Você está na página 1de 10

the way we see it

Green ITIL
Capgemini explains how the ITIL life-cycle
provides easily implemented opportunities to
adopt sustainable IT
Contents
1. Executive Summary 03

2. Adopting Green ITIL 04

2.1. The Governance Link 04

2.2 Lowering the Environmental Impact of New and Existing Services 05

2.3. A Service-Led Approach 05

2.4. Controlling Adherence to CSR Policy 09

2.5. Reporting into the CSR Balanced Scorecard 09

3. Conclusions 09

4. Reference 09
the way we see it

1. Executive Summary footprint as mandatory PC hardware n Identify and control the


It’s a tough job, but someone’s got to buying criteria. environmental impact of its IT
do it n By 2011, suppliers to large global services;
Today’s IT manager needs to provide enterprises will need to prove their n Continuously improve its

a competitive edge for the business, green credentials via an audited environmental performance, and;
reduce energy consumption and increase process to retain preferred supplier n Implement a structured approach to
the sustainability of IT services – ‘it’s a status”. setting targets and measuring
tough job, but someone’s got to do it’.
performance over time.
The good news is that reducing the
Powering business growth is a constant carbon footprint of IT also leads to Capgemini aims to help organisations
challenge for today’s IT managers benefits. Over the past 20 years, develop and implement an approach
because competition is becoming government studies have found that to lowering the environmental impact
increasingly global in nature and organisations can save up to 20% on of IT by proposing the utilisation of
energy prices are rising at an alarming their energy costs by managing their the ITIL framework to achieve
rate. energy use and investing in cost- sustainable IT.
effective energy efficiency measures.
Add the fact that Information With the introduction of the Climate
Communication Technology (ICT) Change Levy (2001), the benefits of
now accounts for 2% of global CO2 becoming more energy efficient means
emissions1 and it becomes clear that some organisations can cut the
today’s IT managers are facing more amount of their levy5.
constraints than their predecessors -
the big challenges are: While Gartner’s predictions will probably
n Increasing cost of power: “The cost become reality, there will be a significant
of power consumption by data centres time-lag before organisations can rely
doubled between 2000 and 2006, to on a strategy of procuring more
$4.5 billion and could double again sustainable IT equipment as a means
by 20112. of reducing their energy costs and CO2.
n Social demands of employees and

customers: “...people are demanding Relocation is one alternative. Some


a reduction of the environmental organisations are thinking about
footprint of equipment manufacture.”3 moving their data centres to Iceland6
n Changing regulatory control: WEEE
*
to harness the country’s natural energy
resources and reduce the costs of
and RoHS in Europe and RCRA
** ***
powering and cooling their IT systems.
in the US.
While this seems a reasonable plan for
some CIOs, is this an affordable
The Gartner Group has identified
option for everyone?
“Green IT” as one of the 10 most
important topics concerning CIOs in
Capgemini believes ITIL service
20084. Gartner’s predictions include:
management offers an adaptable
n “By 2009, more than one-third of IT
method for making use of existing
organisations will have one or more processes to deliver sustainable IT
environmental criteria in their top today. This document explores the use
six buying criteria for IT-related of the ITIL life-cycle as part of a wider
goods and services. organisational approach to sustainable
n By 2010, 75% of organisations will IT. Leveraging ITIL to enable an
use full life cycle energy and CO2 organisation to:

* The WEEE Directive and WEEE Targets require organisations to recognise the principle of ‘producer liability’ for the production and disposal
of IT equipment with recovery, re-use and recycling targets ranging from 50% to 80%.
** The RoHS Directive bans new electrical and electronic equipment containing more than agreed levels of lead, cadmium, mercury,
hexavalent chromium, polybrominated biphenyl (PBB) and polybrominated diphenyl ether (PBDE) flame retardants.
*** The RCRA is the public law in the US that creates the framework for the management of hazardous and non-hazardous solid waste.

Green ITIL 3
2 Adopting Green ITIL Figure 1 – ITIL, the link between CSR policy and measurable targets
Capgemini suggests that IT managers
make use of the ITIL life-cycle to
Corporate Social Responsibility Policy
integrate environmental targets into
Governance
the performance measures for new Corporate Balance
and existing IT services. Scorecard
IT Social Responsibility Policy

Using governance to link the CSR


policy and the IT function, managers
can convert an organisation’s Service Management Policy
IT Balanced Scorecard

environmental vision and strategy into


measurable targets as illustrated in
Figure 1.
IT Function IT Services
ITIL
Our fundamental approach to Application services Processes
Methods
identifying opportunities for KPI
Infrastructure services Functions
Roles
improving IT sustainability begins Network Services Activities
with understanding an organisations
Data Services
current position. Capgemini uses a
combination of energy matrices, the Security Services

ITIL framework and its environmental


service review methodology to
calculate an IT function’s existing
score against best practise. IT governance achieves the delivery retained functions or externally from
of strategic outcomes including outsource providers.
Once a score is identified, we develop environmental targets through its
an activity plan, with milestones and interface with service management. IT The recognised industry best practice
metrics, to implement energy saving governance acts as the decision authority standard for service management is
initiatives. These initiatives then and empowers service management ITIL. ITIL is a lifecycle approach with
become ingrained within the ongoing with the decision rights to carry out strategy at the heart of the framework
service improvement philosophy. the delivery of IT in more sustainable as illustrated in the model below:
way; sourcing services internally from
Capgemini proposes this service-led
approach as a complimentary approach
to a technology focus where the © Crown
ITIL V3 copyright
emphasis is on component performance.
This is because a service-led approach
more readily links IT services to Gover
nance Methods
St
s

an
ill

business services and therefore value.


Sk

da

Continual Service
rd
&

s
e

In a service-led approach, any IT that Improvement


dg

A
lig
le
w

nm

does not contribute to business


no

en
K

services becomes a carbon overhead Service


Cas

Design
irrespective of its performance.
s
Topic

eS
tud

Service
iality

ies

Strategies
2.1 The Governance Link
Spec

IT governance controls the successful


Templates

ITIL
implementation of an organisational
Service
strategy – and environmental policy – Operation
Ex

by linking it with IT strategy. It achieves Service


ec

Co Imp

e n ice
uti

Transition
nt ro

e m erv

y
t
in ve

this control through SMART (specific,


ve

ilit
ov S
ua m

b
Int

pr al
l S en

ala
Im tinu

measurable, achievable, realistic and


rod

er t

Sc
vic

n
uc

Co

time-bound) performance targets


e
tio
n

designed to demonstrate the ongoing St


ud W
in
s
yA ck
value of IT. The purpose of IT id
s Qu
i

governance is to enable the link Qualifications


between CSR and IT to operate
efficiently.

4
the way we see it

ITIL service management offers the in process or performance. Continual 2.4 Controlling Adherence to
opportunity for IT to adopt an service improvement liaises with strategy, CSR Policy
organisation’s environmental policy in design, transition and operations in While ITIL service management
a pragmatic way through a number of order to plan improvements that enables the IT manager to develop
life-cycle phases: strategy, design, result in desired outcomes for existing ways to reduce the environmental
transition, operation, improvement services as well. impact of IT services and align the IT
and retirement. It then falls to IT strategy with the organisation’s CSR
governance to assess how well the 2.3 A Service-Led Approach vision, it is the ITIL processes such as
organisations environmental objectives It is important to consider the incident, change, configuration,
have been reached by reviewing environmental impact of the whole capacity and service level management
historic performance against SMART IT service rather than the individual which control the adherence to these
targets. configuration items that form the aims. This is achieved by monitoring
service. This is because focusing on services against the targets, established
2.2 Lowering the Environmental the environmental impact of an through the IT governance link and
Impact of New and Existing individual component is too implemented in the service strategy
Services simplistic. IT managers must focus phase.
The ITIL framework allows on integrated IT services supporting
environmental targets to be built into business services in order to deliver Carbon reduction activities and
new and existing services through its sustainable IT. measures must be developed
lifecycle phases of strategy, design, collaboratively rather than proscribed.
transition, operation and continuous Mapping IT configuration items to This is particularly important in
service improvement. an existing IT service will identify customer-supplier relationships in
equipment that is vital for the delivery order to avoid unfulfilled expectations
Service portfolio management is a of a business service. By identifying or missed opportunities.
primary activity of the first stage, the equipment that forms the IT Implementing control measures and
service strategy. Business outcomes services supporting the business, targets through the ITIL service
and financial targets are key inputs for managers will identify components management life-cycle requires people,
service portfolio management in the that add the most value and items that process and tools.
development of new services. are more of an overhead.

Environmental targets are ideally Configuration items which cannot be People


suited as inputs for service portfolio mapped to a business service need to Organisational behaviour is managed by
management when provisioning new, be assessed and removed if possible. policy e.g. travel, procurement, expense
and equipment usage policies (including
more sustainable, IT services. This As a result of a similar exercise to map
desktop monitors and printing).
is because managers can assess its configuration items to IT services a
predicted performance targets global bank removed over £1 million To change behaviours, policies must be
against environmental policies before in annual service charges7 a fact which introduced and/or updated to achieve
agreeing to commission a new service. demonstrates that the benefits are not desired outcomes. An organisation’s
just environmental. travel policy can be used to proscribe a
The remainder of the lifecycle takes desired target for the frequency of travel
over once the service is commissioned. Configuration items required for or justification for travel i.e. to meet a
The new service and its environmental services that are sub-24/7 can also customer or to take part in an internal
targets pass through the design, be investigated for energy saving meeting.
transition and operations phase before opportunities. If office lights are
The same applies to services: it is the
eventual retirement. During the switched off overnight, it is possible
people involved in each step of the
operations phase, continual service that idle technology can be set to
service management life-cycle that must
improvement seeks to make gains hibernate, provided that it is not be aware of the environmental policy
on financial and environmental mission critical. and targets in order for the measures to
performance and once at the end of be implemented and monitored
its useful life, the service is retired. By taking an end-to-end view of successfully.
IT/business services rather than
The continuous service improvement focusing on configuration items, IT Targets must be aligned to the overall
phase of the ITIL life-cycle provides managers are able to ascertain the full CSR policy for the organisations
the opportunity to analyse service environmental impact of an strategic aims to be realised. People
trends, review baselines and benchmark IT/business service, improve energy agree, implement, monitor, review and
report on performance and are a key
results in order to identify improvements efficiency and cut costs.
enabler.

Green ITIL 5
Process
sustainable IT activities not only allows n Are site visits required?
The control of processes is managed by an organisation to extract greater n Are there internal support resources
Performance Indicators. Environmental value from its investments in good based on-site?
targets can easily be adopted as part of practice, it also provides a reporting
the established processes performance mechanism that will assist in monitoring Results are then measured by incident
indicators. The simplest approach is to the adoption of CSR targets. resolution classification, where the
absorb environmental targets into
least carbon generating resolutions are
existing performance monitoring and Example – Incident management assigned 1 (i.e. industrialised,
reporting activities or incorporate a Incident Management provides the
scoring mechanism as part of the
mutualised off-shore centres resolving
opportunity to assess the environmental application incidents remotely) and
process, for example:
impact of IT service recovery. To those which are high carbon
n Incident Management scoring: measure performance, environmental
provides a measure of the
generating are scored 5 (i.e. long
targets need to be incorporated into distance travel for site visits,
environmental impact of incidents
existing service level agreements where replacement equipment containing
using a scoring mechanism where 1
can be defined as low impact and 5
each resolution category has a carbon high levels of environmentally
high impact. score. The aim is to establish an incident unfriendly materials, equipment
management environmental impact manufactured and shipped from
n Change Management scoring: offers
the ability to track the number of RFCs
baseline, so that it can be measured, overseas).
submitted where the environmental monitored and then improved.
impact of the change is considered An illustration of an incident
and a score awarded based on pre- The incident management categories management classification table is
agreed criteria. must be defined using an organisation’s provided to demonstrate the
n Configuration Management scoring: existing service management delivery information likely to be included in a
provides data on the number of model to identify where its carbon more sustainable service level
configuration items in the CMDB with generating activities occur. The agreement.
energy efficiency data. following illustrate the broad questions
that need to be asked e.g.:
n Does the organisation use

Tools outsourced remote support?


The choice and approach to managing
environmentally friendly IT tools occurs
through the life-cycle of selection, Illustration of P1 Incident Management Carbon Scoring Measures
procurement, support and disposal. The
efficient selection of enterprise
architecture is often a centralised
function which selects products based Incident Incident Carbon
on features, integration, reliability, Category Carbon Category* Score*
maintainability serviceability and
security. The inclusion of environmental
considerations is an enhancement to Category A 1
this process and would take into
account the supply chain production
methods, embedded energy (energy Category B 2
used in the manufacturing process) and
disposal of the components. The
P1 Category C 3
desired outcome being the selection of
tools based on criteria that include
environmental considerations. Category D 4

While our fundamental approach Category E 5


advocates a blend of people, processes
and tools, this paper focuses on ITIL
processes as a low cost method of
* Examples used are purely for the purposes of illustration and should not
controlling the environmental impact be considered normal targets – each organisations metrics will be different
of IT services. and will reflect a unique set of circumstances.

Making use of existing ITIL processes


to control the implementation of

6
the way we see it

Using this method results in a monthly management and comply with equivalent Energy Star® rating. Such
and annual score that can be used to organisational CSR activities. a declaration will set a measurable
measure the impact of incidents over environmental target. It then becomes
time. Examples of these include: the role of configuration management
n Change Validation: each RFC to report on the compliance of the IT
submitted for approval should be infrastructure with the CSR policy on
assessed on its environmental impact energy efficiency.
and compliance with the CSR targets.
Periodic P1 incidents A scoring mechanism allows the Example - Capacity Management
(By Carbon Category) change manager to rank the RFC Capacity management is a key
in terms of its adherence with element of the service design phase of
policy as part of the assessment of the ITIL lifecycle and provides an
x priority. This allows for an RFC to organisation with the ability to plan
be understood in terms of its how it introduces IT capacity in a
environmental impact (positive/ more sustainable way and to limit idle
Score for Carbon
negative). usage through demand management
Category
n Change Advisory Board (CAB) and service level management. Its
Meetings: to minimise the purpose is to focus on future business
environmental impact of Change requirements, current service delivery
=
Management, all CAB meeting are capability and current delivery – in
carried out virtually to avoid the order to provide the most energy and
Periodic Carbon
need for CAB members to travel. cost efficient IT services for the
Score for P1 incidents
(By Carbon Category) n Change Reporting: change
business.
management data feeds into the
The capacity manager is responsible
continual service improvement
for tuning activities, deriving forecasts,
process to assess the environmental
influencing demand and producing
impact of an IT service over time.
The objective is to develop a mechanism the capacity management plan. Key
This data also feeds the service
that allows an organisation to begin activities of the process include trend
level management reporting
measuring the environmental impact analysis, planning and modelling.
function. Over time, the expectation
of its incidents over time and then All of these activities are ideal for
is that changes to IT services reduce
identify the means to decrease this integrating the environmental needs
the environmental impact of a
impact through continual service of the CSR policy and influencing the
service in line with CSR targets.
improvement – looking for initiatives capacity requirements of the business
n Change Management Tool: all
and innovations which reduce the by encouraging reduced consumption,
number of incidents. Problem change management information is reuse and recycling of capacity.
management trend analysis can also held electronically with no requirement
identify those incidents, or groups of for paper-based records. Proactive Capacity Management
incidents, that have produced the In our experience environmentally
highest carbon scores. Example – Configuration friendly IT makes use of the capacity
Management management process to plan the
Example – Change Management Asset and configuration management introduction of sustainable IT services
Change management provides an has an important part to play in the as part of the service design stage of
approach for considering the environmental compliance of IT the ITIL lifecycle.
environmental impact of Requests for because it is responsible for managing
Change (RFCs) before they take place. information on the components that To successfully integrate CSR policy
This allows an organisation to test form the IT services. The attributes of and capacity management activities,
each RFC and either accept or reject it configuration items should include IT functions must possess strong
using a rationale that includes indicators such as energy labels used forecasting capabilities and understand
environmental impact as well as by ‘White Goods’ manufacturers or the future capacity needs of the
financial, business and technology. the EU Energy Star® used to label business and the impact of emerging
energy efficient office equipment8. technologies; the ability to effectively
The scope of activity is not limited to forecast capacity will result in better
the RFCs passing through the process. In future, Capgemini believes CSR planning and the timely implementation
There are a number of initiatives policies will state an organisation’s of more energy efficient technology.
which Capgemini advocates to mitigate intended choice of IT infrastructure
the environmental impact of change using energy label rating ‘A’ or

Green ITIL 7
Reactive Capacity Management Negotiation with customers and It is recognised that negotiating more
A more reactive approach to capacity business users must be guided by the environmentally friendly service level
management focuses on influencing CSR policy in organisations where the agreements is more complex for
demand today and requires the assistance sustainability of IT services is a global organisations where services are
of the service level management to strategic consideration. By using the fully utilised over a 24 hour period.
negotiate with the end customer. CSR policy in this way, the aim is to While some services will offer little
evolve the process of agreeing service opportunity to make savings, it
A strong ITIL relationship exists level agreements from one based on remains the responsibility of service
between capacity management and ‘business impact’ and ‘price’ to one level management and continual
service level management. This interface which also considers the environmental service improvement to identify
allows the capacity management impact of an IT service. opportunities to make IT services
process to influence demand via the more sustainable.
service level management process. By For example, supporting IT services
making use of this interface, it is typically operate over the entire Critical Success Factors – Service
possible to include environmental working week even though they are Management and a Joint CSR Policy
service capacity requirements in the often only required by the business The existence of the service management
service level management process, Monday-Friday during office hours. function is a key success factor for
especially as part of the negotiations sustainable IT, especially in a
for new and existing service level While providing service 100% of the multisourced supply chain environment.
agreements. time during the week may satisfy the
business and be an acceptable cost, it The service management function
The challenge for capacity management may be unacceptable from an coordinates the integration of
is to ensure service level management sustainability point of view on the sustainable IT processes across
is equipped with environmental impact grounds that the service is generally multiple delivery towers. The Service
scores in addition to business case idle during evenings and weekends Management function ensures that
data in service cost model to support when the users are away from the software, hardware and network
negotiations with the customers. This office. The key objective of service capacity, and their associated service
allows for the sustainability of an IT level management is to identify idle levels, are integrated as part of the
service to be considered when services and challenge the business to end-to-end service and comply with
negotiating SLAs and when purchasing reduce its energy consumption. the CSR policy.
new equipment.
Office cultures vary and there will A second key success factor is the
Example – Service Level Management always be a proportion of the workforce existence of a joint CSR policy between
In negotiations with customers, that continues to work outside office all the stakeholders involved in the
service level management must deal hours. It will fall to the service level delivery of sustainable IT services.
with the business and the supporting management to negotiate with the The existence of a jointly agreed policy
supply chain to agree service level customer as to whether the between the parties ensures that
agreements, operating level agreements environmental impact of this level negotiations between an organisation
and underpinning contracts. of service is appropriate given the and its partners operate within a
wider CSR policy. shared framework, where all parties
The important factor is the existence are expected to work towards reducing
of joint CSR policy. In situations Where organisations want to actively the environmental impact of IT.
where services are outsourced to one discourage energy waste and influence
or a number of partners, the CSR demand, the service level management Through the existence of a green
policy needs to be agreed between the process can apply financial measures service management function, a joint
parties for it to become truly effective to reduce the demand for idle services CSR policy and the control offered by
in supporting the creation of more – using energy surcharges. the ITIL processes and activities,
sustainable IT services. organisations can communicate and
Energy surcharges are additional monitor their adherence to
Service level agreements are typically costs applied to idle services, outside environmental targets.
agreed through the service level normal working hours, and are used
management process which defines to encourage a reduction in energy The ITIL service management model
the requirement, agrees the contract, consumption. Only with senior provides a reporting mechanism to
monitors performance, reports and management support can energy capture performance data that can be
reviews the outcomes. Of particular surcharges reasonably be used to fed into the CSR balanced scorecard;
importance in this process is the deter idle services. this equips senior management with a
activity of negotiation. low cost loop-back mechanism upon

8
the way we see it

which to assess the performance of 3 Conclusion Enhancing the existing ITIL framework
the overall CSR policy. IT managers today need to achieve to support the implementation of
sustainability IT targets that are environmental management activities
The CSR balanced scorecard is the directly linked to an organisation’s will not only make good use of
corporate tool for assessing performance environmental vision and strategy. existing process today, it will save the
and demonstrating an organisation’s This is to counter the big challenges time and cost of developing and
green credentials to its stakeholders facing the IT manager: implementing alternative approaches
and wider community. If no CSR n Maintain the competitive business edge that rely on environmentally friendly
balanced scorecard exists, it becomes n Reduce energy consumption
products becoming available and
difficult to demonstrate progress. affordable tomorrow.
n Increase the sustainability of IT

2.5 Reporting into the CSR services. 4. References


Balanced Scorecard All links correct at time of going to
Incorporating organisational CSR Searching for a solution that is reliant press.
policy into IT strategy targets is the on equipment with a smaller build/
mechanism for the downward run carbon footprint is a long-term [1] ICT Industry: 2% of Global CO2
delegation of environmental vision component-focused plan likely to Emissions
and strategy. The use of the ITIL deliver benefits in the future; but http://www.gartner.com/it/
lifecycle provides the vehicle to there is an opportunity cost of doing
achieve this in practise. nothing in the mean time. [2] It's Too Darn Hot
http://www.businessweek.com/magaz
It is important to ensure that the results Capgemini proposes a service-focused ine/content/
of the vision and strategy are fed back approach which utilises the ITIL
to the senior stakeholders in order to lifecycle as a means for realistically [3] Green IT: We’re getting there.
assess progress and ascertain whether incorporating CSR policies as targets Slowly
outcomes are meeting objectives and in the delivery of new and existing IT http://www.it-analysis.com/
IT is becoming more sustainable. services. The lifecycle approach
incorporates activities to reduce the [4] Gartner's Top Predictions for IT
The ITIL lifecycle provides the means environmental impact of IT services at Organizations and Users, 2008 and
to monitor, measure, assess and report each stage of the lifecycle: strategy; Beyond: Going Green and Self-
on IT strategy sustainability targets. design; transition; operation-disposal. Healing
Individual outputs used to measure Gartner Research, 8 January 2008, ID
the performance of each ITIL process It recommends a service mind-set G00154035
need to feed into a CSR balanced through which organisations can
scorecard that is derived from the adopt measures to embed compliance [5] A strategic approach to energy
overall organisational balanced with regulatory requirements such as and environmental management
scorecard. WEEE and RoHS into the day-to-day Carbon Trust, Good Practice Guide,
IT processes. GPG376
The CSR balance scorecard is used www.thecarbontrust.co.uk/energy
to measure the organisation’s The ITIL lifecycle provides all the
performance in adopting a greener necessary control mechanisms to [6] It's Too Darn Hot
approach to the delivery of IT and ensure the adoption of sustainability http://www.businessweek.com/magaz
business services and is the means to targets utilising processes such as ine/content/
assess how intended strategy and Change Management, Incident
realised strategy are achieving Management, Configuration [7] ABN Amro - Banking on Sourcing
environmental aims. Management, Capacity Management Management
and Service Level Management. http://www.oblicore.com/resources/w
ebinars.php
Data captured to measure the
performance of operations provides [8] Introducing the EU ENERGY
a feed for reporting the ongoing STAR®
adherence to sustainability targets http://www.eu-energystar.org/en/
and environmental policy. Capgemini
recommends the use of this data as
inputs for a balanced scorecard designed
to measure the performance of green
ITIL.

Green ITIL 9
www.capgemini.com

About Capgemini
and the Collaborative
Business Experience

Capgemini, one of the world’s


foremost providers of consulting,
technology and outsourcing services,
enables its clients to transform and
perform through technologies.

Capgemini provides its clients with


insights and capabilities that boost their
freedom to achieve superior results
through a unique way of working - the
Collaborative Business Experience -
and through a global delivery model
called Rightshore®, which aims to offer
the right resources in the right location
at competitive cost. Present in 36
countries, Capgemini reported 2007
global revenues of EUR 8.7 billion and
employs over 83,000 people
worldwide.

More information is available at


www.capgemini.com

For further information:

Christopher Cherrington
Service Management Consulting
Practice Director
+44 (0)870 904 3933
chris.cherrington@capgemini.com

David Greenway
Principal Service Management
Consultant
+44 (0)870 904 5633
david.greenway@capgemini.com

Capgemini plc
Capgemini plc
No.1 Forge End
Woking
Ref: 101308

Surrey
GU21 6DB
tel: 01483 764764
fax: 01483 786161

©2008 Capgemini. No part of this document may be modified, deleted or expanded by any
process or means without prior written permission from Capgemini.

Você também pode gostar