Você está na página 1de 11

Annexure A: Independent Sources Corroborating Vigilante Violence of Salwa Judum Y= confirms presence of violence etc.

NA not applicable, not focus of report I = Nandini Sundar and ors (WP 250/2007), II= Kartam Joga and ors (WP 119/2007), Vol. 1 & Vol. 2 refer to paperbooks in 250/2007 Statutory Bodies and Commissions Appointed by Government S.No. Name of Source Type Annexure/Page State Violence s Nos sponsorshi (deaths, p rapes etc.) Forced Internment in Camps Minor SPOs & Other Violations of international humanitarian laws Y Recommendations

1.

2.

National Human Rights Commission National Commission for Protection of Child Rights

Report to Supreme Court 2008 NCPCR factfinding Report 2007 by Shanta Sinha, JM Lyngdoh, Report and covering letter 2007 News report covering NCW report 2007 Order Staying Forest

See full index

I, P/25, pg. 417, Vol.2 II, P/14, Sept 2007, pg. 107

NA

p. 112 plus SJ burnt testimonies villages, 119-138 forced people into camps

Want adherence to UNHCR principles on internal displacement, II/ 111 SPOs look like minors Dont recruit youth as SPOs, disrupts edu.

Rehabilitation, compensation, further enquiry Recommendations related to children; sent testimonies on killing and rape to NHRC for action

3.

National Commission for Women NCW

I, P/7, 239-246, Vol. 1

4.

II, P/15, Sept 2007, pg. 147

Govt has identified itself with SJ (p. 239) Violations against women NA

People caught in between

Independent investigations into violence against women

5.

AP High Court

I, P/38, Feb 2008, pg. 491, Vol. 2

NA

Shows refugee prob. in AP

NA

6.

7.

8.

department burning of IDP huts 2007 Report of Planning the Expert Commission Group on Developme nt Challenges in Extremist Affected Areas, 2008 7th report of Administrative Admin Reforms Reforms Commission Commission Veerappa Moily, Chairman, 2008 Ministry of Rural Cttee on State Agr. Development Relations & Unfinished Task of Land Reforms, 2009, Chairman, Minister, RD

I, P/43, Oct 2008, pgs 49, 84

State sponsorshi p of vigilantes

Calls it an abdication of state responsibility, should be undone immediately

II, P/27, March 2008, pg 234

Policy of raising local resistance groups

NA

Camps indicate failure of policy

NA

Recommended disbanding SJ, pg. 236

Pg 160-161 of report, report not annexed

Points to Y state and corporate involveme nt in Salwa Judum

Displacement NA because corporate want to grab land

Tribal communities in SJ camps must be resettled in their occupied land irrespective of the cutoff date under FRA (2006). pg 15, recommendation 8.12

Annexed Documents showing Government sponsorship of Salwa Judum S. No 1 Name of document Dantewada Collectors Monthly Returns and Police Daily Diaries Annexure/page nos I, March 2009 aff., quoting NHRC annexures, pages 2430. Paras 1.37, 1.38, 5.04, 6.09 I, P/ 1, May 2007, pg. 30, Vol. 1 I, P/2, May 2007, pg 10, Vol. 1 I, P/2, May 2007, pg. 44, Vol. 1 I, P/3, May 2007, p. 44-75, Vol. 1; also in NHRC annexures I, P/8, May 2007, pg 247, Vol. 1 II, P/1, Sept 2007, pg. 21 II, P/7, Sept. 2007, pg 62-63 II, P/7, Sept 2007, pg 64-66 I, P/8, May 2007, pg 248, Vol. 1 I, P/15, May 2007, pg Remarks Shows participation by top ministers in SJ Rallies, funding of SJ etc.

2 2 3 4. 5.

NHRC Report Ministry of Home Affairs Annual Report MHA Status Paper on Naxal problem, 2006 Minutes of Co-ordination Centre Collectors Work Proposal, 2005

Shows participation of security forces in SJ rallies States have been advised to form local resistance groups Govt advised to ensure safety of SJ activists CG Chief Secretary: will gear up SJ in 2 blocks before spreading; states will promote local resistance groups Complete blueprint for Salwa Judum, with financial proposals; if excesses take place, higher ups must keep silent (p. 58) Raman Singh lauds Salwa Judum, calls it Gandhian movement Raman Singh calls Salwa Judum holy battle; reiterates support to it DGP describes SJ as success Describes SJ as non-violent war; says people are warned against leaving camps CG government temporarily suspends Salwa Judum Shows attempt to make camps permanent 3

6. 7. 8. 9.

Hindu News Report, 14.7.2006 Gulf Times news report, 16.8.2007 UNI report quoting DGP Chhattisgarh, 7.7.2007 Force magazine interview with Home Minister, CG, Ram Vichar Netam, Aug. 2007 NewKerala News Report, 11.4.06 Lists of camps

10. 11.

12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18.

Indian Express, 24.4.07 Indian Express, 8.1.07 Letter from CG PIO, 4.4.07 Letter from Collector, Dantewada, 3.5.07 Zee News quoting CM supporting SJ, 26.1.09, Photos of SJ rally held at Konta, 24.2.06 Hindu, News Report. 24.9.09

271-286 I, P/12, May 2007, pg. 266, Vol. 1 I, P/14, May 2007, pg 270, Vol. 1 I, P/30, Feb 2008, pg. 462, Vol. 2 I, P/41, Feb. 2008, pg 497, Vol. 2 I, P/1, March 2009, pg 41-43 I, P/11, March 2009, pg 162-164 I, Anx A, Nov 2009, pg. 615-616

CG police fudging data to project win, get rewards CG police encouraging fake surrenders States that no criminal case has been filed against any SPO Shows services to villages stopped after SJ, refers to SJ camps as base camps CG Govt extends full support to SJ Shows participation of Senior Police/CRPF/Collector and MLA in SJ rally National Security Advisor defending Salwa Judum

Reported Statements and Interviews with Senior Ministers and Officials critical of Salwa Judum S.No. Name of Source Type Annexure/Page State s Nos Sponsors hip Violenc e (deaths, rapes etc.) Forced Internme nt in Camps Minor SPOs Recommendations & Other Violations of internationa l humanitaria n laws Opposes Operation Green Hunt, criticizes CG leadership for wrong vision

1.

2.

KPS Gill, Former Security Advisor to Chhattisgarh Government Jairam Ramesh, Union Minister

Interview in Tehelka, Oct 24, 2009

Not annexed

Hindu news report, 9.9.07

I, P/22, Feb., 2008, pg. 406, Vol. 2 II, P/11, March 2008, pg. 97

3.

PR Kyndiah, Minister Tribal Affairs

News report, The Telegraph, 22.7.06

4.

Ajit Jogi, former Signed article, CM Indian Express, 30.6.06

I, P/23, Feb 2008, pg. 408, Vol. 2 II, P/12, March 2008, pg. 98 I, P/24, Feb 2008, pg. 410, Vol. 2 II, P/13, March 2008, pg. 102

SJ formed as an outfit aimed at peoples participati on Arming tribals to fight tribals wrong

People running away from SJ

Review SJ

Called for end to SJ

Mention s large scale violence

Compares it to Hitlers lebensrau m

Stop SJ, disband camps

Fact-finding Reports by Independent Civil Society Organisations Annexed S.No. Name of Source Type Annexure/ Pages Nos State sponsor ship Violence (deaths, rapes etc.) Forced Internment in Camps Minor SPOs & Other Violations of internationa l humanitaria n laws Y Recommendations

1. Human Rights Watch 2. PUCL-PUDR report 3. Independent Citizens Initiative (BG Verghese and ors) 4. All India Womens team

Being Neutral is our Biggest Crime, 2008 Factfinding Report, 2006 Fact-finding report, 2006

I, A-2, Oct 2008, p. 184-367 I, P/4, May 2007, pg 76117, Vol. 1 I,P/5, May 2007, pg 118-189, Vol. 1

92, 100104 134-135

94-97

99-100

Minor SPOs

End Govt support to SJ, address impunity for SJ and police abuses, protect and assista persons displaced etc. End to SJ, enquiry, disband camps

144-150

151-157

Minor SPOs; Violation of Geneva Conventions, pg 162 Minor SPOs

End SJ, disband camps, enquiry, no recruitment of minors

Factfinding report

5.

6..

International Association of Peoples Lawyers Medico Friends Circle and Jan Swasthya Abhiyan

Factfinding report, 2007

I, P/6, May 2007, pg. 190-238, Vol. 1 I, P/36, Feb. 2008, pg. 476, Vol. 2 II, P/17, March 2008, pg. 159

215-222

199-201

End SJ, independent enquiry, disband SPOs

116

117

118

End SJ, dismantle camps, allow enquiry

Factfinding report on medical conditions, 2007

171

162-3, 167

Close camps, restore services to villages, public health enquiry

7.

Independent team of Women Professionals

Factfinding on rapes and violence against women, Oct 7-10, 2008

I, P/9, March 2009 affidavit, pg. 127-158

Immediate closure of SJ camps, disbanding of SPOs, enquiry into all deaths etc.

Some News Reports on Salwa Judum which have been annexed S.No. Name of Source Type Annexure/Pages State Violence Forced Nos sponsorship (deaths, Internment rapes in Camps etc.) Minor SPOs Recommendations & Other Violations of international humanitarian laws SJ forcing people to camps

BBC

Guardian

Detailed news coverage, 30.6.06 Detailed reportage, 9.5.06

3 4 5. 6. 7.

Le Monde Diplomatique Economist

8.

9.

Reportage, 1.2.08 Reportage, 17.8.06 Outlook Reportage, 15.5.06 Down to Earth Reportage, 31.10.06 Siddharth Editorial Article, Varadarajan, 8.9.07 The Hindu Pratap Mehta, Indian Express, President, Op-Ed article, Centre for 8.2.08 Policy Research Ajay Sahni, Indian Express, Inst. for Conf. Op-ed Article, Management 2.3.06

I, P/31, Feb. 2008, pg. 463, Vol. 2 I, P/32, Feb. 2008, pg. 467, Vol. 2 II, P/16, March 2008, pg. 149 II, P/19, March 2008, pg. 185 II, P/18, March 2008, pg. 181 II, P/20, March 2008, pg. 192 II/P10, Sept. 2007, pg 72 I, P/28, Feb. 2008, pg 454, Vol. 2 II, P/23, pg, 209 I, P/26, Feb. 2008, pg. 447, Vol 2

SJ violent

Y Y Y Y Y

Y Y Y Y Y

Y Y Y Y Y

Y Y

SJ - state terrorism SJ - scorched earth policy SJ led to displacement

Y Y

SJ causing displacement End SJ

End SJ

End SJ

10.

Bijo Francis, Op-ed article, UPIAsiaonline 29.1.08 Times of India Editorial, 8.2.08 Editorial The Hindu Editorial, 30.5.07 The Hindu News report, 10.1.09

11. 12. 13.

I, P/29, Feb.2008, pg. 458, Vol. 2 II, P/21, March 2008, pg 206 II, P/22, March 2008, pg. 208 I, P 8, March 2009, p. 111

End SJ

SG is vigilantism Enormous social damage Y Y Exposes SPOs killing of civilians in Singaram, 8.1.09

14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23.

Mail Today Hindustan Times Tehelka The Hindu Outlook Tehelka Tehelka The Hindu New Indian Express Nai Duniya

News Report, 7.12.08 News Report, 11.1.09 News Report, 7.2.09 News Report, 24.3.10 News report, 22.2.10 Interviews/news, 6.2.10 News/interviews, 13.2.10 News/analysis, 6.2.10 News report, 25.11.09 News, 6.1.10

I, P 8, March 2009, p. 113 I, P 8, March 2009, p. 115 I, March 2009, P 8, pg. 117 I, 31 March 2010, Anx A I, March 2010, p 44-45 I, March 2010, p 52-61 I, March 2010, p 62-65 I, March 2010, pg. 66 I, March 2010, pg. 67-68 I, March 2010, pg. 76

Y Y Y

Y Y Y

False encounter in Singaram Fake encounter in Singaram Fake encounter in Singaram Schools occupied by CRPF

Y Y Y Y Y

Y Y Y Y Y

Y Y Y Y Y

Y Y Y Y Y

Bloodbath in Bastar We the non-people A struggle to find new memories Green Hunt killings Attack on village and arson Shows state support for absconding SJ leader

Photos which have been annexed as evidence S.No. 1 2 3 Type of Photo and date taken SPOs and Salwa Judum (SJ), Feb. 2006 SPOs and Salwa Judum, Feb. 2006 SPOs and memorials to them, May 2006, 2008 Annexure/page nos I, P/9, Sept 2007, p. 250, Vol. 1 I, P/9, Sept. 2007, p. 251, Vol. 1 I, p/9, Sept 2007, p. 252, Vol.1; I, P/33, Feb. 2008, 470, P/34, 471, Vol. 2 I, P/13, May 2007, pg 268, Vol. 1 I, P/13, May 2007, pg 269, Vol. 1 I, P/16, May 2007, pg 287, 288, Vol. 1 II, P/5, Sept. 2007, pg 53-54 I, P/16, May 2007, pg. 289290, Vol. 1 II, P/5, Sept. 2007, pg 55 I, P/11, March 2009, pg 162164 I, Aug 09, P/7-8, pg. 597, Vol. 2 I, March 2010, P/3, pg. 6970 I, March 2010, P/4, pg 76 I, March 2010, P/5, pg. 77 I, March 2010, P/6, p. 78 Remarks Armed with guns Armed with guns Photos of minor SPOs; Police memorials to SPOs revealing real age contra to fudged data

4 5 6

Women displaying SJ style of beating, May 2006 Women in Mookabelli village, 2005 Burnt houses, 2007

Violence against women Women killed by SJ Arson by SJ

7 8 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.

Condition of relief camps, 2007 Refugee settlements in AP, 2007 SJ rally held at Konta, 24.2.06 Houses burnt at Vechapal village, June 2009 Attack on village Tatemadagu, 9.11.09 Absconding Salwa Judum leader Soyam Mooka openly leading a demonstration, Jan 2010 School and ashram in village Bhatpal occupied by security forces, Feb 2010 Malnourished children, AP, March 2010

Internal Displacement Internal Displacement Shows participation of Senior Police/CRPF/Collector and MLA in SJ rally, SPO mob armed with guns Houses burnt by CRPF and SPOs/SJ, June 2009 Houses burnt by security forces and SPOs, November 2009 Shows police refusal to implement court orders against Salwa Judum accused Shows CG perjury before SC, refusal to vacate schools despite claiming this in Court Condition of IDPs in AP 10

11

Você também pode gostar