Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
+ Focus on Research:
Charlene Senn
+ International Day for the
Elimination of Racial
Discrimination
+ Focus on Teaching:
Frances Cachon
+ High School Social
Justice Forum
+ Human Trafficking
+ ChangeCamp Windsor-Essex
+ Social Justice Project of
the Year Award
www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice
Volume 5, Issue 2, Fall 2010
2 | www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice
Centre for Studies in Social Justice
3
Volume 5, Issue 2, Fall 2010
4 | www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice
Centre for Studies in Social Justice
5
Volume 5, Issue 2, Fall 2010
Arthur Barbut,
Volunteer, Teachers for Global Awareness
6 | www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice
Centre for Studies in Social Justice
and the Criminal Code. The difficulty
The Windsor Essex Anti-Human Trafficking Action with these is that they speak to only
By Shelley Gilbert one part of what the Palermo Protocol
expected. That is, they deal only with
I n many com-
munities
across the
these concepts would seem fairly
straight-forward and clear. However,
this is not the case as there is ongoing
the punishment of offenders. There is
nothing in the legislation assisting with
prevention or providing protection to
country, includ- debate and discussion both internally survivors.
ing Windsor, within our own organization, but also In an attempt to address that need,
members of the with local and federal enforcement the Temporary Resident Permit for
public, govern- agencies as to what constitutes these victims of trafficking was introduced in
ment agencies, elements. 2006. It provides 180 days of
and other com- Some questions that arise in our dis- “reflection time” to individuals deter-
Shelley Gilbert, cussions are, for example: Should
Co-ordinator of Social Work
munity partners mined to be survivors of human traf-
Services, Legal Assistance have begun the deplorable work and/or living condi- ficking by an immigration official. Al-
of Windsor, and, Co-chair, process of both tions be considered abusive or ex- though this is certainly a step in a posi-
Windsor-Essex Anti-Human
Trafficking Action Group identifying hu- ploitative? Is the threat of deportation tive direction, there remain two difficul-
man trafficking when the person has incurred a ties. First, the permit is still temporary.
and determining what to do about this $10,000 debt to come to Canada a It is possible that a victim might fully
human rights violation. Locally, the form of coercion or control? Is charg- cooperate with the police investigation
Windsor Essex Anti-Human Trafficking ing someone $6,000 to $10,000 to and the criminal court process only to
Action Group has established an on- come to Canada a form of exploitation be expected to return and reintegrate
going dialogue with survivors of traf- that keeps them in an abusive work in their country of origin. Although the
ficking while providing direct support environment and does this constitute a permit can be renewed by immigration,
and advocacy to victims. In addition to form of debt bondage? permanent residency can not be re-
direct representation and support, the What has been most troubling is that quested until the individual has held
Action Group provides education to these abused individuals live among the permit for 3 years. Secondly, dur-
service providers as to signs of human us while being ignored by all levels of ing the “reflection time” individuals re-
trafficking and the emotional/physical government. Federally, there are poli- quire provincial services to address
symptoms often experienced by survi- cies that ignore the problems experi- both basic and psychosocial needs.
vors. The Action Group has dveloped enced by foreign workers and which Yet currently there is little to nil funding
service delivery protocols with govern- may, inadvertently, contribute to ex- for provincial services to address
ment services to ensure survivors are ploitation and abuse. Provincially, for these needs. Agencies are forced to
recognized and treated humanely and example, there is little enforcement of patch together services without ade-
lobbies provincial and federal govern- employment standards or protection quate resources or expertise to meet
ments for effective legislative reform. and very little funding to assist ser- the needs of these survivors.
Currently, each of the men and vices for outreach, education or advo- It is apparent that enacting legisla-
women we support has been exploited cacy. It has been our experience that tion is not enough. We must make
by means of forced labour and debt the current legislation and policies in available the services, the resources,
bondage arrangements. place, as well as a lack of enforcement and the expertise in order to assist
As our group has witnessed first of employment standards, may bolster people. Only then can organizations
hand, human trafficking is profitable the very elements that define human operationalize the legislation meant to
due to the trafficker‟s ability to move trafficking. protect victims and survivors of human
and “reuse” the human being, much as The Palermo Protocol provides the trafficking.
one would handle a commodity. This most useful public policy guidelines for The Windsor Essex Anti-Human Traf-
cycle may repeat indefinitely over an understanding human trafficking. This ficking Action Group believes that for-
extensive period of time. Human protocol essentially requires its ratify- eign workers, no matter the environ-
trafficking, therefore, differs from ing countries to: 1) introduce national ment whence they come, have the
trafficking in illicit materials. For legislation to prevent and suppress same rights in the workplace as do all
example, once drugs or guns are sold, trafficking, 2) to punish traffickers, and Canadians. We must ensure that our
they disappear along with the buyer. 3) protect its victims. This protocol government enacts legislation to pro-
Not so with a trafficked human being recognizes the need for a combined tect people from exploitative recruiters
who can be moved from one place or approach integrating the effective pre- hired by Canadian employers. Work-
community to another, changing hands vention of trafficking along with the ers must also be educated about the
from one employer to another over prosecution of traffickers and the pro- laws and standards in Canada. Finally,
and over again. tection of human rights and assistance we must enforce those standards and
There are four key elements of hu- to victims. ensure people are provided the ser-
man trafficking. These are: recruit- In response to the Palermo Protocol, vices they require to be healthy, pro-
ment, movement, coercion, and exploi- Canada enacted legislation in the Im- ductive members of our communities.
tation. Given the context we work in, migration and Refugee Protection Act The unfortunate reality is that ►P8
7
Volume 5, Issue 2, Fall 2010
Focus on Teaching: situated knower allowed me to de- proach I relinquished the role of pro-
construct knowledge as external and fessor and became a facilitator. Sub-
Frances Cachon conceptual. Reenergized by a new verting the traditional authoritarian
appreciation of Dorothy Smith‟s and student/professor dynamic I opened
◄P5 to deal with the emotions such Patricia Hill Collins‟ theoretical work myself to experience and participate
engagement evoked. I would finish a on standpoint knowledge, which em- in the learning process. I also began
course feeling depressed, frequently phasizes the vital importance of our to introduce non-traditional texts,
hearing from students, “I liked your lived or embodied experience as a such as hip-hop music, film, and po-
class, but you ruined everything!” basis of knowledge, I found my etry. This pedagogical strategy pur-
Intellectually this was a great compli- voice. posefully intervened and altered the
ment, but I was growing increasingly During class I began to empha- classroom atmosphere. Provocation
disenchanted with the process. size the importance of experience as and engagement were invited, so
Teaching introductory sociology a standpoint on which to base analy- that emotion became a vital peda-
as a pregnant woman further exas- sis. The results were amazing! The gogical tool. When for example we
perated this discontent. Standing tone of my classes changed com- addressed Canada‟s painful history
before hundreds of students worry- pletely, students became more en- of residential schools and forced cul-
ing about leaking breast milk chal- gaged and connected to the course. tural assimilation, many of us cried.
lenged my feminist sensibilities. I Sharing my excitement with a friend The classroom morphed from isolat-
became painfully aware of the mind/ she loaned me a copy of bell hook‟s ing and depleting, to participatory
body dualism that pervaded my ana- Teaching to Transgress—deeply and affirming. Consequently, I am
lytical understanding of gender as a moved, I read the book in one night. once again actively engaged in the
social construction. My physical ex- It seemed unreasonable that I hadn‟t transformative potential of education.
perience of pregnancy, the physio- previously encountered Paulo Thanks to bell hooks, I now realize
logical changes this entailed made Freire‟s work. that education is not inherently lib-
the erasure of my body in the class- Critical pedagogy, a theory and eratory. It fulfills this critical potential
room impossible. And so I began to practice of helping students achieve only when we open ourselves to ac-
incorporate the actualities of my own critical consciousness, gave me the tively and passionately engage with
life in relation to the curriculum I was tools I needed to help students to our students. ■
teaching. Presenting knowledge as a think critically. In adopting this ap-
8 | www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice
Centre for Studies in Social Justice
gial, and from the feedback and com-
ments we received, the attendees
ChangeCamp Windsor-Essex were certainly keen on getting together
again. The organizers had requests
9
Volume 5, Issue 2, Fall 2010
10 | www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice
Centre for Studies in Social Justice
11
Volume 5, Issue 2, Fall 2010
Editors
Tanya Basok, University of Windsor, Canada,
Suzan Ilcan, University of Windsor, Canada,
Jeffrey Noonan, University of Windsor, Canada
Contact Us
Involved in Social Justice Research?
Contact the Center for Studies in Social Justice if Tanya Basok, PhD,
Director
you want to form a research interest group in your 251 Chrysler Hall South, University of Windsor
field of research. (519) 253-3000 ext. 3498, basok@uwindsor.ca
12 | www.uwindsor.ca/socialjustice