Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Nevagonnabslim 19:57 how does the EBacc fit with the government's commitment to Voc
EDand so won't achieve the new 'gold standard' EBacc? #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 19:58 Will the Eng Bacc divide Academic + Vocational Learners or provide
personalised pathways? #ukedchat
colport 20:01 Can we start by explaining the Eng Bacc for non-2nd'ary colleagues
please? #ukedchat What does the change mean?
#ukedchat for me, my students & daughter EBacc is restrictive to
Hero_project 20:02 options not indicative of academic excellence and undermines voc
courses
Govt have decided that certain subjects make up the EngBacc &
dailydenouement 20:02 schools now being judged against that as well as GCSE results
#ukedchat
@colport #ukedchat and explain for non England UK teachers too
carolinebreyley 20:02
please
#ukedchat it will not provide personalised learning pathways as
sharland 20:02 vocational courses will lose support as schools attempt to remain
relevant
Nevagonnabslim 20:02 Welcome the discussion is Will the EBacc divide learners or provide
personalised pathways #ukedchat
The English Baccalaureate will cover achievement in English,
Nevagonnabslim 20:03 mathematics, sciences, a language and a humanities subject.
#ukedchat
@dailydenouement So, are some subjects valued more than
colport 20:03
others? #ukedchat
colport 20:03 @carolinebreyley Good point :-) #ukedchat
#ukedchat "A big danger is that some disciplines will find
colport 20:04 themselves relegated to the "extra" curriculum elem… (cont)
http://deck.ly/~khS23
Nevagonnabslim 20:04 Are these the right subjects? #ukedchat
Page 1 of 42
Creativeedu 20:04 A*-C qualifications in English, Maths, Science, a Language and either
History or Geography = EBacc #UKEdChat
MattSL 20:04 #ukedchat new school ranking on the proportion of their pupils
achieving A*-C passes in five subject areas specified by ministers
#ukedchat EngBacc = English,Maths,Science,1 Language & 1
dailydenouement 20:04 Humanity. Only History, Geography or Ancient History count as
Humanity
RT @ClaireJoanne35: where do music, RE & drama fit in? #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:05
<they don't!
dailydenouement 20:05 Exactly. Two tier subjects. RT @colport: @dailydenouement So, are
some subjects valued more than others? #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:05 Why these subjects and not others? #ukedchat
dailydenouement 20:05 #ukedchat Other non-Bacc subjects will suffer as schools push
pupils into Bacc subjects for league table purposes.
ClaireJoanne35 20:05 where do music, RE & drama fit in? #ukedchat
ianpocock 20:06 @colport does this automatically mean a return to the two-tier
education system academic v vocational? #ukedchat
ICT is not part of the EBacc. Can this be right in this day and age?
Nevagonnabslim 20:06
#ukedchat
dailydenouement 20:06
Limiting for progression through to A Level very worrying #ukedchat
Page 2 of 42
#ukedchat talking 2 worried yr 8 who wants to be engineer but sch
MattSL 20:07 now has 7 mandatory GCSEs & he won't b able 2 select all the ones
he needs
BAFDiploma 20:07 #ukedchat How many option choice do students have in your
schools for GCSE. In mine it is 4 blocks.
Nevagonnabslim 20:07 Should primary school teachers not be more aware of the EBacc? Its
what they are sending kids to #ukedchat
dailydenouement 20:07 It's awful. RT @Nevagonnabslim: ICT is not part of the EBacc. Can
this be right in this day and age? #ukedchat
@ianpocock I admit I am knew to this subject, but it does sound like
colport 20:07
it! #ukedchat
mosquitomax 20:07 RT @Nevagonnabslim: ICT is not part of the EBacc. Can this be right
in this day and age? #ukedchat >> every job needs it!!!
Creativeedu 20:07 positive - extending the focus beyond english and maths. negative -
not extending it far enough? #UKEdChat
Dunfordjames 20:08 #ukedchat choice will be more guided for most, depending on
school attainment and targets. Forces Lang. And hums onto agenda
Nevagonnabslim 20:08 with obsesity rising is it right that PE teachers are being fired in
favour of subjects that meet the EBacc? #ukedchat
ClaireJoanne35 20:08
@Nevagonnabslim doesn't seem right. does it? #ukedchat
doc_gnome 20:09 @MattSL agree, this is the trouble with Eng Bacc - too restrictive.
Pushes pupils into subjects rather than need/desire. #ukedchat
RT @CyberSafeFamily: and what is the answer? ;) RT @svenhall: To
GlogsterEDU 20:09 Glog or to Blog that is the question???? #ukedchat #edchat
#edtech
presumably it will mean a rise in language learning? is that a good
Creativeedu 20:09
thing? #UKEdChat
@colport @MattSL being iconoclastic about it - is it a bad thing?
ianpocock 20:09 Should everyone study same subjects or does that miss talent?
#ukedchat
colport 20:09
Anyone within this #ukedchat forum support the plans? If so, why?
Easy on the primary teachers - many secondary teachers are still
TeacherTalks 20:10
working this one out #UKEdChat
doc_gnome 20:10 @BAFDiploma once the Eng Bacc subjects are taken into account
ours only really have one to choose from! #ukedchat
Page 3 of 42
Iris_Connect 20:10 RT @Nevagonnabslim: ICT is not part of the EBacc. Can this be right
in this day and age? #ukedchat <--- surely not, ridiculous really
dailydenouement 20:10 No! *Stamps Feet* And no again! RT @colport: Anyone within this
#ukedchat forum support the plans? If so, why?
Creativeedu 20:10 How similar is the EBacc to IB? I was at uni with a lot of IB grads
who were far more well rounded than me. #UKEdChat
Is it right for goverment to decide what subjects a student must
Nevagonnabslim 20:10
take? #ukedchat
@CreativeEdu languages for as long as possible can never be a bad
ianpocock 20:10 thing. Rest of Europe seem to keep learning them all way through
#ukedchat
Correct me if I'm wrong, but but what is the purpose of the EBacc?
tonycassidy 20:10
#ukedchat
I've just returned from Yr 9 Options eve - very few parents
DuncanTigerHero 20:10 mentioned EBacc. They still choose subjects on what interests
them. #ukedchat
RT @CreativeEdu RT @ClaireJoanne35: where do music, RE &
Reteach10 20:10 drama fit in? #ukedchat <they don't! <something fundamentally
wrong with that idea
Creativeedu 20:11 @ianpocock maybe but I wish I'd spent my time learning HTML or
.NET instead of French would have served me better...#UKEdChat
#ukedchat Assuming Maths, Eng + Sci and 4 other choices, if1 is
BAFDiploma 20:11 Geog/Hist and another MFL. Pupils still have 2 choices. Is this a
narrowing?
ClaireJoanne35 20:11 my daughter was quite flexible & so happy to be chosen for eBacc
at her school but I agree it is restrictive #ukedchat
#ukedchat are schools killing creativity? With EBacc they are!
Smichael920 20:12
@SirKenRobinson
Page 4 of 42
RT @Dunfordjames: #ukedchat it is mystifying, but look at it this
dailydenouement 20:12
way... Gove is trying to recreate his education for all, regardless of
need or ambition
@IRIS_Connect my daughter is doing eBacc but will still study ICT
ClaireJoanne35 20:12
#ukedchat
DuncanTigerHero 20:12 @Nevagonnabslim I think ICT should be integrated into all subjects -
in a perfect world. #ukedchat
Dunfordjames 20:12 #ukedchat it is mystifying, but look at it this way... Gove is trying to
recreate his education for all, regardless of need or ambition
Nevagonnabslim 20:12 Government believes schools should offer pupils broad range of
academic subjects & the EBacc promotes that #ukedchat
@Creativeedu would argue it decreases breadth rather than
doc_gnome 20:12 increasing it. Forces pupils into a narrow band of 'approved'
subjects. #ukedchat
mosquitomax 20:13 At my school the perception was that the choices had become
limited due to the "constraint" of the EBacc #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:13 I have 16 IB students and 5 GCSE students, clearly I feel that the IB
S's have more options to choose #ukedchat
familysimpson 20:13 @colport well i'm not sure but it sounds similar! parents voting with
feet when it restricts their child's options after school. #ukedchat
Page 5 of 42
dailydenouement 20:13 RT @Smichael920: #ukedchat are schools killing creativity? With
EBacc they are! @SirKenRobinson
tonycassidy 20:13 The bigger issue from my perspective is that we already have an
unfair curriculum hierarchy #ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim No, and I would encourage parents, students to
theokk 20:13
resist pressures #ukedchat
RT @colport: @ianpocock @MattSL We all have specialisms in
MattSL 20:13 different areas. These plans sound like narrowing the curriculum
#ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:13 so is that broad ? #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:14 What is Ebacc? #ukedchat
@CreativeEdu will encourage more students to choose a language
ClaireJoanne35 20:14
to study? #ukedchat
@theokk but theres been nothing much in the press why?
Nevagonnabslim 20:14
#ukedchat
Smichael920 20:14 @colport I think many primaries have moved too far & wouldn't
want to limit learning opportunities for pupils #ukedchat
pupils selecting a less desired subject to fit in with the eBacc
mosquitomax 20:14
#ukedchat
tonycassidy 20:14 Why take Geography (1 GCSE) when you can take another subject in
the same time for the equivalent of four #ukedchat
Page 6 of 42
RT @mosquitomax: At my school the perception was that the
Grevster73 20:14 choices had become limited due to the "constraint" of the EBacc
#ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:14 What about Voc Ed in this? Are we back to two tier schools and
segregation? Clever and stupid kids? #ukedchat
@TeacherTalks #ukedchat i don't think this government actually
familysimpson 20:14
believes in anything
Nevagonnabslim 20:15 @doc_gnome The goverment does even if it is latin which they see
more important than ICT? #ukedchat
RT @tonycassidy: Correct me if I'm wrong, but but what is the
itsmotherswork 20:16 purpose of the EBacc? #ukedchat <To make schools look bad
against new measure
tonycassidy 20:16 I'd welcome equivalent qualifications, each having equal worth,
with a free students choice #ukedchat
@Smichael920 But if curriculum review comes out with a tighter
colport 20:16 prescriptive curriculum, then primaries will have no option
#ukedchat
familysimpson 20:16 #ukedchat EBacc article "GOVERNMENT COMES UNDER FIRE FOR
EBACC SUBJECT CHOICE" http://is.gd/LWdNRX
@GillDeCosemo Would he have made those choices without #Ebacc
BAFDiploma 20:17
?#ukedchat
Page 7 of 42
tonycassidy 20:17 Does anyone have an Ebacc? #ukedchat
ukedchat 20:17 @bucharesttutor Please remember #
familysimpson 20:17 @colport what call? i can't think of a parent who would want to
restrict what their child experiences at school! #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:17 Personally see that IB S's have subjects like art, PE, humanities to
name a few new ones $ ukedchat
Remember that the Coalition EdBill is based on ideology not
Grevster73 20:17
evidence #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:17 I finished school 10 yrs ago and even then HAD to do a lang, a
humanity, eng, maths and 3 sciences #UKEdChat
@familysimpson I think of the middle classes who worry about their
colport 20:18 child achieving in SATs, getting into grammar schools, etc.
#ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:18 @ClaireJoanne35 thanks, surely EBacc is not covering all the main
subjects for the S's to Excel in life #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:18 @MattSL is that a good thing? Depends on what you consider are
the important outcomes re last week's #UKEdChat
@Nevagonnabslim You could make an argument that says they
ianpocock 20:18 some will not have been so successful without the option?
#ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim You could make an argument that says they
ianpocock 20:18 some will not have been so successful without the option?
#ukedchat
#ukedchat many orgs have worked to improve status of vocational
MattSL 20:18 qualifications & jobs. EBacc will put academia firmly in higher status
again
Page 8 of 42
RT @TeacherTalks @tonycassidy: I'd welcome equivalent
familysimpson 20:19
qualifications, each having equal worth, with a free students choice
#ukedchat <YES
#Ukedchat interesting to see how many schools have adopted a
Totallywired77 20:19 knee jerk reaction to EBac - have you seen the amount of MFL jobs
in the TES?
@Smichael920 I totally agree, and see the evidence everyday!
colport 20:19 #ukedchat Would academies be forced to follow new curriculum
though?
@tonycassidy I have the equivalent GCSEs yes. My school made me
Creativeedu 20:19
take them! #UKEdChat
Nevagonnabslim 20:19 Headteachers say the EBacc will lead to more exclusions and bad
behaviour. Do you believe this? #ukedchat
#ukedchat EBacc is not rounded but trad perhaps this removes the
Hero_project 20:19 need for BSF we can all stick to 50s classrooms to match the
curriculum
GillDeCosemo 20:20 @BAFDiploma He wouldn't have chosen French. I like that he has to
do a Lang. He'd have chosen the rest though. #ukedchat
jackieschneider 20:20 #ukedchat schools should be brave & offer what they think is best.
Forget league tables - build relationships with parents
Shaf_Hansraj 20:20 #ukedchat to push any education message you need passion and
enthusiasm. How is this possible if students forced into pathways
Page 9 of 42
ianpocock 20:20 @MattSL but perhaps the job of schools, teachers an policy makers
to make a better case for why it isn't better or worse? #ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim yes, students being restricted in their choices
tonycassidy 20:20
#ukedchat
@bucharesttutor definitely seems to have some important
ClaireJoanne35 20:20
subjects missing! #ukedchat
CliveBuckley 20:20 The Best Web 2.0 Applications For Education — 2010 Interesting
list! http://bit.ly/cjuWbc @Larryferlazzo #elearning #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:21 Personally even in Math, which I teach I see S's in IB are given 3
levels to choose while in GCSE, they are given 2 levels #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:21
@Reteach10 I was also forbidden from doing art ;-( #UKEdChat
BAFDiploma 20:21 #ukedchat Cards on the table, I believe the #Ebacc to be ill-
conceived and an unnecessary measure.
@colport @philallman1 interesting times ahead that's for sure!
Smichael920 20:21
#ukedchat
Grevster73 20:21 @Totallywired77 it's because the benchmark has changed and they
want to play the game - it's the gvnmt that pays the bills #ukedchat
would you be happy for EBacc schools and VocEd schools?
Nevagonnabslim 20:21
#ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:22
is it right for the goverment to choose subjects? #ukedchat
Why is RE not a Humanity for EBacc? #ukedchat We wrote to Gove:
dailydenouement 20:22 unfairly favours faith schools. But EBacc unfairly favours other
subjects
Page 10 of 42
doc_gnome 20:22 @Nevagonnabslim @MattSL even independent schools feeling the
pressure of the Eng Bacc. Parents look at league tables. #ukedchat
BAFDiploma 20:22 #ukedchat Ultimate conclusion is schools jsut offer Ebacc subjects
and devote more curriculum time. It is just another system to play.
@familysimpson those slide rules go for a lot on eBay these days!
mosquitomax 20:22
#ukedchat
kiarakiara 20:23 RT @CreativeEdu: I finished school 10 yrs ago and even then HAD to
do a lang, a humanity, eng, maths and 3 sciences #UKEdChat"
@CreativeEdu #ukedchat History + 'Information Age' = kids who can
mattbuxton10 20:23 find information, sort it, analyse it, form opinions, create
arguments???
Nevagonnabslim 20:23 will primary schools change their curriculum timetable to ensure
students meet engbacc subjects #ukedchat
BAFDiploma 20:23 @Nevagonnabslim @familysimpson Yes but those chisels and stone
tablets are still expensive! #ukedchat #flippantcomment
RT @Shaf_Hansraj: #ukedchat a rounded education of all subjects at
Grevster73 20:23 KS3 to enable choice later on in KS4 < but KS3 has been eroded to 2
yrs!
ColinGoffin 20:23 Curriculum should be driven by what is appropriate for students and
nothing else. This cannot be decided centrally. #ukedchat
@ClaireJoanne35 yes personally speaking IB gives more flexibility to
bucharesttutor 20:23 students. After all, "all work n play makes Jack a dull boy"
#ukedchat
RT @Nevagonnabslim: would you be happy for EBacc schools and
ICTEvangelist 20:23
VocEd schools? #ukedchat
@familysimpson surely will disadvantage students when trying to
ClaireJoanne35 20:23
find work #ukedchat
Page 11 of 42
Reteach10 20:23 #UKEdChat ebacc concerns solved if not as prescriptive but instead
suggestive of an approach to structuring gcse choice?
Creativeedu 20:23 ICT not included in EBacc surely just because Gove went to school
before ICT as a subject existed??? #UKEdChat
bucharesttutor 20:24 @CreativeEdu well this is indeed sad but at least in GCSE they have
ICT and ITGS in IB curriculum #ukedchat
@Totallywired77 will that continue when they fall down in the
Nevagonnabslim 20:24
league tables #ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim It depends on the outcome of the primary
colport 20:24
review, i suppose #ukedchat
@familysimpson knew there was an ulterior motive from Gov!
Smichael920 20:24
#ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:24
What's the difference between EBacc and IB? #UKEdChat
GillDeCosemo 20:24
@familysimpson only French & German at his school. #ukedchat
ianpocock 20:24
@ColinGoffin interesting - how do you best establish it? #ukedchat
@colport i don't doubt it! EBacc = giant inflatable political beach
familysimpson 20:24
ball of 21C education? #ukedchat
@tonycassidy hmm. Then it is unfair on students being entered for
miconm 20:24
them, isn't it? #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:25
@GillDeCosemo for how long ? its only the first year #ukedchat
#ukedchat realisation of aspiration comes from knowing how to &
Hero_project 20:25 being able to make informed choices, through experience &
inspiration
Page 12 of 42
BAFDiploma 20:25 @colport Because everyone is an expert on education as they went
to school once? #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:25 @mattbuxton10 I agree actually History GCSE was a very useful
subject. I used what I learnt more than English or Maths #UKEdChat
Son's school do not make students do EBacc, it's a choice.
GillDeCosemo 20:25
#ukedchat
@familysimpson @colport can I have that globe for geography?
tonycassidy 20:25
#ukedchat
Shaf_Hansraj 20:25 #ukedchat to quote a colleague "schools need to stop being results
whores" not about league tables but about learning and aspiration
AdiNotNow 20:25 @colport because its a dark art to most of the general public and
politicians need to be seen to be in control #ukedchat
Grevster73 20:26 @Totallywired77 will they change their position when this is the
main measure? I'd like to think schools will resist. #ukedchat
RT @ColinGoffin: Curriculum should be driven by what is
Totallywired77 20:26 appropriate for students and nothing else. This cannot be decided
centrally. #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:26
So Latin more important than Business or ICT or PE ? #ukedchat
@ianpocock By knowing your children, their needs and aspirations.
ColinGoffin 20:26 Will mean variation within and between schools but is essential
#ukedchat
Page 13 of 42
@ColinGoffin have wondered about whether a policy for say 5 core
ianpocock 20:26 subjects supplemented by locally relevant subjects would work
#ukedchat
are schools dropping lots of voc subjects to make room in the
Creativeedu 20:27
timetable for EBacc? #UKEdChat
tonycassidy 20:27 I think it's more important at 14 that students have a passion for
learning in subjects they have interest in #ukedchat
mosquitomax 20:27 All subjects are important. Blooms Tax shows the order of thinking,
which can be applied to all subjects #ukedchat do what u love
RT @Smichael920: @Nevagonnabslim a bit like grammar schools &
Nevagonnabslim 20:27
comprehensives!! #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:27 Personally speaking now that I know EBacc, I will add some subjects
like Art, History, PE, Drama etc. to make it more robust #ukedchat
@Grevster73 #ukedchat we've just solved the deficit for them....
familysimpson 20:27
oops.
@Grevster73 #ukedchat we've just solved the deficit for them....
familysimpson 20:27
oops.
Nevagonnabslim 20:28 what about the self esteem of students? how will they feel if not
included in EBacc group? #ukedchat
Page 14 of 42
@Nevagonnabslim and if they continue to be rated good by Ofsted
Totallywired77 20:28 then surely the league table won't matter??? Just a thought!
#Ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim That is very true! Though they are very keen on
GillDeCosemo 20:28 vocational subjects & Bridge so hopefully will keep these!
#ukedchat
@ianpocock Subjects as a starting point is too narrow. Ways of
ColinGoffin 20:28 learning and access to skills and attributes goes beyond subject
#ukedchat
Page 15 of 42
ColinGoffin 20:29 Subjects as a starting point is too narrow. Ways of learning and
access to skills and attributes goes beyond subject #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:29 @Nevagonnabslim Latin is for linguistic S's, surely History n PE could
serve good armour #ukedchat
MattSL 20:30 @Creativeedu some are (will be). Esp those most concerned with
league tables, such as those with notice to improve #UKEdChat
does anyone have research that says enjoying learning for its own
ianpocock 20:30 sake brings better outcomes that focusing on core subjects?
#ukedchat
Page 16 of 42
dailydenouement 20:30 Seeing yourself slide down a retrospectively measured league table
is great for staff morale. *sigh* #ukedchat
GillDeCosemo 20:31 @familysimpson I suspect these will come, langs dept been on
decline due poor uptake, this might kick start it! #ukedchat
colport 20:31 Half way through #ukedchat this week. What do teachers do with
proposed plans? Just lie back and accept?
familysimpson 20:31 @tonycassidy #ukedchat don't see why not but the globe is blank as
no-one knows where the countries are anymore (or the paint for it)
Nevagonnabslim 20:31 will the EBacc mean more problems for teachers that have to teach
students subjects that they dont want to learn? #ukedchat
ColinGoffin 20:32 @Nevagonnabslim Yes. And students will end up failing in these
instead of succeeding elsewhere. Everyone loses #ukedchat
RT @tonycassidy: I think it's more important at 14 that students
familysimpson 20:32 have a passion for learning in subjects they have interest in
#ukedchat <A*
tonycassidy 20:32 The EBacc may also have a huge impact on KS3 teaching, as
specialists are required at KS4... #ukedchat
Page 17 of 42
GillDeCosemo 20:32 @familysimpson rumour has it DT dept panicking. School a tech
college so DT was compulsory. Not now though! #ukedchat
theokk 20:32 RT @colport: Half way through #ukedchat this week. What do
teachers do with proposed plans? Just lie back and accept?
Grevster73 20:32 they have back tracked on the Forest sell-off, they might listen -
teachers do hold a lot of power #Ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:32
@bucharesttutor Choose being the word there though #ukedchat
colport 20:32
RT @ethinking: @colport start a freeschool? #ukedchat
familysimpson 20:32 #ukedchat twitterfall losing grip, but can anyone tell me if EBacc
worth more to university than current A levels etc?
bucharesttutor 20:33 @colport they cannot just lie back n accept, they must present their
ideas n get it heard if it means betterment of the future #ukedchat
Page 18 of 42
familysimpson 20:33 RT @MattSL: #ukedchat it seems differentiation, personalisation &
student centred learning means nothing to this DfE < well said!
#UKEdChat Did training on OFSTED criteria @ lunch. Can't have
ollyo2 20:33 outstanding without engaged pupils. Would conflict with Ebacc for
some.
Will academies / free schools need to report on the eBacc
mosquitomax 20:33
#ukedchat ?
Nevagonnabslim 20:33 @familysimpson noone knows yet but if you fail one of the subjects
in EBacc you fail the Ebacc! #ukedchat
@familysimpson It isn't A level based. Only GCSE level. So no it
BAFDiploma 20:33
won't be worth more. #ukedchat
A set of meaningless arbitrary goalposts replacing the previous ones
grahamwarren 20:33
#ukedchat
RT @briankotts How World of Warcraft helped a student kick his
engelskan 20:33 gaming addiction & pass school http://bit.ly/dJXiO0 #edtech
#ukedchat #edchat
@ClaireJoanne35 #ukedchat in england? sounds like rough times
familysimpson 20:34
ahead. what's your take on this?
Page 19 of 42
lets remember if you fail one of the subjects in the EBacc you fail all
Nevagonnabslim 20:34
of the EBacc #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:35 what would you propose instead of the EBacc - things to carry on as
they were or do you have a better idea? #UKEdChat
the answer is to convert to academy / start a free school, then
mosquitomax 20:35
ignore the eBacc imho #ukedchat
#ukedchat As a Narional Challenge school, if we could ever be
Arakwai 20:35 measured on our #EBacc results, we have to play the game or go
under :-(
bucharesttutor 20:35 @Nevagonnabslim I studied n India where i had a mixed bag of art,
music and sciences besides the usual PE n social sciences #ukedchat
#ukedchat I think may differentiate schs by those concerned with
MattSL 20:35 leagues & those with students. But may look like academic vs non-
academic
@CreativeEdu from those I've spoken to I think it's going to happen
Smichael920 20:35
#ukedchat
@colport is there a difference in opinion of classroom teacher and
doc_gnome 20:35 senior management. Get the feeling there is; makes it hard.
#ukedchat
Page 20 of 42
league tables have corrupted education, exams are no longer seen
tonycassidy 20:36 as a snapshot of progress at a specific point, but the end point
#ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:36 @familysimpson good! #ukedchat
theokk 20:36 @colport agree, teachers should have professional body that is in
touch and has clout, and I don't mean unions #ukedchat
@colport agree again, research based evidence, international Inc,
theokk 20:37
not cherry picked #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:37 Headteachers have put forward an alternative. what would be your
five subjects for a EBACC? #ukedchat
colport 20:37 #ukedchat "Two other words that are notably absent are "future"
and "childhood"" http://bit.ly/fUPcA4
ColinGoffin 20:37 @doc_gnome I'm senior manager but also a teacher! I want quality
learning experiences regardless of subject. #ukedchat
familysimpson 20:37
@GillDeCosemo #ukedchat true - HAS to if it's compulsory!
ronggordon 20:38 @colport Ironic as on paper Lib Dems had best education policies.
Shame they weren't worth paper written on #ukedchat
#Ukedchat Is the EBac an attempt by Gove to increase UK standings
Totallywired77 20:38
in the PISA table?
Page 21 of 42
philallman1 20:38 @colport that's because in gove's head future is past and childhood
is what happened to someone else. #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:38 @Creativeedu they are still exploring #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:38 @Creativeedu Definitely ask for more flexibility in the EBacc system
so that our S's really enter the future better equipped #ukedchat
#ukedchat I have EBacc subjects, my success however is down to
Hero_project 20:38 tenacity, transferable skills and good work ethic could have any 9
o'levels
Nevagonnabslim 20:38 @ColinGoffin but some heads have already changed option
pathways for the EBacc #ukedchat
@Reteach10 we dont know there has been no consultation and
Nevagonnabslim 20:39
press are very quiet #ukedchat
Page 22 of 42
@Nevagonnabslim They have and it's hard not to unless you are
ColinGoffin 20:39 successful or courageous but I say do what's right by the students
#ukedchat
colport 20:39 @theokk You're very agreeable this evening ;-) Gvt cherry picks
what policies they want to put into practice! #ukedchat
Reteach10 20:39 RT @Creativeedu Who is EBacc designed for? Do PARENTS like it?
#UKEdChat does gove even care?
ClaireJoanne35 20:39 @familysimpson yes. Local 2ndary school still has students study
ICT alongside EBacc - maybe needs amalgamating #ukedchat
Page 23 of 42
Reteach10 20:40 RT @theokk: @Nevagonnabslim pointless exercise (5 subjects) we
are living in an age of connected knowledge #ukedchat
rantingteacher 20:40 @Nevagonnabslim there are already core subjects and pupils don't
necessarily want to take them! #ukedchat
@colport Doctors are also being subject to massive changes
MattSL 20:40
#ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:40 Maybe Gove thinks forcing IN EBacc will cause less controversy than
specifically forcing OUT VocEd? but same result #UKEdChat
TeacherTalks 20:40 NICE provides guidance on health and clinical excellence - we need
a NIPE...National Institute for Pedagogical Excellence! #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:40 @CreativeEdu Had never heard if this kind of education ever existed
so I don't ever think if parents will ever approve of it #ukedchat
#ukedchat Let's take it back to the start for a mo; what skills &
mattbuxton10 20:40 knowledge do these kids need for their future? Start there, then
build up?
Creativeedu 20:41 @carterheadteach what are the ramifications of the EBacc for a
small school like yours? #UKEdChat
Voc Ed teachers are scared of losing their job. Are they right to be
Nevagonnabslim 20:41
scared? #ukedchat
ClaireJoanne35 20:41 @tj007 sounds like a good idea #ukedchat
MattSL 20:41 #ukedchat does anyone on here support the EBacc or know of any
education professional that does?
I'm a bit suspicious of trying to predict the future in terms of
tonycassidy 20:41
subjects and skills... #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:41 @Reteach10 No I think it's yet another striking e.g. of trying to
make all schools look like a grammar school... #UKEdChat
ColinGoffin 20:41 @doc_gnome I know many SM who are still absolutely governed by
a commitment to their students and quality learning. #ukedchat
philallman1 20:41
@CreativeEdu makes daily mail readers happy #ukedchat
Page 24 of 42
RT @Reteach10: RT @theokk: @Nevagonnabslim pointless exercise
Nevagonnabslim 20:41 (5 subjects) we are living in an age of connected knowledge
#ukedchat
tj007 20:41 At degree level there is a BA, BSc, BEng etc. - similar could be
applied (instead of EBacc), but not necessary this early... #ukedchat
TeacherToolkit 20:42 My school is facing up to 21 redundancies!!
Grevster73 20:42 RT @MattSL: #ukedchat does anyone on here support the EBacc or
know of any education professional that does? nope
colport 20:42 #ukedchat "As we scour the planet for examples of good curriculum
practice, let's also remember that there is a lot of it about in UK"
Nevagonnabslim 20:42 @MattSL NO #ukedchat
ColinGoffin 20:43 @MattSL Taught well and with the right students the combination is
fine. It's applying it to all where it falls down #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:43 @philallman1 *shudders* #UKEdChat
@colport except we're all teaching in a war zone apparently! #edbill
philallman1 20:43
debate #ukedchat
Page 25 of 42
not support of the EBacc, but in some schools Humanities and
tonycassidy 20:43 Languages have ceased to exist , students don't have these choices
#ukedchat
doc_gnome 20:43 Not that I know of! RT @MattSL: #ukedchat does anyone on here
support the EBacc or know of any education professional that does?
RT @Reteach10: its the lack of consultation that is so worrying. If
Nevagonnabslim 20:43 any lose touch with the c/rm the gov can't even see the c/rm!!
#ukedchat
By definition #ebacc devalues some subjects and distorts the ed
BAFDiploma 20:44 market place. It will aid the few to the detriment of the many.
#ukedchat
hrogerson 20:44 @Nevagonnabslim #ukedchat probably, and that will mean removal
of the subject from ks3 too if the staff member goes, e.g. Drama
RT @colport: @MattSL Agree. My point goes back to teachers and
Grevster73 20:44 teaching not really seen as a 'profession', especially by politicians
#ukedchat
@CarterHeadteach Have you adopted it yet for option choices?
Nevagonnabslim 20:44
#ukedchat
colport 20:44 @MattSL Agree. My point goes back to teachers and teaching not
really seen as a 'profession', especially by politicians #ukedchat
CarterHeadteach 20:44 @CreativeEdu #ukedchat #ebacc is rubbish for us. Options hard
enough and selection further complicates.
Page 26 of 42
Nevagonnabslim 20:44
so if you dont agree with the EBacc what are you doing? #ukedchat
familysimpson 20:45 @BAFDiploma #ukedchat so some schools could do EBacc then IB?
This makes no sense to me - extremely restrictive to future options.
@bucharesttutor thanks. Do you think this is a better option over
ClaireJoanne35 20:45
EBacc? #ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim What about if you went the whole hog and took
ianpocock 20:45 away all set curriculum. What do you think would happen?
#ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:45 @CarterHeadteach presumably it leaves you with very little ability
to teach alternative subjects? #UKEdChat
#ukedchat we need to educate students for jobs that haven't been
MattSL 20:45 created yet. Gove is educating students for jobs that don't exist
anymore
Reteach10 20:46 #ukedchat hang on if we go on skills for the future we'd have to
scrap subjects and just go to teaching office admin. No!
Page 27 of 42
Grevster73 20:46 unis r doing collaborative research b/w disciplines, degrees r more
mixed, so why make schools so restricted for choice? #Ukedchat
TeacherTalks 20:47 Be very wary of international comparisons from Gove - he has got
Alberta all wrong: http://bit.ly/dRXnYI #UKEdChat
tonycassidy 20:47 If you think the EBacc is interesting... just wait for the Core
Knowledge curriculum at Key Stage 3 #ukedchat
Page 28 of 42
Is anyone doing e.g. Spanish a year early to make room for more
Creativeedu 20:47
subjects in year 11? #UKEdChat
mosquitomax 20:47 RT @GillDeCosemo: You are right @BAFDiploma the #EBacc is only
a wrapper for qualifications, not a qual in itself. #ukedchat
@colport we're not scared of change, excepting changing back (to
chris_1974 20:47
19th century!) #ukedchat
GillDeCosemo 20:47 You are right @BAFDiploma the #EBacc is only a wrapper for
qualifications, not a qual in itself. #ukedchat
RT @colport: #ukedchat So what should we do now? >> ignore the
mosquitomax 20:47
eBacc imho
Creativeedu 20:48
@familysimpson There must be one.... #UKEdChat
Creativeedu 20:48 @familysimpson If you find the teacher who voted for the Tories
we'll ask him his opinion!!! #UKEdChat
ronggordon 20:48 So if I am unable to get a job who do I blame Uni, Secondary, Junior,
Infant or Play School? #Govefail #ukedchat
Page 29 of 42
RT @Arakwai: #ukedchat I have a yr9 tutor group & I hate that at
mosquitomax 20:48
14 they may have to choose between #EBacc and a subject that is
important to them.
Nevagonnabslim 20:48
@Creativeedu scared of losing student choice #ukedchat
familysimpson 20:48 @GillDeCosemo #ukedchat again, naive here with specialist colleges
- are there other options or is that just the local school?
hrogerson 20:48 @colport #ukedchat not scarf of change, just sick of it, let things
evolve with gentle nudges and expert advice.
doc_gnome 20:48 @colport I see little value in change for change's sake. Some would
argue there is too much and too frequent change. #ukedchat
ollyo2 20:49 @colport resistant if it goes backwards and fails to consider what's
in the front windscreen at all. #ukedchat
theokk 20:49 @dailydenouement I'll say it till I am blue in the face,the argument
about subject value fr learning is a red herring #ukedchat
@doc_gnome I have a great network. It's not a class teacher/SMT
ColinGoffin 20:49 divide. More of an attitudinal issue that can appear anywhere
#ukedchat
Page 30 of 42
grahamwarren 20:49
The only constant in education is change #ukedchat
colport 20:49
#ukedchat "Nothing will be changed by statute until 2013"
BAFDiploma 20:50 @colport You do not need laws when you publish the figures
retrospectively? It was underhanded and deceitful. #ukedchat
@TeacherTalks and Finland, and Singapore, and Hong Kong #cherry
theokk 20:50
picking #ukedchat
tonycassidy 20:50 @colport have to say after four National Curriculum changes I'm
not scared any more, I just laugh and carry on as normal #ukedchat
@Creativeedu @colport yes they are scared of mis-managed
Reteach10 20:50 change. But look at the crm today full of technology. teachers lv
chg #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:50 @colport No its already part of the league tables. Schools were
judged this year and they didnt even know #ukedchat
Page 31 of 42
well, ukedchat has throttled my tweet stream tonight! Emotive
chris_1974 20:51
issue then..
tonycassidy 20:51 We had a good plan for post 14 education, Tomlinson Report, IB
type qualificaiotn, vocational report- labour fudged it #ukedchat
ollyo2 20:51 #UKEdChat my diploma group, were certainly very vicious about
"this Mr Gove bloke" when their course got scrapped 6months in.
mattbuxton10 20:51 @MattSL #ukedchat Which will be more important then; to be able
to write an essay or analyse a piece of visual imagery?
@Nevagonnabslim seemed very unfair & a bit pointless really
ClaireJoanne35 20:51
#ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:51 @Shaf_Hansraj @teachertalks NIPE is a great idea but would have
been disbanded by Gove already if it did exist... #UKEdChat
#ukedchat @colport teachers are right be scared of change. Change
MattSL 20:51 has happened too much & too fast over last 20 years & everyones
sick of it
@ianpocock Gove says there will be no choice. students must go to
Nevagonnabslim 20:51
local school #ukedchat
RT @colport: @tonycassidy If labour had done their work on time,
Grevster73 20:52 would this gvt be trying to undo it anyway (Tomlinson/Rose etc.)
#ukedchat
Ducking out. Great to hear so much from such passionate people.
ColinGoffin 20:52 Now need to stop neglecting my wife! Work/life balance? Cheers!
#ukedchat
colport 20:52 @tonycassidy If labour had done their work on time, would this gvt
be trying to undo it anyway (Tomlinson/Rose etc.) #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:52 knowledge and facts more important in the EBacc than applying
even Applied Science wont count #ukedchat
hrogerson 20:53 #ukedchat it is the #EBacc going to divide the haves and have nots?
Or should we just teach kids all the same right to 16 and beyond?
Nevagonnabslim 20:53
@CarterHeadteach LOL Gies a Job. I will undoom ya #ukedchat
tonycassidy 20:53 @petemona lots of facts #ukedchat
colport 20:53
@Nevagonnabslim Who funded that report? #ukedchat
Page 32 of 42
I've heard horror stories, GCSEs starting year 8, year 10 students
tonycassidy 20:53 having to change courses- not in their interest but schools (?)
#ukedchat
Reteach10 20:53 #UKEDCHAT interesting on this just how separate politics and
education are. Thus has to change if we are to move on successfully
Nevagonnabslim 20:53 But why does a recent report say private schools will fall down
league tables with the EBacc? #ukedchat
CarterHeadteach 20:53
@Nevagonnabslim #ukedchat Oh dear... Doomed.
familysimpson 20:54 @Reteach10 #ukedchat ok, relevant for some but the world is not
full of office admins (or children who want to be office admins)
Page 33 of 42
@mattbuxton10 flexible, transferable skills & the ability to learn to
MattSL 20:54
learn #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 20:55 @Nevagonnabslim Guess we need to have subjects for the future
like Math, ICT, Econ etc #ukedchat
BAFDiploma 20:55 @CreativeEdu Flash #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:55 @CarterHeadteach LOL #ukedchat
Suze01 20:55 I worry that some students will feel *obliged* to follow EBacc route
at the expense of what they enjoy or are good at. #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:55 #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:55 @CarterHeadteach LOL #ukedchat
BAFDiploma 20:55 RT SirHumphreyApp "Minister, if you must do this damn silly thing,
don't do it in this damn silly way!" > Still pertinent! #ukedchat
ClaireJoanne35 20:55
@CreativeEdu probably be something else next year!! #ukedchat
Page 34 of 42
RT @tonycassidy: I've heard horror stories, GCSEs starting year 8,
dailydenouement 20:56
year 10 students having to change courses- not in their interest but
schools (?) #ukedchat
Creativeedu 20:56 @familysimpson LOL #UKEdChat
#UKEdChat in favour of encouraging higher expectations (even for
ollyo2 20:56 challenging pupils) but not forcing unwanted subjects on them.
Ebacc.
Totallywired77 20:57 #Ukedchat Remember Gove might be able to tell us what to teach,
but he will never be able to tell us how to teach
CarterHeadteach 20:57 #ukedchat have not heard enough from NAHT/ASCL re: Ebacc.
#disappointed Or have I not looked hard enough?
Creativeedu 20:57 @familysimpson to be fair I voted Lib Dem which as it turns out was
just as bad #LittleDidIKnow #UKEdChat
Nevagonnabslim 20:57 lots of emotions about the EBacc. Lots of talk in the staffrooms.
Why nothing in the press #ukedchat
Page 35 of 42
@Nevagonnabslim we're not changing our guided choices. MFL
chris_1974 20:57
compuls anyway(Lang coll), but if they don't choose hist / geog,
fine. #ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 20:58 @chris_1974 even if you come bottom of the leagues when 5 a -c
goes and your left with the EBacc? #ukedchat
#ukedchat Guy Caxton says "politicians are between irrelevant and
MattSL 20:58 irritating". Not sure I agree, but suggests he thinks most will ignore
it
mosquitomax 20:59 good point @theokk we teach each and every pupil in front of us,
not politician #Gove #ukedchat
CarterHeadteach 20:59 @MattSL #ukedchat good point.
tonycassidy 20:59 If students do follow the Ebacc, then take the traditional A-levels,
they won't be able to afford higher education anyway #ukedchat
@BAFDiploma:Errr, could bias be a reason for the lack of press
Nevagonnabslim 20:59 coverage? Also Nothing in Express as Princess Di not involved
#ukedchat
@Nevagonnabslim well, it's not my decision (fully, anyhow), but so
chris_1974 20:59
far. #ukedchat
@familysimpson getting Tech status benefitted feeder primaries
GillDeCosemo 20:59 with DT & ICT help. New head & curric being revamped &
broadened. #ukedchat
jennitonic80 20:59 #UKEdChat how much of all this change is to push more people into
free schools system?? Wash their hands of us?? Leave us to it??
Page 36 of 42
GillDeCosemo 21:00 @familysimpson Hopefully #EBacc won't stifle her curric reforms &
schools pledge to vocational subjects!! #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 21:00 RT @Nevagonnabslim: NO #ukedchat
theokk 21:00 If you get a chance watch "Our live Experiment is worth more than
3,000 Textbooks" http://is.gd/s2d0fk #ukedchat #Iwasthere
Nevagonnabslim 21:00 NO #ukedchat
bucharesttutor 21:00 Math, ICT, Economics, PE/Drama, English, Music/Dance are most
relevant subject for S's today #ukedchat
@cherylren It feels like I've been doing that for the last 20 years
ronggordon 21:00
#ukedchat
hrogerson 21:00 #ukedchat trying to be positive: what if he gave out the certificate,
but didn't put it in league tables, making #EBacc a personal choice
jackieschneider 21:01
#UKEdChat - will cooking in sec schools be dropped?
NOOOOO! #ukedchat @nevagonnabeslim thanks for facilitating
Hero_project 21:01
enjoyed it!
@Totallywired77 @Nevagonnabslim I really hope that was sarcasm!
BAFDiploma 21:01
#ukedchat
RT @Nevagonnabslim NO #ukedchat No No No (re teacher... always
Reteach10 21:01
clearly going to be against)
Page 37 of 42
theokk 21:01 @Totallywired77 yes agree - but we need to map it out - not
everyones interest can equal? #ukedchat
EBacc puts ofsted in an interesting position- curriculum rated
tonycassidy 21:01 outstanding, meeting the needs of their students, now not?
#ukedchat
mushychelle 21:01 @Nevagonnabslim no! #ukedchat
RT @tonycassidy: I think it's more important at 14 that students
itsmotherswork 21:01 have a passion for learning in subjects they have interest in
#ukedchat
BAFDiploma 21:01 @theokk Who are schools serving? Should be Pupils. Think for some
it's League tables though. #ukedchat
Totallywired77 21:01 @Nevagonnabslim #Ukedchat you don't need an ICT lesson to teach
ICT it can be embedded in EVERY subject
@Nevagonnabslim NO NO NO NO NO #ukedchat Can I vote 5
hrogerson 21:01
times!
petemona 21:01 @theokk to me that's an easy one the interest we should have are
the kids - prob is the govt dont see that #ukedchat
Page 38 of 42
Creativeedu 21:02 Thanks @Nevagonnabslim for hosting a really interesting
#UKEdChat shame we can't fix it! #UKEdChat
RT @Nevagonnabslim: Thank you to all who contributed, I have
CarterHeadteach 21:02 really enjoyed this discussion. Now off to start a revolution!
#ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 21:02 Thank you to all who contributed, I have really enjoyed this
discussion. Now off to start a revolution! #ukedchat
Page 39 of 42
I've contacted Tesco about sponsoring a free 'value range 'school,
tonycassidy 21:03 you're all welcome to come and work for me- we'll do the TESbac
#ukedchat
Nevagonnabslim 21:03 @jackieschneider not part of the EBacc but not dropped. But less
importance if EBacc stays #ukedchat
@MattSL: @hrogerson well it should be personal choice, but as it
doc_gnome 21:04 WILL be in league tables many schs will take choice away #ukedchat
> agreed
Page 40 of 42
cherylren 21:05 @ronggordon Yes. Perhaps one day we'll all just refuse to jump
through any more hoops #ukedchat - Really, really free schools : )
Nevagonnabslim 21:06 Try again. Gove would be terrified to meet a teacher he wasnt
paying to speak for him. Even in the virtual world. #ukedchat
#ukedchat wow what a fascinating discussion! thanks
familysimpson 21:06
@Nevagonnabslim for hosting!
Creativeedu 21:06
@Shaf_Hansraj @teachertalks I'm in! Let's start NIPE! #UKEdChat
Totallywired77 21:06 @tonycassidy every little helps #ukedchat
todayilike 21:08 RT @ukedchat: Please join @janwebb21 next week at 8pm for
#ukedchat The poll will be released shortly.
Nevagonnabslim 21:08
Can I just summarise by saying. NOone likes it ! #ukedchat
Page 41 of 42
RT @squiggle7: one last push for Teachmeet Midlands this
familysimpson 21:08
Saturday, lots of great presentations planned & fab prizes
http://bit.ly/tmm11 #tmm11 #ukedchat
RT @Creativeedu: @Shaf_Hansraj @teachertalks I'm in! Let's start
Reteach10 21:08
NIPE! #UKEdChat
familysimpson 21:08
@tonycassidy #ukedchat surely the CASbac? #chipandpin
mosquitomax 21:08 @Nevagonnabslim Thanks for a great #ukedchat this eve. Not sure
Gove would know how to get online...
TeacherTalks 21:09 In case you #ukedchat haven't had the pleasure, here's my poem
for Michael Gove: http://wp.me/pVuKt-4V Please RT
Page 42 of 42