCIAL3ECURITYSYSTEMINTACT=v!NRIG *R 'NODATE -YTHSABOUT3OCIAL3ECURITY4HE#ENTURY
&OUNDATION)SSUE"RIEFHTTPWWWTCFORG0UBLICATIONS2ETIREMENT3ECURITYMYTHS  PDF4HE%CONOMIC2EPORTOFTHE0RESIDENT
DISCUSSESTHEIMPLICATIONSOFTHEMOSTCOMMONLYDISCUSSED3OCIAL3ECURITYREFORMPLAN4HEREPORTINDICATESTHATTHEIMMEDIATEIMPACTOF
IMPLEMENTINGTHEPRIVATEACCOUNTSPLANISTOINCREASETHEBUDGETDElCIT ALTHOUGHTHISIMPACTWOULDBEOVERCOMEINTIMEh7ITHTHEREFORM
THEUNIlEDBUDGETDElCITREACHESPERCENTOF'$0IN7ITHOUTREFORM THISDElCITISREACHEDINSTEADIN4HEBENElTSOFTHEREFORM
APPEAROVERTIME MAKINGAPOSITIVEIMPACTONTHE&EDERALBUDGETAFTERP HTTPWWWGPOACCESSGOVEOPINDEXHTML


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

OFADMINISTERINGTHESYSTEMWEREHIGHERTHANANTICI !BUNDANT
PATED AND3OCIAL3ECURITYHADTOUSEINTERESTFROM
THETRUSTFUNDSTOPAYBENElTSSTARTINGIN RATHER
THANINASPROJECTEDIFTHESYSTEMHADREMAINED
UNCHANGED4HEFEDERALGOVERNMENTHADTOBORROW

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
TOlNANCETHENEWPROGRAM ANDTHEBUDGETDElCIT

2ESOURCES
INCREASED&INALLY 3OCIAL3ECURITYAND-EDICAREWERE
INCRISIS ANDTHEPROGRAMSBEGANTOCOLLAPSE4HIS h,IVEAND,ET$IEv
ACUTElNANCIALSITUATION COMBINEDWITHTHEMASSIVE
DElCITSACCRUEDSINCETHEWARONTERRORBEGANIN
3CARCE
LED#ONGRESSANDTHE0RESIDENTTOTAKEDRASTICACTION
4HEYHADTORAISETAXES BORROWMASSIVEAMOUNTSOF
MONEYTOKEEPTHEFEDERALGOVERNMENTRUNNING AND
MAKESUDDENANDSEVERECUTSIN3OCIAL3ECURITYBEN ,OOKING!HEAD
ElTSANDOTHERGOVERNMENTPROGRAMS.OONEDARED !STHENATIONALLEADEROFPARENTSCONCERNEDABOUT
MENTIONVOUCHERS EDUCATION OURWORKLIESINHELPINGPARENTSUNDERSTAND
3TILL THEPUBLICDEMANDEDTHATSOMETHINGBE HOWTHEYCANMAKEADIFFERENCEINTHEIRCHILDSSCHOOL
DONETOhlXvTHEhCHARTERSCHOOLPROBLEMv#ONGRESS ING3CHOOLINGNOWISMOREABOUTMAKINGYOURCHOICES
DECIDEDTHATTHESTATESHADBLOWNTHEIRCHANCE4HE COUNTTHANLIVINGWITHINABROKENDOWNSYSTEMOR
PUBLICWANTEDCHOICE ANDCHARTERSCHOOLSOFFERED lGURINGOUTHOWTOESCAPEABROKENDOWNONE4HE
THEMTHATCHOICE WITHOUTTHEBAGGAGEOFVOUCHERS NEW#HARTER3CHOOL!CCOUNTABILITY!CTWILLPROVIDE
WITHOUTTHEBURDENOFADDITIONALFUNDING7HATTHE SOMESTABILITYTOTHECHARTERSCHOOLMOVEMENTANDTHE
STATESHADFAILEDTODOWASHOLDCHARTERSCHOOLSAC RELATIVELYNEWMARKET DRIVENPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEM
COUNTABLE4HEYWEREPUBLICSCHOOLS AFTERALL)NA INTHE5NITED3TATES)NTHISCONTEXTOFMORECHOICES
BIPARTISANCOMMITTEEMEETING AHANDFULOFREPRESENTA 0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONSROLEWILLBETOHELPPARENTS
TIVESCRAFTEDTHE#HARTER3CHOOL!CCOUNTABILITY!CT MAKESMARTCHOICESABOUTSCHOOLINGFORTHEIRCHILDREN
4HEBILLWOULDREQUIRESTATESTOHOLDCHARTERSCHOOLS
TOTHESAMEACCOUNTABILITYSTANDARDSASOTHERPUBLIC
SCHOOLSINTHESTATE.OW NOTONLYFUNDING BUTALSO !NALYSISOF3CENARIO
ACCOUNTABILITY WOULDFOLLOWSTUDENTSINTOSCHOOLSOF
)MPLICATIONS
CHOICEh9OUWANTTHEMONEY YOUTOWTHELINE vSAID
#ONGRESSWOMAN3CHEFFERASSHEINTRODUCEDTHEBILLh! )NTHISSCENARIO PUBLICSCHOOLSWILLBEFORCEDTO
CHARTERSCHOOLISSTILLAPUBLICSCHOOLv7HENTHE0RESI COMPETEINAMOREMARKET DRIVENCLIMATETHANTHEY
DENTSIGNEDTHEBILLONLYTWOWEEKSLATER HECOMMENT HAVEEVERFACED4HISSCENARIOHOLDSGREATPOTENTIAL
EDONITSFAIRNESSh7EHAVELEARNEDTHATCHOICEDOES FORBOTHPARENTSANDSTUDENTSASMORECOMPETITIONIN
BENElTEDUCATION BUTWEHAVEALSOLEARNEDTHATTHE PUBLICSCHOOLINGMIGHTOFFERHIGHERQUALITYEDUCATION
GOVERNMENTHASAROLETOPLAYINENSURINGSTANDARDSFOR FORMANYCHILDREN(OWEVER ADRAMATICRISEINTHE
QUALITYv NUMBEROFCHARTERSCHOOLSTHATAREHELDTODIFFERENT
STANDARDSOFACCOUNTABILITYTHANTRADITIONALPUBLIC
SCHOOLSCOULDLEADTOWIDELYDISPARATELEVELSOFQUALITY
INPUBLICEDUCATION!LTHOUGHTHISISNOTNECESSARILYA
NEWPROBLEMTOEDUCATION GREATERFREEDOMOFCHOICE
WITHINTHEPUBLICEDUCATIONSYSTEMISNEW
'ROWTHINCHARTERSCHOOLSCOULDMEANMORE
FRAGMENTATIONFOR0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION4RENDSOVER
THEYEARSnINDICATETHATPARENTSWANTMORE

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

CHOICESANDARETAKINGADVANTAGEOFTHECHOICESTHAT  )NCENTIVESATTHEFEDERAL STATE ANDLOCALLEVELS


EXISTWITHINTHEPUBLICSYSTEM"UTCURRENTTRENDS THATENCOURAGEANDFUNDTHEDEVELOPMENTAND
ALSOINDICATEADECLININGMEMBERSHIPFOR0ARENTSFOR MAINTENANCEOFCHARTERSCHOOLS
%DUCATION0ARENTSREMAINCONCERNEDABOUTEDUCATION
 0ARTNERSHIPSWITHPRIVATEDEVELOPERSTOBUILD
PROBABLYMORESOTHANEVERBEFOREHOWEVER THEYWANT
CHARTERSCHOOLSINNEWHOUSINGDEVELOPMENTS
TOBEINVOLVEDINVERYTANGIBLEACTIVITIESTHATHAVE
IMMEDIATEIMPACTS"ECAUSEANATIONALORGANIZATION  )MPROVEDTESTSCORESPERFORMANCEFORCHARTER
BYITSVERYNATURE SEEMSREMOVEDFROMhIMMEDIATEv SCHOOLSANDINCREASEINEVIDENCEOFCHARTER
IMPACTSONINDIVIDUALSANDTHEIRFAMILIES THISCHAL SCHOOLEFFECTIVENESS
LENGEWILLREMAINTHEBIGGESTFOR0ARENTSFOR%DUCATION
-ORECHOICESWILLMEANMOREINFORMATIONISAVAIL
/PTIONS
ABLETOPARENTS-ORECOMPETITIONWILLMEANMORE
PRESSURE MOREPROPAGANDATOUTINGONESCHOOLOVER 4OPREPAREFORTHISPOSSIBLEFUTURE 0ARENTSFOR%DU
ANOTHER ANDMOREREALDECISIONSTOMAKE$ESPITE CATIONMIGHTCONSIDERTHEFOLLOWINGOPTIONS
BEINGTHEMOSTEDUCATEDGENERATIONOFPARENTS AN  $EVELOPSTRATEGIESFORMOBILIZINGPARENTSINCOM
ARRAYOFCHOICESANDABARRAGEOFCAMPAIGNMESSAGES MUNITIESWHERESCHOOLSFACERESTRUCTURING-ANY
FROMDIFFERENTSCHOOLSWILLCREATEANEEDFORSOURCES IFNOTMOSTPARENTSINTHISSITUATIONWILLNEED
OFUNBIASEDINFORMATION4HISNEEDWILLBEACUTEFOR GUIDANCEANDSPECIlCSTRATEGIESTHATTHEYCANUSE
PARENTSWHOARENOTAPARTOFTHEHIGHLYEDUCATED TOMAKEADIFFERENCEINWHATHAPPENSTOTHEIR
POPULATION0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONWILLNEEDTOlGURE COMMUNITYSCHOOLS
OUTHOWTOADDRESSTHESENEEDSOFPARENTS
 $EVELOPTOOLS MATERIALS RESOURCESTHATPARENTS
)NDICATORS CANUSETOHELPTHEMMAKESMARTCHOICESABOUT
SCHOOLINGFORTHEIRCHILDRENANDSERVEASA
%VIDENCEALREADYINDICATESATRENDTOWARDAMORE
CLEARINGHOUSEFORQUALITYANDUNBIASEDINFORMA
COMPETITIVEPUBLICSCHOOLMARKET&OREXAMPLE INA
TIONONSCHOOLCHOICES4HISSTRATEGYCOULDPROVE
-AY  ARTICLEh#HARTERSDENTPUBLICSCHOOLS v
TOBEAhHOTPOTATOvBECAUSEITISTRICKYTOBE
THE$ENVER0OSTREPORTSTHATINTHEPASTFOURYEARS
INTHEBUSINESSOFPROVIDINGUSEFULINFORMATION
APPROXIMATELY STUDENTSANDMILLIONHAVE
THATWILLHELPPARENTSMAKEINFORMEDDECISIONS
LEFT$ENVER0UBLIC3CHOOLS-OSTOFTHOSESTUDENTS
AMONGAVARIETYOFPROVIDERS(OWEVER IFTHIS
ANDTHEDOLLARSTHATFOLLOWTHEM HAVEMOVEDTO
SCENARIOPLAYSOUT THISAREACOULDBETHESINGLE
CHARTERSCHOOLS4HISSAMEARTICLEREPORTSTHATIN
BIGGESTNEEDFORPARENTS0ARENTSWILLNEEDTO
4UCSON !RIZONA SCHOOLOFlCIALSBELIEVECHARTERSHAVE
ANSWERQUESTIONSLIKEh)MTHINKINGOFSENDING
COSTTHEMABOUTMILLIONINTHEPASTlVEYEARS AND
MYCHILDTOAN%DISONSCHOOLWHATDO)NEED
IN3T,OUIS STUDENTSMIGRATINGTOCHARTERSHAVE
TOKNOWABOUT%DISONSCHOOLS7HATTYPESOF
COSTTHEDISTRICTABOUTMILLION!$ENVERELEMEN
INFORMATIONDO)NEEDTOMAKEASMARTDECISION
TARYSCHOOLPRINCIPALISQUOTEDINTHISARTICLEASWORRY
(OWDO)GATHERTHATINFORMATIONv0ARENTSFOR
INGTHATANEARBYCHARTERSCHOOLWILLhPOACHvHERTH
%DUCATIONCANLIKELYPROVIDESOMEINFORMATION
GRADERS
INACLEARINGHOUSEFORMATANDMIGHTALSOPROVIDE
0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONSHOULDWATCHTHEFOLLOWING MORESUPPORTTHROUGHGUIDANCEANDCHECKLISTSFOR
TRENDSASINDICATORSOFTHISSCENARIOUNFOLDING PARENTSTOUSEASTHEYhINVESTIGATEvASCHOOL

 )NCREASEDENROLLMENTSINPUBLICSCHOOLSOFCHOICE

 )NCREASEDENROLLMENTSINCHARTERSCHOOLS


.ATIONAL-EMBERSHIP!SSOCIATION3CENARIO

 0URSUEANADVOCACYROLEATTHENATIONALLEVELFOR !BUNDANT


ACCOUNTABILITYFORALLPUBLICSCHOOLS INCLUDING
CHARTERS!NADVOCACYROLEATTHENATIONALLEVEL
ISASTRATEGYTHATMAKES0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONREL
EVANTANDNECESSARY)TSNOTSOMETHINGTHATIN

,IMITED
3CHOOL#HOICES

-ANY
DIVIDUALPARENTSWORKINGWITHINDIVIDUALSCHOOLS

2ESOURCES
CANDO)TISHOWEVER ADVOCACY ANDSOCARRIES
THERISKSASSOCIATEDWITHTHATTYPEOFWORK4HIS h,IVEAND,ET$IEv
PIECEWILLBECRUCIALFORPARENTS4HISSTRATEGY
PROBABLYWOULDBEBESTEXECUTEDINCONJUNCTION
3CARCE
WITHSTRATEGYABOVE

 #REATEANDNURTURENETWORKSFORPARENTSTOUSEAS
COMMUNICATIONANDINFORMATIONGATHERINGTOOLS
2ESEARCHSHOWSTHATPEOPLEWHOHAVEANEED
ANDADESIREWILLPARTICIPATEINONLINENETWORKS
TOGATHERANDSHAREINFORMATIONANDLEARNFROM
EACHOTHER4HISAPPROACHCOULDBERELATIVELY
LOWCOSTFOR0ARENTSFOR%DUCATIONANDMIGHTBEST
BEEXECUTEDASANINTEGRALPARTOFAROBUST7EB
SITETHATSERVESASAPORTALFORINFORMATIONABOUT
EDUCATIONDESIGNEDFORPARENTS

$ISCUSSION1UESTIONS
 !RETHECRITICALUNCERTAINTIESTHATFORMTHE
SCENARIOFRAMEWORKTHOSETHATYOUWOULDCHOOSE
ORARETHEREOTHERUNCERTAINTIESTHATSEEMMORE
CRITICALTOYOU

 !RETHESTORIESPLAUSIBLE#OULDTHEYTURNOUTTO
BETRUE)FNOT WHATWOULDYOUCHANGE

 #ANYOUTHINKOFOTHERIMPLICATIONSANDOPTIONS
FORTHEORGANIZATIONINADDITIONTOTHOSEWRITTEN
INTHE!NALYSISSECTIONS

 )FYOUWERELEADINGANORGANIZATIONOFTHISTYPE
WHATWOULDYOUDONOWTOPREPAREFORTHESE
IMAGINEDFUTURES

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN
4AKINGTHE.EXT3TEPS
(OWAREYOUPREPARINGYOURSELFANDYOURSCHOOLDISTRICT STATEAGENCY OROTHEREDUCATIONALINSTITUTION
FORTHEFUTURE)SSCENARIOPLANNINGAGOODSTRATEGYFORYOU
4HE'LOBAL"USINESS.ETWORKWWWGBNCOM WHICHHASCODIlEDTHESCENARIOPLANNINGMETHOD
ANDTEACHESITTOORGANIZATIONALLEADERSACROSSTHEWORLD RECOMMENDSTHATYOUUSETHEMETHODONLYTO
ADDRESSACHALLENGINGPROBLEMSURROUNDEDBYAHIGHDEGREEOFUNCERTAINTYANDONLYIFYOURORGANIZATION
ISOPENTODIALOGUE TOCHANGE ANDTOCONSIDERINGFUTURESOTHERTHANTHEhOFlCIALFUTUREvTHATHASGUIDED
THEORGANIZATIONINTHEPAST)NADDITION THEORGANIZATIONS
LEADERSMUSTSUPPORTANDACTIVELYPARTICIPATEINTHEINITIA
TIVE ANDADEQUATERESOURCESMUSTBEALLOCATEDTOSUPPORT
h.#,"AHISTORICSUCCESS
THEEFFORTOVERTHELONGTERM&ORORGANIZATIONSWILLINGTO
TAKETHISLEAP -C2%,ISAVAILABLETOHELP OF!MERICANSCHOOLS
"UT EVENWITHOUTDEVELOPINGANDWRITINGYOUROWN MEET!90INv
SCENARIOS THEREAREANUMBEROFWAYSINWHICHYOUCAN
MOVEYOURORGANIZATIONINTOTHEFUTUREINATHOUGHTFUL h#ONGRESSENACTSNATIONAL
CREATIVE ANDDELIBERATEMANNER3OMEIDEASINCLUDE CURRICULUMANDASSESSMENT
ASPARTOF.#,"))v
s #REATEYOUROWNhDRIVERSOFCHANGEvTABLE)DENTIFY
ANARCHIVISTANDROUTINELYCOLLECTINFORMATIONABOUT h.OWWHAT3CHOOLSTAKEN
INDICATORSOFCHANGE0ERIODICALLYREVIEWTHETABLE OVERFOURYEARSAGO DEEMED
ANDDISCUSSITSIMPLICATIONS
FAILURESONCEAGAINv
s %STABLISHABOOKGROUPFOCUSEDONTHEWIDEARRAYOF
CURRENTBOOKSABOUTTHEFUTURE!SK-C2%,FORA h%DUCATIONONTHE#HOPPING
READINGLISTORGOTOTHE7ORLD&UTURE3OCIETY7EB "LOCK3CHOOLSLOSEOUT
SITEWWWWFSORG ORTHE'LOBAL"USINESS.ETWORK TOHEALTHCAREAND3OCIAL
SITEWWWGBNCOM FORIDEAS 3ECURITYv
s #REATEANOPPORTUNITYFOROTHERSINYOURORGANIZATION
h.EWMILESTONEPERCENT
TOhBRAINSTORMvABOUTDRIVERSOFCHANGEANDDISCUSS
OFNATIONSSTUDENTSENROLLED
CRITICALUNCERTAINTIESFROMTHEIRPOINTOFVIEW
INSCHOOLOFCHOICEv
s )NCLUDEDISCUSSIONSOFCRITICALUNCERTAINTIESAND
POSSIBLESCENARIOSONTHEAGENDASOFREGULARLY h7HITHERPUBLICSCHOOLS
ESTABLISHEDGATHERINGSOFKEYSTAKEHOLDERGROUPS /NCEINEVERYNEIGHBORHOOD
s %XPANDYOURVIEWSBYEXCHANGINGIDEASWITH PUBLICSCHOOLSAREGOINGTHE
hREMARKABLEPEOPLEvOUTSIDEOFEDUCATION WAYOFTHE6#2v

)NGENERAL PREPARINGFORTHEFUTUREREQUIRESTHEDISCIPLINE h4ERRORISTSATTACK#RAWFORD


TOCONSTANTLYASKTHEQUESTION WHATIF7HATIFYOUWAKE 4EXAS ELEMENTARYSCHOOL
UPTOMORROW ORNEXTYEAR ANDSEETHEHEADLINESTOTHE DIEv
RIGHTINTHEMORNINGPAPER


7OULDYOUBESURPRISED#OULDTHESETHINGSOCCUR(OWWOULDYOURESPOND0REPARINGFORTHEFUTURE
INVOLVESIMAGININGTHEFULLRANGEOFPOSSIBILITIESFORWHATLIESAHEADANDDEVELOPINGSTRATEGIESTODAYTHAT
WILLPREPAREYOUTOMEETTHECHALLENGESOFTOMORROW
4HESCENARIOSINTHISBOOKPROVIDEAGLIMPSEINTOONLYAFEWOFTHEPOSSIBLEWORLDSAHEAD7EOFFER
THEMINTHEHOPETHATEDUCATORSACROSSTHECOUNTRYWILLBEGINTOCREATETHEIROWNSTORIESOFTHEFUTURE
ONBEHALFOFLEARNERSEVERYWHERE!SYOUEMBARKUPONTHISIMPORTANTWORK MAYTHEFOLLOWING!FRICAN
PROVERBHELPGUIDETHEWAY

%VERYMORNINGIN!FRICAAGAZELLEWAKESUP
)TKNOWSITMUSTRUNFASTERTHANTHEFASTESTLIONORITWILL
BEKILLED
%VERYMORNINGALIONWAKESUP
)TKNOWSITMUSTOUTRUNTHESLOWESTGAZELLEORITWILL
STARVETODEATH
)TDOESNTMATTERWHETHERYOUAREALIONORAGAZELLE
7HENTHESUNCOMESUP YOUBETTERSTARTRUNNING

 4HE&UTUREOF3CHOOLING%DUCATING!MERICAIN