Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
In the Matter of
P.V.Ravi Chandran
Advocate,
5, Divya Krupa,
1st Street Extn.
Sri Krishna Nagar,
Maduravayal,
Chennai 600095 …..
Petitioner
Vs.
To
Kuen Lun and or beyond the Kuen Lun range. Some of the
maps of the Survey of India also did not depict the northern
range and the Mariom and Taghdumbash Pamir, i.e. the area
India was on the Kuen Lun range and beyond, the natural
since 1954.
& 56-59 )
viz. , Kugiar, Kilian, Sanju, Kiria, etc.- and that they had no
concern with what lay beyond the mountains” 2i.e. the area
whole of the Kara Kash valley was within the territory of the
noticed that there were a few fruit trees at this place which
1
Aksai Chin and Sino-Indian Conflict by John Lall at pages 56-57, 59, 95, Allied Publishers Private
Ltd, Nav Dehli.
2
For. Sec. F. October 1889, 182/197.
9
Johnson:
Khergiz robbers.”
and also later the Wazir of the Ladakh Wazarat, in July 1865
Lun range not withstanding the fact that even the said map
territory”.
when the Chinese crossed the Kuen Lun range and thus
place.” 5
In 1927, the Indian Government, according to a
6
Himalayan Frontiers by Dorothy Woodman. Pg.66, published inter alia by London Barrie and
Rockliff The Cresset Press 1969
15
China and Tibet dated the 5th July 1914 also depicts the
a red line. Inter alia, even the 1900 edition of the notorious
had for obvious reasons best known to them and with out
Khotan was only along the northern foothills of the Kuen Lun
A.D clearly shows the Kuen Lun range as the southern limits
Sãnjú Tagh in the Kuen Lun range. Another map from the
the Kuen Lun range and the Qara Qash and the Yurung Kash
with the Karakoram range and has its source from the Kuen
one of the northern ranges of the Kuen Lun since both the
17
the Qara Qash and the Yurung Kash were said to have their
these mountains were the same as the Ho lang kwei and the
range of the Kuen Lun range. A map from the Ta Ch’ing hui
the country along one of the northern ranges of the Kuen Lun
with both the Qara Qash and the Yurung Kash are depicted
Nehru, the then Prime Minister of India had, out of the blue
1954, gave orders that all the maps pertaining to the crucial
with any one” under the pretext of the so-called border talks
which are ab initio illegal and is null and Void and the whole
8
Freedom of Expression in Maps, A.G. Noorani Chapter 44, pg. 327, appeared in “Frontline”
Magazine, a Publication of The Hindu dated 8, May 1992. "Citizens' Rights, Judges and State
Accountability"
20
Kashmir like inter alia the Aksai Chin, Raskam, Shimshal and
The fact that the western border of Ladakh with Tibet was
along the Ridges wherein are situate the Mavang Kangri and
Tibetans encountered a
independent of Tibet.
vast area. But later, towards the end of the tenth centuary
the years 1610 -1640, and the second half towards the end
of the 17th century. The work has been translated into English
gon of his kingdom between his three sons, and then the
mchog-dkar-po; at the
Jawaharlal Nehru.
border of Kashmir with what was then the Soviet Union and
Kashmir”:
10
Constitution(Application to Jammu and Kashmir)Order , 1954;C.O.48,
section2(2)
11
Amrit bazaar Patrika, Calcutta 10.10.1961
27
forbids’ ”.12
12
The Constitution of Jammu and Kashmir by Justice Adarsh Sein Anand, 6th Edn. 2010 Published by Universal
Law Publishing Co. Pvt Ltd. C-FF-1A, Dilkhush Industrial Estate, Delhi 110033.
13
The Times of India, November 9, 1962
28
important”14.
13. The occasion and chance came for the said Mr. Nehru to
the Foreign Secretary. Both the Army Chief and the Foreign
the Chinese did not encroach into it, India could not make
any use of it. The boundary had not been demarcated and
had been shifted more than once by the British”. Thus Nehru
and how much unfit he was to hold the office of the Prime
Minister of India.
very much situate within the ambit and purview of even the
Kashmir in 1954 and the 1st Respondent herein and the 2nd
only increased vigour come what may and treat and react to
Supreme Court has held that right to life “embraces not only
P.11(70-71).
the Ministry of Home Affairs for the utility of the public, the plan
furious that the incursions had been leaked out to the proud
34
Chokla…”.
India. The only solace now for the proud people of India is
and is ab initio illegal, and null and void and the same is
which even otherwise was ab-initio illegal, null and void and
and Kashmir.
37
blue under the false guise of a firm and definite frontier, not
and null and void and ultra vires Article 1 (2) (3) and Entry
following Grounds:
GROUNDS
i) The new map issued pursuant to the memorandum
issued by the first respondent in 1954 has no legal
sanctity whatsoever and is perverse and has been
issued in a manner not known to law and the whole
proceedings are vitiated.
pass in the Kuen Lun range, and that the Turdi Kol was
Fort.
15
Alder, British India’s Northern Frontier, P.278
16
Statement of Musa Kirghiz of Shahidullah recorded by Ramsey on 25 May 1889, Foreign Secret
F., July 1889, No. 205
17
Foreign Secret F., July 1889, No. 203-30
43
1969:
Chinese".
19
Himalayan Battleground by Margaret W. Fisher, Leo E. Rose and Robert A. Huttenback, published by Fredreick A.
Praeger, 1963 New York
45
even the said map does not reflect the true findings
Tibet dated the 5th July 1914 which also depicts the
Kashmir.
Raskam.” 20
McMahon was able to prima facie roughly
20
For. Sec.F. October1896, 533/541 (534)
49
21
For. Sec. F.July 1898,306/347 (327)
50
Averment:
21. That The petitioner herein has not filed any other
PRAYER
non-est.
FILED BY:
NEW DELHI
DRAWN ON: 7.3.2011
FILED ON: 7.3.2011
P.V.Ravi Chandran,
(Party-in-Person)
Advocate, Madras
E. No 407 of 1993
5, Divya Krupa,
1st Street Extn.
Sri Krishna Nagar,
Maduravayal,
Chennai 600095
Ph. 04423783059
53
P.V.Ravi Chandran
Advocate,
5, Divya Krupa,
1st Street Extn.
Sri Krishna Nagar,
Maduravayal,
Chennai 600095 …..
Petitioner
Vs.
PAPER BOOK
P.V.RAVI CHANDRAN
PETITIONER IN PERSON
Advocate, Madras
5, Divya Krupa, 1st Street Extn.
Sri Krishna Nagar, Maduravayal,
Chennai 600095
Ph. 04423783059
54
P.V.Ravi Chandran
Advocate,
E. No 407 of 1993
5, Divya Krupa,
1st Street Extn.
Sri Krishna Nagar,
Maduravayal,
Chennai 600095 …..
Petitioner
Vs.
follows:
this affidavit.
submit that the facts stated therein are true to the best of
the originals.
DEPONENT