Você está na página 1de 4

Sweet Surrender: Can Kraft's Cadbury Acquisition Help It Tap the Indian Market?

: India Knowledge@Wharton
(http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/india/article.cfm?articleid=4451)

Sweet Surrender: Can Kraft's Cadbury Acquisition Help It Tap the Indian
Market?
Published : February 25, 2010 in India Knowledge@Wharton

Even skeptics of U.S.-based Kraft Foods' lengthy courtship of U.K.


confectioner Cadbury over the past year have to concede that the
cash-and-shares acquisition -- with a final price tag in February of US$19.4
billion -- makes sense when considered from one particular perspective:
growth. Hit by the Great Recession, Kraft's home market has been suffering,
in sharp contrast to the heady double-digit expansion of its
developing-market businesses. To help fan that growth, Cadbury will give
the multinational something it didn't have -- a foothold in India. In return,
Kraft will bring a bigger array of products to Cadbury's chocolate-and-gum
portfolio, while cementing the newly expanded company's impressive lead in
the country's confectionery business. As C. Y. Pal, non-executive chairman
of Cadbury India, notes, "India is a very happy story for Kraft and Cadbury."
Kraft's acquisition is the type of "horizontal expansion" that can work well
in today's post-economic downturn environment, according to Wharton This is a single/personal use copy of India
Knowledge@Wharton. For multiple copies,
management professor Larry Hrebiniak. The deal might be overpriced, he custom reprints, e-prints, posters or plaques,
please contact PARS International:
says, but it does allow both companies to "expand on their strengths," while reprints@parsintl.com P. (212) 221-9595
x407.
diversifying in complementary markets in countries such as India. "The
number-one reason for a company like Kraft to do a deal like this is that it is looking for new markets and
the attendant increased size and market share -- and with size and market share comes clout." Indeed, the
acquisition puts it nearly 70% ahead of rival Mars in terms of confectionery sales in emerging markets,
says a Cadbury manager.
But a new market can also bring new headaches, as Kraft, which has tried to enter India before, well
knows. Winning over Indian consumers with new snack foods won't be easy. Chocolate is one thing, says
Hrebiniak, but selling macaroni and cheese is another. "It's not going to be a picnic."
Emerging Stronger
Emerging markets have underpinned both Cadbury's and Kraft's growth strategies for a number of years.
Today, developing countries account for 38% of Cadbury's US$8.3 billion group sales and 20% of Kraft's
US$40 billion in sales, according to London-based research firm Euromonitor International. In most of
those key markets, Kraft dwarves Cadbury -- 2008 revenue in Brazil, for example, totaled US$1.2 billion
against Cadbury's US$400 million; in China, its turnover was US$400 million compared with the U.K.
firm's US$50 million, and in Russia, US$800 million compared with US$200 million.
Yet India is one country where Kraft will be leaning heavily on Cadbury. Since setting up in India more
than 60 years ago, Cadbury is the largest confectioner in the country, with Nestlé a distant number two.
Cadbury brands such as Dairy Milk, 5 Star, Perk, Eclairs and malted milk additive Bournvita have helped
it command some 70% of India's US$425 million chocolate market, and 30% of the US$1 billion sugar
boiled confectionery category, according to marketing research firm ACNielsen.
However, market share is not the only gain for the U.S. multinational. "Cadbury's distribution network
will be invaluable for Kraft," says Sridhar Samu, professor of marketing at Hyderabad-based Indian
School of Business (ISB). Today, a network of 1.2 million shops sells its products across India -- no small
feat in a country with highly fragmented supply chains. "It's a marriage made in heaven as far as the
distribution is concerned," Sanjay Khosla, Kraft's president of developing markets, told The Economic

  All materials copyright of the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.                    Page 1 of 4 
Sweet Surrender: Can Kraft's Cadbury Acquisition Help It Tap the Indian Market?: India Knowledge@Wharton
(http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/india/article.cfm?articleid=4451)

Times during a recent visit to Mumbai.


'Generations Behind'
But Samu adds a note of caution: Indian consumers aren't always quick to embrace Western products, and
getting accepted can take "over a generation." He notes that while the Indian market may look attractive
in terms of size and spending power, "the buying and consumption pattern has not changed significantly
over the years." A case in point: Despite the growing presence of supermarkets and hypermarkets in
India, 98% of food is still purchased from the 12 million neighborhood mom-and-pop outfits called kirana
kirana stores. If nothing else, that makes distribution extremely difficult.
Also, because India is still a very agrarian society, Sumit Chandna, Mumbai-based head of fast-moving
consumer goods (FMCG) at Aditya Birla Retail's MORE supermarkets and hypermarkets, says Kraft
could face an enormous challenge getting its food products on to supermarket shelves. "The whole
processed food category is fairly nascent," he explains, noting that the largest FMCG company in the
country is the personal and home care division of Unilever. "We are generations behind when it comes to
food," says Chandna.
That could partly explain why growth has been relatively slow for Cadbury. Other reasons include the
company's narrow confectionery product range. Over the years, the Cadbury has tried to expand its
repertoire in India, launching, for example, the country's first apple drink, Apella, and Dollops ice cream
and cookies. Yet the purple wrapping of its chocolate bars is still what Indian consumers associate the
Cadbury brand with. Being under the Kraft umbrella, however, will broaden that range to include cheese,
Oreo cookies, more chocolates like Toblerone and Milka, and beverages such as Tang, Kool Aid and
Maxwell House coffee.
With the help of markets like India, Hrebiniak says Cadbury worldwide will need to step up the pace over
the next few years "to justify its purchase price." Kraft, he notes, will want to see the top line at Cadbury
growing globally around 10% and Ebitda (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization)
margins at 27% over the next four or five years to justify the premium Kraft is paying. "Historically,
Cadbury has been a little short of that, approximately 5% and 20% respectively."
Survival Tactics
Regardless of the new diversity of its portfolio, the old challenges of India's confectionery market will
remain. Consider the low unit price of many candies, which range from half a cent to 15 cents. Given the
low prices, a chocolate maker can hit volume targets relatively easily and can regularly roll out new
candiesto keep consumers enticed -- in 2009 alone, there were more than 70 launches. However, the
survival rate is extremely low. According to marketing experts, less than 10% of these new brands
survive beyond their first year. What's more, the low barriers to entry attract many fly-by-night
manufacturers and have also left the market enormously fragmented, to the consternation of many
Western players like Unilever. After just four years, the Anglo-Dutch firm withdrew its Max candy range
in 2005, apparently disappointed that it only had 5% of market share. "The costs didn't justify the
volumes," says a Unilever manager.
To get a foothold in India, innovation is critical, as other confectioners in the country confirm. A case in
point: Perfetti Van Melle (PVM), a privately held Italian-Dutch firm, which owns Chupa Chups lollypops
and Mentos mints. Having entered India in 1994 and set up three factories in various parts of the country,
PVM has a 25% share of the confectionery market today. The company's success, say experts, is due to its
innovative products -- it was the first company to launch center-filled gums and candies in India -- at the
right price points. "The innovation helped us price the products at 100% premium to the competition,"
says Sameer Suneja, the New Delhi-based managing director of PVM.
The company has been innovative in other ways, including sales and distribution. During its early years in
India, PVMsent its entire range of products to retailers throughout the country, but "we soon realized that
retailers operate on a daily working capital basis and choose only fast-moving products," Suneja notes. So
it segmented its sales teamalong product lines -- chocolate, gum and mints -- and the speed at which the
products were sold, tailoring their sales efforts accordingly to increase supply chain efficiency.
But pricing and distribution are not the only hurdles for Western chocolate makers. While there is still

  All materials copyright of the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.                    Page 2 of 4 
Sweet Surrender: Can Kraft's Cadbury Acquisition Help It Tap the Indian Market?: India Knowledge@Wharton
(http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/india/article.cfm?articleid=4451)

huge growth potential -- Cadbury estimates that per capita consumption of chocolate in India is 54 grams,
compared with 11 kilograms in the U.K. -- India has its own formidable confectionery industry. For sure,
Cadbury and the raft of other Western confectioners in India are competing not only with each other, but
also with the ubiquitous assortment of traditional milk-made Indian sweets, or mithai, consumed at home
and on special occasions. "Indians have a massive sweet tooth, but it's fulfilled by mithai, not chocolates,"
says Ramesh Srinivas, executive director of KPMG Advisory Services India, who oversees the consumer
business practice.
Even mighty multinationals like Cadbury have been unable to crack that market. According to a former
marketing head at the company, "We always grappled with the question of how to take on mithai." Some
years ago, he says, Cadbury worked with local brand Amul, which is owned by a dairy cooperative in
Anand in the western state of Gujarat, to make mithai to add to its chocolate. But the Indian-Western
medley ultimately failed to excite consumers.
Snack Attack
The good news is that India is a snacking haven, with every state having its own vast array of sweet and
savory treats. "The snacking market is driven by unorganized players, leaving enough room for
established companies to grow," says Vijay Chugh, vice president of research at Mumbai-based Ambit
Capital.
Kraft is hoping to make the most of that opportunity. The American food giant entered India in 2003 in a
joint venture with Chennai-based Kothari Group to manufacture Tang, its powdered orange drink. The
launch of the premium-priced drink mix coincided with the introduction of 10-cent 200 milliliter bottles
by U.S. soft drink manufacturers Coca-Cola and PepsiCo. With Tang making little headway in a
price-conscious market, Kraft beat a hasty retreat a year later.
Even so, Kraft is a known brand name in India: Products like Kraft cheese and Toblerone chocolate are
imported and prominently displayed on shelves in many of India's new supermarkets and hypermarkets.
"Kraft's portfolio is what I call 'higher order' products," says Aditya Birla's Chandna.
Now, with the Cadbury acquisition sealed, "Kraft's success will require a lot of brand-building activities
to position [other] brands among Indian consumers," says ISB's Samu. Pivotal to Kraft's success in India
will be its ability to forge an "adapt-and-adopt" strategy, says Chandna. "It needs to be very selective
[about] which products in its portfolio it wants to sell and has to know what the local market is ready for.
The key is not where to introduce its products, but what to introduce." Kraft's Khosla echoed this approach
during his Mumbai visit. It's "about being 'glocal' [that is, both global and local]," he said. "We are now
empowering local leaders and listening to local consumers."
In that respect, Kraft might want to take a leaf from PepsiCo's book. With a 20-year track record in the
country, the US$43 billion snack food and beverage multinational is now one of the largest consumer
products companies in India. Its flagship India brand -- Frito Lay's Kurkure snack -- was created
specifically for the Indian palate. Kurkure flavors include "masala munch," "green chutney Rajasthani
style," and "xtreme risky chili," and three years ago, a special edition flavor -- "jaljhalo hit" -- was
launched during the traditional puja festival in the eastern state of Bengal. On the back of Kurkure's
success, Frito-Lay India launched Aliva crackers, which are made with local spices, wheat and other
ingredients, in June last year. As Cadbury's former marketing executive notes, "We need to see if Sanjay
Khosla can do for Kraft what [PepsiCo CEO] Indra Nooyi did for Pepsi India."
Perhaps because of its earlier experience in India, Kraft has been busy honing its "localization" skills in
other emerging markets. Sometimes, it has been a matter of trial and error. In China, for instance, after it
launched the American version of its Oreo cookies, sales were flat initially. Research showed that both the
product and price were problems: The cookies were too sweet for the Chinese palate, and the 72-cent
pack was considered too expensive. Kraft then developed less sweet Oreos in smaller packs costing 29
cents. Also, a new Oreo variant was launched soon after. The four-layered Chinese Oreo -- with vanilla
and chocolate cream coated in chocolate -- soon became the best-selling biscuit in China, racing ahead of
the original Oreos.
However, Cadbury India has been slower to tailor its products to Indian tastes. "Cadbury never thought of
localizing its products until recently," notes Srinivas of KPMG. But it has been making up for lost time. In

  All materials copyright of the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.                    Page 3 of 4 
Sweet Surrender: Can Kraft's Cadbury Acquisition Help It Tap the Indian Market?: India Knowledge@Wharton
(http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/india/article.cfm?articleid=4451)

localizing its products until recently," notes Srinivas of KPMG. But it has been making up for lost time. In
the last year, Cadbury has been changing recipes to improve the shelf life of some of its chocolate bars.
For example, mini-packs of Dairy Milk are now made to withstand India's heat -- which is useful in a
country with many retailers who do not have refrigeration units and who have to contend with regular
power outages -- and are sold in packs costing 4 cents, compared with nearly 50 cents earlier. Distributors
say that the strategy has not only helped Cadbury increase chocolate penetration, but consumers are also
buying more.
Amid all this, Kraft will have to keep an eye on the usual post-merger integration issues, says Wharton's
Hrebiniak, including production, possible structural change, distribution and communication externally
and between the two companies. "Will Kraft try to change anything at Cadbury India?" he asks. Perhaps
not initially. After all, "it needs to learn what the impediments are; what it can and can't do in India. For
that, it needs Cadbury." But given a few years, "I have confidence that they're going to work this out," he
says. "They're going to be big."

This is a single/personal use copy of India Knowledge@Wharton. For multiple copies, custom reprints, e-prints, posters or plaques, please
contact PARS International: reprints@parsintl.com P. (212) 221-9595 x407.

  All materials copyright of the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania.                    Page 4 of 4 

Você também pode gostar