/6>+60

9,:765+;6;/(;&

;/,+,-050;0=,.<0+,
;6-(*,)662
7<)30:/05. 
46+,9(;065

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS
Table of Contents

0 0U[YVK\J[PVU¯7HNL
00 9LHJ[PUNHUK9LZWVUKPUN[V*VTWSHPU[Z¯7HNL
000 :WYLHKPUN7VZP[P]P[`¯7HNL
0= (UZ^LYPUN9LX\LZ[ZMVY0UMVYTH[PVU¯7HNL
= .P]PUN.\PKHUJLHUK(K]PJL¯7HNL
=0 ;LTWLYPUN-Y\Z[YH[PVUMYVT;LJO0ZZ\LZ¯7HNL
=00 4HUHNPUN;OYLHKZVM*VU]LYZH[PVU¯7HNL
=000 4VKLYH[PUN7VZ[Z!2LLWPUN7YVMHUP[`HUK5LNH[P]P[`H[)H`¯7HNL
0? *VUJS\ZPVU¯7HNL

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Introduction
0THNPULPM`V\^PSS[OL[PTL^OLUHI\ZPULZZKLJPKLZ[VZ[HRLHJSHPTVU-HJLIVVR0UKP]PK\HSZH[
[OLJVTWHU`TH`OH]LHWLYZVUHS-HJLIVVRHJJV\U[I\[[OL`OH]LSP[[SLRUV^SLKNLVM[OL[VVSZHUK
YLZV\YJLZH]HPSHISL[VI\ZPULZZLZSVVRPUN[VL_WHUK[OLPYYLHJOPUZVJPHSTLKPH>OLU[OLI\ZPULZZKL
JPKLZ[VZL[\WP[ZUL^-HJLIVVR7HNLP[YLHSPaLZ[OH[HULHNLYMHUOHZHSYLHK`JYLH[LKHUº\UVMMPJPHS»
7HNLMVY[OLIYHUK;OH[»ZWV[LU[PHSS`IHKUL^ZI\[UV[[OLLUKVM[OL^VYSK-HJLIVVRJHULHZPS`
[YHUZMLYMHUZMYVTHU\UVMMPJPHS7HNL[V[OLUL^WHNLZHUJ[PVULKI`IYHUKYLWYLZLU[H[P]LZ;OLYLHS
WYVISLTSPLZ^P[OPU[OL-HJLIVVR7HNL>HSS

0[ZLLTZ[OH[[OL\UVMMPJPHS7HNLOHZILLUSP]LMVYV]LYH`LHYHUK^OPSL[OLJVTT\UP[`PZ[OYP]PUN^P[O
SV[ZVMPUW\[HUKJVU]LYZH[PVUMYVTMHUZ[OLYLPZHZPNUPMPJHU[HTV\U[VMWYVMHUP[`ULNH[P]P[`HUKHI\
ZP]LSHUN\HNLWVZ[LKMVY[OL^VYSK[VZLL;OLI\ZPULZZMPUKZP[ZLSMPUHWPJRSL/V^KVLZH-HJLIVVR
UV]PJLZ[H\UJO[OLMSV^VMULNH[P]P[`^P[OV\[HSPLUH[PUNP[ZJVYLH\KPLUJL&/V^KVLZP[[HRLV]LYP[Z
JVTT\UP[`HUKILNPU[VTHUHNLHUKTHPU[HPU[OL>HSSTHRPUNP[ZHMLMVY\ZLYZVMHSSHNLZHUKIHJR
NYV\UKZ(UKOV^KVLZP[YLZWVUK[V[OLULNH[P]LJVTTLU[ZHUKJVTWSHPU[ZMYVT\ZLYZ^OVOH]L
NV[[LUPUJYLHZPUNS`MY\Z[YH[LK[OH[[OL`OH]LYLJLP]LKUVVMMPJPHSIYHUKYLZWVUZLVUH7HNL[OL`KPKUV[
YLHSPaL^HZº\UVMMPJPHS&»

;OLPTWVY[HU[[OPUN[VYLTLTILYPZ[OH[-HJLIVVRPZHJVTT\UPJH[PVUWSH[MVYTKLZPNULK[VOLSW
WLVWSLHUKIYHUKZJVUULJ[HUKZOHYL0M[OLV]LYHSSNVHSVMOH]PUNHWYLZLUJLVU-HJLIVVRPZ[VNL[
\ZLYZ[HSRPUNHIV\[`V\YIYHUK[OLUOV^KV`V\RLLW[OLZLJVU]LYZH[PVUZ\UKLYJVU[YVS&;OLHUZ^LY
PZ`V\JHU»[¶^P[OV\[KPZHISPUN`V\YMHUZ»HIPSP[`[VJVTTLU[VU`V\Y>HSS9LTLTILY[OPZPZZVJPHS
TLKPH¶L]LY`VULOHZH]VPJLHUKL]LY`VUL[OPURZ[OH[[OL^VYSK^HU[Z[VOLHY^OH[[OL`OH]L[VZH`
5V`V\JHUUV[JVU[YVS^OH[WLVWSLHYLZH`PUNI\[`V\JHU[HRLZL]LYHSWYVHJ[P]LZ[LWZ[VLUZ\YL[OH[
JVU]LYZH[PVUZHUKJVTTLU[ZHYLILULMPJPHS[V[OLV]LYHSSJVTT\UP[`

6\YI\ZPULZZOHZP[Z^VYRJ\[V\[MVYP[>OL[OLYP[SPRLZP[VYUV[-HJLIVVRPZOLYL[VZ[H`0[»ZHZVJPHS
^VYSKHUK[OPZI\ZPULZZPZSP]PUNPUP[:VPZ`V\YZ9LHKVU[VKPZJV]LYH^LHS[OVMHK]PJL[OH[^PSSIL
JVTL`V\YWSH`IVVR[VW\ISPZOPUNHUKTVKLYH[PUNJVU[LU[VU-HJLIVVRPUJS\KPUN!


 ‹)LZ[WYHJ[PJLZMVYYLZWVUKPUN[VJ\Z[VTLYMLLKIHJRHUKJVTWSHPU[Z
 ‹:WYLHKPUNWVZP[P]P[`HIV\[`V\YI\ZPULZZ]PHZVJPHSTLKPH
 ‹)LZ[WYHJ[PJLZMVYHUZ^LYPUNYLX\LZ[ZMVYPUMVYTH[PVU
 ‹)LZ[WYHJ[PJLZMVYNP]PUNN\PKHUJLHUKHK]PJL
 ‹;LTWLYPUNMY\Z[YH[PVUMYVT[LJOUVSVN`PZZ\LZ
 ‹4HUHNPUN[OYLHKZVMJVU]LYZH[PVU
 ‹4VKLYH[PUNWVZ[ZHUKJVU[LU[

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Reacting and Responding to Complaints
6ULVMTVZ[MYLX\LU[S`HZRLKX\LZ[PVUZPUZVJPHSTLKPHPZº/V^ZOV\SK^LYLZWVUK[VW\ISPJS`]PZPISL
JVUZ\TLYJVTWSHPU[Z&»;OLYLHYLHML^MHJ[VYZ[V[HRLPU[VJVUZPKLYH[PVU^OLUKL]LSVWPUNHYLHJ[PVU
YLZWVUZLZ[YH[LN`-PYZ[THU`IYHUKZOH]LHZ[HUKHYKPaLKWVSPJ`PUWSHJL[OH[KPJ[H[LZHWWYVWYPH[L
YLZWVUZLZ[VJVTWSHPU[Z(YLHJ[PVUYLZWVUZLWVSPJ`THRLZWLYMLJ[ZLUZLVUWHWLY/V^L]LY[OLZL
WVSPJPLZJHUVM[LUILZOHWLKI`SLNHSKLWHY[TLU[ZHUKL_LJ\[P]LZ[HRLOVSKLYZ^OVTPNO[UV[OH]LH
M\SS\UKLYZ[HUKPUNVM[OLPU[YPJHJPLZVM[OL-HJLIVVR>HSSHUK5L^Z-LLK

0[»ZPTWVY[HU[[VSLHYU[V^VYR^P[OPU[OLJVUZ[YHPU[ZVM[OLV]LYHSSWVSPJ`^OPSLTHPU[HPUPUNHSL]LSVM
MSL_PIPSP[`[OH[^PSSHSSV^`V\[VYLZWVUK[VLHJOJVTWSHPU[^P[OHWLYZVUHSHUZ^LY(NLULYPJYLZWVUZL
[VJVTWSHPU[Z^PSSUV[^VYR¶HUKJHUMYLX\LU[S`[YHUZMVYTHVUL[PTLJVTWSHPULYPU[VHYLWLH[VMMLUKLY
TVYLVU[OH[SH[LY*VUZ\TLYZ^OVJOVVZL[VW\ISPJS`]LU[[OLPYMLLSPUNZHYLVUHZSPWWLY`ZSVWLVM
MY\Z[YH[PVUHUKHUNLY;OL^YVUNYLZWVUZLJHUW\ZO[OLTV]LY[OLWYLJPWPJLMYVTHIYHUKHK]VJH[L
^P[OHUPZZ\L[VHIYHUKKL[YHJ[VY^P[OHNY\KNL

:LJVUKS``V\YYLHJ[PVUYLZWVUZLZ[YH[LN`ZOV\SKILZWLJPMPJ[V`V\YPUK\Z[Y`;OLYLHYLZVTLOV[
I\[[VUPUK\Z[YPLZ[OH[NLULYH[LHUL_WVULU[PHSS`SHYNLYU\TILYVMJVUZ\TLYJVTWSHPU[ZVUHKH`[VKH`
IHZPZ:WLJPMPJHSS`ZLY]PJL¶IHZLKI\ZPULZZLZSPRLPUZ\YHUJL[LSLJVTHUK[YH]LSOH]LHOPNOPUJPKLUJL
YH[LVMWHZZPVUH[LULNH[P]P[`VU[OLPY-HJLIVVR>HSSZ0M`V\YIYHUKMHSSZPU[V[OPZZPSVP[»ZSPRLS`[OH[
P[^PSSILULHYPTWVZZPISL[VYLHJ[[VL]LY`JVTWSHPU[^P[OHYLZWVUZL[OH[HUHUNY`JVUZ\TLY^V\SK
JVUZPKLYOLSWM\S@V\YYLHJ[PVUYLZWVUZLZ[YH[LN`ZOV\SKM\UULS[OLZLTHSJVU[LU[ZPU[VHTVYLWLYZVUHS
J\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLPU[LYHJ[PVULP[OLYI`WOVULVYKPYLJ[LTHPS

;OLSHZ[[OPUN`V\^HU[PZMVYHZPUNSLJVTWSHPU[[V[\YUPU[VH]VSH[PSL[OYLHKVMIHJRHUKMVY[OWVZ[Z
IL[^LLU`V\YIYHUK[OLPUP[PHSJVTWSHPUHU[HUK[OLPUL]P[HISLIHUK^HNVUQ\TWLYZ^OVILNPU[VJOPTL
PU^P[O[OLPYV^UULNH[P]P[`3HZ[S`HUKTVZ[PTWVY[HU[S`[OL^VYZ[TPZ[HRL`V\JHUTHRLPU`V\Y
YLHJ[PVUYLZWVUZLZ[YH[LN`PZ[VZLSLJ[P]LS`WPJRHUKJOVVZL^OPJOWVZ[Z`V\YLZWVUK[V0M`V\YLZWVUK
[VVULJVTWSHPUHU[`V\ULLK[VYLZWVUK[V[OLTHSS4HU`IYHUKZ[HRL[OLLHZ`YVHKLZWLJPHSS`^OLU
[OL`OH]LHTHZZP]LMHUIHZL[OH[WVZ[ZMYLX\LU[\UZVSPJP[LKWVZ[ZVU[OL>HSSI`VUS`YLZWVUKPUN
[V[OLWVZ[Z[OH[^PSSNLULYH[L[OLSLHZ[JVU[YV]LYZ`>OPSLP[»ZPTWVY[HU[[VILKPWSVTH[PJPUHSS`V\Y
PU[LYHJ[PVUZ`V\ZOV\SKUL]LY[HRLHº^L^VU»[KPNUPM`[OH[^P[OHYLZWVUZL»H[[P[\KL[VTHUHNPUN\ZLY
WVZ[ZVU[OL-HJLIVVR>HSS9LTLTILYTHUHNPUN\ZLYNLULYH[LKJVU[LU[VU[OL-HJLIVVR>HSSPZH
M\SS[PTLQVI0M`V\YN\HYKPZKV^UMVYHZSP[[SLHZOV\YZ`V\TPNO[LUK\W^P[OHU\UTHUHNLHISL
X\L\LVMTLZZHNLZ[OH[ULLKYLZWVUKPUN[V

7YVZ!
‹0TTLKPH[LWLYZVUHSYLZWVUZLPUJS\KLZ
JVU[HJ[PUMVYTH[PVUMVYMVSSV^\W

*VUZ!
‹>OPSL[OLJVTWSHPUHU[PZWLYZVUHSS`
HKKYLZZLKHUHKKP[PVUHSZLU[LUJLJV\SKOH]L
PUJS\KLKHJHSSV\[[OH[YLHZZ\YLZV[OLY\ZLYZ
HIV\[[OLIYHUK»ZJVTTP[TLU[[VL_JLW[PVUHS
J\Z[VTLYZLY]PJL

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Reacting and Responding to Complaints

7YVZ!
‹(WLYZVUHSYLZWVUZLPUJS\KPUN[OLJVTWSHPUHU[»Z
UHTL


‹/\TISLHUKHWVSVNL[PJL_WSHUH[PVU[OH[YLZVS]LZ
[OLWYVISLT

*VUZ!
‹*VTWSHPU[PZWVZ[LKVU:H[\YKH`I\[YLZWVUZLPZ
UV[WVZ[LK\U[PS4VUKH`HM[LYUVVU

‹3HJRVMKPYLJ[JVU[HJ[PUMVYTH[PVULTHPSVYWOVUL
U\TILYKVLZUV[WYV]PKLJVUZ\TLY^P[O[OLHIPSP[`
[VMVSSV^\WVU[OLPYJVTWSHPU[PM[OLYLHYLM\Y[OLY
WYVISLTZ

7YVZ!
‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZLPUJS\KLZN\PKHUJLPU[OLMVYTVM
HKPYLJ[SPUR[V[OLPUMVYTH[PVU[OLJVTWSHPUHU[ULLKZ
[VYLZVS]L[OLPZZ\L

‹(MVSSV^\WYLZWVUZLYLHZZ\YLZ[OLJVTWSHPUHU[
[OH[[OLIYHUKPZJVTTP[[LK[VYLZVS]PUN[OLPZZ\LPU
HUHTPJHISLTHUULY

*VUZ!
‹-V\YKH`ZPZ[VVSVUNMVYHJVUZ\TLY[V^HP[MVYH
YLZWVUZL[VHJVTWSHPU[

‹;OLJVTWSHPUHU[PZUV[WYV]PKLK^P[OHU`JVU[HJ[
PUMVYTH[PVU[VYLHJOHJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLYLWKPYLJ[S`
0UZ[LHKOLT\Z[H[Y\Z[HIYHUK[OH[OLHSYLHK`OHZ
ULNH[P]LMLLSPUNZHIV\[[VNL[PU[V\JO^P[OOPT

7YVZ!
‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZLPUJS\KLZN\PKHUJLPU[OLMVYTVMHKPYLJ[SPUR[V[OLPUMVYTH[PVU[OLJVTWSHPUHU[ULLKZ[VYLZVS]L[OLPZZ\L

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
 Spreading Positivity
9LZWVUKPUN[VWVZP[P]LWVZ[ZPZQ\Z[HZPTWVY[HU[HZYLHJ[PUN[VULNH[P]P[`VU`V\Y-HJLIVVR>HSS>OLU
-HJLIVVR\ZLYZºSPRL»`V\Y-HJLIVVR7HNL[OL`HYLUV[VUS`VW[PUN[VYLJLP]LJVTT\UPJH[PVUZMYVT
`V\YIYHUKVU[OL-HJLIVVR5L^Z-LLK;OL`HYLHSZVYHPZPUN[OLPYOHUKZHUKZ[H[PUN[V[OL-HJLIVVR
JVTT\UP[`H[SHYNLº0HTHUHK]VJH[LMVY)YHUK?»

7VZP[P]LWVZ[ZHUKJVTTLU[ZMYVT\ZLYZKVU»[Q\Z[SP]LVU`V\Y>HSS¶[OL`HYLKPZWLYZLK[V[OL5L^Z
-LLKZVMLHJO\ZLY»ZMYPLUKZ;OPZPZHJOHUJL[VL_WHUK[OLYLHJOVM`V\YH\KPLUJLHZ^LSSHZHU
L_JLSSLU[VWWVY[\UP[`[VZOV^-HJLIVVR\ZLYZHYV\UK[OL^VYSK[OH[`V\HYLJVTTP[[LK[VLUNHNPUNPU
H[^V^H`JVU]LYZH[PVU^P[OWLVWSL,HJO[PTL`V\JVTTLU[VUHWVZP[P]LWVZ[[OH[JVTTLU[THRLZ
P[Z^H`[V[OL5L^Z-LLK:VPMH\ZLYPZNP]PUN`V\WYVWZTHRLZ\YL`V\YLHJ[HUKYLZWVUK^P[OH
WVZP[P]LTLZZHNLVM`V\YV^U-HJLIVVR\ZLYZHYLI\`PUN`V\YWYVK\J[ZZ[H`PUNPU`V\YOV[LSZHUK
\[PSPaPUN`V\YZLY]PJLZ0M[OL`»YLOHWW`HUK[OL`^HU[`V\YIYHUK[VRUV^HIV\[P[SL[[OLTRUV^`V\»YL
SPZ[LUPUN0[^PSSVUS`ZLY]L[VYLPUMVYJL[OLPYWVZP[P]LMLLSPUNZHUKPUJYLHZL[OLJOHUJL[OH[[OL`^PSSNV
[VIH[MVY`V\YIYHUKPU[OLM\[\YL

7YVZ!
‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZL[OH[PUJS\KLZJVTWSPTLU[HY`
SHUN\HNL[OH[YLPUMVYJLZWVZP[P]LMLLSPUNZHIV\[[OL
IYHUK

‹-VSSV^\WYLZWVUZLPUJS\KLZ\ZLVM[OLMVYTHSºZPY»
^OPJOÄ[Z^P[O[OLIYHUK»ZJSHZZ`PTHNL

‹*VU]LYZH[PVUPUJS\KLZKPYLJ[JVU[HJ[PUMVYTH[PVU
WYV]PKPUNHUVWWVY[\UP[`MVY[OL\ZLY[VZOHYLWOV[VZ
HUKTVYLWVZP[P]LZLU[PTLU[MVY[OLIYHUK

7YVZ!

‹6USPULJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLYLWZÄ_HWV[LU[PHSS`ULNH[P]L
ZP[\H[PVUWYVTW[PUN\ZLY[VZOHYLHWVZP[P]LL_WLYPLUJL

‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZLZOV^ZJVTTP[TLU[[VJ\Z[VTLY
ZLY]PJLHZ^LSSHZHTLHUZMVYºZWYLHKPUN[OLNVVK»;OL
\ZLYPZHZZ\YLK[OH[[OLPYWVZP[P]LL_WLYPLUJLOHZILLU
YLJVNUPaLK^P[OPU[OLVYNHUPaH[PVUHUK[OH[[OLJ\Z[VTLY
ZLY]PJLYLWYLZWVUZPISLMVYOHUKSPUN[OLZP[\H[PVU^PSS
YLJLP]LHJVTTLUKH[PVUMYVTTHUHNLTLU[

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
 Spreading Positivity

7YVZ!
‹9LJVNUP[PVUVM[OL\ZLY»ZWVZP[P]LWVZ[NP]LZ[OLIYHUK
HJOHUJL[VZ\NNLZ[M\Y[OLYVWWVY[\UP[PLZMVYLUQV`TLU[
H[[OLWYVWLY[`VU[OL\ZLY»ZUL_[[YPW

‹<ZLVM[OL^VYKºLWPJ\YLHU»Ä[Z^P[O[OLIYHUK»Z
S\_\Y`PTHNLHUKYLZWLJ[Z[OL\ZLY»ZPU[LSSPNLUJLI`UV[
ZWLHRPUN[V[OLSV^LZ[JVTTVUKLUVTPUH[VY

7YVZ!
‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZLJVTT\UPJH[LZ[OH[[OLIYHUKPZ
JVUJLYULKMVY[OL^LSSILPUNVM[OL\ZLY

‹4LU[PVUVMHJVTWL[P[VYPU[OL\ZLY»ZWVZ[WYV]PKLZ
HZVM[IHSSVWWVY[\UP[`MVY[OLIYHUK[VRUVJR[OL
JVTWL[P[PVU0UZ[LHK[OL`[HRL[OLOPNOYVHK
JVUJLU[YH[PUNVUWVZP[P]P[`YH[OLY[OHUMVZ[LYPUNH
ULNH[P]LH[TVZWOLYLVU[OL>HSS

7YVZ!
‹4HU`IYHUKZISVJR\UZVSPJP[LK\ZLYNLULYH[LK
JVU[LU[/.;=^LSJVTLZZ\NNLZ[PVUZWOV[VZHUK[PWZ
MYVT\ZLYZ^OPJOLUNLUKLYZHMLLSPUNVMJVTT\UP[`
PU]VS]LTLU[MVYMHUZ

‹:HS\[H[VY`YLZWVUZLPUJS\KLZ[OLUHTLVM[OL\ZLY
HZ^LSSHZ[OLUHTLVM[OLYLZWVUKLU[*VTWSPTLU[PUN
H\ZLY»ZPUNLU\P[`ZW\YZZ\ITPZZPVUVMTVYL\ZLY
NLULYH[LKJVU[LU[HZ[OLJVTT\UP[``LHYUZMVYWVZP[P]L
MLLKIHJRMYVTHIYHUK[OH[[OL`SV]L

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Answering Requests for Information
;OPZPZWYVIHIS`[OLIPNNLZ[UVIYHPULYPU[OLYLHSTVMYLHJ[PUN[VWLVWSL»ZWVZ[ZHUKJVTTLU[Z>OLU
HWLYZVUHZRZHX\LZ[PVU[OH[VUS`ZVTLVULMYVT`V\YVYNHUPaH[PVUJHUHUZ^LY`V\ZOV\SKWYV]PKL
HX\PJRHUKHJJ\YH[LYLZWVUZL9LZWVUZLZWLLKPZJY\JPHS^OLUP[JVTLZ[VHUZ^LYPUNYLX\LZ[ZMVY
PUMVYTH[PVU:VJPHSTLKPHZP[LZJHUILHOV[ILKVMY\TVYZHUKZWLJ\SH[PVU7LVWSLZVTL[PTLZSPRL[V
WYVQLJ[[OLPSS\ZPVU[OH[[OL`HYLPUZPKLYZ^P[OHJJLZZ[VPUMVYTH[PVU[OH[UVVULLSZLOHZ@V\ULLK
[VYLHJ[ILMVYL[OLY\TVYTPSSZ[HY[ZZWPUUPUN0UHJJ\YH[LPUMVYTH[PVUJHUYHWPKS`ZWYLHKHJYVZZ[OL
-HJLIVVR5L^Z-LLKLZWLJPHSS`PMP[JVUJLYUZHULHNLYS`HU[PJPWH[LKWYVK\J[YLSLHZL)LMVYL`V\RUV^
P[HUPUHJJ\YH[LWVZ[JHUJVSSLJ[O\UKYLKZVMJVTTLU[Z

;OLVUS`^H`[VJ\Y[HPS[OLULNH[P]P[`[OH[JV\SKYLZ\S[MYVTPUHJJ\YH[LPUMVYTH[PVUPZ[VILWYVHJ[P]L
YH[OLY[OHUYLHJ[P]L0THNPULKLHSPUN^P[O[OV\ZHUKZVMHUNY`MHUZ[OH[YLHKH\ZLYWVZ[MPSSLK^P[OMHSZL
PUMVYTH[PVUHIV\[HYLSLHZLKH[LVYZHSL&9LTLTILY[OH[`V\YMHUZHYLSVVRPUN[V`V\[VILH[Y\Z[LK
ZV\YJLVMPUMVYTH[PVU¶ZVNP]L[OLT[OLMHJ[Z[OH[[OL`HYLHZRPUNMVY<S[PTH[LS``V\YNVHSZOV\SKIL
[VTHRLLHJO-HJLIVVR-HUMLLSSPRLHUPUZPKLYILJH\ZL`V\HYLWYV]PKPUN[OLT^P[O[OL]HS\LHKKLK
IVU\ZVMWYPVYP[PaLKHJJLZZ[VPUMVYTH[PVUHIV\[`V\YIYHUK

7YVZ!
‹;OLIYHUKPZHZZ\YPUN[V[OL\ZLY[OH[-HJLIVVR
-HUZ^PSSIL[OLÄYZ[[VOLHYHIV\[[OLYLSLHZLKH[L
MVYHUL^WYVK\J[


‹5LNSLJ[PUN[VWYV]PKLHYVJRZVSPKYLSLHZL
KH[LNP]LZ\ZLYZHYLHZVU[VYL[\YU[V[OL7HNL
MYLX\LU[S`

*VUZ!
‹3HNVUYLZWVUZL[PTLOV\YZNH]LV[OLY
\ZLYZ[OLVWWVY[\UP[`[VHUZ^LY[OLX\LZ[PVU^P[O
PUJVYYLJ[PUMVYTH[PVU

‹*Y`W[PJYLZWVUZLTPNO[LUNLUKLYMLLSPUNZVM
YLZLU[TLU[HTVUNZ[MHUZLHNLYS`H^HP[PUNUL^ZVM
HYLSLHZLKH[L

7YVZ!
‹:WLLK`YLZWVUZL^P[OHJJ\YH[LPUMVY

TH[PVU[OH[WYLJPZLS`HUZ^LYZ[OL\ZLY»Z
X\LZ[PVU

*VUZ!
‹(TPZZLKVWWVY[\UP[`[VWYV]PKLHUL]LU
TVYL]HS\HISLL_WLYPLUJLMVY[OL\ZLY(SPUR
[V[OLOV[LS»ZIVVRPUNLUNPULVYTVYLKL[HPSZ
HIV\[WVVSZPKLZLY]PJLZTPNO[OH]L[YHUZ
MVYTLKHWV[LU[PHSN\LZ[PU[VHJVUÄYTLK
YLZLY]H[PVU

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Giving Guidance and Advice
:VTL[PTLZWYV]PKPUNZPTWSL[PKIP[ZVMPUMVYTH[PVUPZUV[LUV\NO[VZH[PZM`HMY\Z[YH[LKVYJVUM\ZLK
J\Z[VTLY>OLUWLVWSLOH]LUVWSHJLSLM[[V[\YUMVYN\PKHUJLHUKHK]PJL[OL`OLHK[V`V\Y-HJLIVVR
>HSS^P[OPUJYLHZLKMYLX\LUJ`(Z-HJLIVVR»Z\ZLYIHZLJVU[PU\LZ[VNYV^IYHUKTHUHNLYZHYLSPRLS`
[VMPUK[OLTZLS]LZPUHUHSSW\YWVZLWVZP[PVUVMJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLYLWQV\YUHSPZ[HUKJV\UZLSVY

>L»YLYLHJOPUNHWVPU[PUJ\Z[VTLYYLSH[PVUZOPWTHUHNLTLU[^OLYLPUJVUZ\TLYZTH`VM[LUI`WHZZ
[OLNH\U[SL[VMH\[VTH[LKWOVULZ`Z[LTZHUKVUSPULJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLX\L\LZPUMH]VYVMHTVYLYHWPK
WLYZVUHSPU[LYHJ[PVUVU[OL-HJLIVVR>HSS;OPZ]PZPVUVM[OLM\[\YLPZIV[O[OYPSSPUNHUKMYPNO[LUPUN
0[»Z[OYPSSPUNILJH\ZLP[^PSSPUL]P[HIS`SLHK[VZ[YVUNLYYLSH[PVUZOPWZIL[^LLUIYHUKZHUKJVUZ\TLYZ¶H
ZTHSSLYTVYLWLYZVUHS^VYSKPU^OPJOJVUZ\TLYZMLLS]HS\LKYH[OLY[OHUMLLSPUNSPRLQ\Z[HUV[OLY:2<
U\TILYPUHZWYLHKZOLL[

0[»ZHSZVMYPNO[LUPUNLZWLJPHSS`MYVTHSLNHSWLYZWLJ[P]L0M`V\YJ\Z[VTLYZHUKWYVZWLJ[ZHYLYLHJOPUN
V\[MVYN\PKHUJLHUKHK]PJL`V\ULLK[VTHRLZ\YL[OH[`V\YIYHUKPZJHYLM\SHUK]PNPSHU[>OPSL`V\
TPNO[OH]L[OLILZ[PU[LU[PVUZV[OLYZTH`UV[)LZ\YL[VYLZWVUK[VLHJOYLX\LZ[MVYN\PKHUJL^P[O
HUHUZ^LY[OH[WYVHJ[P]LS`WYV[LJ[Z`V\MYVTSP[PNH[PVU^OPSLHSZVWYV]PKPUN[OL\ZLY^P[OHYLZWVUZL
[OH[[OL`^PSSMPUK]HS\HISLHUKHJ[PVUHISL0M[OLYLPZHU`X\LZ[PVUPU`V\YTPUKHIV\[OV^[VYLZWVUK
JVU[HJ[[OLWLYZVUPUX\LZ[PVUKPYLJ[S`;OPZ^PSSSPTP[`V\YL_WVZ\YL[VULNH[P]LJVTTLU[ZHUK
WLVWSL^P[O\S[LYPVYTV[P]LZ^OVHYLQ\Z[^HP[PUN[VQ\TWVUH[OYLHK[OH[^PSSHSSV^[OLT[V]LU[[OLPY
ULNH[P]P[`[V[OLJVTT\UP[`H[SHYNL

7YVZ!
‹:WLLK`WLYZVUHSYLZWVUZLVMMLYZHKPYLJ[SPUR
[VHISVNWVZ[^P[O[OLN\PKHUJLHUKHK]PJL[OL
\ZLYPZSVVRPUNMVY

‹7OVULMVSSV^\WPZWYLZLU[LK[V[OLJVUZ\TLY
HSVUN^P[OHWS\NMVYHWHY[ULY^LIZP[L[OH[VMMLYZ
MYLLHK]PJL[V[H_WH`LYZ

7YVZ!
‹;OLIYHUKYLHJOLZV\[[VWYV]PKL\UZVSPJP[LKHK]PJL
[VH\ZLY^OVZOHYLZOLYMY\Z[YH[PVUHIV\[OLYPUHIPSP[`[V
ÄUKHWYVK\J[[OH[ZOLSV]LZ

‹9LHZZ\YPUNHUKJVTWSPTLU[HY`[VULTP_LK^P[OH
^LHS[OVMPUMVYTH[PVUWYVTW[Z[OL\ZLY[VYLZWVUK
^P[OHWVZP[P]LJVTTLU[HIV\[OLYL_WLYPLUJL^P[O
[OLIYHUK

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Tempering Frustration From Tech Issues
3L[»ZMHJLP[¶[LJOUVSVN`JHUMY\Z[YH[LHZTHU`WLVWSLHZP[MHZJPUH[LZ6M[LU[PTLZ[OH[MY\Z[YH[PVUPZ
JVTWV\UKLKHUKT\S[PWSPLK^OLUJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLYLWYLZLU[H[P]LZLU[LY[OLLX\H[PVU7LVWSLSVVRPUN
MVYHX\PJRZVS\[PVU[V[OLPYWYVISLTJHUZ[HY[[VIVPS^P[OYHNLHZ[OL`ZP[VUOVSKVY^HP[MVYHYL[\YU
LTHPS(Z[OH[YHNLI\PSKZ[OLZLJVUZ\TLYZTPNO[OLHK[V`V\Y-HJLIVVR7HNL[V]LU[¶^OPJONP]LZ
`V\HUVWWVY[\UP[`[VW\[V\[[OLMPYLHUKYLWSHJLP[^P[OZVTL[OPUN[Y\S`]HS\HISL¶[OLHUZ^LY[V[OLPY
KPSLTTH)\[^OH[OHWWLUZ^OLU`V\JHU»[WYV]PKLHUPTTLKPH[LHUZ^LYVY[OLWYVISLTYLX\PYLZHU
PUWLYZVUJVUZ\S[H[PVU&@V\Z[PSSOH]LHUVWWVY[\UP[`[VZH]L[OLKH`I`NP]PUNWLVWSL[OLULJLZZHY`
HTV\U[VMPUMVYTH[PVU[VZVS]L[OLWYVISLT[OLTZLS]LZ-VYL_HTWSLPM0ZWPSSHZVKHVUT`SHW[VW
[OLYL»ZUV[HUVUSPULWOVULJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLYLWVU[OLWSHUL[[OH[^PSSILHISL[VVMMLYTLZVSHJL
-PILYVW[PJZTH`OH]LZWLK\W[LJOUVSVN`I\[HZMHYHZ0RUV^[OLYLPZUVHWW[OH[THRLZ[OLNLLR
ZX\HKZOVV[V\[VM`V\YTVUP[VY[VPTTLKPH[LS`MP_HULHYS`\UMP_HISL[LJOPZZ\L)\[PM0NV[V[OL
-HJLIVVR7HNLVM[OLJVTWHU`[OH[I\PS[T`SHW[VWHUKSLH]LHZPTWSLJVTTLU[º>OVJHUOLSWTLMP_
HJVTW\[LY[OH[0ZWPSSLKZVKHVU&ȦH-HJLIVVRZH]]`IYHUK^PSSOH]L[OLWLYMLJ[YLZWVUZLX\L\LK
\W;OLPYYLZWVUZL^PSSJVU[HPUHSSVM[OLPUMVYTH[PVU0ULLK[VNL[[OLJVTW\[LYMP_LKHZ^LSSHZHML^
^VYKZYLHZZ\YPUNTL[OH[ºHSSPZUV[SVZ[»

7YVZ!
‹)YHUKWYV]PKLZZL]LYHSVW[PVUZIV[OVU
HUKVMÅPULMVY[OLJVUZ\TLY[VL_WSVYL[V
[YV\ISLZOVV[OLY[LJOPZZ\LZ

*VUZ!
‹.\PKHUJLPZUV[]LY`WLYZVUHSVYZWLJPÄJ[V
[OLJVUZ\TLY»ZPZZ\L:\NNLZ[PUNH\ZLYTHU\HS
JVUZ\S[H[PVUVYPUZ[VYL]PZP[[VHYLWHPYSVJH[PVU
ZLLTZSPRLºWHZZPUN[OLI\JR»

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS
Tempering Frustration From Tech Issues

7YVZ!
‹.YHJPV\ZYLZWVUZL[VH[LJOZH]]`\ZLYPUJS\KLZHU
PU]P[L[VQVPUHJVTT\UP[`VMJVUZ\TLYPUÅ\LUJLYZ

‹(KKP[PVUHSWLYZVUHSYLZWVUZLMYVTIYHUK»Z=PJL
7YLZPKLU[KPYLJ[S`HUZ^LYZ[OL\ZLY»ZX\LZ[PVUHUK
WYV]PKLZU\TLYV\ZHS[LYUH[P]LZ[VHUVUZ\WWVY[LK
MLH[\YLYLX\LZ[

*VUZ!
‹9LZWVUZLMYVTIYHUK=7^HZWVZ[LKVUL^LLRHM[LY
VYPNPUHS\ZLYX\LZ[PVUYLZWVUZL

7YVZ!
‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZLPUJS\KLZHUHS[LYUH[LVW[PVUMVY
IVVRPUNZHUKYLZLY]H[PVUZHZ^LSSHZYLHZZ\YHUJL[OH[
[OL[LJOWYVISLT^PSSILZVS]LKZOVY[S`

*VUZ!
‹+LSH`LKYLZWVUZL[PTLHSSV^ZZL]LUHKKP[PVUHS\ZLYZ
[VJVTTLU[HIV\[[OL[LJOUVSVN`PZZ\LZ

‹)YHUKPZUV[WYVHJ[P]LHUKKVLZUV[WVZ[TLZZHNL
HIV\[[OL[LJOPZZ\L[V[OLLU[PYLMHUJVTT\UP[`
;YHUZWHYLUJ`SLHKZ[V[Y\Z[

7YVZ!
‹7LYZVUHSYLZWVUZLZOV^ZHJVTTP[TLU[[V[VW[PLY
J\Z[VTLYZLY]PJL

‹-VSSV^[OYV\NOI`J\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLWOVULZ\WWVY[
[\YULKHWV[LU[PHSS`ULNH[P]LZP[\H[PVUPU[VHWVZP[P]L
L_WLYPLUJL[OH[WYVTW[LK[OL\ZLY[VNP]L[OLIYHUK
WYVWZPUOLYYLZWVUZL

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Managing Threads of Conversation
0UHWLYMLJ[^VYSK`V\Y-HJLIVVR7HNL^V\SKILHJVTT\UP[`VMIYHUKHK]VJH[LZ^OVZOHYLHUHMMPUP[`
MVY`V\YIYHUK6USPULJVTT\UP[PLZ[OYP]LHZHYLZ\S[VM[OLMYLX\LU[JVU]LYZH[PVUZIL[^LLUSPRLTPUKLK
WLVWSL^OVHUZ^LYLHJOV[OLY»ZX\LZ[PVUZHUKZ\WWVY[LHJOV[OLY»ZVWPUPVUZ6I]PV\ZS`[OLYL»ZUV
^H`[VJVTWSL[LS`WYVOPIP[ULNH[P]P[`VU`V\Y>HSS¶HUKHZSVUNHZ[OLULNH[P]P[`PZUV[KLZ[Y\J[P]LVY
OH[LM\S`V\ZOV\SKU»[OH]LHWYVISLT^P[O\ZLYZJVU[YPI\[PUN[OLPYOVULZ[MLLSPUNZ[VHJVU]LYZH[PVU

;OYLHKZVMJVU]LYZH[PVUJHUILHOV[ILKVMULNH[P]P[`ILJH\ZLTHU`-HJLIVVR\ZLYZKVU»[OH]L
X\HSTZHIV\[ZWYLHKPUN[OLOH[L^P[OZ[YHUNLYZVYIYHUKZ;OYLHKZJHUVM[LUZ[HY[HZHZTHSS
JVU[YVSSHISLMPYLI\[JHUX\PJRS`L_WHUKPU[VHMPYLZ[VYTVMWYVMHUP[`HUKULNH[P]LZLU[PTLU[:VOV^
KV`V\Z[VWHWV[LU[PHSS`KHUNLYV\Z[OYLHKILMVYLP[Z[HY[Z[VH]HSHUJOLHUKNHPUULNH[P]LTVTLU[\T&
0[»ZLHZ`[VZH`[OH[JVUZ[HU[]PNPSHUJL^PSSKV[OL[YPJR¶I\[ZVTLIYHUKZKVU»[OH]L[OLYLZV\YJLZVY
Z[HMM[VWVSPJL[OLPY-HJLIVVR>HSSHYV\UK[OLJSVJR;OL[YPJROLYLPZ[VUPW[OPUNZPU[OLI\KILMVYL
\ZLYZOH]LHJOHUJL[V[\YUHZPTWSLJVTWSHPU[PU[VHUHYN\TLU[^P[O[^LU[`WHZZPVUH[LWHY[PJPWHU[Z
4HRLZ\YL`V\»YLYL^HYKPUN`V\YºMHUWVSPJL»[OVZL\ZLYZ^OVNVV\[VM[OLPY^H`[VTHPU[HPUHWVZP[P]L
H[TVZWOLYL¶I`YLZWVUKPUN[V[OLPYWVZ[Z^P[ONYHJPV\ZHUKJVTWSPTLU[HY`JVTTLU[Z;OPZ^PSSVUS`
HKKTVYLZVSKPLYZ[V`V\YHYT`5L_[HKKYLZZULNH[P]LWVZ[Z[OH[HYLUV[PUMSHTTH[VY`VYKLYVNH[VY`
^P[OJVTTLU[Z[OH[HYLZ`TWH[OL[PJHUKWLYZVUHS-PUHSS`HZHUHKTPUVM`V\Y7HNL`V\OH]LHYPNO[
[VKLSL[LHU`JVTTLU[Z[OH[`V\ZLLHZILPUNVMMLUZP]LVYKLZ[Y\J[P]L.VMVYP[¶[OLYL»ZUV[OPUN
^YVUN^P[OWYV[LJ[PUN`V\YIYHUKPTHNL(ZHSHZ[YLZVY[PM`V\OH]LHWHY[PJ\SHYS`ULNH[P]L]VPJLVU
`V\YOHUKZ`V\HS^H`ZOH]L[OLVW[PVUVMISVJRPUNHOH[LM\S\ZLY6UJLISVJRLK[OH[\ZLY^PSSSVZLOPZ
HIPSP[`[VJVTTLU[VU`V\Y>HSSLMMLJ[P]LS`LYHZPUNHU`M\[\YLMHSSV\[MYVT[OLPYUVNVVK^H`Z

*VU!<ZLY
SLH]LZULNH[P]LJVTTLU[ZHIV\[
OV\ZLRLLWPUNHUKMVVKH[OLYOV[LS


7YV!<ZLY
Z\WWVY[Z[OLIYHUKHUKTHRLZZ\NNLZ[PVUZ[V
OLSWYLZVS]L[OLWYVISLT


7YV!)YHUKWVZ[ZJVTTLU[MVY<ZLY
YLHZZ\YPUN[OH[
ZVTLVUL^PSSSVVRPU[VOLYPZZ\LZPTTLKPH[LS`


7YV!<ZLY
JOPTLZPU^P[OHKKP[PVUHSWVZP[P]L^VYKVMTV\[O
HIV\[[OLIYHUK(WVZP[P]LJVTT\UP[`SLHKZ[VHWVZP[P]L
L_WLYPLUJLL_WLYPLUJL


*VU!)YHUKMVSSV^\WZOV^ZSHJRVMPU[LYUHSJVTT\UPJH[PVU
^P[OPU[OLVYNHUPaH[PVU*VTTLU[PZWVZ[LKULHYS`[OYLLOV\YZ
HM[LYPUP[PHSJVTWSHPU[


*VU!<ZLY
HUK<ZLY
SLH]LJVTTLU[Z[V[HSS`\UYLSH[LK
[V[OLPZZ\LH[OHUKWYV]PKPUNHUVWWVY[\UP[`MVY[OL[OYLHK[V
ZWPYHSV\[VMJVU[YVS

7YV!<ZLY
YLZWVUKZ[\YUPUNHULNH[P]LL_WLYPLUJLPU[VH
WVZP[P]LJVTTLU[

7YV!)YHUKYLZWVUKZ^P[OHNYHJPV\ZJVTTLU[[OH[HZRZ<ZLY


MVYTVYLPUW\[[VOLSWPTWYV]L[OLZLY]PJLZHUKHTLUP[PLZH[
[OLOV[LS

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Managing Threads of Conversation

*VU!<ZLY
SLH]LZULNH[P]LJVTTLU[ZHIV\[OLYULNH[P]L
L_WLYPLUJL^P[O[OLIYHUK»Z^LIZP[LZOPWTLU[[YHJRLY

7YV!)YHUKPTTLKPH[LS`WVZ[ZHZ`TWH[OL[PJYLZWVUZLOVWPUN[V
YLZVS]L[OLPZZ\L

*VU!<ZLY
PNUVYLZ[OLIYHUK»ZYLZWVUZLHUKWVZ[Z[OYLL
PUÅHTTH[VY`ULNH[P]LJVTTLU[Z^P[OPUVULOV\Y

7YV!)YHUKMVSSV^Z\WI`YLWLH[PUN[OLPYX\LZ[PVUPUHYLHZVUHISLHUK
WYVMLZZPVUHSTHUULY

7YV!<ZLY
HJRUV^SLKNLZ[OLIYHUK»ZX\LZ[PVU)YHUKPTTLKPH[LS`
YLZWVUKZ^P[OHYLHZZ\YPUNTLZZHNL<ZLY
ZLUKZHNYHJPV\Z
º[OHUR`V\»

*VU!<ZLY
LU[LYZ[OLMYH`HUKZ[HY[Z\WHZLLTPUNS`OHYTSLZZ
JVU]LYZH[PVU^P[O<ZLY
)V[OHYLVI]PV\ZMHUZVM[OLIYHUKI\[
MY\Z[YH[LKI`J\Z[VTLYZLY]PJL(Z[PTLWHZZLZ^P[OV\[HYLZWVUZL
MYVT[OLIYHUK[OLJ\Z[VTLYZ[\YU[OLPYWVZP[P]LPU[LYHJ[PVUPU[VH
THLSZ[YVTVMULNH[P]P[`HUKJVTWSHPU[Z4VYL[OHUOV\YZWHZZ
^P[OV\[HYLZVS\[PVU(VUL[PTLJVTWSHPU[OHZ[OLWV[LU[PHS[V[\YU
[^VIYHUKHK]VJH[LZPU[V[^VIYHUK[YVSSZ

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Moderating Posts: Keeping Profanity
& Negativity at Bay

5V[L]LY`IYHUKOHZ[OLI\KNL[[VPU]LZ[PUHZVJPHSTLKPHZVM[^HYL

ZVS\[PVU[OH[VMMLYZHYVI\Z[TVKLYH[PVULUNPULSPRL[OLVULPU
[OL)\KK`4LKPH7SH[MVYTZVP[»ZPTWVY[HU[[V\UKLYZ[HUK[OH[
TVKLYH[PVUKVLZUV[ULJLZZHYPS`YLX\PYLHOPNOWV^LYLK[VVS[VTVUP[VY
HUKTHUHNLHU\ULUKPUNZ[YLHTVM\ZLYNLULYH[LKTLZZHNPUN;OLMPYZ[
Z[LWPUHZ\JJLZZM\STVKLYH[PVUZ[YH[LN`PU]VS]LZZL[[PUNNYV\UKY\SLZ
MVY`V\YJVTT\UP[`:L[[PUN`V\Y\ZLYZ»L_WLJ[H[PVUZMVYHJVKLVM
JVUK\J[^PSSSL[[OLTRUV^^OH[RPUKVMJVU[LU[PZLUJV\YHNLKHUK^OH[RPUKVMJVU[LU[PZMYV^ULK
\WVU0[»ZPTWVY[HU[[VNP]L`V\Y9\SLZHUK9LN\SH[PVUZ]PZPIPSP[`^P[OPU`V\Y-HJLIVVR7HNL
LU]PYVUTLU[+LWSV`PUNHZPTWSLKLZJYPW[PVUVM`V\YJVTT\UP[`NVHSZ^P[OPU[OLSLM[YHPSILULH[O`V\Y
7YVMPSL7OV[V^PSSLUZ\YL[OH[`V\YN\PKLSPULZHYLZ\YMHJLKUVTH[[LY^OLYLVU`V\Y7HNL`V\Y\ZLYZ
HYLPU[LYHJ[PUN

;OLUL_[Z[LWPUHZ\JJLZZM\STVKLYH[PVUZ[YH[LN`PZ]PNPSHUJL0[JHUILPTWVZZPISL[VRLLWHYV\UK
[OLJSVJR^H[JOVU`V\Y7HNL/V^L]LYPM`V\KV[OPUNZYPNO[`V\TPNO[WYLLTW[P]LS`J\[VMMTHU`
ULNH[P]LWVZ[ZILMVYL[OL`L]LUOHWWLU@V\ULLK[VJVTTP[[VHºTVKLYH[PVUI`JVTT\UPJH[PVU»
Z[YH[LN`0MHºULNH[P]L5LSS`»ZLLZ[OH[`V\YLZWVUK[VL]LY`ULNH[P]LJVTTLU[[OH[PZZ\YMHJLKVU
[OL>HSS[OL`TPNO[[OPUR[^PJLHIV\[SLH]PUNHKLMHTH[VY`TLZZHNL+VU»[MVYNL[[OH[WLVWSLMLLS
LTWV^LYLKI`[OLZLLTPUNHUVU`TP[`VMKPZJ\ZZPVU[OYLHKZHZ^LSSHZ[OLPTWYLZZPVU[OH[[OL`JHU
]LU[[OLPYMLLSPUNZ^P[OV\[NLULYH[PUNJVUMSPJ[3LHKI`L_HTWSLHUKZOV^`V\Y\ZLYZ[OH[`V\HYL
JVTTP[[LK[VI\PSKPUNHZHMLJVTT\UP[`[OH[[OYP]LZVUWVZP[P]P[`

3HZ[I\[UV[SLHZ[NL[I`^P[OHSP[[SLOLSWMYVT`V\Y
MYPLUKZ0U[OPZJHZL`V\YMYPLUKZHYL[OLTLTILYZVM
`V\YJVTT\UP[`,]LY`-HJLIVVR\ZLYOHZ[OLHIPSP[`
[VºMSHNHUKYLWVY[»WVZ[ZTHKLI`LP[OLYH\ZLYVY
HIYHUK,TWV^LY`V\YMHUIHZL[VIL[OLWVSPJL
ZX\HKVM`V\Y7HNLHUK[OL`»SSZ[HY[[VKV`V\Y
TVKLYH[PUNMVY`V\>OLUZ\ITP[[PUNHYLWVY[\ZLYZ
OH]L[OLHIPSP[`[VMSHNHWVZ[MVYZWHTOH[LZWLLJO
]PVSLUJLVYZL_\HSS`L_WSPJP[JVU[LU[;OLZLYLWVY[Z
NVKPYLJ[S`[V-HJLIVVR»ZZLJ\YP[`[LHT0MHULNH[P]L]VPJLRLLWZSLH]PUNKLMHTH[VY`WVZ[ZVU`V\Y
>HSSHUKLUV\NOVM`V\YJVTT\UP[`TLTILYZYLWVY[[OLHJ[P]P[`[OLYL»ZHNVVKJOHUJL[OH[[OL
WLYZVU»Z-HJLIVVRHJJV\U[^PSSILKPZHISLK3L[`V\YMHUZRUV^[OH[`V\HYLSVVRPUN[V[OLT[VRLLW
[OLJVTT\UP[`ZHMLHUK[OL`^PSSYPZL[V[OLVJJHZPVU

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS 
Conclusion
9LTLTILY[OLI\ZPULZZHULJKV[LMYVT[OLPU[YVK\J[PVU&0[»ZUV^LSIV^KLLWPU[OLYLHSTVM-HJLIVVR
7HNLZ0[OHZ\Z\YWLK[OL\UVMMPJPHSIYHUKJ\Z[VKPHUHUK[HRLUJVU[YVSVMJVU[LU[[OH[PZYVSSLKV\[
MVY[OL-HJLIVVR^VYSK[VZLL:\YL[OLI\ZPULZZPZZ[PSSMY\Z[YH[LK[OH[P[JHU»[WYL]LU[ULNH[P]P[`MYVT
YLHYPUNP[ZOLHKVUP[Z>HSSI\[P[ZOV\ZLPZPUVYKLY:V^OH[»ZUL_[&

;HRLUPUKP]PK\HSS`[OL[PWZHUKWVPU[LYZPUJS\KLK^P[OPU[OPZ>OP[L7HWLYHYL]HS\HISL[VVSZ[OH[^PSS
OLSWIYHUKZTHPU[HPUHOLHS[O`Z[YPUNVMPU[LYHJ[PVUZVU[OLPY-HJLIVVR7HNL/V^L]LYPUVYKLYMVY[OL
RUV^SLKNLJVU[HPULKOLYLPU[V[Y\S`ILLMMLJ[P]L^LULLK[V[HRLHZ[LWIHJRHUKSVVRH[[OPUNZMYVTH
OPNOLYSL]LS;OPZKVJ\TLU[PZZ\I[P[SLKº;OL+LMPUP[P]L.\PKL[V-HJLIVVR7\ISPZOPUNHUK4VKLYH[PVU»
0[»ZHWYL[[`SVM[`[P[SL¶I\[P[»ZMP[[PUN;OLU\TILYVUL[OPUN[OH[`V\ZOV\SK[HRLH^H`MYVT[OPZWHWLY
PZ!`V\JHUUVSVUNLYSVVRH[LHJOWPLJLVM\ZLYNLULYH[LKJVU[LU[PUHWPLJLTLHSMHZOPVU6ULJVT
TLU[JHUZW\YO\UKYLKZTVYLHUK[OL`HYLZPUNSLWPLJLZVMH[YLTLUKV\ZW\aaSL[OH[THRLZ\W`V\Y
-HJLIVVR>HSS

:L[HYVJRZVSPKZ[YH[LN`MVYJVTT\UPJH[PUNHUKYLZWVUKPUN[V`V\YMHUZ<ZLLHJOWVPU[LYPUJS\KLK
^P[OPU[OPZ>OP[L7HWLYHZHTPUPIH[[SLWSHUPUHT\JOSHYNLY^HY0M`V\OH]LHJVTT\UPJH[PVUHUKYL
ZWVUZLWSHUPUWSHJL`V\^PSSUV[ILZJYHTISPUN[VYLHJ[[VHU`\ZLYNLULYH[LKTLZZHNPUN¶UVTH[[LY
OV^SHYNL[OLJYPZPZ9LTLTILYTVKLYH[PVUPZLX\HSWHY[Z]PNPSHUJLKPSPNLUJLHUKWY\KLUJL

(U`JVTTLU[Z&

7SLHZLQVPU\ZH[-HJLIVVRJVTI\KK`TLKPH;^P[[LYJVTI\KK`TLKPH^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTVYLTHPS
\ZH[PUMV'I\KK`TLKPHJVT

^^^I\KK`TLKPHJVTWHY[ULY'I\KK`TLKPHJVT )\KK`4LKPH0UJ7YVWYPL[HY`HUK*VUÄKLU[PHS