Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Numéro 6 (2010)
Horizons
...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Sara Di Gregorio
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of
wall paintings
Influence of the thermohygrometric parameters and
the presence of saline contamination on the efficacy
of the treatment
...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Avertissement
Le contenu de ce site relève de la législation française sur la propriété intellectuelle et est la propriété exclusive de
l'éditeur.
Les œuvres figurant sur ce site peuvent être consultées et reproduites sur un support papier ou numérique sous
réserve qu'elles soient strictement réservées à un usage soit personnel, soit scientifique ou pédagogique excluant
toute exploitation commerciale. La reproduction devra obligatoirement mentionner l'éditeur, le nom de la revue,
l'auteur et la référence du document.
Toute autre reproduction est interdite sauf accord préalable de l'éditeur, en dehors des cas prévus par la législation
en vigueur en France.
Revues.org est un portail de revues en sciences humaines et sociales développé par le Cléo, Centre pour l'édition
électronique ouverte (CNRS, EHESS, UP, UAPV).
...............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Référence électronique
Sara Di Gregorio, « Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings », CeROArt [En ligne], 6 | 2010, mis en
ligne le 17 novembre 2010. URL : http://ceroart.revues.org/index1716.html
DOI : en cours d'attribution
Sara Di Gregorio
Introduction
1 The presence of water is one of the main causes that influence the degradation of porous
structures, such as murals, together with all the preparatory layers associated with them. The
water has a very important role in the channeling, solubilization and crystallization of salts,
because of its mobility in the porous system. The mechanisms which engage have a strong
dependence on temperature and humidity conditions and are determined by phenomena of
infiltration or capillary rise within the walls, condensation and percolation in the paint surface.
2 Nanorestore® - based on the mechanisms of nanolime dispersion in isopropyl alcohol1-
represents an innovative solution for the consolidation of wall paintings. The treatment can
restore some of the material lost due to degradation, replacing it with a substance identical
to the binding medium of the artifact; therefore this treatment is entirely compatible with the
mural paint.
3 If, for example, the wall painting has problems of decohesion and does not have sufficient
resistance to withstand cleaning, the consolidating material needs to fulfill the role of
pre-consolidating. It is important to understand, therefore, whether the material used for
consolidation has good results even in a system not yet stabilized. In particular, questions
can be raised in cases of decohesion, whether the consolidating material does not exert an
inhibitory effect in conditions of high salt contamination.
4 When pre-consolidation tests were performed on a study site used during the course of
Master of Conservation and Restoration SUPSI, it was observed that in a situation of high
concentration of nitrate salts on the surface, the use of Nanorestore® gave very positive
responses. It is assumed, therefore, that the presence of hygroscopic salts could affect the
kinetics of crystallization of calcium carbonate formed from hydroxide, slowing the process
of carbonation, giving the finished product the best characteristics.
5 To test this hypothesis, we tried to reproduce similar situations in the laboratory, providing
a standard system to work on. Samples were made to simulate a state of crumbling paint;
they were contaminated with different salt solutions and consolidated with Nanorestore ®.
Additionally, a series of specimens were not treated in order to have materials allowing a
comparison between the treated systems and the untreated samples.
6 Given the results obtained in the laboratory, we subsequently sought to verify the results on
real cases. Surface heterogeneity and the impossibility of obtaining a significant amount of
specimen material because of the destructive nature of the sampling was probably the reason
for not achieving comparable results in situ with proven laboratory research.
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 3
7 The analytical phases of this study were carried out in the laboratories of the consortium CSGI2,
where the product Nanorestore® was developed.
8 Standard system preparation
9 In order to study the influences determined by the different temperature and humidity
conditions and the presence of salts on the consolidation operated by Nanorestore®, a standard
model to work on was prepared on the base of previous experience. The system was designed
with the aim to reproduce the conditions of a mural painting that is crumbling.
10 To obtain a system of crumbling samples3, mortars4 were prepared by increasing the volume
of aggregate5 in comparison to the usual proportions and a considerable amount of water was
added to the mix. The layers of plaster were not compacted with manually to facilitate drying
of the mortar and ensure faster carbonation. A layer of burnt umber paint6 was applied to the
dry plaster two days after application of the plaster.
11 After 45 days, a waterproof coating7 was applied on all sides of the samples , except on the
painted surface and some of the surfaces contaminated saline solutions.
12 As shown in (ill. 1), five sets of samples contaminated with salts8.
13 We used salt solutions selected from those most commonly found in walls and characterized
by relative humidity values of medium-high equilibrium (75-80%): sodium nitrate and sodium
chloride. In addition to these single salt solutions, we set up a mixture of the two salts with
the addition of selected bi-hydrate calcium sulfate (gypsum), which is mainly responsible for
the degradation of salt-contaminated murals.
Fig. 1 Overview of the types of samples studied
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 4
16 The consolidation was performed about 100 days after the completion of the samples.
Nanorestore® diluted in isopropyl alcohol11 in a 1:2 ratio was applied with a brush. In total,
the specimens absorbed about 3 ml of suspension, with an average weight gain of 65 grams per
sample. The process of carbonation of calcium hydroxide nanoparticles was followed under
two different conditions of temperature and humidity: a series of samples was subjected to a
relative humidity (RH) of 50%, and another series to a RH of 85%. Thus, the consolidation
process took place in different conditions: those when deliquescence of hygroscopic salts
occurred and those when salts did not exhibit deliquescence. The specimens treated in this
manner were kept in constant temperature and humidity conditions for 45 days according to
the values shown in (ill. 1).
Results
17 To ensure reproducibility, three different samples from each system under consideration were
subjected to a series of laboratory tests. The following aspects were measured:
• capillary rise12;
• vapor permeability13;
• contact angle14;
• surface resistance to scotch tape test
18 In addition the study of surface morphology of the samples by electron microscopy SEM was
conducted in order to make comparisons in behavior among different types of samples due to
the effect of surface consolidation by Nanorestore®.
19 The extent of absorption of water by capillary action was performed on the same sample before
the "salting" treatment and later, after treatment with Nanorestore®. The extent of absorption
is related to capillary porosity of the material. The more porous it is, the more water it will
rapidly absorb. The continued absorption in a porous system involves filling the entire system
according to kinetics related to the size and distribution of pores, which then influence the
phenomenon. The impregnation of the porous structure by capillary pore water occurs first
in larger pores, initially as a sort of coating of the interior walls, and finally completly filling
them. The rate of absorption decreases with time and reaches an equilibrium value where
the amount of water that impregnates the material is matched by gravity and evaporation,
determining the values of capillary absorption, until achieving an asymptote value. The curves
that are obtained in these cases have an exponential trend15. The experimental data shown in
ill. 2 express the amount of water absorbed by the sample before and after treatment with
Nanorestore® and was collected until the asymptotic value was reached.
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 5
Comparison of capillary absorption curves of samples contaminated with sodium nitrate before and after consolidation,
maintained at a relative humidity of 85%.
Credits : S.di Gregorio
20 The final results are expressed in terms of a capillary absorption coefficient CA16. They were
derived from measurements of the curves of the development of capillary water absorption
and from values of the capillary absorption coefficient. The curves on all analyzed samples
pointed to an apparent slowing of water absorption by capillarity and a reduction in the amount
of liquid absorbed by the samples after treatment with Nanorestore®.
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 6
Before and after treatment with Nanorestore ®, maintained at a relative humidity of 85%
Credits : S.di Gregorio
21 Analyzing the trend of the curves for the different types of samples before and after
consolidation with Nanorestore® (ill. 3), it was found that the water absorbed by the specimens
after treatment was reduced by about 1-2 grams ( about 15-20% less) and that the asymptote of
the curves was achieved about 15-20 minutes later than the curves obtained before treatment.
This suggests that the surface re-cohesion happened and changed the surface porosity of the
specimens.
Fig. 4 Highlighted, average changes in the slope
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 7
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 8
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 9
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 10
Surface morphology observed at 1200 magnification. Uncontaminated sample not consolidated with Nanorestore®.
Credit : S.di Gregorio
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 11
Surface morphology observed at 1200 magnification. Uncontaminated sample consolidated with Nanorestore® (50%
RH)
Credits : S.di Gregorio
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 12
Surface morphology observed at 1200 magnification. Uncontaminated sample consolidated with Nanorestore® (85%
RH)
Credits : S.di Gregorio
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 13
Morphology of surfaces observed at 1200 magnification. Sample contaminated with sodium nitrate and consolidated
with Nanorestore® (85% RH)
Credits : S.di Gregorio
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 14
Surface morphology observed at 1200 magnification. Sample contaminated with sodium chloride and consolidated
with Nanorestore® (85% RH)
Credits : S.di Gregorio
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 15
Surface morphology observed at 1200 magnification. Sample contaminated with mixtures of salts and consolidated
with Nanorestore® (85% RH)
Credits : S.di Gregorio
36 When images of uncontaminated samples are compared, we can find after consolidation (ill.
8) a substantial "filling" of the gaps between the grains with a certain strengthening effect
that should be attributed to the carbonation of calcium nanoparticles on the surface .The
strengthening effect seems to be greater in conditions of relative humidity of 85% (ill. 9); in
fact, the surface shows a greater continuity in the paint layer. This result was found regardless
of temperature and humidity conditions in the two samples contaminated with sodium nitrate
(ill. 10). A similar result was not observed on the samples previously contaminated by sodium
chloride (ill. 11). The effect is even less evident for the samples "salted" by mixtures (ill. 12)
containing sulfate salts.
37 Comparing all the images, we can state that, in general, the values of relative humidity of 85%
(being kept constant during the process of the Nanorestore® reaction) lead to carbonation of
nanoparticles, which produces a more compact layer of paint because of the neoformation of
calcium carbonate.
38 The results of adhesion tests performed by the Scotch tape test did not permit to characterise the
treatment regarding the cohesion of the paint film. This is due to the fact that such specimens
were not suitable for sensitivity testing.
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 16
it was conjectured that the value of solubility of calcium sulfate, very close to that of calcium
hydroxide, might lead to an exchange reaction between the salt and the Nanorestore® product.
40 It was decided for that purpose to select 6 samples among those already prepared in the
laboratory with a 5% weight of salt in the sample. They were contaminated by a saturated
solution of calcium sulfate and were consolidated with a dispersion17 of Nanorestore® that was
diluted in isopropyl alcohol18 and mixed with a dispersion of strontium nanoparticles19. These
nanoparticles are engaged in an exchange reaction with calcium sulfate, thereby permitting
calcium nanoparticles to lead to consolidation without any other interference.
41 After consolidation, the specimens were kept in an environment of 85% RH and 20° C for
about 45 days.
42 The samples have been studied at the end of the consolidation process by analyzing capillary
absorption, measurement of the angle contact and vapor permeability. The results actually
show a positive response to the consolidation with Nanorestore®, due to the action of
strontium nanoparticles on the exchange reaction with the bi-hydrate calcium sulfate.
43 If the obtained values are compared with those of previously analyzed samples, one may
highlight a response to consolidation similar to that found on the untreated samples, always
considering the margin of experimental error. One can then associate such a result to what has
been achieved in a situation that is not influenced by salts.
Conclusions
44 The research shows that the influence of salts in porous materials results in some inhibition
in the consolidation process with the exception of hygroscopic salts, when the consolidation
takes place in a high relative humidity. Some doubts exist regarding the behaviour of sodium
chloride, due to discrepancies between the results of different analysis. This positive behavior
of salts on consolidation can be explained by the fact that, under conditions of high relative
humidity, the hygroscopic salts that contaminate specimens deliquesce, subsequently causing
a high moisture content not only on the surface (as in the untreated samples) but in the internal
system. One can speculate whether this affects the stage of carbonation to the extent that
the process turns to be slow enough to ensure the formation of a very regular and compact
crystalline structure of calcium carbonate, thereby improving the quality of consolidation. This
process would lead to benefits that would counterbalance problems related to the presence of
salts as well as, in some cases, it would probably provide an advantage in the kinetic process
of consolidation.
45 The problems affecting the effectiveness of consolidation, resulting from the presence of
mixtures of salts, have to be attributed to bi-hydrate calcium sulfate salt. The solubility values
for calcium hydroxide and calcium sulfate are so close20that one can assume ion exchange
reactions take place as well as subsequent co-precipitation, which would remove the calcium
hydroxide from the process of carbonation.
46 A solution to this problem was given by the use of alcoholic dispersions of strontium
hydroxide. This, being more reactive to the bi-hydrate calcium sulfate than the calcium
hydroxide, allows Nanorestore® to perform consolidation without the process being affected
by plaster.
47 These data show that Nanorestore® treatment on murals that are affected by the presence
of hygroscopic salts has no contraindications in conditions when relative humidity is above
85%. The water that is absorbed by condensation of the salt species seems to have a positive
influence on the process of carbonation of the involved particles. In the case of plaster, the
product Nanorestore® shows a lower efficiency, and then a more consistent application in
terms of quantity of material or of a support of alcoholic dispersion of strontium hydroxide
is necessary.
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 17
Bibliographie
AMBROSI, M., DEI, L., GIORGI, R., NETO, C., BAGLIONI, P. (2001). « Colloidal particles of Ca(OH)
2
: properties
and application to restoration of frescoes », in Langmuir 17, p.4251-4255.
ARNOLD, A., ZEHNDER, K. (1991). “Monitoring Wall Paintings Affected by Soluble Salts” in The
conservation of wall paintings. Proceedings of the symposium organized by the Courtauld Institute of
Art and the Getty Conservation Institute, London, July 13-16, 1987. Los Angeles, Sharon Cather Editor,
p.103-135.
ARNOLD, A., ZEHNDER, K. (1989). « Crystal growth in salt efflorescence », in Journal of Crystal Growth
n° 97, p.513-521.
BAGLIONI, P., VARGAS, R. C., CHELAZZI, D., COLÓN, G. M., DESPRAT, A., GIORGI, R. (2006). « The Maya site of
Calakmul: in situ preservation of wall paintings and limestone using nanotechnology » in Proceedings
of the IIC Congress “The Object in Context: Crossing Conservation Boundaries”, Munich, Edited by
David Saunders, Joyce H. Townsend and Sally Woodcock, p.162-169.
BAGLIONI, P., GIORGI, R., (2006) « Soft and Hard nanomaterials for restoration and conservation of
cultural héritage », in Soft Matter, A92, p. 293-303.
CILIBERTO, E., CONDORELLI, G. G., LA DELFA, S., VISCUSO E. (2008). « Nanoparticles of Sr(OH)2: synthesis
in homogeneous phase at low temperature and application for cultural heritage artefacts ». in Applied
Physics, p.137-141.
CROVERI, P., L. DEI, CASSAR, J. (2007). “Metodologie di consolidamento di superfici architettoniche
interessate da Sali solubili. Il caso di studio delle fortificazioni maltesi: valutazione dell’efficacia dei
trattamenti e criticità” in Il consolidamento degli apparati architettonici e decorativi. Bressanone,
Arcadia Ricerche, p.539-549.
DEI, L., SALVADORI, B.(2006). « Nanotechnology in cultural heritage conservation: nanometric slaked
lime saves architectonic and artistic surfaces from decay », in Journal of Cultural Heritage, n° 7,
p.110-115.
GAETANI, M. C., SANTAMARIA, U. (2007) “Studio sperimentale per la valutazione di prodotti protettivi
applicati in situ e definizioni di una metodologia”, In Facciate dipinte. Verifiche sui protettivi e
metodologie innovative di pulitura a Feltre e nel Veneto orientale. Saonara (Padova), Il prato, p.15-30.
Notes
1 Nanorestore® is a registered trademark CSGI protecting the technology developed there and protected
by the Italian Patent No. FI/96/A/000255, filed on 31/10/1996 by CSGI Consortium - University of
Florence.
2 Piero Baglioni, Luigi Dei, Rodorico Giorni Consorzio CSGI-Dipartimento di Chimica, Università
degli Studi di Firenze, Via della Lastruccia 3-13, 50019, Sesto Fiorentino.
3 Samples : dimensions 5cm x 5cm x 2cm, 0.5cm thick plaster and 1.5cm arriccio.
4 Slaked lime Candor Company Adriatic Timbers Ltd - S.S.16 Fasano Brindisi (BR) - Italy.
5 Geniobeton SA - 6532 Castione - Canton Ticino – Switzerland
6 Bresciani S.r.l. – via Breda 142 – 20126 Milano – Italy
7 Type road marking paint “Strassensignierfarbe” RUCO Company Rupf Eichstr & Co AG. 42-8152
Glattbrugg - Canton Zurich - Switzerland.
8 VWR International AG - Lerzenstrasse 16/18 - 8953 Dietikon – Canton Zurich – Switzerland.
9 2g/l
10 Arnold Andreas, Zehnder Konrad, Crystal growth in salt efflorescence, Journal of Crystal Growth,
1989, 97, 513-521.
11 CTS S.r.l. –Via Piave 20/22 - 36077 Altavilla Vicentina – Vicenza - Italy.
12 UNI EN 15801 :2010, Commissione Beni Culturali-Normal, UNI, Milano 2009.
13 UNI EN 15803 :2010, Commissione Beni Culturali-Normal, UNI, Milano 2009.
14 UNI EN 15802 :2010, Commissione Beni Culturali-Normal, UNI, Milano 2009.
CeROArt, 6 | 2010
Nanorestore® for the consolidation of wall paintings 18
15 The trend is described by an exponential equation y = a [1 - exp (-b • √ t)], where the term 'a' is
the maximum amount of liquid that is absorbed by capillary action, it is expressed in kg/m2(contact
surface) ; while 'b', expressed in units t-1/2, is a factor that considers the suction speed and the pore
volume filling, it corresponds to the coefficient of water related to height slope.
16 AC = A/ t*1/2, and expressed in g/(cm2 • s1/2), where A indicates the asymptotic value of water
amount absorbed by the sample, t* is the value in the abscissa of the intersection point between the line
through the asymptote and the tangent to the straight section of the curve (s1/2).
17 Nanorestore : 2 parts by volume, suspension of nanoparticles of Strontium : 1 part by volume,
isopropyl alcohol, 6 parts by volume.
18 CTS S.r.l. –Via Piave 20/22 - 36077 Altavilla Vicentina – Vicenza
19 Concentration 8gr /l
20 Solubility in water at 20 ° C : Ca(OH)2 = 1,7 g /l CaSO4.2H2O = 2,4 g /l
Sara Di Gregorio
Sara Di Gregorio (1979) performed art studies and graduates at Florence International University
of Art, on frescos restoration. She started working in the field and she engaged in a work at the
Opificio delle Pietre Dure (Florence). In 2008 she enrolled at the Master of Arts in Conservation and
Restoration at SUPSI.
Droits d'auteur
© Tous droits réservés
Résumé / Abstract
Cet article présente les résultats d’un projet de recherches sur l’effet de l’application du produit
Nanorestore®, dispersion de nanoparticules de chaux dans l’alcool isopropylique, pour la
consolidation des peintures murales ; il évalue l’influence des conditions environnementales
externes (UR et présence des sels en particulier) sur le processus de carbonatation.
Mots clés : consolidation, Nanorestore®, nanoparticules, sels, peintures murales
This paper presents the results of an investigation project on the use of Nanorestore®, a
dispersion of nanolime in isopropyl alcohol, used for the consolidation of wall paintings. The
influence of environmental conditions outside the wall (high humidity environments and high
presence of hygroscopic salts) on carbonation process was considered.
Keywords : consolidation, salts, wall paintings, nanoparticles, Nanorestore®
CeROArt, 6 | 2010