Escolar Documentos
Profissional Documentos
Cultura Documentos
By Aminah Hamam
11
1
Statement of Originality
I certify that the attached material is my original work. No other persons work has been used without due acknowledgement. Some of this material was previously used in the project proposal for this thesis. Other than in the mentioned proposal it has not been presented by me for assessment, in any other course subject at this or any other institution
Aminah Hamam
Page 2
Acknowledgments
I would like to acknowledge and thank Professor Freddy Nager for his support throughout this project. A big thank you to: 1) All the business executives who took time out of their busy schedules to fill out the survey. 2) All the business executives who took the time to correspond with me and answer the four open ended questions. Without their contributions, there would not have been a qualitative factor to this report. 3) Fouad Jeryes, Director of Marketing at D1G, for all his support and encouraging words. 4) Mohamed Parham Al Awadi, co-founder of Wild Peeta, for taking the time to do a phone interview. I would also like to thank my Father for proofreading and my Mother for encouraging me to complete this initiative when I felt I could no longer go on. A special thank you to Mrs. Mona Younes for your guidance and ideas. I would also like to thank my husband who understood how important this masters degree is to me. I hope this journey would teach my two wonderful children that the pursuit of education can be done at anytime and anywhere. I started my masters journey three years ago when they were at a very young age, 4 and 2. They had to give up some Mommy time so that I could complete my studies. I love you Dahlia and Ramy.
Aminah Hamam
Page 3
Aminah Hamam
Page 4
Aminah Hamam
Page 5
Aminah Hamam
Page 6
Figures
Figure 1: Age of Business Executives ...................................................................................................... 59 Figure 2: Gender divide for Survey participants ..................................................................................... 60 Figure 3: Education qualifications of survey respondents ....................................................................... 61 Figure 4: Country of work ...................................................................................................................... 61 Figure 5: Preferred language of respondents ......................................................................................... 62 Figure 6: Preferred language against country of work ............................................................................ 63 Figure 7: Size of Businesses ................................................................................................................... 64 Figure 8: Size of business against Country .............................................................................................. 65 Figure 9: Company budget for Marketing .............................................................................................. 66 Figure 10: Budget allocation .................................................................................................................. 67 Figure 11: Budget allocation against budget .......................................................................................... 67 Figure 12: Budget allocation against company ....................................................................................... 68 Figure 13: Budget allocation against strategy......................................................................................... 69 Figure 14: Experience with social media usage ...................................................................................... 70 Figure 15: Hours of usage per week ....................................................................................................... 71 Figure 16: Hours of usage against experience of usage .......................................................................... 72 Figure 17: Facebook usage by country ................................................................................................... 73 Figure 18: Twitter usage by country ....................................................................................................... 74 Figure 19: Blogs usage by country .......................................................................................................... 75 Figure 20: LinkedIn usage by country ..................................................................................................... 76 Figure 21: Type of consumer ................................................................................................................. 78 Figure 22: Type of consumer according to respondent country .............................................................. 80 Figure 23: Generating Exposure to Business .......................................................................................... 81 Figure 24: Better understanding of the consumer.................................................................................. 82 Figure 25: Generation of more conversations ........................................................................................ 82 Figure 26: Lower costs ........................................................................................................................... 83 Figure 27: Perceptions if social media will be used instead of traditional media ..................................... 84 Figure 28: Perceptions against statement it costs too much ............................................................... 85 Figure 29: Perceptions against opinion that Traditional media is not that effective anymore .............. 86 Figure 30: Perceptions against the statement "I have no knowledge of what the consumer wants " ...... 86 Figure 31: Perceptions against Both social and traditional forms of media will complement each other .............................................................................................................................................................. 87
Aminah Hamam
Page 7
Aminah Hamam
Page 8
Aminah Hamam
Page 9
According to a Booz Allen report titled Winning in MENAs New Media Scene, the shift of the Arab world to new media is on the rise despite the worldwide economic slowdown (Chahine, Bhargava, Smayra and Belcaid). Businesses in the Arab world have only begun to take advantage of social media to reach potential customers. The purpose of this thesis is to explore and analyze the fabric of the Arabic social media user from the point of view of the marketing executive, compared with the West, and to analyze mostly frequented social media and compare usage between the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region and the West. Five countries have been selected to be part of this research: 1) Egypt 2) Morocco 3) Kingdom of Saudi Arabia 4) United Arab Emirates 5) Jordan There were several reasons these countries were selected over others. 1) These countries are the top users of Facebook and Twitter in the MENA region. 2) Jordan is one of the leading companies creating Arabic social media platforms. It has created D1G, Watwet, Jeeran and Maktoob. The social media platforms that will be the focus of this research are: 1) Facebook is one of the top sites used in the MENA region. It is ranked the second most popular online destination in Morocco, Jordan and Egypt; third most popular in UAE and fifth most popular in KSA.
Aminah Hamam
Page 10
The research is designed to explore the Arab business executives usage and perceptions of social media in the MENA region. The research is conducted in two parts: The first part concentrates on the average Arabic social media user and The second and main part is focused on the Arab business executive
Comparisons will be made between MENA and Western users. The research questions are as follows: First Part: The Arab social media consumer, the sites frequented and a comparison with the West. This section will be analyzed and documented from available research. 1) Who is the Arabic social media consumer and how does s/he differ from the Western social media consumer? a. Demographics b. Motivations and Influences c. How does their use differs from Western users 2) An analysis of social media sites frequented by Arabs 3) How does the usage of social media sites reflect on traditional media usage? Page 11
Aminah Hamam
Several research methods were employed to create a more complete picture of the reality of what is occurring in the Arab countries with regards to social media usage by business executives. In terms of quantitative research, web-based surveys enabled responses to be downloaded into a database for further analysis and respondents to complete the questionnaire at their own pace. The online free survey tool kwiksurveys at www.kwiksurveys.com was used to administer the online survey. It does have one major drawback: it does not cross-tabulate the data received. This has been resolved by using Microsoft Excel pivot tables. The questions were segmented in several areas: 1) Questions about the demographics and education of business executives. 2) Questions about the size of company budget and allocations for business marketing.
Aminah Hamam
Page 12
The following is a list of terms and definitions that are used throughout this research: Social Media: As defined by Andreas Kaplan from the ESSEC Business School and Sciences Po Paris and Michael Haenlein a specialist in consumer relationship management, Social media is a group of Internet-applications that build on the ideological and technological foundations of Web 2.0, and that allow the creation and exchange of User Generated Content (Kaplan, and Haenlein 59 - 68). Social media essentially is a category of online media where people establish a social presence on the web. Social media has gained a great deal of popularity because it is engaging. Social media makes it easy to share ideas, photos, videos, likes and dislikes, with the world at large - and find out what they think of them. You can find friends, business contacts and become part of a community or a bunch of different communities (Ward).
Aminah Hamam
Page 13
Aminah Hamam
Page 14
Aminah Hamam
Page 15
It is important to note that with the recent incidences of civil unrest in both Tunisia and Egypt, social media played a vital role in
organizing protests and getting the word out to amass the populations into gatherings. This is an important indicator that social media is very recently widely used and depended in the MENA region.
Aminah Hamam
Page 16
This research consists of nine chapters with the following titles: 1) Introduction: this is the current chapter, it introduces the topic and explains the research methods used to accomplish this research. 2) Literature Review: this chapter discusses statistics obtained about the MENA region as well as statistics from the West. Moreover it discusses several other articles that are relevant to this research. 3) Interview with Director of Marketing of D1G: this chapter includes statistical information about the social media site D1G. 4) Survey Findings: an analysis of the 21 question survey will be presented in this chapter. 5) Open-Ended Questions: this chapter includes discussion about the results of the four open-ended questions asked to various business executives. 6) Discussion: a summarization of the findings from Survey Findings and Open-Ended Questions. 7) Further Analysis: this chapter includes research limitations and areas where further analysis should be conducted in order to tap into additional Arabic social networks. 8) Conclusion and Recommendation: this chapter summarizes the conclusions and recommendations that would enhance the Arab business social media experience.
Aminah Hamam
Page 17
The research required participants in two portions; the survey and open ended questions. Participants were not provided with any monetary incentives to participate except that they will be receiving a copy of this research upon completion. 1.5.1 Survey Candidates There were several methods of recruitment; some were more successful than others. www.Twellow.com is a website that is used as the yellow pages of Twitter. Around forty potential candidates were allocated from Twellow.com. However the site does not include email addresses of the potential candidates, hence an Internet search was conducted to find possible access links, such as a Facebook account, a website, or a blog. However this method was quite time consuming. The second method was to recruit candidates directly from Facebook. The limitation with Facebook is that it is mostly used as a social networking tool for family and friends. Moreover, it was difficult to determine if candidates were in fact business executives. Those candidates were requested to circulate the survey amongst their colleagues. According to Bryman and Bell, this is a form of sampling by which the researcher contacts a small group of participants who are relevant to the research project and then uses these to establish contact with others (Bryman and Bell p.200). Some candidates were contacted through family and friends. LinkedIn was used as the best medium to acquire candidates. According to Bryman, this is defined as convenience sampling (Bryaman and Bell p.197), since LinkedIn members are predominately business executives. Therefore it accommodates the right pool of candidacy to participate in this research. By connecting to relevant groups one may access hundreds of potential candidates. The author became a member in several discussion groups namely:
Aminah Hamam
Page 18
2 3
In LinkedIn, this group is actually named Marketeers not Marketers. LinkedIn members enter information to their account such as work experience, current residence and education.
Aminah Hamam
Page 19
Once participants take the survey, a cookie is downloaded onto their PC which flags the survey tool.
Aminah Hamam
Page 20
The literature review is divided into two portions: 1) Secondary analysis this type of data will be taken from bodies that already performed statistics on the MENA region 2) Documents and articles that are relevant to this thesis Social media usage is still in its infancy in the Arab world there is very limited research that is currently available that documents the usage of social media by business executives or Arab users in general. Documents presented in this research paper that discuss the Arab social media usage scene are all that have been found available up until January 15th 2011. The author decided that it would be beneficial to document what is available and build on it within this research. SPOT ON PR, a company located in the UAE is active in the online community and has published several reports on statistics that lists the behaviors and usage of Arabic users. Some of the published material was done in association with Effective Measure. These reports are titled: Media consumption and habits of MENA Internet Users 101 things brands should know about twitter MENA Twitter demographics and User habits survey
Aminah Hamam
Page 21
These reports are the basis of this literature review, in addition to some of what is currently available in the Western countries.
Secondary analysis includes all the statistics available in the MENA region as well as some statistics available for Western users.
2.1.1 MENA Consumption and Habits of MENA Internet Users: This survey was conducted by SPOT ON PR and Effective Measure. The total sample size is 2,587. The statistics reveal that 88% of MENA Internet users use the Internet daily, fifty-one percent of those who use the Internet use if for more than 3 hours per day. Fifty-four percent of MENA Internet users use mobile apps daily. The most common forms of social media usage by respondents are as follow: Facebook 70% Kooora.com 22% NetLog 18% Maktoob 13% Other local sites 11% Twitter 9% LinkedIn 5 % Jeeran 5%
Aminah Hamam
Page 22
This is important to note that because MENA users use the Internet quite often, there is a lucrative market to obtain by reaching out to these users. The survey also studied the disposition of users on companies that use Internet to communicate their message and that of those who use social media to communicate their message the results follow:
Please rate how you feel towards companies and brands that actively use the Internet to communicate their message Opinion Percentage (%) Highly Positive 17 Positive 32 Neutral 36 Negative 9 Highly Negative 6
Table 1: User disposition with regard to companies using the Internet to communicate their message
Forty-nine percent of users felt positive towards companies that did use the Internet to communicate their message; fifteen percent were negative more than a third of consumers were neutral. Please rate how you feel towards companies and brands that actively use social media to communicate their message Opinion Percentage (%) Highly Positive 12 Positive 27 Neutral 41 Negative 14 Highly Negative 7
Table 2: User disposition with regard to companies using social media to communicate their message
The percentages here take on a slightly lower positive stance. Only thirty-nine percent of users were positive towards companies using social media to communicate their message. 41% of users were neutral to this and a more than one-fifth of the users were negative. This indicates that companies should approach consumers differently, in the focus group discussion later Page 23
Aminah Hamam
Aminah Hamam
Page 24
Aminah Hamam
Page 25
Aminah Hamam
Page 26
Aminah Hamam
Page 27
For each country listed in this report, the top brands and media are listed. This is done to provide a view of where each countrys interests lies. In many instances, gaming and news top the lists. This shows that there are similarities between MENA users and international users. Moreover, businesses can use this information to explore how to tackle market segments. More detailed demographics are presented for each country. Appendix F provides these statistics in tabular format for easy comparisons. Egypt: According to Facebakers.com Egypt currently has 4,262,800 users and is considered to hold the twenty-second place in Facebook usage (the top five countries are USA, Indonesia, UK, Turkey and France in that order). Facebook penetration rate is currently at 5.3%. Since the SPOT ON PR report was written, it has risen 1.3%. The penetration against the online population is currently 25% a five percent increase since May. The top five brands in Egypt are: 1. Vodafone Egypt 2. Coca Cola Egypt 3. City Stars Egypt
Aminah Hamam
Page 28
50% of users are between the ages of 18 and 24. This is around 8% increase reporting from SPOT ON PR. There are 28% of users that are between the ages of 25 and 34. This number has not changed since SPOT ON published the report. Eleven percent of the Facebook community is over 35 years of age. This is a one percent increase since May. Age Distributions Age Segments Under 18 18 24 25 34 35 44 45 54 55 64 Over 65
Table 4: Age distribution in Egypt
Egypt 12 % 50 % 28 % 7% 2% 1% 1%
Gender:
Males out number female users (68% to 38%) and the statistics are consistent since May 2010. Gender Divide
Aminah Hamam
Page 29
Egypt 62 % 38 %
Language Preference:
According to SPOT ON PR usage of Facebooks Arabic intereface has grown sharply over the past year. However statistics show that English is the predominant language of usage for Egyptians and is currently sitting at 64.6%, Arabic usage is 34.3 % and 0.3% users use the French interface. Language Preference Language English Arabic French
Table 6: Languagedistribution in Egypt
Alexa Ranking:
Facebook is the second ranked site in Egypt; Twitter is the thirty-third place; Watwet is ranked at 13,319; D1G is at 206 and the Alexa site has no information on the ranking of LinkedIn in Egypt. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country
Social Media Platform
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) KSA usage of Facebook takes on the thirty-second place world-wide. Saudi population that is currently connected onto Facebook is 2 922 780, since the SPOT ON PR report was published,
Aminah Hamam
Page 30
According to Facebakers.com 38% of the Facebook population are between the ages of 18 and 24. This is an eight percent increase since May. Moreover, 35% of this population is between the ages of 25 and 34 which is a one percent decrease since May. 15% are over the age of 35, again there is a one percent decrease since May.
KSA 13 % 36 % 35 % 10 % 3% 1% 1%
Aminah Hamam
Page 31
The gender divide in KSA follows the same trend along the MENA region, however, KSA is in the lead with 69% males and 31% females. It seems that there is a two percent shift towards the males since May.
KSA 69 % 31 %
Language Preferences:
KSA is the only country in this study that has an almost equal divide with language preferences. The ratio is slightly in the English favor with 49% of the population prefer to use the English interface and 48.6% prefer the Arabic interface. Also 0.3% of users use the French interface. Language Preference Language English Arabic French
Table 10: Language Preference in KSA
Alexa Rankings:
In May 2010, Facebook held the fifth position, however almost six months later Facebook has moved up to the fourth place. Moreover, Twitter holds the fifty-second place, while D1G holds 162nd place. LinkedIn statistics are not present for KSA in alexa.com.
Aminah Hamam
Page 32
N/A 169
Morocco: Facebakers.com states that the current has 2 268 420 users, a 22% increase since May of 2010. The percent of penetration from Internet users is 21.7%. In May it was 17% which means it has increased by a little over four percent. The percent of penetration of the population is 7.17% -- again there is an increase since May as it was documented to be six percent. Morocco is in the fortieth position in terms of usage of Facebook. The top two brands listed in Facebakers.com are: 1. Renault Maroc 2. Sony Ericsson Maroc
Age:
Age distribution is Morocco follows the similar trends of the MENA region. 46% of Facebook users are between the ages of 18 and 24. This approximately translates to an eight percent increase since May. Moreover, 24% of users are between the ages of 25 and 34, nine percent of users are over the age of 35.
Aminah Hamam
46 % 24 % 6% 2% 1% 0.5 %
Gender:
In terms of male to female users, Morocco also follows the norms of the MENA region with females representing 39% of users while males are 61% of all users. Gender Ratios Gender Male Female
Table 13: Gender divide in Morocco
Morocco 62 % 38 %
Language Preferences:
French is the predominant language of use in all of the North African countries (Algeria, Tunis and Morocco). This is reflected in interface usage of Facebook. 82.3% of all Moroccan Facebook users prefer the French interface, while 10.6% use the Arabic interface and a mere 5.6 percent use the English interface. Language Preference Language English Arabic French
Table 14: Language Preference in Morocco
Alexa Ranking:
Facebook is ranked the second most viewed site in Morocco. Twitter holds the thirty-sixth position; LinkedIn holds the seventy-eighth position; and D1G holds the 289th position. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country
Social Media Platform
Morocco 1
Aminah Hamam
Page 34
40 79 292
United Arab Emirates (UAE) There are currently 2 007 080 Facebook users, this represents an increase of 20.47% increase since May 2010. In terms of penetration, from an Internet users stance, Facebook is currently at 53.47%, the highest in the MENA region and it has increased since May by over eight percent. In terms of overall population penetration Facebook is 40.33%. This is again an increase since May by around 7 percent. Therefore those who are becoming Internet users are more or less joining Facebook too. The top brands on Facebook are: 1. Emirates Airline 2. Burger King UAE 3. Etisalat UAE 4. Emirates Airlines 5. Etihad airways
Age:
As quoted from the SPOT ON PR report: the UAE is the most developed Facebook community in the MENA region. They have the biggest spread of age groups, with the loWest percentage of under 25s in MENA and the highest percentage of over 30s 46% of users are between the age of 25 and 34; 16% are between the ages of 35 and 44; and 24% are between 18 and 24. Age Distributions Age Segments UAE
Aminah Hamam
Page 35
8% 24 % 46 % 16 % 4% 1% 1%
Gender:
The MENA trend continues with having a 65% of male population to 35% female. Gender Ratios Gender Male Female
Table 17: Gender divide in UAE
UAE 65 % 35 %
Language Preference:
88% of users prefer to use Facebooks English interface, while there are only 9.3% of users use the Arabic interface and a mere 0.8% French interface users. The UAE shows the greatest amount of Facebook users who prefer to use English. Language Preference Language English Arabic French
Table 18: Language preference in UAE
Alexa Rankings:
In May 2010, Facebook held the second ranking in the UAE, however since then Facebook has become the 3rd in the country. Twitter is holding 15th place; LinkedIn 19th place and D1G holds the 165th place. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country
Social Media Platform
UAE
Aminah Hamam
Page 36
3 16 18 186
Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan Jordan was chosen to be part of this study as companies there are innovators in the field of email and social media. Samih Toukan and Hussam Khoury led a team of people to develop Maktoob.com that was later bought by Yahoo! in 2008 (Sekhri). Watwet was an initiative developed by another team led by Karim Arafat. Watwet is considered to be a clone of Twitter, and those who use Watwet micro-blog less frequently than those of Twitter. Watwets advantage over Twitter is that it allows two-way SMS via telecom providers each in Jordan (ZAIN) and KSA (MOBILY) (Saqer). D1G was also developed by a team of Jordanians lead by Dr. Usama Fayyad in 2007. Jeeran is as well a Jordanian initiative and is now being hailed as one of the largest Arab user content generated platforms (Jeeran). According to Facebakers, Jordans rank in Facebook is in the 63rd position. The Facebook population is 1,030,280 and this is considered to be 16.08% of total population penetration and 59.15% of the total online population. The top five brands in Jordan are the same as those of KSA: 1. XBOX 2. XBOX Daily News 3. XBOX Australia and New Zealand 4. XBOX DE 5. XBOX Canada
Age:
Aminah Hamam
Page 37
Jordan 15 % 48 % 26 % 7% 3% 1% 1%
Gender:
Jordan has the highest percentage of female users amongst the five countries being studied. Females account for 42% of users while males are 58%. Gender Ratios Gender Male Female
Table 21: Gender divide in Jordan
Jordan 58 % 42 %
Language Preference:
Jordanians only work in one of two languages with the majority (68%) choosing English. Arabic only accounts for 31%. Language Preference Language English Arabic French
Table 22: Language preference in Jordan
Jordan 68 % 31 % N/A
Aminah Hamam
Page 38
Facebook is ranked in the second position; Twitter holds the 25th position; LinkedIn holds the 51st position; D1G holds position number 94. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country
Social Media Platform
2 25 45 86
Aminah Hamam
Page 39
The biggest two age groups each holding a 25% share are individuals between 18 and 24 and between 25 and 34. The group aged between 35 and 44 account for eighteen percent of the Facebook population while the age group between 45 and 54 account for twelve percent. Ten percent of the Facebook population is over the age of 55. MENA users who are over the age of 55 tend to be negligible accounting for one percent of the users per country. Age Distributions Age Segments Under 18 18 24 25 34 35 44 45 54 55 64 Over 65
Table 24: Age distributions in USA
USA 11 % 25 % 25 % 18 % 12 % 7% 3%
Aminah Hamam
Page 40
Unlike the trends observed in the MENA region, female users outnumber males. Females account for 56% of users while males account for 44% of users. Gender Ratios Gender Male Female
Table 25: Gender divide in USA
USA 62 % 38 %
Alexa Rankings
According to alexa.com, US traffic to Facebook accounts for the second most visited site, Twitter is the eighth, and LinkedIn is the 15th. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country
Social Media Platform
2 8 15 N/A
The United Kingdom (UK) With a Facebook population of 28,413,560 the UK is ranked in the third place. Facebook has penetrated the overall population by 45.57% and the online population by 55.23%. The top brands: 1. iTunes (UK) 2. Starbucks UK 3. Smirnoff GB 4. Vodafone UK 5. BlackBerry UK & Ireland
Aminah Hamam
Page 41
Age distribution shows similar trends as in the US. Fifty-four percent of the Facebook population is equally divided between two age groups: between 18 to 24 and between 25 to 34. 17% of the users are between the ages of 35 and 44 while nine percent is between 45 and 54 years of age. Six percent account for users who are older than 55 years of age.
UK 14 % 27 % 27 % 17 % 9% 4% 2%
Gender:
As in the US, the gender divide is more biased towards female users with 52%. Males account for 48% of users.
Aminah Hamam
Page 42
UK 48 % 52 %
Alexa Rankings:
The alexa site ranked the UKs usage of the sites with Facebook taking the second place in generating traffic, Twitter in the eleventh position and LinkedIn in the fourteenth position. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country
Social Media Platform
2 11 14 N/A
France: Sitting in the fifth rank of Facebook usage, France has a total of 19,755,460 Facebook users. This accounts for a penetration in the population of around 30% and a penetration of the online population of 44.27%. The top brands are: 1. Oasis Fun Page 2. Nike Football France 3. M&Ms France 4. Schtroumpf Haribo 5. La vache qui rit
Aminah Hamam
Page 43
Frances age distribution is between those of the MENA region and those of the West. 31% of Facebook users are between the age of 18 and 24 while 28% are between 25 to 34 years of age. Thirteen percent of users are between the ages of 35 and 44; ten percent are over the age of 45. Age Distributions Age Segments Under 18 18 24 25 34 35 44 45 54 55 64 Over 65
Table 30: Age distributions in France
France 17 % 31 % 28 % 13 % 6% 3% 1%
Gender:
Gender distribution follows the trends of the West with females accounting for 52% and males account for 48%. Gender Ratios Gender Male Female
Table 31: Gender divide in France
France 48% 52 %
Aminah Hamam
Page 44
The alexa rankings in France are shown in the following table. Facebook is in the second position, Twitter is in the 27th position and LinkedIn is in the 63rd. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country France 2 27 63 N/A
Table 32: Social media ranking in France
2.2.2 Twitter Usage: From Edison research it is determined that 84% of Americans, aged over 12 years have some form of Internet access, with 84% of those having a broadband Internet connection (compared with 13% dial-up access). Moreover, over 50 % of Americans have at least one social networking profile. As such, the US is seeing a significant year over year growth. The majority of people who are getting connected are in the 12-17 age group with 78% growth, followed closely with 18-24 at a 77% rate and the 25-45 age segment with 65% rate. Awareness about Twitter has increased significantly due to the fact that many television, radio and print media are incorporating their Twitter accounts within their programs. However, Twitter is only used by seven percent of the American population. Moreover, most Twitter users tend to read and follow others without actively contributing themselves. Interestingly, as opposed to MENA Twitter users, Americans are split between habitual tweeters and those who access occasionally: 15% tweet less than once a month; 22% of users tweet at least once a month; 30% tweet at least once a week; 15% tweet at least once a day;
Aminah Hamam
Page 45
Across the world, and now including the MENA region, the consumer is being referred to as the Consumer 2.0 (Chahine, Bhargava, Smayra and Belcaid), a consumer who will not absorb online content passively, but rather be proactive with the content. The consumer has become social, and looks for information online before making purchasing decisions. According to the
Aminah Hamam
Page 46
Additionally, with this growth, users are depending on social media to make purchasing decisions. YouGovSiraj a survey company based in the UAE has revealed that 80% of UAE citizens do in fact use social media to do so (AME INFO 23rd February 2010).
2.3.2 The Arab Media Scene From the secondary analysis in the previous sections, it has been revealed that MENA users are avid Internet users; however they still consume television, radio and print.
Aminah Hamam
Page 47
Print Media: Although print media is declining worldwide and even in the MENA region, The Arab Media Outlook report of 2009-2013 indicated that print is still growing albeit at a very decreased pace. Some MENA countries are being awarded with new licenses to launch printed materials. In terms of advertising revenue, magazine circulation is much higher than print. With the fact that the population of the Arab region is relatively younger than their counterparts in the West, many are turning to the Internet to get their news. One of the threats that is seen in the West is online newspapers and blogs. Although this is affecting the Arab region, it is not greatly impacting the print. Hence print is still important to MENA users as a source of obtaining information and viewing ads. According to the report, people who were surveyed indicated that 41 percent of them read the printed newspaper while 40% read online blogs. Moreover, journalists are increasingly using Internet blogging sites as source for news coverage (Arab Media Outlook). This is in fact in line with the report presented by SPOT ON PR with the fact that MENA users are interacting often with journalists and bloggers. Blogging is not seen as a threat to the print, instead it is viewed as a complement (Arab Media Outlook p34). The region is trying several methods to overcome the slowdown. Zawya.com a UAE based business information company has taken its content online and now mainly caters to business news. It has adopted a subscription business model set on three-tiers. Another method is that print is heading for consolidated platforms. Television Revenues generated from television are quite low due to several reasons. Firstly there are around 600 Free-to-Air (FTA) channels distributed across the Arab region, these do not include
Aminah Hamam
Page 48
2.3.3 Impact of Social Media in the Region It has to be noted that by far, the UAE is leading the way in social media usage and consumption across the MENA region. Many companies in the UAE are using social media to interact with consumers. However, this usage is not as what consumers expect. Many companies are talking at their consumers as opposed to engaging with them across the different mediums.
Aminah Hamam
Page 49
2.3.4 The potential of Social Media in the Workforce Using social media responsibly in the workforce only enhances the performance and knowledge of work related issues, by which peers discuss problems and issues with others as well as discussing issues with experts from within the field of their business. The press release titled UAE professionals active social media users stated that 66% of residents indicated that they use social media sites at least somewhat actively, meaning that they use it a minimum of two to three times per week. Professionals mainly use sites such as LinkedIn, Facebook and Twitter to gain knowledge and experience from peers (Stoeterbroek and Taifur). Even though the UAE has one of the most active communities in social media, more than half of the companies forbid employee access, making the UAE the most restrictive amongst the thirteen companies surveyed in this report.
Aminah Hamam
Page 50
2.3.5 Comparison between Social Media Sites and Traditional Media Usage Traditional media is usually a single one-way communications message that is usually broadcasted from TV, radio and advertisements in newspaper and magazines. It is designed to be shouted out to a large audience that may or may not be interested in the product being sold, in the hopes that someone will be interested and becomes a customer. Nowadays, the probability of a commercial or an ad to catch the eye of the consumer is wildly challenged. However, there are two schools of thought that are emerging: 1) Those that say leave traditional media for the cheaper and more tuned social media marketing 2) Those that say a combined offering of marketing is the key to ensuring customer buy-in. In the survey (in the later paragraph, it is evident that the majority of business executives who participated in the survey believe that a combined approach is the optimal solution.) In the following sections, an analysis of each platform will be investigated briefly: Television Ever since the introduction of television time-shifting such as TIVO and ShowBox , consumers can simply fast forward over the commercials in pursuit of their favorite television programs. Moreover, it is too costly to create a commercial only to have it ignored. The cost of the commercial depends on creating the commercial as well as airing it on TV. Also, the cost
Aminah Hamam
Page 51
Cost effective, campaigns can be started and stopped according to the business at hand. Moreover cost wise it is cheaper than TV ads, print ads and billboards
Targeted, social media can be thought of as upon-request marketing. Better feedback, brands have almost instantaneous feedback from their customers on what is going well, what needs improvement and what should not be repeated.
Disadvantages:
Unlike other forms of media, social media is time consuming. Business executives have to be prepared to spend numerous hours per week to build brand awareness, answer questions and interact with their consumers.
Moreover, once a company invested in social media, it cannot abandon ship. There has to be some form of reputation management.
Aminah Hamam
Page 52
2.3.6 A View of American Business Executives In the next chapter (Survey Findings) some of the questions were based on the report provided by Michael Stelzner, founder of Social Media Examiner. The author had several assumptions: 1) Western business executives and MENA executives have similar characteristics 2) Western executives and MENA executives usage is similar 3) Tools used are the same The report investigates some demographics about the business executive and discusses their views on benefits. Some of the interesting statistics are listed below: 85% of business executives who took part in the survey reported that the first advantage of using social media was to generate exposure their businesses. 63% indicated that social media increased traffic to their businesses. 54% indicated that they witnessed a rise in search rankings. 52% indicated that they generated qualified leads. Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn and blogs were the top social media tools used by business executives.
2.3.7 Conclusions of Literature Review Documentation that is available on this subject is very few, as a matter of fact, what is available has been included in this research to provide an overview of existing research. However, a few emerging trends have been identified. Firstly, the MENA region is growing at an accelerated speed and the potential revenue creation that is becoming available is increasing due to the connectivity and the infrastructure that is being laid out. With this increase the usage by segments are taking form and the biggest two that are emerging are women and male youths.
Aminah Hamam
Page 53
Aminah Hamam
Page 54
D1G started operations in November of 2006. During its first ten weeks it attracted more than 300,000 visitors and five million pages (AME INFO, February 2007). To reinforce its position in the Arab world it strategically acquired several other sites to become under the D1G umberella, of those are: Seenandjeem.com, a question and answer bank (AME INFO, February 2007) Yasater.com, a site that incorporates non business and non political news (AME INFO, March 2007) 66g.com, a games, mp3 downloads and movies (AME INFO, July 2007) Moreover, it has created a sister site purely for women and their concerns through a site named 7asnaa.com (the beautiful). Among the sites initiatives, it enabled the platform with services such as A9waat, or sounds. This service allows users to upload and share personal audio clips that can also become part of online discussions. The aim of D1G is to be the leading portal in the Middle East to cater to the needs of Arab youth in one meeting area. The following information about D1G was obtained through an interview conducted to Fouad Jeryes, the Director of Business Development and Marketing.
Age Population of the popular site is distributed amongst four categories: six percent of users accommodate ages less than 17; 53% of users fall between the ages of 18 and 24; 37% of users are between the ages of 25 and 34 and only three percent make up users over the age of 35.
Aminah Hamam
Page 55
6% 53 % 37 % 3%
Gender Gender distribution is similar to those of other social media sites with the majority (60%) males and 40 % females. D1G Gender Ratios Male Female
Table 34: Gender divide for D1G users
60 % 40 %
Country Distributions D1G traffic is segmented into four groups; Gulf States (31%), North African countries (20%), East Mediterranean countries (38%) and other regions (11%). Traffic distributions are as follows: KSA takes up 65% of Gulf States traffic which equals: 20% of overall traffic UAE takes up 17% of Gulf States traffic which equals: 5.27% of overall traffic Morocco takes up 41%of North African traffic which equals: 8.2% of overall traffic Egypt takes up 65% of East Mediterranean traffic which equals: 24.7% of overall traffic Jordan takes up 18% of East Mediterranean traffic which equals: 6.84% of overall traffic The five countries listed make up 65% of all traffic to D1G. Jeryes mentions that the highest activity over the site is on the forum section, followed by the video section. The online trends that they are experiencing today are users will be accessing the Internet for a specific reason. They have created a service called Diwan by which users are allowed to create very specific and content driven social networks under D1G umbrella. As an example, 7asnaa.d1g.com was created, a site catered for womens interests.
Aminah Hamam
Page 56
space in general) in the Arab world. Most sites fail to deliver rich media services and open platforms to users in the region. Moreover D1G contains diverse libraries of relevant photos, videos, audio clips and articles. In the Arab online space, users have a specific taste with regards to content and design. Unlike most sites, D1G concentrates on a special segment of the market (Jeryes). D1Gs Usage The majority of its users (90%) are considered to be of the Youth generation (15-30 years). To D1G, this is considered a critical age that allows the D1G team to influence individuals towards content, brands, and lifestyles. D1G is accessed through users laptops; however, the D1G development team is adding mobile access and applications as well. The highest activity on the site is on forums and videos which is considered typical for Arab users. Business Benefits from Accessing D1G The concentration on user generated content that appeals to youth attracts a great deal of business for D1G. Business partners and advertisers see the value in D1Gs target market because they feel youth are attracted to them at an influential age where they are associating themselves with brand names and products. Businesses cater to these users early and appeal to their interest in manners that attract them. Businesses join D1G by offering banners, SMS, SMS sponsorship and overlays within D1G pages.
Aminah Hamam
Page 57
The survey comprises of 21 closed questions. The graphs that are portrayed in this research are provided in both Arabic and English due to the fact that the survey was bilingual at the time of launching. The analysis of the survey questions are segmented into 5 categories: 1. Demographics 2. Company and budget 3. Usage of Social Media 4. Motivations and benefits 5. Challenges and barriers 6. Perceptions about social media It should be noted that the survey results are very small and thus do not represent a true picture of what is happening in the MENA region. Rather they show that business executives do have awareness in social media and this report is considered to be the beginning of an exploration.
4.1 Demographics
The survey contained five questions that dealt with Business executives demographic data (age, gender, country of residence and education). 4.1.1 Age Out of 58 respondents 12 did not complete this question. 23 (50%) of the remaining respondents selected the category Between 31 and 40 years old. The other notable sections were between 41 and 50 years old with 11 respondents (24%) and between 26 and 30 years old 7 respondents (15%). Page 58
Aminah Hamam
Age
Less than 25 years old - 52
Between 26 and 30 years old -- 62 03 Between 31 and 40 years old -- 13 04 Between 41 and 50 years old -- 14 05 Between 51 and 60 years old -- 15 06
According to the 2010 Social Media Marketing Industry Report the median age of respondents were between 41 and 50 years old. Which leads to the conclusion that Arab business executives who use social media users approximately 10 years younger than their counterparts of the West. 4.1.2 Gender Out of 58 respondents, 46 completed this question. The majority of respondents were male with 42 respondents (91%).
Aminah Hamam
Page 59
Male -- Female --
The Social Examiner reported that there were a slightly higher number of female users to those of male users with a 60% - 40% split. 4.1.3 Education This survey question did not include respondents with no higher educational background. But it is consistent to say that all respondents had some formal training. Out of 58 respondents, 46 answered this question with the following: 20 respondents (43%) have a Bachelors Degree, 17 respondents (37%) have a Masters Degree and 9 respondents (20%) have a Post-Graduate degree. According to data obtained from Boolean Black Belt 75% of LinkedIn users have at least a college education (Cathey).
Aminah Hamam
Page 60
Post-graduate --
4.1.4 Country of Work The survey was sent out to respondents in five countries: Jordan, KSA, UAE, Morocco and Egypt. The question was asked Of the 58 respondents 46 completed this portion of the survey with the following divide:
Country of Work
Egypt -- Jordan -- KSA -- Morocco -- UAE --
Aminah Hamam
Page 61
4.1.5 Preferred Language of Correspondence The findings in this question are interesting; out of the 58 respondents, 46 answered this question with the majority of the participants choosing to correspond in English 40 respondents (87%). Both Arabic and French accounted for three users each. In the previous chapter titled Secondary Research, findings shows that the Arabic language is on the rise.
Language
Aminah Hamam
Page 62
12
10 8 6 4 2 0 Egypt -- Jordan - KSA -- Morocco -- UAE - Arabic -- English -- French --
After performing a cross tabulation on country of residence versus language preference shows the distribution of languages in the countries. As expected, French is one of the predominant languages in Morocco; therefore the 6.5% participants who preferred to use French reside in Morocco. However, the author suspected that the there would be a higher percentage of participants who preferred correspondence in Arabic to reside in KSA. Out of the participants, only one KSA business executive chose Arabic as his/her preferred language.
Aminah Hamam
Page 63
35
30 25 20 15
Medium corporation (between 500 and 1,999 employees) -- 1999 - 005 Small business (less than 500 employees) -- - 005
10
5 0 Total
Figure 7: Size of Businesses
Analyzing further the other two segments, the findings show that Jordans participants are only part of smaller corporations.
Aminah Hamam
Page 64
14
12 10 8 6 4 2 0 Egypt - Jordan - KSA - Morocco - UAE - Medium corporation (between 500 and 1,999 employees) -500 - 9991 Small business (less than 500 employees) -- - 005
According to The Social Media Examiner, 88% of respondents were part of a company less than 500 employees this number also includes sole proprietors (46%), small business owners (17%) and small businesses (25%). 9% is allocated for medium and large companies. The survey shows that 9 respondents (19.6%) are part of medium or large corporations. This leads to the conclusion that Arab companies of larger scale are using social media more than their Western counterparts. 4.2.2 Budget Out of 58 participants, 48 answered this question. The majority of users, specifically 58% indicated that their budget for marketing is less than $30,000. There were no participants who
Aminah Hamam
Page 65
30
Less than $30,000 -- 000,03 Between $31,000 and $50,000 -- 000,13 000,05 Between $71,000 and $90,000 -- 000,17 000,09 Between $91,000 and $100,000 -- 000,19 000,001 More than $100,000 - 000,001
25
20
15
10
0
Figure 9: Company budget for Marketing
4.2.3 Budget Allocation: The question regarding budget allocation asked where was the budget planned on being invested in. 35 respondents (73%) chose Social Media and Traditional Media.
Aminah Hamam
Page 66
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Total
Figure 10: Budget allocation
Social Media alone -- Social Media and Traditional media -- Traditional media alone --
20 15 10 5 0 Social Media Social Media and Traditional media alone -- Traditional media alone -- --
Figure 11: Budget allocation against budget
Less than $30,000 -- 30,000 Between $31,000 and $50,000 - 000,13 000,05 Between $91,000 and $100,000 - 000,19 000,001 More than $100,000 -- 000,001
Aminah Hamam
Page 67
Looking at the countries involved and marketing budget, participants from the UAE have indicated that their budgets have are less than $50,000. Some participants from Morocco, Egypt and KSA have indicated that they have a larger budget to invest in marketing. The question asking where the budget will be spent is an optional question, only 29 responses were received. The breakdown of this question is as follows: 14 respondents (48%) indicated that will spend the allocated budget on an in-house strategy. 8 respondents (28%) indicated that they will be outsourcing their marketing. 5 respondents (17%) indicated that they will deal with marketing in-house without a plan. 2 respondents (7%) indicated that they will be hiring personnel.
Aminah Hamam
Page 68
There were three questions dedicated to this area of the survey that included how long business executives have been using social media, how much time they spend using social media per week and forms of social media used. 4.3.1 Duration of Social Media Usage The question How long have you been using social media in your marketing strategy? led to 58 complete responses from participants.
Aminah Hamam
Page 69
The results yielded: 2 respondents (3%) have heard of social media but are not planning on using it. 2 respondents (3%) have heard of social media and are planning on using it. 10 respondents (17%) are just getting started. 17 respondents (29%) have been using social media for a few months. 27 respondents (47%) have been using social media for a few years.
4.3.2 Length of Time Spent per Week The question How many hours per week do you spend using it lead to 56 out of 58 complete responses. 18 respondents (32%) indicated that they use social media Between 5 and 10 hours; 13 respondents (23%) indicated that they used it less than five hours. 35 respondents (45%) are using social media more than 10 hours per week.
Aminah Hamam
Page 70
Arab Business Executives Usage of Social Media 2011 Usage Per Week
Less than 5 hours -- 5 Between 5 and 10 hours -- 5 01 Between 11and 20 hours -- 20 11 Between 21 and 30 hours -- 30 12 Between 31 and 40 hours -- 40 13 More than 40 hours -- 04 0 5 10 15 20 Total
Aminah Hamam
Page 71
5
4 3 2 1 0
Business executives who are just starting with social media to market their business are spending more than 5 hours. It is interesting to note that there is at least on executive who is just starting out and spending over 40 hours per week; at the same note there are no executives who are just starting out using social media less than five hours. There is a wide range of length of usage amongst those who have been using social media for a few years.
Aminah Hamam
Page 72
The graph indicates that thirteen users from Egypt; six users each from Jordan, KSA and Morocco and two users from UAE.
Aminah Hamam
Page 73
The graph displays 11 users from Egypt, four users each from Jordan and KSA, six users from Morocco and two users from UAE.
Aminah Hamam
Page 74
The graph illustrates that there are 8 users from Egypt, two from Jordan, one from KSA, three from Morocco and 2 from UAE. LinkedIn usage per country is shown:
Aminah Hamam
Page 75
Egypt --
Jordan -- KSA -- Morocco -- UAE --
51 out of the 58 users who completed this survey selected LinkedIn. Excluding the twelve individuals who did not complete the country of work question, the statistics of this survey show: 13 users from Egypt, 11 users from KSA, seven users from Jordan, 8 users from Morocco and four users from the UAE. 4.3.4 Business Executives Followers The question asking business executives perception of what type of consumers follow them yielded 47 responses out of a possible 58. The following definitions were taken from a report that categorized the personas of users titled The Social Profile by Exact Target. The survey described seven categories of followers namely: Shopper: These individuals primary concern is to shop, most of their other actions on social media relate to this activity. 2 respondents (4%) chose this category to describe their consumers. Information Seeker: Before making purchasing decisions, these individuals go online to read reviews and then make informed decision. 18 respondents (42.5%) chose this category of
Aminah Hamam
Page 76
Aminah Hamam
Page 77
16
14
Deal-Seeker take part in reviews but not so much blogs and look for promotional information about products -- --
12
10
8
Information Seeker go online to read reviews about products to make purchasing decisions -- --
Megaphone -- want to connect, educate, and share resources and information online with others. These consumers clearly fall into the influencer category -- --
0 Total
Aminah Hamam
Page 78
Aminah Hamam
Page 79
UAE --
Business First -- Consumers use the internet for business purposes, keeping up with the latest trends, communicating with business contacts, and making new connections through sites like LinkedIn -- -- Cautious Very selective of who they communicate with - --
Morocco --
Deal-Seeker take part in reviews but not so much blogs and look for promotional information about products - --
KSA --
Information Seeker go online to read reviews about products to make purchasing decisions -- -
Jordan --
Megaphone -- want to connect, educate, and share resources and information online with others. These consumers clearly fall into the influencer category -- -- Shopper primary interest is shopping and interacting online -- --
Egypt --
10
15
20
Aminah Hamam
Page 80
The question What do you consider the most benefits of Social Media? was a matrix question by which respondents choose how much they agree with the statements. 56 respondents answered the question with the following results:
Generating Exposure to Business: 35 respondents strongly agree that social media does indeed generate exposure, 18 respondents merely agree and 3 respondents selected neutral. Of those that selected neutral, one respondent was just starting out to use social media and the other two were using social media for a few years. Better Understanding of the Customer: 25 respondents strongly agreed that social media enables one to better understand their consumer; 22 respondents agree, 1 respondent disagrees and 8 felt neutral to this question. One of the major attractions of using social media is to better understand the consumer. 81% of respondents agree with this statement. The majority of respondents who chose strongly agree spent between 5 and 10 hours weekly on social media. The individual who disagreed with this statement spends more than 40 hours.
Aminah Hamam
Page 81
Arab Business Executives Usage of Social Media 2011 Better Understand the Customer
Agree -- Disagree -- Neutral -- Strongly Agree --
More Conversations about your Brand: 26 respondents agreed with this statement; 21 strongly agreed and 9 respondents were neutral. The majority of respondents that strongly agreed spent between 5 and 10 hours using social media.
More Conversations
Aminah Hamam
Page 82
Lower Costs
Agree --
Neutral --
Impacting Search Ranking: This question lead to the most diverse responses from participants; only 11 respondents strongly agreed with this statement while 26 respondents agreed. 16 respondents were neutral; 2 respondents disagreed and one strongly disagreed. Helped to Close Sales: This question lead to the most number of disagreed respondents, a total of 8. Moreover, 20 respondents selected neutral. Eight respondents selected strongly agreed and 20 respondents agreed. 35% of respondents were chose neutral were just starting to use social media. 25% who chose neutral used social media more than 40 hours per week.
Aminah Hamam
Page 83
4.5 Perceptions of Arab Business Executives about Social Media vs. Traditional Marketing
There were two questions allocated to this area of the study. The question do you think that social media marketing will replace traditional marketing in your company? lead to a total of 48 responses. 34 respondents (71%) stated that social media will not replace traditional means of marketing in their businesses.
No -- Yes --
Figure 27: Perceptions if social media will be used instead of traditional media
Aminah Hamam
Page 84
16 14 12 10 8 6 4 No -- Yes --
2
0 Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree
Traditional media is not that effective anymore, the consumer is ignoring it: The strong sentiments are in line with the previous question. Those who strongly disagree (4 participants) selected that social media will not replace traditional marketing, while those who strongly agree are the participants that selected yes to that question (3 participants). 17 participants disagreed with this statement; 15 were neutral and only 9 agreed. Social media is still in its infancy in the MENA region. As previously stated in the literature review, traditional media is still growing in the MENA region albeit at a slower pace. The difference here is that social media is being referred to as selective media, users are choosing to participate in it as opposed to being forced to look at it.
Aminah Hamam
Page 85
12
10 8 6 4 2 0 Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree No -- Yes --
Figure 29: Perceptions against opinion that Traditional media is not that effective anymore
I have no knowledge of what the consumer wants: One of the advantages of social media is that it is traceable (Steitiyeh). Responses to this question lead the following results: 2
respondents strongly agreed with this statement; 6 respondents agreed; 17 respondents were neutral; 17 respondents disagreed and 4 respondents strongly disagreed. Again the strong sentiments are in line with the previous question.
Figure 30: Perceptions against the statement "I have no knowledge of what the consumer wants "
Aminah Hamam
Page 86
25 20 15 No -- 10 5 0 Yes --
Strongly Agree
Agree
Neutral
Figure 31: Perceptions against Both social and traditional forms of media will complement each other
Traditional marketing is more artistic: This question yielded the most diverse responses 2 respondents strongly agreed to this statement; 12 respondents agreed; 22 respondents were neutral; 10 respondents disagreed and 2 respondents strongly disagreed.
Aminah Hamam
Page 87
12
10 8 6 4 2 0 Strongly Agree Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Disagree No -- Yes --
Consumers enjoy having a say: This question indicated that respondents understood the fact that consumers are vocal about their wants and needs. 19 respondents strongly agreed to this statement; 21 agreed; seven respondents were neutral and 1 respondent disagreed.
The majority of respondents showed a lack of understanding of what social media can offer a business. Their answers indicated that they will continue to use traditional media marketing and that social media marketing will not yield the desired results such that social media is lower in Page 88
Aminah Hamam
Aminah Hamam
Page 89
Aminah Hamam
Page 90
Aminah Hamam
Page 91
Weight 5 4 3 2 1
These percentages were multiplied by their assigned weight, added and them divided by five. Five being the number of options respondents can choose from. For example: The question How do I reach my target markets with social media? is calculated as follows: [ (0.57)*5 + (0.28)*4 + (0.16)*3 + 0 + 0 ] / 5 = 0.89. Therefore the questions rated by Arab business executives are as follows: Rank 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Question How do I reach my target markets with social media? How do I measure social media return on investment? What are the social media marketing best practices? What are the latest social media trends? How do I generate traffic and leads using social media? How do I evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each platform? How do I integrate my social media activities? How do I best manage my time with social media? How do I implement social media tactics? How do I get started?
Table 36: Ranking of top questions that business executive would like answered
The weakest question How do I get started? is in line with the findings of this research as the indicated that 75.8% of users have been using social media for at least several months. The question What are the challenges that you face with using social media? garnered a total of 44 responses. Participants were asked to state how much they agreed with set statements. The following is their responses:
Aminah Hamam
Page 92
Aminah Hamam
Page 93
18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2
0
Total
Figure 34: Perceptions of business executives on why others do not join social media
17 respondents (38%) selected Confidence that there is a ROI; 10 respondents (22%) selected Understanding on how to measure return on investment. These responses are in line with the previous sections findings the second most important answer that Arab business executives would like to be answered is how to measure social media return on investment. 9 respondents (20%) selected Knowledge; 8 respondents (18%) selected Motivation and commitment and 1 respondent (2%) selected Other. The comments received by 3 respondents that fall under Other are: Customer education An overall basic knowledge of the above Understanding the values and benefits over traditional, out-dated media
Aminah Hamam
Page 94
A list of four questions was sent out to 40 individuals. Responses came from a total of eight. Details of these participants can be found in Appendix E. This portion of the study was designed to delve deeper into the understanding of how to make Social Media work for the Business executive; it took into account some of the statistics obtained from the online survey that was conducted. Even though responses came back to two distinctive usages of social media (those who promote their products, and those who use it primarily to network) there were similarities in the answers. It must be noted that the number of respondents is small and in the future, further analysis should be conducted to obtain more accurate results.
Question 1A: Overcoming challenges and barriers faced using social media
There were several challenges that were mentioned by participants: 1) Knowing what Social media can do for the business There are numerous social media sites currently available, each with its particular functionality and purpose. One participant, UAE-MA mentioned that his company is still at the beginning of their social media journey. They are primarily using social media within the companys team members and experimenting with the results. However they have not reached the full potential that social media can offer, as they have not actively managed them or used them interactively. 2) Time Dedication In order for the social media strategy to work, business executives must invest time. UAE-MA wrote there was no right person within his team to actively take-on this role: we just hired a
Aminah Hamam
Page 95
3) Moving from direct marketing to participation marketing Several participants suggested that companies often spam their consumers with promotions and marketing campaigns. This was referred to by one individual as Social Media Addiction. Another participant UAE-MP stated that this was the method mostly commonly used in the corporate world. Companies tended to do much talking at the consumer as opposed to talking with the consumer. UAE-MP stated that this ideology was changed when he started his business. Overcoming this challenge was done by changing the type of information that was placed on social media and encouraging consumers to participate. This individual set out several initiatives and tied them in the context of his product. Promotion of his company only came when individuals asked about it. Jordan-FJ stated that engagement of individuals is a problem: in the Arab world it is rare to find a vibrant two-way social stream. Looking at foreign news sites, youll find that only moments after an article is published, youll receive constructive comments, opinions and feedback. For most users, comments come in the form of Thank yous or one liners over anything else. To place this individuals response in context, the following must be taken into consideration: 1) Target market is generally younger than those of the UAE. 2) Penetration in Jordan is currently sitting at 14% as opposed to 35% of UAEs. Another participant Jordan-ZS stated that participation in the conversation was most important; listening and answering questions in blogs.
Aminah Hamam
Page 96
Aminah Hamam
Page 97
6)
Trust
Morocco-OB stated that there are many users who do not use consistent information, or real names, instead opting to use nicknames. He believes this hinders building solid relationships with the online communities.
Most companies in the MENA region are not at this stage yet, however a few words may be mentioned to enlighten business executives of what may behold in the future of social media usage. Jordan-FJ mentioned that it is highly important to be attuned to a companys followers. As a matter of fact, his company data mines all information that emerges from his followers and analyzes them. UAE-MP on the other hand prefers to take a more trial and error approach to new things that will be coming up in the future of social media, analyzing what works and what does not. As stated in an article written by Kim Luu: Twitter didnt exist a few years ago. It might disappear as a tool in a couple of years as Twitter spam grows and new competitors are created (Luu).
Aminah Hamam
Page 98
All participants who were involved in this question replied that they would like to see their consumers change from being just information seekers to becoming influencers Morocco-MC stated Definitely become a Promoter. The word of mouth is more powerful than any media. Jordan-ZS stated that in her line of business, it is essential that her followers become influencers as influencers enhance positive change. UAE-MP stated that when he first started his business initiative he only invited his family and friends. Through word of mouth his company now has 6000 loyal followers. Building on the previous question, UAE-MP mentioned that considering his consumers as his virtual business partners encourages positive growth. It is explained by Jordan-FJ that individuals on the social-sphere will be looking at influencers for advice and recommendations on an array of topics. This will lead to a large amount of supporters who are digesting all that is sent out on social channels. There were some reservations expressed by Morocco-OB: People are very conservative and this relates to our culture some consumers could become influencers but you need to satisfy them and push them to do so. Another mention to the same thread by Morocco-ZL we still find that our customers/contributors are not sharing as much as in developed countries. People are more concerned about getting information than about sharing it unless it has an emotional relation (personal photos, personal live events). An event that did create live buzz about a product was mentioned by Morocco-ZL, a customer mentioned on his Facebook account a year ago an experience he had in a bank agency based on Bluetooth product we designed for the bank, it made some very significant and positive buzz.
Aminah Hamam
Page 99
Respondents agree that many companies are hopping onto the social media bandwagon without understanding how to use it. Jordan-FJ wrote that most companies, governments, organization and others have jumped onto social media in hopes of gaining more business and saving their current client base. Unfortunately, many of these transitions are not organic as they come late to the game and have much to learn about social media etiquette. UAE-MP said that corporations look at quantity as opposed to quality of followers, and using bribing methods to buy followers. There are several points that can be taken into account for business to adapt to the Arabic social media consumer: Networking. According to Jordan-ZS this is the most important factor to promoting her business. Sharing information about the company both online and offline this information does not necessary be just about the product/business, but it can also be about the person him/herself Talking about things that are in the context of the product, but not directly about the product and be involved in other initiatives that relate to the product. UAE-MP has six categories of initiatives that are discussed online: Education Adventure Small business Business integrity Travel Music
Aminah Hamam
Page 100
These areas are discussed within the context of his product. Hence interest is built about the product throughout many follower interests. This allows for his company to target a wider audience. Identifying key people efficiently, according to Morocco-OB, Morocco will only continue to use social media platforms such as Facebook to establish connections with important decision makers. Especially now that Morocco has over two million people connected. Morocco-ZL uses social media for his company to: Communicate to and through the consumer Interact with them Get content from them
However, UAE-MA mentioned that they still have to investigate other Arabic Social Media Platforms.
Aminah Hamam
Page 101
Aminah Hamam
Page 102
6.1 Who is the Arabic social media consumer and how does s/he differ from the Western social media consumer?
Facebook is the leading social media site that is frequented by the majority of Arabic social media users. It is ranked second in each of Morocco, Jordan, and Egypt; third in the UAE and fifth in KSA. These rankings were taken from www.alexa.com on November 10, 2010. The countries of the GCC (UAE and KSA) have a higher penetration rate of social media users than there are in Morocco, Jordan and Egypt. This could be explained by the reason that the income in the GCC countries is higher therefore affordability of Internet connectivity is more abundant in the Gulf States than it is in other countries. The highest penetration percentage lies in the UAE. MENA users tend to be younger than their Western counterparts. The only exception is again the UAE which has the most age distributions and the oldest age group. By comparing the age differences, the Western countries have older members that use Facebook. In terms of gender divisions, the MENA region witnesses a higher influx of male users over female users, with KSA displaying the highest percentage of males and it stands at 69%. The country with the highest percentage of females is Jordan with a percentage of 42%. This is not the trend that is present in the Western countries. At a glance, the US, UK and France have a higher percentage of women users than men. Currently the majority of MENA users with the exception of KSA, use social media in English. KSA users are divided almost 50-50 between English and Arabic. Moroccos users mostly use
Aminah Hamam
Page 103
Even though the fourth segment, only accounts for five percent, they are the most pragmatic users. These professionals use LinkedIn. According to SPOT ON PR, LinkedIn accommodates five percent of MENA traffic. One could argue that these professionals also make up the five percent of LinkedIn users.
Aminah Hamam
Page 104
6.4 An analysis of Arab business executives who use social media in comparison to Western counterparts who use social media
The survey showed that the Arab business executives have the following demographics. 83.9% are between the ages of 31 and 50. Only 15% are between the ages of 26 and 30. 91% of respondents were male and the majority of business executives surveyed had indicated that English was their preferred language. More emphasis on Arabic should be made to accommodate the language fragmentation. From respondents who answered the survey question regarding education, 43% had a bachelors degree, 37% had a masters degree and 20% had a post-graduate degree. In comparison to global LinkedIn users, 75% (Cathey) From the open ended questions, there were several challenges and barriers that were identified by participants: 1) Knowing what social media can do for the business
Aminah Hamam
Page 105
6.5 How are Arab businesses using social media to cater to Arab social media users?
Many business executives find that numerous companies are using social media without a clear strategy. This will likely to yield a failed social media effort. From the open ended questions, five points emerged as key to operating in the MENA area: Networking Identifying key people efficiently Sharing information about the company both online and offline Talking about things that are in the context of the product, but not directly about the product involved
Aminah Hamam
Page 106
Aminah Hamam
Page 107
These three sites are repeatedly presented in the top 100 in the five MENA countries selected. It is recommended that these sites are investigated to see how business executives can use them to gain followership. As with the example from UAE-MP by stating that he talks about community concerns in the context of his product, these sites may offer suitable followership in order to grow ones business. Furthermore, business executives should be on the lookout for new Arabic platforms that will be emerging over the upcoming time frame. It must be noted here that the business executives upon completing the survey the author found that they use social media sites differently than those of the regular Arabic social media user: Some of the sites that are more prominently used by the average social media user are: Maktoob.com, YouTube, Jeeran.com, kooora.com, Tagged.com, Orkut and blogging sites. Business executives should be exploring these sites in order to gain higher leverage amongst users. It is also apparent that there was a low response rate from the UAE, from the secondary research, the UAE is active in the social media arena, this is not reflected well in this research. It is recommended that these research questions be asked again at a later date to business executives to better understand the impact of this research. Some questions that should be addressed to business executives are:
Aminah Hamam
Page 108
Aminah Hamam
Page 109
Aminah Hamam
Page 110
Aminah Hamam
Page 111
1) The Social Media Examiner found that there are ten questions that were on business executives minds, and they are listed. Could you please order them in importance according to yourself? 1 How do I measure social media return on investment? 2 What are the social media marketing best practices? 3 How do I best manage my time with social media? 4 How do I reach my target markets with social media? 5 How do I generate traffic and leads using social media? 6 How do I implement social media tactics? 7 What are the latest social media trends? 8 How do I get started? 9 How do I integrate my social media activities? 10 How do I evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of each platform? 2) How long have you been using Social Media in your marketing strategy? a. Never used it b. Heard of it and not planning on using it c. Heard of it and am planning on using it d. Just getting started e. Been doing it for a few months f. Been doing it for a few years 3) What motivated you to use Social Media? a. Ease of use b. Affordable c. A chance to interact with consumer d. Everyones using it 4) How many hours per week do you spend using it? a. Less than 5 hours b. Between 5 and 10 hours c. Between 11and 20 hours d. Between 21 and 30 hours
Aminah Hamam
Page 112
It costs too much Traditional media is not that effective any more, the consumers are ignoring it I have no knowledge of what the consumer wants Both traditional marketing and social media marketing will complement each other Traditional marketing is more artistic Consumers enjoy having a say
9) Which type of marketing do you prefer? a. SMS b. Social Media c. Email Marketing campaigns d. Newspaper e. Television f. Radio g. Billboards
Aminah Hamam
Page 113
11) Where do you plan to invest this money? a. Social Media alone b. Social Media and Traditional media c. Traditional media alone 12) If you selected Social Media, how will you be spending the budget? a. Plan on hiring b. Outsourcing c. In-house d. Develop a strategy 13) What are the challenges that you face with using social media? a. Creating content b. Turning followers into customers c. Getting traffic to your website, blog or Facebook page d. Creating positive noise and buzz about your brand 14) How big is the business you are in? a. Large corporation (more than 2,000 employees) b. Medium corporation (between 500 and 1,999 employees) c. Small business (less than 500 employees) 15) As a person in the business world, what do you think Arab businesses need to enter the Social Media marketing scene? a. Knowledge b. Motivation and commitment c. Understanding on how to measure return on investment d. Other, please comment 16) What are the nature of consumers that Friend or Follow you on Social Media? a. Cautious Very selective of who they communicate with
Aminah Hamam
Page 114
Aminah Hamam
Page 115
Aminah Hamam
Page 116
1) When you first started using social media, what were the challenges and barriers did you face and how did you overcome them? Do you see any future challenges that you may still need to overcome?
2) Most of the respondents in the current survey selected that their consumers are information seekers. Do you find this satisfactory or would you prefer that your future consumer becomes an influencer, hence promoting your product?
3) 69.6% of respondents to the survey stated that interacting with consumers was mostly what motivated them to use social media. How have you adapted your business to cater to the Arabic social media consumer?
4) Could you provide me with some Lessons Learned on winning methods that you followed to achieve your successful use of social media with your business?
Aminah Hamam
Page 117
Aminah
Aminah Hamam
Page 118
The email went out to 40 individuals and the following were the respondents of open ended questions portion of the study. To ensure anonymity of individuals only country of residence and gender were documented. Each participant was given a pseudonym. Country of Residence Jordan Jordan UAE UAE UAE Morocco Morocco Morocco Egypt Egypt Pseudonym Jordan-ZS Jordan-FJ UAE-AA UAE-MA UAE-MP Morocco-MC Morocco-ZL Morocco-OB Egypt-MA Egypt-AM Gender F M M M M** M M M M M*** Experience with SM High High High Low High Medium High High High High
Aminah Hamam
Page 119
Egypt
KSA
Morocco
Under 18 18 24 25 34 35 44 45 54 55 64 Over 65
12 % 50 % 28 % 7% 2% 1% 1%
13 % 36 % 35 % 10 % 3% 1% 1%
21 % 46 % 24 % 6% 2% 1% 0.5 %
8% 24 % 46 % 16 % 4% 1% 1%
15 % 48 % 26 % 7% 3% 1% 1%
11 % 25 % 25 % 18 % 12 % 7% 3%
14 % 27 % 27 % 17 % 9% 4% 2%
17 % 31 % 28 % 13 % 6% 3% 1%
Table 38: Age distributions of MENA countries and top 3 Western countries
Table 38 discusses displays the Facebook age distributions according to the five MENA countries as well as the top 3 Western countries. In a subsequent table Facebook country rankings are displayed. Percentages highlighted in yellow show the highest in a particular age segment, while the percentages highlighted in green show the loWest in a given age segment.
Gender Ratios Country Gender Male Female 62 % 38 % 69 % 31 % 62 % 38 % 65 % 35 % 58 % 42 % 44 % 56 % 48 % 52 % 48 % 52 % Egypt KSA Morocco UAE Jordan USA UK France
Table 39: Gender divides of MENA countries and top 3 Western countries
Table 39 displays the Facebook gender ratios according to the five MENA countries and the three top Western countries. The table shows that KSA has the highest male percentage; the USA shows the loWest male percentage.
Aminah Hamam
Page 120
The table above displays the language preferences in the MENA region. Social Media Sites Ranking per Country UAE KSA Morocco Jordan USA
Country
Social Media Platform
Egypt
UK
France
2 33 N/A 200
3 16 18 186
5 49 N/A 169
1 40 79 292
2 25 45 86
2 8 15 N/A
2 11 14 N/A
2 27 63 N/A
These ranks were checked on November 10, 2010. According to Alexa.com these are calculated the average user traffic over a one month period. Facebook Ranking / Country France Egypt KSA 5 22 32
Country Rank
USA 1
UK 3
Morocc o 41
UAE 46
Jordan 63
Aminah Hamam
Page 121
Aminah Hamam
Page 122
The technology adoption life cycle describes how people adopt to the use of technology with people being segmented into five categories:
Aminah Hamam
Page 123
Aminah Hamam
Page 124