Você está na página 1de 33
Sex and Death in the Rational World of Defense Intellectuals Author(s): Carol Cohn Source: Signs,

Sex and Death in the Rational World of Defense Intellectuals Author(s): Carol Cohn Source: Signs, Vol. 12, No. 4, Within and Without: Women, Gender, and Theory (Summer, 1987), pp. 687-718 Published by: The University of Chicago Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3174209

Accessed: 21/09/2008 22:04

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless

you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.

Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=ucpress.

Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission.

JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We work with the scholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform that promotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. The University of Chicago Press is collaborating with JSTOR

The University of Chicago Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Signs.

http://www.jstor.org

SEX AND DEATH IN THE

SEX AND

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

DEATH IN THE

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

SEX AND

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

RATIONAL WORLD OF

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

DEFENSE INTELLECTUALS

COHN

CAROL COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

COHN

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

CAROL

"I can't believe

"I can't believe that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

"I can't believe

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

that," said Alice.

"I can't believe

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying tone. "Tryagain: drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

drawa

pitying tone. "Tryagain: drawa

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

"Can't you?" the Queen said in a pitying

tone.

pitying tone.

pitying

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

tone.

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

"Tryagain:

long breath,

long breath, and shut your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

your eyes."

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

long breath,

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

and shut

"One can't

Alice laughed. "There's no use trying," she said. "One can't

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

Alice

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

"One can't

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

laughed.

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

"There's no

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

use

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

trying,"

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

she said.

believe

believe impossible things."

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

believe

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

things."

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

impossible

"I

Queen.

"I daresay you haven't had much practice," said the Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

Queen.

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

"I

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

daresay you

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

haven't had much practice,"

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

said the

"When I was your age, I always did it for half-an-houra day. Why,

before

sometimes I've believed as many as six impossible things before

sometimes

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

before

breakfast." [LEWIS CARROLL,

breakfast." [LEWIS CARROLL, Through the Looking Glass]

I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I always did it for half-an-houra day. Why,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

"When I was your age,

day. Why,

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

day. Why,

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

always

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

did it for half-an-houra

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

I've believed

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

as

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

many

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

as six

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

impossible things

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

breakfast."

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

[LEWIS

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

CARROLL,

the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

Through the Looking Glass]

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis startedin the summer of

close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My

My

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

My close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

startedin the summer of

close encounter with nuclear strategicanalysis

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

1984.

teachers (one

teachers (one often women) attending

(one often women) attending

often women) attending

I was one of forty-eight college teachers (one often women) attending

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight college

I was one of forty-eight

summer workshop on nuclear weapons, nuclear strategic doctrine, and

and

and

and

and

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

summer workshop

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

strategic doctrine, and

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

teachers (one often women) attending

summer workshop

college teachers

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

weapons,

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

on nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

strategic doctrine,

strategic doctrine,

strategic doctrine,

strategic doctrine,

arms control, taught by distinguished "defense intellectuals." Defense

distinguished

arms control, taught by distinguished

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

taught by

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

"defense intellectuals." Defense

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

arms control,

intellectuals are men (and indeed, they are virtually all men) "who use the

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

all men) "who use the

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

intellectuals are men (and indeed,

they are virtually all men) "who use the

men) "who use the

men) "who use the

taught by

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

distinguished

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

are

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

virtually

all

all

of a kind and

concept of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

concept

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have weapons of a kind and

of a kind and

of a kind and

of a kind and

of a kind and

of a kind and

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have

of deterrence to explain why it is safeto have

weapons

weapons

weapons

weapons

weapons

weapons

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

number it is not safe to use."' They are civilians who move in and out of

1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

1 Thomas Powers, "How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

"How Nuclear War Could Start,"New YorkReview of Books (January

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

Thomas Powers,

33.

17, 1985), 33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

17,

33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

33.

17,

17,

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

1985),

[Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 1987, vol. 12, no. 4]

[Signs: Journal of

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

Culture and

4]

? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

?

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

4]

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

[Signs: Journal of

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Women in

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

Society

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

1987, vol.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

12, no.

1987

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

1987 by The University of Chicago. All rights reserved. 0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

1987

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

0097-9740/87/1204-0013$01.00

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

The

Chicago. All rights reserved.

Chicago.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University

University

University

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

University of Chicago. All rights reserved.

of Chicago. All rights reserved.

All rights reserved.

of

of

687687687687687687687687687687687687687687687687

CohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohnCohn

//////////////// DEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEDEFENSEINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALSINTELLECTUALS

government, working sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

government,

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

government, working

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

working sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

working sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

working sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

working sometimes as administrativeofficialsor consultants,

government,

government,

government,

sometimes at universities and think tanks. They formulate what they call

sometimes

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

call

"rational" systems for dealing with the problems created by nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

"rational" systems

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

sometimes

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

at universities and think tanks. They formulate what

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

for

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

dealing

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

with the

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

problems

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

created

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

weapons: how to manage the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons:

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

weapons: how to manage

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

the arms race; how to deter the use of nuclear

weapons; how to fight a nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons;

weapons; how to fight a

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

weapons; how to fight

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

nuclear war if deterrence fails. It is their calcula-

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

a

nuclear destructive

tions that are used to explain the necessity of having nuclear destructive

tions that are used to explain

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

nuclear destructive

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

tions that are used to explain

the

the necessity of having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

having

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

the

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

necessity

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

of

capability at what George Kennan has called "levels of such grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

capability

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

dimensions as to defy rationalunderstanding. "2 At the same time, it is their

capability

capability

capability

capability

capability

capability

capability

capability

capability

capability

grotesque

capability

capability

capability

capability

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

grotesque

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

at what

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

George

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

Kennan has called "levels of such

reasoning that is used to explain why it is not safe to live without nuclear

reasoning

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

reasoning that is used to explain why

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

it is not safe to live without nuclear

that is used to explain why

weapons.3 In short, they create the theory that informs and legitimates

weapons.3

that informs and legitimates

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

American nuclear strategic practice.

weapons.3

weapons.3 In short, they create the

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

weapons.3

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

In

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

short,

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

they

create the

create the theory

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

create the

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

theory that informs and legitimates

discussion of

For two weeks, I listened to men engage in dispassionate discussion of

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

For two weeks,

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

discussion of

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

listened to men engage in dispassionate

fascinated-not

nuclear war. I found myself aghast, but morbidly fascinated-not

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

nuclear

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

fascinated-not

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

war.

I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

found

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

myself aghast,

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

but

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

morbidly

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

by

nuclear weaponry, or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

nuclear weaponry,

images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

nuclear weaponry, or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

or by images of nuclear destruction, but by the extraor-

nuclear weaponry, or by images

nuclear weaponry, or by images

or

or

or

or

or

by images

by

by

by

by

that character-

dinary abstractionand removal fromwhat I knew as reality that character-

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

dinary

ized the professional discourse. I became obsessed by the question, How

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

ized the

can they think this way? At the end of the summer program, when I was

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

can they

abstractionand removal fromwhat I knew as reality that character-

abstractionand removal fromwhat I knew as reality that character-

abstractionand removal fromwhat I knew as reality that character-

abstractionand removal fromwhat I knew as reality that character-

abstractionand removal fromwhat I knew as reality that character-