Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
Widener University
Introduction
The three articles that I chose to compare and critique are “ ‘Like
framework of total institution as the guide to analyze the data that was
homicide and loss of a loved one were the foci of the qualitative study
time factor. Implications for social work practice based on the findings
The third article that will be used for comparison and contrast is
collect the qualitative data. The author provides the findings of her
reflects the nature in which the data was collected. The titles of the
DeWard, Johnson, Sosluski articles all indicate that the data was
used to collect data were life history and narrative analysis. Although
Each journal article title clearly informs the reader about the
flattering since the statement “like a prison” leads the title. The
titles, the Sosulski article title (“Life History and Narrative Analysis:
with Severe Mental Illness”) uses the most jargon. The excessive use
of jargon may deter potential readers who are not well versed in
three articles used for the comparison and contrast, I found the
informative. The reader of the abstract will be clear on the fact that
the research.
Out of three articles that were read for compare and contrast, on
in which data was collected. It was unclear whether or not the abstract
Sosulski article does not give a concrete nor concise synapsis of the
indicate that the findings uncovered “the need for rigorous, culturally
BALL-COMPARISON AND CRITIQUE 6
Sosulski article, the outline of the purpose of the research and manner
need for research in each of the targeted areas. The literature review
mental illness, but feels the need to define life history analysis as well
have been done in a clearer manner that the reader could easily follow
and comprehend.
their parents, knew the intent and manner of the study. Johnson
informs the reader that the project was approved and reviewed by the
compensated 10 dollars an hour. One thing that Sosulski does that the
other authors do not was making available the expertise of the team
The findings of the DeWard article are listed in the context of the
“Maria” is told in the subject’s own words. The authors used the
The findings of the Johnson article are clearly laid out and can be
that pertains to ways in which the death of a friend or loved one affects
their data and data analysis. Each author went back to the basis of
and books are outline according to APA style. Additionally, each article
has an eclectic mix of books and magazine articles that have shaped
Overall Assessment
girls and homicide to be the most well written, concise, and clear
article out of the three articles that I analyzed for this assignment.
research presented. I believe that far too often social workers write for
themselves and other social workers; the data that we collect affect
laden with jargon and terms that only clinicians and academicians can
understand.
and see firsthand how the author devised the conclusions. I will be
research.
BALL-COMPARISON AND CRITIQUE 11
enlightened by the three different styles and was able to take from
policy.
BALL-COMPARISON AND CRITIQUE 12
References
Sosulski, M. R., Buchanan, N. T., & Donell, C. M. (2010). Life history and
narrative
analysis: Feminist methodologies contextualizing Black Women’s
experiences with severe mental illness. Journal of Sociology &
Social Welfare, XXXVII(3), 29-57,