Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
www.e-conservationline.com
© All images are copyrighted to the owners of the respective works of art and to the authors of this article
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
In Italy, and particularly in the collection held by the Egyptian Museum of Turin, there are many
archaeological findings representing a challenge, in terms of conservation. Most of them were
unearthed during the archaeological excavation campaigns carried out in Egypt during the XIXth
and XXth century whilst some of them are donations received from private collections formerly
belonging to wealthy personality and noblemen of the XIXth century, when it was fashionable to
own Egyptian artefacts or even mummies. In many cases these collectors or their heirs donated
such items to the museums for patronage or when they were no longer willing to possess them.
These donations often constitute small collections, almost unknown, and held in Archaeological
and/or Civic Museums.
Until recently, archaeological findings of this kind were stored as and exhibited without the care
required for a museum object, submitting them to improper restoration involving irreversible
consequences, such as in case of mummies’ bandage removal and inappropriate use of
sarcophagi, and well as invasive and irreversible treatments.
The conservation of this type of archaeological material is difficult although quite often
reserving unexpected surprises and great satisfaction. In this essay we will focus on some
preservation and conservation issues we had to face when performing conservation activities on
the mummies and sarcophagi acquired by some museums from private collections.
Special attention will be drawn on environmental parameters, research and analysis,
transportation systems, compatibility of materials and philosophy of conservation.
Introduction
Throughout the nearly 60 years of experience Pa Sheri en Aset (Museo Archeologico di Genova
in conservation boasted by the three Pegli, Italy) were exposed in vertical position
generations of the Nicola family, several for many years and, after falling down, both
interventions were made on Egyptian artefacts the corpse and the container were seriously
formerly belonging to private collections and damaged and had to be restored to face the
then acquired by public Institutions. This emergency. The subsequent intervention
essay will focus on archaeological findings of conducted actually involved an "archaeological
such provenance nowadays held by the Italian research" into the finding, which brought to
Civic and/or Archaeological Museums. This the recomposition of the written text inside
choice is due to the fact that such findings are the sarcophagus and the reconstruction of the
particularly interesting under the conservation complex outfit of funerary objects. Another
point of view since they usually went through interesting case we had to deal with was the
many vicissitudes, a history which seems to be conservation project relating to the Egyptian
more complex than the one discovered when mummy and the relevant sarcophagus belonging
restoring the mummies and the funerary to the Museo Civico di Merano, Italy, involving
outfits belonging to great collections such as the recovery from the damages caused by a
those of the Egyptian Museum of Turin. In the mouse and the removal of a previous,
past, the mummy and the sarcophagus of inappropriate restoration. At the moment1,
e_conservation 23
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
we are also carrying out some analysis in order Pa Sheri en Aset’s mummy and sarcophagus
to plan the best possible conservation activity (Museo Archeologico di Genova Pegli, Italy)
required on a Roman age Egyptian mummy
belonging to the Museo Scarabelli, Imola, Thanks to the conservation project, started in
presenting problems which were apparently 1991 and ended in 1999, it has been possible
due to the putrefaction process. The operations to apprehend some interesting information on
performed during conservation activities the construction of these findings and to better
required for mummies are sometimes incorrectly understand their history. The sarcophagus
defined with the Italian term "restauro" belongs to the anthropoid bivalve type:
(which literally corresponds to "restoration", apparently, this technique was often used in
although the term is usually translated as the construction of coffins of mummies of the
"conservation" to correctly match the meaning same age of the one under review (images 1, 2).
in English) however, they are actually steered
towards the material preservation, with the The wooden moulded parts composing the
aim to ensure the possibility of further studies sarcophagus were not glued one to the other
by means of non-destructive analysis. but rather fixed by wooden pegs with circular
1 2
24 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
6 7 5
e_conservation 25
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
In this sarcophagus there wasn’t a canvas Furthermore, it became evident that the drawing
incorporated in the preparatory layer, which was sketched in red and then the colours were
has been found sometimes within coffins of laid with a particular order: red first then yellow,
the same age. During the conservation green, blue and finally black. The latter marks
activities, it has been possible to ascertain out the drawing in some particular areas. This
that the whole decoration was originally drawn colour sequence, detected looking at the super-
on the coffin keeping it open; such type of imposing layers of the hues, often recurs in the
decoration differs from the one executed on a decoration of Egyptian findings of this age. On
closed coffin, with the mummified body inside, the top, in correspondence with the areas over
the decorative motifs on the bed are the mummy’s chest and legs, the remains of a
independent from those on the top, in other semi-transparent amber-coloured substance,
words there is no continuity (image 8). similar to a varnish, were detected (image 9).
26 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
10
e_conservation 27
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
From the results of this preliminary exam we After temporarily fixing the lift-ups of the
were expecting to find out a serious damage, interior decoration still in place and carefully
which was actually ascertained after the opening collecting the fragments fallen on the bandages,
of the sarcophagus after having eliminated the the corpse was transferred on a specially
tissue paper sealing its two parts. The remains provided stretcher, carefully avoiding to alter
of the mummy, which were completely dis- the position of the mummy’s remains. In the
articulated, occupied the lower half of the area where the corpse was laying inside the
sarcophagus as a compact mass taking the shape bed, many fragments of the coffin’s interior
of the coffin’s interior. Many fragments of decoration were found, as well as a few faïence
painted plaster detached from the coffin and amulets and a multitude of annular and
felt on the corpse whilst many particles were cylinder shaped beads (nearly 13,000), which
deposited among the bandages (image 13). originally formed the magic armour (image 14).
14
28 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
15 16
17
In the past, the sarcophagus certainly was
exposed to a severe trauma, which caused the
breakage of a few parts of the wooden coffin
and of the corpse. Such distress did not
happen recently: in an old photograph of the
Museum, the sarcophagus is standing, secured
by a rope winded around the abdomen and
a wire around the throat in order to prevent
its falling down inside the glass cabinet
(images 18).
19
e_conservation 29
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
20 21 22
All the findings were selected and recorded. some of the original strength of the structure.
At this point it was possible to start restoring We did our best to limit the use of glues,
the wooden sarcophagus: the fragmentary which have been employed only for anchorage
parts found inside the case, including the and consolidation of the detached fragments
carved beard have been put back in place; the whilst no glue was used to fix the pegs or the
broken pegs have been replaced if not original set-up in order not to alter the
recoverable whilst the missing ones have original cabinet. Only in one case it was
been replaced and fitted into the original necessary to insert a stainless steel pin, in
housing. The new pegs have been made out the left side area of the coffin’s bed. Once
of robinia wood as the mechanical stress completed the coffin’s assembly it was possible
performance is similar to the original pegs’ to proceed with consolidation, fixing the
one and also because it is easily recognizable colours as well as the preparatory layer to
by laboratory analysis or under UV light as its the wooden support; such operation turned
fluorescence is peculiar. The assembly of all out to be quite difficult due to the presence
the parts back in place enabled to recover of wax, which had been applied in previous
restorations as a fixative (images 23, 24).
23 24
30 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
25 26 27
For this reason it was first necessary to execute (carried out by an Egyptologist2) and on the
an accurate cleaning of the decorated surfaces, preliminary study on the morphological and
even if this operation was particularly technical features of the fragments, including
difficult, considering the frailty and porosity of the plaster’s thickness, the distinguishing
the paint. The dust and organic substances marks of the wood fibres on the plaster and
deposited on the surface were removed first. the brushstrokes (images 25–27).
The old wax fixatives were then removed by
extraction using organic solvents applied on All the blue faïence elements, the beads, the
cellulose supports. At this point the lengthy tiny cylinders, the amulets and the sacred
work of repositioning the many detached scarab have been collected with care, in order
fragments of the coffin’s interior decoration, not to further damage the part of the mummy
almost tiny fragments, could start. Most of the still in the original anatomic position.
interior’s inscriptions have been recomposed Therefore, in some cases we preferred not to
relying on the work of text interpretation extract some beads fallen deeply into the still
swathing mummy’s legs and pelvis. Finding
28 29 the above mentioned recovered elements we
could understand that the mummy was
probably adorned by magic armour made of
extraordinarily tiny elements. As agreed with
the Principal and the Superintendent, these
elements have been used to recompose the
fragmentary magic armour taking as a model
some analogous findings of the same age
existing in various museums.
More particularly, the magic armour belonging
to the Musée du Louvre, Paris, is composed by
a series of round shaped beads which are
e_conservation 31
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
similar to the ones found on the Pa Sheri en construction scheme of the Egyptian magic
Aset mummy, even if the size of the faïence armours of that age (images 28, 29).
small cylinders is smaller and the shape of the Nevertheless, the result is merely a proposi-
sacred winged scarab is different. The tional and not a faithful reconstruction and is
embroidery recomposition has been executed easily reversible hence not precluding any
using linen threads, following the typical further development. The remains of the
mummy have been placed in anatomic
30 position, even without proceeding with the
complete reconstruction of the skeleton
(image 30).
32
32 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
36
e_conservation 33
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
34 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
We avoided as much as possible, using glue The mummy was inside the sarcophagus and
and wooden junctions, to join the various was overcrowd by cotton padding and wood
parts of the original framework6 as alien, not shavings.
compatible or distinct whilst the fractures During the operations carried out to find out a
within a single element have been normally suitable package to safely transport the mummy
bonded with vinyl glues (image 41). to the laboratory, the above mentioned material
was removed and we discovered that the
41 cotton stuffing came from the interior of a red
velvet pillow placed under the mummy during
the previous conservation intervention, dating
back to the beginning of the XXth century.
42
43
e_conservation 35
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
44 45
46
The pillow was removed from the original provided frame, moulded to include the shape
position by a mouse: the rodent also damaged of the mummy: this way it was possible to lift
the mummy to build up its nest with cotton the corpse without causing any damage, as
stuffing and bone fragments taken from the shown in the radiographies executed before
mummified body. The corpse of the mouse was and after transportation (images 46, 47).
also found under the sarcophagus. Once duly
packed, the remains were taken to the The mummy was "cleaned" using a micro
laboratory, where the mummy was withdrawn vacuum cleaner to remove the dust on the
from the bed containing it (images 42-45). surface whilst the ragged bandages and cloths
were fixed with stitches. The survived
To withdraw the mummified body from the bed cartonnage elements were removed and
we had to provide a harness in order to restored separately. The mummy’s safe
prevent the structural failure of the damaged withdrawal from the sarcophagus allowed us
parts of the corpse. The harness was made to better work on the sarcophagus, as
securing the corpse and the velvet pillow with illustrated previously.
some braids, using a Teflon needle. The However, there still was the problem of the
braids were then fixed to a specially mummy’s conservation: the mummy was
36 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
48 49 50
51 52
53
Then the lower part was covered with a nylon
sheet and a canvas, both fixed to the
structure though well adhering to the
mummy. The nylon sheet was placed to make
sure that the cast could be easily removed
whilst the canvas would strengthen the
plaster cast. Once obtained the shape of the
body from the cast it was finally possible to
realize the fibreglass shaped support required,
which was drilled in order to allow air
circulation. The holes are hidden by canvas
54
coverage (images 53, 54).
e_conservation 37
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
38 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
59 60
61 62
e_conservation 39
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
40 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
66
67
Near the feet and the head some bitty hair is to the pillow on which the corpse was lying
visible at the showcase’s bottom and over the down. We noted the leg fractures in the area
green cloth. Some white particles deriving centred around the knees, put back in
from the showcase’s interior peeling deposited anatomic position during the previous
and adhered to the skin, which was slightly conservation intervention. Inside the glass
deliquescent, sticky and soft (image 68). showcase there were four bottles containing,
according to the labels, calcium chloride and
The rupture of the right arm in the area synthetic camphor. Nearby such bottles the
centred around the omeral joint had been decorative cord has faded, uniformly and
repaired by means of a little greenish pin therefore independently from the content
and the arm was laid on a piece of wood. of the bottles whilst the original hue of the
The ercolation of the brownish-lucid substance most distant parts is in perfect conditions.
on the body caused the adhesion between of The radiographies revealed serious damages
the arm to the wood as well as of the corpse to the skeleton and the presence of pins
e_conservation 41
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
69
70
42 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
71 72
e_conservation 43
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
At the moment1, while waiting for the new the museum’s dimensions and fruition
showcase, the corpse is kept inside a Plexiglas capacity, the conditions in which the item is
cabinet with climate control (18-20°C; 50-55 exposed and finally the problems which
% Relative Humidity) (image 75). apparently determined the worsening of the
mummy’s conditions.
There are no items similar to the aforesaid For the new showcase we also took into
mummy, in terms of conservation parameters consideration some variables, such as
required, at the Archaeological Museum of durability of the materials to be used for the
Imola. In the case of mummies, it is showcase and their suitability for the
necessary to design a specific container for proposed solution. Last but not least we
the conservation of archaeological findings examined the context in which the showcase
requiring particular attention. It is actually should be fitted, under the aesthetical point
necessary to conciliate the complexity of view. Hence, the options polarized towards
deriving from conservation needs, design a showcase with aluminium framework, wood
costs, realization and museum management. lining and stratified glass including UV filter
Having analysed the conservation environment film. It will be possible to control the climate
adopted by different museums worldwide to parameters inside the glass showcase
preserve their mummies, we’ve been able to throughout the specially provided
find out different parameters, which do not instruments; in case of imbalance exceeding
depend exclusively on the climate area in the safety limits, it will be possible to
which each museum is located. In the course intervene for corrective action.
of this study we evaluated the museum A further campaign of analytical analysis9 on
environmental conditions, the microclimate the mummy turned out to be extremely
inside the museum and the macroclimate interesting as identifying some of the materials
outside, the number of visitors in relation to within the archaeological findings.
75
44 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
Of particular note was the X Ray-Fluorescence University and of the Anthrpological Museum
(XRF) portable instrument, which requires no of Turin, also relying on various analyses, still
sampling and is therefore a non-invasive and have to be completed. The results of the
non-destructive analysis. Throughout this aforesaid studies, together with other
technique, it was possible to obtain some more information relating to the preservation and
detailed information on gold, which turned out conservation of this particular mummy will
to be particularly pure (images 76, 77). be presented at the VI World Congress on
Mummy Studies, which will be held in
Chlorine and Potassium signals were often Lanzarote (Canary Islands) in February 20071.
detected as well, suggesting the use of chlorides
during embalming operations or afterwards, for Conclusions
conservation. At the moment further analysis
throughout gas chromatography has been These three cases are certainly significant
undertaken to identify the organic substances however we could narrate about many others,
of the brownish-lucid layer on the mummy’s revealing some embarrassing anecdotes. As an
surface and to verify the presence of henna or example, during the performance of conservation
other dyes used for hair colouring. activities on a mummy belonging to the Civic
Radiocarbon dating of the cloth found at the Museum of Asti11, we detected some damages
base of the skull will provide further details on which were probably imputable to the former
the age of the archaeological finding and will owners or to the museum conservators who
improve our knowledge on the Egyptian tried to withdraw the amulets from the corpse
embalming techniques. without the necessary care. Thanks to the X-
Some anthropological studies and analysis Rays analysis, the missing parts of broken
carried out by the academics10 of the amulets exposed in the Museum’s showcase
were found inside the mummy.
Hopefully, conservation may help us under-
standing as well as enhancing our knowledge
as no conservation intervention can leave
knowledge aside. In the near future, the
sarcophagus belonging to the Narni Museum
as well as a mummy - not belonging to this
institution – which has already been studied
by the academics of the University of Pisa
76
from the anthropological point of view, will be
the occasion for new studies steered towards
77
an in-depth knowledge of this archaeological
finding, considering that many coffins were
re-used in the past. Even in this case, an
interdisciplinary approach will be necessary
to obtain reliable scientific results12 while
coordination is essential to properly use and
elaborate the information available.
e_conservation 45
GIAN LUIGI NICOLA, MARCO NICOLA and ALESSANDRO NICOLA
1. The present article was presented at the EITEC 11. Compare in bibliography "Museo Archeologico di Asti:
Workshop (Encontro International de Tecnologias La collezione Egizia" pag. 43.
Aplicadas à Museologia, Conservacao e Restauro), 19-20
October 2006, Coimbra, Portugal. 12. Compare in bibliography "Sarcofagi della XXI dinastia
(CGT 10101-10122)"
2. Dr. Valeria Cortese - Torino.
Bibliography
3. Compare the construction technique of the fibreglass
tray described in relation to the case of the mummy 1. E. Leospo (ed.); Io vivrò per sempre – Storia di un
belonging to the Museo Civico di Merano. sacerdote dell’antico Egitto. Tormenta Editore, Genova
(1999)
4. The use of screws is certainly less stressful than
employing nails, which have to be inserted with a 2. G. L. Nicola; Restauro di opere restaurate:
hammer, involving a serious trauma for the layers of problematiche di intervento in due casi limite.
plaster and paint. The damage is particularly serious Proceedings of XIX International Conference "Science and
when single nails are used whilst the appliance of plates Cultural Heritage" Bressanone (Italy) 1-4 July 2003,
fixed by means of more than one fastener is less invasive. Arcadia Ricerche, Padova (2003)
5. When it was necessary to replace a missing peg into 3. E. Leospo (ed.); Museo Archeologico di Asti – La
the original housing, the new peg has been made out of collezione egizia. Ages Arti Grafiche, Torino (1986)
Robinia wood – a species which did not grow in ancient
Egypt – having similar mechanical stress performance to 4. G. Fornaciari, A. G. Naccarato, F. Mallegni; Autopsia per
the Nile Acacia and other hard woods usually employed una mummia. Archeologia Viva – Anno XIII n° 44 Marzo-
to make pegs. Furthermore, this type of wood is Aprile 1994 - Giunti (1994)
absolutely recognisable and therefore distinct for the
typical fluorescence to UV light. 5. A. Niwinski (ed.), G. L. Nicola, T. Radelet, G. Laquale;
Sarcofagi della XXI dinastia (CGT 10101-10122) Ministero
6. The original technique required the union of dei Beni e de delle Attività Culturali, Torino (2004)
structural elements throughout pegs which were
sometimes totally hidden in the wood thickness and 6. A. M. Donadoni Roveri; Passato e Futuro del Museo
Egizio di Torino. Allemandi & C., Torino (1989)
*Article submitted to EITEC 2006 7. G. L. Nicola (ed.); De Gypso et Coloribus. Celid, Torino (2002)
46 e_conservation
CONSERVATION OF MUMMIES AND SARCOPHAGI
In 1966, after completing his studies in visual Marco Nicola represents the third generation of
arts, Gian Luigi Nicola graduated at the a family of conservators. He took an honours
Accademia Albertina of Turin and was awarded degree (110/110) in chemistry at the
with professorship one year later. Since then University of Turin in 2003, presenting his
he’s been working with his father, not only in final dissertation on Protein-based media
the restoration of paintings but mainly identification and ageing in Art. In 2005 he
specialising in conservation of archaeological started his Science and Material Technology
findings of various materials such as wood, PhD, working on the bio-susceptibility of
stone, plaster, and clay (particularly from restored materials. On February 2005, with his
Egypt) requiring treatment in situ. In 1988 the friend Dr. Admir Masic, he founded ADAMANTIO
experience of all members of the Nicola family S.r.l., a start-up hosted by University of Turin
merged into the new-born NICOLA RESTAURI and CNR-ISTEC, carrying out specific projects
S.r.l. Gian Luigi Nicola is one of the Technical relating to conservation, including scientific
Directors in-charge, by virtue of the great analysis and researches focused on preservation
experience acquired working with the Egyptian and restoration of cultural heritage. As Board
Museum of Turin and a number of Italian Director and Conservation Scientist in charge
Archaeological Museums for which he restored of research and conservation projects, Marco
so many artefacts, including more than 200 Nicola’s professional experience in conservation
old Egyptian wooden sarcophagi, nearly 900 ranges over a variety of subjects, including
ceramic vases and handicrafts, stone artefacts and monuments of architectural and
monuments and almost all the statues of historical interest, archaeological sites, mural
pharaohs and gods held by the Egyptian paintings, oil and tempera paintings on canvas
Museum of Turin. In 1975 and 1983 by and wood panel, book and paper conservation,
appointment of the Egyptian Government, he as well as stuccoes, stone, wood, terracotta,
drew up two preparatory projects for the mosaics, enamels, metals and archaeological
conservation of the Tomb of Nefertari and, in findings such as mummies. He performed some
1992, he was invited by the Egyptian interesting analysis and research campaigns
Government, to participate to the focused on material identification, dating and
international conference on the Sphinx damage assessment thereby providing advice
conservation project, being one of the 16 on conservation strategies as well as analysis
members of the international team of experts driven to identify and eventually carry out the
working on this goal. Last but not least, since most appropriate treatments required. Since
1998, Gian Luigi Nicola is Professor of 2004, he has been cooperating with the family
conservation and training at the Academy of company, NICOLA RESTAURI S.r.l., as R&D
Fine Arts of Turin, for the BA and MA degree Manager in-charge of chemical and scientific
courses in Conservation Studies. analysis for conservation projects and activity.
e_conservation 47
No. 3, February 2008 LICENCE
Property
e-conservationline, Teodora Poiata
Executive Editor
Rui Bordalo
Noncommercial. You may not use this work for
Editors commercial purposes.
Teodora Poiata, Anca Nicolaescu
Collaborator:
Anca Dina
Graphic Design and Photography No Derivative Works. You may not alter, transform, or
Anca Poiata, Radu Matase build upon this work.
Execution
Teodora Poiata
Address
Rua Peixinho Júnior, nº 9, 1 D
2770-163 Paço de Arcos
Portugal
e_conservationline informs that the published information
www.e-conservationline.com is believed to be true and accurate but can not accept any
legal responsibility for any errors or omissions that may
All correspondence to: occur or make any warranty for the published material,
general@e-conservationline.com which is solely the responsability of their authors.